Still life paintings by Vincent van Gogh (Paris)

Still life paintings by Vincent van Gogh (Paris) is the subject of many drawings, sketches and paintings by Vincent van Gogh in 1886 and 1887 after he moved to Montmartre in Paris from the Netherlands. While in Paris, Van Gogh transformed the subjects, color and techniques that he used in creating still life paintings.

He saw the work and met the founders and key artists of Impressionism, Pointillism and other movements and began incorporating what he learned into his work.  Japanese art, ukiyo-e, and woodblock prints also influenced his approach to composition and painting.

There was a gradual change from the somber mood of his work in the Netherlands to a far more varied and expressive approach as he began introducing brighter color into his work. He painted many still life paintings of flowers, experimenting with color, light and techniques he learned from several different modern artists before moving on to other subjects.

By 1887, his work incorporated several elements of modern art as he began to approach his mature oeuvre.  Excellent examples are the Pairs of Shoes paintings, where in the space of four paintings one can observe the difference between the first pair of boots made in 1886, similar to some of his earlier peasant paintings from Nuenen, to the painting made in 1887 that incorporates complementary, contrasting colors and use of light.  Another example are the Blue Vases paintings made in 1887 that incorporate both color and technique improvements that result in uplifting, colorful paintings of flowers.

In the spring of 1887, Van Gogh left the city proper for a visit to Asnières with his friend Émile Bernard.  While there his work was further transformed stylistically and through the use of bright, contrasting color and light.  See his works from Asnières and Seine.

Background

Netherlands
From 1880 to 1885, Van Gogh began working as an artist in earnest. He was influenced not only by the great Dutch masters but also to a considerable extent by his cousin-in-law Anton Mauve a Dutch realist painter and a leading member of the Hague School.

Van Gogh's palette consisted mainly of dark earth tones, particularly dark brown.  His brother Theo, an art dealer, commented that his work was too somber to be marketable and encouraged him to explore modern art, particularly Impressionism for its bright, colorful paintings.

Modern art
In 1886, Van Gogh left the Netherlands and traveled to Paris to explore emerging artistic movements under the guidance and continued support of his brother Theo van Gogh, an art dealer. Surprised that Vincent had come to Paris unannounced, and in opposition to their conversations about timing of his arrival, Vincent stayed in Theo's apartment on Rue Laval until a larger apartment could be acquired. For four months, Van Gogh studied with Fernand Cormon, painting plaster casts, live nude models and props available at Cormon's studio.  Cormon also encouraged open-air painting.  There he met Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec, Émile Bernard, and Louis Anquetin. Through Theo and artistic social circles he also met Edgar Degas, Camille Pissarro, Paul Signac, Georges Seurat, and Paul Gauguin.  Through the fellowship with these men, he was introduced to Impressionists, Symbolists, Pointillists, and Japanese art, Ukiyo-e, and woodcut prints. In spite of his unusual demeanor, disheveled clothes and often time frightening manner, Paris was the one place where Van Gogh developed friendships with other artists.  So much so that when Toulouse-Lautrec heard disparaging remarks against Van Gogh, he challenged the man to a duel. Seeing and trading artwork with the Parisian avant-garde artists, Van Gogh understood what Theo had been trying to tell him for years about modern art. He was able to experiment with each of the movements to develop his own style, becoming what some say is "one of the most important artists in modern art."

Romanticism
Romanticism was an art and literature movement formed by people looking to escape the drab world.  Its characteristics are paintings of "exotic lands" with grandiose feeling and intense color. Adolphe Joseph Thomas Monticelli developed a highly individual Romantic style of painting with richly colored, dappled, and textured painting and glazed surfaces. Monticelli was a French painter of the generation preceding the Impressionists who was friends with Narcisse Diaz, a member of the Barbizon school, and the two often painted together in the Fontainebleau Forest. Vincent van Gogh, greatly admired his work after seeing it in Paris when he arrived there in 1886. Van Gogh was influenced by the richness that he perceived in Monticelli's work. In 1890, Van Gogh and his brother Theo were instrumental in publishing the first book about Monticelli.

