Source: s3://data.kl3m.ai/documents/govinfo/USCOURTS/USCOURTS-caed-2_97-cv-00152/USCOURTS-caed-2_97-cv-00152-72/pdf.json

Nature of Suit Code: 535
Nature of Suit: Habeas Corpus - Death Penalty
Cause of Action: 28:2254 Ptn for Writ of H/C - Stay of Execution

---

Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

Ô

×“ Ãÿ¤ À“×Ã¤‹ ÕÃflÃ¤Õ ‹×ÕÃŒ×›Ã ›—ÀŒÃ

⁄—Œ Ãÿ¤ ¤flÕÃ¤Œ“ ‹×ÕÃŒ×›Ã —⁄ ›fl‘×⁄—Œ“×fl

‘fl“›¤ ×fl“ —Õfifl“‹Ù

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÙ “±Ú ›× ÕÛÁÈÛðÔÎÓ ...fiÕ ’÷”

TM­Ú ‹¤flÃÿ –¤“fl‘Ã« ›flÕ¤

Œ—fi¤ŒÃ ‘Ú fl«¤ŒÕÙ ÷ÆÚÙ

 ...øÆoa2 ±o Õø2 œ ́a2 ̈·2

 Õ ̈ø ̈a –Æ·­±2Ù

Œa­°±2oa2 ̈Ú —Œ‹¤Œ

 Ò

—2 ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÔËÙ ÓððË  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧aøÆo øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈ ±2  ̈ ̧a Ø ́a­ ̈·±2 ±o ­aø¥·21  ̈ ̧a

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈Ú Ã·TM±2 Õ1⁄2 ̧øÆo¥ ø°°aøÆao o±Æ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÚ Ã·3 fiÆ±­2ø2 °øÆ ̈·1⁄2·°ø ̈ao

 ̈a¥a° ̧±2·1⁄2ø¥¥ß o±Æ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÚ ...øÆo ›ø3°æa¥¥ ø2o Õ ̈a° ̧ø2·a ”· ̈1⁄2 ̧a¥¥ ø°°aøÆao o±Æ Æa­°±2oa2 ̈Ú

À°±2 ÆaTM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧a o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ·2 ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ ø2o ±°°±­· ̈·±2Ù  ́°±2  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈ ̧a øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈­ ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥

ø2o 1±±o 1⁄2ø ́­a ø°°aøÆ·21  ̈ ̧aÆao±ÆÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·2o­ ø2o ±ÆoaÆ­ ø­ o±¥¥±©­Ú

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 1 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 fia1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æa°±Æ ̈aÆ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 øÆÆ·TMao ¥ø ̈aÙ  ̈ ̧a 3±Æ2·21 ±o  ̈ ̧a Ô

o·Æ­ ̈ oøß ±o  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ©ø­ Æa1⁄2±Æoao æß  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ a¥a1⁄2 ̈Æ±2·1⁄2 ­± ́2o Æa1⁄2±Æo·21 ø2o

 ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·æao æß –a ̈Æ·¥¥ø Œa°±Æ ̈·21Ú Ã ̧·­  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ·­ ­a°øÆø ̈a oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2oaÆ

±o  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ù © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ©ø­ Æa1⁄2±Æoao ø2o  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·æao æß ‹·ø3±2o ›± ́Æ ̈ Œa°±Æ ̈aÆ­Ú

Ã ̧a  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2oaÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ·21 ­ ̈øÆ ̈­ ©· ̈ ̧ TM±¥ ́3a ×Ù °ø1a ÔÙ ø2o ·­ ·oa2 ̈·o·ao

 ̧aÆa·2 ø­ ç¤ÃÚå

Ó

Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ °Æ·±Æ ±ÆoaÆ­ ­a ̈ ± ́ ̈  ̈ ̧a æø1⁄2μ1Æ± ́2o o±Æ  ̈ ̧·­ ·­­ ́a ·2 3±Æa oa ̈ø·¥Ú

fiÆ·ao¥ßÙ  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a ÆaØ ́·Æ·21 Æa­±¥ ́ ̈·±2 øÆ±­a æao±Æa  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈øÆ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ú fl °Æ·±Æ

±ÆoaÆ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao oÆ±3 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 o·­1⁄2¥±­ ́Æa ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 oÆ±3  ̈Æ·ø¥ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ o·¥a­ °Æ±TM·oao æß

°a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̈± Æa­°±2oa2 ̈ o ́Æ·21 o·­1⁄2±TMaÆßÚ ‹ ́Æ·21 °Æa°øÆø ̈·±2 o±Æ  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ù  ̈ ̧a

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ­± ́1 ̧ ̈ ·2° ́ ̈ oÆ±3 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ øæ± ́ ̈ © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ø2ß ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ­ ̧± ́¥o æa °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ø2oÙ ·o ­±Ù  ̧±©Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ­°a1⁄2·o·1⁄2ø¥¥ß o± ́2o  ̈ ̧a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ ø°°¥·1⁄2øæ¥a

±2¥ß  ̈±  ̈ ̧a o·­1⁄2±TMaÆß °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ æ ́ ̈ Æa1⁄2±12·¶ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ­±3a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 o·­1⁄2¥±­ao o ́Æ·21  ̧aøÆ·21

3·1 ̧ ̈ ­ ̈·¥¥ ÆaØ ́·Æa 1⁄2±2o·oa2 ̈·ø¥· ̈ßÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 3øoa 1⁄2¥aøÆ ±2  ̈ ̧a o·Æ­ ̈ oøß ±o  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈ çø ̈

¥aø­ ̈ ø 2øÆÆ±© øÆaø ±o  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß ø2o aTM·oa21⁄2a Ú Ú Ú 1⁄2± ́¥o æa °Æ±°aÆ¥ß ­aø¥aoÙ ø2o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ©± ́¥o æa

aTM·oa21⁄2a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ©± ́¥o 1⁄2Æaø ̈a °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a ±2 ø2ß Æa ̈Æ·ø¥Úå ¤TM·oa2 ̈·øÆß ÿaøÆ·21 ÃÆø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ±o

–Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ±2  ̈ ̧a 3±Æ2·21 ±o fl°Æ·¥ ÓÌÙ ÓððÈ  ̄ÏÒÓÌÒðÈ flÚ”Ú ¤Ã ̃ ø ̈ ÓÊÔÔÛÔÍÚ flo ̈aÆ · ̈ æa1⁄2ø3a Ô

o·oo·1⁄2 ́¥ ̈  ̈± ·oa2 ̈·oß ·2 øoTMø21⁄2a ¶ ́­ ̈ © ̧ø ̈ 3·1 ̧ ̈ 2aao  ̈± æa ­aø¥aoÙ ø2o o ́a  ̈± ¥ø1⁄2μ ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ·2 ø ̈ ̈a2o·21  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ oa ̈aÆ3·2ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a 3±­ ̈ aoo·1⁄2·a2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ­a

©± ́¥o æa  ̈±  ̈a3°±ÆøÆ·¥ß ­aø¥  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a a2 ̈·Æa  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­  ̈Æ·ø¥ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ø2o

±o ø oaoa2­a ¶ ́Æß 1⁄2±2­ ́¥ ̈ø2 ̈Ù ø2o a®ø3·2a  ̈ ̧a ­aø¥·21 ·­­ ́a øo ̈aÆ  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ·21Ú ¤Ã ÓÍÊÔÓÛÔÌÂ fl°ÆÚ

ÓÏÙ ÓððÈ —ÆoaÆÚ flo ̈aÆ 2 ́3aÆ± ́­ °Æ±æ¥a3­ ø2o oa¥øß­ ·2  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æa°±Æ ̈aÆé­

 ̧aøÆ·21 2± ̈a­Ù  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a ­aø¥ao °±Æ ̈·±2 ©ø­ 1⁄2±3°¥a ̈ao ·2 —1⁄2 ̈±æaÆ ÓððÈÚ fl ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈·3aÙ

 ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·­­ ́ao ø  ̈a2 ̈ø ̈·TMa Æ ́¥·21 Æa· ̈aÆø ̈·21  ̈ ̧a ¥a1ø¥ æø­a­ o±Æ μaa°·21  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß

°Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ø­ ±°a2 ø­ °±­­·æ¥a © ̧·¥a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·21 °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø1ø·2­ ̈ °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a  ́°±2 ø2ß Æa ̈Æ·ø¥Ù

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 2 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ øÆ1 ́a­  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ TM·±¥ø ̈ao  ̧·­ o ́a °Æ±1⁄2a­­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈­ æß 3øμ·21 ø  ̈a2 ̈ø ̈·TMa Ó

Æ ́¥·21Ú Ã ̧a ±ÆoaÆ ·­ 1⁄2¥aøÆ  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a Æ ́¥·21 ·­  ̈a2 ̈ø ̈·TMa ±2¥ß ø2o aTMa2 °Æ±TM·oa­ ø æÆ·ao·21 ­1⁄2 ̧ao ́¥a

o±Æ  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­  ̈± 1⁄2 ̧ø¥¥a21a  ̈ ̧a Æ ́¥·21Ú —1⁄2 ̈Ú ÓÓÙ ÓððÈ —ÆoaÆ ø ̈ ÓÙ ÎÙ ø2o ÍÚ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­± 3øμa­

 ̈ ̧a 1⁄2 ́Æ·± ́­ øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ 2± Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ  ̈ ̧·­ ·­­ ́a æa1⁄2ø ́­aÙ øæ­a2 ̈ ø 1⁄2 ̧ø¥¥a21a

oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ±Æ  ̈ ̧a 3ao·øÙ  ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ 2± 1⁄2ø­a ±Æ 1⁄2±2 ̈Æ±TMaÆ­ßÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈ ±o 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Æ±±3

°Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ø2o  ̈ ̧a o±Æ3ø ̈ ±o ø2ß o·2ø¥ oa1⁄2·­·±2 øÆa ©a¥¥ ©· ̈ ̧·2  ̈ ̧a ° ́ÆTM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈éø ́ ̈ ̧±Æ· ̈ßÚ ... ̧ø ̈ °øÆ ̈­Ù ·o ø2ßÙ ±o  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ Æa3ø·2 ­aø¥ao ·­ ø 1⁄2Æ· ̈·1⁄2ø¥

oa1⁄2·­·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a¥ß °Æa1⁄2aoa­ ø2ß o·2ø¥ o·2o·21­ ø2o Æa1⁄2±33a2oø ̈·±2­ ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧·­

1⁄2ø­aÚ Ã ̧a ­ ́11a­ ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2ø22± ̈ ­ ́ø ­°±2 ̈a Æø·­a  ̈ ̧a­a °Æ±1⁄2ao ́Æø¥ 1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2­ ·­ 2± ̈ ©a¥¥

 ̈øμa2Ú Õaa ›· ̈·¶a2­ ⁄·Æ­ ̈ “ø ̈Ú fiø2μ ±o –Æ·21⁄2a ̈±2 TMÚ ›·21⁄2·22ø ̈· ×2­Ú ›±ÚÙ ÔÈË ⁄ÚÌo ÁÏÌÙ ÁÏÏ  ̄È ̈ ̧

›·ÆÚ ÔÁÁÁ ̃  ̄çÃ ̧a oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2 ±o 1±±o 1⁄2ø ́­a 1⁄2ø22± ̈ æa a¥·oao æß ø¥¥±©·21  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­  ̈± ­aø¥

© ̧ø ̈aTMaÆ  ̈ ̧aß ©ø2 ̈Ù o±Æ  ̈ ̧a2  ̈ ̧a ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ·2 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2· ̈ß ©·¥¥ 1±  ́2°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao  ́2¥a­­  ̈ ̧a 3ao·ø øÆa

·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ao ·2  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a ø2o 3±TMa  ̈±  ́2­aø¥Ú Ã ̧a ¶ ́o1a ·­  ̈ ̧a °Æ·3øÆß Æa°Æa­a2 ̈ø ̈·TMa ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ·2  ̈ ̧a ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2a­­ ø2o ·­ o ́ ̈ßÛæ± ́2o  ̈ ̧aÆao±Æa  ̈± ÆaTM·a© ø2ß ÆaØ ́a­ ̈  ̈± ­aø¥  ̈ ̧a

Æa1⁄2±Æo  ̄±Æ °øÆ ̈ ±o · ̈ ̃Ú Õaa flÆ ̈ ̧ ́Æ ŒÚ ”·¥¥aÆÙ ç›±2o·oa2 ̈·ø¥· ̈ßÙ –Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa —ÆoaÆ­Ù ø2o – ́æ¥·1⁄2

fl1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈­Ù ÔðÎ ÿøÆTMÚ ‘Ú ŒaTMÚ ÏÓÈÙ ÏÁÓ  ̄ÔÁÁÔ ̃Ú ÿa 3øß 2± ̈ Æ ́ææaÆ ­ ̈ø3° ø ­ ̈·° ́¥ø ̈·±2

 ̈± ­aø¥  ̈ ̧a Æa1⁄2±ÆoÚ ×2 Æa ’Æß2·1⁄2μ·Ù ÁËÌ ⁄ÚÓo ÈÏ  ̄È ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚÔÁÁÓ ̃  ̄1⁄2 ̧ø3æaÆ­ ±°·2·±2 ̃Úå ̃Ú

Ì

ø2o o·2o·21 · ̈ ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a  ̈±  ́2­aø¥  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a a®1⁄2a° ̈·±2 ±o ±2a

­a1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú —1⁄2 ̈Ú ÓÓÙ ÓððÈ —ÆoaÆÚ Ã ̧aÆaøo ̈aÆÙ  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­ ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao æÆ·ao­ ±2  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́aÚ Ó

fl“fl‘«Õ×Õ

Ã ̧a ·2· ̈·ø¥ ·­­ ́a æao±Æa  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·­ oa ̈aÆ3·2·21  ̧±© ­ ̈Æ±21  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ­ ̧± ́¥o æa ©· ̈ ̧ Æa­°a1⁄2 ̈  ̈± ø2 aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ·2 ø oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­

°Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ú Ã ̧·­ ø2ø¥ß­·­ 2a1⁄2a­­øÆ·¥ß 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ­ ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ o·2ø¥ oa1⁄2·­·±2 ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­

æa1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ oa1⁄2·­·±2 ©·¥¥ ø2ø¥ß¶a  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa21⁄2a ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao ø ̈  ̧aøÆ·21Ú Ã ̧a 2a® ̈ Ø ́a­ ̈·±2 ·­ © ̧a2

 ̈ ̧ø ̈ °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ 3øß æa ±TMaÆ1⁄2±3aÚ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø ̈ ̈a3° ̈­  ̈± ÆaÛoÆø3a  ̈ ̧a­a ·­­ ́a­ æß

oa­1⁄2Æ·æ·21  ̈ ̧a Ø ́a­ ̈·±2 ø­ ±2a ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao æß  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈

°Æ·TM·¥a1a ø2o ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú Ã ̧ø ̈ ·­ 2± ̈  ̈ ̧a Æa¥aTMø2 ̈ Ø ́a­ ̈·±2Ú ”±Æa±TMaÆÙ ø­ a®°¥ø·2ao

 ̈±  ̈ ̧a a® ̈a2 ̈ 2a1⁄2a­­øÆß æa¥±©Ù  ̈ ̧a ø ́ ̈ ̧±Æ· ̈ß °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ 1⁄2· ̈a­Ù © ̧a2 a®ø3·2aoÙ ±o ̈a2 o±a­ 2± ̈

­ ́°°±Æ ̈  ̧·­ øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈Ú

×2 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈·21  ̈ ̧a ÆaØ ́·Æao ø2ø¥ß­·­Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 3 ́­ ̈ ø­μ © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21­Ù ø2o 2a1⁄2a­­øÆ·¥ß o·2ø¥ oa1⁄2·­·±2­ ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­Ù øÆa  ̈Æøo· ̈·±2ø¥¥ß øoo±Æoao

­a1⁄2Æa1⁄2ßÚ flo ̈aÆ 3øμ·21  ̈ ̧·­  ̈ ̧Æa­ ̧±¥o oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2ø2 oa1⁄2·oa  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈ø2oøÆo æß © ̧·1⁄2 ̧

·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 °Æa­a2 ̈ao ø ̈  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 3øß æa ­aø¥aoÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̈ ̧a2 1⁄2ø2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ  ̈ ̧a

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 3 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

Ï

1·­ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ·­­ ́aÊ 3 ́­ ̈Ù ø­ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ øÆ1 ́a­Ù ø¥¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ø2o  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao

o ́Æ·21 ø2 aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ù © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2 a· ̈ ̧aÆ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao æß  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ

1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ±Æ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Ù æa ­aø¥aoÙ ±Æ ­ ̧± ́¥o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ a®ø3·2a  ̈ ̧a °± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥ o±Æ

°Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a ±o aø1⁄2 ̧ · ̈a3  ̈± oa ̈aÆ3·2a © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ­aø¥·21 ·­ ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a· flo ̈aÆ  ̈ ̧±Æ± ́1 ̧ ø2ø¥ß­·­ ±o

 ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø©Ù  ̈ ̧a °±¥·1⁄2ß Æaø­±2­ ­ ́°°±Æ ̈·21 æ± ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø2o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a­ ø2o

°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­ ø­­aÆ ̈ao æß °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÙ ø2o  ̈ ̧a 2ø ̈ ́Æa ±o  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ù  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈

1⁄2±21⁄2¥ ́oa­  ̈ ̧ø ̈Ù © ̧ø ̈aTMaÆ  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈ø2oøÆo  ́­ao  ̈± oa ̈aÆ3·2a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21­Ù

æao±Æa ø2ß ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ­ ́æ¶a1⁄2 ̈  ̈± ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ±Æ ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 °Æa­a2 ̈ao

o ́Æ·21 ø  ̧aøÆ·21 ±2 o·­°±­· ̈·TMa ·­­ ́a­ ·­ ­aø¥aoÙ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ­ ̧± ́¥o æa ÆaØ ́·Æao  ̈± oa3±2­ ̈Æø ̈a ø

°± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥ o±Æ °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a Æa­ ́¥ ̈·21 oÆ±3 o·­1⁄2¥±­ ́Æa ±o aø1⁄2 ̧ · ̈a3 ±o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̧a ­aaμ­  ̈± ­aø¥Ú

×Ú ‘a1ø¥ Õ ̈ø2oøÆo­ o±Æ Õaø¥·21 ¤TM·oa2 ̈·øÆß ÿaøÆ·21 ÃÆø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ø2o ¤® ̧·æ· ̈­

