Product review (3 stars): Main problem, it does not drain water fast enough.
This item came with my Evolution Excel. The noise is low and there is no splash back however, it did not drain very well when when the disposal was not in use. The sink would begin to fill with water unless the disposer was on or I pushed the edge of the baffle to allow the air bubble out and the water to drain.

On closer inspection I noticed that the two top slots on my baffle were not nearly as big as the ones on all the pictures or animations. I am not sure if it is a manufacturing defect or they think it does not matter.

I took an exacto knife and made the slots as big as possible(Like the pictures!) and now it drains very well.

I docked two stars for having to modify this product to it own supposed configuration and to get it to drain normally.