On 1 January 2018 episode of "Raw", Bálor teamed with Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson to defeat Elias and The Miz Touareg (Curtis Axel and Bo Dallas) in a six–man tag team match. The following week, the trio officially reunited and formed "Bálor Club", an homage to their former stable. That same night, they defeated Intercontinental Champion Roman Reigns and Raw Tag Team Champions Seth Rollins and Jason Jordan in a six–man tag team match. On 28 January, at the 2018 Royal Rumble, Bálor entered his first Royal Rumble match at number 2, lasting over 57 minutes and eliminating four participants before being eliminated by John Cena. A month later, Bálor competed for the first time in an Elimination Chamber match at the namesake pay–per–view, where he entered last but was the second participant eliminated by Braun Strowman. Throughout March and April, Bálor started a short feud with The Miz and Seth Rollins over the Intercontinental Championship, which led to a triple threat match at WrestleMania 34 (which was also Bálor's Wrestlemania debut) where Rollins won the title. Three weeks later, at the Greatest Royal Rumble event, Bálor once again unsuccessfully challenged for the Intercontinental Championship in a fatal four–way ladder match against Rollins, Miz and Samoa Joe. In June, Bálor competed in a Money in the Bank ladder match, however, the match was ultimately won by Braun Strowman.