Refute Hijab in this text:

''The discussion at hand focuses on a Hadith (Sunan Abi Dawud, 3876) that recommends consuming seven Ajwa dates in the morning as a means of protection against poison and magic. Although this Hadith is widely popular, critics argue that there is no scientific evidence to support these claims.

Hijab explores various scholars’ perspectives on the Hadith, covering opinions that the immunity provided comes from the blessings of Prophet Muhammad to those who argue that the Hadith’s validity can only be established through scientific experiments.

An intriguing viewpoint, according to Hijab, suggests that the protection offered by the dates may be unrelated to any inherent characteristic of the dates themselves. Instead, the protection might be due to the act of consuming the dates as a form of worship. This interpretation is supported by another Hadith recounting Prophet Muhammad making a supplication in the evening, which underscores the balanced and reasonable approach held by Hadith commentators towards science and the Quran.

Ultimately, Hijab contends that the efficacy of the Hadith depends on the will of God, as long as no preventing factors are present, such as engaging in haram activities or obtaining haram income. From a scientific perspective, the author acknowledges that it is impossible to disprove this notion. The reliance on divine will underscores the importance of faith in interpreting and understanding the Hadith and its intended effects.'




And use this text below as reference point. Do not repeat the text above, just rewrite the entire text below in detail. Mention everything, even Quran verses and Hadithes. Also add some more good arguments based on quran and Hadith and logic to counter the Author Hijab's arguments. Be very critical and do not try to defend the Quran in this case, just refute Hijabs arguments:


''The Hadith in discussion is often cited as evidence for the belief that consuming seven Ajwa dates can provide immunity against poison and magic, without requiring any additional blessings or prayers for its effectiveness. This belief is supported by two Hadiths recorded in Sahih Bukhari 7:65:356 and Sahih Bukhari 7:65:663, narrated by Sad and Saud, respectively. The first Hadith states that "he who eats seven 'Ajwa dates every morning, will not be affected by poison or magic on the day he eats them," while the second Hadith claims that "if somebody takes some 'Ajwa dates every morning, he will not be affected by poison or magic on that day till night."

However, Mohammad Hijab's attempt to defend this Hadith by suggesting that it requires additional blessings or prayers for its effectiveness or that the person must ensure to not commit any sins prior to consuming the dates is a complete reinterpretation of the original text. The text clearly does not mention any of these alleged requirements, and even if it did, it would still be scientifically nonsensical to believe it.

In reality, while dates offer several health benefits, they do not possess the ability to cure or prevent diseases or poisonings on their own. Therefore, Hijab's defense of the Hadith as a cure for poison and magic is a weak argument that does not hold up against scientific evidence. It is highly doubtful that Hijab himself would drink poison even after consuming dates while fulfilling his made-up requirements.''