Task: Wrong Candidate Generation
Input (English): Context: We ve seen quite a bit of Katie Holmes since she relocated to the Big Apple for her stage debut in All My Sons , and on September 4 the Dawsons Creek star made yet another fashion statement as she made her way to rehearsal in the morning . Poor Kat has been the subject of pretty intense scrutiny lately , getting flack for everything from her boyish haircut to her oversized jeans and poorly assembled fits . Even Tim Gunn chimed in with his two cents , commenting , I have to say , Katie Holmes has become so much more sophisticated in so many ways , but I think she s in a dip right now . I ca nt explain it . 
Question: Who is being critiqued heavily in this narrative ? 
Correct Answer: It is the star of Dawson 's Creek .
Output (English): It is Tim Gunn .