The following dialogue is between g, the guide, and f, the follower. Assess the overall efficiency of the communication and provide an overall score out of 10. Provide a brief explanation for your assessment.
Found 2 args.
Observation: q1nc7; Result size: 477; atts: 2
who	$m	
g	have we just started 	
f	yeah 	
g	right 	
g	ehm right 	
g	you've got the start haven't you 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	above the caravan park 	
f	above the caravan park yeah 	
g	right 	
g	eh have you got something between the caravan park and the old mill have you got something in the bottom left-hand corner 	
f	the bottom left-hand corner i've got i've got a picket fence 	
g	right 	
g	see when you get start can you go round the picket fence 	
g	right 	
g	right round it and up over the old mill 	
f	wait minute the car-- the picket fence is at the bottom left-hand corner 	
g	mmhmm 	
g	but can you go 	
f	and the start is above the caravan park right 	
g	uh-huh 	
g	i just can you go down from the caravan park go down draw a line underneath the picket fence 	
f	so i'm going round the left of the caravan park 	
g	uh-huh sorry uh-huh 	
f	an-- to the very bottom of the page and round the p-- 	
g	to the botto-- un-- uh-huh 	
f	and round the picket fence 	
g	to the very bottom 	
g	round 	
g	then when you get get to the end of the picket fence go up straight up round pa-- 	
f	right 	
g	see the old mill 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	go right up there 	
g	see the top par-- er left-hand corner the old mill 	
g	go ri-- you go you're going round the old mill on the left-hand side 	
f	li-- going round the left-hand side of the old mill 	
g	uh-huh of the mill 	
g	right 	
f	so 	
f	i'm going between the picket fence and the mill 	
g	right 	
g	if the you start right you go down straight down under the picket fence 	
f	under the picket fence right 	
g	go right round the picket fence 	
g	right 	
f	right 	
g	got to do a curve come straight up 	
f	right 	
f	i'll have you know like i'll have to so i'm going between the picket fence and the mill right 	
g	no 	
g	are you not going right under the picket fence 	
f	yes 	
f	but you see the mill kind of overlaps my picket fence 	
g	well 	
g	you'll have to go right round it on the left-hand side 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	right 	
f	so i'm going rou-- round the left-hand side of the mill 	
g	of the old mill uh-huh 	
g	and get to the top of the roof 	
g	right 	
g	you're you're at the roof right so go up and there's about mm 	
f	right 	
g	see the fenced meadow 	
g	on the on the right-hand side at the bottom 	
f	uh-huh 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	right 	
g	see above that bi-- an inch and a half right about two inches right 	
g	mark that mark a spot right above th-- about two inches above the fenced meadow on the very left of that picture go up about two inches right and mark a spot 	
f	on the left of the fenced meadow 	
g	uh-huh on left of that picture right of the fenced meadow 	
g	come about two inches 	
g	right 	
f	oh the from the bottom of the picture 	
g	uh-huh uh-huh 	
f	come up about two inches 	
g	where the fence is right on the left-hand s-- 	
f	right i'm 	
f	so i'm below a forest 	
g	so 	
g	uh-huh 	
g	and see where the o-- bi-- that but see where the old mill is 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	see you come up draw a line between that and that where that fenced meadow where you've just made a mark right draw a straight line 	
f	right 	
f	so i should be just a ve-- just below the forest as well 	
g	yeah 	
g	well 	
g	i don't have a forest so ehm 	
f	oh right i see 	
g	i presume it must be 	
g	so you must go round that 	
g	right 	
g	see where you are then 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	draw a straight line going up 	
g	right 	
g	and curve round the abandoned cottage right above it 	
f	i ha-- 	
f	i have to curve round the forest 	
g	right so 	
g	and curve right up round above the 	
f	so i'm going round the right-hand side of the forest which you haven't got 	
g	to to your 	
g	mmhmm you will be yeah 	
f	right 	
g	go round the right side 	
g	and then right round t-- to to your left curve round to your left and you're going up above the abandoned cottage 	
