Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-3_08-cv-00547/USCOURTS-cand-3_08-cv-00547-1/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 890
Nature of Suit: Other Statutory Actions
Cause of Action: 28:2201 Constitutionality of State Statutes

---

!	
"#	$	
  

%&'()*+,-).,/

!0$

1"!
#	$	
 

'2/3&)+4-()*+,-).,/

	5
66

6

!	
"

6&*	789

)	)*#	

):-8;<=>

6,+/+);<= >

	**&82?&?8%8*

$
	"$
"!"

	

"

6	6
	

86&8,+,+7++8

0	##

)+8*+??#

7

$
	"$
"!"#

?8%8*

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

=

	

	

	

	

+,)9&8%%+,7&2,*+7+*2+8*-+,*+8&)+')2*+87)7:&%9,*+8?

,8?+%8*+)#:&:&+*&2#&:&+7*+8?&/*+8?&.-+,-:,+):&*,*+8?&/:93)+,

%+,)9&8%?&/9?&82:9&:*-&*-8:&,9*+84*-+)+*+4*+8.9)%3

.&&8*%	,,&%+84)2#*-:&*+-&32*+:9)**8%:*+*+8*-,9&**8*&*-

?)).+84*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&-:&*+,'8.)%4*-**-+
&%&%8*,8?&

3)8'*:&*,*+88))%+,)9&&&:8*%+,7&28%*-**-:&*,*+8+*??&%

@*8%8)2**-)+/+*%+8?&/*+8&+*/*-*&8*+*)%98%&*-::)+,3))4)

:&+8,+:)**&*/8*,8?+%8*+)-:&*+?9&*-&,'8.)%4#*?&*-+8,*+8

#3).#*-**-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&,&*88*+*)/8**?+),8?+%8*+)

+8?&/*+898%&)A+7+),)9) >*?&*-*-:&,%9&*-*/9*3?)).%

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 1 of 12
	

 

 

8%&?),**-*8%&%*-*.+))3::)+%.-8:&*2':&/++8?&/*-,9&**

?+)/*&+)98%&)

	

&*2;82:&*2**-+,*+8#+8,)9%+84))?+*??+,&#%+&,*&#/:)2#

,89)*8*#&*+8%@:&*#8%9*+%,98)<8%*-+&9::&**??=

+,)9&&+,7&2*&+);))+*/&+8?&/*+8#&4&%)?*-/%+9/&

/88&48&*%#*&%#&/+8*+8%<+8,)9%+84#/84*-&*-+84#**+/82#

*&8,&+:*#&*84+3)*-+84=*-*&:&%9,%&48&*%+8%+,)9&&&:8

*%+,7&2+8*-+/**&

B8?+%8*+)C8?&/*+8&*/;+8?&/*+8<&4&%)?-.48&*%#*&%&

/+8*+8%=&*84+3)*-+84*-*D9)+?2?&:&*,*+898%&*8%&%%7):%

98%&6+7<,=

B"+4-)28?+%8*+)E	**&82F2
8)2C8?&/*+8&*/;@*&/)28+*+7

B8?+%8*+)8?&/*+8&*/C.-%+,)9&*8*-&&*2&88:&*2.9)%

,&*93*8*+)&+'?&+9+8G9&2*-*,9)%8*37+%%32)&*&+,*+7

/8

,+7+84&*2;&*2*-*&,+7+,)9&&+,7&2*&+)?&/

&%9,+84&*2

&%9,+84&*2;&*2&88>:&*2*-*:&%9,+,)9&&+,7&2*&+)+8

*-+,*+8

+48*+84&*2;&*2&88>:&*2*-*%+48*+8?&/*+8&+*/*-*+*

:&%9,+8%+,)9&&+8&:8*%+,7&2B8?+%8*+)C&B"+4-)2

8?+%8*+)H	**&82F2
8)2C

&*,*%*&+);82+,)9&&+,7&2*&+)*-*+%+48*%

B8?+%8*+)C&B"+4-)28?+%8*+)E	**&82F2
8)2C

 
9*+%98);**&82.-&8*/:)2?&*239*.-&&*+8%*

&:&8*&%7+&*2+8*-+,*+8

"998);**&82.-&/:)2?&*2

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 2 of 12
	

 

