You%20are%20an%20expert%20researcher%20specializing%20in%20turning%20complex%20documents%20into%20simple%20executive%20summaries:%20taking%20the%20most%20interesting%20findings%20and%20presenting%20them%20in%20a%20way%20that%20any%20reader%20can%20take%20away%20value.%20Your%20summaries%20should%20always%20draw%20from%20data%20presented%20in%20the%20documents%20I%20show%20you,%20focusing%20on%20accuracy%20and%20simplicity.%20Please%20read%20the%20attached%20document%20carefully,%20and%20summarize%20it%20in%20the%20format%20of%20an%20Executive%20Summary:%20focusing%20on%20the%20most%20interesting%20findings%20and%20ensuring%20that%20they%20are%20accessible%20to%20any%20reader.%20Please%20highlight%20any%20important%20statistics,%20and%20interpret%20the%20main%20conclusions%20of%20the%20report.%0AText:%0A%23%23%23%23%0A%3Ciframe%20src%3D%22https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html%3Fid%3DGTM-NLXNPCQ%22%20height%3D%220%22%20width%3D%220%22%20style%3D%22display:none;visibility:hidden%22%3E%3C/iframe%3E%0ASkip%20to%20content%0A%0AARS%20TECHNICA%20HOME%0A%0A%0A%0A%0ATHEME%0A%0A%0ASIGN%20IN%0A%0A%22THERE%20IS%20NOTHING%20GOOGLE%20CAN%20DO%22%0AGoogle%20has%20no%20duty%20to%20refund%20gift%20card%20scam%20victims,%20judge%20finds%0AFTC%20has%20estimated%20that%20a%20large%20chunk%20of%20gift%20card%20scams%20target%20Google%20Play%20users.%0AASHLEY%20BELANGER%20%E2%80%93%20NOV%205,%202024%203:58%20PM%20%7C%2045%0A%0A%0ACredit:%20Jeff%20Greenberg%20/%20Contributor%20%7C%20Universal%20Images%20Group%0A%0ATEXT%20SETTINGS%0A%0AThere's%20nothing%20unfair%20about%20Google%20collecting%20fees%20to%20profit%20off%20Google%20Play%20gift%20card%20scams%20while%20refusing%20to%20refund%20victims%20who%20collectively%20lost%20millions,%20federal%20Judge%20Beth%20Freeman%20ruled%20Monday.%0ALargely%20granting%20Google's%20motion%20to%20dismiss%20a%20proposed%20class-action%20suit%20seeking%20substantial%20damages%20for%20a%20range%20of%20allegedly%20unfair%20practices,%20Freeman%20found%20that%20Google%20is%20shielded%20from%20liability%20because%20the%20tech%20giant%20did%20not%20induce%20victims%20to%20purchase%20the%20gift%20cards%E2%80%94scammers%20did.%0AThe%20lawsuit%20was%20filed%20by%20Judy%20May,%20who%20lost%20$1,000%20in%202021%20when%20scammers%20tricked%20her%20into%20buying%20Google%20Play%20gift%20cards%20by%20claiming%20she%20was%20eligible%20for%20a%20government%20grant.%20May%20was%20told%20she%20could%20send%20codes%20from%20the%20gift%20cards%20to%20cover%20%22certain%20costs%20upfront%20to%20receive%20same-day%20delivery%20of%20the%20grant%20money.%22%20After%20she%20fell%20for%20it,%20she%20realized%20she'd%20been%20scammed,%20but%20Google%20refused%20to%20provide%20a%20refund,%20citing%20terms%20May%20considered%20%22unconscionable.%22%0AMay%20claimed%20that%20Google%20knows%20that%20its%20gift%20cards%20are%20a%20preferred%20way%20for%20scammers%20to%20steal%20funds%20and%20should%20put%20warnings%20on%20gift%20cards%20alerting%20customers%20to%20common%20scams.