COMPLAINT
(fot' filers who are prisoners without lawyers)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN
(Full name of plaintiff(s))

"-"'d ,J[ StM;[i""[) S iJu._f~l WCl l"'''""'e.r"

tiA

iso [.J,_J

AL~~;A,"Lve..

[,..,fi"e..ue.;.J,
•

v.

Case Number:

(Full name of defendant(s))
W;~li<>M P.ll,.J.,_&,;/WA ~,j.e_, i.•L k« oH><;J u.r.c'd:1, (to be supplied by Clerk of Court) JP11y ~1eli , J,~ £. Lit>d.u C."l:ky Jw, D,, Sc~Mi,l~ 1 B,;"""' GreFf, P«u l lul11if""'
ToVJ 0 DoMVd"', c,_r{,_;.._ We.sf,,,, tis. B..;,sl
C. o. Cu"Jy, AC Rc J""''- ,1 J.~.. D."' l-ID,
Ie.>sie_ J. ScL1~ecJIU' I s~.w,._ !1. LJaii!U I Iue""t L. Sfa-.,ieL,
J.s"fit 6M.L.M1""'j Lk" D.e.s t·lD, ""'J
,_l[ otlt.e;-~ i" H,..,_;, ·,Al;uiLuoJ Al'\1 Jf.uJ &~~,_~+·,,_,.

A PARTIES
1. Plaintiff is a citizen of _ _,\J.J.Ji~<LD""""''"'!..!.·i"'-"'----------'' and is located at
(State)
~W«..,.,u~u'!'_."'~C.~•'£'',"-~L~L~"'""-Li~l~VI!.!...'~"'-J~,J!oi!·,,~"'~(w~n..__''4-).._,p.-'='0_,_."'-'8"'-'-~"'-'.35=...o[_\""j""""f"'u.l!!,"',....,._..._531/. 3.
(Address of prison or jail)

(If more than one plaintiff is filing, use another piece of paper.)
2. Defendant ..l!\J~;l.!!IJwi"~M"--!.p.!!!,[~Lrmd,___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
(Name)

Complaint- 1
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 1 of 34 Document 1

J

5,;•., Fo,Je.r 1 WC. I, P. {). f'l,~ 351 1 LJ""f"~ 1 WI 5311.3 .

4.. '""1 ~1~l;, Wc.r, P.D. B,x 351, ki..T.,,IJI 53%3. DOC

5. Jo"' t..Lisc.L4 1 DOC(c."""l"'J) 1 P.o.B.xl1l5,M,_l·.so~o,\JI5:n67-l1Z5.

IP. CAky Je.s.s 1 DOC(u_,.J,.,I), P.O. B.~ 1ns, M..L"", Wr 53767-1125.

7. D,. SJ,Mdtl Uti, P.O. 13,,,, 351 11JM\'")Jr S3'1L.s. Doc..

2_ B,;,._"'- G,sr,L...tC'I,P.o. B.dst~W""'f""'lJr 5311,~. Doc.

1 q, f,_u.\ lwlu'/'""'1 \..itl1 P.o. B.dsl, W/W. 1L~, \.Jr 53'11.3. DDt.
\D. TuliA Q' Do..,oi/<LVI (u.v~\<,.,o<.JV<),
U. t;·k,~ tJ.,t,,.._,Uc.rl P.O. Elor.. ?:.5l, w.~f""'l Wr S.3%L DOc.

\2. ~t. ~•"'' 1 Wti, P.O. B". 3Sl 1 \-J""Fu0 1WI 53'llo3. DOL.
13. C. 0. [_u.,j~' Uti, P.O. Box. 35 \I u,."'l"~ IUI 53'1£. 3. DOL.
l'i. AcJzl J""._ ,_,1 T.k,., tl.ti 1-10, \Jc._r, P.o. ~:,.dsll \J....1..~,LJrs31L,3. "D~.
1s. Je.s,., ... 1. ~d,,11..ik,. 1 Ucr, P.O. 5.,_,s51, ~J.wi""'IWL531t...J. DDL. 1L. j~'"".c ~l WJiu.,lJc..I,P.o. fl.~; :sst,W...r~~Ur 531/,3. DOL.
11. 1~"-""'~ l. St."';.c",W0_I P.O.f!l.x 351,\Ju,r..-~LJISJ1L,3. DOC. 1
IX. los~~\, f::-.M1M 1 \,.,[L.I, P.O. B.~ 35[,\J,_ul""'rWI 53'fla3. DDL.
1t 'J.~,~ \J., ,_ 10, 1~c.r, P.o. B.. 3st, ll... r""l Ur 53~1.,3. boc.

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 2 of 34 Document 1

is (if a person or private corporation) a citizen of _W"""''"'<w"'-"'"'=-'''-"'""=-------------
(State, if known) and (if a person) resides a t - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(Address, if known) and (if the defendant harmed you while doing the defendant's job)
worked for ~LuVIs'"' DrtM•" l Of 11,,0LLM. f'. D. &x 1125, t1..L,."' . LJI 5.3767- 1'16.
(Employer's name and address, if known)
(If you need to list more de.fendants, use another piece of paper.) S'M. ALc.LeJ enqe..
B. STATEMENTOFCLAIM
On the space provided on the following pages, tell: 1. Who violated your rights; 2. What each defendant did; 3. When they did it; 4. Where it happened; and 5. Why they did it, if you know.
I. E..v:.~ VIILMerJ dete.vtdml h.u AcieJ u.Je, cnlo,, of s},,Je. la.w L dep-rive.

2. The. Vl/l(ohlli' .~ r""~' f'l'Se.{)t il.V\j r~ture rri>MlllS h.e ll l,y +~e. Jei~!..Air

- ~UW\ ';·ola..ti e.

c \ve Co~(,.,e.....<1.¥\t c.') :... U..e.

1.
Su
Complaint- 2
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 3 of 34 Document 1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 4 of 34 Document 1

£ -lU!BidWO::J

u 11C,-J J"'F"'lt'' "'" T"'-'"!r\7

·T'"'"1 "f"~"J-rv.Jv~ ·'jJ:1v~·r1 T~"lcr' 1IOOI·x3 V')

j __, """""

J(I~T'T

t J" "T'"""' ,' '-""Vf"'oJ"f <>"jt "'~ rvnjC>Mt' 5~

"'"1"'"""" f"'" T'l"""'

1-., o"\ \ ; fY1 f."' n IF6:5 ''1t " ! s'"' vrvs ~"

'i* \JTlfl'"U'

1>'7--tl...-..-vJI~ (Vl,V'V•It\'1lV>nr'\

IA-.:>Innii\"VJI

r-~\'I\1I"IIC'Ul 1 1l!V1 fro -;I<O"T\ I"Vlli-:Tl'l <'!VIi Ji) 11lJ'l"""J711'1fllJ\rrr1 -in

\A..., r "'~''"F' "~""It "l'n'"'1t .:1" 1"''t .J" OV!~l?V1lilv "1t .v: '"\1'"!T"""\ llJ

!iv!'"'.Wf

(}1t '·1TJ 'GJ'Jl/ll7\llQ1 V!')'VVI -...t.ll

• 17J

J >.11'711>'11\Ac;:liAI"";:U LVt

-:>UI

..JO'.l 1,,

I -.•. ..- .,,A, ,,.

f , ~·~-

VTQQVlfi''1'r"!f''"'' yvv tvvd "i'1!'VlvJs-ao ""'~' 'Qi ..,.'41 1 sooQ ""1"1' f"'"' 'vv'1'Qvg

'-n!"'"1S ·~"1\'T'\ ·' ""F'"VI'VS '-uosG!nfnl 'JJ"~J'T"~~'/""1\"d T"Yf""'j"Q ·:;

• '1'7YQ 'IF" t7f

']J_v-uvv~xv"-tl'iY J" '""!·I ir"'Y!'!f"'J "X\o d" {""""'"P" J r"'v

t"VV~(ll (7 VI! ynu'-1

T'""~t -om t """"!

"'o. ''t 1'<7V·

"'" rv~ ti

Tw·J~nJ onT"'n-J ''"j r'-'•!f'!•tsoJ 'r "'\ l"f'"r'1ns <NV """"It F"'""!!J S"<l"""!""l

'l'QllVJrll'--v;} tSW\J rVV' -\-VQVl/otJ!(j.J,!.\111(} tJV!/\~1 ('SVVt1S"

"'Q/I~r7\•JtS(I~

·py,,s tv\v~...,..,....~.• ,...,, '"u .,,,,,..,.... ~"'"~r-.•r.o ...,,..,YJ n,..,,..,-,,..,-::~., "TJrv-v '••-.?r..-~ -a 1\t'J ••

!"\ -y '! ti

r-·t"'"" r t \f . _, "{Q

r V><J"-'7

\.HI! Sof ""T"~\

/"'V>!"'."" T gt '"'"T'?!.:f~l'o""' """"~ '1t:("l TJl''\ '1,

<>ll!t "I "5! ?<-vWl-f(>\IM f"" "1t .:1" ''f"fS -, >!

""'""'5 f'il~~11
-c/WQlfl~_jV'OJ

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 5 of 34 Document 1

"£ -t~'.V\Jw•J

. SO)""' 'f'J o~o ""Jr" :;-.ra"'"J~_,J ""j o"-'~~,, 4V<U"'"'1 s:VlnJ -v J" .Lrtd D' 'f''''r"':f"f

()1f i" IP' /:1 yo.m T"'Yl r'Vli~sar s; snit f"" 'rsnol "1 •t f"\11 ""'"~" Tin"('?

n rVlfl Na"'"'~_,) '']''"t('l v: t\AQW''-'OJ~~vva wv "1 >tiAno=y Y1 "~

'"~ "1L ·z

(SOO! ·~]) 'fVOw!''.nbctv f't ~>oiNl ]"''" ynvt 5 '5jj?f""~ '"1t ron>Q >'"1 'Y':1f'l V1J~t ,, l VSI yubvlT)rJ yrvv
t(;.,,_"d~VJovorJYffij ''tr'VSSYI tvor~I\ 1 WU~?"()O>J ~:~u~o"jroAsd wuJn rr,-,T"'~
.J""'""'f>?"Jt ""~sn'p' v: ?fw?vro •t 'f.JY}nf fr-os moll"' 1'~"\f'l ;,""v•os!J ~a::>
rlJI" YJ!r~vJJ J\1 "1t fV1V! '1"'T1~ b., "1t V'(f1J['lt"1 tVol'VV'O'~""'r 'rF"'1 'll "':"tv:wrv Tv" 'T"t"Y"j.nJ 'rt'JO"" """'1'01 "~lt1 souq_ ~'l"J y~"''~'1""9
'-ro:vrrJ ~ '""Jr''f'\ '""]':""'T0 'dj<l'':] 'vos6!'f"l '"'T"'J"\ '"""""u'\J ,Q I '"'P'f l
'=r ':r·~~ 'T"WJ 't"'"fVl"f'Y t"'"'"vcJ "'1t "+ -zw• t""F ~· "'O ·L

(zoot ·x 1) ·ss<w'lr r''tvroYV\ If"' f'T"'.'95S'9 ssoVlP'·

r S'wofdYV>,{,- <r.IY'f'". VTVV f''lt ""'":t•>V(,> )""' hrrVlV5~ ':"1t 1f"' L:/,"1

rJ::J'i)rvm STJOV()bVNy <7 "t o)l'<'JO'"'r"JI (JVV S'«<tnH~J <'SU1[_ ''f'"dJV o~!'']f'N

s:-t'. >~<;? >'\llUVJt STIIJ~r~SV'~ 1 V<l.

lAQJTl OSn

Yf .jq ?JV('YV\ATIQV171()f'IOVJ1''t;j Y) fPV f"5

"'f'""q..,j ;;r" ,'f"'T"<Jof o'1t ~"J r•jptnt s.-ovq'J_,J tsvw '.f'!J'"~ "0 '"'

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 6 of 34 Document 1

H;- rvrlwo:~

· o099" 'L • <:; <J<JS ~· · o 1t'"'"llVVV]s:vonJ
r VVJQj "f"'J "T " "' r o)n 'j""'F"J'T "'lt '1bn'1t ''T"""~"''"' ''1 't
r'"'JJns '~ '1~:1\"1 snf"P "J\1 rt"\ "5 ~ rJ"'"l",J "~ •"" 'J1T~-.r '~l Q!!)

·(J't"''J)"""T"'JoS T'll"T'''J f"'Y '(~'S b""d,)"'''.pJoA.s vvv~'Jd '(, bO ,,)
"' "l"""~'J., ~ """ "'~ J~':"-'51\l v"" '"~"9-.. 'U r~ 't pv~j'~ ,~'"T'P.. "'1_L C!!)

""""'tor V'! P""''JT -"'It bv:u9 1J J" ,.,9~tmJ f'"'" ''9

0 .J \f . rV"\< •

"~'d S" ""cr~ T I Y""" >Obvr<'-i 'g rvrv '1 V>uo ('"T' \ VVV/JGJ V' I""T

J.,P J" ,J~t _, "~I' Si'"'T' P T"'" "''T'T'"\ f" mv-[,"1' L,~ ~rv" VJ~Yl0"1t

tvo""'l'~"'ncJ ""j '~ f"T\ /,.0 "It j" U'ST' YV'" t""wLv)~wo r"""vn>t "''LL (!)

:sf'l'l1~0 SYl -orv .:"'"Tr"". ".'J1,.. 'Lvr'"':JL T"'" 's~-vl""""H ',,(-yrn0 "'" """'1 r"Z

'lrr.:' 't ya~:jV"'-;J orv o("l ''"'"f'l"n ..<~"F'mf"S )""" 'sh''T'J 'sh-'T'""'Y'Tl I ,t,.F'"~

r"'n 1119 '"n"1 E"Z YJIW o<-!S WQQJlf"! 't ""''}" P"'~j"'VV ~Jr"'!'IAt ()'V

bus

'1-T v~ J\j Pf"l9J] r&"'"l~rJ 1-y_ywhJ"QJns .,..~ 'Jrtv;'lr 111 '"'"~Pl""T "(71

. wvmJ ~""~1 ~!-"T ""j ovv •Lo ~ b "'VT'T'JuJ b-us j'Tt "It J' f"vl\ tvT'vv:P"
r lnAOSY(H (,"""\\.j~7'T ""'j ()if':' YV7~~3Y~Y""f'!' fres hr~qph{l F"" "'1L "b

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 7 of 34 Document 1

"'t-jv~vJJ"''';]

:rvt J <J.f"froJtV'V/) t'V''-"Vp holt oJQ"j['l

]J" <-<U;J '-'1'1VV01 j"'j&v•.V''I<IY¥

Wo'lt

·r m!'4 f1t v<?~rl "'! Lui ,rJ .]"' <PT""J /t "'"fVfOJ"f \lit ~ '1 "'!WS<r;I(JVJ 1->/W)"'!V\' ',"j!l r~"''f •<IV r"'n '·s "'1t V! S<(iV"':~ JV nv (!!/\)

T1.(!I"'"s r''" T f' r:""<lf '7(l.W uS?JOJro 'jjo-rsup '·ruuf"'! V>Y J'"''tt" "t f,l~" F'n ~"S

'"'l"\ 05! (FJ-t "'~ J"'VlYt"'~'IV'I' CIJ'l rvrv vv-<'JO~J ''Jt'"f'J "'1t VI~ p(Ylo]Jl7

JV . 'OAoVl voN 5FiJ"'"''.J

VY10'1 '-"V ""j +~'~lVl"S f'"0T '1f(T1 as;o.n;;o ""'Fr"

f"'iltro "t rwwlr'' """' T"' 17 I ( G-v~r r"1 ""T'T"J,J )"VOV'O{J y 'lr'~ 11'0 "Jr"~\

"""'rry ""Jt

"'! >!

'r'~)('li __}

1/

VVY)m<1l

"1tJO]J\~v,, f""' ,,"'"TSVJNt,, f"jj"-;i

-yraJY

~'S

"t

""!A""J"~ f'{\QVV> o"Y

yoop r"]'.''}¥" OV]f'l s•-uvvs:nl JV

'''Nl

(!!\)

. ovv~Jr.J "'"!f"j "'! yoh."I"J /' osmp I sf''T""J"f 't "nF VJ<VJ"f~V>'1
r )"t"'"VV r"'Y "'''F ""'""'~ (~Q)'"f"t ~ "'o'·t-."J"f1o '~T"r'! "'·
f vrovv<J?w~ 't r""~ '1n3 aT<' "" VJQo"] on'O"\ "'If" 'jjlt"'!"JJ 'lL (I\)

. "''!" 'C!D fV1" (!) "'! rt<'·l sobi/IY~ I" ""5"f"P ""'t "t ~·r"""F 't
7l""!f/,"'Y f" f'"'"Jn3 ()JTl O"U """1 '"1P" '117VU h/t lvo!snj7uS" ?f"';J''f~~
[" f'" T""f'lJPj <Jfl~YVI 't r"'•jp" f""' oro 'jj!r:"IJ "It '"'!S (11!)

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 8 of 34 Document 1

rt- t V!Y,~WO;J

syV"?n? (,5 o~''i""'-NV (}IOVJi "! ~J_V-,r:J~! ~"'.'~.JOn.rr'J vt T.T1JJ.,o" Vjr\1 ""'tJ)
O"lf ~: JtVJ)yv:\1 (}<1'(7 1<'""jl''O"'t 1yVI-v fJVT<I~ t"Vl or >Y'"'WY>J <>50"]\ 'S'T()V'OS! ,J <-=' }"'":"''t'io• f"'" jJ"·p h"J f"J"'',t'j """VV' >Vil"l' ?"\1 "'"\ f"-J"'"'oVV1 """"' rv.~-rwvv;J h"""'"~f'tS"'"V1 bv~v,_-.Y'I'?.., '"'JL ·vvoJ », "'o:f'\ •so.., pv-v ~fr"n(\, ""'f t''l r""n•

51'ITOVV'(T,) -osu'1_L_ · '"'<'.r.JlM-;;) --n"" lf" J'."P '"lt j" "'"Th:J)(u ""H "Jf<'l svvvuJ 'o-'

JVI'O 50~'-''I!J "'lt J

«I"~)!"" "'71

V>O

rtV'nQV'A

5>'.0'-"Yr.J ~

A.rvv":1-"'f s <IJ"\- --~··t

J

~\

"'"!J~\~"w('"'o\ r.nf'i') ;} ·'p;s~v;J vnt',<'> 07"'1'\F"~""' ',f"'n hu~ ""Jl (X)

• S"WQVYJ <>S""Jt L~Jvr.Jso ~D'j (!SI,QV> ""'t "IJdn"" 0-t snrNYJJJ7 Hbv>'IJ-J "QVVVJ ,. b"'!J;fjnV¥ y tTl""" '~}-"''T'"f37 o"Jt f''1t T"lS '')r'f'7 ""I 'r:s rpvv ''""''r "'0
bv\ bvry\ I bv'."~"" 1bv~vvV()VJS '""""'"'!""\ 't -,nr rno\ L~~ 5\ f" n lros "11 (X!)

·"'" "'~ •rv1 f'"l m~.J f""'l'"" t""o>J "" P'j\1 3 ;, V "'!"t""" ~~'!

"t"J~..,!t"""J

""

1"0 '1"&

rvr()n"V

qt

r'f"'"jfl'

two

"
• ..,

I
'"<l'""''!'J

" Jfj

(!!!/\)

. J"il!JJJn5 ·t"" -.~Y/'1 "t f"'""W t"" ·h·o ("~"'V\!/\)J"'"(IIJ)C71 rV'YJ Cll ""~,Jf"t7V"'1

r7"'d""' T"" '''0!t"l"'! /"!"o:.' r'" /"'t"'o"""'".'~"'" o.fil~-.~ 't f""!"1nr
oJY t'J'"11~1 P"''O '( // v•o """'""'S "T"'"VIf' ""P A t'i (}VJ' sp:~ hVJ""JF

f"1

JP'J 'r'\A

~"'"r~~('l ""'

T·~n

f"t"'""

"~"1

f""'"'Yi7

'""~f"

17 "Vil

"~!! 1.,

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 9 of 34 Document 1

"!)- r7"~"'":7

Y'·"~" "t -'1"'1Jou1 ~f~""'CJ"s '~It t:~)J'" 1T'!'.'jJ" ~""'\""'Jm il\"':nb

'M"tS" .r"'n t.& "VJt ;f" S()W~T rn/ hvl""' ;JJl'tS If" '""3 ()1Y'ra;Juotl

1/ Lq f"'"

oJ ~f JflJ-.s t ncr Pq

"'r bv) ~"'T/''YVVI ""' S! <.fil!l

(A! X)

·qb)?vv; rt~P\T " f'"IJ"' '""'!VV' /]T"" rVJn ~ 11\f ()!!XJ

. "' 0!f"\l>!:! f' "f"'j Ji' "'11 J. '1 wwpv '1 1Auv\ oA,b"\t -q5Ylv;:r"\
·w t~n t--T\7 T"'" ~"7 mvus~-rJ n! l,ll"t"'"\N ''""'l;~ ~lf"t"'"VV '"" 1'JI\
v~ "'1-f fV i<Js s.r-.vws!.J "'\t j" of., j'J t 'W"j17 /if'! ]'I"\ yv'Y "'"!PW'"'j<'; "'0 . mw"'!j J if lV>oVVJ-p P'n"l r""' J\;1 T'T'1 D5! rbvrTj "'1 'WI rr-'"1~
-J.JV ']"f~-o:ns oJY "1(" T"'v 15S<l"'jjl )''f"'ilVVl ynu}.COJ "Jf1'1 '"'"'"s.''cJ (!\X)

-rz "n"""rl r r .L

"fS "o!pnJrVv;J " "'fl 5f"'C105

vv-v-a.r;n;- r" ~vry~ S•TiJV'VS~n~

U'il1 ['7 f'"Jt 'T""".J ]T"fTI ~V!'"l 11'\ '()1t \fr y;r:>v>nol f"1-J ""J'd bv~""T""1f

7/ 5V1 ("'(")~ h~)n IJ) snvvs)~ J"J sn mnu1 f'"11 ub"'V--' UV)_L ( !'/{)

(t"JOQJ fV'l''i·J'JQOJ'Xj)'f"' 11 J'""" r"j.(,"" 11 ''M ""'1+~

"'j f"'Y ,"! '""WV'!.J t F'"Jw rvr-v '"'"f"''"'~t, J~ T'" "t f"l.hc" """11 T~"'lf'l

:~'Jt ¥17.) sh l ()7Wl7)lloM n s <

"'l >Sl>V'lj""'i' t -')1 "Jf ["1 ""Tvv"'J (l.r<' f "'<' of""CJo

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 10 of 34 Document 1

Jt T.'T""'"J

-'Y""nf "'11 TJ\11" I"'f'\'1 L~7) ~'"f -ro 5VVQH'1t'"\ ~vr(l v;"t"'v.7 -vrilfY' C)Q~ ""T"o

oVJt """' 5--;r(,,, -:ra ~ o"11 "<1YJf~"V1 <JslT<TTol"\ I b,.•.f.,_,t o{,>r.J "" s-FU '1 :l o"l\ "'17

sv~"t s ":O"H "" S<TYOj Tv>" --v~;•Vl Vl'"'t"'"'"' y '-'V ~-tpJ olll' _,-.~;:> 7UJ "'lt Cl)

1 !r'""t"'"!l;J ,s~J Jrts F'r" OO"Jf'"' f\no<'l '"'"'"·'~.,..\ hvrv"' fo"\\ -1-·m5Q b"';.m\
'""~"~!j t1nvssv T"'" <>'5"'F ~)J""'!Jht sy""n{, hs CI"Jt \17:'""'5V<N t".'"'"\T"j

OVJt

'".j

70 "

F"''t}"

f'"~

'"'if"J

'"'"'"'.'~ J'V

T"f'lv'! i"'vH

(1!!/\X)

'<;QVpTI·cJo r"" !'YJ(j'1 IT"" '"'~:rr'."hy -J-oa,s 50f'"J~ yr sosnv.:J r ot """'SUJX(l
rrlvrol'"d ."n"~pJ.J vro f1.£! I "{1 "'I f"'n tor;, "'1t "! 1!'9 'P"J (JiflX)

T w"':'l '>17QioJ ""j C"'Wj "'Y'J J'tj •~'t"\lJ'S'. "'1 5'?'-"'S).,J f""\1 vv,,)oj "" vv!"''"F'" -.~!]f)~)""\ •!11 c>n""j 'f"'"T-''".Pf <>"'j_ (!/Vi)

t • CIVV!f ""li T v[, l)L rrvvvT'" V'Y ]fi'7 j-y vv--Jr.jt •t 11" "t
I!()V'1Js;rrJ 17 ""'.Jh.., ,\-."'t ""'VJf"'1 h-:rvo~.rJ ).V''YI ""l"'05\~ oV]y "f!""""] h"lt "f """" 'st~nss~ J"f"'"YY> "?"It r''1" svovm\J "'f<'' v\tb'W(}i f" >JJ"t •t -ow;-\ T-v)
c,n I-'/''"""~ t-as ":U"lt bv'.'nt' h"F ~dJf·~n ""?!~'Os r'!-?"fT/''::1 ?VJl (AX)
'5+~"T"Ul Sn11~\JOS ""1f' on 1 <~5~-r,;J bv.•.rny f"'iJS(lj L:u"J {,.,,j,VJ(JF /,'j AfJ1"P'fV'n<T:TJ)?

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 11 of 34 Document 1

(t" T7"J~"'""J

t'. VV<fVfYJ "t "'f-r<> ""' 'lf'f> Vil("J"'P ""~t v: ""t"Vf'l v")t bV'!V'VlYhJ ~pnol~o,.J +un
lp.wJvnJ (IPfO\"'"\S '"T""vJ w'1cn "'.'f']"J!"'VY\' JPt' bvT'"'"" b"~("loWJ "'lt ~"1
--abv>v~ JV "'lt ~v """'"'!.rJ lvs "~tvrynps:r Apl"""'1T"f 'T~ (,., "11 (\XX)

J v '()5V'1'7J7'J Vl'?J NoVO'!J

rvrv "'rvT1 f"lt 'o""!f j'flll' f" ""I S"lfV"VV'

V'QSYlQS ~Jj UVJt '"'~-rny =j;FJ ""

'vVJ tVVJ 1--v(lt •/q,_,o'l''"'!"v'T"',J.•r ~b""" .~()J'V""'I~ •--arv>'Yl<• "J ·tvow 1 ~:V'nJ

,.,3 ~~ '"'1f~ <JJ•L...~ J..,.,~.Jn,)'waJ f'"'W OJ '.' )"''t ""'"'""!j JYJ Qt 'f'~f"'_J

'1JP'"'1 '"""~t f' f,rl !'f")'-"'f'Y'"'n '0"1t Y"" ""'""'':,J J 9 't "1'1"f"~" T""f".,.J

W7<>t"Vi7 OV''U3 '-"""("]P~ ~r""J-'?f P''"'"' "'tr"""\ "f'""~'r"F --r 5: <>.ro'tL (XX)

. t"l hvql\ -..rv /n,'1t fl"" Ar•w"'·pc•· f"ll' u-1'9 '11"" UV~t .:J'· ""I Lf \P'
sn~tr:J .rup•-"n f'""l "'.' l'tS """'f"" "'"'"'-.s~-rJ '.nn•<>J5 1,"'..\ tv~r'"'1't"""~t •rn> p•v
1·nW'.J:Ht ()"" 'll.., "v!t ''1 t~·~ L).,JS hl-rvo yvrv 1""t"'T'\ 'Jr"'J '"t t~:""'l U \X)

r:-.w v /"'" ''-'V"Jf"t"tl" -:JUJ

JQ"Jf"J rJ nvC" Sif"QlA17;)•~ J

'T''V() f" + 1-ro"lp

'-'()Y\11(l"i1)<';1

6v•_ow''1t i"l J<)J f-., 'f'/£!j """"j rvv <JV!'Tl ?n'"J 5(JW!pvvus 5JOV•S!..J CrJ f~~'"

rvv I t-,,_.,JNoW<J )""':'

>' {" t""'~" v! ~ott"' 1 ]lv::J ~-JV'c'b"f)vvo vrr '1"1 svGv;J

z/ "'lt ( 'TiJJ '"" SU"P'""no <l'"'T"J ~t 71JV :J VVQO ""! s.ru~"s!.J bv:'"' 't '"':f'H

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 12 of 34 Document 1

'1 t ·tU:V)~""''?

-svb111v" vo(""1 -o'1t vo ']1"'" !!"'T f""'7~n•~VJt f"" (l\mn "'i P'YVl )""'"J

r"'n rf""lj f""' J,-ro~T'7'(1'1 (lAYVj T"'l7Jrr-1 ~"'"~f "'m.r

~-s "ll (A"X'X)

· WO"Jt vv••j bv!JcJ <P1lJJ":Y ""tnv lv~fov" "!"'11 o~""V] J.l\'"''111 rv>v'rJJlJ" 'F"f'"""J I f""'~"F '"" hlwoWV"v,;> sA""t !""3 (,, 'U {/\)XX)

· "'"T"JUS! '!o"Jt F"'nodvvu:> "f W'"""d'1f v; (n]J5<>f ho/t 5"'V11lS]vJ
..r t~, ~9 1..-vrn o'!f"'nJ""' '-"! SJF oSl>"Jt om v>etF ~''1.\.. .LT'\ () V'O SJ)<lv
"'":f"A~nJ"]' AvoS>r.J5 "f'"J "1' '<!S \'YO\ l" "']"\:"'~"'"NI 'f"'"'f"''Jl'f ""'l. (!J!!<X)

· (f)/10 '30£ 700 f"" I 0 ·y,(7r;: "JQQ •t t""~SVV'J ,;'"!f."'"d"'o" 11 ol "t J""'JJn) 5! J\f "J{nQlTJ" 'd<J I"! 5J()V1>5!vd oi" fO""JVV'V!/ SVV<ltl
Av"J.vcl f''VVS"OJ ~:l7fVO? L~'\'51>JSOJ vvo'j J"f'!vp-•v """' 5"""'"'!"' JY (1\XX)

""l-r ''f'>'J J'f7

p bvT"Vt> tCVVl o'-'<'f'7 o(Y' (}~") >JU\'O")p sn bv!sn[VJ

rvv sn hv~5:5VJ~~ 't"'oWT-'"'"""'vrv f,.,.1ff'l r{v;~'"' J\f ll"")~ VJ~~N~~ ~j]Vr-'

n~rn SVil\'1""].5 U'")t bv:rlv"" 'f~ "1t f"'Y '""'T"" t"'"'1f I' S()W!T \fil\"T""]S rWhiOVI "'Jf ""'"'d 'f"!Aof CZJ!>.J01'7""!:'. hp[7<if'7 '1f'1 -ro >"'7 ss~w "t ·'"'~o5~j J\.;j "'"1Jl f""v J \f )".Jvvv.:> '1"!"Jf'l ·'"'fTl"'1 s bv!=<~'j '>J"t "t m bc.nm;J yvru

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 13 of 34 Document 1

! t -}v."'l,\.'"")

nt · ~~ Jl?O"J , '"'V'1111·vt~ "1 -~' •t ""1 "'"" "'~T'T'-"! rLT~ O)"V('1)7

"/1 t .r~

fWWWTTJ J' V~VY)J ~~ V) J" S"i/O)J ()'Jj f" li'O~>!n-f()JV>, fJ<H!fV~ -<V --;)il''!f

..0'1\ -.eve) 1 wv '•tVOV'""'~:>>v -rp!j;f" 'hj'orr.ns "'~rTP"'~ !)''VilA" "1t ~"j "'1'1~'\AT)JsoJ
": -a'1 Tns 'V .IYfl <FJt i" ''f'"~'CJ:_ /.Fmn() ·~ ! \'l\1 t"'7""J"\l_ Tl

. vos!-n! '"11 f' ''•:r""'~ F'"' "''TNt .HV_'V'"J" ]P'"'I\l) "'Tf ••;~ "ll~'"'o~<Jv ·~ ""! y:~ns "V
JVn . "'I/l 1/J t-no 'Y" T'"'?' IV}"\ •Vjt f' ny ·~ vop• J tu'J'"'iiJ"Q .71

''-'Jtl'n1 "t ...,~'J\01 -~ VN/0} VV!f'T'! 'VVJQrbvo\ rlt <JVY('T" 5? "II ."Jj~f"'~'Tl

u~t J' "'".'t 'T'-'.' p£~"1''~ J" --o:>!FoJ -olt t._.~,(lJQf"'" -aso'1-\ f~All hs J >~:'~] .J

r"'"

·"' "TTVVi]

-a1t -"'d

"IT swulso~

51 '

'j--1

."Tv "'t'~"' 15'-'~!Ff """

~-a:s

fV117

J\f "" sl~"f"""" -r;)"'"'~vJ -frv,:l""!nw P"" '-:Jy :!" ""'T"'"P'" su mV<lp•
v vo wo~>.toOf bv':T)vvr I T''""""'"I.J J\f f ·rJJ, f'''!( '1""'VV7>V]~ J (fl'dvV.)

""tfw\J \'U:~~ t~""""~J""'J 17~WT~"''""f\f "1t £v~l'7i'!ll(l-l b~-'lrv: v·o>!_,.,l "1t

J" -v>o:y"\JflJo F\>n7 "~~t-wp:v~v'T" lT"""'"' "11 -'•d "1"PV111J.so~ 5'0fl1 "'1 T"s 'V

)lju/E ·"11/11/1 "-t

~">j Ifl)l -a'Jl r -vqr~n >'l'('l T'fY!ll "d f"'"'f"'CCJ'CI ·ll

''?r" r 5~0"}j "It . . ,~ S'Jj?>'Ji7 Lvo5'WV' W<vj j('l'VJY 'r-'"5"'~ -dl'"ft jq t'"t~
·s~sv~ ~~])rrv'v r"" t,.:/lj IP" f"F"j"''· "'"' '11"'-' Fn bas "'~1 (!/\XX)

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 14 of 34 Document 1

rs -r!YJL"J

. 'Jt]'llil"J "t 7:'){QT ""\ Vl''-7 VO!'"T""S rlvv\"_J f"1t (j\IV["TV
""" '1f"Q . p~~"\ "'rf,,J .., >J ~"''!~f"l . 'J""'VVPTI JV ""j swo~f'J"'"VV""VJoV
u?_("YV' T""' )-fqVCV5)-fJ pyvfo<hs 11" J" -"''Tf""'J b"'!"! l T"''l7 rw"""'t''""~ "li 1o~ "l1!'"'"JxP oiY /.u"Jl (,SdJ,)""'.'A""Jn0 n••T""'l) vvy-rbo"d 'It''! ('1""1
woJ.''I'"'l YVl' 'SI(7Z l'""H r'"'Y "t Zl(Si(L ""••o 'svrv' JP"j 'r'T"'"l"\l 'LI

.,. . nrs pl,.,~r~r 'rJJ" I~JW.n>"\ "1\ J' o-rrl(')'<' ,~ "1 t'~'·JQTtjJ y 'Y ·p:{,"\"'1",(,.!

'H . jJ'(lt:S Tro.~ T'"'v >P!"""s J'''~.tTT'~d .f' ""T,.F!""!vvr' o'1j ms,f()(fl!

(.nSd,)

rvn nn S'QJ!N"S r'~""rrl~

"lt jU m!n.qJns '! i F""T'S t"""F""'j'il\l ''ll

·r "' ·'ir1 "t ? !x

Wf"J t"""J'V'()VT"V;J rt ~ 1u ':

""""l-L"1 f'1i ,,,.wl" '~ ")S ."'"T'T''! rL·"r",.J T""" t,s b"'7r>l"v! '""~Fl'lfl<r,J

I""'".'.J!'ft'"~ '".'f"'JJV 5fJ!7T7j ""j rr 'J'U'OJJY JY Lq';>Tclf ""j "l'r'"'"J"" 5~ "'7~ VJ!'"' 'V

. JOCL ""~t r ()'lfClJ'""rrt'"'I tl.,fV J" ,..,t'70J!'Z '1 =[ f"T'"J"\l_ ·s l

''Jt)YO"J ,>vo'-'OS!,J "t ':X"t "j Wf-;J 'Q7TYT~ v'T"\"''· '"'~J""~ 'f'.C'l---:J\70 "It f"1f
ell (NY!('TV '1 .'r"JJ~"" _,.! '0)'-'0S: """ JVI'U}' lT<>F LifT> r~! svu:p•vo~' -;J 1.7(] .,~.,
fr'"/t""'f'"'~"nJn, F"""vrob n'1 "i'ro·s;J ~ rt:S .,M "'J 'T"S ''V '11\JZ lrv"'""'l
r\A"Q.ry/ "" "'" .--~:s "'J a'1. "'1t f" ;;"1""70~ '! "'l"Tl r"r "'"1"\l. .r1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 15 of 34 Document 1

)/ r- t~'--r"'"~J

ro rV}"\7 1 5V<Jf"<lj > h"'!rnrvu:;> 15/,'()Vl '1"'"',1 F""" t'''j7J"""'1 6"'7"'"''1. JVj "J,~SV'.J_WJ

bvT'\ \J '~t I oJiif'l "1""] . 'f{)511"'

•t 71H yvnorv j "-<OJ

f"'17 "]9T'if '"1t 'I P"'t! IT9 'OJ

,,ry

bo~" """

f""'

1 """''

1C7\

Mit!

S<>"'l ~VJ•I

T""' 1""VJ'<ll~'--,-.,~""'r~:.

'f'"'""f""'J"\:1__

·oz

T:f"JV~ >; "'"!f"l U5! pbv17T") f''lt uM("Trl ._, 1f~ . '"""'"'!.,) JV J '"'"1H""?

rvrv hs P'" WQl''rl! y•l-"011),)

~j F' JVl'l>\M f"""l "'1t o]'J15'-1'VJ,.,V vVTJ

l'""' SVQ!f"T"<>WVV'"OJ;)~ t"''Y¥"7)T\ J'V 'f"'Y"\11 "l~"l . '"'"'""·_,..,\ t,, )l"' ]" 71~~-o

r tvowr~(IV+ "'H fV'1' 1>VQ>.'Jf' 4s hvo;s~nooJns IArorr.ros ""j 'J~lSv!UJSi)J liVQ(''l 'W9

-~IU? "t 7102' rVVIO-fYJ v-'Nj ~s ~! _f"w/,""0 ITJ)l7 wen "J)"j\ TVJV 1/197 ..-\ ]WZ: 1"'"1'17

"7i'f'l}'l"] ,,-fvrav-or-o:l -f,s"•voM '"'JI''J)1JV., VOJ:Ow'r'\S 't"''T""'.P\1_ 'bl

'1tF1 "t --,!xot

r r J'Of'T'~' y, }"11VVT<'"'!j""''l Ftwl"-rd l'"'lt o-.!1'('717 CJV'(l TV(l

''J'V r'f"l vs.l

YV -'"t- bwo] ;)" ""·t --,-.,.~ --o vt 6uT"MW'() L?7JVV\I - """-''!""/ JO.:l ~ <J J1 '"' oJ S;))

J'\1 -oro T'"l · (lsYRr"' "-. ?7'-"vmv.'t"'"""

""j 'rTcnn•J "lf'"~"' "] TV''~~

't uow""vl_J 'JV 5l!Z("VV) 'T'!"J0 --;J';fJY '"1t :!" ~"<'"\"'""Y'l "'1n-h,__, 1-'"''1'7 ""'

I 'T""'" """'ell """'1t 1 "'"\l "'"lT ,.--.'""'I ~"'" (PJ) «J?!jjo .<V'~T"''•J

>~ ,(.F"'0 T"'"' I VUJ')""rl )"!"v:l '.' '~""8 rv"'"J'd)J\J "It ;f" "'·,"11 1"'17

r .""F''f\ 1"Jf\ ?VJt f" "'~"'th·v ' ·~ {"'OV>

,0 ,-yf'l I

VJ'l'p?IM\1

'tv>"J'V"OJ"\[_ . Oi

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 16 of 34 Document 1

I t -~ v~"JJ.,"J

"1001 'X] rrif"' 1'~""' 'oA"'T" 1"7- '1 f" }'0"!] f"~ 1-,JT"j o-11TV"' r'" Of"""\

rt'!'""'L-"""'\ )'{I'"\\" ""t"'' ~~i'O~T''T \'{T"Y\1' L1·""T •·rnp-.,"'l F''"J -;);) 'm'rw~

'"'?"' '"""'1" 1C7Z-bl F"'" Ll'~l'\1 t" rt'!1 ,'f'"f"'"J'T' "'lt "t 7'""".1."

1'\""ln~~

rv r\ Tv "'· """ 'r""

'1t f"

?J'C I '"T' "'t"'' I Aml r"'--q I W'·)\ fT\ I>Qn<>~~

I'F"T'l''T'JJ ',•r•g"V~ ·hog ~r.,~~"\,];~ f"1t ~~ "V'V<l L ..'TICl ·zz

· "f\ "'"5~,1 r t"'"l''-""'! ''JV"T" "~t

,y-,. "t yo~VVU? S'o' tV'-.T.>,'j!''A!, F"'"

J~r' """/("Qi"'l 'LtrTZ Y"'" '<MVT"'OI-]1 v•.

r"~ltno >V'OTJwv;) "li f' f"'Jf" iJ~'riTIWrr;J 'It \f(Yl r(l~t"'"' 1VO()VIi'O"!j"'v;J ""T"\ u''· rt"'T'J ~~"lt -"""1'" 1so'"T''~ ~t""1ll v ,"'a'.vt T''"'~" 'T'Vd slt"'"w l\

Vl""Jt ""'"" .,.j TJ II '1t r JV rr"l"5~ 1'Y""""~"'5 ,rb"'"l"J<\ ~~'! 'C.<'~lll,)

Av'lll n"'l f"'" '(:vlf"l\Jv;l\f')\ ji'"'IS 1(/'"~"\j\\)sono;~ 5!nl 1(,.TT\,)
rrvg TT\ "'"1s~ '(,~r"·dyr)d -vl'"J;J '"'"Ol""l. 'Cr'li:l ,t~. ,VI \'1vroCJ
(,;JJT"·")J,, '<~tJ"<<J01.1}"-"'~""""' '"'T' •n•·t"rJ F""' ~~g ~'\~\'>\,\;-\ JJ!f"!v\J ""!fVJtv"'"'~",.,

fl""' "'''"1'<~M~" '~I -'II Y""" ~\-'<\ 1 11 f" f"W'(/~ f"'"f"'Tl' "F'] 'IZ

SW IU'l'J NOH"'lOJ ~ SSVTJ GJSOdOi!J

'1""'YV>(I"~J""V7 ""T'r'l yol""l",.J r f'"Jf' \~j"""'j
"h "'1/ J' ""'1""9 !>_ ·Mol "'T"j,sJ f' F''T'P --r; s~ "JO!""'t S ·NotAvs~J (,..!5'A~Jn)

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 17 of 34 Document 1

w \: -t":-o'/J"'";:I

'h"'J hr1?\;-1 -;J V ""TT'? VV-"'r tv~\ 5 :'1 j" t""m t""'T " 'V ·c;z

'j..~w "J>~nh~nv

rvv j"'"!f"""" J'"''l f'-JYWV' l5W3\~V~ J;rop- f -'~o:y,rar! o)'~'!'fl~ !""f'"''"''YJ r"j"";lf\ -y j"

JWQ lt"li'!WV).J ftAOf 5p-IQJ ri.IIV tVfO-JJW~CN ~cr~n;;Js )vrt? VlN!t /\)\ VQ!t"f".;)q~ ,II;JS~r \17Vl0!~'177JO ! .?t(1

'Y'It"'i" ~pnnj!]"w!p "t Ar"'f'""mJ/-."1 ~:rw~F "t 1'tT"1'-tJ-mPs"'J/,'1 F"' tf'TV<l•""JI,"\ ! "''~""' "t ~r"?t :'""''"'-J~'1 l"'oT't""!"11'!f' r"'V!'""'o ! """"~ ,Yq-liJ~ )'""' ~,~""'""" J"''!"J""!
!'"'"lt"'t""'Vv.:l ,,.J ! .,?war:~ l-y'1"'11 rrvv IIT'!'i,VJJ S' -•vmu~v ! Vr!~ ! tn W" 1!S><WI

-,51J]J"'1: sb".'(Y!S' -yuuw !,LT'"j '"-,\ ,1 /,~T"T" f' S'"\- SS""i"\j )""'":-\"""" f"""!,-v-,JVTJ

.'w,!so'vhf' r"'"'.sv.r;m ! ''f""Jt" co!v>-.J J"V>1>!"177>0 ! htT'f"FJV) !,..,fS t"'"ts!s,.-J :'"''"j')""'Ar

"wr"'T"'~'

f

\.)

nuS I I. 1'1

b" !"'"W'd

"'"H

~"'!"V'd!"'>Jn

('lOVl

'~ ~· -"'"\

1--,'iJ k\~171+1

s-rw/.

sz

~"vi-\

o vvvv> J" J Y -., "T" J'"<·' 'X """'"QJn~ '-vv"'t - hm, I ' 11 r• t'"Jj" f'"~T --,; 'V

'1..7 I' v

r'!JilVV ' r .50T Jl "P"-T JO"'f" 1\llY t""'Y\1 v ;>"JlN! )!7USVVJ7/\sJ Y"'" Is-vv-c\I'"'J

IV 5SI!V' l"'"W'

b"''ts:')(Q<I_,J j" """~·f'"jvo:Jl((.l 'Aonr·-"~ \"t-vrwv Yrrt".'-'ilf d" :>!-"~'' rT""T'"'ns " r"' 'l~r..-~

'tflJ f''""Y f?"Vl -y-vvvn'\ 7~:5'1"\ -v ;f" ''"'·'l"' "'1"'l'hvl y~~'w'."'!::jf'J\'s;w•:\'\''r'T\

'"f"~J '"!!'8:;}~ 'hg J.,..,lv~>j.W so~'~"f yvro "A'f-V'"J """ 'f'1"1"'1 'Lr-~< "! tn" P'

f""' "f'"""\ f"f"""J""7V'\ fT 1150 \t1<"1 """Jt"-l"t t""JJ" -•":tv\n~o-;7 "·""\1 ~~ '?~V"fY

'IJl-r "" I"'~!Jt"o 5Vl"!j-~1'~vo JV Y"f"/"'!'x''"'-'.rvJns'""""i~~"'ol "1l 'FZ

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 18 of 34 Document 1

"' 't -1 v~"\ J"''"J

. ""Y"""~~ ItT"'"'""'&-·! ""F""'!'{ ~i-'f""'"·'""cl ""!f..-,FJ'~! -I"'"WVO)·""] f'IJ"T'"J "''
"7""f""J,1 ""Vl"i'1nS -trd ! ""F'"'\1, f""'T"'J : . .. -cv!J"f"''\1:, '" r:.,•"T''V
:""Y'"'~'q trr"""''"~ r?"T"\i! "'r'"~\J. r"'"""d r:w"l-""n 1 "J~l rrH -JQr""' 5~\
lr rV'OS11 :J v ~~ J""'VY'<T7)'~ ':'1 ~t .ro~,,.J scrll->5: F"'>' S(J5SoV1JV t"t""'"" .,~:trvv
b~•_r'1o/'rd "'lj /"''1 "fl ·r~Yljr f"t"'"""' >'"'"-J(ls -v 'Qs-ld '1f"f'1 p'o"'.£v!f \A""1 ""\
'''1-J~""'' z~ +""!" ""'J "'0'·f'IU'! ": ""'"'"~ """"\ "'1\'l '•r·~,}~ '-t"'"lNo":Jw"" l"'f'J"S)
';pw,.Jn_r 'rb"''I".J '~1 f' f""JP r;r"'T v 57/'f'T"i T"'" "'"!J"""J"r! "'0 Tl

"( wa 1

J) .£ x

11""W""Ifl

""T'"'~J

'+

Lr-:r<'J,7

~1,

J"

""~"1

Sdi'~,J,r

"'orr"'!

r""'~jlfiVV

r+ V'1t F"''~' 'r7n-y "'! Alrt""',.,..""'.'~"'" '! 1V>qvv>-r>yJY"~

·~"] f'"1t W"Qvv>

o""('117 f}FV

'~+""'"-- '~'"'lr Tf,'tf'-""1"'~ (f'"'""A"""\1..0 '"T''f\ 'W"J ,,.,,.L~ynl' "'"'"''·Pl

~ T""'Wd 1

1

!

