Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-azd-3_95-cv-01313/USCOURTS-azd-3_95-cv-01313-2/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 442
Nature of Suit: Civil Rights Employment
Cause of Action: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act

---

984241 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

WO 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

DISTRICT OF ARIZONA 

George Rudebusch, et. al, 

 Plaintiffs, 

v. 

State Of Arizona; Northern Arizona 

University; The Arizona Board Of Regents, 

 Defendants. 

NO. CIV 95-1313-PCT RCB and 

NO. CIV 96-1077 PCT RCB 

JUDGMENT 

(Assigned to the Honorable Robert C. 

Broomfield) 

The parties jointly submitted the following proposed judgment. By jointly 

submitting this proposed judgment, the parties agree only that the form of judgment and 

damage calculations are correct based on the Court’s rulings. Neither party waives the 

right to appeal any other issue or prior ruling. 

On June 30, 1995, Plaintiff=s George Rudebusch, et al., filed the first of two 

consolidated cases, CIV 95-1313 PCT RCB. In this class action Complaint, the Plaintiffs 

alleged violations of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and Civil 

Rights Act violations pursuant to 42 U.S.C. '1981 and 42 U.S.C. '1983 suing Defendant 

Hughes in his individual capacity. 

Thereafter, on May 2, 1996 forty individual plaintiffs filed a related action against 

Defendants in CIV96-1077 PCT RCB. In this Complaint, the Plaintiffs alleged violations 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 1 of 30
 2 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

of Title VII of the Civil Rights act of 1964, as amended. The Court granted Plaintiffs=

motion to consolidate theses case on November 1, 1996. 

Defendant Hughes responded to the Equal Protection claims by moving for 

summary judgment on qualified immunity grounds. This Court granted the motion in 

part, concluding that the law was clearly established and that Defendant Hughes was 

reasonable in concluding that a compelling interest justified his actions. But this Court 

reserved for trial the ultimate issue of qualified immunity because of factual issues 

surrounding the remedy imposed. 

On December 12, 2000, this case proceeded to a jury trial (Minute Entry (doc.233) 

in which evidence was considered over the course of four days. Id. at 233-27. On 

December 18, 2000, the jury rendered its verdict in Defendants’ favor and Judgment was 

entered thereon December 29, 2000. See doc.=s 241, 248. On January 24, 2000, 

Plaintiffs filed their Notice of Appeal. Notice (doc. 250). 

On December 18, 2003, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a mandate which 

affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded the case to this Court for additional 

proceedings. Mandate (doc.259). The Ninth Circuit’s decision affirmed the judgment in 

favor of the Defendants in CIV 95-1313 PCT RCB, the class action equal protection claim 

against Eugene Hughes and his spouse in their individual capacities. 

The only case that survived the Ninth Circuit’s decision was the Title VII claim by 

the forty individual Plaintiffs. The sole issue remaining for determination upon remand 

was whether Defendants could be held liable under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 

1964, 42 U.S.C. '2000 et seq. Id at 32. 

At a pretrial conference held on December 19, 2003, the parties stipulated to try the 

remaining issues on remand to this Court, as opposed to a jury, at a trial which would 

commence on January 6, 2004. Minute Entry (doc.267). Also, on December 19, 2003, 

the parties stipulated that, for purposes of the January 6, 2004 trial, the Court would 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 2 of 30
 3 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

determine the issue of Aliability@ under Title VII only, and that if a determination of 

liability is made, Athe Court will set a later trial date and will grant the parties an 

opportunity to conduct additional discovery@ as to the question of damages. Order 

(doc.268) at 3. 

On January 4, 2004, the Court conducted the trial to the issue of Title VII liability 

as ordered by the Ninth Circuit=s mandate. Minute Entry (doc.269). On June 30, 2004, 

the Court issued its Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on this matter, finding that 

liability for Defendants= violation of Title VII had been established. Order (doc.277). 

The Court noted that damages in relation to this violation was a factual issue that the 

parties stipulated would be present at a later trial after additional discovery was taken. Id.

at 20. 

On September 28, 2005, Defendants filed Motion for Summary Judgment on the 

issue of damages. Motion (doc.16). Thereafter, Plaintiffs filed their response to this 

Motion, as well as, a Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment. Cross-Motion (doc.305). 

The Motions were fully briefed on January 23, 2006. P. Reply (doc.315). 

IT ITS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendants= Motion for Summary Judgment 

(doc.16 in case number CIV 96-1077 PCT RLB) is denied. 

