Product review (4 stars): Cautiously optimistic after about a month.
Seems to fit just fine, but I think I'm noticing a bit more noise from the ice maker.  Not sure if that's my imagination ;-)  I bought this one because it's USA made and I wanted to be extra cautious about the replacement. I live in a condo and a friend just had her ice maker leak and it destroyed all her flooring in her condo and some of the floor in the unit next door.  That's made me very paranoid about leaky ice makers.