 

98)<.+*-9*D9)+?+&=;
9*+%98)8%"998)<.))*-+&

9::&**??=

@:&*;:&8.+*-:,+)+I%'8.)%4&@:&+8,+8/**&:&*+88***-

)+*+4*+8.--38&*+8%32&*2&+*,98)*&78@:&*.+*8&

,89)*8*+8*-+,*+88%.-+8*:*&,9&&8*/:)2?&*2&?

,/:*+*&?&*2F8%.-#**-*+/?&*8*+8#+8*8*+,+:*%*3,/8

/:)2?&*2&,/:*+*&?&*2F-+%?+8+*+8+8,)9%:&?+8)

G9&2&*&+),89)*8*&*+8%+8,88,*+8.+*-*-+)+*+4*+8

&?+8)8%&;:&8&8*+*+*-*:&7+%)+*+4*+89::&*&7+,<4#

:-*,:2+84A7+%*:+84A*&8)*+84A:&:&+84@-+3+*&%/8*&*+8A&48+I+84#

*&+84#&*&+7+84%*+882?&/&/%+9/A*,=8%*-+&/:)28%

93,8*&,*&

-:&*,*+8,8?&&%32*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&,7&8*8)2&*,*%

*&+)<%?+8%37=#39*)82+8?&/*+8,:+%&@*&,*%*-&?&/#.))

)),:+#@,&:*#9//&+#&,/:+)*+8*-&?#:)9**+/82#,87&*+8#&

:&8**+832:&*+&,98)*&+8,9&*&+8*-&**+84*-*/+4-*&7)&*,*%

*&+)

	

78?*&*-*&/+8*+8?*-+)+*+4*+8#*-,8?+%8*+)+*23)+4*+8+/:%32

*-+
&%&-))&/+8+8??,*98*+)+48*+84&*24&*-&.++8.&+*+84&,9&*

&%&*-&.+%+&,*

		

@&,+?*&+8*8%&+8+48*+84*&+)?&&*,*+8,-&*2 &

88>:&*2*-*%+48*+8?&/*+8&+*/?&:&*,*+898%&*-+
&%&/9**'

,&*)+/+*829,-%+48*+8*:,+?+,/*&+)*-*D9)+?+98%&*-::&:&+*

*8%&%	+48*+84&*2/9**',&*%+48*?&:&*,*+88)2*-

:&*?/*&+)#%,9/8*#+*/#&&)&.&+**8,//98+,*+8*-*D9)+?2E

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 3 of 12
	

 

 

*-**-&:&*+8?*-/*&+)#%,9/8*#+*/#&,//98+,*+8?&.-+,-

:&*,*+8+8*.&&8*%&8*.:*98G9*+?+3)2.+*-+8*-/3+*?*-+
&%&

#+8%+,&+/+8*#&&9*+8+I%%+48*+8&:&-+3+*%+48*+8*-*&

-.8*3,)&)298G9*+?+%#&*-*-738/%?&8+/:&:&:9&:<4#*

988,&+)28,9/3&&&*&%*-,%7):/8*:&,#&*+/:

988,&2@:88%39&%88*-&:&*+=#@:*-+48*+84&*2*

8,*+8?+*,/*&*2F&88>:&*2F**8*+8*-*+8?&/*+8&+*/*-*

+*%+48*%?&:&*,*+8%8*D9)+?2?&:&*,*+8*))#&%8*D9)+?2?&*-

)7)?:&*,*+8+8+*+))2&*%#*-*&*2&88>:&*2/9*:&/:*)28*+?2))

