Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-casd-3_17-cv-00108/USCOURTS-casd-3_17-cv-00108-27/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 830
Nature of Suit: Patent
Cause of Action: 35:0271 Patent Infringement

---

1

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

IN RE:

QUALCOMM LITIGATION,

Case No. 3:17-CV-00108-GPC-MDD

[Consolidated with 3:17-CV-01010-GPCMDD]

ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND 

DENYING IN PART MOTIONS TO 

SEAL

[ECF Nos. 1120 and 1121.]

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 1 of

 40
2

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Before the Court are the parties’ requests to seal certain exhibits and deposition 

designations to be sealed to the extent such materials are received into evidence at trial in 

Case No. 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD. ECF Nos. 1120 and 1121. Both parties have filed 

oppositions to each other’s respective motions. ECF Nos. 1136 and 1137 Upon review 

of the moving papers, the Court GRANTS in part and DENIES in part the motions.

LEGAL STANDARD

There is a presumptive right of public access to court records based upon the 

common law and the first amendment. See Nixon v. Warner Commc’ns, Inc., 435 U.S. 

589, 597 (1978); Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. General Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 

1212-13 (9th Cir. 2002). Nonetheless, access may be denied to protect sensitive 

confidential information. Courts are more likely to protect information covered by Rule 

26(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, but are not limited by items listed in 

protective orders. See KL Group v. Case, Kay, & Lynch, 829 F.2d 909, 917-19 (9th Cir. 

1987) (letter to client from attorney); Kalinauskas v. Wong, 151 F.R.D. 363, 365-67 

(D. Nev. 1993) (confidential settlement agreement). 

“Unless a particular court record is one traditionally kept secret, a strong 

presumption in favor of access is the starting point.” Kamakana v. City & Cty. of 

Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172, 1178-80 (9th Cir. 2006) (citing Foltz v. State Farm Mut. Auto. 

Ins. Co., 331 F.3d 1122, 1135 (9th Cir. 2003)). “In order to overcome this strong 

presumption, a party seeking to seal a judicial record must articulate justifications for 

sealing that outweigh the historical right of access and the public policies favoring 

disclosure.” Id. at 1178-79. 

The presumption of access is “based on the need for federal courts, although 

independent—indeed, particularly because they are independent—to have a measure of 

accountability and for the public to have confidence in the administration of justice.” 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 2 of

 40
3

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

United States v. Amodeo (Amodeo II ), 71 F.3d 1044, 1048 (2d Cir.1995); see also Valley 

Broad. Co. v. U.S. Dist. Court—D. Nev., 798 F.2d 1289, 1294 (9th Cir.1986) (explaining 

that the presumption of public access “promot[es] the public's understanding of the 

judicial process and of significant public events”).

Accordingly, “[a] party seeking to seal a judicial record then bears the burden of 

overcoming this strong presumption by meeting the ‘compelling reasons' standard.” 

Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1178. Under this stringent standard, a court may seal records only 

when it finds “a compelling reason and articulate[s] the factual basis for its ruling, 

without relying on hypothesis or conjecture.” Id. at 1179. The court must then 

“conscientiously balance[ ] the competing interests of the public and the party who seeks 

to keep certain judicial records secret.” Id. (quoting Foltz, 331 F.3d at 1135) (alteration in 

original) (internal quotation marks omitted). What constitutes a “compelling reason” is 

“best left to the sound discretion of the trial court.” Nixon, 435 U.S. at 599.

Previously, some courts applied a “compelling reason” or “good cause” standard 

for sealing depending on whether the pending motion was dispositive or non-dispositive. 

E.g., Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1180 (9th Cir. 2006) (parties seeking to seal documents in a 

dispositive motion must provide “compelling reasons” to support a sealing whereas for 

non-dispositive motions the parties must show a lesser “particularized showing” under 

the “good cause” standard pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c)); Phillips ex 

rel. Estates of Byrd v. Gen. Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1213 (9th Cir. 2002) (when a 

party attaches a sealed discovery document to a nondispositive motion, the usual 

presumption of the public's right of access is rebutted).

Other courts rejected this binary approach. In re Midland National Life Insurance 

Company Annuity Sales Practices Litigation, 686 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir.2012), is one such 

case that rejected the literal dispositive/nondispositive label. In that case, an intervenor 

moved to unseal documents attached to a Daubert motion. Id. at 1118. The district court, 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 3 of

 40
4

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

like the district court here, concluded that the documents should remain under seal 

because “the Daubert motion was non-dispositive,” as it “would not have been a 

determination on the merits of any claim or defense.” Id. at 1119. The Ninth Circuit 

rejected the district court's focus on whether the motion was literally “dispositive”: “That 

the records are connected to a Daubert motion does not, on its own, conclusively resolve 

the issue.” Id. As the motion, in effect, “pertain[ed] to central issues bearing on 

defendant's summary judgment motion,” we treated that motion as dispositive. Id. 

Similarly, the court in Ctr. for Auto Safety v. Chrysler Grp., LLC, 809 F.3d 1092, 1100 

(9th Cir. 2016) observed that it would not allow the technically nondispositive nature of a

Daubert motion to cloud the reality that it was able to significantly affect the disposition 

of the issues in the case. 

Here, the motions to seal relate to numerous potential trial exhibits and deposition 

designations that the parties may intend to call into evidence at trial. This Court will 

apply the “compelling reasons” standard to these motions and related briefing as those 

submissions pertain to central issues at trial and are “more than tangentially related to the 

underlying cause of action.” Ctrs. for Auto Safety v. Chrysler Grp., 809 F.3d 1092, 1099 

(9th Cir. 2016). 

Compelling reasons for sealing information exist “when such ‘court files might 

have become a vehicle for improper purposes,’ such as the use of records to gratify 

private spite, promote public scandal, circulate libelous statements, or release trade 

secrets.” Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179 (quoting Nixon, 435 U.S. at 598). Trade secrets 

“may consist of any formula, pattern, device or compilation of information which is used 

in one’s business, and which gives him an opportunity to obtain advantage over 

competitions who do not know or use it.” Restatement (First) of Torts § 757 cmt. b. 

Because trade secrets concern proprietary and sensitive business information not 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 4 of

 40
5

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

available to the public, sealing may be warranted where disclosure would harm a 

litigant’s competitive standing. Nixon, 425 U.S. at 598. 

The Ninth Circuit has explicitly recognized that compelling reasons exist for the 

sealing of “pricing terms, royalty rates, and guaranteed minimum payment terms” of 

license agreements. See In re Elec. Arts, Inc., 298 F. App’x 568, 569 (9th Cir. 2008). 

Courts in this circuit have also recognized that information subject to confidentiality 

agreements may also meet the “compelling reasons” standard when accompanied by a 

particularized factual showing. See Foltz, 331 F.3d at 1137-38. 

DISCUSSION

The Court now turns to the substance of the instant sealing motions. The majority 

of information that the parties seek to seal constitutes confidential business information 

of the parties, including trade secrets, proprietary business records, discussions of internal 

strategy, company dealings, and materials designated as “Highly Confidential.” To the 

extent that the proposed redactions are narrowly tailored and relate to the rationale above, 

the Court agrees that the parties have demonstrated that compelling reasons exist for 

sealing the information subsumed by these categories. Analysis from this Court’s prior 

orders granting the parties’ motions to seal is applicable here. See ECF No. 1143. 

However, the Court also finds that a substantial portion of the information that the 

parties seek to seal has already been publicly disclosed elsewhere – such as in the FTC v. 

