Please%20read%20the%20text%20carefully.%20Identify%20the%20main%20topic%20and%20key%20points%20covered%20in%20the%20text.%20%0AWrite%20a%20concise%20summary%20of%20the%20text%20in%20exactly%203%20bullets%20in%20markdown,%20focusing%20solely%20on%20the%20main%20topic%20and%20key%20points%20you%20identified.%20Your%20output%20should%20contain%20only%20the%20summary%20text%20itself.%20Do%20not%20include%20any%20explanations,%20introduction,%20or%20other%20extraneous%20text%20like%20%22%20Here%20is%20a%20concise%20summary...%22.%20The%20summary%20should%20be%20able%20to%20stand%20alone.%20%0AHere%20is%20the%20text%20to%20summarize:%0A%3Ctext%3E%0ASkip%20to%20main%20content%0A%0A%0A%0A%0AAll%20About%20Space%20Magazine%0AWhy%20subscribe%3F%0A%09%09Jam%20packed%20issues%20filled%20with%20the%20latest%20cutting-edge%20research,%20technology%20and%20theories%20delivered%20in%20an%20entertaining%20and%20visually%20stunning%20way,%20aiming%20to%20educate%20and%20inspire%20readers%20of%20all%20ages%0A%09%09Engaging%20articles,%20breathtaking%20images%20and%20expert%20knowledge%0A%09%09Issues%20delivered%20straight%20to%20your%20door%0AFrom%0A$28.75%0AVIEW%0A%0A%0ATRENDING%0A%09%09SpaceX%20Starship%20Flight%206%20Video%0A%09%09Aurora%20Forecast%0A%09%09Best%20Telescopes%0A%09%09Night%20sky%20tonight!%0A%09%09Next%20Full%20Moon%0A%09%09Best%20Binoculars%0A%09%09Best%20Star%20Projectors%0A%09%09Space%20Calendar%0A%09%09Lego%20Star%20Wars%20deals%0A%09%09Best%20Drones%0A%09%09Solar%20System%20Planets%0A%09%09Night%20Sky%20Tonight%0A%0A%0A%0A%09%09Space%20Exploration%20Missions%20Mars%20Rovers%0ADid%20NASA's%20Perseverance%20rover%20find%20organics%20on%20Mars%3F%20These%20scientists%20aren't%20so%20sure%0ANews%0ABy%20Victoria%20Corless%20published%2020%20November%202024%0AA%20groundbreaking%20find%20on%20Mars%20sparks%20debate%20among%20scientists%20%E2%80%94%20could%20these%20organic%20molecules%20be%20a%20clue%20to%20life%20on%20the%20Red%20Planet%20or%20something%20else%3F%0A%09%09%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8Comments%20(0)%0AWhen%20you%20purchase%20through%20links%20on%20our%20site,%20we%20may%20earn%20an%20affiliate%20commission.%20Here%E2%80%99s%20how%20it%20works.%0A%0A(Image%20credit:%20NASA)%0A%0AThe%20quest%20to%20find%20life%20beyond%20our%20planet%20has%20captivated%20humanity%20for%20decades,%20driving%20missions%20that%20continue%20to%20push%20deeper%20into%20the%20solar%20system.%20Last%20summer,%20NASA%E2%80%99s%20Perseverance%20rover%20made%20a%20groundbreaking%20discovery%20on%20Mars%20when%20it%20detected%20carbon-based%20molecules,%20known%20as%20organics,%20that%20many%20scientists%20believe%20could%20hint%20at%20the%20possible%20presence%20of%20ancient%20extraterrestrial%20life.%0A%0AThe%20finding%20has%20fueled%20excitement%20and%20debate%20within%20the%20scientific%20community,%20as%20it%20brings%20us%20closer%20to%20answering%20the%20age-old%20question%20of%20whether%20life%20ever%20existed%20%E2%80%94%20or%20maybe%20still%20does%20%E2%80%94%20on%20the%20Red%20Planet.%0AHowever,%20there%20may%20be%20a%20bit%20of%20a%20caveat:%20Scientists%20can't%20be%20sure%20that%20the%20signals%20are%20100%25%20attributable%20to%20organic%20molecules.%20Though,%20for%20many,%20the%20possibility%20is%20likely,%20it%E2%80%99s%20not%20the%20only%20explanation,%20and%20the%20uncertainty%20comes%20down%20to%20the%20rover's%20instruments%20%E2%80%94%20they%20can%20provide%20strong%20indications%20and%20gather%20valuable%20data,%20but%20they%20are%20not%20as%20comprehensive%20as%20Earth-based%20laboratories.