Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-3_08-cv-03267/USCOURTS-cand-3_08-cv-03267-2/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 894
Nature of Suit: Energy Allocation Act
Cause of Action: 28:1441 Petition for Removal

---

!"#$%&
&
	

	

	

	

	

'

()

*!+,-+..)

/"%

0'0( %%

( 

1)% 

( 

0 

1( 

0( 2'&)

%)+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!2'8

1)% 0( 

%%9%)% 1'

()+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!

(0()%)

(0()%)

+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!:8

1

;)'0

)%)

+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!'08

0()8

)%%%)+,3+/+34!**5

!,33676!')2

(10)!6<6!

	

	

	

	

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 1 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 1 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

260%)

)%)+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!

)(1

)2)

21))

)'

%))'8

%)1)

=))

1)

%2%%)%)1&:'%

0)11

(()%2%(%)

'080()

%)'>()%)(

0)%)2

()%)0%)'

;)0>:'

;%)%)>0

;()%)

0(911%)%)

'(&2)2

;)(

()&0(

()%!,3-?@$4A?

)

)

#.#,3!,-"%

?#B!@-+#"C?+D??!/##E#D4-#3-?+"-+B4*!-+$,?#@#75"-+B4*!-#!".$**$C"

 
 !"#$%&

% ?#B!@-+#"B$""#""+,.$@F!-+$,C?+D?F!57#3##F#3D$,.+3#,-+!*-?!--?#5

C+"?-$F!+,-!+,!"D$,.+3#,-+!*G?#@#+,!.-#@HIJ!,3-?!-F!57#

@#K4#"-#3+,.$@F!*$@+,.$@F!*3+"D$/#@5+,-?+"!D-+$,%

% ?#B!@-+#"3#"+@#-$"-+B4*!-#-$!B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@"!,D-+$,#375-?#$4@--$

B@$-#D-"4D?.@$F4,,#D#""!@53+"D*$"4@#!F$,A-?#B!@-+#"

!,36$@-$-?+@3&B!@-+#"!""B#D+.+D!**5B@$/+3#37#*$C%

% 25#E#D4-+,A-?+""-+B4*!-#3B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@)-?#"+A,!-$@5B!@-+#"3$,$-

C!+/#!,5@+A?-")F$-+$,")$@3#.#,"#"@#A!@3+,AD?!**#,A#"-$-?#$4@-L"M4@+"3+D-+$,%

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 2 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 2 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

 	 &"'($#")(
)*
)(*"+ (#"$%
(*),-$#")(

% $@B4@B$"#"$.-?+"$@3#@)HI+"

+,.$@F!-+$,3#"+A,!-#3!""4D?+,!DD$@3!,D#C+-?-?#B@$/+"+$,"?#@#+,!,3

!% +"D*$"4@#$.C?+D?C$4*3/+$*!-#!B#@"$,!*$@.+,!,D+!*+,-#@#"- !-@!3#

"#D@#- D$,.+3#,-+!*@#"#!@D?)3#/#*$BF#,-$@D$FF#@D+!*+,.$@F!-+$, $@

$-?#@+,-#@#"-B@$-#D-#375*!C $@

7% "B@$34D#3$@3+"D*$"#375*!+,-+..!*+.$@,+!'!-#@#@/+D#"$FB!,5)$@!

.#3#@!*)"-!-#$@*$D!*A$/#@,F#,-!A#,D5)!,3C?+D?3+"D*$"#"$@D$,"-+-4-#"

+% -?#B?5"+D!*!33@#""$@A#$A@!B?+D*$D!-+$,$.B47*+D3@+,<+,AC!-#@

C#**")"-$@!A#.!D+*+-+#")B4FB+,A"-!-+$,"!,3C!-#@-@#!-F#,-

.!D+*+-+#" 

++% C!-#@"5"-#F"D?#F!-+D"!,3.!D+*+-5F!B" 

+++% B+B#*+,#F!B" 

+/% .!D+*+-5B*!,"!,3"B#D+.+D!-+$," 

/% C!-#@"5"-#F/4*,#@!7+*+-+#"C?+D??!/#,$-7##,B47*+D*53+"D*$"#3 

/+% C!-#@"5"-#F?53@!4*+D"$@$B#@!-+$,!*B@!D-+D#" 

/++% #F#@A#,D5$B#@!-+$,"!,3@#"B$,"#B*!," 

/+++% C!-#@"5"-#F"#D4@+-5B*!,")B@!D-+D#"!,36$@B@#D!4-+$,")+,D*43+,A

B*!,,#3"#D4@+-5#,?!,D#F#,-" $@

+E% B#@"$,!*+,.$@F!-+$,!7$4-#FB*$5##")"4D?!"?$F#B?$,#,4F7#@"

$@!33@#""#"%

% B@$-#D-#375-?+"@3#@"?!**,$-+,D*43#

+,.$@F!-+$,C?+D?+"

!% !C.4**5@#D#+/#375!B!@-5.@$F!"$4@D#$-?#@-?!,-?@$4A?3+"D$/#@5+,

-?+"!D-+$,.@$F-?#B!@-5!""#@-+,A-?#D*!+F$.D$,.+3#,-+!*+-5 $@

7% 47*+D<,$C*#3A#$@+,.$@F!-+$,)$@+,.$@F!-+$,C?+D?7#D$F#""4D?!.-#@

3+"D*$"4@#$-?#@-?!,-?@$4A?!,!D-$@$F+""+$,$.!B#@"$,$@#,-+-5

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 3 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 3 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

@#D#+/+,A$@F!+,-!+,+,A-?#+,.$@F!-+$,3#"+A,!-#3D$,.+3#,-+!*B4@"4!,--$

-?#B@$D#34@#"+,-?+"@3#@%

D% ,.$@F!-+$,3#"D@+7#3+,"#D-+$,%-?!-?!"7##,3#"+A,!-#3

)74-)4B$,$7M#D-+$,B4@"4!,--$-?#

B@$D#34@#+,"#D-+$,)+",$-3#F$,"-@!-#375-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5-$

D$,"-+-4-#+,.$@F!-+$,-?!-"?$4*37#B@$-#D-#3!"D$,.+3#,-+!*%

% ,.$@F!-+$,F!5$,*57#3#"+A,!-#3HI+.