Ã ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ °Æ±TM·oa­ ø Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥  ̈Æ·ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ o±Æ

 ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø2o °Æa­­Ú çflæ­a2 ̈ ø2 ±TMaÆÆ·o·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈ao ·2 o·2o·21­Ù  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æ·ø¥ ±o ø 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥

1⁄2ø­a 3 ́­ ̈ æa ±°a2  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Úå Œ·1⁄2 ̧3±2o “a©­°ø°aÆ­Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ ·Æ1·2·øÙ ÏÏË ÀÚÕÚ ÎÎÎÙ ÎËÔ

 ̄ÔÁËð ̃  ̄°¥ ́Æø¥· ̈ß ±°Ú ̃Ú ... ̧·¥a  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ 2± ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ø¥­± ø°°¥·a­

 ̈± 1⁄2·TM·¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ù · ̈ ­ ̈Æ±21¥ß ­ ́11a­ ̈ao ø­ 3 ́1⁄2 ̧ ·2 Œ·1⁄2 ̧3±2o “a©­°ø°aÆ­Ú Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈é­

°¥ ́Æø¥· ̈ß ±°·2·±2 2± ̈ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a o·o 2± ̈ Æø·­a  ̈ ̧a Ø ́a­ ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2é­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± ø ̈ ̈a2o  ̈Æ·ø¥­

±o 1⁄2·TM·¥ 1⁄2ø­a­Ù çæ ́ ̈ ©a 2± ̈a  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̧·­ ̈±Æ·1⁄2ø¥¥ß æ± ̈ ̧ 1⁄2·TM·¥ ø2o 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­  ̧øTMa æaa2

°Æa­ ́3° ̈·TMa¥ß ±°a2Úå ×oÚ ø ̈ ÎËð 2ÚÔÈÚ ÷ ́­ ̈·1⁄2a Õ ̈a©øÆ ̈é­ 1⁄2±21⁄2 ́ÆÆa21⁄2a ·­ aTMa2 1⁄2¥aøÆaÆÊ ç ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈

ø2o ⁄± ́Æ ̈aa2 ̈ ̧ fl3a2o3a2 ̈­ 1⁄2¥aøÆ¥ß 1·TMa  ̈ ̧a °Æa­­ ø2o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈Æ·ø¥­

 ̈ ̧a3­a¥TMa­Ù 1⁄2·TM·¥ ø­ ©a¥¥ ø­ 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥Úå ×oÚ ø ̈ ÎÁÁÚ

⁄aoaÆø¥ ø°°a¥¥ø ̈a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ·21  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a  ̧øTMa  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈

Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø°°¥·1⁄2øæ¥a  ̈± o·­°±­· ̈·TMa 1⁄2·TM·¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ú Õaa Œ ́­ ̧o±Æo TMÚ “a© «±ÆμaÆ

”ø1ø¶·2aÙ ×21⁄2Ú Ù ËÏÍ ⁄ÚÓo ÓÏÁÙ ÓÎÌ  ̄Ï ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËË ̃  ̄ç...a æa¥·aTMa  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a 3±Æa Æ·1±Æ± ́­ ⁄·Æ­ ̈

fl3a2o3a2 ̈ ­ ̈ø2oøÆo ­ ̧± ́¥o ø¥­± ø°°¥ß  ̈± o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ o·¥ao ·2 1⁄2±22a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ©· ̈ ̧ ø ­ ́33øÆß

¶ ́o13a2 ̈ 3± ̈·±2 ·2 ø 1⁄2·TM·¥ 1⁄2ø­aÚå ̃Â ...a­ ̈3±Æa¥ø2o TMÚ ›±¥ ́3æ·ø fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21 Õß­ ̈a3Ù ×21⁄2ÚÙ ÈÎÓ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 4 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

Î

⁄ÚÓo ÔÍÙ ÓÌ  ̄Óo ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÏ ̃Â ”ø ̈ ̈aÆ ±o ›±2 ̈·2a2 ̈ø¥ ×¥¥·2±·­ Õa1⁄2 ́Æ· ̈·a­ ‘· ̈·1ø ̈·±2Ù ÈÌÓ ⁄ÚÓo ÔÌðÓÙ

ÔÌÔÌ  ̄È ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÏ ̃  ̄°Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø°°¥·a­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ·21­  ̧a¥o ø2o aTM·oa21⁄2a ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao

·2 1⁄2±22a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ©· ̈ ̧ 3± ̈·±2  ̈±  ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈a 1⁄2¥ø·3­ ̃Â – ́æ¥·1⁄2μaÆ ×2o ́­ ̈Æ·a­ TMÚ ›± ̧a2Ù ÈÌÌ ⁄ÚÓo ÔðÍÍÙ

ÔðÍËÛÈÔ  ̄Ìo ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÏ ̃  ̄⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø°°¥·a­  ̈± 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­Â ç ̈± ¥·3· ̈  ̈ ̧a

° ́æ¥·1⁄2é­ ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­  ̈ ̧aÆa 3 ́­ ̈ æa ø ­ ̧±©·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a oa2·ø¥ ­aÆTMa­ ø2 ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈

1±TMaÆ23a2 ̈ø¥ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ø2o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ 2± ¥a­­ Æa­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈·TMa ©øß  ̈± ­aÆTMa  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1±TMaÆ23a2 ̈ø¥

·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈Âå °øÆ ̈ß 3 ́­ ̈ ­ ̧±© 1±±o 1⁄2ø ́­a o±Æ ­aø¥·21 ±ÆoaÆ æø­ao ±2 ­°a1⁄2·o·1⁄2 ­ ̧±©·21 ±o ç1⁄2¥aøÆ¥ß

oao·2ao ø2o ­aÆ·± ́­ ·2¶ ́Æßå ̃Â fiÆ±©2  ̇ ...·¥¥·ø3­±2 Ã±æø1⁄21⁄2± ›±Æ°Ú TMÚ ⁄Ã›Ù ÈÔð ⁄ÚÓo ÔÔÍÎÙ ÔÔÈË

 ̄Í ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÌ ̃  ̄⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø°°¥·a­ çø­ ©a¥¥  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥Úå ̃Â ­aa ø¥­±

À2· ̈ao Õ ̈ø ̈a­ TMÚ fiøÆaÆÙ “±Ú ðÍÛ”›ÛÁðÓÔÛfiŒÙ ÓððÈ ...‘ ÏÏÎÎÌË  ̄‹Ú —ÆÚ ⁄aæÚ ÓÙ ÓððÈ ̃  ̄Æa¥ß·21 ±2

– ́æ¥·1⁄2μaÆ ø2o Õ·® ̈ ̧ ø2o ÕaTMa2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ 1⁄2ø­a­Ù 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ø°°¥·a­ ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±

1⁄2·TM·¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21 ̃Ú Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a “·2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧ø­ 2± ̈ Æ ́¥ao ±2  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́aÚ 

ÿø1a­ ̈øo TMÚ ÃÆø1a­­aÆÙ ÏÁ ⁄ÚÌo ÔÏÌðÙ ÔÏÌÏ 2ÚÍ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁÁÎ ̃  ̄ ̨“a· ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a Õ ́°Æa3a ›± ́Æ ̈ 2±Æ

 ̈ ̧·­ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧ø­ Æ ́¥ao ±2  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a Å±o © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ 1 ́øÆø2 ̈aa­  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­

 ̈± ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ã ·2  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±2 ̈a® ̈ ±o ø 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥ ±Æ Æa1⁄2±Æo­ ·2 1⁄2·TM·¥ 1⁄2ø­a­Ú ̨ ̃Ú

Ã ̧a °±¥·1⁄2ß 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­ ­ ́°°±Æ ̈·21 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ø°°¥ß  ̈± 1⁄2·TM·¥

°Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ø­ ©a¥¥Ú Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a Õ·® ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ a®°¥ø·2ao  ̈ ̧Æaa æø­a­ o±Æ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

 ̈Æ·ø¥­Ê

⁄·Æ­ ̈Ù ° ́æ¥·1⁄2  ̈Æ·ø¥­ °¥øß ø2 ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ Æ±¥a ø­ ± ́ ̈¥a ̈­ o±Æ ç1⁄2±33 ́2· ̈ß

1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2Ù  ̧±­ ̈·¥· ̈ßÙ ø2o a3± ̈·±2­Úå ... ̧a2 ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ oa1⁄2·­·±2­ øÆa

μ2±©2  ̈± æa ¶ ́­ ̈ ø2o © ̧a2  ̈ ̧a ¥a1ø¥ ­ß­ ̈a3 ·­ 3±TM·21  ̈± TM·2o·1⁄2ø ̈a

­±1⁄2·a ̈ø¥ ©Æ±21­Ù 3a3æaÆ­ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33 ́2· ̈ß øÆa ¥a­­ ¥·μa¥ß  ̈± ø1⁄2 ̈ ø­

­a¥oÛø°°±·2 ̈ao ¥ø© a2o±Æ1⁄2aÆ­ ±Æ TM·1·¥ø2 ̈a­Ú çÃ ̧a 1⁄2Æ ́1⁄2·ø¥

°Æ±° ̧ß¥ø1⁄2 ̈·1⁄2 ø­°a1⁄2 ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧a øo3·2·­ ̈Æø ̈·±2 ±o ¶ ́­ ̈·1⁄2a 1⁄2ø22± ̈

o ́21⁄2 ̈·±2 ·2  ̈ ̧a oøÆμÂ 2± 1⁄2±33 ́2· ̈ß 1⁄2ø ̈ ̧øÆ­·­ 1⁄2ø2 ±1⁄21⁄2 ́Æ ·o ¶ ́­ ̈·1⁄2a ·­

èo±2a ·2 ø 1⁄2±Æ2aÆ Å±ÆÃ ·2 ø2ß 1⁄2±TMaÆ ̈ 3ø22aÆÚéå

Õa1⁄2±2oÙ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ °Æ±TM·oa­ ø 1⁄2 ̧a1⁄2μ ±2 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­Ú Ú Ú Ú ...· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ù  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 1⁄2ø22± ̈ ø2ø¥ß¶a ø2o 1⁄2Æ· ̈·Ø ́a

 ̈ ̧a Æaø­±2·21 ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Ú Ã ̧a Æa3ao·a­ ±Æ °a2ø¥ ̈·a­ ·3°±­ao æß

 ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ©·¥¥ æa 3±Æa Æaøo·¥ß ø1⁄21⁄2a° ̈aoÙ ±Æ 1⁄2±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈ao ·o aÆÆ±2a± ́­Ù ·o

 ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2  ̧ø­ ø2 ±°°±Æ ̈ ́2· ̈ß  ̈± ÆaTM·a©  ̈ ̧a oø1⁄2 ̈­ °Æa­a2 ̈ao  ̈±  ̈ ̧a

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Ú

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 5 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

Í

⁄·2ø¥¥ßÙ Ú Ú Ú ±°a2  ̈Æ·ø¥­ °Æ±3± ̈a ç ̈Æ ́a ø2o ø1⁄21⁄2 ́Æø ̈a oø1⁄2 ̈ o·2o·21Úå

– ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ 1⁄2Æaø ̈a­ ø 1⁄2Æ· ̈·1⁄2ø¥ ø ́o·a21⁄2a ø2o  ̧a21⁄2a a21⁄2± ́Æø1a­

 ̈Æ ́ ̈ ̧o ́¥ a®°±­· ̈·±2 ±o oø1⁄2 ̈­Ù ø2 a­­a2 ̈·ø¥ o ́21⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o ø  ̈Æ·ø¥Ú

fiÆ±©2  ̇ ...·¥¥·ø3­±2Ù ÈÔð ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔÔÈË  ̄Ø ́± ̈·21 Œ·1⁄2 ̧3±2o “a©­°ø°aÆ­Ù ÏÏË ÀÚÕÚ ø ̈ ÎÈÔÙ ÎÁÍ ̃Ú 

Ã ̧a ¤¥aTMa2 ̈ ̧ ø2o ¤·1 ̧ ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ ›± ́Æ ̈­ ±o fl°°aø¥­ ø°°¥·ao  ̈ ̧a­a °±¥·1⁄2ß

1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­  ̈±  ̧±¥o  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø°°¥·ao  ̈± ç ̧ßæÆ·oå °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ä

1⁄2·TM·¥ 1⁄2ø­a­ ©· ̈ ̧ 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ 1⁄2 ̧øÆø1⁄2 ̈aÆ·­ ̈·1⁄2­Ù ø oa­1⁄2Æ·° ̈·±2 ø°°¥·1⁄2øæ¥a  ̈± ø  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21

ø­ ©a¥¥Ú ×2 “a©3ø2 TMÚ ŸÆøoo·1⁄2μÙ ÍÁÍ ⁄ÚÓo ÈÁÍ  ̄ÔÔ ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÌ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o± ́2o ø

⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ·2 ø 1⁄2·TM·¥ °Æ·­±2 ±TMaÆ1⁄2Æ±©o·21 1⁄2ø­aÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧a¥oÊ

⁄±1⁄2 ́­·21 ±2  ̈ ̧a æa2ao·1⁄2·ø¥ 1⁄2±2­aØ ́a21⁄2a­ ±o 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­ æa·21

1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈ao ·2 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Ù ©a ­aa ¥· ̈ ̈¥a o·ooaÆa21⁄2a æa ̈©aa2 ø 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥

 ̈Æ·ø¥ ø2o  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­  ̧aÆa © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ Æa¥ø ̈a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a Æa¥aø­a ±o

1⁄2±2TM·1⁄2 ̈ao °Æ·­±2aÆ­Ú Ã ̧·­ ¥· ̈·1ø ̈·±2 1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2·21 °a2ø¥

øo3·2·­ ̈Æø ̈·±2 ·2 fl¥øæø3ø ·­ ±o °øÆø3± ́2 ̈ ·3°±Æ ̈ø21⁄2a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a

1⁄2· ̈·¶a2­ ±o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ­ ̈ø ̈aÚ Ã ̧aß  ̧øTMa ø ¥a1· ̈·3ø ̈a ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ·2 ¥aøÆ2·21

© ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ·23ø ̈a­ øÆa æa·21 Æa¥aø­ao oÆ±3 °Æ·­±2 ø2o  ̈ ̧a Æaø­±2­ © ̧ßÚ

Ã ̧aß 3øß Æaø­±2øæ¥ß ©ø2 ̈  ̈± μ2±© © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ­ ̈ø ̈a ±oo·1⁄2·ø¥­ øÆa

Æa1⁄2±33a2o·21  ̈ ̧a Æa¥aø­a ±o ±2¥ß  ̈ ̧±­a © ̧± øÆa 3±­ ̈ oa­aÆTM·21 ±Æ

 ̈ ̧±­a © ̧±  ̧øTMa °±¥· ̈·1⁄2ø¥ ±Æ ± ̈ ̧aÆ ·2o¥ ́a2 ̈·ø¥ 1⁄2±22a1⁄2 ̈·±2­Ú Ã ̧a  ̈ß°a

±o °Æ·­±2aÆ æa·21 Æa¥aø­ao 3øß  ̧a¥°  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ·2 · ̈­ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2

±o © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈± °ÆaTMa2 ̈ ±TMaÆ1⁄2Æ±©o·21 æß ·21⁄2Æaø­·21  ̈ ̧a ­·¶a ±Æ

2 ́3æaÆ ±o °a2ø¥ oø1⁄2·¥· ̈·a­ ±Æ æß 3±o·oß·21 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ ¥ø©­Ú ×o · ̈ ·­

æa2ao·1⁄2·ø¥  ̈±  ̧øTMa ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ­1⁄2Æ ́ ̈·2ß ±o 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 3øß

Æa­ ́¥ ̈ ·2 1⁄2±2TM·1⁄2 ̈·±2 ø2o ° ́2·­ ̧3a2 ̈Ù  ̈ ̧a2 · ̈ ·­ ø¥­±  ̧a¥°o ́¥  ̈± ø¥¥±©

° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2·TM·¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 3±o·oß  ̈ ̧a aøÆ¥·aÆ  ̈Æ·ø¥­ æß

oÆaa·21 °Æ·­±2aÆ­ æao±Æa  ̈ ̧a·Æ ­a2 ̈a21⁄2a­ øÆa 1⁄2±3°¥a ̈ao ±Æ °øÆ±¥a  ̧øæaa2 1Æø2 ̈aoÚ

...a 2aao 2± ̈  ̧aÆa oa1⁄2·oa  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ±°a22a­­ ø°°¥·a­

 ̈± ø¥¥ 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­Ú fl¥¥ ©a oa1⁄2·oa ·­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­ © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ °aÆ ̈ø·2  ̈±

 ̈ ̧a Æa¥aø­a ±Æ ·21⁄2øÆ1⁄2aÆø ̈·±2 ±o °Æ·­±2aÆ ø2o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±2o· ̈·±2­ ±o  ̈ ̧a·Æ

1⁄2±2o·2a3a2 ̈ øÆa °Æa­ ́3° ̈·TMa¥ß ±°a2  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °Æa­­ ø2o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Ú

“a©3ø2Ù ÍÁÍ ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ËðÔÚ ×2 ×2 Æa ×±©ø ⁄Æaao±3 ±o ×2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ›± ́21⁄2·¥Ù ÈÓÏ ⁄ÚÓo ÍÎËÙ ÍÍÔ

 ̄Ë ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÌ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2±21⁄2¥ ́oao ç ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ a® ̈a2o­  ̈±

°Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ o±Æ 1⁄2±2 ̈a3° ̈Ù ø  ̧ßæÆ·o 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2·21 æ± ̈ ̧ 1⁄2·TM·¥ ø2o 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ 1⁄2 ̧øÆø1⁄2 ̈aÆ·­ ̈·1⁄2­Úå

Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·2o­ ø ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ­ ̧± ́¥o ø°°¥ß  ̈±  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß

 ̧aøÆ·21 ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥  ̧øæaø­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ú Ã ̧a  ̈ ̧Æaa °±¥·1⁄2ß 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­ ­a ̈ ± ́ ̈ ·2 fiÆ±©2  ̇

...·¥¥·ø3­±2 ø°°¥ß o ́¥¥ß  ̈±  ̈ ̧·­ μ·2o ±o °Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ú Ã ̧aÆa 1⁄2ø2 æa 2± Ø ́a­ ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ oaø ̈ ̧ °a2ø¥ ̈ß