%0A%0A%0A%0AFor%20some%20background,%20Perseverance%20made%20the%20find%20using%20an%20advanced%20instrument%20called%20SHERLOC%20(Scanning%20Habitable%20Environments%20with%20Raman%20and%20Luminescence%20for%20Organics%20and%20Chemicals),%20which%20is%20designed%20to%20hunt%20for%20organic%20molecules.%0AYOU%20MAY%20LIKE%0A%09%E2%80%A2%09NASA's%20Perseverance%20rover%20finds%20organic%20chemicals%20on%20Mars%0A%09%E2%80%A2%09Possible%20sign%20of%20Mars%20life%3F%20Curiosity%20rover%20finds%20'tantalizing'%20Red%20Planet%20organics%0ARelated:%20NASA's%20Perseverance%20rover%20begins%20ambitious%20ascent%20up%20a%20Mars%20crater%20rim%0A%0A%22The%20SHERLOC%20instrument%20is%20our%20premier%20tool%20for%20detecting%20organic%20matter,%22%20Ken%20Farley,%20project%20scientist%20for%20the%20Perseverance%20rover%20mission,%20told%20Space.com.%20%22It's%20really%20the%20only%20instrument%20that%20we%20think%20has%20a%20reasonable%20chance%20of%20finding%20organic%20matter%20at%20the%20concentrations%20that%20are%20likely%20present.%22%0ASHERLOC%20relies%20on%20two%20primary%20techniques:%20deep%20ultraviolet%20luminescence%20and%20Raman%20spectrometry.%20%22SHERLOC's%20luminescence%20mode%20produces%20a%20very%20high%20signal%20per%20unit%20amount%20of%20certain%20organic%20molecules,%20but%20it%20is%20not%20especially%20diagnostic,%22%20said%20Farley.%0AGet%20the%20Space.com%20Newsletter%0A%0A%0AContact%20me%20with%20news%20and%20offers%20from%20other%20Future%20brands%0A%0AReceive%20email%20from%20us%20on%20behalf%20of%20our%20trusted%20partners%20or%20sponsors%0ABy%20submitting%20your%20information%20you%20agree%20to%20the%20Terms%20%26%20Conditions%20and%20Privacy%20Policy%20and%20are%20aged%2016%20or%20over.%0ALuminescence%20is%20the%20process%20by%20which%20a%20substance%20emits%20light%20as%20a%20result%20of%20absorbing%20energy%20%E2%80%94%20without%20exhibiting%20an%20increase%20in%20temperature.%20There%20are%20many%20examples%20of%20this,%20ranging%20from%20neon%20lights%20to%20fire%20flies.%20But%20onboard%20the%20Mars%20rover,%20SHERLOC%20takes%20advantage%20of%20this%20phenomenon%20to%20help%20identify%20the%20presence%20of%20different%20organic%20compounds.%0ABut%20there%20is%20a%20catch:%20%22Many,%20many%20things%20luminesce%20%E2%80%94%20there%20are%20other%20things%20that%20do%20that%20besides%20organic%20matter,%22%20said%20Farley.%20%22It's%20related%20to%20subtle%20characteristics%20of%20the%20chemical%20composition%20of%20the%20materials.%22%0AThis%20is%20where%20SHERLOC's%20Raman%20mode%20comes%20in.%20%22It%E2%80%99s%20much%20less%20sensitive,%20but%20a%20much%20better%20fingerprint,%22%20Farley%20said.%20Raman%20spectroscopy%20is%20a%20technique%20common%20to%20most%20chemistry%20labs,%20where%20the%20vibrational%20modes%20of%20molecular%20bonds%20can%20be%20measured%20in%20order%20to%20glean%20information%20about%20a%20molecule's%20chemical%20structure.%0A%22There%20are%20patterns%20of%20peaks%20in%20a%20Raman%20spectrum,%20and%20you%20can%20relate%20them%20to%20specific%20types%20of%20organic%20molecules,%22%20explained%20Farley.%20%22But%20it's%20a%20trade%20off.%22%0AWith%20both%20instruments,%20Farley%20believes%20there's%20a%20chance%20of%20detecting%20false%20positives.%20%22You%20might%20draw%20the%20positive%20conclusion%20without%20recognizing%20that%20there%20are%20alternative%20interpretations,%22%20he%20explained.%0ACould%20Percy%20have%20found%20something%20else%3F%0APerseverance%20was%20tasked%20with%20collecting%20and%20analyzing%20samples%20from%20Mars'%20Jezero%20Crater,%20chosen%20for%20its%20history%20as%20an%20ancient%20open-system%20lake%20approximately%203.5%20billion%20years%20ago.