+-?!"7##,@#/+#C#375!,!--$@,#5!,3+.-?!-!--$@,#5#,-#@-!+,"!A$$3.!+-?7#*+#.-?!--?#

+,.$@F!-+$,+"#,-+-*#3-$D$,.+3#,-+!*+-5!"3#.+,#3+,"#D-+$,%%

% @$34D#3$D4F#,-"%B!@-5$@-?+@3&B!@-5B@$34D+,A3$D4F#,-"+,.$@F!*

$@+,.$@F!*3+"D$/#@5-?!-+-)+,A$$3.!+-?)7#*+#/#"D$,"-+-4-#$@D$,-!+,

"?!**B@$34D#!D$B5$."4D?3$D4F#,-G"JC+-?!*!7#*-?!-"-!-#"

HI$,-?#.!D#$.#!D?B!A#$.-?#3$D4F#,-G"J%

"4"#3?#@#+,)-?#-#@FH3$D4F#,-"I+,D*43#"!**C@+-+,A")$-?#@F#3+!$,C?+D?

+,.$@F!-+$,+"@#D$@3#3!,3$-?#@-!,A+7*#-?+,A""47M#D--$B@$34D-+$,4,3#@4*#$.-?##3#@!*

4*#"$.+/+*@$D#34@#!,36$@!*+.$@,+!$3#$.+/+*@$D#34@#N
%

%,5B!@-5

@#D#+/+,A!3$D4F#,-*!7#*#3!"+"@#"B$,"+7*#.$@F!+,-!+,+,A

-?#3$D4F#,-!"B4@"4!,--$-?+"@3#@%

% ,-#@@$A!-$@5,"C#@"%.!B!@-5!,"C#@+,A!,+,-#@@$A!-$@57#*+#/#"-?!-+-"

!,"C#@D$,-!+,")+-"?!**"#-.$@-?+-"!,"C#@+,!"#B!@!-#

3$D4F#,--?!-+"B@$34D#3!,33#"+A,!-#3!"+,-?#"!F#

F!,,#@!"!B@$34D#33$D4F#,-4,3#@"47B!@!A@!B?%%?#,$,&3#"+A,!-#3!,"C#@"-$

+,-#@@$A!-$@+#""?$4*3F!<#@#.#@#,D#-$-?#"#B!@!-#*5B@$34D#33$D4F#,-D$,-!+,+,A-?#!,"C#@

C+-?)74-"4D?3$D4F#,-"?$4*3,$-7#!--!D?#3-$-?#!,"C#@"

-$+,-#@@$A!-$@+#"%

%	 #"+A,!-+$,$.$D4F#,-"!"$,.+3#,-+!*%,-?##/#,-!B!@-5@#K4#"-+,A-?#

B@$34D-+$,$.3$D4F#,-"#*#D-"-$.+@"-+,"B#D--?#3$D4F#,-"B@+$@-$F!<+,A!3#D+"+$,!"-$

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 4 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 4 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

C?#-?#@-$@#K4#"-@#B@$34D-+$,$.D$B+#")-?#B@$34D+,AB!@-5"?!**F!<#-?#3#"+A,!-+$,$.

)+.3##F#3,#D#""!@575-?#B@$34D+,AB!@-5).$@-?$"#

3$D4F#,-"+,!3/!,D#$.-?#+@@#B@$34D-+$,%

%
 #B$"+-+$,@!,"D@+B-"%,*#""$-?#@C+"#!A@##3-$75-?#B!@-+#"$@$@3#@#3

75-?#$4@-)C+-?+, D!*#,3!@3!5"!.-#@-?#@#D#+B-$.!3#B$"+-+$,-@!,"D@+B-G$@+.-?#-@!,"D@+B-+"

@#D#+/#3C+-?+,
D!*#,3!@3!5"$.-?#3!-#"#-.$@-?#7#A+,,+,A$.-@+!*)C+-?+,?!*.$.-?#,4F7#@

$.3!5"@#F!+,+,A7#.$@#-?#3!-#"#-.$@-?#7#A+,,+,A$.-@+!*J)!B!@-5F!5+,.$@F-?#$-?#@B!@-+#"

-$-?#!D-+$,$.-?#B$@-+$,"$.-?#-@!,"D@+B--?!-+-C+"?#"-$3#"+A,!-#!"

%,-+*"4D?-+F#?!"#*!B"#3)3#B$"+-+$,-@!,"D@+B-"+,-?#+@#,-+@#-5!@#-$7#

D$,"+3#@#3!"%**B!@-+#"+,B$""#""+$,$.!D$B5$.!

3#"+A,!-#33#B$"+-+$,-@!,"D@+B-"?!**!BB@$B@+!-#*5F!@<-?#-@!,"D@+B-D$/#@!,3-?#3#"+A,!-#3

B!A#"!"D$,-!+,+,A%

% ,.$@F!-+$,#"+A,!-#3H$,.+3#,-+!*I,-?#@+-+A!-+$,%B!@-5

@#"B$,3+,A-$3+"D$/#@5"?!**,$-C+-??$*3$@$7M#D--$-?#B@$34D-+$,$.+,.$@F!-+$,+,+-"

B$""#""+$,)D4"-$35$@D$,-@$*$,-?#A@$4,3"-?!-"4D?+,.$@F!-+$,+"$@F!57#"47M#D--$!

