Product review (5 stars): Its expensive but fits and no leaks, water is clear and fine.
This has one black rubber gasket at the top, the filter that came with the refrigerator had 2 thinner gaskets.  Anyway, it works, no leaks, no cloudy, its fine.  I just think $50 is too much when the generic ones are $9 to $16.  Next time I'll try a third party.  I just didn't want to risk a water leak.