Product review (3 stars): OK quality - iffy documentation
This is a very good replacement for the ice maker on my Whirlpool fridge.  It's not an exact replacement, but it's definitely comparable.  To me, "very good" means I didn't have to hack around to make it fit or function.  The quality is just OK though.

___________________
Pros:

* Makes ice!
* Pretty simple to install
* Plastic ice tray instead of the plastic coated metal tray of the OEM.  (Plastic coating peeled off and corroded the metal tray and made weird ice.  It's a good thing I'm done making babies, because it shed some pretty funky stuff into the ice!)
* Good assortment of wiring harnesses and hardware included.

___________________
Cons:

* The instructions were pretty slim and didn't even really apply to this model.
* Not as well constructed as the original unit.  Definitely more flimsy.
* Makes ice pretty slowly.  Our old ice maker would fill the bin in a day--even under daily use.  This one hasn't filled it yet!
* Drops the cubes straight down and doesn't hit the bin every time.