Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-4_05-cv-02275/USCOURTS-cand-4_05-cv-02275-13/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 890
Nature of Suit: Other Statutory Actions
Cause of Action: 28:1331 Fed. Question

---

!"#$ 

$#%&"%''( 

)(

*+*,
+ 	 # 	!)#-#

./01/0#"%/&2!"#$

!'!&-#&"(

	 

 	
+

	 ,+

	/ 

	

		

	

 

	

 
		
	

	

#"!3 10%$ 

%4!3 3 #4

$#.!3 /50"0//4  "6$//0

5-7!3 /&/0#8$! 69$$%(  #4%$"/&

6%( "%15$#"%/& %( !&"!0!- %&"/ 89#&- 8!":!!& ./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( #&- "6%0-

1#0"91$#%&"%''( *+*9("!4( &. #&- 4&%10/ &./01/0#"!- ;./$$!."%)!$9

<./5&"!0.$#%4#&"(<= /& "6! /&! 6#&- #&- ./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( #"##0> &. #&-

&"!0"!.6&/4%.( &. #&- "6%0- 1#0"9-!'!&-#&""!)! #0#$#48%!:;./$$!."%)!$9

*
*,	  
? ;@	 =

	
 ,	

A		

B
*
	
 

 0!4/&""0!!" 5%"! 

#& 0#&.%(./ 

!$!16/&!3 

#.(%4%$!3 

""/0&!9( '/0 /5&"!0-!'!&-#&"(

#"##0> &. #&- &"!0"!.6&/4%.( &.

#&- 6%0-#0"9!'!&-#&""!)! #0#$#48%!:

  
C	
 
? ;@	 =

+@D 

 0/&""0!!"

#& 0#&.%(./ #$%'/0&%# 

!$!16/&!3 

#.(%4%$!3 

""/0&!9( '/0 /5&"!0.$#%4#&"( #&- 6%0-

#0"9$#%&"%''( *+*9("!4( &. #&-

4&%10/ &./01/0#"!-

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 83 Filed 03/30/06 Page 1 of 6

	 	 

	  

<./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"(<= /& "6! /"6!0 6#&- "60/576"6!%0 0!(1!."%)! ./5&(!$

6%( "%15$#"%/& %( 4#-! :%"60!'!0!&.! "/ "6! '/$$/:%&7'#."(3

 & 	/)!48!0   ./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( '%$!- #& 4!&-!-

/5&"!0.$#%4 #7#%&(""6! ./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( 150(5#&""/ # ("%15$#"%/& 89#&- 8!":!!&

"6! 1#0"%!( ;<<=

@ 6!  #((!0"( # .$#%4 '/0 &'#%0 /41!"%"%/& 150(5#&""/

#$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/.!((%/&( /-! !."%/&  ;<%0("$#%4 '/0 !$%!'<= #&-

'/0 )%/$#"%/&( /'#$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/'!((%/&( /-! !."%/&(   #&-

#$%'/0&%# !&#$/-! !."%/&  ;<!./&- $#%4 '/0 !$%!'<=

 6! %0("$#%4 '/0 !$%!'%( 8#(!- %& 1#0" /& #& #$$!7#"%/& %&

1#0#70#16;#= '/0 )%/$#"%/& /'#$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/'!((%/&( /-! !."%/& 

#&- #$%'/0&%# !&#$/-! !."%/&  #&- "6! !./&- $#%4 '/0 !$%!'%( 8#(!- %& 1#0" 

/& #)!04!&"( %& "6!  #"1#0#70#16(  #&- 

 6!  #$(/ %&.$5-!( %& %"( 10#9!0 '/0 0!$%!' #4/&7/"6!0 0!$%!'3 %&

1#0#70#16 <./41!&(#"/09-#4#7!(< 150(5#&""/ #$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/'!((%/&(

/-! !."%/& 2%& 1#0#70#16 "6! 0!'!0!&.! "/ #$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/'!((%/&(

/-! !."%/&  #&- "6! :/0-( <#&- 4#>%&7(!.0!"1#94!&"(<2%& 1#0#70#16 "6!