%20On%20Earth,%20similar%20environments%20often%20show%20signs%20of%20ancient%20microbial%20life,%20making%20Jezero%20a%20prime%20target%20for%20investigating%20potential%20past%20life.%0AUsing%20its%20SHERLOC%20instrument,%20the%20rover%20detected%20luminescence%20signals%20that%20initially%20suggested%20the%20presence%20of%20organic%20molecules.%20A%20paper%20published%20in%20the%20journal%20Nature%20reported%20these%20findings,%20indicating%20diverse%20aromatic%20molecules%20on%20the%20Martian%20surface%20that%20persist%20despite%20harsh%20conditions.%0AA%20year%20later,%20a%20study%20in%20Science%20Advances%20offered%20an%20alternative%20explanation,%20suggesting%20that%20the%20signals%20thought%20to%20indicate%20organics%20could%20instead%20come%20from%20inorganic%20materials,%20specifically%20cesium%20ions%20(Ce3+)%20in%20phosphate%20and%20silicate%20defects%20from%20ancient%20magma%20flows.%0A%22Multiple%20chemicals%20can%20give%20rise%20to%20these%20same%20spectral%20features,%22%20explained%20Eva%20Scheller,%20a%20planetary%20scientist%20at%20the%20Massachusetts%20Institute%20of%20Technology%20(MIT)%20and%20corresponding%20author%20of%20the%20recent%20study%20as%20well%20as%20a%20contributing%20author%20on%20the%20original%20Nature%20paper.%20%22In%20spectroscopy,%20we%20call%20this%20a%20degeneracy,%20%5Band%20it's%5D%20a%20very%20common%20challenge%20when%20trying%20to%20interpret%20spectra.%22%0ADegeneracy%20often%20makes%20interpreting%20these%20results%20impossible,%20according%20to%20Scheller,%20and%20in%20less%20critical%20cases,%20many%20scientists%20would%20typically%20leave%20the%20data%20uninterpreted.%20However,%20the%20stakes%20for%20the%20Perseverance%20team%20means%20there%20will%20be%20an%20ongoing%20push%20to%20try%20and%20interpret%20the%20data%20despite%20the%20challenges.%0A%22Previous%20studies%20noted%20that%20the%20spectra%20are%20consistent%20in%20appearance%20with%20the%20luminescence%20profile%20of%201-%20and%202-ring%20aromatics,%20this%20is%20true,%22%20said%20Scheller,%20referring%20to%20specific%20organic%20molecules%20made%20of%20one%20or%20two%20connected%20carbon%20rings.%20Aromatic%20molecules%20are%20unique%20because%20their%20structures%20include%20stable,%20ring-shaped%20formations%20with%20alternating%20single%20and%20double%20bonds,%20known%20as%20conjugated%20bonds.%20These%20molecules%20are%20significant%20because%20they%20can%20be%20found%20in%20biological%20compounds,%20such%20as%20amino%20acids%20and%20pigments.%20However,%20while%20the%20detection%20of%20such%20molecules%20is%20intriguing,%20it%20doesn't%20guarantee%20biological%20origin.%20%22And%20it%20does%20not%20mean%20much%20if%20the%20data%20is%20degenerate,%22%20added%20Scheller.%0AFarley%20and%20Scheller%20both%20point%20out%20that%20the%20original%20paper%20does%20note%20this%20as%20a%20possibility,%20and%20does%20also%20mention%20the%20possibility%20of%20Ce3+%20and%20defect%20inorganics%20as%20alternative%20explanations.%20%22They%20were%20presented%20among%20a%20menu%20of%20possible%20interpretations,%22%20said%20Farley.%0AThough%20it%20was%20determined%20that%20the%20presence%20of%20aromatic%20organics%20would%20be%20more%20likely,%20Scheller%20argues%20that%20this%20could%20come%20down%20to%20scientists'%20biases%20and%20fields%20of%20expertise.%0A%0AA%20close-up%20view%20of%20an%20engineering%20model%20of%20SHERLOC%20(Scanning%20Habitable%20Environments%20with%20Raman%20%26%20Luminescence%20for%20Organics%20%26%20Chemicals)%20(Image%20credit:%20NASA/JPL-Caltech)%0ADealing%20with%20uncertainty%0AOn%20Earth,%20ambiguous%20results%20like%20these%20can%20often%20be%20clarified%20by%20using%20different%20analyses%20to%20corroborate%20the%20findings.