*-&:&*+*-*+*+.+*-%&.+84*-/+*'8%+48*+8

88&8%+/+84?+48*+8@,:**-&.+:&7+%%+8*-+
&%&<#

4#,8%:&4&:-?,*+8<=#3).=#&*-&.+*+:9)*%&&%&%#

/*&+)*-*D9)+?+?&:&*,*+898%&*-+
&%&/9*3,)&)2%+48*%

3?&*-/*&+)+%+,)%&:&%9,%

+48*+8+8,8?&/+*2.+*-*-+
&%&&D9+&;

<=?&+8?&/*+8+8%,9/8*&2?&/<:&*?&/*&8,&+:*?%:+*+8&

*-&:&*&+)&*&+):&,%+84=#*-**-&%9,+84&*2??+@*-)48%

B
6
	C&B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0C*

*-*:?,-:4*-*,8*+8:&*,*%/*&+)

	&*2&88>:&*2*-*/'&+4+8)%,9/8*&/*&+)7+)3)?&

+8:,*+88%8*%+48**-/?&:&*,*+898*+)?*&*-+8:,*+84&*2-

+8%+,*%.-+,-/*&+)+*.9)%)+',:+%8%:&%9,%9&+84*-+8:,*+88%

3?&*-%+48*+8#))?*-/*&+)/%7+)3)?&+8:,*+8-))3%/%

B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0C	?*&*-+8:,*+84

&*2-+%8*+?+%*-%,9/8*+*.8*,:+%8%:&%9,%#*-&%9,+84&*2

/9*%*&/+8.-+,-%,9/8*#&:&*+8*-&?#D9)+?2?&:&*,*+898%&*-+

&%&#*-8#3?&:&%9,+84*-:,+?+%%,9/8*#*-&%9,+84&*2/9*??+@

*-::&:&+*)48%<B
6
	C&B"1"0
6
	E

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 4 of 12
	

 

 

	

0F0

0C=**-*:?,-:4*-*,8*+8&*,*%*&+)

<3=?&**+/824+78+8%:+*+8&+8*-&:&*&+)&*&+):&,%+84#*-*

*-&*2&88>:&*2??&+84&:8&+84*-**+/82+%8*+?28*-&,&%#3?&

*-,)?*-%:+*+8#-&+84#&*-&:&,%+84#)):&*,*%**+/82#8%

?9&*-&:,+?282:&*+8?*-**+/82*-*D9)+?2B"1"0
6
	

E	

0F0

0C5-8+*++/:&,*+,)*+%8*+?2:&*)2,-

:&*+8?**+/82*-*+8*+*)%*:&*,*+8#8%.-8+*::&*-*93*8*+)

:&*+8?*-**+/82/2D9)+?2?&:&*,*+8#*-&*2&88>:&*2*-*:8&#

??&#&4+7*-**+/82/2+87'8*-&,&%<3?&*-%:+*+8&

:&,%+84+,8,)9%%=&+4-**-79:*%2*+%8*+?2*-:,+?+,:&*+8?

*-**+/82*.-+,-:&*,*+8+94-*8%*:,+?2*-)7)?:&*,*+83+84

&*%<B
6
	C&B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0C=
8)2*-:&*+8?*-**+/82*-*&::&:&+*)2%+48*%?&

:&*,*+8.+*-+8*-%2-))3,7&%32*-:&7++8?*-+*+:9)*%

&*,*+7
&%&

&8,&+:*:4,8*+8+84&*,*%*&+)/9*3:&*)2398%32*-

,9&*&:&*&#.-/9*??+@**-*:?,-9,-:4*-)48%

B
6
	C&B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0#C

+8*&9,*%32*-&*2&88:&*2??&+84&:8&+84*-.+*8&:&8*+84*-

**+/82

<,=?&+8?&/*+8:&%9,%+8/?&/*-&*-8%,9/8*&2#8%?&82

*-&*84+3)+*/#*-**-&%9,+84&*2??+@+8:&/+88*:),8*-@*&+&?

