Product review (5 stars): An excellent replacement for the silverware basket that came in our dishwasher
I have no idea what the one-star reviewers got, but we got a full, three-part basket, very similar to the OEM model. The handle in ours swivels, allowing the two middle compartments to be used with larger utensils, which our original one did not. Also, our original model had square mesh on all sides, including the bottom. We have a lot of workout bottles, things with large straws that can be removed, and small kitchen utensils. In the old basket, they would often get stuck in, or fall through, the mesh on the bottom. The new baskets have a much tighter hexagonal pattern that even a standard straw would not fall through. We were worried that the dishwasher might not clean as well, but we've had no problems, and it has been even better than the original in every way.