Product review (5 stars): Great Product
After reading reviews we were skeptical. However, we are 4 days into a 3 week road trip and this oiler has been fantastic! No ice mess, no items swimming in water and sloshing around! Very quiet! We did put a 5lb bag of ice for drinks in a plastic container and we still have some of the original ice.  Very happy with this purchase so far. The real test is to see how long it will work but we are very happy with this product.