Product review (2 stars): As good as the ones that came with the fridge...but unfortunately they were junk!
As good as the one that came with the fridge.  That being said...it's far from good!  The fridge is junk, and we will replace it as soon as we can.  We ordered 2 of these 9 months ago, and one of them just broke a couple of days ago.  I don't think we're significantly more hard on the fridge than your typical family of 6, but we have had SO MANY parts of this thing break!  I did just order another one of these to replace the one that broke...again.  Until we can replace it, these are an affordable option to keep it functional!