Literature Survey of Brain Tumour Image Segmentation
Dr., M., Jahir, Pasha., R., Sreevani., N., Siri, Chandana., M., Sreenidhi., T., S., Chowdary. (2023). Brain Tumour Image Segmentation Using Deep Networks. 1-7. doi: 10.1109/conit59222.2023.10205722
1)The paper "Brain Tumour Image Segmentation Using Deep Networks" focuses on the advancements in automated segmentation techniques for brain tumours, particularly through the analysis of MRI images. Here are some key points derived from the context:
•	Importance of Automated Segmentation: The paper emphasizes the critical role of automated segmentation in the analysis of diseases, especially for brain tumours, which are known for their malignant nature and heterogeneous cell tissues. This complexity necessitates precise segmentation techniques for effective intra-tumour classification [1].
•	Comparison of Techniques: The research compares deep learning algorithms with traditional context-based computer vision techniques. It highlights that deep learning approaches, particularly in semantic segmentation challenges, outperform conventional methods. This suggests a significant shift in the field towards more advanced computational techniques for medical imaging [1].
•	Deep Learning Models Used: The study utilizes two specific deep learning models: 3-Dimensional Space Invariant Artificial Neural Networks and U-Net. These models are noted for their effectiveness in biomedical applications, particularly in achieving high accuracy in disease detection. The paper discusses how these models were trained separately on the BraTs dataset, a well-known dataset in the field [1].
•	Results and Performance Metrics: The results of the segmentation models are presented with specific performance metrics. The proposed models achieved roll ratings of 0.768, 0.915, and 0.820 for the detection of cancerous cells, whole tumours, and tumour layers, respectively. These metrics indicate a promising advancement in the accuracy of tumour segmentation compared to existing designs [1].
•	Future Directions: While the paper primarily focuses on the current methodologies and results, it implicitly suggests the need for further research in refining these models and exploring additional datasets to enhance the robustness and applicability of the segmentation techniques in clinical settings.
In summary, the literature survey within this paper highlights the evolution of image segmentation techniques in the context of brain tumours, showcasing the superiority of deep learning models over traditional methods and providing a foundation for future research in this critical area of medical imaging.
2)
The paper titled "Causality-Driven Graph Neural Network for Early Diagnosis of Pancreatic Cancer in Non-Contrast Computerized Tomography" addresses a significant gap in the early diagnosis of pancreatic cancer, which is often challenging due to the lack of characteristic symptoms in its early stages. Here are some key points from the literature survey based on the provided context:
•	Challenges in Early Diagnosis: The paper highlights that pancreatic cancer is often referred to as the "emperor of all cancer maladies" due to the absence of effective screening methods. This emphasizes the need for innovative diagnostic approaches, particularly using non-contrast computerized tomography (CT), which is commonly used in clinical settings [1].
•	Existing Methods: Traditional methods for diagnosing pancreatic cancer may not leverage the full potential of available imaging techniques. The authors propose a novel automated method that utilizes non-contrast CT images, which are more accessible for routine check-ups, to improve early diagnosis [1].
•	Graph Neural Networks (GNNs): The paper introduces a causality-driven graph neural network (GNN) as a solution to enhance the stability and generalization of early diagnosis. GNNs are known for their ability to model complex relationships and interactions within data, making them suitable for medical imaging tasks [1].
•	Multiple-Instance Learning Framework: The authors develop a multiple-instance learning framework to extract fine-grained features of pancreatic tumors. This approach allows for a more detailed analysis of tumor characteristics, which is crucial for accurate diagnosis [1].
•	Causal Contrastive Mechanism: A unique aspect of the proposed method is the causal contrastive mechanism, which aims to separate causal and non-causal components of the features. This helps in improving the model's stability and generalizability, addressing common issues faced in medical image analysis [1].
•	Validation on Multi-Center Datasets: The effectiveness of the proposed method is validated through extensive experiments on multi-center datasets, demonstrating its clinical significance and potential as a valuable tool for early diagnosis of pancreatic cancer [1].
In summary, the literature survey indicates a clear need for improved diagnostic methods for pancreatic cancer, and the proposed approach leverages advanced machine learning techniques to address this critical issue.
3) Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Segmentation Techniques
•	Challenges in Traditional Methods: Traditional segmentation methods often struggle to accurately capture the complexities of tumor sub-regions, leading to suboptimal results in brain tumor segmentation. This paper addresses these challenges by introducing a novel approach using Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) that incorporate both spectral and spatial insights to improve segmentation accuracy [1].
•	Supervoxel Creation Techniques: The research evaluates various supervoxel creation methods, including VCCS, SLIC, Watershed, Meanshift, and Felzenszwalb–Huttenlocher. These methods were assessed based on criteria such as homogeneity, moment of inertia, and uniformity in shape and size, which are crucial for effective segmentation [1].
•	Graph Representation of MRI Images: After creating supervoxels, the study represents 3D MRI images as a graph structure. This representation allows for a more nuanced understanding of the relationships between different tumor tissues, which is essential for accurate segmentation [1].
