Task: Question Generation
Input (English): Table TABREF14 shows the results of our main experiments on the 2016 and 2018 test sets for French and German. We use Meteor BIBREF31 as the main metric, as in the WMT tasks BIBREF25 . We compare our transformer baseline to transformer models enriched with image information, as well as to the deliberation models, with or without image information.

We first note that our multimodal models achieve the state of the art performance for transformer networks (constrained models) on the English-German dataset, as compared to BIBREF30 . Second, our deliberation models lead to significant improvements over this baseline across test sets (average INLINEFORM0 , INLINEFORM1 ).
Output (English): What dataset does this approach achieve state of the art results on?