Her second collaboration with Nicholson, "Wreck &amp; Ruin" (September 2012), reached No. 6 and provided another ARIA Award for Best Country Album in the next year. Keefe found the album has, "the married couple layering intricate vocal harmonies over some casual, mostly acoustic country-rock... Though [it] impresses for its thematic focus and gallows humor, the economy of language in the songwriting occasionally scans as a bit pedestrian."