02/19/201 0 13:5 7 FAX 202433514 2 FA A + DM S 21001/00 7

•/>";j . UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D . C . Federa l Aviatio n Administration , Complainant ,

Air Charter Inc. , Responden t Respondent . 

### W Ft,-. . 20 9 

## •-'^ARm an r

FAA Docke t

No . CP09SO000 8 DMSNo.FAA-2009^010 0 FA A Cas e No . 2008SO19025

4 Judg e Isaa c D . Berki n 

## OCKE T

e. r CT )

- i " o cr 5

COMPLAINANT' S RESPONS E T O RESPONDENT' S NOTIC E O FSATISFACTIO N O FCIVI LPENALT Y PLEAS ETAKENOTIC Ethat th e Complainant

ha s appeale dth e decisio n i n thi s matter . Exhibi t

1 , Therefore , Respondent' s submissio n o f achec k in paymen t

o f th e civi l penally i s premature . Exhibi t 2 . i t i s hereb y rerarne dwit

hthi s filing pendin g adecisio n o n the appeal . Respectfully submitte dthiso? 1 t hda y o f January , 2010 .

GERAI. D A . ELLI S Attorney OfTic e o f th e Regiona

l Counse l w« « /f% . t\li«m^'^-rr^ ' Lm' A 1 TM JU» ^ 

### FE B - 2 201 1 

## HEAR'KJ G DOCKE T02/13/201 0 13:5 7 FA X 202433514 2 FA A+ OM S @1002/00 7

CERTIFICATE O FSERVIC R I hereb y certif

y that th e foregoin g Complainant' s Respons e T o Respondent' s Notic e O f

Satisfactio n O f

Civi l Penalt

y ha s bee n sent

b y Federa l Expres. ^ (wit h returne dcheck) to ; Gabrie l I . Penagaricano , Esq . 12060 8 PM B 23 9 40 5 Ave. , Esmeralda , Ste . 10 2 Guaynabo , Puert o Ric o 0096 9 TEL : 787-287-902 4 FAX : (787 ) 731-067 9 Andby Certifie dMai l to : Attention ; Heariiif ; Docke t Clerk , AG C 430 , Wilbu r

Wrigh t Buildin g - Suit e 2WTOO 0 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n i{0 0 indcpeudenc e Avenu e Washington , D C 20S9J 

## 0 JAweyf^of o Date d02/13/201 0 13:5 7 FA X 202433514 2 FA A + DM S 0003/00 7

UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A DEPAR l MEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D . C . 

# -

- 

# r\\ S

Federa l Aviatio n Administration , Complainant , vs . Ai r Charter Inc. , Respondent . FA A Docket No . CP09SO000 8 DM S No . FAA-2009-010 0 FA ACase No . 2008SO19025 4 Judg e Isaa c D . Bcnki n

COMPLAINANT' S APPEA LO PINITIA LDECISIO N Pursuan t t o 1 4 C.F.R . §13-23 3 o f

th e Rule s o f

Practice , Complainant , b y and throughthe undersigne dcounsel , hereb y files thi s Notic e o f Appea l o f th e Adminislrativ e La w Judge' s Initia

l Decisio n i

n thi s matter , serve dJanuar y 8 , 2010 , Respectfully .submittedthi s / S da y of January , 2010 .

GERAL D A . ELLI S Attorney Office o f th e Regiona

l Counsel 

# t\U' ^ /02/13/201 0 13:5 7 FA X 202433514 2 FA A • > DM S 1004/00 7

CERTIFICATE OFSERVIC E I hereb y certif

y tha t th e foregoin g COMPLAINANT' S APPEALO FINITIAL DECISIO N ha s been .sen

t b y Certifie dMail to : Attention : Hearin g Docket Clerk , AGC 430 , Wilbur

Wright Buildin g Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 800 Independenc e Avenu e Washington , D C 2059 1 Suit e 2W100 0 (original - certified )

Th e Honorabl e Isaac D . Benki n DOT , Administrativ e La

w Jiidy e Offic e o f Hearings , M-2 0 1200 New Jerse y Avenue , S E Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloo r .RoomE12-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 TEL : 202-366-043 7 FAX : 202-366-213 2 Gabrie l I . Penagaricano , Esq . PMB 23 9 40 5 Ave. , Esmeralda , Ste . 10 2 Guaynabo . Puen o Ric o 0096 9 TEI. : 787-287-902 4 FAX : (787 ) 731-067 9 U.S . Posia l servic e p-^ CERTIFIE D IVlAIL.;^]^ECEI^: , prnvidpd )

a r u m ( T a • nalumR*M4plF M (F^MonanMn l R*qulr«d ) neaiKclo l Mluar yF« a (Enaor»«m»n l RaqutneiJ ) T O M KOS(S9 B a FM S $ PDaimar k Mere

•So w T o SHKfr/Jficw:."" ' arPOBatfe . "CiV:Sai«,"57fvi" " 