''::.[_'

'fY'T''"J"f flv-v 'm"T1 VV>~> f"'" Jr 5>c>v l"t VJ;)YVI

5 '·1

f' "'"">J

raT ~It '! iru'J ""l":?t ,),.\ J" t "'"""'"":j'"'iJ f'T"l"''· x•w.raJns 'rot~ur,.l "11- ·"rz

; 7-,VW IOJns.:<> '(,.:ld ~)li tT'] """'~""d o-m?;>s v'.'"'-.-"T\ ""'t f" r''"v"\ L:v'1 >WJ prnr""" -v•,nrr;J -?f""'(,V'.f '~:!L 'SS'"'Ir r'r"'~"' '""':''"" ,.'~z\1~~ " WOT'"'T""TJ '1tl""'1 J"l"'"""
-. ~ '~'""'{,!f ':!)_.. ny.rvs!<L ~f 1-,.w"'Y"Od f'!""T"tf -., /"'" -,J~f,""'t="'J<JJ - "f""''\J.
\"""!'nl"Q." "Jf['"l 7ljoJjL f"'"'"" Y"'"w{"''l' .>vM'mVllV J''t"'"vv ""!.rJ vV> T"'1 "''J01

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 19 of 34 Document 1

a~ -r~yrw"J

''1f "f {,.'f""'" J'(fJY oVJt """~j c<amo YJ f"""Jf!('"l '"/10Z J;"~'~""'f''J yvv

}""'ny ·r 5) oz

V()<II'T""' 1 J~ "'~ '"Jt"OY'<' ")

•t I qnvp 'b I - L I r~v

•rV\• Sl-'i I 111 f" ')-"'"T""'J3f ""lt t,"l

I.J'."''"t:"llfi7 "'('C) ',.,rveh ~ 1"""\i

"""w -"'j iv<>vvo"':jVV'J •nJr'lu~ v: """'1 "''1 •1 n 'of""d ·o~

f""'-."T ~"I . 11! OV!"'1V"((j yvo-v ! 'fll""'l-\ t a; n:'

11' ['7 f!"VS !"'~"' u 1 J"" t'TTVP ""n> V"

1 svoo~f'Fd)'vcJ tVV()VJ !fw"'VV7JVV craod '"'".'niJJaT' tv~.,.J ~"flno"!)> fv"' 7\-::~"\

rorr ·~V" ~ •..,6"'" f"J!"AO,Jv>n!,bv~rn:l

11f'<1f tuo"':YV'VV~ J 1'Vtlj YJ7 ()5()'1+

O<''f':r.750f 011 ·or-my"'AS n~ S y VJ""""?\ 5"11-'r'N r-:J!,,(VJJ f"'" ,.,...,~i."la"l"'~"'J

I ,,

\1

-as-ro~r 6w~-;>tA<lrv-Jxo s~ 11r•·'J 't~Y'(!v~j"'"'-;7 oA·'f"r'! w~,- £"'"I

vo s!/ j" f'"j fO f""JT " yy;l f".Jf/ J""" '1a!fWJ"J":

'bZ

._,,"' wr +"'"lfY ~:v. t >: x"

;uvv••r S:"' L:t'9"\""7V7\(J '! '1"'"1('}

nrl s- v·"~

5Y Vl rov>~ ""!rYO~ r'!St"JJ

II

rVl'Y ('''to) "'TJ~5J -;)5-TOJlfl' Avr'PVV 'V-'!'1 bv"_mv-;J s~ "'"T"l ~s! r£""'1v.J

s-:'1'JVT"1 "'0 'f'""V'.'"""TJ Jy T"r''l"" "f!":'J?f"'~ >~1 ()?'-'!-" sovv~t "1
r'"'" sv "'! r•"'rJ "'""~ s-v1 "rl ·s~vvoH" •r:c>~ns v: 5-a"'T"""Q[

'soArS\'\'u~t S<JJnb~j '!f '•r rVIV /5<1vYlf"'' U"'j("l IIV1~ ,:""tr'7'1 >' >! 'l\ •5S?VIll\•

rt""'"' JY)?'\JQS " ,, ·~zl-I]1V.~ ,\ s: Vl"'fP?'P"T JfJYfil'J t't"'>W ','T'<J,lYJ ·u

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 20 of 34 Document 1

J~ -t"?..,r""'·o

J~""f'? vro5~J fron:fjT ~ oT pn!Jlf'J .v>, ·""\ L'P~ ('l ,,"'"Tf'" v"' ~)1 v-.S<>J 11

JY Y'·j1")--1Vi)~ (_:; v"'"Jt -~""""'

C/)\TJ")~ "''! Vf7<1'j ~ 5()~<11.1V ·~T

· .>cm5l"~ '~j -roj 1~0~J'Y7!J"'V'(' L:'7J"t "'-41 •t f"'".!J hl fV!(IT(I;A
-"'1 r"' ·Iq:sld .I if"F"'"'"~\1 "IrJ-vv"''""d r:-·'"' :r\7 .1"Vl·"""I""\l -rv_rQW "'1f"" yu'a"'h:r ""'"'1 -"''1 'JOT\ "'"'-rr-sl ""'~ +""'"'"<PT't ·~"1 ""...!~ ·zr

. t', -'!..,.,Wn""" VVCTJ - H"5 f!rv .I .rso"' ~"1t>I ""V' ·Isnv•-rol" o1·I .r:n"V VJ ' ~II)

. ""VJt ' 5!i")"'""r~ -'"~r"l'VV(.Itr •r-:7!~

Y""

I QV!ft"J-j)oj"

'It,"'-or

I

VI"?"'/ I" o""'VV"

sl.A~VJt fv'.T<I5 J 5V''~f''":"'ll"\! ""'!""' •t ifAT>lfi"s"'J~ ;"'"!f'f "'"~"' s:r

! s&ss(I?Q,J r/n''1t T""jVU-;J !~.n>VV?vY <OUJ !v.. Js "'"T""W' t''"!S

rp· L-v 't1
.

J"OTI'1 t rn>

)"''1 'VI\ : -rohv>v r"\ on oJ, n ! ~'f'.

"1 !, bv~ (YJJ yooy..n ! A.~: l"'j

"rr oA"l'") .,t

")"<' J' no\ I mvT'lj ,~"'OTV'-"" !v.,~m.rhy V'' !I'VVl! irF'l'T""'~

nns 5'0 <'SO"Jt 'll 5(/"W""'F "7)VVVyrV~~

yY V>f"OV''I -'~"T'l'dV f'""~'i"'J

r?•. •

•

rVI"Jl

.t•1•'1-;!J <JS.f()Ar bvonvo!"1lch-a >'! lp1t~ 0YV pp f-riO~J' -J'Oj .J.V'oVV"

- ""!j"'u;:J aA'f'J'''! '"""'·raJn.\ v~ """\ '"V) "'1 1'1 ''T""j\ 'i'-""w<Jv~j~v"J <l/\!f~'jo'~

vv.rot -6vQI >:11) J~ f'jJ" f'"!f "Sf}'{"!)""! F"'" "'"T'""'"'T! "'0 "lr

. (vJ(&)~O. ~Or J(JQ s -or""J "IV ""}\ f' 't~"vv"v!"k"

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 21 of 34 Document 1

?r-r"7~]Jw"'

r • N-<>_Jmvhr c),.~~t "1- <JV) J,.?.>'1'?}\ tw ~ rT"'-'"j
"'Vil1 "'"1 '"YJ .-f-..""'Wl"~~j ""07 Pf"T,.' \ "': ·f""w"7 "TJ sv711 fT\ "'vl ."'r

-h""WQV\1 ~l)J TT"" 'v"~f"'t ""iT\'""' -ruJ! """~ ~"'-t'""tf" t"'YJ5 ~ (.?S"vTo""'l) "".'PP~!

* !svv;:pmt~' "+ "'QT~'""J?,YJ !,.,,~mvhr!n~h !,_,v:p'f'"lj tVJ~!'of'l:5(1rJ"""'1 ! 6S"'p '1-t;"] J-oap I)HV15S<lj \A'j)YVvp! }'l b\A17 rt'""VV o-IOflOS s-v '''"' t Yil1~"'10f ·~

:,{)WllJr1. rm s. rv r~,t~ yvv r~ to)"VJ~ t,,J SY' \.1('7\7"7] J'-'01.r'<7QIJ

(JSJ(lfl

'1fJ'7 fl'V'I' "'""~ _,--,'1 "'!1 f'TI I S'.JVO/, 3J c; ~""1f <JJ"YV J tVQVV<lJVJj"'VJ ll~: f'l ""]

"'0 vv I(Jr Jvol ":1 f f"'j f" r"'T -. 517 ',J"lr'1 T""' "'~!f'""'"j"!

·t;r

. 'J2H"H ~ "'n\"H --v ~1 nm>.'f'J 'f'!J"~ "'0 ·vv>T'"Jwo (,VY!vovvtJ

r"'o'T"l )""'"' 'Tl 1ff"' )"f'!/j] "1Qilj "'T" '"'"' '\\ ."")""5·'\l

""f'"o'!\.l_

lr F"'vs""ct - !H"}~ ! ""TJ"5!\L ""J-J?~(''f'""'!Q. "J\''"l~"'-:f ""f""''l\l ,~!'lmlwJ

''1tr"' "!FFJ" (J~ISS0510 l fir~!f"'' 'QJ)TI'l!<JS

hpvnw r.wi)"JVl!:

Y~"') v>O

ll "t "'<7 ~t J"") f""Jt <'""l"YJ3~ J!5hvrJ f""" f"''£,f"l">hJ (!SJQ~r p-ovr<J!Vil'lX<t
""r n·1 -"' n-a!f'l J Yj r'f'Ivs: "" tv"l ':'1 T r"H" t""~ '·\ " '1( .rf.

'-:Ja-;J\f IJ)l ?VJt h~ JV 77"'-'nv!t0"i) J""'J:J.f"("Til!~"~,, f'"l >"M "jl ''#f'T'Il "] A-ron<~

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 22 of 34 Document 1

'~ .i v~"),j"'"""J
?A!fi>f"Yl J7Wn>Jn:S'-orv:pr:'pn"'1f"'"::7 UVJt fVV 'svv-J'I'l '1'7n$ T'J()jjn.~
ro\ 1 y•n:f'J Tv" "PJCJ.p 'f"T"I ~" 'Y""' !.a~ i.r'1+~ t""lt Y"1V '"'"!J., ""f'' ~ ,;,"""l r/JV 1'"':1 f'Tl I 'Ff"\," r""'d ,...., y:m~ '"""~r "t +""YY
- ·:·Jvv; }'" """"'1 r-r.>~v"\n~sJ rv 7T~v-<vsv-vp~J fv>V w JS(IV' P't-wovv
osnv:~ -v>vr;; rVI\7 's-vT .ror: 'sv~"T~ F"'"'cr·~·<J ·~I h~ lr.r!)j,~ 5J7
ffl"'Jr r-J""'"' 5VI"~""s ··Jr("'J '"""'"'~..J :r 1t~~ 'P'VJt ~t "'~x~t '·' fV•!rr""=t, r""T"J='"
r'"' 'f"yv•<>w"'""!"VY() 'r;.>UJ rj b-v~crv<W'I f" 7f"\ /"'" "'"T"\""! r'{v"\ ,,J f'"\t
ovY("'J"Yl o"'>' 1o~"'P' 1/,J-"11 T""' <;1-[J '11 f" T"t'71 jvrvr"J"f fO""""' T"'J '1,\;-
. UY'~It l"J\"l)j-,(7. ~0~ 'JOC] ii 't t ,......,s.,..,J
f""vv--pv\_J J\f f"Yw~f'V7 '"'!f''."fn7 v; j"')\j f' T<'"j bv;v~J "~
l"'"t"~ t~.,T~I r'P"t'..J " I 5"T' ""r! ILl F"'-v ''~1rf1' m<'.'J"1''1'""J1'11Frud
'or'~<;],,~~ '/,'J, i.r17],Y4 'f"'"~ f7C7'IW~ -:JOO PF"J '"'T\f J1·r1 ·xr
·'"-'1thv-v _1-nvc')Y vVV? "--\- hf/.17" J 5n1J fV17 !tf'!ll"'l' f.YIT"'J3'"l?Jo"j !Yilvv!t p 11'-"0~WV --,i £"!/11--yt "'~ tSlN<'tv:sry !'-"'~~ .'-n~\4l' fs£><!]Q<Jj r:7"'> !-tVTY
: '"""flvv~s '~vvv-ryvo t ~ nHs" f"'1~"'~"r L!f'l'W;J "It F"'"~-m~x.., ,-vv-1 IVVQ,~ 1 "'""'t
-arovr j_VOW"il"'!dv'? <>n.'f'l UJ! "'! V<T<II H'1 ""Jf" 'j_,_,.,l'+vrowul"?jJVo--;:7 'O~'f'T""
vv-rcrtvo] -':) f' t.,"jjo t'""'f" 5YJ J-.1\"'1 T""' woT"w~oj"'' '\/10 'LS

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 23 of 34 Document 1

'~C -r--:oJL""J

rvrr ~.., V'V~.JQF'i) ·w~ Jt1{)""\ 0\A ~ V'~'(]JJ" T'"Flft(JJ"f ~~~t

T 1woT;J17

•t

,,t"'QJNQV\ju onJf'T'!"""'TV .. l"l"1 "'If (,li'IVJ7Vtf" "~ . vo~~""'1"'1 t V<J~4T1;7

"'~ po,JdtV! rN'1r·"' f'TJT'-"UV Tlo "":} :1" 150 ""t~~ 'T''d ,}~ f"'"'(/

'h"l '"I'd 's-u/1"-')V''ron '1'!"'~ Qt 'rJ}I OVJt t~' J~ ""'f"1'5~

f' '"''.'t-n.'JJJY lF./QI\<;1 J:O"jt r-<-v 1S{"l<Jin<>~ JT/ 11wvv "J J '(l J \j "lt

n "''1r" (l>Tl 01 ""'"!-\'''"" "" (JIIY"1

I?n 0"]17 I\, I -LI f"'" c;j - fl'

1-y f"P!\

'f""'f""J'f "'ll 'f"~ . 't""VV77'7~ J'r} "':"'11 OJM!S swv-A.o~ 'rJ:t] nvv

rP~""'9 """'1 vpvo fVIV ''(!j '•:1~ ""''"r:'t;LH r" 1(,'-d'J,) tV11h~

t--mrv>u " r17'1 rv> """I ',\"""l r? ''T"d I m•~r ''f""fl .)r

·""'~•jv"7 ot ~fT"l" f"'V "f'ts )''f'""VV' ~;o"JT "t r.Nk" 1r11 lls>?<pv
""j f"?V" •t '""·P' >r<f-'! 'rar'.'tJ''TJ<J ,'(r:l t/"'8: ~"Jv!::Hr~ Mj vo!""F'v ""'?)t'),\"'1 .,!f"~J~~ Yvrq "~T'"\'T's " f' 1-,"J " /fen ~("'Q.'r<N 'H"•"'-'
:r "' VVli'JS r'" Lr'""J-'-.J <N()VVJ ·v-.:·11-y "It VJ~"'"'It W ~ll'T"'JVV'
Ajrno~JQS "'t r J'V '-'l\'.+"1"5! ·r~-'J"f"'' j• <PT'"J '"'Tli"'F-~"'OJ

r= 'b "<JA'<7Vj 10""''Y" 1- "/\

<;]-\iJ'\1 J"' l'ts!J 'f""r""':JOY "'ll '0/-J

f' ' l.NV'I'"j "(TV)r'flj 1V IVVifVL1 5'>'1 "!"(1.5

7j S !" r"',fll''?j ~"JDS 1'{!nl_!;'S<n )'((> V" IV!("VV')\

novr '5"'r ,., ]" lftO'VJt

?VJt ""'•~T" OVJt :!" ''"'" lrv>v "" JP' J' 'JV

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 24 of 34 Document 1

+[ -t"'~"'IJ"",;:J

?1t v~ b"'~"'"~t'~ f"'<>? •~:<:.rorr J 'vv!(,., -.! "f ''"!(" ""1 "'·' ,f,"""l f"'ll

''v·lf'T'l 15(1/Co.')V 'TT\ I "F"'d ''T'~.j;~ I /,'J: 4/vn/ ,~J rrO(Irynr

aI n•it I "'"\); "'l_'l IF('l W1.f"'g t """T~'F VQJ!jj• "ry ~K ,.

'I r";J ')'";) C!V)f 'wol. Xj rv'rJAU/17 '£ ffT f no P·' D' rJ""f0"1i_,J

"It f om "!I

s1c;-zju V'/11 ('10/)'J I

•t r:;

I/TOQP"J'<I~ '0f..\'l smn-;'f.-r"" '" tno'l" ~·j .~ h

. ()VV!t fl\1~ f' Arro r'i'VV F"ll T1t f""'1~"""11 -'7lf11P

,,?l'':l'·vnJV7<'V'""'<' V~ VTQOJ 5'1'1 OVj r"'j l1'1t f'Vl'<' I~Jq lfi05\_,) j'O 'l"''1'1· 7 V'1

/vvv:r" "'1t "t r~VV'v;) -t"'""'F"'b:J lvrv 1-,.-,!JifYl s: rV117 sJVOi -..z,'.;rI

vv:"' v>'~ 1t <JJ'DY\1' -TVj or.roJ -r>j ~1 "\ ,.£! \" ": O'\ "1

r5~ V-;J JVl'<iAU"J'Y

'&I·LI T"'" c;t-n'n f' r·ew-p'-' 'f11'1'V!OJ"r "''1t "~ 1"'"VVCJ"~j"'"? o~!rl@ 5:
rbVl<TTJ~ T"''7 -:J'{ ()rv·~pr"'.' '-': t"'"VVUJ"\j 'solv 4'0tV.''F!1t"fl '71,

• J V "f"')jOf"':' yonv!f'"" "'.""lt
lj~pn; "t f~firV?3}VVJ fTvVl ""' s0 o•'Cl"J·t rVl-v 'f'nTvvv )"/"W f"fOJ'.")'JIIt (}~17"\

''"T" ""'tv! '"f!'~ ;H Y""' '~"JYl'"f"'"d '""""!~ '7""n o""1rrl krvp'-"Y>J""J
~rJ<}VVI .,,,_, f""" t""INi)~!J"'v.7 ·~T"'.J •rVl.:JOf":'-xvw""J~ ""~ t x"P,.,\ "(/

r OJ17 ,/'{'10,11\(hlll OJ.l_ . '-19!1717 "Qf\1f'..;t:;~v~w f"" .. tl.A~ V1Q!t-,-v hV'?V?~I~!7f! V\A\10:) V1Y,I>It

Jv JV <17Y'Yt'VJnS "'! J'(J

""lt '·'jj;=t~~"\~ "'1t "t w-uv-CoJJ

"f)j Y"'Oj ,,L:s y

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 25 of 34 Document 1

Tl 'i" -tv>.'<\ Jw"J

. ·vlT'"""']" 11 FV)" f"":"J""'' /,l)"tVTQVV' ~lt"'""'P "I <;"'0(1' f'"lt'f,)"""'""' 'IJ[V\
"1\ "t 1.-,'8: t-,, v~ ~, H j" vt1j """~-t -,'1t ""-1 VIVSVJil~ "1t r"rt:v i'T<JI/17] I s
·c;r "~"It FVJ, 'T"W /"''' 1T)l"J 'f".T''"J'I ZljJI/L r'T' _,. "'0

.f w~lrt~..r o'"Jt "t p<m~v -'~) F•nj /J"'""fYl h'Jt r'"' "'~~ 5fVI<J"'-' F>l7 jl Q;J f'~T
'nsJ 1-vyJ I tr>r.JQ~ r'1t n:Sd hi Tl ot OVWJ f""' 'Tr>J f'''H "''. .t"'.'""/
sw'l"\''~ £.w!11vl >vi"' <J1 r'vlt 5!"'71(/v "'-'""'t t"'!<f'lT f-vn> bvT'\"'? u~

JJ"p n5d YJ Qt "'1 zv~/h ot ZI/U/z r"}" vo .,0 'f"m;JV vo]l"j\

v Fn uz 'T':'")CVl

Y' t "" rm"Wl 71") "t I rvrvobm

-h& Vl(!lt a'Jt 1""11\\ "t

ytyqn<ira" f"""""-s "f'-w'-' "'\ 71JS/h "+ Zl/51/L f'0'l" .n1 40 · 550" W '~V"\

J"f""' J\ J<>?"i'>a 'T"·'T' 1j J S "j"\ o,WV('l t"1AQV\1"'<7"71W1? vr;;> n! (ZZZ()) )J d.J

F f "'"!J"~l~ /,""WR> 0f""'1 'f -o ~~ w;"j

~i"t ""!f''vv"'~ -"11...,1\ t"'"f"'"J"f

"""'1"' F'TI £,~ vw.ro~n.s T;Jfl ""'t •t JJ ST~ "'""""Jng q"'t

S'-"NJ V\>'O>j r-'lfiij

NC') QV] Z1/11/L "'" 1<J"""l" 1s;z "': tn<;> i"' S'<1 &1/C:li/L

F'-"T'O'J-.:1 rus-ov>?-.T lag ~"1"'1,}J "t ""'""'? rt""'IJV1 "'1\.f (.ISfHJ;Ti)g • r~

'fV<iVV>J~~..,.{vro rVJQ~tVWo rvrv rt!P()W Sjj?f"'~"'l~ ""'i I" IP' r:sr>v-;J
P'"·T"" usv1L. "vv!+ ??"'f bv.""f T""lt 'lf''"T' f'TJvv.' ""I nh" "·t h.'[ t:'Tftj ,N rt...,.··~ "' "T'' W'l~·~ ' ~""""1 s bv!TU''J f "'""j

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 26 of 34 Document 1

r1\ T':'I-Jv""J

r '<WF's· t"' .f"V pr '""~rrhll" f""f""'f"F ~''())\() LTvnnlvw:)v: rVJV
'r<;l oz I'.J-\f "t 21/11/L P'"1" INO<j I jPJ') r-v nyT()II''V\~ f"'Y I ~IQZ ~~~
"l Z\jii/L t"v")'' "''""j'"'Jr'j\ Fv>"''£1{91/ZI 't <;;Jjoz/"1 rvrv 7:.1}~/~­ "t ZlfVL F'~'' ""'"'j 'J'P!VTY·t-s- 'A:''T""'Pf l,I""W~vJ ''"T""t '0~'."'/Qo;J
rv"rl s-r•~XO'-' S>"OI'fl'l\ 'i.lno-nlt L!~"Tf'""J --~;sJ?Jnl "t (IV~, f""~'")f\-5 "t
-'r"' nS'H I"'"' (~ -o'1t ~·. h-.~ ("r'·'/\,0 "'"J" >0'/"""'~ ""It" rvrr ""
J [)jm r-p~J\ t"nrncr;J rj[V'VV('l jO (l5"T1<7J bvrmv>~t"'") '1' "'1. 'Lb

r '\lT"I 'L

F"' ...

1
IOOI-x-]

rvrv '•~"l"'5 P f"'V ps """f"7";J ·;q ""'i

bv:m

''f'~'ljf' {f''""'"S- I'Jf'\ "vli 1,'1 Jn-J"'IYl"Wj F"'"'T"7!jf' ~f""""~­
.:1 JS)1 "'1-f f' ~".'f'"' ~~ fl]11T '-'~ T"'n\v~ (\[)yoLmJ o"<>r' rwvlL"h5

..-orm:y J"~"\"T'T ,_l"'J t"r!'>\ ·Y~ '.:PT"1 F"'" "'"T"""""Jv: "'0 ·o;h

. 37XJ f' -1 "'"

rvv r T'()MV\' 9 {1 "t -'t>•-Jh"

:r~" ~~VV<r,J -"'1 bv~r'<> n~ 1"''1 ,(,.,.r 1 .rvj

,J_~VJI'/'S:ni!IATI l"'f'·'rW V! "''_l'""''il"' 'l- w~~ r("'"ll'' 4-.VJt 'V""!f' VV"~~ J

,J r""' 7~~ t --:>J5!.J

f'' .Y.f<l7).1() 1-"('!""';'1 -v

w!"j

TJ'rl'

vvwn'1 r~-j-)VO.l-5<l v>V

[" vv:i ]"'"'.rhF hj"'o\1"D '«W'")"'rf' t"'!f"""Jvv-;7"': 71/"~1/b "-! Il/11/l

"''"'"i ''ro/)"'f1 pvv'T't~ 'F"'Wd sr""j ''O"lt ;]" T""h'5\1' mll\'"J 1\'J"\

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 27 of 34 Document 1

"'r- t'T""'J

I'"T" ""f"l~~c ..~ F"'"'s"'"'t"f11T'T\ r-,rn"d rlflV ls"T' "'T'l '""'n"~l\l~'T"g ·~~
I hg A.r:>t?W 'J.ft"''"'~ w "wr¥"1 "'""'1 ·t 1'"llj1l r'11l'"'r':u"vr. ~ r"'lllo1
vr£noJ'1t I "'"0 "'T'I T'-ro """'l "Jti"JV T""' ~tr~n\J '"-"'"QI-,TT\ lvrvn""'O,O ,.,,,(Tnl
IjJ"~"J Ii rw·-r5 ·,"'I I""'"''fl 1 !J"t~ Ir·wd 't""rV!"J"r ·u .1· "'"!'!"'~' ·1,b
·cbC19ZJ?.L-oL7'Lt>P"H ·1 ·Wd ·n oL 'F'-;JG rv f'"ll"t'''l jo ""'vfS 'It "f"li"'I f''1r
"'TV "f'tS t'0 tr4y "'V:f'T'd -T"'T"'"'V t'' 1.f~1~"!)1"'"'I T"""'"';J"''J----t""'f l"'S
JU ""~fl ''I L:""'rrH ~'1l rvv ":vJ,,Q ·Ar•!wv I r""l ,w ''"JHT :c6~1 t ""''5T
l:r ''"'()A"f~("lClOc)Zr;c;'Jzc; ·s·n l>J,c;''l"-.IJ -~ F"""~ ., ... tvvv \"''...!JJ" """"J '"""'J(I~ 't ;J" .,,.J..nJ "It •! r '1~:"l[T1 1"'".... 1"'""'\1 t""'J "It F "''"T'I·~n
": r '!is rv r"ll''J"'l :f' ""''1 Js ''1t "'r""'! f''1t "'"·t--,y "f't 5 ~"'T rt W<Y,J
,,! ''"jf'w J",.T"!Jo f""'..,T!f'"'l"""'tln"l]'"?"si\-.-,Timl tn"T" '>fv1'1t 't 'vow.~~ '"'""""] "+ Ar-rvJYI, <loV<J v•oJn sab"''.'j'-'! 'r!")C'1 "''f'" 7 !jj" Y\ I hiT't""VV f"SQ(l'R"'~ rvru :,1 lff(l''T" Jm!",(~ '"!f'J!'f"'.'f vo1t" r""' 'f""vv"•.vJw! TVI" "';yJ )".'7o5'•vpA) "" 1]vv•!f"~" '!Yf'"VV' J" 1''." (IA!>SW?Io "'" t!l vvu1t 'f"J .ro sosmro r'J+ "'"l"l"-'~ /"''•'·f''Jn771J ['""" lti"''QV\0>1 "'.'/'fU(I lj"("QS !lr"'\\"r'! jV S'-'ll)rr V<T.J IFQTvn JY '"~ 5JJT''Tj Jf" t~sn~~ •t sj "'jlft;)j"f Jl" j" "'"!s~"")' '"'1.L ·g h
At!O]Hl l'v'~Jl

r"' 57?r"t ·,ool.'~3 "': r""':lt.," ""'lfrn.:l """

F '"~'.'""'"V

'"'".'X•VJ

"'"i""f\ '"1_L ·vv,rvr1 J"'"'"!)vw0 yvv f"'tlffQVYl Jj:f"'~"~ o")t osnVJ •t (l>n<'jY

f\/117 "'"!rT"t"~ J" --aw~-hV' II I •t --;jl~(l f"'~l '1 'j7 TY()V'J'/1t oro IY""'"T"'""

lr"'"'-' ~ ....~ f"i-,n)·'7lf""\ "<'")j\o ~ lii'Y1 'tvo5il~ "1\ 't ZI/11/L f'T" W""j

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 28 of 34 Document 1

X E. t V.f"IJ"'''"J
I -"'"Q_ "''1J:_ F""' 1""'r'9 V7"''J'F' rl"'"" J" ""v"<Q t~~n"'T''"" -x> "'I .?<;
T''"'}w~ ll1(j 0 1t r-v
r '7,1-J 2' T"'" I/7Z 5'§ 'J ·s ·n gJ 'Wl_ 'Y:IJ'v ~'\1 'lEl.. ""'TT':" ~·. 1t"'"w""
rr\ r"" '"J \11 '~'1t tno1rcn I '"T' ""r! I t.ryl T"'Y ''"'1 I .l'i)M~rv 'loT\ I oyv'''d
1"/'.'"'J 't~ I log t..rr>J+I 'vlo '"T""VJ(/ t"'~"''TT"<v;J j"'"'!'''T" I r~ hlf""'T ,.
'rn··t~"" ~~! "'f~T~·,ns "~"''H 1"""1"'t lr"':'T'?"VV lr"t""'vv'IJ""\ ""1f!' 't"'"su.J 'It
•t 7/w ,;!".I """"'F1'C71 1t""1t 1 '"\\. ~"lT r"'""'1""'Q' ''7Q~"'"tS' I ""Wf\ 1 "'F!O""r~ ·~osb:ArPl ~J":J ITW 'T""Jrd T'''T""J"f Y""r""" r ">V'liTi' t~~n":rn -. "'I 'Is;
'(Zhbl F'N ·q·n) zoz'~tl rz .JJ"t; '.:J f-/ 111">] ·o h""EHJ ''t'1-b'." f''vvrvcavvy "W"'rn:l T"'" 'Ttr.:l I 'j;Pf"~"lj .f' ""T'T"!n "'! I rntVTv;:l vrvo~J <~"Jt "'! J:)Sf''"'1
fV>V:>.•yvrl:s yvv JY'CJ!J/.f"' VTY '! r""""~.'j""O'J '1...,"5 '""VJM t"'"'t"'! ,(t'"''Jil Y"f'"t".,J
f"fP<>">7 'T'P " ,,.[l!'t 'f'""'"'smk r"'"' ""'.rv"\ ]"t""'"" :1" l'\~ rs•?<u?v~ v>v
f" V>?)t t"'?WJ rVI'(7 ';\'<'!ITlNn If'""' "] VV""(S'}" A"T""'npraJ &~'TT"'~ V'Jj"
t~':>"'J""' Awnr"" -v l,!nY\ """lFI"" "'f"'n J'V f"f"/0'! rL~ 1 u,J I"''""""Jn-'
v-~ 'soT" "'tv''~"\ )YI's~lf"J'1'S<J"".~ 'T"M ''fn"d 1""r•g,~~ 1""Q A"r'1~,~~ -"jj:~~~"JJ ""'!j""v.> "t ''M'f" '1,/1 f" f'\IVYM l/""'J'f ]I'YJ }" vo•~rv "'jl_ ·os;
( "/001 .."] ""S)'( LOQZ ''1 'Q l~) IZ"' 1YL 7 'h<;"'
Jl .JJn'ii ':1 b£''? 1"F\"1S" ·n ""am~prl ~ (z<WZ ''!)''\ 'Q '}'\) c;Jol't,OOI rz .JJns; ·1 t/SZ
171f;"Q ., """'""''1 1(1 CWl ''T'n··n) s;1-")JJ1 '"!WI fZ .JJnS j p"JI 'ub""IJ '" \l ,"'v"L
..}I b~o t "'"'1""'""'1 lt+J ""1t f' "'"·t'T':~ ~: ""'""'1 JQ ">\ '~~ VI(I10VT)j rl/T'j7
f'""J()_,j -, "t YI'CVIt T":'r' r-v 'vJt/'1 )T"""VV j" rn•J ?~.SVI '~It Qt ">j5'.v
Tvrrn~:J'.Vl.{,~_.,"' .><>SOJ IL(>S'<P0\0 '"fl )"""\"'~"" r'11 WUV]t m~.J.r P'Jfl L:..,"jVTQ
~ n""t"VVI--. J"'?"'"'l "'"Tf"'<'il "IJ'·tr"'' ""f"'n "JV r'f'lu",'w"'"I"J,, IF"h"'"lv-rJ ""·

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 29 of 34 Document 1

Ab - j-~;vJJ"""J

.-l.~,(V> ~o""'r~ry\1" '1f'1~J ,..,, J" "'"Tr:~~ v'. ~"''1 f"'.T""" ly

rt""'"" '""~ {,.,] ~~~ ,l~ """y-~ "-\' S7T'"t sno!"J\0\1' T"'" '~"!""'IU? ,.,.~"""

•sr·,_, r"'v ,,_,, , t~~~·?rr'-'V;} (I'A'_SJ<il\l' '"':"

T"'" "'·~r~rr•H r -·v.-~iru" -..

'•t •l-o r~~l"\ yr~·.,t vo'r"'·rv""'lrsyrv;Jiv~ Y"f"J:':t""J 101 vyl""'\t I

m'C ~'1:r_ 1"'"'""'1'"'9 I ,.,,:nyr•l'T'v4 'T""Wd I JJ>•"J '""F""'"YT 1 ""\\'T\
rS ,_,.~,..t~ 't""'l'"""Pf f/VVJ •~'.rnJY :J• "'"no;J f".,.,.,""!f"'"' v ~I .

, p£!. +~""T"""'V' '1rvr£\] '~"] J" "'•!f"] "!" ~~ vvvv'1 f' )\"."
"'f"""'1 r~v t"''"".nl -y 't ~!'1 r r " :"'n~ T"'" '1H"'"1 r't"'""" J" rn"1 •;wl
>',Vj "t 'F!'' "J!l t"""!j!vrb]5 Y' rso•l tlfl5S07iJV1 r~·.~:vv '1' J vv'·'1 f"'!~f fit '"'"lfTv""' "'"lf""1, f,JV3v-as ""'~.,-,Jns ""r"'n /rc,SJ (,.T!)\,~~ r'noj
'-z ysljh 't -zy11jL V'(IO('lPI 1"'11T\ F""" 'T'v~ 'r""Wd 'J ~'"f"'";l"\l 'E"s;

.r"'rv•v~. /f'1/'J •it f"'i7 '(J j'-;J <;p •Jt:J_ f' ~"T'T':n ~: +vow'isJni., f'"rvvo
r V'l? r~V'QY'O """"'t psnY;:J T:lr" J n'' ''tY<l'lt lf""F PTL.... J"
""?""!'"" 11 't l.'[ ~") v!>l·,w rt71'!'J"S "T" VV'1'7Q~ . SV<J(<l0"0 (,,.~') r VV~OJ ""Jt v: /,_,~"'·.'tT"'"'" ""·5'(10')7 j• \ffiJVV~.f..a, y 't I'"'·\" v;)t~: J "''n7J /y
'S"'~>j f"}'\ 'SCIAo!j\I'TT\ '?f"Jd ''Y 1''g '~~ 1 J..g hT·i\ ,~J f"t '"~'1"' 101 '1 {n"1t

C. JURISDICTION
~am suing for a violation of federal law under 28 U.S.C. § 1331.
OR
D I am suing tmder state law. The state citizenship of the plaintiff(s) is (are)
different from the state citizenship of evety defendant, and the amount of money at stake in this case (not counting interest and costs) is $_ _ _ __
D. RELIEFWANTED
Describe what you want the Court to do if you win your lawsuit. Examples may include an award of money or an order telling defendants to do something or to stop doing something.
A. Irtiurtc.Hve. Re.lieF
w·

Z. A rrtliMlY\!V'\1 Drd"-" !>M.V1.1..L7 Hue. j,"".L.Je re.lecue. L "' 7e"'u',_(_f"ful..t:o/~

Lr.rs .sd L.., a.ll rIA;vl

!.Lll.,o b.HiL ~uA bA"-""- !/,,,.,,

ID y!UUs.

:~

AL-

3 A r""liruiMJ''j orARP r,.,/,;laiL' !Le defewl ••J, h ....... us\"J
'1 oc "-Vl~ o\1,.. COfH'l"e. f'f'oc£Acu\e.s "f"" tk ti"';... Lrr,
Complaint- 4
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 30 of 34 Document 1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 31 of 34 Document 1

'"""b T'~"l L""J

r . ·oS"i> .~ "'~Y/t 'T" "t I J''lf] r wvvC'T )'
'l\:rn ( 5901. XJ) w-v.J•d Yf lA""':] ~ovv~ov VVJi .rv llj:>T!S vv-.k"'J -;Jy
•n "(iv'vl " l'J'~l T''F" '1-!'""'J"¥ "'1t '"?f''f""YlVIP .nrJV Aro"':vv!r,J V "Is

·'TT yvrv'"""?t 1ovv'9"' :tVIr.r bvl/""!-f-u1 ot yuv)l-." ·~ f"'n Cvr/nli ~

v . ""lt L~f!Y.o "11 l"'!'<']V1() 5V'QPQJ IF f"'lt b":'f"f"'WV\1 vvr~a ,(Jl'~~w!J"j

L

n -'0"'"" . J"Jt'"•j ~''fY!l1 T"'" I]/V11'JV S""r1 "1t I

L F " ) " ' V I S

I Yilj''."JITV

rvry "?f"'O"\S ''IP' "'"T"n""''f"II'UVl t~XOI5""~"'~.rJ

J:f"j-1" hi )'"sYl ')\Q(IVV IP'

rvrv lr.s """'?t ]'RJ '-"! J'"=ii~

)':<Jn,m~ f'"1t f"'n

?"Jl Tnovrbnor'Jt S!I"UVVT.l

"':1v~TI\NJ"'"'Jrtw! '"''Yfl" 5)-"'f'woj•f f"Jt b"'!f"f"'1IV"' "f-'G """"'!""l"J 1f ·•1

"J\j WNJ (lmrv rr"ruJJ ""j r'"W.:J "t """~"'!j ""JV >CU:.J ""oJfirv
'T"I:J -,w!Jt vrf'."<(!, " 'F\ 'T'1 "' '+'"'T""'Ff 'It i.vTT""VVI "'Y'• hrvv""':'f"J V ·c;

. r"'I.Jvv.,. '!v/f "'! tnq ps w"Tf~"" J\j "rT ... ..,} ""'t "'! 'JjT'"~ "It Cv~5""'1 """•j 't"'Yrv'"f'/ "if C"'TTT'.J ""T''o ,("'"'!w:)"nl V -p
•tv;-.,JJvvn•;> '!"jf

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 32 of 34 Document 1

'l.); -1 "~"lJ"'"J
.'""t'l'"' "'! ""!r"'nd s'
·r JY llP'f'/'5! r"L~I""J f' 'f<YVV /t"''"F"'"J'f ""'f f"1t ""'~f'""ro~ \1
.r JYV"l'l >~ ~if "'; V1]T"1nvv•.pey ,...,,."~f',J,.,=u fVI'T/
'r-'+"""'"'"":11111" 'f"'-'"J)'T"L1T"" J" tnT""'.J ,'f''f""'J'Y OV/1 f"1t "'oT"J>IrvCI V -~
v ~+""''V"i>"TITJ J rn"'~l"'~ lvT OAT "! rY/ 'J'f f
d(lJJ bVI!VI!YIVV'O< ": F".r;)t"'' ht"",~l rr•t OJ " 'J:f1 VI!"!Jr 't """), (Y) F"'Y CVJW~o·go~ Y"" rO''bClt -:JQCJ s~ 'TJ ·vvry ''!M fit VJQT""'r"CJ \1 ..2
'-'],J!J tVIfl'"T""""Y lt"'""tH"j r""''~f'1~:l'IU:l'P'!j ,'1J'tvY"\J
?VJt f"f'\11!1\ JV>"l"~vv-o \"'" 'I' 't V''T"'".f'f "If f'"\\: ""'f''-''T'G V 'I
~IAcwbpn.r. AJOf17Nj-;>o(J ·g
-:;y . Yf<J''V>!.,J "''1f' 'If r 'trr?-vJwv-;:J "t J""Yl
\ p-;i - ;j" -.pro (l~!f {JfTYYV ~j{"''P!J~IA.£,.'5 T"J'! Jl'",J p u:y••11;) vs '(150VJt F"'v f"'f ...'-'j (,f"'"~os ""1 ~:f'1 --;J\;f r't"'"\"-rd AvaA uvojr< '''9Tf"'0i7
J:7 ": Jfi>U<Jy:·,J \J V ''n""l •t (d ':JH Wr"'n ¥"-'fTJ.J r'"""'J '~man f"f:~p·~ ('Til"' "' 1'!\T"t,.., 'ri"'V"T f'"ll t"'·fl'"'m ""f-'O "~''tf 'h

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 33 of 34 Document 1

;lj, - r:vr"'"J
."""3 h"'""tf" rv>-v 'P"" +""<77 i"'!rpv! I fM '"!It f' -f5ITJ ~ -[ ! f''r"'F\ '1'1"~1 "j'lVO W~Jj J:JT'-""1~ '1'7ViJ
·t .Y'-'""11 vy Jl''"'""'Jf f"''fVl'l"j - •{7lt :f' 1MJ'1S II"Jt v~ YU~""Vf h'T"Jv.Jv .z
:-t-"'vrV)"FT "IT"!] ~ ""~'j jJT!..,Ij vrrvo •t YVY/111' ff"Yl'novli rJrn'1-01'1t f' w-n-s u"Jt V'~ r-rvrTv SiiivwYf "~T~nd 'I
J()~w'vo .J

E. JURY DEMAND

I want a jury to hear my case.

&YES

0-NO

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Complaint signed this __:3:::_~1___ day of -~'--1-"tJJ=Lh""--_ _ _ _ _ 20--'.L._
Respectfully Submitted,

~ 2.1AZ Plaintiff's Prisoner ID Number
(Mailing Address of Plaintiff) (If more than one plaintiff, use another piece of paper.) REQUEST TO PROCEED IN DISTRICT COURT WITHOUT PREPAYING THE FULL FILING FEE
@ I DO request that I be allowed to file this complaint without paying the filing fee.
I have completed a Request to Proceed in District Court without Prepaying the Full Filing Fee form and have attached it to the complaint.
D I DO NOT request that I be allowed to file this complaint without prepaying the
filing fee under 28 U.S.C.§ 1915, and I have included the full filing fee with this complaint.
Complaint- 5
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 34 of 34 Document 1

Ex. 100 I
f"j"- I of 2

L___],

LJ. 0

•

Tke.
TIAIL

'"l"·"'j

~!!r<PJ<
_s.,_,,_

~ • .,ls
~o,.,L

I DU
•td

!My<. Mkll:.,

rru.i( t~ lee.. CJI.IW..J\..\.

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 1 of 8 Document 1-1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 2 of 8 Document 1-1

cg·•1J TMJ "'"lij.s;l~ ., "T""' T'!'1"
(~n) "Tyv!iS l'""''!tTn-""'n '>Jt ''T"""I(S"J) s"J""'TS' T""'"Tf"'lJ
''11 · tl -- ~;n- .. S"J ·~ l'f"}l b-w: "'•Tr'J r''"~=rJ "ll Ch

( L.J rrvtro) · 'T"'·'P "'VW"'V t 1 I'"'J"A" Lrr"'J,!<" IT("l
1 f"1t <>S1dTJJru< ""' ">]''" "t htT""~v-;:7 ?l')t J(!"lJ:,v sn nw~p .,. T!"1f"l .,.,, l"':1/l-1"9'3\

J" ,Jlt C"T''J'II"tn~ <tA.':t<l]j'" .., >! (,, "",J lu!'V''!fr"""J )"''Cl!S"'lJ """!A'Iffi'd (\0
1 : 5("0]1 OJ 5l7 HoVI05!j t~!jff'lVn JSV!J,J' V?V"cln4 II>O)r7,';f~~OW v0j~'9'1<J
t-raovv "' 'I"'! f J" "'17 :sv-a~vrvv /f""'F""Jilf '"lt .ruj t'111 J'. "'~'."''"1 >JVOJJ,

5ilr"'""' (I ,J ru"l""tt") fl)'l>j o")t

ovJ r~n~ /F'J/\VOS rvJ f""l "11 r'."Jf"' ""! "''"T""

T""J 1L . l""t "' ""!'""J •t T"",..., ""~ r 1M fVJ~!\ \P" UVJt "Jff'l """r l'P" Sl'

f" t""!f"""F 7 '1 •t ,.......,!,J ''lt ""~n~ 'T"J'""'f"Y •rt f""""'"'"'"CTV'"'" ·'!it "'I . "'TJ'

""f"'! 'h""'Tlf r••j ('W" '?P nv) l"v~s 't 'tli'Vf'~J'f 'It /,"/ r's.,, (Z .J J"''F"tf' mJ

VV<lt '~" vvv.>"'r! 11"1 "~f!r"'"!MJA"'d " '1"~t...:J -'\l'J r~n l.y "It L."'V CY

'f~n t""'W'il"'!j"'V? ""T'J'"1 xvwnJns f"" '"'t ;JV "f'"fS -y

'(. rn "-s~ ""tJ""""I) ,n 11 t.J., -r"n b"'!""H ''T~'t""l:l l1Jj'1 "It jO ,,nbvrvJ" "' 1' I :J9
t""'wob!AV~"l7 11"" f""Y ro~,.,, r?!'A'1J "11 'r~..l.y I .J ,,.. "'!t"'t'"j]! "'11 (I

!!~f r·\j)\() r

: 5f"'o!r:9 5l' rvc9 '[!S""'JS'il,- yo l'Yl""1i S

.I/

H

I'Tr'i"" "t 'f'"F"'"f'f "'1t "' F"n hr;, T;J]"\ "It Vj ynvvw<l ""''f'

/"' 7YV vt ""''f /v."i!l '! f''1~"' '"'!"r~" '"T"]I':l '1i 'J"! 1"1 F""' 'u:""'1~Jio f""'!F

1(.,.! F""'F""F"'Tl '~'! f'"'"<'jv! i._., :J' t"'l "''t 't S<l'J!""' ~'I(] l,r!)j ,~,1 "'•t~ "'l

,.J'IOOI '11)

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 3 of 8 Document 1-1

tr. vJvr;~ ""'t O""J t)""lnboJ "lfs "'"~•~,) ''1-t r~" "~fs "'"""'t"~) "''\"'~)7 "'1/s

'"'~I "'MO ·/,""~\) 'f t"'!""f Y""j "'7t "'F""J /)'T'h,J !"""~ '1t suvow F"l

/,i

u

. r"/ ""'!fS f"'t""Vl --., )'17 J:JV rt"'F (I.JJ'''""s r••:J l'""nJ, P"''l "F'j (-v

; 5(""jl''j SY J<>WVS!j J'd\f<il~fl't Y'

t'"'!"h, ~Y"~"]~""'O ll'] "t "!fnt ""H F""' T"""T' f "'"T""',J"~ b,.?J,.T"'~ I o-w\lnvt

vpvi! "<!110 ~~"tY117;J <s~-J"<!Xa ')"~7!jjo """S.'A.roJns f"""VVVV'r,} f' "'!"''T' '"it ~""''11

·hvrA:r•r ~YVt L!Y>Yf VV(ItS~) S~"Jt v+ """"lr' ~lr'1"P vt rv:wt !IVP srJVnt Ins 'li

""'t U ·Jyyvoj 'QV)t f'""' T""t "1t tl1'nT'" """ ~n a"Jt J'l' S'J "f"w f""j
1 'f'"T"''j'f "'lt "'l ·bn 1-;JM -.1+ "1 ·"'""'"'!~ "1 yooj bw)A""l j" "F'lYV -uvJl

rr""' "~"Jfrl T'YY''fl"'o "! 1<;"-')1 ,-""J "'! rno ps l'(lV"f'"",J T""'

oll'1" "il (?,

(g )) · S'J " '"' yasn "1

rm v '']" VIT'f/ son-;:> ~""Ff"17 F""' I"'"'!I\ . r""'T,!S "" "T"1P,\ " :ry

~J '"1 V/'r,}

. sn _,,l )'Y -~s,_,uJnJ ""'"'" "1t ">J"A() "t Ar7VdV<J "1t ··~,1\,;:>-y Vlv>) r 'sn 7 r"l 1f ('1 ("'"l"!?Vsn>) bv! ;~ T"t""doJ "Jbnon\t eYV~ t "<J~U I (l.,.,..,.,JJQJ >' ~ 0/\(1 tOIJl

""f l1 "<''I I(Z .J) sn/nw:p j"'t""l/1 -v 5-v Jj" T"t~ /,1/"~F' S'J \j (L

sn v '(I)Cf'l/JSQJ ?~!rv-'t-''"! v>V S<>r~" f'lt L!'1t 1'"'"' '!

