Product review (4 stars): Good with a couple sticking points.
Filter is direct replacement, instructions weren't totally clear.  They recommend to soak the filter for 15 minutes before installing (can't remember if this is in the pamphlet, but not on the packaging, or the other way around).  Now when I get water out of the door, the stream is strong, but there is also a little bit of dribble toward the front of the dispenser.  There's a joke there, but it's not intentional.  Overall it's good, and cheaper than the original.