0!'!0!&.! "/ #$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/'!((%/&( /-! !."%/& 2#&- %& 1#0#70#16

 '/0 "0!8$! -#4#7!( 150(5#&""/ #$%'/0&%# @5(%&!(( #&- 0/'!((%/&( /-! !."%/&

  #&- '/0 0!#(/&#8$! #""/0&!9(E '!!(

 /0 "6! ./&)!&%!&.! /'"6! /50"#&- "6! 1#0"%!( "6! #$$!7#"%/&( %&

"6!  #"1#0#70#16(   ;#= "6! !./&- $#%4 '/0 !$%!'#&- "6! 1#0"( /'

./5&"!0.$#%4#&"(E 10#9!0 '/0 0!$%!'-!(.0%8!- %& 1#0#70#16 #8/)! #0! 0!'!00!- "/ 6!0!%&

#( "6! <--%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4(<

 & #&5#09  ./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( '%$!- # 	/"%.! /'+/"%/&

#&- +/"%/& ! $#%&"%''#&- /5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( #"#1#0> &. #&- &"!0"!.6&/4%.( 

&. #&- 6%0- #0"9!'!&-#&""!)! #0#$#48%!:E(3 ;= +/"%/& "/ %(4%(( 50(5#&""/

!-!0#$5$! /'%)%$0/.!-50! ;8=;= #&- ;= +/"%/& "/ "0%>! 50(5#&""/ !-!0#$

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 83 Filed 03/30/06 Page 2 of 6

	 	 

	  

5$! /'%)%$0/.!-50! ;'= ;<+/"%/&( ! 4!&-!- /5&"!0.$#%4(<=

* & !805#09  ./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( '%$!- #&- (!0)!- "6!%0

11/(%"%/& "/ "6! +/"%/&( ! 4!&-!- /5&"!0.$#%4(

 6! 6!#0%&7'/0 "6! +/"%/&( ! 4!&-!- /5&"!0.$#%4( %( (!"'/0

6!#0%&7/& 10%$ 

 /5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( #&- ./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( ;!#.60!'!00!- "/ 6!0!%& #(

# <#0"9< #&- ./$$!."%)!$9#( "6! <#0"%!(<= &/::%(6"/ !&"!0 %&"/ # ("%15$#"%/& "/ 0!(/$)!

.!0"#%& .$#%4( (!"/5"%& "6! /5&"!0.$#%4 #&- "6! +/"%/&( ! 4!&-!- /5&"!0.$#%4(

@9"6%( "%15$#"%/& "6! #0"%!( :%(6"/ !''!.""6! :%"6-0#:#$/'"6! +/"%/&( ! 4!&-!-

/5&"!0.$#%4( :%"6/5"10!F5-%.! #( "/ "6! 4!0%"( # )/$5&"#09-%(4%((#$:%"610!F5-%.! /'

"6! --%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4( #&- # ("%15$#"%/& "6#"./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( 4#9

10/41"$9'%$! # (!./&- #4!&-!- ./5&"!0.$#%4 "6#"%( (58("#&"%)!$9%-!&"%.#$"/ "6! 

:%"6/5"#((!0"%/& /'"6! --%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4( #&- #70!!4!&"89

./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( &/""/ #((!0" %'#"#$$ #7#%&("./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( 4&%4!G #$!&"%&

*!/07%!) 0#(%4%0 */(1/-%&/)#&- H)!"#& +%>/) /0 #&9/'"6!4 #&9.$#%4 .#5(! /'

#."%/& -!4#&- %& #&9./50"/0 "0%85&#$"6#"1!0"#%&( %& #&9:#9"/ "6! (58F!."/'/0

#((!0"%/& /'"6! --%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4( 5&"%$"!04%&#"%/& /'"6%( ."%/& 

%&.$5-%&7"6! ./41$#%&"#&- ./5&"!0.$#%4 89'%&#$F5-74!&" %&.$5-%&7#$$#11!#$( 

(!""$!4!&"/0 %& #&9/"6!0 4#&&!0

	D 

 "6! #0"%!( #70!! #( '/$$/:(3

 6%( "%15$#"%/& %( !&"!0!- %&"/ 150(5#&""/ !-!0#$5$!( /'

)%-!&.! 5$!  #&- #$%'/0&%# 
)%-!&.! /-! !."%/&  #&- (6#$$&/"8!

