Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-cand-4_05-cv-02275/USCOURTS-cand-4_05-cv-02275-9/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 890
Nature of Suit: Other Statutory Actions
Cause of Action: 28:1331 Fed. Question

---

!	

"# 	# $%&'#

'&()%(**+#

,+

--.# 	# &	$,&/&01231

2&%(1) $%&'

$*$)/&)%+

	1 

	

	 

	

	

	 

	

		
		

	

	
 
 	

	
 
.

 	 (+ $)%$2$/()%1 45&)/4$%6$$) 3'&()%(**+7018)%$2

/$*$)/&)%+ 
&%&&29# )0 &)/)%$2%$0:)1;(0+# )0 &)/%:(2/3&2%5/$*$)/&)%%$,$

&2&'&;4($6# 45&)/%:218<:%:$(2018)+$' -2$<125'&) 8%0:(91*()$2.&)9$'$,(%=

8)+:()$ >$<$)+%2$(*# 1) %:$ 1)$ :&)/# &)//$*$)/&)%+# 018)%$20'&(;&)%+ &)/

%:(2/3&2%53'&()%(**+ --5+%$;+# )0 &)/;)(321 )012312&%$/# &)//$*$)/&)%+

;)(;$?# "2&+(;(2-1+31/()1,# !&'$)%() -$12<($, &)/=,$%&) (91, @A/$*$)/&)%+AB#

45&)/%:218<:%:$(2018)+$' 
&,(/ '$?&)/$21*C!&6# 1) %:$ 1%:$2:&)/

:(+ %(38'&%(1) (+ ;&/$ () '($81*&;1%(1) 382+8&)%%1 (,(' 10&' 8'$+ 

 &)/ 6(%:2$*$2$)0$ %1 %:$ *1''16()< *&0%+D

-2$<125'&) 8%0:(9# +E @C	 B

	.	"!F# 		

>-	 

 2$;1)%%2$$%# %: '112

&) 2&)0(+01# &'(*12)(&

$'$3:1)$D 

 &0+(;('$D 

%%12)$5+ *12'&()%(**+718)%$2/$*$)/&)%+

&%&&29# )0 &)/)%$2%$0:)1;(0+# )0

&)/:(2/&2%5
$*$)/&)%%$,$ &2&'&;4($6

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 74 Filed 03/15/06 Page 1 of 3
	  	
 
	

	 

	  

 :$ 182%:&+ +$%&5#  &+ %:$ '&+%/&5*12%:$ 3&2%($+ %1 01;

3'$%$ 

 :$ 3&2%($+ :&,$ 0:1+$) ;$/(&%(1) &)/+$'$0%$/(0:&2/G$('# +E

&+ %:$ ;$/(&%12 32(12$?%$)+(1) 1*%:$ /&%$ %1 01;3'$%$ ;$/(&%(1) *21; $428&25#

 %1 &5#  6&+ <2&)%$/%1 &''16%:$ 3&2%($+ %1 01)/80%/(+01,$25

 :$ 3&2%($+ :&,$ 4$<8) /(+01,$25# :16$,$2+84+%&)%(&' /(+38%$+

:&,$ &'2$&/5&2(+$) 4$%6$$) %:$ 3&2%($+# ()0'8/()< 3'&()%(**+H&)//$*$)/&)%+H*&('82$ %1

2$+31)/%1 /(+01,$252$E8$+%+# %:$ &/$E8&051*3'&()%(**+H/$+(<)&%(1) 1*%2&/$ +$02$%+

382+8&)%%1 1/$ 1*(,(' 210$/82$ $0%(1)  &)/%:$ /$+(<)&%(1) 1*+&;$#

6:(0:&2$ 0822$)%'5/$+(<)&%$/A%%12)$5+H5$+ )'5A :$ 3&2%($+ $?3$0%;1%(1)+ %:&%

+$$92$+1'8%(1) 1*%:$+$ ;&%%$2+ %1 4$ *('$/+11) $)/()< 2$+1'8%(1) 1*%:$+$ ;1%(1)+#