*-,8*+8&&,8*+8&+8.-+,-*-+8?&/*+8&+*/+*&%*-)48%

B
6
	C&B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0C

?8)2:&*+8?*-+8?&/*+8&+*/.&&8*:&*,*+8#*-&%9,+84&*2#**-

@*8*:&,*+,3)#-))+%8*+?2*-:&*,*%:&*+8#:,+?2+84.-*-&*-2D9)+?2

B8?+%8*+)C&B"+4-)28?+%8*+)E	**&82F2
8)2C

8%7&*8*6+)9&*+48*?*+/)2,&&,*%#8+8%7&*8*?+)9&*%+48*

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 5 of 12
	

 

 

D9)+?+%+8?&/*+8&+*/B8?+%8*+)C&B"+4-)28?+%8*+)E	**&82F

2
8)2C%8*#*8%+84)8#.+7*-+48*+84&*2F&+4-**,9&

:&*,*+898%&*-+
&%&?&9,-/*&+)?/*&+)+::&:&+*)2%+48*%

B8?+%8*+)C&B"+4-)28?+%8*+)E	**&82F2
8)2C?*&*-/*&+).

+8+*+))2:&%9,%#*-,+7+84&*2#8*+/)28*+?+,*+8?*-%+48*+8#/9*

/'&83)??&**9&*-**-/*&+)+*&*%+8,,&%8,.+*-*-

:&7++8?*-+
&%&

		

+/+84?-))848):&/:*,-))84*+48*+84&*2F

,8?+%8*+)+*2%+48*+8+8,&2*7+%?&3)93*8*+)98?+&8#

988,&2,8/+,39&%8#&)*&+48+?+,8*%+&9:*+8&%)2?*-)+*+4*+8#

&*2%8*.+7+*&+4-**,-))84,8?+%8*+)+*2%+48*+832),*+848*

*/98*,-))84:&/:*)2?*&*-&+4+8)%+48*+8+%+,)%

*8%8?&	&*2*-*),**+8+*+*,-))84*+48*+84&*2F

,8?+%8*+)+*2%+48*+8/9*%+84%?+*-8%/9*34+8*-:&,32

,8?&&+84%+&,*)2<+87+,*7+,%+)49A*-&?&/?,//98+,*+8&8*

9??+,+8*=.+*-,98)?&*-+48*+84&*28,8?&&+84#*-,-))84+84&*2

/9*@:)+8*-3+?&+*3)+?*-**-,8?+%8*+)+*2%+48*+8.8*:&:&

8%/9*4+7*-+48*+84&*28::&*98+*2*&7+.*-%+48*%/*&+)#*

&,8+%&*-,+&,9/*8,#8%#+?8,-84+8%+48*+8+??&%#*@:)+8*-

3+?&*-,-8%+48*+8	,-))84+84&*2/2:&,%**-8@**4?

*-,-))84:&,8)2+?+*-844%+8*-+/*8%,8?&:&,?+&*

J9%+,+)8*&78*+8	&*2*-*),**:&,-))84*,8?+%8*+)+*2

%+48*+8?*&,8+%&+84*-G9*+?+,*+8??&%32*-+48*+84&*2/2?+)

8%&7/*+898%&+7+),)9)<8%+8,/:)+8,.+*-+7+),)9)

 >#+?::)+,3)=*-*+%8*+?+*-,-))84%/*&+)8%*?&*-+8%*+)*-

3+?&*-,-))84,-9,-/*+8/9*3,,/:8+%32,/:*8*

%,)&*+8*-*??+&/*-**-/78*-,/:)+%.+*-*-/*8%,8?&

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 6 of 12
	

 

 

&D9+&/8*+/:%+8*-:&,%+84:&4&:-8%*-**?&*-.+*-:,+?+,+*2*-

G9*+?+,*+8?&*-,8?+%8*+)+*2%+48*+8*-*.4+7832*-+48*+84&*2

+8*-/*8%,8?&%+)49

-39&%8?:&9+8+8829,-,-))84:&,%+84-))38*-+48*+84

&*28*+)*-,9&*&9)8*-,-))84#)):&*+-)),8*+89*??&%*-

/*&+)+8D9*+8*-)7)?:&*,*+8*.-+,-+*+8*+*)%98%&*-&%9,+84

&*2F%+48*+8

	
	

