Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-4_05-cv-02275/USCOURTS-cand-4_05-cv-02275-14/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 890
Nature of Suit: Other Statutory Actions
Cause of Action: 28:1331 Fed. Question

---

!

"

#

$

 

!

"

#

$

 

!

"

#

	  

		 	

	 	 	

%& 	& '()*&

*)+,(+--.&

/.

0& 	& ) 	'/)1) 23453

4)(+3, '()*

'-',1),(.

	3 

	
	
 

		
		

	
	

	
	
		

	

	  	

	 0

 	 +. ',('4'1+,(3 67),16'(8'', 5*)+,(+--.923:,('4

1'-',1),(. )())4;& ,2 ),1,('4('2<,3=+2.& ,2 ),1(<+415)4(71'-',1),(('/'

)4)*)=6+'8& 67),1(<43:><(<'+4 23:,.'* 
4'>347*), :(2<+;3- +,'4 0),;'*'/+(?

:,.<+,' @'>',.(4'+- & 3, (<' 3,' <),1& ),11'-',1),(.& 23:,('42*)+=),(. ),1

(<+415)4(75*)+,(+--. 

7.('=.& ,2 ),1=,+543 ,234534)('1& ),11'-',1),(.

=,+='A& %4).+=+4 
3.531+,3/& )*',(+, 
'34>+'/),1?/'(), +;3/BC1'-',1),(.CD&

67),1(<43:><(<'+4 23:,.'* )/+1 *'A),1'4 3- E)8& 3, (<' 3(<'4 <),1

<+. (+5:*)(+3, +. =)1' 8+(<4'-'4',2' (3 (<' -3**38+,>-)2(.F

 '-',1),(. -+*'1) 	3(+2' 3- 3(+3, ),13(+3, (3 '=3/' *)+,

4'>347*), :(2<+;& .G BE	 $! D

	 0	%H& 		

@
	

$$ 4'=3,((4''(& (<*334

), 4),2+.23& )*+-34,+) $!

'*'5<3,'F !!#$

)2.+=+*'F !!#$

((34,'7. -34 *)+,(+--.93:,('41'-',1),(.

)())4;& ,2 ),1,('4('2<,3=+2.& ,2

),1<+41)4(7'-',1),(('/' )4)*)=6+'8

Case 3:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 82 Filed 03/30/2006 Page 1 of 3
 Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 84 Filed 03/31/06 Page 1 of 3
	 

 	  

	 
		 

	  

 !

 

!

"

#

$

 

!

"

#

$

 

!

"

#

(+--. '.+>,)(+3, 3- ((34,'7. 7'. ,*73, )42<!& " (3 =3/' (<+. 3:4((3 4'

=3/' (<' ((34,'7. 7'. ,*7C 1'.+>,)(+3, -43=5*)+,(+--.I +1',(+-+2)(+3, 3- (<'+4 (4)1'

.'24'(. ),14'.53,.'. (3 1'-',1),(. -+4.(.'(3- +,('443>)(34+'. B

3(+3,D

 , )42<& "& )>+.(4)(' 5'43 341'4'1(<)(F (<' 

3

(+3, 83:*16' .'(-34 <')4+,>3, )7& "& (<)(5*)+,(+--. 83:*1-+*'9.'4/' (<'+4 3553

.+(+3, 6754+* & " ),11'-',1),(. 83:*1-+*'9.'4/' (<'+4 4'5*76754+* $& "

)>+.(4)(' 5'43 )*.3 341'4'1(<' 5)4(+'. (3 =''(),123,-'4 -:4(<'4 +, 5'4.3, ),1(3 -+*'

8+(<(<' 3:4() 3+,('(('4

  <' 5)4(+'. <)/' ='(),123,-'44'13, (<' .:6.(),(+/' +..:' 3- (<'

3(+3, ),1<)/' )>4''1(<)(F

) <' 

3(+3, .<)** 6' 8+(<14)8,& 8+(<3:(54'J:

1+2'& ),1(<' 341'4 .'((+,>(<' <')4+,>964+'- 2)*',1)4 -34 (<' 

3(+3, /)2)('1

6 '-',1),(. .<)** <)/' )22'.. (3 5*)+,(+--.I '2(+3,

$ (4)1' .'24'(.()('=',(),15*)+,(+--.I '.53,.' 	3  (3 23:,('42*)+=),(.