Impressionism
The Impressionism movement was a change from traditional artistic techniques.  With Impressionism the intention was to depict colors and images the way they are seen, not the way that artists were taught to paint them.  Aspects of Impressionism include using gleaming spots of light, color in shadows, colors straight from the tube in dots or dashes, and dissolving firm outlines.

Neo-impressionism
Van Gogh was influenced by Impressionists Edgar Degas and Claude Monet, but even more so by Neo-impressionist Georges Seurat, partly because of the use of dots of contrasting colors to intensify the image, a technique called Pointillism.  Van Gogh likened painting with constructing small, thoughtfully placed dashes of color to writing "words in a speech or a letter".

Cloisonnism
Cloisonnism is a style of Post-impressionist painting with bold and flat forms separated by dark contours. The term was coined by critic Edouard Dujardin on occasion of the Salon des Indépendants, in March 1888. Artists Émile Bernard, Louis Anquetin, Paul Gauguin, Paul Sérusier, and others started painting in this style in the late 19th century. The name evokes the technique of cloisonné, where wires (cloisons or "compartments") are soldered to the body of the piece, filled with powdered glass, and then fired. Many of the same painters also described their works as Synthetism a closely related movement.

Post-impressionism
Post-Impressionism is the term coined by the British artist and art critic Roger Fry in 1910 to describe the development of French art since Manet. Fry used the term when he organized the 1910 exhibition Manet and Post-Impressionism. Post-Impressionists extended Impressionism while rejecting its limitations: they continued using vivid colours, thick application of paint, distinctive brush strokes, and real-life subject matter, but they were more inclined to emphasize geometric forms, to distort form for expressive effect, and to use unnatural or arbitrary colour.

Japanese ukiyo-e
Characteristic features of Ukiyo-e woodprints include their ordinary subject matter, the distinctive cropping of their compositions, bold and assertive outlines, absent or unusual perspective, flat regions of uniform colour, uniform lighting, absence of chiaroscuro, and their emphasis on decorative patterns. One or more of these features can be found in numbers of Vincent's paintings from his Antwerp period onwards. Van Gogh wrote, "If we study Japanese art, we see a man who is undoubtedly wise, philosophical and intelligent, who spends his time… studying a single blade of grass.  But this blade of grass leads him to draw every plant, and then the seasons, the wide aspects of the countryside, then animals, then the human figure… isn't it almost a true religion which these simple Japanese teach us, who live in nature as though they themselves are flowers.  And you cannot study Japanese art, it seems to me, without becoming much gayer and happier."

Color theory and technique

One of the most transformational elements of Van Gogh's work during his period in Paris was his use of color.  Van Gogh used complementary, contrasting colors to bring an intensity to his work.  Two complementary colors of the same degree of vividness and brightness placed next to one another produce an intense reaction, called the "law of simultaneous contrast."

From his days in the Netherlands Van Gogh became familiar with Delacroix's color theory and was fascinated by color. While in Nuenen Van Gogh became familiar with Michel Eugène Chevreul's laws in weaving to maximize the intensity of colors through their contrast to adjacent colors.

In Paris, Van Gogh eagerly studied Seurat's use of complementary colors. Excited to try out complementary studies, Van Gogh would divide a large canvas into several rectangular sections, trying out "all the colors of the rainbow." There he was also exposed through his brother Theo to Adolphe Monticelli's still life work with flowers, which he admired.  He saw Monticelli's use of color as an expansion of Delacroix's theories of color and contrast.  He also admired the effect Monticelli created by heavy application of paint.

In the still life series, particularly of flowers, Van Gogh experimented with color relationship, such as complementary, contrasting colors which are colors across from one another on the color wheel.  A second color relationship, harmonious colors are colors adjacent to one another on the color wheel.  He also used the trio of colors, where the relationship on the color wheel forms a triangle.