%:$ /(+01,$252$<&2/()< %:$ 0'&(;+ %:&%%:$5(),1',$ 0&))1%3210$$/ )%(' 2$+1'8%(1) 1*

%:$ (++8$+ &)/%:$ &001;3&)5()< /(+01,$25(+ 01)/80%$/# ;$/(&%(1) &%%:(+ %(;$ 618'/

)1%4$ ;$&)()<*8' :$ 3&2%($+ 32131+$ %:&%;$/(&%(1) 4$ 01)/80%$/6(%:() %:(2%5@B

/&5+ 1*%:$ 01;3'$%(1) 1*)1)$?3$2%/(+01,$25@8'5# B# ($# 8<8+%# 

 :$ 3&2%($+ &2$ ;()/*8' %:&%(%(+ () %:$ 182%H+ /(+02$%(1) %1 $?%$)/

%:$ '&+%/&%$ 456:$) 
() %:(+ ;&%%$2;&54$ 01)/80%$/

	G#  # %:$ 3&2%($+ &<2$$ &+ *1''16+D

 :(+ %(38'&%(1) (+ $)%$2$/()%1 382+8&)%%1 
10&' 8'$ 

 :$ 3&2%($+ &<2$$ %:&%%:$ '&+%/&%$ *12;$/(&%(1) +:18'/4$ 2$+$%%1

8<8+%#  4$*12$ (0:&2/G$('# +E

 :$ 3&2%($+ 6('' +$%&)$6/&%$ *12;$/(&%(1) 6(%:%:$ ;$/(&%12&)/

&'' &++10(&%$//&%$+

 :$ 3&2%($+ &+9%:&%%:$ 182%$)%$2%:(+ +%(38'&%(1) &+ &) 12/$2# ,&

0&%()< %:$ 32(12/&%$ &)/+$%%()< &)$6/&%$ 1*8<8+%#  &+ 6:$) %:$ 3&2%($+ ;8+%

01;3'$%$ &24(%2&%(1)

777

777

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 74 Filed 03/15/06 Page 2 of 3
	  	
 
	

	 

	  

 :(+ %(38'&%(1) +:&'' 4$ *('$/6(%:%:$ 182%&)/%:$ 3&2%($+ &<2$$ %1

4$ 418)/45%:$ %$2;+ :$2$1*

	.	"!F		

>-	 

&%$/D&20:#  C5 +7-2$<125'&) 8%0:(9

-2$<125'&) 8%0:(9

%%12)$5+ *12'&()%(**+718)%$2/$*$)/&)%+

&%&&29# )0 &)/)%$2%$0:)1;(0+# )0 &)/

:(2/&2%5
$*$)/&)%%$,$ &2&'&;4($6

C!G 

&%$/D&20:#  C5 +7
&,(/ '$?&)/$2

&,(/ '$?&)/$2

%%12)$5+ *12
$*$)/&)%+ --5+%$;+# )0#

;)(;$?# ;)(321 )012312&%$/# !&'$)%()

-$12<($,# "2&+(;(2-1+31/()1, &)/=,$%&)

(91,

	

&,()< 2$&/%:$ *12$<1()< +%(38'&%(1) &)/<11/0&8+$ &33$&2()< %:$2$*12#

%:(+ 182%,&0&%$+ %:$ 32(1212/$2+$%%()< &5#  &+ %:$ '&+%/&%$ *12;$/(&%(1) %1

10082&)/12/$2+ %:&%;$/(&%(1) () %:(+ ;&%%$24$ 01;3'$%$/)1 '&%$2%:&) 8<8+%#

&%$/DIIIIIIIIIIIII

:$ 1)12&4'$ :5''(+  &;('%1)

3/15/06

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORN

I

A

IT IS SO ORDERED

Judge Phyllis J. Hamilton

Case 4:05-cv-02275-PJH Document 74 Filed 03/15/06 Page 3 of 3