Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-ared-4_05-cv-01132/USCOURTS-ared-4_05-cv-01132-0/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 365
Nature of Suit: Personal Injury - Product Liability
Cause of Action: 28:1332 Diversity-Personal Injury

---

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS

WESTERN DIVISION

 : MDL DOCKET NO. 4:03-CV-1507-WRW

IN RE: :

PREMPRO PRODUCTS LIABILITY :

LITIGATION : ALL CASES IN EXHIBIT A1

ORDER

Pending is Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment re: California Statute of

Limitations (Doc. No. 2242). Plaintiffs have responded and Defendants have replied.2

Defendants assert that each of the Plaintiffs listed in Exhibit A filed their cases in

California “more than two years after both the date of her breast cancer diagnosis and the July 9,

2002, public announcement that the National Institutes of Health had terminated the Prempro

arm of the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) study.”3

 Accordingly, Defendants contend that

each case is barred based on California’s two-year statute of limitations.

In response, Plaintiffs state only that each Plaintiff now has a case pending in Minnesota,

and dismissing the California cases would not have a res judicata effect on the Minnesota cases.4

Since Plaintiff appears to have conceded the issue, Defendants’ Motion for Summary

Judgment (Doc. No. 2242) is GRANTED. Accordingly, the cases listed in Exhibit A are

DISMISSED.

IT SO ORDERED this 13th day of May, 2010.

 /s/ Wm. R. Wilson, Jr._______________

 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

1

The Clerk of the Court is directed to file this order in the In re Prempro case and in each

case listed in Exhibit A.

2

Doc. Nos. 2256, 2262.

3

Doc. No. 2243.

4

Doc. No. 2256.

