Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-3_04-cv-04981/USCOURTS-cand-3_04-cv-04981-49/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 440
Nature of Suit: Other Civil Rights
Cause of Action: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act

---

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

LOUIS A. LEONE, ESQ. (CSB #099874) 

KATHLEEN DARMAGNAC, ESQ. (CSB #150843) 

STUBBS & LEONE 

2175 N. California Blvd., Suite 900 

Walnut Creek, CA 94596 

Telephone: (925) 974-8600 

Facsimile: (925) 974-8601 

Attorneys for Defendants 

SAN FRANCISCO COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT, et al. 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 

MARGIE CHERRY and ESTORIA CHERRY 

on behalf of themselves and all others 

similarly situated, 

 Plaintiffs, 

 vs.

THE CITY COLLEGE OF SAN 

FRANCISCO (“City College”); et al. 

 Defendants. 

Case No.: C04-4981 WHA 

[PROPOSED] ORDER

RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED 

VIOLATIONS

Trial Date: February 14. 2006 

 Hon. William H. Alsup 

On January 19, 2006, over objections and subject to rights of appeal, per the Court’s 

order defendants filed an “admitted violations” list that was compiled by reviewing defendants’ 

court-ordered responses to the items specifically identified on plaintiffs’ “alleged” barrier list.

The Court now finds that those items are admitted as violations of Section 504 of the 

Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. The 

items are specifically set forth herein (identified first by campus, then building (where 

applicable), location in the building, and then the specific item described), as follows: 

1

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 1 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

CASTRO VALENCIA CAMPUS

Location of Item Condition

Path of Travel Between Boundary of Site 

and Primary Entrances: Ramp to 

Designated Accessible Entrance - East Side 

of Building at Southeast Corner 

Ramp: The vertical drop step approx eight feet 

from the ramp end of the landing is not protected by 

a raised edge along the face of the bottom landing, 

as required

DOWNTOWN CAMPUS

Location of Item Condition

2ND Floor: Library 

 Media Room/ Computer Room 

Entry Door: Door requires greater than the 

maximum 5 lbs of force to open. 

3rd Floor: Women's Restroom 

Accessible Stall: The clear floor space between the 

side of the toilet and the face of the adjacent stall 

wall is significantly below the 32” minimum 

required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs of force to open. 

Toilet: The centerline of the toilet is not 18" from 

5th Floor: Men's Restroom the wall as required. 

Vestibules: The strike edge provided on the pull 

side of this door is below the 18” minimum. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs of force to open. 

Stall: The door swings between the front face of the 

toilet and the door swing is less than the 48" 

required. 5th Floor: Women's Restroom 

Toilet: The centerline of the toilet is not 18" from 

the wall as required. 

8th Floor: Men’s Restroom 

Urinals: The urinals provided in this restroom 

project below the required 14” minimum and are 

mounted above the maximum 17”. 

8th Floor: Room 822 

Door: Door does not have accessible operating 

hardware. 

2

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 2 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

EVANS CAMPUS

Location of Item Condition

Coat Hooks: Set at a height which exceeds the 

permitted maximum height of 48".

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall. 

Grab Bars: The rear grab bar is less than minimum 

36”. 

Paper Towel Dispenser: Does not have accessible 

operating hardware. 

Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced water/ 

drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a safety 

issue.

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

Men’s Restroom off Auto Shop 

Toilet Paper Dispenser: The toilet paper dispenser 

is not within 12” as is required. 

Coat Hook: Set at a height which exceeds the 

permitted maximum height of 48". 

Grab Bars: The rear grab bar is less than minimum 

36”. 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extend 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall. 

Paper Towel Dispenser: Does not have accessible 

operating hardware. 

Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/ drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

Women’s Restroom off Auto Shop 

Stall Door: The door to the accessible stall swings 

into the stall; this configuration does not meet all 

clearances required in the stall 

///

3

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 3 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

GOUGH STREET CAMPUS

Location of Item Condition

Entrance: No compliant signage is provided as 

required. 

