The next two seasons were less impressive and Murphy eventually resigned in May 1985, after seven years at Sincil Bank. His departure came just 10 days before Lincoln played Bradford on the final day of the season in the game where 56 spectators died in the Bradford City disaster. The Murphy era is remembered fondly by the Imps faithful, with players such as Steve Thompson, Glenn Cockerill, Trevor Peake, Mick Harford, Tony Cunningham, Dave Felgate and John Fashanu (signed by Murphy) contributing to one of the finest teams in Lincoln's history.