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 6 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

È

1⁄2ø­a­ øÆa a2±Æ3± ́­¥ß ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Ú Ã ̧a ç1⁄2±33 ́2· ̈ß 1⁄2ø ̈ ̧øÆ­·­å 2a1⁄2a­­øÆß ·2 ø¥¥

1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ 1⁄2ø­a­ ·­  ̧a·1 ̧ ̈a2ao ·2 ø oaø ̈ ̧ °a2ø¥ ̈ß 1⁄2ø­a æß  ̈ ̧a ­aTMaÆ· ̈ß ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2Æ·3a ø2o ·3°±­· ̈·±2

ø2o ·3°¥a3a2 ̈ø ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a  ́¥ ̈·3ø ̈a °a2ø¥ ̈ßÚ Ã ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2ø ̈ ̧øÆ­·­ 1⁄2ø2 ±2¥ß ±1⁄21⁄2 ́Æ ·o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 1⁄2ø2

°øÆ ̈·1⁄2·°ø ̈a ·2  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2a­­Ù ø2o o ́¥¥ß  ́2oaÆ­ ̈ø2o ø2o ÆaTM·a©  ̈ ̧a æø­a­ o±Æ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ oa1⁄2·­·±2­Ú Ã ̧ø ̈

oa© 3a3æaÆ­ ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø ̈ ̈a2oao ø  ̧aøÆ·21 ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2ø­a ·­ ±o ¥· ̈ ̈¥a Æa¥aTMø21⁄2aÚ Õaø¥·21

­·12·o·1⁄2ø2 ̈ °±Æ ̈·±2­ ±o  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ©± ́¥o oa2ß ø2ß±2a ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ao ·2 ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 øæ± ́ ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a

 ̈ ̧a øæ·¥· ̈ß  ̈± ÆaTM·a© °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2¥ø·3­ ø2o  ̈ ̧a æø­a­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ oa1⁄2·­·±2Ú ›±3· ̈ß

1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­ øoo ø2± ̈ ̧aÆ ¥øßaÆ ±o ·2 ̈a2­a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈  ̈± ø 1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2ø­aÙ 1·TMa2  ̈ ̧a

oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ ÆaTM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧a ¥a1· ̈·3ø1⁄2ß ±o ø oa1⁄2·­·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈ø ̈aé­  ̧·1 ̧a­ ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Ú Ã ̧ø ̈ ÆaTM·a©

3 ́­ ̈ æa ø­  ̈Æø2­°øÆa2 ̈ ø­ °±­­·æ¥aÚ fl­ ø ­·­ ̈aÆ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ a®°Æa­­aoÊ

Ã ̧a Õ ́°Æa3a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±æ­aÆTMao ·2 –Æa­­Û¤2 ̈aÆ°Æ·­a ××Ù ÏÈË ÀÚÕÚ ø ̈ ÔÌÙ

ÔðÍ ÕÚ › ̈Ú ÓÈÌÎÙ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ›Æ·3·2ø¥ ø1⁄2 ̈­Ù a­°a1⁄2·ø¥¥ß 1⁄2aÆ ̈ø·2 TM·±¥a2 ̈

1⁄2Æ·3a­Ù °Æ±TM±μa ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2Ù ± ́ ̈Æø1aÙ ø2o  ̧±­ ̈·¥· ̈ßÚ ⁄ ́Æ ̈ ̧aÆÙ

­·21⁄2a  ̈ ̧aÆa øÆa ­ ̈Æ±21 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­ 2± ̈ ±2¥ß ·2  ̈ ̧a °Æ±3° ̈

a®a1⁄2 ́ ̈·±2 ±o ­ ̈ø ̈a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ ¶ ́o13a2 ̈­Ù æ ́ ̈ ø¥­± ·2  ̈ ̧a

ø­­ ́Æø21⁄2a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ­ ̈ø ̈a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ ¶ ́o13a2 ̈­ øÆa 1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥Ù

 ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ ø 1⁄2±ÆÆa­°±2o·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ·2  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ̆­ ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±Ù ø2o

 ́2oaÆ­ ̈ø2o·21 ±oÙ aTMaÆß ­ ̈ø1a ±o  ̈ ̧a ø°°aø¥­ °Æ±1⁄2a­­  ̈± © ̧·1⁄2 ̧

1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥ oaoa2oø2 ̈­ øÆa a2 ̈· ̈¥ao ·2 ±ÆoaÆ  ̈±  ̈a­ ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥· ̈ß

±o  ̈ ̧a·Æ oaø ̈ ̧ ­a2 ̈a21⁄2a­Ú ›±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­ ±o 1⁄2±3· ̈ß ø2o oaoaÆø¥·­3

­ ́11a­ ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ̆­ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ·2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±Ù ø2o ø2  ́2oaÆ­ ̈ø2o·21

±oÙ  ̈ ̧a ø°°aø¥­ °Æ±1⁄2a­­ ·­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 3 ́1⁄2 ̧ 3±Æa ­·12·o·1⁄2ø2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ Æa­°a1⁄2 ̈

 ̈±  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ù © ̧aÆa  ̈ ̧a ¥a1· ̈·3ø1⁄2ß ±o ­ ̈ø ̈a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈

1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ 1⁄2±2TM·1⁄2 ̈·±2­ øÆa 1⁄2 ̧ø¥¥a21ao ·2 oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­Ú

fl­ ̧©±Æ ̈ ̧ TMÚ fiø1¥aßÙ ÌÎÔ ⁄Ú Õ ́°°Ú Óo ÈËÍÙ ÈÁð  ̄ÕÚ‹Ú — ̧·± ÓððÎ ̃  ̄a3° ̧ø­a­ ·2 ±Æ·1·2ø¥ ̃Ú Ã ̧a

­a1⁄2±2o  ̈©± °±¥·1⁄2ß 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­ øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈ao ·2 fiÆ±©2  ̇ ...·¥¥·ø3­±2 ø°°¥ß ø­ ©a¥¥ ÛÛ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ °aÆ3· ̈­ ø2  ́2oaÆ­ ̈ø2o·21 ±o 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ °Æ±1⁄2a­­a­ ø2oÙ ·o 2a1⁄2a­­øÆßÙ ø 1⁄2 ̧a1⁄2μ ±2  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­Ú × ̈

ø¥­± °Æ±3± ̈a­  ̈Æ ́ ̈ ̧o ́¥2a­­ ø2o ·2 ̈a1Æ· ̈ßÙ ø 1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2 ·2  ̈ ̧·­ ø2o aTMaÆß °Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ú

¤TMa2 ·o  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ ·­ ·2ø°°¥·1⁄2øæ¥aÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© °Æ±TM·oa­ ø Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ú çÃ ̧a a®·­ ̈a21⁄2a ±o ø 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ø2o  ̈± ·2­°a1⁄2 ̈

¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ Æa1⁄2±Æo­ ·­ æaß±2o o·­° ́ ̈aÚå – ́æ¥·1⁄2μaÆÙ ÈÌÌ ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔðÍÍÚ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø­μ­  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̈±  ́­a

ø2 ça®°aÆ·a21⁄2a ø2o ¥±1·1⁄2å  ̈a­ ̈  ̈± oa ̈aÆ3·2a © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© °Æ±TM·oa­ ø Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ú

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 7 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2ø­a ©ø­ ±2a ±o  ̈ ̧a o·Æ­ ̈ ·2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ ±ÆoaÆao °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ Ì

o·­1⁄2±TMaÆao oÆ±3  ̈Æ·ø¥ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ o·¥a­Ú Õaa —­æø2o TMÚ ...±±oo±ÆoÙ ÓÁð ⁄ÚÌo ÔðÌÍ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÓ ̃Ú 

Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­  ́° ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2ao ́Æa ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2ø­a ø2o ¥ø ̈aÆ ·2 fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆ TMÚ ...±±oo±ÆoÙ ÌÌÔ

⁄ÚÌo ÈÔÎ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÌ ̃Ú

Ë

¤®°aÆ·a21⁄2a ·­ çè© ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a °¥ø1⁄2a ø2o °Æ±1⁄2a­­  ̧øTMa  ̧·­ ̈±Æ·1⁄2ø¥¥ß æaa2 ±°a2  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °Æa­­ ø2o

1a2aÆø¥ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Úéå – ̧±a2·® “a©­°ø°aÆ­Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ À2· ̈ao Õ ̈ø ̈a­ ‹·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ ›± ́Æ ̈Ù ÔÎÍ ⁄ÚÌo ÁÏðÙ ÁÏÍ

 ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁÁË ̃  ̄Ø ́± ̈·21 –Æa­­Û¤2 ̈aÆ°Æ·­a ›±Ú TMÚ Õ ́°aÆ·±Æ ›± ́Æ ̈Ù ÏÈË ÀÚÕÚ ÔÙ Í  ̄ÔÁËÍ ̃ ̃Ú ‘±1·1⁄2 ·­ 

çè© ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ °¥øß­ ø ­·12·o·1⁄2ø2 ̈ °±­· ̈·TMa Æ±¥a ·2  ̈ ̧a o ́21⁄2 ̈·±2·21 ±o  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥øÆ

°Æ±1⁄2a­­ ·2 Ø ́a­ ̈·±2Úéå ×oÚ Ã ̧a ¥ø ̈ ̈aÆ ç¥±1·1⁄2å  ̈a­ ̈ ·­ aø­·¥ß 3a ̈ æß  ̈ ̧a °±¥·1⁄2ß 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2­

o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao øæ±TMaÚ fl ÆaTM·a© ±o 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø© ­ ̧±©­  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ça®°aÆ·a21⁄2aå  ̧ø­ æaa2 ±2a ±o ±°a2Ù ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a­ ·2TM±¥TMao ·2 ø 1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥  ̧øæaø­ °a ̈· ̈·±2Ú

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ °±·2 ̈­  ̈± 2± 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø© oa3±2­ ̈Æø ̈·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈ a· ̈ ̧aÆ aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21­ ±Æ

o·­°±­· ̈·TMa oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2­ ·2 ø oaoaÆø¥  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·3°¥·1⁄2ø ̈a­ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈

ø2o ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a­  ̧øTMa æaa2 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈ao ·2 ­a1⁄2Æa1⁄2ßÚ Œø ̈ ̧aÆÙ ç©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a a®1⁄2a° ̈·±2 ±o

°Æ±°±­ao æ ́o1a ̈­ ø2o 3± ̈·±2­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a  ́­a ±o o ́2o­  ̈± a3°¥±ß a®°aÆ ̈­ o·¥ao ·2 1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥

 ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ·2TM±¥TM·21 ·2o·1a2 ̈ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ­Ù  ̈ ̧·­ ›± ́Æ ̈ μ2±©­ ±o 2±  ̈Æøo· ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈

 ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ øÆa 1⁄2¥±­ao ø2o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ o·¥ao ·2 ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ øÆa ­aø¥aoÚå

fl­ ̧©±Æ ̈ ̧Ù ÌÎÔ ⁄Ú Õ ́°°Ú Óo ø ̈ ÈÁðÚ Ã ̧a ±2a Ø ́ø¥·o·1⁄2ø ̈·±2  ̈±  ̈ ̧·­ ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈ ·­  ̈ ̧a oø·Æ¥ß Æa1⁄2a2 ̈  ́­a

±o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ­ o ́Æ·21 o·­1⁄2±TMaÆßÚ ÿ±©aTMaÆÙ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̧ø­ 2± ̈ ­ ̧±©2  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a­a o·­1⁄2±TMaÆß Ì

°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ­  ̧øTMa °Æ±TM·oao  ̈ ̧a æø­·­ o±Æ ­aø¥·21 o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao ©· ̈ ̧ o·­°±­· ̈·TMa

3± ̈·±2­ ±Æ aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß ø2o a® ̧·æ· ̈­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a ° ́Æ°±­a ±o oa1⁄2·o·21 °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­

1⁄2¥ø·3­Ù ±Æ  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧aß  ̧øTMa æaa2 ø°°¥·ao  ̈± ­ ̧·a¥o oÆ±3 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 TM·a© ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ́°±2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ø

oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æa¥·a­ ·2 oa ̈aÆ3·2·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø ­ ̈ø ̈a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ oa1⁄2·­·±2Ù ·2 © ̧±¥a ±Æ ·2 °øÆ ̈Ù ç©ø­ 1⁄2±2 ̈ÆøÆß

 ̈±Ù ±Æ ·2TM±¥TMao ø2  ́2Æaø­±2øæ¥a ø°°¥·1⁄2ø ̈·±2 ±oÙ 1⁄2¥aøÆ¥ß a­ ̈øæ¥·­ ̧ao ⁄aoaÆø¥ ¥ø©å ±Æ ç©ø­ æø­ao ±2

ø2  ́2Æaø­±2øæ¥a oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a oø1⁄2 ̈­å  ́2oaÆ ÓË ÀÚÕÚ›Ú y ÓÓÎÏ ̄o ̃Ú

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 8 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

Á

×2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ·21  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ù · ̈ ·­ ©±Æ ̈ ̧

2± ̈·21 ­±3a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ o·Æ­ ̈ ¥±±μ  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ©a·1 ̧ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2Ê

... ̧a2  ̈ ̧aÆa øÆa ±æ¶a1⁄2 ̈·±2­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a o·­1⁄2¥±­ ́Æa ±o ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Ù

o·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ 3 ́­ ̈ oa ̈aÆ3·2a  ̈ ̧a ©a·1 ̧ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ·2

oøTM±Æ ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ æß aTMø¥ ́ø ̈·21  ̈ ̧a Æ±¥a ±o  ̈ ̧a 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥ ø ̈ ·­­ ́a

·2  ̈ ̧a a®aÆ1⁄2·­a ±o flÆ ̈·1⁄2¥a ××× ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ °±©aÆ ø2o  ̈ ̧a Æa­ ́¥ ̈ø2 ̈ TMø¥ ́a

±o ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̈±  ̈ ̧±­a 3±2· ̈±Æ·21  ̈ ̧a oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­Ú

Ÿa2aÆø¥¥ßÙ  ̈ ̧a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ©·¥¥ oø¥¥ ­±3a© ̧aÆa ±2 ø 1⁄2±2 ̈·2 ́ ́3

oÆ±3 3ø ̈ ̈aÆ­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ o·Æa1⁄2 ̈¥ß øooa1⁄2 ̈ ø2 øo¶ ́o·1⁄2ø ̈·±2  ̈± 3ø ̈ ̈aÆ­  ̈ ̧ø ̈

1⁄2±3a ©· ̈ ̧·2 ø 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ̆­ ° ́ÆTM·a© ­±¥a¥ß  ̈± ·2­ ́Æa  ̈ ̧a·Æ ·ÆÆa¥aTMø21⁄2aÚ

Ã ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ·­ 1·TMa2 1Æaø ̈ ©a·1 ̧ ̈ © ̧aÆa  ̈ ̧a ÆaØ ́a­ ̈ao

o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ©aÆa ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao ø ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥ ±Æ ©aÆa ± ̈ ̧aÆ©·­a 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥  ̈± ø

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ̆­ o·­°±­· ̈·±2 ±o ø 1⁄2ø­a ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­Ú ×2 aø1⁄2 ̧ ±o  ̈ ̧a­a 1⁄2ø­a­Ù

 ̈ ̧a ­ ̈Æ±21 ©a·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± æa ø1⁄21⁄2±Æoao  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±

¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ©ø­ ¥øÆ1a¥ß oaÆ·TMao oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a Æ±¥a  ̈ ̧±­a

o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ °¥øßao ·2 oa ̈aÆ3·2·21 ¥· ̈·1ø2 ̈­ ̆ ­ ́æ­ ̈ø2 ̈·TMa Æ·1 ̧ ̈­Û

1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈ ø ̈  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ ̈ ±o flÆ ̈·1⁄2¥a ×××Ûø2o oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a 2aao o±Æ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

3±2· ̈±Æ·21 ±o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈Ú

ÚÚÚ

flo ̈aÆ  ̈ ̧a ©a·1 ̧ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ·­ a­ ̈øæ¥·­ ̧aoÙ o·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­

3 ́­ ̈  ̈ ̧a2 æø¥ø21⁄2a 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 oø1⁄2 ̈±Æ­Ù ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ø­ ¥ø© a2o±Æ1⁄2a3a2 ̈

1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2­Ù ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ aoo·1⁄2·a21⁄2ßÙ ø2o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TMø1⁄2ß ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧a

°øÆ ̈·a­Ù ø1ø·2­ ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2Ú Ã ̧a  ̈ø­μ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ ·­  ̈± ©a·1 ̧

 ̈ ̧a ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­ øoTMø21⁄2ao æß  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­ ·2 ¥·1 ̧ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈

ø2o  ̈ ̧a o ́ ̈ß ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­Ú

‹·TMaÆ­·o·ao ŸÆ± ́°Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ ‹ø ́1aÆoø­Ù ÓÔÈ ⁄ÚŒÚ‹Ú ÔÎÓÙ ÔÎËÛÎÁ  ̄ÕÚ‹Ú“Ú«Ú ÓððÌ ̃  ̄1⁄2· ̈ø ̈·±2­

±3· ̈ ̈ao ̃Ú À2oaÆ ø ©a·1 ̧·21  ̈a­ ̈ ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ø­  ̈ ̧·­Ù ø¥¥ aTM·oa21⁄2a ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß

 ̧aøÆ·21Ù ¥·μa ø  ̈Æ·ø¥Ù ­ ̧± ́¥o æa a2 ̈· ̈¥ao  ̈± ø  ̧aøTMß °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ú Õaa ×2 Æa flo±æa

Õß­ ̈a3­Ù ×21⁄2Ú Õa1⁄2 ́Æ· ̈·a­ ‘· ̈·1ø ̈·±2Ù ÔÏÔ ⁄ÚŒÚ‹Ú ÔÎÎÙ ÔÎË  ̄“Ú‹Ú ›ø¥Ú ÔÁÁÓ ̃  ̄çÃ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ·­ ­ ̈Æ±21a­ ̈ Æa1øÆo·21 o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ±ooaÆao ·2 aTM·oa21⁄2a ø ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥Ù aTMa2 ·o  ̈ ̧a o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ øÆa 2± ̈