Entrance at Gough St Entrance Door: Does not have required 3-second 

pause. 

Exterior entrances: Main Entrance 

 at Parking Lot 

Entrance: No compliant signage is provided as 

required. 

JOHN ADAMS CAMPUS

Location of Item Condition

1st Floor Elevator Lobby 

Doors: Door requires greater than the maximum 

allowable force to open. 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Grab Bar: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall. Basement Level: Men’s Restroom Rm. 48 

Stall Door: The stall door closer is broken. 

Basement Level: Unisex Restroom Rm. 54 Entry Door: Does not have sufficient 3 second 

sweep time. 

Gymnasium: Men’s Restroom 

Grab Bar: The edge of the side grab bar is more 

than the permitted maximum of 12” from the rear 

wall.

Gymnasium: Men’s Restroom 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs of force to open. 

Gymnasium: Women’s Restroom 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs of force to open. 

OCEAN CAMPUS BATMALE HALL

Location of Item Condition

4th Floor Men’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

4

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 4 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS BATMALE HALL

Location of Item Condition

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from the rear 

wall.

4th Floor Women’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

5th Floor Men’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

5th Floor Women’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

6th Floor Men’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

6th Floor Women’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

7th Floor Men’s Restroom 

Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

7th Floor Women’s Restroom Stall A: U-shaped handle or loop is required on 

both sides of the accessible stall door. 

OCEAN CAMPUS CHILD CARE CENTER

Location of Item Condition

Ramp at East Building Entrance 

Ramp Landing: Bottom landing at ramp not level 

(2% slope max). 

OCEAN CAMPUS CLOUD HALL

Location of Item Condition

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

1ST Floor Men’s Restroom (Rm. C134) Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs of force to open. 

5

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 5 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS CLOUD HALL

Location of Item Condition

Accessible Semi-Ambulant Stall: No loop handle 

on the interior side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

1 lbs of force to open. st Floor Women’s Restroom (Rm. C129) 

Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue. 

2nd Floor 

Building Directory: Information locating the 

accessible restrooms and elevators is not provided. 

Accessible Semi-Ambulant Stall: No loop handle 

on the interior side of the stall door as required. 

2nd Floor: Men’s Restroom (Rm. C250) Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs of force to open. 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Accessible Stall Door: The landing at the pull side 

of the stall door less than minimum of 48” clear 

space due to obstruction of the paper towel 

dispenser and lavatory. 

Door: Door requires greater than the 5 lbs. of force 

to open. 

2nd Floor: Women’s Restroom (Rm. C234) 

Sink: The P-trap extends from the wall beyond the 

maximum of 6”. 

3rd Floor 

Building Directory: Information locating the 

accessible restrooms and elevators is not provided. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

3rd Floor: Men’s Restroom (Rm. C360A) Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue.

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

3rd Floor: Women’s Restroom (Rm. C361A) Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

4th Floor: Unisex Restroom (Right Side) Hallway Width: There is less than minimum (sic) 

48” deep landing at push side of door. 

6

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 6 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS CREATIVE ARTS BUILDING

Location of Item Condition

1st Floor: Men’s Accessible Room 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door required. 

1st Floor: Women’s Restroom 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door required.

2nd Floor: Men’s Restroom 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door required.

2nd Floor: Women’s Restroom 

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

3rd Floor Men’s Restroom 

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

3rd Floor: Women’s Restroom 

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

Diego Rivera Theatre: 

Men’s Restroom (Rm. 153) 

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

Diego Rivera Theatre: 

Women’s Restroom (Rm. 154) Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue. 

OCEAN CAMPUS CREATIVE ARTS EXTENSION

Location of Item Condition

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from the rear 

wall.

1st Floor: Men’s Restroom (Rm. A194) 

Toilet Paper Dispenser: The toilet paper dispenser 

is not mounted below the grab bar as required. 

