Carroll signed to the UK Independent record label One Little Indian in 2011. The label released a 12 track retrospective collection, "In Silence" in the same year. Released as a Limited Edition 200gram Heavyweight Vinyl and CD. Most of the vinyl was destroyed in a warehouse fire at the PIAS headquarters during the London riots of 2011. The album received a 4 star review in "Uncut magazine" as well as the 'Must have reissue' in the British "Sunday Times". The album also garnered 4 star reviews from "Americana", "Sunday Express" and other publications. "Record Collector Magazine" wrote, "Having been making music just under the radar for well over a decade now, it's only fair that Carroll gets his turn in the spotlight. While his albums should receive more attention than this compilation, "In Silence" certainly serves as a good introduction to his multifarious talents."