Product review (2 stars): Not as good as OEM GE or Brita
I wanted to love this product because it was nearly half-price when compared to GE and Brita filters, but I don't think I would buy it again even with this huge difference in cost.

Pros:

1. Flat bottom which allows it to stand up on a countertop.  As I recall, the competitors' are round.

Cons:

1. Rubber gasket didn't fit tightly within the filter, so when I filled the new filter with water, it almost floated into the garbage disposal

2. Required substantially more force to twist onto the filter housing--thought I would break the part connected to the refrigerator

3. Water flow was substantially less within 60-90 days.

Stick with Brita or GE.