Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-3_14-cv-01417/USCOURTS-cand-3_14-cv-01417-8/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 190
Nature of Suit: Other Contract Actions
Cause of Action: 28:1441 Petition For Removal--Other Contract

---

!"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

61781957:;78<=0>?2@AB

CDEFD5EGHEFIJKLMHNDOFOKE5PGC 689Q0RR025S=A8Q87:?2@AB CFPTKNNK5UJVFTFEGMHNDOFOKE5PGC " #!$##WX# 2GJYTQGOK2YEKKYZ2JFYK RG[1VIKNK[Z9DNF\GEVFD] 3KNKOTGVK^ 55 _DP[FCFNK^ 55 1YYGEVK`[\GE;K\KVHDVYDVH9GJVYKE]9NDFCDVY :931<:AZ8A95 

)!"# !#"$&#&%$# )%$a!$)#"$&#%b#& b%$) #  )#b$ )&&%#"'%)#

9R8__R1@:cZd75ZDVFVHFeFHJDNZ

fNDFVYF\\Z e5 :931<:AZ8A95ZDgD[TFVIYGVZ;595 PGEOGEDYFGVZ ;K\KVHDVY5

9120A:5]Pe]]97@

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$## 9GCONDFVY_FNKH^ _KhEJDE`Z 3EFDN;DYK^ AGVK2KY

:931<:AZ8A95ZDgD[TFVIYGVZ;595 PGEOGEDYFGVZ 

9GJVYKE]9NDFCZ e5 9R8__R1@:cZd75ZDVFVHFeFHJDNZ 

9GJVYKE];K\KVHDVYZ 1VH 70R138i83c2f:732ZRR9ZD;KNDjDEK PGEOGEDYFGVZ 9GJVYKE];K\KVHDVY5

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 1 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

5 f=7f:2021A;R8683138:A2 ;F[PNG[JEKDVHHF[PGeKE`DPYFeFY`FVYTF[DPYFGVDEKNFUKN`YGFVeGNeKOEGHJPYFGVG\ PGV\FHKVYFDNZOEGOEFKYDE`ZGEOEFeDYKFV\GECDYFGV\GEjTFPT[OKPFDNOEGYKPYFGV\EGCOJhNFP HF[PNG[JEKDVH\EGCJ[K\GEDV`OJEOG[KGYTKEYTDVOEG[KPJYFVIYTF[NFYFIDYFGVCD`hKjDEEDVYKH5 1PPGEHFVIN`ZYTKODEYFK[TKEKh`[YFOJNDYKYGDVHOKYFYFGVYTKPGJEYYGKVYKEYTK\GNNGjFVI2YFOJNDYKH fEGYKPYFeK:EHKE53TKODEYFK[DPUVGjNKHIKYTDYYTF[:EHKEHGK[VGYPGV\KEhNDVUKYOEGYKPYFGV[GV DNNHF[PNG[JEK[GEEK[OGV[K[YGHF[PGeKE`DVHYTDYYTKOEGYKPYFGVFYD\\GEH[\EGCOJhNFPHF[PNG[JEK DVHJ[KKkYKVH[GVN`YGYTKNFCFYKHFV\GECDYFGVGEFYKC[YTDYDEKKVYFYNKHYGPGV\FHKVYFDNYEKDYCKVY JVHKEYTKDOONFPDhNKNKIDNOEFVPFONK[53TKODEYFK[\JEYTKEDPUVGjNKHIKZD[[KY\GEYTFV2KPYFGV 5ZhKNGjZYTDYYTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKEHGK[VGYKVYFYNKYTKCYG\FNKPGV\FHKVYFDN FV\GECDYFGVJVHKE[KDNl9FeFNRGPDN7JNK][KY[\GEYTYTKOEGPKHJEK[YTDYCJ[YhK\GNNGjKHDVH YTK[YDVHDEH[YTDYjFNNhKDOONFKHjTKVDODEY`[KKU[OKECF[[FGV\EGCYTKPGJEYYG\FNKCDYKEFDN JVHKE[KDN5 5 ;0_8A838:A2 5 9TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`^DfDEY`GEAGV]fDEY`YTDYPTDNNKVIK[YTKHK[FIVDYFGVG\ FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKC[JVHKEYTF[:EHKE5 5 m9:A_8;0A381Rn8V\GECDYFGVGE8YKC[^FV\GECDYFGV?EKIDEHNK[[G\TGjFYF[ IKVKEDYKHZ[YGEKHGECDFVYDFVKHBGEYDVIFhNKYTFVI[YTDYoJDNF\`\GEOEGYKPYFGVJVHKE_KHKEDN7JNK G\9FeFNfEGPKHJEK?PB5 5 mQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcn8V\GECDYFGVGE 8YKC[^KkYEKCKN`[KV[FYFeKm9:A_8;0A381R8V\GECDYFGVGE8YKC[ZnHF[PNG[JEKG\jTFPTYG DVGYTKEfDEY`GEAGV]fDEY`jGJNHPEKDYKD[Jh[YDVYFDNEF[UG\[KEFGJ[TDECYTDYPGJNHVGYhK DeGFHKHh`NK[[EK[YEFPYFeKCKDV[5 5 9GJV[KN?jFYTGJYoJDNF\FKEB^:JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEHDVHQGJ[K9GJV[KN?D[ jKNND[YTKFE[JOOGEY[YD\\B5 5 ;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`^DfDEY`GEAGV]fDEY`YTDYHK[FIVDYK[FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKC[YTDY FYOEGHJPK[FVHF[PNG[JEK[GEFVEK[OGV[K[YGHF[PGeKE`GEYTDYTD[hKKVGYTKEjF[KOEGHJPKHFV

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 2 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

HF[PGeKE`D[m9:A_8;0A381RZnGEmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02 :ARc5n5 ;F[PNG[JEKGE;F[PGeKE`6DYKEFDN^DNNFYKC[GEFV\GECDYFGVZEKIDEHNK[[G\YTK CKHFJCGECDVVKEFVjTFPTFYF[IKVKEDYKHZ[YGEKHZGECDFVYDFVKH?FVPNJHFVIZDCGVIGYTKEYTFVI[Z YK[YFCGV`ZYEDV[PEFOY[ZDVHYDVIFhNKYTFVI[BZYTDYDEKOEGHJPKHGEIKVKEDYKHFVHF[PNG[JEK[GE EK[OGV[K[YGHF[PGeKE`FVYTF[CDYYKE5 5 0kOKEY^DOKE[GVjFYT[OKPFDNFLKHUVGjNKHIKGEKkOKEFKVPKFVDCDYYKEOKEYFVKVYYG YTKNFYFIDYFGVjTGTD[hKKVEKYDFVKHh`DfDEY`GEFY[PGJV[KNYG[KEeKD[DVKkOKEYjFYVK[[GED[D PGV[JNYDVYFVYTF[DPYFGV5 5 QGJ[K9GJV[KN^DYYGEVK`[jTGDEKKCONG`KK[G\DODEY`YGYTF[DPYFGV5QGJ[K 9GJV[KNHGK[VGYFVPNJHK:JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEHGEDV`GYTKEGJY[FHKPGJV[KN5 5 AGV]fDEY`^DV`VDYJEDNOKE[GVZODEYVKE[TFOZPGEOGEDYFGVZD[[GPFDYFGVZGEGYTKENKIDN KVYFY`VGYVDCKHD[DfDEY`YGYTF[DPYFGV5 5 :JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEH^DYYGEVK`[jTGDEKVGYKCONG`KK[G\DODEY`YGYTF[ DPYFGVhJYDEKEKYDFVKHYGEKOEK[KVYGEDHeF[KDODEY`YGYTF[DPYFGVDVHTDeKDOOKDEKHFVYTF[DPYFGV

