Product review (4 stars): Compatible Maytag water filter
UPDATE:  October 7, 2014:
This filter works, but doesn't match the size of the original Maytag part; is short in length by abou 3mm.  Because of that difference in length, it doesn't fit snugly into place within my new model Maytag French door refrigerator, and therefor, has a tendency to leak -- but only very little; nothing you'll have to watch.  Placing a small rubber washer behind the non-attaching side of the filter made it fit into place, snugly, and seems to prevent any drop of water leaking.

One other thing I notice upon installation, was how grey they water was during priming the filter.  This is the only filter (of four) that I've ever seen this, and primed three liters of water through before using it.  The water is now crystal clear.  We also have a whole-home water filter system, so there was no need to guess where the grey water was coming from.

So far, water flow is excellent, and the water tastes fine.  I would recommend at least two liters of priming before use.  Now, it's only a mater of time to see how well the filter performs...

------------------------------------------ Previous Review------------------------------------------------
Fast delivery, fits correctly, less expensive.  I can't post a full review until the filter has been in use for a while.