Product review (4 stars): Here's the scoop
It's the right part and fits well.  It is easy to replace and allows the renewed use of the door shelf.  The price on Amazon is very competitive.  It is plastic and seems a little thin - but so was the original which is why it broke.  I have been using this part for about a year and it is holding up very well.  I would buy again... but I hope I don't have too  :)