Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-ared-4_08-cv-04153/USCOURTS-ared-4_08-cv-04153-0/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 355
Nature of Suit: Motor Vehicle Product Liability
Cause of Action: 28:1332 Diversity-Motor Vehicle Product Liability

---

I

Case 4 :05-cv-04077-RTDDocunlent 23 Filed 07/211200$ Paqe ? of 7

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF' ARITANSAS

TEXARI{ANA DTVISION

ANTIIONY ancl IA$HA FRAZIFR,

lndividua.lIy and as Co'Personal

Represcfltatives of thix Estatii of

SHAMARA FRAZIER, Deceased

T''LAiNTIFI+S,

FORD MOTOR COMPANY and

CHNTTJRY PR(JDIJCTS CO.,

DSFENDANTS.

Civil CrLse No O5-4077

aGEELDIIII_RoTEIIIVE oFI}ER

This Matter, having come before the Court ofl the agrccmerlt of thc

plairrtiffs and Gracd Children's Producqs, Inc.; it lurther apPe 'ing that

clocurnel'rts produced - or wlrich may be later prorluced - ptrrportedlv con$litute

tracle secret and/or oliher coflIicluntial re$earch, develoPment, competitive or

cnmmercial informatiott as sucl'I terfls rnay be defined arrd used uuder the

laws $f 1:1rr S1;ate of Arkansas; and it furtirer appear'ing that judicial tcoflDrrly

will be serr;ed by cntering of this Order,

IT IS HERHBY ORDERED THAT:

I. 'fhis Order ehall Eovern documents a:rd other tnaterial ot

infornration {"Litigation Materials") produccd by Graco, fonnally pr inlqlrmally,

in the cor"rr$e of litigation, including but flot limited to document$, data, things,

information, deposition testimony afld answers lo discovery

Case 4:08-cv-04153-JLH Document 24 Filed 07/24/06 Page 1 of 6
, 7 Case 4:05-cv-04077-RTDDocument 23 Filed 07/?1/2006 Paqe 3 of 7

l A$ u$ed in this t)rder, "Cotrfldential Material" shall refer' to any

docurnent Dr other Litigolion Matlerials, ol any Portion tlrereof, designated as

confidenlial, as well as inforrnation contBined in such dDcuments or othet

Litigation Materials.

I Graco may designate material$ Produced as r:onfidetrtial by placing

or affixing thereon in such rfianner as will not interfere with tlre reasonable

legibilify thereof tl're following, or otlrerwisc aPProPriate, nrrtice: "Cotrfidential

Material subject to Protective order entered iu llm4er u, GrEEo' Childrenls.

Products. Ing,. et aL, Case No.: 05-4077, Llnited States District C'lourt' westerll

District rrf Atkatrsas, Texari(alla Division." Such designal;ion slrall be made ifl

good faith and sl,all constitute a lePresefltatioll)y Graco that it has conducted

a thorough investigation afld has a rea$onable and legitimate basis to claim

Lhdt the mater ial so designated is appropriate for the protection provirlt:rJ iIr

tbis t)rrler and thet it is entitled to claim such protcction Jor the rnatcrial' The

Plaifltifi may require that an authorized t'epresentativc rrf Graco execute an

a.ffi davit verifying the represe)rtatiofl .

4 Confidential Material and any copy thereof afld atly notes or

summar'ieo made tl'rerdfrorn $hall not be used by any party receiving i1:,

including srrch party's attorn$y or od1er rePrBsentatitres including expert

witnesses, for any purpose otller than the litigation of this action, urrle.ts tire

representations macle are untrue,

Case 4:08-cv-04153-JLH Document 24 Filed 07/24/06 Page 2 of 6
Case4:05-cv-04077-RTD Document Filed 07/21/200$ Paae 4 of 7

5 All Confidential Materiel recei

i

and properly $ecltr€d by that attoTfley to

reproductiofl ol, the Confidential Materia.l

ed by an ati:orney shall bd cofltrolled

prevent unauthofized accesE to, or

6 Oonlidential materia-l atld fl,ny copies thereof, afld note$ Qr excerPts

rnadc tlleflefrom, shall be rlisclosed only to "Qttalifiecl Pcr'sons," arld only to thc

Bxtcnt necessary for the Iitigation of this action- Qualified Pet sotrs :Lre limitlctl

to:

Courrsel o[ rccord lor the partics and t]re parties themselves;

The non-technical and clerical staff employeri by Counsel of

fccord;

Independent persontrel retained by Counsel of record t,r

furnish tcchnical services, expert setvices, advice, or to givc

expert testlmony;

(d) Coult icporter$ and depositiDn transcript reForlersi flnd

(e) The Court and its artl,horizerl $taff,

7 in addition, the attor[ey disclosing the Confidential Mal:erjal shall

take all necesshry $tepe tD ensure that all persons receiving Conlldential

Matedai {a} maintain such material in e protecterl and secr:re manncr, wi[JI

access resttictcrd ai, alJ times to Qualified Persons and (b) abide by the tr':rrns rli

this Protective Older"

