Carofiglio competed at the first Italian Serie A where her club placed third and individually she placed fourth in the all-around. She next competed at the 2017 City of Jesolo Trophy where she placed 21st in the all-around, fourth on vault, and fifth in the team final. At the second Italian Serie A she placed third in the all-around behind Martina Maggio and Asia D'Amato. Carofiglio competed at the Italian Gold Championships in May where she won silver in the all-around and on vault behind Maggio, fifth on uneven bars and balance beam, and won gold on floor exercise. In June she competed at the FIT Challenge where she placed 12th in the all-around and helped Italy win gold. At the Italian National Championships Carofiglio placed sixth in the all-around, second on vault behind D'Amato, and fourth on floor exercise. In October Carofiglio competed at the 2017 World Championships but did not qualify for any event finals.