## A m &^u ^ 

# r lj 02/13/201 0 13:5 7 FA X 202433514 2 ! 1 USP S - Track

& Confir m UMTEDSTATE 5 POSTA L S£R\/KE. . FA A + DM S 121005/00 7

Pag e 1 o f 1 Morn * 1 Hel p ) SIgni n 

## Trac k & Confir m TrajC. k & Confir m FAQ s Searc h Result s Label/Receip t Number : 700 9 225 0 000 3 106 5 601 7 Service(s) : Certifie d Mail' " Status : Ddlivftre d You rite m wa s delivere d a t 7:2 1 A M o n Januar y21 , 201 0 i n WASHINGTON , D C 20591 . Triac k & Confir m Enie rLabel/Receipt Niimber . Co^ Detaile d Results : • DeHvered , Januar y21,2010.7:2 1 am , WASHINGTON , D C 2059 1 • Arriva l a t Unit , Januar y21,2010 , 6:4 4 am . WASHINGTON , D C 2002 2 Notificatio n OptiDf) ^ Trac k & Confir m b yemai l Ge t curren t even t informatio n o rupdate s fo ryou rite m sen t L o yo u o rothers byemali . ' G o '

Sii rMa n Custome rS«rvie « Korm » Ctjv' l Scivip:! ! dur^ n IVivac yPolic yImrc a i: ' ut rHuimei s C'-sisfie ; Ca'.cwi ; copyright ©

701 0 USPS - Al l Rlgh B Reserved . N^ > I h Al' i AC

TFF O OflV

f mi A9 ^



### /--2 > http://trkcnfintnl.smi.usps.com/PTSIntemetWeb/InterLabelInquiry.d o 1/27/201 002/13/201 0 13:5 7 FA X 202433514 2 USP S - Trac k

& Confim i UNITE D STATE S POSTA L SEnVKB

^ FA A + DM S 0003/00 7 Pag e 1 of 1 Harn e | Help | Sig n I

n 

## Trac k & Confir m TracI * & Confir m FAQ s Searc h Result s Label/Receip t Number : 700 9 225 0 000 3 106 5 599 7 Service(s) : Certifia d Mail" " Status : Arriva l a t Uni t You rIte m arrive d a t 8:3 0 A M o n Januar y16 , 201 0 i n GUAYNABO , P R 00968 . Information , i f available , i s update d periodicall ythroughou t tfi e day . Pleas e chec k

agai n later . Track s ronlin n Ente rLabel/Receipt Number . Go> Notificplio n Option s Trac k & Confir m b yemai l Ge t curren t even t informatio n o rupdate s fo ryou rite m sen t t o yo u o rother s b yemail . G o ;

•''^^'7 ? . •-.-^ni.^r'jr-vr rfnrm; ; Cipv' t r.f:rvu:«i . CWK^I AJ'rivsc y r'O'lO V Irrmr . n : Use : ;^;;s'ni^ s CI^luIFlfc,'IjJ^iewJi y Copyrlphcj,'201 0 USPS. Al l Right s Reserved . N

o f LA KAc l LLC J IJOt o I ' 01.- ^ O ^

http://trkcnii-ml.smi.usps-com/PTSIntemctWeb/lnterLabelInquiry.d o 1/27/201 002/19/201 0 13:5 8 FA X 202493514 2 AI R CHARTE R INC . AM F FACltm rP.O . BO X 8 J 035 2 CAROLINA , PUERT O RIC O 00981-035 ? FA A + OM S O ^ Banco 4 y ^ Santonde r Puert o Ric o •UCUfUALWU i JUA N ' BA N JUAH . WliHT O MO D 10 1 •234-21 5 12007/00 7 

### b b r o

Memo : FA

A Docke t

No . CP09SO000 8 Fiv e Hundre dFift y an d00/10 0 Dollar s PA Y r O TH F ORDEf l Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n ^ ^ 8 0 0 Iridependenc e Avenue , S.W ,

Wilmington , D

C 2059 1 [JSA Ja n 14 , 201 0 *****S550.0 0 DATt AMOUN T Duplicat e I f 

### J

MJTMOfllZE O SlGr4A l UR E ii'OOEi 6 7 5ii ' i: 0 2l50E3i,li ; 30 0 3 B TRf i 7 5'i ' -J i NOTIC E O F SATlSJACTIQ>vI O F C"VT L -PENALT Y COME S NO W Responden t i n th e cas e an captio n and byhi s undersigne. J respectfull yinform s i t ha s fu'^filied th e civi l penalt y levie d arje.inst i t b ytranftm

i t t ir. qt o Ccr.-.plainan t a copyo f thi s notice , t o whic h i t ha s attache d a chec k i n accor d an d satisfactio n o f th e afore-gai d penalty . RESPFCTFULL Y SUBMITTED , I n Guaynabo , P.R. , thi.- i 1 8 • dayo f January , 2010 . I cer-;;if

ytha t befor e filin g -.h e above , a cop yhereo f wa s thi s da ymaile d wit h posrag e full yprepa::. d thereo n T: O Geral d A . Ellis , Esq. , t o hi s addres s o f record . 

# 'm m At^<'f t ^0 ^

ihP^ . RffilONA l COUNSE L GABRIE L I . PENAGARICAN O 12060 8 FMB 23 9 ^.0 5 Ave . Esmeralda , Ste . 10 2 Guaynabo , P.R . 0096 9 287-9024 , Fax . 731-067 9 gi?-?l.<534 3r.oT:mail.com 

### /x-/? - • / / ^