Title: Maise v.Lee

State: hawaii

Issuer: Hawaii Supreme Court

Document:

LAW LIBRARY

*** NOT FOR PUBLICATION ***
No. 27378

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAI‘T

 

 

PHILIP B. MAISE, Plaintiff-Appellee/Counterclaim Defendant

  

CECIL LORAN LEE, Defendant-Appellant/Counterclainant
ng
and z 8
MICHAEL BOYD, Defendant 28 2
t= 8
APPEAL FROM THE THIRD CIRCUIT CouRT “S/F
(cIv. NO. 01-1-0444) al S
pisMissine

(ay: Nakayama, J., for the court?)

Upon review of the record, it appears that ell claims
against all the parties have been resolved in Civil No. 01-1-

0444, but @ judgment resolving all claims has not been entered

pursuant to HRCP 98. sv. Ci Flemis

Height, 76 Hawai'i 115, 119-120, 869 P.2d 1334, 1339-39 (1994) (In
) an appeal.

 

a multiple claim, multiple party circuit court ca!

may be taken after entry of 2 judgment that, on its face,

resolves 211 cleims against all the parties.). The September 30,

2004 judgment resolved only the plaintiffs claims against

defendant Lee. The judgment did not resolve the plaintiff's

claims against defendant Boyd and purported to, but did not

resolve defendant Lee’s counterclaim. Thus, this appeal is

risdiction. Therefore,

 

premature and we lack

 

Der Levingon, Nekayana, Acobe

 
*** NOT FOR PUBLICATION ***
Gr 15 HBREEY ORDERED that thie'appeal As donissed for
rack of appellate jurisdiction.
bATeD: Honotute, Howe's, ceteber 27, 2008,
ron ie count: |G

Penn ONRae nay aere
Associate Justice 8.