%20Her%20complaint%20noted%20that%20gift%20card%20scams%20are%20underreported,%20while%20citing%20Federal%20Trade%20Commission%20data%20finding%20that%20Google%20Play%20gift%20card%20scams%20accounted%20for%2020%20percent%20of%20reported%20gift%20card%20scams%20between%202018%E2%80%932021%20and%20triggered%20more%20than%20$17%20million%20in%20losses.%0AGoogle%20takes%20a%2015%20to%2030%20percent%20commission%20when%20gift%20cards%20are%20used%20to%20make%20purchases%20in%20the%20Play%20Store,%20May's%20complaint%20said.%20In%20that%20way,%20Google%20allegedly%20profits%20off%20scams%20while%20telling%20customers%20%22there%20is%20nothing%20Google%20can%20do%22%E2%80%94downplaying%20the%20fact%20that%20Google%20had%20the%20%22technical%20means%20to%20track%20transactional%20information%20related%20to%20the%20Google%20Play%20gift%20cards.%22%0A%0A%0ABut%20Freeman%20ruled%20that%20%22May%20suffered%20economic%20harm%20because%20of%20third-party%20scammers%E2%80%99%20fraudulent%20inducement,%20not%20Google%E2%80%99s%20omission%20or%20misrepresentation.%22%0AAdditionally,%20May%20failed%20to%20show%20that%20Google%20had%20any%20duty%20to%20refund%20customers%20after%20Google%20cited%20Target%20and%20Walmart%20policies%20to%20show%20that%20it's%20common%20to%20refuse%20refunds.%0AScam%20victims%20did%20not%20use%20gift%20card%20%E2%80%9Cas%20designed%E2%80%9D%0AFreeman%20mostly%20sided%20with%20Google,%20deciding%20that%20the%20company%20engaged%20in%20no%20unfair%20practices,%20while%20noting%20that%20May%20had%20not%20used%20the%20gift%20cards%20%22in%20their%20designed%20way.%22%20The%20judge%20also%20agreed%20with%20Google%20that%20May's%20funds%20were%20not%20considered%20stolen%20at%20the%20time%20she%20purchased%20the%20gift%20cards,%20because%20May%20still%20controlled%20the%20funds%20at%20that%20point%20in%20time.%0AAdditionally,%20May's%20attempt%20to%20argue%20that%20Google%20has%20the%20technology%20to%20detect%20scams%20failed,%20Freeman%20wrote,%20because%20May%20couldn't%20prove%20that%20Google%20deployed%20that%20technology%20when%20her%20particular%20scam%20purchases%20were%20made.%20Even%20after%20May%20argued%20that%20she%20reported%20the%20theft%20to%20Google,%20Freeman%20wrote,%20May's%20complaint%20failed%20because%20%22there%20is%20no%20allegation%20that%20Google%20had%20a%20duty%20to%20investigate%20her%20report.%22%0AUltimately,%20May's%20complaint%20%22identifies%20no%20public%20policy%20suggesting%20Google%20has%20a%20duty%20to%20refund%20the%20scammed%20victims%20or%20that%20the%20harm%20of%20Google%E2%80%99s%20conduct%20outweighs%20any%20benefits,%22%20Freeman%20concluded.%0AIn%20her%20order,%20Freeman%20provided%20leave%20to%20amend%20some%20claims%20in%20the%20next%2045%20days,%20but%20Ars%20could%20not%20immediately%20reach%20May's%20lawyer%20to%20confirm%20if%20the%20complaint%20would%20likely%20be%20amended.