Product review (4 stars): Smells horrible, but it works.
This stuff works as a paste. Applying to wet cloth (from directions) didn't get the job done, but the alternate directions of making a paste worked splendidly. I will say that the stuff smells like death! It smelled like an electrical fire the whole time I was cleaning, but the Whirlpool Affresh cleaner I followed up with cleared the smell right up. No gouges, no pits... and no more rust!