Case 4:05-cv-01132-BRW Document 3 Filed 05/13/10 Page 1 of 3
EXHIBIT A

Allen, Dorothy 4:05-cv-01198-WRW

Allen, Judith 4:05-cv-00673-WRW

Anderson, Patsy 4:05-cv-01821-WRW

Andrews, Loretta 4:05-cv-01244-WRW

Arbogast, Janet 4:05-cv-01474-WRW

Aros, Helen Penny 4:05-cv-01772-WRW

Awald, Karen 4:05-cv-00766-WRW

Bannerman, Carol 4:05-cv-00700-WRW

Barnes, Phyllis 4:05-cv-00837-WRW

Barrett, Joanne 4:05-cv-00781-WRW

Bethea, Betty 4:05-cv-01532-WRW

Black, Joanne 4:05-cv-01241-WRW

Bowden, Mary 4:05-cv-01274-WRW

Brouwer, Juanita 4:05-cv-01789-WRW

Burgess, Hazel 4:05-cv-00839-WRW

Burpee, Joyce 4:05-cv-00826-WRW

Campbell, Virginia 4:05-cv-00565-WRW

Cargan, Nata 4:05-cv-01757-WRW

Carrera, Adrianne 4:05-cv-01225-WRW

Carter, Lois 4:05-cv-01406-WRW

Carter, Nancy Jo 4:05-cv-01765-WRW

Casto, Joan 4:05-cv-01763-WRW

Chamness, Margaret 4:05-cv-00746-WRW

Chrisco, Mary 4:05-cv-01197-WRW

Clemons, Peggy 4:05-cv-00480-WRW

Collins, Sally 4:05-cv-01632-WRW

Conner, Marian 4:05-cv-01827-WRW

Cordon, Alba 4:05-cv-01736-WRW

Couch, Barbara 4:05-cv-00564-WRW

Cowart, Wilma 4:05-cv-01810-WRW

Dawson, Mary 4:05-cv-00680-WRW

Duffy, Lois 4:05-cv-01473-WRW

Edwards, Janet 4:05-cv-01764-WRW

Eells, Linda 4:05-cv-01393-WRW

Farr, Frances 4:05-cv-01399-WRW

Faulkner, Wilma 4:05-cv-01724-WRW

Flaman, Marjorie 4:05-cv-01184-WRW

Foltz, Margaret 4:05-cv-01264-WRW

Foltz, Wanda 4:05-cv-00911-WRW

Foster, Delois 4:05-cv-01125-WRW

Fragoso, Isabel 4:05-cv-01769-WRW

Gilliam, Gail 4:05-cv-01327-WRW

Gist, Doris 4:05-cv-01807-WRW

Goode, Phyllis 4:05-cv-01778-WRW

Haemker, Sharon 4:05-cv-01222-WRW

Haney, Carol 4:05-cv-01725-WRW

Harris, Margaret 4:05-cv-01273-WRW

Hess, Louise 4:05-cv-01126-WRW

Hinceman, Wanda 4:05-cv-01182-WRW

Holtzman, Alice 4:05-cv-01221-WRW

Hren, Rita 4:05-cv-01548-WRW

Hunter, Nancy 4:05-cv-01265-WRW

Hutchinson, Yvonne 4:05-cv-01183-WRW

Ivey, Glenda 4:05-cv-01223-WRW

Jerome, Doris 4:05-cv-01267-WRW

Katte, Nancy 4:05-cv-01788-WRW

Kiger, Grace 4:05-cv-01227-WRW

Case 4:05-cv-01132-BRW Document 3 Filed 05/13/10 Page 2 of 3
Kirkland, Sandra 4:05-cv-01610-WRW

Kruse, Patricia 4:05-cv-01783-WRW

Kunkel, Marcia 4:05-cv-01210-WRW

Laufketter, Sally 4:06-cv-00252-WRW

Lawton-Wilson, Patricia 4:05-cv-01188-WRW

Lee, Monica 4:05-cv-01349-WRW

Maiello, Katherine 4:05-cv-01270-WRW

Mallette, Dorothy 4:05-cv-01275-WRW

Maury, Nan 4:05-cv-01800-WRW

McAdoo, Nola 4:05-cv-01348-WRW

McComas, Charlene 4:05-cv-01823-WRW

Meeks, Lillian 4:05-cv-00479-WRW

Moran, Anna 4:05-cv-01722-WRW

Nicholson, Brenda 4:05-cv-01283-WRW

Nickel, Joanne 4:05-cv-01185-WRW

Norvell, Barbara 4:05-cv-00842-WRW

O'Neil, Jo Garrison 4:05-cv-01200-WRW

Orr, Reva 4:05-cv-01228-WRW

Parker, Regina 4:05-cv-01522-WRW

Patterson, April 4:05-cv-01271-WRW

Perkinson, Kathleen 4:05-cv-01305-WRW

Peters, Donna 4:05-cv-01608-WRW

Petersen, Judith 4:05-cv-01786-WRW

Peterson, Joanne 4:05-cv-01614-WRW

Phillips, Mary 4:05-cv-01132-WRW

Pitsinger, Muriel 4:05-cv-01721-WRW

Plieseis, Viola 4:05-cv-01196-WRW

Podhayski, Joyce 4:05-cv-00478-WRW

Preston, Kathleen 4:05-cv-01306-WRW

Robbins, Ruby 4:05-cv-01784-WRW

Rogers, Patricia 4:06-cv-00549-WRW

Ross, Lydia 4:05-cv-00460-WRW

Roszak, Elizabeth 4:05-cv-01256-WRW

Rydjeske, Jan Costa 4:05-cv-01767-WRW

Simon, Diane 4:05-cv-00654-WRW

Sitzmann, Ruth 4:05-cv-01609-WRW

Solis, Mary 4:05-cv-01211-WRW

Sorensen, Mary 4:05-cv-00811-WRW

Spencer, Flora 4:05-cv-01329-WRW

Standriff, Sue 4:05-cv-01180-WRW

Steele, Mary 4:05-cv-01811-WRW

Stone, Patricia 4:05-cv-01284-WRW

Taube, Donna 4:05-cv-01813-WRW

Thompson, Joan 4:05-cv-01226-WRW

Tolkin, Jewell 4:05-cv-01804-WRW

Valentine, Tena 4:05-cv-00699-WRW

Wachter, Bertha 4:05-cv-01023-WRW

Walters, Diana 4:05-cv-01520-WRW

Walters, Marion 4:06-cv-00550-WRW

Waugh, Joyce 4:05-cv-01799-WRW

Wegenast, Judy 4:05-cv-01201-WRW

Weinmann, Charlene 4:05-cv-01613-WRW

Whaley, Helen 4:05-cv-00679-WRW

Wheeler, Donna 4:05-cv-01756-WRW

Will, Marilyn 4:05-cv-00678-WRW

Wixen, Francine 4:05-cv-01269-WRW

Wood, Joyce 4:05-cv-01266-WRW

Zissel, Bea 4:05-cv-01203-WRW

Case 4:05-cv-01132-BRW Document 3 Filed 05/13/10 Page 3 of 3