Task: Story Composition
Input (English): Premise: Patty wanted my pencil. 
 Initial Context: She asked to use it. 
 Original Ending: She never gave it back. I confronted her. Patty claimed she lost it. 
 Counterfactual Context: I let her use it but she didn't like it and gave it back.
Output (English): She only pretended to give it back. I confronted her. Patty claimed she lost it.