Give me original and cohesive de detailed commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone and make sure it keeps the same meaning without twisting it, I want to keep it identical but different original wording and include all details and infos and don't mention me: Western artist have gotten a lot of hate for lip syncing in the past, just recently people were hating on Sabrina Carpenter for “lip synching” at her concert recently (she shut the rumors down and said she’s been singing live) so Lisa whose trying to break into the western market by lip synching her performances is not giving her a good look.

The west values artist that are good performers and who can sing live when the time comes, you don’t have to be a exceptional singer but if your like Taylor Swift for an example she is an “ok” singer and a great song writer.

Lisa is trying to push herself into the west but isn’t doing it correctly, maybe things would be different when she drops her album but so far her live performances have all received backlash for the lack of singing live. Rockstar doesn’t have difficult choreo, but I noticed a lot of her choreo is heavily reliant on her background dancers carrying her from Point A to B or her doing model walks across the stage.

Western artist don’t do much choreo like kpop idols do, most of their performances have some choreo but they heavily favor singing live and interacting with their fans, whereas Lisa isn’t doing the latter but more so barely doing choreo while lip syncing.

The western market focuses on individuality that’s why you see artist that were part of groups branch off to be soloist (Beyoncé, Justin Timberlake, Harry Styles, Camilla Cabello etc) This is what Lisa is doing branching off to be solo but when your introducing yourself to a new market you gotta market yourself really great and if you have a rocky start it’s going to be hard to shed that off (Dua Lipa getting hate for her viral dancing meme years ago and people still talk about it till this day despite her improving)

I expected Lisa to be more like Normani who is known as the best dancer in 5th Harmony and she is also a great singer, Normani incorporates good choreo and also sings live, this is something I think Lisa should do.


Lisa must develop one wow factor when she performs. She needs a hit song, but the stage production is also important. Singing or dancing. If she can't do both, then she must pick one to really showcase onstage. She's still new at this as a soloist so she may get better.  Lisa needs to show one thing she's really, really good at. Find a team that will help her maximize her strengths and make up for what she still needs to improve.  She's still performing like the camerawork is a Kpop production: try to sing, pose and give face to look cute/cool/sexy, do a little choreo, then continues the performance. It's coming across as dull and uninteresting because she herself isn't immersed in her own music and performance, the visuals are still given priority. As I've mentioned before: singing or dancing. If she cannot sing live, then put on theatrics and a whole stage production. Otherwise, there'd be nothing for people to tune into. Madonna at her age is still reinventing herself. This is what it means to be a popstar in the West. You always have to show something new or improve on what you're already good at, or people will move on from you.  I think the criticism would be much less, at least in the music circles if Lisa was offering jaw dropping performances, with choreographies overflowing with charisma. There's clearly demand to have female acts dance, we see it with Tate McRae, Victoria Monét, Beyoncé, etc, these women are adored for their dancing. Lisa should tap into that even if she doesn't sing her songs, it has always been her strength.