Product review (5 stars): Enjoy the silence
This item solves the problem of spoons and other items dropping into your disposal and has the great side-effect of making the disposal much quieter.  It does take a little more work to get the stuff into the disposal that you WANT to go there, but I don't think you can have it both ways and after a few weeks with this, we are 100% satisfied.  I did not even have to remove the existing baffle, just slid this right on top of the existing one and it works well.  We have the InSinkErator Badger model 1-83, by the way.