Qualcomm case – or does not constitute confidential or sealable information – as is the 

case with Apple’s indemnification agreements with the CMs. Even where the parties 

seek to cover information that may properly be sealed, they should seek to seal only the 

narrowly sealable information and not whole paragraphs, documents, sections, or 

presentations that do not justify extensive redaction. In some documents, the information 

at issue is too general to warrant sealing. A number of proposed sealings are markedly 

overbroad. Other suggested redactions would inappropriately shield stale information 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 5 of

 40
6

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

that is too old to be presently confidential. And yet other redacted exhibits and 

depositions in their current states would close from the public exhibits that lie at the very 

heart of this case, including proposed redactions to the SULAs and royalty rates and 

payments. In light of the public’s right to access, this Court finds no colorable 

justification to seal those exhibits that would be highly relevant to the adjudication of the 

claims at issue in the trial. Repeated requests to close and clear the courtroom would be 

unduly cumbersome to the Court’s interest in managing the trial. Sealing such 

information would hamstring the parties and stymie them from litigating key issues 

effectively and efficiently. Furthermore, over-sealing crucial exhibits would impede the 

jury and the public’s ability to understand the nature of the proceedings and the factual 

basis for the parties’ claims. 

Accordingly, the Court finds that the parties have not articulated “compelling 

reasons” to keep all the requested information from the public. As such, the Court 

GRANTS in part and DENIES in part each of the motions to seal and instructs the 

parties to introduce – if called at trial – redacted versions of their documents consistent 

with the following tables:

IT IS SO ORDERED. 

Dated: April 15, 2019

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 6 of

 40
7

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1

2 Qualcomm’s Requested Exhibits to Seal

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

DTX00021 1-2 GRANTED.

DTX00044 3 GRANTED. 

DTX00064 3, 5 GRANTED.

DTX00065 5, 11 GRANTED.

DTX00066

7-9, 13-14, 17, 19, 

20

GRANTED.

DTX00068 9-10 GRANTED.

DTX00082 3, 4 GRANTED.

DTX00085 1-2

GRANTED.

DTX00090 5, 7

GRANTED.

DTX00097 1, 4, 5 GRANTED.

DTX00104 5-6, 8, 10, 12 GRANTED.

DTX00254 4, 10

GRANTED.

DTX00256 11 GRANTED.

DTX00261 4-5, 7-9, 13-14 GRANTED.

DTX00262

3, 11, 12, 25, 27, 

35, 37-38, 44

GRANTED.

DTX00274 1 GRANTED.

DTX00309 1-6 GRANTED.

DTX00370 13-15, 19 GRANTED.

DTX00373 2-5 GRANTED.

DTX00382 4, 5, 7-11 GRANTED.

DTX00397 3 GRANTED.

DTX00497

7, 10-20, 23, 24, 

27-38, 40, 46, 49-

59, 62-63, 66-77, 

79-81 

DENIED with respect to portions of pages 10-20, 23-24, 

29, 31, 37-38, 40, 49-56, 58-59, 62-63, 68, 70-73, 76-77, 

79-80 that contain contract provisions that are not financial 

in nature or CBI and stale. GRANTED with respect to 

other requests to seal financial and indemnity terms.

DTX00504

7, 9, 10, 14, 19, 

20, 22, 23, 27, 28, 

42, 58, 59

DENIED with respect to portions of pages 7, 9-10, 14, 

42, 58-59 that contain contract provisions that are not 

financial in nature or CBI and stale. GRANTED with 

respect to other requests to seal financial and 

indemnity tterms. 

DTX00548 3, 5-6 GRANTED.

DTX00713 7 GRANTED.

DTX00736 2-4 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 7 of

 40
8

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

DTX00737 3 GRANTED.

DTX00842 5 GRANTED.

DTX00862 3 GRANTED.

DTX00869 1, 7-9

GRANTED.

DTX00882 2

GRANTED.

DTX00890 4-6, 10-11, 39 GRANTED.

DTX00907 3 GRANTED.

DTX00910 3 GRANTED.

DTX00932

7, 10, 12, 15, 21-

22, 25, 26, 29-31, 

35, 37, 38, 40, 42

GRANTED.

DTX00998 3 GRANTED.

DTX01000 20-35 GRANTED.

DTX01002 10-11, 15-17 GRANTED.

DTX01003 10, 15 GRANTED.

DTX01008 35 GRANTED.

DTX01019 3, 4

DENIED. 

DTX01038 2-10, 15

DENIED with respect to pages 2-4, 7-10 with respect 

to Samsung gag requirements. GRANTED in part 

with respect to other requests. 

DTX01039 2-3, 6-7, 16, 18-20 GRANTED.

DTX01045 1 GRANTED.

DTX01065 1 GRANTED.

DTX01105

5, 6, 8-11, 15, 17-

18, 21-22, 29, 31, 

37, 41-43, 47-50

GRANTED.

DTX01173 3-4 GRANTED.

DTX01189 3-10 GRANTED.

DTX01368 2, 5, 9 GRANTED.

DTX01375 5-6, 9-11 GRANTED.

DTX01381 3 GRANTED.

DTX01402 2 GRANTED.

DTX01403 4 GRANTED.

DTX01407 9-13 GRANTED.

DTX01437 3, 10-11 GRANTED.

DTX01440 1-3, 5

GRANTED.

DTX01447 9-13 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 8 of

 40
9

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

DTX01454 1-2

GRANTED.

DTX01456 5, 6 GRANTED.

DTX01462

4, 6-8, 10-14, 19-

21, 24, 25, 27-29, 

31-33, 36-39, 50-

58, 63, 64, 65, 68, 

69, 81, 82, 85, 86, 

95-99

DENIED with respect to definitions that are not 

financial or CBI in nature on 4, 20, 55-58. GRANTED 

with respect to the remainder of the request. 

DTX01463

2, 4-6, 8-12, 17-

19, 22-23, 25-27, 

29-31

DENIED with respect to definitions that are not 

financial or CBI in nature on 2 and 18. GRANTED 

with respect to the remainder of the request. 

DTX01464 1, 2, 5, 6 GRANTED

DTX01475 2, 5, 9, 12 GRANTED

DTX15700

8, 10, 14-16, 19-

25, 27-38, 49-58

GRANTED

DTX19462 7, 11, 13 GRANTED

JTX002 1-11, 13-14 GRANTED

JTX003 1-6 GRANTED

JTX004 1-2, 5-7

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

provisions on 1, 2, 5-7. GRANTED with respect to 

other requests. 

JTX005 1-4 GRANTED

JTX006 3, 4 GRANTED

JTX009 13-15 GRANTED

JTX010 2-6

GRANTED

JTX026 3

GRANTED

JTX108 7

GRANTED

JTX114 2-3

GRANTED

JTX116

3, 7, 10-12, 16, 24, 

57, 59

GRANTED

JTX117 2-3, 5 GRANTED

JTX119

2,3, 5-11, 13-16, 

19-36, 38, 39, 41, 

48, 49, 52-54, 56-

57, 61-65, 67, 68, 

71-85 

GRANTED

JTX120 2, 3 GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 9 of

 40
10

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

JTX126

10-16, 19-22, 31-

32, 40, 46, 54-56, 

71-78

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

provisions on 19-22, 46, 71-78. GRANTED with 

respect to other requests. 

JTX127 8

GRANTED

JTX132 5, 13, 21-24

GRANTED

JTX136

3, 12, 19-22, 41, 

43, 

GRANTED

JTX143 4, 8, 11, 13, 15-20

GRANTED

PTX000086 1

GRANTED

PTX000154 1-2, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX000389 1, 7-10

GRANTED

PTX000406 1-2

GRANTED

PTX000453 3

GRANTED

PTX000485

8, 15-16, 24, 48-

50, 54, 57, 63, 68, 

70, 71, 73-74, 78-

79, 81, 89-90, 95, 

96, 103-115, 122, 

128-131, 144-145, 

147, 152, 157-158, 

160-162, 164-168

GRANTED

PTX000579 1-2

GRANTED

PTX000594 1-2, 4-5, 7-8

GRANTED

PTX000597 3-4, 6-7

GRANTED

PTX000598 2

GRANTED

PTX000610 1-2

GRANTED

PTX000612 5, 10-11 GRANTED

PTX000636 2-3

GRANTED

PTX000642 1

GRANTED

PTX000648 1-2, 4-5, 7-8

GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 10

 of 40
11

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX000662 1-2, 4-7

GRANTED

PTX000685 7

GRANTED

PTX000686 1-2

GRANTED

PTX000716 1, 3

GRANTED

PTX000727 1

GRANTED

PTX000830 2

GRANTED

PTX000852 1-2

GRANTED

PTX000891 1, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX000891.001 1, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX000893 4-6, 8, 17, 20

GRANTED

PTX000901 1, 4, 6-7

GRANTED

PTX000904 1-2, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX000904.001 1-2, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX000910 2

GRANTED

PTX000926 2

GRANTED

PTX000941 2, 5 GRANTED

PTX000949 6, 7

GRANTED

PTX000949.001 6, 7

GRANTED

PTX001006 2, 4, 5

GRANTED

PTX001007 1, 2

GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 11

 of 40
12

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX001008 1-4

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

provisions on 1-2. GRANTED with respect to other 

requests. 

