Kearns' follow up, appearing at the Leicester Comedy Festival as "No More Mr. Niche Guy", later becoming "Shtick", acknowledges the impact of his previous show's success on himself and his career. Directed again by Brittain and returning to the same venue that had hosted his 2013 Edinburgh Festival Fringe run, The Voodoo Rooms, the show saw positive reactions from audiences and press, as well as another Fosters Comedy Awards nomination, this time for Best Show. On 23 August 2014, he won the award, becoming the first act to win Best Newcomer and Best Show in consecutive years.