#-4%((%8$! %& '!-!0#$/0 #$%'/0&%# ./50"( /0 #&9/"6!0 "0%85&#$/0 #08%"0#$10/.!!-%&7'/0

#&91501/(! !G.!1""/ "6! !G"!&"&!.!((#09"/ 10/)! "6! !G%("!&.! /'"6%( "%15$#"%/& 

%&.$5-%&785"&/"$%4%"!- "/ #&9%((5! #0%(%&7'0/4 "6! #11$%.#8$! ("#"5"! /'$%4%"#"%/&(

&-!0 &/ .%0.54("#&.!( (6#$$!%"6!0 #0"95(! "6%( "%15$#"%/& &/0 8! 1!04%""!- "/ 5(!

"6%( "%15$#"%/& "/ 10/)! /0 -%(10/)! $%#8%$%"9 %'$%#8%$%"9%( $#"!0 #$$!7!- 89!%"6!0 #0"9 

!G.!1"%& /11/(%"%/& /0 #( # -!'!&(! "/ #&9.$#%4 4#-! %& )%/$#"%/& /'"6! "!04( /'"6%(

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 83 Filed 03/30/06 Page 3 of 6

	 	 

	  

"%15$#"%/&

 1/& !G!.5"%/& /'"6%( "%15$#"%/& ./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( (6#$$10/41"$9

'%$! # /$5&"#09%(4%((#$D%"60!F5-%.! /'"6! --%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4(

150(5#&""/ !-!0#$5$!( /'%)%$0/.!-50! ;#=;= #&- #$$'#."5#$#$$!7#"%/&( 7%)%&7

0%(! "6!0!"/

 /5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( /& "6!%0 /:& 8!6#$'#&- /& 8!6#$'/'"6!%0

0!(1!."%)! 1#0!&"./41#&%!( (58(%-%#0%!( #&- #''%$%#"!- ./41#&%!( 1#("#&- 10!(!&"

/''%.!0( -%0!."/0( (6#0!6/$-!0( 10%&.%1#$( !41$/9!!( 10!-!.!((/0( (5..!((/0( 

#""/0&!9( #7!&"( #&- #((%7&( %&-%)%-5#$$9#&- ./$$!."%)!$9 #&- !#.6/'"6!4 6!0!89

#70!! "6#"!#.6(6#$$&/"#((!0" %'#"#$$ #7#%&("./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( 4&%4!G +!((0(

*!/07%!) */(1/-%&/)#&- +%>/)/0 #&9/'"6!4 #&9.$#%4 .#5(!( /'#."%/& -!4#&- %&

#&9./50"/0 "0%85&#$"6#"1!0"#%&( %& #&9:#9"/ "6! (58F!."/'/0 #((!0"%/& /'"6!

--%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4( 5&"%$"6! "!04%&#"%/& /'"6%( ."%/& %&.$5-%&78/"6

"6! ./41$#%&"#&- ./5&"!0.$#%4 89'%&#$F5-74!&" %&.$5-%&7#$$#11!#$( /0 89

(!""$!4!&"/0 %& #&9/"6!0 4#&&!0 /5&"!0.$#%4#&"( 4&%4!G +!((0( *!/07%!) 

*/(1/-%&/)#&- +%>/)(6#$$&/"80%&7#&9.$#%4( .#5(!( /'#."%/& -!4#&-( %& #&9

./50"/0 "0%85&#$#7#%&("./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( '/0 0!./)!09/'#&9#""/0&!9(E '!!( /0 ./("( /0

#&9/"6!0 .$#%4 "6#"1!0"#%&( "/ "6! (58F!."4#""!0 /'/0 "6! +/"%/& "/ %(4%(( "6!

--%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4( /:!)!0 &/"6%&76!0!%& (6#$$10!.$5-!

./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( 4&%4!G +!((0( *!/07%!) */(1/-%&/)#&- +%>/)'0/4 #((!0"%&7

#&9-!'!&(!( "/ #&9.$#%4( .#5(! /'#."%/& -!4#&-( #((!0"!- 89./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( "6#"

1!0"#%& %& #&9:#9"/ "6! (58F!."/'/0 #((!0"%/& /'"6! --%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!-

/5&"!0.$#%4(

 /5&"!0.$#%4#&"( (6#$$6#)! "!& ;= -#9( '/$$/:%&7"6! !G!.5"%/& /'

"6%( "%15$#"%/& "/ '%$! # (!./&- #4!&-!- ./41$#%&""6#"%( (58("#&"%)!$9%-!&"%.#$"/ "6!

