On 8 May 2019, it was reported that Angelico had signed with All Elite Wrestling (AEW). He would reform his team with Jack Evans, now known as The Hybrid2. The team made their debut at AEW's inaugural pay-per-view event Double or Nothing on May 25, losing to Best Friends (Trent Beretta and Chuck Taylor). At Fight for the Fallen on July 13, The Hybrid2 competed in a three-way tag team match against Jungle Boy and Luchasaurus and The Dark Order (Evil Uno and Stu Grayson), which the Dark Order won. At the All Out "Buy In" pre-show on August 31, The Hybrid2 lost to Private Party (Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen). Angélico obtained his first win in AEW on the October 8 episode of "AEW Dark", teaming with Evans and the Lucha Brothers (Fénix and Pentagón Jr.) to defeat Best Friends and Private Party in an eight-man tag team match.