Write%20an%20extensive%20article%20about%20the%20given%20topic,%20providing%20in-depth%20analysis,%20supported%20arguments,%20and%20a%20well-structured%20narrative.%0A%0A%23%20Steps%0A%0A1.%20**Introduction**:%20%0A%20%20%20-%20Begin%20with%20a%20hook%20to%20engage%20the%20reader.%0A%20%20%20-%20Clearly%20state%20the%20thesis%20or%20main%20purpose%20of%20the%20article.%0A%20%20%20-%20Provide%20a%20brief%20outline%20of%20the%20points%20that%20will%20be%20discussed.%0A%0A2.%20**Body%20Paragraphs**:%0A%20%20%20-%20Organize%20the%20article%20into%20coherent%20paragraphs.%0A%20%20%20-%20Each%20paragraph%20should%20focus%20on%20a%20single%20point%20or%20argument%20supporting%20the%20thesis.%0A%20%20%20-%20Use%20evidence,%20examples,%20and%20citations%20to%20support%20each%20point.%0A%20%20%20-%20Ensure%20smooth%20transitions%20between%20paragraphs%20to%20maintain%20the%20flow%20of%20the%20article.%0A%0A3.%20**Conclusion**:%0A%20%20%20-%20Summarize%20the%20main%20arguments%20made%20in%20the%20article.%0A%20%20%20-%20Reiterate%20the%20thesis%20in%20the%20light%20of%20the%20discussion.%0A%20%20%20-%20Offer%20final%20thoughts%20or%20implications%20of%20the%20topic.%0A%0A%23%20Output%20Format%0A%0AThe%20article%20should%20be%20structured%20in%20paragraph%20format,%20with%20a%20clear%20introduction,%20several%20body%20paragraphs,%20and%20a%20conclusion.%20Write%20heading%20sections%20if%20necessary.%20The%20expected%20length%20will%20vary%20based%20on%20the%20complexity%20of%20the%20topic%20but%20should%20be%20comprehensive%20and%20thorough.%20Use%20standard%20article%20formatting%20with%20appropriate%20headers,%20if%20necessary.%20Output%20in%20markdown.%0A%0A%23%20Notes%0A%0A-%20Make%20sure%20to%20stay%20on%20topic%20and%20address%20the%20prompt%20thoroughly.%0A-%20Avoid%20repetition%20and%20ensure%20clarity%20in%20your%20arguments%20and%20narrative.%0A-%20Maintain%20an%20academic%20tone%20and%20adhere%20to%20proper%20grammar%20and%20style%20conventions.%0A-%20Your%20article%20should%20be%20approximately%203000%20words%20long.%20Aim%20to%20be%20within%2010%25%20of%20this%20target.%0A-%20Write%20the%20article%20in%20English.%0A%0A-%0A%0AWrite%20your%20response%20with%20the%20following%20requirements%20in%20mind:%20%0A%0ADon't%20use%20this%20words:%20Overall,%20Explore,%20Captivate,%20Tapestry,%20Leverage,%20Embrace,%20Resonate,%20Dynamic,%20Testament,%20Fascinating,%20intersection,%20Delve,%20Elevate,%20Navigate,%20Navigating,%20Landscape,%20Unravel,%20Dive.%0A%0ALonger,%20descriptive%20phrases%20are%20preferred%20over%20single%20adjectives.%20Output%20only%20the%20final%20article%20without%20any%20additional%20introduction%20notes.%0A%0A-%0A%0ATOPIC:%0Adid%20the%20universe%20have%20a%20beginning%20today%20I%20have%20two%20of%20the%20world's%20leading%20cosmologists%20to%20debate%20this%20fascinating%20question%20firstly%20leaning%20towards%20the%20affirmative%20that%20the%20university%20did%20have%20a%20beginning%20we%20have%20Thomas%20herto%20professor%20of%20theoretical%20physics%20at%20Lin%20University%20he%20was%20one%20of%20Steven%20Hawkings%20closest%20collaborators%20he's%20also%20author%20of%20the%20recent%20book%20on%20the%20origins%20of%20time%20so%20welcome%20Thomas%20hi%20Phil%20well%20pleasure%20to%20be%20here%20and%20in%20the%20opposite%20camp%20we%20have%20Robert%20brandenberger%20who%20is%20the%20Canada%20Research%20chair%20professor%20of%20physics%20at%20McGill%20University%20he's%20perhaps%20best%20known%20for%20developing%20string%20gas%20cosmology%20alongside%20one%20of%20the%20world's%20leading%20string%20theorists%20K%20vafa%20so%20welcome%20Robert%20thanks%20for%20having%20me%20okay%20so%20now%20before%20we%20kick%20off%20both%20Thomas%20and%20Robert%20have%20started%20in%20some%20of%20my%20cosmology%20documentaries%20so%20if%20you%20want%20to%20see%20more%20of%20those%20do%20click%20on%20the%20Channel's%20cosmology%20playlist%20and%20they%20both%20appear%20in%20my%20upcoming%20book%20Battle%20of%20the%20Big%20Bang%20which%20is%20about%20competing%20models%20of%20the%20very%20early%20universe%20is%20co-authored%20with%20Nia%20Shi%20and%20you%20can%20just%20start%20pre-ordering%20it%20now%20uh%20there'll%20be%20a%20link%20in%20the%20description%20below%20but%20enough%20Shameless%20plugs%20why%20don't%20we%20get%20to%20know%20our%20guests%20a%20little%20bit%20before%20we%20launch%20into%20the%20debate%20proper%20so%20so%20Thomas%20why%20don't%20we%20start%20with%20you%20tell%20us%20how%20did%20you%20get%20involved%20in%20early%20Universal%20cosmology%20and%20what%20was%20it%20like%20being%20Stephen%20Hawkins%20PhD%20student%20I%20got%20involved%20in%20cosmology%20because%20of%20Stephen%20um%20I%20guess%20in%20the%20'90s%20I%20was%20advised%20to%20come%20to%20gbridge%20which%20must%20which%20was%20a%20MEAP%20for%20for%20theoretical%20cosmology%20at%20the%20time%20and%20um%20I%20got%20to%20know%20haing%20and%20turo%20and%20fellow%20eminent%20cosmologists%20and%20I%20was%20just%20very%20much%20interested%20in%20in%20this%20field%20from%20from%20the%20start%20I%20guess%20as%20a%20young%20boy%20I%20was%20interested%20in%20maths%20but%20also%20philosophy%20and%20they%20these%20two%20Fields%20seem%20to%20come%20together%20when%20you%20talk%20about%20the%20big%20bang%20and%20I%20just%20thought%20he%20was%20very%20fascinated%20and%20Steven%20was%20one%20of%20these%20rare%20cosmologists%20I%20think%20who%20was%20very%20much%20driven%20by%20the%20idea%20of%20tackling%20age-old%20philosophical%20questions%20using%20modern%20scientific%20methods%20and%20I%20was%20hooked%20from%20day%20one%20what%20about%20you%20Robert%20how%20how%20did%20you%20get%20involved%20in%20this%20area%20of%20physics%20right%20so%20I%20got%20involved%20in%20a%20very%20different%20way%20it's%20by%20accident%20so%20I%20started%20out%20in%20graduate%20school%20in%20mathematical%20physics%20so%20constructive%20Quantum%20field%20Theory%20very%20very%20mathematical%20sub%20branch%20of%20of%20physics%20and%20uh%20but%20then%20one%20spring%20a%20friend%20of%20mine%20Jenny%20Tran%20who%20is%20a%20fellow%20student%20she%20suggested%20that%20uh%20some%20of%20us%20ought%20to%20do%20something%20over%20the%20summer%20which%20no%20one%20with%20a%20PhD%20knew%20about%20and%20she%20had%20come%20across%20an%20article%20by%20an%20unknown%20physicist%20by%20the%20name%20name%20of%20Alan%20goth%20this%20is%20actually%20the%20original%20article%20on%20inflation%20and%20so%20over%20the%20summer%20we%20taught%20ourselves%20the%20material%20to%20be%20able%20to%20understand%20this%20article%20and%20this%20was%20rather%20fascinating%20so%20instead%20of%20um%20just%20listening%20to%20lectures%20and%20thinking%20about%20things%20which%20other%20people%20had%20done%20decades%20ago%20it%20was%20thinking%20about%20things%20which%20were%20new%20so%20at%20the%20end%20of%20the%20summer%20I%20went%20to%20my%20advisor%20Arthur%20J%20mathematical%20physicist%20and%20I%20I%20asked%20him%20is%20it%20possible%20for%20me%20to%20do%20my%20PhD%20in%20cosmology%20and%20then%20he%20said%20fine%20as%20long%20as%20I%20don't%20have%20to%20read%20it%20so%20this%20is%20the%20way%20that%20I%20got%20into%20cosmologies%20it%20wasn't%20I%20was%20actually%20at%20the%20right%20time%20at%20the%20right%20place%20I%20was%20very%20lucky%20I%20don't%20regret%20going%20into%20this%20direction%20at%20all%20it's%20fascinating%20it%20was%20fascinating%20when%20I%20started%20and%20it's%20still%20fascinating%20today%20so%20in%20the%201960s%20we%20got%20a%20lot%20of%20evidence%20that%20the%20Eternal%20steady%20state%20theory%20of%20oil%20Bondi%20and%20gold%20is%20wrong%20and%20the%20Big%20Bang%20Theory%20of%20fredman%20lra%20and%20gamov%20is%20right%20but%20did%20that%20prove%20that%20the%20Universe%20had%20a%20beginning%20uh%20Robert%20why%20don't%20you%20you%20sort%20of%20give%20us%20your%20your%20thoughts%20on%20this%20right%20so%20my%20short%20answer%20is%20no%20but%20let%20me%20elaborate%20on%20that%20so%20the%20standard%20Big%20Bang%20Theory%20or%20model%20was%20initially%20a%20bad%20word%20so%20it%20was%20a%20pejorative%20term%20in%20fact%20uh%20I%20was%20told%20by%20slav%20mukanov%20the%20story%20of%20zelich%20that%20when%20he%20heard%20about%20this%20idea%20of%20the%20expanding%20Universe%20the%20standard%20Big%20Bang%20he%20said%20that%20this%20cannot%20possibly%20be%20right%20because%20if%20it%20were%20right%20there%20would%20be%20a%20microwave%20background%20now%20afterwards%20the%20microwave%20background%20is%20actually%20discovered%20so%20we%20know%20that%20the%20standard%20big%20buying%20Theory%20explains%20the%20evolution%20of%20the%20universe%2013%20billion%20years%20into%20the%20past%20um%20it%20might%20not%20explain%20the%20evolution%20beyond%20that%20so%20uh%20if%20you%20take%20the%20standard%20Big%20Bang%20model%20and%20you%20go%20forwards%20in%20time%20then%20you%20find%20that%20the%20microwave%20background%20was%20produced%20300,000%20years%20after%20this%20hypothetical%20big%20bang%20and%20so%20we%20know%20that%20standard%20Big%20Bang%20model%20has%20been%20extremely%20successful%20but%20it%20doesn't%20explain%20everything%20and%20in%20particular%20it%20is%20based%20on%20generativity%20a%20classical%20Theory%20and%20it%20is%20based%20on%20describing%20matter%20in%20terms%20of%20classical%20stuff%20and%20we%20know%20that%20at%20high%20densities%20matter%20can%20be%20described%20using%20classical%20physics%20and%20I%20think%20we%20also%20know%20that%20at%20high%20densities%20the%20universe%20cannot%20be%20described%20by%20classical%20general%20relativity%20so%20we%20know%20that%20there's%20a%20question%20mark%20that%20should%20replace%20the%20beginning%20of%20the%20universe%20in%20the%20context%20of%20the%20standard%20Big%20Bang%20Thomas%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20on%20this%20let%20you%20know%20we'll%20we'll%20come%20on%20to%20the%20penis%20talking%20theorems%20a%20little%20bit%20later%20but%20just%20on%20this%20sort%20of%20observational%20evidence%20that%20we%20saw%20in%20the%201960s%20you%20know%20with%20the%20CNB%20and%20the%20structure%20of%20galaxies%20what%20does%20that%20does%20that%20tell