Product review (1 stars): Water inside the fridge and not the glass ... not a good thing,
I wish there was a zero for the review process.  Absolutely horrid.  Purchased in a pack of 2 when the last of my latest 'extra' filters needed to be changed out.  I've become a fan of Amazon Prime.  A quick search turned this product up as a good replacement.  While not always thrilled with the quality of Amazon products, they've always met minimal expectations.  These filters fell below the bottom rung for me.  The first attempt at replacement was a mucky mess.  The silicone used as a lubricant covered both the inside and outside of the filter.  Replacement left me with a leak at the junction of the fridge and the new filter.  Removal and resetting of the added rubber compression ring provided no relief.  Everyone gets a bum product once in a while.  I decided to give the second of the pair a try.  I had noticed that the packaging of the first filter seemed like it had received a bit of bad treatment but overlooked it.  The second box had clearly been opened.  The plastic wrapping (that was NOT present on the first) had been opened and stuffed back into the box.  The silicone was not quite as plentiful as the first but required some care to avoid slippery hands.  Soaking the filter (as suggested in the instructions that were not present in the second box) was as successful as the first.  Soaking is error proof.  Inserting the filter produced a larger leak and a bigger mess than the first.  Removal stopped the leaking.  Cleaning, drying and re-seating the black rubber seat left me ready to try yet again.  I will admit.  The leaks are consistent but certainly not desirable.  It was time to remove the second replacement and dry the floors.  I figured that at this point there must be a failure in the O-ring at the point of attachment in the fridge.  It couldn't be the filters.  They were both new!  So, I tried inserting the "no filter plug" that came with the Bosch fridge.  It went on easily and didn't leak.  Odd.  I removed it and installed the original spent filter.  Sealed like a champ.  The replacements were, simply, losers.

I've had products I could have reviewed as a '6' (if allowed.)  I've now seen the other end of the spectrum.  I've definitely used the reviews of others.  I find that my lack of objective comments in the past may have provided other potential purchasers with useful comments (he typed vainly.)  Lesson learned.