Board Meeting Comments Log 

Send Us Your Board Item Comments

Below is the Comment Log for State Implementation Plan (sip07). 

# Received From Subject Comment

Period

Date/Time 

Added to 

Database

Additional 

Form 

Letters 

or 

Attachments

1 

Newell, Brent , 

Center on Race, 

Poverty & the 

Environmen

Comments on 

Proposed Pesticide 

Strategy and 

Revision to 1994 

Ozone SIP for 

Ventura County 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-12 

16:03:11 

Attachment

2 

OvermyerVelazquez, 

Rebecca, North 

Whittier 

Neighborhood 

Watch

Air Pollution Health 

Crisis 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-13 

09:53:39 

3 Trevino, Rene, 

Dept. of the Navy

Comments on 2007 

Ozone SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-13 

12:36:37 

Attachment

4 Martinez, 

Adriano, NRDC 2007 SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-13 

14:36:32 

Attachment

5 

Kegley, Susan, 

Pesticide Action 

Network North 

America

Pesticide Inventory Non-Reg 

2007-06-14 

06:33:05 

6 

Fratz, Doug , 

Consumer 

Specialty 

Products 

Proposed State 

Strategy for 

California’s 2007 

SIP; Board Agenda 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-19 

10:16:48 

Attachment
Association Item # 07-7-7 

7 

Wohlmuth, John , 

Coachella Valley 

Assocl of Govts

Delayed Adoption of 

the AQMD's AQMP Non-Reg 

2007-06-19 

15:20:49 

Attachment

8 Elliott, Phyllis, 

Please reduce air 

pollution 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-19 

15:38:59 

1

9 

Anderson, 

Megan, STA in 

NC

Comments on State 

Strategy 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-20 

11:30:45 

Attachment

10

Tomlinson, Rick , 

California 

Strawberry 

Commission

Appendix H: 

Amendment of SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-20 

11:41:56 

Attachment

11

Irvin, Joe, CA 

Ethanol Vehicle 

Coalition

SIP Revision - and 

Stage II ORVR 

waiver 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-20 

13:12:28 

Attachment

12

Pohle, Timothy , 

Air Transport 

Association of 

America

ATA Comments on 

Draft California 

Proposed State 

Strategy for the State 

Implementation Plan 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-20 

15:45:52 

Attachment

13 Kubsh, Joe, 

MECA

MECA comments on 

the 2007 California 

SIP 

Non-Reg 

2007-08-14 

11:38:54 

Attachment

14 Ochoa, Evelina, 

Take action to 

protect farm workers 

in the nation's 

smoggiest town 

Non-Reg 

2007-08-27 

11:17:44 

165

Attachment

15

Chapman, Rev. 