Balls of yarn
To help him choose colors for his studies, Van Gogh collected strands of different shades of yarn to experiment with color combinations.  He rolled selected strands together into balls in combinations matching specific paintings, such as the yellow and ocher combinations found in Still Life with Quince Pears and Lemons (F383). The box and his sample balls of yarn have survived and are held by the Van Gogh Museum.

Still life
Soon after Van Gogh arrived in Paris, he began painting still lifes with the goal of experimenting with contrasting colors. He wrote to a friend in England that his goal was to create "intense coloration, not gray harmony."

His started with still lifes of flowers.  At first his still lifes maintained the subdued tones that he used in the Netherlands.  The more he became immersed in his painting, he continually added brighter colors to his work until he was using colors directly from the tube.  Then he moved on to other subjects from everyday life that reflect his use of vivid colors and a free brushstroke.

Van Gogh courted Agostina Segatori, the owner of the Café du Tambourin on the boulevard de Clichy, for a period of time and gave her paintings of flowers, "which would last for ever".

The energy that Van Gogh put into his Still Life paintings is representative of his habit for "working systematically, concentrating on a theme until he had exhausted it."

Flowers
Flowers were the subject of many of Van Gogh's paintings in Paris, due in great part to his regard for flowers.  Knowing Van Gogh's interest in making still life paintings of flowers, friends and acquaintances in Paris sent bouquets of flowers weekly for his paintings. He also purchased inexpensive bouquets himself, choosing flowers in a variety of types and colors for his paintings. Many of his still life paintings of flowers reflect a sense of overabundance of European still lifes, where blossoms fill the canvas, blooms spill out of the vase or stems of flowers teeter on the edge of the vase.

Van Gogh carefully studied the art of floral arranging, the works of Dutch masters, Japanese woodcut prints and Impressionist still life arrangements to master his paintings of flowers. Expressing his enthusiasm for the subject and the number of paintings he completed in Paris, Van Gogh wrote to his sister Wil, "I painted almost nothing but flowers so I could get used to colors other than grey - pink, soft or bright green, light blue, violet, yellow, glorious red." His expertise in color, composition, texture and placement may have made an impression on Constance Spry, a noted floral arranger who created guidelines for flower arranging as an art form.  She learned a great deal about "structure, style, form, balance, harmony and rhythm" from studying the paintings by great masters of flowers.

The longer he was in Paris, the more he had an Asian aesthetic for flowers. As he said to his brother Theo: "You will see that by making a habit of looking at Japanese pictures you will come to love to make up bouquets and do things with flowers all the more."

Van Gogh had an agreement with the Agostina Segatori proprietress of Café du Tambourin, an establishment that catered to Montmartre artists, for meals in exchange for a few paintings each week.  Soon the walls of the café were full of floral still life paintings.

Carnations

Chrysanthemums
Chrysanthemums, often depicted in Japanese woodcut prints, were painted by Impressionists primarily in floral arrangements.  The most desired chrysanthemum was an autumn-blooming variety from Japan.

Fritillaries
Imperial Fritillaries in a Copper Vase (F213) reflects the influences of Neo-Impressionist Paul Signac.  The background is painted with Pointillist brushwork. The painting was made with complementary, contrasting colors of blue and orange. Van Gogh was not a purist; he varied the shades of contrasting colors and chose subjects that he enjoyed, such as painting still lifes. Fritillary is a bulb that flowers in the spring with between three and ten flowers for each bulb. Imperial fritillaries, with an orange-red flower, were grown in French and Dutch gardens at the end of the 19th century.

Gladiola
 The Gladiolus, plural Gladioli, was one of Van Gogh's favorite flower.  He especially enjoyed how they opened up like a fan after having been placed in a vase. Because of their height, Van Gogh liked to use Gladioli to create triangular-structured compositions, such as Vase with Gladioli and Carnation (F237) or an inverted triangle as in Vase with Gladioli and China Asters (F248a).

