Product review (5 stars): Home Depot filter is cheaper, but...
I saw the price for this GE filter at Home Depot ($45) and Amazon ($36) and decided that was too high.  Home Depot had their own store brand replacement filter, at $50 for a two-pack model HDX, so I decided to try them.

Big mistake.

First off, the water dispenser came down with a bad case of the "drips".  That subsided after a day.

Then the Home Depot filter started making this awful rattling noise when dispensing water.  Not all the time, but sometimes it happened three times when filling up a single glass.  The rattling stopped when you stopped filling the glass, but it was a royal pain.  We started filling our glass from the sink after filling up with ice.

So I broke down and ordered the GE filter from Amazon.

Problem solved.  No more drips, no more rattles.  Sometimes you get what you pay for.

To their credit, Home Depot accepted my return of both filters, one with some water still in it.