•	Combination of Spatial and Spectral GNNs: The paper highlights the innovative combination of Spatial and Spectral GNNs to capture both local and global information. The Spectral GNN utilizes the Laplacian matrix to map tumor tissue connectivity, enhancing the model's ability to classify brain tumors into distinct types such as necrosis, edema, and enhancing tumor [1].
•	Performance Metrics: The model's performance was rigorously validated using metrics like the dice coefficient and accuracy. The results demonstrated significant improvements in segmentation accuracy for various tumor sub-regions compared to traditional methods. For instance, the Spectral–Spatial GNN model showed a 10.6% improvement in accuracy for the necrotic core over the Spatial GNN [1].
•	Implications for Future Research: The findings underscore the potential of the Spectral–Spatial GNN model to enhance brain tumor segmentation accuracy, precision, and computational efficiency. This advancement could pave the way for further research in the application of GNNs in medical imaging and other complex segmentation tasks [1].
This literature survey encapsulates the key advancements and methodologies presented in the paper, highlighting the innovative approaches to overcoming existing challenges in brain tumor segmentation.
4)
Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Detection and Classification
•	Challenges in Brain Tumor Analysis: The detection and segmentation of brain tumors from MRI scans are complex tasks that are critical in medical diagnostics. Traditional methods often struggle with the intricacies of different MRI modalities, such as T1, T1c, T2, and FLAIR, which capture various tumor characteristics. This complexity can lead to issues like overfitting and extended training times, making it difficult to achieve reliable results [1].
•	Existing Approaches: Many current techniques have shown promise on datasets like BRATS 2018, but they often require significant computational resources and time. The literature indicates that while some methods have achieved competitive results, they still face challenges related to model complexity and the risk of overfitting [1].
•	Proposed Solutions: The paper introduces a two-step approach to address these challenges. The first step involves a preprocessing method that narrows the focus to a small region of interest within each MRI slice. This strategy not only reduces computation time but also helps in mitigating overfitting, which is a common issue in deep learning models [1].
•	Innovative Network Architecture: The second step features a Cascade Convolutional Neural Network (C-CNN) that is designed to extract both local and global features through separate routes. This architecture aims to enhance the model's ability to accurately segment tumors by leveraging different feature extraction pathways [1].
•	Distance-Wise Attention Mechanism: A novel Distance-Wise Attention (DWA) mechanism is also introduced in the proposed method. This mechanism improves segmentation accuracy by considering the spatial relationships between the tumor center and the surrounding brain tissue, which is crucial for precise tumor localization [1].
•	Performance Validation: The proposed method has been validated against the BRATS 2018 dataset, achieving impressive mean dice scores for whole tumors, enhancing tumors, and tumor cores. These results indicate that the approach not only addresses the existing challenges but also outperforms many state-of-the-art models in the literature [1].
In summary, the literature highlights significant challenges in brain tumor detection and classification, while the proposed methods in this paper offer innovative solutions that enhance efficiency and accuracy in medical image processing.
5)
Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Segmentation Techniques
The literature survey in the paper "An early detection and segmentation of Brain Tumor using Deep Neural Network" highlights various approaches and advancements in the field of brain tumor segmentation, particularly focusing on deep learning techniques. Here are the key points derived from the contexts:
•	Deep Learning in Healthcare: The paper emphasizes that deep learning has recently shown significant effectiveness in healthcare image segmentation and information extraction. This includes pixel-based classification, which is a novel approach in deep learning techniques for segmenting brain tumors [1].
•	Existing Research: Several studies have been referenced that contribute to the understanding of brain tumor segmentation:
o	One study utilized a Deep Convolutional encoder model for segmenting brain tumors from MRI images, enhancing learning by extracting features from complete images rather than using patchwork selections [1].
o	Another research focused on early detection of brain cancers by examining MRI images to identify tumor-bearing areas and categorize them [1].
•	Challenges in Segmentation: The literature acknowledges the challenges faced in brain tumor segmentation, such as the wide variety of tumor structures, shapes, and visual characteristics. These complexities make segmentation a difficult task [2].
•	Advancements in Techniques: The paper discusses improvements made to existing models, particularly the Improved Residual Network (ResNet). This model addresses issues related to gradient diffusion and enhances the flow of information through network layers, which is crucial for effective segmentation [2] [3].
•	Performance Metrics: The literature review also mentions the use of the Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) as a common assessment indicator for evaluating segmentation results. This metric measures the overlap between predicted and actual tumor regions, providing a quantitative measure of segmentation accuracy [3].
•	Comparative Analysis: The proposed methodology in the paper is compared with traditional methods like CNN and Fully Convolutional Neural Networks (FCN), showing over 10% improvement in accuracy, recall, and F-measure, indicating the effectiveness of the improved ResNet model [2].
This literature survey provides a comprehensive overview of the current state of research in brain tumor segmentation, highlighting both the advancements and ongoing challenges in the field.
6)
Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Segmentation Methods
The paper titled "Research on Segmentation Method of Brain Tumor Image Based on Deep Learning" presents a significant advancement in the field of medical image analysis, particularly focusing on brain tumor segmentation using deep learning techniques. Here are some key points derived from the paper:
•	U-Net Model Utilization: The research employs the U-Net model, which is widely recognized for its effectiveness in biomedical image segmentation. U-Net's architecture is particularly suited for tasks where precise localization is crucial, such as identifying tumor regions in MRI scans [1].
