Task: Wrong Candidate Generation
Input (English): Context: He agreed , but first wanted to dial into my computer , after which he giggled at my desktop background , which I happen to love : I , getting pissy , said " So now you know I ' m Catholic " which seemed a cue for him to launch into his own views . You 'll be glad to know that he believes in God , Jesus and the second coming . He seemed surprised that Arthur and one daughter are atheists and that I had n't made them Catholic . I said " It 's a free country " and that seemed to stump him . 
Question: What may have caused him to be surprised about Arthur and the daughter ? 
Correct Answer: They did n't share his beliefs .
Output (English): They are Catholic .