PTX001010 1-2

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

provisions on 2. GRANTED with respect to other 

requests. 

PTX001011 2, 4

GRANTED

PTX001023 1-4

GRANTED

PTX001029 1-2

GRANTED

PTX001049 1, 5 GRANTED

PTX001049.001 1, 5 GRANTED

PTX001117 2

GRANTED

PTX001137 1, 2

GRANTED

PTX001154 2

GRANTED

PTX001215

6, 9-13, 15-16, 19, 

21, 24-28

GRANTED

PTX001238

2-24, 27-38, 40-

63, 66-77, 79

GRANTED

PTX001303 3

GRANTED

PTX001312 2-3

GRANTED

PTX001357

2-5, 8-9, 12-14, 

16, 18

GRANTED

PTX001378 4-103

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

provisions on 5-12, 15-16, 18-27, 29, 31-33, 36-39, 

43-46, 48-55, 57-65, 69, 71. GRANTED with respect 

to other requests. 

PTX001378.001 4-103

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

provisions on 5-12, 15-16, 18-27, 29, 31-33, 36-39, 

43-46, 48-55, 57-65, 69, 71. GRANTED with respect 

to other requests. 

PTX001388 2, 4 GRANTED

PTX001434

45-46, 48-49, 51-

52

GRANTED

PTX001474 2, 4 GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 12

 of 40
13

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX001477 5, 6 GRANTED

PTX001558 1-4

GRANTED

PTX001567 4-8

GRANTED

PTX001573 7,8,10-14 GRANTED

PTX001621 1-2

GRANTED

PTX001643 1, 3

GRANTED

PTX001647 1, 4

GRANTED

PTX001653 1

GRANTED

PTX001657 1

GRANTED

PTX001673 1-3

GRANTED

PTX001674 1

GRANTED

PTX001675 2-4, 8-10 GRANTED

PTX001684 1-7

GRANTED

PTX001684.001 1-7

GRANTED

PTX001686 1-2, 4-5, 7-13 GRANTED

PTX001686.001 1-2, 4-5, 7-13 GRANTED

PTX001690 1-2

GRANTED

PTX001749 4, 8, 13, 15-20

GRANTED

PTX001749.001 4, 8, 13, 15-20

GRANTED

PTX001785 1, 8-9, 11-12

GRANTED

PTX001785.001 1, 8-9, 11-12

GRANTED

PTX001832 4, 6-10

GRANTED

PTX001888 1-2, 4-5, 8

GRANTED

PTX001888.001 1-2, 4-5, 8

GRANTED

PTX001941 2-4

GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 13

 of 40
14

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX001943 2, 5

DENIED with respect to comments that are not 

financial or CBI in nature on 5. GRANTED with 

respect to other requests. 

PTX001963 3, 7-11

DENIED with respect to the “Antitrust/FRAND ‘peace 

treaty’ provision” on 11. 

PTX001984 1-5, 7 DENIED. 

PTX001992

6, 8, 10, 13-17, 19, 

21, 23, 25-29, 31-

33, 37-39, 43-48, 

52-54, 56-59

GRANTED

PTX001992.001

6, 8, 10, 13-17, 19, 

21, 23, 25-29, 31-

33, 37-39, 43-48, 

52-54, 56-59

GRANTED

PTX002027 1-3

GRANTED

PTX002043 2-5, 7-8

GRANTED

PTX002049 4, 9 GRANTED

PTX002064 1-7

GRANTED

PTX002068 5

GRANTED

PTX002104 6, 7, 9, 12, 13, 15 GRANTED

PTX002135

7-9, 13-14, 17, 19-

21, 23-26, 30, 39, 

42

GRANTED

PTX002144 2-68, 70-81

DENIED with respect to pages 2-18, 36-63, 70-81 

that are not financial or otherwise CBI and SULA 

terms unrelated to royalties. GRANTED with respect 

to other requests.

PTX002155

10, 14-16, 19-25, 

27-38, 49-63, 65

GRANTED

PTX002155.001

10, 14-16, 19-25, 

27-38, 49-63, 65

GRANTED

PTX002167 1-19 GRANTED

PTX002169 3

GRANTED

PTX002189 4, 5 GRANTED

PTX002240 1, 2 GRANTED

PTX002248 3-5, 7-11 GRANTED

PTX002261 3-5

GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 14

 of 40
15

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX002266 13, 14, 25-27 GRANTED

PTX002320 20-35 GRANTED

PTX002334 1

GRANTED

PTX002385 27-29

GRANTED

PTX002412 3-4, 7-9

GRANTED

PTX002412.001 3-4, 7-9

GRANTED

PTX002492 1

GRANTED

PTX002501 1-3

GRANTED

PTX002504 1-2

GRANTED

PTX002505 1-2

GRANTED

PTX002510 1-2

GRANTED

PTX002520 4-6

GRANTED

PTX002520.001 4-6

GRANTED

PTX002540 7-9, 14 GRANTED

PTX002540.001 7-9, 14 GRANTED

PTX002557 3

GRANTED

PTX002567 1

GRANTED

PTX002597

19, 34, 36, 41, 43, 

45

GRANTED

PTX002597.001

19, 34, 36, 41, 43, 

45

GRANTED

PTX002598 3-5, 8, 10, 11 GRANTED

PTX002598.001 3-5, 8, 10, 11 GRANTED

PTX002640 1-4

GRANTED

PTX002642 1

GRANTED

PTX002645 1-2

GRANTED

PTX002684 1, 4

GRANTED

PTX002709 1-2, 6-9, 16-21

DENIED with respect to pages 1-2, 16 relating to 

2015 business strategies that relate to issues in this 

case. 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 15

 of 40
16

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX002730

8, 12-13, 18-20, 

26-31

DENIED with respect to page 3, 4, 26 

regarding risks, overall strategic change, and 

mitigation strategies that are non-financial and 

CBI in nature. GRANTED with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX002738

4, 7, 8, 12, 19-22, 

28-33

DENIED with respect to Qualcomm’s mitigation 

strategies on page 28. GRANTED with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX002762 1-3

GRANTED

PTX002776 2, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX002776.001 2, 4-5

GRANTED

PTX002814 1, 3

GRANTED

PTX002814.001 1, 3

GRANTED

PTX002835

2, 5, 6-23, 25-27, 

32-36, 41-56, 71, 

73-75, 79-84

GRANTED

PTX002861 1

GRANTED

PTX002875 4-7

GRANTED

PTX002875.001 4-7

GRANTED

PTX002895 1

GRANTED

PTX002898 1

GRANTED

PTX002904 1-2

DENIED. 

PTX002914 15-16, 21, 26

GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 16

 of 40
17

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX002922

3, 12, 16-20, 22-

33, 35-42, 44

46, 49, 54-57, 60, 

64, 66, 80, 83, 84, 

86-88, 90, 94, 101-

102, 106, 107, 

110-111, 114, 116, 

118-120, 125, 130-

131, 139-143, 144, 

150, 155-158, 164, 

167, 169

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

information on pages 94, 116, and 175. GRANTTED 

with respect to the remainder. 

PTX002925 1-5

GRANTED

PTX002933 2-3

GRANTED

PTX002944 1

GRANTED

PTX002946

1, 7-9, 13-20, 22-

27, 30, 32-33, 35

DENIED with respect to page 8 regarding risks to 

Qualcomm’s business. GRANTED with respect to 

the remainder. 

