Stucker played for the Ball State Cardinals from 1988 to 1991. He was named to the All-MAC First Team as a junior and senior after being named to the second team as a freshman and sophomore. He connected on 93-of-96 extra points and 62-of-87 field goals in his career. Stucker was selected to play in Blue-Gray College Football All-Star Game after his senior season. He was inducted into the Ball State Athletics Hall of Fame in 2009.