Poppies
Vase with Red Poppies (F279) is another illustration of how Van Gogh used red and green primary, complementary colors to make both colors appear more intense, set before a blue background.  He paints pink in the unopened buds and sienna in the table.

Roses
Van Gogh's paintings of rose, or any flowers, are evocative of his quote, "Ah, what portraits could be made from nature with photography and painting."

Sunflowers

Two Cut Sunflowers (F375) is one of a sequence of four paintings that Van Gogh made in the summer of 1887. The first (Van Gogh Museum, F377) was a preparatory sketch.  Paul Gauguin had the second and third Two Cut Sunflower paintings (F375, F376) and hung them proudly in his Paris apartment above his bed.  In the mid-1890s he sold them to fund his trip to the South Seas.  The image of the four sunflowers was made on a large canvas.

Zinnias
Vase with Zinnias and Geraniums (F241) reflects the influence of Adolphe Monticelli (1824–1886) in its vivid color and impasto paint.  Van Gogh admired, and later collected, Monticelli's work. Van Gogh had been introduced by his brother Theo to Monticelli's still life work with flowers in Paris.  He admired Monticelli's use of color as an expansion of Delacroix's theories of color and contrast.  Secondly he admired the effect Monticelli created by heavy application of paint called "impasto". It was partially Monticelli, from Marseilles, who inspired Van Gogh's southerly move to Provence in 1888.  He felt such kinship for the man, and desire to emulate his style, that he wrote in a letter to his sister Wil that he felt as if he were "Monticelli's son or his brother." The first owner in the provenance of this painting is "C.M. van Gogh Gallery, Amsterdam, the Netherlands", which was owned by Van Gogh's uncle and an art dealer, Cornelius Marinus van Gogh (1824–1908).

Bowl with Zinnias and Other Flowers (F251), painted within days of Vase with Zinnias and Geraniums (F241), is evidence of Van Gogh's transition to a lighter color palette. Picking up elements of Impressionism Van Gogh painted with a more vigorous brushstroke, with thick application of paint, called "impasto" which created a three-dimensional relief.

Other flowers
Unable to pay for models to pose for portraits, Van Gogh threw himself heartily into painting still lifes of flowers, "red poppies, blue corn flowers and myosotis, white and red roses, yellow chrysanthemums."

Vase with Autumn Asters (F234) is one example of the many still lifes that Van Gogh painted after he arrived in Paris.  As he said to a friend, he wished for his paintings to take on intense colors, rather than the grey tones. In this arrangement Van Gogh plays with harmonizing colors: rose, pink, red and brown.

Basket of pansies (F244) is an example of Van Gogh's experimentation with contrasting colors.  In this case the contrasting pair are purple and yellow. He also used the contrasting red in the tambourine and green in the background for the painting, also known as Tambourine with Pansies.  Van Gogh found pansies an example of natural color theory.

Vase with Hollyhocks (F235) was painted in the summer in contrasting shades of red and green.  Van Gogh believed that he could express the season of the year by the colors that he used in his work.  He experimented in this painting with creating an image that was nearly one-dimensional.  The decorative jug used in this painting also appears in Van Gogh's Vase with Autumn Asters (F234). Hollyhocks, native to China and Japan, were favored by Impressionists "for their spire-like growth, deeply-lobed green leaves and their satiny, cup-shaped flowers that hug the upper flower stem."

Blue vase

Vase with Daisies and Anemones (F323), also known as Flowers in a Blue Vase, was painted late in Van Gogh's stay in Paris.   The vase holds a lively selection of daisies and anemones made with a range of colors.  Dark red-brown is enlivened by shades of yellow, pink and white.  He particularly works with the various shades of yellow, likely having selected colors for the combinations of color and shades that he wanted to portray.  The vase is painted in a contrasting shade of blue.  Techniques of Impressionism and Divisionism are reflected in his brushstrokes of the background, having used broken strokes and dots of color.