øo3· ̈ ̈aoÚå ̃Ú

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ Æa¥·a­  ́°±2 1⁄2ø­a­ ·2TM±¥TM·21 °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ TMaÆß o·ooaÆa2 ̈ oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ù ø2o o·2ø¥ 3aÆ· ̈­ oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2Ù ø ̈ ·­­ ́a  ̧aÆaÚ ”±­ ̈ 1⁄2ø­a­ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ 1⁄2· ̈a­

·2TM±¥TMa  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± °øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥øÆ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Ú Ã ̧a­a 1⁄2ø­a­ 3·1 ̧ ̈  ̧øTMa Æa¥aTMø21⁄2a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a

·­­ ́a ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± a® ̧·æ· ̈­ ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ú ÿ±©aTMaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈±

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ o·¥ao ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·ooaÆ­ oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 9 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

Ôð

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 · ̈­a¥oÚ Õaa ø¥¥aß fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21 ›±Ú TMÚ À2· ̈ao Õ ̈ø ̈a­ ‹·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ ›± ́Æ ̈Ù ÈÁË ⁄ÚÓo

ÔÓËÁÙ ÔÓÁÌ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÍ ̃Ú Ã ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ·­ ±o ̈a2 1⁄2 ̧øÆø1⁄2 ̈aÆ·¶ao ø­ ø 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈

 ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·­ øTMø·¥øæ¥a ±2¥ß o±Æ ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Úå ×oÚÂ ‘ ́1±­1⁄2 ̧ TMÚ –ßÆø3·o ›±Ú ±o —2±2oø1øÙ ÏÌÎ

⁄ÚÌo ÔÔðÙ ÔÔÁ  ̄Óo ›·ÆÚ ÓððÍ ̃Ú Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a Õa1⁄2±2o ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­

øÆa ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥å ·o  ̈ ̧aß øÆa çÆa¥aTMø2 ̈  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °aÆo±Æ3ø21⁄2a ±o  ̈ ̧a ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o ́21⁄2 ̈·±2 ø2o  ́­ao ́¥ ·2  ̈ ̧a

¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2a­­Úå ×oÚ ×2  ̈ ̧a “·2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈Ù o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao ø ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥ ±Æ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ øÆa 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥  ̈±

 ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ o·­°±­· ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­ øÆa ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥Úå Õø2 ÷±­a ”aÆ1⁄2 ́Æß “a©­Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ À2· ̈ao Õ ̈ø ̈a­

‹·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ ›± ́Æ ̈Ù ÔËÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÔðÁÍÙ ÔÔðÓ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁÁÁ ̃  ̄ ̈ ̧a oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ a® ̈a2o­  ̈± 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥­ ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao ·2 1⁄2±22a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ©· ̈ ̧ 3± ̈·±2­ o±Æ ­ ́33øÆß ¶ ́o13a2 ̈ ·2 1⁄2·TM·¥

1⁄2ø­a­ °Æ·±Æ  ̈± ¶ ́o13a2 ̈ ̃Ú fl¥¥ a® ̧·æ· ̈­ ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 3ø ̈ ̈aÆ øÆa

 ̈ ̧ ́­ ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥Úå

—2a ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈­ ·­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ øÆa ±2¥ß  ̈ ̧±­a 2a1⁄2a­­øÆß

 ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ o·2ø¥ oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2 ø2o  ̈ ̧aÆao±Æa · ̈ ·­ °Æa3ø ̈ ́Æa  ̈± 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ © ̧ø ̈ ­ ̧± ́¥o ø2o

­ ̧± ́¥o 2± ̈ æa 3øoa ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø©Ù  ̧±©aTMaÆÙ ·oa2 ̈·o·a­ æ± ̈ ̧ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao o ́Æ·21

ø  ̧aøÆ·21 ø­ ©a¥¥ ø­  ̈ ̧±­a 2a1⁄2a­­øÆß  ̈± ø 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ oa1⁄2·­·±2 ø­ ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥Úå flo±° ̈·±2 ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­

2øÆÆ±© 1⁄2±2­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­å ©± ́¥o oaoaø ̈ ±2a ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·3øÆß ° ́Æ°±­a­ ±o  ̈ ̧a

° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ o±1⁄2 ̈Æ·2aÚ ...· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈ μ2±©·21 ø¥¥  ̈ ̧a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 øTMø·¥øæ¥a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Ù  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

©± ́¥o 2± ̈ æa øæ¥a  ̈± ø2ø¥ß¶a ø2o 1⁄2Æ· ̈·Ø ́a  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ Æaø­±2·21Ú Õaa fiÆ±©2  ̇ ...·¥¥·ø3­±2Ù ÈÔð

⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔÔÈËÂ ×2 Æa flo±æa Õß­ ̈a3­Ù ×21⁄2Ù ÔÏÔ ⁄ÚŒÚ‹Ú ø ̈ ÔÎË  ̄ç­ ̈Æ±21å °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ o±Æ

o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ o·¥ao ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Â ç­ ̈Æ±21aÆå °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 o±Æ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­  ́°±2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æa¥·a­ ·2

3øμ·21 o·­°±­· ̈·TMa oa1⁄2·­·±2Â ç­ ̈Æ±21a­ ̈å °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 o±Æ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ±ooaÆao ·2 aTM·oa21⁄2a ø ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥ ̃Ú

¤TMa2 © ̧a2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ·21 °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2· ̈ø ̈·±2­ ±2¥ß ©· ̈ ̧ Æa­°a1⁄2 ̈  ̈± ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±

·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2ao ·2 aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 a® ̧·æ· ̈­Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2· ̈ø ̈·±2­ øÆa 2± ̈  ̧a¥°o ́¥ æa1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧aß

·2TM±¥TMa  ́2·Ø ́a ­· ̈ ́ø ̈·±2­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ o·ooaÆ ­·12·o·1⁄2ø2 ̈¥ß oÆ±3  ̈ ̧±­a ·2TM±¥TM·21 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± a®ø3·2a  ̈Æ·ø¥

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 10 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 ⁄±Æ ° ́Æ°±­a­ ±o  ̈ ̧·­ ±ÆoaÆé­ a®ø3·2ø ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± a® ̧·æ· ̈­Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ ·2 3·2o ø Ï

­1⁄2a2øÆ·± ±o ­·3°¥a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ÆaTM·a© ø2o 1⁄2±°ß a® ̧·æ· ̈­Ú ×o 3±Æa 1⁄2±3°¥a® ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ·­­ ́aøÆ·­a ¥ø ̈aÆÙ  ̈ ̧aß ©·¥¥ æa øooÆa­­ao ø ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈·3aÚ

 –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­± 1⁄2· ̈a­  ̈ ̧a oa1⁄2·­·±2 ·2 ›Æ±©a TMÚ ›± ́2 ̈ß ±o Õø2 ‹·a1±Ù ÓÔð ⁄Ú Õ ́°°Ú Óo Î

ÔÔËÁ  ̄ÕÚ‹Ú ›ø¥Ú ÓððÓ ̃Ù © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ·­ ·2ø°°±­· ̈aÚ Ã ̧aÆaÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆao ø 2a©­ 3ao·ø 3± ̈·±2  ̈±

 ́2­aø¥  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈­ ±o 3aa ̈·21­ ·2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ø ¶ ́o1a Ø ́a­ ̈·±2ao ¥ø© a2o±Æ1⁄2a3a2 ̈  ̈± oa ̈aÆ3·2a © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ

ø 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ ·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈·±2 ©ø­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21 ©· ̈ ̧ Æaø­±2øæ¥a o·¥·1a21⁄2aÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o± ́2o 2± Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a­a  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ç ̈± © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ o± ́2o 2± °øÆø¥¥a¥Úå ÓÔð ⁄Ú Õ ́°°Ú Óo

ø ̈ ÔÔÁÓÚ Ã ̧a ©a·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø2ß Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a a® °øÆ ̈a 1⁄2±2TMaÆ­ø ̈·±2­ ·2 ›Æ±©a æaøÆ­ 2±

Æa¥ø ̈·±2­ ̧·°  ̈± 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ø2 aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­ ±o ø

1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2ø­aÚ

ÔÔ

a® ̧·æ· ̈­Ú ⁄±Æ a®ø3°¥aÙ ·2 “·®±2 TMÚ ...øÆ2aÆ ›±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­Ù ×21⁄2ÚÙ ÏÌÎ ÀÚÕÚ ÎËÁ  ̄ÔÁÈË ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a Ï

›± ́Æ ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 2a· ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ Æa1⁄2±Æo­ 2±Æ  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈

fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­ 1øTMa  ̈ ̧a °Æa­­  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± ±æ ̈ø·2 ø2o 1⁄2±°ß  ̈ø°a

Æa1⁄2±Æo·21­ ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao o ́Æ·21 ø 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥  ̈Æ·ø¥Ú Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ Æa¥·aoÙ ·2 °øÆ ̈Ù ±2  ̈ ̧a a®·­ ̈a21⁄2a ±o

ø¥ ̈aÆ2ø ̈a 3aø2­ ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧±­a  ̈ø°a­Ú ×2 øoo· ̈·±2Ù  ̈ ̧a °Æa­­ ©ø­ °aÆ3· ̈ ̈ao  ̈± ¥·­ ̈a2  ̈±

 ̈ ̧a  ̈ø°a­ ø2o ©ø­ 1·TMa2  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧a3Ú ÏÌÎ ÀÚÕÚ ø ̈ ÍðÁÚ ×2 Ã·3a­ ”·ÆÆ±Æ ›±ÚÙ ËÈÌ ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈

ÔÓÔËÙ  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o± ́2o 2± Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ­aøÆ1⁄2 ̧ ©øÆÆø2 ̈­ ø2o ­ ́°°±Æ ̈·21 øoo·oøTM· ̈­

Æa¥ø ̈·21  ̈± ø2 ±21±·21 ·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈·±2 ±Æ  ̈± 1Æø2o ¶ ́Æß °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ æa1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧a­a °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­

 ̈Æøo· ̈·±2ø¥¥ß øÆa ­a1⁄2Æa ̈Ú Ã ̧aÆa ©ø­ 2±  ̧·­ ̈±Æß ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø2o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o± ́2o 2± ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

2aao ¶ ́­ ̈·oß·21 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ú ×2 ø¥¥aß fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21 ›±ÚÙ ÈÁË ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔÓÁÌÛÁÈÙ  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­

1⁄2±2­·oaÆao  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± 1⁄2±°ß ø ́o·± ø2o TM·oa±  ̈ø°a a® ̧·æ· ̈­ ø­  ̈ ̧aß ©aÆa Æa1⁄2a·TMao ·2 aTM·oa21⁄2aÚ

Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o± ́2o ø 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a­a ç¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­å ø2o  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧a °Æa­­

 ̧øo ø Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± ±æ ̈ø·2 ø2o 1⁄2±°ß  ̈ ̧a3Ú ×2 À2· ̈ao Õ ̈ø ̈a­ TMÚ ›±Ææ· ̈ ̈Ù ËÈÁ ⁄ÚÓo ÓÓÏÙ ÓÓÁ  ̄È ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ

ÔÁËÁ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ a®ø3·2ao ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± °ÆaÛ­a2 ̈a21⁄2a Æa°±Æ ̈­Ù © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ç ̧øTMa  ̈Æøo· ̈·±2ø¥¥ß æaa2

1⁄2±2o·oa2 ̈·ø¥ÚåÎ

flÚ ¤®1⁄2a° ̈·±2­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Œ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o fl1⁄21⁄2a­­

Ã ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ù ±o 1⁄2± ́Æ­aÙ ·­ 2± ̈ øæ­±¥ ́ ̈aÚ fl1⁄21⁄2a­­ 3øß æa

oa2·ao o±Æ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­ oao·2ao ø­ ç±TMaÆÆ·o·21Ùå ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21Ùå ±Æ ç·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈Úå ×2 Œ·1⁄2 ̧3±2o

“a©­°ø°aÆ­Ù  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ­°a1⁄2·o·ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø2ß ç±TMaÆÆ·o·21å ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ 3 ́­ ̈ æa çøÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈ao ·2 o·2o·21­å

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 11 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

ÔÓ

æao±Æa ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ 3øß æa oa2·aoÙ ·2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2ø­a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥  ̈Æ·ø¥ · ̈­a¥oÚ ÏÏË ÀÚÕÚ ø ̈ ÎËÔÚ ×2

Œ ́­ ̧o±ÆoÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧a oa2·ø¥ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ o·¥ao ·2 1⁄2±22a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ©· ̈ ̧ ø ­ ́33øÆß

¶ ́o13a2 ̈ 3± ̈·±2 3 ́­ ̈ æa 2a1⁄2a­­· ̈ø ̈ao æß çø 1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 1±TMaÆ23a2 ̈ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ø2o 2øÆÆ±©¥ß

 ̈ø·¥±Æao  ̈± ­aÆTMa  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈Úå ËÏÍ ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÓÎÌ  ̄Ø ́± ̈·21 Ÿ¥±æa “a©­°ø°aÆ ›±Ú TMÚ Õ ́°aÆ·±Æ ›± ́Æ ̈Ù

ÏÎÈ ÀÚÕÚ ÎÁÍ  ̄ÔÁËÓ ̃ ̃Â ­aa ø¥­± ø¥¥aß fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21Ù ÈÁË ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔÓÁÓ 2ÚÏ  ̄­ø3a ­ ̈ø2oøÆo ̃Ú Ã ̧a

›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a Ã ̧·Æo ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ a®°¥ø·2ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ¥·3· ̈ø ̈·±2 ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± 1⁄2·TM·¥  ̈Æ·ø¥­

ÆaØ ́·Æa­ ø ­ ̧±©·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ç ̈ ̧a oa2·ø¥ ­aÆTMa­ ø2 ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ 1±TMaÆ23a2 ̈ø¥ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈ ø2o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ 2±

¥a­­ Æa­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈·TMa ©øß  ̈± ­aÆTMa  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1±TMaÆ23a2 ̈ø¥ ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈Úå – ́æ¥·1⁄2μaÆÙ ÈÌÌ ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔðÈð

 ̄°Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ±2 3± ̈·±2 o±Æ °Æa¥·3·2øÆß ·2¶ ́21⁄2 ̈·±2 3 ́­ ̈ æa ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ̃Ú

fiÚ ¤®1⁄2a° ̈·±2­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ›±33±2 ‘ø© Œ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o fl1⁄21⁄2a­­

Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a “·2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧ø­ 2± ̈ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ç1⁄2±33±2Û¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈

·­ 2± ̈ ±o 1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥ o·3a2­·±2Ù ·­ 2± ̈ øæ­±¥ ́ ̈aÙ ø2o ·­ 2± ̈ a2 ̈· ̈¥ao  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ­ø3a ¥aTMa¥ ±o

°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 øoo±Æoao 1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥ Æ·1 ̧ ̈­Úå ø¥¥aß fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21Ù ÈÁË ⁄ÚÓo ø ̈ ÔÓÁÌÚ ÿ±©aTMaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a

°øÆø3a ̈aÆ­ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø©  ̈a­ ̈ øÆa 2± ̈ a2 ̈·Æa¥ß 1⁄2¥aøÆÚ ×2 ø¥¥aß fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21Ù  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o

fl°°aø¥­ oao·2ao  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø©  ̈a­ ̈ ø­ ø ç°Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ùå © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ 3øß æa ±TMaÆ1⁄2±3a æß

çøÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈ao oø1⁄2 ̈­ μ2±©2  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Ù 2± ̈ ±2  ̈ ̧a æø­·­ ±o  ́2­ ́°°±Æ ̈ao  ̧ß°± ̈ ̧a­·­ ±Æ 1⁄2±2¶a1⁄2 ̈ ́ÆaÚå

×oÚ ø ̈ ÔÓÁÏÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2 ø¥¥aß fiÆ±øo1⁄2ø­ ̈·21 o·­ ̈·21 ́·­ ̧ao  ̈ ̧a ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 1⁄2·Æ1⁄2 ́3­ ̈ø21⁄2a­å  ̈a­ ̈

ø2o 2± ̈ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ · ̈ 1⁄2øÆÆ·a­ ø çæ ́·¥ ̈Û·2 æ·ø­ oøTM±Æ·21 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Úå ×oÚ ø ̈ ÔÓÁÌÚ

Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ·2 oøTM±Æ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̧ø­ æaa2 1⁄2 ̧øÆø1⁄2 ̈aÆ·¶ao øç­ ̈Æ±21Úå Õaa Õø2 ÷±­a ”aÆ1⁄2 ́Æß “a©­Ù ÔËÈ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÔÔðÓÂ ÿø1a­ ̈øoÙ ÏÁ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÔÏÌÏÚ ”ø2ß

oa1⁄2·­·±2­ ±o  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a “·2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧øTMa  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 3øß æa

±TMaÆ1⁄2±3a æß çø 1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2å o±Æ © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈ao ø oø1⁄2 ̈ ́ø¥ æø­·­Ù ç©· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈

Æa¥ß·21 ±2  ̧ß°± ̈ ̧a­·­ ±Æ 1⁄2±2¶a1⁄2 ̈ ́ÆaÚå ÿø1a­ ̈øoÙ ÏÁ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÔÏÌÏÂ ­aa ø¥­± –·2 ̈±­ TMÚ –ø1⁄2·o·1⁄2

›Æao· ̈±Æ­ fl­­é2ÚÙ ÎðÏ ⁄ÚÌo ÈÁÓÙ ËðÔ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÈ ̃Â ’ø3øμø2ø TMÚ ›· ̈ß ø2o ›± ́2 ̈ß ±o ÿ±2±¥ ́¥ ́Ù

ÏÏÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÔÔÈÓÙ ÔÔÈË  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÍ ̃  ̄çÅøÃ °øÆ ̈ß ­aaμ·21  ̈± ­aø¥ ø ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ Æa1⁄2±Æo ÚÚÚ æaøÆ­  ̈ ̧a

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 12 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ 1⁄2±3°¥ø·2­ ­ ̈Æa2 ́± ́­¥ß øæ± ́ ̈  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ °Æ·±Æ ·oa2 ̈·o·1⁄2ø ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a Í

ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å  ̈a­ ̈ ø­ ø ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈  ̈a­ ̈Ú ×2 · ̈­ —1⁄2 ̈±æaÆ ÓÓÙ ÓððÈ ±ÆoaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈

1⁄2· ̈ao 1⁄2ø­a­ © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ́­ao  ̈ ̧a ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å  ̈a­ ̈ æ ́ ̈ ·21⁄2±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈¥ß ·oa2 ̈·o·ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈a­ ̈ ø­ øÆ·­·21