GVhKTDN\G\YTDYODEY`GEDEKD\\FNFDYKHjFYTDNDj\FECjTFPTTD[DOOKDEKHGVhKTDN\G\YTDYODEY`5 5 fDEY`^DV`ODEY`YGYTF[DPYFGVZFVPNJHFVIDNNG\FY[G\\FPKE[ZHFEKPYGE[ZKCONG`KK[Z PGV[JNYDVY[ZEKYDFVKHKkOKEY[ZDVH:JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEH?DVHYTKFE[JOOGEY[YD\\[B5 5 fEGHJPFVIfDEY`^DfDEY`GEAGV]fDEY`YTDYOEGHJPK[;F[PNG[JEKGE;F[PGeKE` 6DYKEFDNFVYTF[DPYFGV5 5 fEG\K[[FGVDNiKVHGE[^OKE[GV[GEKVYFYFK[YTDYOEGeFHKNFYFIDYFGV[JOOGEY[KEeFPK[ ?K5I5ZOTGYGPGO`FVIZeFHKGYDOFVIZYEDV[NDYFVIZOEKODEFVIKkTFhFY[GEHKCGV[YEDYFGV[ZDVHGEIDVFLFVIZ [YGEFVIZGEEKYEFKeFVIHDYDFVDV`\GECGECKHFJCBDVHYTKFEKCONG`KK[DVH[JhPGVYEDPYGE[5 5 fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN^DV`;F[PNG[JEKGE;F[PGeKE`6DYKEFDNYTDYF[HK[FIVDYKHD[ m9:A_8;0A381RZnGED[mQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARc5n 5 7KPKFeFVIfDEY`^DfDEY`YTDYEKPKFeK[;F[PNG[JEKGE;F[PGeKE`6DYKEFDN\EGCD fEGHJPFVIfDEY`5 

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 3 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

5 29:f0 3TKOEGYKPYFGV[PGV\KEEKHh`YTF[2YFOJNDYFGVDVH:EHKEPGeKEVGYGVN`fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN ?D[HK\FVKHDhGeKBZhJYDN[G?BDV`FV\GECDYFGVPGOFKHGEKkYEDPYKH\EGCfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNl ?BDNNPGOFK[ZKkPKEOY[Z[JCCDEFK[ZGEPGCOFNDYFGV[G\fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNlDVH?BDV`YK[YFCGV`Z PGVeKE[DYFGV[ZGEOEK[KVYDYFGV[h`fDEYFK[GEYTKFE9GJV[KNYTDYCFITYEKeKDNfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN5 QGjKeKEZYTKOEGYKPYFGV[PGV\KEEKHh`YTF[2YFOJNDYFGVDVH:EHKEHGVGYPGeKEYTK\GNNGjFVI FV\GECDYFGV^?DBDV`FV\GECDYFGVYTDYF[FVYTKOJhNFPHGCDFVDYYTKYFCKG\HF[PNG[JEKYGD 7KPKFeFVIfDEY`GEhKPGCK[ODEYG\YTKOJhNFPHGCDFVD\YKEFY[HF[PNG[JEKYGD7KPKFeFVIfDEY`D[ DEK[JNYG\OJhNFPDYFGVVGYFVeGNeFVIDeFGNDYFGVG\YTF[:EHKEZFVPNJHFVIhKPGCFVIODEYG\YTK OJhNFPEKPGEHYTEGJITYEFDNGEGYTKEjF[KlDVH?hBDV`FV\GECDYFGVUVGjVYGYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY` OEFGEYGYTKHF[PNG[JEKGEGhYDFVKHh`YTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`D\YKEYTKHF[PNG[JEK\EGCD[GJEPKjTG GhYDFVKHYTKFV\GECDYFGVNDj\JNN`DVHJVHKEVGGhNFIDYFGVG\PGV\FHKVYFDNFY`YGYTK;K[FIVDYFVI fDEY`51V`J[KG\fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNDYYEFDN[TDNNhKIGeKEVKHh`D[KODEDYKDIEKKCKVYGEGEHKE5 5 ;=7138:A 0eKVD\YKE\FVDNHF[OG[FYFGVG\YTF[NFYFIDYFGVZYTKPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`GhNFIDYFGV[FCOG[KHh` YTF[:EHKE[TDNNEKCDFVFVK\\KPYJVYFND;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`DIEKK[GYTKEjF[KFVjEFYFVIGEDPGJEY GEHKEGYTKEjF[KHFEKPY[5_FVDNHF[OG[FYFGV[TDNNhKHKKCKHYGhKYTKNDYKEG\?BHF[CF[[DNG\DNN PNDFC[DVHHK\KV[K[FVYTF[DPYFGVZjFYTGEjFYTGJYOEKrJHFPKlDVH?B\FVDNrJHICKVYTKEKFVD\YKE YTKPGCONKYFGVDVHKkTDJ[YFGVG\DNNDOOKDN[ZEKTKDEFVI[ZEKCDVH[ZYEFDN[ZGEEKeFKj[G\YTF[DPYFGVZ FVPNJHFVIYTKYFCKNFCFY[\GE\FNFVIDV`CGYFGV[GEDOONFPDYFGV[\GEKkYKV[FGVG\YFCKOJE[JDVYYG DOONFPDhNKNDj5 5 ;028<A138A<f7:30930;6130781R 5 0kKEPF[KG\7K[YEDFVYDVH9DEKFV;K[FIVDYFVI6DYKEFDN\GEfEGYKPYFGV50DPTfDEY` GEAGV]fDEY`YTDYHK[FIVDYK[FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKC[\GEOEGYKPYFGVJVHKEYTF[:EHKECJ[YYDUKPDEK YGNFCFYDV`[JPTHK[FIVDYFGVYG[OKPF\FPCDYKEFDNYTDYoJDNF\FK[JVHKEYTKDOOEGOEFDYK[YDVHDEH[5 5 6DVVKEDVH3FCFVIG\;K[FIVDYFGV[50kPKOYD[GYTKEjF[KOEGeFHKHFVYTF[:EHKE ?[KKZK5I5Z[KPGVHODEDIEDOTG\[KPYFGV5?DBhKNGjBZGED[GYTKEjF[K[YFOJNDYKHGEGEHKEKHZ ;F[PNG[JEKGE;F[PGeKE`6DYKEFDNYTDYoJDNF\FK[\GEOEGYKPYFGVJVHKEYTF[:EHKECJ[YhKPNKDEN`[G

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 4 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

