Product review (4 stars): Icemaker good.  Packaging (lack of) not good.
The icemaker fits & works like a charm.  Perfect/direct replacement for my original Whirlpool Gold icemaker.
I absolutely love Amazon, but I was really surprised about how this thing came in the box.  No bubbles, no air cushions.. it was sitting in a much deeper, much higher box (width was closer).. so it was able to move freely during shipping.  Also, the icemaker itself was not in any type of plastic bag, so it was dusty/dirty in the box.  I held mine securely by the motor, washed the tray w/ soapy water, rinsed it good & let it air dry for hours, before installing it in it's frozen environment.  4 out of 5, because of the packaging & dust - otherwise excellent.