Product review (4 stars): Good at making ice - but not keeping it
OK, the goods:

1)  Kicks out a reasonable quantity of ice in a reasonable time.
2)  Looks nice.
3)  Seems pretty rugged.

The bads:

1)  The ice starts melting.  Since we're using this as a temporary measure (our ice maker died, and we're remodeling the kitchen in a few months), we use this to put ice in the freezer through-door feeder.  The ice is pretty wet and tends to freeze together when put into the freezer.