D$,.+3#,-+!*+-5$@B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@#,-#@#3+,!,$-?#@B@$D##3+,A)4,*#""-?#+,.$@F!-+$,+,K4#"-+$,

G!JC!"3#"+A,!-#3HD$,.+3#,-+!*I+,"4D?$-?#@B@$D##3+,A75!,#,-+-5$-?#@-?!,-?#@#"B$,3+,A

B!@-5!,3G7J@#F!+,""47M#D--$-?#D$,.+3#,-+!*+-5$@B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@+,-?#$-?#@B@$D##3+,A)+,

C?+D?D!"#-?#@#"B$,3+,AB!@-5F!5C+-??$*3-?#+,.$@F!-+$,)74-"?!**B@$/+3#-?#@#K4#"-+,A

B!@-5C+-?-?#+3#,-+-5$.-?##,-+-5-?!-3#"+A,!-#3-?#+,.$@F!-+$,HD$,.+3#,-+!*)I!*$,AC+-?!

3#"D@+B-+$,$.-?#+,.$@F!-+$,"4..+D+#,-*53#-!+*#3-$#,!7*#-?#@#K4#"-+,AB!@-5-$$7-!+,"4D?

+,.$@F!-+$,3+@#D-*5.@$F-?#3#"+A,!-+,A#,-+-5%

% #"+A,!-+$," 75?+@3&!@-+#"%B#@"$,$@#,-+-5-?!-+",$-!B!@-5-$-?+"

!D-+$,)74-?!"7##,"47B$#,!#375!B!@-5+,-?+"!D-+$,)$@+"$-?#@C+"#B@$34D+,A3$D4F#,-"$@

+,.$@F!-+$,.$@B4@B$"#"$.-?+"!D-+$,)F!53#"+A,!-#+,.$@F!-+$,$@3$D4F#,-"!"

B4@"4!,--$-?#-#@F"!,3@#K4+@#F#,-"?#@#-$%25F!<+,A-?+"

3#"+A,!-+$,)-?#-?+@3&B!@-5!A@##"-$7#7$4,375-?#-#@F"!,3@#K4+@#F#,-"$.-?+"-+B4*!-#3

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 5 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 5 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

@$-#D-+/#@3#@!,3!A@##"-$"47F+--$-?#M4@+"3+D-+$,$.-?+"$4@-.$@B4@B$"#"$.!,5+""4#"

@#*!-+,A-$-?$"#3#"+A,!-+$,")+,D*43+,A$7M#D-+$,"%

 ./ !#")(&
#)
	 &"'($#")(&

% 7M#D-+$,"1#,#@!**5%ED#B-!"B@$/+3#3.$@+,"47B!@!A@!B?%7#*$C!,3

4,*#""$-?#@C+"#!A@##3-$75-?#B!@-+#"$@$@3#@#375-?#$4@-)!,5B!@-5$7M#D-+,A-$!,+,+-+!*

3#"+A,!-+$,$."?!**,$-+.5-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5+,C@+-+,A%?#

$7M#D-+,A!,3-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-+#""?!**B@$FB-*5D$,.#@+,!,!--#FB--$@#"$*/#-?#+@3+..#@#,D#"%

.-?#3#"+A,!-+,A!,3$7M#D-+,AB!@-+#"!@#4,!7*#-$@#"$*/#-?#+@3+..#@#,D#")-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5

"?!**?!/#-C#,-5$,#GJD!*#,3!@3!5".@$F-?#@#D#+B-$.-?#C@+--#,$7M#D-+$,-$.+*#C+-?-?#

D$4@-!F$-+$,.$@B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@+,!DD$@3!,D#C+-?-?#@4*#"!,3B@$D#34@#"$.-?#$4@-%?#

3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5"?!**?!/#-?#74@3#,$.B@$$.$,!,5"4D?F$-+$,.$@B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@-$M4"-+.5

-?#3#"+A,!-+$,%**3$D4F#,-"+,+-+!**53#"+A,!-#3!"

"?!**D$,-+,4#-$7#"47M#D--$-?+"$@3#@4,*#""!,34,-+*-?#

$4@-@4*#"$-?#@C+"#$@-?#B!@-+#""$!A@##+,C@+-+,A%.!3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5#*#D-",$--$F!<#!

F$-+$,.$@!B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@C+-?@#"B#D--$3$D4F#,-"-$C?+D?!,$7M#D-+$,?!"7##,F!3#)+-"?!**

7#3##F#3-$?!/#C+-?3@!C,+-"3#"+A,!-+$,!,3"?!**"#,3!D$B5$.-?#B@#/+$4"*53#"+A,!-#3

3$D4F#,-"C+-?$4--?#3#"+A,!-+$,-$#!D?B!@-5-$C?$F-?#

B@#/+$4"*53#"+A,!-#33$D4F#,-"C#@#$@+A+,!**5B@$34D#3%

% 7M#D-+$,"#!@@+!*%,-?#D!"#$.3#"+A,!-+$,"@#D#+/#3C+-?+,.$@-5.+/#

GJD!*#,3!@3!5"$.-?#3!-#"#-.$@-?#7#A+,,+,A$.-@+!*)-?#$7M#D-+,AB!@-5"?!**?!/#?!*.$.-?#

@#F!+,+,A-+F#7#.$@#-@+!*+,C?+D?-$@!+"#!,$7M#D-+$,-$-?#3#"+A,!-+$,%.!,$7M#D-+$,+"

@#D#+/#3C+-?+,-C#,-5$,#GJD!*#,3!@3!5"$.-?#3!-#"#-.$@-?#7#A+,,+,A$.-@+!*)-?#

3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5F4"-.+*#+-"F$-+$,.$@B@$-#D-+/#$@3#@$,!,#EB!@-#7!"+"C+-?!@#K4#"-.$@!,