HK[FIVDYKHhK\GEKYTKCDYKEFDNF[HF[PNG[KHGEOEGHJPKH5 ;K[FIVDYFGVFVPGV\GECFY`jFYTYTF[:EHKEEKoJFEK[^

?DB\GEFV\GECDYFGVFVHGPJCKVYDE`\GEC?K5I5ZODOKEGEKNKPYEGVFPHGPJCKVY[ZhJY KkPNJHFVIYEDV[PEFOY[G\HKOG[FYFGV[GEGYTKEOEKYEFDNGEYEFDNOEGPKKHFVI[BZYTDYYTKfEGHJPFVI fDEY`D\\FkYTKNKIKVHm9:A_8;0A381RnGEmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q 0c02:ARcnYGKDPTODIKYTDYPGVYDFV[OEGYKPYKHCDYKEFDN58\GVN`DOGEYFGVGEOGEYFGV[G\YTK CDYKEFDNGVDODIKoJDNF\FK[\GEOEGYKPYFGVZYTKfEGHJPFVIfDEY`DN[GCJ[YPNKDEN`FHKVYF\`YTK OEGYKPYKHOGEYFGV?[B?K5I5Zh`CDUFVIDOOEGOEFDYKCDEUFVI[FVYTKCDEIFV[B5 1fDEY`GEAGV]fDEY`YTDYCDUK[GEFIFVDNHGPJCKVY[GECDYKEFDN[DeDFNDhNK\GEFV[OKPYFGV VKKHVGYHK[FIVDYKYTKC\GEOEGYKPYFGVJVYFND\YKEYTKFV[OKPYFVIfDEY`TD[FVHFPDYKHjTFPT CDYKEFDNFYjGJNHNFUKPGOFKHDVHOEGHJPKH5;JEFVIYTKFV[OKPYFGVDVHhK\GEKYTKHK[FIVDYFGVZDNN G\YTKCDYKEFDNCDHKDeDFNDhNK\GEFV[OKPYFGV[TDNNhKHKKCKHmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp 133:7A0c2q0c02:ARc5n1\YKEYTKFV[OKPYFVIfDEY`TD[FHKVYF\FKHYTKHGPJCKVY[FYjDVY[ PGOFKHDVHOEGHJPKHZYTKfEGHJPFVIfDEY`CJ[YHKYKECFVKjTFPTHGPJCKVY[ZGEOGEYFGV[YTKEKG\Z oJDNF\`\GEOEGYKPYFGVJVHKEYTF[:EHKE53TKVZhK\GEKOEGHJPFVIYTK[OKPF\FKHHGPJCKVY[ZYTK fEGHJPFVIfDEY`CJ[YD\\FkYTKDOOEGOEFDYKNKIKVHm9:A_8;0A381RnGEmQ8<QRc 9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcnYGKDPTODIKYTDYPGVYDFV[fEGYKPYKH 6DYKEFDN58\GVN`DOGEYFGVGEOGEYFGV[G\YTKCDYKEFDNGVDODIKoJDNF\FK[\GEOEGYKPYFGVZYTK fEGHJPFVIfDEY`DN[GCJ[YPNKDEN`FHKVYF\`YTKOEGYKPYKHOGEYFGV?[B?K5I5Zh`CDUFVIDOOEGOEFDYK CDEUFVI[FVYTKCDEIFV[B5 ?hB\GEYK[YFCGV`IFeKVFVHKOG[FYFGVGEFVGYTKEOEKYEFDNGEYEFDNOEGPKKHFVI[ZYTDYYTK ;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`FHKVYF\`GVYTKEKPGEHZhK\GEKYTKPNG[KG\YTKHKOG[FYFGVZTKDEFVIZGEGYTKE OEGPKKHFVIZDNNOEGYKPYKHYK[YFCGV`DVH[OKPF\`YTKNKeKNG\OEGYKPYFGVhKFVID[[KEYKH5gTKVFYF[ FCOEDPYFPDNYGFHKVYF\`[KODEDYKN`KDPTOGEYFGVG\YK[YFCGV`YTDYF[KVYFYNKHYGOEGYKPYFGVDVHFYDOOKDE[YTDY [Jh[YDVYFDNOGEYFGV[G\YTKYK[YFCGV`CD`oJDNF\`\GEOEGYKPYFGVZYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`CD`FVeGUKGVYTK EKPGEH?hK\GEKYTKHKOG[FYFGVZTKDEFVIZGEGYTKEOEGPKKHFVIF[PGVPNJHKHBDEFITYYGTDeKJOYGHD`[YG FHKVYF\`YTK[OKPF\FPOGEYFGV[G\YTKYK[YFCGV`D[YGjTFPTOEGYKPYFGVF[[GJITYDVHYG[OKPF\`YTKNKeKNG\ OEGYKPYFGVhKFVID[[KEYKH5:VN`YTG[KOGEYFGV[G\YTKYK[YFCGV`YTDYDEKDOOEGOEFDYKN`HK[FIVDYKH\GE

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 5 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

OEGYKPYFGVjFYTFVYTKHD`[[TDNNhKPGeKEKHh`YTKOEGeF[FGV[G\YTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKE5

1NYKEVDYFeKN`ZD;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`CD`[OKPF\`ZDYYTKHKOG[FYFGVGEJOYGHD`[D\YKEjDEH[F\YTDYOKEFGH F[OEGOKEN`FVeGUKHZYTDYYTKKVYFEKYEDV[PEFOY[TDNNhKYEKDYKHD[m9:A_8;0A381RnGEmQ8<QRc 9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARc5n fDEYFK[[TDNNIFeKYTKGYTKEODEYFK[VGYFPKF\YTK`EKD[GVDhN`KkOKPYDHKOG[FYFGVZTKDEFVIGEGYTKE OEGPKKHFVIYGFVPNJHKfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN[GYTDYYTKGYTKEODEYFK[PDVKV[JEKYTDYGVN`DJYTGEFLKH FVHFeFHJDN[jTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1BDEKOEK[KVY DYYTG[KOEGPKKHFVI[5#3TKJ[KG\DHGPJCKVYD[DVKkTFhFYDYDHKOG[FYFGV[TDNNVGYFVDV`jD`D\\KPYFY[ HK[FIVDYFGVD[m9:A_8;0A381RnGEmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARc5n# 3EDV[PEFOY[PGVYDFVFVIfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN[TDNNTDeKDVGheFGJ[NKIKVHGVYTKYFYNKODIKYTDYYTK YEDV[PEFOYPGVYDFV[fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNZDVHYTKYFYNKODIK[TDNNhK\GNNGjKHh`DNF[YG\DNNODIK[?FVPNJHFVI NFVKVJChKE[D[DOOEGOEFDYKBYTDYTDeKhKKVHK[FIVDYKHD[fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNDVHYTKNKeKNG\OEGYKPYFGV hKFVID[[KEYKHh`YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`53TK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`[TDNNFV\GECYTKPGJEYEKOGEYKEG\YTK[K EKoJFEKCKVY[51V`YEDV[PEFOYYTDYF[OEKODEKHhK\GEKYTKKkOFEDYFGVG\D]HD`OKEFGH\GEHK[FIVDYFGV[TDNN hKYEKDYKHHJEFVIYTDYOKEFGHD[F\FYTDHhKKVHK[FIVDYKHmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q 0c02:ARcnFVFY[KVYFEKY`JVNK[[GYTKEjF[KDIEKKH51\YKEYTKKkOFEDYFGVG\YTDYOKEFGHZYTKYEDV[PEFOY [TDNNhKYEKDYKHGVN`D[DPYJDNN`HK[FIVDYKH5# ?PB\GEFV\GECDYFGVOEGHJPKHFV[GCK\GECGYTKEYTDVHGPJCKVYDE`DVH\GEDV`GYTKE YDVIFhNKFYKC[ZYTDYYTKfEGHJPFVIfDEY`D\\FkFVDOEGCFVKVYONDPKGVYTKKkYKEFGEG\YTKPGVYDFVKE GEPGVYDFVKE[FVjTFPTYTKFV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCF[[YGEKHYTKNKIKVHm9:A_8;0A381RnGE mQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARc5n8\GVN`DOGEYFGVGEOGEYFGV[G\ YTKFV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCjDEEDVYOEGYKPYFGVZYTKfEGHJPFVIfDEY`ZYGYTKKkYKVYOEDPYFPDhNKZ[TDNN FHKVYF\`YTKOEGYKPYKHOGEYFGV?[BDVH[OKPF\`YTKNKeKNG\OEGYKPYFGVhKFVID[[KEYKH5 5 8VDHeKEYKVY_DFNJEK[YG;K[FIVDYK58\YFCKN`PGEEKPYKHZDVFVDHeKEYKVY\DFNJEKYG HK[FIVDYKoJDNF\FKHFV\GECDYFGVGEFYKC[HGK[VGYZ[YDVHFVIDNGVKZjDFeKYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`q[ EFITYYG[KPJEKOEGYKPYFGVJVHKEYTF[:EHKE\GE[JPTCDYKEFDN5=OGVYFCKN`PGEEKPYFGVG\D HK[FIVDYFGVZYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CJ[YCDUKEKD[GVDhNKK\\GEY[YGD[[JEKYTDYYTKCDYKEFDNF[ YEKDYKHFVDPPGEHDVPKjFYTYTKOEGeF[FGV[G\YTF[:EHKE5