#4!&-!- ./5&"!0.$#%4 !G.!1"'/0 -!$!"%/& /'"6! --%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4(

;<!./&- 4!&-!- /5&"!0.$#%4< /0 <<= /5&"!0.$#%4#&"( (6#$$&/"&/:#((!0"%&

"6!%0  &/0 !)!0 0!#((!0"#&9--%"%/&#$$9!$!#(!- /5&"!0.$#%4 8#(!- /& #&9

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 83 Filed 03/30/06 Page 4 of 6

	 	 

	  

#."%)%"%!( /0 ./&-5."/'./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( /0 #&9/'"6!%0 1#0!&"( (58(%-%#0%!( #''%$%#"!-

./41#&%!( 1#("#&- 10!(!&"/''%.!0( -%0!."/0( (6#0!6/$-!0( 10%&.%1#$( !41$/9!!( 

10!-!.!((/0( #""/0&!9( %&(50!0( #&- #7!&"( %&-%)%-5#$$9/0 ./$$!."%)!$9 /..500%&710%/0

"/ #&- %&.$5-%&7"6! -#"! /'"6%( "%15$#"%/& 0/)%-!- "6#"./5&"!0.$#%4#&"( "%4!$9'%$!

#  #( -!(.0%8!- %& "6%( 1#0#70#16 ./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( (6#$$6#)! ":!&"9;= -#9(

'0/4 "6! (!0)%.! /'(5.6!./&- 4!&-!- /41$#%&""/ '%$! "6!%0 #&(:!0

 44!-%#"!$9'/$$/:%&7"6! !G!.5"%/& /'"6%( "%15$#"%/& 

./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( (6#$$'%$! # 	/"%.! /'D%"6-0#:#$/'"6!%0 +/"%/&( ! 4!&-!-

/5&"!0.$#%4( :%"6/5"10!F5-%.!

 './5&"!0.$#%4#&"( 80!#.61#0#70#16(  /0  /'"6%( "%15$#"%/& "6!

+/)%&7#0"%!( 4#90!&/"%.! "6! +/"%/&( ! 4!&-!- /5&"!0.$#%4( /0 #&91/0"%/& /0

1/0"%/&( "6!0!/'

 	/"6%&76!0!%& (6#$$./&("%"5"! # :#%)!0 (5(1!&(%/& /0 "/$$%&789

"6! ./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( /'#&9("#"5"! /'$%4%"#"%/&( -!'!&(! "6#"!G%("!- 10%/0 "/ "6! -#9

"6! ./5&"!0.$#%4 :#( '%$!- #&- "6! ./5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( 0!(!0)! #$$-!'!&(!( #&- #&9#&-

#$$/"6!0 #11$%.#8$! -!'!&(!(

 6%( "%15$#"%/& (6#$$8! '%$!- :%"6"6! /50"#&- "6! 1#0"%!( #70!! "/

8! 8/5&- 89"6! "!04( "6!0!/'

	
 ,	

A		

B
*
	
 

#"!-3 +#0.6  @9 (I*0!7/09$#& 5".6%>

*0!7/09$#& 5".6%>

""/0&!9( '/0 /5&"!0-!'!&-#&"( #"##0> &.

#&- &"!0"!.6&/4%.( &. #&- 6%0-#0"9

!'!&-#&""!)! #0#$#48%!:

+@D 

#"!-3 +#0.6  @9 (I#)%-  $!G#&-!0

#)%-  $!G#&-!0

""/0&!9( '/0 /5&"!0.$#%4#&"( #&- 6%0- #0"9

$#%&"%''( *+*9("!4( &. #&- 4&%10/

&./01/0#"!-

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 83 Filed 03/30/06 Page 5 of 6

	 	 

	  

	

	 	 	  * 
D	 

 

#"!-3 JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ

6! /&/0#8$! 69$$%(  #4%$"/&

&%"!- "#"!( %("0%."/50"5-7!

3/30/06

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORN

I

A

IT IS SO ORDERED

Judge Phyllis J. Hamilton

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 83 Filed 03/30/06 Page 6 of 6