Product review (3 stars): it's ok
Seems ok compared to the old one made by Pur, but I think the water smells. It's funny how the price of these have gone up when they pretty much filter the same thing as the old design. I did buy and off brand name a couple years ago and it didn't work the water stunk so guess you are stuck with this for your Maytag or Whirlpool refrigerators.