Product review (5 stars): Great replacement filter.
This is the filter brand/model I have always purchased as a replacement for the five years we've owned our refrigerator. We have never noticed any issues with it causing a smell to the water or the ice and it is considerably less expensive than the factory filter.  Also, I've not had any issues with leaking as others have described.  As far as I can tell (five years), this is a great replacement filter.