5'2+)* ,('443>)(34+'.& +4.('(B*)+,(+--.I 4)1' '24'(()('=',(D). -3**38.F

*)+,(+--.I 4)1' '24'(()('=',(.<)** ,3(*')/' 53..'..+3, 3- 1'-',1),(.I )((34,'7

'-',1),(.I 4'/+'8.<)** 322:4 3,*7:,1'4 .:5'4/+.+3, 3- (<'+4 )((34,'7& )(<+. 3--+2'&

),11'-',1),(. .<)** ,3(6' 5'4=+(('1(3 ();' ,3('. 34 =);' 235+'. 3- *)+,(+--.I 4)1'

'24'(()('=',(

! <+. (+5:*)(+3, .<)** 6' -+*'18+(<(<' 3:4(),1(<' 5)4(+'. )>4'' (3

6' 63:,167(<' ('4=. <'4'3-

	 0	%H		

@
	

)('1F )42<$& " E7 .9
4'>347*), :(2<+;

4'>347*), :(2<+;

((34,'7. -34 *)+,(+--.93:,('41'-',1),(.

)())4;& ,2 ),1,('4('2<,3=+2.& ,2 ),1

<+41)4(7'-',1),(('/' )4)*)=6+'8

Case 3:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 82 Filed 03/30/2006 Page 2 of 3
 Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 84 Filed 03/31/06 Page 2 of 3
	 

 	  

	 
		 

	  

 !

 

 

!

"

#

$

 

!

"

#

$

 

!

"

#

EK 

)('1F )42<$& " E7 .9)/+1 *'A),1'4

)/+1 *'A),1'4

((34,'7. -34 '-',1),(. 

7.('=.& ,2&

=,+='A& =,+543 ,234534)('1& )*',(+,

'34>+'/& %4).+=+4 
3.531+,3/),1?/'(),

+;3/

	

)/+,>4')1(<' -34'>3+,>.(+5:*)(+3, ),1>3312):.' )55')4+,>(<'4'-34F

 <+. 3:4(/)2)('. (<' 54+34 341'4 .'((+,>(<' <')4+,>),164+'-+,>

2)*',1)4 -34 (<' 

3(+3,

 '-',1),(. .<)** <)/' *+=+('1)22'.. (3 *)+,(+--.I '2(+3, $

(4)1' .'24'(.()('=',(),15*)+,(+--.I '.53,.' 	3  (3 3:,('42*)+=),(. 5'2+)* ,('4

43>)(34+'.& +4.('(B*)+,(+--. 4)1' '24'(()('=',(D). -3**38.F *)+,(+--.I 4)1'

'24'(()('=',(.<)** ,3(*')/' 53..'..+3, 3- 1'-',1),(.I )((34,'7 '-',1),(.I 4'/+'8

.<)** 322:4 3,*7:,1'4 .:5'4/+.+3, 3- (<'+4 )((34,'7& )(<+. 3--+2'& ),11'-',1),(. .<)**

,3(6' 5'4=+(('1(3 ();' ,3('. 34 =);' 235+'. 3- *)+,(+--.I 4)1' '24'(()('=',(

  

)('1F LLLLLLLLLLLLL

 )>+.(4)(' :1>' 3.'5<5'43

Case 3:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 82 Filed 03/30/2006 Page 3 of 3

March 31, 2006

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORN

I

A

IT IS SO ORDERED

Judge Joseph C. Spero

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 84 Filed 03/31/06 Page 3 of 3