%20us%20anything%20about%20whether%20the%20universe%20had%20a%20beginning%20or%20not%20my%20take%20on%20those%20discoveries%20is%20that%20they%20put%20the%20question%20of%20whether%20the%20universe%20had%20a%20beginning%20Central%20in%20cosmology%20I%20think%20it's%20important%20to%20realize%20that%20when%20L%20Matra%20and%20and%20and%20certainly%20fredman%20when%20they%20speculated%20on%20the%20idea%20that%20the%20Universe%20might%20have%20at%20the%20beginning%20this%20was%20this%20was%20extreme%20speculation%20and%20it%20was%20also%20regarded%20as%20such%20it%20was%20it%20was%20in%20a%20in%20in%20in%20a%20sense%20brilliant%20speculation%20grounded%20in%20theory%20and%20clear%20intuitive%20thinking%20but%20it%20was%20certainly%20uh%20an%20extremely%20wild%20extrapolation%20of%20what%20was%20known%20at%20the%20time%20the%20simply%20the%20idea%20that%20the%20Universe%20might%20once%20have%20been%20in%20a%20completely%20different%20state%20that%20I%20think%20the%20discovery%20in%201960s%20changed%20completely%20the%20question%20became%20became%20a%20scientific%20a%20pro%20presumably%20uh%20observationally%20interesting%20question%20and%20so%20forth%20um%20so%20that's%20what%20it%20did%20to%20me%20uh%20the%20meaning%20I%20think%20of%20those%20of%20those%20early%20um%20of%20of%20the%20of%20the%20discovery%20of%20the%20CNB%20right%20right%20so%20then%20we%20get%20you%20know%20the%20Penrose%20Hawking%20Singularity%20theorems%20also%20in%20the%201960s%20and%20and%20Thomas%20you%20know%20in%20the%20film%20you%20we%20made%20a%20movie%20together%20um%20you%20can%20you%20can%20watch%20it%20on%20the%20channel%20on%20the%20cosmology%20playlist%20it's%20Thomas%20it's%20Jim%20harto%20it's%20Steph%20Hawking%20and%20in%20that%20movie%20Steph%20said%20you%20know%20that%20these%20theorems%20proved%20that%20the%20Universe%20had%20a%20beginning%20do%20do%20you%20agree%20with%20that%20statement%20and%20what%20is%20the%20case%20for%20that%20you%20know%20what%20what's%20your%20thoughts%20I%20think%20it's%20a%20typical%20Hawking%20sentence%20right%20um%20so%20we%20have%20to%20be%20a%20little%20careful%20of%20course%20within%20the%20realm%20of%20classical%20generativity%20the%20STS%20prove%20that%20Universe%20had%20a%20beginning%20um%20but%20as%20Robert%20points%20out%20we%20all%20know%20that%20classical%20general%20relativity%20will%20probably%20won't%20apply%20in%20the%20earliest%20instances%20so%20the%20real%20lesson%20of%20the%20theories%20of%20the%20theorems%20of%20the%20singularity%20theorems%20is%20that%20our%20classical%20notion%20of%20time%20probably%20ceases%20to%20be%20meaningful%20in%20these%20extreme%20conditions%20in%20at%20a%20big%20bang%20or%20or%20or%20perhaps%20inside%20black%20holes%20um%20to%20what%20it%20so%20so%20so%20to%20me%20the%20theorem%20suggest%20really%20okay%20if%20you%20read%20that%20theorem%20strictly%20you%20would%20be%20led%20to%20conclude%20that%20the%20actual%20beginning%20is%20a%20singularity%20and%20therefore%20not%20even%20part%20of%20science%20very%20few%20scientists%20have%20read%20have%20interpreted%20the%20theorem%20as%20such%20right%20we've%20pretty%20much%20all%20interpreted%20that%20as%20saying%20there's%20new%20physics%20quantum%20physics%20Quantum%20gravitational%20physics%20um%20entering%20in%20in%20those%20early%20instances%20out%20of%20which%20presumably%20one%20way%20or%20another%20a%20fairly%20classical%20relativistic%20notion%20of%20time%20must%20emerge%20so%20in%20that%20sense%20the%20theorem%20is%20profound%20it%20sort%20of%20says%20that%20even%20time%20is%20an%20emergent%20quality%20of%20the%20universe%20incidentally%20uh%20baby%20versions%20of%20the%20Hing%20Penrose%20Singularity%20theorems%20were%20already%20proven%20in%20the%201930s%20by%20the%20likes%20of%20lra%20upon%20the%20suggestion%20of%20Einstein%20who%20of%20course%20understood%20immediately%20that%20the%20singularity%20would%20be%20a%20big%20game%20Cher%20and%20and%20potentially%20a%20big%20problem%20Robert%20what's%20your%20take%20on%20these%20um%20hulking%20penr%20or%20or%20is%20it%20penr%20hulking%20theorem%20I%20think%20I%20agree%20with%20what%20uh%20Thomas%20said%20so%20I'm%20now%20teaching%20a%20class%20for%20um%20non%20science%20students%20called%20space%20time%20and%20matter%20and%20when%20I%20talk%20about%20when%20I%20introduce%20the%20Big%20Bang%20model%20and%20the%20singularity%20I%20always%20um%20look%20at%20the%20audience%20and%20ask%20is%20there%20a%20mathematician%20in%20the%20audience%20and%20then%20I'll%20say%20that%20for%20for%20you%20uh%20you%20know%20you%20can%20deal%20with%20singularities%20you%20can%20prove%20statements%20about%20singularities%20but%20uh%20no%20experimental%20physicist%20will%20ever%20measure%20anything%20which%20is%20infinite%20so%20I%20I%20think%20if%20the%20theory%20predicts%20an%20Infinity%20then%20it%20just%20means%20that%20uh%20the%20theories%20run%20up%20to%20its%20limit%20and%20it%20has%20to%20be%20replaced%20by%20something%20else%20but%20let%20me%20just%20push%20you%20on%20that%20Robert%20because%20isn't%20there%20an%20issue%20of%20well%20I%20don't%20like%20the%20infinite%20density%20is%20infinite%20pressure%20infinite%20curvature%20of%20a%20singularity%20but%20suppose%20I%20removed%20it%20and%20and%20the%20Universe%20was%20eternal%20into%20the%20past%20isn't%20that%20another%20Infinity%20I%20mean%20why%20do%20we%20prefer%20one%20over%20the%20other%20yeah%20this%20is%20a%20very%20good%20question%20so%20maybe%20to%20go%20forwards%20to%20what%20you%20actually%20want%20to%20address%20towards%20the%20end%20of%20the%20discussion%20so%20I%20actually%20think%20that%20there%20are%20limits%20of%20Science%20and%20uh%20I%20actually%20don't%20think%20think%20that%20with%20pure%20science%20with%20pure%20physics%20we'll%20ever%20be%20able%20to%20definitively%20answer%20the%20question%20where%20there%20a%20beginning%20of%20time%20or%20not%20and%20as%20Thomas%20pointed%20out%20just%20before%20it%20also%20uh%20what%20is%20time%20so%20the%20question%20of%20what%20is%20time%20that's%20related%20to%20the%20question%20was%20there%20beginning%20or%20not%20so%20but%20back%20to%20what%20you%20said%20if%20you%20have%20a%20model%20in%20which%20time%20runs%20from%20minus%20Infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20then%20you%20still%20have%20the%20question%20what%20is%20the%20Infinity%20the%20what%20does%20the%20infinite%20time%20range%20mean%20so%20you%20might%20have%20shifted%20the%20philosophical%20problem%20but%20you've%20not%20eliminated%20a%20philosophical%20problem%20but%20I%20think%20it's%20still%20interesting%20to%20explore%20where%20models%20which%20are%20consistent%20with%20the%20data%20that%20we%20have%20and%20we%20will%20have%20in%20the%20future%20whether%20they%20indicate%20a%20preference%20for%20one%20or%20the%20other%20scenarios%20right%20right%20what's%20what's%20your%20take%20on%20that%20Thomas%20is%20there%20should%20how%20should%20we%20think%20about%20Infinity%20like%20is%20should%20it%20be%20allowed%20in%20any%20sense%20or%20is%20there%20a%20difference%20between%20the%20curvature%20Singularity%20and%20saying%20the%20the%20future%20could%20be%20infinite%20or%20the%20past%20could%20be%20infinite%20are%20they%20should%20they%20be%20treated%20differently%20or%20or%20the%20same%20so%20in%20my%20younger%20days%20when%20uh%20when%20I%20was%20uh%20indeed%20I%20grew%20up%20in%20the%20late%20in%20in%20scientifically%20in%20the%20late%2090s%20early%202000s%20and%20people%20were%20talking%20a%20lot%20about%20eternal%20inflation%20producing%20a%20Multiverse%20which%20is%20infinite%20in%20yet%20another%20sense%20now%20spatially%20infinite%20and%20um%20at%20the%20time%20it%20seems%20people%20were%20easygoing%20about%20all%20all%20sorts%20of%20Infinities%20and%20as%20Robert%20indicates%20I%20think%20we've%20come%20to%20realize%20that%20both%20curvature%20singularities%20but%20also%20other%20kinds%20of%20Infinities%20infinite%20future%20infinite%20past%20Infinite%20Space%20are%20really%20Pro%20problematic%20certainly%20philosophically%20but%20I%20would%20argue%20even%20scientifically%20there%20there%20are%20an%20indication%20in%20in%20in%20in%20no%20matter%20which%20dimension%20you%20go%20into%20Infinity%20that%20something's%20wrong%20with%20either%20your%20assumption%20your%20your%20theory%20or%20your%20uh%20or%20your%20Viewpoint%20um%20and%20this%20is%20this%20is%20partly%20what%20I%20what%20I%20discuss%20in%20my%20book%20as%20well%20right%20um%20so%20I%20do%20think%20that%20and%20and%20so%20I%20think%20first%20there's%20an%20alternative%20to%20which%20we%20can%20come%20later%20um%20but%20in%20the%20case%20of%20uh%20the%20infinite%20space%20for%20instance%20in%20the%20Multiverse%20um%20there%20I%20and%20it%20became%20clear%20that%20there's%20that%20this%20is%20a%20fundamental%20problem%20it%20leads%20to%20the%20the%20issue%20that%20such%20a%20theory%20is%20is%20not%20even%20falsifiable%20not%20because%20of%20course%20we%20can't%20go%20from%20one%20bubble%20Universe%20to%20another%20but%20because%20you%20don't%20even%20even%20make%20unambiguous%20predictions%20for%20where%20we%20should%20be%20and%20therefore%20what%20we%20should%20be%20observing%20in%20such%20a%20universe%20so%20what%20so%20in%20that%20case%20I%20think%20it's%20clear%20that%20the%20the%20problem%20is%20both%20philosophical%20and%20scientific%20it's%20philosophical%20because%20you've%20disconnected%20your%20theoretical%20framework%20for%20from%20the%20simple%20fact%20that%20we%20have%20an%20observer's%20Viewpoint%20from%20within%20the%20universe%20it's%20a%20scientific%20because%20science%20should%20be%20able%20to%20make%20unambiguous%20predictions%20let%20alone%20whether%20you%20can%20verify%20this%20that's%20a%20different%20matter%20um%20and%20so%20somehow%20I%20think%20Infinities%20as%20Robert%20says%20are%20always%20indicative%20of%20you%20having%20pushed%20your%20theoretical%20framework%20whatever%20it%20is%20beyond%20the%20limits%20of%20its%20uh%20reach%20of%20its%20domain%20of%20applicability%20so%20in%20a%20sense%20for%20us%20theorists%20they're%20an%20important%20guideline%20but%20let%20me%20just%20push%20one%20last%20on%20this%20I%20mean%20