7

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 7 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS CREATIVE ARTS EXTENSION

Location of Item Condition

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door required.

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

1st Floor: Women’s Restroom (Rm. A192) 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from the rear 

wall.

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

2nd Floor: Men’s Restroom Rm. 272 Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from the rear 

wall.

Accessible Stall: The centerline of the toilet is not 

18” from the wall as required.

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door required.

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from the rear 

wall.

2nd Floor: Women’s Restroom Rm. 270 

Sanitary Seat Cover Dispenser: Mounted higher 

than the permitted 40” maximum above finished 

floor. 

OCEAN CAMPUS: - EXTERIOR PATHS OF TRAVEL

Location of Item Condition

Curb Ramp at Crosswalk #8 (South) 

Curb Ramp: Built-up curb ramp projects into 

traffic lane. 

Curb Ramp East of Crosswalk #12 

Curb Ramp: No level landing (2% slope max) 

provided at top of curb ramp. 

Curb Ramp in Front of Science Hall 

Public Pay Telephone: The highest operable 

mechanism of the telephone is more than the 

8

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 8 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS: - EXTERIOR PATHS OF TRAVEL

Location of Item Condition

maximum of 48” on center as specified. 

East Sidewalk on Phelan Ave. 

Sidewalk: Pavement dislocation and bridge 

transition creates abrupt change in level exceeding 

1⁄2” in height. 

Entrance to Pedestrian Overpass to BART 

Walkway: Pavement dislocation and bridge 

transition creates abrupt change in level exceeding 

1⁄2” in height. 

Upper Accessible Parking at Central 

Campus 

Accessible Parking: Two of eight accessible 

parking do not have designated (outlined and 

hatched) access aisles. 

Upper Ramp Landing 

Ramp: At transition, pavement dislocation creates 

an abrupt change due to a 1” wide gap between 

panels. 

OCEAN CAMPUS: - ORNAMENTAL HORTICULTURE

Location of Item Condition

Exterior Entrance (#1): Main Entrance 

(North) 

Swing Door: Do not have required 3 second pause. 

Accessible Stall: The stall door closer is broken. 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

Men’s Locker Accessible Restroom 

Sink: Knee space clearance does not meet 

minimum 27” above finished floor. 

Path of Travel 

Walkways: Broken cement. 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

Women’s Locker Restroom lbs. of force to open. 

Mirror: The lower edge of the mirror is above the 

required maximum of 40” above finished floor. 

9

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 9 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS: - ROSENBERG LIBRARY

Location of Item Condition

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

1st Floor: Unisex Restroom (Rm. 109) Sanitary Seat Cover Dispenser: Mounted higher 

than the permitted 40” maximum above finished 

floor. 

2nd Floor: Computer Lab Rm. R209 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

2nd Floor: Computer Lab Rm. 210 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

2nd Floor: Language Lab Rm. 205 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

2nd Floor: Learning Assistance Center 

 Rm. R207-R232 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

2 lbs. of force to open. nd Floor: Men’s Restroom Room 201 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall.

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall.

2nd Floor: Women’s Restroom Rm. 202 

Semi-Ambulant Stall: No loop handle on the 

interior side of the stall door as required.

3rd Floor: Audio Visual Rm. R306 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

3rd Floor: Disabled Students Persons 

 & Services R 323 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

3rd Floor: Men’s Restroom Rm. 303 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

10

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 10 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS: - ROSENBERG LIBRARY

Location of Item Condition

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

Grab Bars: There is no side grab bar provided.

Stall Door: The strike clearance at the push side of 

the door is less than the required minimum 12” 

clear.

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required.

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

3 lbs. of force to open. rd Floor: Men’s Restroom Rm. 317 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall.

3rd Floor: Multi-Media Rm. 301 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

Accessible Seating: There are 63 fixed seats and 

there is one designated wheelchair space provided 

in the back (4 accessible wheelchair spaces are 

required.) 

