Product review (2 stars): I think I got a bad one.
I think I got a bad one because I've used this filter before in our same fridge and it was great.  This time though, the water tastes funny, like something biological is not getting filtered out..there's a slight rotten taste. The new funky taste appeared when we replaced this same EveryDrop model filter with the new one. The old EveryDrop one still had 2% of use on it according to our fridge, but we replaced it with this new one and the water immediately tasted weird. I went on Amazon to see if I could get a free replacement but I'd have to return the old one. That is not easy to do. It's wet, it's been used and is still being used until we can replace it.
So, I've just been waiting for enough time to pass that buying another fridge filter makes financial sense.  Not sure I'll buy this one though.