pres%20so%20you%20mentioned%20aernal%20inflation%20and%20clearly%20in%20that%20framework%20you%20know%20lots%20of%20bubble%20universes%20there's%20an%20issue%20of%20you%20know%20uh%20how%20do%20you%20make%20predictions%20what%20should%20our%20universe%20look%20like%20and%20that's%20covered%20in%20your%20book%20um%20but%20even%20if%20we%20don't%20go%20to%20inflation%20cosmology%20which%20we're%20going%20to%20come%20on%20to%20in%20a%20second%20you%20know%20presumably%20the%20universe%20could%20be%20spatially%20infinite%20I%20mean%20we%20can't%20just%20rule%20that%20out%20a%20priority%20or%20or%20can%20we%20Robert%20what%20do%20what%20do%20you%20think%20I%20would%20say%20we%20cannot%20now%20when%20we%20think%20about%20these%20questions%20I%20think%20uh%20every%20one%20of%20us%20physicists%20we%20we%20come%20with%20some%20um%20preconceptions%20which%20which%20come%20from%20our%20education%20and%20from%20our%20everyday%20experience%20and%20I%20think%20from%20our%20everyday%20experience%20I%20think%20it%20is%20easy%20to%20conceptualize%20Infinite%20Space%20it%20is%20for%20me%20it%20is%20also%20easy%20to%20conceptualize%20infinite%20time%20but%20that%20that's%20uh%20a%20statement%20of%20uh%20the%20background%20I%20come%20from%20right%20right%20well%20let's%20move%20on%20to%20inflationary%20cosmology%20so%20you%20know%20the%20the%20late%2070s%20early%2080s%20Alan%20Guth%20proposed%20inflation%20cosmology%20which%20is%20this%20exponentially%20fast%20expansion%20of%20the%20universe%20there's%20also%20a%20theorem%20called%20the%20bord%20GU%20for%20Linkin%20theorem%20which%20says%20inflation%20you%20know%20can't%20have%20been%20going%20on%20for%20to%20the%20Past%20you%20know%20some%20people%20have%20argued%20that%20this%20proves%20the%20universe%20had%20a%20beginning%20so%20does%20it%20Robert%20what's%20your%20take%20on%20this%20and%20and%20on%20inflation%20in%20general%20okay%20so%20first%20of%20all%20what%20about%20uh%20inflation%20in%20general%20so%20that's%20so%20I%20think%20we%20do%20not%20need%20inflation%20in%20order%20to%20explain%20the%20data%20that%20we%20have%20now%20there%20are%20good%20Alternatives%20in%20the%20market%20and%20I%20would%20actually%20claim%20that%20at%20least%20the%20inflationary%20models%20the%20way%20that%20we%20treat%20them%20terms%20of%20physics%20they%20are%20sick%20they%20are%20basically%20they%20are%20non-unitary%20and%20violate%20second%20of%20an%20so%20but%20let's%20leave%20that%20aside%20and%20come%20back%20let's%20assume%20that%20there%20was%20inflation%20then%20what's%20the%20status%20of%20this%20border%20goth%20V%20Linkin%20theorem%20so%20I%20view%20that%20as%20a%20small%20extension%20of%20The%20Pen%20Rose%20Hawking%20theorems%20uh%20it%20extends%20the%20applicability%20of%20the%20theorems%20to%20matter%20of%20the%20type%20which%20is%20used%20to%20drive%20inflation%20so%20so%20I%20think%20I%20accept%20what%20the%20theorems%20tell%20us%20that%20the%20inflationary%20phase%20had%20a%20beginning%20and%20before%20that%20there%20was%20something%20else%20which%20obeys%20the%20usual%20Penrose%20Hawking%20theorems%20but%20again%20that%20in%20in%20the%20past%20of%20that%20there%20are%20Infinities%20and%20those%20Infinities%20tell%20us%20that%20we%20need%20a%20better%20Theory%20right%20but%20the%20claim%20that%20this%20theorem%20the%20bord%20theorem%20proves%20an%20absolute%20beginning%20of%20time%20what%20what%20would%20you%20say%20to%20that%20so%20it's%20it's%20not%20true%20in%20the%20same%20way%20that%20the%20singularity%20theorems%20of%20penos%20and%20Hawking%20right%20uh%20address%20this%20issue%20Thomas%20what's%20your%20thoughts%20do%20you%20think%20we%20need%20inflation%20and%20if%20so%20does%20it%20tell%20us%20anything%20about%20the%20beginning%20of%20the%20universe%20whether%20it%20had%20one%20or%20not%20I%20guess%20I'm%20more%20sympathetic%20to%20uh%20inflation%20as%20a%20paradigm%20or%20or%20as%20a%20as%20a%20as%20as%20a%20yeah%20as%20a%20phase%20in%20the%20early%20Universe%20I%20guess%20the%20match%20between%20um%20The%20observed%20CNB%20fluctuations%20the%20the%20temperature%20and%20isotopies%20and%20and%20and%20the%20general%20predictions%20of%20inflation%20I%20guess%20that%20has%20left%20just%20a%20big%20impression%20on%20me%20um%20I%20find%20it%20yeah%20perhaps%20this%20is%20a%20bit%20biased%20but%20I%20find%20it%20a%20plausible%20elegant%20mechanism%20to%20generate%20those%20fluctuations%20um%20but%20then%20on%20the%20on%20the%20bord%20venin%20theorem%20I%20I%20I%20completely%20agree%20with%20Robert%20it's%20it's%20it's%20it's%20an%20extens%20of%20Hing%20Penrose%20and%20it%20should%20be%20interpreted%20in%20the%20same%20way%20as%20Hing%20Penrose%20as%20we%20already%20discussed%20it's%20indicative%20of%20um%20something%20something%20deeper%20a%20deeper%20layer%20being%20there%20that%20said%20the%20fact%20the%20simple%20fact%20that%20our%20classical%20notion%20of%20time%20can't%20go%20back%20all%20the%20way%20must%20have%20must%20have%20ceased%20to%20be%20meaningful%20is%20a%20very%20strong%20uh%20it's%20it's%20not%20just%20like%20a%20small%20thing%20right%20it's%20it's%20a%20serious%20thing%20it%20means%20that%20essentially%20the%20classical%20notion%20of%20SpaceTime%20is%20too%20limited%20to%20describe%20the%20earliest%20phases%20um%20so%20this%20is%20this%20is%20a%20big%20thing%20it%20means%20like%20genuinely%20Quantum%20gravitational%20physics%20of%20one%20sort%20or%20another%20must%20play%20out%20there%20must%20be%20relevant%20there%20and%20and%20and%20ultimately%20um%20either%20predict%20the%20origin%20of%20inflation%20or%20uh%20predict%20the%20expansion%20in%20in%20some%20other%20way%20we're%20g%20to%20come%20on%20I%20want%20Robert%20go%20ahead%20yeah%20so%20I%20completely%20agree%20with%20um%20what%20Thomas%20said%20regarding%20the%20theorem%20but%20I'd%20like%20to%20say%20something%20about%20uh%20inflation%20so%20the%20conditions%20that%20will%20give%20the%20microwave%20background%20fluctuations%20these%20beautiful%20uh%20curves%20see%20they%20were%20well%20understood%2010%20years%20before%20inflation%20there%20are%20important%20papers%20by%20zel%20zun%20and%20by%20pe%20andu%20who%20point%20out%20that%20if%20the%20ear%20Universe%20satisfied%20three%20conditions%20that%20then%20you%20get%20all%20the%20beautiful%20data%20and%20so%20what%20inflation%20is%20it's%20the%20first%20causal%20way%20to%20get%20a%20model%20which%20uh%20which%20gives%20us%20the%20three%20conditions%20but%20now%20there%20are%20other%20models%20that%20have%20been%20been%20proposed%20which%20yield%20the%20same%20three%20conditions%20so%20after%20I've%20seen%20these%20beautiful%20papers%20of%201970%20by%20Z%20in%20pees%20and%20you%20I%20basically%20uh%20don't%20accept%20when%20people%20say%20that%20acoustic%20oscillations%20in%20the%20microwave%20background%20prove%20inflation%20all%20right%20Thomas%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20on%20you%20know%20the%20some%20people%20have%20said%20what%20Robert%20just%20said%20you%20know%20that%20these%20features%20of%20the%20microwave%20background%20um%20yes%20they%20may%20be%20predicted%20by%20inflation%20but%20they%20were%20predicted%20before%20inflation%20so%20it's%20not%20really%20convincing%20evidence%20of%20inflation%20what%20are%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20on%20that%20I%20agree%20that%20so%20far%20um%20inflation%20probably%20is%20not%20a%20unique%20way%20of%20generating%20these%20uh%20patterns%20um%20as%20Robert%20says%20the%20patterns%20observed%20come%20down%20to%20two%20or%20three%20clear%20conditions%20which%20uh%20for%20which%20inflation%20is%20is%20an%20appealing%20mechanism%20I%20guess%20but%20but%20um%20probably%20not%20the%20only%20one%20I%20guess%20there%20are%20two%20two%20things%20to%20say%20follow%20up%20foll%20following%20up%20on%20this%20um%20observers%20are%20not%20done%20yet%20there%20might%20be%20a%20pattern%20of%20gravitational%20waves%20showing%20up%20one%20day%20and%20then%20their%20consistency%20relations%20or%20or%20not%20and%20then%20indeed%20alternatives%20to%20inflation%20may%20become%20more%20prominent%20uh%20and%20and%20more%20important%20um%20the%20other%20thing%20is%20more%20personal%20all%20these%20theories%20alternatives%20to%20inflation%20and%20inflation%20struggle%20as%20we%20have%20been%20discussing%20with%20the%20actual%20beginning%20the%20actual%20origin%20how%20do%20you%20get%20a%20universe%20in%20the%20first%20place%20how%20do%20you%20think%20about%20the%20something%20which%20replaces%20The%20Singularity%20of%20Hing%20penos%20and%20so%20forth%20and%20of%20course%20there%20I'm%20again%20somewhat%20biased%20I%20do%20regard%20the%20the%20model%20that%20I%20developed%20with%20Hing%20um%20at%20least%20it's%20one%20model%20that%20well%20Thomas%20that%20was%20that's%20our%20next%20topic%20actually%20so%20why%20don't%20why%20don't%20we%20get%20you%20to%20unpack%20so%20what%20so%20you've%20developed%20with%20Hawking%20and%20harle%20the%20their%20famous%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20they%20proposed%20it%20in%20the%20early%2080s%20and%20you've%20worked%20on%20it%20and%20published%20many%20many%20papers%20on%20it%20can%20you%20and%20and%20if%20people%20want%20to%20learn%20more%20about%20it%20they%20should%20watch%20the%20film%20that%20I%20made%20with%20Thomas%20and%20Stephen%20and%20Jim%20uh%20but%20could%20you%20give%20us%20like%20the%20short%20Cliff%20Notes%20two%20minute%20summary%20what%20is%20what%20does%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20actually%20say%20happens%20before%20for%20inflation%20if%20inflation%20did%20happen%20well%20no%20I%20what%20I%20was%20about%20to%20say%20is%20that%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20for%20the%20which%20which%20is%20a%20Quantum%20model%20for%20the%20Big%20Bang%20which%20replaces%20the%20classical%20Singularity%20it%20predicts%20inflation%20and%20it%20doesn't%20predict%20any%20anything%20else%20as%20the%20early%20stages%20so%20it%20goes%20very%20well%20together%20with%20this%20it%20in%20it's%20I%20would%20say%20it's%20sort%20of%20the%20quantum%20counterpart%20or%20the%20ukan%20counter%20part%20to%20what%20we%20call%20uh