Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-3_07-cv-05944/USCOURTS-cand-3_07-cv-05944-66/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 410
Nature of Suit: Antitrust
Cause of Action: 15:1 Antitrust Litigation

---

c;ase3:37-cv-Q56& -SC iloc~ri1eniD9C i-;leail8i29l'i I Page'i of "I1 

GUIDQ SAVERI (Bar No. 22349) guidqZJsaveri.&m 

R. ALEXANDER SAVERI (Bar No. 173 102) 

rick@averi.com 

CADI0 ZIRPOLI (Bar No. 179 108) 

cadio@veri.corn 

SAVERI & SAVERI, MC. 

706 Sansome Street 

San Francisco, Califbrnia 941 1 1 

Telephone: (41 5) 21 7-68 10 

Facsimile: (41 5) 217-6913 

Interim Lead Come1 for the 

Direct Purchaser Piainfi@is Chs 

MAXI0 N. ALIOTO (Bar NO. 56433) 

rnalioto@tatp.com , 

LAUREN C. RUSSELL (Bar No. 241 15 1) 

laurenru~seU@tatp.co 

TRUMP, ALIOTO, TRUMP & PRESCOTI', LU 

2280 Union Street 

Ssn Francisco, California 94123 

Telephone: (41 5) 563-7200 

Facsimile: (4 15) 346-0679 

Interim Lead Counsel for the 

Indirect Purchaser Plaintifi Chs 

James L. McGinnis (Bar No. 95788) 

jmcpiMis@shqpardmullin.com 

SHEPPARD MULLIN RICm & HAMPTON LLP 

Four Embarcadem Center, 17th Floor 

Sm Fmncisco, California 941 I1 

Telephone: (4 5 5) 434-9 0 00 

Facsimile: (41 5) 434-3947 

Lkfenre Liaison Counsel 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNJA, SAN FTUNCISCO DMSION 

IN RE: CATHODE RAY TLTBE (CRT) 

ANTITRUST LITIGATION 

MASTER FILE NO.. 07-CV-5944 SC 

MDLNO. 1917 

STIPULATION AND 

ORDER 

827532'727532.5 WCV-5944 SC 

STIPULATION AND [PROPOSEDJ ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 1 of 11
It is hereby stipulated by and between the Direct Purchaser Plaintiffi ("DPPs") and the 

Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffi ("IPPst') and the undersigned defmdants ("Defendantsn) in this don 

as follows: 

WHEREAS, on June 29,201 1, the Honorable Samuel Conti ordered upon the 

recommendation of the Special Master, Charles A. Legge, that DPPs and PPs have until 

September 1,201 1 to provide a list to Defendants of certain documents produced in the In Re: 

TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation, Care No. M07-1827 U(*in Re: TFTLCD") action for 

the limited purpose of idcnwg documents for potential production in this action ("LCD 

Document Stipulation" attached hereto as Exhibit A). 

WHEREAS, DPPq and IPPs continue to review the LCD document productions for 

re1 evant documents; 

WHEREAS, the DPPs and IPPs have requested, and the Defendants have agreed to extend 

the deadline for the production of the LCD document list an additional forty five days, such that 

the list shall now be provided to Defendants on October 17,201 1 ; 

WHFBEAS, DPPs and IPPs agree to provide the Defendants with the list of documents on 

a rolling basis; 

IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED, by and between counsel for the 

undersigned Plaintif5 and Defendants that: 

The &dine for DPPs and IPPS to serve Defendants with a list of LCD documents 

pursuant to the June 29,201 1 LCD Document Stipulation is extended uatil October 17,201 1. 

DATED: August 29,201 1 SAVERI & SAVERI, INC. 

GUM SAVER1 

R. ALEXANDER SAVERI 

CADI0 ZIRPOLI 

By: is/ Cmido Saveri 

GUDO SAVERI 

Interim Lead Counsel for the 

Direct Purchaser Plaintrs Class 

827Sj2.717532.5 2 07-CV-5944 Sc 

STIPULATION AND PROPOSED] ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 2 of 11
DATED: August 29,201 1 TRUMP, ALIOTO, TRUMP & PRESCOTT, LLP 

MARIO N. ALIOTO 

By: WarioN.&to 

MARIO N. ALIOTO 

Interim Lead Counsel for the 

Indirect Purchaser Plainti's Class 

For the Limited Pqse of this Stipulation, Liaison Counsel 

DATED: August 29,201 1 SHEPPARD mLIN RICHTER & HAMPTON 

LLP 

JAMES L. MCGINNIS 

By -innis 

JAMES L. MCGNNIS 

Defense Licrson Counsel and Counsel for Defdanh 

Samg SDl America, Inc., Samsung SDI Co., Ltd., 

Samrung SDI (Uokuysia) Sdn BM, Samung SDI 

Mexiw S.A. de C. V.. Sumsung SDI Brasil Ltda., 

Shenzhen Samng SDI Co. Ltd., and Tiaqjin Samsmg 

SDI Co., Ltd 

AlTESTATION PURSUANT TO GENERAL ORDER 45 

I, Cadio Zirpoli, attest that wacurrenw in the ~g of this document has been obtained 

from alf signatories. I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of 

America that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 29th day of August 201 1, at San 

Francisco, California. 

is/ Cadio Zirpoli 

027532.727532.5 3 07-W-5944 Sc 

SlT.PULAnON AND [PROPOSED] ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 3 of 11
, 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

2ase3:G7-cv-0594i-jr= 130c~,neni9EB ,'rled38129/'i 'I Page4 ofl : 

IT. IS SO RECOMMENDED. 

