Product review (3 stars): Positive and Negative Aspects are pretty much balanced.
I think this wine chiller is pretty balanced in terms of its positive and negatives sides. That is why I think a 3-star rating is fair enough. On the positive side of it, it is very elegant-looking and suitable for various occasions. Unlike ice cubes, its cooling capability does not come at the expense of the wine's taste, as in it doesn't get diluted afterwards. It is more convenient in terms of preparation and cleaning up. And since it's stainless steel, I think it won't easily break.

On the downside though, the chiller stick is not long enough to reach where it should. If you have consumed almost half the bottle, it would be totally useless as it wouldn't be able to reach the liquid anymore. The cooling capability is not as strong as that of ice cubes. Also, I think it's too costly for just simple wine cooling.