PTX002946.001

1, 7-9, 13-20, 22-

27, 30, 32-33, 35

GRANTED

PTX002946.002

1, 7-9, 13-20, 22-

27, 30, 32-33, 35

GRANTED

PTX002972

2, 5, 8, 10-12, 14, 

17, 34-35, 37, 46, 

48, 49, 57, 59, 60, 

62, 71, 73, 81-82, 

84, 95, 97, 98, 

105-106, 108, 120-

121, 126, 133-136, 

138

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

information on 5, 8, 10, 48, 57, 73, 81, 97, 105, 121, 

and 134. GRANTED with respect ot the remainder. 

PTX003026 1, 4, 5 GRANTED

PTX003083 8-11, 14-16, 19-23

DENIED with respect to Lenovo’s options for 

Qualcomm on 8-11. GRANTED with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX003083.001 8-11, 14-16, 19-23

DENIED with respect to Lenovo’s options for 

Qualcomm on 8-11. GRANTED with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX003110 1

GRANTED

PTX003137

35, 37, 39-43, 48-

49, 74-76, 79

GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 17

 of 40
18

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX003268 2, 3, 5-7

GRANTED

PTX003296 8, 11 GRANTED

PTX003369

7, 9, 17, 19, 21, 

23, 31, 35, 39, 41, 

51, 59, 61, 72, 80, 

82, 86, 88, 90, 

100, 102, 104, 

108, 114, 116, 

128, 130, 132, 

134, 136, 138, 

140, 142, 144, 

146, 148

150, 152, 154, 

156, 158, 160, 

162, 164, 166, 

168, 172-175

DENIED with respect to 9, 21, 39, 128, 172-175 with 

respect to SEP analysis, Samsung non-CBI 

reference, non-CBI list of patents, references to 

certain assumptions about resolution with Apple and 

assumptions about Apple. GRANTED with respect to 

the remainder. 

PTX003386 1-2

DENIED. 

PTX003393 3-9

GRANTED

PTX003393.001 3-9

GRANTED

PTX003403 1

GRANTED

PTX003410 1

GRANTED

PTX003429 5, 13 GRANTED

PTX003447 3-16, 18

GRANTED

PTX003447.001 3-16, 18

GRANTED

PTX003471

4, 6-8, 10-14, 19-

21, 24-25, 27-33, 

35-41, 50-58, 63-

65, 68-69, 81-82, 

85-86, 95-99

DENIED with respect to information that is nonfinancial or CBI on 4, 19-21, 55-58. GRANTED with 

respect to the remainder. 

PTX003548

9, 12-14, 22, 23, 

26, 45

GRANTED

PTX003569 3, 6 GRANTED

PTX003571 2-4

GRANTED

PTX003585 3-4

GRANTED

PTX003587 2, 5, 9-20, 22-25 GRANTED

PTX003588 4-5, 10-14, 19-23 GRANTED

PTX003657 4-6, 15-18 GRANTED

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 18

 of 40
19

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Exhibit Page/Line Ruling

PTX003665 6, 9, 14, 21, 24 GRANTED

PTX003691 2, 5, 9 GRANTED

PTX003759 3-5, 9, 10, 12 GRANTED

PTX003795

2, 4-6, 8-12, 17-

19, 22-23, 25-27, 

29-31

DENIED with respect to non-financial or CBI 

information on 2, 18-20. GRANTED with respect to 

the remainder. 

PTX003796 1-7

GRANTED

PTX003798 2-10, 15

DENIED with respect to gag provisions. GRANTED 

with respect to the remainder. 

PTX003799 1-6, 9

DENIED with respect to patent exhaustion on 2, 4. 

GRANTED with respect to the remainder. 

PTX011034 1, 2, 4 GRANTED

PTX011036 1, 2 GRANTED

PTX011078 1

GRANTED

PTX011080 1-4, 8-9

GRANTED

PTX011127

2,3, 5-7, 9-12, 15-

19, 21-24, 26, 28-

31, 33, 35-38, 42-

45, 47-50, 52-59, 

63-64

GRANTED

PTX011255 9, 12, 13-17, 29 GRANTED

PTX011256

7, 10, 12, 15, 21-

22, 25-26, 29-31, 

35, 37-38, 40, 42

GRANTED

PTX011259 1, 2 GRANTED

PTX011263

10, 11, 16-18, 25-

29

DENIED with respect to Qualcomm’s mitigation 

strategies on 24. GRANTED with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX011264 1, 3-6

DENIED with respect to talking points on 3-5. 

GRANTED with respect to the remainder. 

PTX011269

3-4, 7-9, 11, 14-

16, 19, 29, 63, 67, 

70, 77, 79, 81-88, 

90-104

GRANTED

1

2

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 19

 of 40
20

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 20

 of 40
21

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1 Apple’s Requested Exhibits to Seal

2

Exhibit Information Sought to Be Sealed 

According to Apple and the CMs

Ruling

JTX006 

DTX00082

Q2017MDL1_01061812-816 AAPL-QC00128495-99DENIED as 

overbroad. The Court 

will GRANT 

Qualcomm’s narrower 

set of redactions as 

most of the redacted 

material is not 

sensitive business 

information or is at 

issue in this case. 

JTX010 Q2014FTC03250056 GRANTED.

JTX062 Q2017MDL1_03051478-79 

Q2017MDL1_03051481 

Q2017MDL1_03051484 

Q2017MDL1_03051486-92 

Q2017MDL1_03051499 

Q2017MDL1_03051508-09 

Q2014FTC00345631-632 

Q2014FTC00345634 

Q2014FTC00345637 

Q2014FTC00345639-640 

Q2014FTC00345640-641

Q2014FTC00345641-642 

Q2014FTC00345642-645

Q2014FTC00345652

Q2014FTC00345662

DENIED as overbroad. 

JTX006 

DTX00082

Q2017MDL1_01061812-816 AAPL-QC00128495-99DENIED as 

overbroad. The Court 

will GRANT 

Qualcomm’s narrower 

set of redactions as 

most of the redacted 

material is not 

sensitive business 

information or is at 

issue in this case. 

JTX010 Q2014FTC03250056 GRANTED.

JTX062 Q2017MDL1_03051478-79 

Q2017MDL1_03051481 

Q2017MDL1_03051484 

Q2017MDL1_03051486-92 

Q2017MDL1_03051499 

Q2017MDL1_03051508-09 

DENIED as overbroad. 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 21

 of 40
22

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Q2014FTC00345631-632 

Q2014FTC00345634 

Q2014FTC00345637 

Q2014FTC00345639-640 

Q2014FTC00345640-641

Q2014FTC00345641-642 

Q2014FTC00345642-645

Q2014FTC00345652 

Q2014FTC00345662

JTX063 

DTX01445

Pegatron_0000000649, paragraph 3

Pegatron_0000000654, paragraph 5.2

Pegatron_0000000655-661, paragraph 5.2.1

Pegatron_0000000661-664, paragraphs 5.6-

6.3

Pegatron_0000000672 

Pegatron_0000000681-684 

Pegatron_0000000686-687 

Q2017MDL1_03114799 

Q2017MDL1_03114804-811 

Q2017MDL1_03114822 

Q2017MDL1_03114831-834 

Q2017MDL1_03114836

DENIED. 

JTX102 APL-QC-FTC_14513387; APLQCFTC_14513402-03

DENIED.

JTX104 AAPL-FTC-00128293 DENIED as already public. 

JTX108 AAPL-FTC-00131619; AAPL-FTC00131640;

AAPL-FTC-00131642; AAPL-FTC00131644;

AAPL-FTC-00131672-74; AAPL-FTC00131676

AAPL-FTC-00131672-74; AAPL-FTC00131676

GRANTED.

JTX113 APL-QC-FTC_16508200-01 DENIED as these royalties 

are directly at issue in this 

case. 

PTX000409 

DTX00074

AAPL-FTC-00125254; AAPL-FTC00125256DENIED as stale. 