$+,&+8,+:)	,+7+84&*2/29&*,*%*&+)*-*+%+,)%&

:&%9,%328*-&&*2&3288>:&*2+8,88,*+8.+*-*-+,8)2?&

:&,9*+84#%?8%+84#&**/:*+84***)*-+)+*+4*+89,-&*,*%*&+)

/23%+,)%8)2**-,*4&+?:&88%98%&*-,8%+*+8%,&+3%+8

*-+
&%&5-8*-)+*+4*+8-38*&/+8*%#,+7+84&*2/9*,/:)2.+*-

*-:&7++8?,*+8#3).<6	

=&*,*%*&+)/9*3

*&%8%/+8*+8%32,+7+84&*2*),*+88%+8,9&/88&*-*

89&*-*,,+)+/+*%**-:&89*-&+I%98%&*-+
&%&

+,)9&?B
6
	C8?&/*+8&*/8)*-&.+&%&%32

*-,9&*&:&/+**%+8.&+*+8432*-+48*+84&*2#,+7+84&*2/2

%+,)82+8?&/*+8&+*/%+48*%
6
	8)2*;

<=*-,+7+84&*2F
9*+%98)?&,&%+8*-+,*+8#.))

/:)2?+%98)*.-/+*+&83)28,&2*%+,)*-+8?&/*+8

?&*-+)+*+4*+88%.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$$98%32&*,*+7
&%&C

*-*+**,-%-&*@-+3+*	A

<3=*-??+,&#%+&,*&#8%/:)2<+8,)9%+84"998)=?*-

,+7+84&*2*.-/%+,)9&+&83)28,&2?&*-+)+*+4*+88%.-

-7+48%*-B	4&/8**$$98%32&*,*+7
&%&C<
@-+3+*	=A

<,=@:&*<%?+8%+8*-+
&%&=?*-,+7+84&*2*.-/%+,)9&

+&83)28,&2?&*-+)+*+4*+88%.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 7 of 12
	

 

 

$98%32&*,*+7
&%&C<
@-+3+*	=A

<%=*-9&*8%+*:&88)A

<=,9&*&:&*&#*-+&*??#8%:&?+8)78%&*.-/%+,)9&+

&83)28,&2?&*-+)+*+4*+88%.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$

$98%32&*,*+7
&%&C<
@-+3+*	=A

<?=%9&+84*-+&%:+*+8#.+*8+8*-,*+8*.-/%+,)9&+

&83)28,&28%.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$$98%32&*,*+7

&%&C<
@-+3+*	=4?*&8,&+3%%:+*+8**+/82&@-+3+**%:+*+8

*-*&7)&*,*%*&+)/9*3:&*)2398%32*-,9&*&:&*&8%/28*

3%+,)%*828@,:*:&/+**%98%&*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&

<4=*-9*-&?*-%,9/8*&*-&+4+8)9&,?*-+8?&/*+8

+,)9&?B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0C8?&/*+8

&*/8)*-&.+&%&%32*-,9&*&:&/+**%+8.&+*+8432*-+48*+84

&*2#,+7+84&*2/2%+,)82+8?&/*+8&+*/%+48*%B"1"0

6
	E	

0F0

0C8)2*;

<=*-,+7+84&*2F
9*+%98)?&,&%+8*-+,*+8#.))

/:)2?+%98)*.-/+*+&83)28,&2*%+,)*-+8?&/*+8

?&*-+)+*+4*+88%.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$$98%32&*,*+7
&%&C

*-*+**,-%-&*@-+3+*	A

<3=@:&*<%?+8%+8*-+
&%&=<=*.-/%+,)9&+&83)2

8,&2?&*-+)+*+4*+8#<=.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$$98%32

&*,*+7
&%&C<
@-+3+*	=#

<,=*-9&*8%+*:&88)A

<%=,9&*&:&*&#*-+&*??#8%:&?+8)78%&*.-/%+,)9&+

&83)28,&2?&*-+)+*+4*+88%.--7+48%*-B	4&/8**$$98%

32&*,*+7
&%&C<
@-+3+*	=A8%

<=*-9*-&?*-%,9/8*&*-&+4+8)9&,?*-+8?&/*+8

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 8 of 12
	

 

 

 

 	
!				
	