(7

r • ;)'J '"!A I""F"'n I 5r"' /'T'"VV"i"d '"it "'!"] Jxo> I~""F'I '( L r ("/ YVN 10~""1"' Icc:; T""" ( :•rN
.sn r"" S'J ;f t"'~""'J '~ iv-.yo•:n~<r.J )-v?!SSVp .«nny.J f'"'lt ""'T"""'J -·~.L (<g

r·J'IOOI -x-3

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 4 of 8 Document 1-1

"""'f' . OHJ?"""" f-n!b"I''Y'hJ J swn-j

fV!'v "-~~'TT"'" '"!S"'II\' "':J

(~''l"i'Z .,J) 1J"'"'~f5 sm~X"'-' J" k'<'vVY -'~Jt""'J"' " "t vv!"j ,,,j,., 'f "d1fl17>)

'~j •.nJs 'l7 pt-JY+ 't ("r"f WiJWI"h~ 7 ''T"t 11~("'] oVV!t J"IIW T'!'!jJ' r~f'\ "''t

(""'!" ~r">QVV(JAvw r"'"' 911-T"T'" ll'" :f' t»u 't"'"'J 11'"" 5:1 t" "'T~n+""JJ, "'''\"\" "'
,{,...,~! 1"/' !''';) L.vny) """"~!,) r"fP[,.f"Pt --- J f'"'""'-'Ov~n"'o "It }" "'''·rr nl'."'VVVI Fl/)"

u ....,JJsn F"'" s~ F b"'!"~J J' hv['l ~,, (-SJ) •sJ }"TT·l"!,, '"' (+S"J) 'SJ
.,.\~'f"f:JXo" "" ""If." sSJ 1_,-'"~l'"s S' ?m TV>V 6v)J,j 1bno•ll CP

T''!.r-d ,t;"'"''T'"'',J ''1t f"'.~61 t"'"wi..IL'" "'."If J,,1 't 'VVJ ~"1t i 1 5"'T"" ~'"'"ll'j
t""vv fvn7 n.fr.ro -,..rv ""JM f"Sll r"'lJ rJJ.vJ <NY 'J'""n~ <J!10N J f'"Jj Vl'lnt.,

-v ,.,,J,..17)1, ''"j . ssJ 517 rowoul, t"'!'1 '""' "'"~t f'"H (1VYlrl7"'Tl All"T·"'~

"i tYJYV' ""'',S . S·I(J~"((S /"'j P'"l S" f"" •t r"Jl-, . J "QJV/ 't j;"]o lt "I Vl<;l

tn s syrq,, hV/'iVV> oW'·t "'AO . .5 r·"l "" I T"" fd'l +•\ V/Q "l : 'l'W Ar'T t
f?J uJF /.l"vT''" TJf'\ ""Ji tv T"'"""""!J'""'J ""~'.f"J"'· "'' SJQ'-"Q'~'d (J
·"'t )V>'·'Y' 1'~ t "'1 1-...,~t.l •!sh"\J '-,~. 1·"' '! ,;''""J-'"~.. "ll "(''"'\'I'S ~n•"""\'\

7]WOv>otnv ""') Y<Tmvv> 'W'VVI5 r~v (uS'? ':It "': ''IVI\]111') l'lt "1t J" "•Try

fv!~r""'' o)V'GJSu~ \yo..to,a~S~'1~ c"t"'nl 01\'-'~ v>'Q b~~'1°1\(J "<J"! 1<1A!X<ljj"J <! r"'V

'"""'''~.;\ ''1t L'.f'"JJ" ''\"'fl 'rr·.~ """ s: f"'•"' ...,,..•Jsw-snrw:p "1l (9

· 'SJ -., ("loiJ\ 5\ f""n~ '!jl ·~"'1\ "'<><>cnp~ ,}'"") •s•••JS<J• ·snln""~F.,
-. L'.""""J C"E .J r"'" r ..,J ••>) f9"j •1t .f' "S"'"Jso~ "It •w~• 't

h'J'IOOI ·xJ

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 5 of 8 Document 1-1

."T' "'t "'T . rV),.,~ t"'l""'!~ JYld v•rr":Y "'? n hvrJ""'"lt 7f' "'1 ~ tJ,.,. pr/t"'-""'~i ~TJvv~ VN1 '1"Y7 t-nr.>SQ bv~-mf 'fv''"'f'''" f' ~~~"'USHI _,-., 1-."'""'"' )"'!t"""J
rrhN ''Tl~-vxo JVj I swo:'t~nr~ r"_g,YJQJt;l V" '"I'T''t-~"jlN'CJVIT) I bv:"'"r""~'1t
"" l"''VV7>"~ f''o"~ll";j ! ( ">f""'Jb}fi!{''f"l "rl\"1VV);\ hv!-n<N.:J '1fr' ~"!f''",jvvv.J

"'' (t""''"'i '1t""'F) ·r~'J"? """'"1~ mu J~l "'! tvr<>W<>T"r' '"'"! Ft"J""'

i •r.'Fr.J '<lf"'•"!s -u•ws VVfl "; fVOW?JYr sn"TPJqJ :(f"'""lt ''JP'"f f"l]Jw!) rl'f'!'F'<~
V(J("lov rvv Jd~ ("'"I ri!]) rVO?J "Yf V! t""'VV7'"~ f"f''aJ.J ! WV'Jt "Jfr" l""J!YIJ Jl}
,j,j?A!f''"Jso~'"'"!'F"\ r"'" )'TI!nsuvv/ n f"tvoSli_,J 'JJ'll rvv 'f"""~ "t"vv"j f¥17

'Jpp r sr"nrb or"" """I ,t¥, "!vJ rrroh~ v; 1V<JFI' '!'Jt t w:vh -T''T'""f"f lt'Jt
/,1 f"5l1 T"w~p sm!~""' :!" S<JJht J-vmos '""lt ~VIlJw>'tf • lJ nwJtS ~m7!XQN (01

. '-"'17v?-uvd L:1AlJ)fr"J on\SJQ~Y r'tVJ?_51"17V'V1T1

VTYl "': SQS~,,l,•• r""'"!t~YVJ "'"'t: F"'";J "f f""JP "'! ( L.J) bv-)V!J'q(/1 (J?fVj •t

\Av!J!J) ,,r:'t \\ -~~Tt'J-•• vr'n"'1f "df'Pl n,•Jt VJ-oJn 'tw-'9f140Pf -o"'t A'1

rvrp p)Yl ~V~<'"J S~

J'<'"~'VJ VTY;J ?JllVV!t.S .fM!XVV!-\/''1"1' -f"T' 5n•J'XOV1 'Jf.f"'

r t SJ "'''IJW'<7J(Q "":)I r''T'"tQJ bv~VIVVU] 5V"J 5n bv!V\IVJVJQ vrv 'f'!J"'.J -JV

5)"w&?s +SJ ""sm,.,.~ ·vsvn>JS(J~ f"J't""t'!T -v SOJf"n" \S'"JJ "'f"' ro~:ml ""'1m (Sn)

rfl""?t5 !plw~rs. 5710))( crt!' 'orWVXo -"'.:)I;

J l"'J<l/I(JJ vSTl Cv~~r'nv~ '"'1f""t -'~"'!VYI\

1'1 .r~'1t "l'TL. W'Tl' T'TfOJ'r "'1L ' SQSWob~ rv-o1rVIr(J 1A17TfV'17" "t '"":/\"!'"\

rvrv 5'T'P tv•!tVYV(l f1'·'1 "'! "'t ""/-ro!"""1"1 T""" "'f"F f""O!pW(J @C>ryrv: •t
f<>5l1'"'1 "'"'''sn "~F" -SJ ""'sn 1f"' +S\J f" '"!"."J rr·""·u \b

S .J '! 001 ·x]

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 6 of 8 Document 1-1

.""·'tsn"~"" f'Vl r~ "'"T""'vfJxo r'.11 :•t•j\1
. ViJMo~ f-Nn' P" 7
7J}t F"'" J"ilflJ"iJS rJVYlt T"'"l "''If .". ~ I .<'I()~T"f r'":J 'r"""" "TJVni If'")
-u ITO")f'l 0 vnyr;n~J n "J/nvf --r; o)n nwTu~- :}"'lvoJ"f "11-- (\:1
.,if"Iro"l "<~flU 'lrr7 't -ru IA(>5UVi7 J~t pv~vtv VIV"JTa'
Dt J07""d f,,'-"'1 ~ ",." hvrr~ "1t "'I ·uf~n vJ"' f'"iJ"""'""!I\vo U'Jt
Jr "': 5 f!YQ/10 l.n0<1f'"lp1 (S"'"1f"?"5"JV)-'"'"T"""'""T.T t"'lt Vl"'ov}"'"~ 7V ~''
"'"T''V~"J""'v ~l 'f ""'w"'o'.'n"'o ""~r J" "'"T"l"J~"'"'I""Y l"J"JVY 'Tt,"J"'t ~1t ·r
't ":}-""'f""'J"T ":11- . "f"7~ <.mwvvv;;> ~T /'""" fYl VVf"'"Jdf Cl'j t "'. f f''~("l Slh!Y>)
(Apn!X"J,f"')I,1J""'T'\/V'Or17 "()V11) I /,117<l'""ii roho~"T ''. 7J "'"1]1 CZI
.r""'"V")S''",.,J S'. tI . fV<!W"Jfl.nCVT)J FV'l' "':"'J I"V1"T"YV;) l'v l"'tVfQVV slv~"'l
lw:n "01\Jv"oliJ --v w• q"""!P "'"'t" Y"'" ·"'"!X•V> •t ?vns.-Jxo un!fp~ ( 11
"J .J '100) "X)

Classical Conditioning (Pavlov) ILearning Theories

L.IOOLr.7

• Home • Index of Learning Theories and Models • Definitions • Paradigms • Buy the eBook! • Submit a New Theory Home» Behaviorist Theories » Classical Conditioning· (Pavlov)
Classical Conditioning (Pavlov)
Posted in Behaviorist Theories I 1 comment
Summary: Classical conditioning is a reflexive or automatic type ofleaming in which a stimulus acquires the capacity to evoke a response that was originally evoked by another stimulus. Originators and Key Contributors: First described by Ivan Pavlov (1849-1936), Russian physiologist, in 1903, and studied in infants by John B. Watson (1878-1958). Keywords: stimulus-response, psychic reflexes, unconditioned stimulus, conditioned response, respondent conditioning Classical Conditioning (Ivan Pavlov) Several types of learning exist. The most basic form is associative learning, i.e., making a new association between events in the environment. There are two forms of associative learning: classical conditioning (made famous by Ivan Pavlov's experiments with dogs) and operant conditioning.
Free Personality Test
The most accurate personality test available
lre.e on the web today.
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 7 of 8 Document 1-1

Classical Conditioning (Pavlov) I Learning Theories

------1

Pavlov's Dogs
In the early twentieth century, Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov did Nobel prize-winning work on digestion. While studying the role of saliva in dogs' digestive processes, he stumbled upon a phenomenon he labeled "psychic reflexes." While an accidental discovery, he had the foresight to see the importance of it. Pavlov's dogs, restrained in an experimental chamber, were presented with meat powder and they had their saliva collected via a surgically implanted tube in their saliva glands. Over time, he noticed that his dogs who begin salivation before the meat powder was even presented, whether it was by the presence of the handler or merely by a clicking noise produced by the device that distributed the meat powder.
Fascinated by this finding, Pavlov paired the meat powder with various stimuli such as the ringing of a bell. After the meat powder and bell (auditory stimulus) were presented together several times, the bell was used alone. Pavlov's dogs, as predicted, responded by salivating to the sound of the bell (without the food). The bell began as a neutral stimulus (i.e. the bell itself did not produce the dogs' salivation). However, by pairing the bell with the stimulus that did produce the salivation response, the bell was able to acquire the ability to trigger the salivation response. Pavlov therefore demonstrated how stimulus-response bonds (which some consider as the basic building blocks ofleaming) are formed. He dedicated much of the rest of his career further exploring this finding.
In technical terms, the meat powder is considered an unconditioned stimulus (UCS) and the dog's salivation is the unconditioned response (UCR). The bell is a neutral stimulus until the dog learns to associate the bell with food. Then the bell becomes a conditioned stimulus (CS) which produces the conditioned response (CR) of salivation after repeated pairings between the bell and food.

l1mu,(l, Ci1edat',fl(lir J'06aNoiL H(l aoxoiJum O'o
:)I(;CAJdKCZ fl n~mudtl('nl lU.~f~t·-:t fWI(tt'fU'ttUitl 6 IUitlfC• IJGflf.". f/t~ ,1/l,~eAy{~iJff fUO•J"-h"tl fHH) l'i•ltl1JUII~?,1t HeprNW?t) $O.Jfi.I,I)I\:'Q:{',.o:tUn flf,lf}f'Alfetll J«CtMyd()iJRbltf (()r(,
John B. Watson: Early Classical Conditioning with Humans
John B. Watson further extended Pavlov's work and applied it to human beings. In 1921, Watson studied Albert, an 11 month old infant child. The goal of the study was to condition Albert to become afraid of a white rat by pairing the white rat with a very loud, jarring noise (UCS). At first, Albert showed no sign of fear when he was presented with rats, but once the rat was repeatedly paired with the loud noise (UCS), Albert developed a fear of rats. It could be said that the loud noise (UCS) induced fear (UCR). The implications of Watson's experiment suggested that classical conditioning could cause some phobias in humans.
For more information, see:
• Pavlov, I. P. (1927). Conditioned Reflexes: An Investigation ofthe Physiological Activity of the Cerebral Cortex. Translated and Edited by G. V. Anrep. London: Oxford University Press. Ful1 text available onlim~
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 8 of 8 Document 1-1

Clinical and Forensic Psychologist, Northern California
Segregation psychosis
The exponential growth in super-maximum security prisons and Security Housing Units (SHU's) has led to a concurrent rise in psychotic symptoms among prisoners. These symptoms may mimic those of schizophrenia, but with the crucial distinction that they are rapidly reversible. Unfortunately, prisoners suffering from segregationinduced psychosis may be misdiagnosed as suffering from a more chronic mental illness, rather than from a temporary, environmentally induced condition.
Psychotic symptoms among individuals subjected to solitary confinement has been observed as far back as the early 1800s. Between 1854 and 1909, dozens of articles appeared in German journals that described a constellation of segregation-induced psychotic symptoms including hallucinations, paranoid thinking, and persecutory delusions. Indeed, by 1890 the U.S. Supreme Comt had condemned solitary confinement on psychiatric grounds, stating that it caused "a considerable number of prisoners" to become "violently insane."
Stuart Grassian, MD, of Harvard University has studied the effects of Security Housing Units on prisoners in Massachusetts. He describes strikingly consistent symptoms that mimic those produced by other sensory-deprivation experiences. These symptoms include:
• Perceptual distortions and hallucinations • Massive free- floating anxiety • Impaired concentration and memory • Acute confusional states, at times associated with dissociation, mutism, and partial
amnesia • Persecutory thoughts, at times reaching delusional proportions • Impulsive behavior, for example sudden sea:mutilation or violence • Rapid subsiding of symptoms once isolation is terminated
This constellation of symptoms can be induced among individuals with no preexisting psychiatric problems. Not suprisingly, however, the problem is worse for prisoners with preexisting mental disorders. Such individuals almost invariably experience a dramatic worsening of their psychotic symptoms.
Further resources:
Stuart Grassian, MD (1983). Psychopathological effects of solitary confinement. American Joumal ofPsychiafl)' 140 (II), pp. 1450-1454
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 1 of 2 Document 1-2

Terry A. Kupers (1999). Prison madness: The mental health crisis behind bars and what we must do about it. Jossey-Bass Publishers Btuce Porter (1998). Is solitary confinement driving Charlie Chase crazy? New York Times Magazine, November 8, 1998, pp. 52-58 Related blog post: "Supermax: Hell on earth or not as bad as we thought?"
nrawiug: Sketch by SHU prhoner lft•nmm Wallace, Louisiana State Penitentiary, Angola
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 2 of 2 Document 1-2

Ex. 1003 a 1,. 1 •f
Faith-based state group seeks Waupun prison abuse probe

'

I

j
~~ \

•

! I
.,' l ~~~'"""-"·'~··
' i

! 'I I

r: \ ~;.
'

' !llt~'-

~

I
i

l.
}.

I

it

~~ (I )hoto: Photo: Lauren Fuhrmtmn.'\Visconsin Center for Inn~stigati\'C Journalism)

I;
;._

I' I~

r ;;_,-

f;:
¥·

~

I

li 'r / :c.,";:

~ I tl-·-~
~

~

s' ·~"· ,.?'J,

C:o1\i:--IEC:TJ\HJ.J:LL';l-:l JA~CC l~li\ lEi'TI'Ei\ IA TL:\1ORE

A statewide advocacy group on Tuesday asked \\'isconsin Gm·. Scott \Valker to investigate allegations that guards at

\\'aupun Correctional Inslitution hm·c abused inmates in the prison's segregation unit dozens of times since 2011.

nit is now clcc1r that the \\risn>nsin Department of Corrections, as a maHer of policy, routinely engages in torture,"

said the lcucr from \\'isdom, a fnith~lmscd group with chaptt~rs around the state. A 11 s go\'crnor, you ha\'C tlw

authority and rcsponsihHily to end the toJ1urc now. 11

\\'alkcr spokeswoman Laurel Patrick declined comment, referring questions to the state Department of Corrections.

DOC SJX)keswomaH Joy Staab declined to comment on \Visdom's letter but issued a statement: "EYery allegation of

assault that is brought to the attention of staff is ilwcstigatcd. The Dodge County Shetifrs Department routinely

inYcstigatcs allegations. During the past scvcml years there have been no substantiated allegations of stnff on inmate

almsc at Waupun Correctional Institution."

\Visdom's letter was prompted hy a series of articles rl'lcascd last week by the \Visconsin Center for Investigative

Journalism and published or cited by 29 news organizations around the state. The Center identified 40 allegations of

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 1 of 8 Document 1-3

physical or psychological staiT-on-inmale abuse involving 33 inmates in the prison's solitary confinement unit over the past three years. The letter from \\'isdom president Sandra lvlilligan said \Visconsin's usc of solitary confinement, in which prisoners spend months if not years with little human contact, "h by definition torture.'' She cited the Center's series in saying that the problem is "particularly acute at \Vaupun." T11 he exhaustive five-month investigation hy the independent Center for Investigative Journalism found that many of the inmates in solitnry confinement arc mentally ill and subject to alkgcd routine abuse by guards and indifference hy staiT," she wrote. The three-part series was based on prisoner lawsuits, complaints, intetTicws and letters. ivluch of the alleged physical abuse involved inmates who said they were hnndcuffed and not resisting. Inc.ident reports provided by \Vaupun officials confirmed that inmates were subjected to the usc of force, including lasers, pepper spray, knee strikes nnd take downs, and in some cases sustained injuries. But the reports portrnyed the prisoners as instigators, saying stnff used only necessary force. Two-thirds of those allegations in\'ol\'ed a single correctional officer, Joseph Beahm, who has worked in Waupun's segregation unit since 2006. Top corrections officials denied the allegations, accusing the inmates of lying. llealuu has ne\'cr been disciplined for any inmate-:rclatcd infraction. I .nte l<tst week, the DOC declined a request from the Center to interview Secretmy Ed \Vall about the alJegations documented in the series. 'Val\, in April, released a memo saying the state was reviewing its usc of solitary confinement, which "may really just be helping to create a worse behavior problem and habitual threat. u Segregntion cells feature concrete <llld steel furnishings, one small window and n steel trap door through which ftx)d :md medication arc passed. A regular segregation ceiJ mensures 6 feet2 inches hy 12 feet. The letter called on '\Valkcr to take a series of steps in rcsiXlllSe to the series, inclmling: • Request an independent investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice, saying the slate DOC "cannot he asked to investigate itself. 11 • Transfer the officer named in the majority of the complaints to other duties until the investigation is completed, mul ensure that no prisoners experience retribution for cooperating with investigators. • Order the state Department or Corrections to implement changes including rotating correctional officers in segn~gation units to other duties e\'ery three months, improving training for dt•aling with difficult inmates nml creating an independent complaint system for inmates. 11\Ve really feel that it's time that the go\'ernor step in mul invesligate whnt1s going on in the Department of Corrcctions,11 snid Da\'id Liners, executive director of\Visdom. - The \Yisconsin Center for Investigative Journnlism collahoratcs with \Visconsin Public Radio, \Visconsin Public
Tclerision, other news media and the t f\V-1\Iadison School of Journalism and Mass Communication.
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 2 of 8 Document 1-3

15\Visconsin\Vatch.org (!ntp://wisconsinwatch.org/2014/0?/waupun-guard-named~rcpeatcdly~in-abusc-complaims/)

CRUEl AND UNUSUAl?

July 21, 2014

Waupun guard named repeatedly in abuse complaints

Stale officials defend officer) say in males arc lying in claims of mistreatment

By: BILL LUEDERS

Part 2 oj3

At his sentencing hearing on Feb. 28, Wisconsin prison inmate Leighton Lindsey admitted Chttps:ffsJ,amnwnuws.comls3,documcntcloud.org/doeumcntsl1z.tt98SIIcighton-lindsct-scntcncing-hcaring.pdf) in court that he bit a correctional officer in the segregation unit at the state's Waupun Correctional Institution.

He said he did so because the ofl1ccr, Jesse Jones, was restraining him while another officer, Joseph Beahm, assaulted him.

"J was hcing held up so that Beahm could punch me, kick me, knee me, nil that stuff," he told the judge, saying Ill' at:tcd in self-defense. "I had no choke."

Name: BEAHM, JOSEPil D

Beahm's report <https:!fsJ.nm<tl':onaws.com
/sJ.doctunentcloud.on•ldocumcntsltl.tlqBSibcahm-
report-on-lindsey.pdfl on the Dec. 23, 2011, incident said Lindsey spat at ofncers and was actively resisting Jones, then hegan biting him. The two officers subdued Lindsey "using strong side knee kicks and strong side forearm strikes," the report says. Jones sustained a bite mark
<h t t p$: f/~ }\lmo.wnaws .comts3.docu mcntcloud.o rg
/documcntsft2I6U9/jopes-bjte ltltlrk-from-lindscy-
..:(\Se.pclfl and sore knee. Photos show Lindsey with a bloody gash ChttnS'!/;n.amazonuws corn Is 1.Jocu me ntcloud .(•rg/docu mcnts/il.I19A'Mii nJ~c\"bcad-woqpd-(rom -dcc-201 1-jncit!cnt.pd () ilCfOSS his forehead.

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 3 of 8 Document 1-3

fhllr:/lu6,·fi·.jml>z0gs•"(ik(9~(dw.••r•·r:gill<~nffdna-ntl1.<mnflrp-rou/o'll/
Wisconsin Depattment of Corrections
Joseph Beahm, a correctional officer in the segregation unit at Waupun, is named in more than two dozen allegations of inmate abuse.
state oflldals and an inmate-rights acti\•ist.

The case is among the 40 allegations of staffon-inmate abuse since 2011 identified by the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism in \Vaupun's segregation unit, commonly known as solitary conllnemcnt. Most involve indications that inmates received post-incitlent physk;ll or mental health attention.
The allegations were made in lawsuits, internal inmate complaints, interviews, and letters to

Of the .jO allegations, officer Beahm is named in 28. A dozen inmate lawsuits since 2011 accuse Beahm of physical or psychological abuse; six have been dhnnissed and six are pending.

The state Department of Corrections has denied these allegations and act.: used the inmates making them of lying. Bttt the nature and volume of the complaints has drawn the notice of state Sen. Lena Taylor, D-Milwnukee, and former state prison chief Walter Dickey, who has called for an investigation in response to the Center's lln~lings.

Beahm, a nine-year department employee, did not respond to written requests for an interview or offers to go over the allegations in detail.

'A rogue guard'

Beahm, a state prison guard since 2005, has worked since October 2006 in Waupun's segregation unit, where inmates arc often scm for disciplinary reasons. He is well-known to inmates at the prison 55 miles northeast of Madison.

"lie talks like a tough man, he talks like a bully," said Talib Akbar, a former \Vaupun inmate released last October after serving 20 years for two counts of sexual assault. "When something happens, he's the first one there, because he wants to down somebody."

In September 2012, Akbar said he watched from his cell as Beahm pushed a handcuffed inmate face-first to the Jloor, then pounced on his back. "Beahm's knee was in his hack, and his head was pulled ha~kwards!' t\khar said the inmate «Jidn't weigh 130 pounds soaking wet. lie was hurt."

Akbar wrote a letter Cht tps :{{s}anHl zomm·s...:om f s3,doc tunc n t cloud .ory!do .;u ments I !21224-J/f!Kbar-Jc.t tcr-to-pollnrd .pdf) to Waupun Warden William Pollard, reporting what he had sl.'en, mlding that Beahm "has a habit of this type of abuse." The letter Jrew a reply from Waupun se~urity director Tony T>.k!i, saying tbe inl'idcnt "will he rcvkwt:d by law enforcement."

The rccmds identify the inmate as

Holden Rodriguez, who the prison

snys weighs 135 pounds. The

incident reports say l~odriguez resisted, threatened and spat at

Kate Golden/Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism

officers, and W;ts directed to the ground with the least amount of force necessary. The incident led to Rodrigucr, being convicted of "pri:wrwr throw/expel bodily

Former inmate Ta/ib Akbar reported witnessing physical abuse of another prisoner to the Waupun warden, alleging the guard, Joseph Beahm, "has a habit of this kind of abuse."

substances,'' a felony, and

st•ntcnced to <Ill additional six months.

According: to other records released to tlw Center, Beahm has been the subject of only one disciplinary investigation during his time at \Vaupun. That was a 2011 incident in which he allegedly fell asleep at a desk. Beahm denied it, and complained about being "written up,'' which he said had never happened
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 4 of 8 Document 1-3

he fore.

"I worry that I not only have to worry about inmates lying about me, but now I have to worry about management," he stated at the time in his response to the inquiry.

In a three-month period just prior to the biting incident, inmate Lindsey filed at least five internal complaints against Beahm, alleging harassment and threats. "He is a rogue guard and you all know it," Lindsey wrote in one complaint. "l~verybody can't be lying on this guy."

The complaint were promptly rejected. "You have little credibility with the behavior you exhibit in segregation/' Mcli wrote. Lindsey ahw nieJ nn internal complaint against Beahm over the Ike. 23 incident and asked a Dodge County judge to launch a John Doc probe. Both were rejected.

n: (/ittr: l/r!t',•~··l ;•!1' tf! fjoW·l t<;.'Ho"!/.11!'>'11?:"11o'.>lo'"I.fl'-/ fdt/.(~11! /u !' rOII/<711 .'!<!•.'• •·1·l<:'."•!.f 1
n,..- •Lin·l.'oT hfol-1 Hwm,f fmm )0JJ fndJml-iW2
Wisconsin Department of Corrections
Inmate Leighton Lindsey admits biting a guard in 2011, but says he did so because the guard was holding him while another guard beat him. The photo, taken by authorities, was provided by Lindsey's lawyer, William Mayer.
incident, agreed to a_ plea deal that ad Jed a year to his sentence.

Lindsey's defense attorney, \Villiam Mayer, fileJ a request for the judge to review Bcalun's personnel nle. Hc noted Lindsey's prior complaints and induded aft1davits from three other prisoners accusing Beahm of abuse. But the review did not produce any records of disciplinary action against Beahm.
Lindsey, facing a maximum sentence of 10 years for the biting

Mayer, in an interview, said he "believes from what he's heard from Lindsey and other inmates that
abuse is occurring in the segregation unit at Waupun. Most commonly, he l'laid, this involves "the
or instigating behavior- doing things to get under (inmates') skin, to get them going, rather than
dealing: with them in a professional manner." Ile thinks the allegations warrant further investigation.

Allegations of 'torture'

~ome of the complaints identified by the Center allege extreme mistreatment.

\Vaupun inmate Patrick \Veeks, in a letter (https:!/sJ.amnzonuws.com/sJ,documcntcloud.('rgldocuments fllR4I63!patrick weeks assault 3 !;!.pdf> to state prisoner advocate Peg Swan, alleges that Beahm on Feh. 5 l'ituck his finger into \Veeks' mouth after first inserting it into Weeks' rectum during a strip search. These alh.•gations were Jeemed '\mfounded" and \Veeks received a conduct report for "lying about staff." Other inmates allege inappropriate touching of their genitals during strip scardtes, which arc rout indy conducted.

A federal lawsuit nled in January by inmate Clarence Wilks alleges <https:UsJ.amuzonaws.com /sJ.documcntcloud.org/documcnt~{It84!46/wilks-complaint.pdf) that segregation unit guard Andrew .l'vloungey "struck plaintill' repeatedly with a closed list about the plainti!Ps head and both sides of the face anti slammed plaintiff's face into the wall." Then the guard allegedly "repeatedly kicked both of plaintiff's legs" and "struck plaintiff in his ribs and grabbed him hy the throat." The defendants have denied (http~:/ln.nmnonnws.com/sJ.dncurncntcloud.org/documcnts/1210990/wilks-nnswcr.pdf) the allegations, which led to Wilks receiving: a conduct report for lying about staff. The lawsuit is pending.

In another pending federal lawsuit, inmate Laron McKinley alleves Chttps:lfs1.umnzonnws.com /sJ,d<lcumcntcloud.org/documcnts/u~:.\l'\Jimckinlcy·complaint.pdf) being subjected to "torture" on March H, 2.013. McKinley, convicted of multiple crimes including kidnapping and attempted murder, admitted in an aflldavit (https:I/~J.nmuwn•\Ws.wmls}.Jocumcntdnud.orgldocumcntl'llllSOS64/taffiduvit-of-1u-ron·mckinlcy­ S-Ifi-l].p.lfl that the episode began when he threw fecal matter at a guard.

By McKinley's account, Ueahm
suhscqut•ntly arrived at his cell aml announced, "I'm going to kill you," later
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16

Page 5 of 8

Document 1-3

amending this to, "I'm going to hurt )rou real had!" Another inmate, Shirell Watkins, produced an afndavit
fhpndlsJ nmqzonaws corn
/s3.documentchntd.onr/documcnts/ttfttt6,;
i<1ffldavit of shirdl watkins 3 20 13 (lll·nH:kinlcy.pdfl ~aying he heart! Beahm's death threat "from my own car~."

1\ft~._•r h.mJcufl1ng him from behind,

!\lcKinley alleges, Beahm and other oflkcrs

twisted his wrist "to its limit and ncar

breaking point," slammed him face first

into a strip ~age door and stomped on his

shackled ankles. I fc said his wrist, hand

and ankles were "contorted nnd wrenched"

for "at least 30 mintttes of continuous

ngony." At one point McKinley states that he lost mntrol of his bowels and defecated

Wisconsin Department of Corrections

on the tloor.

Inmate Laron McKinley alleges in a lawsuit that he

'!'he state, in a court liling
<https:lls3.amuzonaws.com /s3 documenh·loud om/documentsflJ84tS9
/mckinlcy-proposcd~findings-of-fnet.pdf) in

was subjected to "torture" in retaliation for throwing fecal matter at a guard. He says the guard, Joseph Beahm, told him, "I'm going to kill you."

February, t!enics these alleg:ations, saying

staff used only necessary force. It allows that McKinley "rdeased feces from his anus" ami was ordered

to "stop pooping."

At a disciplinary hearing: in April20IJ, McKinley was found "more likely than not" to have battered staff and thrown lluid; he was sentenced to an additionalJ60 days in segregation. He is also facing felony charges over this incident, for throwing or expelling bodily substances. That case is scheduled for trial in Altgust.

;Name: MOUNGEY, ANDREW C

Officer Mounge;t, hired in zon, is named in ll of the 40 complaints. Another officer, Lt. Jessie Schneider, hired in 2001, is named in 15. Moung:ey and Schneider did not respond to interview requests :;ent via letter and email. DOC records show that neither officer has been investigated for allegations of inmate abuse, although flchncider was accused lust year of fabely reporting that he administered one dose
or pepper spray to a non~compliant inmate when
in fact it was two.

(htlp:I/Uhf{(.l·q/> >Q t'jiTt'k(orl flm. HT>"I1>?l.!I•'·!JrtJ11,l-CdiJ.Cmn/h'£ (nHif>JI lu!•IMd.<ll<:>l1i<Jt/,\lo:<11f!)'.frg2
Wtsconsin Department of Corrections
Andrew Moungey.
iName: SCHtiEIDER, JESSIE

In all, the Center ohtuinl.'d records of disciplinary invcstig<Hions for eight Waupun employees named frequently in inmate complaints. All were for minor infractions, like being late, and except for the incident involving Schneider, none dealt with the treatment of inmates.
The state DOC, in response to a records request, provided information on some incidents. But it refused 1o release records regarding inmate injuries, saying this was confidential medical information. lt also denied access to internal complaints filed by inmates against gtmrds and videos taken during some alleged incidents of abuse, saying this would jeopardize security.

'lleenlooked into'

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 6 of 8 Document 1-3

Advocate Swan, a retired nurse's aide who lives in rural Hichland County, wrote the DOC early this year asking that Beahm be removed from duty pending an investig;Hion into the complaints against him.

James Schwochert, the DOC's assistant aJmini:;trator of adult institutions, told Sw;tn in a letter <https:!ls3.nmmwnnws ...:om
Is3.Jocumc nh: loud.orvtJocumc n ts I 114no s
fschwoclJcrt-lcttcr-to·swun.pdf> dated Feb. 18 that this would not happen.

''These C<lmplaints have been looked into, by

1•1!'/r>_!•f>llo!./fnr/S.:hl!d•lcr.iri)
Wisconsin Department of Corrections

either internal or external investigator:;," Schwot:hcrt wrote. "Based on our llnJings, they

Lt. Jessie Schneider.

appear to be fabricated to the point that the

inmates place themselves at risk of being

subject to discipline for making t:1lse allegations about stafL"

"Based on our findings, (the complaints) appear to be fabricated to the point that the inmates place themselves at risk of being subject to discipline." - State prison
official

But Dickey believes the large number of complaints merits further inquiry.
"Even if everything tlwy say in that letter is true, l'm not sure why you want to keep the guy in scg," Dickey said. "There's obviously something going on."
"It's a psychological warfare environment," said former Waupun inmate Marvin Smith, who RjH:~nt the majority of his seven years at the prison in segregation. "They know which inmntcs arc \\'eak. They know which inmates they can prey upon."
Smith, whose alleged case of abuse did not involve Be;1hm, said he's heard Beahm state that he will remain in segregation: "He's not going anywhere. I te's said that. Because he knows he's free to make inmates' life a living hell.''

"\\'aupunleads in lawsuits

Currently, inmates alleging abuse have few options besides tiling their own lawsuits.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Wisconsin <http:lfwww.tlciu-wi.org() iN monitoring conditions at the Milwaukee County Jail and 'J'aychcedah state women's prison, both the subject Of past litigation, but has no other active cases concerning prison conditions.
The Legal Assistance to Institutionalized Persons Prokct <http:/tlnw.wisc.cdulfir/laipO, run through the University of Wisconsin Law School, does not take sudt cases. And Legal Action of\Visconsin rhttp:llwww.lct•,lfaction.org/J, a federally llmdeJ nonprofit agency, is barred by law from doing so.
"There's a big void bccam:c Congress doesn't want to help inmates," said John Ebbott, Legal Action's former executive director.
Lawsuits by in mutes in federal court arc not uncommon. rvlatthcw Frank, who served as DOC secretary from ZOOJ to 2007, said the position brings "the dubious distinction of being the most-sued person in :-:tate government."
Pollard, the warden at \Vaupun, ha!o: been sued hundreds of times. But only a small number of suits proceed far enough to rcquirt· till' state to present a defense.
During the tl1rcc-year period fr~nn 2011 through 2013, the state Department of Justice represented state prison ofncials 01149 inmate lawsuits alleging excessivt• use afforce, according: to a tally provided by department spoh•swoman Dana Brueck.
Of these, 13 suits arc from inmates at Waupun, more than for any other state prison. Several of the suits have hccn dismissed, others are pending.
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 7 of 8 Document 1-3

Brueck declined to comment on whe'ther the large number of lawsuits alleging the use of excessive force at Waupun might indicate a systemic problem. "That is a question for the DOC," she wrote in an email. She said her office's role is to "defend the state and pursue remedies in the best interest of the state." The DOJ's list, prepared in March, omits at least four additional lawsuits liled by Waupun segregation inmates in late 2013 and early 2014. It also does not include a lawsuit liled on Feb. 11, 2013, by !1·1arcus Childs, an inmate in segregation. Childs alll'!rpd Chttps-!ls3 qmazotHlWs cornls1 documcntcloqd ore /Jncumcntsflli.J?ROI/childs complllint.pdfl that when he was placed naked in a cold cell in :?.on, officer Beahm tknied him access to a blanket that a psychologist had okayed. That case was Jismisscd in March 2013 because Childs failed to submit a required filing. Childs missed the filing because he hung himsclfin his ccU (Hl.Feb. 21,2013. Tlh•nonprofil Wis.:omi11 c,•ntafor lnwstig,lfiw Jounwlism (H1ru:\Visconsii!Watch.on') wOabomt.·s with Wimmsin Public Ra,lio, Wi>comiu l'ub/ic Tdt'l·[>fon, ather lim's 11tt'tlia aud the UlV-M<ldil'oa School of]allnU!lism 1111d Mnss Commtmiwtion. Allwork> frt'<llt'<~ pub/il'h,•d, post.-d ordisst'il!inufl'tl by tht' Ct'lltt•r do notneo.·ssan1)' rcjlc.:t tilt' t•i,•ws or opinions ofUW-Mrlolison or any ofits affi/ialt'S.
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 8 of 8 Document 1-3

I [ :q g~pil'-:X: ~ ~

"f.'
>

D

E
('

0
..c

{J

~
; • t.r>
-~;-. >
(;
~

L.
r>

rJ D
z:

H -1

(/> :::0

-+ ~

D r

,I"
'-'> (P

-+-6

c

.._5__ tJJ

::0
:r:

CP
r

c:: r"'

c: :>:;...

r:..

~

"~ '

E

t,'--

'

?

.

... ... ," "~'00

r:l
0

;t~

~

f

~
7"

-

F

(
'

'

r

.",_' ~, .
t
t
'n
~
c.t"".,_' ~ " ' 1 "('. ·- -·

~
1 ~ ~·

- .· ....· '"'1"1 v OS\f?J!'Jf $ ,

J)?rrt\I~VfS

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR FiledI 04/29/16

I

I

D
~
~"· '
Page 1 of 1

Document 1-4

--l

Warden Pollard Dr. Ingres Dr. Ludigson Toni Mell HSC Director WIDOC health director
RE: longterm Seg./AC Program~ WCI (Common Grounds)

L.lOOS ,f·l.F 'L

Warden Pollard, et al: Please find enclosed the CG (Common Grounds) longterm seg/AC program resolution that FFUP's "think tank"
has put together and donated to Waupun lU try to address the longterm seg/AC problems that exist there. We believe a fresh look at the AO!ongterm seg. problem is needed, and we bel/eve common grounds can be
part of that solution.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. we request feedback as to whether this program will be used or any comments on it.

Sincerely,

FFUP Director and Prison Rights Advocacy Coordinator. Common Ground (CGS)

Logline: Transitloning Prisoners From AC and Longtime Seg.

Goals: Addressing conflict resolutions that prisoners In AC/Iongtlme segregution have with prison staff and/or among themselves, resulting In the hopeful transitionlng and release from AC/IOng time seg.

Premise of Program: CGS begins with the premise that if a prisoner has been placed and held In AC/Iong seg. status

there has to be an existence of some kind of conflict has lead to this long time segregation placement.

between

either

staff or

the

prisoner

and

other

prisoners

that

Unique Approach: Instead of placing blame or approaching the conflict from a subjective point of view, CGS is
designed to not take a particular position in the conflict, but equali~e the concerns voiced by both the prisoners/staff conflict or prisoner/prisoner conflict that led to the AC/Iong seg. placement, and focus on resolutions withOut
placement of blame.

This unique approach Is effective because, as in any conflict, resolution and all points of vle.w must be aired and ·espected as part of the resolution discussion. No problem has ever been solved by one party in a given conflict being lurdened with blame, while the other takes on a superiority complex.

3bjective: The objective is to find common grounds that everyone can respect each other's security and :lassif/cation concerns without placing blame and the use of inferiority labels that makes one party feel the need to be

defensive, which IS what most prisoners who are held in AC/Iong seg. feel. This defensiveness has been the main reason no previous administration/ clinical programs have successfully led to the prisoners transitloning and eventual release from AC/Iong seg. Designed: This is what makes CGS unique and effective. It was designed specifically-with AC/Iong seg. prisoners In mind. After careful review of complaints, court cases, and other view points of prlson~rs held in these statuses, The CGS think tank recognized the fault Jines that kept the prison officials security claims and goals from registering with the prisoners and the prisoner's views being considered by the prison officials. Both sides took a "my way or'the highway" approach. Resulting in the stalemate with the prisoner stuck in AC/iong,seg. for indefinite years and the prison officials having to pay the cost of these prisoners becoming more defensive and in the more extreme cases, psychologically damaged beyond the objective penological goal of the status. And a psychologically damaged prisoner Is not In anyone's best Interest. It is certainly not in the best Interests of society, where some, If not most, of the prisoners will be freed to; nor the tax payers, who now have to pay extra to staff special housing units to pollee segregated mental units that are In fact disciplinary segregation units, which only exacerbate the original conflict. Workshops: The CGS Is organized in six workshop sessions: Session One: Begins with both the prison official and prisoner reducing to written word what each feels Is the contributory problems.
CGS freedom of expression: In order for the workshops to be effective there has to be a. certain level of free expression. CGS believes all participants must be allowed to state their views free of punishment. Free expression does not entitle abusive language used to provoke or disrespect the other participants, or create more problems. Session Two: begins with the prison official recitation of the prisoner's point of view and the pris~ner recitation of the prison officials. Or, in case of prisoner/prisoner, each would recite the other's views. The participant must defend each other's view point as If it was their original view to examine and experience the difference In each other's views.
Session Three: begins with each participant putting forth prospective resolutions to the c·onfllct, with discussion.
Session Four: begins with the mediator of CGS ~ a neutral and Independent person ~ putting forth resolutions that participants ~hould consider. The participants can accl:lpt or alter these resolutions and stipulate. Session Five: begins with the participants pointing out what Issues of concern that the other one has. They can agree these are ones to be dealt with and agreements to resolve them. Session Six: begins with all participants putting forth future resolution commitments to prevent and stop future problems and incidents.
Completion of CGS: Upon completion qf CGS, which is a six week session workshop, the prisoner participant should be placed Jn a transition housing to be phased back to general prison population •. Homework Assignments: After each y..orkshop the participant shOuld take a story of real life conflict (past and present, over the span of the workshops) and write a report stating now both sides to that real life conflict could resolve the matter. Also, what might be the fault line problems preventing the current resolutions. The reports should also point out valid points that each side has that should be taken more serious by the other side.
Final Report: At the completion of CGS, the participant should write a one hundred word essay
on how the examination of the report conflicts has impacted their opinion, and if so, made a change in view point.
Disclaimer: The reports written should be permitted some freedom of expression and not be used to continue

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 1 of 2 Document 1-5

(5)
J

AC/Seg. placement, nor future plac~ment. The reports will be either read at sessions or by the mediator who wlll
return them to the participant. Rights: CGS was Created by ~\FUP in house prose legal consult, R. U. and FFUP reserves all rights. Donation: FFUP waives the rights to WI DOC to use CGS as part of the prisoner AC/Iong time seg. remedy.
FFUP/R.U.

----,

3
~-
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 2 of 2 Document 1-5

...

New post on Solitary Watch-

;]~~""""'~
i\}:¥]

-- ,_.

reme Court Justice Kennect Denounces "Human .
ToH" of Sofita1 r Confinement and Invites_ ·
Constitutional Chalfeng~
by Solitary Watch Guest Author
Guest Post by Samuel Weiss and Amy Fettig

Samuel Weiss is Ford Foundation F;ellow at t!Je ACLU's Center for Justice. Amy Fettig is

· Senior Staff Counsel at t!Je ACLU's:National Prison Project.

_, _.,._._

::....-.

.---- ~

f :::: • ...

In March, Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy was testifying before the House
Appropriations Subcommittee when h't r-·-;eived a question on prison overcrowding. He

responded with a sweeping condem'mwonof the American prison system. "Total

incarceration," . he

stated,

"just

isn'hl•irking."

'

-.

He '

re.served

h.is

ha. rs-hest

words

for

t-he

practice of solitary-confinement: "Solitary confinement literally <:frives_men.mad."

Justice Kennedy's V<Ords:were powerful but also left an open question: He called the prison · system "overlooked" and "misunderstood," lamenting that'We nave no in!erest in,
a corrections." But he is no outside academic, critiquing the inattentiveness of others. He ·is
member of a Court both able and required to ensure that conditions inside-prisons comport with the Constitution. Indeed, he is often the Court's swing justice, casting the deciding vote on what the Constitution requires. His influence in determining constitutional questions has led law professor Noah Feldman to write, "It's Justice Anthony Kennedy's country- the rest of ua just live in it." If solitary confinement were indeed a primary concern for the Justice, when would it make its way to the pages of the Supreme Courts opinions?