Plants
Van Gogh preferred to select items from daily life to portray in his still life paintings. With Flowerpot with Chives (F337) Van Gogh used a thin brush to carefully create this painting of a pot of chives.  Contrasting colors of red and orange against green are used in this work.  The background is a pattern that Van Gogh used in other works, such as Still life with Carafe and Lemons (F340). From the time this painting was made in 1887 and forward, Van Gogh used colorful backgrounds for his still lifes and portraits.

Bulbs

Books
Still Life with French Novels and a Rose is a painting with a number of novels with bindings of contrasting colors: green against pink and red. The books are meant to represent seven Parisian novels Van Gogh owned, that Van Gogh described as "a great source of light", regardless of the somber literature they contain.  The dashes of lemon, pink, orange and green seem to bring life to the books, like the blossoming flower that also adds a feeling that the paintings is made for a woman.  In 1888 Van Gogh gave this painting and another to his sister, Wil for her birthday.  The other painting was made in Arles and is titled Blossoming Almond Branch in a Glass with a Book (F393).

Still Life with Books (F335) was painted by Van Gogh on a lid of a Japanese tea box. The books are Naturalist novels: "Braves Gens" by Jean Richepin, "Au Bonheur Des Dames" by Émile Zola and "La Fille Elisa" by Edmond de Goncourt. Van Gogh, an avid reader, was particularly interested by French Naturalists. To his sister Wil, he once wrote "they paint life as we ourselves feel it, thereby fulfilling the need we have for people to tell us the truth."

Pair of shoes
Van Gogh made Pair of Shoes (F255) from a pair of boots he purchased at a flea market.  He wore the boots on an extended rainy walk to create the effect he wished for this painting, which may have been a tribute to the working man.  The Van Gogh Museum speculates that they may also be symbolic for Van Gogh of his "difficult passage through life." Of his walking through mud to make the shoes look more worn and dirty, Van Gogh was known to say "Dirty shoes and roses can both be good in the same way."

Van Gogh's friend and fellow artist, John Russell, received Van Gogh's Three Pairs of Shoes (F332) in 1886.  Russell had painted a portrait of Van Gogh that he dearly loved.  In exchange for the portrait he had given Van Gogh, Russell selected Three Pairs of Shoes and a lithograph copy of Worn Out (Eternity's Gate) (F997) that Van Gogh made in 1882.  Russell selected these works at a time when Van Gogh had begun to make more colorful work.  Russell's selections indicate that he understood who Van Gogh was and the messages about the peasant or working man that he wished to convey through his work.

Food and drink

Glass of Absinthe and a Carafe (F339) was made by Van Gogh in a café. On the table sits a glass of absinthe, its green-yellow liquid lighter for window's sunlight and in contrast to the brown background.  The painting catches a moment in the café from a patron's perspective, with a view of pedestrians walking on the street.  Absinthe was popular to Van Gogh and other artists both as a drink, although toxic and in some cases deadly, and because of its unique color, it was also favored as a subject for paintings.

Absinthe may have significantly contributed to Van Gogh's poor health.  When he lived in Paris, absinthe was a popular drink among artists. Paul Signac commented that Van Gogh drank steadily drinks of brandy following drinks of absinthe. By the time Van Gogh left Paris he was in very poor health and known to say to a friend that drinking and smoking left him "seriously sick at heart and in body and nearly an alcoholic." According to author Doris Lanier, author of "Absinthe the Cocaine of the Nineteenth Century": Many of Van Gogh's symptoms following his arrival in Paris are indicative of absinthe poisoning: stomach and nervous system problems, hallucinations and convulsions.