?,+7+84&*2+&7%.+*-93:8&8&%&+9%+8*-&)+*+4*+8*-*

.9)%,/:)%+,)9&?82+8?&/*+8&+*/%+48*%+8*-+,*+8

B
6
	C&B"1"0
6
	E	

0F0

0#C*-

,+7+84&*2/9*8*+?2*-+48*+84&*2#+8.&+*+84<32?@#+?:+3)=

+//%+*)28%+8878*/&*-8*-&,9&*%2?*&&,+7+84*-93:8&&%&

9,-8*+?+,*+8/9*+8,)9%,:2?*-93:8&,9&*&%&

-,+7+84&*2)/9*+//%+*)2+8?&/+8.&+*+84*-&*2.-,9%*-

93:8&&%&*+9+8*-*-&)+*+4*+8*-*/&))*-/*&+),7&%32*-

93:8&&%&+*-93G,*?*-+&*,*+7
&%&8%%+*+8#*-,+7+84&*2/9*

%)+7&,:2?*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&:&/:*)2**-&*2+8*-*-&,*+8*-*

,9%*-93:8&&%&*+9-:9&:?+/:+84*-%9*++*)&**-

+8*&*%:&*+**-@+*8,?*-+&*,*+7
&%&8%*??&%*-+48*+84&*2+8

*-+,8::&*98+*2**&2*:&*,*+*,8?+%8*+)+*2+8*&*+8*-,9&*?&/.-+,-*-

93:8&&%&+9%-+48*+84&*2-))3&*-39&%88%*-@:8?

'+84:&*,*+8+8*-*,9&*?+*,8?+%8*+)/*&+)E8%8*-+84+8*-:&7++8

-9)%3,8*&9%9*-&+I+84&8,9&4+84,+7+84&*2+8*-+,*+8*%+32

).?9)%+&,*+7?&/8*-&,9&*

"

#		
	

?,+7+84&*2)&8*-*#32+8%7&*8,&*-&.+#+*-%+,)%&*,*%

*&+)*82:&8&+882,+&,9/*8,8*9*-&+I%98%&*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7

&%&#*-,+7+84&*2/9*+//%+*)2<=8*+?2+8.&+*+84*-+48*+84&*2?*-

989*-&+I%%+,)9&#<3=9+*3*??&**&*&+7)),:+?*-&*,*%*&+)#

<,=+8?&/*-:&8&:&8*.-/989*-&+I%%+,)9&.&/%?))*-*&/?

*-+
&%&#8%<%=&D9*9,-:&8&:&8*@,9**-B	,'8.)%4/8*8%

	4&/8**$$98%C*-*+**,-%-&*@-+3+*	

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 9 of 12
	

 

 

$	

5+*-9*.&+**8:&/++8?&/*-+48*+84&*2&,9&*&%&,9&%?*&

::&:&+*8*+,*))+8*&*%:&8#&*2/28*?+)+8*-:93)+,&,&%+8*-+,*+8

82&*,*%*&+)	&*2*-*'*?+)98%&)82

&*,*%*&+)/9*,/:)2.+*-+7+),)9) >

	

8)*-&.+&%&%&4&%+8.&+*+8432*-&%9,+84&*2#.+*-+8+@*2%2

?*&*-?+8)*&/+8*+8?*-+,*+8#,-,+7+84&*2/9*&*9&8))&*,*%*&+)