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 6 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

5 9Q1RR0A<8A<9:A_8;0A381R83c;028<A138:A2 5 3FCFVIG\9TDNNKVIK[51V`fDEY`GEAGV]fDEY`CD`PTDNNKVIKDHK[FIVDYFGVG\ PGV\FHKVYFDNFY`DYDV`YFCK5=VNK[[DOEGCOYPTDNNKVIKYGD;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`q[PGV\FHKVYFDNFY` HK[FIVDYFGVF[VKPK[[DE`YGDeGFH\GEK[KKDhNKZ[Jh[YDVYFDNJV\DFEVK[[ZJVVKPK[[DE`KPGVGCFP hJEHKV[ZGED[FIVF\FPDVYHF[EJOYFGVGEHKND`G\YTKNFYFIDYFGVZDfDEY`HGK[VGYjDFeKFY[EFITYYG PTDNNKVIKDPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`HK[FIVDYFGVh`KNKPYFVIVGYYGCGJVYDPTDNNKVIKOEGCOYN`D\YKEYTK GEFIFVDNHK[FIVDYFGVF[HF[PNG[KH5 5 6KKYDVH9GV\KE53TK9TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`[TDNNFVFYFDYKYTKHF[OJYKEK[GNJYFGV OEGPK[[h`OEGeFHFVIjEFYYKVVGYFPKG\KDPTHK[FIVDYFGVFYF[PTDNNKVIFVIDVHHK[PEFhFVIYTKhD[F[ \GEKDPTPTDNNKVIK53GDeGFHDChFIJFY`D[YGjTKYTKEDPTDNNKVIKTD[hKKVCDHKZYTKjEFYYKV VGYFPKCJ[YEKPFYKYTDYYTKPTDNNKVIKYGPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`F[hKFVICDHKFVDPPGEHDVPKjFYTYTF[ [OKPF\FPODEDIEDOTG\YTKfEGYKPYFeK:EHKE53TKODEYFK[[TDNNDYYKCOYYGEK[GNeKKDPTPTDNNKVIKFV IGGH\DFYTDVHCJ[YhKIFVYTKOEGPK[[h`PGV\KEEFVIHFEKPYN`?FVeGFPKYGeGFPKHFDNGIJKlGYTKE \GEC[G\PGCCJVFPDYFGVDEKVGY[J\\FPFKVYBjFYTFVHD`[G\YTKHDYKG\[KEeFPKG\VGYFPK58V PGV\KEEFVIZYTK9TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`CJ[YKkONDFVYTKhD[F[\GEFY[hKNFK\YTDYYTKPGV\FHKVYFDNFY` HK[FIVDYFGVjD[VGYOEGOKEDVHCJ[YIFeKYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`DVGOOGEYJVFY`YGEKeFKjYTK HK[FIVDYKHCDYKEFDNZYGEKPGV[FHKEYTKPFEPJC[YDVPK[ZDVHZF\VGPTDVIKFVHK[FIVDYFGVF[G\\KEKHZ YGKkONDFVYTKhD[F[\GEYTKPTG[KVHK[FIVDYFGV519TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`CD`OEGPKKHYGYTKVKkY [YDIKG\YTKPTDNNKVIKOEGPK[[GVN`F\FYTD[KVIDIKHFVYTF[CKKYDVHPGV\KEOEGPK[[\FE[YGE K[YDhNF[TK[YTDYYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`F[JVjFNNFVIYGODEYFPFODYKFVYTKCKKYDVHPGV\KEOEGPK[[FV DYFCKN`CDVVKE5 5 dJHFPFDN8VYKEeKVYFGV58\YTKfDEYFK[PDVVGYEK[GNeKDPTDNNKVIKjFYTGJYPGJEY FVYKEeKVYFGVZYTK9TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`[TDNN\FNKDVH[KEeKDCGYFGVPTDNNKVIFVIPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`JVHKE 9FeFNRGPDN7JNK?DVHFVPGCONFDVPKjFYT9FeFNRGPDN7JNK]ZF\DOONFPDhNKBjFYTFVHD`[ G\YTKFVFYFDNVGYFPKG\PTDNNKVIKGEjFYTFVHD`[G\YTKODEYFK[DIEKKFVIYTDYYTKCKKYDVHPGV\KE OEGPK[[jFNNVGYEK[GNeKYTKFEHF[OJYKZjTFPTKeKEF[KDENFKE50DPT[JPTCGYFGVCJ[YhK DPPGCODVFKHh`DPGCOKYKVYHKPNDEDYFGVD\\FECFVIYTDYYTKCGeDVYTD[PGCONFKHjFYTYTKCKKY DVHPGV\KEEKoJFEKCKVY[FCOG[KHFVYTKOEKPKHFVIODEDIEDOT5_DFNJEKh`YTK9TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`YG

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 7 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

