Product review (3 stars): With modifications, it works.
The inlet hose had to be cut to fit on the end of this valve, but otherwise, the installation was easy.

We also had to prime the ice maker by pouring a cup of water into it after the valve was installed before the ice maker started making ice again. That part wasn't included in any instructions.

Finally, this valve is a lot noisier than the old one, which wasn't very quiet anyway.

But at least we're now getting ice again!