"I Made It" received generally positive reviews from music critics who praised its composition and Fantasia's performance. The song was nominated for the Dr. Bobby Jones Best Gospel/Inspirational Award in the BET Awards 2017, but lost Lecrae's 2016 song "Can't Stop Me Now (Destination)". It peaked at number 15 on the "Billboard" Gospel Airplay chart. Fantasia promoted "I Made It" on "Good Morning America" and Tribbett's show "Joyful Noise", and the performances were met with positive feedback.