Product review (5 stars): Works great!
After reading the reviews I was a bit concerned, but none of the broiler pans had great reviews so I went with this one.  The color is beautiful =)

The first one that came was clearly enameled/fired poorly as there was an un-coated (subject to rust) area on the top part, right on the top, near the edge. I sent it back and got another one.

My next question/concern was whether it would warp under the broiler, like many reviewers said theirs did.  I've had other broiler pans, years ago, that warped and I was able to broil just fine on them, so it wasn't going to be a deal-breaker like the un-coated bit mentioned above was.  Well, I'm a happy camper; no warp.  Which leads me to wonder if perhaps it is the broiler that the pans are being used under that could be the problem (uneven heat?).  My last stove was a good one and I had no warping problems with either of the broilers pans (that I left with the stove not realizing stoves no longer come with them) and my current (brand new) stove is also a good one; again, no warping of this broiler pan.