Title: Moyle v. Y & Y Hyup Shin Corporation

State: hawaii

Issuer: Hawaii Supreme Court

Document:

LawuBRas

isto

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAT'

38 Bud

00

   

 

HY
qa

ROGER SCOTT MOYLE, Plaintiff-Appellant-Petiti:

 

s
both a/b/a 00 RE ME
KARAOKE Defendants-Appellees-Respondents.

Y¥ & ¥ HYUP SHIN, CORP., and TTJJKK INC.

 

 

No. 26582

CERTIORARI TO THE INTERMEDIATE COURT OF APPEALS
(cIv. No. 01-21-2747)

 

SEPTEMBER 11, 2008

ORDER OF AMENDMENT AND CORRECTION
(By: Moon, C.J., Levinson, Nakayama, Acoba, and Duffy, JJ.)

‘The opinion of the court, filed on September 4, 2008,
is hereby amended as to the following:
(1) At Page 2, after the paragraph ending with the

 

word “injured,” add the following paragraph:
For the reasons discussed herein, ve

hold that the ICA erred in concluding (1)
that the jury instructions regarding the
foreseeability of third-party criminal acts
given by the circuit court were not defective
and (2) that the circuit court correctly
included a non-party on the special verdict
form, We therefore vacate the ICA's Novenber
23, 2007 judgment and the circuit court’s
March 5, 2004 judgment. This matter is
remanded to the circuit court for further

proceedings consistent with this opinion.
(2) At Page 38, in the conclusion, add the following
underscored text:
For the foregoing reasons, we vacate the
circuit court's March 5, 2004 judgment and
the _iGA’s November 23, 2007 iudament, and we
remand this matter to the circuit court for

further proceedings consistent with this

 

opinion.

In light of the amended opinion, references to page
nunbers in the majority opinion in Justice Nakayana’s concurring
and dissenting opinion and Justice Acoba’s concurring opinion are
corrected where dened necessary.

‘An amended opinion, an amended concurring and
dissenting opinion, and an amended concurring opinion are being
concurrently filed with this order of anendnent and correction.
‘The Clerk of the Court is directed to provide a copy of this
order and a copy of the amended opinion to the parties and notity
the publishing agencies of the changes. The Clerk of the Court
is further instructed to distribute copies of this order of

amendment and correction to those who received the previously

Gre
Plena om
Presa Casey

Go. .

5. Rls ys

filed opinion.