### UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION A GE NC Y 

### WASHINGTON , D

. C

. 20460

O F F I CE OF AIR AND RADIATION 

## MEMORANDUM Subject: From: To: Summary of Stakeholder Meetings Kristi en Knapp Dock e t s EPA -HQ-OAR-201 3, EPA-HQ -OAR-2013-060 3, and E PA

- HQ

- OAR2013-0495 This memorandum summarizes meetings with stakeholde r s during the wee k of Jul y 7 , 2014. On July 7, Administrator Gina McCarthy met with Ben Fowke ofXcel Energy. Ms. McCarthy answere9 questions about the clean power plan proposal for existing sources. On Ju l y 8, Associate Assistant Administrator for C li mate and Senior Counse l for Air and Radiation Joseph Goffman met with David Doni ge r and other representativ es of the Natural Resources Defen se Co uncil. Mr. Goffman answered basic questions about th e clean power plan proposal for existing sources. On July 9, Associate Assistant Administrator for Cl imate and Senior Counsel for Air and Radiation Joseph Goffman met with B ill Bump ers and other representatives of the Coalition for Innovative Climate So lution s. Mr. Goffman answered basic questions about the clean power plan proposal for existing sou rces. Sign- i n sheet and power point slides attached. On July 

## 9, Assoc i ate Ass i s tant Admin i strator for Cl imate and Senior Counsel for A i r and Radiation Joseph Goffman participated in a conference call with the NAACP Climate Justice Initiative. Mr. Goffman generally described and answered basic questions about the clean power plan proposal for exist in g sources. Sign-in sheet attached.

l n teme l A ddress ( U R L ) • h ltp : //

www
. epa
. g o v Recycled/Recyclable • Pr i nled wi t h V eg et able O il Based Ink s on 1 00% Pos t cons ume r
. P rocess Chlor i ne F r ee R ecy c le d P a per

## Date:



# -t~ t:;j' 20 I L{

. . 

## Meeting: 

# C, 

# 1 (2c,-,



# '?~ 

# f:J Cv> c.-0 

# ;tL 

# N A 

# F>C-P 

# CJ lrYl<L



# ~._.:
**~** 

# J..a.-1-tZ. Rule(s)Discussed: 

# (I



# I~)

**(C~~** ' 

## Written Materials? Yes/No 

# (;fA 

# huc:;J e:\' 

# pa»v- po ,,..-,.}t, 

## Name Organization Phone Number



# Y.l 0
- 

# S'£0

. tt:;;l/1



# J.(J")-



# ~L\- **:>uo~**

## Date: 

# 1t.J.o**~** 

# > 

# t..u \ y Meeting: Rule(s) Dis cussed : . 

# ll \**~)** Written Materials? Yes/No 

## Name Organizat ion Phone N urn ber 

# .J (J 

# K {If 

# /TPJ!fv "" 

# /15 £/}/- &z. 

# .%y**~** Zg/ 

# k fVW Cf/Lf_J£J1li/ I ( 

# r r**~~** 

# %"Y 06/;
{ 

# 1(6/ /J 

# /!!/-If 

# IIEY tr 

## 1 ( 

# I? IV I



# A-A/**Fi~5** 

# !fFIP 1 

## I 

## /I

..., 

# !low AlP/) 

# 1/rJH-ff/JJV / 

# />

# I;'~~ 

# //Pt;**//1/J~)J** 

# qy Lt9 

# , /1- L J 7 

# M,/**~ ~**  

## ..... 

# ,...., y , l v l 

## -/ 

# ffJ !/

# ~ 

# (7 

# r__;/J£5 f/ --v / 

# -Louisiana

- EPA Proposed
C0
2 Emission Rate
T r ajectory EPA Clean Power Plan 1,800 -r-------

- -- --

-
- --

- --- --- --

-
-
-
- --------- --- -- ---- --- • EPA assumes

a 54% reduction

in 1,600

I -P .,- ·-t ...

n

• •

.nau= Ill Gil !II .....
.. ..

I state Coal

- fired

& Oil/Gas Steam - .s;, 3: 1,400 **~** :a- - 1,200 ! "' a: c 0 1, 000 .iii en · - E LU N 0 u 800 600 2012
2014

20 1 6 2018
1,015 lb/MWh II' 2020

20 22 Year generation
by 2020 with that generation replaced
by other resources EPA Interim Goal* -2029 948

1 b/MWh 202 4 2026

3) 2028

20 3014001300-12ooI1,093lb/MWh........:91100-cu"'a:1000c0'Vi900"'EL&.lN8000u70060020122014Mississippi-EPAProposedC02EmissionRateTrajectoryEPACleanPowerPlanStateplaninplace2016201820202022Year*EPAassumeso100%reductioninstateCool-fired&Oil/GasSteamgenerationby2020withthatgenerationreplacedbyother*(2020-2029Average)7321b/MWh20242026202820302,0001,800-.J:3:1,600........c-1,400cua:c01,200.iiiEw1,000N0u8006002012Arkansas-EPAProposedC02EmissionRateReductionTrajectoryEPACleanPowerPlan1,634lb/MWh20142016StateplanInplace20181,0281b/MWh¥20202022Year"'EPAassumesa64%reductioninstateCoal-fired&Oil/GasSteamgenerationby2020withthatgenerationreplacedbyotherEPAInterimGoal*(2020-2029Average)9681b/MWh2024202620282030Carbon Dioxide (C0

2 ) Emission Reductions Required

in Arizona EPA Clean Power Proposal 1,800 .---- --

-

- -- --- -- -- --

-

- --- --- -- --- --

-

- Current (2012) Emissions 1,453 lb/MWh

EPA takes action on state plans 1,600 +-- -1-- --

- -- -----, JC..- --

- ----

- ---- --- ---

- - i 1,400 **~** :::::. **~** 1,200 s **~** ·- E ...... N
1 , 000 8 800 600 2012 2014 2016 2018

* EPA assumes
all in-state coal-fired generation will be replaced
by other generation resources by 2020 to meet Interim Goal EPA 2030 Goal 7021b/MWh

- 2020
EPA Interim Goal

• (2020-2029 Average) 7351b/MWh 2022 2024 2026 2028 2030

# Coalition for Innovative Climate Solutions Meeting with EPA , July 9, 2014 Baker Botts, LLP , 1299 Pennsylvania Ave. , N W Wa s hington DC 20004 

## In Person
NAME COMPANY BARR, Kelly J

. Salt River Project BARLOW, Chuck D. E ntergy BERGE, Megan Baker Botts LLP BUMPERS, Bill Baker Botts L LP EASTMAN, Renee Salt River Project HENDRICKS , Ray Portland General Electric HARMON, Shani Baker Botts LLP IHLE, Jack Xcel Energy
) 

## JEZOUIT, Debra Baker Botts LLP LOVELESS, Brad Westar MARTIN , Nicolas Xcel En ergy MASER, Gabe Baker Botts LLP MAYO , Kent Baker Botts L LP McQ UEE N, Kelly Entergy MONTALVO, Kara Salt River Project OTT , Katherine PPL PABLO, Jeanette PNM Resources REVLETT , Gary LGE-KU ROBERTSON , Dave Portland Genera l Electric

Active 1 6 29 6441 .1