%20However,%20conducting%20experiments%20on%20Mars%20is%20much%20more%20challenging.%0AThere%20is%20limited%20capacity%20to%20send%20bulky%20instruments%20on%20a%20rover%20that%20needs%20to%20travel%20between%20planets.%20As%20a%20result,%20equipment%20must%20be%20miniaturized%20and%20made%20mobile,%20all%20while%20operating%20in%20an%20extreme%20and%20unpredictable%20environment.%20Unlike%20Earth,%20where%20conditions%20can%20be%20controlled%20and%20instruments%20are%20highly%20sensitive%20and%20accessible,%20Mars%20presents%20harsh%20temperatures,%20dust%20storms,%20radiation%20and%20limited%20resources.%20These%20factors%20complicate%20precise%20analysis%20and%20introduce%20uncertainties,%20making%20it%20difficult%20to%20draw%20definitive%20conclusions%20from%20the%20data.%0A%22This%20is%20the%20point%20of%20the%20whole%20sample%20return%20proposal,%22%20said%20Scheller.%20This%20would%20also%20allow%20the%20scientists%20to%20better%20understand%20the%20origins%20of%20any%20organic%20molecules,%20should%20it%20be%20determined%20they%20are%20present%20in%20the%20Jezero%20Crater.%0ABut%20both%20Farley%20and%20Scheller%20are%20quick%20to%20point%20out%20that%20even%20if%20organic%20molecules%20are%20present,%20this%20doesn't%20mean%20they%20are%20a%20potential%20sign%20of%20life.%20%22I%20don%E2%80%99t%20think%20anyone%20on%20the%20team%20%E2%80%94%20even%20the%20ones%20strongly%20proposing%20an%20organic%20origin%20for%20the%20luminescence%20signals%20%E2%80%94%20would%20argue%20that%20luminescing%201-%20or%202-ring%20aromatic%20organics%20could%20be%20a%20potential%20sign%20of%20life,%22%20said%20Scheller.%0A%22To%20be%20able%20to%20differentiate%20abiotic%20types%20of%20organic%20chemistries%20%5Bthose%20created%20through%20non-biological%20processes%5D%20from%20life%20you%20need%20really%20sophisticated%20laboratory%20techniques%20utilizing%20highly%20detailed%20characterization%20methods%E2%80%94and%20you%20cannot%20do%20this%20with%20a%20miniature%20spacecraft%20instrument%20adapted%20to%20extreme%20environments,%E2%80%9D%20she%20added.%20%22In%20%5Bour%20papers%5D,%20we%20are%20simply%20showing%20that%20we're%20struggling%20to%20confirm%20or%20rule%20out%20the%20presence%20of%20basic%20abiotic%20organic%20molecules%20using%20SHERLOC.%22%0AFarley%20emphasizes%20that,%20while%20the%20back-and-forth%20may%20seem%20like%20disagreements%20among%20scientists,%20it%20is%20actually%20a%20vital%20and%20inherent%20part%20of%20the%20scientific%20process.%0A%22This%20is%20error%20correction,%20and%20it's%20the%20way%20the%20scientific%20process%20has%20to%20work,%22%20he%20said.%20%22%5BAs%20a%20scientist%5D,%20one%20needs%20to%20be%20open%20to%20that%20possibility%20that%20they%20may%20be%20wrong%20and%20not%20fight%20it.%0A%22If%20you%20accept%20that%20if%20you%20put%20your%20arguments%20out%20there%20and%20somebody%20finds%20a%20better%20interpretation%20and%20you%20look%20at%20it%20and%20you%20agree,%20then%20science%20corrects%20itself%20%E2%80%94%20that%E2%80%99s%20just%20the%20nature%20of%20the%20beast,%20that%20knowledge%20evolves%20and%20that%E2%80%99s%20a%20good%20thing.%E2%80%9D%0AJoin%20our%20Space%20Forums%20to%20keep%20talking%20space%20on%20the%20latest%20missions,%20night%20sky%20and%20more!%20And%20if%20you%20have%20a%20news%20tip,%20correction%20or%20comment,%20let%20us%20know%20at:%<PRESIDIO_ANONYMIZED_EMAIL_ADDRESS>.%0ASEE%20ALL%20COMMENTS%20(0)%0A%0A%0AVictoria%20Corless%0A%0AContributing%20Writer%0AA%20chemist%20turned%20science%20writer,%20Victoria%20Corless%20completed%20her%20Ph.D.