Toquero once again was a regular starter for Athletic during 2010–11, opening his official goal account on 30 January 2011 by netting twice in a 2–0 win at Atlético Madrid. At the end of the following season, he came off the bench in both the UEFA Europa League and the Spanish Cup finals, both of which ended in 3–0 defeats; in October 2012 he renewed his contract, due to expire in June 2013, for three more years.