$@3#@"?$@-#,+,A-+F#$,-?#?#!@+,A+,$@3#@-$!--#FB--$?!/#-?#F!--#@?#!@37#.$@#-?#

7#A+,,+,A$.-@+!*%.-?#F!--#@?!",$-7##,?#!@37#.$@#-@+!*)-?#+""4#F!57#?#!@375-?#-@+!*

M43A#+,B@#-@+!*B@$D##3+,A"%

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 6 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 6 of 18

	

	

	

 &	&

 !"#$%&
&
	

0 $(+%"('
)(*"+ (#"$%
(*),-$#")(
,"),
#)
,"$%

% 4-?$@+O#3+"D*$"4@#"%,*#""$-?#@C+"#!A@##375-?#B!@-+#"$@$@3#@#375

-?#$4@-)"?!**7#3+"D*$"#375-?#@#D#+/+,AB!@-5$,*5-$-?#

.$**$C+,AB#@"$,"

!% --$@,#5"$.@#D$@3+,-?+"B@$D##3+,A)+,D*43+,A-?#+@,#D#""!@5!""$D+!-#")

B!@!*#A!*")D*#@<")!,3"#D@#-!@+!*!,3D*#@+D!*B#@"$,,#* 

7% ,&?$4"#D$4,"#*G!,3-?#+@"-!..J$.!B!@-5)F!,!A#F#,-G!,3-?#+@"-!..J$.!

B!@-53+@#D-*5+,/$*/#3+,-?#B@$"#D4-+$,$@3#.#,"#$.-?+"!D-+$,)!,36$@

#FB*$5##"$.!B!@-53#"+A,!-#375+,&?$4"#D$4,"#*$@75F!,!A#F#,--$

!""+"-C+-?-?#B@$"#D4-+$,$@3#.#,"#$.-?+"!D-+$, 

D% ;4!*+.+#3B#@"$,"-!<+,A-#"-+F$,5+,/$*/+,A"4D?+,.$@F!-+$,)!,3,#D#""!@5

"-#,$A@!B?+D)/+3#$-!B#!,3D*#@+D!*B#@"$,,#* 

3% @+!*#EB#@-")#EB#@-D$,"4*-!,-"!,3-?#+@"-!.."C?$!@#@#-!+,#375D$4,"#*

.$@!@#D#+/+,AB!@-5.$@-?+"!D-+$, 

#% '+-,#""#"C?$!*@#!35<,$C-?#7#+,A

3+"D*$"#3G!"D$,.+@F#3-?@$4A?D$4,"#*+,!3/!,D#$.!,53+"D*$"4@#-$-?#

C+-,#""!,36$@!"3#F$,"-@!-#375-?#C+-,#""7#+,AD*#!@*5"?$C,!"!,

!4-?$@$@B@+$@@#D+B+#,-$.-?#$,-?#

.!D#$.-?#3$D4F#,--$7#3+"D*$"#3J 

.% #B$,#,-"G!,33#B$,#,-P"D$4,"#*J+,-?+"!D-+$,-$C?$F3+"D*$"4@#+"

@#!"$,!7*5,#D#""!@5 34@+,A-?#D$4@"#$.!3#B$"+-+$,$@+,B@#B!@!-+$,.$@!

3#B$"+-+$,$@-@+!* 

A% ,"4@#@-?!-+""4#3B$*+D+#"-$!B!@-5-?!-F!5B@$/+3#+,"4@!,D#D$/#@!A#.$@

-?+"!D-+$, 

?% +"D$/#@5F!"-#@"$@"#--*#F#,-M43A#"!BB$+,-#375-?#$4@-$@!A@##3-$

7#-C##,-?#B!@-+#")C?$!@##,A!A#3+,B@$D##3+,A"D$,,#D-#3C+-?-?+"

!D-+$,)!,3B#@"$,,#*@#A4*!@*5#FB*$5#375-?#F 

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 7 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 7 of 18

	

	

	

 &
&

 !"#$%&
&
	

+% ?#$4@-)$4@-"-!..!,3$-?#@B#@"$,,#*7#.$@#C?+D?-?+"!D-+$,+"

B#,3+,A%

@#D#+/+,AB!@-5F!5B@$/+3#-$!4-?$@+O#3

B#@"$,"3#"+A,!-#3+,"47B!@!A@!B?"%G3J)G#J)G.J!,3GAJ!7$/#$,*5+."4D?B#@"$,"!D<,$C*#3A#

+,C@+-+,A-?!--?#5?!/#@#!3-?+"-+B4*!-#3@$-#D-+/#@3#@!,3!A@##-$7#7$4,375+-"-#@F"%G

.$@F$."4D?!D<,$C*#3AF#,-+"!--!D?#3?#@#-$!"E?+7+-%J4D?C@+--#,!D<,$C*#3AF#,-"?!**

,$-7#3+"D$/#@!7*#+,-?+"!D-+$,%!D?B!@-5-!<#"@#"B$,"+7+*+-5.$@#,"4@+,A-?!-!**!4-?$@+O#3

@#D+B+#,-"$.!@#+,.$@F#3$.!,3!A@##-$-?+"-+B4*!-+$,!,3

@$-#D-+/#@3#@%,53+"D*$"4@#"4,3#@-?+"B!@!A@!B?!@#!4-?$@+O#3$,*5-$-?##E-#,-,#D#""!@5

-$B@$"#D4-#$@3#.#,3-?+"*+-+A!-+$,%

% ,!4-?$@+O#3+"D*$"4@#"%.+"3+"D*$"#3

-$!,5B#@"$,$-?#@-?!,+,-?#F!,,#@!4-?$@+O#375-?+"-+B4*!-#3@$-#D-+/#@3#@)-?#B!@-5$@

B#@"$,@#"B$,"+7*#.$@-?#3+"D*$"4@#)!,3!,5$-?#@B!@-5$@B#@"$,C?$+""47M#D--$-?+"@3#@!,3

*#!@,"$."4D?3+"D*$"4@#G+,D*43+,AC+-?$4-*+F+-!-+$,!**#FB*$5##")$..+D#@")3+@#D-$@")!A#,-"!,3

!--$@,#5"$.#!D?B!@-5-$-?+"*!C"4+-J)"?!**+FF#3+!-#*57@+,A"4D?3+"D*$"4@#-$-?#!--#,-+$,$.

