Summarize this: Skip to main content
The Verge homepage

Menu

Menu
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE/TECH
OpenAI’s CEO confirms the company isn’t training GPT-5 and ‘won’t for some time’ / CEO Sam Altman quashed rumors that OpenAI is already developing GPT-5. However, the comments likely won’t be of much consolation to those worried about AI safety.
By JAMES VINCENT

Apr 14, 2023, 12:28 PM GMT6 Comments / 6 New
Share this story



If you buy something from a Verge link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

An image of OpenAI’s logo, which looks like a stylized and symmetrical braid.
Image: OpenAI
In a discussion about threats posed by AI systems, Sam Altman, OpenAI’s CEO and co-founder, has confirmed that the company is not currently training GPT-5, the presumed successor to its AI language model GPT-4, released this March.

Speaking at an event at MIT, Altman was asked about a recent open letter circulated among the tech world that requested that labs like OpenAI pause development of AI systems “more powerful than GPT-4.” The letter highlighted concerns about the safety of future systems but has been criticized by many in the industry, including a number of signatories. Experts disagree about the nature of the threat posed by AI (is it existential or more mundane?) as well as how the industry might go about “pausing” development in the first place.

At MIT, Altman said the letter was “missing most technical nuance about where we need the pause” and noted that an earlier version claimed that OpenAI is currently training GPT-5. “We are not and won’t for some time,” said Altman. “So in that sense it was sort of silly.”

However, just because OpenAI is not working on GPT-5 doesn’t mean it’s not expanding the capabilities of GPT-4 — or, as Altman was keen to stress, considering the safety implications of such work. “We are doing other things on top of GPT-4 that I think have all sorts of safety issues that are important to address and were totally left out of the letter,” he said.

You can watch a video of the exchange below:

GPT hype and the fallacy of version numbers
Altman’s comments are interesting — though not necessarily because of what they reveal about OpenAI’s future plans. Instead, they highlight a significant challenge in the debate about AI safety: the difficulty of measuring and tracking progress. Altman may say that OpenAI is not currently training GPT-5, but that’s not a particularly meaningful statement.

Some of the confusion can be attributed to what I call the fallacy of version numbers: the idea that numbered tech updates reflect definite and linear improvements in capability. It’s a misconception that’s been nurtured in the world of consumer tech for years, where numbers assigned to new phones or operating systems aspire to the rigor of version control but are really just marketing tools. “Well of course the iPhone 35 is better than the iPhone 34,” goes the logic of this system. “The number is bigger ipso facto the phone is better.”

Because of the overlap between the worlds of consumer tech and artificial intelligence, this same logic is now often applied to systems like OpenAI’s language models. This is true not only of the sort of hucksters who post hyperbolic 🤯 Twitter threads 🤯 predicting that superintelligent AI will be here in a matter of years because the numbers keep getting bigger but also of more informed and sophisticated commentators. As a lot of claims made about AI superintelligence are essentially unfalsifiable, these individuals rely on similar rhetoric to get their point across. They draw vague graphs with axes labeled “progress” and “time,” plot a line going up and to the right, and present this uncritically as evidence.

This is not to dismiss fears about AI safety or ignore the fact that these systems are rapidly improving and not fully under our control. But it is to say that there are good arguments and bad arguments, and just because we’ve given a number to something — be that a new phone or the concept of intelligence — doesn’t mean we have the full measure of it.

Instead, I think the focus in these discussions should be on capabilities: on demonstrations of what these systems can and can’t do and predictions of how this may change over time.

That’s why Altman’s confirmation that OpenAI is not currently developing GPT-5 won’t be of any consolation to people worried about AI safety. The company is still expanding the potential of GPT-4 (by connecting it to the internet, for example), and others in the industry are building similarly ambitious tools, letting AI systems act on behalf of users. There’s also all sorts of work that is no doubt being done to optimize GPT-4, and OpenAI may release GPT-4.5 (as it did GPT-3.5) first — another way that version numbers can mislead.

Even if the world’s governments were somehow able to enforce a ban on new AI developments, it’s clear that society has its hands full with the systems currently available. Sure, GPT-5 isn’t coming yet, but does it matter when GPT-4 is still not fully understood?


