On November 22, 2015, Gomez performed "Same Old Love" at the American Music Awards flanked by a bevy of tuxedo-clad male dancers on a cabaret-themed stage with an illuminated staircase and disco balls. "Billboard" magazine wrote, "Gomez's set offered the night's most eye candy", while "Entertainment Weekly" said "Gomez delivered what might have been the sultriest performance of the night". Brittany Spanos of "Rolling Stone" called it a "stylish performance". The song was included as part of Gomez's set list for iHeartRadio's Jingle Ball Tour throughout December 2015. As the musical guest on "Saturday Night Live" on January 23, 2016, Gomez performed a medley of "Good for You" and "Same Old Love".