CDUK[JPTDCGYFGVFVPNJHFVIYTKEKoJFEKHHKPNDEDYFGVjFYTFVHD`[?GEHD`[ZF\DOONFPDhNKB [TDNNDJYGCDYFPDNN`jDFeKYTKPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`PTDNNKVIK\GEKDPTPTDNNKVIKHHK[FIVDYFGV58V DHHFYFGVZYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`CD`\FNKDCGYFGV[JOOGEYFVIDPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`HK[FIVDYFGVDYDV` YFCKZFVPNJHFVIjFYTEKIDEHYGYTKHK[FIVDYFGVG\DHKOG[FYFGVYEDV[PEFOYGEDV`OGEYFGV[YTKEKG\5 1V`CGYFGVhEGJITYOJE[JDVYYGYTF[OEGeF[FGVCJ[YhKDPPGCODVFKHh`DPGCOKYKVYHKPNDEDYFGV D\\FECFVIYTDYYTKCGeDVYTD[PGCONFKHjFYTYTKCKKYDVHPGV\KEEKoJFEKCKVY[FCOG[KHh`YTK OEKPKHFVIODEDIEDOT5 3TKhJEHKVG\OKE[JD[FGVFVDV`[JPTPTDNNKVIKOEGPKKHFVI[TDNNhKGVYTK;K[FIVDYFVI fDEY`5_EFeGNGJ[PTDNNKVIK[ZDVHYTG[KCDHK\GEDVFCOEGOKEOJEOG[K?K5I5ZYGTDED[[GEFCOG[K JVVKPK[[DE`KkOKV[K[DVHhJEHKV[GVGYTKEODEYFK[BCD`KkOG[KYTK9TDNNKVIFVIfDEY`YG [DVPYFGV[5=VNK[[YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`TD[jDFeKHYTKPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`HK[FIVDYFGVFVjEFYFVIZDNN ODEYFK[[TDNNPGVYFVJKYGD\\GEHYTKCDYKEFDNFVoJK[YFGVYTKNKeKNG\OEGYKPYFGVYGjTFPTFYF[ KVYFYNKHJVHKEYTKfEGHJPFVIfDEY`q[HK[FIVDYFGVJVYFNYTKPGJEYEJNK[GVYTKPTDNNKVIK5 5 1990223:1A;=20:_f7:30930;6130781R 5 @D[FPfEFVPFONK[517KPKFeFVIfDEY`CD`J[KfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNYTDYF[HF[PNG[KHGE OEGHJPKHh`DVGYTKEfDEY`GEh`DAGV]fDEY`FVPGVVKPYFGVjFYTYTF[PD[KGVN`\GEOEG[KPJYFVIZ HK\KVHFVIZGEDYYKCOYFVIYG[KYYNKYTF[NFYFIDYFGV52JPTfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCD`hKHF[PNG[KHGVN`YG YTKPDYKIGEFK[G\OKE[GV[DVHJVHKEYTKPGVHFYFGV[HK[PEFhKHFVYTF[:EHKE5gTKVYTKNFYFIDYFGVTD[ hKKVYKECFVDYKHZD7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CJ[YPGCON`jFYTYTKOEGeF[FGV[G\[KPYFGVhKNGj?_8A1R ;82f:2838:AB5 fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCJ[YhK[YGEKHDVHCDFVYDFVKHh`D7KPKFeFVIfDEY`DYDNGPDYFGVDVH FVD[KPJEKCDVVKEYTDYKV[JEK[YTDYDPPK[[F[NFCFYKHYGYTKOKE[GV[DJYTGEFLKHJVHKEYTF[:EHKE5 5 ;F[PNG[JEKG\m9:A_8;0A381Rn8V\GECDYFGVGE8YKC[5=VNK[[GYTKEjF[KGEHKEKH h`YTKPGJEYGEOKECFYYKHFVjEFYFVIh`YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`ZD7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CD`HF[PNG[KDV` FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCHK[FIVDYKHm9:A_8;0A381RnGVN`YG^ ?DBYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`q[:JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEHFVYTF[DPYFGVZD[jKNND[KCONG`KK[ G\[DFH:JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEHYGjTGCFYF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`YGHF[PNG[KYTKFV\GECDYFGV

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 8 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

\GEYTF[NFYFIDYFGVDVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHnYTDY F[DYYDPTKHTKEKYGD[0kTFhFY1l ?hBYTKG\\FPKE[ZHFEKPYGE[ZDVHKCONG`KK[?FVPNJHFVIQGJ[K9GJV[KNBG\YTK7KPKFeFVI fDEY`YGjTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`\GEYTF[NFYFIDYFGVDVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTK m1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1Bl ?PB0kOKEY[?D[HK\FVKHFVYTF[:EHKEBG\YTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`YGjTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[ EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`\GEYTF[NFYFIDYFGVDVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH 1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1Bl ?HBYTKPGJEYDVHFY[OKE[GVVKNl ?KBPGJEYEKOGEYKE[DVHYTKFE[YD\\ZOEG\K[[FGVDNrJE`GEYEFDNPGV[JNYDVY[ZCGPUrJEGE[ZDVH fEG\K[[FGVDNiKVHGE[YGjTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`\GEYTF[NFYFIDYFGVDVHjTGTDeK [FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1Bl ?\BHJEFVIYTKFEHKOG[FYFGV[ZjFYVK[[K[FVYTKDPYFGVYGjTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[EKD[GVDhN` VKPK[[DE`DVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1BZ JVNK[[GYTKEjF[KDIEKKHh`YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`GEGEHKEKHh`YTKPGJEY5fDIK[G\YEDV[PEFhKH HKOG[FYFGVYK[YFCGV`GEKkTFhFY[YGHKOG[FYFGV[YTDYEKeKDNfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCJ[YhK[KODEDYKN` hGJVHh`YTKPGJEYEKOGEYKEDVHCD`VGYhKHF[PNG[KHYGDV`GVKKkPKOYD[OKECFYYKHJVHKEYTF[ 2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKE5 ?IBYTKDJYTGEGEEKPFOFKVYG\DHGPJCKVYPGVYDFVFVIYTKFV\GECDYFGVGEDPJ[YGHFDVGEGYTKE OKE[GVjTGGYTKEjF[KOG[[K[[KHGEUVKjYTKFV\GECDYFGV5 5 ;F[PNG[JEKG\mQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcn 8V\GECDYFGVGE8YKC[5=VNK[[GYTKEjF[KGEHKEKHh`YTKPGJEYGEOKECFYYKHFVjEFYFVIh`YTK ;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`ZD7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CD`HF[PNG[KDV`FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCHK[FIVDYKHmQ8<QRc 9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcnGVN`YG^ ?DBYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`q[:JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEHFVYTF[DPYFGVZD[jKNND[KCONG`KK[G\[DFH :JY[FHK9GJV[KNG\7KPGEHYGjTGCFYF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`YGHF[PNG[KYTKFV\GECDYFGV\GEYTF[ NFYFIDYFGVDVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHnYTDYF[DYYDPTKHTKEKYG D[0kTFhFY1l

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 9 of 17
	

 ]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

?hB0kOKEY[G\YTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`?BYGjTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`\GEYTF[ NFYFIDYFGVZ?BjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1BZDVH?B D[YGjTGCYTKOEGPKHJEK[[KY\GEYTFVODEDIEDOT5?DBZhKNGjZTDeKhKKV\GNNGjKHl ?PBYTKPGJEYDVHFY[OKE[GVVKNl ?HBPGJEYEKOGEYKE[DVHYTKFE[YD\\ZOEG\K[[FGVDNrJE`GEYEFDNPGV[JNYDVY[ZDVHfEG\K[[FGVDNiKVHGE[ YGjTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`\GEYTF[NFYFIDYFGVDVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVY

DVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1Bl ?KBjTKEKDIEKKHYGh`YTKODEYFK[FVDHeDVPKZHJEFVIYTKFEHKOG[FYFGV[ZjFYVK[[K[FVYTKDPYFGVYG jTGCHF[PNG[JEKF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`DVHjTGTDeK[FIVKHYTKm1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG @K@GJVHn?0kTFhFY1BZJVNK[[GYTKEjF[KDIEKKHh`YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`GEGEHKEKHh`YTKPGJEY5fDIK[G\ YEDV[PEFhKHHKOG[FYFGVYK[YFCGV`GEKkTFhFY[YGHKOG[FYFGV[YTDYEKeKDNfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCJ[YhK [KODEDYKN`hGJVHh`YTKPGJEYEKOGEYKEDVHCD`VGYhKHF[PNG[KHYGDV`GVKKkPKOYD[OKECFYYKHJVHKEYTF[ 2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKElDVH ?\BYTKDJYTGEGEEKPFOFKVYG\DHGPJCKVYPGVYDFVFVIYTKFV\GECDYFGVGEDPJ[YGHFDVGEGYTKEOKE[GV jTGGYTKEjF[KOG[[K[[KHGEUVKjYTKFV\GECDYFGV5 5 fEGPKHJEK[\GE1OOEGeFVIGE:hrKPYFVIYG;F[PNG[JEKG\mQ8<QRc 9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcn8V\GECDYFGVGE8YKC[YG0kOKEY[5 ?DB=VNK[[GYTKEjF[KGEHKEKHh`YTKPGJEYGEDIEKKHYGFVjEFYFVIh`YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`Z DfDEY`YTDY[KKU[YGHF[PNG[KYGDV0kOKEY?D[HK\FVKHFVYTF[:EHKEBDV`FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCYTDY TD[hKKVHK[FIVDYKHmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcnOJE[JDVYYG ODEDIEDOT5?PB\FE[YCJ[YCDUKDjEFYYKVEKoJK[YYGYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`YTDY?BFHKVYF\FK[YTK IKVKEDNPDYKIGEFK[G\mQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcnFV\GECDYFGV YTDYYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`[KKU[OKECF[[FGVYGHF[PNG[KYGYTK0kOKEYZ?B[KY[\GEYTYTK\JNNVDCKG\ YTK0kOKEYDVHYTKPFY`DVH[YDYKG\TF[GETKEOEFCDE`EK[FHKVPKZ?BDYYDPTK[DPGO`G\YTK 0kOKEYq[PJEEKVYEK[JCKZ?BFHKVYF\FK[YTK0kOKEYq[PJEEKVYKCONG`KE?[BZ?BFHKVYF\FK[KDPTOKE[GV GEKVYFY`\EGCjTGCYTK0kOKEYTD[EKPKFeKHPGCOKV[DYFGVGE\JVHFVI\GEjGEUFVTF[GETKEDEKD[

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 10 of 17
	

 ]]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

G\KkOKEYF[KGEYGjTGCYTKKkOKEYTD[OEGeFHKHOEG\K[[FGVDN[KEeFPK[ZFVPNJHFVIFVPGVVKPYFGV jFYTDNFYFIDYFGVZDYDV`YFCKHJEFVIYTKOEKPKHFVI\FeK`KDE[ZDVH?BFHKVYF\FK[?h`VDCKDVH VJChKEG\YTKPD[KZ\FNFVIHDYKZDVHNGPDYFGVG\PGJEYBDV`NFYFIDYFGVFVPGVVKPYFGVjFYTjTFPTYTK 0kOKEYTD[G\\KEKHKkOKEYYK[YFCGV`ZFVPNJHFVIYTEGJITDHKPNDEDYFGVZEKOGEYZGEYK[YFCGV`DYD HKOG[FYFGVGEYEFDNZHJEFVIYTKOEKPKHFVI\FeK`KDE[5 ?hB1fDEY`YTDYCDUK[DEKoJK[YDVHOEGeFHK[YTKFV\GECDYFGV[OKPF\FKHFVYTKOEKPKHFVI ODEDIEDOTCD`HF[PNG[KYTK[JhrKPYfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNYGYTKFHKVYF\FKH0kOKEYJVNK[[ZjFYTFV HD`[G\HKNFeKEFVIYTKEKoJK[YZYTKfDEY`EKPKFeK[DjEFYYKVGhrKPYFGV\EGCYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`5 1V`[JPTGhrKPYFGVCJ[Y[KY\GEYTFVHKYDFNYTKIEGJVH[GVjTFPTFYF[hD[KH5 ?PB1fDEY`YTDYEKPKFeK[DYFCKN`jEFYYKVGhrKPYFGVCJ[YCKKYDVHPGV\KEjFYTYTK ;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`?YTEGJITHFEKPYeGFPKYGeGFPKHFDNGIJKBYGYE`YGEK[GNeKYTKCDYYKEh` DIEKKCKVYjFYTFV[KeKVHD`[G\YTKjEFYYKVGhrKPYFGV58\VGDIEKKCKVYF[EKDPTKHZYTKfDEY` [KKUFVIYGCDUKYTKHF[PNG[JEKYGYTK0kOKEYCD`\FNKDCGYFGVD[OEGeFHKHFV9FeFNRGPDN7JNK ?DVHFVPGCONFDVPKjFYT9FeFNRGPDN7JNK]ZF\DOONFPDhNKB[KKUFVIOKECF[[FGV\EGCYTKPGJEY YGHG[G51V`[JPTCGYFGVCJ[YHK[PEFhKYTKPFEPJC[YDVPK[jFYT[OKPF\FPFY`Z[KY\GEYTFVHKYDFNYTK EKD[GV[jT`YTKHF[PNG[JEKYGYTK0kOKEYF[EKD[GVDhN`VKPK[[DE`ZD[[K[[YTKEF[UG\TDECYTDYYTK HF[PNG[JEKjGJNHKVYDFNZDVH[JIIK[YDV`DHHFYFGVDNCKDV[YTDYPGJNHhKJ[KHYGEKHJPKYTDYEF[U5 8VDHHFYFGVZDV`[JPTCGYFGVCJ[YhKDPPGCODVFKHh`DPGCOKYKVYHKPNDEDYFGVHK[PEFhFVIYTK ODEYFK[qK\\GEY[YGEK[GNeKYTKCDYYKEh`DIEKKCKVY?F5K5ZYTKKkYKVYDVHYTKPGVYKVYG\YTKCKKYDVH PGV\KEHF[PJ[[FGV[BDVH[KYYFVI\GEYTYTKEKD[GV[DHeDVPKHh`YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`\GEFY[EK\J[DN YGDOOEGeKYTKHF[PNG[JEK5 8VDV`[JPTOEGPKKHFVIZYTKfDEY`GOOG[FVIHF[PNG[JEKYGYTK0kOKEY[TDNNhKDEYTKhJEHKV G\OEGeFVIYTDYYTKEF[UG\TDECYTDYYTKHF[PNG[JEKjGJNHKVYDFN?JVHKEYTK[D\KIJDEH[OEGOG[KHB GJYjKFIT[YTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`q[VKKHYGHF[PNG[KYTKfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNYGYTK0kOKEY5  8\YTK0kOKEYhKNFKeK[DV`G\YTF[FV\GECDYFGVF[[JhrKPYYGDPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`GhNFIDYFGVYGDYTFEH] ODEY`ZYTKVYTK0kOKEY[TGJNHOEGeFHKjTDYKeKEFV\GECDYFGVYTK0kOKEYhKNFKeK[PDVhKHF[PNG[KH jFYTGJYeFGNDYFVIDV`PGV\FHKVYFDNFY`DIEKKCKVY[ZDVHYTKfDEY`[KKUFVIYGHF[PNG[KYGYTK0kOKEY [TDNNhKDeDFNDhNKYGCKKYDVHPGV\KEjFYTYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`EKIDEHFVIDV`[JPTKVIDIKCKVY5

