Task: Story Composition
Input (English): Premise: Chuck was frustrated that his new pet dog would not behave. 
 Initial Context: Chuck couldn't seem to teach the dog commands or get it to obey. 
 Original Ending: Somebody suggested that Chuck bring the dog to an obedience trainer. That turned out to be an excellent idea. The dog now responds when told to come, sit, stay and lie down. 
 Counterfactual Context: Chuck started beating it.
Output (English): Somebody suggested that Chuck stop beating his dog. That turned out to be an excellent idea. The dog now responds when told to come, sit, stay and lie down.