On 22 January 2019 it was reported that Priestley was close to signing a contract with All Elite Wrestling (AEW) after turning down a WWE contract. It was announced on the edition of 27 February 2019 of "Road To Double Or Nothing" that Priestley would be joining the company, and would be making her debut at Fight for the Fallen on 13 July 2019, where she would team with Shoko Nakajima to defeat Britt Baker and Riho, and Priestley drew criticism when her first move in the match was giving Baker a stiff kick to the back of her head, giving Baker a concussion and temporarily blinding her in one eye. She entered an on-screen feud with Britt Baker, eventually losing a singles match to Baker at AEW Full Gear. Priestley appeared on the 11 December 2019 edition of Dark, where she was defeated by "the Alien" Kris Statlander.