%20inflation%20or%20accelerated%20expansion%20um%20so%20of%20course%20that's%20theoretical%20bias%20but%20I'm%20I%20guess%20my%20main%20problem%20with%20alternatives%20to%20inflation%20is%20not%20so%20much%20um%20at%20the%20level%20of%20the%20predictions%20so%20far%20I%20I%20do%20agree%20there%20are%20various%20Alternatives%20but%20to%20do%20bit%20the%20more%20fundamental%20aspects%20how%20do%20you%20actually%20complete%20those%20models%20into%20a%20theory%20that%20does%20genuinely%20resolve%20the%20singularity%20problem%20right%20Rob%20Robert%20before%20we%20come%20back%20to%20you%20Thomas%20though%20could%20you%20just%20outline%20like%20for%20the%20lay%20person%20what%20does%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20say%20happened%20if%20we%20go%20back%2013.8%20billion%20years%20you%20mentioned%20this%20phrase%20ukian%20but%20I%20don't%20know%20that%20people%20would%20be%20familiar%20with%20that%20can%20you%20unpack%20what%20ukan%20means%20and%20what%20does%20an%20boundary%20proposal%20really%20say%20happened%2014%20billion%20years%20ago%20well%20I%20guess%20one%20way%20of%20describing%20the%20no%20boundary%20idea%20is%20%5BMusic%5D%20um%20that%20in%20the%20earliest%20stages%20of%20the%20universe%20time%20and%20space%20themselves%20became%20sort%20of%20fuzzy%20so%20that%20the%20fuzziness%20of%20quantum%20theory%20which%20we%20know%20from%20quantum%20theory%20and%20from%20particles%20uh%20yeah%20penetrated%20even%20even%20into%20the%20realm%20of%20space%20and%20time%20um%20to%20the%20extent%20that%20both%20these%20Dimensions%20which%20are%20very%20different%20today%20of%20course%20began%20to%20mingle%20and%20the%20proposal%20was%20from%20by%20by%20Hing%20and%20harle%20was%20that%20hey%20wait%20wait%20a%20minute%20if%20time%20becomes%20fuzzy%20and%20maybe%20it's%20starts%20to%20mingle%20with%20space%20in%20these%20earliest%20phases%20that%20led%20to%20a%20new%20way%20of%20dealing%20with%20the%20singularity%20ethereums%20namely%20you%20turn%20time%20into%20a%20space%20Dimension%20early%20on%20and%20model%20the%20the%20Big%20Bang%20the%20actual%20origin%20in%20as%20as%20a%20purely%20spatial%20geometry%20so%20time%20would%20in%20a%20sense%20have%20evaporated%20away%20early%20on%20um%20and%20the%20surprise%20has%20been%20that%20if%20if%20you%20buy%20into%20that%20model%20which%20is%20a%20very%20specific%20model%20of%20course%20but%20it's%20bad%20enough%20to%20try%20to%20come%20up%20with%20model%20um%20then%20you%20find%20a%20strong%20link%20between%20this%20particular%20model%20and%20uh%20a%20phase%20of%20inflation%20only%20universes%20with%20a%20primeval%20phase%20of%20inflation%20can%20emerge%20from%20that%20no%20boundary%20uh%20idea%20at%20the%20at%20the%20bottom%20so%20to%20speak%20anyway%20I%20mean%20I%20don't%20want%20to%20take%20up%20too%20much%20time%20but%20Robert%20what%20have%20you%20looked%20at%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20do%20you%20have%20an%20opinion%20on%20it%20let%20me%20start%20out%20by%20saying%20something%20very%20simple%20so%20when%20we%20do%20theoretical%20physics%20we%20have%20equations%20and%20um%20the%20equations%20tell%20us%20how%20to%20start%20with%20some%20conditions%20in%20the%20past%20and%20to%20produce%20uh%20conditions%20in%20the%20future%20and%20so%20I%20view%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20as%20a%20way%20to%20get%20the%20initial%20conditions%20at%20some%20finite%20time%20and%20then%20to%20evolve%20them%20into%20the%20future%20so%20so%20I%20think%20that%20probably%20um%20it's%20a%20much%20obviously%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20is%20something%20much%20more%20fancy%20but%20it%20it's%20something%20that%20gives%20these%20initial%20conditions%20at%20a%20fixed%20time%20so%20yeah%20it%20also%20shows%20that%20it's%20a%20very%20it's%20a%20strange%20thing%20right%20as%20Robert%20says%20it's%20a%20theory%20of%20initial%20conditions%20whereas%20normal%20theories%20in%20physics%20or%20theories%20of%20evolution%20so%20it%20is%20but%20one%20thing%20is%20that%20if%20you%20want%20to%20get%20inflation%20out%20of%20it%20you%20do%20need%20to%20introduce%20a%20scaler%20field%20with%20the%20potential%20which%20is%20quite%20fine-tuned%20so%20um%20you're%20not%20insensitive%20to%20you%20are%20putting%20in%20extra%20stuff%20so%20does%20that%20make%20the%20theory%20less%20probable%20to%20be%20true%20is%20that%20what%20you're%20saying%20Robert%20um%20this%20is%20not%20a%20criticism%20of%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20at%20all%20it%20is%20just%20a%20criticism%20of%20the%20state%20statement%20that%20inflation%20follows%20from%20it%20right%20so%20you%20could%20imagine%20the%20no%20so%20are%20you%20saying%20you%20could%20imagine%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20which%20can%20we%20summarize%20it%20Thomas%20as%20this%20idea%20if%20we%20want%20to%20summarize%20it%20in%20a%20sentence%20that%20when%20we%20go%20back%2014%20billion%20years%20ago%20instead%20of%20having%20four%20sorry%20three%20space%20dimensions%20and%20one%20time%20Dimension%20we%20have%20four%20space%20dimensions%20I%20mean%20that's%20sort%20of%20the%20big%20picture%20view%20of%20it%20is%20that%20is%20that%20a%20fair%20summary%20Thomas%20sure%20but%20that%20sort%20of%20omits%20many%20things%20right%20uh%20why%20four%20space%20dimensions%20I%20mean%20the%20idea%20of%20how%20King%20and%20Harter%20was%20four%20geometries%20with%20four%20space%20dimensions%20describe%20profoundly%20Quantum%20properties%20of%20gravity%20whereas%20clearly%20we%20have%20three%20space%20dimensions%20and%20one%20time%20Dimension%20that's%20good%20for%20classical%20gravity%20The%20Singularity%20theorems%20of%20course%20insist%20on%20the%20time%20Dimension%20being%20all%20the%20way%20there%20so%20they%20insist%20on%20this%20very%20classical%20orine%20Viewpoint%20that's%20why%20they%20run%20into%20a%20singularity%20right%20right%20but%20Robert%20is%20saying%20that%20you%20you%20know%20you%20don't%20easily%20get%20inflation%20out%20you've%20got%20to%20F%20tune%20the%20scal%20of%20field%20and%20so%20it's%20not%20uh%20so%20easy%20to%20to%20get%20inflation%20out%20of%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20that's%20that's%20right%20and%20and%20wrong%20um%20if%20you%20don't%20have%20an%20appropriate%20potential%20then%20you%20don't%20get%20anything%20out%20of%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20there%20will%20be%20no%20classical%20Universe%20emerging%20whatsoever%20so%20s%20let%20me%20can%20you%20describe%20what%20you%20mean%20by%20an%20appropriate%20potential%20that%20may%20be%20a%20phrase%20the%20one%20that%20Robert%20the%20one%20that%20Robert%20was%20talking%20about%20you%20need%20a%20scaler%20field%20with%20um%20specific%20conditions%20in%20order%20to%20drive%20inflation%20in%20the%20first%20place%20yeah%20you%20need%20you%20need%20only%20certain%20types%20of%20scaler%20Fields%20will%20will%20will%20be%20able%20to%20drive%20inflation%20um%20if%20you%20don't%20have%20those%20fields%20then%20sure%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20is%20not%20going%20to%20is%20not%20going%20to%20is%20not%20going%20to%20magically%20produce%20inflation%20but%20it's%20not%20going%20to%20magically%20produce%20anything%20else%20either%20it's%20just%20it%20will%20be%20a%20in%20that%20case%20you%20have%20a%20wave%20function%20which%20is%20a%20generally%20Quantum%20thing%20which%20has%20no%20cosmological%20relevance%20whatsoever%20um%20so%20let%20me%20let%20me%20just%20um%20it's%20a%20theory%20of%20the%20origin%20of%20inflation%20right%20but%20let%20me%20let%20me%20focus%20on%20this%20issue%20at%20the%20beginning%20of%20the%20universe%20because%20one%20thing%20that%20came%20up%20in%20the%20film%20that%20we%20made%20and%20I%20think%20it%20would%20be%20worth%20having%20you%20both%20comment%20on%20it%20is%20that%20there's%20sort%20of%20two%20Notions%20of%20time%20there%20real%20time%20the%20sort%20of%20time%20that%20we're%20familiar%20with%20real%20numbers%20that%20we're%20familiar%20with%20and%20there%20are%20these%20things%20called%20imaginary%20numbers%20where%20you%20know%20if%20you%20square%20them%20they%20they%20come%20to%20a%20negative%20number%20which%20normally%20doesn't%20happen%20and%20so%20the%20comment%20was%20made%20that%20the%20beginning%20of%20the%20universe%20in%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20is%20in%20imaginary%20time%20but%20in%20real%20time%20you%20have%20this%20eternal%20universe%20so%20um%20so%20there's%20a%20sort%20of%20a%20question%20as%20to%20how%20we%20should%20interpret%20let's%20presume%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20is%20is%20the%20correct%20description%20of%20the%20Universe%20um%20is%20there%20a%20question%20of%20interpretation%20whether%20it%20means%20as%20a%20beginning%20to%20the%20universe%20or%20not%20Thomas%20can%20you%20can%20you%20just%20unpack%20that%20a%20little%20I%20don't%20understand%20the%20statement%20that%20in%20real%20time%20the%20universe%20would%20be%20Eternal%20that's%20clearly%20not%20true%20um%20that's%20comment%20I%20should%20say%20that's%20a%20comment%20made%20from%20Aaron%20wall%20he%20said%20that%20the%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20only%20has%20a%20beginning%20in%20imaginary%20time%20sure%20but%20it%20has%20but%20it's%20not%20Eternal%20in%20real%20time%20it%20would%20stop%20in%20real%20time%20right%20well%20that's%20what%20he%20alleged%20is%20that%20in%20real%20time%20it's%20actually%20Eternal%20I%20mean%20Jim%20described%20a%20sort%20of%20bouncing%20universe%20that%20would%20appear%20in%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20but%20also%20there%20that%20the%20arrow%20of%20time%20is%20finite%20in%20One%20Direction%20right%20okay%20so%20you're%20saying%20that%20because%20there's%20a%20reversal%20of%20the%20ER%20of%20time%20yeah%20yeah%20that%20that's%20still%20a%20beginning%20right%20I%20think%20it's%20I%20think%20people%20have%20in%20the%20past%20read%20a%20little%20bit%20too%20much%20interpretation%20into%20this%20imaginary%20time%20business%20I%20don't%20find%20it%20particularly%20helpful%20okay%20the%20originality%20of%20of