Title: Hawaii Providers Network, Inc. v. AIG Hawaii Insurance Company, Inc.

State: hawaii

Issuer: Hawaii Supreme Court

Document:

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAI'I

 

~--000-

a

HAWAII PROVIDERS NETWORK, INC., Plaintiff-Appellant

AIG HAWAII INSURANCE COMPANY, INC., ALLSTATE
INDEMNITY CO., ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO., AMERICAN
AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY, AMERICAN INSURANCE,

COMPANY, ASSOCIATED INDEMNITY CORP., BUDGET
RENT-A-CAR SYSTEMS, INC., DAI-TOKYO ROYAL STATE
INSURANCE COMPANY, LIMITED, FIREMAN’ S FUND
INSURANCE COMPANY OF HAWAII, INC., FIRST INDEMNITY
INSURANCE OF HAWAII, INC., FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY
OF HAWAII, LTD., GEICO CASUALTY CO., GEICO INDEMNITY

CO., GOVERNMENT ‘EMPLOYEES INSURANCE COMPANY, HARTFORD
‘ACCIDENT AND INDEMNITY COMPANY, ISLAND INSURANCE

COMPANY, LTD:, LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY,

LISERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE CO., NATIONAL SURETY CORP. ,
‘PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, PROGRESSIVE
HAWAII INSURANCE CORP., PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN
INSURANCE COMPANY, PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN
INSURANCE COMPANY, PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INSURANCE
COMPANY, ROYAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA, STATE
FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE CO., STATE NATIONAL
INSURANCE COMPANY, THE HAWATIAN INSURANCE AND
GUARANTY COMPANY, LIMITED, TIG INSURANCE COMPANY,
'TIG PREMIER INSURANCE COMPANY, TOKIO MARINE AND
FIRE INSURANCE CO., LTD., TRADEWIND INSURANCE COMPANY,
‘TRAVELERS INSURANCE CO., USAA CASUALTY INSURANCE CO.,
Defendants-Appellees

and

JOHN AND JANE DOES 1-10, DOE CORPORATIONS 1-10,
DOE PARTNERSHIPS 1-10 and DOE ENTITIES 1-10, Defendants

No. 27345

MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION
(CR. NO, 04-1-0077)

aa

hel Kd €1 10 9000

 
JULY 13, 2006

pen C08
(By: Moon, C.J., Levinson, Nakayama, Acoba, and Duffy, JJ.)

upon consideration of the motion for reconsideration
submitted on June 2, 2006 by Plaintiff-Appellant Hawaii Providers
network, Inc. (HPN), that this court reconsider its opinion filed
on May 23, 2006, affirming the first circuit court’s June 1, 2005
order granting sunmary judgment in favor of Defendants-Appellees
insurance companies,’ the papers in support and in opposition,

and the record herein,

I? IS HEREBY ORDERED that HPN’s motion is denied.

Paul Maki,
on the motion for
Plaintiff-Appellant. .

geffrey H.K. Sia and

Gary S. Miyamoto (Ayabe,
Chong, Nishimoto, Sia & Preis Or renedinns

Nakamaza) for
Defendant s-Appeliees

Hartford Accident and

Tndennity Company and

Travelers Insurance Co., Coron. Dates h-

in opposition.

+ pefendants-Appeliees are AIG Hawaii Insurance Co., Allstate
Insurance Con, Alistate fndeanity Co., American Autenobile Insurance Co.
Jnsurance Cecrance Con, Associated Indemnity Corp., Budget Rent-a-Car Systems,
American Tokyo Roya State insurance Co., Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. of
irc Nacee First tndeanity Insurance of Hawaii, Inc., First Insurance
Hewes) of avails Ltd. Geico Indemnity Co., Geico Casualty Co., Governnent
serRertS rneurance Co., Hareford Accident and Indemnity Co., The Hawaiian
sre eeete and Cusrenty Co., Jeland Insurance Co., Liberty Mutual Fire
insukance Cos, Liberty Motuel Insurance Co., National Surety Corp.
pasorenet ve Casualty insurance Co., Progressive Hawais Insurance Corp.,
Frogrestive fiorthers Insurance Co., Progressive Northwestern Insurance’ Co
Progressive Specieity insurance Co:, Royal Insurance Co. of Anerica, Ste
Progrestivt Auconcbile Insurance €o., Seate National Insurance Co., The Hawait
ind Gearanty Corps, 116 Insurance Co., T1G Premier Insurance Co.
serie oe and Fire Ingurance Co., Tradewind insurance Company, Travelers
Joe renee orcad USAA Casualty insurance Co, (collectively, Defendants)

 

 

 

 

 

2
Richard B. Miller (Tom Petrus &
Miller) for Defendants~
Appellees AIG Hawaii Insurance
Company, Inc., et al., in
opposition.

Randall Y.S. Chung and
James H. Monma (Matsui Chung)
for Defendants-Appellees
Allstate Insurance Co. and
Allstate Indemnity Co., on the
joinder.

Keith K: Hiraoka (Roeca, Louie &
Hiraoka) for Defendants-Appellees
American Automobile Ins. Co., et al.,
on the joinders.

parolyn Hatsuko Lendio and
John Y. Yamano (McCorriston
Miller Mukai MacKinnon) for
Defendant-Appellee State Farm
Mutual Automobile Insurance
Company, on the joinders.

Michael F. O'Connor for
Defendant-Appellee USAA
Casualty Insurance Co., on
the joinders.

 

Michael N. Tanoue and
Jeffrey 8. Masatsugu (The
Pacific Law Group), for
Defendant s-Appellees Island
Insurance Company, Ltd. and
‘Tradewind Insurance Company,
on the joinders.