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiffs= Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment 

(doc.305 in case number CIV 95-1313 PCT RLB) is GRANTED in all respects but for 

Plaintiffs= request for attorneys= fees which was not properly filed in accordance with Local 

Rule 54.2. 

 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiffs shall be awarded damages as set forth 

below: 

The total sum designated as “lost salary” for each Plaintiff shall be subject to (a) 

FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare tax); (b) employment tax withholding, and (c) 

reporting by NAU to the IRS on Form W-2 as Social Security and Medicare wages for the 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 3 of 30
 4 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

calendar year in which it is paid. 

For each Plaintiff except Plaintiff Riskin, the amount of “lost salary,” minus the 

employee’s contribution to ASRS or the ORP shall be (a) taxable as “wages;” (b) subject 

to federal and state income tax withholding; and (c) reported by NAU to the IRS on Form 

W-2 for the calendar year in which it is paid. For Plaintiff Riskin, the amount of “lost 

salary” shall be (a) taxable as “wages,” (b) subject to federal and state income tax 

withholding; and (c) reported by NAU to the IRS on Form W-2 for the calendar year in 

which it is paid. 

For each Plaintiff except Plaintiff Riskin, the amount designated as “interest on lost 

salary,” minus interest paid to the Arizona State Retirement System (ASRS) or the 

Optional Retirement Plan (ORP) as interest on Plaintiff’s retirement contributions, will be 

reported to the IRS on Form 1099-INT. The interest payment will not be subject to federal 

income tax withholding. All lost interest awarded to Plaintiff Riskin will be reported to the 

IRS on Form 1099-INT and shall not be subject to federal income tax withholding. 

Subject to these provisions, judgment to the individual Plaintiffs shall be as follows: 

James Bartell

 Plaintiff James Bartell shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$46,211.61, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $23,345. Of that amount, $752.20 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System and submitted to ASRS on the 

Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $21,421. Of that amount $693.41 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 4 of 30
 5 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Employer ASRS Contribution: $752.20. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $693.41. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System. 

Gary Bateman

Plaintiff Gary Bateman shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$8,463, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $3,427. Of that amount, $240 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $4,482. Of this amount, $314 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $240. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $314. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Harvey Becher 

Plaintiff Harvey Becher shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$77,849, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $34,012. Of that amount, $2,381 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 5 of 30
 6 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Lost Salary: $38,744. Of this amount, $2,712 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,381. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $2,712. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

John Bloom 

Plaintiff John Bloom shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$7,840, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $3,058. Of that amount, $214 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $4,269. Of this amount, $299 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $214. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $299. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Burton Brown

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 6 of 30
 7 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Plaintiff Burton Brown shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$74,177, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $40,063. Of that amount, $2,804 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $29,262. Of this amount, $2,048 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,804. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $2,048. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Craig Caldwell

Plaintiff Craig Caldwell shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$3,315.76, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $1,243. Of that amount, $39.03 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System and submitted to ASRS on the 

Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $1,974. Of that amount $59.73 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 7 of 30
 8 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Employer ASRS Contribution: $39.03. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $59.73. This amount will be paid on 

Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Keith Cunningham 

Plaintiff Keith Cunningham shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total 

sum of $22,255, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $12,627. Of that amount, $884 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $8,172. Of this amount, $572 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $884. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $572. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,022. 

Thomas Dillingham

Plaintiff Thomas Dillingham shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total 

sum of $1,963, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 8 of 30
 9 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Lost Salary: $1,114. Of that amount, $78 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $721. Of this amount, $50 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $78. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $50. This amount will be 

paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by $89. 

Michael Falk

Plaintiff Michael Falk shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$64,548, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $37,171. Of that amount, $2,602 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $23,154. Of this amount, $1,621 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,602. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 9 of 30
 10 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,621. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$3,146. 

Jay Farness

Plaintiff Jay Farness shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$102,916.72, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $60,389. Of that amount, $2,257.10 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System through fiscal year 2006 and 

submitted to ASRS on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $38,974. Of that amount $1,296.62 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution through fiscal year 2006. The 

balance shall be paid directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal 

Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $2,257.10. This amount will be paid on 

Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System 

for contributions through fiscal year 2006. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $1,296.62. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System for interest on contributions through fiscal year 2006. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$4,903. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 10 of 30
 11 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Steven Funk

Plaintiff Steven Funk shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$30,886.49, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $18,141. Of that amount, $678.02 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System through fiscal year 2006 and 

submitted to ASRS on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $11,679. Of that amount $388.47 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contributions through fiscal year 2006. The 

balance shall be paid directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal 

Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $678.02. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System for 

contributions through fiscal year 2006. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $388.47. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System for contributions through fiscal year 2006. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,473. 