Janet, First 

Christian Church

State Strategy for the 

CA State 

Implementation Plan 

Non-Reg 

2007-08-30 

10:41:37 

Attachment

16

Cedillo, Gilbert, 

22nd Senate 

District

State Strategy for the 

CA State 

Implementation Plan 

Non-Reg 

2007-08-30 

14:09:07 

Attachment

17 Klein, Meredith, 

Pillsbury 

2007 AQM Plan for 

attaining the federal Non-Reg 

2007-09-20 

11:40:53 

Attachment
Winthrop Shaw 

Pittman

8-hour Ozone and 

PM 2.5 Standards 

18 Green, Peter, 

Univ Calif, Davis

In favor of Appendix 

H Non-Reg 

2007-09-24 

13:41:44 

19 Franken, 

Laurence , 

Proposed regulation 

to limit ozone 

emissions from 

indoor air cleaning 

devices 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-24 

15:36:25 

Attachment

20

Wiens, Lloyd, 

Friends of the 

Grapevine

So. San Joaquin 

Valley Air Quality 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-25 

07:30:42 

21 Holmes, Colin, Vote for cleaner air Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

09:37:12 

22

Shinault, Tom, 

Director of 

Environmentql 

Affairs

Please approve SIP 

and PM2.5 and come 

to our celebration 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

10:55:37 

23 Fratz, D. 

Douglas, CSPA

Comments on Board 

Items #07-7-7 and 

07-9-4 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

11:03:46 

Attachment

24 Wright, Gregory, 

Agenda Item # 07-9-

4 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

11:13:01 

Attachment

25

Warren, 

Elizabeth , 

FuturePorts

Agenda Item # 07-9-

4 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

11:39:08 

Attachment

26

Barr, Michael, 

Pillsbury 

Winthrop Shaw 

Pittman LLP

COMMENTS ON 

PROPOSED 

FUNDING 

REQUEST TO 

OFFSET 

LOCOMOTIVE 

EMISSIONS IN SIP 

Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

11:51:51 

Attachment

27

Schrap, Matthew, 

California 

Trucking 

Association

SIP Comments Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

11:55:01 

Attachment
28

Pohle, Timothy, 

Air Transport 

Association of 

America

ATA Comments on 

Revised SIP Proposal Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

12:00:29 

Attachment

29

thomas, william, 

Best Best & 

Krieger LLP

Comment Letter re 

Item 07-7-7 Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

12:04:10 

Attachment

30

Wiens, Lloyd, 

Friends of the 

Grapevine

Dairy Applications & 

Project EIRS Non-Reg 

2007-09-26 

14:49:49 

Comments posted to sip07 that were presented during the Board Hearing:

# Received From Subject Comment

Period

Date/Time 

Added to 

Database

Additional 

Form 

Letters 

or 

Attachments

1 

Warmerdam, 

Mary-Ann, 

Dept. of 

Pesticide 

Regulation

Appendix H: 

Pesticide Element of 

the 1994 Ozone SIP 

for the Ventura Co. 

Nonattainment Area 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

13:57:15 

Attachment

2 Wu, Frances, 

CTFA

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

13:58:20 

Attachment

3 

Wilhelm, Steve, 

Niklor Chemical 

Co., Inc.

Proposed Strategy for 

CA's 2007 SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:00:09 

Attachment

4 Hogo, Henry, 

SCAQMD

SCAQMD Staff 

Comments on the 

Proposed State 

Strategy for the CA 

SIP for the Federal 8-

Hour 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:01:21 

Attachment

5 Chang, Elaine, 

SCAQMD

SCAQMD Staff 

Comments on the 

Proposed State 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:03:47 

Attachment
Strategy for the CA 

SIP 

6 Messina, 

Barbara, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:07:26 

Attachment

7 Messina, 

Barbara, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:08:16 

Attachment

8 Campbell, Todd, 

Clean Energy

Todd R. Campbell's 

Testimony before 

CARB on behalf of 

Clean Energy 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:16:13 

Attachment

9 

Lange, Travis , 

City of Santa 

Clarita

Proposed State 

Strategy for the CA 

SIP for the Federal 8-

Hour Ozone & PM 

2.5 Standards 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:18:09 

Attachment

10

Beeson, Larry, 

Loma Linda 

University

Loma Linda Univ. 

Adventist Health and 

Smog (AHSMOG) 

Study 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:25:15 

Attachment

11

Hansberger, 

Dennis, 

SANBAG

Proposed State 

Strategy for SIPOzone and PM 2.5 

Standards 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:34:24 

Attachment

12 Fratz, Douglas, 

CSPA

Draft ARB's 

Proposed State 

Strategy for CA's 

2007 SIP 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:35:44 

Attachment

13

Schilling, Ty, 

San Bernadino 

Assoc. 

