Product review (4 stars): Works for Maytag Model MF12569YEM0
Purchased this unit to replace a worn out ice maker in a Maytag French Door Refrigerator Model MF12569YEM0. It worked, but required the following:

1) No mounting screws are provided with this replacement unit, and the screws required to mount it are different than those on the original unit. This Supco replacement unit requires three Machine Screws to mount, whereas the old OEM unit used a coarser thread screws which will not work with this replacement unit. Once we found three suitable screws it mounted fine.

2) The fill funnel is smaller on this replacement unit than the one on the OEM unit, but this one works fine without leaking any water so I guess it's large enough.

3) The ice cubes made by this replacement unit are about 30% larger than the ice cubes made by the OEM unit, but there does not seem to be any issue with dispensing the larger cubes.

4) DO NOT DISPOSE OF YOUR OLD ICE MAKER UNIT UNTIL THIS REPLACEMENT IS INSTALLED because you will need many of the old parts, including the wiring harness. If you have the same model Maytag refrigerator as ours you will note that your icemaker has an on-off switch on the right side of the front cover. The Supco replacement unit does not come with this switch, but since you are reusing the wiring harness from your old ice maker, just use this same front cover with the integrated switch on the replacement unit and discard the cover that comes with the Supco. It's recyclable.

Have only had the unit 1 day but it has already make a bunch of ice and seems to be working fine. I will be keeping an eye out for flaking paint down the road as I have seen that comment several times, but for <$40 this seems like a pretty good deal/