Product review (3 stars): The 2nd best ice trays I've ever used.
I've been searching for more of the ice trays that came with my fridge for years, so was very excited to find these.  $10/each is steep for an ice tray, but the ones that came with my fridge really are enough better than everything else I've used to justify it.

Sadly, these aren't as good.

If I hadn't used the ones that came with my fridge, I would have been completely satisfied, and called these the best ice trays I'd ever used.  Compared to the originals, these fall a little short.  The plastic is thinner, which makes the trays a little flimsy, and the finish isn't very good--they've got rough, untrimmed edges, and don't quite stack properly.

The issues aren't show-stoppers, and they're still miles better than the usual trays, they just don't hold up next to the originals.  I'd still recommend them if you can't get the ones they're an imitation of.