Last Thursday, it arrived. In Davis v. Ayala, the United States Supreme Court decided an unrelated question on the exclusion of a defense attorney from part of a hearing on jury selection. The defendant, however, had spent much of the past twenty years in solitary confinement, and Justice Kennedy wrote a separate concurrence to addr~ss the practice.

Justice Kennedy opened with the long cultural history of the horrors of solitary confinement, citing an 18th century report on prison conditions and a 19th century novel that detail the damage solitary confinement has wrought. He continued to 1890, when a United States Supreme Court case described how even short stints in solitary left people

Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 1 of 2 Document 1-6

"violently insane." He connected these trends to the present, citing to the story of Kalief Browder, a child who spent years in solitary confinement while being held, though never tried, for allegedly stealing a backpack. Earlier this month, Browder took his own life. While this long-standing knowledge of the dangerousness of solitary confinement was "[t]oo often" and "[t]oo easily ignored," Kennedy wrote, a "new and growing awareness" on solitary confinement is emerging. Most significantly, he closed by appearing to invite a case to address these concerns directly: "In a case that presented the issue, the judiciary may be required, within its proper jurisdiction and authority, to determine whether workable alternative systems for long-term confinement exist, and, if so, whether a correctional system should be required to adopt them." When a Supreme Court Justice talks, the world listens. The New York Times dedicated an editorial to the concurrence, writing that Justice Ks;1r.edy "raises a constitutional question even if some of his colleagues would rather avoic ·.. fhe Los Angeles Times wrote of the "rare instance of a Supreme Court justice virtually :. . ;J a constitutional challenge to a prison policy." Slate chided Justice Kennedy for his lack of self· awareness in accusing others of apathy: "Kennedy rnay have only just discovered the cruelty of solitary confinement, but civil liberties-minded individuals and advocacy groups have fought against the practice for decades." As civil rights lawyers leading the ACLU's Stop Solitarv campaian, we know well that advocates have worked for years to confront the practice, but there is also no question that the Justice's concern reflects a new and growing national movement to end solitary confinement. That movement now has one of the nation's leading moral and legal voices as its center. Read more of this post
Case 2:16-cv-00521-RTR Filed 04/29/16 Page 2 of 2 Document 1-6

 
 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN

LA RON MCKINLEY BEY, also known as, Laron McKinley, and all similarly situated WCI prisoners in isolated Administrative Confinement,

Plaintiff,

-vs-

Case No. 16-CV-521

WILLIAM POLLARD, BRIAN FOSTER, TONY MELI, JON E. LITSCHER, CATHY JESS, DR. SCHMIDT, BRIAN GREFF, PAUL LUDVIGSON, CAPTAIN JOHN O’DONOVAN, CAPTAIN WESTRA, CO CUNDY, JESSIE J. SCHNEIDER, SHANE M. WALLER, JEREMY L. STANIEC, JOSEPH BEAHM, JOHN DOES 1-10, MS. BONIS, and JANE AND JOHN DOES, sued as “ACRC Jane and John Does 1-10,”

Defendants.

SCREENING ORDER

The pro se plaintiff is incarcerated at Waupun Correctional Institution (WCI). He filed an amended complaint on behalf of all similarly situated prisoners in isolated Administrative Confinement at WCI, alleging that prolonged placement there violates inmates’ rights under the United States Constitution. This matter comes before the court on the plaintiff’s petition to proceed without prepayment of the filing fee (in forma pauperis), motion for preliminary injunction, motion to certify class, and

motion to appoint counsel. The plaintiff has been assessed and paid an initial partial filing fee of $6.19. See 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(1).
The Court shall screen complaints brought by prisoners seeking relief against a governmental entity or officer or employee of a governmental entity. 28 U.S.C. § 1915A(a). The Court must dismiss a complaint or portion thereof if the prisoner has raised claims that are legally “frivolous or malicious,” that fail to state a claim upon which relief may be granted, or that seek monetary relief from a defendant who is immune from such relief. 28 U.S.C. § 1915A(b).
A claim is legally frivolous when it lacks an arguable basis either in law or in fact. Denton v. Hernandez, 504 U.S. 25, 31 (1992); Neitzke v. Williams, 490 U.S. 319, 325 (1989); Hutchinson ex rel. Baker v. Spink, 126 F.3d 895, 900 (7th Cir. 1997). The Court may, therefore, dismiss a claim as frivolous where it is based on an indisputably meritless legal theory or where the factual contentions are clearly baseless. Neitzke, 490 U.S. at 327. “Malicious,” although sometimes treated as a synonym for “frivolous,” “is more usefully construed as intended to harass.” Lindell v. McCallum, 352 F.3d 1107, 1109-10 (7th Cir. 2003) (citations omitted).
To state a cognizable claim under the federal notice pleading system, the plaintiff is required to provide a “short and plain statement of
- 2 -

the claim showing that [he] is entitled to relief[.]” Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(a)(2). It is not necessary for the plaintiff to plead specific facts and his statement need only “give the defendant fair notice of what the . . . claim is and the grounds upon which it rests.” Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555 (2007) (quoting Conley v. Gibson, 355 U.S. 41, 47 (1957)). However, a complaint that offers “labels and conclusions” or “formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of action will not do.” Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009) (quoting Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555). To state a claim, a complaint must contain sufficient factual matter, accepted as true, “that is plausible on its face.” Id. (quoting Twombly, 550 U.S. at 570). “A claim has facial plausibility when the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows the court to draw the reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged.” Id. (citing Twombly, 550 U.S. at 556). The complaint allegations “must be enough to raise a right to relief above the speculative level.” Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555 (citation omitted).
In considering whether a complaint states a claim, courts should follow the principles set forth in Twombly by first, “identifying pleadings that, because they are no more than conclusions, are not entitled to the assumption of truth.” Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 679. Legal conclusions must be
- 3 -

supported by factual allegations. Id. If there are well-pleaded factual allegations, the Court must, second, “assume their veracity and then determine whether they plausibly give rise to an entitlement to relief.” Id.
To state a claim for relief under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, a plaintiff must allege that: 1) he was deprived of a right secured by the Constitution or laws of the United States; and 2) the deprivation was visited upon him by a person or persons acting under color of state law. Buchanan-Moore v. County of Milwaukee, 570 F.3d 824, 827 (7th Cir. 2009) (citing Kramer v. Village of North Fond du Lac, 384 F.3d 856, 861 (7th Cir. 2004)); see also Gomez v. Toledo, 446 U.S. 635, 640 (1980). The court is obliged to give the plaintiff’s pro se allegations, “however inartfully pleaded,” a liberal construction. See Erickson v. Pardus, 551 U.S. 89, 94 (2007) (quoting Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 106 (1976)).
Amended Complaint Allegations The plaintiff filed an amended complaint on May 2, 2016. (ECF No. 5.) He seeks to bring this class action on behalf of “present and future prisoners held by the defendants in supermax, long-term isolative Administrative Confinement (“AC”) in the WCI Restrictive Housing Unit (“Seg Unit”)[.]” (ECF No. 5 at 3 ¶ 2.) The plaintiff is suing: former WCI Warden William Pollard; WCI Warden Brian Foster; Security Director
- 4 -

Tony Meli; Wisconsin Department of Corrections (“DOC”) Secretary Jon E. Litscher; DOC Director of Adult Institutions Cathy Jess; WCI Psychological Services Unit Supervisor Dr. Schmidt; former Program Corrections Supervisor Brian Greff; current Program Corrections Supervisor Paul Ludvigson; former Captain John O’Donovan; Captain Westra; Officer Cundy; Segregation Lieutenant Jessie J. Schneider; Segregation Lieutenant Shane M. Waller; Segregation Officer Jeremy L. Staniec; Segregation Officer Joseph Beahm; Segregation Officers John Does 1-10; Ms. Bonis; and ACRC Jane and John Does 1-10.
The amended complaint contains allegations on behalf of the plaintiff and also on behalf of several “putative class members.” Those individuals are: Daniel McBride; Terrance Prude; Rayshun Woods; Luis Nieves; Shirell Watkins; and Lamar Larry. The plaintiff alleges that the defendants have held him and the other named class members in prolonged, supermax isolated administrative confinement at WCI for more than eight months each.
The plaintiff alleges that the defendants regularly expose them to an insidious classical conditioning procedure without their consent. The procedure relates to the manner in which meal trays are delivered to the plaintiffs in their cells. The procedure is dangerous because the prisoners
- 5 -

are vulnerable, and it toys with their personalities and emotions which can
result in symptoms and illness associated with mental illness.
In addition, the plaintiff alleges that the long-term, supermax,
isolated administrative conditions deprive them of basic human needs and
put them at a substantial risk of serious mental injury, exacerbation of
preexisting mental illnesses, medical problems, psychosocial impairments,
and other disabilities.
The plaintiff alleges that he has been in administrative confinement
for over twenty-five years and he has or is now experiencing the following
“SHU Syndrome” symptoms:
Persistent stress; irritability; occasional panic attacks; occasional depression; occasional emotional flatness – loss of ability to have feelings; mood swings; hopelessness; hostility; anger; outbursts of physical and verbal violence; poor concentration; impaired memory and verbal recall; occasional disorientation; hypersensitivity to noises; hyper-reactivity and hyper-susceptibility to stimuli; hyper-reactivity to stimuli/easily startled, etc.; occasional disorientation in time and space; recurrent and persistent ruminations of a vengeful character; suicide ideations; sleep problems; and mental and emotional anguishment.
(ECF No. 5 at 17 ¶ 24.) The plaintiff also alleges that as a direct result of
his long-term isolative confinement, he was diagnosed with antisocial
personality disorder and delusional disorder – persecutory type in July
2012. According to the plaintiff, his prolonged isolative confinement
- 6 -

deprives him of the capacity to function normally.
The plaintiff also alleges that the conditions in administrative
confinement have had significant adverse effects on the other named class
members. (ECF No. 5 at 18-22 ¶¶ 27-37.) Each defendant allegedly knew
that:
prolonged isolation and lack of meaningful social, environmental, and occupational stimulation is toxic to the health of prisoners with serious mental illness as McKinley Bey, McBride, and Nieves, inter alia, and can cause mental illness and psychosomatic and psychosocial harm and impairment to others such as Prude, Woods, Watkins, and Larry[.]
(ECF No. 5 at 22 ¶ 39.) In addition, he alleges that the defendants have:
a long-standing practice of indefinite isolative administrative confinement of the seriously mentally ill through the device of mere perfunctory and sham 6 month reviews with a lack of a substantive and realistic brightline criterion for McKinley Bey, McBride, Nieves, inter alia, to meet for release with regard to their mental state and ability to conform.
(ECF No. 5 at 22 ¶ 40.)
For about four weeks in November 2015, following use of the
conditioning feed procedure, defendant Beahm and John Does 1-10
subjected the plaintiff and others to a regime of aversive condition in the
form of freezing showers. Beahm also subjected the plaintiff to regular
implied death threats during this time.
- 7 -

After the plaintiff was diagnosed with a mental illness in July 2012,
he was transferred from the Wisconsin Secure Program Facility to the WCI
supermax segregation unit where defendant Waller immediately placed
him in a sensory deprivation cell in an environment worse than Wisconsin
Secure Program Facility, which exacerbated his illness. The plaintiff
remained in mental anguish for 64 days, despite his complaints and
requests to be moved.
The plaintiff alleges that his delusional disorder symptoms were
purposely induced initially by action of the Wisconsin Secure Program
Facility security officials, and followed up by the WCI security officials,
using the conditioning procedure referenced above.
In a continuing course of wrongful conduct via use of cc and other procedure upon McKinley Bey in the Seg and HSU units to subject him to aversive conditioning through various noxious and coercive tactics, primarily defendants Staniec, from about 7/5/12 to 3/8/13 and 6/20/13 to 12/10/13, and Waller, from about 7/11/12 to May 2013, and Schneider and Greff, from about 7/11/12 to April 2015, and incorporating every defendant and allegation set out at 5, above, from about 7/11/12 to the present, have each eiter participated in, caused, condoned, or turned a blind eye to, a regime of retaliation and abuse to cause the plaintiff mental and emotional harm. The various noxious and coercive tactics used are outlined in Ex. 1001.
(ECF No. 5 at 26-27 ¶ 47.)
The plaintiff claims that the defendants violated his, and class
- 8 -

members’, rights under First, Eighth Amendment, and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Consitution. He also references two criminal statute violations (18 U.S.C. §§ 241, 242) and unspecified provisions of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
For relief, the plaintiff seeks a preliminary injunction, declaratory relief, and monetary damages.
Discussion The plaintiff’s allegations implicate his constitutional rights. Specifically, he alleges violations of his rights under the First, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments. However, as explained below, the plaintiff may not proceed on a class action. Therefore, the Court will require him to file an amended complaint limited to his own allegations if he wants to proceed. The Court will address the requirements of an amended complaint at the end of this Screening Order.
Motion for Class Certification The plaintiff has filed a motion for class certification. (ECF No. 11.) He contends that he has satisfied the requirements of Federal of Civil Procedure 23(a) and 23(b) such that the Court may grant his motion. However, under Rule 23(a)(4) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the class must be provided adequate representation. Because of this
- 9 -

requirement, courts have repeatedly declined to allow pro se prisoners to represent a class in a class action. See Howard v. Pollard, 814 F.3d 476, 478 (7th Cir. 2015); see also, Oxendine v. Williams, 509 F.2d 1405, 1407 (4th Cir. 1975) (holding that it would be plain error to permit imprisoned pro se litigant to represent his fellow inmates in a class action); Caputo v. Fauver, 800 F. Supp. 168, 169-70 (D. N.J. 1992) (“Every court that has considered the issue has held that a prisoner proceeding pro se is inadequate to represent the interests of his fellow inmates in a class action.”); see also Fymbo v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co., 213 F.3d 1320, 1321 (10th Cir. 2000) (“A litigant may bring his own claims to federal court without counsel, but not the claims of others.”). Because the plaintiff is proceeding pro se, the Court will not certify a class action in this case.
Motion for Preliminary Injunction The plaintiff has filed a motion for preliminary injunction. (ECF No. 7.) He contends that the plaintiffs will suffer irreparable harm if the injunction is not granted. The motion and supporting brief do not request any specific relief. Presumably, the plaintiff seeks the preliminary injunctive relief requested in the amended complaint. He seeks the following relief in the amended complaint: 1. A preliminary order prohibiting the defendants from
- 10 -

confining any plaintiff with a serious mental illness: MH2a, MH2b, etc., in supermax isolative AC or any prolonged nonpunitive or punitive condition of isolation compatible with solitary confinement. Prolonged is more than 30 days.
2. A preliminary order mandating the immediate release to a general-population setting all plaintiffs who have spent more than 10 years in AC.
3. A preliminary order prohibiting the defendants from using classical conditioning or any other coercive procedures upon the plaintiff as set out in this complaint.
4. A preliminary order prohibiting the defendants from housing the plaintiffs in the punitive AC conditions set out in this complaint.
5. A preliminary order mandating the defendants establish a Brightline Rule Criterion for AC prisoners to follow for projected release from AC.
6. A preliminary order mandating that defendants obtain, install, and maintain cameras throughout the Seg Unit that surveil and record in real time all areas used by staff and prisoners, except nonobservation cells, shower cubicles, strip search cages, the HSU room, and visitor booths.
7. A preliminary order mandating that all persons entering or exiting the RHU/Seg Unit be required to log-in/log-out: name, time, and date.
8. A preliminary order mandating the defendants establish a bona fide AC Program such as the Common Grounds Program (Ex. 1005) with a dignified path to release.
9. An order mandating that defendants establish a new Restricted Housing General Population (RHGP) to house AC prisoner in GP conditions where very prolonged AC will be severely limited and those so confined provided significantly
- 11 -

more time out-of-cell and to congregate. (ECF No. 5 at 30-32 ¶¶ 1-9.)
To obtain preliminary injunctive relief, the plaintiff must show that (1) his underlying case has some likelihood of success on the merits, (2) no adequate remedy at law exists, and (3) he will suffer irreparable harm without the injunction. Woods v. Buss, 496 F.3d 620, 622 (7th Cir. 2007). If those three factors are shown, the Court must then balance the harm to each party and to the public interest from granting or denying the injunction. Id.; Korte v. Sebelius, 735 F.3d 654, 665 (7th Cir. 2013); Cooper v. Salazar, 196 F.3d 809, 813 (7th Cir. 1999).
The plaintiff has not satisfied the first prong because his complaint focuses on a class action and he cannot proceed on a class action. The Court cannot evaluate the plaintiff’s claims until he files an amended complaint limited to his own allegations and claims. The plaintiff has not demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits. Therefore, the Court will deny his motion.
Motion to Appoint Counsel The plaintiff has filed a motion to appoint counsel. He states that he needs an attorney because he suffers from a mental illness. In a civil case, the Court has discretion to decide whether to recruit
- 12 -

a lawyer for someone who cannot afford one. Navejar v. Iyola, 718 F.3d 692, 696 (7th Cir. 2013); 28 U.S.C § 1915(e)(1); Ray v. Wexford Health Sources, Inc., 706 F.3d 864, 866-67 (7th Cir. 2013). First, however, the person has to make a reasonable effort to hire private counsel on their own. Pruitt v. Mote, 503 F.3d 647, 653 (7th Cir. 2007). After the plaintiff makes that reasonable attempt to hire counsel, the Court then must decide “whether the difficulty of the case – factually and legally – exceeds the particular plaintiff’s capacity as a layperson to coherently present it.” Navejar, 718 F.3d at 696 (citing Pruitt, 503 F.3d at 655). To decide that, the Court looks not only at the plaintiff’s ability to try his case, but also at his ability to perform other “tasks that normally attend litigation,” such as “evidence gathering” and “preparing and responding to motions.” Id.
The plaintiff states that he has attempted to find an attorney on his own. However, he is capable of proceeding without an attorney because all he has to do right now is file an amended complaint. The plaintiff’s filings demonstrate that he is capable of filing an amended complaint. Therefore, the Court will deny the plaintiff’s motion to appoint counsel.
Conclusion If the plaintiff wants to proceed, he must file an amended complaint curing the deficiencies in the original complaint as described herein. Such
- 13 -

amended complaint must be filed on or before July 29, 2016. Failure to file an amended complaint within this time period may result in dismissal of this action.
The amended complaint must bear the docket number assigned to this case and must be labeled “Amended Complaint.” The amended complaint supersedes the prior complaint and must be complete in itself without reference to the original complaint. See Duda v. Bd. of Educ. of Franklin Park Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 84, 133 F.3d 1054, 1056-57 (7th Cir. 1998). In Duda, the appellate court emphasized that in such instances, the “prior pleading is in effect withdrawn as to all matters not restated in the amended pleading[.]” Id. at 1057 (citation omitted). If an amended complaint is received, the Court will screen it pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915A. The plaintiff should use the enclosed form complaint to file an amended complaint.
ORDER IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for leave to proceed without prepayment of the filing fee (in forma pauperis) (ECF No. 2) is GRANTED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for preliminary injunction (ECF No. 7) is DENIED.
- 14 -

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion to certify class (ECF No. 11) is DENIED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion to appoint counsel (ECF No. 13) is DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that on or before July 29, 2016, the plaintiff may file an amended pleading curing the defects in the original complaint as described herein.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk’s Office mail the plaintiff a prisoner complaint form.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Secretary of the Wisconsin Department of Corrections or his designee shall collect from the plaintiff’s prisoner trust account the $343.81 balance of the filing fee by collecting monthly payments from the plaintiff’s prison trust account in an amount equal to 20% of the preceding month’s income credited to the prisoner’s trust account and forwarding payments to the Clerk of Court each time the amount in the account exceeds $10 in accordance with 28 U.S.C. § 1915(b)(2). The payments shall be clearly identified by the case name and number assigned to this action.
IT IS ALSO ORDERED that copies of this order be sent to the Warden of Waupun Correctional Institution.
- 15 -

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, pursuant to the Prisoner EFiling Program, the plaintiff shall submit all correspondence and case filings to institution staff, who will scan and e-mail documents to the Court. The Prisoner E-Filing Program is in effect at Dodge Correctional Institution, Green Bay Correctional Institution, Waupun Correctional Institution, and Wisconsin Secure Program Facility and, therefore, if the plaintiff is no longer incarcerated at one of those institutions, he will be required to submit all correspondence and legal material to:
Office of the Clerk United States District Court Eastern District of Wisconsin 362 United States Courthouse 517 E. Wisconsin Avenue Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53202 PLEASE DO NOT MAIL ANYTHING DIRECTLY TO THE COURT’S CHAMBERS. It will only delay the processing of the matter. As each filing will be electronically scanned and entered on the docket upon receipt by the clerk, the plaintiff need not mail copies to the defendants. All defendants will be served electronically through the court’s electronic case filing system. The plaintiff should also retain a personal copy of each document filed with the court. The plaintiff is further advised that failure to make a timely
- 16 -

submission may result in the dismissal of this action for failure to prosecute. In addition, the parties must notify the Clerk of Court of any change of address. Failure to do so could result in orders or other information not being timely delivered, thus affecting the legal rights of the parties.
Dated at Milwaukee, Wisconsin, this 30th day of June, 2016. BY THE COURT: __________________________ HON. RUDOLPH T. RANDA U.S. District Judge
- 17 -

 
 COMPLAINT
(for filers who are prisoners without lawyers)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN
(Full name of plaintiff(s))

v.

Case Number:

(Full name of defendant(s))

_,l,.,lo'----_,C._.V'----...._5_.,2."-1------

"-1;[1;,....., Poll.t.J B.;..., Fos+e.~, Tovo.y tvle.L, 1

(to be supplied by Clerk of Court)

J•., £. I :hebe., C,fb.v Im,. De S,J,.,;J.I.,

Brio._" G.e..fP 1 PALL[ c-"rt.,_j., Ues! ... I

ALclLRJe'•i.,soT.a.,to1eJo1L1..V,.(I

O'DoV\oVA.V>, J.b"' Doe.~: L-ID/

Je..s5ie.. r. SJ,.,_..tJ.,., sloOJile. M. Wu..U~, 1ere.w~y L.) !. . .,;u.,
Ioscfb Bu.lom 1a11J IMe. r~..wl Talon Dae_r 1-151 all ;.,_ tl..e.ir ;.,Jiv;.l.u.J. o..n.L ..N;(..;J. uf._,_;_.l:;u:.

A. PARTIES
1. Plaintiff is a citizen of -W!.!l.!..li~st..O[dl.J::n~sl.!!.l,]___ _ _ _ _~ and is located at (State)
W,lLf"'" t,,,,uL"'J t"'st.!...!i•.lt,Jc.r'~ PD Bo11. Jst,ltJa"F""•I../I S3~ia3.
(Address of prison or jail)

(If more than one plaintiff is filing, use another piece of paper.)
2 Defendant Wi ll.:..M P._tlA.!' J.

(Name)

Complamt-1
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 1 of 31 Document 19

3. Bria"' Fostll.l' 1 WC.l, PO Box 351, Wauf'"' WI 53'11.3. DOC..
{. T""Y ~1..1;,WC.I,PO 5.x. 351, W"'uru"',Wl5.311.3. Doc. 5. J""' E.. Us.:ku, Doc(c.u,.~,,,J), Po B""ln5,M.l;m,,WI 531D7-71l5.
Lo. C.O.{ky Tess, DOC.Iie..J,.J), PO Box l'lZS, ~1..1:so"',lJ.I 53781-lqzs. 7. D•. Sc..~"";,H, WCI, PD Box 351, ~"'r""''Wl531lo3. DOC. 8. B.;...lll G,e.J'F, \JC...I,PO Box 351, Wtwru"', Wl5391.3. DOL.
t p.._... [ Lulv;Jsm 1 WCl, P 0 Box 351 1 \Jo.ui"', WI 5.3'11,3. DDC.
11. C.."i\-..;.... \J.,J,,_, Wt_I, Po &.. 351, W""rVl' Wl5.3%3. OOC...
12.. AC.Rc. J"'"'~""'l Jok"' D.u l-ID, Wc.I., PO B.dSI,WauiVJ,WI. Doc
13. Tmie. I S.:.-~.-, ...._;_le..t-, WC'..I, PD Box 35 I, W.....1 , 1 WI 53'!{., 3. Doc..
1~. SlollV\e. ~t W.1b, Wc..l, p 0 BoJ( 1151, w"'"l"' I \Jl 53163. DOL.
15 Te..re.w..y L. ~~I>.VI<e.c-,hlC.I, PO~"'~ 35t,W.u.iu...,,WI .5311,3. Doc.
llo. Jo<er ~M.L,vv.,WU.,Po !Sax :-sl,kL..f'""• \JI 539£..3. DOL. 11. J...,.t~_,_<AJ J~"'~~~'Do2-s t-ts,lJCl, PoE,.~ ,351, iJ""r""''IJI S3'llo3. DOC.,
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 2 of 31 Document 19

is (if a person or private corporation) a citizen of _,W"-"-'i""st"""""'""""''"'"~---------
(State, if known) and (if a person) resides a t - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(Address, if known) and (If the defendant harmed you while doing the defendant's job)
worked for '[)!?.f""iMui. Q{ C..,..,d;•.,, C'DD [') PD !).~~. 1'\ lS. NJ;s.a,J1Wl537ll7 .
(Employer's name and address, if known)
(If you need to list more defendants, use another piece of paper.)
B. STATEMENT OF CLAIM
On the space provided on the following pages, tell: 1. Who violated your rights; 2. What each defendant did; 3. When they did it; 4. Where it happened; and 5. Why they did it, if you know.

Z "1he ff. ;,, LFF ;, be lJ b)' ±I.e ldwJ!I..;-t ;.. s.ufgcw. ><.. l.o, -kr""

c'), . . i~a l.J :"e.. A.L;()·,rt-uS,\tL c•.,J'II'II'..MI!.A--q-('A

U..vy k... : s..

~ c.,_.,(:' ,;,e l'l<le..vc

j.,. H..~ L U RI'.S-\-~1<-ti'lL

U ' • wL. e. ke... !t...r

Complaint- 2
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 3 of 31 Document 19

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 4 of 31 Document 19

'" -r~~,J....;]
"'1"""1 "'F,..JJ1>7!'! j1!.t'~""r ,~!'1r'' IIOOI ·x) ~; -1.n" p:s {'llnJ ·•""'"' 5" A"'"T"f

roj

• r f"

I :)_."'17fV<!j?f "I-I- v~

P""'.,T"~p

51

{)Vfl-p-:Jo~

f"'Y

rr·vv -on_ (,IJJ,J L~"'V'ff""'" r~J"5'11]7

"_l,.V0JV'0;7 rVV""""j"'~ 51"\

v __!.~lrf"l f:"n (,..s "d'"Jt v~ ji:.1::"."r ..,,J., """f<l"ord '"'' "'UT F"''

rnt-:J'(l h"'d r7~n"IQ) tA""O~fl"\

5Y'"·'r '"'~ I"" J j" ?Sn

•'1t v-<> If TT'"WV"'-o;J

yvry yv.tvnry "1f lv~ "'~"f'T""1T11 f' b~; J"'""'--j- u"Jt I j" d"Jlii"VV'"Ot"'~"V"'
-- O"'Jt If' V'U'-l:(Jt"'""""TL! "'It ""j I+V17nvJ "'1t "t ""210Z ~, n\ VIUo<""'fO"\
'r~~~ f""' l..,.J -~l1'.""'"Jn_, '", lc;J -I Yil"CJ "'"~"_[ 1'"'" ·~ 1""' '7"~"'"''<;

1""Wjl 1 "1lr""''1°S l"'usb! 1Tl 1 J:P"J 1 T·~~ 'I""Jr'J '..1-"''TVOJ"'l_ ·r

. ' r "V(I 5[J"U? Q [
5' ~n'"T' J" '>""''f f"'T"~/"'! )(; s J" (50£V>N "J fM' g1\f) Vl;f'l bv•.'n"1

f"""lr•(Tlt """''1t J" (t:""Jn ]1"" "JL:s OY,I ~vow:~·.,J~, "'" P'l ti

sr r r : ..SIJSOJ .,..,J qli·T·"'n_J "";j SW<'~r):Jp·~

"t

"jllj qV"V (}vo'1t

F'nl '""""'VJ'.v-J tsVY\1 f"'v l"'"'YV'",..,..!~""' bv!~!\ -.s,.,J.s. 'rJl"'tV'";:}

'•~T!T"" h1'~'-'1 ..., ,,_ n ·5"T"'!, L~"''.Vwro" 't'- wu ""' 11 I'""'""'"' r

b'":'VlUj j"'V ll"{TJ , t1 rsvpvro "r·'t''"J >'. rVlTl 1r'1t I >JQ('J01 VITlt

r•tvro? . ., ~t tVOY'f!f\f . .,.(;!~f "'•!f"n~o~j hFITY"'J f''"i" f"':(;'.'" 'Y

rvm "t "':::J:,...,..,TT"V\11 ""'"~ '11'-"' IJM "It "':It'"

tvulfV'•"'!Jvw.7 •n!f"1°~~

'lll'NV""J" 5 l"~--.•Jt-:1"-~f'iS "Y} •: f"'D h;) '"""ll :t!"'n '-'C1!fr7&ii~i7ils T

lN"3W3NI:INO:J .:10 SNOiliONO"J ~HilNI'fld

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 5 of 31 Document 19

rrt --~ ·t"'!'F"""";:J

"JV'9'SVOJI ,<""""''1-J!'-'l~l """j "uvYJ OHJS"b "'"T'I"J,J bu~

QY]t

f' -\-"'"1+ 6""~f'""'T'Cl 1~V10>JTQ'-' AJ'!'"''-l.J,_-;-~~'T' ""j oJYI '"'"'-"S'""'T" bu~

If ~f""r<'"VVI F""~A "'1L "s-c>jn-' "f'T'')\ lP'j('"' S•'OIAllS!,.J .ru_::~ 0 w~~~

f'-"" VYI1 '~ VlT>J -v j" tv-o-d "' T/1"T"'(IJ"l' .,t j" 1P' h."' yosn rVT}'

rvr£~sor ~· )Y1'1t F"'" I r'n-""1 ""' •t t17V (JSUO'"fil 11""01 Y-r.JIIIQS"~J

r:VJr'"l v: f""""'"'"~!~VI() 11'"1> ·~ 't"'nv--.m> W ~"1 f"'n ~":S 01-Jl "L

(~OOl"llj)"f""w"\"~ntv>q rT''"vv "f"'""' W3~f> \Jrt"':""\J
.,, (15YI>l,J Yl"-\ "1"~'1 f'"l "'"'-t"']""' yo£v"r"_,J f"'" 'L ~ ~"'<'lfVI- -lV<IJ ''tJn-w)}ll l"'"l":lll"'a'-"~ j'.t")a-VIahsJ 11\oJn r"f"77",J t"'""'T'•~t
/J CI~'-'"'V ~! • .t--rJV'a ot 'fv-vn.{, bus '><'"'")\" ,...,,_"Y)r :>"<!"'""_,..\ fres V
..It F"'"'-'F~ bn "'1t""'u<H''P"' t""'""'"'o"~~-v>a '1'-t'"l" "VI:'~'f"':""'IN' F"'" rr·~pJvuJ 'rut""V(J..r;) •~""'"\ 't:il-1 '"'G ""'IT r~ ""'"I rii'J'
'""'"f""I:J '""""'·"'"t~- I "")1-.1\ I"'T""'"P() Ij,f"~'J '-."t"'l"\ 'V'"V,QVV<J ,Q I SS<JI
I :1---w I 1""II 0 d 't"Vl.,f"'"JOF f'""~ ""~t ·t -z 1(16 rn·~., "0 a.... "UJ

(c0!71 ·x3J · s--s•"Jr [':_},.."'<>VV '1t: r'"l f'l'C'?V>'>Y7 W Ho"'

ry>7 .. s·~Jl,,,~,> -,,r~ VT/7 ~-v·,n S"'"-T'""" TlfVV ttT"'Vl"U;-rJ

""1t If~ n L, t~t )'.,.:}'FcPf"'"tTJf!'n s-non~r -.. ot 01 "j'tiJOVT'l/\

""•it [,..~'T"VVI ''P"Jf3 (~""+"'nrnv>:) •~'."lfUlJ"~ 't'· f' ""IVVOit ,_,,Jn

-..~n -'""-'r.~"'~ 'f p """ll""m ,,,.., on"'1" .1""' f"J "'"'!"""~ 71?

' ~-f"''T''9JUT

/, 1 !"if11brot

~ .nl .H"Q v-n

P"""'

1
J1'

T""l

v\J

"5

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 6 of 31 Document 19

'I 't -1~:-o] JW<TJ
r 't- -.~•.t ~~'1 f'":"'"~ 5~ /""""~' "'""'\ S"V") ·~I vov•.mr' 'T"'\f"T VII.

ru J"

f-"",...,•"j """""~ •t f",...,"/1'' f'"' •: Jj!f"!"IJ ""'It 77"'!S' (A!)

"C"'\"'1 1 XIlC)( P""' /\)()('!!!X X1 n"lt 1XJX''!!""X 1 !!1/\- !A f"'V'"~''P' 1 "J·r ••s .l.,
r 'two""15'.vonJ S' ""''"j T"l'j""""f "'9 S'<' usn 'tVl""T""';f'f "It '1{"ll'1t
'"T'."'"J.,.Ol/l ""' Dt r5oJJns S! 5''t''1S JV ',jjT'!l1]J ''11 (!!!)

'cJ•s ·(,,\"tv'J.)"'":t~""'J.S PW't"''"J r 17

!•.d,)"'.T''h"h.s vvw~ •.d '(,,<;G,)

"'"~f"~o'S ,(_,..~~~.J!"'!q <J.JV "'""\""~' vt P""'ljo'-' ,, Sl)SYlf'f',. 011 (!})

· -~·-rhr V'~

F"vrn\3 "'11

""·'(I' '0

f"

t~J 5 "'"·'

a, T"'... 1 t1 r., V ·"'~"~ "J f' s"'oW'J F"'v n~"'"" 8 F"'" V 11'7>f'lt

m""r vvv.Ao.,) J-.p J' ,Jf.t 'Q ...,~~ nsnr't5- 'V ""'!t""~'l"'' .J"

5"1"0:-rvfl

"~if'Q<Vlt f''"'I} 1 " "'"J ""'J " t""n '.,-; •1 t r " sn 1.., oJO\I'O-t "'1l u)

r . s ..,,."' z J')"J '(/ ...t
fU"'!j ""'iJ 5'. <f'-1 sA··r"""U.. f""' TV"' I ,,(... H I :sh-vrVJn~ "'CJ T' •.vo~ "'oJJ"

•t " F"j.CU;j pn-vv< V'OiJ" ()"\ ~"""'"''\ ("'l>l rwotp

(1'"\ :>QSOUVJ-;)

j~ T'"ll 'sA.,f",.,f"'S, 1'"~5t-orJj 's~"P""'Pf"\ I ,h,P":L '""'

>VTJ"V"\ \:'l 11...., "~1t "1 P"''.J"'-u-;7 " "\1 ~··r-~ 4 .,..."1 X"ll "It
r "',.,'\ t"'l 11""" o<.•s VVUO-'It'"''\ -., "t "~"1" vv~'1 "'"'~j1f''U';:/
~Jr,.,~JI.t 'J\j T'T''J"-'.' pLnTvJ >,JJ!f'\"'1~ "'11 :~o!pJosr ·g

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 7 of 31 Document 19

-, t- t~~-vr·,.'"J
!5"11"'!7,(,<7-nl )'VV'OO;nra ~~ or"J~~~tnJ V"! <;QO,.JJ\'0-3. t ~ r ; fl' V'U)~-,J -q (}!\Vi
l--uVorv!J :(~\VO<) VIQQ""'i -horV0<71fV\ ""f~l\ ~'\ o.rv T"~ ~<JV'"""tf"
f"1 \1") 'f'>~~ <:'"'"f"''.\1 "' 'y1:11_1\ t""tV'<r.J aK•Vj rii'II'YJ I .l'"'l"'"'~j
-:J y /()'1t" YJr r" .,f" ?,F.(,V'lT;J t •vo V'Vo7 '"'\ " o/()"1 \'1 : f:r'T'' "' ~-c vv , '4
r·1 (;..,,.v'lr<JVV II"' J" ""~'1 ""~...J.,r "'t rr1 q.., 1vv """T"Y"'! .r 'T'VV
-~"'"'F"'"Pi "'1t t."' "r5S07o\l' rvv~~:VV' ',(Jj'\ " W!"\ >O!VOT
f"' n '"~ o"'t ~~ t"'"""""~'j"'VV pb"'"l ._,J <,h~ ""r'~'>l ,~~ (!!/\)
•.J_"\.(!j"''lS r~o'~j' j" r"l\Clf 50~VJ
r"'V'07"] £"T "'~ -rnlv<' ·~·~<(17\o 'jJ<:1-roJVr<J 1-rmorV'~ vrv F"'"tf" "t 1:1 "'"'
F'n lr.r; ""'f"l">~ crVJt "'' 1'"~!"t"'!'VVVI <>SV fi"V'IIV'l'"'"'d It""\'! "'1t "': r(VTtilP' Vill\0"' oJV/ )J()'"V~~.J 1V -,nul WJ' _,.,1 J-'1h:\V'Yl5
t"o'~T "'f,..., o5~-c>J()Y"<) """rtng rl"'"]lYl o.JC rVl'{7 I ~""·lT""1 "'"'.t - "'\ ,JuJ ]""""'"P "'17 '1\"H ll""J '1f"f\J a"jf "'! 5! "J'7!'1"' ,,ll"vJo"d ''\\"~.,
Y"'v ,,"'"'f'"'""t P\1"-;~ ""JV 6-aJ rolt""'"' "t ....,.T'\vs~ f' t""
H
.ru~~"'\""1 rj\O'VV\ (1"'7 yvo& t"'l''1)<'" 0"]('1 "JV NoV'P5!,..J "'"N (!/\)

. oYV!{,.J "'"!f"\ "'! yah...." Io.J T"'V o~nj"'' ''tVl"'f"''>'f"f ~T ""T ,,..,"TT'""\

f'T""""' fll'" m•t'~ f' •~nvTcl1 (,SO,) '"ft'b "'"T"I\""s~Q "1'T"Ios•

rd T""'Vr t t""" "'! 'V'I)li'10JV

•t

~ ~ 1'1"'; S'. 1"""" VIQV"\ '""\ jj

·~1 (/\)

. """i"' '(\\)/"' (!)"" f"P!l ,.CV1'9J F" >w'fT' '"'t •t "'"~1""""f

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 8 of 31 Document 19

l' t -t~~--~~... •:J
tr~/1-ranA ~l t"'J~." 1fr1 """P~" "~-t v•~ TJ'rv~11 """
'-o\llJro"fJ"jT'f'""' +""' ur rVV::JQJ n'"(l~l7'7 ?S1'1j Tn<j '<>~"'VI!J fU":""t50" -yrvv :JJ'"t~> ~~ Pff"n\•";1 mvo o"li vo~ P"t"n•w

tvv t .,,.J" QJJ7 5"10\l()VV'"l'""J

(11L VIO! '9fSV10lA bvt~l/ll."lJl(V~-:

"'".'tnllT;oJ

tr f\IJOI

)>'YJ~ "1t JnJ rvv;Jo~ "II 5-;>V<JW1'7 ·--v"'vvon vo-'17

~

stj"'·r·:J , T 11""' T"'V J\"fS lPJt f"'l7 "l JVV OQ. ?<JO

y-J/I"VJ

I"

"It vn> f"t"'nuvv ,,>""<l"'-'"Y""J t•ll'V'O~f"P,. -osJ-.] · "(JY>'~f "'"!f"\1110" -('101

0""11"5 f" sp~s'-"'-v-;> vvop~~ oT"'"9\]'o~vn~ ',f"'n ks, ''11 (X)

• TtloV'<' oWjt ""~~>';750 vvo~;

()1117"' ""'t oj;Jj",..... "I >V.'""'l~ -,vv11:5 11'9 sny".rvJ~ '"'!jJJ'W'-' -. {"'\~"""

5~'T"'"f3f ""'t l"V1t 'l'"Jn:'i '·11"'('1 IT' I')\"'~ 5 rpvv I s..-uoy V'O &~:~V>vq

'hvo _,tV'<' 1

I '"''VVIV<J.r:1S

"t

•nr

r""\

"''"11

tlr"''.Jlt

'~

f"T\

~~

"11

(X!)

-C., "': "F1r'l sw"V.A,U,.\ r""J'JU t"'..,'D"" ,,1'""1'1 1 ~ V,. "':"-t,..._ "'!
"f"J!'TI"\'TJ "" r"TS f1K;)trv ""t (Yl"lr'' r"' a>/ll v SVil"'"'!j J (IJIA)

. cr·rur~ I !!! A f""'Y
''~"T"'(!!\)fvov (A!)Y, r"" & 7<1.l")~r'!")""': f"'.,..,J"'" ~~-. vo~tvrw!f>
j" 11 f'f'" "'"T"\ o:;• 'o"'F'j_""Jrrnu r"'J"1-.VQVV"'"':~ll'<> 'f.r.>"S
'y!S~")-J <1~11(15 "t rr1f15 "'"'~s"':"\VV"-:7 "'.1 5I h1"0Vil/t fJ'" 'v;
~-v<~"""P r'" .n-u '1'5o'J "It t"l "t roy"':f'l TPv S!VJ vo.J. f""'"'"-:1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 9 of 31 Document 19

-a r -J._'"...JJ"' "~

r"~-v vt "r'1J"~\ ffnr.r;J:s s'"\1 r"\Jn 'T'-,'jf" ~"""'""".J.-v., lr";:raJS{I

'-b 'jf"t;). r"'n

""lt

f"

"f'J )'"V

1 f)VVl"(7V1

1 SGW!t

f."i.ojlw,V'()

jf'-1;~

)1,. ""i +vovv-ov~~.Q,..~ tn<r "'u\ JV'~-~"\ LT'f'vrvvv' 17V' ~' """'11 (AJX)

• "(r,vv! F'T,'P!T -v
'·s P"lf''' ,,., ... _,~Y'l ,sH"l~ vr.J("'O''P Ylv-v ,'IT"" r~n llV O!!X)

·vv~f'T""~ j" 'f-..,"JP uYJf h\ "''JJ]llV<>J VIQ-oi -.~)•"'t -as!Tl70"\ trn> t""

T'~"" j"" Wii"Jt J' L,.H . Jl! f,Jrt"'•WI """' Tvf\ OVJi f'' ~"~ "''

-'"""'"l!j UV~f J" ,~-<> 1"' ~TrVi" JO~r"' yvv "'"!r""'.J"11d V! "'O . 5~"'.,"\v-J
~ 1f £VT"f!VV!V rsno1 T"" J If yoi"'"\"J "'~ '11""\ yon~ u'"

"""" Irr'~ns

""]('1 I~~'"''I"SiiV>w rrA()Y\11 snv~JQJ lffTI SJ()I!!US!~d (!!'lCJ

r . L-p7 •rs "'"T"~t·'vr"" ~ "']'I srVImrs i)P'""~fl V\rrrans ;vov

.J "' i t....,,. ~"'I' 1 'l\ '1 -'.rc>"'"'! vro fV1 l'"1t 'T"n'!; \?[Yl

(TJ ]P"1

n~ 1 j f' .nr:> V>

l""lf u"l--n b"'\.r"i""n'1f " "''1 (n1'1•l ~v!J"\ """J) 11t...,w J V "11 (!X)

(~001 I""' .,.J'IOOI ""3). rnyvnrv ]"'jb"17"f'l '"'1i"
""'1 rvrv I~! 5/0V'"S!j trn'V>517 JV'll I V>Of"<~"'1t I Jn -p> •t F'IJ""
t £.'11 -y:>~ 1 r1 WUt5~ :r -;r:rvv \F<l n.rns "'·~t v~ s-SQvrL(""M 5'·'1 "'f rn
"""T""""d v"ll 1"'17 "+""~".k s-r.ron{, C.J ""11 . nra>JYJ -;solt "'~ 't"''l'~""'\

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 10 of 31 Document 19

j [ - f ~'"'l_J"""J
aS'T" ~11-r>nJkt syvvnt -Ins VVJt (I) ;sv•o5'f'il" bv~~""ll"j "'t """J 1<>11 /'"•jt" tov> VOVJt"'~ 'JV "": '''""'anvJ ~"'"!VVI' "Jl'] 'JJ~f""!"'JJ "1-Jl (X !X)

x -IIT.7 "' 5" "·~s "~"'t t ""117 nhr-.J rUMU?j tvr

rvn oV"I7 "'.,rm---pv-uJ T"''{l ""~' "'~ su~VJ ,,_,

tvc; "'11 (!! 1AX)

· "'"VV'-v -al-a ;rv

rv' ~.Is r 1""'1 "'"!f"'.'doi

SVJ""'!J"cT.>YIX<J TV17 )?)Tl'r.}

"1" ij"'"J,j"OJ)l(l

r"t,(""1"Jd . ~lT""pJvoJ '-'Q tvyi'·\ " 517\ 11-q;) 'T'J"j (!]AX)

-r (""11"J J~ WQJj ClJ(Iilj').J -.rvj

1A'ITJ

elfl'f'lll)~

v~

W<JlA05~vJ

f'"\t

r VV"'I'A o_J -.ro ~"' Q JQ -r;~ •"'~ H"1-(,~ -'~ •"' -of\"'"\ 'f"'Vf""'-Pf 0111 C!1\X)

1- 71t rr"vv i" • () w

jQ ot, bh

t l1u ~ '>0 "'" j j._\Al).

