Product review (5 stars): and is better than manual ice trays
Expectations are that the unit makes ice, doesn't leak, and is better than manual ice trays.  This fits the bill.  Nothing fancy - it just works.
I replaced a leaking ice maker in an Amana top freezer.  The replacement took less than 15 minutes, and within an hour, the unit was running and making ice.  The ice cycle seems a little longer than the original, but it works!  I adjusted our freezer temperature, and the ice speed increased somewhat - sufficient for a family of 4-5.