f	right 	
f	so i'm going to the left-hand side of the abandoned cottage 	
g	no 	
g	go right 	
g	right 	
g	see where the forest is right 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	you're go-- you're curving right up and keep curving right round the side of the right-hand side sorry of the abandoned cottage so you're going round in a circle 	
f	right 	
f	i'm curving round it 	
g	uh-huh 	
f	right 	
g	th-- the right-hand side go down right 	
g	see where they've they've got the chimney right 	
f	chimney no 	
g	right see where that's s-- no 	
f	i don't have a chimney 	
g	see where the chimney is on the abandoned cottage 	
f	oh yes 	
g	right 	
f	right 	
g	right have you sto-- okay 	
g	stop about there 	
g	okay 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	have you got a fenced meadow on your le-- and about halfway up as well 	
f	no 	
g	you don't have a fenced meadow er 	
f	where's that 	
g	it's int-- half it's about halfway up the page and it's on the right the left-hand side of the page 	
f	right 	
g	halfway up 	
f	i'm kind of in line with the a-- abandoned cottage 	
g	well 	
g	about a wee bit eh an angle down towards your left a wee bit i-- it's eh 	
f	right 	
g	right 	
g	go up 	
g	see where the chimney is right 	
g	sort of make about a forty-five degree angle towards for about about an inch 	
g	okay 	
g	an inch 	
g	did it go down d-- 	
g	make an ang-- an angle to the bottom of that picture right going to your left 	
g	right 	
g	so you're about an inch away from the abandoned cottage if you what i mean you're curving right round 	
f	i've curved round the abandoned cottage 	
g	right so 	
g	sort of right right where you've stopped right 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	at that curve it should be about an inch away from the abandoned cottage right 	
f	i'm not that far away 	
f	i never knew 	
g	right 	
g	well can you make it make that curve 	
f	but e-- i oh sorry i've still avoi-- i've still avoided the abandoned cott-- 	
g	and then where you've stopped the curve sort of make a wide circle 	
g	eh have you got something between the a-- beside the abandoned cottage 	
f	no 	
f	well 	
f	i've got i've just got a monument to the right 	
g	to the right 	
g	mm ah so have i 	
g	i know where you are 	
g	so 	
g	do you know west lake is at the top 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	have you got a trig point 	
g	no you don't do you 	
f	no 	
g	have you got anything between west lake and abandoned cottage 	
f	no 	
g	nothing at all 	
f	no 	
f	have you 	
g	uh-huh 	
f	what 	
g	i've got a me-- a fenced meadow but in the dire-- 	
f	right 	
f	so i have to avoid that 	
g	mmhmm 	
f	so 	
f	am i going round the west lake 	
g	so 	
g	say the fenc-- say the fenced meadow's about halfway up 	
g	right 	
g	see where the abandoned cottage is 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	just down a wee bit right from that on the left 	
g	so you make sure you avoid that right round the very left-hand side the page sort of mark a bit so you avoid that 	
f	it's it's down a bit from the abandoned cottage 	
g	abandoned cottage about a 	
f	on the left 	
g	a centimetre uh-huh 	
f	right 	
f	i-- it's f-- the very left of the page 	
g	uh-huh the very left uh-huh 	
f	right 	
g	right 	
g	see right where are you now at the bottom of the abandoned cottage 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	about an inch away 	
f	no 	
f	the top of the abandoned cottage 	
g	did you make a curve 	
f	no 	
f	i've just come i've curved round the top of the abandoned cottage 	
g	right 	
f	that's all i've done 	
g	i-- mark about an inch away from the abandoned cottage right and to your left mark about an inch away from that 	
g	right 	
g	a wee dot there 	
f	eh no 	
g	no can you mark a dot there 	
f	where 	
g	about an inch away from the abandoned cottage on the left-hand side make it make it about an inch right 	
f	i'm not right 	
g	and see where the roo-- you've the top of the roof is 	
g	your your curve make a make a cu-- a line from there to there 	
f	uh-huh 	
f	right 	
g	okay 	
f	right i've done that 	
g	right 	
g	see where the west lake is 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	brrrr see where ehm the very bottom curve of it is 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	can you make it like 	
