Product review (2 stars): ... say right away our problems with this could as easily be user error
This was the first replacement filter we bought for our fridge and I should say right away our problems with this could as easily be user error.  However, for the first month of use it would seem like the filter either did not engage or did not work and the water would sometimes smell badly - like wet dog.  Other times it worked fine.  And now we don't seem to have that problem anymore.....