Product review (4 stars): Good quality but has its quirks - we're happy so far
We went ahead and bought our Bosch appliances after reading several reviews.  We had a Bosch dishwasher which was outstanding in terms of how truly quiet it was.  But it was at the end of its life and had to be replaced so we wanted to stick to a Bosch dishwasher and my wife insisted that all the appliances had to match in appearance, so we stayed with the brand including the Refrigerator.

As people had pointed out, it was loud after the 1st 24 hours of operation and we were wondering if we had made a mistake.  I called that Appliance store and they said that all new high efficiency refrigerators are on the loud side.  I took that with a grain of salt.  However, after realizing that the temperature setting for the Crisper drawer was much lower than that of the Refrigerator, I bumped it up a bit (i.e. the Refrigerator is at 39, and the Crisper is at 37.)  This dramatically brought the noise level highly infrequent and at a much lower level.  I'm wondering if the temperature differential in the same side of the refrigerator was making the cooling system compensate frequently and perhaps decreasing the difference fixed the problem.

We're much happier with the purchase in the 3 months we've owned it.  As others have noted, it depends on what people are used to but the water dispenser doesn't have a dispense latch that opens the valve.  Instead it is activated by the button up in the front, which doesn't bother us, but guests that we have over appear to look for it.

We love the SuperCool feature.  There were concerns initially on whether the refrigerator was cooling sufficiently, but as time has gone by, we are used to how the system works.  We have not used the SuperCool feature in the last month and the cooling is very consistent with no worries.