Product review (4 stars): No more ice trays!
We have never had an ice maker in the house and this fit the bill.  It was incredibly simple to hookup, and the directions were very clear and concise.

The only reason I took a star off is because of the water valve.  First, one of the hose hookups is a weird teeth clamp thing I haven't dealt with and I am worried it might leak in the future.  Second, the thing is loud.  When it is pulling water you can hear it.  This puppy is loud and makes a clacking sound.  My parents ice maker at their home is the same model and isn't near as noticeably.  Luckily it only does it for a couple of second every hour or so.

I'm sure I will tune the noise out and not notice it in the future.  Totally worth it to get rid of the ice trays!