Product review (5 stars): This filter was a perfect match. We installed it and have had no ...
We had purchased another filter for our whirlpool refrigerator using model# 4396508 which supposedly was a fit for our model.  However, it did not work - the filter leaked water and the dispenser would not turn off.  We returned it for a refund.

We then ordered the Odoga since it also include model# EDR5RXD1.  This filter was a perfect match.  We installed it and have had no problems and it's working perfectly.  Plan to buy it again.