Aisle Width: Aisle from the door to the front of the 

room is obstructed at a width less than the 36” 

minimum based on location of fixed seats. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open 

Door: The strike clearance of the door is blocked 

by fixed seating (18” minimum to a depth of 60” 

minimum.) 

3rd Floor: Multi-Media Rm. R304 

Door: The landing on the push side of the door is 

less than the required 48” minimum.

Accessible Seating: There are 56 fixed seats and 

there is one designated wheelchair space provided 

in the back (4 accessible wheelchair spaces are 

required.) 

Aisle Width: Is less than the required 36” 

minimum from the door to the front of the room. 

Door: The landing on the push side of the door is 

less than the required 48” minimum. 

3rd Floor: Multi-Media Rm. R305 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

11

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 11 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS: - ROSENBERG LIBRARY

Location of Item Condition

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

3 lbs. of force to open. rd Floor: Women’s Restroom Rm. 302 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall.

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

3 lbs. of force to open. rd Floor: Women’s Restroom Rm. 318 

Semi-Ambulant Stall: No loop handle on the 

interior side of the stall door as required. 

4th Floor: Library Lab R414 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

4th Floor: Main Library Entrance 

Gates: There are four (4) gates with a more than 

10” above finished floor minimum smooth solid 

bottom on the push side. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

Entrance Gate Gap: The entry/exit gate has more 

than allowed 10” above finished floor minimum 

gap. 

4th Floor: Media Center Rm. 403 

Gates: The clearance between the series of gates is 

less than the required 48” minimum. 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

4 Grab Bars: There is no side grab bar provided. th Floor: Men’s Restroom Rm. 402 

Stall Door: The strike clearance at the push side of 

the door is less than the required minimum 12” 

clear.

4th Floor: Reserve Book Rm. R407 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

12

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 12 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS: - ROSENBERG LIBRARY

Location of Item Condition

Stall Door: There is a 5” strike clearance at the 

push side of the door that is blocked by the checkout 

counter (12” minimum.) 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: There is a twist type lock. 

4th Floor: Women’s Restroom Rm. 401 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open.

5th Floor: Drinking Fountain: 

 Near the Women’s Restroom 

Drinking Fountains: Existing drinking fountains 

are not accessible. 

5th Floor: Group Study Rms. R511-R516 

Stall Door: There is a 5” strike clearance at the 

push side of the door that is blocked by the checkout 

counter (12” minimum.) 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required. 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

Grab Bars: The edge of the side grab bar extends 

less than the required minimum 52” from rear wall.

Path of Travel to Accessible Stall: The clearance 

between the front of the lavatory and the partition 

wall is less than the required 44” minimum clear 

width in path of travel. 

5th Floor: Men’s Restroom Rm. 522 

Sanitary Seat Cover Dispenser: Mounted higher 

than the permitted 40” maximum above finished 

floor. 

Accessible Stall: No loop handle on the interior 

side of the stall door as required.

Semi-Ambulant Stall: No loop handle on the 

interior side of the stall door as required. 5th Floor: Women’s Restroom Rm. 523 

Toilet Paper Dispenser: Outer edge not within 

36”from back wall and maximum 12” from front 

edge of toilet. 

Exterior Entrance: 4th Floor 

Signage: There is no conforming signage provided. 

13

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 13 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS - SCIENCE HALL

Location of Item Condition

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

Grab Bars: Fixed seat cover dispenser obstructs 

grab bar use. 

Grab Bars: At toilet, providing side transfer, side 

grab bar starting less than 52” from rear wall. 

3rd Floor: Men’s Restroom 337 

Stall Door: Stall door to accessible compartment 

not self-closing. 

Door: Does not have accessible operating 

hardware. 

Grab Bars: At toilet, providing side transfer, side 

3 grab bar starting less than 52” from rear wall. rd Floor: Women’s Restroom 321 

Water Closet: Less than 18” from near sidewall to 

centerline of toilet. 

