Nash moved to Everton, the team he supported as a boy, as reserve goalkeeper to Tim Howard on a two-year contract on 1 September 2008. He made his only appearance in a Europa League dead rubber group tie at home to Belarusian club BATE Borisov on 17 December, which Everton lost 1–0. He was on the bench for the 2009 FA Cup Final, which his team lost 2–1 to Chelsea.