PTX000451 

DTX00907

Q2014FTC03938580-82 GRANTED.

PTX000461 

DTX00872

Q2014FTC00934630; Q2014FTC00934636-

37;

Q2014FTC00934639; Q2014FTC00934641-

42;

Q2014FTC00934644-50; 

Q2014FTC00934668-71; 

Q2014FTC00934674-75; 

Q2014FTC00934677-82; 

DENIED. 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 22

 of 40
23

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Q2014FTC00934630 

Q2014FTC00934636-637 

Q2014FTC00934639 

Q2014FTC00934641-642 

Q2014FTC00934644-645

Q2014FTC00934645-647 

Q2014FTC00934647-650 

Q2014FTC00934657, ¶14.2 

Q2014FTC00934668-669 

Q2014FTC00934671 

Q2014FTC00934674-675 

Q2014FTC00934677-678 

Q2014FTC00934678 

Q2014FTC00934679 

Q2014FTC00934680-683

Q2014FTC00934687 

Q2014FTC00934690

PTX000636 AAPL-FTC-00012322-24 GRANTED.

PTX000800 

DTX01015

Q2017MDL4_00013341 

Q2017MDL4_00013346 

Q2017MDL4_00013347-352 

Q2017MDL4_00013353-354 

Q2017MDL4_00013362 

Q2017MDL4_00013370-373 

Q2017MDL4_00013336-37; 

Q2017MDL4_00013341; 

Q2017MDL4_0001334649; 

Q2017MDL4_00013351

DENIED. 

PTX000809 

DTX00871

Q2014FTC00932770; Q2014FTC00932794-

95;

Q2014FTC00932799-800; 

Q2014FTC0093280410; 

Q2014FTC00932812; 

Q2014FTC00932799-800

Q2014FTC00932804-814 

Q2014FTC00932822 

Q2014FTC00932831-834

DENIED.

PTX000810 

DTX00934

Q2014FTC00418698 

Q2014FTC00418702 

Q2014FTC00418702 

Q2014FTC00418707-714 

Q2014FTC00418715-717 

Q2014FTC00418726 

Q2014FTC00418734-737 

Q2017MDL1_00304099; 

Q2017MDL1_00304103-104; 

Q2017MDL1_00304108-118; 

Q2017MDL1_00304127; 

DENIED. 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 23

 of 40
24

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Q2017MDL1_00304135138 

Q2014FTC004543250; 

Q2014FTC004543254; 

Q2014FTC004543255; 

Q2014FTC004543259-269; 

Q2014FTC004543278;

Q2014FTC004543286-289

PTX000941 PTX000941 at 1-9, 11 GRANTED.

PTX001038 PTX001038 at 1 DENIED as overbroad. 

PTX001162 Pegatron_0000000631-32 GRANTED.

PTX001422

DTX00029

AAPL-FTC-00035200 GRANTED.

PTX001429 

DTX00056

AAPL-FTC-00100547-49; AAPL-FTC0010055153 GRANTED.

PTX001436 

DTX00050

AAPL-FTC-00080047; AAPL-FTC00080050-51; AAPL-FTC-00080055-56 GRANTED.

PTX001457 

DTX00020

AAPL-FTC-00010255-56 GRANTED.

PTX001477 

DTX01456

Q2017MDL1_01247724-25; 

Q2017MDL1_01247728-30 

Q2014FTC01408454 

Q2014FTC01408455 

Q2014FTC01408458-461

 GRANTED.

PTX001496

DTX00054

PTX001496: APL-FTC-00087975-77,

AAPL FTC-00087981-83, AAPL-FTC00087985-87, AAPL -FTC-00087994-95

DTX0054: APL-QC-FTC_34560911-13;

APL-QCFTC_34560917-19; APL-QCFTC_34560921-23;

APL-QC-FTC_34560925; APLQCFTC_34560930-31

 GRANTED.

PTX001675 

DTX00254

APL-QC-FTC_14513290-92; APLQCFTC_14513296-98; APL-QCFTC_14513306;

APL-QC-FTC_14513320

DENIED as overbroad, 

previously made public, or at 

issue in the case. The Court 

will GRANT Qualcom’s 

narrower set of redactions.

PTX001713 APL-QC-FTC_26500921 DENIED as previously made 

public. 

PTX002043 AAPL-FTC-00077424-27; AAPL-FTC0007742930

 GRANTED.

PTX002135 

DTX00066

AAPL-FTC-00108173-74; AAPL-FTC00108176-

78; AAPL-FTC-00108182-83; AAPL-FTC00108186; AAPL-FTC-00108188-90; 

AAPL-FTC00108192-95; AAPL-FTC-00108199; 

AAPL-FTC00108204; AAPL-FTC-00108206; AAPLFTCDENIED as already public 

information. The Court will 

GRANT Qualcomm’s 

narrower redactions.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 24

 of 40
25

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

00108208; AAPL-FTC-00108211

PTX002189 AAPL-FTC-00128664-65 GRANTED.

PTX002240 AAPL-FTC-00005038-39 GRANTED.

PTX002320 

DTX01000

Q2014FTCO1246467

Q2014FTCO1246469

Q2014FTCO1246471

Q2014FTCO1246473

Q2014FTCO1246475-504

Q2014FTCO1246508

Q2017MDL1_03080403-06;

Q2017MDL1_03080408;

Q2017MDL1_03080410;

Q2017MDL1_03080412;

Q2017MDL1_0308041443;

Q2017MDL1_03080447

 GRANTED.

PTX002640 Q2014FTC04597436-38 GRANTED.

PTX002762 AAPL-FTC-00153047-49 GRANTED.

PTX002944 AAPL-FTC-00132744 GRANTED.

PTX003026 

DTX00097

APL-QC_00088525-26; APLQC_00088528-29DENIED as overbroad. 

The Court will GRANT 

Qualcomm’s narrower 

redactions.

PTX003031 APL-QC-FTC_07606882 DENIED as already public.

PTX003357

DTX00101

APL-QC_00450897-99; APLQC_00451010-11;

APL-QC_00451020-27; APLQC_00451032; APLQC_00451045; APL-QC_00451053-54

 GRANTED.

PTX003375

DTX01128

Pages 4-10, 13-14, 17-19 DENIED as overbroad and 

at-issue to the case.

PTX003605 

DTX00567

AAPL-FTC-00005290-291, 300 GRANTED.

PTX003606 

DTX00857

Pegatron_0001298536; 

Pegatron_0001298545; 

Pegatron_0001298550-51 

Pegatron_0001298536, paragraph 2.5 (b) 

Pegatron_0001298545, paragraph 7.3

Pegatron_0001298551, paragraph 14.1, 14.2

 GRANTED.

PTX003615 

DTX00829

Pegatron_ 0000053922; Pegatron_

0000053931;

Pegatron_ 0000053936-37 

Pegatron_0000053922, paragraph 2.5 (b) 

Pegatron_0000053931, paragraph 7.3

Pegatron_0000053937, paragraph 14.1

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 25

 of 40
26

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

PTX003656 

DTX00847

Pegatron_ 0000831093; Pegatron_

0000831095;

Pegatron_ 0000831098; Pegatron_

0000831100-06

Pegatron_0000831093, paragraph 3.4

Pegatron_0000831093, paragraph 3.5

DENIED as to 

indemnification information 

on page 4. 

PTX003661 

DTX00831

Pegatron_ 0000210803-04; Pegatron_

0000210806;

Pegatron_ 0000210809; Pegatron_

0000210811-16

Pegatron_0000210804, paragraph 3.1(b)(i) 

Pegatron_0000210804, paragraph 3.1(b)(ii) 

Pegatron_0000210804, paragraph 3.1(b)(iii) 

Pegatron_0000210804, paragraph 3.4

Pegatron_0000210804, paragraph 3.5

Pegatron_0000210806, paragraph 5.7 

Pegatron_0000210809

Pegatron_0000210811-

Pegatron_0000210816

 GRANTED.

