Case: Firm Hansraj Nathu Ram Vs. Firm Lalji Raja &amp; Sons

2. On December 3, 1949, a decree was passed in favour of the respondent by the Sub-ordinate Judge, Bankura, in West Bengal and a certificate of transfer was applied for on July 27, 1950, granted on August 8, 1950, and was transferred for execution on August 28, 1950. On September 25, 1950, the decree-holder took out execution in the Court of the Additional District Judge, Morena, in what was Gwalior State and subsequently became a part of the United State named Madhya Bharat and after the Constitution the Part B State of Madhya Bharat. On the judgment-debtors objection the application for execution was dismissed on December 29, 1950, but the appeal against that order was allowed by the High Court on November 15, 1954.

Court's reasoning:
6. It was next argued that the appellant firm was not a foreigner because it did not fall under the Foreigners Act (Act 31 of 1946) and reference was made to S. 2 (a)(iii) which was amended by Act 38 of 1947 on December 15, 1947; but this Act is not relevant for the purpose of finding out whether the decree was a foreign decree or not because the execution of decrees is governed by the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure and not by the Foreigners Act. Under the former a decree can be executed by a Court which passed the decree or to which it was transferred for execution and the decree which could be transferred has to be a decree passed under the Code and the Court to which it could be transferred has to be a Court which was governed by the Indian Code of Civil Procedure. But in the present case it was not transferred to a Court which at the time of the transfer was governed by the Indian Code of Civil Procedure and therefore the transfer was ineffective for the purpose of execution and as we have said above, S. 43 of the Indian Code was inapplicable before Act II of 1951 to the State of Madhya Bharat. It is not necessary to go into the other questions raised if the above two questions are decided against the respondent.