Task: Question Generation
Input (English): To examine the utility of four criteria for distinguishing aortic from mitral valve prostheses on supine anteroposterior (AP) chest x rays in critically ill patients.', 'Two reviewers independently examined the post operative chest X-rays (CXR) of all patients undergoing either an aortic or mitral valve replacement over a 32 month period, in a blinded fashion. They applied four criteria to each film. For each criterion a sensitivity and specificity of differentiating the valve positions correctly was calculated for each reviewer, as well as a kappa statistic for inter-observer agreement between the two reviewers.', "Two hundred and twenty seven CXR's were evaluated by each of the reviewers. There were 174 aortic and 53 mitral valve replacements. There was a high level of inter-observer agreement for all four criteria applied (kappa values 0.785 to 0.966). Criterion one (imaginary line method) could be applied by both reviewers to less than 50% of CXR's, and when applied was specific but not sensitive. The other three criteria could be applied by both reviewers to approximately 80% of films. Criterion 2 (orientation method) was sensitive but not specific. Criteria 3 (valve orifice method) and 4 (perceived direction of blood flow method) were both highly sensitive and specific and are therefore the best methods.
Output (English): Is the imaginary line method reliable for identification of prosthetic heart valves on AP chest radiographs?