7

"''""'t "t 7]\~-t "t n'"".~!·.-J " il·Pn!h~ b'1T '·TO"ll'l ~7V!\I ..J huy

~ J ~ ~ r r"Q ,.-,V'">! j c"Jt <'f? 0

k<l") " j VU V> I S(}TI )<

tV QV'll O!oj \

l y

S"'VIV',\.,.,1

"Jff"

l

t

1
WOJ

p

lr''1

"t j)W>t 71'171 15f"'MOJ ~{IJ

·~o"Jt

L.-mf 'Jf"'t' n~d .J'r/ -T"'·'Pf'" rv~ 1l"VJ ri)V" ru-.rvr L.~"l r ""'"'"~ >"'>JV"5~J 11' /'ll"1'-"()l'VI lvp:nO\fo~ ~1W07\<J~ 5r<lrJ 'i','YJ ["'1

!.,Tj ~w:V'()<'.ns -v /f'"l (,W;)d.)F'n s-;n~ "I()~ )!,"\ •v{,~J ""l.l (AX)

~""'T''"'~ ,rro~""' vo'1f7 ·~ •~s~n bJV'""f +~nl L"'."'1 ~~L•f /,'1 ifl''f"t"'no;):JY

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 11 of 31 Document 19

b£ - fvrv)J""•J ___l-.'1t ~....,t~"'ll f" ""''lt"'"Y" "'1-VT'\ /'JV'Y Vl<J5'(7;J~ Tl"" T"'V "j\1

s-J•"f "'1t

bv~v""T 1??j,fu::>

"""

1
VJ07i

tu1 '-v<~t 'ho"'ll'1 'S""!VVl'l'f'l\ 1

"l~n<n

")'-' (l JV ·~t 'a r""'?XO ""! T''oVV 1'~ v nJ 'Til:) lllllV)t ""'lf' • ~~J ~n~

r~7!~T"'cJ t""W" '! ~"It "'"Vl"~~J 1v "t T'T"rJ 111~ ""'li ::l

hn:·r"FYJ~Y11'T1 OVJt f"'1 r-ro"U'\~ d c:J •t "1"1,1 ~""'11)7 ~rnro_,J vmtVTYJ

"r-rrl ·~ "'(Jc>P'rl

T5 fjo'-'<1"\ It r'"l "f'""1TT -y 5.' OJ"il1l_ (I XX)

· t"'1 Av-oTI 7-JYI ~~ Tl"P

lrrr ~P""""T''0 r~, tl.JV '1'1'0 -vrt f -It' '

n" S>JOI\<>-~ "'i"'Tl pi V'~

hp ""'~t-v~ -'"""'"''-',.~ , '"~""'' b.,.,l '"''·1,..., 'r"'n "J7"S TlVJ ~n""!JAt

'"17 'll"" •1t'"'~tV'"VV' L:.Js ~1-rvo rrl.nrT" 'Jr''J "'1t '"'!Jlla ccx)

."''P.C"t P -nJ rul\-y "''1P~ l'F''"'<'l ~JQ\11-us~.,J

v t-v J /v>-v '"7'Jt"O '1'7'Q(I P" tv<OVV'fl"V')(d /,V'~('?Q~"'t 1"1 T<J~

'f'lt!J >OJ<lJ

Y"'" ()V'l;<'n aJ1111 SO>YI!t"""'"S H?li'(JS~J ( ~) F""' '~-;yvob-rowra. f"7!j<l'YVI ;F'

tvn.n ,! "'qH y"'l )P'-;} /,-,Vl(j~J()vv>(} "'""' '1""'\ sob.,-;7 7Q'-' ~., --.-"lt ('e)

: 5';i1''fo~t '(l1101jllJ "'! llt --;)o-.} 1N!Q'-' ;j W7>\.10S!v-J b~~"'"\ o-1 o>"j1P

s-rvvn' Vy\t JV'l7 Ili()r.}\Y] b"'!7J"'!Jf -.ro 511\'G<Uir"~ V'~>'tvrDV "Ul"W

5fl'1'7 ,,,_. "'T''" •'1t V>JVI

7'N ?Vtt "'"'F"Vl ())'1To709 I b"T'.J -.h'J

rv V" '\1 ""'t "'" 5V1~)1p ":<>"\t J-o 5070J F"'" ""''."Tl "":tvrv-.J

l't]'j

k cNYJ 71hl "It (7J .~ f'Ylr ~r~5~'1-J j:f''t> F'~v VO")t""'" flno('l

5VQ1110)!v-<:l Avvw l i t (h'OQIT3) t~s<J bv~vT\r $VQVIO'i~"" tln~sl7 rvrv

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 12 of 31 Document 19

'1 !: -V~"/~"""J

·wro·~o't -:JOG
rVP ,o·)lo~ -:JCJG "'t tV>~,,.,J .,'"TI'.f:V"J""'"'...1 "t ro51'Jh ~, r J J \f '1.{'"""/ t d'J "'~ os~vl S"<JV' .,t yo~ .,,."? t V!Oo '-"""7 rl/>'1' ~ I .JQ~ 17 r=mJ .,~"'t""" tvJ')'SO~ """~3 T"f'~'1"'"" o-l-o ·~c'-10'51 ,..,\ J'V (fi!X X)

• 1 Jl7d ~f" "' 'VVI '\Jt .f' V> o ~r"l n~vti l-,,. V><l~

"".::l ~""~ ~ ")S s ·t 1"> ~' "t r ~vv<:n '1()'(}" >Of' "''V'il L J" S~{'\" "''

~llfO"('J I!

"1"'17

s rvn por''")Jil aJfl

lr.. "It "'1

SJ()"<O~!J JV

(!!]XX)

. "J1'f lF;;> OV\1 P £.,.·'f"'"fS t"Vl oJQ("l hit osn~"\ 5"(Jf'"WVJ> 5JOJV">,vJ b"'~<;"jO" 1 Vll7
(..,~5TvJh1 1 fVT?>VVl<PVY"71f'V1'9 r""'1l~(Cl 1 b-,!r:n J\f "\t '1..-bnunt\, "\]"""rl n:\'1 WO>\'")S lT'H L~r"T"'VV rn~ (P1t 1'91-u,n_t""' tVI"1rr
>UY"'~, V(lf'"'"l ~ fVV\VfUVl 'It VVU"J 'T"~11<1f CZJ I ::S'O>(Yl0"]..-5 ~(1('1
"\f'l ..r~ o""'1lJ 5~1vY' lJt VVolT p~"""'j:' ~'7~~1" 5"iH,''1""j) .{, VI~TO<J~-j o)r"t "-t
vv"'lt (;r'~""""o Y"'Y 1~ ""'Vl'M "t JQy.ro "'~ ~lr"P "W"''F "l 0 1t "'! JOf'Tl OV\1 '"'.V"/In-11 h\so'U~Tio,.J 1'"" hpro~,..J (I): svorno1s L,~f~"u.,J VJOV1r<>
"'"'T'TJ'VIliV\f' :W"P L~r J'(/-h,. .L_.(TTOW'j ""'t ~,., ,lVIN J y "It vru ro.rn•l
~"<lit" rv jj~t"'rvr~ -oh·r-"VIT'~r /, P\""""1'-"PY 'f"""~ to~ "11 (IJX X)
'(("•Jol 'X lXX <><>..-) •~"~''P"-,,\ V>~ :S:I(I~.YI~ "JV

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 13 of 31 Document 19

! ~-t~.rvl.Jw"J
•lt b"'' ~ !1\""3-.J ~ "'T nl "'~ vrv "-'~ V1t j" "'oT"""J" f"V cno~T
-""t <!v~1Nr"Y7 l\""~'JO~Tl ""Jt ""j "1 ')!>"'.J,""3" 5"V7f'l -;<\ VJ7n> '\f . "/ljll/1 •t

vror'""JI 11/LZ/'f VV"j Bf'\ 0\t :F

J'7rl F""'\1"d t"~f'-''2jPQ "b

(s;oo r ·x-1) ·"rv '"'V'"''.-nl d'J )'7

rm IO/""rn

Ql -<).)('1-r"Jvrnl "t r('"lQJP' t'JVI 0-VY "~"'"5!,1 JV r;JJT110"\ I VQJJo-p

}'!7 1"""1 f' 'P""l vrt~"1 If" rr!..., s• ""f"rri t"'.'71"'~T '~l (X!X X)

nvv r•J .nLN .J(H,..,"J

rno ')lT.I n"jt ~ nl1"'1t ""'~' n f"'Y "'tt"VV\n

PF'l J

111 J,_ra/rl79 ~~~17'1 pv wro ~s rv\'Nf \JO('TH F"'n ''11 (!!!AXXJ

'It · 51J'Wl l l l 'Vl7"\.:J

...,~ '7\JYI"il ciii<JS:"OW wvvj )f'l""""J V"il'jt f" t'""~~

·'f"""3W'. '"'!J""-r;) rr "-!~\j 1r....., r"P"J"'! ''"' 'W" r"n -4"' --a'll (!!AXX)

.r f'""'JfT,J "1 osnpv ~1J....,..,,.Jl,t \l'.C'"' 5rV"'7Y1~ hs "~t h""t !";J " "'" £~~~'>5!'N ,, J'."""'r "" IIV'"t' ru"j ._.,
j i . WOVJt VV'"j '"!JU<'~ """"17Vj .JT0 ""t;/bv!f'VJ ":1\t o1'11VJ l\l"""~f] f"'>'
'f"JJ!""'YV Ir""">')''~'v.J 'f"vo~-.p oJY hl~~>oVV""''r,J :J-Nt f""j hs '~l. (!AX X)

· "'"'f"J"'! '·'"It F'""J""""" 1 vvoUV\1 "'! "'~h,,.f l'lt s--nr••m•.J

4n bv:V"V\.J ~'1 lrfY"\ ""T".J " .n 1F -'"'t 7sn 1Aojo

.L,~f'\ J '"'"

'IT";~ "'•TY7ll!rJ.c,f A"'"""' "t...,..J"I"' "':vt~·;rw '-t..,....f""'f'f "'11 (AXX)

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 14 of 31 Document 19

.r"~-t-l~'-("Ti'l~""\r'""'I "\J"c"JV'"V~\vJ "t -:>~7>0t "'"\ "VJY;J

"\l · .-.uT'l o> ~ p&"'"'J ov-J f'/j- aJ'I'<"">-rl S:

s:"\ J" TV!-vvvwo-;J

"''"lV]J

vn

l'-"'~,1 j17 d"ft JU ''""''~'~"""~ t--:r,JJT"'~ -IO paJ~1' ""0")\· -""J rl/)-Q I 5fV'(IlN"'~S5'!'

crt s JG>~ JJQ I ~f VY"I'Jr)~ VlOtr

\r' WI

VQl\<J <lV\t "'0 "\'1~ ~\IIU.J,O" S \ ""\

"P'"'"" 'V . TJ\'\ "'11 ~· ~Qt..4 !G. lr..-rno~ s~ ~l"t-.1 t""'fvraJ"Cl. . ''

I "+ ""t- . vlf "6"]

I""'J-"1 71)\U+ ""' )"'J

Oj: vv

tl"'"'l J,.""'1i uV"Vr'1' ~ "tt

'/'""'l,..,l"5~ yobl"'"\o-nl J" <P~r'Cl~ -iJ'1t bJ":h\.,....'JT""n CIW"Jt flY /n 5

J" ,.,,_7~\ J rrv :f'Jl"-'tT"l"' OVJt "".:1 <71'1~ 5rJ.su" 'tT Y'. '""T"' V(1tV\~

'sv-".'FJ'-v:> frv5 TT"" JV a~ 54--"''."fL'v;:~ JC)V>~,,,.J L~PTO.'IIii·' FJ""''"'J\f 5"
v S'Vl"TVOf:Xo .ru }U5VCIJ"~ "'" :5]''".'~7 (1"'7/JNV' I'j_IK(IW~ J Jl rJ17
_r<Wf I ~VOVV07"'~ J V ()'cl J YJ ootr""'J ("Jo~~ iLvovv-a~-r·J ·~~t
rr -"""P~vry\f V'1t bv:rvro:~<>~ -tr•.rnpv: V117>!j o"1i f' !"'"~""i'JOJ_,

1"'"?_1."551."' •.vvyv )f-.I(l/';" 0"\t ""::J "1'1~svroJs.,~ 5~ UV] "'!rm:; 'f/ ·,t""''50~

11/l'/I 'V"lt "t

vv""j D)1 11"/f i" vror.ro}\ ~·. V'Of'_] +-vror""'PG .()j

'jfT'TO\ '!t "'.T)'OT a"} Vlv;J VU~f"~">~ l'V"()r'V'Vl +-""'lt <'J'!I[TV 5: "ti 'jj:r?1'~ ott J -v>Vl·f'T'"'~ f"j"""JOJ ;f' Q7~rTI7ifd UVJt (-,.~Al""T'VT'J oSOjf T"'Y &.)
if n':-'~1 o.J )1Vll sv-v•ryvrv;l "'1t ""'J "1'115V1!J,...,, Y1 "~ . "'T' ""·r~
,5,....TYvnr.:> (;-;,) r., J'r/ "" 'r:rY~rJ,""J """11>·'"'\ /VI,("Q_'~..~ r'""J'tf :r
5"'0-'t""'t-xo VT7 nwo)""' .,.,.,. sv.,,,,_..nr ./,1"-'Cf'fV' '5l'""""'""'l~ 'JV :f' T'"~ f'',.T
r ',r()VV..,.. JV CJ'8J~)OiltrWW"J ro'I!O?J t"'"wpv-'J"'"J ·A~r"t':v:vvr\f

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 15 of 31 Document 19

>~ -r"'.YJI~~·J
V'1T "'"\'" o~ '1f''g "Ft"]uvv..,/,l_J """ <~ v"'~'"f"l ''}vn"""''\J -;JV "'J rrm·rr""'"""""11J<l~ "7Jvvv r-v''"""'"IJ>'.J r+-*-.A.vs 11"" J"
J""·:rr"'~-:7 i~,"!\ )7"" l"""'tV<J.It ...3 "'q's'""Js•• ()\ll' ~•'1t ,...,V't ""':wr 'If ·e,sc~""JJ-rV"S:•·'<)J~\ 1/'"YJrf,."d ""~·T'"u •'1t I S1 ("117VI Vlf7S~'"rl r r
'r51oz 'r"Jof"'?vi tn"'P' ~t -zlJsi/L """J:f's:vr-J JJ""C) 't"~J'Cl ·s1
. "'"!''T""s /"(,"~\ .sJ :f 'FJP l"'J""""'"\ "'1\" JU "-"'f"lY
'~ "'1 l ''~"\"T"(,,J --. '-y . -\ s~~"\ •")-:>~J jf't s 'f"""\ f"''ll SQ<J~n./QS r7: bol "l"hsJ ;J VIOT"'t'~ v:vv r' OVJt >OOFoOO 'II "(.n~d.)f"n su>:n""'S
)~~·1 "'1"~'d TI)l O"ll d" v-uw,-roJ"'~ '1 ff?vv"r''S" t""TV>'aJ'Cl ·rl
.'1t]-n"\ "t ..,!~"t "'1 VI"? r"oVV'<P'\rlT:J Pl"llT"S1 w.,.t- Lo,
S1t •-rvrrll "· 0l~ · VI"T"\")! yob"''T'~ I"'"V fro:~ ""'·T'r'v~ ,~"Tfv1TJ r"'D!t~t~P"'~ bv~ r:r'H" so,-J~\oJ .n-;~ yvv 'T'"J~"' 'JY ~"''rT!lf "";l "l1'.'"'11J,.., s-v11 o"J~ "\"'Vls 'V · ~""')0-r.J"S ~t~JoG I"""' ,, l'"'-v ]QQ
r "'11 (JYG,:) "'"'·tntTV'I tlnTV f ""f""'!Cl. "'r'"l ~>"I t"'""T"''J'G tl
. '1t ]"YTO"\ !j ''>J01ft1/5 '1 ?~ ~ "t
0 1 VI'!T";J -q:>~l'~'_,.J ....,'f"l"'~ '"'"l"j 'f'll-7()(1 0"/t f'"'lt o""M'<' "'\'
)."''·"I.JW";) ~""..,.,.,~,J vro 5"'.,~ ''V(tl b"':l'nr~~ s'-"o' f'"'Jl} "JOG JO~" hr•olt"""
h.nn]J\_,Jn~ \YJ""vro~ ~~ ""\'r<:n:;J~·-\-"fS ·"j\ ""J'vr'"'\ 'V ""]ICTZ kronv""l. rv'noro JTJ voo • .,..,~~ iCJG ""'l f" ~""P-r.J<lS "· "'vr~rl t\II"T""'J'Cl .71

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 16 of 31 Document 19

,~ -r..~r'Vl>-:~

rv" (,~~~~""J,...,

's-17)['1016 £~~r""T"'"J 'sL"t 'T"1""1 fr' t""JZ('Oi1"1 V~

lVl'f'-"'"'\ ""j "11'-""'~'" """"" 'T'"_l . }-"''SV',J "'1f "t '"ZHJZ Fv~o"l7 """":l

t~'f'\'"J I"'" "l'l'T"'B, ""~t "t r·J~m 'C7J ,1 h0,.,"v-v Y"'"'? u,f()rn

'Cil-\ "'"'\, ~T·_r.. F"'" ""'"L pv-v 1 VVV)"fi~ 1 -:>"~"'"fS 'tv.,.l"'"f<l\.1_ ''&]

'Jnjvv\1'17"\ 5~ d""T'T"s! f"'~""'f"...J J.""lt o""'r"' oJ"Y
if(!, · Wilvr<'>~J -J\f fo >~.'F/"'"'7 Co, /r' ro'l:"\ro><: j"bl""\"_j JT'" if' _L~W'_).."VV"f ""~T .nd "1"11Y·""J,." o-ra f1"" 51"•1J..-.Tv"'~""'v;J().J' +VOWQJ"\_J
~r •rvv '1'"'"'..1 •:>"'lv-n~.J ires 11' j" ~ rr ~V'V~j,_"""4- ?Jt f"'"
1 '"''!JJ" fr.s t,,,:"""J"'J 1hr ,.,.,.,s "'J -.,"~~'~"J""" """"' lt~'il · ~ 1o-z "+ ~ nn:
r"'no.ro """"j h:s v~ J. VO'VQ~V05 "'\" Y"V(Yl ""ll'T'\ 1'"', I "]I Ol "1 II Q(, 1\'10'1" "'"",...,P"' 1 ~--""'r":l "'s,, o'RJ,..., n.IT"f1 l"~""' "'r:r"'•...,~ '+""..,F"J>\.1. ·u

''1rj-.o"\ ~+ ':7\v, ~ fV"'F\,., 1 r'"'~j~-nl f"\1 r""" ov-vro-v """' l"'<'il
·~"E 1'()J"'.7J..,lt~ J' JV rP\"'·' 'T"'~Pr": f' "'T'"~ '(} "t L.t"'"'"VV'"
bf':'<-('W'-vro:>...,..,T '"'j 711~'>voj,,'" a""' 'T''Yj · u5'7dp< ~ 07"'"n~:Tl/l<r;)
"JY ""'j ,/\1<' !"•~.. '1tV'O"V' ~ fl"~ 't""'VV?7~JJ 'JV 5"7J YVVO ,,.., :'1,.., JllJV

o'\T f" -'nl"]VVu>V> ""lnh-r 1 fv'?;o~ o~ ~T 'llOl ~j:J:,_ vv-."j o'rW' ~

'Two"""' 0'1-1 "'"\] "'""~"I l'v.-. ""'~'l rvov '-:J'd)'r/ "It f' ~~"T;:J fl""' I'JJ"\

?VJ-j

'\'"

~~"'t_J"'J

'"; 1"''-'VI

"'"tsq)\

l'l"v

1 S"r"'

"'"'""~~~ ,Q

'f'"T''"J"Cl

'"'\

·11,1 ·t ..,~ "'T""\ VJV\) "'.. ~ 5"'f"' rL,TvJ

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 17 of 31 Document 19

"' 'C - t ~·-,.lw•J
'""1"'1 'F--z-z ~"'__1,.," t~:s fi""Y ".J."'fCTVI r~'~""'"' "Sl711 "~r~

·ru")p£•'t

4-"?jf'

"'~\ nwn-;-1

~ra~ "''

1
(.17\""'1"

1

jl,

jb""'"lt

t,

JV'

f"l"'.lt"" '"'""'fl'"'r.> -:J"f f"!-"\UJ! 'n•vv"1JJ<V5 lw,.T·b~~\ "JL TZ

· roop3 ra·r"tr" r--.'•fi"'P' s- r ~,
r"'.'W'" Lllnj "D'[T)YV F"" "P 110'1 f"-1'-""""J"""I"' 'i'(l I"T' "Qt"'! '~vo~.·pr
f'""' 'I"~""T uvn'f"""n! J'""J 5rn>lf~SV11 1'""'1" I 111· Sl p~ t 1·11 '\, j11 l"'t'~l

-.JL~"rvo.py O'Ji "t yusJ.xo /.,\ "'l"h' "'""'1 '""\ ""1 t"'\'~t" ""'"'n"\

-v

"'"h"\ "1

vro"l~

1")107'L rW",.L "t

1

1

7107 11

hi'".J.. .-!:{''"'!"

wu•;~

1\JM

"'1t rfl JV' .,, ~, r""l (.,~ ~r~?j.,v-\ r'"1~ h.,r ")"''r.> i"~~"'"'l ·n

."n ~·,~ nl JD <"_Ll"'J'~-:J'-'~ tr.~:r""' "t rV1(1Jvvuv Sl7 J.""7!j~"'.{,!5 f/"" ].,..,!Jhp CIO'

1"'"1(/11 />[- 07 rrvvi"CC/\"'"]'171 ¥>- ~ 1."]7 f"JV!J L"V W".'+7 """" -u>J1 JO

'rl'V'"" r"vro'., ..r"JP '"·'r

""'~F'"t "VJ.l "lf:rl

..1. VI'<IYVO"'!j'-"Vi7

~

OVJt 'ii'-'Ol,.., -1 50~'\"'! ~-\-''"9! \ T".h"""..r:J "F'i' 5 --<' s-rob~!"t 1 f'7"]"1 1 L7.

•tt J."" _1..,.,., f":> lv"':L"J"h~

t 1rr'l '1.,'"1('1 'VJ-t"'"nn .,.,11 "D""W'

"":l n Jl ""'t t" 0 V r".b.v' V1~ -'?J"'S )(IVVV' roL "I. j "'~ t.,<a ~'T"\ov~

11(1'1 <l""''1 •·~"'1" ILl -s1 r""-. rJ-11'1, ..J-17 rV'V"V' 1."'"Y""'JOf '0VJ .b,

~1"()VY'iJ)'"j1"'? •n'.i_'Vf" 5'~ rtJ""'] ovJ J r'"Jf" j""j VVI)?l ll")t
1 y "i)V'Y("JT/ >: "l;l ·Mor..1nhJ :f' JLvort~, ,, ...,.,,V1"0 ~ .""'"""'·'J

AJ"~ ,u.,.'Jwe. t-.tJl 1ttll<!.5 t'{ck,J"-'J 8e{' oJ .L L.tL<t<- L..uM"-~ 1/\~e_j_ wL'~ f"Ts \,;..,. ll'r 6-- '5.-<..inf'h;;'\;J oisiL .J' :><!.riDu.> ..vtlLvl.T.J t~11JJ''jt
~x,.~\,,L)..,.,I J re.~ot.~'f:·.J, .M~TuJ ;L\~x, AAe-J,J iaJ.,~~-,
fYcA-IJ_=.,.J '""f~" ""'e_n'\1~.~..ALl a tku L'stLI. i / ;t:eJJ ,

LZ. A, 6..- L,uJ ..~r<!<...t .J: \..c,, ;"leJ,·..:J,_, tSaL,J;><"-- A_c__ ""vl s..l"~/

J Gu,._\,: ,,J"-M.,w;:r- AA<lr-1'- t~-.~ 'L_l ~<; ,1 M<lAb..s: 1 M_cl.t_,r!{"'t 'B~ t......_~ a.r l-S
II
f"'e.s""'t!; ~,uc_;,.,1 k ~<.LUow;,.u't S \Au SicL.._....: .r~Mrk' r js.o.~-t<A-y----
s+.o_ss; (.,._;A._i.,,(Jri acu.sia.J.J j"'."'"' ,:1f,;);-", a.c<..As,~~a.-1 1"1e.ssio~,' a~ia~.J

"-'"or.._.,"'[ r-I..L.m-l.H S .J.vl11 t ~"v"-- F,,_[;..Jys; wJ ~w.vtr,· ke.Jri!!E"'e.s>;

l..osUJ1; M?v, UJ.LUwsts J ft''wJ aAd lli!J'bJ u:..le...~<L,- p=" Uv"\cL-:r;..._"t:A,-

'""1"-'"'J Me.A"'"~ arJl ve..bJ [ ~~1 Qc.£.AswvtJ 1s"--";._.,.,i,_"'{i,,., i {.,_'tF'se.v.s~tcu~t/

t" Mis-e.s ; kn'-''u.J;,d1 MLJ l'W""'us~e.jL!.cUJ -L di...,u/ ~/ sf,._... 't StJJ-flfL

o£.ac.J'"""' j o_c.C.A<l<UAJ

l:saJ-lt>AL~"'i:~.J

i~

-i;..,e_ Ahd

"f""-e.__ ~~Lcoo&l1 1

,._,.,_.J

i£.o'"' ~~."~:~~ •.:\;.M.s J"' IIU'\tJ..J ~...~:..JUt 1 s...;.w.le.._ ,.J.eo.T,aAJ,,· i L~e.r

j'-'"-b ~~-~ 1"'-ALl jb 1\AILVI ""j L.A~{ ;~,.,...._( AA~ ~;;-!, .M.e...t"'i)_

H." A< A l3

tk L e<>L'T' <!.Jru.3J J !.. :s IaAl ') i.u- "" i '-'> Ill.'f,II 11... C.

k;"(' J ~e.; 1

r;oJ" ul._ [,.J V\0

M~T.vl ;Llll\1'55 LJtlS L,.,..,e_J b.N..u...IJ 1bo/IL wJI....

•'fi 11.. b~Ls;._..,.J D:~aJ'lv ---l'vs~\f.,.../ "l'yr'- "-"J .._ )L-t.-_)J>c:J . p"-"'-""'J

D,<o.J·J..u. \1...~, },"t""S;J' «> A tMe.I\\J L.Q....[ \t cJ.,s;C:o.>.\{.o-1 \' ~1M lA,~

{}_ H..riou< ..v\!l..EI..~.J .U ...ss . lk,,.j' di"'"'"H'" c,;fL-;,_ i!_xc.lulu' htJ \oe,·"'J c<>.MrO..L'! t . :1 ,

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 18 of 31 Document 19

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 19 of 31 Document 19

0 ~ _:!.:':"I J"'FU"J
I fl'""/"'lVPi:J "'1 f">' I ~vv,rq1 l'n-J rV.fOjjY'vS 517"\ ~dVJ h]l'"?] o\t4

_T"1t

r--v

~vv I tyoVVJ

l

1'1"

VV'~

tl'"""""vrA>tl rrv" ''l"'~~""-' 0")'7 td

oSTn1---;J Vv;:J -pv-v ,J--.)1 "·r·7j,~~ <:;>' ffi"W rtwtJV11 '-'~+:f"l S">"'OIJ())

)\rj)Vl("~j r ''f-\)'<'0"1 O"Jt "t --_,~-x--oif y~ 1/'l'~vr""'~-t::, ,rrr"'_b""l'J,..-.-;,-o r11''17

r rQVI; ~~j bv~ r ·r" rut m t 1

1

WJW V_ll''-"0

VTVOV\" jV --:Jf'"l lt117 "'""'. \II>!

V1lp.l

r "'Z f""J--1- u""'M" aJll I ul'O"'Y, 't 1 - b l" t"'17 r""'JOT Wi'V' Vj--J"YI] .

'Vo.J1J~J ]JUSW'\ ![::!_b"'>Q- V-lj:. (J)~Vt11n V: OVj 1"'0/-'"Pj
h(Jvlt --X'vlf f"'':X"J""">.' "f"''JOfl"~ J" (.(?- '1'-'t"':J I"~ ----<' W~~ T_J vy>'vjf'r'
I ()J"'W,n>lJ' f'o'_h"l"r'j -p;vv f'"J.."""""jr'~ ~u~ o.g.- Lr7'(!JYJ 511
)v:J-w~ 1¥"~"')0>' rn"'T"1>J ~'1t rv I f1PY1fV~ hlr__lu-q-vvv-uJ~~VQ oJl7 ~ w~ V'()lN.J','"Vd yrv-v '"""t Jw~5 rfli'OVV s:"] .J.-"11 oVV("l)l uVV 1 ~"l-<jjt.v '""'t l'""
I <71-1 <;(I"G "'"T"I I F"'" (lVYI l\:lJV rvrv '4-rvv-vrs, Vlll~""'"'l.Q '---.'f"T'\
'"'lrj"\ Inrl()"I"S I vrvs£~~ rnl 'jf""J I""'T''fl 'qov~ I''"j,.' "'0-\5_3 '1' flllT'd
~--vrl1fV"JOJ f"Y 1 SW11tJW~ IT'"" S"S()llln~ of"'u"VV S\\1 f' uSOVJ +"''~r --.;> ~~
L,g 4ul"''7]-,}~ J' iLVQVI.<;Jl'!jli'1D ro1")<1:\\' X"\'11""0~ '?f v~PF"'· "JL- .s7
' sn f"'"':t T'" 'u YTf'~"I'I'"'1J~51A<Jt"'JJ~ 7~1A1/0vy;:)
'?f\'1 fdf" IJf" "'""~ <;"1'1 I S'Sti"'W rr"'"vv """" Jrrn~rh 1~ .rQ~JJ 0"11' 14 ~'1«'
I L-.g j,r7J?~~ --f-""VVO"~jVUV ""T'I 0"1~ rl"olo,) :f' P~Jra f""T 'V 'f' .rZ
,, )IY">'.fQJnS""' IC,-:1 ct-51"1,) itT'3. vv-.bod "~s V~'f"""''T\ OVJ~ f" -r>n• '1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 20 of 31 Document 19

f" )71 5 nv If)V" Ylltl I .,.,_.

ol"J·~ 0-;)

Jt "J...~~-,J~w':J

'+' ''"1-\" r1"\7 I 1 I,., YV

s n Q! 11 0 Vl

s T1 Q ~ roJ\

t 1 vv~'1 /~'l""'d uq~ £f"'J"o_'1'Tvv:~ CJl\!SJfl1\l1 0 sn FfY 'V'I""r'j

" 7 "1"'.' "'+ ~""JJO pOJUVV""V1 1~m'"'H '"11m 'L ""'':'..L '4-, ll o-z'n Ars.

r rr~OJ"T' ""'";) ~~~ 5non "'.'_}.V07 J F"'.ffJ~ v J,..'110'1{no,Vj1 \N~"\

vv\ ..,. L"I:J /,-vr:~>\r1 ~ !".. c,n'"S:[-1..) t'"'n SQ:>~IInG '1t r'"1t rv-w

c.. rr ~ """'t V'l p~r...,t f'-'Y <;OJTI-rn'";;J "'l")rlJ

7-:J j1l oSY] l?>n

r·j .Enl'V'UJ '"'~"M .f' ,...'..h....,r''~)\ o11~ KYJ\ YJVI/'">7 bJV;nv~tV'"OJ 17 ~ b'"Z

• () J'"'INOV> V".'_t,""""l"nj "1b i""!JL"'"'"'"j 1": rw"l- ht' I""'~

J f": ""' __.!:,.yo:' 1 j -j''S

w ~ 1 .rill\~~ T.,~ '1 n _JYO"" Y'"" ~ ~ '' yo Vf 'fl

.ro J Vt>IJ v+

l\T 'F r"" "i....,t" f"_6.VOVV' .I'I_VJ "'t rrohJ Vft:ll oS"")o~ J'l'-j P""" ..1

1....~. t,T:'i\,}J ,..,.~ ~"'.-nt':'-;) ""':l1'1~!"i "":vvp'1Y15 of' ~--r?l _, '1fl'l

~rut..., ·r;JJ J q')~ ~ "Jt .s 1'1{)1/f(P

v>V vv "] v>rvvj'S yr'

v>nj

-a>f7JW

]\(ll OVJ+ V] n-oJ '1-'\-

Jf ,.(11"-1-V'()w (p,u.•vo-s ''1t f' vV ''T"l..,~ 'T"'Pr'v: J" 717'r".J

("'-'f"'...ts'"'"1 -v ()]\'I"' '""'1..,, L1- £1 1"""" 11 'b .J;--. '_'b.""fV'OJOT "ll.. ·gz

. ( F)-(...,)\."Z)}O.~Qt ""JOG \l "t J,.,,.q,.n)Jnl _b."'""""'"~ "JV
v -pn"!f•"v.l L......r"n..., v: rv-. J f" ?<l~j bv! ""':"VV'II~ v~ fS"JOt V? ~t-Til"l' 1
rr'"f'j ... ~"?:} (,,T~.,}-1 't"'"~ J-r<J"W~ 'JC7Cl ~ "IJ ·wry .5"1Y\ 'LZ

· VV Jl"/'1 pu!•/05 j" 7j ~!~
r":tv""p1ns '""~'.....-;17q "' ...,,,"'1 "'9 ,,J JV •~n-vl"1! "t'"'::rorv•

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 21 of 31 Document 19

~r -_.,_.. ~...r1"'"''J
pnnr"'~ /-, rv5oJmJ """r'l s-vv-vtJ""h> 'IOJ"'5~\ r"~""''"PT .;bCJ hr'71 >)A ~""7r f'V'Y rI ""J I b'J f" I 0 0 I X] 1-~ l n ° P 5 ()·.fYTQ:]",J
"It /,~"''n r--pnf"'' ' i "'-r.J 1_,'1'~' ""-tv~ l.r;JT"'''f l~'l"o~'niOf
f" 5""'"'tJ""~5' rvry '17'"\""''J P~f"'\ rVI\7 "~·rw.r-vJ"'' VIO .Ot'

. I 00 I '') fY! F" "J UP 0 "?"Jt"l"Lj () •f\7 p5Y1 '~t7(7+ 11"\7 5(111t: v '100+

Lr oJ\~)·r<~<Q )11"~ "'f\ "'1t .f'

_:_!(J"'o'""'l~~n£vp r"lA..T"wo 1-...w

r~_!'c,}'"oVC

pvv l-,ru~ 5.f"ZU1fl

I )'C('1UV[!:JI fj"<'!JW

fO.YF\1"

jjJ_1.Vn'l~

o"Jt

·Hnv,, "1\o tJ5711v J1"v 1":1."'·'\ "_1a" f" aw~t.o~ " '"'·+" oAu rv'\i

-y; r"'JYl'l- ~ IJJID"f" _5l,V~YlrJ,,J!Q ~'f J'?J':I.IINS'T l~"~'j.Sql\v: n>
1}+ __!]J''OIIOJ f"l ;-r~j 'fO"'"f'.ru;J I rsnYTJ I v• ~....,J,..,t.rvJ o!O"Jfo "J"lTil f"~
"r '_3Y'oSt!.rJ "I+ 71/11/L ""'110j ~""'T"'c?jTl) ":uv!r ~9 j:J:_Lv~'T'\
~ ~WI\.V<>.J__)._Sl•VV' b1if"lTI~f'"' OVJt J 0J_'_b.'11V' yo o.f'JM ""'"11 bv>'>VVYJ

r OJt J'VV:I:J\J{)dnJ

lollP"j'<l'r _1.'\7 _1,110

P~

f'I0~_1.""'11'7

_1.1"-,fY<ljOf ~of01\()

bov_'_1._,11>J.n-J''! 1 "l)07 ~~en_~ ''t ~l_bVVt~ ~"""3.."'~ ~1{ g(~ yvn<:>JY! wu":J

'vvYJV<l'8_, 11"'~' I,S\QZ r~ "i -z.y\1/L ~'711'~)? VVN.:J 'jd"":J yrvv .fqr/1:-~vvv'j
JT'v 1,5106 JQ")"''""""\I,_l>"'~~-v "4- dTJ AJ_lT'"H'·"'""~Jt"'~ l1"11 ~ IOZ {""}~

/L VVP~j ~-"\­ ot L 1/\1 _j.Tl<'"j>'

"'H'T'\ I

0"'\t '1fr'l jY01ST\"\'\ VJ IV l __JL"IIl(IY<J.J

JV1 I,J>~"+~!w~"~ 7'1"~ <tl/01/71 "+ ~ljcrz]'1 r"''\7 ?.1/g/cz ~1 ci{r:,I/L

__j'Y1"'1l7 vvovj I Uo\"1_..,{,,J r'~ T"l""'T':S r.roV1~""' I ')<JllA'lltJS. ~"'"f"''PT

~':""vv.•.rJ ___1."'1 >j"T~~T"'J tr-'vvv '"J"!TI"f'~ 1~: '"'l"' -rot"'~ I.J.!'""""'"'~""o

~ ~lNV"~ ~ I J.' -;J J-t' J" I" O!J.-'

Jn f"'<'VV' I 5 -}:7.'! I

J-vj"P'_),""nf: I)7J":N""-J- "''

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 22 of 31 Document 19

, £ s~"J~""~J
'T"lr~ '7JYWd ''f'7lj -~ ;f" l'rrho'~l' s-nppo"' '1~\f'\ 'oJ"r''"'''Y'" Y"'Yl

r"'.'-vJV"~ h 11 v_.\-"'<~'"" rs-o"V'~":T "'"'"' ~tvro:Jo" r:'ll) "'I c. 1-.""'v"' 1TJjY\

~ ~ ~'T1 V' +- <r")t tn

v-ufv 0

"":J f' ""j YIAV'J UVJ.t

m " ' - ' 0

l OVl-\- < (Y1Q "')'\ I

J"''1t rvv' T'~~ Y"',.' T"'l1"d ').VVf"'"Pf 7. 1{ 11/L ___h.'YH'"P' """ ""\] . 'i?t:

_:.iTn-tro~ o'}j- "t _!.)on~"' ~~"] 5'511J f1 nur~ ha"Jt _A,") '!lJ"ow"'£~ >>V
"+ JP7 •11- iT ' n ~d 1~ V1 'lr"Tl7,)~ __K"1t nS:d A1 r 1 }Y/r1 rr""'
J I \ T''7 __~,_-v'1t I"'~ bI" :" 1 5 ~ 1"\ " ~ ~ t ,- bI"' -v "\ ) ,.p-1 ""1 __,._.., ") rt" " 0 J •"''1-t t~~ vny IJ"y bvT" !"1 n "'! jJ''P Sd fl ~t "01/j 71/"i { b "i

7..1/Ltj"f:, Q.""i'l' .r<> "0 . rjn.PJ Vil/I"'J' T':/('1 ZUu F _11"""
yo flOW "i o!f nJI'T'\ "t" ~'>onbo,, J'li'~IO~ ("J(}fi"O-S "F"""V "'1 71 {Sf b ot Zlj.5>1jL _1..,'"'1""' "'Q -t-m.rrv' yv_1nw ~"\ f0_);_171-'07~

)j\ 1": '1".,."']('1 '.JJ

JW"Jf <JJvO("'l _AY<JW!/"'"'-"Il"Vd ,...,.,

(ZTl J) fF~

1~"'.1..,":-rbr A.ru<."<!s "_r.,j •r--. rv.• w!'1 f'P""liJ i1"''lin .J,1VV3+-Gl~

_,__v:·n ?o\ UVJt 'voll'T'\ s1T',.'f'"~J3-T •vo'1rn F"n h~ ·~:J._,\05~

)1YWJQJ'l, I'J)I "'1+ "-f jJ)j"\ ')l17VVJOJ,5 "1t w-.oJ r'"llj'"''9Jt

'"1"1 "'1 71/11/ L Vlo '-;~"o"''!l'~ 'l "'~ _x-no p·~ 5"17 -zl(OljL J""'0Jy/
FY"II'CYl'T ~~ h.l~,./),lrJ ~t ""117Vj r".kvrow o/j- J" ojYn'7"<a ·I~

· -ovnp-, o,) 7»
o!1"~-r 0'11- l,.~~~n 'r"·"'1Jf"' 1rVT1700, TvM "'1t "~ Jq<w'"\1"J
T'"'V '5r·7~S" tr'TT7P'S J d:SJ\ uvrt r "'".'P"' il .t;11"T'v'

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 23 of 31 Document 19

, ~ ·J..."':"r.I""~J

rr-v .r/VfYlOt {)VV~ o"lt

ol'YVj

\IY'...rJ"T ""~t W'"Vj("l rr' J,Jf\V':"~ r oS<r"Jt . v+ sw:"P

v•wvvo;;~ oruVJ" "I" -.f'_('l·"JOQ r" Iv)\ OVJt f" <rwu;~,.rJ -;} V •·"Yj

1"")7 rvryl f' tlft()>o,.J

)>V \-;) )Y10-IQW'11Vl

o r j -.)lllU"j -v7 s: otm]_L . } t

• /V ~~-, '1~ 7' ny V'~

nlli'Y J?:p rvo'(l "'t' f-;"'"<10 VV (I.{(I(") 1

"1 1 V> 0

~I _j,...'V'O"'-"'')

f'l/111~ t ~ VV'() TJ"'Y

r-:. , .!.v<()YY' r"'" ~"(! ("1"1 -s yon-'"" ,,,_1"' .ror~ j j T''~"'~ 7Vl1 -yos nv,J

'V)"W"'"' "5~. o""~t '"'It ,.,,_...,.,-p T'"'~lt "'lf'"l' r~~vv: VVJn'-o" "t

L.t\ i.,l ~:">1·}~ rr~"JOS "'I"' YVVJ""'g . Yvof"l<TVt,S bv:mJj J" ""'-"'j

"O"V'Jt ~: b"''."'"!f.Tvru:7 'dn~YVc!~V jU llVV'~~.J -v "t Sv3VU5~~ '"'\tQ ywv

hg ~)"'-')f,hj T"f'"~,n~ Ql-1 "'·o ·r VlV\ F"'.. av'l "'lf.r" VV'JV()~ ~'""'"'f"'ojOT

"VP?jj" ,,j {...~ ""\t 1011'""1"'[, t" fno f"S' n>o.rn-rvo,.j F""j 771 "'\t j"
0 sn ":"\ b~:~o))"j" 'c;l{S"Zj\\ •t r:;'}\~\ VJ"Qil("lf""l r'>jO'W' :>non""!t"'VJ f' f'Wf!'
II"J r7TJl'VIU';I \"j'"'·-'("1 r "'"'f"]OIJI '"T"lnl'VIn-;) '1A~nv:tvrvv _...,"'I -~r

.JZT)J f'_l:,.'frt' ronow ""' ~ 'j,._'io1l1T()J 1"JV17 :.tY'>'rLCTJ V"1 tf"!j,""T't>:"JJ
/.,l _,,(Yf p/ ""J _19"0""1f~71ffVV r_l_FOVV rn, fV:'~'W<IJ "Lf I.N:Vj
r('10n'P t'O"Jt ~"""'~" \N-1'0') .:r ~P~" ""'5':1""37XO VI('"'"""~ "' l.""f 11\.-'~"
+.J f"1' poVI fVvVV Yl'"J Q"~t"lf'O,j'S(j fV'</ {" Wlllj rl\l.rtlur hr5~" nv;J
,raw I <JIH'1" '1 ~ (IV'E'.,.J~,, f I 1[sI/1, "+ (._ \/11/ L W1>.Jj I M rrv'V

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 24 of 31 Document 19

t~ -t~!Y\L~""J

r r r VJ[>HJ""'

1""'50j " •t vv:l TJiW'1~

''JfJ'fi"J r-tllr,lW' J" 1"''"1

_ , '7~5l1'1 '.'1 "t 7\5'.~ +"'V>!j:"~~_)--, nsod I hr:;-)O?QV\ "J'I rvv~v~w J w.'V\

.ru·~·-Jor ]"d.JO L;-'""~"'0 f)I'T'VV ~ ~f'~r\V'l swo:Y'r~u;J .,~!t]"""' \T3j"'T1

J v rorrs~ ')l'l""'fOJ~ 'ro'A17\"..J "': lr.'d t.,T"/.\o\;--1 Jrt"':~J~ n'

.rar:"' Jr· .r,}lr'T\ h ~t jVT()VV' ?V!j V'v;l

I

l'"'"

vp& f"'17 I 01 - l nu\1. ~ VJ"' I

r s ''"i- J C!JV rvv '""'T")I . ,Q WVIIWV'O'! •V'U'S{, ' l l 'jJ'~"''J •trwvr

I m~ "''~"Tl .:r·H. ""P"J I r.roll 0 d '~"'~f~AJOP j" "'"' 5~"'1' '"11. .'K

'(bC701:)7L-OL"lll\l"l'"'ll 'l 'trd ·n OL '1"-"'-JS rv'{ f"']Pt"'I JQ

,~J~ -.'1t '"T"""'1 f'1t ""T'V 'T'tS' F"'~vby '"'.T'"t"d ',t"'"wT"'"wV ~''!j
~t f~~)j """'T : Y"'"""'l'~~f"0 A""rrs ;JQ "'"Tl"'"I t,~"'"l'P'H ''U f"'Y "~vis-.Cl
At''"""Y 'T""l,~~ ~'..JJ"I 1 c6~~t'""''.'T 1 "l 1s"r"""~S)("1GQ0J 'ZSS 1\ZS ·s n ~he;
"t r '<1""'""\1 ·~ J'Ylil9 .r".j-"'9 r!jf" VV17•j of\V(JSi).J J IISU~_,.rl "'1t ~
~"Jr j-vro""T'-.""'V P"-'j ""'t J" "'•:rr:n "': r".J~ rn f"•n•r·~ !t' oJUVJ~:5 OVJt -"T"f\"'', r·\+ v>o•.ry •rt~ t..~tTPVv;J I ~-"W""' r,.,rJ~~
,..,,,_·p~t"" 'U,""'tlnvlf'!"1>"1'1~rloJ -1-.,.."l..., '1"'''1t '1-'"'as,.,.•'"'"""\ •t
I,:J'!IJYI~ '.'1 "'~Jn "vL!Jj'V': 'r'T")rl "'·~t711 o':'\jJO S\ I l""!~""""'""j"~ srr>ov-d

"t Afj!'r" S~"J 5J:-JV"! -rvrv l,(f\"1~ T""""'""'v! 1s+v"wr-y u'·5r''1J

rrnJ vv: vd () J 0 r _J,.vq "'"' J

~ --yv' -v 'V'

!7!11 0")0 ,(

V1>~ t f" ~ v-<> I

f'VVO I

Vl()n'

1')-'; J

fJII"'="'Jr t" 5+n~ CJfil.5>..-nrtl VlfV'0'7]-.,

W\'1

V'\"0"'7j ~!"'\ "f''T'"""Xo

V'T;J A='ll "'"l" rw~t ~ j" 'FI r l7 VTO'I. f"JVS~ )"T'J"l7.ro J'V'Y If tVdW

]" - ""'"./TV'? I r~ I r),J ·r~~f?T'V''. 5"'·TrV><>-;J .rar"'" 'JV ~: jJ.'f"'"lJ

J1!

£) J'T"" vv

t • 0VJ

1 5Y)1]

• t

5 f"""'J"JOf

lP'

JP

1 /tO

~'

~

"'JL

.S <;:"

"~O]Hl lV~Tl

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 25 of 31 Document 19

n ~ - f"!"r"""'"J

)r T"""'l"""'"'Y "W'i1] '"1t l"v '·Cl .:l""J ')f!l '"2 )">Zl'v-o lrZ ~~
.-;) ·s- ·n Yl1 "W_L iJ' ro~"J".'~ r! _hiFil"'"VJ$•.n£vv 0\Jio~f'wo f"v rJ..~
psnvrv Y>'Vj "Y':")rn j_YT05"'QJ fOW"'jf"'. <Y'.llj _ln""lf\' ko<J. /,.\~7\ ;H
ro ooJT'_1'<17UJ bv:"'o.'FjV'!r.l u·'!"'J7 I f05Tl 1r-M~~ ""I rwJtVU;J
'"': 50-l""'~f"'"'.-v, J~t r'"''·""t'r"''Vt"''.vvv'rtvoVV(I\.\w,. """lfa
l voso-nl OVJt "t 110Z 1TT V(Jof"'lp"j 's"l -I ~a VIIT'l f"'" (l"l>T f"'Y
/ VV''1\7j\~ I '"·'"'"t:S' '"Wr\ I voy:>VI'Y"S I "YU5~!"1'"l 'jP•<J ':r·\M li"'T\"d
~".,f"'"j"f Ff"Vol rY\j£"'.."M j" U)QT'T'.I\ ""~t"lnvvn-.,-., \I)I ·jl,C-

'(ELl\ .kN ·aT1) WZ 1S"b\ n .J~ns J h

1 L~, , k~,.... , • ...L-rb~, tvo,.,rvry lfT(j"\.rn"J, ":Y) f' f"0 'J,::"r-u:r-

...., I t;nltvtw;J Vli>',J OVJt "'. J'.VJoT./Y"\ __L\11""~ r.vvl: s fVY r~J~ yv

lll'll >! .J.""OVPII"'~ j "'lr.J ovn-3 u'lO") f'"1 po "'T' ~ ht JO"j~ \ r~f"vJ ~t--nn
q.f"l" --v ;;-..rohb~•t 'il."'~"'":j-SoJ 'T"n~ J" 0<'':') ""\ a+ J_~H f"fVilt".,.J

r -<7 '""':"\ fO_lVI'OJt 51}"\ /V"]:,."ln+o~ {,"1 "1t6 u:t

'_rL'V'11VVI'J,hl.nh'IJ

rt"'"w r"' w.rvl j" ~~I.JI ro5'11<JVJ~'. v>'<' -P-"" "":"] '"'~ttJ r~v :,"5("70~1\CIJ,,

'1tvurr '7J vv"'ll p'v ,(""f'"'nifvod bv.Tf'"'~ 'rjJ" bv.?-"'JVl• hlfntnvv~

v -v {"'~'TIIVJ '"""'''\:~ ""f"'TI J J"fj~.' '-..r\?W~")' '•rv'f"VV'· "'~ jj.'t"'~V~

-.~:jVT17iJ 1 '""F'J t-Jw," '"'f t" pwv"' 't~""'J"f ll'" f' "''!fi1Y ""11 "LCZ

("1001 ... ] """5) '(LCJoz·~ ·a·H)Iil~'6L "''pc;1 fl .j,},~ J b~1
'vaTl"'tS .A "' 05""~1T'\ \'ti7Cil "'T\ ·a·M)SIOI'l.WI rz .JJns ·:1 nz'~·~"'
.n IIN71M011" j !( t O\JZ . 'T'\ .G M) s z-"J\1 I ''7J,QI Tl ..lJn-s j p"J I '~""lid " 1l, ,.~T
'UhbiJZbl 1HZ ·s n IQS'""r·~ ·n "'0 '1Tl !(HbOr£1b'sn ·s·n 11s 'vn-V'~Sl t ·• •.....vv>.rv' "}~! > v-.vv F""""\1 "Jf ~! J ':vj J" v"~f'T"~II "'. w ""'1 snu•.-r.>s j" 7J'.'v

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 26 of 31 Document 19

"' £" T'~vfl'Y<'J

('".T" hZ"""J "ifi)') 'J-rb'."__!l:'"VV'T'..,.wV; "H vyC~j V1.'1 .Y JV•]>--.QV.'r~ JV'.