•	Attention Mechanism: The introduction of the Attention mechanism enhances the U-Net model's ability to focus on relevant features within the multi-modal MRI images. This mechanism allows the model to weigh the importance of different parts of the input data, improving segmentation accuracy [1].
•	Data Set and Preprocessing: The study utilizes the BraTS2021 dataset, a well-known benchmark in brain tumor segmentation research. The dataset is divided into training, validation, and testing sets in an 8:1:1 ratio. Preprocessing steps include random clipping, center clipping, random flipping, and various transformations to augment the data, which helps in training a robust model [1].
•	Performance Metrics: The experimental results indicate that the U-Net model with the Attention mechanism achieves high accuracy rates for tumor enhancement areas (78.94%), core areas (78.81%), and overall areas (88.75%). Additionally, the model demonstrates a low loss function value of 0.1653, indicating effective learning and segmentation performance [1].
•	Operational Efficiency: The proposed method is noted for its simplicity and efficiency, making it a practical option for MRI brain tumor image segmentation. This aspect is crucial for clinical applications where time and accuracy are paramount [1].
In summary, this paper contributes to the existing literature by combining deep learning techniques with advanced preprocessing and attention mechanisms, showcasing a method that not only improves segmentation accuracy but also enhances operational efficiency in medical imaging.
7)
Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Segmentation Techniques
The paper "Multi-class Brain Tumor Segmentation using Graph Attention Network" addresses the critical need for effective brain tumor segmentation from MRI scans. Here’s a survey of relevant literature and techniques that have influenced this research:
•	Manual Segmentation Limitations: Traditional manual segmentation methods are time-consuming and prone to human error. This has led to a significant demand for automated segmentation algorithms that can enhance diagnostic accuracy and efficiency [1].
•	Advancements in MRI Technology: The evolution of multiparametric MRI (mpMRI) has provided richer data for analysis, allowing for better differentiation between tumor types. This paper leverages these advancements to improve segmentation outcomes [1].
•	Graph Neural Networks (GNNs): The introduction of GNNs has revolutionized how data relationships are modeled. GNNs can effectively capture the spatial relationships in imaging data, making them suitable for tasks like tumor segmentation. The paper specifically utilizes a Graph Attention Network (GAT), which is a variant of GNNs, to enhance the segmentation process [1].
•	Region Adjacency Graph (RAG): The authors represent mpMRI data as a region adjacency graph, which allows the model to learn from the relationships between different regions of the brain. This approach is innovative as it combines the structural information of the brain with the capabilities of GNNs [1].
•	Benchmark Datasets: The paper evaluates its model on benchmark datasets, specifically the BraTS2021 validation dataset. This is crucial as it allows for a comparison with existing state-of-the-art methods, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed model [1].
•	Performance Metrics: The results show that the proposed model achieves competitive mean dice scores and Hausdorff distances, outperforming a GNN-based baseline by significant margins. This highlights the potential of GATs in medical imaging tasks, particularly in brain tumor segmentation [1].
In summary, the literature surrounding brain tumor segmentation emphasizes the shift from manual to automated methods, the role of advanced imaging techniques, and the application of GNNs, particularly GATs, in improving segmentation accuracy. The findings in this paper contribute to this growing body of research by demonstrating the effectiveness of these modern techniques in clinical applications.
8)
Literature Survey of the Paper
The paper "Enhanced brain tumor classification using graph convolutional neural network architecture" presents a novel approach to brain tumor detection and classification, leveraging advanced neural network techniques. Here are key points from the literature survey relevant to this research:
•	Importance of Early Detection: The paper emphasizes the critical need for early brain tumor detection, which is vital for accurate diagnosis and effective treatment planning. This aligns with existing literature that highlights the role of timely intervention in improving patient outcomes [1].
•	Limitations of Conventional Models: Traditional models often struggle with non-Euclidean distances in image data and fail to learn pixel similarity based on proximity. This limitation has been noted in previous studies, which have called for more sophisticated methods to address these challenges [1].
•	Graph Neural Networks (GNNs): The paper introduces a Graph Convolutional Neural Network (GCNN) model, which is a significant advancement over conventional Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs). GNNs have been recognized in the literature for their ability to process data structured as graphs, making them suitable for tasks where relationships between data points are crucial [1].
•	Combination of CNN and GNN: The proposed model combines a 26-layer CNN with GNN techniques, which is a novel approach in the context of brain tumor classification. This integration allows for the consideration of local neighborhood information, enhancing the model's ability to classify tumor types accurately. Previous research has suggested that combining different neural network architectures can lead to improved performance in various classification tasks [1].
•	Performance Metrics: The paper reports that the proposed model, particularly the Net-2 architecture, achieved a high accuracy of 95.01%. This performance metric is significant when compared to existing models in the literature, which often report lower accuracy rates in similar classification tasks [1].