OCEAN CAMPUS - EOPS 

Location of Item Condition

EOPS Office Suite: Women’s Restroom 

Door: Door requires greater than the maximum 5 

lbs. of force to open. 

OCEAN CAMPUS - STADIUM 

Location of Item Condition

Lower Accessible Seating (North) 

Ramp: Bottom landing at ramp not level (2% slope 

max.) 

Lower Ramp to Accessible Seating (South) 

Ramp: Running slope greater than 1:12 (8.3%). 

Multi Accommodation Men’s Restroom 

Sink: Knee space clearance does not meet 

minimum 27” above finished floor. 

14

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 14 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS - STADIUM 

Location of Item Condition

Urinal: Fixture mounted with rim more than 17” 

above floor. 

Multi Accommodation Women’s Restroom 

Semi-Ambulant Stall: Semi-ambulant stall in 

restroom not compliant (one required where 6 or 

more exist.) No grab bars provided. 

Grab Bars: Rear grab bar less than 36” long. 

Sink: Clear floor space of 48” in front of fixture, 

extending 19” maximum under the lavatory, not 

provided. 

Stall: The existing toilet exceeds the requirements. 

Swinging Door: At push side, door does not have 

clear and level maneuvering space measuring door 

width x 48”. 

Water Closet – Flush Control Handle: Not 

mounted toward wide side of stall. 

Restroom Serving Chancellor’s and Press 

Box 

Wheelchair Clearance: Clear wheelchair turning 

space with a diameter of 60” not provided (T-space 

acceptable.)

Door: Does not have accessible operating 

hardware. 

Single Accommodation Men’s Restroom Grab Bars: Grab bars not at 33” from floor if no 

tank toilet. 

Sink: Knee space clearance does not meet 

minimum 27” above finished floor. 

Stall Door: Does not have accessible operating 

hardware. 

Toilet: The centerline of the toilet is not 18” from 

the wall as required. 

Single Accommodation Women’s Restroom 

Water Closet – Flush Control Handle: Not 

mounted toward wide side of stall. 

Upper Accessible Seating (North) 

Sidewalk: Grating along entire accessible seating 

area has grid openings greater than 1⁄2” along the 

line of traffic flow. 

Upper Accessible Seating (South) 

Sidewalk: Grating along entire accessible seating 

area has grid openings greater than 1⁄2” along the 

line of traffic flow. 

15

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 15 of 16
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

OCEAN CAMPUS – VISUAL ARTS

Location of Item Condition

Grab Bars: In the accessible stall the seat cover 

dispenser is located above the grab bar behind the 

toilet. The required 30” x 48” clear ground required 

for front or side approach is not provided. Interior Upper Level First Floor: Men’s 

Room Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue. 

Grab Bars: In the accessible stall the seat cover 

dispenser is located above the grab bar behind the 

toilet. The required 30” x 48” clear ground required 

for front or side approach is not provided. 

Mirror: The lower edge of the mirror is above the 

required maximum of 40” above finished floor. 

Interior Upper Level First Floor: 

Women’s Room 

Sink Pipe Insulation: Hot or sharp-surfaced 

water/drain pipe not insulated or covered which is a 

safety issue. 

Path of Travel to Visual Arts Lower 

Courtyard

Walkway: When the slope exceeds 5%, the walk 

must meet the requirements for a pedestrian ramp. 

Visual Arts Lower Courtyard 

Path of Travel: The cross-slope of the walk is 

excessive. The maximum cross-slope of a walk 

shall not exceed 2%. 

IT IS SO ORDERED. 

Dated: __________________________ 

 HON. WILLIAM ALSUP 

 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 

16

[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: DEFENDANTS’ ADMITTED VIOLATIONS 

C04-4981 WHA

Case 3:04-cv-04981-WHA Document 599 Filed 02/01/06 Page 16 of 16