Product review (3 stars): The water dispenser and the ice maker work fine without one installed
I dropped one on the floor when trying to install it and it shattered into many pieces. Probably all of these type filters would do the same.

I'm not buying any more of these filters (or any other brand). The water dispenser and the ice maker work fine without one installed. You can put a big filter under your sink in the supply line to the fridge for not much money.