In summary, the literature survey within this paper highlights the necessity for improved brain tumor classification methods, the limitations of existing models, and the innovative use of GNNs combined with CNNs to enhance detection accuracy. This research contributes to the ongoing discourse in the field by proposing a solution that addresses previously identified gaps in the literature
9)
Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Segmentation Using Deep Learning
The paper titled "Brain Tumor Segmentation Using Deep Learning on MRI Images" explores the advancements in the field of brain tumor diagnosis and segmentation through deep learning techniques. Here are the key points derived from the provided context:
•	Challenges in Brain Tumor Diagnosis: The diagnosis of brain tumors is traditionally a lengthy and complex process that requires significant expertise from radiologists. As the number of patients has increased, the volume of data to be processed has also grown, making conventional techniques less effective and more costly [1].
•	Emergence of Deep Learning: In response to these challenges, researchers have turned to deep learning (DL) methods, which have gained popularity for their ability to create algorithms that can quickly and accurately diagnose or segment brain tumors. This shift is significant as it addresses the limitations of previous methods [1].
•	Use of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs): The paper highlights the use of pre-trained convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for identifying brain tumors in medical images. CNNs are particularly effective in image processing tasks, making them suitable for the segmentation of brain tumors in MRI scans [1].
•	Brain Tumor Segmentation Dataset: The authors mention the creation of a benchmark dataset specifically for brain tumor segmentation, which includes 335 annotated MRI images. This dataset is crucial for developing and evaluating algorithms aimed at improving the accuracy of brain tumor diagnosis and segmentation [1].
•	Model Development and Performance: The study details the model-building process, which involved training a deep CNN using the BraTS dataset. The model employed a categorical cross-entropy loss function and the Adam optimizer. The results were promising, with the model achieving a validation accuracy of 98% in identifying and segmenting brain tumors [1].
In summary, the literature survey within this paper emphasizes the transition from traditional diagnostic methods to advanced deep learning techniques, particularly the use of CNNs and specialized datasets, to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of brain tumor segmentation in MRI images.
10)
Literature Survey of the Paper
The paper "Enhancing Glioma Brain Tumor Detection from MRI using Deep Learning Techniques" presents a comprehensive approach to improving the detection of brain tumors through advanced methodologies. Here are the key points derived from the paper's context:
•	Importance of Brain Tumor Detection: The classification of brain tumors from MRI images is a critical area in biomedical research. Traditional methods often rely on subjective interpretation, which can lead to inconsistencies in diagnosis. Automated detection methods are proposed to enhance diagnostic accuracy, addressing the need for reliable solutions in this field [1].
•	Proposed Hybrid Model: The study introduces a hybrid model that integrates deep learning, machine learning, and traditional image processing techniques. This combination aims to leverage the strengths of each approach to improve the overall detection process [1].
•	Methodology Overview:
o	Image Enhancement: The first stage of the proposed model employs histogram equalization to enhance the quality of MRI images. This step is crucial for improving the visibility of features relevant to tumor detection [1].
o	Feature Extraction: In the second stage, features are extracted using the grey level co-occurrence matrix from the enhanced images. This technique helps in quantifying the texture of the images, which is vital for accurate classification [1].
o	Classification: The third stage utilizes convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to categorize the images as normal or abnormal. CNNs are known for their effectiveness in image classification tasks, making them suitable for this application [1].
o	Segmentation: For abnormal cases, a morphological segmentation algorithm is applied to isolate the tumor from the surrounding brain tissue, facilitating further analysis [1].
•	Performance Evaluation: The study suggests various performance criteria, including accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity, to evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The results indicate that the hybrid model outperforms existing methods in these metrics, showcasing its potential for clinical application [1].
In summary, the literature survey highlights the significance of automated brain tumor detection, the innovative hybrid model proposed in the study, and the methodologies employed to achieve superior performance in MRI image analysis.
11)
Literature Survey of Improved Brain Tumor Segmentation
The paper "Improved Brain Tumor Segmentation in MR Images with a Modified U-Net" presents a significant advancement in the field of medical imaging, particularly in the segmentation of brain tumors using deep learning techniques. Here are the key points from the literature survey based on the provided context:
•	Importance of Brain Tumor Detection: The paper highlights the critical role of detecting brain tumors in medical diagnostics due to the severe health risks they pose to patients. This establishes the necessity for effective segmentation methods in clinical settings [1].
•	Deep Learning in Medical Imaging: The authors emphasize that deep learning approaches can greatly enhance the localization of various medical conditions, especially brain tumors. This indicates a growing trend in utilizing artificial intelligence to improve diagnostic accuracy in healthcare [1].
•	U-Net Architecture: The study focuses on modifications to the U-Net architecture, which is a popular model for image segmentation tasks. The paper discusses various adjustments made to the U-Net, such as changes in kernel size, the number of channels, dropout ratios, and the activation function, switching from ReLU to Leaky ReLU. This reflects ongoing research into optimizing neural network architectures for better performance in specific applications [1].
•	Performance Metrics: The paper reports impressive results, achieving a Global Accuracy of 99.4% and a Dice similarity coefficient of 90.2%. These metrics are crucial for evaluating the effectiveness of segmentation models, indicating that the proposed modifications significantly enhance performance [1].
•	Training Efficiency: The model was trained, validated, and tested on a large dataset of magnetic resonance images, with a training time not exceeding 19 minutes on a powerful GPU. This efficiency is important for practical applications in medical settings, where time and computational resources are often limited [1].