Clarence Harrison

Plaintiff Clarence Harrison shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $1,590, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $620. Of that amount, $43 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 11 of 30
 12 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Lost Salary: $866. Of this amount, $61 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $43. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $61. This amount will be 

paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

William Hildred 

Plaintiff William Hildred shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $70,017, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $32,825. Of that amount, $2,298 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $32,611. Of this amount, $2,283 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,298. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $2,283. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

John Hill

Plaintiff John Hill shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$5,411, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 12 of 30
 13 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Lost Salary: $2,031. Of that amount, $142 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $3,026. Of this amount, $212 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $142. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $212. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan.

 Thomas Hoisch 

Plaintiff Thomas Hoisch shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$65,530, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $37,802. Of that amount, $2,646 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $23,441. Of this amount, $1,641 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,646. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 13 of 30
 14 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,641. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$3,183. 

Edward Hood 

Plaintiff Edward Hood shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$32,271, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $18,509. Of that amount, $1,296 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $11,650. Of this amount, $816 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,296. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $816. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,786. 

Guenther Huck

Plaintiff Guenther Huck shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$44,013, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 14 of 30
 15 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Lost Salary: $24,953. Of that amount, $1,747 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $16,180. Of this amount, $1,133 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,747. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,133. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,954. 

Stephen Jackson

Plaintiff Stephen Jackson shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $6,788, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $2,560. Of that amount, $179 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $3,784. Of this amount, $265 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $179. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 15 of 30
 16 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $265. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Arnold Johnson

Plaintiff Arnold Johnson shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$7,949.76, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $2,980. Of that amount, $93.57 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System and submitted to ASRS on the 

Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $4,733. Of that amount $143.19 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $93.57. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $143.19. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System. 

David Kitterman 

Plaintiff David Kitterman shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $23,945, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $13,581. Of that amount, $951 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 16 of 30
 17 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Lost Salary: $8,797. Of this amount, $616 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $951. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $616. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,088. 

Stephen Lapan

Plaintiff Stephen Lapan shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$8,694.98, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $5,149. Of that amount, $193.01 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System through fiscal year 2006 and 

submitted to ASRS on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $3,245. Of that amount $107.97 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution through fiscal year 2006. The 

balance shall be paid directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal 

Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $193.01. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System for 

contributions through fiscal year 2006. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 17 of 30
 18 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $107.97. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System for contributions through fiscal year 2006. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by $432. 

Eugene Loverich 

Plaintiff Eugene Loverich shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $84,764, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $47,002. Of that amount, $3,290 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $32,217. Of this amount, $2,255 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $3,290. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $2,255. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$4,274. 

Michael Malone 

Plaintiff Michael Malone shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $10,377, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 18 of 30
 19 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Lost Salary: $5,938. Of that amount, $416 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $3,760. Of this amount, $263 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $416. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $263. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by $450. 

Ken Nicholls 

Plaintiff Ken Nicholls shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$50,479, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $22,809. Of that amount, $1,597 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $24,367. Of this amount, $1,706 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,597. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 19 of 30
 20 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,706. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Andrew O’Dell 

Plaintiff Andrew O’Dell shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$57,610, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $27,846. Of that amount, $1,949 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $25,995. Of this amount, $1,820 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,949. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,820. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Richard Packard

Plaintiff Richard Packard shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $6,749.71, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $2,722. Of that amount, $97.62 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System and submitted to ASRS on the 

Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $3,800. Of that amount $130.09 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 20 of 30
 21 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $97.62. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $130.09. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System. 

Gilbert Pogany

Plaintiff Gilbert Pogany shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$23,657.06, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $9,234. Of that amount, $320.12 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $13,650. Of that amount $452.94 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $320.12. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $452.94. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System. 

Timothy Porter 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 21 of 30
 22 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Plaintiff Timothy Porter shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$29,326, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $16,792. Of that amount, $1,175 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $10,616. Of this amount, $743 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,175. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $743. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,328. 

Loren Reser 

Plaintiff Loren Reser shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$44,042, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $24,980. Of that amount, $1,749 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $16,180. Of this amount, $1,133 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 22 of 30
 23 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,749. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,133. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$2,002. 