DATED: ~ugust Lq, 201 1 

Special Master 

IT IS SO ORDERED UPON THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE SPECIAL MASTER 

DATED. 4gjet-z 2011 

ISTRICT JUDGE! 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

1s 

19 

20 

2 1 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

crtsvr 

827532.7275325 4 07a-5944 SC 

SllPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 4 of 11
EXHIBIT A 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 5 of 11
1 11 GULDO SAVERT (Bar No. 22349) 

2 (1 RALE pid;~$s"&ERl (Eo No. 173 102) 

rick@sweri.com 

CADI0 ZIRPOLI (Bar No. 1 79 108) 

SAVERI "jFm" SAVEIU.rnC. 

111 Pine Stroct, Sub 1700 

San Francisco, California 941 1 1 

Telephone: (415 217-6610 

PBCSdlB: (?15{2174913 

(1 MARION. ALIOTO mar No. 56433) doto@tatp.com 

LAUREN C. RUSSELL (Bar No. 241 151) Iauruuussel@atp.com 

TRUMP. ALIOTO, TRUMP & PRESCOTI; LLP 

2280 Udon Sweet 

San Fmisco, Cali 94 123 

! ~amea &-m L. McGinais (Bar No. 95788) ullin.com 

RI-Bt-ONUP 

Pour Embarcadem Center, 17th Floor 

Saa FmW, Califbmh 94 1 1 1 

Ttlcphonc: (41 5) 434-91 00 

Famamile: (41 5) 434-3947 

" 11 ITNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

STIPlLAl'ION AND -1 

ORDER 

21 

22 

23 ' 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORMA, SAN FRANCISCO DMSION 

IN IUk CATHODE RAY TUBE (CRT) 

ANTITRUST LITlGATION 

MASTER FILE NO.. 07-CV-5944 SC 

MDLNO. 1917 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 6 of 11
Uocui oeni998 ,'iieaGd~LLi' rage; oi 'I i 

EMWE3 &IkMW~l &ii~%f'& 

It ia hereby stipulated by end between the Direct Purchasar Plaintiffs ("DPPsn) and the 

Indirect Purcfianer Phirttiffi ("IPPs") and the undenigned defcndmts ("Defendants") in this action 

as fbllows: 

I. That all docum produced h the Jh Re: TFT-TCD (FJut Punel) Antif- - 

UIgutbh Cnss No. W7-1827 Sl ("in Re: TFT-LCD") by entities, including theiu affiliates except 

for Toshiba Mobile Display Co., Ltd.. that produd documents in In Re: TlcTLCD and are 

defwdmts in this action, coa be revlewd by Plaintiffs' oounsel in this action for the liiitcd 

purpose of identifying documents fa potential pnxluction in this don pursuant to the proccdurca 

dwcrl'bcd in Paragaphe 2 and 3 below. Such mkw will be subject to the protecthe order in h 

Rd; TFT-LCD (Docket No. MI) as well as the protcctivt order herein (Docket No. 306). 

2. On or Mom Scptunber 1,201 1, Plaintiffa shall provide to all defondauts a list of 

the begoing documcnta hrn h Re: TFT--LCD that they seek to use fn tbis action. The defendant 

that produced, or whose dliliate produced, a dmument in In Re: TIST-LCD so idcntificd 

("Roduciag Party") shan have 45 days to state objcctiolls to adding any such dacument to the 

CRT dIwovay record. Any document as to which no objedoru have been mado shall be deemed 

produced herehr. The psrtlw sfd meet Prld canfa ta ctsolvs any objecdme made and, if 

necessaty. diww a process far siacMag a ding hm the Spbcial and the COWL 

3. After his initial list is provided, PlahltifE may suppleanent the list as necessary 

with additional dawmcnto covd by Panrgraph 1 above to the extent that Plainti& were in god 

faith &lo to finish their miew of documents for inclusion in the list coatemplated by hagraph 

2 abwc. Plainti5 shall provide 110th b ail defendants of any addjdons to the list of documents 

horn the TFT-LCD adon that they seek to uss in this action, absent a showing of good cause, no 