•	Clinical Implications: The authors suggest that their approach can be integrated into medical care and hospital protocols, assisting radiologists in identifying tumor locations and suspicious regions. This potential for real-world application underscores the relevance of their research in improving diagnosis and treatment effectiveness [1].
In summary, the literature survey within this paper underscores the significance of deep learning in medical imaging, particularly through the innovative use of modified U-Net architectures for brain tumor segmentation, demonstrating both high accuracy and practical applicability in clinical environments.
12)
Literature Survey of Automatic Brain Tumor Segmentation
The paper "Automatic Brain Tumor Segmentation from MRI Scans using U-net Deep Learning" presents a significant advancement in the field of medical image analysis, particularly focusing on brain tumor segmentation. Here are key points from the literature survey relevant to this study:
•	Importance of Segmentation: The paper emphasizes that segmenting brain tumors is essential for enhancing diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment options. Manual identification of brain tumors is often challenging and time-consuming, which highlights the need for automated solutions [1].
•	Role of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs): Recent advancements in CNNs have shown their effectiveness in segmenting medical images. The literature indicates that these networks can significantly improve the accuracy of tumor identification, which is crucial for timely treatment [1].
•	Preprocessing Techniques: The study discusses the importance of preprocessing in enhancing the visibility of tumors in MRI scans. Specifically, it mentions the use of Edge Enhancing Diffusion (EED) filtering, which is a technique aimed at improving contrast and intensity homogeneity in the images. This preprocessing step is considered a form of "hard attention" as it focuses on the tumor regions [1].
•	U-net Architecture: The paper builds upon the U-net architecture, which is widely recognized for its effectiveness in biomedical image segmentation. The proposed method incorporates a redesigned decoder path that utilizes attention mechanisms to improve the model's ability to distinguish between tumor and non-tumor areas. This is a notable enhancement over traditional U-net implementations [1].
•	Attention Mechanisms: The integration of channel and spatial attention mechanisms is highlighted as a way to capture long-range dependencies and reduce background noise. This approach is crucial for improving the segmentation performance of the model [1].
•	Evaluation Metrics: The study uses the BRATS 2020 challenge dataset for evaluation, reporting impressive average Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) scores of 90.80% and 92% on the sensitivity scale. These metrics indicate the effectiveness of the proposed method in accurately segmenting brain tumors [1].
In summary, the literature survey underscores the significance of automated segmentation techniques in medical imaging, particularly through the use of advanced neural network architectures and preprocessing methods. The findings from this paper contribute to the ongoing research in improving diagnostic tools for brain tumor identification.
13)
Literature Survey of the Paper
The paper "Enhancing Glioma Brain Tumor Detection from MRI using Deep Learning Techniques" presents a comprehensive approach to improving the detection of brain tumors through advanced methodologies. Here are the key points derived from the paper's context:
•	Importance of MRI in Tumor Detection: The paper emphasizes that brain tumor classification from MRI images is a critical area in biomedical research. MRI is widely used due to its ability to provide detailed images of brain structures, which is essential for accurate diagnosis [1].
•	Challenges in Image Interpretation: One of the significant challenges highlighted is the subjective nature of interpreting MRI images. This subjectivity can lead to inconsistencies in diagnosis, underscoring the need for automated detection methods that can enhance diagnostic accuracy [1].
•	Proposed Hybrid Model: The study introduces a hybrid model that integrates deep learning, machine learning, and traditional image processing techniques. This model aims to automate the detection process, thereby reducing reliance on subjective interpretation [1].
•	Methodology Overview:
o	Image Enhancement: The first stage of the proposed model involves using histogram equalization to enhance the quality of MRI images. This step is crucial for improving the visibility of features relevant to tumor detection [1].
o	Feature Extraction: In the second stage, features are extracted using the grey level co-occurrence matrix from the enhanced images. This technique helps in quantifying the texture of the images, which is vital for distinguishing between normal and abnormal tissues [1].
o	Classification: The third stage employs convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to classify the images as normal or abnormal. CNNs are known for their effectiveness in image classification tasks, making them suitable for this application [1].
o	Segmentation: Finally, the abnormal brain tumor is segmented using a morphological segmentation algorithm, which aids in isolating the tumor from surrounding tissues for better analysis [1].
•	Performance Evaluation: The paper suggests various performance criteria, including accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity, to evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The results indicate that the hybrid model outperforms existing methods in these metrics, demonstrating its potential for clinical application [1].
This literature survey highlights the innovative approach taken by the authors to address the challenges in brain tumor detection using MRI, showcasing the integration of multiple advanced techniques to enhance diagnostic capabilities.

14)
Literature Review: Deep Learning for Brain Tumor Segmentation
Introduction
The segmentation of brain tumors from medical imaging is a critical task in neuro-oncology, directly impacting diagnosis, treatment planning, and patient outcomes. Recent advancements in deep learning have introduced sophisticated methodologies that significantly enhance the accuracy and efficiency of brain tumor segmentation. This literature review synthesizes current research findings in the field, highlighting state-of-the-art techniques, common challenges, and future research directions.