Fish or seafood

Anecdotally, one cold Parisian day Van Gogh, dressed more like a cattle drover than an urban artist, peddled a painting of pink shrimp on pink paper to a shopkeeper who sold old ironworks and inexpensive oil paintings.  Out of charity, the man gave the hungry Van Gogh five francs (less than a dollar).  Out on the street, Van Gogh saw a prostitute who had recently escaped from Prison Saint-Lazare.  With thoughts of the novel about a prostitute, "La Fille Elisa" by Edmond de Goncourt, Van Gogh gave her the five francs and quickly moved on his way. The novel appears in Van Gogh's Still Life with Books (F335).

Assorted fruit
In Van Gogh's first months in Paris, he stayed in his brother Theo's small apartment on Rue Laval.  Vincent's behavior could be disruptive and unnerving to Theo and others.  A friend of Theo's wrote of Vincent, "The man hasn't the slightest notion of social conditions.  He is always quarreling with everybody.  Consequently Theo has a lot of problem getting along with him." As means of calming himself, Vincent painted fall fruit in the autumn of 1886, which he imbues with seemingly "supernatural vitality and beauty." Multi-colored, contrasting colored brushstrokes radiate in a circle from the fruit with an "aura of electrical radiance."

Still Life with Apples, Pears, Lemons and Grapes (F382) was Van Gogh's opportunity to explore Blanc's recommendation about combining colors: "If one brings together sulfur (yellow) and garnet (dark red), which is its exact opposite, being equidistant from nasturtium (orange) and campanula (blue-mauve), the garnet and sulfur will excite one another, because they are each others' complementaries." In the background, Van Gogh used short brushstrokes of light blue and pink, giving the impression that the fruit is sitting in a basket.  Van Gogh may have seen Claude Monet's Still Life with Apples and Grapes in Paris, but while the subject matter is roughly the same, the composition is not.  Monet paints the fruit on a diagonally placed table to "anchor his composition in space." Having removed any form of distraction, such as a table or background, Van Gogh placed each piece of fruit by itself, creating a "semi-abstract, decorative effect."

Still Life with Quinces and Lemons (F383) is a study in yellow.  The painting, and even the frame, are in shades of yellow, ocher and brown.  The painting also has highlights in pink, red, green and blue.  A fine example of an Impressionist painting, Van Gogh dedicated the painting to his brother Theo for his guidance and introduction to modern art. Over the  yellow frame, Van Gogh painted criss-cross marks, evocative of Japanese calligraphy. Adding a painted frame to a work of art was not unusual for painters of this time; Georges Seurat and Paul Signac also painted their frames.  What is unusual is that the painted frame remained with the painting.  In most cases the original frames were replaced over the years to suit its owner's taste.

Apples

Basket of Apples (F99) was made in 1885 when Van Gogh experimented with Delacroix's color theory.  To his brother Theo, Van Gogh wrote: "There is a certain pure bright red for the apples, then some greenish things.  Now there are one or two apples in another color, in a kind of pink – to improve the whole.  The pink is the broken color, created by mixing the first red and green mentioned.  This is why there is a connection between the colors.  Then I painted a second contrast, in the back- and foreground.  One was given a neutral color by "breaking" blue with orange; the other the same neutral color, only this time changed by adding a little yellow."

Lemons
Still Life with Lemons on a Plate (F338) is one of the paintings that Enrica Crispino, author of "Van Gogh" uses to illustrate Van Gogh's progression in the use of light and movement from colors darkened with black to "pure color".

Van Gogh made Still life with Carafe and Lemons (F340) quickly, with a very thin layer of paint that does not completely obscure the canvas.  The carafe of water catches the reflection of the papered background.  Complementary colors are used well in the painting, such as yellow lemons against its purple shadow.  The green in the foreground contrasts with the red in the background.  Van Gogh signed this still life, indicating that he was pleased with the result.

How Van Gogh integrated modern art concepts

Impressionism
Van Gogh's work in still life reflects his emergence as an important practitioner of modern art, particularly integrating techniques of Impressionism.  The table identifies key Impressionist techniques and examples of how Van Gogh used them in this series of still life paintings.

