Product review (1 stars): Not sucking up water
This is not sucking up the water into the foam like the original filter. The water line only reaches about 1 in height which means the humidifier is no longer working properly.

I live in Texas so we have very mild winters. This replacement filter is only reaching 22 percent humidity where the original easily made it to 55 percent.  This is with full water containers and set to maximum humidity levels and fan speed.

I would not recommend this as a replacement filter, get an original.