Advances in Deep Learning Techniques
The evolution of deep learning, particularly in the context of medical imaging, has been marked by the development of various architectures such as Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) and Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs). These frameworks have demonstrated superior performance over traditional machine learning methods in various applications, including brain tumor segmentation (Alom et al., 2019). The application of CNNs, in particular, has been crucial, as they allow the extraction of hierarchical features from images, which is essential for accurately identifying tumor sub-regions.
The Multimodal Brain Tumor Image Segmentation Benchmark (BRATS) has been a significant resource in this domain, facilitating the evaluation of multiple state-of-the-art segmentation algorithms on a diverse dataset of multi-contrast MRI scans (Menze et al., 2015). The benchmark revealed variability in algorithm performance, underscoring that no single method excels universally across all tumor sub-regions. This finding points to the potential benefits of combining multiple algorithms to enhance segmentation accuracy, a notion supported by subsequent studies that advocate for ensemble approaches to tackle the challenges of tumor heterogeneity (Naser & Deen, 2020).
Challenges and Strategies
Despite the progress made, challenges remain in the segmentation of brain tumors using deep learning. One significant issue is the scarcity of labeled data, which complicates the training of robust models. The exploration of different learning approaches—supervised, unsupervised, and semi-supervised—has gained traction as a means to mitigate this challenge (Zhou et al., 2020). Moreover, the introduction of data augmentation techniques has been essential in enhancing model performance by artificially increasing the size of training datasets (Ranjbarzadeh et al., 2021).
The integration of advanced imaging modalities with AI techniques has been proposed as a means to improve the accuracy of brain tumor care (Nalepa et al., 2019). However, the literature indicates a gap in studies focusing on the integration of these modalities with deep learning frameworks, suggesting that more research is needed to fully exploit their potential in clinical settings.
Innovations in Segmentation Approaches
Recent innovations have focused on employing multi-scale processing techniques within CNN architectures to improve the classification of different tumor types without extensive preprocessing (Mazurowski et al., 2018). Additionally, the integration of Conditional Random Fields (CRFs) with Fully Convolutional Neural Networks (FCNNs) has been shown to enhance segmentation outcomes by refining the boundaries of tumor regions (Zhao et al., 2017).
Furthermore, the use of ensemble methods that incorporate radiomic features has emerged as a promising approach for improving segmentation accuracy while also predicting patient survival outcomes (Naser & Deen, 2020). This integration not only improves tumor segmentation but also provides valuable prognostic insights, thereby enhancing clinical decision-making processes.
Knowledge Gaps and Future Directions
While the advancements in deep learning for brain tumor segmentation are notable, several knowledge gaps persist. One significant area is the need for extensive validation of existing models across diverse populations and imaging conditions to ensure generalizability. Moreover, the integration of multi-institutional data sharing without compromising patient confidentiality remains a challenge, as highlighted by research advocating for collaborative frameworks (Sheller et al., 2018).
Future research should also focus on the development of novel deep learning architectures tailored specifically for brain tumor segmentation. Exploring the use of unsupervised learning techniques and self-supervised learning approaches could further enhance model training, particularly in scenarios with limited labeled data.
Additionally, the continuous improvement of benchmark datasets like BRATS is essential for fostering advancements in this field. As tumor imaging techniques evolve, ensuring that datasets remain representative of current clinical practices will be critical for the ongoing development and validation of deep learning methods.
Conclusion
Deep learning has revolutionized brain tumor segmentation, offering promising solutions to longstanding challenges in medical imaging. As researchers continue to explore innovative techniques and address existing gaps in knowledge, the potential for deep learning to improve patient outcomes in neuro-oncology remains significant. Future studies should prioritize collaborative efforts and the integration of diverse datasets to harness the full capabilities of these advanced methodologies in clinical practice
15)
Brain Tumor Identification and Classification of MRI images using deep learning techniques
(2020)
This paper proposes a Fully Automatic Heterogeneous Segmentation using Support Vector Machine (FAHS-SVM) for brain tumor segmentation based on deep learning techniques. The paper begins by discussing the importance of brain tumor detection and segmentation, and the challenges associated with manual methods. It then provides a background review of related research, including machine learning-based methods such as the Back propagation neural network (MLBPNN) and Extreme learning machine local receptive fields (ELM-LRF), as well as image processing techniques like Berkeley Wavelet Transformation and Support Vector Machine (BWT-SVM) and Multilevel Segmentation by Weighted Aggregation (MSWA). The paper then describes the proposed FAHS-SVM method in detail, including the pre-processing steps of skull stripping and morphological operation and segmentation. It also discusses the feature extraction process, which includes textural features such as mean, standard deviation, entropy, and homogeneity or inverted moment of difference (IDM). The paper also mentions the use of the Structural Similarity Index (SSIM), mean square error (MSE), and peak signal to noise ratio (PSNR) as quality evaluation metrics. The paper then presents the experimental results of the proposed FAHS-SVM method, including the Dice similarity coefficient, probability of detection ratio evaluation, and classification error. The results show that the proposed method achieves high accuracy and outperforms other existing methods in terms of segmentation accuracy and classification error. The paper concludes by summarizing the contributions of the study and discussing the potential applications and future directions of the proposed FAHS-SVM method in brain tumor segmentation.