%20this%20particular%20approach%20to%20quantum%20gravity%20is%20that%20geometries%20with%20four%20space%20dimensions%20can%20capture%20certain%20course%20grin%20properties%20of%20the%20a%20true%20Quantum%20realm%20um%20their%20interpretation%20is%20very%20very%20difficult%20you%20want%20to%20go%20there%20in%20this%20four%20space%20like%20uh%20geometry%20you%20would%20be%20profoundly%20Quantum%20and%20confused%20and%20it%20would%20not%20make%20sense%20so%20I%20view%20it%20more%20as%20the%20statement%20that%20if%20we%20go%20back%20in%20time%20our%20usual%20notion%20of%20time%20becomes%20more%20and%20more%20fuzzy%20so%20the%20notion%20of%20evolution%20the%20notion%20of%20causality%20becomes%20more%20and%20more%20fuzzy%20and%20a%20way%20to%20model%20this%20that's%20the%20create%20the%20create%20the%20genius%20of%20of%20Hing%20which%20he%20first%20tried%20out%20on%20black%20holes%20right%20the%20way%20to%20model%20this%20is%20to%20use%20these%20purely%20spatial%20geometries%20right%20you%20end%20up%20with%20something%20bizarre%20you%20end%20up%20with%20a%20theory%20of%20initial%20conditions%20whereas%20all%20other%20initial%20conditions%20in%20life%20and%20in%20physics%20are%20boundary%20conditions%20which%20we%20impose%20Robert%20do%20you%20have%20any%20thoughts%20on%20this%20issue%20of%20imaginary%20time%20but%20also%20I%20want%20to%20talk%20about%20this%20notion%20of%20a%20reversal%20of%20the%20arrow%20of%20time%20because%20Thomas%20is%20saying%20well%20there's%20still%20a%20beginning%20but%20I%20know%20like%20other%20people%20Don%20Page%20Alan%20go%20Sean%20car%20they'%20said%20this%20is%20not%20a%20beginning%20because%20the%20the%20the%20middle%20is%20just%20the%20middle%20it's%20it's%20not%20a%20beginning%20uh%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20on%20this%20so%20I%20completely%20agree%20with%20Thomas%20for%20for%20me%20that%20in%20this%20approach%20there%20is%20a%20beginning%20of%20what%20we%20see%20as%20classical%20real%20time%20and%20so%20there%20may%20be%20several%20branches%20but%20in%20each%20branch%20there's%20a%20there's%20a%20beginning%20of%20real%20time%20and%20this%20is%20a%20bit%20different%20from%20uh%20maybe%20other%20approaches%20to%20the%20initial%20conditions%20for%20classical%20Evolution%20which%20we%20might%20talk%20about%20later%20right%20well%20why%20why%20don't%20we%20come%20on%20to%20that%20because%20you've%20proposed%20um%20this%20model%20string%20gas%20cosmology%20and%20also%20you%20have%20a%20sort%20of%20a%20newer%20version%20the%20the%20the%20matrix%20model%20can%20you%20explain%20what%20are%20these%20models%20um%20and%20you%20know%20brief%20description%20of%20of%20what%20they%20are%20and%20what%20do%20they%20mean%20for%20whether%20the%20universe%20uh%20has%20a%20beginning%20or%20not%20right%20so%20I%20actually%20believe%20that%20in%20order%20to%20really%20make%20progress%20at%20understanding%20the%20universe%20at%20highest%20densities%20we%20do%20need%20to%20work%20from%20top%20down%20not%20from%20bottom%20up%20so%20we%20need%20to%20ask%20what%20is%20the%20theory%20or%20the%20best%20candidate%20for%20Theory%20which%20can%20describe%20all%20forces%20of%20nature%20Quantum%20mechanically%20so%20the%20universe%20has%20lots%20of%20matter%20in%20and%20as%20we%20approach%20the%20classical%20Big%20Bang%20Singularity%20not%20just%20the%20curvature%20blows%20up%20but%20also%20the%20density%20blows%20up%20so%20I%20believe%20that%20the%20starting%20point%20ought%20to%20be%20a%20theory%20which%20unifies%20all%20forces%20of%20nature%20at%20a%20Quantum%20level%20and%20so%20the%20only%20candidate%20that%20we%20have%20that%20does%20that%20is%20super%20strength%20Theory%20so%20that's%20indeed%20our%20starting%20point%20and%20um%20good%20now%20having%20said%20said%20that%20the%20problem%20is%20that%20super%20string%20theory%20is%20in%20development%20it%20is%20not%20a%20wellestablished%20theory%20and%20let%20me%20make%20an%20analogy%20with%20the%20theory%20of%20particles%20so%20everyone%20knows%20how%20particles%20move%20classically%20they%20are%20described%20by%20Newton's%20Laws%20we%20also%20know%20how%20particles%20scatter%20Quantum%20mechanically%20but%20if%20we%20want%20the%20real%20theory%20of%20particles%20then%20we%20need%20Notions%20which%20are%20different%20from%20particles%20they%20are%20Fields%20Quantum%20fields%20and%20parles%20are%20localized%20excitations%20of%20these%20Quantum%20Fields%20so%20now%20the%20idea%20of%20super%20string%20theory%20is%20that%20the%20building%20blocks%20the%20classical%20building%20blocks%20of%20nature%20are%20fundamental%20strings%20and%20not%20Point%20particles%20and%20over%20the%20last%20three%20decades%20we've%20learned%20how%20strings%20scatter%20Quantum%20mechanically%20but%20we%20don't%20have%20the%20analog%20of%20field%20Theory%20and%20so%20basic%20we%20can%20we%20uh%20we%20can%20proceed%20in%20two%20ways%20we%20can%20either%20try%20to%20develop%20a%20toy%20model%20of%20the%20old%20Universe%20which%20is%20based%20on%20some%20taking%20some%20fundamental%20principles%20of%20that%20differentiate%20between%20point%20particles%20and%20strings%20and%20that's%20the%20it's%20these%20ideas%20which%20gave%20rise%20to%20string%20gas%20cosmology%20so%20if%20you%20take%20a%20classical%20space%20and%20you%20replace%20point%20particles%20by%20strings%20and%20strings%20have%20um%20uh%20have%20Oso%20excitation%20modes%20which%20point%20particles%20do%20not%20have%20and%20strings%20also%20can%20why%20in%20space%20and%20this%20then%20gives%20rise%20to%20what%20Raff%20and%20I%20did%20but%20let's%20go%20the%20other%20direction%20the%20more%20ambitious%20Direction%20so%20in%20the%20late%201990s%20there%20was%20a%20proposal%20for%20what%20this%20unknown%20theory%20is%20that%20gives%20the%20non-perturbative%20definition%20of%20super%20string%20theory%20and%20this%20is%20a%20matrix%20model%20no%20space%20there%20is%20time%20and%20you%20see%20now%20comes%20my%20philosophical%20bias%20and%20it's%20a%20un%20a%20philosopher%20would%20I'm%20sure%20vehemently%20uh%20object%20to%20my%20bias%20basically%20the%20philosopher%20would%20said%20would%20say%20that%20my%20bias%20comes%20from%20not%20having%20studied%20philosophy%20and%20having%20uh%20studied%20much%20classical%20physics%20so%20um%20this%20new%20model%20it's%20a%20matrix%20model%20the%20fundamental%20ingredients%20are%20matrices%20n%20byn%20matrices%20where%20this%20n%20goes%20to%20Infinity%20there's%20a%20time%20there%20a%20lan%20so%20it's%20something%20that%20we%20naive%20physicists%20can%20deal%20with%20but%20you%20see%20my%20I%20I've%20stuck%20in%20the%20philosophical%20bias%20of%20having%20a%20quantum%20mechanical%20model%20so%20there's%20a%20time%20okay%20now%20what%20we've%20done%20is%20we've%20um%20taken%20this%20quantum%20mechanical%20matrix%20model%20and%20we've%20stuck%20it%20in%20a%20finer%20temperature%20State%20now%20we've%20lost%20the%20time%20Evolution%20and%20our%20approach%20is%20to%20get%20everything%20out%20of%20this%20matrix%20model%20so%20we%20have%20to%20get%20emergent%20time%20we%20get%20emerging%20space%20we%20get%20an%20emergent%20metric%20and%20all%20of%20that%20so%20this%20is%20a%20research%20program%20and%20um%20there%20are%20indications%20that%20what%20follows%20from%20this%20research%20program%20is%20a%20model%20in%20which%20when%20space%20emerges%20classically%20it%20emerges%20with%20infinite%20size%20in%20three%20dimensions%20precisely%20three%20dimensions%20and%20um%20there%20are%20fluctuations%20since%20we%20started%20in%20a%20thermal%20State%20and%20these%20fluctuations%20they%20give%20rise%20to%20the%20same%20predictions%20which%20rff%20and%20collaborators%20and%20I%20work%20out%20in%20the%202006%202007%20so%20they%20are%20consistent%20with%20observations%20that%20we%20have%20now%20and%20they%20give%20rise%20to%20a%20particular%20consistency%20relation%20for%20future%20observations%20with%20which%20it%20can%20be%20distinguished%20from%20the%20inflationary%20Paradigm%20so%20so%20I%20like%20so%20I%20think%20Thomas%20and%20I%20are%20on%20the%20same%20both%20in%20the%20sense%20of%20replacing%20classical%20Real%20Time%20by%20something%20we%20are%20just%20replacing%20it%20by%20something%20else%20and%20again%20we%20also%20agree%20on%20fuzziness%20of%20SpaceTime%20because%20this%20is%20also%20what%20happens%20in%20this%20emerging%20space%20time%20it%20is%20all%20fuzzy%20at%20the%20beginning%20and%20then%20out%20of%20this%20fuzziness%20it%20is%20G%20it's%20exactly%20three%20dimensions%20of%20space%20that%20emerge%20and%20so%20basically%20would%20I'd%20be%20correct%20to%20say%20the%20difference%20between%20inflation%20inflation%20generates%20fluctuations%20Quant%20Quantum%20fluctuations%20in%20a%20in%20a%20cold%20V%20vacum%20and%20you're%20generating%20them%20from%20thermal%20fluctuations%20in%20in%20a%20hot%20state%20is%20that%20is%20that%20right%20right%20in%20terms%20of%20fluctuations%20that's%20the%20key%20difference%20right%20but%20then%20let's%20just%20go%20back%20to%20this%20issue%20of%20Beginnings%20um%20what%20what%20does%20if%20I%20were%20to%20ask%20you%20is%20this%20model%20have%20a%20beginning%20of%20time%20or%20does%20it%20not%20have%20a%20beginning%20of%20time%20okay%20so%20in%20this%20model%20the%20time%20that%20emerges%20runs%20from%20minus%20infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20right%20okay%20okay%20Thomas%20have%20you%20had%20a%20chance%20to%20look%20at%20this%20model%20have%20you%20looked%20at%20string%20gas%20cosmology%20it's%20predecessor%20or%20or%20just%20alternative%20alternatives%20to%20inflation%20what%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20Thomas%20well%20I%20looked%20at%20string%20cosmology%20the%20predecessor%20of%20the%20models%20that%20Robert%20described%20yes%20um%20but%20listening%20to%20Robert%20now%20I%20was%20just%20wondering%20how%20whether%20whether%20you%20are%20at%20risk%20of%20running%20into%20a%20measure%20problem%20when%20space%20is%20infinite%20so%20hang%20on%20we%20should%20just%20explain%20for%20the%20for%20the%20viewer%20the%20measure%20problem%20is%20this%20issue%20of%20um%20how%20do%20we%20make%20predictions%20if%20you%20have%20Infinities