Governments

Proposed State 

Strategy for SIPOzone and PM 2.5 

Standards 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:36:46 

Attachment

14

Murai, Mark, 

CA Strawberry 

Commission

Comments on the 

2007 SIP-Appendix 

H 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:38:00 

Attachment

15 Wuebben, Paul, 

SCAQMD

Testimony of the 

SCAQMD on the 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:39:25 

Attachment
ARB Proposed State 

Strategy for the CA 

SIP 

16 Miyasato, Matt, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:40:25 

Attachment

17 Beltran, Mario, 

RC Comments 

Before CARB Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:43:42 

Attachment

18

Field, Erin, 

Western 

Growers

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:44:27 

Attachment

19

Pascaul, Romel, 

Env. Ofc. of 

Mayor Antonio 

Villaraigosa

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP 

Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:49:37 

Attachment

20 Trautman, 

Diane, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

14:50:28 

Attachment

21 Cattell, Sandra, 

Sierra Club

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:00:05 

Attachment

22 Martinez, Nury, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:01:46 

Attachment

23 Barnett, Donna, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:04:53 

Attachment

24 Maslow, Sally, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:05:40 

Attachment

25 Barajas, Marisol, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:06:34 

Attachment

26 Romo, Cynthia , 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:07:06 

Attachment
27

Leon, Rey, 

Latino Issues 

Forum

Comments on 2007 

SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-28 

15:08:39 

Attachment

28 S., George, 

New State Strategy 

for the CA SIP Non-Reg 

2007-06-29 

09:09:25 

Attachment

29 Burke, William, 

SCAQMD

Proposed State 

Strategy for the CA 

SIP for the Federal 8-

Hour Ozone & PM 

2.5 Standards 

Non-Reg 

2007-07-02 

14:20:39 

Attachment

30 Paukovits, 

Jason, 

San Joaquin Valley 

Regional Planning 

Agencies' Director 

Committee 

2007-10-09 

12:45:32 

Attachment

31 Wallace, Lee, 

Statement of Souther 

California Gas Co. 

and San Diego Gas 

and Electric Co. 

2007-10-09 

13:09:28 

Attachment

32 Pascual, Romel, 

Statement Submitted 

from Romel Pascual 

2007-10-09 

13:47:09 

Attachment

33 Logan, Angelo, 

East Yard 

Communities for 

Enviornmental 

Justice 

2007-10-09 

13:55:13 

Attachment

34 Edgar, Sean, 

Testimony of Sean R. 

Edgar reguarding 

agenda item 07--9-4 

2007-10-09 

14:02:30 

Attachment

35 Martinez, 

Adriano, 

Comments on South 

Coast Air Quality 

Management Plan 

2007-10-09 

14:21:56 

Attachment

36 Sauer, Eric , 

California Trucking 

Association 

Comment 

2007-10-09 

14:28:36 

Attachment

37 Miller, John, 

Comments of John 

Miller for Hearing of 

"Marine Vessel 

2007-10-09 

14:59:09 

Attachment
Emission Reguction 

Act of 20007" 

38 McVaigh, Rick, 

The San Joaquin 

Valley Air Pollution 

Control District 

Comment on 07-7-7 

2007-10-09 

15:22:24 

Attachment

39 Peters, Charlie, 

Charlie Peters of 

CAPP on 07-7-7 

2007-10-09 

16:09:21 

Attachment

40 Newell, Brent , 

Brent Newell 

Comment on 07-7-7 

2007-10-09 

16:15:40 

Attachment

41 Robles, Enrique, 

Ernrique Robles 

Comment on 07-7-7 

2007-10-09 

16:19:37 

Attachment

We expect that any written comments received during the Board Hearing will be posted 

within one week of the Board Hearing. 

Compilation of all printable comments for sip07 

If you have any questions or comments please contact COTB at (916) 322-5594. 

Board Meeting Comment Logs

Send Us Your Board Item Comments

 

Back to Top | All ARB Contacts | A–Z Index 

Decisions Pending and Opportunities for Public Participation

Conditions of Use | Privacy Policy

How to Request Public Records 

The Board is one of five boards, departments, and offices under 

the umbrella of the California Environmental Protection Agency. 

Cal/EPA | ARB | DPR | DTSC | OEHHA | SWRCB