Color relationships
Van Gogh experimented with each of the three color relationships:

Light
Van Gogh experimented with use of light over his ten-year painting career.  A trio of still lifes shows his developing style for managing light.  At first he placed light subjects against a background, as in Still Life with Four Stone Bottles, Flask and White Cup (1884) Then he realized the effectiveness of using "pure colors, such as in Still Life with Lemons on a plate (1887) and even more so in Still Life: Drawing Board, Pipe, Onions and Sealing-Wax (1889)."

Later in 1887

After he made most of the still life paintings, Van Gogh left the city in April 1887 for the tranquil Parisian suburb called Asnières and to paint with his friends and Asnières residents Paul Signac and Émile Bernard. Asnières is located beyond the city fortifications, along the banks of the Seine and the island of Grand Jatte.  There he experimented with an even lighter, more colorful palette than used in his early Montmartre, Still Life and Dutch paintings and more fully defined his unique brushstroke: one that was rapid with thickly painted strokes laid closely together.

See also
 List of works by Vincent van Gogh

Citations 
For books, also see the bibliography using the author's last name and, if indicated, the year the book was published.

General and cited references 
 Balakian, A; Balakian, A.E. (2008). Symbolist movement in the literature of European languages. Netherlands: John Benjamins Publishing. .
 Beaujean, D (2000). Van Gogh: Life and Work. Cologne: Konemann. 
 Crispino, E (2008). Van Gogh. Minneapolis: The Oliver Press.
 Fell, D (1997) [1994]. The Impressionist Garden. London: Frances Lincoln Limited.  .
 Fell, D (2001). Gogh's Gardens. United Kingdom: Simon & Schuster. .
 Fell, D (2005) [2004]. Van Gogh's Women: Vincent's Love Affairs and Journey Into Madness. New York: Carroll & Graf Publishers.  .
 Galbally, A (2008). A remarkable friendship: Vincent van Gogh and John Peter Russell. Carlton, Victoria: Melbourne University Publishing. .
 Hamilton, G (1993) [1967]. Painting and Sculpture in Europe: 1880-1940. Yale University Press. .
 Hansen, Nichols, Sund, Knudsen, Bremen (2003). Van Gogh: Fields. Hatje Cantz Publishers for Toledo Museum of Art Exhibition. .
 Lanier, D. (1995) Absinthe the Cocaine of the Nineteenth Century.  Jefferson, NC: McFarlane. .
 Mancoff, D (2008). Van Gogh's Flowers. London: Frances Lincoln Limited. .
 Maurer, N (1999) [1998]. The Pursuit of Spiritual Wisdom: The Thought and Art of Vincent van Gogh and Paul Gauguin. Cranbury: Associated University Presses. p. 63. .
 Munro, E (1974). The Encyclopedia of Art. New York: Golden Press.
 Ross, B (208). Venturing Upon Dizzy Heights: Lectures and Essays on Philosophy, Literature and the Arts. New York: Peter Lang Publishing.
 Silverman, D (2000).Van Gogh and Gauguin: The Search for Sacred Art. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. .
 Thomson, B. (2001) Van Gogh. New York: Harry N. Abrams with Art Institute of Chicago. .
 Tralbaut, M (1981) [1969]. Vincent van Gogh, le mal aimé. Edita, Lausanne (French) & Macmillan, London 1969 (English); reissued by Macmillan, 1974 and Alpine Fine Art Collections, 1981. .
  Turner, J. (2000). From Monet to Cézanne: late 19th-century French artists. Grove Art. New York: St Martin's Press. 
 Van Gogh, V and Leeuw, R (1997) [1996]. van Crimpen, H, Berends-Albert, M. ed. The Letters of Vincent van Gogh. London and other locations: Penguin Books.
 

1886 paintings
1887 paintings
Paintings of Montmartre
Paintings by Vincent van Gogh
Paintings of Paris by Vincent van Gogh
Series of paintings by Vincent van Gogh
Still life paintings by Vincent van Gogh