-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5%'+-?$4-B@#M43+D#-$$-?#@@+A?-"!,3@#F#3+#"$.-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5)-?#

@#"B$,"+7*#B!@-5$@B#@"$,"?!**F!<##/#@5@#!"$,!7*##..$@--$$7-!+,-?#@#-4@,$.-?#

!,3-$B@#/#,-.4@-?#@3+"D*$"4@#$,+-"$C,B!@-$@$,-?#B!@-

$.-?#B#@"$,C?$C!"-?#4,!4-?$@+O#3@#D+B+#,-$."4D?+,.$@F!-+$,%

% $4@-+*+,A"%**F$-+$,")-@!,"D@+B-"$.3#B$"+-+$,")#E?+7+-")!,"C#@"-$

+,-#@@$A!-$@+#")3+"D$/#@5@#"B$,"#"!,36$@$-?#@3$D4F#,-"!,36$@B*#!3+,A".+*#3C+-?-?+"$4@-

-?!-D$,-!+,"?!**7#F!@<#3HI!,3"?!**7#

.+*#3!,3"#@/#3 B4@"4!,--$-?#B@$D#34@#"!,3@#K4+@#F#,-"$.+/+*$D!*4*#
&.$@-?#%%

+"-@+D-$4@-$.-?#$@-?#@,+"-@+D-$.!*+.$@,+!G$@)"?$4*3!,5$-?#@D$4@-B@#"+3#$/#@-?+"

!D-+$,)-?#@4*#"$.-?!-D$4@-.$@.+*+,AD$,.+3#,-+!*+,.$@F!-+$,4,3#@"#!*J%

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 8 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 8 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

1 $(+%"('
)(*"+ (#"$%
(*),-$#")(
	2,"('
,"$%

C?+D?+""47M#D--$-?+"@3#@)!,33##F#3!3F+""+7*#!"

-@+!*#/+3#,D#75-?#D$4@-)F!57#F!@<#3!,34"#3!"-@+!*#E?+7+-"75!B!@-5!DD$@3+,A-$-?#

-#@F"+FB$"#375-?#-@+!*D$4@-!--+F#$.-@+!*%**B!@-+#"@#"#@/#-?#@+A?--$!33@#""-?#-@+!*D$4@-

7#.$@#!,334@+,A-@+!*@#A!@3+,A-?#F!@<+,A)?!,3*+,A!,34"#!--@+!*$.3#"+A,!-#3

)+,D*43+,A$7M#D-+$,"-$3#"+A,!-+$,"%

 $(+%"('
*# ,
"($%
	"&3)&"#")(

	% $,'$@<@$34D-!-#@+!*"%'+-?+,,+,#-5G
JD!*#,3!@3!5"$.-?#.+,!*

3+"B$"+-+$,$.-?+"*!C"4+-!"-$!@#D#+/+,AB!@-5)-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5F!5@#K4#"-+,C@+-+,A$.!

@#D#+/+,AB!@-5-?!-!,5$@!**#+-?#@7#@#-4@,#3-$-?#

3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5$@3#"-@$5#375-?#@#D#+/+,AB!@-5)!--?#$B-+$,$.-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5%.-?#

3$D4F#,-"!@#@#K4#"-#3-$7#@#-4@,#3)-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5"?!**B!5@#!"$,!7*#"?+BB+,AD$"-"

!""$D+!-#3C+-?@#-4@,+,A"4D?3$D4F#,-")74-"?!**,$-B!5.$@-?#-+F#$.B#@"$,,#*$.-?#

@#D#+/+,AB!@-5-$!DD$FB*+"?-?#@#-4@,%?#@#K4#"-"?!**"B#D+.+D!**5+3#,-+.5-?#3$D4F#,-"$@

-?+,A"-$7#@#-4@,#3$@3#"-@$5#3+.@#-4@,$@3#"-@4D-+$,$.*#""-?!,!**

+"@#K4#"-#3%?#!--$@,#5.$@-?#@#D#+/+,AB!@-5"?!**D$**#D-)!""#F7*#!,3#+-?#@

@#-4@,$@3#"-@$5G!--?#$B-+$,$.-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5JC+-?+,,+,#GJF$,-?"!**"4D?

)+,D*43+,A!**D$B+#")#E-@!D-"!,3"4FF!@+#"-?#@#$.+,-?#

B$""#""+$,$.-?#@#D#+/+,AB!@-5)+-"D$4,"#*$@$-?#@!4-?$@+O#3@#D+B+#,-")74-,$-+,D*43+,A

#E-@!D-"$@"4FF!@+#"-?!-D$,-!+,$@D$,"-+-4-#!--$@,#5L"$@#EB#@-L"C$@<B@$34D-$@B*#!3+,A".+*#3

C+-?-?#$4@-)#ED#B--?!--?#@#D#+/+,AB!@-5F!5)!-+-"$C,$B-+$,)3#"-@$5)@!-?#@-?!,@#-4@,)!,5

"4D?+.+-+"F!@<#3$@C@+--#,4B$,75!,5!--$@,#5$@#EB#@-

?#@#+,%#D#+B-$.@#-4@,#3"?!**7#!D<,$C*#3A#3+,C@+-+,A+.