± ́ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ­ ̈ø2o­ 1⁄2±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈ao ±2  ̈ ̧·­ °±·2 ̈Ú fl­ ­a ̈ o±Æ ̈ ̧ øæ±TMaÙ © ̧·¥a

 ̈ ̧a ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å  ̈a­ ̈  ̧ø­ æaa2  ́­ao oÆaØ ́a2 ̈¥ß ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ ·2 1⁄2·TM·¥ 1⁄2ø­a­Ù  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o

fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a “·2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧ø­ 2± ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ ø°°¥·1⁄2øæ¥a  ̈± ø 1⁄2·TM·¥ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ù

·21⁄2¥ ́o·21 ø  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ú

ÔÌ

æ ́Æoa2 ±o ±TMaÆ1⁄2±3·21 ÚÚÚ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å ­ ̈ø2oøÆo ̃Â ⁄±¥ ̈¶ TMÚ Õ ̈ø ̈a ⁄øÆ3 ” ́ ̈Ú fl ́ ̈±Ú ×2­Ú

›±ÚÙ ÌÌÔ ⁄ÚÌo ÔÔÓÓÙ ÔÔÌÎÛÌÍ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÌ ̃ÚÍ

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ øÆ1 ́a­  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å  ̈a­ ̈ ·­  ̈±± ­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ ø2o ·12±Æa­ “·2 ̈ ̧

›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ °Æa1⁄2aoa2 ̈ a­ ̈øæ¥·­ ̧·21 ø  ̈a­ ̈  ́2oaÆ © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ç­ ́oo·1⁄2·a2 ̈¥ß ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­å

1⁄2ø2 ±TMaÆ1⁄2±3a  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a­a øÆa  ̈©± ­a°øÆø ̈a  ̈a­ ̈­

·­ æø­ao ±2 ø ­a¥a1⁄2 ̈·TMa Æaøo·21 ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø©  ̧a 1⁄2· ̈a­Ù ø2o ·­ 2± ̈ ©a¥¥  ̈øμa2Ú ... ̧·¥a  ̈ ̧a  ̈a­ ̈  ̧øæaa2 oa­1⁄2Æ·æao ø­ aTMø¥ ́ø ̈·21 © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ç­ ́oo·1⁄2·a2 ̈¥ß ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­å a®·­ ̈ ·2

Õø2 ÷±­a ”aÆ1⁄2 ́Æß “a©­ ø2o ·2  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ 1⁄2· ̈a­Ù – ̧·¥¥·°­ TMÚ Ÿa2aÆø¥ ”± ̈±Æ­Ù æ± ̈ ̧ 1⁄2ø­aø¥­± oao·2a  ̈ ̧a  ̈a­ ̈ ø­ ø ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å  ̈a­ ̈Ú Õø2 ÷±­a ”aÆ1⁄2 ́Æß “a©­Ù ÔËÈ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÔÔðÓÛðÌ

 ̄ç°Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 1⁄2ø2 æa ±TMaÆ1⁄2±3a æß ­ ́oo·1⁄2·a2 ̈¥ß ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­å ø2o o·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 3 ́­ ̈ æø¥ø21⁄2a  ̈ ̧a ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­ ø2o æø­a · ̈­ oa1⁄2·­·±2 ±2 ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­ ø2o ­°a1⁄2·o·1⁄2 oø1⁄2 ̈ ́ø¥

o·2o·21­å ̃Â – ̧·¥¥·°­ TMÚ Ÿa2aÆø¥ ”± ̈±Æ­ ›±Æ°ÚÙ ÌðÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÔÓðÍÙ ÔÓÔÓ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÓ ̃  ̄1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·2o­

°Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ Æaæ ́ ̈ ̈ao o±Æ ø ­aø¥ao o·­1⁄2±TMaÆß o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈ ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao ©· ̈ ̧ ø 2±2Ûo·­°±­· ̈·TMa

3± ̈·±2Â  ́­a­ ­ø3a ¥ø21 ́ø1a ø­  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ́­ao ·2 Õø2 ÷±­a ”aÆ1⁄2 ́Æß “a©­ ̃Ú

××Ú ¤ooa1⁄2 ̈ ±o –Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa —ÆoaÆ

Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ø¥Æaøoß  ̧ø­ oa ̈aÆ3·2ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ ·­­ ́ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a

o·­1⁄2±TMaÆß ° ̧ø­a o±a­ 2± ̈ ø ́ ̈±3ø ̈·1⁄2ø¥¥ß a® ̈a2o  ̈± o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ±Æ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 øo3· ̈ ̈ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ú fl°Æ·¥ ÓÏ ø2o —1⁄2 ̈±æaÆ ÓÓÙ ÓððÈ —ÆoaÆ­Ú “±2a ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈­

°aÆ­ ́øoa  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̈± 1⁄2 ̧ø21a  ̈ ̧·­ °Æ·±Æ oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2Ú fl °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ ·­­ ́ao o ́Æ·21 o·­1⁄2±TMaÆß

­ ̧± ́¥o æa ÆaÛaTMø¥ ́ø ̈ao ø ̈  ̈ ̧a  ̈·3a ±o o·­°±­· ̈·TMa °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ú Õaa – ̧·¥¥·°­Ù ÌðÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÔÓðÍ  ̄Á ̈ ̧

›·ÆÚ ÓððÍ ̃Â fiø® ̈aÆ ×2 ̈aÆ2ø ̈·±2ø¥Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ flææ± ̈ ̈ ‘øæ±Æø ̈±Æ·a­Ù ÓÁÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÎÏÏÙ ÎÏÍÛÏÈ  ̄È ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 13 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 ‹ ́Æ·21 øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈ ±2  ̈ ̧·­ ·­­ ́aÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ø­μao °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ · ̈ ©± ́¥o æa È

ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a  ̈± 3øμa ø o·­ ̈·21⁄2 ̈·±2 æa ̈©aa2  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a o±Æ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ ø2o

 ̈ ̧a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­ o±Æ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ­·3°¥ß Æa°¥·ao ç2±Úå

Œa­°±2oa2 ̈é­ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ øÆ1 ́ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø2ß 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ ­ ́æ¶a1⁄2 ̈  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a ­ ̧± ́¥o Æa1⁄2a·TMa

1Æaø ̈aÆ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø2 ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Ú

ÔÏ

ÓððÓ ̃  ̄çÅ‹Ã·­°±­· ̈·TMa o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ·2 ø2ß ¥· ̈·1ø ̈·±2 a2 ̈aÆ  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 Æa1⁄2±Æo 2± ̈©· ̈ ̧­ ̈ø2o·21 ø2ß

aøÆ¥·aÆ ø1Æaa3a2 ̈Ú ÿ±© a¥­a øÆa ±æ­aÆTMaÆ­  ̈± μ2±© © ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ­ ́· ̈ ·­ øæ± ́ ̈ ±Æ ø­­a­­  ̈ ̧a ¶ ́o1a­é

o·­°±­· ̈·±2 ±o · ̈·å ̃Â ›ø¥·o±Æ2·ø TMÚ Õøoa©øßÙ ÌÎÎ ⁄Ú Õ ́°°Ú Óo ÔÔÔÔ  ̄›Ú‹Ú ›ø¥Ú ÓððÎ ̃Ú

×××Ú ŒaØ ́·Æa3a2 ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ Õ ̧±© –± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥ o±Æ –Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a  ̈± —TMaÆ1⁄2±3a –Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o

 fl1⁄21⁄2a­­

⁄±Æ ° ́Æ°±­a­ ±o  ̈ ̧·­ ø2ø¥ß­·­Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ©·¥¥ ø­­ ́3a ©· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈ oa1⁄2·o·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a

1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© ­ ̈ø2oøÆo ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ø°°¥·a­Ù  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ­ ̈ø2oøÆo 1⁄2Æaø ̈a­ ø ©aøμaÆ °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈ ̧ø2 o±a­  ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈Ù æ ́ ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ·­ ©a·1 ̧ ̈ß 1·TMa2  ̈ ̧a o·­°±­· ̈·TMa

2ø ̈ ́Æa ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ Æa¥ø ̈ao  ̈±  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ú Ã ̧a Ø ́a­ ̈·±2Ù  ̈ ̧a2Ù ·­ © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ

·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2ao o ́Æ·21 ø2 aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­ ±o 1⁄2ø°· ̈ø¥  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­

1⁄2¥ø·3­ ø2o ­ ́æ¶a1⁄2 ̈  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ø2oÒ±Æ ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ·­ a2 ̈· ̈¥ao

ø ́ ̈±3ø ̈·1⁄2ø¥¥ß  ̈± æa μa° ̈ oÆ±3 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 TM·a©Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ øÆ1 ́a­ · ̈ ·­Ú ÿa  ̧ø­ ¥· ̈ ̈¥aÙ ·o ø2ßÙ ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ È

o±Æ  ̈ ̧a °Æ±°±­· ̈·±2 ·2 ø 1⁄2ø­a ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ø­  ̈ ̧·­ © ̧aÆa °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̧ø­ ©ø·TMao  ̈ ̧±­a °Æ·TM·¥a1a­ ø2o

°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­Ù  ̧±©aTMaÆ 2øÆÆ±©¥ßÙ æß æÆ·21·21 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3­ ·2 ø  ̧øæaøø1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ ­± ́1 ̧ ̈  ̈± 1⁄2±2o·Æ3  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø2ß ©ø·TMaÆ ·­ ø 2øÆÆ±© ±2a æß ­ ́11a­ ̈·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈

°a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ oa3±2­ ̈Æø ̈a  ̈ ̧a °± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥ o±Æ °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a ·o  ̈ ̧a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̧a ­aaμ­  ̈± °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ ©aÆa  ̈± æa

3øoa ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̧ø­ oa1⁄2¥·2ao  ̈ ̧·­ ·2TM· ̈ø ̈·±2Ú ×2 ¥·1 ̧ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a °±¥·1⁄2·a­  ́2oaÆ¥ß·21 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ù  ̈ ̧a ·3°±Æ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß °Æ·TM·¥a1a­ ø2o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­ 1⁄2¥ø·3ao æß °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÙ ø2o

 ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ ÆaTM·a©Ù  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·2o­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ÆaØ ́·Æ·21 ø ­ ̧±©·21 ±o  ̈ ̧a °± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥ o±Æ °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a  ̈± æa

2± ̈ ±2¥ß ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ao æß 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø© æ ́ ̈  ̈ ̧a 3±­ ̈ aØ ́· ̈øæ¥a ø°°Æ±ø1⁄2 ̧Ú

ÒÒÒÒÒ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 14 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­± øÆ1 ́a­  ̧·­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± 1⁄2±2o·oa2 ̈·ø¥¥ß 1⁄2±2­ ́¥ ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ ø2 ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ·­ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao æß Ë

 ̈ ̧a ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈Ú —21⁄2a ø1ø·2Ù  ̈ ̧a  ̈©± 1⁄2ø­a­ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2· ̈a­ o± 2± ̈ 1± ø­ oøÆ ø­ ­ ́11a­ ̈aoÚ

“a· ̈ ̧aÆ øooÆa­­a­  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±2o·oa2 ̈·ø¥ ø­°a1⁄2 ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ Æa¥ø ̈·±2­ ̧·°Ú Õaa ”± ̈ ̧aÆ­ ̧ao TMÚ

÷ ́­ ̈·1⁄2a­ ±o Õ ́°Æa3a ›± ́Æ ̈Ù ÏÔð ⁄ÚÌo ÍðÓ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÎ ̃  ̄1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æa1⁄2±12·¶a­ ⁄·Æ­ ̈ fl3a2o3a2 ̈

Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈±  ̧·Æa ø2o 1⁄2±2­ ́¥ ̈ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ·2 1⁄2 ̧ø¥¥a21a  ̈± 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æ ́¥a Æa­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈·21 °Æø1⁄2 ̈·1⁄2a æß ± ́ ̈Û±oÛ­ ̈ø ̈a

ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß­ ̃Â ⁄Æßa TMÚ Ãa2oaÆ¥±·2 ÿ± ́­·21 ›¥·2·1⁄2Ù ×21⁄2ÚÙ ÌË ›ø¥Ú Ï ̈ ̧ ÓÌÙ ÌÁÛÏð  ̄ÓððÍ ̃  ̄⁄·Æ­ ̈

fl3a2o3a2 ̈ a21⁄2±3°ø­­a­ ø­­±1⁄2·ø ̈·±2ø¥ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o 1Æ± ́°­Ù ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ø­ ¥a1ø¥ ø·o ±Æ1ø2·¶ø ̈·±2 ·2  ̈ ̧·­

1⁄2ø­aÙ  ̈±  ́2· ̈a  ̈± ø­­aÆ ̈  ̈ ̧a·Æ ¥a1ø¥ Æ·1 ̧ ̈­ ø­ aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa¥ß ø2o a1⁄2±2±3·1⁄2ø¥¥ß ø­ °Æø1⁄2 ̈·1⁄2øæ¥a ̃Ú

 –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ Ø ́± ̈a­ ø ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈ oÆ±3 À2· ̈ao Õ ̈ø ̈a­ TMÚ ”a ̈ ̈Ù ÔÈË ⁄ÚÌo ÔðÎËÙ ÔðÍÎ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ Á

ÔÁÁÁ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ç© ̧aÆa ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ·­ 1⁄2±21⁄2aÆ2aoÙ  ̧øÆo 1⁄2ø­a­ ­ ̧± ́¥o æa Æa­±¥TMao ·2 oøTM±Æ

±o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1aÙ 2± ̈ ·2 oøTM±Æ ±o o·­1⁄2¥±­ ́ÆaÚå Ã ̧a ·­­ ́a­ ·2 ”a ̈ ̈ æaøÆ 2± Æa­a3æ¥ø21⁄2a  ̈±  ̈ ̧±­a ·2

 ̈ ̧a °Æa­a2 ̈ 1⁄2ø­aÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2 ”a ̈ ̈ 3øoa  ̈ ̧·­ ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈ © ̧a2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ·21 © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ø2

ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÒ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ Æa¥ø ̈·±2­ ̧·° a®·­ ̈aoÚ

ÔÎ

Ã ̧a ·3°±Æ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ·­  ́2Ø ́a­ ̈·±2øæ¥aÙ ±o 1⁄2± ́Æ­aÚ Ã ̧a Ë

­ ̈ø ̈a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ oa­1⁄2Æ·æao · ̈ ø­ çèo ́2oø3a2 ̈ø¥  ̈± Å· ̈­Ã ¥a1ø¥ ­ß­ ̈a3å ø2o çø  ̧ø¥¥3øÆμ ±o Å· ̈­Ã

¶ ́Æ·­°Æ ́oa21⁄2aÚéå fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆÙ ÌÌÔ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÈÓÔ  ̄Ø ́± ̈·21 –a±°¥a TMÚ Õ ́°aÆ·±Æ ›± ́Æ ̈  ̄ ‘øoo  ̃Ù ÓÎ ›ø¥Ú Ï ̈ ̧

ÈðÌÙ ÈÔÎ  ̄ÓððÔ ̃ ̃Ú fl2 ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßé­ o ́ ̈ß  ̈± ç3ø·2 ̈ø·2 ·2TM·±¥ø ̈a  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±2o·oa21⁄2aå ±o  ̧·­ ±Æ  ̧aÆ 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ ·­

 ̈ ̧a æø­·­ o±Æ ø2 aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß Æ ́¥a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ç·­  ̧a¥o TM· ̈ø¥  ̈±  ̈ ̧a aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa øo3·2·­ ̈Æø ̈·±2 ±o ¶ ́­ ̈·1⁄2aÚå ×oÚ

 ̄1⁄2· ̈·21 Œ±æaÆ ̈­ TMÚ ›· ̈ß ±o –ø¥3oø¥aÙ Î ›ø¥Ú Ï ̈ ̧ ÌÍÌÙ ÌËð  ̄ÔÁÁÌ ̃ ̃Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2 fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆ Á

Æa1⁄2±12·¶ao  ̈ ̧a  ̈a2­·±2 æa ̈©aa2  ̈ ̧a Æ ́¥a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ©ø·TMa­  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a æß 3øμ·21 ø2

·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3 ø2o  ̈ ̧a ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ °±¥·1⁄2ß æa ̧·2o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a ä  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ±o

a21⁄2± ́Æø1·21 çoÆø2μ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­Úå ×oÚ ø ̈ ÈÓÓÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o± ́2o  ̈ ̧a ©±Æμ

°Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ o±1⁄2 ̈Æ·2a  ̈±  ̧øTMa ­·3·¥øÆ ·3°±Æ ̈ø21⁄2a æa1⁄2ø ́­a · ̈ a21⁄2± ́Æø1a­ ¶aø¥± ́­ Æa°Æa­a2 ̈ø ̈·±2Ú ×oÚ  ̇

2ÚÍÚ fiø­ao ±2  ̈ ̧a­a °±¥·1⁄2·a­Ù  ̈ ̧a fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ©ø·TMaÆ ­ ̧± ́¥o æa oÆø©2 ø­ 2øÆÆ±©¥ß

ø­ °±­­·æ¥a ­±  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·o  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ©aÆa ­ ́1⁄21⁄2a­­o ́¥ ±2  ̧·­ ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥

1⁄2¥ø·3­Ù  ̧a ©± ́¥o 2± ̈ æa °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2ao  ́°±2 ø2ß Æa ̈Æ·ø¥Ú ×oÚ ø ̈ ÈÓÓÛÓÌÚ ”±Æa±TMaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2

fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆ a®ø3·2ao ±2¥ß  ̈ ̧a o·­1⁄2±TMaÆß Ø ́a­ ̈·±2 Æø·­ao æß  ̈ ̧a °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­  ̈Æ·ø¥

1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ o·¥a­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a Æa­°±2oa2 ̈  ̈± °aÆ3· ̈ Æa­°±2oa2 ̈  ̈± oaoa2o ø1ø·2­ ̈  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ú

Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·o 2± ̈ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ·­­ ́a­ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆao  ̧aÆaÚ

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ 1⁄2¥ø·3­  ̈±  ̧øTMa o·Æa1⁄2 ̈ ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ o±Æ  ̧·­ ø­­aÆ ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao ø2o

