[PAGE 1]
1. I have just been advised of the proposed action to be taken in the casc of Messrs. Drum and Gottlieb and feel that in view of πy position and responsibilities, it is my duty to exprcss an opinion in this ratter.

2.. I fecl that a formal rcprimand in this casc would be an injustice since reprimands arc applicable to those guilty of negligence, disloyalty, or willful acts detrimental to an organization, rather than to those involved in difficult circumstances caused by mischanec or factors beyond our control. In this case, I believe that both men concerned acted in gaod faith and with the desire to aivance their work. Whether they lacked the forcsight or wisdom to grasp all the possibilities that might occur is, of coursc, dcbatable.

3. If such action were taken in the tradition of the sca where the commander is automatically at fault in case of failure, then it would be in order to apply the reprimand to both Dr. Gibbons and myself,

4. I sinccrely hope that this matter will be again reviewed, not only in the intercst of justice, but also in te interest of maintaining the spirit of initiative and enthusiasm so neccssary to our . work.

TSS/OC:ldef/jel (2 February 1954)

VIA : Gen. Cábell

MEMORANDUM FOR: MR, DULLES

LUIS deTLOREZ ResearchChiirman

Memo fot Rncord: Original reiurned to Idn deFlorez on l0 Feb, W/note iros uen Cabeli (on the cover shect) as follows: "Your request acceded to." …km.