%20in%20organic%20synthesis%20at%20the%20University%20of%20Toronto%20and,%20ever%20the%20clich%C3%A9,%20realized%20lab%20work%20was%20not%20something%20she%20wanted%20to%20do%20for%20the%20rest%20of%20her%20days.%C2%A0After%20dabbling%20in%20science%20writing%20and%20a%20brief%20stint%20as%20a%20medical%20writer,%20Victoria%20joined%20Wiley%E2%80%99s%C2%A0Advanced%20Science%20News%C2%A0where%20she%20works%20as%20an%20editor%20and%20writer.%20On%20the%20side,%20she%C2%A0freelances%C2%A0for%20various%20outlets,%20including%20Research2Reality%20and%20Chemistry%20World.%0A%0A%0AMORE%20ABOUT%20MARS%20ROVERS%0A%0A%0AAdorable%203D-printed%20rovers%20learn%20to%20find%20blue%20ball%20in%20Mars-like%20environment%0A%0A%0AStrange%20green%20spots%20on%20Mars%20found%20by%20NASA's%20Perseverance%20rover%20(photo)%0A%0A%0A'There%20are%20lots%20of%20mysteries%20in%20our%20backyard':%20Revised%20solar%20system%20chemistry%20explains%20long-standing%20puzzles%0ASEE%20MORE%20LATEST%C2%A0%E2%96%BA%0A%0A%0ANo%20comments%20yet%20Comment%20from%20the%20forums%0A%09%09%0AMOST%20POPULAR%0A'It's%20bananas:'%20Toy%20fruit%20becomes%20first%20zero-g%20indicator%20to%20fly%20on%20SpaceX%20Starship%0AThe%20Unistellar%20eQuinox%202%20is%20our%20top-rated%20smart%20telescope%20and%20now%20has%20a%20$500%20price%20cut%20in%20this%20Black%20Friday%20deal%0A'Mind-blowing'%20dark%20energy%20instrument%20results%20show%20Einstein%20was%20right%20about%20gravity%20%E2%80%94%20again%0ATrump%20watches%20SpaceX%20launch%20Starship's%206th%20test%20flight%20(photos)%0APentagon%20UFO%20chief%20tells%20Senate%20'very%20anomalous%20objects'%20need%20careful%20study%20(video)%0ASpaceX%20Starship%20launches%20banana%20to%20space,%20skips%20giant%20rocket%20catch%20on%206th%20test%20flight%20(video,%20photos)%0AIndia's%20Chandrayaan-2%20moon%20orbiter%20avoids%20collision%20with%20South%20Korea's%20Danuri%20spacecraft%0AGeminid%20meteor%20shower%20begins%20tonight.%20Here's%20what%20to%20expect%20from%20one%20of%20the%20best%20meteor%20showers%20of%20the%20year%0ATrump%20to%20attend%20SpaceX%20Starship's%206th%20flight%20test%20today%0ASpaceX%20Starlink%20satellites%20seen%20as%20%E2%80%98wonky%20streaks%E2%80%99%20by%20ISS%20astronaut%20(photos)%0ARocket%20Lab%20signs%201st%20customer%20for%20its%20powerful%20new%20Neutron%20rocket.%20But%20who%20is%20it%3F%0A%0A%0A%0A%0A%0A%0A%09%09MORE%20FROM%20SPACE...%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A8%E2%80%A81%E2%80%A8ISS%20fires%20thrusters%20to%20dodge%20hunk%20of%20space%20junk%E2%80%A82%E2%80%A8Somewhere%20in%20the%20multiverse,%20dark%20energy%20is%20helping%20stars%20and%20life%20form%E2%80%A83%E2%80%A8Scientists%20find%20extremely%20young%20exoplanet%20orbiting%20star%20with%20a%20wonky%20disk%E2%80%A84%E2%80%A8Solar%20Orbiter%20spacecraft%20captures%20sharpest%20views%20yet%20of%20sun's%20surface%20(images)%20%E2%80%A85%E2%80%A8'Superhighways'%20connecting%20the%20cosmic%20web%20could%20unlock%20secrets%20about%20dark%20matter%0A%0ASpace%20is%20part%20of%20Future%20US%20Inc,%20an%20international%20media%20group%20and%20leading%20digital%20publisher.%20Visit%20our%20corporate%20site.%0A%09%09About%20Us%0A%09%09Contact%20Future's%20experts%0A%09%09Terms%20and%20conditions%0A%09%09Privacy%20policy%0A%09%09Cookies%20policy%0A%09%09Accessibility%20Statement%0A%09%09Advertise%20with%20us%0A%09%09Web%20notifications%0A%09%09Careers%0A%C2%A9%20Future%20US,%20Inc.%20Full%207th%20Floor,%20130%20West%2042nd%20Street,%20New%20York,%20NY%2010036.%0A%0A%0A%3C/text%3E