02/19/201 0 13:57 FAX 2024335142 FAA + DMS 21001/00 7 

•/>";j. 

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D. C. 

Federal Aviation Administration, 

Complainant, 

Air Charter Inc., Respondent 

Respondent. 

W 

Ft,-.. 209 

•-'^ARma nr 

FAA Docket No. CP09SO0008 

DMSNo.FAA-2009^0100 

FAA Case No. 2008SO190254 

Judge Isaac D. Berkin 

OCKET 

e.r 

CT) 

- i " o 

cr5 

COMPLAINANT'S RESPONSE TO 

RESPONDENT'S NOTICE OF SATISFACTION OF CIVIL PENALTY 

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Complainant has appealed the decision in this 

matter. Exhibit 1, Therefore, Respondent's submission of a check in payment of the civil 

penally is premature. Exhibit 2. it is hereby rerarned with this filing pending a decision on 

the appeal. 

Respectfully submitted thiso?1 th day of January, 2010. 

GERAI.D A. ELLIS 

Attorney 

OfTice of the Regional Counsel 

w«« /f%. 

t\li«m^'^-rr^' Lm'A 1 TM JU»^ 

FEB - 2 2011 

HEAR'KJG DOCKET 
02/13/2010 13:57 FAX 2024335142 FAA + OMS @1002/007 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICR 

I hereby certify that the foregoing Complainant's Response To 

Respondent's Notice Of Satisfaction Of Civil Penalty has been sent by Federal Expres.^ (with 

returned check) to; 

Gabriel I. Penagaricano, Esq. 

120608 

PMB 239 

405 Ave., Esmeralda, Ste. 102 

Guaynabo, Puerto Rico 00969 

TEL: 787-287-9024 

FAX: (787) 731-0679 

And by Certified Mail to: 

Attention; Heariiif; Docket Clerk, 

AGC 430, Wilbur Wright Building - Suite 2WTOO0 

Federal Aviation Administration 

i{00 indcpeudence Avenue 

Washington, DC 20S9J 

0 JAweyf^ofo 

Dated 
02/13/2010 13:57 FAX 2024335142 FAA + DMS 0003/007 

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

DEPARl MENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D. C. 

-- r\\S 

Federal Aviation Administration, 

Complainant, 

vs. 

Air Charter Inc., 

Respondent. 

FAA Docket No. CP09SO0008 

DMS No. FAA-2009-0100 

FAA Case No. 2008SO190254 

Judge Isaac D. Bcnkin 

COMPLAINANT'S APPEAL OP INITIAL DECISION 

Pursuant to 14 C.F.R. §13-233 of the Rules of Practice, Complainant, by and 

through the undersigned counsel, hereby files this Notice of Appeal of the Adminislrative 

Law Judge's Initial Decision in this matter, served January 8, 2010, 

Respectfully .submitted this / S day of January, 2010. 

GERALD A. ELLIS 

Attorney 

Office of the Regional Counsel 

t\U'^ / 
02/13/2010 13:57 FAX 2024335142 FAA •> DMS 1004/007 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that the foregoing COMPLAINANT'S APPEAL OF INITIAL 

DECISION has been .sent by Certified Mail to: 

Attention: Hearing Docket Clerk, 

AGC 430, Wilbur Wright Building 

Federal Aviation Administration 

800 Independence Avenue 

Washington, DC 20591 

Suite 2W1000 

(original - certified) 

The Honorable Isaac D. Benkin 

DOT, Administrative Law Jiidye 

Office of Hearings, M-20 

1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE 

East Building Ground Floor 

.RoomE12-320 

Washington, DC 20590 

TEL: 202-366-0437 

FAX: 202-366-2132 

Gabriel I. Penagaricano, Esq. 

PMB 239 

405 Ave., Esmeralda, Ste. 102 

Guaynabo. Pueno Rico 00969 

TEI.: 787-287-9024 

FAX: (787) 731-0679 

U.S. Posial service p-^ 

CERTIFIED IVlAIL.;^]^ECEI^:prnvidpd , ) 

a 

ru 

m 

(T 

a 

• 

nalumR*M4plFM 

(F^MonanMnl R*qulr«d) 

neaiKclol Mluary F«a 

(Enaor»«m»nl RaqutneiJ) 

T O M KOS(S9B a FM S $ 

PDaimark 

Mere 

•Sow To 

SHKfr/Jficw:.""' 

arPOBatfe. 

"CiV:Sai«,"57fvi"" 

Am &^u ^ 

r l 
j 02/13/2010 13:57 FAX 2024335142 

! 

1 USPS - Track & Confirm 

UMTEDSTATE5 

POSTAL S£R\/KE.. 

