Task: Wrong Candidate Generation
Input (English): Context: Pulling out his pack of cigarettes Jude pulled out another . " You still smoking or did you manage to give it up ? " " I ' m not good at giving up sinful pleasures , " Orlando chuckled and took the offered cigarette before rummaging in the pocket of his too tight jeans to find his lighter . " I know that feeling . ". 
Question: what may have happened if Orlando does not smoke ? 
Correct Answer: He would n't have stated that smoking is a sinful pleasure.
Output (English): He would have brought out a lighter.