Title: Hawaii Medical Association v. Hawaii Medical Service Association, Inc.

State: hawaii

Issuer: Hawaii Supreme Court

Document:

Nos. 25923 & 25924

IN THB SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAT'Z

(Civ. No. 01
HAWAII MEDICAL ASSOCIATION,

 

-1880)
Plaintiff-Appellant,

HAWAII MEDICAL SERVICE ASSOCIATION,
Defendant-Appellee.

anc.

 

(civ. No. 02-1-1872 DDD)

MAXWELL COOPER, M.D., and MICHON MORITA, M.D.,= S

on behalf of themselves and all othere aimilariy
situation, Plaintiffs-Appellante,

 

 

HAWAII MEDICAL SERVICE ASSOCIATION,
Defendant -Appellee.

APPEAL FROM THE FIRST CIRCUIT COURT
(CIV. NOS. 2-1-1880 & 02-1-3872 DDD)

mc.

‘MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION
(By Moon, C.J., for the court!)

Upon consideration of defendant-appellee Hawaii Medical

Service Association's motion for reconsideration, filed September
18, 2006, the papers in support thereof, in opposition thereto,
and the record herein,

 

* considered by: Moon, C.J, Levinson, Nakayima, and Acoba, 23.1
Circuit Judge Blondis, in place of buffy, J.» recused
ET 1S HEREBY ORDERED that the motion is denied.
Associate Justices Nakayama and Acoba, having dissented in part
from the majority's Septenber 8, 2006 opinion, do net concur and
would grant the notion.

DATED: Honolulu, Hawai'i, October 25, 2006.

 

ELien odbey carson and FoR THE court
Paul Altos (of Alacer Hunt
Floyd tng) end Reber
Garton Godby and Jess H. te Fite
Griftitne. (of Godoy Ore ifsehe fllee sae »
Reis), for deterdeny-oppelice a)
In appeal Noss 25943 erbssaee SEAL”
on the motion oe

oe

Warren Price, III, Robert
A. Marks, and Rick J. Bichor,
(Of Price Okamoto Himeno &
Lum); Robert P, Miller; and
Pamela M. Parker, pro hac
vice (of Lerach Coughlin
Stoia Geller Rudman &
Robbins, San Diego); Edith
M. Kallas and Joseph P.
Guglielmo, pro hac vice,

(of Whatley Drake & Kallas,
LLC, New York),

for plaintif£-appellant

in appeal No. 25523 and

for plaintiffs-appellante

in appeal No. 25924,

in opposition