Title: State ex rel. Tucker v. Matia

State: ohio

Issuer: Ohio Supreme Court

Document:

[Until this opinion appears in the Ohio Official Reports advance sheets, it may be cited as State 
ex rel. Tucker v. Matia, Slip Opinion No. 2016-Ohio-7450.] 
  
 
 
 
 
NOTICE 
This slip opinion is subject to formal revision before it is published in an 
advance sheet of the Ohio Official Reports.  Readers are requested to 
promptly notify the Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Court of Ohio, 65 
South Front Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215, of any typographical or other 
formal errors in the opinion, in order that corrections may be made before 
the opinion is published. 
 
 
SLIP OPINION NO. 2016-OHIO-7450 
THE STATE EX REL. TUCKER, APPELLANT, v. MATIA, JUDGE, APPELLEE. 
[Until this opinion appears in the Ohio Official Reports advance sheets, it 
may be cited as State ex rel. Tucker v. Matia, Slip Opinion No.  
2016-Ohio-7450.] 
Mandamus—Relator was convicted of attempted murder, not attempted felony 
murder, and was not entitled to resentencing under State v. Nolan—Denial 
of writ affirmed. 
(No. 2016-0089—Submitted July 12, 2016—Decided October 26, 2016.) 
APPEAL from the Court of Appeals for Cuyahoga County, No. 103333,  
2015-Ohio-5154. 
_____________________ 
Per Curiam. 
{¶ 1} We affirm the Eighth District Court of Appeals’ dismissal of appellant 
Samuel L. Tucker’s complaint for a writ of mandamus.  In 2002, Tucker pleaded 
guilty to attempted murder and kidnapping and was sentenced to consecutive prison 
terms of 10 and 5 years, respectively.  Tucker filed this action in mandamus, 
SUPREME COURT OF OHIO 
 
2
seeking a writ ordering appellee, Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge 
David Matia, to vacate his sentence under State v. Nolan, 141 Ohio St.3d 454, 2014-
Ohio-4800, 25 N.E.3d 1016, and resentence him.  Judge Matia filed a motion for 
summary judgment, which the court of appeals granted.  Tucker appealed. 
{¶ 2} To be entitled to a writ of mandamus, Tucker must establish a clear 
legal right to the requested relief, a clear legal duty on the part of Judge Matia to 
provide it, and the lack of an adequate remedy in the ordinary course of the law.  
State ex rel. Waters v. Spaeth, 131 Ohio St.3d 55, 2012-Ohio-69, 960 N.E.2d 452, 
¶ 6.  Tucker must prove that he is entitled to the writ by clear and convincing 
evidence.  Id. at ¶ 13. 
{¶ 3} Tucker claims that he was convicted of attempted felony murder and 
that because we determined in Nolan that attempted felony murder is not a crime 
in Ohio, the trial court lacked jurisdiction to convict him.  Therefore, Tucker argues, 
his conviction for attempted felony murder should be vacated.  In Nolan, we held 
that a requisite of the attempt statute is that a person cannot commit an attempt 
offense unless he or she has acted purposely or knowingly.  Nolan at ¶ 7.  On the 
other hand, the felony-murder statute imposes strict liability; intent need not be 
proven to obtain a conviction of felony murder.  Id. at ¶ 9.  We concluded that a 
person cannot be guilty of attempting to cause an unintended death.  Id. at ¶ 9-10. 
{¶ 4} The court of appeals granted Judge Matia’s motion for summary 
judgment because the language of Tucker’s indictment, to which he pleaded guilty, 
tracks the language of R.C. 2923.02, which sets out the elements of attempt, and 
R.C. 2903.02(A), which sets out the elements of the offense of murder—not R.C. 
2903.02(B), which sets out the elements of felony murder.  In other words, Tucker 
was sentenced for attempted murder, not attempted felony murder, and Nolan 
therefore does not apply. 
{¶ 5} Tucker is not entitled to a writ of mandamus, and the court below was 
correct in granting the motion for summary judgment.  We affirm its judgment. 
January Term, 2016 
 
3
Judgment affirmed. 
O’CONNOR, C.J., and PFEIFER, O’DONNELL, LANZINGER, KENNEDY, 
FRENCH, and O’NEILL, JJ., concur. 
_________________ 
Samuel L. Tucker, pro se. 
Timothy J. McGinty, Prosecuting Attorney, and James E. Moss, Assistant 
Prosecuting Attorney, for appellee. 
_________________