"4D?!,!D<,$C*#3AF#,-+"@#K4#"-#3%$4,"#*.$@-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5!A@##-$@#-!+,.$@.+/#GJ

5#!@".@$F-?#3!5$.@#D#+B--?#@#-4@,#375-?#@#D#+/+,A

B!@-5%

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 9 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 9 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

	% '$@<@$34D-!-#@+!*"%--$@,#5"P)D$,"4*-!,-"P!,3#EB#@-"PC$@<B@$34D-

@#.#@@+,A-$$@@#.*#D-+,AF!57#@#-!+,#3!.-#@@#D#+B-$.!

@#K4#"-!"3#"D@+7#3+,!@!A@!B?	%?#@#$.)74-!**"4D?C$@<B@$34D-"?!**7#"47M#D--$-?#-#@F"

$.-?+"@3#@4,*#""!,34,-+*"4D?C$@<B@$34D-+"B#@F!,#,-*53#"-@$5#3%

 4",+
$,#5
2.3) ($

?$4*3!@#D#+/+,AB!@-5@#D#+/#.@$F!,5+,3+/+34!*$@#,-+-5-?!-+",$-!B!@-5?#@#-$!

"47B$#,!)3+"D$/#@5@#K4#"-)D$4@-$@3#@)$@$-?#@!4-?$@+-!-+/#3#F!,3$@@#K4#"-.$@!,5

3#"+A,!-#3!""4D?75!,$-?#@B!@-5?#@#-$)-?#B!@-5@#D#+/+,A

"4D?@#K4#"-C+**+FF#3+!-#*5,$-+.5-?#B!@-5-?!-3#"+A,!-#3-?#+,.$@F!-+$,!"

!,3B@$/+3#-?!-B!@-5C+-?!,$BB$@-4,+-5-$$7M#D--$)D?!**#,A#)$@$-?#@C+"#

D$,-#"--?#3#F!,3$@@#K4#"-.$@+-"7#.$@#!,5"4D?

+"3+"D*$"#3%-"?!**7#-?#$7*+A!-+$,$.-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5

-$B@$FB-*5-!<#C?!-#/#@"-#B"!@#@#K4+@#3-$B@$-#D-+-"

7#.$@#!@#"B$,"#.@$F-?#"47B$#,!#3B!@-5+"@#K4+@#3 ?$C#/#@)-?#"47B$#,!#3B!@-5C+**,$-

B@$34D#$.-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5)4,*#""-?#"47B$#,!#3B!@-5

@#D#+/#"-?#D$,"#,-$.-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5$@!,$@3#@.@$F!,5D$4@--?!-@#K4+@#"B@$34D-+$,+,

@#"B$,"#-$-?#3#"+A,!-+,AB!@-5L"!--#FB--$B@$-#D-+-"%

 )
-3%" +
6$"7 ,&

?##,-@5$.-?+"@3#@"?!**,$-7#+,-#@B@#-#3!"!C!+/#@$.-?#@+A?--$$7M#D-)B4@"4!,--$

!,5!BB*+D!7*#*!C$@@4*#)-$-?#.4@,+"?+,A$.+,.$@F!-+$,+,@#"B$,"#-$3+"D$/#@5@#K4#"-"$@-$

$7M#D--$!@#K4#"-#3+,"B#D-+$,$.3$D4F#,-"$@.!D+*+-+#"%ED#B-!""B#D+.+D!**5B@$/+3#3?#@#+,)

,#+-?#@-?#!A@##F#,--$),$@-?#-!<+,A$.)!,5!D-+$,+,!DD$@3!,D#C+-?-?#B@$/+"+$,"$.-?+"

@3#@),$@-?#.!+*4@#-$$7M#D--?#@#-$)"?!**7#+,-#@B@#-#3!"!C!+/#@$.!,5D*!+F$@B$"+-+$,$@

3#.#,"#+,-?+"!D-+$,)$@!,5$-?#@!D-+$,"%

8 ($+7 ,# (#
	"&!%)&2, 
),
,)+2!#")(

?#+,!3/#@-#,-B@$34D-+$,$.!,5B@+/+*#A#3$@$-?#@C+"#B@$-#D-#3$@#E#FB-#3

+,.$@F!-+$,)!"C#**!"-?#+,!3/#@-#,-B@$34D-+$,$.+,.$@F!-+$,C+-?$4-!,!BB@$B@+!-#3#"+A,!-+$,

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 10 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 10 of 18

	

	

	

 &
&

 !"#$%&
&
	

$.D$,.+3#,-+!*+-5)"?!**,$-7#3##F#3!C!+/#@$@+FB!+@F#,-$.!,5D*!+F$.B@+/+*#A#)B@$-#D-+$,

$@D$,.+3#,-+!*+-5)+,D*43+,A74-,$-*+F+-#3-$-?#!--$@,#5&D*+#,-B@+/+*#A#)-?#B@$-#D-+$,!..$@3#3-$

C$@<&B@$34D-F!-#@+!*"$@-?#"47M#D-F!--#@-?#@#$.)$@-?#D$,.+3#,-+!*,!-4@#$.!,5"4D?