%20so%20if%20I%20have%20a%20finite%20deck%20of%20cards%20you%20know%20I%20can%20predict%20you%20know%20what%20the%20probability%20of%20getting%20an%20ace%20is%20but%20if%20the%20deck%20is%20infinite%20you%20know%20what's%20the%20probability%20of%20getting%20an%20ace%20well%20it%20depends%20on%20how%20you%20order%20the%20deck%20uh%20is%20that%20is%20that%20a%20fair%20description%20Thomas%20of%20this%20measure%20problem%20yeah%20well%20in%20of%20cosmology%20uh%20ordering%20the%20deck%20means%20you%20and%20me%20and%20Robert%20agreeing%20on%20uh%20who%20we%20are%20or%20where%20we%20are%20on%20so%20it's%20it's%20it's%20it's%20a%20profound%20issue%20I%20guess%20Robert%20I%20guess%20you're%20thinking%20of%20a%20a%20fairly%20homogeneous%20universe%20or%20statistically%20homogeneous%20universe%20or%20well%20you%20see%20what%20we%20can%20given%20our%20starting%20point%20we%20can%20actually%20get%20an%20emergent%20metric%20and%20we%20can%20compute%20its%20properties%20and%20it%20turns%20out%20to%20be%20spatially%20flat%20M%20and%20modular%20the%20the%20fluctuations%20which%20are%20used%20by%20by%20the%20thermal%20fluctuations%20yeah%20the%20answer%20is%20I%20don't%20think%20there's%20a%20measure%20problem%20at%20all%20in%20this%20yeah%20yeah%20I%20think%20the%20key%20point%20it's%20not%20there%20other%20philosophical%20problems%20but%20I%20there's%20the%20Infinity%20of%20time%20which%20which%20you%20alluded%20to%20but%20if%20time%20runs%20from%20minus%20infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20there's%20still%20an%20Infinity%20there%20and%20this%20um%20so%20the%20way%20that%20this%20actually%20works%20in%20the%20matrix%20model%20is%20is%20that%20we%20do%20calculations%20for%20finite%20size%20matrices%20and%20then%20the%20uh%20you%20get%20the%20Continuum%20space%20time%20in%20a%20limit%20where%20the%20uh%20dimension%20of%20a%20matrix%20goes%20to%20infinity%20and%20it's%20only%20that%20limit%20that%20uh%20time%20and%20space%20run%20to%20Infinity%20so%20are%20there%20any%20other%20if%20you're%20happy%20with%20fundamental%20discreteness%20then%20you%20would%20not%20take%20the%20N%20going%20to%20Infinity%20limit%20and%20then%20you%20would%20have%20um%20a%20t%20a%20time%20with%20a%20finite%20uh%20duration%20in%20the%20past%20and%20the%20future%20but%20I%20don't%20know%20what%20happens%20at%20the%20beginning%20at%20the%20end%20so%20the%20philosophical%20problems%20remain%20even%20if%20I%20work%20with%20finite%20n%20so%20so%20I'm%20excited%20about%20this%20research%20program%20not%20because%20it%20eliminates%20philosophical%20problems%20it%20it%20I%20I%20like%20it%20because%20it%20starts%20from%20a%20from%20a%20top%20down%20Theory%20that's%20some%20string%20theory%20Thomas%20what's%20your%20view%20on%20strings%20versus%20other%20competitors%20in%20quantum%20gravity%20like%20loot%20quantum%20gravity%20or%20Cal%20sets%20or%20um%20Jaa%20LIF%20shifts%20do%20do%20you%20think%20strings%20is%20the%20way%20to%20go%20or%20or%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20I%20think%20so%20yes%20um%20and%20one%20truly%20remarkable%20remarkable%20prediction%20of%20string%20theory%20has%20been%20holography%20right%20that's%20what%20we%20want%20to%20come%20on%20to%20next%20so%20great%20segue%20tell%20us%20about%20holography%20can%20you%20explain%20what%20is%20holography%20and%20what%20does%20it%20mean%20for%20these%20issues%20well%20I%20guess%20holography%20is%20one%20way%20to%20understand%20how%20quantum%20theory%20and%20gravity%20quantum%20theory%20and%20relativity%20uh%20which%20are%20seemingly%20adult%20with%20one%20another%20uh%20can%20in%20fact%20talk%20with%20one%20another%20and%20and%20and%20and%20be%20consistent%20um%20I%20would%20say%20that%20holography%20is%20the%20discovery%20that%20quantum%20theory%20and%20gravity%20can%20be%20two%20very%20different%20descriptions%20in%20a%20different%20language%20with%20different%20quantities%20of%20the%20same%20reality%20and%20one%20description%20is%20useful%20often%20when%20the%20other%20one%20is%20not%20and%20vice%20versa%20um%20and%20I%20would%20say%20yeah%20and%20the%20surprise%20of%20course%20has%20been%20hence%20the%20name%20holography%20that%20one%20of%20the%20two%20descriptions%20is%20has%20seemingly%20one%20dimension%20less%20the%20quantum%20description%20right%20now%20you%20might%20say%20well%20how%20the%20hell%20is%20this%20possible%20intuitiv%20intuitively%20the%20reason%20that%20Quantum%20description%20gets%20away%20with%20one%20dimension%20less%20is%20because%20quantum%20theory%20can%20store%20information%20in%20a%20different%20way%20in%20a%20more%20intricate%20way%20it%20can%20store%20information%20using%20entanglement%20so%20in%20a%20non-local%20manner%20so%20the%20extra%20Dimension%20that%20gravity%20needs%20is%20sort%20of%20stored%20in%20nonm%20local%20information%20in%20the%20quantum%20description%20now%20the%20key%20point%20to%20me%20is%20that%20when%20you%20start%20thinking%20about%20how%20these%20ideas%20of%20holography%20which%20came%20out%20of%20string%20theory%20originally%20came%20out%20of%20a%20top-%20Down%20Construction%20in%20string%20theory%20how%20do%20they%20apply%20to%20cosmology%20to%20an%20expanding%20universe%20and%20the%20very%20first%20question%20is%20which%20one%20of%20the%20dimensions%20is%20gone%20is%20is%20is%20is%20the%20holographic%20one%20is%20the%20one%20that%20holographically%20pops%20out%20of%20a%20Quantum%20description%20you%20find%20out%20that%20it's%20the%20time%20dimens%20Di%20menion%20and%20of%20course%20the%20time%20Dimension%20is%20the%20one%20you're%20obsessed%20with%20certainly%20the%20beginning%20and%20the%20one%20which%20has%20been%20indeed%20the%20problematic%20Dimension%20since%20uh%2090%20years%20right%20since%20the%20discovery%20of%20the%20expansion%20of%20the%20universe%20in%20the%20singularity%20theorems%20if%20you're%20going%20to%20truly%20understand%20and%20we've%20mentioned%20this%20if%20you're%20going%20to%20truly%20understand%20the%20origin%20of%20time%20the%20beginning%20of%20time%20you're%20going%20to%20have%20to%20invent%20some%20sort%20of%20physics%20which%20doesn't%20rely%20on%20time%20being%20an%20a%20priori%20entity%20right%20the%20terminal%20state%20of%20Robert%20or%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20there%20there%20are%20not%20many%20proposals%20out%20there%20but%20I%20do%20think%20this%20is%20the%20way%20to%20go%20if%20time%20is%20an%20emergent%20quality%20it%20should%20emerge%20from%20something%20more%20fundamental%20uh%20so%20this%20is%20another%20angle%20which%20made%20me%20more%20convinced%20of%20the%20low%20boundary%20construction%20which%20is%20that%20stepen%20and%20I%20at%20some%20point%20discovered%20a%20close%20connection%20between%20the%20no%20boundary%20wave%20fun%20function%20on%20the%20one%20hand%20and%20these%20ideas%20of%20holography%20on%20the%20other%20hand%20from%20a%20holographic%20Viewpoint%20you%20go%20uh%20what%20is%20what%20is%20that%20business%20with%20the%20imaginary%20time%20that%20you%20mentioned%20before%20because%20which%20I%20didn't%20want%20to%20answer%20because%20it's%20so%20vague%20from%20a%20holographic%20Viewpoint%20the%20Hologram%20would%20be%20the%20holographic%20screen%20would%20be%20much%20like%20the%20universe%20today%20and%20you%20would%20go%20back%20in%20time%20going%20reconstructing%20the%20past%20history%20you%20would%20do%20so%20by%20taking%20a%20fuzzier%20and%20fuzzier%20view%20on%20the%20Hologram%20so%20going%20further%20back%20into%20the%20past%20you%20would%20erase%20more%20and%20more%20information%20from%20the%20Hologram%20you%20would%20just%20retain%20the%20few%20large%20scale%20features%20from%20this%20perspective%20you%20come%20to%20the%20beginning%20you%20come%20to%20the%20bang%20because%20you%20at%20some%20point%20you%20take%20such%20a%20fuzzy%20view%20on%20the%20Hologram%20that%20there's%20no%20information%20left%20that's%20the%20end%20point%20of%20your%20past%20reconstruction%20and%20so%20the%20Big%20Bang%20the%20beginning%20the%20origin%20of%20time%20becomes%20almost%20like%20an%20epistemic%20horizon%20it%20the%20laws%20of%20the%20holographic%20laws%20of%20physics%20simply%20don't%20take%20you%20further%20back%20into%20the%20past%20it%20sort%20of%20they%20they%20run%20out%20in%20a%20sense%20it%20would%20also%20be%20the%20origin%20of%20yeah%20the%20origin%20of%20the%20laws%20of%20physics%20themselves%20so%20I%20claim%20this%20is%20just%20a%20hypothesis%20of%20course%20but%20I%20claim%20this%20is%20not%20just%20a%20scientific%20theory%20but%20that%20it%20also%20is%20one%20that%20resolves%20some%20of%20the%20deep%20philosophical%20issues%20we've%20been%20mentioning%20um%20associated%20with%20Infinities%20or%20with%20the%20origin%20of%20time%20can%20you%20just%20unpack%20that%20a%20little%20before%20I%20put%20it%20back%20to%20Robert%20which%20philos%20phical%20issues%20are%20you%20talking%20about%20the%20issue%20of%20the%20Infinity%20of%20time%20and%20space%20or%20are%20you%20talking%20about%20other%20because%20I%20know%20in%20the%20book%20you%20talk%20about%20this%20claimed%20anthropic%20coincidences%20that%20con%20of%20naturein%20oh%20no%20I%20was%20not%20really%20thinking%20about%20going%20there%20um%20philosophical%20issues%20like%20yeah%20the%20infinities%20are%20gone%20right%20because%20it's%20all%20it's%20all%20very%20much%20finite%20um%20but%20I%20guess%20also%20the%20simple%20idea%20of%20where%20do%20these%20laws%20of%20nature%20come%20from%20no%20one%20ever%20gave%20a%20clear%20answer%20to%20to%20right%20are%20they%20mathematical%20truths%20that%20transcend%20the%20universe%20or%20not%20%5BMusic%5D%20um%20and%20indeed%20yeah%20where%20is%20the%20where%20is%20the%20observer%20in%20those%20but%20that's%20that's%20that%20that%20was%20predominantly%20a%20problem%20for%20Multiverse%20theories%20of%20course%20so%20and%20in%20fact%20the%20the%20our%20our%20model%20our%20thinking%20our%20hypothesis%20emerged%20from%20taking%20these%20philosophical%20problems%20with%20our%20cosmological%20theories%20I%20guess%20a%20little%20more%20serious%20than%20than%20most%20people%20right%20right%20and%20how%20exactly%20no%20let%20me%20let%20me%20put%20it%20back%20to%20