Product review (4 stars): Looks better than the corroded & peeling original, but doesn't match the surrounding surfaces like the old one did.
The original tray had a finish with a brushed stainless look matching all of the other surrounding finishes on the door and dispenser/control panel area, but it had gotten corroded from mineral deposits and was peeling down in the well area. It looked tacky, and needed to be replaced. While the new one fits perfectly, and is identical in every other aspect, the finish is shinier and doesn't match like the original it replaced. That cost it one star in my rating.