Product review (3 stars): Eh - maybe.
I cook.  A LOT.  So we have a lot of scraps that go down the garbage disposal.  Our old one was falling apart, so needed a newer splash guard.  This one fits okay, however, being new, I constantly have to push food through it.  I guess since it's new, you have to push it harder than I used to have to push my food down.  I guess that means it will last longer, but I find myself taking it out so I can fit more food faster into my disposal.  It's likely just preference, but I'm kind of annoyed :)  It does serve it's purpose and stops the food from being thrown out at me - so that is a plus.