Robert%20what%20are%20your%20thoughts%20on%20holography%20and%20this%20seems%20to%20be%20contrary%20to%20what%20in%20your%20model%20you're%20saying%20time%20goes%20from%20minus%20infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20what%20Thomas%20is%20saying%20is%20no%20time%20disappears%20when%20we%20when%20we%20go%20back%20um%2014%20billion%20years%20into%20the%20past%20so%20we're%20in%20a%20sort%20of%20Timeless%20State%20um%20how%20how%20do%20you%20sort%20of%20square%20this%20okay%20so%20the%20model%20of%20holography%20from%20String%20Theory%20which%20has%20really%20been%20worked%20out%20in%20detail%20um%20verified%20by%20many%20calculations%20this%20is%20the%20correspondence%20between%20uh%20a%20space%20with%20negative%20cosmological%20constant%20and%20a%20boundary%20Theory%20which%20has%20time%20running%20from%20minus%20infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20so%20in%20this%20approach%20to%20holography%20the%20famous%20Malena%20construction%20there%20there%20is%20a%20time%20which%20which%20does%20run%20from%20minus%20infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20now%20I%20may%20be%20wrong%20but%20uh%20so%20what%20Thomas%20says%20is%20very%20exciting%20but%20um%20are%20the%20is%20a%20level%20at%20which%20these%20um%20correspondences%20have%20been%20worked%20out%20is%20this%20as%20rigorous%20as%20for%20anti%20deit%20space%20so%20I%20don't%20know%20the%20answer%20to%20that%20I%20thought%20the%20answer%20was%20no%20but%20I%20may%20be%20wrong%20right%20Thomas%20you%20want%20to%20comment%20on%20that%20that%20in%20the%20boundary%20is%20it%20in%20the%20boundary%20Theory%20the%20other%20side%20of%20the%20holographic%20equation%20time%20runs%20from%20plus%20infinity%20to%20minus%20infinity%20so%20that%20would%20imply%20that%20oh%20no%20no%20no%20that's%20not%20what%20Robert%20says%20right%20Robert%20says%20that%20in%20the%20in%20the%20top%20down%20con%20top%20down%20setting%20where%20um%20holography%20has%20been%20discovered%20by%20malasa%20and%20and%20Sask%20and%20so%20forth%20uh%20indeed%20this%20is%20this%20is%20a%20universe%20with%20which%20is%20very%20different%20from%20our%20expanding%20universe%20it's%20more%20like%20a%20it's%20more%20like%20a%20gravity%20box%20and%20um%20it%20has%20negative%20dark%20energy%20and%20and%20so%20forth%20in%20that%20context%20holography%20works%20very%20differently%20and%20it%20does%20different%20things%20um%20in%20the%20context%20in%20which%20I%20was%20talking%20it's%20it's%20indeed%20it's%20it's%20a%20generalization%20if%20you%20wish%20of%20the%20uh%20old%20malasa%20uh%20correspondency%20which%20indeed%20is%20uh%20less%20developed%20it's%20um%20more%20or%20um%20it's%20yeah%20the%20the%20tools%20the%20dictionary%20the%20the%20detailed%20construction%20is%20is%20still%20under%20development%20but%20the%20broad%20conceptual%20scheme%20I%20believe%20is%20clear%20and%20in%20particular%20the%20fact%20that%20it's%20the%20time%20Dimension%20that's%20the%20emergent%20one%20just%20like%20if%20you%20imagine%20a%20black%20hole%20what%20would%20be%20a%20holographic%20description%20of%20a%20black%20hole%20it%20would%20presumably%20some%20Theory%20living%20on%20the%20horizon%20surface%20what's%20the%20diam%20the%20radial%20Dimension%20inside%20the%20black%20hole%20it's%20not%20a%20radial%20Dimension%20as%20usual%20it's%20time%20Dimension%20time%20and%20space%20flip%20across%20the%20Horizon%20so%20even%20naively%20thinking%20about%20the%20holographic%20properties%20of%20a%20black%20hole%20the%20surface%20entropy%20which%20was%20discovered%20in%20the%2070s%20um%20already%20suggest%20that%20there's%20something%20holographic%20about%20time%20and%20that%20aspect%20is%20and%20this%20is%20a%20little%20bit%20bizarre%20to%20me%20to%20my%20mind%20that%20that%20aspect%20is%20absent%20in%20the%20in%20the%20old%20malasa%20story%20now%20there's%20another%20version%20again%20a%20ukian%20version%20of%20the%20malasa%20story%20where%20which%20is%20more%20closely%20connected%20to%20the%20holographic%20story%20of%20of%20of%20theand%20R%20function%20but%20um%20yeah%20so%20no%20no%20it's%20it's%20it's%20it's%20it's%20we're%20on%20the%20far%20fringes%20of%20physics%20right%20but%20yeah%20you're%20asking%20these%20difficult%20questions%20about%20the%20origin%20of%20time%20so%20what%20can%20we%20do%20right%20so%20just%20to%20clarify%20then%20so%20the%20M%20Desa%20conjecture%20was%20between%20an%20anti-%20de%20space%20so%20that's%20the%20opposite%20of%20what%20we%20observe%20in%20our%20universe%20we%20observe%20our%20universe%20has%20accelerated%20expansion%20so%20this%20would%20be%20the%20opposite%20of%20that%20we'd%20have%20a%20cosmological%20constant%20that%20would%20have%20the%20other%20side%20so%20that's%20where%20things%20are%20all%20worked%20out%20well%20we%20sort%20of%20understand%20it%20but%20our%20universe%20has%20a%20different%20sign%20so%20there%20things%20are%20a%20bit%20more%20uncertain%20is%20that%20is%20that%20sign%20and%20a%20completely%20different%20geometry%20you%20see%20entire%20the%20c%20space%20is%20like%20a%20fixed%20box%20like%20a%20cylinder%20time%20runs%20and%20runs%20and%20runs%20as%20Robert%20says%20this%20is%20very%20different%20from%20our%20expanding%20Universe%20right%20Robert%20let%20me%20take%20it%20back%20to%20you%20how%20how%20can%20we%20how%20do%20you%20make%20your%20model%20the%20matrix%20model%20with%20this%20infinite%20time%20back%20and%20forth%20consistent%20with%20the%20with%20h%20holography%20okay%20so%20there%20is%20a%20holographic%20ingredient%20and%20this%20just%20comes%20from%20the%20fact%20that%20the%20basic%20uh%20objects%20in%20the%20theory%20are%20strings%20and%20strings%20look%20like%20Point%20particles%20in%20one%20dimension%20less%20and%20this%20is%20actually%20a%20manifestation%20of%20phography%20and%20you%20see%20that%20if%20you%20work%20out%20the%20density%20perations%20then%20you%20you%20can%20uh%20see%20that%20there's%20a%20holography%20that%20that%20enters%20so%20the%20thermal%20fluctuations%20have%20of%20strings%20have%20holographic%20look%20holographic%20from%20the%20point%20of%20view%20of%20thermal%20fluctuations%20of%20Point%20particles%20so%20there%20is%20holography%20inbuilt%20via%20the%20strings%20but%20it%20appears%20in%20a%20very%20different%20way%20right%20right%20well%20let%20me%20go%20on%20to%20another%20topic%20and%20that%20is%20uh%20this%20issue%20of%20entropy%20so%20uh%20Roger%20penro%20Sean%20Caroll%20they've%20been%20raising%20this%20question%20of%20why%20was%20the%20entropy%20so%20low%20at%20the%20big%20bang%20and%20and%20how%20can%20we%20explain%20that%20and%20um%20also%20there's%20this%20question%20of%20well%20how%20how%20could%20it%20be%20if%20the%20if%20you%20say%20Robert%20that%20time%20goes%20from%20minus%20infinity%20to%20plus%20infinity%20um%20how%20is%20it%20that%20we're%20not%20at%20like%20maximal%20entropy%20um%20what%20happened%20to%20the%20entropy%20if%20you%20go%20through%20the%20middle%20can%20you%20sort%20of%20unpack%20these%20issues%20for%20us%20Robert%20why%20don't%20you%20start%20okay%20I%20can%20unpack%20try%20to%20unpack%20the%20first%20one%20so%20if%20you%20have%20a%20Prejudice%20that%20uh%20the%20universe%20starts%20out%20very%20small%20let's%20a%20plunk%20size%20and%20then%20you%20want%20to%20ask%20the%20question%20how%20does%20our%20universe%20emerge%20then%20it%20looks%20then%20without%20inflation%20you%20would%20have%20you%20would%20never%20have%20as%20much%20entropy%20as%20we%20see%20today%20so%20from%20this%20point%20of%20view%20of%20of%20taking%20the%20equations%20and%20moving%20forwards%20in%20time%20it%20looks%20like%20our%20universe%20contains%20enormous%20amount%20of%20entropy%20but%20now%20what%20Penrose%20and%20late%20TR%20Gibbons%20and%20TR%20say%20is%20that%20if%20you%20work%20backwards%20from%20the%20present%20time%20the%20present%20Universe%20could%20contain%20much%20more%20in%20entropy%20than%20it%20does%20so%20now%20I%20have%20a%20philosophical%20bias%20of%20wanting%20to%20work%20forwards%20in%20time%20and%20so%20from%20from%20this%20point%20of%20view%20I'm%20more%20sympathetic%20to%20the%20old%20view%20of%20the%20success%20of%20inflation%20that%20inflation%20takes%20something%20with%20very%20little%20entropy%20and%20it%20produces%20something%20with%20a%20lot%20of%20entropy%20now%20to%20get%20to%20the%20second%20part%20of%20what%20you%20asking%20about%20in%20our%20approach%20we%20start%20with%20a%20thermal%20State%20and%20so%20we%20start%20with%20a%20certain%20amount%20of%20entropy%20at%20a%20fundamental%20level%20which%20is%20set%20by%20the%20temperature%20and%20then%20we%20ask%20what%20happens%20in%20the%20future%20and%20then%20we%20find%20that%20if%20the%20temperature%20has%20a%20particular%20value%20which%20is%20not%20too%20it's%20lower%20than%20the%20plunk%20temperature%20then%20we%20get%20the%20right%20amplitude%20of%20density%20perations%20so%20um%20I%20haven't%20answer%20the%20question%20where%20that%20does%20that%20Thal%20State%20come%20from%20and%20where%20does%20that%20amount%20of%20entropy%20come%20from%20that's%20just%20hang%20hang%20one%20second%20so%20is%20that%20just%20an%20open%20question%20then%20you're%20saying%20Robert%20well%20we've%20stuck%20in%20the%20amount%20of%20entropy%20as%20initial%20condition%20right%20the%20amount%20of%20entropy%20in%20the%20present%20universe%20or%20in%20the%20present%20Universe%20yeah%20yeah%20because%20otherwise%20you%20are%20you%20probably%20face%20the%20problem%20that%20a%20smaller%20fluctuation%20or%20so%20would%20be%20more%20likely%20or%20probable%20so%20a%20higher%20entropy%20in%20other%20words%20right%20so%20we%20we%20work%20in%20a%20fixed%20Quantum%20State%20and%20then%20we%20we%20basically%20so%20you%20now%20you're%20asking%20the%20question%20how%20do%20we%20how%20does%20a%20classical%20Universe%20really%20emerge%20from%20a%20Quantum%20State%20yeah%20and%20would%20it%20not%20be%20more%20likely%20or%20so%20to%20have%20a%20a%20classical%20Universe%20which%20thermalizes%20much%20sooner%20or%20which%20which%20which%20has%20initially%20a%20higher%20entropy%20okay%20so%20if%20we%20just%20take%20averages%20then%20that's%20not%20what%20happens%20but%20I%20