Later than seven calendar dnys before intended we in aay &position, submission or oh 

peeding, and no later than 30 days prior to the diswvery cut off. Absent a showing of god 

caw Plaintifb may identiq. no mom than tcn additional dcmments In advance of each 

deposition. The Producing Party &dl promptly state objections to adding any document 

identifted by Plahiffi to the CRT dlscsvary mrd, if any, and the partlts shaU use lhc 

procedurts wed upon for rtmMon of disputes as d in Pacagraph 2 abova Any suoh 

mn7n25 2 07-W-.59U SC 

SllPULATIW AND ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 7 of 11
1 resolution will be done on an expedited basis so as not to disrupt tho taking of a noticed II 

3 (1 4. MI objectim~ by Dafindanu with respect to relevancy and admissibility am 

7 Display America, Inc. (collectively "LG Display'?. Nothing in this stipulation shall preclude I I 

4 

5 

6: 

8 PIaM hm seeking in this litigation the production of documents produced by LG Display in II 

pnscrved as to any document from In Re: TFT-LCD that may be produced pursuant to the 

hrcgotng~uren. 

5. Absent Court order, thts stipulation shall not apply to LO Display Co, Ltd. and LG 

9 In Re: TETLCD. 11 

June 17.201 1 

June 17,201 1 

By: 

0UIM)SAVERI liltdm LeadihnteI&r the 

hct Pvrck PMnt3drj Class 

TRUMP, ALIOTO, TRUMP % FRESCOTT, ]UP 

MARIO N. ALIO1'0 

By: -b& 

MARIO N. ALIOTO 

By: -1 

SCOlT A. STEMPEL 

21 

22 

DATED: June 1 7,201 1 MORGAN, LEWIS & BocKNs LLP 

DML. WEBS 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 8 of 11
DA'ED: June 17,201 1 

DATED: June 17,201 1 

ARNOLD & PORTER LLP 

ERIC SHAPLAND 

By: 

ERIC SRAPLAND 

ComwI@r &@dmis LG Eiectrona I=, LG 

El&= USA, hc, MdUf iiktro~cs Taiwatt 

Taipei Co.. Ud 

DEWEY & LEOEUF LLP 

JEFFREY L. KESSLER 

By: -P 

JEFFREY L. KESSLER 

CWW~~~OT ~e>-&nts ~muL#Jnic Cbpwatiim o 

Nd Mw, MT PfctLpe Dls ay Cb., Ltd 

Panmanic Cwporatlon Wd 

J 

lRdkebkJ CoJ 

Lh*r -ic 

]SAK]eR ms LLS. 

JOSEPH OSTOYICH 

w 

JAMES L. MCGRWB 

BY: - . - 

JAMES L MCOINNIS 

lh&w Liastm Cod and Comlfbr 

SmnnutgSDIAnrmMcq, I=, $aarJungSDI 2- ., Ldd, 

nu2.n71xu 4 070-5944 SC 

SllPULATIW AND ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 9 of 11
O'MELVENY & MYERS, LLP 

IAN SIMMONS 

1 

2 

3 

d 

5 

7 

8 

9 

10 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

BY /s/lanSimmoM IAN SIMh4ONS 

Cowslfir&findana Smr~sungEkct*oni~~ Co., Lld 

and Sumrung Eledmnics America, Inc. 

DATED: June 17,201 1 

DATED: June 17,201 1 

DATED: Junc 17,201 1 

DATED: Jwo 17,201 1 

B-R & McKENZIP. LLP 

PATRICK J. ARERN 

By: -m 

PATRlCK J. AH;ERN Coumel for Lkfimht Tatmg Cow of Amedcq 

mc, 

WEUTE a CASE LLP 

LUClUS B. LAU 

By: 

FRESHFIELDS BRUCKHAUS LIBRINGER US 

LLP 

19 

U) 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

23 

By: TERRY CALVANI 

C-lfir Dc$nuht Bevkig Mihita &for CRT 

CovW, Lrd 

mm.n75x.s 5 WCV-5944 SC 

STlPULAnoNAND ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 10 of 11
2 b 

C;ssed:b; -w-05 Ld~~~~~,I~~db8 i11edG8123/ ~$JZ 4 'I of f.1 1. 

I ce383m S~~~RZI#?~?J hikW{3?41 ~#p r@O e6 

1 

2 

' 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

ATTESTATION PURSUANT TO GENERAL ORDER 45 

I. Lauran C. Russell, attest that concltnoncc in the filing ofthiis document has been 

obtained from dl sipauories. I doslarc under plulty of perjury wdm tbo laws of the United 

Stsru of America thn the fare~oing i8 tm and correct Executed thia 17th day of June 201 1. at 

San Francisco. California. 

8 

IT LS so RECOMMENDED. 

DATED: June A& 201 1 

. Hod Charles A Ltggt 

Spacial Master 

L 18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

FT IS SO ORDERED UPON TEIE RECOMMENDATION OF THE SPECIAL MASTER 

DATED: Junt~ZOli 

Bnsnmm5 6 W-CV-SW SC 

STIPULATION AND ORDER 

Case 3:07-cv-05944-JST Document 1000 Filed 09/02/11 Page 11 of 11