Task: Wrong Candidate Generation
Input (English): Context: And as he wondered , all the doubts about the wisdom of getting her something new and different resurfaced . Maybe he 'd been foolish to listen to Ron - after all , when it came to understanding Hermione , Ron did not have the best record . And was n't it possible that giving her a cloak , nice as it was , could be seen as a rather impersonal sort of gift ? He flinched inwardly - God , he hoped she had n't thought that !. 
Question: Why would he be wondering about getting Hermione a new gift ? 
Correct Answer: He 's wondering if getting her a cloak was too impersonal .
Output (English): He 's just reminding himself he made the right choice for her .