g	see where you are now you're about an inch away from the abandoned cottage right 	
g	can you make a sort of a wide circle sort of a half circle towards the ehm bottom of that point that curve of west lake 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	right see where the "e" is in west lake 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	in lake 	
g	eh go r-- it's right underneath there 	
g	you know i'm talking about that point 	
g	where it starts to curve like it's to there eh you need a kind of wide ci-- a h-- half circle 	
f	yes 	
f	a w-- 	
g	eh but you're about an inch and a half away from the edge of the page 	
f	what am i avoiding 	
f	see this eh what is it the thing you told me to mark 	
g	it's a fenced meadow 	
g	you're going above that 	
f	i'm going above that right 	
g	you're going above that 	
g	and you're about two inches away from the page 	
f	so i'm doing a cir-- 	
g	about a minute 	
f	so see on-- see 	
f	once i've done a circle up to where the 	
g	the west lake is 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	mmhmm follow the curve of the west lake 	
f	where do i go after that 	
f	because i just i don't understand 	
f	what way 	
g	right to oh aye to the ehm right 	
g	okay 	
f	so i'm what am i avoi-- you know how i'm curving round what am i avoiding 	
g	nothing 	
g	there's nothing there either 	
f	so why am i curving 	
g	well 	
g	that's what it is that's where the route is 	
f	right 	
g	okay 	
f	right i've done that 	
g	ehm 	
g	so you've curv-- and like you follow the curve of west lake 	
g	right 	
g	see where that see where i told you to go to stop at 	
f	you know 	
f	so i'm like i'm really kind of doubling back on myself a bit 	
g	uh-huh 	
g	you've got you're following to the to the right-hand side you're going right round the right-hand side see right see when you come to the right see right imagine you're at th-- the that point okay underneath the "e" 	
f	right 	
f	i've done 	
g	right 	
f	yes 	
g	at west lake right we're at that corner go round right round the circle 	
f	to the right 	
g	then 	
g	uh-huh to the right 	
g	then up keep going up 	
f	how far 	
f	am i just sort of circling round the west lake 	
g	'til you stop 	
g	uh-huh 	
g	'til you stop 	
g	where it starts you know where it starts eh sort of going sharply to the left in a straight line 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	stop there 	
f	have you got farm land above there as well 	
g	at that point 	
g	uh-huh mmhmm so y-- 	
f	about an inch below the farm land right 	
g	uh-huh 	
f	right i've done that 	
g	right 	
g	see beside ehm see where you've stopped then right do you know where that sharp bit is i'm talking about 	
f	just it curves round and then it goes up vertically and then you've i-- 	
g	follow that bit up vertically right 'til it stops going vertically that's what i mean right 	
f	uh-huh i've done that right 	
g	right 	
g	see where you've stopped 	
g	and how you can see a kind of a straight line it's almost a straight line 	
f	mmhmm 	
f	ehm 	
g	to your left in the west lake you know it goes folli-- it's sort of goes up vertically and it goes straight to your left well it goes up a bit 	
f	it goes up vertically then it goes to the left 	
g	uh-huh 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	well 	
g	just where it stops going vertically right 	
f	right 	
g	can you see the monument 	
f	i don't have a monument 	
f	oh no i have a mo-- 	
g	you do have a monument it's on the it's on the right-hand side it's to the right-hand side of the page about halfway up 	
f	uh-huh 	
f	away down 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	right 	
g	see where you've stopped 	
g	draw a straight line in that in that in that angle 	
g	see where that that vertical see that ehm 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	that line on the west lake goes sh-- sharply up 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	dra-- draw eh that's it's that angle i'm talking about draw a straight line to the monument from there 	
f	right down to the monument eh 	
g	mmhmm 	
g	on that angle 	
f	and eh 	
f	have you got a golf course 	
g	no 	
g	i take it you're going round the golf course 	
g	just draw a straight line 	
f	no 	
f	the golf course is like nearer the east lake below the east lake so 	
g	ah so it is 	
f	so i would be going to the left-hand side of the golf course 	
g	right 	
g	so where see the monument is 	
g	you're going underneath the monument and up 	
g	okay 	
g	you're curving round the monument 	
f	i'm com-- i'm doing like a i'm drawing a straight line down to the monument and curving r-- 	
g	and go round underneath it 	
f	round the bottom of it 	
g	and curve round the bottom of it uh-huh 	
f	i mean and like you've not got any obstacles here have you below 	
g	no 	
f	between the west lake and the monument 	
g	the west lake and the monument 	
g	i've got a p-- trig point 	
f	where's that so i have i have to avoid it 	
g	that's that's it's abou-- it's okay if you've gone right up towards that if you've gone right up 	
f	but where is it anyway 	
g	where the vertical bit is 	
f	where is it 	
g	see where the west lake is with the writing west lake 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	it's just about two inches away from that beside beside west lake 	
f	okay 	
f	right 	
f	so if i draw down 	
g	you should have curved over it if you had followed that curve west lake 	
f	i will have right uh-huh 	
g	you will right 	
g	and then you go straight it's a total straight line 	
f	a straight line 	
g	going sloping downwards towards the monument 	
f	right 	
f	i've and then curve round the monument 	
g	round the monument 	
f	right 	
g	just right round that 	
f	i've done that 	
g	eh sort of right 	
g	are you at the of top the monument see the guy's head 	
f	yes that's where i am 	
g	right 	
g	stop about there okay curved above it 	
g	ehm you know the east lake is 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	just go vertically up there 	
f	right 	
f	how far 	
g	fact 	
g	i'll tell you what would be even better 	
g	see the the guy's head on the monument the guy's hand sorry 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	where it's pointing right 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	so 	
g	go straight draw the line to you know where your fa-- 	
g	see that curve that you're drawing round the monument 	
g	stop above his hand 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	right 	
f	ah i went a bit further 'cause i thought you said 	
g	uh-huh 	
g	right 	
g	and just c-- and go from there go straight up towards the east lake so you should be directly under the the "e" in lake 	
f	no 	
f	my monument's more to the right of the page than that the east lake's fa-- 	
g	uh-huh 	
g	see the "e" in the word lake 	
f	oh the word the "e" in the word la-- 	
g	the word "e" 	
f	right 	
g	in the lake right 	
g	see directly u-- underneath that on the on the coast line of that if you know what i mean the edge of it 	
f	mmhmm 	
g	make a dot there right 	
f	direc-- 	
f	directly 	
f	underneath the "e" 	
g	underneath the "e" 	
g	underneath the "e" 	
g	make a dot right beside the lake 	
g	and from the monument the guy's hand on the monument draw a line from that 	
g	okay 	
g	to the east lake and then just follow the curve of the east lake 	
f	right 	
g	so you follow the curve of the east lake to the left 	
g	sorry i've thought it was to the left 	
f	right 	
f	right 	
g	right 	
g	so eh 	
g	you know the bottom left of the east lake 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	about in a centimetre away from that keep drawing a line and then finish it 	
g	okay 	
f	the botto-- wha-- 	
f	say that again 	
g	see the "e" in the east 	
f	yes 	
g	the letter the word east 	
g	underneath that draw a line about an inch away from that okay keep following the coast line 	
g	but don't don't go up don't go up vertically 	
f	right 	
f	don't go up 	
g	you kn-- h-- just go straight along that except carry the line on 	
f	uh-huh 	
f	how far 	
g	for about another centimetre 	
g	and just draw a cross 	
f	a centimetre from the "e" 	
g	mmhmm 	
f	is that all 	
f	right 	
g	mmhmm 	
g	y-- but see where the east lake is see that that kind of line you followed 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	s-- of the lake 	
f	uh-huh 	
g	d-- you haven't gone up have you 	
g	'cause the line goes straight up you know how it goes vertically up 	
f	what with the 	
f	no i haven't done that 	
g	well 	
g	that's okay 	
g	that'll be it finished