**-&%9,+84&*2	9%+8*-+93%+7++8#B))&*,*%*&+)C+8,)9%)),:+#

3*&,*#,/:+)*+8#9//&+&82*-&?&/?&:&%9,+84&,:*9&+8482?*-

&*,*%*&+)5+*-:&/++8+8.&+*+84?&/*-+48*+84&*2#*-,+7+84&*2

/2%*&2/&))?*-&*,*%*&+)+8*%?&*9&8+84+*5-*-&*-&*,*%

*&+)+&*9&8%&%*&2%#*-,+7+84&*2/9*93/+*.&+**8,&*+?+,*+8**-

&%9,+84&*2<8%#+?8**-/:&8&8*+*2#**-+48*+84&*2=32*-+@*2%2

%%)+8*-*+%8*+?+<32,*4&2#.-&::&:&+*=))*-&*,*%*&+)*-*.

&*9&8%&%*&2%8%*-*??+&/*-**-,+7+84&*2-8*&*+8%82,:+#

3*&,*#,/:+)*+8#9//&+&*-&?&/?&:&%9,+84&,:*9&+8482?*-

&*,*%*&+)*.+*-*8%+84*-+:&7++8#98)&8*+*)%*&*+88&,-+7)

,:2?)):)%+84#/*+8::&#*&8,&+:*#)4)//&8%#,&&:8%8,&**&82

.&':&%9,*#78+?9,-/*&+),8*+8&*,*%*&+)	829,-&,-+7),:+*-*

,8*+8&,8*+*9*&*,*%*&+)&/+893G,***-+&*,*+7
&%&*?&*-+8

,*+8<	
=#37

*-+84+8*-+
&%&3&+%4*-&+4-*?82:&8*'+*/%+?+,*+832*-

9&*+8*-?9*9&+4-**	&*
*-&
3G,*+8$2*+:9)*+84**-8*&2?*-+

&*,*+7
&%&8&*2.+782&+4-*+**-&.+.9)%-7*3G,**%+,)+84&

:&%9,+8482+8?&/*+8&+*/8824&98%8*%%&%+8*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7

&%&+/+)&)2#8&*2.+782&+4-**3G,*8824&98%*9+87+%8,?82?

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 10 of 12
	

 

 

*-/*&+),7&%32*-+&*,*+7
&%&

	

*%;J89&2#	5
66

6

!	
"

KK&'	)*+,-

$2;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

!	
"

	**&82?&?8%8*

$
	"$
"!"

*%;J89&2#
F

0M0

KK&+/)2

$2;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

0

	**&82?&)+8*+??

0	#

	
	
#

*%;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

"
	N
"

0

January 31, 2008

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 11 of 12
	

 

 

%!

&'		!!
	

#LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL#?LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLO?9))%%&P#%,)&98%&:8)*2?

:&G9&2*-*-7&%+8+*8*+&*28%98%&*8%*-*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&*-*.

+9%32*-8+*%**+*&+,*9&*?&*-&*-&8+*&+,*?)+?&8+8

LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL+8*-,?+2#8,73&-$*-!+&,-A

4&*,/:)2.+*-8%*3398%32))*-*&/?*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7

&%&8%98%&*8%8%,'8.)%4*-*?+)9&*,/:)2,9)%@:/*8,*+8

8%:98+-/8*+8*-8*9&?,8*/:*)/8)2:&/+*-*.+))8*%+,)+882

/88&82+8?&/*+8&+*/*-*+93G,***-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&*82:&8

&8*+*2@,:*+8*&+,*,/:)+8,.+*-*-:&7++8?*-+
&%&?9&*-&4&*93/+*

**-G9&+%+,*+8?*-8+*%**+*&+,*9&*?&*-&*-&8+*&+,*?)+?&8+?&

*-:9&:?8?&,+84*-*&/?*-+*+:9)*%&*,*+7
&%&#78+?9,-8?&,/8*

:&,%+84,,9&?*&*&/+8*+8?*-+,*+8

*;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

+*28%**.-&.&88%+48%;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

&+8*%8/;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

+48*9&;LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

Case 3:08-cv-00547-MMC Document 16 Filed 01/31/08 Page 12 of 12