°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ø ́ ̈±3ø ̈·1⁄2ø¥¥ß ·­ a2 ̈· ̈¥ao  ̈± °Æ·TMø1⁄2ß ·2  ̈ ̧a °Æa­a2 ̈ 1⁄2ø­aÚ ÿa 1⁄2 ̧øÆø1⁄2 ̈aÆ·¶a­ ø

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 15 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

ÔÍ

2 ́3æaÆ ±o 1⁄2ø­a­ ø­ o±¥¥±©­Ê ç1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ ø°°¥·ao ø 1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21Û·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈  ̈a­ ̈Ù ø2o oa ̈aÆ3·2ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a

·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈­ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao æß  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ø2o ©±ÆμÛ°Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ o±1⁄2 ̈Æ·2a ± ́ ̈©a·1 ̧ao  ̈ ̧a

° ́æ¥·1⁄2é­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± o·­°±­· ̈·TMaÙ æ ́ ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2Ù ·2 1⁄2·TM·¥ 1⁄2ø­a­Úå –a ̈éÆé­ ”øÆÚ ÍÙ

ÓððË Œa°¥ß ø ̈ ÓÚ ‹a­°· ̈a  ̈ ̧a øoø3ø21⁄2ß ±o  ̧·­ Æ ̧a ̈±Æ·1⁄2Ù °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ °±­· ̈·±2 o±a­ 2± ̈  ̧øTMa  ̈ ̧a

­ ́°°±Æ ̈  ̧a 1⁄2¥ø·3­ o±Æ ø°°¥·1⁄2ø ̈·±2  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °Æa­a2 ̈ 1⁄2ø­aÚ

—2a ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a­  ́°±2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ Æa¥·a­ ·­ ‘ ́1±­1⁄2 ̧ TMÚ ›±21a¥Ù “±Ú ›× ÔÊððÛ

› ÛðÈËÏÙ ÓððÍ ...‘ ÁÌÔÍËÈ  ̄“Ú‹Ú“Ú«Ú ”øÆÚ ÈÙ ÓððÍ ̃Ú Ã ̧aÆaÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ oa­1⁄2Æ·æao  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ

1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ø2o ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ ø­ ç±o  ̈ ̧a  ̧·1 ̧a­ ̈ TMø¥ ́a­ ©· ̈ ̧·2 ± ́Æ ¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ ­ß­ ̈a3Úå ×oÚ ø ̈

ˆÔÈÚ ÿ±©aTMaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a ·2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2ø­a ©ø­ ©ø·TMaÆÚ Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ±2¥ß o± ́2o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a ø2o

°Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ©aÆa ç1⁄2±3°a¥¥·21 Æaø­±2­å ø2o ç1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 oø1⁄2 ̈±Æ­å  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ç­ ́oo·1⁄2·a2 ̈¥ß ± ́ ̈©a·1 ̧

 ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2é­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­å © ̧aÆa  ̈ ̧±­a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­ ©aÆa 2± ̈ ©ø·TMaoÚ ×oÚ ø ̈ ˆÌÍÚ ... ̧aÆa  ̈ ̧a

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o± ́2o ©ø·TMaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ©ø­ o ́¥¥ß o·­1⁄2¥±­aoÚ ×oÚ ø ̈ ˆˆÌÈÙ ÏÍÚ ×2 ¤¥¥± TMÚ Õ·21 ̧Ù ÎÌÔ ⁄Ú

Õ ́°°Ú Óo ÎÎÓ  ̄ÕÚ‹Ú“Ú«Ú ÓððÈ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̈a3°±ÆøÆ·¥ß ­aø¥ao ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­

­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao ø¥±21 ©· ̈ ̧ ø 1⁄2±3°¥ø·2 ̈ ±2¥ß ¥±21 a2± ́1 ̧  ̈± 1·TMa  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­ ø2 ±°°±Æ ̈ ́2· ̈ß  ̈± øÆ1 ́a

© ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ­ ̧± ́¥o æa ­aø¥aoÚ ×2 Õ3· ̈ ̧ TMÚ ”1⁄2‹ø2·a¥Ù “±Ú ÓÊðÈÛ› ÛððÌÔËÛ÷›”ÛŒ÷÷Ù

ÓððÈ ...‘ ÌÓðÌÔÔÍÙ ø ̈ ˆÔ  ̄‹Ú “aTMÚ —1⁄2 ̈Ú ÓÎÙ ÓððÈ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o± ́2o 3±± ̈  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a ±o ­aø¥·21

o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ o·¥ao ø¥±21 ©· ̈ ̧ ø ÆaØ ́a­ ̈ o±Æ ø ­ ̈øß o ́a  ̈± °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ ·21⁄2±3°a ̈a21⁄2aÂ ·2 o·1⁄2 ̈øÙ ø2o

©· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈ 3 ́1⁄2 ̧ ø2ø¥ß­·­Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ­ø·o · ̈ ©± ́¥o  ̧øTMa 1⁄2±2­·oaÆao ­aø¥·21  ̈ ̧a o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ±2  ̈ ̧a

3aÆ· ̈­Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·o 2± ̈ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ  ̈ ̧a 2ø ̈ ́Æa ±o  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈øß °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­Ù © ̧·1⁄2 ̧Ù  ́2¥·μa  ̈ ̧a

°Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ø ̈ ·­­ ́a  ̧aÆaÙ ©aÆa 2± ̈ o·­°±­· ̈·TMa ±o  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­aÚ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­± 1⁄2· ̈afiø® ̈aÆÙ ·2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a ÕaTMa2 ̈ ̧ ›·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈ 1⁄2±2o·Æ3ao °Æ·±Æ  ̧±¥o·21­  ̈ ̧ø ̈

ço·­°±­· ̈·TMa o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ·2 ø2ß ¥· ̈·1ø ̈·±2 a2 ̈aÆ  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 Æa1⁄2±Æo 2± ̈©· ̈ ̧­ ̈ø2o·21 ø2ß aøÆ¥·aÆ

ø1Æaa3a2 ̈Úå ÓÁÈ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÎÏÍÛÏÈ  ̄a3° ̧ø­·­ ·2 ±Æ·1·2ø¥ ̃Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2 fiø® ̈aÆ o·o ·oa2 ̈·oß ø oa©

1⁄2ø ̈a1±Æ·a­ ±o o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­  ̈± æa μa° ̈ 1⁄2±2o·oa2 ̈·ø¥ ±21⁄2a  ̈ ̧a·Æ æaøÆ·21 ±2  ̈ ̧a 3aÆ· ̈­ ©ø­ ÆaTMaø¥aoÚ

Ã ̧±­a 1⁄2ø ̈a1±Æ·a­ ·21⁄2¥ ́oao  ̈Æøoa ­a1⁄2Æa ̈­ ø2o ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Ú ÿ±©aTMaÆÙ · ̈­

­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈ øæ± ́ ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ·­ ±2¥ß °øÆ ̈ ±o ø 1a2aÆø¥ o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­Ú “a· ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a 2±Æ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 16 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 ‹ ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ·21 ±2  ̈ ̧·­ ·­­ ́aÙ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­± øÆ1 ́ao  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ oa1⁄2·­·±2 ·2 Ôð

Œ± ̧ø2 a® Æa¥Ú Ÿø ̈a­ TMÚ ...±±oo±ÆoÙ ÌÌÏ ⁄ÚÌo ËðÌÙ ËðÍÛðÈ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÌ ̃ ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ao ­aø¥·21Ú Ã ̧a

o·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2ø­a ·­­ ́ao ø2 ±ÆoaÆ  ́2oaÆ ­aø¥ Æa1øÆo·21  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2±3°a ̈a21⁄2ß  ̈±

°Æ±1⁄2aao ©· ̈ ̧  ̧·­  ̧øæaø­ °a ̈· ̈·±2Ú fl­ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ øo3· ̈ ̈ao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a  ̧aøÆ·21 ·2  ̈ ̧·­

1⁄2ø­aÙ  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a­ ·2 Œ± ̧ø2 ©aÆa 2± ̈ o·­°±­· ̈·TMaÚ Œ± ̧ø2 o±a­ 2± ̈ ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈­Ú

ÔÈ

©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2 ·­ o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao ø2o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·o 2± ̈ o·­1⁄2 ́­­  ̈ ̧a aooa1⁄2 ̈ ±o ø2ß ©ø·TMaÆÚ

Õ·3·¥øÆ¥ßÙ © ̧·¥a  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2 ‹·TMaÆ­·o·ao ŸÆ± ́°Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ ‹ø ́1aÆoø­Ù ÌðÏ ⁄Ú Õ ́°°Ú Óo ÎðÈÙ ÎÔÔ

 ̄ÕÚ‹Ú“Ú«Ú ÓððÌ ̃Ù o·o ­ ̈ø ̈a  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ©ø­ ­ ́oo·1⁄2·a2 ̈  ̈± ± ́ ̈©a·1 ̧  ̈ ̧a

°Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2 ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ o±Æ ­ ́33øÆß ¶ ́o13a2 ̈ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Ù ©ø·TMaÆ ©ø­ 2± ̈ ø2 ·­­ ́a ·2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2ø­aÚÔð

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ¥øÆ1a¥ß ·12±Æa­  ̈ ̧a o·­ ̈·21⁄2 ̈·±2 æa ̈©aa2 ø­­aÆ ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈

°Æ·TM·¥a1a æß ø °øÆ ̈ß oaoa2o·21 ø ­ ́· ̈ ø2o ø­­aÆ ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a ±ooa2­·TMa¥ßÙ ø­  ̧aÆaÙ æß  ̈ ̧a

°øÆ ̈ß æÆ·21·21 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ú ÿ·­  ́­a ±o  ̈ ̧a ‹ø ́1aÆoø­ 1⁄2ø­a ·¥¥ ́­ ̈Æø ̈a­  ̧·­ oø·¥ ́Æa  ̈±  ̈a¥¥  ̈ ̧a © ̧±¥a ­ ̈±ÆßÂ

‹ø ́1aÆoø­ o±a­ 2± ̈ o·Æa1⁄2 ̈¥ß øooÆa­­  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́aÚ Œø ̈ ̧aÆÙ ·2 ø °Æ·±Æ ±°·2·±2Ù  ̈ ̧a ­ø3a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈

1⁄2±2­·oaÆao  ̈ ̧a °Æ±°Æ·a ̈ß ±o  ́2­aø¥·21 o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao æß  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­ ·2 ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ ø2o

±°°±­· ̈·±2  ̈± 3± ̈·±2­ o±Æ ­ ́33øÆß ¶ ́o13a2 ̈Ú Ã ̧a ‹·TMaÆ­·o·ao ŸÆ± ́°Ù ×21⁄2Ú TMÚ ‹ø ́1aÆoø­Ù ÓÔÈ

⁄ÚŒÚ‹Ú ÔÎÓ  ̄ÕÚ‹Ú“Ú«Ú ÓððÌ ̃  ̄ç‹ø ́1aÆoø­ ×å ̃Ú Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2ø­a ©ø­ ø ­ ́· ̈ æß  ̈ ̧a °¥ø·2 ̈·ooÙ ø  ̈ø®

3øÆμa ̈·21 o·Æ3Ù ø1ø·2­ ̈ · ̈­ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß o±Æ æÆaø1⁄2 ̧ ±o o·o ́1⁄2·øÆß o ́ ̈ß ø2o æÆaø1⁄2 ̧ ±o 1⁄2±2 ̈Æø1⁄2 ̈ Æa1øÆo·21

ø  ̈ø® ­ ̈Æø ̈a1ßÚ Ã ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­ ­ ̈·° ́¥ø ̈ao  ̈±Ù ø2o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ±ÆoaÆaoÙ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2·21

ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ ø2o °Æ±°Æ·a ̈øÆß ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ©± ́¥o æa o·¥ao  ́2oaÆ ­aø¥Ú ×oÚ ø ̈

ÔÎÍÚ ‘ø ̈aÆÙ øo ̈aÆ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ Æ ́¥·21 ±2 ­ ́33øÆß ¶ ́o13a2 ̈ ø2o ø ­a ̈ ̈¥a3a2 ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­aÙ ø ¥a1ø¥

°aÆ·±o·1⁄2ø¥ ­± ́1 ̧ ̈ ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ­aø¥ao o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧a¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈

°Æ·TM·¥a1a ©ø­ ø 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 oø1⁄2 ̈±Æ ­ ́oo·1⁄2·a2 ̈  ̈± ±TMaÆ1⁄2±3a  ̈ ̧a ç­ ̈Æ±21 °Æa­ ́3° ̈·±2å ±o ° ́æ¥·1⁄2

ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a ­aø¥ao o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­Ú ×oÚ ø ̈ ÔÎÁÛÍÓÚ ... ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ±Æ 2± ̈  ̈ ̧a °¥ø·2 ̈·oo  ̧øo ©ø·TMao ø2ß Æ·1 ̧ ̈

 ̈± ø­­aÆ ̈ ø °Æ·TM·¥a1a ©ø­ 2± ̈ o·­1⁄2 ́­­aoÚ Œø ̈ ̧aÆÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ­°a1⁄2·o·1⁄2ø¥¥ß o·­ ̈·21 ́·­ ̧ao 1⁄2ø­a­

·2TM±¥TM·21 ±ooa2­·TMa  ́­a ±o °Æ·TM·¥a1ao 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥ æß  ̈ ̧a  ̧±¥oaÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1aÚ ×oÚ ø ̈ ÔÍÔ 2ÚÈ

 ̄o·­ ̈·21 ́·­ ̧·21 ÷±ß TMÚ “±Æ ̈ ̧Ù ÍÁÓ ⁄ÚÓo ËËð  ̄Óo ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÓ ̃ ̃Ú ¤TMaÆß 1⁄2ø­a  ́°±2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ̈ ̧a

‹ø ́1aÆoø­ × 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ Æa¥·ao ·2TM±¥TMao oaoa2­·TMa  ́­a ±o °Æ·TM·¥a1ao 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥Ú ×2 oø1⁄2 ̈Ù 3±­ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧±­a

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 17 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 × ̈ ø°°aøÆ­  ̈ ̧a oa© o·­ ̈Æ·1⁄2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̧øTMa oaø¥ ̈  ̈± oø ̈a ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a a3aÆ1·21 ·­­ ́a ÔÔ

øooÆa­­ao ·2  ̈ ̧·­ ±ÆoaÆ  ̧øTMa 2± ̈ o±2a ­± ·2 ø °øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥øÆ¥ß ­ø ̈·­oø1⁄2 ̈±Æß 3ø22aÆ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ °Æ±TM·oa­  ̈ ̧·­

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ 1 ́·oø21⁄2aÚ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̧·3­a¥o ø°°aøÆ­  ̈±  ̧øTMa ­a2 ̈ 3·®ao 3a­­ø1a­Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­

3± ̈·±2 o±Æ aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 ©ø­ o·¥ao ° ́æ¥·1⁄2¥ßÙ oa­°· ̈a  ̈ ̧a oø1⁄2 ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈ · ̈ ·21⁄2¥ ́oao ­±3a

·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 1⁄2±TMaÆao æß  ̈ ̧a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆÚ Õaa ”øÆÚ ÔËÙ ÓððÎ —ÆoaÆÚ ”±­ ̈ ·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈¥ßÙ  ̧a  ̧ø­

2± ̈ ­ ̧±©2  ̧a  ̧ø­ æaa2 °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2ao ·2 ø2ß ©øß æß  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ­± oøÆÚ

ÔË

1⁄2ø­a­ o·­ ̈·21 ́·­ ̧ao  ̈ ̧a ­· ̈ ́ø ̈·±2  ̧aÆa ÛÛ ©ø·TMaÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a °Æ·TM·¥a1a ø2o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­ æß ø °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ

ø¥¥a1·21 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ÛÛ oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a ­· ̈ ́ø ̈·±2­ Æa­±¥TMao æß  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­é oa1⁄2·­·±2­

·2  ̈ ̧±­a 1⁄2ø­a­Ú ×oÚ ø ̈ ÔÍðÛÍÔ  ̇ 2ÚÈÂ ­aa Õ·ao¥a TMÚ – ́ ̈2ø3 ×2TMa­ ̈3a2 ̈­Ù ×21⁄2ÚÙ ÔÏÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÈÙ ÔÔ  ̄Ô­ ̈

›·ÆÚ ÔÁÁË ̃  ̄1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ­°a1⁄2·o·1⁄2ø¥¥ß ­øß­ °Æ·TM·¥a1a 2± ̈ ©ø·TMao ·2 ­ ́· ̈ æß ¥ø©ßaÆ ø1ø·2­ ̈ o±Æ3aÆ 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈Â

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ o·­ ̈·21 ́·­ ̧a­ 1⁄2ø­a­ © ̧aÆa 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ ©ø·TMao °Æ·TM·¥a1a  ̈± ø­­aÆ ̈ ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o

1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ̃Â ›Æß­ ̈ø¥ ŸÆ±©aÆé­ ›±Æ°Ú TMÚ ‹±ææ·2­Ù ÍÔÍ ⁄ÚÓo ÏÎË  ̄Ôð ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËð ̃  ̄ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈

°Æ·TM·¥a1a 2± ̈ ©ø·TMao © ̧aÆa ­±3a 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ æa ̈©aa2 °¥ø·2 ̈·oo ø2o · ̈­ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß­ Æa¥aTMø2 ̈  ̈±

¥ø©­ ́· ̈ æ ́ ̈ °¥ø·2 ̈·ooé­ ­ ́· ̈ 2± ̈ ø1ø·2­ ̈ · ̈­ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß­ ̃Â ‹±3æÆ±©­μ· TMÚ fia¥¥ fl ̈¥ø2 ̈·1⁄2 ›±Æ°ÚÙ ÔÓË ⁄Ú

Õ ́°°Ú Óo ÓÔÍ  ̄¤Ú‹Ú –øÚ Óððð ̃  ̄2± ©ø·TMaÆ ·2 ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßé­ ­ ́· ̈ ø1ø·2­ ̈ o±Æ3aÆ 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ ̃Â ⁄·Æ­ ̈ ⁄aoÚ ÕøTMÚ

 ̇ ‘±ø2 fl­­é2 TMÚ —°°a2 ̧a·3Ù fl°°a¥Ù ‹·®±2  ̇ ›±ÚÙ ÔÔð ⁄ÚŒÚ‹Ú ÎÎÈ  ̄ÕÚ‹Ú“Ú«Ú ÔÁËÍ ̃  ̄2± ·­­ ́a ±o