PTX003677 

DTX00832

Pegatron_0000214163-64; 

Pegatron_0000214166; 

Pegatron_0000214171-72; 

Pegatron_000021417479 

Pegatron_0000214164, paragraph 

3.4

Pegatron_0000214164, paragraph 3.5

Pegatron_0000214166, paragraph 5.7

Pegatron_0000214171, paragraph 

5 Pegatron_0000214172 

Pegatron_0000214174-

Pegatron_0000214179

DENIED with respect 

to pages 4 and 9 as 

already public and 

overbroad. 

GRANTED in part 

with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX003684

DTX00017

AAPL-FTC-00000049, 70

APL-QC_00087671, 92

 GRANTED.

PTX003691 

DTX01368

AAPL-FTC-00005413-417 GRANTED.

PTX003700 

DTX00277

APL-QC-FTC_16514387 GRANTED.

PTX003703 

DTX00353

APL-QC-FTC_26392667-668 GRANTED.

PTX003714 

DTX01192

DTX-01192 at 3-4 DENIED as overbroad and 

already public. 

PTX003728 

DTX00436

APL-QC-FTC_36256878-886 GRANTED.

PTX003729 

DTX01359

Wistron_ 00004 75142_ 00001-04; Wistron_

00004

75142_ 00006-07

Wistron_0000475142_00001 

Wistron_0000475142_00002 

Wistron_0000475142_00003-00004, ¶7.8

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 26

 of 40
27

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Wistron_0000475142_00006 

Wistron_0000475142_00007

PTX003745 

DTX00084

AAPL-FTC-00130926-927 GRANTED.

PTX003747 

DTX00279

APL-QC-FTC_16514430-31 GRANTED.

PTX003756 

DTX00102

APL-QC_0045117-118, 133, 154 GRANTED.

PTX003767 

DTX00623

APL-QC-00451166, 168, 172, 176, 184,

186, 347348, 350

 GRANTED.

PTX003768 

DTX01193

PTX03768 at 2

DTX01193, Exhibit 11 Page 86, paragraph

5.1

DENIED with respect to 

indemnification on page 3. 

Already public and 

overbroad. 

PTX003777 

DTX00278

APL-QC-FTC_16514420-422 DENIED with respect to 

indemnification information 

on pages 1-3. Already public 

and overbroad. 

PTX003779

DTX00386

APL-QC-FTC_30594007, 017-019 GRANTED.

PTX003780 

DTX00404

APL-QC-FTC_32644283-285 DENIED.

PTX003783 

DTX01191

Pages 3-4 DENIED. Indemnification 

evidence is already-public 

and is at-issue. 

PTX003784 

DTX01194

Pages 3-4 DENIED.

PTX003785 

DTX01195

Pages 3-4 DENIED. 

PTX011034 AAPL-FTC-00128302-305 DENIED as stale and 

overbroad with respect 

to pages 1-3; the Court 

will adopt Qualcomm’s 

narrower set of 

redactions. GRANTED 

with respect to the 

remainder. 

PTX011036 

DTX01374

AAPL-FTC-00101148 DENIED as overbroad. 

The Court will adopt 

Qualcomm’s narrower 

set of redactions.

PTX011271 APL-QC-FTC_36177930-931 DENIED. 

DTX00021 AAPL-FT-00012225-36 GRANTED.

DTX00042 AAPL-FTC-00070233-34 DENIED as overbroad. 

The Court will adopt 

Qualcomms narrower set 

of redactions.

DTX00043 AAPL-FTC-00070277-78 DENIED as overbroad 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 27

 of 40
28

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

and stale. The Court will 

adopt Qualcomm’s 

narrower set of 

redactions.

DTX00044 AAPL-FTC-00070391 GRANTED.

DTX00047 AAPL-FTC-00075750 DENIED as stale and 

overbroad The Court will 

adopt Qualcomm’s 

narrower set of redactions.

DTX00051 AAPL-00080179-181 GRANTED.

DTX00057 AAPL-FTC-00100755, 757-760, 764-765 GRANTED.

DTX00064 AAPL-FTC-00106992-995 DENIED as overbroad 

The Court will adopt 

Qualcomm’s narrower set 

of redactions.

DTX00065 AAPL-FTC-00107709-711, 715-717, 724 DENIED as already 

public. 

DTX00068 DTX-00068 from 9-10, 12 DENIED as already public 

and overbroad. The Court 

will adopt Qualcomm’s 

narrower set of redactions.

DTX00078 AAPL-FTC-00128294-296 DENIED as already public. 

DTX00085 AAPL-FTC-00132140-141 GRANTED.

DTX00090 AAPL-FTC-00144026-029 GRANTED.

DTX00095 AAPL-FTC-00154236-237 GRANTED.

DTX00104 APL-QC_00458287-292, 294 GRANTED.

DTX00112 APL-QC_04376913-915 GRANTED.

DTX00243 Pages 2-8; 10, 12-17 (all of the attachment 

which does not have bates labels)

 GRANTED.

DTX00261 APL-QC-FTC_14804367-73; APLQCFTC_14804375-78; APL-QCFTC_14804381;

APL-QC-FTC_14804383-85; APLQCFTC_14804387-90; APL-QCFTC_14804394;

APL-QC-FTC_14804403; APLQCFTC_14804406

 GRANTED.

DTX00274 APL-QC-FTC_16508197 GRANTED.

DTX00298 APL-QC-FTC_20443065; APL-QCFTC_20443070-73; APL-QCFTC_20443076-77

APL-QC-FTC_20443079-82; APLQCFTC_20443086-87; APL-QCFTC_20443091;

APL-QC-FTC_20443100-01; APLQCFTC_20443104-05; APL-QC-

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 28

 of 40
29

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

FTC_20443110-12; APL-QCFTC_20443123; APL-QCFTC_20443128; APL-QCFTC_20443131;

APLQC-FTC_20443133; APL-QCFTC_20443141-42;

APL-QC-FTC_20443145-47; APLQCFTC_20443149-50; APL-QCFTC_20443158;

APL-QC-FTC_20443162; APL-QCFTC_20443168-69; APL-QCFTC_20443173;

APL-QC-FTC_20443175-77; APLQCFTC_20443185-87; APL-QCFTC_20443190;

APL-QC-FTC_20443192; APL-QCFTC_20443195; APL-QCFTC_20443198;

APLQC-FTC_20443200-01; APLQCFTC_20443205-

06; APL-QC-FTC_20443209; APLQCFTC_20443212-13; APL-QCFTC_20443216;

APL-QC-FTC_20443218-21; APLQCFTC_20443223; APL-QCFTC_20443226-27;

APL-QC-FTC_20443230-31; 33; 

APLQCFTC_20443236; APL-QCFTC_20443240-43;

APL-QC-FTC_20443245; APL-QCFTC_20443247; APL-QC-FTC_20443249; 

APLQC-FTC_20443251; APL-QCFTC_20443252;

APL-QC-FTC_20443261; APLQCFTC_20443265; APL-QCFTC_20443268

DTX00321 APL-QC-FTC_22481437-41; APLQCFTC_22481443

 GRANTED.

DTX00324 APL-QC-FTC_22482714-18 DENIED as overbroad. 

DTX00370 APL-QC-FTC_29334869-74; APLQCFTC_29334877; APL-QCFTC_29334879-83;

APL-QC-FTC_29334885

 GRANTED.

DTX00382 APL-QC-FTC_30330006-07; APLQCFTC_30330009-13

 GRANTED.

DTX00388 ENTIRE DOC DENIED as overbroad and 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 29

 of 40
30

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

directly relevant to the 

claims at issue. 

DTX00390 ENTIRE DOC DENIED as stale and 

overbroad. 

DTX00395 APL-QC-FTC_32299877-78 GRANTED.

DTX00399 APL-QC-FTC_32616906 GRANTED.

DTX00401 APL-QC-FTC_32617099-100; APL-QCFTC_32617102-06; APL-QCFTC_32617109-10;

APL-QC-FTC_32617112-13 APL-QCFTC_32617118; APL-QC-FTC_32617141;

APLQC-FTC_32617158-61; APL-QCFTC_32617180

 GRANTED.

