Anchor: (The analogy is imperfect, because there's no fixed line of demarcation between fiction and nonfiction, only a broad gray field.)
Entailed: It's uncertain where to draw the line between fiction and nonfiction in the analogy.
Contradiction: There is definitive proof that the analogy is meant as nonfiction.
Contradiction: Don't underestimate the veterans of the ring. 
Contradiction: Scandals don't have to be based on truth.
Contradiction: The man is playing the flute.
Contradiction: We do many things for them to help, but they end up coming back again.