©ø·TMaÆ o±Æ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥­ æß  ̈ ̧·Æo °øÆ ̈ß oaoa2oø2 ̈Â 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 2± ̈aÆ ́¥a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ © ̧aÆa 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ ·2· ̈·ø ̈a­ ø o·­° ́ ̈a ø1ø·2­ ̈ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÙ °Æ·TM·¥a1a ·­ ©ø·TMao ̃Ú

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­± 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ù ©· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈ 1⁄2· ̈ø ̈·±2  ̈± ø ́ ̈ ̧±Æ· ̈ßÙ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ÆaØ ́·Æ·21 ÆaTMa¥ø ̈·±2 ±o

·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 1⁄2±TMaÆao æß  ̈ ̧a °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ ç°Æ±3·­a­ oÆø3ø ̈·1⁄2 o·­Æ ́° ̈·±2­ ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2ø­a ø2o 3ø2ß

± ̈ ̧aÆ­ °a2o·21 ±2  ̧øæaø­ ø2o ø ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥Úå –a ̈éÆé­ ‹a1⁄2Ú ÔðÙ ÓððÈ fiÆ·ao Æa Õaø¥·21 –±Æ ̈·±2­ ±o ¤TM·oÚ

ÿÆ1Ú ÃÆø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ø ̈ ÌÊÎÛÍÚ fia1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧a °Æa1⁄2·­a ·­­ ́a °Æa­a2 ̈ao  ̧aÆa o±a­ 2± ̈ ø°°aøÆ  ̈±  ̧øTMa æaa2

øooÆa­­ao °ÆaTM·± ́­¥ßÙ ø2o 1⁄2aÆ ̈ø·2¥ß 2± ̈ ·2 1⁄2±2 ̈Æ±¥¥·21 °Æa1⁄2aoa2 ̈Ù  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 1⁄2±21⁄2¥ ́oa­  ̈ ̧a­a

­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈­ øÆa  ̧ß°aÆæ±¥·1⁄2Ù ø ̈ æa­ ̈Ú ¤TMa2 ø 1⁄2 ́Æ­±Æß ÆaTM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø©Ù ­ ́33øÆ·¶ao æa¥±©Ù ÔÔ

­ ̧±©­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21­ ±2 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3­  ̧øTMa æaa2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆao

±°a2Ù ø2o °Æ·TM·¥a1a­ ø2o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­  ̧øTMa æaa2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆao ©ø·TMaoÚ 

×2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ·21 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ù 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­  ̧øTMa ¥±21 a®ø3·2ao

2± ̈ ±2¥ß ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Ù æ± ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a ©±Æμ °aÆo±Æ3ao ø2o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ±°·2·±2­Ù æ ́ ̈ ø¥­±Ù © ̧aÆa

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 18 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

ÔÁ

Æa¥aTMø2 ̈Ù ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­Ú “± ̈ ±2¥ß o±a­  ̈ ̧a Æa­ ́¥ ̈·21 æ±oß ±o ¥ø© a®·­ ̈Ù · ̈ ©øø2o ·­ 2a1⁄2a­­øÆß  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2Æaø ̈·±2 ±o Õ·® ̈ ̧ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ ­ ̈ø2oøÆo­ ±o ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈Ú Õ ̧Æ± ́o·21

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­é 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2 ±o 1⁄2¥ø·3­ ±o ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ·2 ø æÆ±øo 1⁄2¥±øμ ±o ­a1⁄2Æa1⁄2ß

©± ́¥o oaoaø ̈ ø2 a­­a2 ̈·ø¥ ° ́Æ°±­a ±o 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­é ÆaTM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧a­a 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ê oao·2·21 ­ ̈ø2oøÆo­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a

ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a Æa°Æa­a2 ̈ø ̈·±2 ±o 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ oaoa2oø2 ̈­Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ ø­­aÆ ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ç ̈ ̧aÆa  ̧ø­ 2aTMaÆ

æaa2 ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈± ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥­å ø ̈ ̈a3° ̈­  ̈± Æa©Æ· ̈a ø ©a¥¥Ûa­ ̈øæ¥·­ ̧ao ¥·2a ±o 1⁄2ø­a­Ú –a ̈éÆé­ ‹a1⁄2Ú

ÔðÙ ÓððÈ fiÆ·ao Œa Õaø¥·21 –±Æ ̈·±2­ ±o ¤TM·oÚ ÿÆ1Ú ÃÆø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ø ̈ ÔÍÚ

... ̧aÆa Æa¥aTMø2 ̈Ù ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ øÆa o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao ·2 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­é ø2ø¥ß­a­

±o Õ·® ̈ ̧ fl3a2o3a2 ̈ 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ú Ã ̧a ­a3·2ø¥ 1⁄2ø­a ­a ̈ ̈·21 o±Æ ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈ø2oøÆo­ o±Æ ø2ø¥ß­·­ ±o ø2

·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3 ·­Ù ±o 1⁄2± ́Æ­aÙ Õ ̈Æ·1⁄2μ¥ø2o TMÚ ...ø­ ̧·21 ̈±2Ù ÏÍÍ ÀÚÕÚ ÍÍË

 ̄ÔÁËÏ ̃Ú Ã ̧aÆaÙ  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ­ ̈ø ̈ao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2 ±o 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ æa ̈©aa2  ̈ ̧a oaoa2oø2 ̈ ø2o

 ̧·­ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß 3øß æa 2a1⁄2a­­øÆß © ̧a2 a®ø3·2·21 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ©±ÆμÊ ç·2Ø ́·Æß ·2 ̈± 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­

1⁄2±2TMaÆ­ø ̈·±2­ ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a oaoa2oø2 ̈ 3øß æa 1⁄2Æ· ̈·1⁄2ø¥  ̈± ø °Æ±°aÆ ø­­a­­3a2 ̈ ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­

·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈·±2 oa1⁄2·­·±2­Ù ¶ ́­ ̈ ø­ · ̈ 3øß æa 1⁄2Æ· ̈·1⁄2ø¥  ̈± ø °Æ±°aÆ ø­­a­­3a2 ̈ ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ± ̈ ̧aÆ

¥· ̈·1ø ̈·±2 oa1⁄2·­·±2­Úå ÏÍÍ ÀÚÕÚ ø ̈ ÍÁÔÚ Ã ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2±2TMaÆ­ø ̈·±2­ ©· ̈ ̧ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ©aÆa ø μaß  ̈±

 ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈é­ oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·o 2± ̈ aÆÆ ·2 ¥·3· ̈·21 3· ̈·1ø ̈·21 aTM·oa21⁄2a ·2 Õ1⁄2 ̧Æ·Æ± TMÚ

‘ø2oÆ·1ø2Ù £££ ÀÚÕÚ £££Ù ÔÓÈ ÕÚ › ̈Ú ÔÁÌÌ  ̄ÓððÈ ̃Ú ×2 “·® TMÚ ... ̧· ̈a­·oaÙ ÏÈÎ ÀÚÕÚ ÔÎÈ  ̄ÔÁËÍ ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a

›± ́Æ ̈ a® ̈a2­·TMa¥ß o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ ©· ̈ ̧  ̧·­  ̈Æ·ø¥ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß  ̈± ø2ø¥ß¶a ø

1⁄2¥ø·3  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ©ø­ ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa o±Æ oø·¥·21  ̈± 1⁄2±±°aÆø ̈a ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ oa­·Æa  ̈±

 ̈a­ ̈·oßÚ ×2 ...±3ø1⁄2μ TMÚ ‹a¥ –ø°øÙ ÏÁÈ ⁄ÚÌo ÁÁËÙ ÔððÓ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÈ ̃Ù 1⁄2aÆ ̈Ú oa2·aoÙ ÔÓË ÕÚ› ̈Ú ÁÓË

 ̄ÓððË ̃Ù  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­ © ̧a2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ·21  ̈ ̧a

Æaø­±2øæ¥a2a­­ ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈ ·2 øoTM·­·21  ̈ ̧a oaoa2oø2 ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±2­aØ ́a21⁄2a­ ±o ø 1 ́·¥ ̈ß

°¥aøÚ

›± ́Æ ̈­ oÆaØ ́a2 ̈¥ß o·­1⁄2 ́­­ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Ù 2± ̈ 3aÆa¥ß © ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·o æ ́ ̈

© ̧ß  ̧a ±Æ ­ ̧a o·o · ̈Ú Ã ̧·­ ¥ø ̈ ̈aÆ ­±Æ ̈ ±o ç±°·2·±2 ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈å ·­ ±o ̈a2 1⁄2±2­·oaÆao  ̈± æa a2 ̈· ̈¥ao

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 19 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 Ÿa2aÆø¥¥ßÙ çoø1⁄2 ̈ ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈å ·­ oao·2ao ø­ ç©Æ· ̈ ̈a2 ±Æ ±Æø¥ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̈Æø2­3· ̈ ̈ao  ̈± ÔÓ

 ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ø2o Æa1⁄2±Æoao ø­ 1⁄2±2TMaßao æß  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈Ùå © ̧·¥a ç±°·2·±2 ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈å ·­ çø2ß

3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥ Æao¥a1⁄2 ̈·21  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß ̆­ 3a2 ̈ø¥ ·3°Æa­­·±2­Ù ±°·2·±2­Ù 1⁄2±21⁄2¥ ́­·±2­Ù ¶ ́o13a2 ̈­ ±Æ ¥a1ø¥

 ̈ ̧a±Æ·a­Úå ×2 Æa fl2 ̈· ̈Æ ́­ ̈ ŸÆø2o ÷ ́ÆßÙ ËðÎ ⁄ÚÓo ÔÎÎÙ ÔÍÌ  ̄Í ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÔÁËÍ ̃  ̄1⁄2· ̈·21 ÿ·1⁄2μ3ø2 TMÚ

Ãøß¥±ÆÙ ÌÓÁ ÀÚÕÚ ÏÁÎ  ̄ÔÁÏÈ ̃ ̃Ú

 ‹ ́Æ·21 øÆ1 ́3a2 ̈Ù °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ©ø­ ø­μao  ̧±©  ̧a Æa1⁄2±21⁄2·¥ao  ̈ ̧a oø1⁄2 ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧aÆa ÔÌ

a®·­ ̈­ ø æ±oß ±o 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø© Æa1øÆo·21 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ © ̧aÆa ©ø·TMaÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a

°Æ·TM·¥a1a­ ø2o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­ ·­ ø­­ ́3ao ø2o  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßé­ ©±Æμ o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao ° ́æ¥·1⁄2¥ßÚ –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­

1⁄2± ́2­a¥ Æa­°±2oao  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 3±­ ̈ 1⁄2ø­a­ o·­1⁄2 ́­­ ±2¥ß © ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·o ±Æ o·o 2± ̈ o± ø ̈ ø 1⁄2aÆ ̈ø·2  ̈·3aÚ 

Ã ̧·­ a®°¥ø2ø ̈·±2 aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa¥ß 1⁄2±21⁄2aoa­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ © ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·oÙ ·2 ± ̈ ̧aÆ ©±Æo­  ̈ ̧a °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ ±o

1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ©±ÆμÙ ·­ 1⁄2±33±2¥ß o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao ·2 ° ́æ¥·­ ̧ao 1⁄2ø­a­Ú × ̈ ·12±Æa­Ù  ̧±©aTMaÆÙ  ̈ ̧a 2 ́3aÆ± ́­

1⁄2ø­a­ o·­1⁄2 ́­­·21 ±°·2·±2 ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Ú

Óð

 ̈± 1Æaø ̈aÆ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø2 çoø1⁄2 ̈ ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈Úå ÕaaÙ aÚ1ÚÙ ”±Æa2± TMÚ fl ́ ̈±¶±2aÙ ×21⁄2ÚÙ “±Ú ›ÛðÎÛ ÔÓ

ÏÏÌÓ ›ŒfiÙ ÓððË ...‘ ÁðÍÎÔð  ̄“Ú‹Ú ›ø¥Ú fl°ÆÚ ÔÙ ÓððË ̃Ú «a ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ ±°a2¥ß ÆaTM·a© æ± ̈ ̧ μ·2o­ ±o

©±Æμ ·2 ø2ø¥ß¶·21 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3­Ú ⁄±Æ a®ø3°¥aÙ  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ·2 ÔÌ

Õ ̈Æ·1⁄2μ¥ø2o ÆaTM·a©ao 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ç­ ̈Æø ̈a1·1⁄2 1⁄2 ̧±·1⁄2a­å æß ¥±±μ·21 2± ̈ ±2¥ß ø ̈ © ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·o æ ́ ̈

© ̧ø ̈  ̧a  ̈ ̧± ́1 ̧ ̈Ú ÏÍÍ ÀÚÕÚ ø ̈ ÍÁÁÚ fl ÆaTM·a© ±o Æa1⁄2a2 ̈ 1⁄2ø­a­ ­ ̧±©­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈­ oÆaØ ́a2 ̈¥ß

a®ø3·2a 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­  ̈ ̧± ́1 ̧ ̈ °Æ±1⁄2a­­a­  ̈± oa ̈aÆ3·2a © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ oa1⁄2·­·±2­ 3øoa æß 1⁄2± ́2­a¥

1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈ao ¥a1· ̈·3ø ̈a ­ ̈Æø ̈a1ß ±Æ  ́2·2o±Æ3ao 1⁄2 ̧±·1⁄2a­Ú Õaa ‹±a TMÚ ...±±oo±ÆoÙ ÎðË ⁄ÚÌo ÎÍÌÙ ÎÍË

 ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÈ ̃  ̄o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o °ÆaÛ ̈Æ·ø¥ °­ß1⁄2 ̧·ø ̈Æ·1⁄2 a®ø3Â 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ a®°¥ø2ø ̈·±2 ±o oa1⁄2·­·±2  ̈±

ø¥¥±© °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̈± 3øμa ø ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈  ̈± °±¥·1⁄2a ̃Â ”ao¥aß TMÚ Œ ́22a¥­Ù ÎðÍ ⁄ÚÌo ËÎÈÙ ËÍÔ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ

ÓððÈ ̃  ̄o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o æø­·­ o±Æ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßé­ Æa1⁄2±33a2oø ̈·±2  ̈± 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̧a 2± ̈  ̈a­ ̈·oß ̃Ù 1⁄2aÆ ̈Ú

oa2·aoÙ ÔÓË ÕÚ › ̈Ú ÔËÈË  ̄ÓððË ̃Â fiÆ±©2 TMÚ —Æ2±­μ·Ù ÎðÌ ⁄ÚÌo ÔððÍÙ ÔðÔÌ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÈ ̃

 ̄1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ±°·2·±2­ Æa1øÆo·21 æa2ao· ̈­ ±o ·2 ̈Æ±o ́1⁄2·21 °­ß1⁄2 ̧·ø ̈Æ·1⁄2  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß ø ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥Â 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­

·3°Æa­­·±2­ ±o oaoa2oø2 ̈é­ 3a2 ̈ø¥ ­ ̈ø ̈a ø2o  ̧·­ Æaø­±2­ © ̧ß  ̧a o·o ±Æ o·o 2± ̈ ·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈a

3· ̈·1ø ̈·21 aTM·oa21⁄2a ̃Â ›±ÆÆa¥¥ TMÚ Œßø2Ù £££ ⁄ÚÌo £££Ù ÓððË ...‘ ÓðÌÁðÈÏÙ ø ̈ ˆÓÔ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ”øß ÔÏÙ

ÓððË ̃  ̄o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o oaoa2­a 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ ­ ̈Æø ̈a1ßÊ ø ̈ ̈a3° ̈·21  ̈± ­ ̧±©  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø 1±±o °aÆ­±2Â

 ̧a ç©ø­ æø­·1⁄2ø¥¥ß  ̧±°·21 Å ̈ ̧a ¶ ́o1aÃ ©± ́¥o  ̈ ̧·2μ · ̈ ©ø­ ø ±2aÛ ̈·3a ·21⁄2·oa2 ̈ ø2o ©ø2 ̈  ̈± 1·TMa ”ÆÚ

›±ÆÆa¥¥ ø æÆaøμÂå 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·o 2± ̈ oaa¥ ± ̈ ̧aÆ °± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥¥ß 3· ̈·1ø ̈·21 aTM·oa21⁄2aÙ ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ø­ aTM·oa21⁄2a ±o

oÆ ́1 øoo·1⁄2 ̈·±2 ø2o øæ ́­aÙ ©ø­ çoøTM±Æøæ¥aå ̃Â ⁄Æ·aÆ­±2 TMÚ ...±±oo±ÆoÙ ÏÍÌ ⁄ÚÌo ÁËÓÙ ÁËÈ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 20 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 ×2 øoo· ̈·±2Ù ø Æa1⁄2a2 ̈ °Æø1⁄2 ̈·1⁄2a 1 ́·oa ±2 ›ø¥·o±Æ2·ø 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ ¥ø© Æa1⁄2±12·¶a­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ ÔÏ

1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ø2o ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ 3øß æa o·­1⁄2¥±­ao ·o ø oaoa2oø2 ̈ ¥ø ̈aÆ Æø·­a­ ø

1⁄2¥ø·3 ±o ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥Ú Õaa ‘Ú ‘aTMa2­±2Ù ›ø¥·o±Æ2·ø ›Æ·3·2ø¥ –Æ±1⁄2ao ́Æa

y ÔÊÔÓ  ̄ç© ̧a2 ø 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ æÆ·21­ ø2 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ 1⁄2 ̧ø¥¥a21aÙ  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß 3øß

o·­1⁄2¥±­a ·2 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ø2ß 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ 1⁄2±2o·oa21⁄2a­ ø2o ­a1⁄2Æa ̈­ Æa1øÆo·21 Æa¥aTMø2 ̈ 3ø ̈ ̈aÆ­å ̃ ø2o ›±33a2 ̈  ̈±

y ÌðÊÓð  ̄ç”±­ ̈ °a ̈· ̈·±2­ o±Æ ø ©Æ· ̈ ±o  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ ø¥¥a1·21 ·2aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa ø­­·­ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2± ́2­a¥

3 ́­ ̈ æa ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ao æß oa1⁄2¥øÆø ̈·±2­ oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø2o  ̈Æ·ø¥ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥Ú ⁄·¥·21 ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ oa1⁄2¥øÆø ̈·±2­