16) Deep Learning for Brain Tumor Segmentation: A Survey of
State-of-the-Art
This paper provides a literature survey on deep learning methods for brain tumor segmentation in medical images. The authors discuss the challenges of manual segmentation and the need for automated methods due to the large amount of data and the need for objective, reproducible, and scalable approaches. They review both traditional machine learning and deep learning methods, with a focus on convolutional neural networks (CNNs) due to their record-shattering performance in computer vision tasks. The authors also discuss the challenges of medical image analysis, including the lack of large datasets and the need for ground truth annotation. They highlight state-of-the-art deep learning techniques for brain tumor segmentation and discuss unique challenges and their possible solutions. The paper also mentions the use of ensembles and U-Net based models for improving segmentation performance. The authors conclude by summarizing the advancements in the field and the potential for further research.

17) BrainGNN: Interpretable Brain Graph Neural Network for fMRI
Analysis

The research proposes BrainGNN, a graph neural network framework for analyzing functional magnetic resonance images (fMRI) and discovering neurological biomarkers. BrainGNN contains novel ROI-aware graph convolutional layers and ROI-selection pooling layers, which provide transparency in medical image analysis. The framework outperforms alternative fMRI image analysis methods in terms of four different evaluation metrics on two independent fMRI datasets: an Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) fMRI dataset and data from the Human Connectome Project (HCP) 900 Subject Release. The obtained community clustering and salient ROI detection results show a high correspondence.

18) Design and Implementation of Brain Tumor Segmentation Using Convolutional Neural Networks in MRI Images
he research proposes a brain tumor segmentation method using Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) in Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) images. The study demonstrates that the proposed method is effective and efficient through experimental examinations using benchmark data. The rifleman technique, a statistical region merging approach used in picture segmentation, is also introduced to improve comprehension of both normal brain activity and abnormalities associated with psychiatric diseases. The researchers suggest that this method can be expanded to advanced 3D and 4D images and used for forecasting cell states in brain imaging in future work. Feature extraction, also known as data reduction, is used to discover and eliminate unnecessary data features, allowing data mining algorithms to run faster.

19) Brain Tumor Classification from MRI Using Image Enhancement and Convolutional Neural Network Techniques

The research outcome is the development of a novel methodology for categorizing brain tumors using a combination of image enhancement techniques and a proposed convolutional neural network. The methodology achieved a remarkable level of accuracy of 97.84%, demonstrating the model's robust capacity for generalization and making it a valuable tool within the medical field for expeditious and accurate brain tumor diagnosis. The study also aims to revolutionize medical imaging methods by creating real-time brain tumor detection systems and establishing three-dimensional networks to analyze other medical images. The methodology was tested on a publicly accessible MRI dataset obtained from the Kaggle repository, which combines three publicly accessible datasets: Figshare, SARTAJ, and BR35H. The dataset consists of 7023 MRIs of the human brain provided in grayscale and jpg format, including primary types of brain tumors, namely glioma, meningioma, pituitary tumors, and images without tumors. The proposed methodology employed various image enhancement techniques, including Gaussian-blur-based sharpening and Contrast-Limited Adaptive Histogram Equalization (CLAHE), to enhance the quality of the images and reduce the manual effort needed for feature extraction. The methodology also incorporated distinctive concatenation concepts within the convolutional layers, demonstrating superior performance compared to alternative methods. The study also compared the proposed methodology with pre-trained models, including VGG16, ResNet50, InceptionV3, MobileNetV2, and VGG19, and showed that the proposed methodology outperformed the pre-trained models in terms of accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score. The limitations of the study include the need for comprehensive evaluations to test the method's suitability for different imaging modalities and clinical scenarios and its flexibility for image enhancements
20) Brain tumor segmentation based on deep learning and an attention mechanism using MRI multi-modalities brain images https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-90428-8
The research proposes a brain tumor segmentation method using a preprocessing approach, a Cascade Convolutional Neural Network (C-CNN), and a Distance-Wise Attention (DWA) mechanism. The preprocessing approach focuses on a limited area of the image to extract key features, reducing unnecessary uninformative parts and the need for a very deep convolutional model. The C-CNN model mines both local and global features in two different routes, and the DWA mechanism considers the effect of the brain tumor location in four input modalities. The proposed method achieves competitive results on the BRATS 2018 dataset, with mean whole tumor, enhancing tumor, and tumor core dice scores of 0.9203, 0.9113, and 0.8726, respectively
21) Advancing Brain Tumor Segmentation with Spectral–Spatial Graph Neural Networks
The research introduces a novel Spectral-Spatial Graph Neural Network (GNN) model for brain tumor segmentation in MRI images. The study demonstrates that the proposed model outperforms traditional segmentation methods and individual Spatial or Spectral GNNs in terms of accuracy and precision. The Spectral-Spatial GNN model shows significant improvements in both whole tumor and sub-region segmentation, as evidenced by the dice coefficient and other metrics. The findings have the potential to enhance brain tumor diagnosis, treatment planning, and fundamental research.