+,.$@F!-+$,)B@$/+3#3-?!--?#B@$34D+,AB!@-5"?!**+FF#3+!-#*5,$-+.5@#D#+/+,AB!@-5+,C@+-+,A

C?#,+,!3/#@-#,-B@$34D-+$,+"3+"D$/#@#3%B$,@#D#+/+,AC@+--#,,$-+D#.@$F-?#B@$34D+,AB!@-5

-?!-B@+/+*#A#3+,.$@F!-+$,)C$@<&B@$34D-F!-#@+!*$@?!"7##,

+,!3/#@-#,-*5B@$34D#3)!**"4D?+,.$@F!-+$,)!,3!**D$B+#"-?#@#-$"?!**7#<#B-75D$4,"#*.$@-?#

@#D#+/+,AB!@-5!,3D$4,"#*"?!**,$-4"#"4D?+,.$@F!-+$,.$@!,5B4@B$"#4,-+*.4@-?#@@3#@$.-?#

$4@-)$@4,-+*-?#B@$34D+,A!,3@#D#+/+,AB!@-+#"?!/#!A@##34B$,!"!-+".!D-$@5@#"$*4-+$,$.-?#

+,!3/#@-#,-*5B@$34D#3+,.$@F!-+$,%?#B@$34D+,AB!@-5F!5-?#,)+.,#D#""!@5)F$/#-?#D$4@-.$@

!,@3#@D$FB#**+,A@#-4@,$.-?#F!-#@+!*%,5!,!*5"#")F#F$@!,3!$@,$-#"C?+D?C#@#

+,-#@,!**5A#,#@!-#37!"#34B$,"4D?+,!3/#@-#,-*5B@$34D#3+,.$@F!-+$,"?!**+FF#3+!-#*57#

-@#!-#3+,D$,.$@F!,D#C+-?-?#B@$-#D-#3,!-4@#$.-?#+,.$@F!-+$,%

 2#4),"#5
#)
9 !2# 

!D?D$4,"#*"+A,+,A-?+"-+B4*!-#3@$-#D-+/#@3#@$,7#?!*.$.?+"$@?#@D*+#,-G"J

@#B@#"#,-"-?!-!D$B5$.-?+"-+B4*!-+$,!,3@$-#D-+/#@3#@?!"7##,B@$/+3#3-$!-*#!"-$,#

!4-?$@+O#3#FB*$5##$.#!D?D*+#,-D$FB!,5C?$?!"!4-?$@+O#3-?#"+A,!-$@5-$7+,3-?#D*+#,--$

-?#-#@F"$.-?+"-+B4*!-+$,!,3@$-#D-+/#@3#@)+,D*43+,A-?$"#B@$/+"+$,"?#@#+,C!+/+,A-?#

!DD#""$.-?#D*+#,-$@+-"#FB*$5##")$..+D#@"$@3+@#D-$@"G+,D*43+,A!,5"47"+3+!@5$@!..+*+!-#

-?#@#$.J-$3#"+A,!-#3%

 9 !2#")(
"(
)2(# ,3$,#&

?+"@3#@F!57##E#D4-#375.!D"+F+*#"+A,!-4@#!,3+,D$4,-#@B!@-"!,3#!D?#E#D4-#3

D$4,-#@B!@-F!57#D$F7+,#3-$D@#!-#$,#$@+A+,!*3$D4F#,-%

 )("'($#),5
	 * (+$(#&

$F#$.-?#,!F#33#.#,3!,-"+,-?#$FB*!+,--$-?+"!D-+$,?!/#,$-#E#D4-#3-?+"

-+B4*!-#3@$-#D-+/#@3#@7#D!4"#-?#5!@#3+""$*/#3)-?#5?!/#,$-7##,"#@/#3)-?#5!@#

D?!**#,A+,A"#@/+D#) -?#5!@#D?!**#,A+,A-?#M4@+"3+D-+$,$.-?#D$4@- !,36$@-?#5!@#,$-@#B@#"#,-#3

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 11 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 11 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

75D$4,"#*%*"$)!33+-+$,!*#,-+-+#"$@B#@"$,"F!57#!33#3!"B!@-+#"-$-?+"!D-+$,+,-?#.4-4@#%

$@#D#+/#)!,5,$,&"+A,!-$@53#.#,3!,-$@!,5"47"#K4#,-*5&

!33#3B!@-5"?!**.+*#!,3"#@/#!B*#!3+,A"-!-+,A-?!-+-?!"@#D#+/#3!,3@#/+#C#3-?+"-+B4*!-#3

@$-#D-+/#@3#@)!,3-?!-+-!A@##"-$7#7$4,375+-"-#@F"!,3@#K4+@#F#,-"!"+.+-?!3"+A,#3-?#

+,+-+!*-+B4*!-#3@$-#D-+/#@3#@%

)%

!-#3

0$,%4"!,**"-$,

,+-#3-!-#"+"-@+D-:43A#

%

!-#3 #B-#F7#@)

 1(%).6<6!

(

25 6"6:!F#"0%$*$B5)"K%

$4A*!"%($4,A)"K%

:!F#"0%$*$B5)"K%

4-?,,!"-@$)"K%

 2Q 

4""24+*3+,A

$,-A$F#@5-@##-)
-?*$$@

!,@!,D+"D$)

$4,"#*.$@3#.#,3!,-#A!D54*D!,$@B%D#@-+.+#"-?!-D$,D4@@#,D#?!"7##,$7-!+,#3

.@$FD$4,"#*.$@#!D?B!@-57#*$C-$#E#D4-#!,3.+*#-?+"B*#!3+,A$,7#?!*.$.-?!-B!@-5)!,3-?+"

B*#!3+,A+"-?#@#.$@#7#+,A.+*#3+,D$FB*+!,D#C+-?1#,#@!*@3#@$%)#D-+$,8%2%

!-#3

'(

25 6"6

+D-$@%?#@)"K%

!@,+#%+33*#)"K%

+D?$*!"1%!FB+,")"K%

0  

+""+$,-%)4+-#

!,@!,D+"D$)

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 12 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 12 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

!-#3

0'0(

25 6"6

1#,,!@$%+*+D#)"K%

-#B?#,:%!*#,)"K%

!,+#*:%+D?$*")"K%

) 2')  9  

!<##@@+--*!O!