Adrian Riskin 

Plaintiff Adrian Riskin shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$12,326, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $5,341. Professor Riskin was a member of the ASRS, but terminated 

his membership and withdrew all funds. No retirement contributions are being 

made on his behalf.

Interest on Lost Salary: $6,985. 

George Rudebusch 

Plaintiff George Rudebusch shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total 

sum of $140,130, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $78,333. Of that amount, $5,483 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $52,630. Of this amount, $3,684 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 23 of 30
 24 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $5,483. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $3,684. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$6,096. 

Howard Salisbury 

Plaintiff Howard Salisbury shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $79,965, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $37,611. Of that amount, $2,633 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $37,122. Of this amount, $2,599 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,633. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $2,599. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Michael Sanera 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 24 of 30
 25 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Plaintiff Michael Sanera shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$14,787, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $5,662. Of that amount, $396 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $8,158. Of this amount, $571 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $396. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $571. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

James Simmerman 

Plaintiff James Simmerman shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total 

sum of $152,359, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $85,486. Of that amount, $5,984 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $56,906. Of this amount, $3,983 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $5,984. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 25 of 30
 26 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $3,983. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Wayne Sjoberg 

Plaintiff Wayne Sjoberg shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$27,340, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $15,293. Of that amount, $1,071 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $10,258. Of this amount, $718 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $1,071. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $718. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Raise in Current Salary: Plaintiff’s current annual salary shall be raised by 

$1,931. 

Michael Tanner 

Plaintiff Michael Tanner shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$13,356, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $6,058. Of that amount, $424 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 26 of 30
 27 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Lost Salary: $6,424. Of this amount, $450 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $424. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $450. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Charles Way

Plaintiff Charles Way shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$4,557.29, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $2,385. Of that amount, $75.11 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $2,032. Of that amount $65.18 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $75.11. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $65.18. This amount will be paid on 

Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

James Windes

Plaintiff James Windes shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$45,298.66, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 27 of 30
 28 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Lost Salary: $19,700. Of that amount, $708.67 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $24,062. Of that amount $827.99 shall be withheld and 

submitted on Plaintiff’s behalf to the Arizona State Requirement System as interest 

on Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid 

directly to the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 

Form 1099. 

Employer ASRS Contribution: $708.67. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement System. 

Interest on Employer ASRS Contribution: $827.99. This amount will be paid 

on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Arizona State Retirement 

System. 

Michael Wunsch

Plaintiff Michael Wunsch shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum 

of $29,146, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $12,739. Of that amount, $892 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $14,500. Of this amount, $1,015 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $892. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 28 of 30
 29 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $1,015. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

Robert Zoellner 

Plaintiff Robert Zoellner shall have Judgment against Defendants in the total sum of 

$68,320, attributed and to be paid as follows: 

Lost Salary: $28,936. Of that amount, $2,026 shall be withheld as Plaintiff’s 

contribution to the Optional Retirement Plan and will be submitted to the Optional 

Retirement Plan on the Plaintiff’s behalf. 

Interest on Lost Salary: $34,914. Of this amount, $2,444 shall be withheld and 

submitted on the Plaintiff’s behalf to the Optional Retirement Plan as interest on 

Plaintiff’s share of the retirement contribution. The balance shall be paid directly to 

the Plaintiff and shall be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on Form 1099. 

Employer ORP Contributions: $2,026. This amount will be paid on Plaintiff’s 

behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement Plan. 

Interest on Employer ORP Retirement Contributions: $2,444. This amount will 

be paid on Plaintiff’s behalf, by Defendants, directly to the Optional Retirement 

Plan. 

IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiffs no longer employed by NAU shall provide NAU 

with income tax withholding forms (IRS W-4) within 10 days of the entry of judgment. 

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the above amounts shall be paid within 15 

business days after receipt of all of the individual Plaintiffs’ tax withholding forms. All 

payments to the Plaintiffs shall be forwarded to Plaintiffs’ counsel and shall be considered 

“paid” upon Plaintiffs’ counsel’s receipt. Payments to the ASRS and ORP shall be 

considered “paid” when transmitted by NAU. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 29 of 30
 30 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that post-judgment interest shall be awarded in 

accordance with 28 U.S.C. § 1961. 

DATED this 23rd day of February, 2007. 

Case 3:95-cv-01313-RCB Document 344 Filed 02/23/07 Page 30 of 30