Product review (5 stars): Beautiful fridge--we love it!
We bought this fridge a month ago after a LOT of research and we are very happy with it. It is so bright inside, and we use the door in door feature all the time--so handy for grabbing things like milk or condiments. The only problem to note with the door-in-door is if you don't actively push it closed, the outer half of the door won't latch onto the inner part of the door. Unlike a full-on fridge door that has enough mass to swing all the way closed if you just nudge it in the right direction, the outer door is light and doesn't have the mass needed to latch itself. My husband gets the fridge-door-open beep all the time as a result because he forgets it won't latch itself!
As for the general style of this fridge, my husband and I are both tall so it's so nice having everything we use regularly--i.e. the stuff in the fridge, not the freezer--up higher and easier to access. The in-door ice maker is nice since it doesn't take up any space in the main area of the fridge, though the shelves on the ice maker door are laughably small (both depth-wise and height-wise--jars of things like horseradish are about all that will fit there). So far we haven't had problems with running out of ice due to this ice maker's smaller capacity, but it's just my husband and I. One thing to note that I really did not think about before buying (this would obviously be a problem for all fridges of this style) is how short all the shelves are in general. I struggled finding places tall enough for things like bottles of ketchup or salad dressing. Without adjustment (making one shelf very short), literally the only place something as tall as a jug of milk will fit is in the door shelf. Knowing this wouldn't have changed my decision to buy this style of fridge, it was just something I hadn't really thought about beforehand. Overall we love this fridge and would make the same choice again if we had to do it over.