0!@@+"$,-%)-?*$$@

!<*!,3)	&

!-#3

%%(

25 6"6

,3@#C%$@-*)"K%

1(9 () 

,#'!*,4-@##<#,-#@

@+,A*#/#,4#)4+-#

'!*,4-@##<)	

!-#3 1)%

25 6"6

1!@5:%F+-?)"K%

5!,%!D$@3!)"K%

219 ) %%

	$,-A$F#@5-@##-)4+-#

!,@!,D+"D$)
&

!-#3

0

25 6"6

-#B?#,%#C+")"K%

!4@##,%>+,A)"K%

21) ) '9 ) 

!*+.$@,+!-@##-),3*$$@

!,@!,D+"D$)
&

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 13 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 13 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

!-#3

1(

25 6"6

-#/#,0%14@,##)"K%

:$?,%!"$,)"K%

19 

$4A*!"2*/3%)4+-#

$"#/+**#)		&

!-#3

0(

25 6"6

!,35:#..D$!D?)"K%

>2') 

+/#@!@<*!D#!"-

@#",$)

!-#3 (0()%)

+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!:81

;

25 6"6

?@+"-$B?#@%2#D??$*3)"K%

00

'!*,4--@##-)-?*$$@

+,D+,,!-+)0
&

!-#3 %%9%)%

25 6"6

@+D1@!,-)"K%

0>0

$*"$F2$4*#/!@3)4+-#

!D@!F#,-$)	

:$?,2%?$F!")"K%

2@+!,%7@!F"$,)"K%

0>0

$4+"+!,!)4+-#

0$4"-$,)8

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 14 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 14 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

!-#3 (1)%

G+FB@$B#@*5"4#3!",+$,@5D*#!,+,A@$34D-"

%%%!,3#!*"-!@),D%)+,3+/+34!**5!,33676!

#!*"-!@J

25 6"6

@+D1@!,-)"K%

0>0

$*"$F2$4*#/!@3)4+-#

!D@!F#,-$)	

:$?,2%?$F!")"K%

2@+!,%7@!F"$,)"K%

0>0

$4+"+!,!)4+-#

0$4"-$,)8

!-#3 

25 6"6

4"!,%!*3C#**)"K%

5!,#!F)"K%

>>() ) 9 '

	
'+*"?+@#2$4*#/!@3)+A?-?*$$@

$",A#*#")

&

!-#3 >0;()%

25 6"6

-#B?#,%B!-!@$)"K%

9 

:!5"'!5

+,AA$*3)1

	&

!-#3 =)%

25 6"6

-#B?#,%B!-!@$)"K%

9 

:!5"'!5

+,AA$*3)1

	&

!-#3 %2%%)%

25 6"6

%!5F$,30!F@+D<))"K%

$4A*!">%!D<#5)"K%

0>9 ) 

,+/#@"!*+-5*!O!)4+-#

,+/#@"!*+-5)	
&

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 15 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 15 of 18

	

	

	

 &&

 !"#$%&
&
	

!-#3 11((%

25 6"6

:!,%1@#7#,)"K%

129 

,!D!B!-@##-)4+-#

!,-!2!@7!@!)

!-#3 '>()%

25 6"6

!/+3%#*-$,)"K%

,+/#@"+-5/#%)4+-#

!D@!F#,-$)

!-#3

(0)%

25 6"6

'+**+!F0%>$D?#,3#@.#@)"K%

) '>9 >0) 

0#@3!*@+/#)4+-#

474@,)	

!-#3 2()%

25 6"6

!-@+D<%!*$,#5)"K%

29 

+A4#@$!-%R

$",A#*#")

!-#3 ';

25 6"6

/!,%2#@F!,)"K%

>#,,#-?%>!,)"K%

229 2

'#"-*5FB+D2*/3%)+E-?*$$@

$",A#*#")

	

!-#3 '(&2

25 6"6

!@<2%1+*F!@-+,)"K%

'>2% 1

-?-@##-)4+-#

!,-!$,+D!)

&

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 16 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 16 of 18

	

	

	

 &	&

 !"#$%&
&
	

!-#3 2;

25 6"6

?$F!"'%0$$3)"K

09 

2#!D?2*/3%)4+-#

04,-+,A-$,2#!D?)	

!-#3 80)%.6<6!

'?+-#$,"$*+3!-#3,34"-@+#"),D%G#@@$,#$4"*5

"4#3!"*#D-@$*4E$@B$@!-+$,J

25 6"6

+D?#*#%$C#@")"K%

9 2 

$4-?0$B#-@##-)+E-##,-?*$$@

$",A#*#")

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 17 of 17 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 17 of 18
	

	

	
	

 !
"#
$!
 % 

%&

'
' (
 ' !

( 
 %

) ' 
*"  '&

+'+
 %
*"  '"
"#
"#' '
#", '"
-.) ' 

*"  '&
/0
 % 
1(
'((
2!
 %
' 
)  (
'( ' 
" 
#"
 %
" %
'( ' 
"#

'#"'
'
 %
(
"#
	

		 	3

(
"4
5678679:;<
)4

+
 "
",!
1' %

 "
2
2"
2!

 %
 ,(
"#
 %'(
) ' 
*"  '&

( 

="1+
 % 
#'
 "
("
",!
"
>"(
,
 "
( '"(

'(%, 
'
 %
 
"#
" , 4

1'
" 
'("(
'
!
,
!
'#", '"
"

' ,
 % 
'(
(2$ 
 "
 %'(
) ' 
*"  '&

 "
!
("
"
 ' !
> 
'
( ' 

",'
1' %
 %
"&'('"(
"#
 %'(
4

# %
+
 "
(2,' 
 "
 %
$'(' '"
"#
 %
' 
)  (
'( ' 
" 
#"
 %

" %
'( ' 
"#
'#"'
#"
 %
"(
"#
#"'+
 %
 ,(
"#
 %'(
) ' 

*"  '&
3
&
'#
(%
#", 
"'+(
"
# 
 ,' '"
"#
 %'(
 '"4

 ?
 @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

*' 
,?

@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

)'+ ?
 @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 69-2 Filed 09/19/2008 Page 1 of 1 Case 3:08-cv-03267-SI Document 77 Filed 09/23/08 Page 18 of 18