FAA + DMS 121005/007 

Page 1 of 1 

Morn* 1 Help ) SIgnin 

Track & Confirm 

TrajC.k & Confirm FAQs 

Search Results 

Label/Receipt Number: 7009 2250 0003 1065 6017 

Service(s): Certified Mail'" 

Status: Ddlivftred 

Your item was delivered at 7:21 AM on January 21, 2010 in 

WASHINGTON, DC 20591. 

Triack & Confirm 

Enier Label/Receipt Niimber. 

Co^ 

Detailed Results: 

• DeHvered, January 21,2010.7:21 am, WASHINGTON, DC 20591 

• Arrival at Unit, January 21,2010, 6:44 am. WASHINGTON, DC 20022 

Notification OptiDf)^ 

Track & Confirm by email 

Get current event information or updates for your item sent Lo you or others by emali. ' Go ' 

Siir Man Customer S«rvie« Korm» Ctjv'l Scivip:!! dur^n IVivacy Policy Imrca i:' utr Huimeis C'-sisfie; Ca'.cwi; 

copyright© 7010 USPS- All RlghB Reserved. N^> Ih Al'i ACT FF O OflVf mi A 9 ^ 

/--2> 

http://trkcnfintnl.smi.usps.com/PTSIntemetWeb/InterLabelInquiry.do 1/27/2010 
02/13/2010 13:57 FAX 2024335142 

USPS - Track & Confimi 

UNITED STATES 

POSTAL SEnVKB^ 

FAA + DMS 0003/007 

Page 1 of 1 

Harne | Help | Sign In 

Track & Confirm 

TracI* & Confirm FAQs 

Search Results 

Label/Receipt Number: 7009 2250 0003 1065 5997 

Service(s): Certifiad Mail"" 

Status: Arrival at Unit 

Your Item arrived at 8:30 AM on January 16, 2010 in GUAYNABO, PR 

00968. Information, if available, is updated periodically throughout tfie 

day. Please check again later. 

Tracks ronlinn 

Enter Label/Receipt Number. 

Go> 

Notificplion Options 

Track & Confirm by email 

Get current event information or updates for your item sent to you or others by email. Go ; 

•''^^'7 ? . •-.-^ni.^r'jr-vrr fnrm;; Cipv't r.f:rvu:«i. CWK^IA J'rivscy r'O'lOV Irrmr. n: Use: ;^;;s'ni^s CI^luIFlfc,'IjJ^iewJiy 

Copyrlphcj,'2010 USPS. All Rights Reserved. No f LAK Acl LLCJ IJOto I' 01.-^ O ^ 

http://trkcnii-ml.smi.usps-com/PTSIntemctWeb/lnterLabelInquiry.do 1/27/2010 
02/19/2010 13:58 FAX 2024935142 

AIR CHARTER INC. 

AMF FACltmr P.O. BOX 8 J 0352 

CAROLINA, PUERTO RICO 00981-035? 

FAA + OMS 

O^ Banco 

4 y ^ Santonder Puerto Rico 

•UCUfUALWU i JUAN ' BAN JUAH . WliHTO MOD 

101 •234-215 

12007/007 

bb ro 

Memo: FAA Docket No. CP09SO0008 

Five Hundred Fift y and 00/10 0 Dollars 

PAY 

rO THF 

ORDEfl Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 

^^ 8 00 Iridependenc e Avenue, S.W, 

Wilmington , DC 20591 

[JSA 

Jan 14, 2010 *****S550.00 

DATt AMOUNT 

Duplicat e 

I 

f 

J 

MJTMOfllZEO SlGr4Al URE 

ii'OOEi6 7 5ii' i:0 2l50E3i,li ; 30 0 3 B TRfi 7 5'i' 

-Ji 

NOTICE OF SATlSJACTIQ>vI OF C"VTL -PENALTY 

COMES NOW Respondent in the case an caption and by his 

undersigne.J respectfully informs it has fu'^filied the civil penalty 

levied arje.inst it by tranftmi tt ir.q to Ccr.-.plainant a copy of this 

notice, to which it has attached a check in accord and satisfaction 

of the afore-gaid penalty. 

RESPFCTFULLY SUBMITTED, 

In Guaynabo, P.R., thi.-i 18 • day of January, 2010. 

I cer-;;ify that before filing -.he above, a copy hereof was this 

day mailed with posrage fully prepa::.d thereon T:O Gerald A. Ellis, 

Esq., to his address of record. 

'mm 

At^<'ft ^0 ^ 

ihP^. RffilONAl COUNSEL 

GABRIEL I. PENAGARICANO 

120608 

FMB 239 

^.05 Ave. Esmeralda, Ste. 102 

Guaynabo, P.R. 00969 

287-9024 , Fax. 731-067 9 

gi?-?l.<534 3r.oT:mail.com 

/x-/?- •/ / ^