Product review (5 stars): Ice Boss Ice Maker
This is the second ice maker I've purchased.  The last one lasted one year--almost exactly.  But, about six months in I had to take it apart and fix it.  The last time it quit I wasn't willing to work on it--even though a simple part probably would have set it back to working.

Okay.  The Ice Boss--makes LOTS of ice.  The old one kept up with my ice usage (which is a lot) but sometimes got behind when company came over.  The Ice Boss has a larger water reservoir and a larger basket.  It also has three ice cube sizes to choose from.  I usually just run it all day one day--one fill up of the reservoir--and don't need it the next day.  (The older one had to run every day and required a couple of refills).

Pros:  Makes lots of ice quickly.
  Is an attractive design
  Large reservoir
  Three size choices
  I filter the water before filling the reservoir and the ice tastes GREAT.

Cons:  The Ice Boss is a little larger than some--but only a little.  If size is a problem you might want to look at the dimensions before purchase.
  It makes a little noise--some people have said that bothers them but its not a problem for me.
  Most of the reviews say it probably won't last any longer than my old ice maker--I think they are good for about 6-12 months maximum--
  however, even buying one a year is cheaper than buying bag ice from the convenience store--and this tastes much better.

I've only had this a few weeks.  I'll update if any problems show up.