VV\Il71 fV"OT'WCi yr"'~ o..i""'vv h.eg, h-,F~?H •ST>"YTJ "t ls;7:rTV1

rvrv YYIU!JIVI(l

(lT\?..r;)<r,J .JflU'~.,..,f\ yvv/7-;1 I bv~vv~t~f"'""\J -~~:>"?]\>'

-..tu (JVV~hJ ""?11 (J5nj'i7 f"'V fV0 _;j_.n?T"JoJ j"

"t1
-p

f"'!\j '(} f"VJ""t

""I r'"'"'Tvnr,;> 'p~YJ lv: PA~'7~JVJ 'c;l-1 '""'( ""1'1._ J oVT>!_L j'Y

'""'J'il~ 'vv<;CI'T1 1:\''H 'f"T\ "J 1 jJO~'J 1uo;:a"'r-b 1""WT\ '-ro~"'...t'S

f' -o-nTin r 3.."'-<"r'""~Pr P'"'r~ u.nr_'STij"!J

Vl"~P.r! ~

._._..rr;] ""' " ' ] .,

'1-V. OJV'O""V It vy£!l •"YJt J" "'~~PI• ~1\ ~'-' . W'"'") .:f' 7f'~J rv ~o"'7) /" _j,_'Vl150.rd ....., v-l-
r r "'":'1 rn ~ '1 n-s r,v 'ItJllOVj CA..'V<IVY' J' rra.I "'~ s..,."l ~ '1 .,t s 71 I J
_LT'"l'':r:i:l , pw·Lhr;rsoT<l"' -a;p I uvv~...,_vn-. f' vv•.VJ r1\~.,.l..r __1.---1~
.>v>oT f"""1 (""Y' "~~ L">Vil'> J\""""""J"s ""'J'"TTl J:\~'·""'~ j<P""""l 'l1/r;;, 1} b
"t Zlfli/L """<'1P'1 'ral\""f'\ !W" 1 T'~~ 'rnlr'd '+""'f"P'( ·oh
_:j.vo"""/""'if 'ft~-'J "v~ jJ"" '· 0 ·J."v ~p 'lf,l__
,r: j" d'-'"".'1_ I\ "VI: J_""".,.., /~'>'."bV>v O""'"T'W(} J-. rJ,..V><J'VV' w~"\ fOF'Y7
T-:1'"" f n~ 15'1f"""~t '1-r~oy J"!\--J"".' f' vow:t,,. .. "1- """:"\ T"-["'"~4n5
"'I" w")-vo~ · '>JOf'1""1f> bv~TIOJj f' ""'""':l ""1\ "'. L~vro~t'1'VTUJ <Jil'.S"<!nY
vt j V1o-N1t.~ "V S.JOVjr F"'"' Ira~ hr'7H~ -rr"r1n5 I; 1-1 .>'ii"CC
"'T',l_ T"'v "~ }""' 'vv·vJmSJ .J.-."'"T""Pf "'".TT":~ QIITT'""IT;) -."'} "J:,£

C. JURISDICTION
~I am suing for a violation of federal law under 28 U.S.C. § 1331.
OR
D I am suing under state law. The state cihzenship of the plaintiff(s) is (are)
different from the state citizenship of every defendant, and the amount of money at stake in this case (not counting interest and costs) is $._ _ _ __
D. RELIEFWANTED Describe what you want the Court to do if you win your lawsuit. Examples may include an award of money or an order telling defendants to do something or to stop doing something.
A.. lrt.iundive. Re.lie.t
illll'\ill i...._ surJ'{IM.\1. it<li.I.J,~e. AC oi' ilVt.J ral""'J~ Vlao/lr"'-',tiviL a.1'
f""'i·Lue_ c..aJ>J;-1-;,,_ J.' ·,s.,LJ~<~-"' c.a_oi\Ar+•~te.. u.Jitl ~•.J,-L.,.y
l. A fJ;""''"'tw\/ aJ'A.u f"--t..~~n.t;...,_l -!ke.. 1e...l.ve..r--;.,_J, lt.L 7 , 5u-v·, oJ'o -1w.. fi?Se..AL..1 of ~MeA!, L ~1' L,!e_y B~ i<~ "- Wl4-14VLV wiAue..b/ "'"'/ 1L~F r~'"' !"" ~ re.ule; lk F4. Hle..l :ulje._J) \,1 A. fucul .J'
.s.e.lleJ-J .se.c.a.Vl.d< t .~. .vuJ 11\A.'"'"'JI!..<: ~,q_JQJ'e.. ~k ,;u-.·J. r:.al lJ~vi!.J-V·
co_aAL ....t ""' o..HL,_~...e.t rjl()
Complamt-4
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 27 of 31 Document 19

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 28 of 31 Document 19

-., b- t~~"/./"""J

Y"'" \;101 "KX] o-a>) rf'-""IN(}'q J'" j~:l fOT.,"fP o1~ I"' _1"" f05

r?.' :r 5J'111~PJOJ

•

il

t'""'J 'YVJt j ['"0! t_J"r G,v n r., V'~ I 0 SYi>pJ ":"t "\U '"t

1PJ r~ f'"~'f '{] If('"! vv<>Ao~d Trno«J VOVV"'V"O PT"tiv

v t 0"/f "' rns \I>"I'~"Jd ""J

I~·.,, '1 '"f! j 'IJ\h(l"\ "

y :>rJ \A'Ilf"'"J'T

""~t rr Lv ~ lPVJiN ror"' t~" "'"W J .,..f'l rV>Y r.ro .ro .L..,...'VVli"J v -s

·o-r*,:~"\f f' Fll,, F \ISIOI !-z.roJ'-z·d'UJOOI

·xx 3 -.os) '"""""!j J'r/ IQV}r '1}:n "J"'£.rf..,.v.J 11t rv" lf""J_O"_..b..m

r r • vv!t fl1U'V /,'(L"V>?f:'A..,

"".J P"'T"VJ vy .,o1t prr f'Tw~ I

wrn 1oJ(l/\(l5 ""\

J'r/ r'"'"I",J ~Vii{\ <Ni!Yjf""' ,.,."Tr"ii dJ VI!

s-J()vn:_,J J\j v"'"'111f (d9H'8) f"n """TT~~d J""<l""':J bl":5n"{\

p ""1 f'':'t~ r'<'VI ,. "J"!IT't><> !(Lv"r"'"f'T _P)t 6"":'./.''j'"'ITVV ""T"" VJ'rf .

. JY 1 l/VfN (J>Vi>r-i
rr.:·.J "'j i"1"''T1d ""r jj!t~::r ,.~ "'"'"'r-u 'T'll ""'~lf11~~sr
__,.. 'F]I"'p<l '.f""'FvroJOT _l.,1t trJ."fV11JVV' ""f"" ~v-vv~w·p.J \J .£

· o"YV't]"~~yr L: ./VII _1 f1Q r-vu1 -.
L!f"""J"j ~"'l"h~ ""_fYJ"""Jf' "(> 't.rv:J f""j --q f" _tiJIOY:J ~t VVO"j f""j
{,_,f\Vi!.S vv-.J j j:rvp hvp t"'.' t ~ '1''1 o,-J l1 JO'F'IJvvun-o "'1 ~ '~'11

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 29 of 31 Document 19

, r·t"''.l'JJW'J
'f"o:r- pbr--"\""j f' "?~f"vJ /'.1"""FII'Of1 f o"lf J-rqlt r•TI>~I'\t,. \;} -~
·j2"aw><P"~ --:J'rf f"""''t"'OOJ bl".'r.TJf\Y I"~ rv ''J'rf f "''~
ll":u~vvvraJ "'! tS"'il""f"~ ~t"'1'] rr"t"j "<' j]!f"..,\..,\ '+'"""'+ (T)VJ£.,..,~"\t
(vJ;!JpCl'KQt' F r'Y'W'i' "JOG §8 '1'u 'VIT\i '!Jl J--,t "'"'T"rvf"G If ·-z
-.,.~'11:, (j,_VI~VVr-f·Wv /f"'?"t"n:J rwv'it'1£.'] IF"~ .'Jff"':'<J~
0 '17 T"f'T'~ ~ """.'"s~vv>o /"7'<7 "F 't""'f"''f"f ?VJt f"'1t vn>~r""FO V ·1
t1A<Iwhpnr A"Qf11-1Vi-;J<~a -£1

·:1"'r rl"'ll
'''~""!("vY"'-' :ru-boJI~-Lo] •t r•:n~v ""\ rvn hS"/Oft'~ "''1t
bv_'r:nv/bv:"'T'o Jf'F Jr' -i.-vv\+ /I":.K"f"'""" ""l'"" ~""'"'!w.•p_J V L

' 1 t ' k 'S'1f""1 '~t;>~n /"'V 1ovvoJ nst-1

")">NOS J!'p'nf"~"jflJ O<J(''JO'")S'']lo.1

t, rm "";f"ns"J""'"VI ;..'l<l'5""v~_,vJ JY" dd"'P

o~'t ]1"' 5Y7i!JVI

j"aJ

"''. f"=3" yvv I"'~ms f"'1t f"n hr;;, •'1t r·.f.·J'1t '.NJJOVV"<T'J "':'l"'~.,""

v rv<' 'JrtSV"'. lw"T'l" T"'"FV<ljOf f'"'\t t..'.f"FV'""<''f\1' "'fJU h.rv,:w:p-nl ·ur

'CV~IOI

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 30 of 31 Document 19

"r-t~'"fw~

iro"' rr ~ ll"~r r "'~ r To<IJ ""tf"

_ 1 ' ) O ; J

,JTlcr;)

SL ." f' t I nJ· Y!t\

,-;:7

_!_1-vrvrv><>n <lj'T''!l y>V() VVOJj jjc1 v~~r "t YJVn''l
T"'"'S"n"'t j"'f"Y1Vr <(T1t .f' W'1:5 '"1r "'~ rr""rvrv .nt17VVllf (,".J_""S'"<Jj""'"J ·-z

v:vr !_1."'"'fv;)jilT 111T"-'\ vy=<> I.N"lNj j-;J'i

"-'r 5-f"ll"f

rrJ17\)V rvsm/t f"' r~'l -•rot ;)" ~ Wnj' v:

5'0~<'VVl"f ol\~rVl"O .,

n~a '"J

. "'""hl"VI ~~ ""~rvnJ 5', ._.r::<']f<l -u~.'1."'l""""-, 't'- r-: J'rf
~on~J"I""·' f"{Yo)ord :F • r ,'_l.''Nrvrosor QYJt J>"",t "".'f"l'?l'\l 'V .h

• rJ>V-""11) S! ~l )": ]]'. j,)J''t'"<lTV' 'O"lt J Y"]l-v\ nv-~p ] 7('") ft"" I"'•'J-.f"'! rr":T"J¥7--.,-.., rv\7 't7''>t"!J 'rt"'OJ"'V'"'.'flCI

E. JURY DEMAND

I want a juty to hear my case.