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 11 of 17
	

 ]]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

5 f7:30930;6130781R2=@f:0A10;:7:7;070;f7:;=90;8A:3Q07 R838<138:A 8\DfDEY`F[[KEeKHjFYTD[JhOGKVDGEDPGJEYGEHKEF[[JKHFVGYTKENFYFIDYFGVYTDYPGCOKN[ HF[PNG[JEKG\DV`FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKC[HK[FIVDYKHFVYTF[DPYFGVD[m9:A_8;0A381RZnGE mQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcnYTDYfDEY`CJ[Y^ ?DBOEGCOYN`VGYF\`FVjEFYFVIYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`52JPTVGYF\FPDYFGV[TDNNFVPNJHKDPGO` G\YTK[JhOGKVDGEPGJEYGEHKEl ?hBOEGCOYN`VGYF\`FVjEFYFVIYTKODEY`jTGPDJ[KHYTK[JhOGKVDGEGEHKEYGF[[JKFVYTK GYTKENFYFIDYFGVYTDY[GCKGEDNNG\YTKCDYKEFDNPGeKEKHh`YTK[JhOGKVDGEGEHKEF[[JhrKPYYGYTF[ fEGYKPYFeK:EHKE52JPTVGYF\FPDYFGV[TDNNFVPNJHKDPGO`G\YTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKElDVH ?PBPGGOKEDYKjFYTEK[OKPYYGDNNEKD[GVDhNKOEGPKHJEK[[GJITYYGhKOJE[JKHh`YTK ;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`jTG[KfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCD`hKD\\KPYKH5 8\YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`YFCKN`[KKU[DOEGYKPYFeKGEHKEZYTKfDEY`[KEeKHjFYTYTK [JhOGKVDGEPGJEYGEHKE[TDNNVGYOEGHJPKDV`FV\GECDYFGVHK[FIVDYKHFVYTF[DPYFGVD[ m9:A_8;0A381RnGEmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q0c02:ARcnhK\GEKD HKYKECFVDYFGVh`YTKPGJEY\EGCjTFPTYTK[JhOGKVDGEGEHKEF[[JKHZJVNK[[YTKfDEY`TD[GhYDFVKH YTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`q[OKECF[[FGV53TK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`[TDNNhKDEYTKhJEHKVDVHKkOKV[KG\ [KKUFVIOEGYKPYFGVFVYTDYPGJEYG\FY[PGV\FHKVYFDNCDYKEFDNpDVHVGYTFVIFVYTK[KOEGeF[FGV[ [TGJNHhKPGV[YEJKHD[DJYTGEFLFVIGEKVPGJEDIFVID7KPKFeFVIfDEY`FVYTF[DPYFGVYGHF[GhK`D NDj\JNHFEKPYFeK\EGCDVGYTKEPGJEY5 5 1A:A]f173cq2f7:30930;6130781R2:=<Q33:@0f7:;=90;8A3Q82 R838<138:A ?DB3TKYKEC[G\YTF[:EHKEDEKDOONFPDhNKYGFV\GECDYFGVOEGHJPKHh`DAGV]fDEY`FVYTF[ DPYFGVDVHHK[FIVDYKHD[m9:A_8;0A381RnGEmQ8<QRc9:A_8;0A381Rp133:7A0c2q 0c02:ARc5n2JPTFV\GECDYFGVOEGHJPKHh`AGV]fDEYFK[FVPGVVKPYFGVjFYTYTF[NFYFIDYFGVF[ OEGYKPYKHh`YTKEKCKHFK[DVHEKNFK\OEGeFHKHh`YTF[:EHKE5AGYTFVIFVYTK[KOEGeF[FGV[[TGJNH hKPGV[YEJKHD[OEGTFhFYFVIDAGV]fDEY`\EGC[KKUFVIDHHFYFGVDNOEGYKPYFGV[5

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 12 of 17
	

 ]]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

?hB8VYTKKeKVYYTDYDfDEY`F[EKoJFEKHZh`DeDNFHHF[PGeKE`EKoJK[YZYGOEGHJPKDAGV] fDEY`q[PGV\FHKVYFDNFV\GECDYFGVFVFY[OG[[K[[FGVZDVHYTKfDEY`F[[JhrKPYYGDVDIEKKCKVYjFYT YTKAGV]fDEY`VGYYGOEGHJPKYTKAGV]fDEY`q[PGV\FHKVYFDNFV\GECDYFGVZYTKVYTKfDEY`[TDNN^ ?BOEGCOYN`VGYF\`FVjEFYFVIYTK7KoJK[YFVIfDEY`DVHYTKAGV]fDEY`YTDY[GCK GEDNNG\YTKFV\GECDYFGVEKoJK[YKHF[[JhrKPYYGDPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`DIEKKCKVYjFYTDAGV]fDEY`l ?BOEGCOYN`OEGeFHKYTKAGV]fDEY`jFYTDPGO`G\YTK2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKE FVYTF[NFYFIDYFGVZYTKEKNKeDVYHF[PGeKE`EKoJK[Y?[BZDVHDEKD[GVDhN`[OKPF\FPHK[PEFOYFGVG\YTK FV\GECDYFGVEKoJK[YKHlDVH ?BCDUKYTKFV\GECDYFGVEKoJK[YKHDeDFNDhNK\GEFV[OKPYFGVh`YTKAGV]fDEY`5 ?PB8\YTKAGV]fDEY`\DFN[YGGhrKPYGE[KKUDOEGYKPYFeKGEHKE\EGCYTF[PGJEYjFYTFV HD`[G\EKPKFeFVIYTKVGYFPKDVHDPPGCODV`FVIFV\GECDYFGVZYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CD`OEGHJPKYTK AGV]fDEY`q[PGV\FHKVYFDNFV\GECDYFGVEK[OGV[FeKYGYTKHF[PGeKE`EKoJK[Y58\YTKAGV]fDEY`YFCKN` [KKU[DOEGYKPYFeKGEHKEZYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`[TDNNVGYOEGHJPKDV`FV\GECDYFGVFVFY[OG[[K[[FGV GEPGVYEGNYTDYF[[JhrKPYYGYTKPGV\FHKVYFDNFY`DIEKKCKVYjFYTYTKAGV]fDEY`hK\GEKD HKYKECFVDYFGVh`YTKPGJEY51h[KVYDPGJEYGEHKEYGYTKPGVYEDE`ZYTKAGV]fDEY`[TDNNhKDEYTK hJEHKVDVHKkOKV[KG\[KKUFVIOEGYKPYFGVFVYTF[PGJEYG\FY[fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN5 5 =A1=3Q:78>0;;829R:2=70:_f7:30930;6130781R 8\D7KPKFeFVIfDEY`NKDEV[YTDYZh`FVDHeKEYKVPKGEGYTKEjF[KZFYTD[HF[PNG[KHfEGYKPYKH 6DYKEFDNYGDV`OKE[GVGEFVDV`PFEPJC[YDVPKVGYDJYTGEFLKHJVHKEYTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK :EHKEZYTK7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CJ[YFCCKHFDYKN`?DBVGYF\`FVjEFYFVIYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY`G\YTK JVDJYTGEFLKHHF[PNG[JEK[Z?hBJ[KFY[hK[YK\\GEY[YGEKYEFKeKDNNJVDJYTGEFLKHPGOFK[G\YTK fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNZ?PBFV\GECYTKOKE[GVGEOKE[GV[YGjTGCJVDJYTGEFLKHHF[PNG[JEK[jKEK CDHKG\DNNYTKYKEC[G\YTF[:EHKEZDVH?HBEKoJK[Y[JPTOKE[GVGEOKE[GV[YGKkKPJYKYTK m1PUVGjNKHICKVYDVH1IEKKCKVYYG@K@GJVHnYTDYF[DYYDPTKHTKEKYGD[0kTFhFY15 5 8A1;i0730A3f7:;=938:A:_f78i8R0<0;:7:3Q07g820f7:30930; 6130781R gTKVDfEGHJPFVIfDEY`IFeK[VGYFPKYG7KPKFeFVIfDEYFK[YTDYPKEYDFVFVDHeKEYKVYN` OEGHJPKHCDYKEFDNF[[JhrKPYYGDPNDFCG\OEFeFNKIKGEGYTKEOEGYKPYFGVZYTKGhNFIDYFGV[G\YTK

