Product review (5 stars): This one worked fine for my fridge!
One day my ice tasted like chemical funk.  I had not paid attention to the filter and it was long overdue.  Many reviews were critical of this filter but it fit my fridge and did not leak.  I emptied the ice tray and let 3 rounds produce, then dumped them just to make sure anything in the lines would be purged.  Ice was back to good after that!