Product review (1 stars): Correct part, bad seal, how to fix
Correct part, but the gasket didn't seal properly, and it leaked through the middle hole where the sensor is.
Even used a torque wrench and set it to 2.5 lbs so it was tightened the correct amount (per manufacturer).
FIX: I ordered some food safe sealant (DAP 00688 All-Purpose Adhesive Sealant 100% Silicone 2.8oz), and sealed around the sensor and outter rim during install.
One month later, the sealant is still holding strong, and the heating element is doing its job