Product review (5 stars): This thing makes ice! Don't forget to mount the thermostat in the metal clamp against outside of tray.
Installed this a week ago and it's been making ice as good as the original. As some have already stated, you do need to mount the thermostat (molded plastic thingy on one of the wires) in the metal clamp against outside of tray (instructions did not mention this and you may have to get creative so the plug reaches your freezer's socket once thermostat is clipped on). And just check the water fill depth with a toothpick and turn adjustment screw if necessary until water is between 1/2" and 3/4" deep.