22) Detection and isolation of brain tumors in cancer patients using neural network techniques in MRI images
The research proposes a hybrid approach called HCNN-RF for tumor detection in MRI images using a combination of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) and Random Forest (RF) algorithms. The method was evaluated using the BRATS 2019 dataset and achieved significant improvements in accuracy, sensitivity, and F1 score compared to alternative methods, with an increase of 99.3% in accuracy, 97.3% in sensitivity, and 98.5% in the F1 score, respectively. The study also suggests potential future works, including the use of deeper neural networks, new pre-processing methods, and expanding the method to detect tumors in other parts of the body.
23) Brain Tumor Detection Based on Deep Learning Approaches and Magnetic Resonance Imaging
The research outcome is the development of a fine-tuned YOLOv7 model for brain tumor detection in MRI images, which achieved 99.5% and 99.3% precision and recall, respectively. The proposed model outperformed other CNN architectures, such as Xception, InceptionResNetV2, ResNet50, InceptionV3, VGG16, EfficientNet, and the original YOLOv7 model, in terms of validation accuracy. The study also demonstrated the importance of transfer learning and fine-tuning in enhancing the precision of brain tumor diagnosis and the unique capacities of each CNN design.
24) Enhancing brain tumor classification in MRI scans with a multi-layer customized convolutional neural network approach

Literature Survey of the Paper
The literature survey in this paper highlights the evolution and advancements in the use of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly convolutional neural networks (CNNs), for diagnosing brain tumors from MRI scans. Here are the key points derived from the contexts:
•	Traditional Methods: Initially, traditional machine learning techniques like Support Vector Machines (SVMs) and Random Forests were employed for brain tumor classification. These methods relied on manually extracted features from MRI scans, which limited their effectiveness due to the potential for overlooking critical details and the need for expert-driven feature selection [1].
•	Early CNN Models: Early CNN models were shallow due to computational constraints, which restricted their ability to capture complex features. However, deeper architectures such as AlexNet and VGG improved feature extraction capabilities but faced challenges like overfitting and the requirement for extensive labeled datasets [1].
•	Transfer Learning: To address data scarcity, transfer learning became a popular approach, allowing models pretrained on large datasets (e.g., ImageNet) to be fine-tuned for specific tasks. This method significantly improved classification accuracy, especially when integrating multimodal MRI data [1].
•	Advanced Techniques: Recent studies have introduced various advanced methodologies, including:
•	Attention Mechanisms: These enhance interpretability by focusing on relevant regions within the MRI scans.
•	3D CNNs: These models preserve spatial relationships for volumetric analysis but introduce computational complexities.
•	Ensemble Learning: This approach improves accuracy but increases computational demands [1].
•	Challenges in the Field: Despite advancements, challenges remain in brain MRI analysis due to the unique complexities of brain anatomy and the diverse manifestations of tumors. This necessitates a tailored approach in AI model development [1].
•	Proposed Method: The paper introduces a custom-designed CNN architecture optimized for the specific challenges of detecting brain tumors in MRI scans. This model aims to enhance accuracy and efficiency, building on foundational research while integrating state-of-the-art feature extraction and deep learning optimization strategies [1] [2].
This literature survey establishes the context for the proposed research, emphasizing the need for optimized CNNs in the specialized domain of brain tumor detection from MRI scans

25) Research on Brain Tumor Segmentation and Identification Technology Based on Improved Unet

Literature Survey of Brain Tumor Segmentation Technologies
The paper titled "Research on Brain Tumor Segmentation and Identification Technology Based on Improved Unet" addresses the critical issue of brain tumor segmentation using advanced deep learning techniques. Here’s a summary of the relevant literature and methodologies discussed in the paper:
•	Importance of Accurate Segmentation: Brain tumors pose significant health risks, and accurate segmentation from MRI scans is essential for effective diagnosis and treatment planning. Traditional manual segmentation methods are often time-consuming and subjective, leading to the need for automated solutions [1].
•	Existing Models: The paper compares its proposed improved Unet model with several existing segmentation models, including:
•	Unet: A widely used architecture for biomedical image segmentation, known for its encoder-decoder structure.
•	PSPNet: A model that employs a pyramid pooling module to capture contextual information at different scales.
•	ICNet: A model designed for real-time semantic segmentation, focusing on efficiency.
•	Fast-SCNN: A lightweight model aimed at fast segmentation tasks [1].
•	Proposed Improvements: The authors introduce several enhancements to the traditional Unet model:
•	Downsampling: The model is downsampled three times to effectively extract features while minimizing parameters and preserving edge details.
•	Multiple-Attention based Feature Pyramid Network (MA-FPN): This module is integrated into both the encoding and decoding phases to enhance multi-scale feature extraction and improve the model's ability to handle class ambiguities.
•	Edge Extraction Module: This additional module combines semantic features from the backbone network with edge features obtained through Canny edge detection and morphological operations, improving the model's edge learning capabilities [1].
•	Experimental Results: The paper presents comparative experimental results demonstrating that the improved Unet model outperforms traditional models in terms of segmentation accuracy, with notable percentage increases over Unet, PSPNet, ICNet, and Fast-SCNN [1].
In summary, the literature survey highlights the evolution of brain tumor segmentation techniques, the limitations of existing models, and the innovative approaches taken in the proposed improved Unet model to enhance segmentation accuracy and efficiency.

give table with sno author year model dataset result for 25 papers