%20However,%20the%20judge%20notably%20dismissed%20a%20claim%20seeking%20triple%20damages%20because%20May's%20complaint%20%22failed%20to%20show%20a%20likelihood%20that%20May%20will%20be%20a%20victim%20of%20gift%20card%20scams%20again%20given%20her%20awareness%20of%20such%20scams,%22%20which%20may%20deflate%20May's%20interests%20to%20amend.%0AThat%20particular%20part%20of%20the%20ruling%20may%20be%20especially%20frustrating%20for%20May,%20whose%20complaint%20was%20sparked%20by%20a%20claim%20that%20she%20never%20would%20have%20been%20victimized%20if%20Google%20had%20provided%20adequate%20warnings%20of%20scams.%0AGoogle%20did%20not%20immediately%20respond%20to%20Ars'%20request%20to%20comment.%0A%0A%0AASHLEY%20BELANGER%0ASENIOR%20POLICY%20REPORTER%0AAshley%20is%20a%20senior%20policy%20reporter%20for%20Ars%20Technica,%20dedicated%20to%20tracking%20social%20impacts%20of%20emerging%20policies%20and%20new%20technologies.%20She%20is%20a%20Chicago-based%20journalist%20with%2020%20years%20of%20experience.%0A%0A45%20COMMENTS%0A%0A%0APREV%20STORY%0ANEXT%20STORY%0A%0A%0AMOST%20READ%0A%09%091.%E2%80%A8Drugmaker%20shut%20down%20after%20black%20schmutz%20found%20in%20injectable%20weight-loss%20drug%E2%80%A8%0A%09%09%E2%80%A82.%E2%80%A8After%2031%20cargo%20missions,%20NASA%20finds%20Dragon%20still%20has%20some%20new%20tricks%E2%80%A8%0A%09%09%E2%80%A83.%E2%80%A8China%E2%80%99s%20long-term%20lunar%20plans%20now%20depend%20on%20developing%20its%20own%20Starship%E2%80%A8%0A%09%09%E2%80%A84.%E2%80%A8Guy%20makes%20%E2%80%9Cdodgy%20e-bike%E2%80%9D%20from%20130%20used%20vapes%20to%20make%20point%20about%20e-waste%E2%80%A8%0A%09%09%E2%80%A85.%E2%80%A8Hundreds%20of%20code%20libraries%20posted%20to%20NPM%20try%20to%20install%20malware%20on%20dev%20machines%E2%80%A8%0A%0A%0AArs%20Technica%20has%20been%20separating%20the%20signal%20from%20the%20noise%20for%20over%2025%20years.%20With%20our%20unique%20combination%20of%20technical%20savvy%20and%20wide-ranging%20interest%20in%20the%20technological%20arts%20and%20sciences,%20Ars%20is%20the%20trusted%20source%20in%20a%20sea%20of%20information.%20After%20all,%20you%20don%E2%80%99t%20need%20to%20know%20everything,%20only%20what%E2%80%99s%20important.%0A%0AMORE%20FROM%20ARS%0A%09%09ABOUT%20US%0A%09%09STAFF%20DIRECTORY%0A%09%09NEWSLETTERS%0A%09%09ARS%20VIDEOS%0A%09%09GENERAL%20FAQ%0A%09%09RSS%20FEEDS%0ACONTACT%0A%09%09CONTACT%20US%0A%09%09ADVERTISE%20WITH%20US%0A%09%09REPRINTS%0A%0ADO%20NOT%20SELL%20MY%20PERSONAL%20INFORMATION%0A%C2%A9%202024%20Cond%C3%A9%20Nast.%20All%20rights%20reserved.%20Use%20of%20and/or%20registration%20on%20any%20portion%20of%20this%20site%20constitutes%20acceptance%20of%20our%20User%20Agreement%20and%20Privacy%20Policy%20and%20Cookie%20Statement%20and%20Ars%20Technica%20Addendum%20and%20Your%20California%20Privacy%20Rights.%20Ars%20Technica%20may%20earn%20compensation%20on%20sales%20from%20links%20on%20this%20site.%20Read%20our%20affiliate%20link%20policy.%20The%20material%20on%20this%20site%20may%20not%20be%20reproduced,%20distributed,%20transmitted,%20cached%20or%20otherwise%20used,%20except%20with%20the%20prior%20written%20permission%20of%20Cond%C3%A9%20Nast.%20Ad%20Choices%0A%0A%23%23%23%23