Stanton pitched for the New York Yankees for seven seasons. During that span, Stanton was a large part of the Yankees World Series teams, proving himself in big roles out of the bullpen. He garnered a 6–1 record in 1997, and appeared in 64 games. In the 1997 American League Division Series, he allowed one hit in one inning while striking out three. In 1998, Stanton went 4–1 and collected six saves during the Yankees' 114-win season. After not pitching in the Division Series, he returned during the Championship Series and allowed two hits and one walk while striking out four over three games. In the 1998 World Series, Stanton allowed three hits and two earned runs. Despite his lackluster performance, he earned a World Series ring as the Yankees swept the Padres four games to none. In 1999, he was 2–2 in 73 games, and did not pitch in the Division Series.