UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 20460 

OFFICE OF 

AIR AND RADIATION 

MEMORANDUM 

Subject: 

From: 

To: 

Summary of Stakeholder Meetings 

Kristien Knapp 

Dockets EPA-HQ-OAR-201 3, EPA-HQ-OAR-2013-0603, and EPA-HQ-OAR2013-0495 

This memorandum summarizes meetings with stakeholders during the week of July 7, 2014. 

On July 7, Administrator Gina McCarthy met with Ben Fowke ofXcel Energy. Ms. McCarthy 

answere9 questions about the clean power plan proposal for existing sources. 

On July 8, Associate Assistant Administrator for Climate and Senior Counsel for Air and 

Radiation Joseph Goffman met with David Doniger and other representatives of the Natural 

Resources Defense Council. Mr. Goffman answered basic questions about the clean power plan 

proposal for existing sources. 

On July 9, Associate Assistant Administrator for Climate and Senior Counsel for Air and 

Radiation Joseph Goffman met with Bill Bumpers and other representatives of the Coalition for 

Innovative Climate Solutions. Mr. Goffman answered basic questions about the clean power plan 

proposal for existing sources. Sign-in sheet and power point slides attached. 

On July 9, Associate Assistant Administrator for Climate and Senior Counsel for Air and 

Radiation Joseph Goffman participated in a conference call with the NAACP Climate Justice 

Initiative. Mr. Goffman generally described and answered basic questions about the clean power 

plan proposal for existing sources. Sign-in sheet attached. 

lntemel Address (URL) • hltp://www.epa.gov 

Recycled/Recyclable • Prinled with Vegetable Oil Based Inks on 100% Postconsumer. Process Chlorine Free Recycled Paper 
Date: -t~ t:;j' 20 I L{ . . 

Meeting: C, 1 (2c,-, '?~ f:J Cv> c.-0 ;tL N A F>C-P CJ lrYl<L ~._.: ~ J..a.-1-tZ. 

Rule(s)Discussed: (I I~) (C~~ ' 

Written Materials? Yes/No (;fA huc:;J e:\' pa»v- po ,,..-,.}t, 

Name Organization Phone Number 

Y.l 0 - S'£0 . tt:;;l/1 

J.(J")- ~L\- :>uo~ 
Date: 1t.J.o ~ > t..u \ y 

Meeting: 

Rule(s) Discussed:. ll \ ~) 

Written Materials? Yes/No 

Name Organization Phone N urn ber 

.J (J K {If /TPJ!fv "" /15 £/}/- &z. .%y ~ Zg/ 

k fVW Cf/Lf_J£J1li/ I ( r r ~~ %"Y 06/; { 

1(6/ /J /!!/-If IIEY tr 1 

( 

I? IV I A-A/ Fi~5 !fFIP 1 I /I ..., 

!low AlP/) 1/rJH-ff/JJV / 

/> 

~ 

I;'~~ ..... ,...., y 

//Pt; , l v 

//1/J~)J qy Lt9 ,/1- L l 

J 7 M,/ ~ -/ 

ffJ !/ ~ (7 r__;/J£5 f/ --v / -
Louisiana - EPA Proposed C02 Emission Rate Trajectory 

EPA Clean Power Plan 

---- ----- - --- --------- - - - ---------------------

• EPA assumes a 54% reduction in 

.. n • • .nau= Ill Gil !II ......... I state Coal-fired & Oil/Gas Steam 

2014 2016 2018 

1,015 lb/MWh 

II' 

2020 2022 

Year 

generation by 2020 with that 

generation replaced by other 

resources 

EPA Interim Goal* 

-2029 

948 1b/MWh 

2024 2026 

3) 

2028 2030 
MWh 

2014 

Mississippi - EPA Proposed C02 Emission Rate Trajectory 

EPA Clean Power Plan 

State plan in place 

2016 2018 2020 2022 

Year 

*EPA assumes o 100% reduction in 

state Cool-fired & Oil/Gas Steam 

generation by 2020 with that 

generation replaced by other 

* 

(2020- 2029 Average) 

7321b/MWh 

2024 2026 2028 2030 
Arkansas - EPA Proposed C02 Emission Rate Reduction Trajectory 

EPA Clean Power Plan 

1,634lb/MWh 

2014 2016 

State plan In place 

2018 

1,0281b/MWh 

¥ 

2020 2022 

Year 

"' EPA assumes a 64% reduction in 

state Coal-fired & Oil/Gas 

Steamgeneration by 2020 with that 

generation replaced by other 

EPA Interim Goal * 

(2020- 2029 Average) 

9681b/MWh 

2024 2026 2028 2030 
arbon Dioxide (C02) Emission Reductions Required in Arizona 

EPA Clean Power Proposal 

--- - ------------ - -------------- -

Current (2012) Emissions 

1,453 lb/MWh 

EPA takes action 

on state plans 

-1----- -------,JC..---- ----- -----------

2014 2016 2018 

* EPA assumes all in-state coal-fired generation 

will be replaced by other generation resources 

by 2020 to meet Interim Goal 

EPA 2030 Goal 

7021b/MWh -

2020 

EPA Interim Goal • 

(2020-2029 Average) 

7351b/MWh 

2022 2024 2026 2028 2030 
Coalition for Innovative Climate Solutions 

Meeting with EPA, July 9, 2014 

Baker Botts, LLP, 1299 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington DC 20004 

In Person 

NAME COMPANY 

BARR, Kelly J. Salt River Project 

BARLOW, Chuck D. Entergy 

BERGE, Megan Baker Botts LLP 

BUMPERS, Bill Baker Botts LLP 

EASTMAN, Renee Salt River Project 

HENDRICKS, Ray Portland General Electric 

HARMON, Shani Baker Botts LLP 

IHLE, Jack Xcel Energy ) 

JEZOUIT, Debra Baker Botts LLP 

LOVELESS, Brad Westar 

MARTIN, Nicolas Xcel Energy 

MASER, Gabe Baker Botts LLP 

MAYO, Kent Baker Botts LLP 

McQUEEN, Kelly Entergy 

MONTALVO, Kara Salt River Project 

OTT, Katherine PPL 

PABLO, Jeanette PNM Resources 

REVLETT, Gary LGE-KU 

ROBERTSON, Dave Portland General Electric 

Active 16296441 .1