Task: Wrong Candidate Generation
Input (English): use of religious symbolism depends upon its context. These general principles are sound, and have been adopted by the Court in subsequent cases____Accordingly, our present task is to determine whether the display[s at issue in this case], in their respective "particular physical settings,” has the effect of endorsing or disapproving religious beliefs. Allegheny, 492 U.S. at 596-597, 109 S.Ct. 3086. 7 .Reconciling the majority's holding in Allegheny with the outcome in Lynch, however, is more complicated than Justice Blackmun's neatly drawn summary might imply. Compare A.C.L.U. v. Schundler, 104 F.3d 1435, 1448 (3rd Cir.1997) (enjoining Jersey City from displaying a creche and a menorah in front of its city hall) with Elewski v. City of Syracuse, 123 F.3d 51, 55 (2nd Cir.1997) (<HOLDING>). 8 . The Town argues that a second municipal 
 Holding statements: (A) holding that establishment of christmas day as legal public holiday did not violate establishment clause (B) holding that display of solitary semipermanent menorah in city hall park closely associated with seat of city government violates the establishment clause (C) holding that a city owned creche and christmas tree erected in a public park adjacent to another park with a christmas tree lights and a privately owned menorah did not offend the establishment clause (D) holding there was no establishment clause violation in displaying a privately funded menorah during chanukah in the public plaza on which city hall and county building are located (E) holding that a civic center building or recreational building on property dedicated to the city as park property was inconsistent with its use as a park
Output (English): holding that display of solitary semipermanent menorah in city hall park closely associated with seat of city government violates the establishment clause