rzG. YES

0-NO

I declare tmder penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

-.<T' Complaint signed this 2 if: iC. day of _j LJ

20~

Respectfully Submitted,
~~~;;of~~J}j ~

11LLA2.
Plaintiff's Prisoner ID Number
Jts vJ[llJf'"'"' ~~~~_J;~ LL'f.:,..J,. .f Q 'R., t>( 35'/,
Jllli;tL" I LJft..A!>·,.J S'3.'1t:. 3
(Mail· g Address of Plamtrff)

(If more than one plaintiff, use another piece of paper.)

REQUEST TO PROCEED IN DISTRICT COURT WITHOUT PREPAYING THE FULL FILING FEE
~ I DO request that I be allowed to file this complaint without paying the filing fee. I have completed a Request to Proceed in District Court without Prepaying the Full Filing Fee form and have attached it to the complaint.
D I DO NOT request that I be allowed to file this complaint without prepaying the
filing fee tmder 28 U.S.C.§ 1915, and I have included the full filing fee with this complaint.

Complamt-5
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 31 of 31 Document 19

Ex. IOo I
f"je I oF 'l
0 Q []
• --
1\Lt. .·n:,""- tv-e. z..
L.A CuJTI
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 1 of 39 Document 19-1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 2 of 39 Document 19-1

'1101 TJ rovrvnvJ CJ--sn Su ,, l'f"H L:"'"'tTv 1"~'"'1\J "11 'h

( y,·J) -,,, nYT~F "'>"lr"'"q ~, rT~<I hli""V'.~'.IU SV('l f'll']t

"-'""'Jso~ "<< ·y~· ., ~r"" oJt SO"~"~" rnl"""T~ " 'j"'."j('"l v•. 'v:'-'m1
f" -.J~t("T'vv•tn-v)o~~""IJ'J YJ >~ (,,>""J,:} bv:~"~t:f"'"J f"l55'0lJ "1Y~"v]'"d 't ; S{"'O]l"j 5"'1' S,JQ'-'~1.-J

L:tr"""'11 rv~~"' ,..w~h"' JV"]7'Tj"1N' "11:w'"1'"'1 tJ?I\<7,7 " •tv.• f :F

NUIH(l~"'V;) ~nOT5V'~ /l~vrvraJ'i ""t ~j 1""' 1~ n~~lfl(lj 5"17JJJ, (I'~ P'T'IP')
T""j ""t 5<\F.rJ rN'06 """J"U~ r"J T"1 "'1t T~"~"' "'~ 'tYV<> r··j
ooyvoorhs , ...t ]" vsn S' sp;sV<TJ "vnf""",.J FJ "'11- ·~"'t --u uf'\7JQJ "t
r· 5_)J,""'M "1 -J. JV" t"l£! \ )\"? ?Vlt "\f0 """]' n-n '~1 LT,..,P (1, "t r,rVI"S~_,J

"'1t

""~n1,.J

""'t :bt"F""'f"T

"'l !\t 1 VOYV""n'-'nOV'III'\1 5

·--o~r

""t"': I """'~T'f f""j

(o'IQ .Cronnv) r""'b!r •t stvrvF""~f "11 ~~ yosn ('i--z ,_,! '/, .J f'l71'tt-v) VVI•pL·

w, """""''T~ ~T .....?IIVI~""d -.. Sl J{l<llT'"j 5,JF t'-"'n '':5 WJt 'vowy ·z
,rvm t"\n(jV"QVIjY><>:J ""!f]V"S! Jl"lfl'JilJns t""-""ll_f'_orts -y

1 (

t)~n

II

h5 ""tJ""'""')-m-Hl -r"'n

II

"

1\

bv• "'")--\ ""·f''JF"B

I!JlIv\

"'1t J"

,,,/,wv, II "'

J"

I

J"

~V7JW7,/I""!JJ'{' 11"' r tl10~"1 r-7~5/,YJJ ""'t 'f''J.r .II vro v·~r·t"'ll' '11 'I

: s-cnoll"j IT (1. JYJ I ,.J r"r"H"' ""') .}"'"''1 u>vroJ,-o. snln""~P II "'lf f"J~Ac>

.-wjr lprv "J'!IT't'" ot '1'"T''"J"T OVJt 1.1 t""ll {,S" IJM "'1t !'' >v~""'~j

"t

r ~t ol"V' """T bv.-,, ,., f"1(Tl ~7\~" t~fYjOJl"-;1 ~t ljil·'l", 1""''-07""'!.,)"' r'"J1'

•bvnrvol>tJJ"Orn 'v·~r"w'"r~ f,w r P''l "''t •t '"'j'<?h hog ,('T"~>I?~~ \AO~ "l

l'J I I001 "X]

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 3 of 39 Document 19-1

hnno~.,-,Jns Tvt>wvvoo:J J" ~·""f" J'"''J} '7'"•'1L ·A"iln.'J"f ~••t L:.f'lr vvvp-~s ~'"'t •t
"-"'~P hlf\'t-1 •t /"''"1 oJY TITJJ (,5 ·~·(1-d) ~-"T"Jy.J I rn"j ""H
f"'Y rrJ"()nt "''t hll",t"" 'OJJ' ~n "'lt F S'J ""lt •row f"'j 'srvrvrurr
"1j- "'1 .£-.s 1\Jf\ ""\-\ "'. .nvrn•J "t r"1 'v·~--m J" Of"""' ~-\ ~··'1\'S''
)'"Tf'''fWCJ 5~ I'"'~"P' I (j- p ,_,J ~• t"O ps I<JvnJ'"'oj l'vv ]"f""" ""~~-. ""\l .&

(L - r '""J I I,I " "' ·J f' l I0 I ')(] ! 7. "'j, ~ ·J) ·<;"J ~

5--a pm <I") \Pv;J sn r'""''P :f' rv•--:t ~~"<' hlT""tPJ\ r~-v nrr» ,(_,f fY1J'

r""v \"'"''!!\ "(7-1 ,_,_J~~,, ... "'.J 1s1*s J f" IIOI.J(]J ,,r·A~ 5 ,,"" ''l'~f"J

v .~n ""t "-""~() S"J -v S"l7 r5n ""' VOV-;J

•"lt 5'17 <J5VOV-k._J f) VII'<> J

ot

Jf-""JVJ ""lt ""'~nb f 'Sn , "'f!~'~ (~"f";->vs-no) ,-/..,!~..,.J f"t"'J.J VJA""'"'t

"""'~) 'tnq -1'31\0 ( b"J) ''T"~~"~tJ fTmt' v jf S"<' T'"F L\\""'Tl"? S'J V L

(~1* 5 .J fl'
sn v ") 1101"") (FilS). ()S""'"JSH ""~r"'!tS"'~ vry 50"::j""" F'1t b"''lt""'v ·~

• .,., bv:~1-"J'v"'

r : >(71,., rt""'W'j"'":J '"'t v:~,Jxo'"o\"1 IL rvv '1 F""' '"""1" '~ y· "t"N

(S: "JVJ I b .,) )

"(H"J)","'"J~ T""'"TF~"J , t<r>nyovJ C'r'·~t,, T"lln) sn yv-. ~"J J" sL~·~._,j r"t"'J.tl ·~n /" S"J S' t.,~_,:,J •: n mTJT"J f'11 """F",J '~1 ·s
(Z -ml'g~·Jf" \\0\""]!~-l ,""J,b.J) "(ti)"'"'"Js"!:l --. S<J)Ju"" 'l,.'"1"' ('i:rlJ'T~'\S
f"""'rr~="Tl l)lt sor?<}.nl (SJYT""T5 rv··n V"u '"')l .( 01 ... £ J f"

~:·J '1001"'1,]

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 4 of 39 Document 19-1

sn F" SJ .f' ~"'.J!vJ :f Av"' l, (hi""'.Jf"IIOI.x)) -S"J ,f.rT'l'"lv~,:I7J

cr +SJ f"Tt!""11' .. w ~"'f!" ''SJ r.sol\0< f' "'" lo/17 L:J!..,,J '1~"u"Vjl

T~voJ ~~~-'"U!'T",J ?~Jt T"'u~''1 .J.vo""k.lJW() ·~"1\ J,4 r oJ17

r ry h.vy j '. >J<lf"' r•n"j J,xnl\1

,.hr. -rm 1/-rf' "1 ['1

rJJ •.J oJ'il ,,,..rJ

"T'J F ["'"IJ "'r""' "' ··~wvxo ~1 ., S"J , rw"""' &v~1 <JJ'Il ~ f"'1t

pJVf"1"rVJn h1r"Tv: ..,, hvw --.~·~ .mnm FJ r l 5'17 ]" "t T"JJ,.J "?JY' 'tf.15

rw "'f"'\ ~~ T""' hW"N" t """' """0 tfll:i rv 7 "'' l T"" W1~ H I vno 7 ;
~ 1-"'J ~ rJ"""""" 1J""'TN JJ]"l UlJf f' t""'w"""'jv<o• '"TI-n' "'. ~,..,...,..,,~,d p

·oot r!'jr;)i5J f'1 o-'~ruhvrJ ~"'<< t'V' Sl

tl5"'~bJ "')l'(JZ-#'?.J f" IIOI'Xj !W">J't'S ,rnon"'N '71VVOVOi"'rJ 01~) S11flD1"" '1f"W5

T""' Cl ""J ·s.. -z .J I" JJOI'"J !()s-v;~ ~VJt "' L"~Tl) 5 f"'"l+ ""~t J" JV"~t"l7

li"!~Q~v: -,5'~~ 0 ,t•r:sh-rJ hrvjl"'llrllf'~ J"V tv:7J~"" ·e·! 'ul\.'l<OIJ<l.J r~ f""Y
'JO"'"'.'.,j 7"lt L! F'Jf" 41"'" I rr~ s: 'I" -': ,~""\ (1JV11JJ?-r snrw!p '"'1L (9

. SiJ -v ~"''"' ~ T""j 'Jl- .VVO'JI]t "~rp~ J""'1 ,,vouJ,.rr'T""~F".,. {~!,."'J

('i -7 .J b WVJ I f""" 1ul\"1'CJ I 'i """ our) F"J O'l'Jj f" ()5tf"~.) "'1t -.:rn? •t hr.'w.IT',J
_,.J.. ~1t('F'J ~ OlJ /> sn"'lr:l~.J UVJt P'" ""1/" vro<J~"fOi) Ya•~nhv "'1/>

'""!t "'~0 ·.A.,.ro'l"T f""j 0"\t "'F•nl ~lJY'n--hJ rJVn' UVJ1 r--•-nvv J""l ..

·snrw·p )~'t7lq111 " rv jj" 1""tS ~(\~S r"j r~ F1 'Y'"] ('V

;W'O)T"j J"" -rovvr~.J Ftf"(,.,..ry f'"'~~ pA~-r~ '1 vt S"''f'"t ~ r"'

.' r""·' p f" uo:f"""u bl"'rnrv! 'OJIA!PnVI 'r''I1V -rno r't"""' o5"'-'UX11 T'~!jjQ

b'J '1001 'X')

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 5 of 39 Document 19-1

!"' _B""VV?'"r .,.,~'t'f'J.J !·r·,,-v "'('1.,~ '""'11"" '"lt ~~ f"""""""r """~rf'J.,

t(~ ""'J'h.J -.-.s)}vavv'"'~" -..Ht t~~IV 1-r•g ""f 5l' (f'''''4t 'J.l"df 1'~rvv~)nr~"J"7
"IOMOY)P yY" 'OJ ( m1f'1,~)) )'""'"lj -nor V·~ J.V11"1/;i7'TJ J"'t-v<IJ.J' ! ""'"Jf "1fl"'l r·~J

"" 'hpn•porh-..J 'm:'F"I F rf"'1rn~vv"'1 ,..., ]'tv'""~ 'JJ"P 1vv ryrtn-(, •rw•J

·rVVl . . T"'v 'jJ"P TVIV sr.rv"~

oJl' jj~r~r ""lt r~ ~!7 T'"'f""'.PT o")t hi 'Q''-'t

pfrirfoJ ""! yn•~p sn.,ruV> f" ,.Jlt f"!O"' '1t ~'"'""Y ·!JOW!fS sno!XQN "01

"YfojjU 'J'· j" JY"""~)S!n~vv "'1"\ ~[""~Jlo")IW'i'JO-J bvw11~t'-l'V1JJ on•.>J0]\)1 /"'., -;)-;)

(j.'J'-"'5"117Vln VY ~ <OY"OJriJ' aT""" ~"Tfw-v:l "t t.,..,JJO v~ l &"J) bv>V'.ry;jl

77.,....j "1 r "'"'""~¥) '~"""J "t JIT~ "'1) ~.I, 'tVTI1f"".f!l OI'Jt ;,'1 yosn vm"' '"1 /f!'t ""'TPJ,, ")in-o''t T~'P ""If' "'" ,,.,..~~~""' "lf" T"J~J t S""J "" o5n""<m\] . -;;15V1l~oJ 1".1 t'"t 'T l7 "'1"'"" ~J 'JfM f"J~...J e~n) Tl""~P """?""vv>

'<' +., 'n!f1 Jr>O'I_.ro~ h"] 5~'1\ ") '!J_jVV"7.>'!7 T",f"'PF ~ . 505"'"6' f""'T'W<l

r,v "'"Tf"'"" •t '""'n""1"1 F"'" .>ilf"lfl rv>l):rVV"-o r1'."\"~ of"<"' ""'"17'1""1

><>-rp

r""'Tvv" "'"'Y"': "'~" 'sn "lf,..., -SIJ ""'sn "~f"" tSIJ f' '":J,.J J'"t""'~ .h

"V''Or.J.JdO;] o't'rvrhsJ J SV"V"d f'J"':"J

rv ..,.~.,

Cl'''"IIV"'J s! Vln~) (,v,_v~wrvv;} oA!'"""" .,~ ( ('1•r"\ 'Ql ._,. J) T'""~P

ynu.'X"Vl f" hvuu ys-.ltvur~ -v 1- ""~'1 os•J)f(l ~t VO!VIU!~,n) 7'rTcJ~ '(} f?~"'t
~,. Vl?w•hJ" ""'T"t n!n "'""'t ~~o 'O"~!Jr Itlrl •'1t C"..,f"''+V1Jvv•'uvv

fJ"V '"'t'AIF 11"" .f' r"., 't"'"'J l'J'D '!1 f" '"T""1""JJ, "'"\-\"' ""''""""!J"f
f""j '""'"'"'!) lf1'-"1ls.'.J rtfOCJllt " f' f"'~~'"'"'•<~nvra OVJt f' "'•TTJ:vrvvv> 1'""'

S J '1001·x]

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 6 of 39 Document 19-1

r~l v.Jl\"(1:) 1'""'nt o"li ·o ! I AvanT"!' f""j "F"_J ~r.rvnt 1t"'1 ""'1r"
-osn-p""".rl r"J n "1 'Tn"f "' "sn "'~-'t ""''US .1."',.T""J'F "11-. .~I

··-'"r "T'7J 1f"l

VJ(ll\(j

vo '-J-vowo-v'\l'"' •:•VJi p"';~v Vl"VQ\ ~T ye:'""j (l.~'i ,..,,.". L"' ~'11 ~I

"oy<'Y\1 <NV t"""'"uJ:•vra <>"Jt ~~ '}~"" "'QQ'"'"'fo, (>""ol-f"!'OH'<')5V'"T"QVvCT;J

1-'"""\t ux '"vnFo,J """ VJrrn 1'""~"""~":"1"'"";] ''" tva""vruJ:"""' ""11 :f' f""'J"JnJ~~-.ro l-nf'J"Jl7 ,...,~. <"'1\ '}'" ~vvOT.Jv -:J,..."'"!"JOf "'Jl- ·"'1"'".6" ""11 f'

vr k-,ponthJj

"+"" ,cl'["'n~ .., 'f'df:f" T"'V '"'11 f" {..,"''n\i)Jj Fl'"' "1 OJ

"'t lrovn~ I

"11-. "f"T7:UnWV\Ju;J

"t

t ~'<'r-)

T'"'Fv<Uf'f II

r: f! f'"'Jr"' SV'J'<Til\

( lp~~XII)j"J) h/)"7T""'ot"--v 0 voQ hit-;>~~"""' f"~"\J"\ ·~ """ "''"\)'\ ·7.1

. <J<I"'•Jn, ""'t f'
{,...,)p.Jj rr "1'""1 1/f'l"'"~ "'~t 'f"'j1" T'W!t' ""'t j ~-:>von<h·j I" "t"J ,(ffnt "'11-. tv;wv]'!"""J ~ ti .t""'""'?'!"~"" rr' "''~ r~Tvua ]'v" r+\/Yi!""' J .(.~J") frv(Tl d~~u-J(Il':J '<' ~: 1 r"".'f "<~'1t" r sno!X""' •t oJnsoJ)(c T"f""J~ .,,

.-.T' "'t~~'1 T"''"''s (;.,,..,~"!J .,...,, V'Ofp"-s -.:n tvrJ.. t.ru1 7f'"'P .'sv·~.f'mfs f'v_":F"'t"'~ "" rvr(nr v:
f'"'">V7'"r f~n'hj !J~-p~f+-vo''1t r~~vv~ vy ~" t_,..,"' t,.,:.,.,.r '\.v~v<poJ r
bvJ_vroso~\ "" l"'fl""fj)-1 f'T,....J rr'aJ.J. b"" ''""~'t"'f! IT\j 5JOHfS "" 1oJ'T'T'"j"""""'n
'bv_""'T"'"'lt ; I""'W7T>'r f""'n~<~ ! T'"'"'lt r~]J~! SMTP~"J \'f'O"/'S)"'f"r'
..,.,,...,.'1, t,~T<f'J:) '1f'"" """T"JV:"l""o;:J f'~ (f"'"VJt '1f""T)"I'."J""7 "<<F'"lljS mw,l.l

"'·J'IOOI.)(]

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 7 of 39 Document 19-1

.f""~~ nj , •.1."1 nd~'-'I"VV' "t .J"'1 0\ ~r'J-vdlT;) OV\f --.-:>"'01 I Fnl""J
<11 ~vv W~"]f"'l ''t '-'"Vf"'"PT t .. fvytn17]" (CI J) -~...~~21 ruv~Tr"'\)
Lv ('~".'l"f f""j If r-> "'"'.f"~"':"'v,l v'. "'l t""' ~..,vv "' {wwo f"'1t) •sn yvov 'SJ .rc"lp ~""'vv 1\'("1 ~'1"·~~-.J '1(,"."'1t
<IW:' ""nO .l"j j)"'t r-v IP~ "''t 'i'.n rr·Jp""'wor ''"1~"d
raV>vr'j)yY' qWV<;" O"'Jt VI (':in) roo1 O"Ji "'Jf.rl iv:J~J fOtVOJ.,
.JOf f9 )"J " 5()"""ll'Jcl1 5"'1+ j"'nC '! 'JL T""j Y'1l f' o.\rhJ OVJj
r•raV' . . ":>jV~C/ "t ~r7•dr.:> OVJ-t S<lJ~n!h-v (IYV~t "<<f\0 +"""\I S"l"""''P
51' j S' "t'"t-~" hlrT "'~ h""D~\7f b,.,·""-r yvn:'J UVJt 50F.J ~ lVI •hJ
o1~" fJ'l"t" L~r-•j f' 'T"vv ·\"'.,pv: "'1\ "'I. ·sn 1nw:p '0"1"\""'11
J" --..svuJ,.-.~ fJ'lt ·-r'"CI "t ~f'"Jv, 0'11 so.f!J.n"' ·'nl""':p- _,
.,, "'1 .l Z,.,.) 's;.,. "Z J P' 1101 ·xJJ s-n "'~t '"faoo.J ,(,,.,T" ~J 01'11 • T;] ypnro.J t~lt """F"J O"Jf •: sn rv S"J J bv~vrvd
dV.HH
·van.ros r"'nt pv1 ""11 rvv
L J'I 0 0 I "lC"]

Classical Conditioning (Pavlov) JLeamiog Theories

• Home • Index of Learning Theories and Models • Definitions • Paradigms • Buy the eBookl • Submit a New Theory
Home» Bebayiorist Theories>> Classical Conditioning" (Pavlov)

Classical Conditioning (Pavlov)

Posted in Behaviorist Theories Jl comment

Summary: Classical conditioning is a reflexive or automatic type of learning in which a stimulus acquires the capacity to evoke a response that was originally evoked by another stimulus.

Originators and Key Contributors: First descnoed by Ivan Pavlov (1849-1936), Russian physiologist, in 1903, and studied in infants by John B. Watson (1878-1958).

Keywords: stimulus-response, psychic reflexes, unconditioned stimulus, conditioned response, respondent conditioning

Classical Conditioning (Ivan Pavlov)

Several types ofleaming exist. The most basic form is associative learning, i.e., making a new

association between events in the environment. There are two forms of associative learning:

classical conditioning (made famous by Ivan Pavlov's experiments with dogs) and operant

conditioning.

·

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 8 of 39 Document 19-1

Classical Conditioning (Pavlov) I Learning Theories

Pavlov's Dogs

In the early twentieth century, Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov did Nobel prize'wJnhing work ""'

digestion. While studyiitg !be role ofsaliva in dog('mgestive processes, be stumbled upon a

phenomenon be labeled ''psychic reflexes." While an accidental discovezy, be had the foresigh~ ·1-.

see the impor\llllce of it. Pavlov's dogs, restrained in an experimental chamber, were presented ,

with meat powder and they had their saliva collected via a surgically implanted tube in their salt""'"

glands. Over time, he noticed that his dogs who begin salivation before !he meat powder was eV2V!
presented, whether it was by the vresence of the handler or merely by a clicking noise produced hy

the device that distn"buted the meat powder.

·

Fascinated by this finding, Pavlov paired the meat powder with various stimuli such as the ring)"'f of a bell. After the meat powder Md bell (auditory stimulus) were presented together several times, the bell was used alone. Pavlov's dogs, as predicted, responded by salivating to the sound ofthe bell (without the food). The bell began as a neutral stimulus (i.e. the bell itself did not produce the dogs' salivation). However, by pairing the bell with the stimulus that did produce tke.. salivation response, the bell was able to acquire the ability to trigger the salivation response. Pavlov therefore demonstrated how stimulus-response bonds (which some consider as the basic building blocks oflearning) are fmned. He dedicated much ofthe rest of his career further exploring this finding.

In technical terms, the meat powder is considered an unconditioned stimulus (UCS) and the dog~ salivation is the unconditioned response (UCR). The bell is a neutral stimulus until the dog leath5 to associate the bell with food. 'Then the bell becomes a conditioned stimulus (CS) which prodll[E.!; the conditioned response (CR) ofsalivation after repeated pairings between the bell and food.

John B. Watson: Early Classical Conditioning with Humans
John B. Watson further extended Pavlov's work and applied it to human beings. In 1921, Watsm• studied Albert, an II month old infant child. The goal ofthe study was to condition Albert to become afraid of a white rat by pairing the white rat with a very loud, jarring noise (UCS). At first, Albert showed no sign of tear when ha was presented with rats, but once the rat was repeaiedly paired with the loud noise (UCS), Albert developed a fear ofrats. It could be said that the loud noise (UCS) induced fear (UCR). The implications ofWatson's experiment suggested that classical conditioning could cause some phobias in humans. For more infonnation, see:
• Pavlov, I. P. (1927). Conditioned Reflexes: An Investigation ofthe Physiological Activity of the Cerebral Cortex. Translated and Edited by G. V. Anrep. London: Oxford University Press. Full text available online
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 9 of 39 Document 19-1

Segregation psychosis
The exponential growth in super-maximum security prisons and Secunty Housing Uruts (SHU's) has led to a concmrent rise in psychotic symptoms among pnsoners. These symptoms may mimic those of schizophrema, but with the cmcial distinction that they me tapidly reversible. Unfortunately, pnsoners suffering from segregationinduced psychosis may be misdiagnosed as suffering from A- a more chronic mental Illness, rather than from a :,;., tempmary, environmentally mduced conditiOn.
Psychotic symptoms among indivtduals subJected to solitary confinement has been observed as far back as the early 1800s. Between 1854 and 1909, dozens of articles appeared in Getman Journals that descnbed a constellation of segregation-induced psychotic symptoms mcludmg hallucmations, pmanoid thmkmg, and persecutory deluswns. Indeed, by 1890 the U.S. Supreme Court had condemned solitary confinement on psychtatric grounds, stating that it caused "a constderable number ofprisonets" to become "violently insane."
Stumt Grassian, MD, of Hm vard University has studied the effects of Secuuty Housmg Units on pnsoners in Massachusetts. He describes strikingly consistent symptoms that mtmtc those p10duced by other sensory-depnvation experiences. These symptoms include:
• Perceptual distortions and hallucinations • Massive flee-floating anxiety • Impaued concentration and memmy • Acute confusional states, at tunes associated with dissociation, mutism, and pmtial
amnesta • Persecutory thoughts, at times reachmg delusional proportions • Impulsive behavior, for example sudden self-mutilation or vwlence • Rapid subsiding of symptoms once isolatton ts termmated
This constellatiOn of symptoms can be induced among individuals with no preexishng psychiauic problems. Not suprismgly, however, the problem is wmse for pnsoners with preexisting mental disorders. Such individuals almost invariably experience a dramatic worsening of theu psychotic symptoms
Further resources:
Stuatt Grassmn, MD (1983). Psychopathologtcal effects of solitary confinement. American Journal ofPsychiat1y 140 (II), pp 1450-1454
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 10 of 39 Document 19-1

Terry A. Kupers (1999). Pnson madness: The mental health crisis behind bars and what we must do about it. Jossey-Bass Publishers Bmce Potter (1998). Is solitary confinement driving Charlie Chase crazy? New York Times Magazme, November 8, 1998, pp. 52-58 Related blog post: "Supeunax: Hell on earth or not as bad as we thought?"
Drawitrg · Skelcll by SHU prisoner lfermtm 11'(1//tu e. Lomsuma State Pemtentinry, Angola
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 11 of 39 Document 19-1

Ex. 1003 f" I •f ll

Faith-based state group seeks Waupun

prison abuse probe
:::. ; rvx__,· . : .7 Boll Lncdc" 6 36 am CD"! July 31,201.\ -~:;~~;~jit}f
~

•. ·-~,1
'j((' ,;~ ~-

,.
>
i "
...,..

·~. .''

r·
f", I
'

t

'*"

'---1'

' '

!

} '

.j' '
'\

•

fl"'"~iff'j:,·

I

~~:Y,-..

~i,

•

.,..

(Photo Photo Lam en Fuhun.aHn'\\'J~COil\111 C'cnlci fm hwc\1:g.tllYc loumaltMu)

' <4 I ;
'r~~.._.' ' '

'# r' .'
.. ' } 'f·
~

( 01\NECT1.\.U!J.U'\ KIJ lhCO~Jl\IEN'I'E~ lA TUIORE

A \l,tlc\\ tdc advol.Icy g:wup on Tnc~dfl) a~kcd "'I~LoHo;;m Gm· Scoll 'Valkc1 to tm·c~tJgatc allcg:altons that guard\ elL

\\'auptm CoHccttonal In~lltullon hm c <1hu~cd mnwtco;; mthc tm~on's ~cgtcgallon umt do1cns of tunc~ \mcc 20 II

"IL J\ nm' clcnr Ihill the \Viscon~Hl Dcp.u tmcnt ol Corrcctton'>, a\ a maHer of polK y, IOUimcly engage-; Ill tmllu c,"

f-.<11(1 the letter ftom \\'t.,dolll, a fmth-IM-;cd group \\tilt chaplet~ <Jtonnd the <,late A 11 s gm'ctnot, )OU ha\c the

.1111/IOIH) cllld ICSJIOII\IIHhl) fO end Che f0!1liiC 110\\ u

\Val"ct ~pokco.,wonHHl Lmucl Paluck declined commcnt,tcfcumg quc~lton<, to the slfltc Department of Couccllono;;

DOC ~lX)kC\WOlllilll Joy Staab dccJmcd to COili111CJll on \ViMiom'~ lcllct bult~sucd a :-,tcllcment "E\'Cf)' allcgaiiOJJ or

av·.ault11mt 1~ brought to the <Jilcnllon of .':.l.tff ts lll\Tsllgatcd The ])(xlgc County Shcnfr.-, Dcpmtmcnl routinely

Jll\'C'illg<IICS nllcga!Hm"i Dmlllg the pao;;t SC\'Ctal ycat s tltCI c ha\'C been no <,lJh\tanllalcd allcgalloJI~ or ... taff on llllll.liC

ahusc at Waupun Cuncclionallmlilillion "

\Vp,dom'r., letter wno;; prompted h) 11 <,cue~ of atllclc~ tclcm:cd last week by the \\'t<,LOHMH Ccnlct for hl\'c"iiJgatn·c

.lmnnah'-lm .md publt<.;hcd 01 cJlcd hy 29ncw~ mgatuLaltons mound the o;tate The Center tdctlltftcd 40 allcgnllon~ of

"f;

l
!

I''
~~ 0
I f, ~
i ;. j~ I

f
.'1

~

'

i' ''

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 12 of 39 Document 19-1

phys1cfll 01 p<;ychologlcdl ~laff-on-mnuttc abu<.,c mvolvmg 33 nunalc.<.mthc pu.<.on•.., .<.uhtmy Lonfntcment umt ovet the pa.<.l tlu ee ycm s I he lcllcr Jwm \V1..,dom p1cs1dent Sandra ~J1lhg.m .<..nd \Vt.-.;con.<.m's u...c of sohtatT confmemcnt, m wludt pu..,oncrs spend month~ 1f not )'CdiS '' tth hlllc human conlacl, "Is by dehmllon tort me." She c1tcd the Centct'.., ...ene.<. 1n saymg that the pwhlcm1s "pmtictdcnly acttlc .11 'Vaupun" ''The c,\hau-;tn·e Jn·c-month mvesttgallon by the nulependenl Centc1 for hwcshgallvc Jomnalism found that many ol the mmatcs Ill soht.uy conflllement me meutally Ill and subject to alleged routmc abu~c by gumd~ and mdtffetence b~ 'ltaff," she WI Ole The tlucc-p.ut .<.cue.., wa.<. based on pusoner la\-\'.<.lllts, compla1ut..,, mtc1 \'tcw.<. and lcllc1s ~fuch of the fllleged ph~ ..,,cnl flbu.<.c tm'oh·ed mnt.Itc.<. who ~aid they were lmndculfcd and not rc.<.tslmg lnctdenttepmt.<. pwvulcd by "'aupnn off1cHJls confnmcd lltalllllllates wctc subjected to the u...c of fotl.C, mdmhng taset.<., peppet sp1.ty, knee ~t11kc.., mnltakcdowns, and 111 some cases sn.<.lamed llljllrtes But the tepmls pot1rayed the pm..oner\ as m~llgatm~. ~aymg ~laff U\Cd only necessary fmce 'I \\'O-thud~ of tho-;c allcgattoll') mvol\'ed a smglc couectional oJftLet, Joseph llcahm, who has wmkcd 111 \Vaupun's .<.egregallon mut smcc 2()()(, Top <..otrccllons offtctals demed the allegatiOns, accu.<.mg the mmates of lymg llcahm lhl~ nc,·et Uccn dt~uplmcd fot an~ Hunatc-lcl.Itcd mflflCIIOH Late Ja\1 \\ cck, the DOC dcclmed a Icqne~t f1om the Ccntc1 to mterncw Secretary bd \\'all ahout the allcgnhon<; documented mthc scncs \Vall, in Aprd,telcased a memo :-.aymg the Mate \\'fl~ rcvtewmg tl.<. u~c of sohlmy confmement, winch "may 1eally JU.<.t be hclplllg to create a wmsc bchavim ptoblcm amllmbitualthrcat " Segicg<JIIOn cells Jc.annc conetctc ami steel furmslungs, one small wmdow and a .<.tecl hap dtxH lluough wluch food :md medication m-e pa.<.~cd A tcgulal \cg1cgallon ccllmeasmes 6 feel 2mches by 12 feel I he lcllcl called on "'alket to lake a series of .-.;tep.-.; llliC.<.pon.<.c to the ~cuc~,Htcludmg • Requc\1 .Jilllldcpcndenl un·e\llg<Jtmn hy the US Department of .lust1cc, .<.aymg the ..,talc DOC "L.mnot be <l'>kcd to mveMtgatc 1t:>.elf" • Tmmfer the officer named mthe llt.lJOrtty of the complmnts to other dulles unllllhe mvesugatmn ts completed, and en.<.t1rc that no p11sonet~ cxpenencc rctribullon fm coopctatmg wtlh lll\'CMtgctiOit-.. • Order the slate Depmtment of Corrccllons to tmplcmcnl changes mclmhng rolatmg coHccll<lllal offtccts m .\CI!regnltonumts to olhc1 dut1cs C\'eJy three month..,, 1111)>10\'lllg li<Hillllg fm dealing Wtlh dtfl'tcult Inmate~ and CJCalmg anmdepcndcnt Lompl.allll \plcm fm Hllllalc:-. "\Vc Jc<tlly feel thalli':-. lime that lhe go\'cutor .<.tep 111 mul Im·esiJgate what'.<. gomg on mthe Depattmcnl of Com.·cltom.," satd Dand Lmer..,, exccull\'C ducctor of \Vt.<.dom - rhe \Vt:-.COIIMII Centct fm Im·c~llgflli\'e Jomnaltsm collabmatc\ Wtlh \Vtsconsm Pubhc Radto, "'I:-.consm Pubhc 'I clc' lr-.ton, othc1 new<., medta amlthc U\V-~Iadt:>.on School of Jomnahsm amlt\Ia.<..<. Comnnuucallon
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 13 of 39 Document 19-1

MNJsCoiisin\VatciJ.org (11np /JwJscon&:Jnwatch org/20J4/07f.vaupun-guard-named-rcpeatedl}'-lll-abusc-complamts/)

CRUEl AND UNUSUAL?

July 21, 2014

Waupun guard named repeatedly in abuse

complaints

St.tlc offict.tls defend officer. s.ty inn1.1lcs .tre lying tn clatm~ of mistrc.tlmcnl

By BILL LUEDERS

Part 2 ofJ

At Ius scnrcncmg hcanng on reb 28, Wisconsin pnson mmate Leighton Lmdsey ad mated (hltps //s1 amnzonaws com/sJ documcntdond orcldocumcntslt21128SIIe•ghton-lmdset-sentencmg-heurmg pdfl In collrl that he bLt a cone<.llonal officer m the segregation umt at the smtc's \Vaupun Correctwnal lll'lllllHIOJI

He sa1d he d1d so because the officer, Jesse Jones, was restrammg IHm wiHic another off1cer, Joseph Beahm, assauhcd lum
"I WJ~ bcmg held up MJ th.H Bc.1hm could pu111..h me, k1ck me, knee me, .d/ th.lt stulf," he told the judge, s.•vmg he J<.tcd m '!C!f-dcfcnsc "I had no ch01<.c"

Name: BEAHM, JOSEPH D

Dcahm's report (hups:l/sJ am,wmHlw~.com ISJ documentc!oud on•lducumentsll2I19BS/bcJhW rcport-on-hndscy pdQ on the De<. 23,2011, mctdent smd Lmdsey spat at <.llficers and WJS .tctJvclr rcsJsung Jones, then bcg.tn bmng ]um The two officers subdued Lmdscy "usmg strong su.lc knee k1cks JJH.l strong s1de torearm stnkcs," the report says Jones sustamed .1 hue milrk (hllps lfs1 •lnHlt.onuws wmlsJ,documcntdoud.org ldocumcntsiizl6zzqfloncs-bJtc-mJrk-from-1Jndscy-
cn~c pJ{ 1 .mJ :-.ore knee Photo!> !>how l.mdo,ey
With a bJgm!y vesh O,!lps //;=] QWjl?Q" ms! om /q,doLument<.louJ ,org/JoLu mcnt ~/l2ti91'Hi/lt nJ~c'bq.!-wgund-lmm-dec-2op wr~olent ndO aero<><: Ius forchc.ul.

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 14 of 39 Document 19-1

lhtlr lju6rfr.JzqbJOgp'll6kfyt(d'mnTt'nRII!r m1dm1. rdn cmnlnp-rontf711
Wtsconsm Department of Correctrons
Joseph Beahm, a correctional off1cer 1n the segregation untt at Waupun, ts named m more than two dozen allegations of mmate abuse.

The case IS among the 40 allcgattons of staffon-inmate abuse smcc 2011 1dcnt1fied by the \Visconsin Center for Investigative Journahsm Ill \Vaupun's segregatiOn Ulllt, commonly known as sohtary LOnlinement Most mvolve mdiLJ.tJOns th.u mmatc~ receiVed po~t-muJent phys1cJI or mental health .ttlcnuon
The .tllegJnons were made m IJwsu1ts, internal mmalc complmnts, mterv1ews, and letter<; w

01 the 40 alleg.tlwns, off1ccr Deahm 1<: named m 28 A do?en mmatc J.nvsmts smce 2011 .tccuse Ue.thm ol phV"IcJ.I or p<iycholog•cal abu<ic, SIX hJvc been d1smt~sed and SIX arc pendmg
The state DepJ.rtment of Corrections has den1ed these allegauons and accused the mmatcs makmg them of lymg Uul the nature and volume of the complamts h.ts drawn the notu:e of stJtc Sen Lena Taylor, D-MJ!w.mkee, and former state pn<ion clue[ Walter D1ckey, who has ~._ailed lor an mvest1gat1on Ill respou~e to the Center's findmgs
Ue.thm, J. mnc-ye.tr department employee, dtd not respond to wntten reque<;t-; lor an mtcrv1ew or offers to go over the .tlleg.tt10ns in det.tJI
'A rogue guard'

Beahm, a state pnson guJ.n.l smcc zoos, ha1:o worked smcc October 2006 111 \Vo.upun's segregauon umt, where mmates arc often sent for -.hsctplmary reasons He ts well-known to mmates at the pnson 55
nules rwnhe.1~l ol M.tdl<;on

"He talks hkc a tough man, he talks hke .t bully," s.ud T.thb Akbar, .t former \Vaupun mm.ne released IJ<il October .tfter t-ervmg: 2oye.tr:. for two counts of:;;exunl a<;sault "'When <;omctlung happen<;, he's the lirst one there, because he wants to down "iomehody."

ln September 2012, Akbar ~aid he watched from Ius cell as Beahm pushed a hand~._uffcd mmotc f.tcc-lina to the noor, then pounced on Ius bJ.ck "Beahm'<: knee was mlu~ b.tck, .tnd In~ head was pulled b.tckwarJs "AkhJr s.tJd the mmate "d1dn't we1gh IJO pounds S<Mkmg wet. He was hurt."
Akb.tr wrote a l£ll£r.
(hllp~·/lq,am.:Jzomm s com In documcutcloud org!Jo<...umcnl" /JztzZ4-!hkbar-lcltcr-to-poll.lrd pJr) to \Vaupun \VJ.rden W11llllm Pollatd, reporung whJL he had. seen, J.ddmg thJ.l BeJhm "hJ.~ .-. hab1t ol tlus type of Jhuw " The letter drew a reply Irom \V.tupun secunty duector Tonr Mel!, s.1ymg Lhc mudent "will be revtewed by IJ.w enfon.emcnt.''

The record~ ldcnllf,·thc llllllJte ns I lt,hlen Rotlngue7:, who the pr1~on ~J)'<i weighs 135 pounds The lllCHh-'nl reports t-J.y Rodnguc..: resl"ited, threatened and ~ll.ll .lt olficcr~, .J.nd wJs ~hreLLed to the ground wnh the lcJ"it .J.IHOUIH of lone nccc<;<;J.rV Tbe mctdcntlcd to UodrlbTJ.IC7. hemg conv1clc~l ol "pn~onu throwfe'\:pel bodily <iubst.tnu:s," .tlclony, .111d ~entenced to .10 J.Jdnwnal <;I\ months

Kate Golden/Wisconsm Center for Investigative Journalism
Former 1nmate Talib Akbar reported w1tnessmg phys1ca/ abuse of another pnsoner to the Waupun warden, allegrng the guard, Joseph Beahm, "has a habrt of thrs k1nd of abuse"

Accordmg lo other records relc.u.ed to the Center, Beahm has been [he sUbJeCt ol only one diSCiphn.try mvest1g.tt1on dunng: Ius tunc J.t \Vaupun 'J'IlJ.t WJS .l20JIIHCJdcnt m winch he J.l!egcdly fell :J<;Iecp J.t a desk Beahm dented Il, and compiJ.med Jbout bcmg "wntten up,'' whtch he s.ud had never h.tppcned
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 15 of 39 Document 19-1

before

"I worry that I not only have to worry abour mmates lymg about me, bUl now I h.1ve to worry about management," he stJtcd at the ltme mlus response to the mqu1ry

In .1 three-month pcnoJ JUSt prior to the b1tmg mctdent, mmatc Lindsey filed .Jt le.ua f1ve mternal ~_.omplamts ag.Jmst Dcalun, .11legmg harassment and tlueats "He IS a rogue guard and you all know it," Lmdscy wrote m (Jile comp)dml- "Evcrybml)• can't be lymg on thts guy"

The <.omplaml were promptly reJC<.tcd "Ynu have little credibility With the behavior you e.:..Iub1t m segregatiOn," Mch wrote I.mdo;;ey also llled. anmternal cnmpl.um .1gamst neahm over the Dec 23 mculcnt .mJ .J<.ked a Dodge County JUdge to launch a John Doc probe Doth WClC rcJCCteJ

0111!' l{r11<~r, 1-q/1, {ii'"JI 1 1 ;(<,'Cf, H lifo lc?''lo' 11,-; f11 I f'IIU ~ir/h !' ffJIJ/o111 'llf'[", 1.\'.>fl! (o'
'Ll"•t<, 1 h~l I li'O'fPI•I from Dt't .>r/1 m,-.,J, 11/Pr;)
W1sconsm Depatlmenl of Coneclwns
Inmate Leighton Lmdsey adm1ts b1t1ng a guard 1n 2011,
but says he d1d so because the guard was holdmg h1m
wh1le another guard beat h1m. The photo, taken by authont1es, was provided by Lmdsey's lawyer, Wilham
Mayer.
mcHlcnl, <~greed to a plea deal rh,n .tddcd a yc.u to Ius :.entence

L!ndo:;cy'o;; defcno;;e attorney, \Vtlll.un M,tyer, filed a request for the JUdge to rc\•tcw Dc.1hm's personncllile He noted Lmdsey's pnor compl,unt:. .Jml Included affidavits from three other pnsoners at..t.usmg
Deahm of abu.,e nm the rcv1ew d1d
not prodw..c .my rc<.ords ol dJ<:Ciplmary .1ctwn agamsl Beahm
Lmdsey, f.1ung .1 maxtmum o;;entcncc of 10 yc.us for the bmng

Mayer, man intervieW, saH.l he behevc~ from wh.H he's heJ.rd from Lmdsey .md other mmates th.tt .dmsc IS nct..urnng 111 the segreg.ttlon umt .Jl \V.mpun Most commonly, he sa1d, tlus mvolves "the m~t1g.nmg of bciM\'IOr- domg thmgs to get under (mmatco;;') skm, to get them gmng, rather than dcalmg w1th them m a professional manner." lie thmks the allegations warrant further mvesugauon

Allegations of 'torture'

Some oi the comptunts 1dent•fied by the Center allege cJ>.trcmc nustrcatmenr

\V,mpun llllndte Patrick \Vecks, Ill d lener (http~:/{q .unu,wnaw~ com/q dot..umentcloud org/documents ln1'!416Jiputud \\ccJ..~-u~~uuh-J-1"1 pdfllo <:talc pnsnncr advo1...J.lt! Peg Sw.1n, .dleges thdl Beahm on reb 5 stuck Ius linger mto \Vccks' momh ,lfter 11rstmscrtmg Jtlnto Weeks' rectum dunng a stnp search These allegatiOns were deemed "unfounded" aml Weeks rcce1veJ a conduct report for "lymg about <:l.lfl "Other IIIIIIJles allege Hwppmpn.lle touclung uf thc1r gemt.ll~ dunng stnp se.trt..hes, wluch arc routme.ly condut..tcd

A fcderalldWSllll filed m Jan nary by mmate Clarence \V1lko:; allege<: Chups /In umuzonuws com fq docmncntt..lonJ org(Jocumcnt~fll~41 16/w!lk~-compi.Hnt pdQ that segregation Ulllt guard Andrew Moungey "struck plainult repeatedly w1th a closed fist .Jbout the plamllll 's head and both s1des of the f.It..C and slammed plamuff's fJce mto the wall "Then the guard allegedly "repedted.ly k1cked both ol plamuff's Iego;;" and "struck pl.unuff m Ius nbs and grabbed hnn by the throdt." The defendants have dcmed {huw·/I~J unn•wnn\\S .::om/sJ dncumcntcloud org(documcnh/I2lo990{wllks answer pdf) the dllcg.:HIOil<:, wh1ch led to W1lh recelvtng a wndnct report for lymg about staff The lawsmt IS pendmg

Tn dlluther pt'nthng lederallawsmt, mmatc Lacon McKmlcy a.l.lcgcs CI•Ups 1/n qmuzona1\s com l~J,documcntcloud org/dowmcnls/11841<;;3/mckmlcy-compl.unt pdf} bcmg subJected to "torture" on March M, 2013 Mt..Kmlcy, convicted ol mult1ple en me~ including kidn.tppmg and Jllcmptcd mnrdcr, .tdmillcd Ill dll alfid.lvtt {http-;,1/sJ nrnu.-,onni\S com/s1 documcntcloud org/documenls/J150564ftaffidJ.vlt-of-IJ.-ron-mcklnleyS·J6-n pJJ I lhdt the ep1soJe hcg.1n when he threw fecal llldllcr at a guard

By J\kKmlcy's .tuount, lleahm
subwqucntly .lrnvcd dt luo;; t..cllantl
<lllnount..ctl, "J'm gomg to kill you," later
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16

Page 16 of 39

Document 19-1

amemhng tins to, "I'm gomg ro hurt you real hJ.d!" Another mmate, Slurcll Watkmc;, produced .m affidavit
(bup~ flu ,JnJHOQ,)WS com (q documcnlclou.l orghlocum<-nt~luH::~t64
lrllllc.htv!l-ol-slurcll-\\atklm 3 20 11 on-mdmlcy mlrl 'i..l\'tng he he.ut!IJeJ.hm's de.nh thrc.ll "from my own c.~r~."

Aflcr h.mdulllmg 111111 lrvm helmnl,

!\kKmlcy alleges, Beahm and other oii1Lcrs

lWio;;tctlluo;; wno;;t "to 1ts lnmt and ncJr

hrcJkmg poml," ::.l.unmed hun face first

lllto .1 '>lnp (...tgc door .uul stomped on ius

~h.J.l..kleJ ankleo;; He s.11d Ius wrist, h.md

Jnd. ankles were "~._ontorted .md wrenched"

for ",tl Jea'>t JO llllllUleS of COIHIIlUOUS agony" At one pumL MLKmky '>L.Ill.s that he lost lOntrol ol h1c; bowclo;; anJ dclec.lted

& £1111p 11•16. Jn1•-li••sn:6lr!~ftnr UJHlfll,' ,,,!lri,J , lrr rollll!tp co11r, nt'!•p:lfl L<
/.!QI >'or/[ mm \l•lill'• •lr{l
W1sconsm Department of CorrectiOns

on the lloor

Inmate Laron McK1nley alleges m a lawsUit that he

The slate, m .1 court filnw (IJllps fin amazon.I\\s,coru
/s3 doc!!mentclpud org/dpc!!!!!cplsf]JS4159
/mckmlcy-propo~cd-findlll(!S of-facl n•.lrl m

was subJected to "torture'' 1n retahat1on for

throwmg fecal matter at a guard He says the

"' m guard, Joseph Beahm, told h1m,

gomg to k11/

you."

J'cbru.uy, dcmc~ thc!>e J.llegatiOJls, s.Iylng

staff used only nc<.-ess;~ry force It ,11/ows riML McKmlcy "rclc.to;;cJ. fcc<.s from lm .mus" .111d. W.IS ordered.

to "o;;LOp poopmg"

Al J. t!ISL!plmary hc.1nng Ill Apnl2013, McKmlcy W.Is found "more hkcly than not" to ha\'C b.J.ltcrcd staff and thrown flmd, he was scntcJKcd. Lo .m addlllon.liJ60 d.1ys 111 scgregJtlon lie 1s also facmg felony charges over thlo;; mcld.cnt, for throwmg or cxpdhng bod1ly subst.Inces Th,tt c,lsc 1s scheduled for trmlm August.

Name: MOUtiGEY, AIIDREW C
1

Officer Moungcy,lurcd m 2011, IS 11.1med m 11 of the 40 complauns Another offit-er, l.l Jes~ie Schnc1der, lured. 111 2001, I" named. 1n IS Moungey Jnd Schnc1dcr d1d not respond to mtervH.'W request:. sent v1a letter Jnd ema1l. DOC records show that nc1Lhcr olfiLcr h;~s been mvcst1gatcd for .dlcgauons of mmate ,1buse, Jlthough Sdmeu.ler WJs a u used Jao;;t year of l<~lscly reporting that he athmmstered one dose of pepper spray to a non-compll.lntlhlllJlc wlum Ill f<1Ll ll was two.

(h>lr lfm>r(r r-q~'{!g£!...,6Jfyl(dnLnrr>'glllr 11mfn.1 cJ11 cmn/nr rmi!m! lu;•lo-.:ds'.>I:'!Jio71\IQ wgq• rpgl
W1sconsm Department of Couect10ns Andrew Moungey.
1Name: SCilNEIDER, JESSIE

In all, the Center obl,uncJ rcLortls nl dJsc1plmal)' mvcsllgJLIOIIS for eight \Vaupun employees named frequently m mnutc complo~mts All were for minor mfrJLllOns,IJke hc1ng l.•te, and except for the mudcnt mvol\'mg Schneider, none dealt With the treatment of
mmate~
The st.Ite DOC, m response to a record~ request, pro\'Jdcd mform.Illon on some mctdcnts. But ll rei used to release records regardmg mmate llljllTIC!>, o;;aymg tbts WOIS LOilfldCJll!a/ med!LJI mfurmat10n It also JemcJ access to mtcrnJI complamts filed by mm.Iles agamst gu.uJs Jnd v1J.cos tJken Junng o;;ome alleged mc1dems of .1buse, saymg th1s wouiLI JCopJrdtt,c seen my

'Been looked into'
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 17 of 39 Document 19-1

Advocate Swan, a retired nurse's .ude who hvcs 111 rural H1chland County, wrote the DOC e.:arly tlu.s year askmg that Beahm be removed from duty pcmlmg an mvest1gat1onmto the l.Omplamts Jg:.nnt.l hun

J;Jme<; SdtwodJert, the DOC'<: a<i"il'ltJnt adnumstr.:ator of .uluh mstltutiOn"i, told Sw.mm a letter Chups.lls3.anwwn11\\S com /s1 documcntdoud org/documcnlsfJl477o) (sdn,o<-hcrt letter tu 'll'no.ndr> d.ned Feh. 18 th.ll tlus wouiJ not h.1ppen

'These unnpl.mlts h.we been looked mro, by

W1sconsm Department of CorrectiOns

c1ther •ntcrnal or cJo.terno~lmvesugators," Schwochen wrote "Da~cd on our finding~, they

Lt Jess1e Schneider

JppeJr to be fJbncJtcd to the pomt that the

mm.ues pl.1ce them:-.ch'cs .:ar n<:k ol hemg

<iUbJcCtto d1sc•phne lor nt.lkmg false alleg.nmns about st.tlf."

"Based on our findings, (the complaints) appear to be fabricated to the point that the inmates place themselves at risk of being subject to discipline." - State prison
official

llullJu..:kcy behcves the large number ol comphunts mcru<: further mquuy
"Even 1f evcrytlung they sJy m tlwtlcucr Is true, I'm nul c:;urc why you want to keep the guy m scg," DlLkey sa1d "There's obv1ously sometlung gomg on "
"ll's a pt.ydlOiugiL.tl WJriJrc envnonment," s.ud former \Vaupun mmate Man•m Snuth, who spent the ma1oruy oflut. seven yc.ut. at the pnson m segregation "They know wluch mmates are weak They know wluch mmates they can prey upon "
Smuh, whose ,,IJcgcd Lase uf abuse thd nut mvolve Bc.1lun, s.ml he's heard Bc.1hm sr.nc th.n he w1ll remamm segregatiOn ''He's not gomg .mywhcre I Ic':-. sa1d thJt l!ccause he knows he's tree to make mmatcs' hfe a hvmg hell"

Waupun leads in lawsuits

Currently, mnMtcs allcgmg abut.c have lew opuons he:m.Jcs lllmg thcu ownlJ.wsulls
The AmenLJ.Il CivJII.ibCrtleS Unwn of \V1sconsm fhttr /lwww 11clu \\'1,orgfl IS monnormg Lomhtwns at the Milwaukee County Ja1l .tnd 'laycheedah stare women's prt'lon, both the subject ol past Jitlgatron, hut has no other act1ve CJ.SC"i Lonccrnmg pn<ion cond1Uons.
The Lcg.tl /\S'liSL.HlLe to Instlluuonahzcd Persons Protect Chttp ftlaww1sc cJulf•rtl.upO, run through the Umversny of \V1scons111 Law Sdwol, does not tJ.ke StlLh cases And Lcg.1l Al.tmn of \Vi~COil"illl 'hllp Uw-..nv lcgnluctwn orgfl, ,1 federally lundcd nonprolit agency, 1s barred by IJ.w from domg so
"There's a h1g vo1d bC"LJliW Congress doc<;n't want to hdp mm.ttes," smd John F.hhou, Lcg.tl Actwn's Iarmer C\.ecUlJve director
I.JW:-.tllts by mm.ttc<: Ill fcder.1l court .tre not uncommon Mallhcw !'rank, who served as DOC secretary I rom 200110 2007, s.m.l the pos•uon hnngs ''the dub1ous di<itmcuon of hung the most-"iucd per<;;on m ~l.ltc government "
Poll .:ant, the WJ.rden at \V.:aupun, h.ts been "ned hundreds ofumcs But only a small number of suns proceed lar enough to reqmrc the- st.lle to present a defense
Dunng the three-yc.1r penud from 20111hrough 2013, the :.tntc Do..partment of Jn<>tlce represented state pnson offil'IJ.ls on 49 mmatc lawstnls alleging excc<>:-.IVC use of loro..e, accordmg to a tally provided by dl'p.Lrtmcnt spokeswoman D.ma Brueck.
Ofthct.c, 13 stilts J.rc fromtnnl.ltes dl \Vaupun, more thJn lor any other stale pnson Several of the still' have been dJstmsscd, others arc pcmlmg
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 18 of 39 Document 19-1

Brueck dcdmc<l to commcm on whethn the large number of lawsuns .1llcgmg the usc of e'CcessJVc Ioree at W.mpun m1ght md1cutc a systemic problem "Th.lt 1s .1 question for the DOC," she wrO[e m .an ematl She saul her offit-e's role ts to "defcmlthc :.lJle Jnd pursue remedtes m the best Interest ol dtc :.tJlc" The IJOJ's hsl, prepared m March, omitS at lcJsl fuur addlltonJII.!wsull:. filed by Waupun segregatton mmatc<; miJtc 2013 .md e.1rl)' 2.014 It also docs not mcludc .1lawsuu filed on Feb 11, 2.013, bv Marcus Childs, an lllll\.llC m segregation Clulds allcgct! C!utm !l;n 4~'1!!ZQD m s comlsJ !]qcnms;n!cloud org /documcolsl!lyzSotlclulds compl.unl pdf) th.ll when he was p)J.ced naked m a cold cell m 20il, olficcr Beahm dcmed hun .11..1..C% to a blanket that a psychologist h.td okayed That <.-.lt.c was d••musscd m l\1,\r<.-h 2011 because Lluld"l f.11lcd to "!Ubtnll .t reqtured f1hng Cluld:. lnls<;ed the lilmg because he hung h1m:.cllm lm cell on Feb 2.1, 2013 1 he nonprofir WtscOIISIII c,,Jr,•rfor fmestJg,IIn r loJtnr•ll•sm (11,111 WJSo.0/15111\VntdJ on•) coUabomro?$ wllh W1Scons111 Pub/1,· Roiiiw, lVIS,'tlrlml P11M1c Trle11sron, o/IJcr 11< !IS m.~l/11 rmd /he UW-MadJSOIZ School ofJorm111l15m anJ z.r,u-s Commrmrmlwn All uorJ,.; cr.~llcri, pulr/JSIU'd, J>o>lcd orrl/SScmm>~l••d f')' lilt· Ccn/,r do no/ nrn'smn1y n:fl••r'/ lh,• \'Jews oropmwm ofUlV-MadJ.SO!J or any ofds (lffilillles
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 19 of 39 Document 19-1

[...1004

BLIND SPOTS

- - ·~

~ :: ---

' ---

.::

,•

F

- - F- •

•,

• • . •.:._.:•-=:

:

-~~

F

.-.-

F-

-=

-_ ~.~._--i"'F-"""g,.,--J.~-=~:;.,.,...1'--r:- ~;:- c:- ~-

:--_- _C;~a:s-e->2?::106~-~c:v:-~0:0-5~21_-W>_C~:G·

F=~ile<d~

0c7/2-_- 5/1~6---P<a=g~e~

20

o~f-

39-~-Docum--en. t

- -.
1- 9--1

--

..,_.
-
--

-

. - --"'-:--. -_.2:..:~~-

-j

-"'f"'"fl' - ' ., -~ ,_

FA!LUREATTIIEFAUCET

Water tainted with lead, copper at two

Wisconsin state prisons

Ex..I005

and staff can bring it in

. 1 .f 2..

"The Fox Lake Correctional Institution water systemis

following all state and federal requirements of the Safe

Drinking Water Act to provide safe water for staff, mmates and

visitors to use for drinking, cooking and bathing," Grothman

said.

The Center's ongoing Failure at the Faucet investigatiOn into

risks facing Wisconsin's drinking water reported, however, that

those standards do not always protect public health when lead

or copper is present m a water system

--

For example, Miguel Del Toral, a top U.S. Environmental

Protection Agency official, found that concentrations of lead in

water can vary widely even in samples taken from the same

source on the same day. Del Toral's study concluded that the

existing federal Lead and Copper Rule, part of the Safe

Drinking Water Act, "systematically misses high lead levels.

and potential human exposure."

Abigail Cantor, a Madison chemical engineer who helps water

DEE J. HALL I Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism

utilities comply with the Lead and Copper Rule, said compliance doPs not mean water coming from every tap is

OsbsmdmAeFlmbwatLdlahSFPamonMlAMAuIpscSeeoeuexrgagneeloearopofrenroaogetsooviuvtpattcddgifeitviiaayxnanohttnplnximnlensesWriedpenWmFedilerswkdcktocglaootctlnlgiLpetlirclasLiehoasaesitiehweiuantngnaasaattaayomnaaes.efnxw,paestniuogteu?oimulnrtiashrkgdigadipnkdlsepeanomhrhn_skifvaLparduafeatemneslum,weawetoenraueslfattmttrahaooeFegocenhiasiaihednohtannaakyonxa,tirfpvaooamle,yb,obvhtuagttdfffeestefiof:leahdaCepxliitowsenruoeotohofewmaacrnbnnhseispCWarrJrgoguncreamvntLiba,gomd.fiahdieophaaaroehnstsomgsoerwte.tasttaroaerluleettttsetrhoredlahhrestkoeaamelsiuatsryer.rhcrlarfoanrndcenteeleyfntdptpicloffeePe.eelthnfamcntiayesdCefaoournnwerniixnCfeetl,gtatseDoeaodseloipzsnatsahctgaiitOdolaroborcattn,srenopsstiueelashdhttitrmstertumoamtniSsdnoleepsmntnonhaekaesrnseleatwlsarvew.armstiteieiievvmwp1esiin.fieIlntancareirTlvgdtainheanr25oantoasertIfgmrsaanDecmaelincshaneett0aftaJir:sttooaeivlitifatta1eesetelse-lalltioebaotitontsteinetysyittttfysropsolc6ntlnniuerhrnasFfvcytefsltemlaowsstwtsorrstel-uouotdoeeaoGrutiyiraewcaosavhaitworslevcnrtitwxrtisqssisittmrovt-etseifenenonoesehdtacaheoouoLlaesgt-o1it,nrnNebbabiddeptliwdlww0ctmrt;diaafhtd,ruaeo7neheeroeaCehyeknt0otmaitwcins0um5tresshhorrtspeeetdseeteua,5meat5hoiaeaeWadheroadn.mpgnopdutdrinliatfr2rnuinusoWsrdaamtntFunsstcoiiueie,botdlC1b'rhlwn.alyecsrssohhoetarsiryeanaeirctRcrldioe-olendfxehlsowsnuofn.ksehhWomalnrcdceaifeafodhydwsg5Lrraacnntaeoss.ostoeeteile6asviDsdotC2eoanarrhnnneovcheCeerti-reebdebkruh0oeasgiotcnOtayeorGatgrooieiobaerirr1dchbvueoasfnmniuccwtsmCgnsuoun4esiewesalhnwdtaellosmttdterCaecbaro'aepslnsatsetrn2n-inethengotwrFoeslalielfdoese0osertiatnlitiiensfnotfiahlarnaegvd1atdtpgclansrdswtnloiierghde4ooolenroesdwercofiu,medropnfduiolsewtatrlenptlofnhteaet0aoaseeneee.ndr7rrsr /25s/p"MaidfwhauDOLB"lDfsSSmWhAtcFScTbnrcas1noeohaResehdiraonaooanouoeaioehnarNvrmlNuoukaie6gcnfovlpdvptkrvteadmitvltxeeefexcyrbeohurlc$wroepeeRecpRaEetecsd.eelw,dirltneeoLll7ore,recetrerempehaPotcaTieoteadturrdlP.arnfnarar.tonium2tttahv6reyhAe,hslfoenscghuiaikttglttolkt0eSaec0onoas~eladhmyleFtrsmohpme1Wbyy0teafloatdsnirnoanhgve.s5aooofleEse8mibagmtaotss.duemrIecunbpacoeaacrxuhf.""i,1artoPpfliblownosomieoeoeeEmonecsss3khleMmbda1LAaleral2rasusfuniyeuodsevoaeraee8eegfxanciarn.lth"ppnar1tyaisaetntrsnnieadthks,tcsewcnteuculsdnhsdrehmufd,dmWiapnieshawaaykaops"labiesrlnaanabst,eota'lssmiomtiaeteaieuitltfifotnhbsuuisoenptnnssmortrdeoWFdsisiwtastwpguoessyen3tusdnmalhnrdr.vabiteodsltdistnsnanmosd9esoooodiehilsfigdiceaoixontnsods.wtrlffascnfomeeoa)tselCreheetmofifihnlmLeaaisgdwotphndneoeodawobrhutassinwdDimlaoxopavgcrggrtpnehanrvnesbtdfaitaeecknoasltathbatdmeseoreabwittyeehn(roleFsiveewhhnesasaenrneopcsnreertdordmi"orerieenm'nh,pifniangoasutsdncrcabstfrdiooteiebwbwetksyt2eesaathmrMcteo,o1etsff)oioderun4olmewFihvoaontorhn.Btertudrhae3ftangtaeowooybtouego1ssraaeoeateratrhainnudtx-psemwhddy6ykrnrrntniaacteomtbnseoothe-ehaltlboflLoarpitftphcoyasiemsnuyetozfole1whooutnafusaitlaecnlatu,hserfrxaictuue9.lwdawrkfoCodcedgnsidedtiohceromtxtoTfeor-,ysrharcweec,hosneaetfwk1binntpakstoherahnbohhs,mhanaalfeFomtmy1,oe"iucyeeaatripeaeesrtngbao0etnucrsret.tetvmspgstggeooapnesvorhlxhaohgbmadetoeisa.,ltrfn1piiahw-eraevittirnLntdcwdgdsfs(oeleneierfbhhiceogiTfgonsoopehnairxrrmopertihoWansawrennrtnkrgdhhecwalunetilnenmdgoafaieeeioteeereal1aatasibmttthbttohtraefgtehpaftl5coriehomw,uspe-lkoulevdddruemelwhebtnu-frrteewstngeaearibifhmooasteaardanaiaowhotdthhah,ncsbwraneettit,unrl3eessiiideoaaalrdyotFOtns.aaee0dhrsnteafotgltomdensthrses.xereos,

limited to buying one "overpriced" case every two weeks. Inmates who cannot afford bottled water, Walker told the group, "would fill cups up and it would be dirty, dingy and metal pieces floating in the water. Now this IS after they have let the water run for about an hour ... and then they would let it sit until the pieces fell to the bottom." DOC spokeswoman Joy Staab said she could not confirm the story about the paper plates. A DNR spokesman, George Althoff, could not identify the sechment but said whatever it is would show up in water tests. Inmate lawsuit alleges harm Inmate Ryan Rozak insists the water at Fox Lake Correctional is making him sick. He is suing corrections officials m federal court, claiming they are violating the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. Rozak blames the drinking water at the prison for diarrhea and other health problems. The water, he said, "messes up my body, bones, mind.~~ Rozak recently got two court-appointed lawyers to represent him in his 2015lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Madison. with Judge James D. Peterson noting that the case presented "complex scienufic public health issues." "We are treated like animals and forced to live in pain," Rozak said in a handwritten amended complaint, High levels of copper in water have been linked in adults to nausea, abdominal pain, diarrhea and vomiting. Exposure to very high levels can cause kidney and liver damage. "Conditions of confinement" claims such as Rozak's are based on the notion that "the state, when It puts people in prison, places them in potentially dangerous conditions while depriving them of the capacity to provide for their own ca1 e and protection," then-Georgetown University visiting law professor Sharon Dolovich wrote in a 2009 New York Umversity Law Review article. Another Fox Lake inmate told the Center in a letter that he is concerned about using the prison's water for cooking. Heating water can concentrate the harmful effects of lead which in adults can include lowered immunity, kidney failure, gout, high blood pressure and nerve damage. "Many times we need to let all the faucets run for hours trying to dear the water from brown to dear," according to the inmate, who said he works in Fox Lake's kitchen. "I worry about the pasta and rice we cook, as this must be cooked m our dirty water." Other Fox Lake inmates reported skin rashes, which they blame on water from the prison. Residents of Flint, Michigan, also reported skin rashes after that city switched to a highly corrosive water source that sent spikes of lead from pipes and fixtures into residents' drmking water. However, those rashes have not been scientifically tied to the increased lead levels. It is not known whether the rashes reported by Fox Lake inmates, including JosephS. Cook, are similar to those afflicting Flint residents.

lin a letter to the Center, Cook wrote that the water "is rough to the skin, causing bumps after showers." Lead, copper in water at Waupun Drinking water samples from Waupun Correctional have exceeded the federal standard 10 times for lead and four times for copper since 2008, according to the DNR drinking water quality database. Utilities -including the Fox Lake and Waupun pnsons, which operate their own water systems -can have up to 10 percent of water samples test above maximum levels without violatmg the federal Lead and Copper Rule. Althoff said the "vast majority" of the 140 water samples taken since 2008 at Waupun have tested below the federal limits. The prison hit the 10 percent threshold in 2014, he said. That year, Waupun was required to notify water consumers of the high lead levels, and the DOC provided a notice that it said was posted at the pnson for inmates and emailed to staff in November 2014. The prison added phosphate to the water to prevent corrosion. Waupun Correctional Institution has strngg!ed with high copper and lead levels for years. The 150-year-old prison is using water treatment to keep metals from aging lead and copper plumbing from leaching mto the water. Brian Cunmngham, who has worked as a cmTectional officer at Waupun for 22 years, said he has no recollection of being notified of excessive lead levels in 2014. Cunningham said he has always nustrusted the water at the prison, opened m the mid-1800s, so he brings his own. The prison limits the amount staff can bring in to two bottles no larger than 16 ounces each, he said. In September, high concentrations were again detected at Waupun, including one sample that registered at 120 ppb eight times the federal limit. Despite the high value, Althoff said the prison remains in compliance with the Lead and Copper Rule. Cunnmgham, president of the Wisconsin Association for Correctional Law Enforcement, said the prison did notify staff of the high lead level last fall. But, "Management did nothing else with it- no adjustments to ensming that staff had water or could bring more water in -just a blank statement with nothing more after," he said Added Cunningham: "Inmates have complained abont the taste and the color of Waupun water since I've started working there." · Wisconsin Publ1c Radw reporter Gilman Halsted contributed to this report. Failure at the Faucet
(http·f!wisconsmwatch oralsenes/faucetfml/) IS /he Wisconsin Center for
Investigative JournalismS ongoing mvest1ganon of risks ro \Visconsm~
dnnking water The nonprofit Center (wwm \Wsconsmllbtch om) collaborates wah m'sconsin Publ1c Rad1o, \\isconsm Publ1c Television, other news medw and the University ofWisconsm-Madlson School of Journalism and Mass Commumcatwn All works created, published, posted or dissemmated by the Center do not necessanly reflect the v1ews or opmwns of UW-Madison or any of its af{lliates

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 22 of 39 Document 19-1

New poston Solitary Watch
Su reme Court Justice Kenned Denounces "Human _ Toll" of Solita Confinement and Invites Constitutional Challeng~
by Solitary Watch Guest Author Guest Post by Samuel Weiss and Amy Fettig Samuel Weiss is Ford Foundation fellow at the ACLU's Center for Justice_ Amy Fettig is Semor Staff Counsel at the ACLU's National Prison Project.
'-
In March, Supreme Court Just1ce Anthony Kennedy was testifying before the House Appropriations Subcommittee when r,,~ •-c::eived a question on prison overcrowding. He responded with a sweeping condemnauon of the American prison system. "Total incarceration," he stated, "just isrl't ,-1urhmg." He reserved h1s harshest words for the practice of solitary confinement: "Solitary confinement literally drives men mad "
Justice Kennedy's words were powerful but also left an open question. He called the pnson system "overlooked" and "misunderstood," lamenting that 'We have no in!erest in. corrections." But he IS no outside academic, critiquing the inattentiveness of others. He is a member of a Court both able and required to ensure that conditions inside-prisons comport w1th the Const1tut1on. Indeed, he IS often the Court's sw1ng justice, casting the decidmg vote on what the Const1tut1on requires His influence 1n determimng constitutional quest1ons has led law professor Noah Feldman to wnte, "It's Justice Anthony Kennedy's country- the rest of u.3 just live in 1!." If solitary confinement were indeed a primary concern for the Just1ce, when would 1! make its way to the pages of the Supreme Court's opinions?
Last Thursday, 11 arrived. In Dav1s v. Ayala, the Umted States Supreme Court dec1ded an unrelated quest1on on the exclusion of a defense attorney from part of a hearing on jury selection The defendant, however, had ::;pent much of the past twenty years in solitary confinement, and Justice Kennedy wrote a separate concurrence to address the practice.
Justice Kennedy opened with the long cultural history of the horrors of solitary confmement, cit1ng an 18th century report on prison conditions and a 19th century novel that detail the damage solitary confinement has wrought He continued to 1890, when a United States Supreme Court case descnbed how even short stints m solitary left people
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 23 of 39 Document 19-1

"violently insane." He connected these trends to the present, citing to the story of Kalief Browder, a child who spent years in solitary confinement while being held, though never tried, for allegedly stealing a backpack. Earlier this month, Browder took his own life.

While this long-standing knowledge of the dangerousness of solitary confinement was "[t]oo often" and "[t]oo easily ignored," Kennedy wrote, a "new and growing awareness" on solitary confinement is emerging. Most significantly, he closed by appearing to mvite a case to address these concerns directly: "In a case that presented the issue, the judiciary may be required, within its proper jurisdiction and authority, to determine whether workable alternative systems for long-term confinement exist, and, if so, whether a correctional system should be required to adopt them."

When a Supreme Court Justice talks, the world listens The New York Ttmes dedicated an

editorial to the concurrence, writing that Justice KFo,lredy "raises a constitutional question

even if some of his colleagues would rather avoic ·. lhe Los Angeles Ttmes wrote of the

"rare instance of a Supreme Court justice VIrtually.

.J a constitutional challenge to a

prison policy."

Slate ch1ded Justice Kennedy for his lack of self-awmeness in accusing others of apathy. "Kennedy may have only just discovered the cruelty of solitary confinement, but civil liberties-minded individuals and advocacy groups have fought against the practice for decades." As civil rights lawyers leading the ACLU's Stop Solitarv camoa1an, we know well that advocates have worked for years to confront the practice, but there is also no ques!lon that the Justice's concern reflects a new and growing national movement to end solitary confinement. That movement now has one of the nation's leading moral and legal voices as its center. Read more of this post

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 24 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document
PAVLOV, CLASSICAL CONDITIONING, AND CONDITIONED EMOTIONAL RESPONSES

Page 1 ofll
[x.IO II

1. BIOGRAPHY. Ivan P. Pavlov born m 1849 in the provincial town of Ryazan in central Russia. His father was village priest and mother the daughter of a priest, but both parents had to earn living by working all day in fields as peasants. Oldest of 11 children. This position meant responsibility and hard work at an early age, qualities he kept all his life. At age I 0 a serious fall resulting in a blow to the head lead to a long convalescence in his godfather's care, the abbot of a nearby monastery. The busy abbot encouraged Ivan to read, but insisted that the enthusiastic boy write down his observations and comments before he would talk about the reading with him. This habit started Pavlov on a lifelong habit of systematic observation and reporting. Did not attend school until age 11 due the accident, but his father had tutored him at home, and in 1860 he entered a theological seminary, intending to enter priesthood. After reading Darwin, changed his mind, won a government scholarship, and in 1870 walked serveral hundred miles to attend St. Petersburg University, where he studied animal physiology, and then the Imperial Medical-Surgical Academy where he received M.D. in 1883. He was

too well-educated and too intelligent for the peasantry from which he came, but too common and too poor for the aristocracy mto which he could never rise. These social conditions often produced an especially dedicated intellectual, one whose entire life was centered on the intellectual pursuits that justified his existence. And so it was with Pavlov, whose almost fanatic devotion to pure science and to experimental research was supported ty the energy and simplicity of a Russian peasant."

In his lab, experiments were run and replicated by the hundreds. New workers never assigned to new or independent projects, but required instead to replicate experiements already done. They learned about work in progress and gave Pavlov a check on the reliability of previous work. If they failed, another replication by a third party was ordered to resolve the discrepancy. As an old man he wrote, "First of all, be systematic. 1repeat, be systematic. Train yourself to be strictly systematic in the acquisition of knowledge."
Work on physiology of digestive glands brought him a Nobel Prize in 1904.

2. INTEGRATED MIND AND BODY. "Pavlov created the body and breathed it into the mind," said Gregory Razran in 1965.
Descartes had said that we have (or are) a mind trapped in the physical structure of a body. He viewed the body as a marvelous machine. Reflected in science fict1on stories about transfemng a mind into a different body.
Pavlov and his colleagues: The mind is the product of the workings of a liVIng body, not as a separate entity. Similar to Aristotle's view. Psychological and biological factors are inseparable, so there 1s no specific ailment that could be called psychosomatic. Any disease is psychosomatic.
In 1959, Platanov wrote, "In light of the theory of the unity of mind and body, any somatic disease is indissolubly connected with the state of the patient's higher nervous actiVIty. (p. 12, ref in Malone)

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/dldaniels/Pavlov.htrnl

07/0112013
-~---.

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 25 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 2 of 11

3. SECHENOV. Pavlov dubbed his teacher Sechenov the "father of Russian physiology." Sechenov developed reflex theory and Pavlov followed up and expanded his work. Sechenov had studied with distinguished German physiologists like Johanes Muller, Hermann von Helmholz, and Freud's teacher Ernst Wilhelm von Brucke.
Sechenov emphasized:
(1) Reflexes. "All psychical acts without exception, if they are not complicated by emotion... develop by way of reflex. Hence, all conscious movements resulting from these acts and usually described as voluntary are reflex movements in the strict sense of the term."
(2) The organism/environment field. "The organism cannot exist without the external environment which supports it, hence the scientific definition of the organism must also include the environment." Lewin as well as Pavlov followed him in this view.
4. SHERRlNGTON. Another foundation of his work: Sir Charles Sherrington's findings on the importance of excitation and inhibition in the workings of the spinal cord. Parlov tried to show that excitation and inhibition were likewise evident in the workings ofthe brain.
5. CONDITIONED REFLEX. At turn of century, Pavlov (1849-1936) began to investigate "psycluc reflexes."
When food placed in dog's mouth, dog would salivate. Tlus reflex required no experience to be triggered by appropriate stimulus. Pavlov found that other stimuli that bore no "wired-in" relation to salivation could also trigger salivary reflex ifthey regularly precededJQod delivery. First CS, then
us.
Pavlov devoted the rest of his life to studying these conditioned reflexes, as they carne to be called.