DTX00476 APL-QC-FTC_37390109-11 DENIED.

DTX00477 APL-QC-FTC_37390826; APLQCFTC_37390829-30

DENIED with respect 

to pages 7-8. 

GRANTED with 

respect to page 4. 

DTX00482 APL-QC-FTC_37394382-83 DENIED. 

DTX00483 APL-QC-FTC_37394422-23 DENIED.

DTX00546 Compal_0000356768

Compal_0000356770

Compal_0000356774-775

Compal_0000356777

Compal_0000356779

Compal_0000356790

Compal_0000356791-794

 GRANTED.

DTX00548 DTX00548 at 3-13 GRANTED with respect to 

non-party names. DENIED 

with respect to the 

remainder. 

DTX00565 ERJC-QCOM-00019614-15 GRANTED.

DTX00579 Foxconn_0000070393 DENIED. 

DTX00581 Foxconn_0000094563;

Foxconn_0000094568;

Foxconn_0000094571-72

 GRANTED.

DTX00582 Foxconn_0000121086

Foxconn_0000121093

Foxconn_0000121095

Foxconn_0000121097

Foxconn_0000121098

Foxconn_0000121099-1100

Foxconn_0000121101

Foxconn_0000121086;

Foxconn_0000121093-95;

Foxconn_0000121097-101

DENIED with respect to page

10. GRANTED with respect 

to the remainder.

DTX00583 Foxconn_0000123115-116 

Foxconn_0000123119 

Foxconn_0000123121 

DENIED with respect to 

product code names on 

pages 7-8 and discussion 

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 30

 of 40
31

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Foxconn_0000123122 

Foxconn_0000123123-124 

Foxconn_0000123125 

Foxconn_0000123111-12; 

Foxconn_000012311516; 

Foxconn_0000123118-19; 

Foxconn_0000123121-25

on 12-13. GRANTED with 

respect to the remainder.

DTX00585 Foxconn_0000200348 

Foxconn_0000200350 

Foxconn_0000200351 

Foxconn_0000200348;

Foxconn_0000200350-51

DENIED with respect to 

pages 5 and 7. GRANTED 

with respect to the 

remainder.

DTX00586 DTX00586 at 4-11 GRANTED.

DTX00588 Foxconn_0000572869_00003 

Foxconn_0000572869_00004 ¶7.2(b), 7.5

Foxconn_0000572869_00007 

Foxconn_0000572869_00009-00010

Foxconn_0000572869_00013 

Foxconn_0001191278 ¶5.4, 5.5

Foxconn_0001191279 ¶7.2(b), 7.5 

Foxconn_0001191282-283 

Foxconn_0001191284-287 

Foxconn_0001191290 

Foxconn_0000087845 ¶5.4, 5.5

Foxconn_0000087846 ¶7.2(b), 7.5 

Foxconn_0000087849-850 

Foxconn_0000087852-856 

Foxconn_0000087859

AAPL-FTC-00005119 ¶5.4, 5.5

AAPL-FTC-00005120 ¶7.2(b), 7.5 

AAPL-FTC-00005123-124

AAPL-FTC-00005126-130 

AAPL-FTC-00005133 Foxconn 

0000768097 ¶4.3, 4.4

Foxconn 0000768098 ¶5.3(b)

Foxconn 0000768099 ¶5.6

Foxconn 0000768101-102

Foxconn 0000768104 AAPLFTC-00159009 AAPL-FTC00159010 AAPL-FTC00159011 AAPL-FTC00159013-9014 AAPL-FTC00159016

Foxconn_0000153229

Foxconn_0000153231

Foxconn_0000153233-235

Foxconn_0000153237

Foxconn_0000080514-515

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 31

 of 40
32

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Foxconn_0000080521-522

DTX0588 Pages 6, 7, 10, 12, 

13, 16, 21, 22,

25 to

30, 33, 38, 39, 42, 43, 45 to 

49, 52, 57, 58,

61, 62,

64 to 68, 71, 75 to 77, 79, 

80, 82, 85 to 87,

89, 90, 92, 95 to 97, 99 to 

101, 103, 106,

107, 108, 113, 114

DTX00595 Foxconn 0000583745_00001

Foxconn 0000583745_00005

Foxconn 0000583745_00007

Foxconn 0000583745_00012

 GRANTED.

DTX00605 DTX00605 Page 6 GRANTED.

DTX00704 INTEL-QCOM007541467-69; 

INTELQCOM007541471-74

 GRANTED.

DTX00835 Pegatron_0000411850

Pegatron_0000411851

 GRANTED.

DTX00837 Pegatron_0000489297, 298

Pegatron_0000489297, paragraph 5.1

DENIED.

DTX00839 Pegatron_0000621871_00002, 004, 010-018

Pegatron_0000621871_00002 

Pegatron_0000621871_00004, paragraph 

5.7

Pegatron_0000621871_00009, paragraph 

5 Pegatron_0000621871_00010 

Pegatron_0000621871_00012-

621871_00017

Pegatron_0000621871-00018

DENIED

DTX00840 Native file, Tab 1, cells M4, N4, Q4, S4, T4,

U4, and V4

 GRANTED.

DTX00842 Pegatron_0000807205 to 207 GRANTED.

DTX00852 Pegatron_0001269562 to 563

Pegatron_0001269562, paragaph 5.1

DENIED.

DTX00853 Pegatron_0001269562 to 563

Pegatron_0001269562, paragaph 5.1

DENIED.

DTX00854 Pegatron_0001284123 to 124 

Pegatron_0001284123-1284124, 

paragaph 5.1

DENIED.

DTX00856 Pegatron_0001284831 

Pegatron_0001284832, paragraph (a), (b)(i) 

and (ii)

Pegatron_0001284833, paragraph 19

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 32

 of 40
33

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DTX00858 Pegatron_0001298598, 600, 601, 603, 605 to

610

Pegatron_0001298598, paragraph 3.4

Pegatron_0001298598, paragraph 3.5

Pegatron_0001298600, paragraph 5.7

Pegatron_0001298603

Pegatron_0001298605-

Pegatron_0001298610

DTX00860 Pegatron_0001301438, 473, 475, 476, 479,

481 to

488

Pegatron_0001301438, paragaph 9

Pegatron_0001301473, paragaph 8

Pegatron_0001301475

Pegatron_0001301476

Pegatron_0001301479, paragraph 5

Pegatron_0001301481, paragraph 5, 6.1, 6.2,

6.3

Pegatron_0001301482, paragraph 6.4.6.5

Pegatron_0001301482-0001301483,

paragraph 8

Pegatron_0001301484-0001301488

DTX00861 PEGATRON_1000000002

PEGATRON_1000000023

PEGATRON_1000000004

PEGATRON_1000000009-10, paragraph

1.29, 1.33

PEGATRON_1000000012, paragraph 3.1

PEGATRON_1000000013, paragraph 3.6

PEGATRON_1000000016, paragraph (f)

and 6.1

PEGATRON_1000000017, paragraph 6.4

GRANTED.

DTX00892 Q2014FTC03405678; Q2014FTC03405681-

82;

Q2014FTC03405687; Q2014FTC03405697; 

Q2014FTC03405673-674 

Q2014FTC03405676

Q2014FTC03405678 

Q2014FTC03405680-681 

Q2014FTC03405681-682 

DENIED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 33

 of 40
34

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Q2014FTC03405682-686 

Q2014FTC03405693

DTX00998 Q2017MDL1_03055012-23 

Q2014FTC01221073-1084

GRANTED with respect to 

non-party names. DENIED 

with respect to the 

remainder.

DTX01045 QAPPCMSD06701327 DENIED.

DTX01050 Entire document DENIED.

DTX01189 Entire document DENIED.

