Product review (3 stars): Not as good as I had hoped
This ice maker does work but you have to physically cut out a portion of the ice maker in order to allow for the water line to line up correctly.  It is made to do this and has what is called a "snap out" area to be removed from the ice maker, but it was not just quite as simple as it sounds.  I needed a razor knife to get this accomplished.

The thin metal arm on the ice maker that rises as the ice is made to tell it when to stop making ice does not work as well as it should.  Too much ice is made because the ice slips over the arm and it never raises sufficiently to shut the ice maker off.  My old ice maker had an extension to put on this arm, and I used it one this one, but the arm on the new ice maker is not the same shape and size as the old one and the extension doesn't fit quite right.

When I installed the ice maker, I had no way of telling right away if it was working, but about an hour or so after installation, I heard the first cubes drop into the ice bucket, so if you install this product you should see some results in about an hour.