Product review (4 stars): New handle!  Beware of color!
Thanks to the reviews, I did manage to get the right color.  If you have the charcoal grey (like me), at first glance it can look black.  Same if you have black, the charcoal grey handle online can look black.  Just make sure to pay attention to your color to match it correctly.

Shipping was fast!  We broke the handle on Monday and I already have the new one installed Wednesday.  It's a crappy design that's prone to breakage, but that's certainly not the seller's fault.  I already planned on getting a new fridge soon and this just reassured me that I need to make that happen soon.

Fixed for now, hopefully we don't break another before we get a new fridge.