±Æo·2øÆ·¥ß 1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈a­ ø ©ø·TMaÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1aÚå ̃  ̄ÓððÍ aoÚ ̃Ú ›aÆ ̈ø·2¥ßÙ 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥

oaoa2­a 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ ·2 ›ø¥·o±Æ2·ø  ̧øTMa æaa2 ø2o øÆa ø©øÆa  ̈ ̧ø ̈ °Æ·TM·¥a1ao ø2o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2

3øß æa1⁄2±3a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 ø ̈ ø ¥ø ̈aÆ  ̈·3aÙ °øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥øÆ¥ß ·o ø °a ̈· ̈·±2 o±Æ  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ ·­ o·¥aoÚ

ÓÔ

ÓððÍ ̃  ̄o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o 2± ̈ ±2¥ß © ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥ o·o ø2o o·o 2± ̈ o± æ ́ ̈  ̧·­ Æø ̈·±2ø¥a ø2o ±°·2·±2­ o±Æ

2± ̈ o±·21 1⁄2aÆ ̈ø·2 ·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈·±2­ ø2o o±Æ Æa¥ß·21 ±2 1⁄2aÆ ̈ø·2 aTM·oa21⁄2a ø ̈  ̈ ̧a °a2ø¥ ̈ß ° ̧ø­a ̃Ù øooéo ·2

Æa¥aTMø2 ̈ °øÆ ̈Ù ÓðÓ ⁄aoÚ fl°°®Ú ÔÎÓ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÍ ̃Ù 1⁄2aÆ ̈Ú oa2·aoÙ ÔÓÈ ÕÚ › ̈Ú ÓÁÈÍ  ̄ÓððÈ ̃Â Œaß2±­±

TMÚ Ÿ· ́Ææ·2±Ù ÏÍÓ ⁄ÚÌo ÔðÁÁÙ ÔÔÔÏÛÔÎ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÍ ̃  ̄o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o  ̈Æ·ø¥ 1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­ aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß

 ̧aøÆ·21  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß Æa1øÆo·21  ̧aÆ ­ ̈Æø ̈a1·a­ ̃Ú ‹aoa2­a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß­é 3·­ ́2oaÆ­ ̈ø2o·21 ±o  ̈ ̧a ¥ø© ø2o

·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈·TMa aoo±Æ ̈­ ©aÆa o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao æß  ̈ ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ·2 ...·¥¥·ø3­ TMÚ Ãøß¥±ÆÙ ÎÓÁ ÀÚÕÚ ÌÍÓÙ ÌÁÎ

 ̄Óððð ̃Ú Õaa ø¥­± ‘ø2μo±Æo TMÚ flÆøTMaÙ ÏÍË ⁄ÚÌo ÎÈËÙ ÎËÏÛËÎ  ̄Á ̈ ̧ ›·ÆÚ ÓððÍ ̃  ̄o·­1⁄2 ́­­·±2 ±o

1⁄2± ́2­a¥é­  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß øæ± ́ ̈  ̧·­ ¥a1ø¥ Æa­aøÆ1⁄2 ̧ ±2 ¶ ́Æß ·2­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2­ ̃Ù 1⁄2aÆ ̈Ú oa2·aoÙ ÔÓË ÕÚ › ̈Ú ÓðÍ

 ̄ÓððÈ ̃ÚÔÏ

–a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ °±­· ̈·±2 ø¥­± ·­  ́2oaÆ3·2ao æß  ̧·­ ±©2 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2ø ̈·±2 ±o æ± ̈ ̧ ­±3a oø1⁄2 ̈

ø2o ­±3a ±°·2·±2 ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ ±o  ̧·­  ̈Æ·ø¥ ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß­Ú ⁄±Æ a®ø3°¥aÙ ø ̈ ̈ø1⁄2 ̧ao  ̈±  ̧·­ 3± ̈·±2 o±Æ ø2

aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 øÆa  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈­ ±o ©· ̈2a­­ ·2 ̈aÆTM·a©­ 1⁄2±2o ́1⁄2 ̈ao æß oaoa2­a ·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈±Æ­Ú

¤®­Ú ÿ ø2o ×  ̈± –a ̈éÆé­ —1⁄2 ̈Ú ÔÙ ÓððÌ ”± ̈Ú o±Æ ¤TM·oÚ ÿÆ1Ú –a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø¥­±  ̧ø­ °Æ±TM·oao ø ¥a ̈ ̈aÆ ø2o

oa1⁄2¥øÆø ̈·±2 oÆ±3 ø2 ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aß  ̧·Æao æß °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ oø3·¥ß  ̈± Æa°Æa­a2 ̈  ̧·3Ú Ã ̧aß ·21⁄2¥ ́oa  ̈ ̧ø ̈

ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßé­ ±°·2·±2­Ú ×oÚÙ ¤®Ú œÂ ¤®­Ú –Ù œ  ̈± –a ̈éÆé­ ”øß ÔËÙ ÓððÎ ”± ̈Ú o±Æ ¤TM·oÚ ÿÆ1Ú ‹ ́Æ·21

 ̧·­ ­ ̈ø ̈a  ̧øæaø­ °Æ±1⁄2aao·21Ù °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ °Æ±TM·oao ø oa1⁄2¥øÆø ̈·±2 oÆ±3  ̧·­ o·Æ­ ̈ ø°°±·2 ̈ao ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÙ

fi ́Æ ̈±2 ‘±a ̧ÆÙ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·21⁄2¥ ́oa­ ‘±a ̧Æé­ ·3°Æa­­·±2­ ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ø2o aTMa2 ø oa­1⁄2Æ·° ̈·±2 ±o

1⁄2±33 ́2·1⁄2ø ̈·±2­  ̈± ‘±a ̧Æ oÆ±3 °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÚ ¤®Ú Ì  ̈± ÔÁÁÈ Õ ̈ø ̈a –a ̈· ̈·±2Ù ¥±o1ao  ̧aÆa ±2 fl°ÆÚ ÔÌÙ

ÔÁÁÁÚ

ÒÒÒÒÒ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 21 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

 Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈  ̧ø­ Æa1⁄2±12·¶ao °ÆaTM·± ́­¥ß  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a Æ·­μ ±o  ́­a ±o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ±2 Æa ̈Æ·ø¥ ÔÎ

ÆaØ ́·Æa­ ø 1⁄2aÆ ̈ø·2 ø3± ́2 ̈ ±o 1⁄2±2¶a1⁄2 ̈ ́ÆaÚ Õaa —1⁄2 ̈Ú ÓÓÙ ÓððÈ —ÆoaÆ ø ̈ Î 2ÚÓÚ ÿ±©aTMaÆÙ 1·TMa2  ̈ ̧a

Æ·­μ­  ̈± °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆÙ ø2o  ̈ ̧a ·3°±Æ ̈ø21⁄2a ±o  ̧·­ øæ·¥· ̈ß  ̈± ­aaμ ÆaoÆa­­ o±Æ ø TM·±¥ø ̈·±2 ±o  ̧·­

1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥ Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± 1⁄2± ́2­a¥Ù  ̈ ̧a ­°a1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈·TMa 2ø ̈ ́Æa ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­  ̧øÆ3 ­ ̧± ́¥o 2± ̈ oaoaø ̈  ̧·­

Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ °± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥¥ß  ̧øÆ3o ́¥ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2Ù ­ ́æ¶a1⁄2 ̈  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈é­ 1⁄2øÆao ́¥ 1⁄2±2­·oaÆø ̈·±2 ±o

aø1⁄2 ̧ · ̈a3 ±o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2Ú

ÓÓ

fia1⁄2ø ́­a °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ  ̧ø­ oø·¥ao  ̈± a­ ̈øæ¥·­ ̧ ø æø­·­ o±Æ ø2 ø1⁄2Æ±­­Û ̈ ̧aÛæ±øÆo a®1⁄2a° ̈·±2

 ̈±  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±33±2 ¥ø© Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­ ·2  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2ø­a  ̈± ø¥¥ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 1⁄2±TMaÆao æß  ̈ ̧a ø ̈ ̈±Æ2aßÛ1⁄2¥·a2 ̈

°Æ·TM·¥a1a ±Æ ©±Æμ °Æ±o ́1⁄2 ̈ °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2­Ù  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 3 ́­ ̈ 3øμa ø o·2ø¥ oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2 © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ­±3a

­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ·2  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21 Æa1⁄2±Æo ·­ a2 ̈· ̈¥ao  ̈± °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú Ã ̧a 1⁄2ø­a ¥ø©

o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao øæ±TMa ­a ̈­ ± ́ ̈ ø Æaø­±2øæ¥a ­ ̈ø2oøÆo o±Æ  ̈ ̧ø ̈ oa ̈aÆ3·2ø ̈·±2Ê  ̈ ̧aÆa 3 ́­ ̈ æa ø2

·3°±Æ ̈ø2 ̈ 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈Ú Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ 3 ́­ ̈  ̈ ̧a2 øÆ ̈·1⁄2 ́¥ø ̈a ø oø1⁄2 ̈ ́ø¥ æø­·­ ±o  ̈ ̧a Æaø­±2­ o±Æ

­aø¥·21  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß ±Æ o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈­ °Æa­a2 ̈ao ø ̈  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21Ú Ã ̧ø ̈ oø1⁄2 ̈ ́ø¥ æø­·­ 3øß 2± ̈

æa æø­ao ±2  ̧ß°± ̈ ̧a­·­ ±Æ 1⁄2±2¶a1⁄2 ̈ ́ÆaÚ

Ã ̧a ›± ́Æ ̈ ±o fl°°aø¥­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2·Æ1⁄2 ́· ̈  ̧ø­ o·­1⁄2 ́­­ao  ̈ ̧a 1Æaø ̈ ·3°±Æ ̈ø21⁄2a  ̈± ø

 ̧øæaø­ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ±o ç±æ ̈ø·2·21 ø oø·Æ øo¶ ́o·1⁄2ø ̈·±2 ±o  ̧·­ °a ̈· ̈·±2 ø2o ­a1⁄2 ́Æ·21 ø Æa ̈Æ·ø¥  ́2 ̈ø·2 ̈ao

æß 1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥ aÆÆ±Æ­Úå fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆÙ ÌÌÔ ⁄ÚÌo ø ̈ ÈÓÓÚ ×o ø °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ·­ ­ ́1⁄21⁄2a­­o ́¥  ̧aÆaÙ  ̈ ̧a oaoaÆø¥

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ç­ ̧± ́¥o ø·3  ̈± Æa­ ̈±Æa  ̧·3  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °±­· ̈·±2  ̧a ©± ́¥o  ̧øTMa ±1⁄21⁄2 ́°·aoÙ  ̧øo  ̈ ̧a o·Æ­ ̈  ̈Æ·ø¥ æaa2

1⁄2±2­ ̈· ̈ ́ ̈·±2ø¥¥ß aÆÆ±ÆÛoÆaaÚ Ÿ·TM·21  ̈ ̧a °Æ±­a1⁄2 ́ ̈·±2  ̈ ̧a øoTMø2 ̈ø1a ±o ±æ ̈ø·2·21  ̈ ̧a oaoa2­a 1⁄2ø­a

o·¥aÛø2o °±­­·æ¥ß aTMa2 o±Æ1⁄2·21  ̈ ̧a o·Æ­ ̈ ¥ø©ßaÆ  ̈±  ̈a­ ̈·oß ø1ø·2­ ̈  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2¥·a2 ̈ o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a ­a1⁄2±2o  ̈Æ·ø¥Û

©± ́¥o ø­­ ́Æao¥ß 2± ̈ ° ́ ̈  ̈ ̧a °øÆ ̈·a­ æø1⁄2μ ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ­ø3a ­ ̈øÆ ̈·21 1ø ̈aÚå ×oÚ ø ̈ ÈÓÓÛÓÌÚ Ã ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈

o·2o­  ̈ ̧·­ μ·2o ±o °± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥ o±Æ °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a  ́°±2 Æa ̈Æ·ø¥  ̈± æa  ̈ ̧a ­±Æ ̈ ±o 1⁄2± ́2 ̈aÆTMø·¥·21 ·2 ̈aÆa­ ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈

©a·1 ̧­ ·2 oøTM±Æ ±o °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·21  ̈ ̧a  ́2oaÆ¥ß·21 aTM·oa21⁄2a oÆ±3 ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 TM·a©Ú –Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·21 ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ÔÎ

°± ̈a2 ̈·ø¥¥ß °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2·ø¥ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ©·¥¥ 2øÆÆ±© °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ ©ø·TMaÆÙ ø­ ÆaØ ́·Æao æß  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ·2

fi· ̈ ̈øμaÆÚ ×oÚ ø ̈ ÈÓÓÚ × ̈ ø¥­± Æa1⁄2±12·¶a­ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈  ̈± ø oø·Æ Æa ̈Æ·ø¥Ù ­ ̧± ́¥o  ̧a ±æ ̈ø·2 ±2a ·2

 ̈ ̧a o ́ ̈ ́ÆaÚ ⁄·2ø¥¥ßÙ · ̈ ­ ̈Æ·μa­ ø2 aØ ́· ̈øæ¥a æø¥ø21⁄2a æa ̈©aa2  ̈ ̧a  ́2°Æa1⁄2aoa2 ̈ao æÆ±øo 1⁄2¥±øμ ±o

­a1⁄2Æa1⁄2ß °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ­aaμ­ ø2o  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2é­ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ø1⁄21⁄2a­­  ̈±  ̈ ̧a æø­a­ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a oaoaÆø¥ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈éoa1⁄2·­·±2Û3øμ·21 ·2  ̈ ̧·­ oaø ̈ ̧ °a2ø¥ ̈ß 1⁄2ø­aÚ

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 22 of 23
Ô

Ó

Ì

Ï

Î

Í

È

Ë

Á

Ôð

ÔÔ

ÔÓ

ÔÌ

ÔÏ

ÔÎ

ÔÍ

ÔÈ

ÔË

ÔÁ

Óð

ÓÔ

ÓÓ

ÓÌ

ÓÏ

ÓÎ

ÓÍ

ÓÌ

fl1⁄21⁄2±Æo·21¥ßÙ ø2o 1±±o 1⁄2ø ́­a ø°°aøÆ·21Ù ×Ã ×Õ ÿ¤Œ¤fi« —Œ‹¤Œ¤‹ ø­ o±¥¥±©­Ê

ÔÚ ...· ̈ ̧·2  ̈©a2 ̈ß oøß­ ±o  ̈ ̧a o·¥ao oø ̈a ±o  ̈ ̧·­ ±ÆoaÆÙ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ­ ̧ø¥¥ o·¥a  ́2oaÆ

­aø¥ ø ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈ ·oa2 ̈·oß·21 aø1⁄2 ̧ °±Æ ̈·±2 ±o  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa2 ̈·øÆß  ̧aøÆ·21  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈Ù ø2o aø1⁄2 ̧ °±Æ ̈·±2 ±o

ø2ß a® ̧·æ· ̈­Ù  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ­ ̧± ́¥o Æa3ø·2  ́2oaÆ ­aø¥Ú ×2  ̈ ̧·­ ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈Ù °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ ­ ̧ø¥¥ a®°¥ø·2Ê  ̄ø ̃  ̈ ̧a

Æa¥aTMø21⁄2a ±o  ̈ ̧a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̧a ­aaμ­  ̈± ­aø¥  ̈± ø2 ·­­ ́a © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ 3øß æa Æø·­ao ±2 ø2ß Æa ̈Æ·ø¥Ù

 ̄æ ̃  ̈ ̧a ¥·μa¥· ̧±±o  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ·­­ ́a 3øß æa Æø·­ao ±2 ø2ß Æa ̈Æ·ø¥Ù ø2o  ̄1⁄2 ̃  ̈ ̧a °Æa¶ ́o·1⁄2a  ̧a 1⁄2± ́¥o ­ ́ooaÆ

­ ̧± ́¥o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 æa ÆaTMaø¥aoÚ

ÓÚ ...· ̈ ̧·2  ̈©a2 ̈ß oøß­ ±o  ̈ ̧a o·¥·21 ±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈Ù Æa­°±2oa2 ̈ ­ ̧ø¥¥ o·¥a

ø Æa­°±2­·TMa ­ ̈ø ̈a3a2 ̈Ù ø¥­±  ́2oaÆ ­aø¥Ú

ÌÚ ...· ̈ ̧·2  ̈a2 oøß­ ±o  ̈ ̧a o·¥·21 ±o Æa­°±2oa2 ̈é­ Æa­°±2­aÙ °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆ 3øß o·¥a ø

Æa°¥ßÚ

ÏÚ Ã ̧aÆaøo ̈aÆÙ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ©·¥¥ oa­·12ø ̈a  ̈ ̧±­a °±Æ ̈·±2­ ±o  ̈ ̧a o·2ø¥  ̈Æø2­1⁄2Æ·° ̈ ø2o

a® ̧·æ· ̈­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ­ ̧ø¥¥ Æa3ø·2  ́2oaÆ ­aø¥Ù ø2o ­a ̈ ø °±­ ̈Û ̧aøÆ·21 æÆ·ao·21 ­1⁄2 ̧ao ́¥aÚ fl ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈·3aÙ  ̈ ̧a

1⁄2± ́Æ ̈ ©·¥¥ ·­­ ́a ø °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈·TMa ±ÆoaÆ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a ­aø¥ao ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ©·¥¥Ù ø3±21 ± ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧·21­Ù

­°a1⁄2·oß  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ©·¥¥ æa °Æ± ̈a1⁄2 ̈ao  ̈ ̧Æ± ́1 ̧± ́ ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æ±1⁄2aao·21­ ·21⁄2·oa2 ̈  ̈±  ̈ ̧a °a ̈· ̈·±2

o±Æ ©Æ· ̈ ±o  ̧øæaø­ 1⁄2±Æ° ́­ °a2o·21 æao±Æa  ̈ ̧·­ 1⁄2± ́Æ ̈Ù ø2o  ̈ ̧Æ± ́1 ̧ ø2ß Æa ̈Æ·ø¥ ±o ø¥¥ ±Æ ø2ß °±Æ ̈·±2

±o °a ̈· ̈·±2aÆé­ 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥ 1⁄2ø­aÚ

‹flÃ¤‹Ê ÷ ́2a ÔÌÙ ÓððËÚ 

PDF created with pdfFactory trial version www.pdffactory.com

Case 2:97-cv-00152-KJM-CSK Document 513 Filed 06/13/08 Page 23 of 23