DTX01207 Foxconn_0000954256 

Foxconn_0000954257 

Foxconn_0000954262-263 

Foxconn_0000954264 

Foxconn_0001177008-012 

Foxconn_0001177017 

Foxconn_0001177019 

Foxconn_0001177021 

Foxconn_0001177023 

Foxconn_0001177025

Foxconn_0001177028 

Foxconn_0001177029 

Foxconn_0001176957 

Foxconn_0001176958 

Foxconn_0001176959 

Foxconn_0001176960 

Foxconn_0001176962 

Foxconn_0001176970 

Foxconn_0000728250_00007 

Foxconn_0000728250_00008 

Foxconn_0000728250_00009 

Foxconn_0000728250_00015-00029

Foxconn_0001176906 

Foxconn_0001176908 

Foxconn_0001176910 

Foxconn_0001176911 

Foxconn_0001176915 

Foxconn_0001176916 

Foxconn_0001176918 

Foxconn_0001176929

 GRANTED.

DTX01208 AAPL-FTC-00080793 

AAPL-FTC-00080794 

AAPL-FTC-00080797 

AAPL-FTC-00080800

Foxconn_0000572332_00003 

Foxconn_0000572332_00004 

Foxconn_0000572332_00007 

Foxconn_0000572332_00008 

Foxconn_0000572332_00011 

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 34

 of 40
35

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Foxconn_0000572869_00003 

Foxconn_0000572869_00004 

Foxconn_0000572869_00007

Foxconn_0000572869_00009-00010

Foxconn_0001191278 

Foxconn_0001191279 

Foxconn_0001191282-287 

Foxconn_0001191290 

Foxconn_0000087845 

Foxconn_0000087846 

Foxconn_0000087849-850 

Foxconn_0000087852-856 

Foxconn_0000087859 

AAPL-FTC-00005119 

AAPL-FTC-00005120 

AAPL-FTC-00005123-124 

AAPL-FTC-00005126-130 

AAPL-FTC-00005133

Foxconn_0001191320 

Foxconn_0001191321 

Foxconn_0001191322 

Foxconn_0001191324-325 

AAPL-FTC-00159009 

AAPL-FTC-00159010 

AAPL-FTC-00159011 

AAPL-FTC-00159013-014

Foxconn_0000153229 

Foxconn_0000153230 

Foxconn_0000153231 

Foxconn_0000153233-235 

Foxconn_0000080514-515 

Foxconn_0000080521-522

AAPL-FTC-00080793;

Foxconn_0000572332_00002; 

Foxconn_0000572869_00002;

Foxconn_0001191277; 

Foxconn_0000087844; 

AAPL-FTC-00005118;

Foxconn_0001191319-20;

MPL-FTC-00159008-09; Foxconn 

0000153228-29;

Foxconn 0000080515-16;

Foxconn_0000080522

DTX01350 Page 

6

Page 

7

Page 8

Page 10

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 35

 of 40
36

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DTX01353 Wistron_0000278617 

Wistron_0000278619 

Wistron_0000278633 

Wistron_0000278636 

Wistron_0000278637 

Wistron_0000278638, ¶ 4 and 5.1

Wistron_0000278639, ¶ 8

Wistron_0000278617, 619, 633, 636 to 639

 GRANTED.

DTX01354 Wistron_0000296747-748 GRANTED.

DTX01356 Wistron_0000324216 

Wistron_0000324216 to 217

 GRANTED.

DTX01357 Wistron_0000332200, ¶ 4.4 and 4.5

Wistron_0000332201, ¶ 4.8 

Wistron_0000332203

 GRANTED.

DTX01363 WISTRON 1000000106

WISTRON 1000000107

WISTRON 1000000107

WISTRON 1000000108

 GRANTED.

DTX01367 AAPL-FTC-00005290-92 GRANTED.

DTX01375 AAPL-FTC-00123664-71 DENIED with respect 

to pages 4, 7, and 8.

DTX01381 AAPL-FTC-00131937-44 GRANTED.

DTX01386 APL-QC_00451162, 166 to 168, 172, 176,

184, 186, 198 to 345, 347, 348, 350

 GRANTED.

DTX01420 APL-QC-FTC_33497306 GRANTED.

DTX01425 APL-QC-FTC_37394004-4007 

APL-QC-FTC_37394013-4017

APL-QC-FTC_37394021, paragraph 5.6 and 

5.9

APL-QC-FTC_37394022, paragraph (c) 

APL-QC-FTC_37394022, paragraph 8.7 

APL-QC-FTC_37394026

APL-QC-FTC_37394027 

APL-QC-FTC_37394030 

APL-QC-FTC_37394032 

APL-QC-FTC_37394033

DENIED with respect to 

indemnification and nonCBI information on pages 4-

7, 13-15, 17, and 23. 

GRANTED with respect to 

the remainder.

DTX01447 Pegatron_0000485684

Pegatron_0000485685

Pegatron_0000485686

Pegatron_0000485687

Pegatron_0000485688

Pegatron_0000485690

Pegatron_0000485691-696

 GRANTED.

DTX01450 Pegatron_0000749605, paragaph 5.1

Pegatron_0000749605 to 606

 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 36

 of 40
37

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DTX01478 WISTRON 1000000117

WISTRON 1000000118

WISTRON 1000000121, ¶3.1

WISTRON 1000000122, ¶3.3, 3.4

WISTRON 1000000125, ¶(f)

WISTRON 1000000126, ¶6.1

WISTRON 1000000129, ¶6.9

WISTRON 1000000130, ¶6.9

WISTRON 1000000133, ¶6.20

DENIED.

DTX19462 Page 3 and 4 Licensing Management

Section-SEP licensing contracts currently

signed by Pegatron Page 5 and 6 Licensing

Management Section-Audit

Page 7 a Licensing Management SectionRoyalty

Page 9-10

Page 11

Page 12

Page 13

Page 14

Pages 3-14 in part

 GRANTED.

1

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 37

 of 40
- 38 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1

2

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 38

 of 40
- 39 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1 Apple’s Will Call Designations

2

Deponent 

Name

Deposition 

Date

Information Sought 

to Be Sealed 

According to Apple 

and the CMs

Basis for Objection

Achour, 

Baaziz

2/21/2018 97:17-98:15 GRANTED.

Ahn, Seung 3/28/2018 71:06-72:05; 73:16-20 GRANTED.

Blumberg, Ira 4/20/2018 141:07-18;

141:20-142:04

 GRANTED.

Chen, Vincent 2/12/2018 124:17 GRANTED.

Copper, 

Kimberly

5/4/2018 24:15-18; 24:20-21;

25:01-11;

26:14-20;

46:11-18;

46:20-22;

54:03-08;

54:10-19;

57:22-24;

58:02-04;

61:12-18

 GRANTED.

Ding, Jian Xin 3/7/2018 112:06-08; 112:11 GRANTED.

Lutton, 

Richard

5/11/2018 247:15-248:23;

Counters: 181:16-24

 GRANTED.

Moynihan,

John

3/23/2018 163:03-07 GRANTED.

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 39

 of 40
- 40 -

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Risher, Jeff 4/18,/2018 95:19-96:14; 96:20-

98:06;

222:16-223:05;

225:03-15

 GRANTED.

Sauer,

Matthias

4/19/2018 231:22-232:05

Counters: 86:08-15;

95:04-06;

104:02-10;

174:16-19;

182:18-23;

182:25-183:01;

229:21-230:03

 GRANTED.

Teskler, Boris 4/20/2018 87:02-06;

Counters: 50:1351:04;

86:21-87:01;

91:18-24;

132:23-134:02;

140:17-141:19;

142:05-09;

142:11-14;

177:07-17;

180:17-181:15

DENIED.

Tien, Shawn 3/15/2018 78:22;

79:02-04

 GRANTED.

Wang, Renee 5/25/2018 93:04; 93:08;

95:03;

95:06;

97:16;

98:06;

98:09;

98:13

 GRANTED.

Wang, Selena 6/14/2018 170:08;

170:13-171:01;

172:09;

172:11-173:07;

175:02-12;

185:24;

186:04;

186:15;

191:18

 GRANTED.

1

Case 3:17-cv-00108-GPC-MDD Document 1155 Filed 04/15/19 PageID.<pageID> Page 40

 of 40