6 COMMENTS6 NEW
More from Artificial Intelligence
An image showing a repeating pattern of brain illustrations
Amazon offers free access to its AI coding assistant to undercut Microsoft
A screenshot of iMessage.
A data scientist cloned his best friends’ group chat using AI
A Bing logo.
You can now talk to Microsoft’s Bing chatbot from your keyboard in iOS with SwiftKey
SPONSORED CONTENT
Belly Fat Removal In 2023 Might Be Cheaper Than You Think! See Now
Belly Fat Removal In 2023 Might Be Cheaper Than You Think! See Now
Belly Fat Removal Mexico | Sponsored
This Is What Belly Fat Removal Treatment Might Cost You!
This Is What Belly Fat Removal Treatment Might Cost You!
Search Ads
Why are houses in Dubai so cheap? (Just look)
Why are houses in Dubai so cheap? (Just look)
Dubai Apartments | Sponsored
Last Week Highlights
07/04 FRI
Samsung’s having a terrible financial yearSamsung’s having a terrible financial year
Substack had negative revenueSubstack had negative revenue
Three new Star Wars movies are on the wayThree new Star Wars movies are on the way
14/04 FRI
First look at Cybertruck’s comically large windshield wiper in actionFirst look at Cybertruck’s comically large windshield wiper in action
The Fox News defamation case might be almost as entertaining as SuccessionThe Fox News defamation case might be almost as entertaining as Succession
Twitter Blue subscribers now have a 10,000 character limitTwitter Blue subscribers now have a 10,000 character limit
13/04 THU
This is the best time in a decade to splurge on a premium OLED TVThis is the best time in a decade to splurge on a premium OLED TV
PBS also stops tweeting after being hit with “government-funded media” labelPBS also stops tweeting after being hit with “government-funded media” label
A data scientist cloned his best friends’ group chat using AIA data scientist cloned his best friends’ group chat using AI
12/04 WED
Harry Potter is getting a 10-year-long TV series on MaxHarry Potter is getting a 10-year-long TV series on Max
Game of Thrones is getting another prequel, and its plot sounds very familiarGame of Thrones is getting another prequel, and its plot sounds very familiar
Max is charging more money for 4K, and that means it can’t suck this timeMax is charging more money for 4K, and that means it can’t suck this time
11/04 TUE
Uber will fund an e-bike buy-back program to help combat battery firesUber will fund an e-bike buy-back program to help combat battery fires
Sony is gearing up for a new cloud gaming push amid rumors of a PlayStation handheldSony is gearing up for a new cloud gaming push amid rumors of a PlayStation handheld
E3 is canceled, but Nintendo Live is coming to the US in SeptemberE3 is canceled, but Nintendo Live is coming to the US in September
10/04 MON
Bitcoin’s insatiable appetite for energy is driving up pollution and costs for Americans, report findsBitcoin’s insatiable appetite for energy is driving up pollution and costs for Americans, report finds
Florida Mayhem won the first Overwatch League pro-am tournament, but the amateurs were the bigger winnersFlorida Mayhem won the first Overwatch League pro-am tournament, but the amateurs were the bigger winners
Domino’s now lets you order pizza via Apple CarPlayDomino’s now lets you order pizza via Apple CarPlay
08/04 SAT
Dell XPS 13 review: Dell is coasting (and that’s fine)Dell XPS 13 review: Dell is coasting (and that’s fine)
Apple’s latest AirPods Pro have hit their all-time low at AmazonApple’s latest AirPods Pro have hit their all-time low at Amazon
Have a Nice Death is a punishing roguelike with a dark sense of humorHave a Nice Death is a punishing roguelike with a dark sense of humor
07/04 FRI
Samsung’s having a terrible financial yearSamsung’s having a terrible financial year
Substack had negative revenueSubstack had negative revenue
Three new Star Wars movies are on the wayThree new Star Wars movies are on the way
14/04 FRI
First look at Cybertruck’s comically large windshield wiper in actionFirst look at Cybertruck’s comically large windshield wiper in action
The Fox News defamation case might be almost as entertaining as SuccessionThe Fox News defamation case might be almost as entertaining as Succession
Twitter Blue subscribers now have a 10,000 character limitTwitter Blue subscribers now have a 10,000 character limit
Recommended by
TERMS OF USE
PRIVACY NOTICE
COOKIE POLICY
DO NOT SELL OR SHARE MY PERSONAL INFO
LICENSING FAQ
ACCESSIBILITY
PLATFORM STATUS
HOW WE RATE AND REVIEW PRODUCTS
CONTACT
TIP US
COMMUNITY GUIDELINES
ABOUT
ETHICS STATEMENT
THE VERGE IS A VOX MEDIA NETWORK

ADVERTISE WITH US
JOBS @ VOX MEDIA
© 2023 VOX MEDIA, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED