Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 2 Filed 06/05/2006 Page 1 of 5

NOT FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

DARREN E. RICHARDSON, lOt al., Plaintiffs, v.
MORRIS COUNTY CORRP,CTIONAL FACILITY, et al.,
Defondants.

Civil Action No. OPINION

IDMC)

Appearances:
PlainLi..fJe, pro se Darren E. Rich"rdeon Terique Jones Omar Thomas P;ennet.h D,3n Is ,Tose Rodriqur]z Morris County Correctional FAcility
43 lJohn StrecL
Morristown, NJ U7960-4237

CAVANAUGH, District Judge:

Darren E. Richardson, Ter'i.qu~' Jones, Omar Thomas, Kenneth

~, and Jose Rodriguez,

Morris County

Correctional FaciliLy in Morristown, New Jersey, have sUbmitted

this Compl"int under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 tind have asked Lho

t.o

all ow Lhem to proceed in forma

under 28 u.s.c. § 1915.'

This

res

coun to determine whether Fed.R.Cjv.P. 20

I An application to

in form,3 pauPcr·i~3 Has submi Lted

by Plaintiff Darren E. Richardson, only.

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 2 Filed 06/05/2006 Page 2 of 5

authorizes the ioindor of these claims and plajntiffs and, if so,

how to assess the filing fee requJ.red under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b).

I. FACTUi\ T, BACKGROUND

PlainLJffs aGsert a Gories of cJaims challenging cell sear~hes and strip searches conducted on prisoners ill Pre-hearing Detention or Disciplinary Detelltion. no Saturd~y mail services. the law libr~ry, the ~de~lacy 01 vegetarian rne~l trays, and the

footweQr provided to prisoners.
1I. ANAL'l'S rs
'1'i1.; . I.e 28 secti.on 1915 govern:; proceedings in forma pauP(lI"j 13

and imposes specit:d limitatj.ons with Y'p.specL to in forma pauperis

actions brought by prisoners. Rule 20 governs permissive joinder

of partie:; and provides. in pertinent part, that "[21111 persons may join in one act.i.on as plaintiffs if they ~8sert any right to relief jointly, severally, or in the alternative ill respect of or

a.rising out of the same tI'ansaction, occurrence. or series of

tr4ansacti,ons or occurrences and if any qU8s'Lj,on of law or fact

common to all these persons will arise in the action.-

Two I'cuit CourLs of Appeals have" ,;lDalyzed the interrelationship of S 1915 and Rule 20. In Hubbard v. il~ley,

262 f.3d 1194 (11th Cir. 2001),

.534 U.S. 1136

(200?), the Court of Appeals for t.he Eleventh Circuit conCluded

the

§ 1915 (b) (1), that "the prisoner shall be

roquired to pay the ],ull amount of a fiJ.ing fee,- requires each

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 2 Filed 06/05/2006 Page 3 of 5

prisoner to bring il. sepuri:lLE' snit and, t.o the ext.ent. that statulory langua']e act.ually conL ]i.ct.s wi Lh Rule 20, the st.atut~'

repeals t.he rule. The Court of Appeals for the Seventh C·i rcui t, however, found

no irreconcilable conflict. between § 1915 (b) (1) and Bule 20 and

held that district courts must accept complaints flIed by multiple prisoncY", if the cd t.eria of permissive joinder are satisfied. boriboune v. Uerye, 391 ~·.3d 852 (7th Cir. 2001).

Nevertheless, the Seventh Circuit held tllat each prisoner joining

in a mult.iple-prisoner civil acLion must pay t.he full l.i.Ung fee in ord~'r t.o comply w.J t.h t.he clear 1anguage of fi 191.5 (b) (l) and to

satisLy t.he financ.la.l incentive of t.he :.;lat.ut.e to deter frivolous

prisoner-· actions. 391 F. 3d tlt. 8S5~S6.

Whet.her or rIot t.here is an inherent conflict between

§ 1915 (b) and Bule 20, at. lea:.;L 1:.\"0 district conrts have .found

t.hat the i.mpracticaliL.i es inherent i.n multiple-prisoner litigat.ion militate against the permissive joinder allowed by

Rule 20.

Wasko v. Allen CounL.y ,Jail, 2006 WL 978956

(N.D.Ind. 2006);

2006 WL 240)33 (D. Mont.

2006). Among t.he difficulLi.es noted by these court.s are t.he need

if I to sign the pJeadings, and t.he consequent.

possibilit.ies that documents may be changed DS they are

ci

OI' that.

SOI1UJ."·S may seek Lo compel prison

authorit

to pe t them t.o

to discuss the joint

3

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 2 Filed 06/05/2006 Page 4 of 5

litigation. These two district C011rts llavc also noted that jail

popu.1ations are Ilot,ab.Ly tY'ansitor:y, mokinq joint litiCJatlon

difficult. A £j.na1 consideration for the District Court for the

District of Montana was the possibility that ·coercio!., subtle or

not, freqnently plays a roJe in relations between inmates."

Swenson, 2006 W1 240233, *1.

This Court finds the reasoning oi these district courts

p8rsuAsive. Prisoner's ClL'C not. in the some ::; 'j tuat.ion as non-

prisoner joint plaintiffs; prisoners' circumstances make joint

li.tigation exceptional.lY difficult. In addi.tion. Plaintiffs here have as~crLcd claims that

require individualized scn)cni.ng pursuant lo 78 U.S.C. 2 1915(e) (2). For eXcullpJe, Plaintiffs chalJenge the failure to

post a law library sclledule and to provide adequate access to

federal case law. The Court construes this as an attempt to

state a claim for violatioll of the right of acccss to the courts. To ~"'Late such a claim, however, a prisoner must. show that prison

off icials caused him past or' imminent "ac Lua.L :i nj ury." See Lewis

518 U.S. 343, 348-~~ and n.3 (1996); Olivcr v. Fauver, 118 F. 3d 17~, J77-78 (3d Cir. 1991). Thus, each prisoner must.

1

injury to him in order t.o state a claim. Joinder of their

claims, howcver, would permit all Plalntiffs to avoid the risk of

a ·strike" undcr § 1915(g) if even one Plaintiff states a claim,

because § 1915(g)

13 a stxike only if tll8 cnLl.re action is

4

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 2 Filed 06/05/2006 Page 5 of 5

dismissed. For all of the foregoing reasons, joi.nder is not

appropriate. Rule 21 provides Lhat -[plerties mny bc dropped [from n

casel

on such terms as are just." It would not bc just

merely to dismiss all but the lead Plaintiff from this casco

Instead, this Court will direct the Clerk to open a separate case

for each of the other Plaintiffs in this action. Each of the

P.laintiffs will be grented leave to fi.l.e an amended complaillL asserting his individual ~leims.
Nothing in Lh.i 6 Opinion should be construed as precluding any or all of the Plaintiffs from cooperating to the extent thaL

they ere able or 16 preventing consolidation of these cases for
trial if th~t becomes appropriate at a laLe( da~e.

III. CONCLUSION

For the reasons set forth herein, tllis Court finds that jojnder of ~laintiffs' claims under Hule 20 js not suitable. An

appropriete Order follows.

Dated: 5/31/06

States District Judge 5

 
 Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 1 of 25

'.

Case 2:06-cv-023Z1OJU11roBE UBfiflJ8J~1A f-R15ONtiBlNimA:NJ&lA Page 1 of 25

CIVil RIGHTS COMPLAINT

UNITED FOR THE

STATES DISTRICT DISTRICT OF NEW

CJOERUSRETt,~i·,~EfrJ:iESITV[RDI'C-CTL':Cr,U',lJ,l{(T

voA/l:~

lnUb MI\Y 23 A 10: 51

~:~M(01 (Dn'C)

v.

-to! Civil Action No.

ygtL~9 OM t)

(To be supplied by the Cleltl of lhe Cou~)

£~".\.".~) sb...Jr f,k'MLY-=-.
!ksbkrl) c,l,;"J R",~\., M"(j-..",,,,")
W'...~(,n If(,,~l c.,}r·(~()k, c." ~1"'1" j
- d ~I"'"

INSTRUCTIONS - READ CAREFULLY
1, This oomplaint must be legibly handwritten or typewritten, signed by the plaintiff and subscribed to under penalty of perjury as being true and correct. All questions must be answered concisely in the proper space on the form. Where more space is needed 10 answer any question, attach a separate sheet.
2, In accordance wIth Rule 8 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the complaint ghould contain (1) a short and plain statement of the grounds upon which the court's jurisdiction depends, (2) a short plain statement of Ihe claim showing that you are entitled to relief, and (3) a demand for judgment for Ihe relief which you seek,
3, YOll mllst provide Ihe hIli name of each defendant or defendants and where they can be
found
4. You must send the original and one copy of the complaint to the Clerk of the District Court. YOLI must also send one additional copy of the complaint f.Q( til.t\c'Q ~dant to the Clerk, Do not send the complaint directly to the defendants,
5. Upon receipt of a fee of $150,00, your complaint will be filed You will be re~ponsible for service of a separate Slimmons and copy of the complaint on each defendant. See Rule 4, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure.
PNJ·ProS.·006·07·10!;/0B)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 2 of 25
Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 2 of 25 FORM TO BE USED BY A PRISONER IN fiLING A CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT

2

DNJ-ProS• .oo6.o7.(IleI98)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 3 of 25
Case 2:06-cv-0231fl1>BiMct'CI!IBE lJIS6QIi\¥!1\ f'~rS~68t\ij/2jj;.!Mti€A Page 3 of 25 CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT

6. If you C6nnot prepay the $150.00 filing fee, you may request permission to proceed in forma pauperis in accordance with the procedures set forth below. (If there is more than one plaintiff, each plaintiff musl separately request permission to proceed in fonna pauperl:;.)
The Prison Litigation Reform Act of 1996 ("PLRA"), effective April 26, 1996, has made
significant changes to the iD flmni 12i!Y.t1~ statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1915. The statute no longer
prOVides for waiver of court filing fees for prisoners who are granted leave to proceed in forma gaugerls. A prisoner who is granted leave 10 proceed in forma paupeds Is nol required 10 pay the filing fees in advance, bUllhe prisoner is obligated to pay the entire filing fee in Installment payments regardless of the outcome of the proceeding. This obligation to pay the filing fee continues even if the prisoner Is transferred to another prison. Therefore, before submitting this application to the Clerk of the Court, a prisoner should con&ider carefully whether he or she wishes to go forward with the action.
The PLRA obligates prisoners who are granted in forma pauperis status to pay the entire filing fee in the following manner, regardless of the outcome of the litigation. 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(1) and (2). The agency having custody over the prisoner shall deduct from the prisoner's
institutional account and forward to the Clerk of the Court (1) an initial partial filing fee equal to
20% of the greater of the average monthly deposits to the prisoner's account or the average monthly balance in the prisoner's account for the six-month period immediately preceding the filing of the complaint, and (2) payments equal to 20% of the preceding month's income credited to the prisoner's Institutional account each monlh the amount in the account exceeds $10.00, until the $150.00 filing fee is paid. 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(1) and (2). Howeller, a prisoner who has no assets and no means by which to pay the initial partial filing fee will not be prohibited from bringing a civil action. 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(4).
Each prisoner plaintiff who desires 10 proceed ill fI'l.an.Il ploll.I[;lfirili must submit the following to
the Clerk of the Court:
a. a completed, signed, and daled application to proceed ill fim:rulIlilJJI2~ris
(attached hereto); and
b. II certified copy of your prison account statement for the 6-month period immediately preceding submission of this application, listing the account balance and all deposits into the account. A prison account statement must bo obtained from the appropriate official of Bach prison at which you are or were confined during the preceding 6 months,
7. If your application to proceed in forma pauperis does not conform to these instructions, you will be notified by letler of the nature of the deficiencies. If these deficiencies are not cured within 120 days of the date of the letter, the complaint will be deemed withdrawn, the Clerk's file will be closed, and no fees will be assessed against you.
8. If you are given permission to proceed in Lorma Qauperis, the Clerk will prepare and issue a copy of the summons for each defendant. The copies of summonses and the copies of the

3

ON J·p'oS.-OO(l-O7-{ 0619S'1

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 4 of 25
Case 2:06-cv-023~I!IIBE 1!i5ElY1!JVl\tl.1p'RIS~~ A Page 4 of 25 CIVil RIGHTS COMPLAINT

complaint which you have submitted will be forwarded by the Clerk to the United States Marshal, who is responsible for service. The Marshal has USM-285 fonns you must complete so that the Marshal can locate and serve each defendant. If the forms are sent to you, you must complete them in full and return the forms to the Marshal.

QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED

1. Jurisdiction Is asserted pursuant to (CHECK ONE)

~

~ ~ ;;~ 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (applies to atate prisoners) p,.... tv-i" I J t .. ",- ..,.

Bivens y. Six Unknown Named Agents of Fed, eyreill of Narcalics, 403 U.S. 388 (1971) and 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (applies to federal prisoners)

If you want to assert jurisdiction under different or additional statutes, lisl theae below:

2. Previously Dismissed Federal Civil Actions or Appeals
If you are proceeding in f2!:m! payoerjs. list each civil action or appeal you have brought in a federal court while YOLI were incarcerated or detained In any facility, that was dismissed as frivolous or malicious, or for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be grllnted. Please note that a prisoner who has on three or mere prior occasions, while detained In any facility, brought an action or appeal In Il federal court that was dismissed as frivolous or malielous, or for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted, will be denied in forma pauperis status unless that prisoner is under imminent dangElr of serious physical injury. See 28 U.S.C. § 1915(9)·
a. Parties 10 previous lawsuit:
Plaintiff(s): _.~ .c:M-j/f-Lf-'\_ _ _ _ ....... ,., __,_..._,_ _ _~_ _ _ __
Defendanl(s): _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

b. Court and docket number: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
c. Grounds for dismissal: ( ) frivolous ) malicious ( 1failure 10 slate a claim upon

4

DNJ·PfoS".006·07·(OOI9&)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 5 of 25
Case 2:06-cv-0234fl~FBE l1ge'l!f11:W'W JlIR1S0kl!!Rl~1@ft§ A Page 5 of 25
CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT
which relief may be granted
d. Approximate date of filing lawsuit: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
e. Approximate date of disposition: _ _ _ _ _ _ _._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~
If there is more than one t:lvil action or appeal, describe the additional civillctions or appeals using this same format on separate sheets.

4. Parties
(In ttem (a) below, place your name In the first blank and place your present address in the second blank. Do the same for additional plaintiffs, 1f any.)
a. Name of plaintiff: J2~~~-.D.:~~::::::.'__'_'!:.:!.;!;!...1+.!.'::!.-'-'l!'~L!!!!~--"~UbL;~­
Address: meC f) ~3 J'dh" S±r.,c:,+/ O1or",J~...."" n,,·oJ Je_~,~(I" /

r b. First defendant -- name: J,w"..! V, Q,'XASMJ

Official position: _\.5.. !....!k~(-'--d~~'------------------­

"I'·, Place of employment: ill. Cg"'''b ~,r, IC'.~ cJ I-f,~

.'

. i..I3 Joh.. -5 \-((.n ! 1Y'\00t';~<M"J "<0", -k,"",:) 01)(, Le) -'1]3'1

How IS thiS person Involved In the case?

.

(i.e., what are you allegil1g that this person did or did not do that Violated yOl.lf

constitutionsl rights?)

I o \k""\") l""J ,tf :~'" Ii~.,4:,t {v.4IM )rb,'/1!'",j"",A lW,J (il oIL,,,,A, I
+I'>l- IYbrf \', ~'\

\/ ;l..tAL~ JA..o\-") "bJ(t~"J'11(.,t.1 hf4..>~ e.;'" t

5

DNJ·ProS.,006·07,(00"'01

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DM· C-M- F -D- ocum~ en- t 1 -F- iled- 05- /23/- 200- 6 - Pag- e 6- of - 25 --Case 2:06-cv-0231tD9MCJG1BE UtiDIIBYr'/\ 'ftIlISOfl(IUM8'f~1illA Page 6 of 25 CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT
..

Cl c. Seoond defendant - name:

I;, t ~\.b ~\d;,..{I.\O"

Official position: W-nJ<-i 'ib"" ~~

Place of employment -'-'.u:L~--"'''''''''Ull~'''''''''''''''''-'-''=k-''-:''O<..I.l~r-_ _ _ _ __

1..\ 3 )01-.., 5tf•.<1- J
How ill this person involved in the case?

<;"J<;'j o">'IH-'llJ7

(i.e., what are you alleging that this person did or did not do that violated your

constitutional rights?)

Ai",tP\~"'1 r'I. I ('/\II"\~ 'yO

_ 0\\':l>'.r., \\~ In "" f ,:s.~" H -19 ~~.8I'~s. 1", "i~\r,'w:s- ,,'..\-;, ,.L",M.t: &

\'(I('\') ,

d. Ifthere afe more than two defendants, attach a separate sheet. For each defendant

specify: (1) name, (2) official pOlSition, (3) place of employment, and (4) involvement of the

defendant.
I1·\t ,T\TAt:\ .,..I-\.

(;II p.\

I, rn~·(,r I

.
"\.'

-JoI "'''

S' \(('\'/

IIIlI<iI\Vf'l~tD""\ 11.1.<........JM~~

0 '"Ho . '03

5. I previously have sought informal or formal relief from the appropriate administrative officials

regarding the aots complained of in the Statement of Claims on page 6.

LYell _ No

P ',,, fA( 0\-

If your answer Is "Yes," briefly describe the sleps laken, Including how reHef was sought. from whom you sought relief, and the reSUlts.
-1b.c'IVl1~'.' 5<.","'" G~\:.i""I\Y",~). (l,.NI... :I.nl"'l.,t<- R<A,v ••1 \=Q'M5 _~d­
'\\';JlJ..uL"\\~J I l\b~) .9(~!W\tf5 .. u&f't- ~(·,,_d! h.:A£(t- ,.u"'}~I.·h·,,,,,
,,'. c.l. J,~ ,·,01

If your answer is "NQ," briefly explain Why administrative remedies were not exhausted.

6

ONJ,pmS••006-07-IOMI8)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 7 of 25 Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 7 of 25
o ~ \,"" \,,\ ~\l '" '1 ID\"1: W(>.{"~ 0"')
~\"C(, J 'CM~\~J'""1V'i:" \'f\Olfl> C.ov-,,~ C()[(t,.hu""\ f 0<,'\,1-:;
'I~c!"., ,e> t\\. Q",dO'" 'i f\\J J\\J< J.. "Ih t\~" (;,c,~,< 7,
lFor' O~t:-("\":J (A,,~ jor ~i'-"\~"h,t;J l'I.",J lor 1'\I"'l",;"T"I''''~' (AV"~ ic,(
1\\\O""'~3 f'\'"- (\"\<-V\': S\-.,ft·h <:'~ljC'Je;(\ \)IO\"t;"...... "''-\'., d";,,,.. J
~ .... 1("t..~ (\ •
Sl\(~l ~\'(III Fit·\(..C,,,' \- Je ~.c.""L\i)\-) _. f\"i"'{'~" -::)0\,,, \:)UL> ,~,,~ '}~hlL
Rue:' \- l j)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 8 of 25
Case 2:06-cv-023~(ft:&!WE LUlU'VI)\ PRISGNriiROtil'f'JJmCEA Page 8 of 25 CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT

6. Statement of Claims
(State here as briefly as possible the facts of your case, Describe how each defendant violated your rights, giving dates and places_ If you do not specify how each defendant violated your rights and the date(s) and place of the violations, your complaint may be dismissed, Include elso the names of other persons who are involved, including dates and places. Do not gIve any legal arguments or cile any cases or statutes. If you intend to allege a number of related claims, number and set forth eaoh claim in a separate paragraph. Use as much space as you need. Attach a separate sheet if neoelillilary,)
\\ • ""I'

I

".....

, ,

~\.--L:\,,---,-1)-,-,-,_" \" Lv 1-.\)" ".::;<:v\.,,,1J ,_ jL~)c,i-rl"l'~_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

, c-
.)

7

ONJ·P roSe·Qo6-{)7-(0618 8)

_-----_ _ - _ Case 2:06-cv-024..6--1--D-.M-C--M-.F...... Document 1.. Filed 05/2•.. 3_._/_2._.0...0. 6 Page 9 of 25
Case 2:06-cv-O~$R~tfE USRI::srrr!AlPRISO&:lI~G:JA Page 9 of 25 CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT

7. Relief (State briefly exactly what you want the Court to do for you. Make no legal t'lrguments. Gile no cases or statutes.)
L ~d ..r-(, -I-h ..~ \:L 'ooJ ..,! Iii tb J•.knJ...,h il lA!.:)l" v C.... i ", b,-",l-.:-J
2....
v' ...4-

(" A""...,..l ~\",'v,~. rfs H,,,-; r ,"u' ~,; d-l-.n..i \- •

B. Do you reQuast a jury or non-jury trial? (Check only one)

(v0Jury Trisl

( ) Non-Jury Trial

I declare under penalty of perjury that the ioregoing is true and correct.

- 1nl - Signed this

Ih day of -\\.'.IJt.\.lj..L,AJ.,~,~"+----~_ _--, 200._[,,,,--_

---/>o.:.JJ.:....:.-~,~'------­ [. ,t..\"",",}Wi) , ,t,Il' I~·,I· .\,,,):()·t)

8

DNJ.ProSMJIl&-07.(06196)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 10 of 25
Signature of plaintiff'

1 EACH PLAINTIFF NAM!"O IN THE COMP~AINT MI,IST SIGN THE COMP~INT HERE ADD ADDITIONAL LINES IF THERE IS MORE THAN ONE PLAINTIFF, REMEMBER, EACH P~INTIFF MUST SIGN THE COMPLAINT,

9

DNJ·P'QS'·006-01~O~198)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 11 of 25

Case 2:0S-cv-02340-DMC-MF , , Document 1-1 '-'P'ff'ed'05/23/2006" Page-11"ot25 ' " , ",,,

.

. :.

-

"

.

.

"MORRI

S

'

COUNTY ,,

COR
"

R

E

C

T

I

O

N

A

L ,

F

A

C

l

l

.

l

T

Y

Inmate Grievance Form #

=

Inmate Name: 5"1'. (, IILe. J Ol"'eJ

LD_ # 2 '5 '\.2 3 Date: 0 JII,· h.

Housing Unit:_...l3_-.J,..t5L.'______

_-'.-\_page of--'-.\_ ' ,

Nature of Grievance:

Received b : Recorded b : Referred to: Answer to levance:

,Y!rk- Date:
Date:
Date:
Date:

- - - ""-'----,----~------------------

Answered b

Date:

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/-23/-200-6 -P-age-12.o_ f 25..

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY

- ..

. _ . " ~.

--"

Inmate Grievance Form #

Inmate Name: Octrttl) '{J\\(\('\''f~SIlT\ __ J.D. # '2..l.\S-'5!) Date: &~r;) t'1,}j

Housing Unit:_jL.-....\B:L-._ _~__

'I page of-l..\_

Narure of Grievance:

Received.b : Recorded b :. Referred to: Answer to levance:

Date: Date: Date:

"._,....., . , . , - - - - - - - - - - , - - _ . _ - - - - - - - - - - - -
.. Date:
- - - - -_ _ _ _-...!.'--L______ '"''"''".'.''' .

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 13 of 25 Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 13 of 25
"
"
/
" .
;
;
II"
I
. I
I
i
I I
, i
.. ,
, ",,, '"' .'.~

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 14 of 25
~~""'!;>!·'·-""'C~o6~tv'!'/l'234l):Drvi'C.W,.."Bt·~61i1~r\t"'1~Y'" 'F\i~ctd5123i2oo6" .Page 14 'of 25' '. ,.
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
INMATE REQUEST FORM
INMATE REQUEST FORM

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 15 of 25 Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 15 of 25

4Wlnrris OInuttlt;! ~4.eriffs ®ffi.c~

~ureau o£ QIm;r:cciions

A N_tinnalIy Accredited Aget\c;y 43 JOHN STREET, !\.fORRIS TOWNSHIP, NEWjERSJ:;Y 07960

RaJ.ph McGrane
l1nrlersherUf

PHONE 973-681-5175. FAX 97t1-995-965S

EDWARD V. ROCHFORD

SHERIFF

TO: FROM: .
DATE:
RB:

Oaqen RiChardson, 3B Paralegal
May I 7. 2006 1I1II!ate Request (5112106)

As per YOW- request dated 5/12106 and per the warden, this Illquest will not be able to be ltiamkeitnedcat(r)ecoasfessinthreatthpeerrteaqinueNsteswthJaeirsyeoyUlal\w,re..s1.Ibmitiing are too vollllllinous and should be
CIfoyrroeUnteh.ave any questiotl$ or conceming regarding this Illllltcr, pJease contact Warden

c: Warden Corrente
. File

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 16 of 25
·c~~~ "2:"06-cv-02340-DMC-MF Docume~t 1-1 Fil~d 05/23/2006 ..);age 16 of 25 .
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL~ACILITY
INMATE REQUEST FORM
$-11-06
/
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
INMATE REQUEST FORM -----,

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 17 of 25 Case 2:0B-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 0512312006 Page 17 of 25

flillrris QIllunity ~~.erif£,$ ®ffic.e

Ralph McGrane .
Und....horift'

:¥ilureau llf Cllnr:redinns
A Nationally Ataedlted Agency
48 JOHN STREET, MORRIS TOWNSHIP, NFiYJERSEY 07960 mONE 973-631-5175. FAX 973-993-9658
EDWARD V, ROCHFORD SHERIFF

Frank Corre.r:ate
Warden

TO: FROM: DATE: RE:

Terique Jones, 3B Paralegal May 17,2006 Irunate Request (5112/06)

tAaksepnercayroeuor fresqinuceestthdiasterdeq5u/e1s2t/0t16wltinYdO~earrethe ~ ~s' request will not be able to be
limited to cases that pertain New JerBeY law, su mlttJ:ng IS too voluminous and should be

If yoil have any questions or concern'· ard'·'

Corrente,

mg reg 109 this matter, please conlllct Warden

c: Warden Corrente
File

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 18 of 25
"··"·'C~s~'2:06-~~~02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 18 of 25
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
~ATEREQUESTFORM

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
INMATE REQUEST FORM

," ,

• ,

.!

! I,· " ..

".

! "

, '

. ," '

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 19 of 25 Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMc-MF Document 1-1 Filed OS/23/2006 Page 19 of 25

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY

Inmate Grievance Form

Inmate Name:--'>J...J)""'lIIrrMl..L&!.l---,-"R-',l,!\~.~.=...J::\""""",__ LD. # 2 ~sYl) Date: tj/2~ /oc

Housing Unit: f ~ B

) page of \ •

Nature of Grievance:

,
Ie.:;·

Received b :
Recorded b :
Referred to: \ K MUJl..t'hL1-
Answer to . .

Date: /.j - :. () Date: ~.

,

'it".

_ _ Answered .Qy: kKfA.~~()lr---

Date: d, !.J

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 20 of 25 Case 2:Q6-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed OS/23/2006 Page 20 of 25

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
~=
Inmate Grievance Appeal Form #

Inmate Name: ikwJ\ ~~\,,,...rLo') I.D. # :1.4.551 .Date: 5") z- 10 ,

Housing Unit: -----,;3=-_13:.L-_ _

~---L.\ page of \ r I

for Appealing: Or.... q. ~~-~on A~i"AII\i'?j ~ Sob ...--------.-:----=--------:-------------~C-r1AAn<&

::r: h_ \.v.a .., .J;....,\""'" ,,- ,..\.'
.c.- . . . . ,,; ''''', .<"'''-' ..t.-I-\... ""'"i..... h...l..... .J

filk....!- ,- .\..\. ll"'~+

r'.\r" .:""""''''''' (Jll'ltL,."·IW!.

!VI"'\ ,\l~ fI,'ll ~ 'I,) l.f..

rt- ,-, ell\' I{v.r;~l<. L ,:\1+-"\-1\. '\'-1. "- I.. .....h\,~ ~",,_ '1M u-tl- ~'MWDk. .. 1'L-

l.>aJi I .m~\....... h:K<k«I n..,:."'\!., £

.1 \..

~ "'+L 1Jsw.~,)JJIC±h~L '}y.. ,~.J...... I

",u: • tel<•. $ '1'1.,.... ~,,_\.. 't-> ,\I..j" A\..L...,: ,o~ I-c:S 4 r . T r ~ Ii...""""

t'Jt ,... ".. k.,,- ,.l.t ~t.t "'''1D... r~"'~-'

<-....

Iorc,L t":D'V\l"Ikl.,1\A

AL ;;:",,~..

+lre. 1 \.........". '\

l. "l \~ Q .. ,,\\. .t ",.,.\-\.,.~ ~,"r .\.i.,.\-.,.I\.-....... :....s +l..+ I\t'

W;:"1 • • ,,1 I:\{';nt' "A-,f;",,+: ..... _J t\... lA-V \;\.[-0 ok bct:!J-'g P"'" (or "i sLJJ:

o;:..u

.t..- ~ \c~" ~_"" ~M),"

\to_I r-c ' "

k. c,,,,,...,J-

'IlL

~.. ,~t

-C,J f;·U..,L

Received oy:

_

...,

Date:-

Recorded by:

Date:

Answered to grievance Up Held

Answer to grievance modified as follows

Administrators Signature:

Date:

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 21 of 25

Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF '.' Dcicument~;1"Fifecj'05/2'3:r2006" PAge 2"1 of'25 ", i'" '.. \~~

.

'

,

,

MORRIS' COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
.-.~~
Inmate Grievance Form #

3 ' . Inmate Name: \~r\~,", '.:)1'1\\ ".
Housing Unit: " ~

LD. # k3~'b3 Date:r;/'la~
__\.... page of_\__

Nature of Grievance: ~---------------------~~~----~----------~--------~--

...

,
I,
...
, Referred b : Receivedb : Recorded b:
Referred to:
.. Answer to rievance:

Date:' ~ Date: Date: Date:

Answered b

Date:

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 22 of 25

Case 2:06-Gv-02340-DMC1':1t:rrJlO,£(11~t"\:;l,,.ls~,il.~~l?~f.906
fI\~rr;> c..v."~" c"u",-",",."",\ f".,-;\,~
L\ 3 Oo\'" Str";"
t'('Iorr,"",_ J ~(.,-, J""~ 0"),\ bo

Page 22 of 25

?t ~r'l\ 2-L\ I MOb

-nl', W\)MW r(t~\Il\l.. C.O{a,I1..UJi'i..
\'f\.rr:'" c.V'''~ (A.....,....r.-..\ \=',.,••\.~ L\ 3, ;}II\... St,......
tl\orr,;~""", l\<-", 1 ...~ O!)'1 ~o
~e.~ V,,,,:r:Uf,J) Nw. I\U~tsT \\J\\SUIlIN"r TO

\-0. A: , ~l ,4 ~ Cs)

W\\'i-l.'ItN C<J~~£.IV\~',

~\t"'~ ~c.vt~\- k'l.-,,, \e~ C15 0.. ..\.1"""\ reo,."";'1 t~ \JU';~;~ f\a4 \-e-"",,\ p,c.,c.,e..:;s

~\I>('''''''''\- +0 \\~ J<tA:)e-:> \H....;"':~+r...\-'\IJ'(" c..h I s~e"'\t';"'\\~ i0fl.',.2.-.'\\,(5") ,5'11-\((;(..\

\6 R ,,* 'n J:1"Il"-"'+'"

~~ "'\.VII-').

",,5

o.",~

()~ ... \

rt~V~)h

(0..11(.

5 '" c..(A'J~

('e:;b\Vt~ -\-\"~J ""..1-\-...

to l~.

~..... .th,,- \>!lS't e-~\"\- \'I"I.<It\\\-s+\."+ :r 'rw...... bu,,- ~I.~t~ 'IY'\ ji"" ~., It:) ) '~j"

Q, <.U~ "'0-} f'I<)\ h"" CJ;lMljk'r-. j\...;J 'hI" <>--\-k.Au\ f'I\.':) s..,\,"'?l. ...\:'0 .J '(h,~ A"'~

+..... O\\.U'" ·1I.',,?O:X~()oJI\.I,. \~\

<Z.. ~((.5c..e.a.e."''' 1)$V\e:,j, ~:fu,.v\.e.~ .".fc.. Cu':,.t-.('",·hGM ~'"

s....~~rt o~ ~ vv;~i~l I"I~ rt4..Vt:ll- ~..... .\.. ~ ~-u50""'\ \~\ ",g,~ 0I.~,j ",,;+\.,

\~:)....,~ +\....+ ::t:. 0""" ~rt.,)o<Al..\-S rus".l,~cA\..o:.(' \'n"'''~ h'-ft. w·~\..,.

::r: -\ell<,,). -lr'\--"'+'!)C>- I,,-J,\\ C<M",'\~ur "':) r~II"\- ~ V"\.- "..,~ ~r"""\- 1"'-1.. t\.....

"""\ ;. .\ f\u.-t~5"'~ \~'"\ il\(..(,U.s o.vc.<>~"""\~' ~

~,,+~ o..S'.M~O\"....c.. "",f.!I\.. 1'\.'''' """~,...

S ".\-e.a , ;.'f. ~u ~

~ ~ 0, (c.c;. ;

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 23 of 25 Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1~1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 23 of 25

, '
MORRIS COlJNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Bureal! of Corrections Inten:al Affairs Unit
43 John Street, JI,':orris Township, NJ 07960 Phone (973) 6315421 * Fax (973) 285·6802

Ralph MeGra"e Undcrsherilr

EDWAk"O V. ROCHFORD
SHERIFF

Frank COlTent. Worden

TO: FROM: , DATE: RE:

Inlnale Jose Rodrigllcz,'C Paralegal Decc'mber 16,2005 Inmate Request (1211410~)

This is to inforlll YOll, per the'warden, if you would like to have the doculllent (release) notarized, you will have to go through your attorney.

(: fik

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 24 of 25

, , •• ~..~ '!r'" .,."

• •

Case 2:06-cv-02340-DMC-MF

Document 1-1

,,",

.. ,

,~.IlI""'...., .....,." ,1t:'>11·",'.' ' '

Filed 05/23/2006 . Page 24 of 25

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY

- ..-

" "

Inmate Grievance Form #

Inmate Name:-U<i.:J...L.I.I........:.~=""'-"-"l.--_ _ Ln. # ZLtC)')0 Date:.....3 . ~~

Housing Unit: -i-13

I page of....l. _

Nature of Grievance: !)~t' ~ "'.\ 111....15 1'" I",wi:.. +,,:( J J" reM ...{\ "'VI
n" .(J;" o('(,LL.... q\.. ..~ k 't,z,l ~v,,;icC , k ... f..,. ..\Ji!.v·.... f ,~I ,,,,,,,~h\ )'\",,J,,, I $till

Ja ."..\ ..J

, )

Ci'I' ~ ;;, IA ""')

(cc-,,\''' .-\/",

J\,~t

1;~

,.lit-\-, 't ..... \"""~ M\ "'I :l-

r,,,(.1.<1 (\:J.\o, b( "'IA~ • OI",'\' 1:..l..ult! (\•..,;..... UN;:'\, ::r 0.'" 0>'" ,..,,,J,,,,,: d,,,d.

eee . . " '"Tk

"J~J -It j,okL.." I;~'\ ' ....\,~<?4"<'~) OliO dS:)!'iI"'.<:' :-k..... ::..s A"d-

i u.D/ -Ik, ;'1L.hJ ,I.-,~L.", "'~ " ...,.c.. CO!;,"';' :r "'.tT- I"\Co ",,(~-h o.~k-J;~

t" ...~ IJArL... C/M\~ ()It",,," \ ..,t

I"'" b" I._ .1....

1oIIN\~t'-' . 'af_

\t..,. ,,'J ,'" /,0{ " \" ''', ...<1-

'~\''- <:..\~s.( or J.~~\.;.h.. 1\it'I"""'\... I"~..! ""j k. ufC ,v..... j ~ ~~. .'1" h.J. ~ ....H ,<.1 ~,

"" "\ ( ~.., \..~.. ~L.. ~,,> 1,'-4 ,'\cKJ ~, Ju.v:.., .~ ("~

Referreii bX:
f--
Received by:

Date: Date:

Recorded by: Referred to:

Date:
.-
Date:

Answer to grievance:

-

,-.....,
..
Answered by:

-
" - - - - -............, ,
F'~~
..................
-

-
Date:

I
-~
... "-.-~-

.. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . ' - - Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 1

Filed 05/23/2006 Page 25 of 25
--

Case 2:0S-cv-02340-DMC-MF Document 1-1 Filed 05/23/2006 Page 25 of 25

•• •

MORRIS

CouNh'

•
CoRRECTIONAL

FACILITY'

Inmate Grievance Form

In~ate Name:.sl..u)a;O..\.cJ...\OI'e:4o--L-t6.lJo:1,::uh=(I!(J4>lJ.S..i1..f)+-.-_ LD. # 2.j5"5"1

Date: 3 2'7/ o~

Housing Unit: 3.,. ~

page of I '

Natiire of Grievance: ::c:. h!).\J;' he.tN1 \..uc.. &' 1II\(h'lt-

tk

, ..

e"~J;·\ 1)-"" ~!d_(,,',>Evf:"-'l"'f>",AI/; Sf_'':'~ ::;":':j~,~'"

l,. '.-A
J. 'Ai.f'f ,I",

0+ 1( ,~"- '.A- ,""",_..:";1,,~ ::f ,J-".y? , -J S I.

.:a~,,,-r::cQ.~"-"1.-"'--Or>-,,"""-""'--'"'~-"------1

, !
C ,":\ '~') ~ '100: )

Date: 'i 1 ' 0 "

 
 '.

FORM TO BE USED BY A PRISONER IN FILING A

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF CIVDIoLcRumIGeHnTt S5 COFMiPleLdA0IN6/T23/2006 Page 1 of 21

UNITED

STATES

DISTRICT

COURT

I!\,~~.

()I~I:l:flI'D,,\-eCf'!

I... [' If \1,
clJ\;:.i

FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

COMPLAINT

v.
(Ybcr~~ ~at:J G(r".,.it yy;,.,)
~;\i~ 15kr~tf fJ.Ie<'CtfJ VI
~c1~rJ/ 'h,~~ R...l,b fYI~&r"I1e.)
W",L Fr"""l... C<,,((c:,..'1~) "lhfl
i.(EUlnt"".rL.bO.£.""~tht."/U:-:I;>nJ,~.me~of~lhe~de~leoLnd:--.nl:=to:.!-,d~.-ten:J.dl. .n-!-ts2 I
In thl••ctlon)

Civil Action No. 0' - 2.1../ bI (Dmc.-)
(To be supplied by Ihe Clerk of tho Court)

INSTRUCTIONS -- READ CAREFULLY
1. This complaint must be legibly handwritten or typewritten, signed by the plaintiff and subscribed to under penalty of perjury as being true and correct. All questions must be answered concisely in the proper space on the form. Where more space is needed to answer any question, attach a separate sheet.
2. In accordance with Rule 8 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the complaint should contain (1) a short and plain statement of the grounds upon which the court's jurisdiction depends, (2) a short plain statement of the claim showing that you are entitled to relief, and (3) a demand for judgment for the relief which you seek.
3. You must provide the full name of each defendant or defendant~ and where they can be found.
4. You must send the original and one copy of the complaint to the Clerk of the District Court You must also send one additional copy of the complaint for each defendant to the Clerk. Do not send the complaint directly to the defendants.
$1:fb ,() (/ 5. Upon receipt of a fee of $"r~p.oo, your complaint will be filed. You will be responsible for
service of a separate summons and copy of the complaint on each defendant. See Rule 4, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure.
DNJ·P roSe-{)06-{)7 -(06196)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DFMOCRM-MTFO BDEoUcuSmEDenBt Y5 A PFRilIeSdO0N6E/R23I/N20F0I6LINGPaAge 2 of 21
CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT
2

Case 2:06-cv-02461F-ODRMMC-TMOFBEDUoScEuDmeBnYt A5 PRFISilOedNE0R6/2IN3/F20IL0IN6G APage 3 of 21
CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT
~1)(J.ov
6. If you cannot prepay the $150.00 filing fee, you may request permission to proceed ill ~
pauperis in accordance with the procedures set forth below. (If there is more than one
plaintiff, ru!.Qh plaintiff must separately request permission to proceed in. forma pauperis.)

The Prison Litigation Reform Act of 1996 (UPLRA"), effective April 26, 1996, has made significant changes to the in fonna pauperis statute, 28 U.S.C, § 1915. The slatute no longer
provides for waiver of court filing fees for prisoners who are granted leave to proceed in forma
gaygeris. A prisoner who is granted leave to proceed in fQrr:rn! pauperis is not required to pay
the filing fees in advance, but the prisoner is obligated to pay the entire filing fee in installment payments regardless of the outcome of the proceeding. This obligation to pay the filing fee continues even if the prisoner is transferred to another prison. Therefore, before submitting this application to the Clerk of the Court, a prisoner should consider carefully whether he or she wishes to go forward with the action.
The PLRA obligates prisoners who are granted in fil.c!!!.i pauperis status to pay the entire filing fee in the following manner, regardless of the outcome oflhe litigation, 28 U.S,C. § 1915(b)(1)
and (2). The agency having custody over the prisoner shall deduct from the prisoner's , institutional account and forward to the Clerk of the Court (1) an initial partial filing fee equal to
20% of the greater of the average monthly deposits to the prisoner's account or the average monthly balance in the prisoner's account for the six-month period immediately preceding the filing of the complaint, and (2) payments equal to 20% of the preceding month's income credited to the prisoner's institutional account each month the amount in the account exceeds
$10.00, until the $~Q filing fee is paid. 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(1) and (2). However, a prisoner who has~ass'ets and no means by which to pay the initial partial filing fee will not be prohibited from bringing a civil action. 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(4).

Each prisoner plaintiff who desires to proceed in forma pauperis must submit the following to

the Clerk of the Court:

.

a. a completed, signed, and dated application to proceed in forma pauperis (attached hereto); and

b. a certified copy of your prison account statement for the 6-month period immediately preceding submission of this application, listing the account balance and all deposits into the account. A prison account statement must be obtained from the appropriate official of each prison at which you are or were confined during the preceding 6 months.

7. If your application to proceed in forma pauperis does not conform to these instructions, you will be notified by letter of the nature of the deficiencies. If these deficiencies are not cured within 120 days of the date of the letter, the complaint will be deemed withdrawn, the Clerk's file will be closed, and no fees will be assessed against you,

8. If you are given permission to proceed in forma Qauperis, the Clerk will prepare and issue a copy of the summons for each defendant. The copies of summonses and the copies of the

3

D NJ.PrQSe.006'()1.(061ll8)

Case 2:06-cv-02461F-DOMRCM-MTOF BCEIDVUoILScEuRmDIGeBHnYtT5SA CPORFIMSilePOdLNA0EI6RN/2TI3N/2F0IL0I6NG PAage 4 of 21

complaint which you have submitted will be forwarded by the Clerk to the United States Marshal. who is responsible for service. The Marshal has USM·285 fonns you must complete so that the Marshal can locate and serve each defendant. If the fonns are sent to you, you must complete them in full and retum the forms to the Marshal.

QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED

1. Jurisdiction is asserted pursuant to (CHECK ONE)

L

pc. . - 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (applies to state prisoners)

-t(,'" \ ck".J",<A,..

Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of Fed. Bureay of Narcotics, 403 U.S. 388 (1971) and 28 U.SC. § 1331 (applies to federal prisoners)

If you want to assert jurisdiction under different or additional statutes, list these below:

2. Previously Dismissed Federal Civil Actions or Appeals
If you are proceeding in forma PlilUperis, list each civil action or appeal you have brought in a
federal court while you were incarcerated or detained in any facility, that was dismissed as frivolous or malicious, or for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted. Please note that a prisoner who has on three or more prior occasions, while detained in any facility, brought an action or appeal.in a federal court that was dismissed as frivolous or malicious, or
for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted. wlll be denied in forma pauperis
status unless that prisoner is under imminent danger of serious physical injury. See 28 U.S.C.
§ 1915(g).
a. Parties to previous lawsuit:
Plaintiff(s): --...lAJ::!..-f/...:.A:-'--_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

Oefendant(s): _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

b. Court and docket number: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
c. Grounds for dismissal: ( ) frivolous ) malicious ( ) failure to state a claim upon

4

ONJ·ProSe-0Q6.07-{06/98)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-FDOMRCM-MTFO BEDoUcSuEmDenBtY5A PRFIiSleOdN0E6R/23IN/2F0I0L6INGPAage 5 of 21 CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT
"
which relief may be granted
d. Approximate dale of filing lawsuit: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

e. Approximate date of disposition: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

If there is more than one civil action or appeal, describe the additional civil actions or appeals
using this same format on separate sheets.

rover \' 3. Place of Present Confinement?

5 ~I-\nb COm,set \e:,<'1< I &,-"II''j

(" \1'1 GG F " )

4. Parties

(In item (a) below, place your name in the first blank and place your present address in the second blank, Do the same for additional plaintiffs, if any.)
a. Name of plaintiff: Te..ridIww Juno
. Sf Address: (hu..f I Lj 3 Juh n (G{.,+ ,

Inmate #: 23 '12 3

b. First defendant -- name: EJ~ \J, Ro~b+UrJ

Official position: --'-SL-uh~!.:I(..!.·'L·~..!.C_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

G-'lb Placeofemployment: (bore;.:>

S}....rJ£'.:. OtL~,e.} Y3 JOh" 51"1

M~ f{' ~-10....V\ In 0 t) 'l 6() - L/.:>'-3' "7

How is this person involved in the case?

j

I

(I.e., what are you alleging that this person did or did not do that violated your

constitutional rights?)

fH apwo.h=-, awl/a f ~Q.(..;\;1-"'J':J Cl~q().,.. CIoA1bt"':r\l\:j

5

DNJ-P,oSe.oOO-07 ·(06198)

'.

FORM TO BE USED BY A PRISONER IN FILING A

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF CDIVoILcuRmIGeHntT5S COFMilePdLA0I6N/2T3/2006 Page 6 of 21

Lh 1'C.t RJ c. Second defendant - name:

~ ~ (\1" G-n'ilVlI!-

6.4 LAn If Official position:

J..~j" ?

~

Place of employment: ...Jill....:...>-c;;".L:;,..:..r-l-1_Ll...,3"'--..J.1""'~:..:..:...l"'--..t.S;.,l,.+.r..c.L"""".'.t..,""-'-'(\!)..J.:::.lOf../...:..=JI~k;;"''''';;''''-':/f-I-1-1--,-',,-J_._

How is this person involved in the case?

o1"JCi. bU -4"2 3 t)

(i.e., what are you alleging that this person did or did not do that violated your

constitutional rights?)

'hr o~e..(O\t;Y\j 0V'\d ~r t<-IL+"\+;'~ OW"IJ lao' MIA''nsttA,VIi''J

d. If there are more than two defendants, attach a separate sheet. For each defendant

specilY: (1) name, (2) official position, (3) place of employment, and (4) involvement of the

as p defendant. (I\i t1,\ ~(.\,ht\»

.

I I

'(1j"4.. t:l b

5. I previously have sought informal or formal relief from the appropriate administrative officials regarding the acts complained of in the Statement of Claims on page 6.

-L Yes

No

If your answer is "Yes," briefly describe the steps taken. including how relief was sought. from whom you sought relief, and the results.

Re.r· Ibc()""h 8C1WClnu \1 lkHv')(J-L.

I":5 1- ~/"'" 5 { 1 /1,.... \.It./b"11~,

If your answer is "No," briefly explain why administrative remedies were not exhausted.
DNJ·l'roS...ooS-07 -(06198)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 7 of 21
d. \~\r~ d.e.k~"".. \- ,- ~ li"'oVl(..: Fr().(\k Corn:."te..
O.r-L~i"'\ ~05ih on: WC).("d,.t-o"I ~\ 0..(..4. "'~ aM~\()~jVI~: (Y\ G(.,~) y,3. Jd~t\ 5'1'«':.-,,-,;') tyIC1N\,;) k,.WY))
nt.....J J 'j(!'fs 0'1%0 - 1.1'2.-3')
~Ol 0ferO\'V'~j (AhJ lor +CJ.L;\ihd';:'" o..l'>.J.jdr--
\'Y\o..;f\-\-o..~(\~~ lor lAl"IO 1 0. \ 0"" ;.,~k fY) u,r STal,f
-In e~IA;~e. I" +ho- vio\v.t-;ve. Q.G.h cL';'''e4 he..,e,\""
e... 'FcJ\.I'r\-~ +'h(\}\. 4\,1" 'I-""t:.,,,-\-~ .~t,~V\~o..(\\--s: J 0 hl'\ Odec5 M c\ -::1" ('., Roc.) \- \ 0
~v ~,'\(},\,.hj '11'\ +'k 01t/\0.-\-;1I(... 0.&\-5
c \g..~M"~ h~~.
bb

'.

FORM TO BE USED BY A PRISONER IN FILING A

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF CIDVoILcuRmIGeHnTt S5 COFMilPedLA0I6N/T23/2006 Page 8 of 21

6. Statement of Claims

(State here as briefly as possible the facts of your case, Describe how each defendant

violated your rights, giving dates and places. If you do not specify how each defendant

violated your rights and the date(s) and place of the violations, your complaint may be

dismissed. Include also the names of other persons who are involved, including dates and

places. Do not give any legal arguments or cite any cases or statutes. If you intend to allege

a number of related claims, number and set forth each claim in a separate paragraph. Use as

much space as you need. Attach a separate sheet if necessary.)

,
L

J oJ

~o\\\:''1 -for <3\\ ',(I/'""\-c.:, In

~(C.hCA'\"'tJ UQ.-bh~1'\

M~

lOM!)'~ =h oSS\ilmc. f.MI\ o.AfI?t~tA;;'(;\(\.\ ~D'jl'l-'Ul"'>,. cru",s0 e,.""bM(·,7I.J;>/'VIU.t o..V'I.\). \Qv.M.\. ~t.Dr.H :tk.·~~Ihr.A·c....
7",

~L.

-"nt 'VlOS"'v.;::t) -\-V?~'"}4)() O\J

~ v'() (?('<'YI)

~'\W>~":~ JO uOS'Y):;lJ ,-,,';\,,\6 i ..,'r>~~~M jY" (J'Y),' -:'\""""''1

\ t Y.l ~ "\\\:'If"'\ .'-:' jJO Y' ?")L\'?S?J&

VII, \,,)JlV>?5

,'?Q 'f;')(~~:)*5 "'q <If. f"'..I'j ,;",,1"0 I '-\-'V'" 1/ dV\~ \,~

"I: \\ ~ 9 \~ t ' \

->\: "\ r-1 (., OO-t I £ c ,\,.)\>0 \}J -\;:"'<''\'0 J 0 0\J \. ~

• -;>S""'OJ ?\'\'" '\ (7)Cl -" ':)
V(lC'1o)j vn 1\6' '.>"II"·W.-J\ ~ V Jaw CJ'")(\'Cl '-,\'JI"JJ?$' \\)-J
.r :r. V) \,,",,\'.7 '\"''''?S'" d,)"", S "J "\-f"l"'\'" S ~t )Y?"'l
f"O(rt 1st, ,')}\O\Jj ~G\I"\(")J\\- I ~QO""L lot ,\'1){)Q1 wO)j"~

't~UY1 o",-;o\"e\,_ <:\\~.o~, ~+

d

,

ar'-\ ~nV)\O '-' :\O~ N""1 ::.r f") ooz, (01. ,-\")x:l1Jj 1..10 \. j

d J , -;l<;>"IYI .. ~,'" '\ OJ

..)0 V(}0'>J) '""'")~" +v'\P~t-'1""") "vt~\JJ(lvJ ("'nl'o ,/)jVl?S

,+" to \ ,1;:1 \Q '('vlYJ (;<l,,,).J'O<>S 0 ~

+:r<l\~V\9 \1'" ~\"r'\ :I

(OjOOZ {lit '\'l)."OW \\(,>"I(,l)~+ (100t: I V"\\ ,"\'"JJ"'\Jj IvVOJj ~()

a",_ 1 (" \' I

~'Vl'I'\ ~

II

:::t 00 \......

'\ Y) (' ~"\f.l.

0.;. '-\' Fv.J \<\

G:, ,\I'<';J

S..,M j:

r ") <JO"'Z ( \1 \

\ '))>JJ Uj

\) 0 \.~

J,D LA oc;"'?J '1\')1\',6' -\ v'\f') '\\-: '""
\\ n ~ VI '0 ~r") C'?- /"'";)5 ~ 'J\" 5

b\.\; u) Ow

Jd •-X;'"""I"VJ] ~'\>0 ~Q

~ <>o~ ,hf\"C

'li'""I"";;)S

t'" :r: -t \",'1? f,,\V\t;' ' \ <;"r4

'Soot I~ n~vJ-;l~ d5 ,\,,-'0),\-+ 'SOot: f Qf ,,~,f\C'Y'~ WOJ~ \."?

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 9 of 21

I') -\L Case 2:06-c0v(-10246m1~-D((M,C,-M~2F!.\D1ocuJm-eonot ~5) \FJ.i,lJe\.d.-:\0.e6-/23~/2006 P-.ay~g).e;\1'.0,)of"2l1cJ(..l-upl/
r l;.fI;\-j We<> ~(LCJ, ,4p b.. !'>h;~pd ,~.dw,,,kJ ;'h
+l- ~t..)<".~ J -kMIA\ t- I7-\L:.:~..--- Oft" w",,\l.) O-hJ.
0-. M-t\-..u- kI'\Ao\e. cr.\.--C\~.(,.",--) w i-\-'hoL-.·t .5 N-~ rc.'-"\)QV'I oV'

b() ~( 0 ~k. C(),.\AX- / 0..... <>- ~ r t'I D "e..YV"!'-!:)--e.-'I(.-:::t (" e."'.'>(,r".s .

l\... v.;,w j ')

6o.~ GOV'I~ -5 t (, () $'eL-M Ghe..) \.a..JI!-H..

d.~ Q-Vc.(,3

be..-&. . v.se I l..-t"}" Ii\ lo<-.,'\,:.-UI ~ I} o.V\a~r I'\u o~k.l (C(AjoV) ,

~) If\(V\","\--c.,j Ih Q,e..ht:<-v''''j \.)\!..-\-e-I'I-\-'vV\ / Ol)<.-';~\i",.,~

D f?( -t, e\(.\1\ 0 i'\ 0. It. (lOt

~ If ~tk.l \,..i I ~l. o.l'j re c-\fc. "h(J>'1 c. ",A,

--\-~(•.(:.,vO':.-) !o (lvt \e,."'V<'!.Th<!"~ (..(. \\ CAy-eo-,

\) ~(a.. k~'-(;(\.j De..--\u\ \~(JV'l (..'V'J 0,::'0;(1 \:I'\(/\t! Oe..-\-ent;~'.. '\\"\/Y'Io-\-o Me. S~(V(~ +"'~~r {V\u,G +\vv,-,,-,I.... slch I\-..
+ka.1'r u\\ Awl'S (Ana, -\-~etr~) A.t.! nv+ \CQo.VL +he..-,'r

cc.\\ o-f('(...CA,.

1 f'I\ Tk OI'\S 1e.-000y\ +~<I'.- sh-t \> .$C-(I>.(chC) CAre.. Uil'\jv"kJ

o.n --h \"11,,1\,,,,,;\ I "'-\-f.. o.",a Cl-iII\ 'bo.((tAjS IY'l rv'I(;'k -\-\.v.-t- CAfe

?\lAd Ih ~<..~u'W.~~ De,,\--(CII\-h'Ov. OV'''~' {)\S,";~ \.""(A~
I lle ~""1 :/J'" ()..~ ~\J\V\\sl" M(.N\ ~ 0\ ;,5<,-', ~ \; VIe..) C £lv5 I~

P ~ tk(;~) 0-- ,''''' OWl

5 v'

0. 0.. V'

v ;() \ CA -\- .':.'.;

~ \!..(S Dh c). \

~ ~hJ. j t b\ Cu \1'\5

\- : j r \ ht.'> (Jf'I <'\ )

0. 01. ; I'\}

l)...V\ f (: '<.J Q hC- <:.

5~(lW'\,,\.\Q.S CAh.J. se;z.lAv<-s ( AM(.""an(.... \- W ) "'r'\ J

12Jtr\ ~ c(V't\ .-;A", 1AV\ "'51ACA \ 9\11.1">\)\.- \VIc-vd-- ( A""t:.V't a.1'Io.(f\ \-

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 11 of 21
2 u .\'fI (= d-e.-V)~0 Ih IN'<X\-1l':-5 ~ 0.LLL6 -b I~"'" \ ~\.-v~ C» \ Ls .

fA) lhe. .::.tflMok In"'VIv'" \ s-i",+eJ +h.:d l.ej" \ k\e..eh.<)~

c.o.\\5 M"J b-c- tv\L>-<k \-\'WuIAJL +k ~,,\~\ (;e.-vvl<..L> LA.V1i+"

h) 50"'0-\ SUJ~S l,--,\' J1ul ~(OV~~ \e:Jt~' ~hor<'.- C-Cl\/J)

c) 0" \Y\~ 2'\ j-<.JO~ 1 J ("~,\u""kl. "it> l"",k c- II
~ M por-\- 0-11'1+ I<.'.j<-l.\+c..-\E:.f hoI'\.€. ,"", \l ,

c\') 0 V\ {Y)o..J 301 )L)Oh I ("1~ r~11'-'>.:1)- wo.~ J e"~l. C-I'\"\

.r. e-.') 0", IYI~J 3D, 2LX.l(.. I

()(\(£ tjG-\V"\ Ie" v(!:>teJ +-0

\VIu.\..c. CA.'" I ""(Xlv ~o-"'+- \~o.' +e\r.-p hut'\l. Co. \ \.

4') 01'\ Mr.:;3 1/ 200(.,) r i-v0.. ~ a.,'" Ac.V) ~..:4 .

3) 0(1 m~) 3\ I )..t10~ / :t -\,\ca (A Gr '~~"V1LL (<j(A--J"'J +\.- j'V\(Atkr t..-'i+h. 1e:J,.. t ~\t.~h()""- [.onJ, AJo ((5~oNe.

h') 01'1 lno::J 31,200'" J :t: ~v()i,~".. j tk ~t!CA''''\ s.:.v,,",L('~

c, vS l}1\;\- ) 1\.w(;"j~

Re"\, vt.H- ~(r'" I oJ. +0

SVl\--

£1.(..:.,05 is ~v,\leJ I o......&. ~(J\,-' to 3<-\- Sv(..h oWS$,

'I) 0", j\J\N. I, 2-00"1 tk Sr)(.,~"'\ S:e,f\i~U''') U,"'I\- '(C)POI'I.J...&

~"~(""":' Me.. -t~(lt l' 0."" .c;"'Y\Xl-;'.ge~\ -k r~Vt".Id- \c.j~)

+t-\e.~\-.ON!. (c..\\.:. -\~V"v uJl the ~"{d'U \.9evv,~ (J".'1-;

hov-..e...v'C,d') ,,\\ ,el\V<')b v-- i\\ b~ Je.-Vlled,

J) meet: v,'O\&>+-U,f\(Vl£l.k,::,' OLLO.5 tv C..(.JV~--\5 (A""c.YI~M-C"1+

, r:: ') ~y>~ ~v<. ~(OL<j> (AI"'(.V\l,\M:At '5mt') ~

tete (Au..£::.5 -h. IM\>ov--kV\+ \e.jO\\

'I' \-v\'"lll- '-.0. \ L.L

cle.n(lIl.l-3

1~

3. JOV.t-9()~ De\IVL~ ~~\c}.~ .. Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5

'J IY\(,OI\I1 I

010;\

Filed 06/23/2006 Page 12 of 21

'1-'"

_J.

0.) Mcc...\= r()\,'vj) ~ C\,.(A)V"~U\V'lU Ir-';+\... S+c.k f()l~';j) 1'5 h
~et~{" 1'\'\,,;\ ··:\-o10MlI'hc..:. 1,...J;~k", (N) \nOV.O it w~~ ((:.cc:.\tu\..
h) ('(10-;\ Je.,\i'vc.~ + 'J fo ~~ GA' \ UV'I F(\a'\:151j. /lut
j.':'~h;~\J\+c.,~ +v ;(\ MCA+--",":> 1,.1.1"'1+;\ C'\ leo.>+- (\')()V'ld'J .
L) G-cl"lt:-vo.\, L-e.JlA\ J C\V\cJ. E'I'~(c;U f\'l",,\ J.Q.\N~ IJ c\QI~J, 6) ~V-(i~ tk ""uk cJ· Dv':.<::..tv.hc/ \CO, 2ooS"; tv1 ",,;\ Vv~j
~~\~ +vOjVI \i'1\V1I,\-h:.s ~, ;1'\ e.'tl,..('.,}...'lof (5) clojs .-- (12.0.)

\f\"," e,,)

~e.t\J4e.~ .\-0 i-k j(X;\ 0" Apr;\ \3) 2.00(, I (,./e...> (\<.it

!\':>1f\b~M ~;V'I""(A~ ~!'Iti\ A~(;) \~I J.OOb 0' lo.-\--e,V,

J

+-) T M~O{-\v.If\+ L(5""\ IY\().\\ l

.tv ;,",kl~

.xX\.). 0"...+

0+ I l'k e..vcx>;~

~ Q(; \ \3J ).oob lr'o..> nut f \~k ..l-vti>

tv QI.A~o\\':j c\~\~J({j ,,\1'\\:\ c.lt-u aeh.r~:J h"vV,J On

~ ~(;'\ \1) I )..m",.

9) ~ e.\"'JJ M lV'\(A\ \ c\e\~c..0 I'.~ ~ ClIV\ ov:j 0 ; ~(oh Ie M Ol+

\)lcLf- - rvw,;j ~e\~fC.J. OV'l t='(\~D..jj i) ~\~I'\" IUVI<>II~

~\).. v.1\t-; \ tx.+ \e.0')1- (Y\oV\~ u~J.J ~c\v.~ ~ L-- ""

po: \vi(.A\ \ Q.IA~ E~ S5 (h 0. i \ .

tJ

'!
Li, CLaes~eo2.:.0\6-cvf-(0\2o4-6i1\-DMI~C-M5~F(A(vDhoe.cu-dmen\,t.5.J;-t~",F,,il,e,+d- \i\~k 06/23/2006 P~arg~e(,1r3do'f.21

g.') ~e.-,", 'J'-"\\ V()\\~ I> 1h{~-+ L-~CA\ MeAdi'> -h be

til' k 5CO.f<.\'~'\

b("If)~ C-di\-t{lA

'\1'\ -\-

So-YhE:- (hlAilv\C-II' CAS

S If) P( ot +k Uf\U"(A \ Co ( ( e.:.> f ()v'l.cA <"nu:..J n.a..l:. ; 1-k

eJ-e.V'\ (A:..

k p~r5()V\ f'tce;v ~ \

[VIiA; \ •

or b') Se,lAf(,~~V'\.j L~c1 \ Mu\i \ withvv-+ tho.. IV\/Vlct+-L 1c.~

~(C5c..h \- frAi6<?.) 15sve.,> c\'Vl~ 't,m1it>hJ o~ w~",,~h.ev C.\.~

.. CV"'~·I~€..t\\\rA \
CW\~ W\.(C.~if

(\,\cA+-e..r ;,.. \ 'is
C\ \\ ~kJ ;~ \

b~.~-=> $t:.(AY)t\c..J or re.v~e.."'-".C~:/
(Av0 loLM\'VI<:.;i\-t:s rc.1'V\(;, I,", GV'K..lClkct.

C) L-CjO<) mo.i \ 5\-w.,Jj b.:. S(:.Q\v<J"e4 'ih 1L ~(~5(,A"\0e 0.('

-t \"-Q... ~usoV\ r·~L-e.\v ~ql......,h M(;:d tv ~5511\(e i-\.v\ ~e...rsoV)

-\-k.+tk le.jo-) cv«c!> ~f1ae..(\(.,.e- (;.\\1'\0- dth.u J.,cx'''",V\;,e..v.+;:r

(\.V\~ ~-\UI(A\s ta.fv'\"~Y\ "htil'0t / (A\t,~ S{) -\-\-w.\ fr~v;\~t-J

p (hIAt-v:1i\ \ -' 51,,,-,\" ()..j+h",\- (1A"C.vk~ ~ tho.. o-\\i(V\:J--
f\·L c:..\ ,~ ~ ~r ,v I\~ e / ('{,MQ\,'h!> Cu ~V'd- I (.l L
5 ~ ~ A) C(AV'v\' v} v..1'\ CU:;.(.J..A5e J, c.r I'M ,1A.1J\ \ krul(A'" t ':r lrCCJIA. \

ht \'fIo-;\ cos, VU)\I};-t-e.. fVl<W'I.) r\.,~b s ....v\-- Mi-k f'l3

o..j",;('.))t 5-<:..H - '''('V;''''';"O\'\-<;''", (\\ 1"\<'y\J.l"\(.,V\~ II LI7J1 e>......

5.

\)~oV'\

ClAj\I\\'s.,',ov\

o.-t-

mC("P I

~I!A-"I\'Y\c..e::>

(,<f(..

~rG!v~~J

I,,-';\-'h,

l>"-")cA~t ~ +h~ \~ o\~ v..V\~ (\(.It c\e.t\If)<'t.\. Of S"Yl.hz.e~

be-ton:.. re.\j:"v e.. -'

G. fY\v.++rc5S<::5 o.f"e... no-\- c\eO\V\e~ C;( .5hJ;\;-z-cJ lA~i.\V\ re,\.)5v~.

FORM TO BE USED BY A PRISONER IN FILING A Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF CIDVoILcuRmIGeHntT5S COFMilePdLA0I6N/2T3/2006 Page 14 of 21

:W n ••
7. Relief (State briefly exactly what you want the Court to do for you. Make no legal arguments. Cite no cases or statutes.)
" S),.:.AM'- .\bCIA +k C<!n.~lr..A.. v~lk AJ.~""J Mts 1.> \IIn\!"I\lc"k\ ,,~ Mc.l\"h~l"\t..vI hVL,'.o) ,
'}... <ZYf.S:>,\n 14 d(!.~II\d.o.,..,b tOM YI()t;"VI\~ -h:, e''lj(''j''- 1\'\ j kc. v\1(l\1tI1..J1l \ oct.:) , 5. 2Cdil4 \1\31'*'-'-.1(. re\;.·)· ~(C.\G'~\--s (I) :l:bl.. (b) ['4.",,'<'3 , b (Y\(}("(;s
CaM'7J Cvl((;.s.! IQ"""\ \=N.A:!!9 ;\-0 red>"" ... +({)\'" lo~ (lr ",ci.'IMtj S\l4..-~ ,,,,.1S.

,. A. . . ~ t/'.... V\""'1\~;{·+ ,-",\-.5 0+ 511';\'

T.~",\ ~f"I(,I,,",,",\:- Sov1l,\-: ~ \.0 1"':lklJ»

8. Do you request a jury or non-jury trial? (Check only one)

(.j) Jury Trial

) Non-Jury Trial

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

Signed this j::s-t~ day Of_""',.\.".."qu.N;;:u..C"--_ _ _ _ _ _, 200.lol.la'-..-_

8

DNJ·ProS• .o06.(l7-(06IllS)

'.

~VKM IV til: Ul:il:U tlY A I"KIl:iVNI:K 11'1 ~IL.II'I\:I Pt.

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF CDIVoIcLumRIeGnHt T5S COFiMlePdL0A6I/N2T3/2006 Page 15 of 21

Signature of plaintiff

1 EACH PLAINTIFF NAMED IN THE COMPLAINT MUST SIGN THE COMPLAINT HERE. ADD ADDITIONAL LINEs IF THERE IS MORE THAN ONE PLAINTIFF. REMEMBER, EACH PLAINTIFF MUST SIGN THE COMPLAINT.

9

DNJ·ProS• .()06-07-(06198)

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 16 of 21

Response to IriIDate Request Form

Terique Jones

23923

5/3012006

5/30/2006

3B

have access to the phones on the block so you can use them or you can VI/rite to whomever you need to. Legal addresses are available in the Law Library.

; ,i"-';

Soeial Services-Margaret

5130/2006

",""",
Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 17 of 21
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
INMATE REQUEST FORM

,~----~~, -~""'---~----------"-~-----------~-
Response to Inmate Reguest Form

Inmates Name

Terique Jones

Inmate ID#:

23923

Date:

5131/2006

Request Received Date:

5/3112006

Housing Unit:

3B

You have access to the phones on your housing unit to place all the legal calls you desire. It is up to the individual on the other end of the line, however, to choose to accept the calL If the call is not being accepted, it is the person on the other end who is denying you access, not the correctional facility. Your first request was denied for this reason; your second request is also denied. Please do not submit any further requests of this nature, as they will also be denied. If you disagree with the disposition of your request, you have a legal right to file a grievance. You may see your housing unit officer or the housing unit sergeant for the grievance form.

Completed by:

4fi Melissa - Social Services Supervisor

Date:

5/3l12006

" ,',...., r" '. ';:," '.", '~, ".
Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 18 of 21
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
INMATE REQUEST FORM

.. Response to Inmate Request Eorm.

,',

,. ','

"

.. ,

"

Inmates Name

;':"::" '
. TeriqueJones

Illlllllte ID#:

··i3~~3" 'k!' ',',>;,,' ", ~,::,·'I~\. :,:....:'.' ,', ',',,' ',:',::, :.,',:;

Date:

6/1/2006 Request Received
Date:

6/1/2006

Housing Unit:

"''''','''i,', "
·\(El

I attempted to see you today on your housing unit, and I was told you were out at court. In response to your inquiry:

You are, in fact, supposed to submit your request for phone use to Social Services. You did exactly what you were supposed to do. However, your request was denied. Actually, it was
denied twice, r believe. As such, 1 felt it was necessary to ask you to please stop making the
same request. The answer will not change regardless of how many times you ask. You did everytbing right, you followed procedure, but the request is still denied. Wbat you can do, since it appears tbat you disagree, is file a grievance against Social Services. My supervisor will examine the situation and detenuine whetber or not Social Services acted appropriately.

As far as Social Services is concemed, tbis matter is closed. Your request has been answered.

¥ou may not agree with the answer, but it was addressed, and as such, further requests for tbis

particular matter are not necessary. If you need otber types of assistance, feel free to reach out

to us and we will attempt to assist you to tbe best of our ability and in accordance with facility

policy and procedure.

("'IJ"\1"nnl"",tp....1 h'(t· I

) 4 ~""".Jl'jl ~.oo"""t;,.....,. ...

I n .............

t:f1/"'tl\{\t:

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 19 of 21

MORRIS COUNTVCORRECTIONAL FACILITY

Inmate Grievance Form #

Inmate Name: Te,{ 11111<-- J Qne > .

'= LD. # 3l12- 3 Date: S J31/ Ob

Housing Unit:--=3:---'b""'-'_______

\ page of_2_- _F '

Nature of Grievance: L e 11 'A\ ~~ 01'1<- (_"" \\$.

Received by:' f~flllIll«::i I'd-.'"1Recorded by: Referred to: Answer to grievance:

Date: 31 YI1Ay QG Date: Date:

f----------------,-----.,--------j

Answered by:

Date:

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 20 of 21

1"(.(1'" Inmate Name: "-)O~) ~~~\~ y.e.~ , ~~~------- LD. # :t 3"-\2. '3

Date:s'/'!,.,fOlJ1 \ i

Housing Unit: 3~ "

page of '=Z"--_

~-,-""""--=.:::..:.::"-,-.o=...:,,-,-,,,..:=,,,---,O"-~"4-'''c.:v-,-t ~~~ 1~ [\">0.,,; ()t.\\",-\- i~ L rL !....." Gl so wI illi",
H -t. .,,\ ,?"",I6.) ",,15\~1-"I"\'(" " .. \1..1 ,11"<1 e

G""b Cj(f~<I'\-\O;" ~ 1. f",,-~1 ;"'\.9

"'-!!J~-"",-_ht!\!j e J, M '" 1"1 ruLJ··

. ..ct I :_1

I---""'"""-'--'-',~f--i,-=""-,--",-"---u-,-,-,",,,",,-+---,-,-~::::-.;,,,-.-,.-.G.,,.-.,.,-,-'tlj fA ·h (I'" '"\--,,~,'J-C~,-,-l-----,-+o-,,----.!..!..~=-'CJ!~
1\ 5~ , (,"'~ . \ 1-\) 0., J, b1 .(.,. IQA \ '3) ~ 1S- ",,-,-I---=<~-'-1
\- f---"""""'JU.-~""'-""';:':"""-<:I'n,-""!.!,;\",,-,l.,,,,,-,,-:,>. -tL C\,~, 'ho~k~hQ(\!!' c<<.US':; -+u( )eJ"') ~b.1 CCI ~.

~~~.;:;,.;..--....LI><-Q.A.-.-.'-~.3.-.'-...-,1-. IS" S 5-t"k .\, ;1-:> ..J.v...l.-.!.""J'C;L=l~,:;);;l-:=-------_ _ _. !1 '. 3 H'5, L- e..j"lh\ "f'ho--~--'------------i . +v G\+toYn~s) cOI,As,l ~r~\...t,~V\ erf£"~'.$J

I

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 5 Filed 06/23/2006 Page 21 of 21

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY

Inmate Grievance Form #

Inmate Name: .-.\-c' ,(\ 0 \Ie -) Vi"'e,j

LD. # 2 '5 q 23 Date::!) If) )UI

Housing Unit_.3.... _--u\3_'______

\ page of \ I

Nature of Grievance: () 1A-1

Received b : Recorded b :
Referred to: .
Answer to levance:

Date: Date:

Answered b

Date:

 
 Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 7 Filed 08/29/2006 Page 1 of 4

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

TERIQUE JONES, Plaintiff, v.
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY, et al.,
Defendants.

: : Civil Action No. 06-2461 (DMC) : : : ORDER : : : : :

For the reasons expressed in the Court’s Opinion filed

herewith,

It is on this 28 day of August

, 2006,

ORDERED that, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(a) and (b), the

application by plaintiff, Terique Jones, to proceed in forma

pauperis is hereby granted; and it is further

ORDERED that the Clerk of the Court is directed to file the

Complaint without prepayment of the filing fee; and it is further

ORDERED that, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b), the Clerk

shall serve a copy of this Order by regular mail on the Attorney

General of the State of New Jersey and on the Warden at the

Morris County Correctional Facility; and it is further

ORDERED that plaintiff is assessed a filing fee of $350.00

which shall be deducted from plaintiff’s prison account pursuant

to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(2) in the manner set forth below,

regardless of the outcome of the litigation; and it is further

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 7 Filed 08/29/2006 Page 2 of 4
ORDERED that, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(2), until the $350.00 fee is paid, each month that the amount in plaintiff’s prison account exceeds $10.00, the agency having custody of plaintiff shall assess, deduct from his account, and forward to the Clerk payments equal to 20% of the preceding month’s income credited to plaintiff’s prison account, with each payment referencing the civil docket number of this action; and it is further
ORDERED that the Complaint is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE, in its entirety, as against defendant, Morris County Correctional Facility, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1915(e)(2)(B)(ii) and 1915A(b)(1), for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted; and it is further
ORDERED that plaintiff’s claims alleging denial of telephone access for legal calls and unconstitutional conditions of confinement are DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1915(e)(2)(B)(ii) and 1915A(b)(1), for failure to state a claim; and it is further
ORDERED that plaintiff’s claims alleging unconstitutional strip searches and interference with his legal mail SHALL PROCEED at this time; and it is further
ORDERED that the Clerk of the Court shall issue summons, and the United States Marshal shall serve a copy of the Complaint, summons, and this Order upon all named defendants, except the
2

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 7 Filed 08/29/2006 Page 3 of 4
Morris County Correctional Facility, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(d), with all costs of service advanced by the United States; and it is further
ORDERED that all defendants, except the Morris County Correctional Facility, shall file and serve a responsive pleading within the time specified in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(g)(2); and it is further
ORDERED that, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(1) and § 4(a) of Appendix H of the Local Civil Rules, the Clerk shall notify plaintiff of the opportunity to apply in writing to the assigned judge for the appointment of pro bono counsel in accordance with the factors set forth in Tabron v. Grace, 6 F.3d 454 (3d Cir. 1993), cert. denied, 510 U.S. 1196 (1994), which sets forth the requirements for eligibility for appointment of pro bono counsel (in this regard, plaintiff is advised that such appointment is not automatic); and it is further
ORDERED that the Clerk shall enclose with such notice a copy of Appendix H and a form Application for Appointment of Pro Bono Counsel; and it is further
ORDERED that, if at any time plaintiff seeks the appointment of pro bono counsel, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 5(a) and (d), plaintiff shall (1) serve a copy of the Application for Appointment of Pro Bono Counsel by regular mail upon each party at his last known address or, if the party is represented in this
3

Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 7 Filed 08/29/2006 Page 4 of 4 action by an attorney, upon the party’s attorney at the attorney’s address, and (2) file a Certificate of Service with plaintiff’s Application for Pro Bono Counsel.
S/ Dennis M. Cavanaugh DENNIS M. CAVANAUGH
United States District Judge
4

 
 Case 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Document 18 Filed 06/08/2007 Page 1 of 1

NOT FOR PUBLICATION

CLOSED

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

:

TERIQUE JONES,

:

:

Plaintiff,

:

:

v.

:

:

MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL :

FACILITY, SHERIFF EDWARD V. :

ROCHFORD, CHIEF RALPH

:

MCGRANE, WARDEN FRANK

:

CORRENTE, JOHN DOES AND JANE :

ROES 1-10, WYZ,

:

:

Defendants.

:

:

Hon. Dennis M. Cavanaugh
ORDER
Civil Action No. 06-cv-2461 (DMC)

This matter coming before the Court upon motion by Defendants Sheriff Edward Rochford, Chief Ralph McGrane and Warden Frank Corrente to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6); and the Court having converted the motion to dismiss to a motion for summary judgment; and Plaintiff having failed to submit opposition or any supplementary evidence; and the Court having further reviewed all submissions; and for the reasons stated in its Opinion issued on this day,
IT IS on this 8 of June, 2007; ORDERED that Defendants’ converted motion for summary judgment is granted.

S/ Dennis M. Cavanaugh

Dennis M. Cavanaugh, U.S.D.J.

cc:

All Counsel of Record

The Honorable Mark Falk, U.S.M.J.

File

 
 Jones v. Morris County Correctional Facility, Not Reported in F.Supp.2d (2007)

2007 WL 1118342 Only the Westlaw citation is currently available.
NOT FOR PUBLICATION United States District Court,
D. New Jersey.
Terique JONES, Plaintiff, v.
MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY, Sheriff Edward V. Rochford, Chief Ralph
McGrane, Warden Frank Corrente, John Does and Jane Roes 1-10, WYZ, Defendants.
Civil Action No. 06-cv-2461 (DMC). | April 13, 2007.
Attorneys and Law Firms
Terique Jones, Newark, NJ, pro se.
Edward R. McMahon, Kevin J. O’Connor, Lum, Danzis, Drasco & Positan, LLC, Roseland, NJ, for Defendants.
Opinion
OPINION
DENNIS M. CAVANAUGH, U.S.D.J.
*1 This matter comes before the Court upon motion by Defendants Sheriff Edward Rochford, Chief Ralph McGrane and Warden Frank Corrente (collectively “Defendants”) to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6). Pursuant to Rule 78 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure no oral argument was heard. After carefully considering the submissions of the parties, and based upon the following, it is the finding of this Court that Defendants’ motion to dismiss is converted to a motion for summary judgment pursuant to Rule 12(b) and subsequent proceedings will take place in accordance with the accompanying Order.
I. BACKGROUND Plaintiff, for all times relevant to this action, was a detainee incarcerated at the Morris County Correctional Facility (“MCCF”). On June 23, 2006, Plaintiff filed an Amended Complaint against the prison facility, various administrative officials, and several unnamed defendants, seeking both injunctive relief and damages. Plaintiff alleges that Defendants interfered with his mail, denied him his right to make telephone calls to his attorney and strip searched him in violation of his Fourth, Fifth, Sixth

and Eighth Amendment rights. While incarcerated, Plaintiff filed grievances with the MCCF on April 17, 2006 regarding the prison’s mail procedures. Plaintiff attached a copy of the grievances to the Complaint. There is no indication that Plaintiff filed any grievances regarding the pre-hearing detention strip searches.
On August 28, 2006, this Court entered a sua sponte order dismissing Plaintiff’s claims except those relating to the strip searches and mail procedures. In this motion Defendants challenge Plaintiff’s Complaint on the grounds that Jones failed to exhaust his administrative remedies required under the Prison Litigation Reform Act (“PLRA”). Specifically, Defendants contend that Jones’ Complaint should be dismissed because he failed to exhaust his administrative remedies, as required under the PLRA. Attached to Defendants’ Rule 12(b)(6) motion is a Certification by Warden Frank Corrente, in which the Warden of MCCF delineates the prison grievance procedures, including the internal appeals process. Attached to the certification are the three grievances Jones attached to the Complaint, as well as the responses to each grievance by various prison officials. Warden Corrente asserts that “[t]here is no record of plaintiff having appealed the denials of his grievances to the Grievance Committee,” and concludes on those facts that Jones failed to exhaust his grievance procedures with regard to the current causes of action before this Court. Corrente Cert. ¶ 7. Plaintiff has filed no response to Defendants’ motion to dismiss.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Standard of Review In deciding a motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6), all allegations in the complaint must be taken as true and viewed in the light most favorable to the plaintiff. See Warth v. Seldin, 422 U.S. 490,501 (1975); Trump Hotels & Casino Resorts, Inc. v. Mirage Resorts, Inc., 140 F.3d 478, 483 (3d Cir.1998). If, after viewing the allegations in the complaint in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, it appears beyond doubt that no relief could be granted “under any set of facts which could prove consistent with the allegations,” a court shall dismiss a complaint for failure to state a claim. Hishon v. King & Spalding, 467 U.S. 69, 73 (1984).
*2 Ordinarily, a 12(b)(6) motion must be decided only upon the allegations set forth in the complaint, without considering any outside documents or available facts. If on a 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss, a party “presents matters outside the pleadings, the district court must convert the motion to dismiss into a motion for summary judgment, and give all parties a reasonable opportunity to present all
1

Jones v. Morris County Correctional Facility, Not Reported in F.Supp.2d (2007)