I If the lllaintiff df,siree to disclose Confiddntial Material to anyone

other than Qrralilied Persons, as that ie defined in Paragraph 6, the Plainiiff

will provide Graco ftrurteen (14) days prior written n$tioe of the intent to

(u)

{b)

(c,

Case 4:08-cv-04153-JLH Document 24 Filed 07/24/06 Page 3 of 6
Case 4:05-cv-04077-RTD

I

Document3 Filed Q7121!2OQ6 Page 5 of 7

state the name ancl address of the additiodal person{s) a.lrd tl'le reason(s) review

by such additional person(s) is desircd. II Graco object,s in writirrg to such

disclosure within that fourteeu (14) irlay period, lhen slt{;h Conficlefll,ial Material

will not be disclosed unless and until tlris Court overrllles Graco's objection,

I lf Confidential Material is utilized or referred to during depositions,

Graco may request and req ire thrrt only Qualified Fersons, lhe deponent and

tire reporter shall bc pre$ent, A par|l shall, eithel at the deposition itself, or

wittrin fourtecn rlays (ia) after actual receipt of the kanscript thereo[, fiotify all

other Far'(ies and the deponent on the recotd or in writing, that the information

is conliderttial dnd shal] designate the transclipt or portions thereof filr which

such claim is rnade.

l0 Confidential Material rhay be referred to or ittcorporated iu briefs,

uffldavits, or ottr(ir clocuments filed with this Cot-u't, hut ctnly to fhe extent

reasonably necesssry for the litigation of thi$ aotiofl and i)r ovided that such

docLrments shall i;e filed with the Cllerk of Courl under $eal and prominently

rnarked "Confidefltial Mater'ial $ubject to Protective Order entered in lrreziet'v.

Gleco*M, Case Nc.r : 05-4077, Uniter] States District

Ccrurt, Wr:stern fJistrict ol Arhansas, Texarkara Division '

I l. If the Plaintiff dieagrees with a claim of confiderr liali ty, tire Plaintiff

sl:all notify (Jraco in writing lf ihe dispr-rte cannDt be lesolved by agreement,

such Confidential material shall lre kdpt coflfidefltia] unless, witfiin terl (t {ll

days of rcceipt hy Graco of $uch notice, or such other time per iod a$ the Fartieo

Case 4:08-cv-04153-JLH Document 24 Filed 07/24/06 Page 4 of 6
Case 4:05-cv-04077-RTDDocument ?3 Filed 07/21i2006 Page 6 of 7

may aErcc uporr, (iraco applies to thi$ Cgurt for an Order seel{ing protectiolr

arrd confidentiEll treatrreflt. If such a rnotiorl is jlled. the irrformation $ha.ll be

Itept corrlid.ential pending a ruling by thie Court If such motion is not lilecl

within the applicable time period, such infbrmation shall lose all conlrdential

$rauts.

12. This Protective Order shall $urvive the tcrminerltion of this actitrn

All Conlldential Material shall retain that desiHflation afld shall rernmin suhjecl:

to this Protective Order r.rntil such time. if ever, ae the Court renders a decision

lhat any challengecl matrrial shail not bc cover'ed by the ternrs of this

ProtecLive Order and any and all proceedings and appeals challenging such

decision shall have becn conoludf,d,

13 lJpon final termination of this action, all Conficleritial Material,

including each copy thereof, and each docLtment and copy thereof that

incorporates or references, in whole or in part, any Confiderrtial Material or

infbrmation contained therein, irrcluding but not limited trr [o1;es or surrrrnari(:,5

concetning or pertaining to sllch Conhdential Material, shall at the option ol

the reoipicrtt oI the Confidcntial Materials be either destroyed or returned to

Graco not later than fourteefl {14) days after the ultirnate dispositiUn oI this

case. The recipient perty Bhail then provide an slfidavit or other affirmation

that at all times the party has abided by tl're terrnE of thi$ Prcrtectjve OIdcr, that

all Confidential Material in the alfiaht's cuetody or control, arrd all Confidential

Mater ial tl'rat affiant discloserl to Qualified Persons or to others, has Lreen

retrieved and returned to Gra.co, or has been des1.t"oved.

Case 4:08-cv-04153-JLH Document 24 Filed 07/24/06 Page 5 of 6
Case4:05-cv-04077-RTD Document Filed 07/21/2006 Paoe 7 of 7

14. Any item rnarked "confiderltldrl" by Graco shall be deetned al

ptlrposes ol the applicabl€

sl-ry cor)fiderrl"iEl rlor:umcnts

aulherrtic business record of the corpordtion fot

mles of evidence. A1l other obiections relatecl to

are specificallv reserved.

..\

SO ORDERED, this ,r) \flay of

cH t\ ,1,136763 |

U S, DISTRICTCOURT WE$TERN DISTHICT AHMNSAS

FILED

JUL 2 4 2006

CHRIS N, JftII{5OI, OLEHK

FI

DEPUTYOI.ERK

States Dis

Case 4:08-cv-04153-JLH Document 24 Filed 07/24/06 Page 6 of 6