First translations of his "psychological" work into English were in 1927. Earlier impact on American thinking was word of mouth aand hearsay.
6. GOAL: TO UNDERSTAND BRAIN. Pavlov's aim: to work out the principles that govern the workings of the cerebral cortex, the "seat of the mind." Used animal subjects and the CR as main agent of communication with brain. Developed a model of brain function based on fields of excitation and inhibition.
His impact in America has been restricted to the bare flact of classical conditioning, the necessary conditions of association and the nature of the associations formed.
To Pavlov, the conditioned response were merely the key to unlock the secrets of the brain. His primary interest: not in a theory oflearning but to develop techniques for studying the brain. Pavlov's approach is different from the S-R psychology of American behaviorism --it's an S-N (neuronal process)-R theory.

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/d/daniels/Pavlov.htrnl
··----· - - -

07/01/2013

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 26 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 3 ofll

7. RESOLUTION OF ANIMAL-HUMAN GAP. learning in people thought of as acquisition of ideas, perceptions, logical relations etc. Behavior of animals thought of as reflexive and automatic.
Discovery of "psychic" or conditioned reflexes presented a dilemma. The new behavior couldn't be interpreted in the terms of human learning, but had to be simply a new reflex. So Pavlov expanded concet of reflex to include learned reactions, and behavior must reflect correspoding events in nervous system.
Pavlov did distinguish between the "first signal system," sensations arising from the outside world, and the "second signal system," which consists of stimuli that reach people in the form of speech. In his view the latter applied only to humans. Conditioned reflexes represent learning contingent on the first signal system. Recent work with primates has shown than apes can respond to a sign language mediated second signal system, and apparently to dolphins and whales.

8. DISTRACTING STIMULI AND ORIENTING RESPONSE. Careful control of experimental situation needed. Difficult to condition a dog on the street due to distraction. Unstead of giving the CR, animal will be constantly producing investigative responses. To know the properties of a given response, must rule out distractmg stimuli.
INVESTIGATORY REFLEX to novel stimuli. Now called orienting response. Occurs when individuals are concerned or naturally curious or an attention-gettig stimulus occurs. Allied to attention. Fading of this reflex called HABITUATION. Disruption of an already established habituation is called DISHABITUATION.
Relevant: Sokolov's (1960) brain-systems theory. Heightened response is provided by ascending retuclar formation of brain, which also discharges arousal, making one sensitive to stimuli. Like urbanites who get accustomed to high level of sound.

9. FISTULAS. Method of study: stomach fistula, or "Pavlovtan pouch." When fistula made into esophagus so food spills out & doesn't go into stomach, response almost as strong as when it does go into stimulus. Called food in mouth an anticipatory stimulus; then found that sight of dish or even attendant would elicit secretion.

10. CLASSICAL CONDITIONING MODEL:
cs
US--R

The procedure that produces classical conditioning: pairing of CS and US.

Timing: http://www.sonoma.edu/users/dldaniels!Pavlov.htrnl

07/01/2013

--1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 27 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page4 ofll

CS -------------- "Simultaneous"
us -----------------

CS ------------------------Delay (works well:
us-------

CS ------ Trace
us-------

CS -------Backward (works poorly)
us--------

with delay conditioning in animals, in most cases max. delays for successful conditioning, several minutes. Optimum time interval--about half a second.

Depends on elicited behavior. Sometimes called respondent.

11. CHOICE OF STIMULI AND RESPONSES
Choice of a particular UR limits the stimuli that can serve as a US--US must be a strong stimulus that will consistently and unconditionally elicit UR.
By contrast, Pavlov found that virtually any kind of stimulus can serve as a CS to signal the oncoming US.

12. INTENSITY OF STIMULI
Within the limits set by inhibition, the more intense the CS, the faster the conditioning and the larger tHe CR tends to be. But if CS is so intense that it elicits pain or fear, we get a defensive reaction.
CS does not have to be emotionally neutrall --just more nearly neutral than the US. If US is intense enough, CS may be far from neutral. Ex: Spragg (1940) found tat hypodermic syringe initially evoked defensive behavior. After it had been used numerous times to give morphine injectios,

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/dldaniels/Pavlov.htrnl

07/0112013
-- 1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 28 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 5 ofll

animals would go hunting fr it. ONSET of a stimulus, like light or noise, is usually more effective CS than stimulus termination.

13. Viewed a complex behavior as an integrated series of stimulus-response events. Because each part Ofthe senes is a reflex, the entire performance classed as a reflex. "Self-defense reflex" consists of large # of specific behaviors taken together.
14. cs & us
Subsequent writers: one common view: conditioning consists ofleaming by stimulus substitution. But not
consistent with what is known now. CR is different from UR in many respects.
Example:
Notterman, Schoenfeld, & Bersh.
Sit subjects in a chair. Remam as quiet as possible for 90 min. Heasure heart rate with electrocardiograph. US--mild electric shock to left hand. CS--audible tone.
After 11 pairings, heart rate CR developed. But whereas UR was a heart-rate acceleration, CR involved a deceleration.
Closer look suggests that in nerly all cases of supposed stunulus substitution differences between CR and UR exist.

15. For Pavlov, all behavior, both instmctive (unconditional) and learned (conditional), explained on the basis of ELICITING STIMULI. Pavlov's viw oflearning --emphasized LEARNED EQUIVALENCE OF STIMULI, not SR connections as American psychology did. Conceived of US as a signal: the CS signals the US.

16. COMPOUND STIMULI
Why does the response link itself only to the tone, the light, or the experimenter's touch? Do not other stimuli in the situation accompanythe resentation of food?
Explanation: these stimuli are present not only when reinforcement is given, but also under conditions of non reinforcement, so extinction occurs.

16. DISCRlMlNATION LEARNING AND DISCRIMINATIVE STIMULI. Describe. Controversy: Generalization: a separate process, or failure of discrimination?

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/d/daniels/Pavlov.htrnl

07/01/2013

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 29 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 6 ofll

17. EXTINCTION. Pavlov discovered basic process. In a sense it is a process of"unlearning," elimmating unuseful cues. Discrimination, or the shaping of behavior, involves the extinction of unwanted responses. NOTE DIFFERENCE AMONG EXTINCTION AVERSNE OR AVOIDANCE CONDITIONING PUNISHMENT
18. SPONTANEOUS RECOVERY.
19. INHIBITION. An "excitatory" CS more or less reliably predicts an UCS. It produces a CR. An "inhibitory" CS more or less reliably predicts no UCS. Note that these words refer to the predictive character of the CS, not whether what IS predicted is good or bad. Thus an excitatory CS may predict food or strong shock. EX.: hungry dog is fed small bits of food. Just before each piece, green light comes on & stays on while food delivered. At other times, tone is briefly sounded and no food is presented. Soon, no tendency to respond after food. Then conditions change. Light comes on, dog still given food. Also given food on one occasion with neither light nor tone on. Accepts and eats it. Then light and food are presented, followed by tone and food presented during tone. Does dog eat food? No. It turns away. If food forced on dog, it refuses it! Then the green light comes on, food is offered, and dog eats it. The tone has become inhibitory: It evokes an "antifood" response. It is likely that such effects are common in human experience and behavior as well.
20. CONDITIONED INHIBITION is a case of the more general process of the inhibition that forms in the process of discrimination learning (or as Pavlov called it, a differentiation).
21. AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM functions are the responses most easily conditioned classically. They involve the action of glands and smooth muscles. These effectors are often associated with states of emotion. Ex.--fear: saliva dries up, sweat pours out, skm cools, pupils dilate, etc. Emottonal states as well as behavior can be induced through classical conditioning.

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/d/daniels/Pavlov.htrnl

07/01/2013

---t

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 30 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document
22. HIGHER ORDER CONDITIONING. Study by Forsikov: 3rd order conditioning.
S (shock)--------------- R (foot withdrawal) I. S (touch)---------///

Page 7 of II

S (touch) -------------- R (foot withdrawal) II. S (bubbling water)---//

S (bubbling water) ----R (foot withdrawal) III. S (tone)---------/II
But very weak, very unstable.
Everyday life example: Males: US woman's touch, ---------------- UR arousal and physical contact security
I. CS picture of scantily clad,---/// apparently warm, friendly woman

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/dldaniels/Pavlov.html

07/01/2013

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 31 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document
US picture of woman--------------- UR arousal and security II. CS expensive cars, clothes,---/// surroundings

Page 8 ofll

US expensive cars etc. ------------- UR arousal and security III. CS "Prestige" brand deoderant ---/I

23. CLASSICAL CONDITIONING OF FEAR, & ONE-TRIAL LEARNING
Conditioning can be an automatic process that takes place at all levels of awareness. Many attitudes, behavioral dispositions, and even thought patterns are acquired through accidental classical conditioning processes. The numerous \random pairings of events\ in our environments can produce conditioned emotional responses. Example: noise lightning and thunderstorm at night--come to fear the dark. Consider the thousands of different kinds of fears people have. (mention "preparedness.")
Conditioned emotional responses can also generalize to entirely new situations.

24. ANXIETY.
Anxiety and fear: anxiety is similar to fear, but the source is vague and poorly defined. Sometimes completely unknown.
In a sense, with classical conditioning, the organism learns to EXPECT the second stimulus. Example: conditioned asthma. Someone who is allergic to goldfish gets a conditioned asthmatic attack from sunlply looking at an empty goldfish bowl.
This illustrates that there is some cognitive mediation going on, and indeed classically cond1tioned emotional states are often complex phenomena made up of cognitive elements as well as changes in bodily states.

http://www.sonoma.edulusers/d/danlels/Pavlov.htrnl

---~----

07/0112013

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 32 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 9 ofll

25. NEUROSIS
Conditioned emotional responses are at the heart of the kinds of problems we call neurotic.
26. EXPERIMENTAL NEUROSIS:
Or pair a circle with food presentations and an ellipse with no food. After the discnmination is formed, the stimuli are made more and more similar unttl subject can no longer distinguish between the two shapes. Dkob becomes agitated, barkes, salivates, bites at its harness, and generally goes beserk. When placed back in the kennel, it may remain "insane" for months .or years. Pavlov believed that experimental neurosis resulted from a
conflict between excitation and inhibition and occurs when an impossible problem is posed.
Or rats on jumping stand. Bang into door and fall into net or go through. After learning the proper discrimination, problem changed so there is no correct answer. Random punishment not contingent on the response. Results: shaking, quivering, immobilization, general nonfunctionality.
27. CLASSICAL CONDITIONING IN EVERYDAY LIFE
Mealtimes as times of criticism and reproof of child's activities. Anger, shame, sadness, and discomfort by child, along with stomachaches, sweating, headaches.
Other time m dining room, no problem. Other time with parents, no problem. So the sight, taste, and smell of food and internal sensations wtth it get conditioned to the unpleasant feelings. Later aversions or anxieties connected with food and eating, resulting from interoceptive classical conditioning.
28. INTEROCEPTIVE CONDITIONING is classical conditioning in which the CS, UCS, or both are applied to a structure within the body. Soviets have studied this since 1928.
Bykov (1957)
Practical application: May want to increase the activity of a sluggish kidney, increasing 1ts fate of filtering blood and producing urine.
An enema produces these effects (UCS)
Pair a tone, colored light, or other stimulus (CS) is paired with enema (UCS), a conditioned response to the cue appears after less than 20 trials. Periodic repairings will prevent extinction.
Or think of conditioned holdmg the breath or hyperventilation. Bykov's studies have also substantiated these effects.

http://www.sonoma.edu/users/d/dan!els/Pavlov.httnl

07/01/2013
----1

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 33 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 10 of 11

29. EXAMPLES OF CLASSICALLY CONDITIONED RESPONSES: A. HEART DISTURBANCES
a. Various cardiac responses, like heart rate, blood pressure, etc, can readily be conditioned in the lab.
b. Disturbed cardiac functioning often accompanies experimental neuroses in sheep.
c. 20% to 50% of patients consulting doctors because of cardiac complaints show no recognizable organic lesions.
d. functional heart disturbances --those for which no organic basis is apparent, are found in virtually every type ofneur01tic patient to soe degree.
Gantt (1953) has arguedd that almost ail CRs have a cardiac component, and that this component is harder to extinguish than the motor components of such responses.

B. OTHER CLASSICAL CRS
Bykov reports cnditioed bile and urinary secretions, constriction of blood vessels, and blood sugar. Riess reported that the response to insulin can be conditioned to the stimulus
cues of a hypodermic needle. Smith and Dalinger produced conditioned serological reactions in animals. Kleitman and Crisher produced a conditioned retching response. Asthma, hypertension, peptic ulcer, other disorders can be conditioned. Razran reports many oter kinds of conditioning by the Russians.
By contrast, when I light a candle and sit in cross-legged posture, I feel immediate relaxation, decrease in heart rate and breathing, even before begin carrying out any meditative practice.

30. PSYCHOSOMATIC ILLNESS
Effects of classical conditioning on our internal organs has been shown to be pervasive and has many implications for "psychosomatic illness."

3 I. SEMANTIC CONDITIONING
I 3-year old boy, Yuri, was conditioned to salivate to sentences and numbers. First, savilation was established to Russian words for "good" and "bad" as CS+ and CS-. Then Yuri salivated to sentences like: "The Russian army was victorious," "Leningrad is a beautiful city," or "The enemy army was destroyed and annihilated." Did not respond much to sentences that referred to lazy or disobedient students.
He was also conditioned to salivate to the number I0 and not to 8. Afterward he salivated much more quickly and with many more drops of saliva to figures that represented a difference, a sum, a quotient, or a product often than to those related to the number 8.
Russian researchesrs aiso found that younger or retarded children generalize phonetically rather than

http://www.sonoma.edulusers/dldaniels/Pavlov.htrnl

07/01/2013

---------,

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 34 of 39 Document 19-1

Untitled Document

Page 11 of 11

in terms of meaning. They respond to words like BEE and TEA rather than BUSH and PINE. Older children and adults tend to generalize semantically.

32. CONDITIONING WHERE NOT EXPECTED: "PSEUDOCONDITIONING." -In defensive situations. Grether (1938) discovered it --Pavlov had missed it. Pretest with bell--little reaction. Then animals frightened by brilliant flash of light --no bell. Then when bell presented along on posttest trial, strong fright reaction. CS never paired with US. Presumably arises from heightened excitability triggered by any novel stimulus.

33. "SENSITIZATION" --similar. A stimulus that initally produces a mild defensive behavior can be augmented simply by giving the aruma! a series ofUSs alone. Another term for the orienting response.

http://www.sonoma.edu!users/dldaniels/Pavlov.htrnl

07/01/2013 - --,

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 35 of 39 Document 19-1

Warden Pollard Dr Ingres Dr Ludlgson Toni Mell HSC D1rector WlOOC ~lth director
RE: Longterm Seg./AC Programs WQ (Common Grounds)

£.x.IO IS ,f·I·F Z.

Warden Pollard, et al:
Please find endosed the CG (Common Grounds) longterm seg/AC program resolution that FFUP's "think tank"
has put together and donated to Waupun to try to address the longterm seg/AC problems that exist there.
We believe a fresh look at the AC/Iongterm seg. problem IS needed, and we believe common grounds can be part of that solution.

Thank you for your attent1on to th1s matter. We request feedback as to wl\ether this prOgram will be used or any comments on lt.

Smcerely,
FFUP D1rector and Prison Rights Advocacy Coordinator.
Common Ground (CGS)
Logllne: Transltlonlng Prisoners From AC and Longtime Seg.
Goals· Addressing conflict resolutions that prisoners In AC/longtlme segregatiOn have with prison staff and/or among themselves, resulting In the hopeful transltlonlng and release from AC/Iong time seg.
Premise of Program: CGS begins with. tl\e premise that If a prtsor.er has been placed and held In ACilong seg. status there has to be an existence of some kind of conflict between either staff or the prisoner and other prisoners tllat has lead to this long time segregation placement
Unique Approach: Instead of placing blame or approaching the connrct from a subjective point of view, CGS Is designed to not take a partiCular positiOn In th.e conflict, but ~ual\ze the c.onterns vole.~ by both the prlsoners{staff conflict or prisoner/prisoner contnct th.at led to the AC/Iong s~. placement, and Focus on resolutions without placement or blame.
This unique approach Is effective because, as In any conflrct, resolution and all points of view must be alred and ·espected as part or the resolution discussion. No problem l'las ever been solVed by one party In a g1ven conflict being Jurdened with blame, while the other takes on a superiority complex
)bjective: The objective Is to find common grounds that everyone can respect each other's security and
·lasslflcatron concerns without placing blame and the use of Inferiority labels that makes one party feel the need to be

defensive, which Is what most prisoners who are held rn AC/Iong seg. feel This defensiveness has been the main
reason no previous administration/ clinical programs have successfully led to the prisoners transltionlng and
eventual release from AC/Iong seg.
Designed: This Is what makes CGS unique and effective. It was designed speclfl~lly with AC/long seg. prtsoners In mind. After careful review of complaints, court cases, and other view points of prisoners held In these statuses. The CGS think tank recognized the fault lines that kept the prison officials security claims and goals from regiStering with the prisoners and the prisoner's views being considered by the priSon offtdals Both sides took a ~my way or 'the highway" approach. Resulting rn the stalemate with the prisoner stuck In AC/Iong seg. for Indefinite years and the prison officials having to pay the cost of these prisoners becoming more defensive and In the more extreme cases, psvcho\oglcaliy damaged beyond the objective penological goal of the status. And a psychologically damaged prisoner Is not in anyone's best Interest. It Is certainly not In the best Interests of society, where some, If not most, of the
prisoners wtll be freed to; nor the tax payers, who now have to pay extra to staff special housing units to pollee
segregated mental units that are In fact dlsdpllnary segregation units, which only exacerbate the original conflict.
Workshops: The CGS Is organized ln six workShop sessions:
Session One: Begins with both the priSon official and priSoner redudng to written word what each feels Is tl'le contributory problems
CGS freedom of expression: In order For the workshops to be effective there has to be a certain lever of free expression CGS believes all participants must be allowed to state their views free of punishment Free expression does not entitle abusive language used to provoke or disrespect tlu! other partiCipants, or create more problems
Session Two: begins with the prison official recitation of the prisoner's point of view and the prisoner recltatron of the prison offlclals. Or, in case of prlsonerfprlsoner, each would recite the other's views The participant must defend eac.h other's view point as If It was their original view to examine and experience the difference In each other's views
Session Three: begins with each participant putting forth prospective resolutions to the conflict, with discussion.
Session Four: begins with the mediator of CGS- a neutral and Independent person- putting forth resolutions that partt<:lpants should consider. The partldpants ccan accept or alter these resolutions and stipulate.
Session Five: begins with the participants pointing out what Issues of concern that the other one tl.as. Ttl.ey ean agree these are ones to be dealt with and agreements to resolve them.
Sesslcn Six~ begins wltl'l an participants putting forth future resolution commitments to prevent and stop future problems and Incidents
Completion of CGS: Upon completion of CGS, which Is a slx week session workshop, the prisoner participant should be placed In a transition housing to be phased t-ack to general prison population.
Homework Assignments: After each y,orkshop the participant should take a story of real life conflict (past and
present. over the span of ttte worksh.op-s) a.nd write a report stating now both sides to that real life confllc:t could
resolve the matter. Also, what might be the fault line problems preventing the current resolut•ons. The reports shOuld also point out v;;~lld points that each side has that should be taken more serious by the other side.
Final Report: At the completion of CGS, the participant should write a one hundred word essay on how the examination of the report conflicts has Impacted their opinion, aml If so, made a change in view point.
D•sclaimer: The reports written should be permitted some freedom of expression and not be used to continue

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 36 of 39 Document 19-1

AC/Seg. placement, nor future placement. The reportS wlll be either read at sess1ons or by the mediator who will return them to the partiCIPant. Rights: CGS was created by~~FUP In house prose legal consult, R u and FFUP reserves all rights Donation: FF'UP watves the rights to Wl DOC to use CGS as part of the prisoner AC/Iong time seg remedy
FFUP/RU
3
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 37 of 39 Document 19-1

• ~
List o'f Demands
Note: The following are hunger striker LaRon McKinley-Bey's list of demands in accord with McKinley- Bey, et al V. Pollard, et al., case No.16-cv-521 and the Dying to Live Notice demands.
' 1) Negotiations to be conducted between the AC pnsoners and the Dying to Live participants, or their chosen team of citizen and pubhc service representatives, and DOC officials on the terms of the following:
2)Abolishment of the current register, December, 2014, no.708 Chapter DOC long term AC practices, and reinstatement of the old more humane Register March 1998, No 412, Register April 1990, NO 412, Chapter HSS 308 and Chapter DOC 308 AC practices (see attached copy) where AC placement was a classification decision made not by the Warden's appointees but by the Program Review Committee (PRC), and confining a prisoners on AC beyond one year are rarely done or needed ( see attached appendix).
3)Abolishment of long term AC with a negotiated time cap limitation on how long a prisoner can be held in AC beyond 1 year in absence of a showing of credible and verification new information of dangerousness ( see attached DOC 308.01) to JUstifY any extensions. In the rare event of such a rare showing a reasonable time cap limiting the number of 6 month extensions shall apply to safeguard the mental and physical health of the prisoner from the harmful effects of long term seclusion, including use of alternative solutions such as Ihtensive one-on-one programming, or a prisoner exchange to another DOC system that is willing to work with the prisoner to transition him into their general population.
4) Removal of all AC prisoners, especially those with MH2Aor MH2B mental health codes, from the serious and substantial risk of harm to their basiC level of mental and physical health that prolonged isolation in AC, or socalled Restrictive Housing Units, poses.
5) Removal of all AC prisoners from conditions of ISolation as set out in 4, above, and placement in general population conditions with full canteen and property (see attached old chapter 308 at 308.04(12)(b),(h) and(i)
with any property restrictions being those that are proven security concerns that must meet the Turner 1est;
Turner v Safely, 482 U.S. 78, 89091 (1987). This can be accomplishment by (1) removing AC prisoner from isolated units and housing them in secure segregated areas of a cell hall or (2) the establishment by converting an existing facility or construction of a new Restrictive Housing General Population Umt(s)(RHGP) to house AC prisoners in GP conditions where prolonged AC will be severely limited and those so confined provided significantly more out of cell time and allowed to earn Congregate Status (CS) to congregate with other AC pnsoners; (3) open up a wing of the present seg umts, or a tier of a cell hall, where AC prisoners will be securely housed under the conditions set out above with allowance to earn the ability to ambulate back and forth unrestricted one at a time(and to lock themselves into staff controlled buzzer Locked) showers, law library and recreation area, including the establishment of outside rec areas with access to direct sunlight.
6) The establishment of one or more mental healthcare treatment centers for male prisoners modelled and operated hke the one for women at the Taychedah Correctional Institution. This can be accomplished by building of one or more new facilities, or by converting the 180 bed capacity punitive Restnctive Housing Unit at the WCI mto DOC-wide male mental health care treatment and rehabilitation Center.
7) Estabbshment of an independent civilian (non-DOC employed) operated prisoner complaint review system, or the use of an ombudsman to contact prisoner complainants, and to investigate, review and resolve complaint d1sputes independent of the ICRS.
8) Allowance of art supplies and AC hobby and Craft program to responsible AC prisoners. Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 38 of 39 Document 19-1

.

e· z.

9) Availability of educational and vocational programming via court ordered or outside correspondence courses and

a cc institutional channel for airing other meaningful self-betterment programming to AC prisoners.

10) Establishment of a realistic Brighthne Criteria of what each individual AC prisoner needs to accomplish for early release form AC.

11) Given the DOC-wide custom of unaccounfability, and Wisconsin DOC officials' established history and custom of retaliation upon prisoners who are leaders in prison reform, we demand transfer of each Dying to Live hunger striker to another DOC system in the BOP for transition to general populatiOn.

List of Demands Appendix In this effort of reform of solitary confinement practices it is essential that Wisconsm lawmakers and the DOC officials recogmze that the state does not have the caliber of vwlent prison network and culture as evidenced by the lack of inmate on guard or of other staff or inmate on inmate murders, either by violent individual prisoners or the dangerous and violent highly organized STG(security threat group) problem that other states are plagued with. ,In California, Texas, Florida , New York, Washington state, Louisiana, the Federal Bureau of Prisons, to name a few, there is a culture that produces a different caliber of prisoner and level of violence that frequently enough claims the lives of many guards and other staff and pnsoners through inmate violence. We invite any of our supporters with the means and know how to conduct a comparative statistical analysis of the inmate on staff and inmate on inmate violence, including seventy of mjuries and deaths between the \Nisconsin DOC and each of the other states. Further, we believe such an analysis between the DOC and any combinatwn of the others states will place Wisconsin among -if not -the least violent system in the nation. Prisoners in the states listed above hav"' a culture and prison code where murder and great bodily harm are the common objective, and homemade knives and other manufactured weapons are the preferred instruments. The Wisconsin prisoner, and the Midwest prison culture in general , produces prisoners who prefer to settle their disputes VIa fisticuffs and nowhere near the level of violence or catastrophic bodily harm to staff or inmates results.

While acknowledging that the Wisconsin DOC does not have the level of violence as does other prison systems, the Wisconsin DOC officials falsely attribute this to the way that they manage corrections. Actually the way that they manage corrections would have a 2009 state audit find that 61% of the prisoners in seg at WCI were mentally ill and 36% in seg DOC wide were mentally ill. When simply put the Wisconsin system ( one of the smallest m the country) never had nor may never have the necessary culture of violence and group cohesion that produces the Highly dangerous and murderous individuals and prison groups so prevalent and problematic in the other systems. In the final analysis the Wisconsin DOC officials' overuse of AC and prolongated solitary confinement is another exaggerated response to a boogie man of their own making. I've been to a few of the above systems and know that there's a substantial cultural difference.

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 39 of 39 Document 19-1

-- __Drr;u_ -.s ~- c_~k._ _

_ _ JJ.v1~kJ Kb,1es_'ilY.,'G~X~w·r

_ __Ls luAl_ IL\;,rt;_~J'-.J' JJJ·..su../L;.J __ ____ __

__ _ ___ st..z_ _U..JJ _<;.'+,.'(.,_,. _O=t--l:ko«,fe._

___s- n E._W<..s.:...K;~ A!Vlv.L __

-~lw...LUP -1MWO-!rea=d.ST:.J•--u~~3202-

un

u-n-n•n

un

---

P.,c

L1 P41LJ, ~ .J

eJ J.,_ -- ~ v. u

••u

•

nn•n

- ----1
' - -

._____ ___ __ ___C.s~ rJ... lLC,.v_ ~2.1_ _ ___ _

~ ~- -'lli.UP _--r.:l;~ ~ L_: - - - - - - - ~~----- - - -

t""' - - - -Per-

re.ue... .sCJ.~"'i"y-O.r.Li!J., (o<lL~ 12) ;,j -L..J!._LauL e.. CJ}.S.

.v~tld

- --- -~~-utJaserJ k ~A"',_,_Jei ~~-.:I :A --fL_, 4-L--'f:•"' -~:,tt.._ ~10k;~·"-~

-
100_1-JDDI.a Mel lCltl 11"'J LOIS -lOtS/\.

- ..
1:N.C.e.t>~~ 1 -- - ---- - --
- ~~----l-V-L- ~~ &L~/h

--

()_·

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 07/25/16 Page 1 of 1 Document 19-2

 
 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN

LA RON MCKINLEY BEY, Plaintiff,
v. WILLIAM POLLARD, et al.,
Defendants.

Case No. 16-CV-521

The pro se plaintiff, La Ron McKinley Bey, filed this lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 alleging violations of his constitutional rights. The plaintiff alleges that he is mentally ill and that his four-plus year stay in segregation at the Waupun Correctional Institution (WCI) violates his rights under the First, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution. His amended complaint includes a motion for a preliminary injunction. The motion is now fully briefed. For the reasons explained below, the court will deny the plaintiff’s motion.
In his motion preliminary injunction, the plaintiff seeks an order: (1) prohibiting his confinement in prolonged solitary confinement because of his mental health needs; (2) establishing a new Restrictive Housing General Population Unit at WCI to house Administrative Confinement inmates; (3) prohibiting the manner in which WCI staff distribute food so that staff do not precede the food; (4) mandating that defendants establish a Brightline Rule Criterion for the plaintiff to follow for projected release from Administrative Confinement; (5) mandating that the defendants install cameras throughout the segregation unit at WCI, except in non-observation cells, shower cubicles, strip search cages, the HSU room, and visitor booth; and (6) mandating that staff entering

and exiting the Restrictive Housing Unit record their names, as well as the time and date, in a

logbook.

Facts1

The plaintiff arrived at WCI on July 11, 2012 from the Wisconsin Secure Program Facility,

and was in Administrative Confinement status when he arrived. He has been in a restrictive housing

status at all times while at WCI. (Foster Decl., ¶ 5.)

The plaintiff has an extensive history of assaultive behavior. (Id. ¶ 16.) He has received

seventeen conduct reports for battery/assault. (Id.) He has attacked both staff and inmates with

weapons during his incarceration. (Id.) In addition, the plaintiff has received seven conduct reports

for threatening staff. (Id. ¶ 17.) The plaintiff’s most recent assault took place in 2013, when he

threw feces in the face of a security staff member. (Id. ¶ 18.) He went to disciplinary separation

following the assault and remained in that status from April 11, 2013, until he returned to

Administrative Confinement status on March 28, 2014. (Id.) The plaintiff has been reviewed every

six months at his Administrative Confinement Review Hearings and has not been recommended for

release due to his significant assaultive history and refusal to participate in treatment or evaluations

by Psychological Services Unit staff. (Id. ¶ 19.)

Beginning in June 2016, the plaintiff started a hunger strike to protest long-term

Administrative Confinement. (Id. ¶ 20.) WCI Warden Brian Foster had a discussion with the

plaintiff regarding his Administrative Confinement and hunger strike. (Id. ¶ 21.) The plaintiff

expressed a willingness to start eating and receive psychological treatment if he were moved to a

1 This section is taken from the defendants’ response to the plaintiff’s motion for preliminary injunction. (Docket 34 at 4-5.)
- 2 -

different institution. (Id.) Based on this conversation with the plaintiff, Warden Foster spoke with the Division of Adult Institutions Administrator and it was determined that Warden Foster would recommend the plaintiff for transfer to the Wisconsin Resource Center. (Id. ¶ 22.)
Warden Foster met with staff at the Wisconsin Resource Center on August 25, 2016, and they agreed to take the plaintiff to work on programming with the goal of transitioning him to a general population setting. (Id. ¶ 23.) The plaintiff will start out on a higher management unit upon intake at the Wisconsin Resource Center, but will gradually be transitioned to less restrictive housing units as he works through programming, with the ultimate goal of moving him to another institution in a general population unit upon successful completion of programming at Wisconsin Resource Center. (Id.)
After Warden Foster’s meeting with Wisconsin Resource Center staff, he informed the plaintiff that Wisconsin Resource Center had accepted him and he immediately began eating again. (Id. ¶ 24.) Once the plaintiff is medically cleared to be moved, Warden Foster expects him to be moved to the Wisconsin Resource Center.2 (Id.)
Discussion To obtain preliminary injunctive relief, the plaintiff must show that (1) his underlying case has some likelihood of success on the merits, (2) no adequate remedy at law exists, and (3) he will suffer irreparable harm without the injunction. Wood v. Buss, 496 F.3d 620, 622 (7th Cir. 2007). If those three factors are shown, the court must then balance the harm to each party and to the public interest from granting or denying the injunction. Id.; Korte v. Sebelius, 735 F.3d 654, 665 (7th Cir.
2 The plaintiff transferred to the Wisconsin Resource Center on October 13, 2016. (Docket 41 ¶ 2.)
- 3 -

2013); Cooper v. Salazar, 196 F.3d 809, 813 (7th Cir. 1999). The plaintiff’s motion for preliminary injunction relates to alleged conditions at WCI. As
noted above, the plaintiff transferred to the Wisconsin Resource Center on October 13, 2016. Because the plaintiff has been transferred to the Wisconsin Resource Center, his motion is moot. See Moore v. Thieret, 862 F.2d 148, 150 (7th Cir. 1988); Morris v. Kingston, 368 Fed. Appx. 686, 689 (7th Cir. 2010). The plaintiff’s reply brief seems to acknowledge this. For example, while the plaintiff states that at the Wisconsin Resource Center, he is still confined in his cell twenty-two and a half hours per day, he also states that he has been placed in programming whereby he can work himself over time to a “general-population like setting.” (Docket 38 at 2.)
The plaintiff is now at a facility where he may receive treatment for his issues and, as he acknowledges, he may work himself up to a general population setting. His request for preliminary injunctive relief is therefore moot and the court will deny his motion on that basis. The plaintiff may renew his motion by filing a new motion if his circumstances change in the future. See Moore, 861 F.2d at 150.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for preliminary injunction (Docket No. 19) is DENIED.
Dated at Green Bay, Wisconsin this 29th day of November, 2016.
/s William C. Griesbach William C. Griesbach, Chief Judge United States District Court
- 4 -

 
 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN

LA RON MCKINLEY BEY, Plaintiff,
v. WILLIAM POLLARD, et al.,
Defendants.

Case No. 16-CV-521

ORDER

On April 21, 2017, the plaintiff filed a motion for appointment of an independent expert or alternatively for recruitment of counsel. (ECF No. 59.) First, the plaintiff requests that the court appoint an independent expert psychiatrist witness to testify to his or her opinion on matters within his or her medical and psychological area of expertise, pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 706(a). According to the plaintiff, this case is complex and an expert witness will assist the court and jury in understanding the issues as well as provide the plaintiff with the ability to meet the essential elements of his case required at summary judgment. The defendants have not filed a response to the plaintiff’s motion.
“On a party’s motion or on its own, the court may order the parties to show cause why expert witnesses should not be appointed[.]” Fed. R. Evid. 706(a). Expert witnesses are helpful “if scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will assist the trier-of-fact to understand the evidence or decide a fact in issue.” Ledford v. Sullivan, 105 F.3d 354, 358-59 (7th Cir. 1997). Courts are not required to appoint expert witnesses and should appoint them only when necessary to understand complex case facts or complicated, conflicting evidence. Vasquez v. Braemer, 586

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 06/02/17 Page 1 of 2 Document 62

Fed. Appx. 224, 227 (7th Cir. 2014). In this case, given the nature of the plaintiff’s claims, the court does not need an expert at this time. See id. (expert would not have helped establish the subjective deliberate-indifference standard in civil rights action where state prisoners alleged that confinement in administrative segregation exacerbated their mental illness). Therefore, the court will deny the plaintiff’s request to appoint an expert witness.
The plaintiff requests, alternatively, that the court appoint a pro bono attorney to represent him. The plaintiff filed his motion on April 21, 2017, and on the same day the court denied without prejudice the plaintiff’s motion to appoint counsel. (ECF No. 58.) As explained in the court’s April 21, 2017 order, once the defendants file their motion for summary judgment, the court will be in a better position to assess whether the factual or legal issues exceed the plaintiff’s capacity to coherently present his case. (ECF No. 58 at 3.) The court will therefore deny without prejudice the plaintiff’s request for pro bono counsel.
THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for appointment of an independent expert (ECF No. 59) is DENIED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion to appoint counsel (ECF No. 59) is DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
Dated at Green Bay, Wisconsin this 1st day of June, 2017.
s/ William C. Griesbach William C. Griesbach, Chief Judge United States District Court - WIED
- 2 -
Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 06/02/17 Page 2 of 2 Document 62

 
 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN

LA RON MCKINLEY BEY,
Plaintiff,
v.
WILLIAM J. POLLARD, BRIAN FOSTER, TONY MELI, JON E. LITSCHER, CATHY JESS, DR. SCHMIDT, BRIAN GREFF, PAUL LUDVIGSON, CAPTAIN JOHN O’DONOVAN, CAPTAIN WESTRA, JESSIE J. SCHNEIDER, SHANE M. WALLER, JEREMY L. STANIEC, AND JOSEPH BEAHM,
Defendants.

Case No. 16-CV-521

ORDER OF DISMISSAL

The plaintiff has filed a motion for voluntary dismissal without prejudice, ECF No. 64, and the defendants have no objection to the plaintiff’s motion, ECF No. 65. The court will therefore grant the plaintiff’s motion. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(a)(2)
THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for voluntary dismissal (ECF No. 64) is GRANTED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this case is DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. Dated at Green Bay, Wisconsin this 9th day of June, 2017.

s/ William C. Griesbach William C. Griesbach, Chief Judge United States District Court - WIED

Case 2:16-cv-00521-WCG Filed 06/09/17 Page 1 of 1 Document 66

 
 CLOSED,PRISONER
United States District Court Eastern District of Wisconsin (Milwaukee) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 2:16−cv−00521−WCG

McKinley Bey v. Pollard et al Assigned to: Chief Judge William C Griesbach Cause: 28:1331 Federal Question: Other Civil Rights
Plaintiff

Date Filed: 04/29/2016 Date Terminated: 06/09/2017 Jury Demand: Plaintiff Nature of Suit: 555 Prisoner: Conditions of Confinement Jurisdiction: Federal Question

La Ron McKinley Bey and all similarly situated WCI prisoners in isolated Administrative Confinement also known as Laron McKinley

represented by La Ron McKinley Bey 042642 Wisconsin Resource Center 1505 North Dr PO Box 16 Winnebago, WI 54985 PRO SE

V. Defendant William J Pollard

represented by Wisconsin Dept of Justice − 1983 Actions Email: DLSFedOrdersEastCL@doj.state.wi.us TERMINATED: 11/03/2016 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin Wisconsin Department of Justice Office of the Attorney General 17 W Main St PO Box 7857 Madison, WI 53707−7857 608−266−1677 Fax: 608−267−8906 Email: conlinsa@doj.state.wi.us LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Ann M Peacock Wisconsin Department of Justice Office of the Attorney General 17 W Main St PO Box 7857 Madison, WI 53707−7857 608−266−9230 Fax: 608−267−8906 Email: peacockam@doj.state.wi.us ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Brian Foster

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 1 of 8

Defendant Tony Meli

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Jon E Litscher

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Cathy Jess

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Dr Schmidt

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Brian Greff

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Paul Ludvigson

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Defendant Captain John O'Donovan

represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Shannon A Conlin Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 2 of 8

Defendant Captain Westra
Defendant Jessie J Schneider
Defendant Shane M Waller
Defendant Jeremy L Staniec
Defendant Joseph Beahm
Defendant Jane and John Does sued as "ACRC Jane and John Does 1−10" TERMINATED: 07/25/2016 Defendant John and Jane Does sued as "Jane and John Does 1−15" Defendant

(See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
represented by Ann M Peacock (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shannon A Conlin (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 3 of 8

Ms Bonis TERMINATED: 07/25/2016
Defendant
CO Cundy TERMINATED: 07/25/2016
Defendant
John Does sued as "John Does 1−10" TERMINATED: 07/25/2016

Date Filed 04/29/2016 04/29/2016 04/29/2016 04/29/2016 05/02/2016
05/05/2016
05/10/2016 05/10/2016
05/10/2016 05/16/2016 05/16/2016 05/16/2016
05/16/2016 05/16/2016

# Docket Text
1 PRISONER COMPLAINT against All Defendants by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1001, # 2 Exhibit 1002, # 3 Exhibit 1003, # 4 Exhibit 1004, # 5 Exhibit 1005, # 6 Exhibit 1006)(tp)
2 MOTION for Leave to Proceed Without Prepayment of the Filing Fee by La Ron McKinley Bey. (tp)
3 Prisoner Trust Fund Account Statement by La Ron McKinley Bey. (tp)
4 LETTER from the clerk to La Ron McKinley Bey re Consent/Refusal to Magistrate Judge David E. Jones and requesting that the consent/refusal form be filed within 21 days (tp)
5 AMENDED COMPLAINT with Jury Demand against All Defendants filed by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Ex 1001−1006 (with bookmarks), # 2 Cover Letter)(Document received for e−filing by WCI on 5/2/2016; received by USDC on 5/4/2016)(tlf) (Entered: 05/05/2016)
6 ORDER signed by Judge Rudolph T. Randa on 5/5/2016 that on or before 5/26/2016 plaintiff shall forward to the Clerk of Court the sum of $6.19 as an initial partial filing fee in this action. (cc: all counsel, via mail to La Ron McKinley Bey and Warden at Waupun Correctional Institution)(cb) (Entered: 05/06/2016)
7 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter, # 2 Proposed Order) (tp) (Entered: 05/11/2016)
8 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 7 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1010, # 2 Exhibit 1011, # 3 Exhibit 1012, # 4 Exhibit 1013, # 5 Exhibit 1014, # 6 Affidavit of McBride, # 7 Affidavit of Luis Nieves, # 8 Affidavit of Rayshun Woods #1, # 9 Affidavit of Rayshun Woods #2, # 10 Affidavit of Shirell Watkins #1, # 11 Affidavit of Shirell Watkins #2, # 12 Affidavit of Terrance Prude, # 13 Affidavit of Lamar Larry) (tp) (Entered: 05/11/2016)
9 DECLARATION of La Ron McKinley Bey (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1007, # 2 Exhibit 1008, # 3 Exhibit 1009) (tp) (Entered: 05/11/2016)
10 REFUSAL to Consent to Jurisdiction by US Magistrate Judge by La Ron McKinley Bey. (tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)
11 MOTION to Certify Class by La Ron McKinley Bey. (tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)
12 DECLARATION of La Ron Mckinley Bey in Support of 11 (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit of Rayshun Woods, # 2 Affidavit of Shirell Watkins, # 3 Affidavit of Lamar Larry, # 4 Affidavit of Daniel R McBride, # 5 Affidavit of Luis A Nieves, # 6 Affidavit of Rayshun Woods #1, # 7 Affidavit of Shirell Watkins #1)(tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)
13 MOTION to Appoint Counsel by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)
14 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 13 MOTION to Appoint Counsel. (tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 4 of 8

05/16/2016 05/16/2016 05/19/2016 05/23/2016 06/30/2016
07/25/2016 07/28/2016 07/28/2016 07/28/2016 08/03/2016
08/04/2016 08/15/2016
08/17/2016 08/23/2016 08/23/2016 08/24/2016 08/26/2016

15 DECLARATION, Exhibit 1007, and letters from counsel(with Bookmarks) of La Ron McKinley Bey in support of 13 Motion to Appoint Counsel. (tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)
16 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 11 MOTION to Certify Class. (tp) (Entered: 05/17/2016)
17 LETTER from La Ron McKinley Bey inquiring about docket entries. Copy of docket sheet mailed to plaintiff 5/19/2016. (tp)
INITIAL PARTIAL FILING FEE Received: $6.19, receipt number MK4689−059150. ; the payment of all future filing fees will be maintained by the financial department (bx)
18 ORDER signed by Judge Rudolph T. Randa on 6/30/2016. 2 Plaintiff's MOTION for Leave to Proceed Without Prepayment of the Filing Fee GRANTED. 7 Plaintiff's MOTION for Preliminary Injunction DENIED. 11 Plaintiff's MOTION to Certify Class DENIED. 13 Plaintiff's MOTION to Appoint Counsel DENIED without prejudice. By 7/29/2016 6/29/2016 plaintiff may file amended complaint on enclosed form. Wis. Dept. of Corrections to collect $343.81 balance of filing fee from plaintiff's prison trust account. (cc: all counsel, via mail to LaRon McKinley Bey (with copy of EDWI complaint form) and Warden at Waupun Correctional Institution)(cb) Modified on 7/1/2016 (asc).
19 AMENDED COMPLAINT with jury demand against all Defendants and MOTION for Preliminary Injunction filed by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibits (with bookmarks), # 2 Cover Letter)(tlf) (Entered: 07/26/2016)
20 MOTION to Appoint Counsel by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(tlf) (Entered: 07/29/2016)
21 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 20 MOTION to Appoint Counsel. (tlf) (Entered: 07/29/2016)
22 DECLARATION of La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibits (with bookmarks))(tlf) (Entered: 07/29/2016)
Due to the unavailability of Judge Rudolph T. Randa, this case has been reassigned to Chief Judge William C Griesbach. Consent/refusal forms for Magistrate Judge William E. Duffin to be filed within 21 days. The consent/refusal form is available at the court's web site: www.wied.uscourts.gov. (blr)
23 LETTER from the clerk to plaintiff re case reassignment and requesting that the consent/refusal form for Magistrate Judge William E. Duffin be filed within 21 days. (blr)
24 ORDER. The 19 Amended Complaint will be the operative complaint in this action. The defendants shall file a response to the plaintiff's request for a preliminary injunction within twenty−one (21) days of the date of this order. Plaintiff's 20 MOTION to Appoint Counsel is DENIED without prejudice. Defendants shall file a responsive pleading to the complaint within 60 days of receiving electronic notice of this order. (See order for further details.)(cc: all counsel and via U.S. Mail to LaRon McKinley Bey and Attorney General Corey F. Finkelmeyer)(Griesbach, William)
25 REFUSAL to Consent to Jurisdiction by US Magistrate Judge by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(tlf) (Entered: 08/18/2016)
26 MOTION for Reconsideration by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(tlf)
27 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 26 MOTION for Reconsideration. (tlf)
28 ORDER denying 26 Motion for Reconsideration. (cc: all counsel) (Griesbach, William)
Copy of Order on Motion for Reconsideration 28 sent via U.S. Mail to LaRon McKinley Bey (lh)

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 5 of 8

09/01/2016
09/01/2016
09/01/2016
09/01/2016 09/08/2016
09/23/2016 09/26/2016
09/27/2016 09/27/2016 10/14/2016
10/17/2016 11/02/2016 11/02/2016 11/02/2016 11/02/2016 11/03/2016 11/21/2016 11/28/2016 11/29/2016 11/29/2016

29 NOTICE of Appearance by Ann M Peacock on behalf of Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra. Attorney(s) appearing: Ann M. Peacock and Shannon A. Buttchen (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Peacock, Ann)
30 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE BY DOJ as to Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra (Peacock, Ann)
31 MOTION for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction (ECF No. 19) by Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra. (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Peacock, Ann)
32 DECLARATION of Monica Burkert−Brist (Peacock, Ann)
TEXT ONLY ORDER GRANTING 31 MOTION for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction (ECF No. 19 ) filed by Defendants, signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 09/08/2016. Defendants have until 9/27/2016 to file a response to the Motion for Preliminary Injunction. (cc: all counsel by efile; McKinley Bey via U.S. Mail)(Griesbach, William)
33 LETTER from La Ron McKiinley Bey requesting a deadline for his reply in support of 19 Motion for Preliminary Injunction. (tlf)
TEXT ONLY ORDER signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 9/26/2016. Plaintiff's reply in support of 19 Motion for Preliminary Injunction is due 10/27/2016. (cc: all counsel via CM/ECF, La Ron McKinley Bey via U.S. Mail)(Griesbach, William)
34 RESPONSE to Motion filed by all Defendants re 19 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction . (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Peacock, Ann)
35 DECLARATION of Brian Foster (Peacock, Ann)
36 ANSWER to 19 Amended Complaint by Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra. (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Peacock, Ann)
37 SCHEDULING ORDER: Discovery due by 1/16/2017 Motions due by 2/14/2017 (cc: all counsel and via US mail to Le Ron McKinely Bey)(Griesbach, William).
38 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 19 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction. (jcl) (Entered: 11/03/2016)
39 DECLARATION of Laron McKinley Bey (jcl) (Entered: 11/03/2016)
40 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by La Ron McKinley Bey (jcl) (Entered: 11/03/2016)
NOTICE of Change of Address as to La Ron McKinley Bey to Wisconsin Resource Center. (tlf) (Entered: 11/04/2016)
41 DECLARATION of Laron McKinley Bey (Attachments: # 1 Disbursement Request, # 2 Letter)(cav) (Entered: 11/04/2016)
42 REQUEST for Production of Documents by La Ron McKinley Bey (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(mac) (Entered: 11/22/2016)
43 DISCOVERY NOTICE by the Court. Sent via US mail to McKinley Bey (mac)
44 ORDER denying 19 Motion for Preliminary Injunction. (cc: all counsel) (Griesbach, William)
Copy of Order on Motion for Preliminary Injunction 44 sent via U.S. Mail to LaRon McKinley Bey (cav)

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 6 of 8

12/01/2016 12/01/2016
12/01/2016 12/07/2016 02/01/2017
02/01/2017 02/02/2017
02/02/2017 03/10/2017 03/10/2017 03/10/2017 03/10/2017 03/10/2017 03/16/2017
03/23/2017 04/21/2017
04/21/2017 04/21/2017 04/21/2017

45 NOTICE of Change of Address as to La Ron McKinley Bey (Attachments: # 1 Clerk's Response Letter) Copy of docket sheet and Clerk's Response Letter sent via US mail to McKinley Bey. (mac) (Entered: 12/02/2016)
46 MOTION for Order to Pay Outstanding Filing Fee Debt from Release Account by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Prisoner Trust Account, # 2 Certificate of No Memorandum, # 3 Request for Leave to File Motion, # 4 Cover Letter)(mac) (Entered: 12/02/2016)
47 DECLARATION of La Ron McKinley Bey (mac) (Entered: 12/02/2016)
48 ORDER granting 46 Motion for Order to Pay Filing Fee from Release Account, signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 12/06/2016. (cc: all counsel, Plaintiff and Warden WRC via U.S. Mail ) (Griesbach, William)
49 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Dispositive Motions by Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra. (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Conlin, Shannon)
50 DECLARATION of Shannon A. Conlin in Support of Defendants' Motion for Extension of Time to File Dispositive Motions (Conlin, Shannon)
TEXT ONLY ORDER GRANTING 49 MOTION for extension of Discovery deadline through May 1, 2017 and extension of Dispositive Motion deadline through August 14, 2017, filed by William Pollard, Jessie J Schneider, John O'Donovan, Tony Meli, Brian Greff, Jon E Litscher, Brian Foster, Paul Ludvigson, Joseph Beahm, Captain Westra, Shane M Waller, Cathy Jess, Dr Schmidt, Jeremy L Staniec, signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 02/01/2017. (cc: all counsel via efile and La Ron McKinley Bey via U.S. Mail)(Griesbach, William)
Copies of 2/2/17 text order extending deadlines mailed to LaRon McKinley Bey and Deadlines reset: Discovery due by 5/1/2017 Motions due by 8/14/2017. (cc: all counsel)(Griesbach, William)
51 MOTION for Leave to File Motions by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(cav)
52 MOTION to Appoint Mediator by La Ron McKinley Bey. (cav)
53 DECLARATION of Laron McKinley Bey re 52 Motion to Appoint Mediator (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(cav)
54 MOTION to Appoint Counsel by La Ron McKinley Bey. (cav)
55 DECLARATION of Laron McKinley Bey re 54 Motion to Appoint Counsel(cav)
56 RESPONSE to Motion filed by Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra re 52 MOTION to Appoint Mediator, 51 MOTION for Leave to File . (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Conlin, Shannon)
57 REPLY BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 54 MOTION to Appoint Counsel, 52 MOTION to Appoint Mediator. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(cav)
58 DECISION AND ORDER signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 4/21/2017 GRANTING 51 Motion for Leave to File Motions, DENYING without prejudice 52 Motion to Appoint Mediator, and DENYING without prejudice 54 Motion to Appoint Counsel. (cc: all counsel and via US Mail to McKinley Bey) (Griesbach, William)
59 MOTION to Appoint Counsel by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Cover Letter)(cav)
60 BRIEF in Support filed by La Ron McKinley Bey re 59 MOTION to Appoint Counsel. # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D) (cav).
61 DECLARATION of La Ron McKinley Bey (cav)

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 7 of 8

06/02/2017 06/02/2017 06/08/2017 06/08/2017
06/09/2017

62 ORDER Denying without prejudice 59 Motion to Appoint Counsel signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 6/1/2017. (cc: all counsel and via US Mail to Plaintiff) (Griesbach, William)
63 FILING FEE PAID IN FULL (bx)
64 MOTION for Voluntary Dismissal by La Ron McKinley Bey. (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of No Memorandum)(mac)
65 RESPONSE to Motion filed by Joseph Beahm, Brian Foster, Brian Greff, Cathy Jess, Jon E Litscher, Paul Ludvigson, Tony Meli, John O'Donovan, William J Pollard, Dr Schmidt, Jessie J Schneider, Jeremy L Staniec, Shane M Waller, Captain Westra re 64 MOTION to Dismiss . (Attachments: # 1 Certificate of Service)(Conlin, Shannon)
66 ORDER DISMISSING CASE. 64 MOTION to Voluntarily Dismiss filed by La Ron McKinley Bey is Granted and this case is Dismissed without prejudice, signed by Chief Judge William C Griesbach on 6/9/2017. (cc: all counsel and via US Mail to Plaintiff)(Griesbach, William)

Case: 2:16-cv-521 As of: 01/23/2018 10:53 AM CST 8 of 8