have%20to%20pass%20on%20on%20on%20this%20issue%20which%20you%20erasing%20CLS%20that's%20a%20good%20good%20question%20and%20I%20have%20not%20thought%20about%20that%20right%20it's%20other%20people%20have%20schemes%20where%20you%20know%20the%20entropy%20either%20like%20has%20some%20kind%20of%20reset%20the%20um%20go%20from%20the%20pre-%20Big%20B%20Universe%20to%20the%20post%20bous%20like%20like%20Penrose%20does%20um%20others%20say%20there%20may%20be%20some%20Observer%20dependent%20effect%20um%20I%20think%20Carla%20relli%20Advocates%20that%20point%20of%20view%20um%20Sean%20Carol%20has%20a%20view%20that%20um%20you%20could%20have%20low%20entropy%20baby%20universes%20popping%20out%20of%20a%20a%20larger%20universe%20increasing%20entropy%20how%20in%20the%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20do%20you%20do%20you%20sort%20of%20tackle%20this%20problem%20that%20Penrose%20raises%20well%20first%20of%20all%20um%20well%20maybe%20this%20this%20is%20my%20my%20own%20line%20but%20my%20interpret%20ation%20of%20the%20issue%20that%20Penrose%20has%20repeated%20for%20decades%20is%20that%20inflation%20needs%20a%20theory%20of%20how%20it%20got%20started%20um%20inflation%20itself%20does%20not%20solve%20the%20entropy%20problem%20or%20whatever%20and%20it's%20probably%20in%20fact%20related%20to%20the%20origin%20of%20Time%20problem%20which%20it%20doesn't%20solve%20um%20so%20the%20no%20boundary%20way%20function%20is%20a%20theory%20of%20how%20inflation%20started%20um%20and%20it%20has%20the%20property%20that%20it%20as%20a%20wave%20function%20encompasses%20a%20whole%20bunch%20of%20possible%20universes%20it%20does%20just%20not%20describe%20like%20a%20single%20Universe%20in%20any%20model%20of%20inflation%20it%20will%20describe%20a%20universe%20with%20a%20lot%20of%20inflation%20and%20another%20one%20with%20no%20inflation%20and%20so%20forth%20so%20it%20sort%20of%20doesn't%20it%20how%20should%20I%20say%20this%20it%20has%20low%20entropy%20and%20high%20entropy%20universes%20in%20one%20wave%20function%20so%20it's%20not%20that%20it%20sort%20of%20wipes%20out%20these%20high%20entropy%20universes%20entirely%20and%20then%20the%20question%20is%20well%20wait%20a%20minute%20in%20which%20one%20should%20we%20be%20or%20how%20should%20we%20think%20about%20this%20wave%20Junction%20or%20what%20should%20we%20be%20doing%20and%20then%20you%20have%20to%20realize%20and%20this%20was%20I%20think%20what%20much%20of%20our%20movie%20was%20about%20right%20what%20sort%20of%20question%20do%20we%20actually%20ask%20of%20a%20un%20of%20a%20wave%20function%20of%20the%20universe%20and%20you%20realize%20uh%20we%20are%20asking%20a%20question%20as%20observation%20as%20entities%20within%20this%20wave%20we%20are%20part%20of%20this%20wave%20function%20in%20contrast%20to%20all%20other%20wave%20functions%20being%20discussed%20in%20quantum%20mechanics%20we%20are%20part%20of%20the%20wave%20function%20of%20the%20universe%20and%20so%20Jim%20and%20Gman%20they%20developed%20a%20whole%20sort%20of%20framework%20to%20ask%20and%20B%20going%20back%20to%20ett%20and%20John%20Wheeler%20to%20deal%20with%20uh%20this%20torny%20um%20fact%20that%20we%20are%20within%20the%20wave%20function%20of%20the%20universe%20and%20so%20to%20speak%20we%20are%20carving%20up%20not%20our%20reality%20within%20this%20we're%20we're%20selecting%20a%20history%20one%20of%20the%20many%20histories%20within%20this%20way%20function%20and%20that's%20a%20whole%20Enterprise%20to%20sort%20of%20extract%20%5BMusic%5D%20um%20learn%20how%20to%20ask%20the%20question%20we%20are%20actually%20asking%20from%20the%20wave%20function%20of%20the%20universe%20and%20if%20you%20do%20so%20you%20finding%20that%20our%20past%20should%20have%20had%20a%20lot%20of%20inflation%20with%20the%20no%20boundary%20origin%20but%20this%20is%20not%20to%20say%20that%20this%20is%20the%20most%20probable%20Universe%20in%20the%20entire%20no%20boundary%20wave%20function%20no%20not%20at%20all%20but%20we%20are%20not%20asking%20a%20global%20question%20thinking%20about%20all%20possible%20universes%20right%20all%20right%20well%20we're%20running%20out%20of%20time%20so%20I%20just%20want%20to%20get%20to%20the%20very%20last%20topic%20um%20and%20that%20is%20a%20question%20of%20experiments%20how%20can%20we%20can%20we%20a%20experimentally%20probe%20further%20than%20where%20we%20are%20like%20we%20know%20the%20universe%20in%20a%20very%20hot%20dense%20State%2013.8%20billion%20years%20ago%20but%20that's%20a%20very%20relevant%20question%20can%20we%20push%20beond%20that's%20question%20one%20and%20then%20question%20two%20is%20will%20we%20ever%20and%20I%20think%20Robert%20you%20were%20saying%20no%20but%20maybe%20we%20should%20just%20go%20back%20to%20that%20can%20we%20ever%20really%20answer%20this%20question%20from%20experimental%20point%20of%20view%20which%20ultimately%20I%20think%20physics%20is%20an%20experimental%20topic%20did%20the%20universe%20have%20a%20beginning%20or%20not%20you%20know%20because%20I%20think%20your%20matrix%20model%20is%20saying%20it's%20a%20turn%20on%20to%20the%20past%20I%20think%20no%20boundary%20proposal%20Thomas%20is%20saying%20doesn't%20uh%20as%20it%20has%20a%20beginning%20um%20so%20so%20those%20two%20questions%20Robert%20let's%20let's%20go%20to%20you%20okay%20so%20the%20second%20question%20I%20think%20that%20we%20will%20never%20really%20be%20be%20able%20to%20answer%20the%20question%20was%20there%20beginning%20of%20time%20or%20not%20however%20we%20have%20models%20so%20you've%20heard%20models%20which%20have%20a%20beginning%20of%20time%20and%20models%20which%20do%20not%20have%20a%20beginning%20of%20time%20and%20each%20of%20these%20models%20can%20be%20worked%20out%20and%20they%20can%20be%20worked%20out%20to%20the%20level%20that%20they%20make%20predictions%20for%20observables%20and%20so%20we%20are%20making%20lots%20of%20progress%20in%20terms%20of%20observational%20cosmology%20and%20uh%20hopefully%20we%20will%20soon%20measure%20the%20spectrum%20of%20gravitational%20waves%20and%20these%20different%20models%20that%20we%20now%20have%20some%20with%20some%20without%20a%20beginning%20of%20time%20they%20make%20slightly%20different%20predictions%20for%20the%20spectrum%20of%20gravitation%20waves%20and%20uh%20for%20example%20that%20uh%20there%20are%20consistency%20relations%20so%20inflation%20makes%20a%20consistency%20relation%20our%20model%20makes%20a%20difference%20consistency%20relation%20so%20we%20we%20will%20learn%20a%20lot%20we'll%20be%20able%20to%20falsify%20lots%20of%20models%20that%20we%20have%20now%20I%20think%20we%20will%20learn%20lots%20of%20new%20things%20I%20think%20we%20We%20Now%20understand%20how%20space%20can%20emerge%20at%20least%20we%20we%20we%20will%20be%20able%20to%20answer%20the%20question%20why%20do%20we%20live%20in%20a%20three-dimensional%20space%20data%20will%20provide%20new%20Mysteries%20and%20we%20will%20be%20able%20to%20make%20progress%20on%20these%20new%20Mysteries%20so%20we%20will%20learn%20a%20lot%20by%20studying%20models%20of%20the%20very%20old%20universe%20and%20we%20will%20we%20will%20construct%20better%20models%20of%20the%20varal%20universe%20as%20well%20the%20the%20ones%20that%20we%20have%20now%20will%20probably%20fail%20we%20will%20construct%20better%20ones%20and%20uh%20there%20we%20will%20probably%20learn%20a%20lot%20about%20the%20nature%20of%20particles%20and%20the%20nature%20of%20forces%20of%20nature%20by%20by%20by%20these%20cosmological%20experiments%20so%20we%20will%20learn%20a%20lot%20but%20I%20think%20the%20one%20question%20which%20we%20will%20not%20be%20able%20to%20definitively%20answer%20is%20was%20the%20beginning%20of%20time%20or%20not%20so%20this%20is%20my%20view%20right%20Thomas%20what's%20your%20view%20um%20yes%20so%20I%20certainly%20agree%20that%20we%20have%20not%20reached%20the%20end%20of%20the%20observation%20program%20right%20I%20mean%20the%20idea%20of%20mapping%20out%20the%20history%20of%20the%20universe%20with%20gravitational%20waves%20which%20is%20going%20to%20play%20out%20in%20the%2021st%20century%20one%20way%20or%20another%20will%20surprise%20us%20and%20will%20probe%20these%20earliest%20stages%20as%20well%20I%20believe%20um%20as%20to%20the%20question%20of%20the%20origin%20of%20time%20I%20guess%20I'm%20a%20little%20less%20pessimistic%20than%20Robert%20in%20the%20sense%20that%20even%20though%20we%20cannot%20probably%20access%20this%20directly%20I%20agree%20with%20that%20but%20our%20theories%20reshape%20the%20question%20and%20it%20seems%20to%20me%20it%20is%20not%20impossible%20to%20hope%20that%20at%20some%20point%20it%20will%20we%20will%20land%20on%20on%20what%20on%20what%20is%20such%20an%20an%20elegant%20consistent%20way%20of%20thinking%20about%20it%20uh%20for%20instance%20we've%20both%20made%20vague%20statements%20that%20somehow%20time%20physical%20classical%20time%20should%20become%20fuzzy%20should%20sort%20of%20evaporate%20should%20sort%20of%20disappear%20in%20these%20earlier%20stages%20or%20vice%20versa%20should%20emerge%20well%20it's%20not%20uh%20impossible%20to%20hope%20that%20that%20process%20of%20emergence%20that%20we%20can%20grasp%20this%20and%20understand%20this%20even%20though%20we%20won't%20be%20able%20to%20fully%20falsify%20it%20and%20so%20I%20think%20when%20we%20understand%20this%20the%20question%20itself%20which%20is%20so%20puzzling%20now%20and%20which%20is%20has%20been%20swept%20under%20the%20carpet%20in%20many%20ways%20uh%20the%20question%20itself%20might%20might%20be%20reshaped%20because%20in%20the%20end%20we're%20dealing%20with%20a%20question%20what's%20the%20origin%20of%20time%20we're%20dealing%20with%20a%20question%20what's%20causality%20somehow%20we%20are%20saying%20that%20causality%20has%20limits%20but%20surely%20once%20we%20understand%20how%20to%20think%20correctly%20about%20it%20we're%20going%20to%20learn%20something%20well%20thank%20you%20so%20much%20both%20Robert%20and%20Thomas%20you've%20been%20amazing%20it's%20been%20so%20fascinating%20and%20if%20you%20guys%20have%20any%20comments%20please%20we'd%20love%20to%20hear%20from%20you%20and%20um%20give%20us%20any%20suggestions%20for%20future%20discussions%20and%20uh%20we'll%20see%20you%20next%20time%20thank%20you%20very%20much%20guys%20thank%20you%20for%20hosting%20us%20okay%20pleasure%20