material pertinent to such a motion under Rule 56.” In re Bayside Prison Litig., 190 F.Supp.2d 755, 760 (D.N.J.2002). In deciding a 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss, the district court may only consider the complaint and limited categories of documents in order to “protect plaintiffs against, in effect, summary judgment by ambush.” Id. (citing Bostic v. AT & T of the Virgin Islands, 166 F.Supp.2d 350, 354-55 (D.V.I.2001)). However, conversion to a motion for summary judgment is not required when a district court considers the following documents: (1) matters attached to the complaint; (2) matters incorporated into the pleadings by reference; (3) matters of public record; (4) matters integral to or upon which plaintiff’s claim is based.” In re Bayside, 190 F.Supp.2d at 760 (internal citations omitted). The Third Circuit allows district courts to consider such documents because “neither party can claim prejudice or surprise by the court’s reliance on the document.” Id.
In addition, this Court is cognizant of the leniency given to pro se litigants. See Haines v. Kerner, 404 U.S. 519 (1972); U.S. v. Albinson, 356 F.3d 278 (3d Cir.2004). However, even with a more lenient reading of Plaintiff’s Complaint, it is apparent on its face that no relief may be granted.
B. PLRA Requirements The PLRA requires prisoners to exhaust available administrative remedies prior to asserting a claim in federal courts pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983. See 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(a); Nyhuis v. Reno, 204 F.3d 65, 67 (3d Cir.1999). Failure to exhaust administrative remedies is an affirmative defense for which Defendants bear the burden of production and persuasion. Jones v. Bock, ---U.S. ----, 127 S.Ct 910, 921 (2007); Ray v. Kertes, 285 F.3d 287, 295 (3d Cir.2002).
In cases regarding PLRA exhaustion, the Third Circuit has been clear that certifications of the sort presented by Warden Corrente are outside the scope of matters relevant to deciding a motion to dismiss. See Camp v. Brennan 219 F.3d 279, 280 (3d Cir.2000) (holding that district court’s reliance on declaration of prison official converted motion to dismiss to one for summary judgment). The Third Circuit has explicitly stated that “[r]eliance on declarations from prison officials requires conversion.” Hemingway v. Falor, 200 Fed. Appx. 86, 90 (3d

Cir.2006). In this case, Defendants ask the Court to consider and rely upon the Corrente Certification in granting the Rule 12 motion to dismiss. As made clear by the Third Circuit, this Court may not grant Defendants’ motion to dismiss without converting the motion to one for summary judgment.
C. Conversion to Summary Judgment *3 When converting a 12(b)(6) motion to one for summary judgment, “all parties must be given reasonable opportunity to present all material made pertinent to such a motion by Rule 56.” Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b). Converting the current motion to dismiss into a motion for summary judgment without allowing Plaintiff further opportunity to respond with additional facts would subvert the policy against “summary judgment by ambush.” Bayside, 190 F.Supp.2d at 760. It is reversible error for this Court to convert a 12(b)(6) or a 12(c) motion into a motion for summary judgment without sufficient notice to the parties. See Castle v. Cohen, 840 F.2d 173, 179-80 (3d Cir.1988); Davis Elliott Int’l, Inc. v. Pan Am. Container Corp., 705 F.2d 705, 706-08 (3d Cir.1983); Crown Cent. Petrol. Corp. v. Waldman, 634 F.2d 127, 129 (3d Cir.1980). As such, this Court and the parties must follow the requirements of Rule 56(c)-(g) in order to fairly give Plaintiff the opportunity to respond to Defendants’ brief and to file affidavits of his own contesting their version of the facts.
Pursuant to the requirements of 12(b), this Court will convert Defendant’s 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss into a motion for summary judgement pursuant to Rule 56. Further, in accordance with Rule 12, all parties are granted an opportunity to respond and “present all material made pertinent to such a motion by Rule 56.” Davis Elliott Int’l, Inc., 705 F.2d at 707 (citing Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b)).
III. CONCLUSION For the reasons stated, it is the finding of this Court that Defendants’ motion to dismiss is converted to a motion for summary judgment pursuant to Rule 12(b). An appropriate Order accompanies this Opinion.
	  

2

 
 CM/ECF LIVE - U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey - Doc... https://ecf.njd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/DktRpt.pl?776059063982971-L_35...

U.S. District Court District of New Jersey [LIVE] (Newark) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF

CLOSED

JONES v. MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY et Date Filed: 05/23/2006

al

Date Terminated: 06/08/2007

Assigned to: Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh

Jury Demand: None

Referred to: Magistrate Judge Mark Falk

Nature of Suit: 550 Prisoner: Civil Rights

Cause: 42:1983 Prisoner Civil Rights

Jurisdiction: Federal Question

Plaintiff TERIQUE JONES

represented by TERIQUE JONES 955194B NORTHERN STATE PRISON 168 FRONTAGE ROAD NEWARK, NJ 07114 PRO SE

V. Defendant MORRIS COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY TERMINATED: 08/28/2006 Defendant SHERIFF EDWARD V. ROCHFORD
Defendant

represented by EDWARD R. MCMAHON LUM, DRASCO & POSITAN, LLC 103 EISENHOWER PARKWAY ROSELAND, NJ 07068 (973) 403-9000 Fax: (973) 403-9021 Email: emcmahon@lumlaw.com LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
KEVIN J. O'CONNOR LUM, DANZIS, DRASCO & POSITAN, LLC. 103 EISENHOWER PARKWAY ROSELAND, NJ 07068-1049 (973) 403-9000 Email: koconnor@lumlaw.com ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

1 of 4

6/26/2007 1:22 PM

CM/ECF LIVE - U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey - Doc... https://ecf.njd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/DktRpt.pl?776059063982971-L_35...

CHIEF RALPH MCGRANE
Defendant WARDEN FRANK CORRENTE
Defendant CAPTAIN COLLINS TERMINATED: 06/26/2006 Defendant CAPTAIN DEEMER TERMINATED: 06/26/2006 Defendant JOHN DOES Defendant JANE DOES 1-10

represented by EDWARD R. MCMAHON (See above for address) LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
KEVIN J. O'CONNOR (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by EDWARD R. MCMAHON (See above for address) LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
KEVIN J. O'CONNOR (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Date Filed 05/23/2006 06/05/2006 06/05/2006

#

Docket Text

1 Complaint Received. (lm2, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 6/2/2006 (lm2, ). (Entered: 05/31/2006)
2 OPINION . Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 5/31/06. (ji, ) (Entered: 06/05/2006)
3 ORDER that Clerk open a case for Terique Jones; ORDER that Clerk enter the Opinion and Order from 06-2340 on this docket; ORDER that Plaintiff file an Amended Complaint and either pay the $250 filing fee or submit a completed and signed IFP application sent when this Order was entered on the docket in 06-2340. Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 5/31/06. (ji, ) (Entered: 06/05/2006)

2 of 4

6/26/2007 1:22 PM

CM/ECF LIVE - U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey - Doc... https://ecf.njd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/DktRpt.pl?776059063982971-L_35...

06/23/2006 06/23/2006 08/29/2006 08/29/2006
08/29/2006 09/28/2006 10/04/2006 10/13/2006 10/16/2006

4 APPLICATION to proceed in forma pauperis by TERIQUE JONES. (Attachments: # 1 account summary)(sr, ) (Entered: 06/26/2006)
5 AMENDED COMPLAINT , filed by TERIQUE JONES.(sr, ) (Entered: 06/26/2006)
6 OPINION . Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 8/28/06. (ji, ) (Entered: 08/29/2006)
7 ORDER granting IFP, assessing a filing fee of $350 to be deducted from prisoner's account in the manner set forth in this Order, and directing the Clerk to file the Complaint and issue summons to be served with Plaintiff's complaint and this Order upon Defendants by the U.S. Marshal; ORDER that Clerk serve a copy of this Order upon the Attorney General of NJ and the Warden of Morris County Correctional Facility; ORDER that Complaint is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE against defendant Morris County Correctional Facility in its entirety and against plaintiff's claims alleging denial of telephone access for legal calls and unconsitutional conditions of confinement; ORDER that Plaintiff's claims alleging unconstitutional strip searched and interference with his legal mail SHALL PROCEED; ORDER that all remaining defendants shall file and serve a responsive pleading in accordance with Fed.R.Civ.P.12; ORDER that Clerk shall notify Plaintiff of the opportunity to apply in writing for pro bono counsel and shall enclose with such notice a copy of Appendix H and a form application for such appointment; ORDER that if Plaintiff seeks such appointment, he shall notify defendants and file a certificate of service with his application. Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 8/28/06. (ji, ) (Entered: 08/29/2006)
8 Summons Issued as to EDWARD V. ROCHFORD, RALPH MCGRANE, FRANK CORRENTE.Days Due - 20 (Placed in U.S. Marshal's Box). (ji, ) (Entered: 08/29/2006)
9 Application and Proposed Order for Clerk's Order to extend time to answer as to Defendants Sheriff Edward V. Rochford, Chief Ralph McGrane and Warden Frank Corrente. Attorney KEVIN J. O'CONNOR and KEVIN J. O'CONNOR for EDWARD V. ROCHFORD and RALPH MCGRANE, EDWARD R. MCMAHON and KEVIN J. O'CONNOR for EDWARD V. ROCHFORD and RALPH MCGRANE added. (O'CONNOR, KEVIN) (Entered: 09/28/2006)
10 SUMMONS Returned Executed RALPH MCGRANE served on 9/28/2006, answer due 10/18/2006; FRANK CORRENTE served on 9/28/2006, answer due 10/18/2006, EDWARD ROCKFROD on 9/28/06, answer due 10/18/06. (sr, ) (Entered: 10/05/2006)
11 MOTION to Dismiss For Failure to State a Claim Upon Which Relief Can Be Granted by EDWARD V. ROCHFORD, RALPH MCGRANE, FRANK CORRENTE. Responses due by 10/27/2006 (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet cover letter# 2 Brief brief# 3 Text of Proposed Order order# 4 Certification cert)(SICA, ANTHONY) (Entered: 10/13/2006)
Set Deadline as to 11 MOTION to Dismiss For Failure to State a Claim Upon Which Relief Can Be Granted. Motion Hearing set for 11/13/2006 before Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh. (PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT THIS MOTION WILL

3 of 4

6/26/2007 1:22 PM

CM/ECF LIVE - U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey - Doc... https://ecf.njd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/DktRpt.pl?776059063982971-L_35...

11/06/2006 11/08/2006 04/13/2007 04/13/2007
05/24/2007 06/08/2007 06/08/2007

BE DECIDED ON THE PAPERS UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTIFIED BY THE COURT) (sr, ) (Entered: 10/16/2006)
12 NOTICE of Change of Address by TERIQUE JONES (sr, ) (Entered: 11/08/2006)
13 CERTIFICATE of Counsel Edward R McMahon by ANTHONY R. SICA on behalf of EDWARD V. ROCHFORD, RALPH MCGRANE, FRANK CORRENTE (SICA, ANTHONY) (Entered: 11/08/2006)
14 OPINION fld.. Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 4/13/07. (sr, ) (Entered: 04/13/2007)
15 ORDER converting 11 MOTION to Dismiss For Failure to State a Claim Upon Which Relief Can Be Granted filed by FRANK CORRENTE, EDWARD V. ROCHFORD, RALPH MCGRANE to a Motion for Summary Judgment, & that pltf shall file & serve, should he so choose, an amended brief together with any other documentation provided for under Rule 56. Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 4/13/07. (sr, ) (Entered: 04/13/2007)
16 Letter from Edward McMahon. (MCMAHON, EDWARD) (Entered: 05/24/2007)
17 OPINION fld.. Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 6/8/07. (sr, ) (Entered: 06/11/2007)
18 ORDER granting (converted to Summary Judgment) 11 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge Dennis M. Cavanaugh on 6/8/07. (sr, ) (Entered: 06/11/2007)

PACER Service Center

Transaction Receipt

06/26/2007 14:24:59

PACER Login:

hs0328

Client Code:

eeoc

Description:

Docket Report

Search Criteria:

2:06-cv-02461-DMC-MF Start date: 1/1/1970 End date: 6/26/2007

Billable Pages:

2

Cost: 0.16

4 of 4

6/26/2007 1:22 PM