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 13 of 17
	

 ]]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

7KPKFeFVIfDEYFK[DEKYTG[K[KY\GEYTFV_KHKEDN7JNKG\9FeFNfEGPKHJEK?hB?B?@B53TF[ OEGeF[FGVF[VGYFVYKVHKHYGCGHF\`jTDYKeKEOEGPKHJEKCD`hKK[YDhNF[TKHFVDVK]HF[PGeKE` GEHKEYTDYOEGeFHK[\GEOEGHJPYFGVjFYTGJYOEFGEOEFeFNKIKEKeFKj5fJE[JDVYYG_KHKEDN7JNKG\ 0eFHKVPK?HBDVH?KBZFV[G\DED[YTKODEYFK[EKDPTDVDIEKKCKVYGVYTKK\\KPYG\HF[PNG[JEKG\D PGCCJVFPDYFGVGEFV\GECDYFGVPGeKEKHh`YTKDYYGEVK`]PNFKVYOEFeFNKIKGEjGEUOEGHJPY OEGYKPYFGVZYTKODEYFK[CD`FVPGEOGEDYKYTKFEDIEKKCKVYFVYTK[YFOJNDYKHOEGYKPYFeKGEHKE [JhCFYYKHYGYTKPGJEY5 5 68290RR1A0:=2 5 7FITYYG_JEYTKE7KNFK\5AGYTFVIFVYTF[:EHKEDhEFHIK[YTKEFITYG\DV`OKE[GVYG [KKUFY[CGHF\FPDYFGVh`YTKPGJEYFVYTK\JYJEK5 5 7FITYYG1[[KEY:YTKE:hrKPYFGV[5@`[YFOJNDYFVIYGYTKKVYE`G\YTF[fEGYKPYFeK :EHKEVGfDEY`jDFeK[DV`EFITYFYGYTKEjF[KjGJNHTDeKYGGhrKPYYGHF[PNG[FVIGEOEGHJPFVIDV` FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCGVDV`IEGJVHVGYDHHEK[[KHFVYTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKE52FCFNDEN`ZVG fDEY`jDFeK[DV`EFITYYGGhrKPYGVDV`IEGJVHYGJ[KFVKeFHKVPKG\DV`G\YTKCDYKEFDNPGeKEKH h`YTF[fEGYKPYFeK:EHKE5 5 _FNFVIfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN5gFYTGJYjEFYYKVOKECF[[FGV\EGCYTK;K[FIVDYFVIfDEY` GEDPGJEYGEHKE[KPJEKHD\YKEDOOEGOEFDYKVGYFPKYGDNNFVYKEK[YKHOKE[GV[ZDfDEY`CD`VGY\FNKFV YTKOJhNFPEKPGEHFVYTF[DPYFGVDV`fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDN51fDEY`YTDY[KKU[YG\FNKJVHKE[KDNDV` fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCJ[YPGCON`jFYT9FeFNRGPDN7JNK]5fEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNCD`GVN`hK\FNKH JVHKE[KDNOJE[JDVYYGDPGJEYGEHKEDJYTGEFLFVIYTK[KDNFVIG\YTK[OKPF\FPfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNDY F[[JK5fJE[JDVYYG9FeFNRGPDN7JNK]ZD[KDNFVIGEHKEjFNNF[[JKGVN`JOGVDEKoJK[Y K[YDhNF[TFVIYTDYYTKfEGYKPYKH6DYKEFDNDYF[[JKF[OEFeFNKIKHZOEGYKPYDhNKD[DYEDHK[KPEKYZGE GYTKEjF[KKVYFYNKHYGOEGYKPYFGVJVHKEYTKNDj58\D7KPKFeFVIfDEY`s[EKoJK[YYG\FNKfEGYKPYKH 6DYKEFDNJVHKE[KDNOJE[JDVYYG9FeFNRGPDN7JNK]?HBF[HKVFKHh`YTKPGJEYZYTKVYTK 7KPKFeFVIfDEY`CD`\FNKYTKFV\GECDYFGVFVYTKOJhNFPEKPGEHOJE[JDVYYG9FeFNRGPDN7JNK ]?KB?BJVNK[[GYTKEjF[KFV[YEJPYKHh`YTKPGJEY5

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 14 of 17
Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 15 of 17
	

 ]]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

$ )#%# %)t###%#%$"!$!"*# #

;130;^uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu  =VFYKH2YDYK[;F[YEFPYv6DIF[YEDYKdJHIK  

December 21, 2015 XXXXXXXXXXX

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 16 of 17
	

 ]]

 !"#$%!&'!#%$"!$##(#(###& !#)%*##+,(&'(-+,+.(&$/# 012345

0wQ8@831 19SA:gR0;<60A31A;1<70060A33:@0@:=A; 8ZuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuxOEFVYGEY`OK\JNNVDCKyZG\uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu xOEFVYGEY`OK\JNNDHHEK[[yZHKPNDEKJVHKEOKVDNY`G\OKErJE`YTDY8TDeKEKDHFVFY[KVYFEKY`DVH JVHKE[YDVHYTK2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKEYTDYjD[F[[JKHh`YTK=VFYKH2YDYK[;F[YEFPY9GJEY\GE YTKAGEYTKEV;F[YEFPYG\9DNF\GEVFDGVxHDYKyFVYTKPD[KG\z{|}}~~~~~5Z9D[K AG5]Pe]]97@58DIEKKYGPGCON`jFYTDVHYGhKhGJVHh`DNNYTKYKEC[G\YTF[2YFOJNDYKH fEGYKPYFeK:EHKEDVH8JVHKE[YDVHDVHDPUVGjNKHIKYTDY\DFNJEKYG[GPGCON`PGJNHKkOG[KCKYG [DVPYFGV[DVHOJVF[TCKVYFVYTKVDYJEKG\PGVYKCOY58[GNKCVN`OEGCF[KYTDY8jFNNVGYHF[PNG[KFV DV`CDVVKEDV`FV\GECDYFGVGEFYKCYTDYF[[JhrKPYYGYTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKEYGDV` OKE[GVGEKVYFY`KkPKOYFV[YEFPYPGCONFDVPKjFYTYTKOEGeF[FGV[G\YTF[:EHKE5 8\JEYTKEDIEKKYG[JhCFYYGYTKrJEF[HFPYFGVG\YTK=VFYKH2YDYK[;F[YEFPY9GJEY\GEYTK AGEYTKEV;F[YEFPYG\9DNF\GEVFD\GEYTKOJEOG[KG\KV\GEPFVIYTKYKEC[G\YTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK :EHKEZKeKVF\[JPTKV\GEPKCKVYOEGPKKHFVI[GPPJED\YKEYKECFVDYFGVG\YTF[DPYFGV5 8TKEKh`DOOGFVYuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuxOEFVYGEY`OK\JNNVDCKyG\ uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuxOEFVYGEY`OK\JNNDHHEK[[DVHYKNKOTGVKVJChKEy D[C`9DNF\GEVFDDIKVY\GE[KEeFPKG\OEGPK[[FVPGVVKPYFGVjFYTYTF[DPYFGVGEDV`OEGPKKHFVI[ EKNDYKHYGKV\GEPKCKVYG\YTF[2YFOJNDYKHfEGYKPYFeK:EHKE5 

;DYK^uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu 9FY`DVH2YDYKjTKEK[jGEVDVH[FIVKH^uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu 

fEFVYKHVDCK^uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu 

2FIVDYJEK^uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu 

Case 3:14-cv-01417-CRB Document 72 Filed 12/22/15 Page 17 of 17