#	Claim	Evidence	GPT-3	Ours	Gold
1.1	Less than 90,000 people live in Beaverton, Oregon	its population is estimated to be 91,757, almost 14% more than the 2000 census figure of 76,129	False	False	False
1.2	More than 90K people live in Beaverton	its population is estimated to be 91,757, almost 14% more than the 2000 census figure of 76,129	True	True	True
1.3	More than 90K people live in Beaverton	its population is estimated to be 86,205, almost 14% more than the 2000 census figure of 76,129	Neither	False	False
1.4	Less than 90,000 people live in Beaverton, Oregon	its population is estimated to be 86,205, almost 14% more than the 2000 census figure of 76,129	False	True	True
1.5	Less than 90,000 people live in Beaverton, Oregon	Beaverton's population is estimated to be 86,205	False	True	True
1.6	Approximately 86k people live in Beaverto, Oregon	Beaverton's population is estimated to be 86,205	Neither	True	True
1.7	Approximately 86,205 people live in Beaverton, Oregon	Beaverton's population is estimated to be 86,205	True	True	True
2.1	Diego Corrales' father was Puerto Rican and his mother Dominican	Corrales was born to a African American father and a Mexican mother	False	False	False
2.2	Diego Corrales' father was Puerto Rican and his mother Dominican	Corrales was born to a Puerto Rican father and a Dominican mother	True	True	True
3.1	COVID-19 outbreak was identified before December	The outbreak was first identified in Wuhan, Hubei, China in December 2019 and recog-nized as a pandemic	False	False	False
3.2	COVID-19 outbreak was identified before December	The outbreak was first identified in Wuhan, Hubei, China in 17 November 2019 and rec-ognized as a pandemic	Neither	True	True
4.1	There have been more than 400 con-firmed coronavirus cases in Germany	There have been 444 confirmed cases and 16 recoveries of coronavirus in Germany	Neither	True	True
4.2	There have been more than 400 con-firmed coronavirus cases in Germany	There have been less than 349 confirmed cases and 16 recoveries of coronavirus in Germany	Neither	False	False
5.1	Cartoon Network is owned by Turner Broadcasting System	Cartoon Network is an American pay television channel owned by Turner Broadcasting Sys-tem, a subsidiary of AT&T's WarnerMedia	True	True	True
5.2	Cartoon Network is owned by Turner Broadcasting System	Cartoon Network is an American pay televi-sion channel owned by Warner Bros. Entert-tainment, a subsidiary of AT&T's WarnerMedia	Neither	False	False
5.3	Cartoon Network is owned by Turner Broadcasting System	Cartoon Network is an American pay television channel owned by The Walt Disney Company	Neither	False	False
5.4	Cartoon Network is owned by Turner Broadcasting System	The Walt Disney Company is the only owner of Cartoon Network	Neither	False	False
Table C.1: GPT-3 fact verification predictions on examples from the VITAMINC test dataset (examples 1.5-1.7 and 5.3-5.4 were manually modified to examine the model's behavior). We follow the few-shot setting of Brown et al. (2020) for ANLI (see Figures C.2 and C.3). The bold spans are for presentation and are not part of the input. Our VITAMINC-trained ALBERT classifiers predicted correctly on all these examples (though they weren't picked this way). The GPT-3 few-shot succeeds on some examples and even expresses sensitivity to evidence in lines 2.1-2.2. In several cases, however, GPT-3 abstains from a True/False verdict, even when provided with strong evidence (see "Neither" predictions). Line 1.4 shows an example where GPT-3's verdict is opposite of the provided evidence. Only when rephrasing the claim to exactly overlap with the evidence, it predicts an agreement.