Product review (5 stars): The rugs are fine. It is true that the rugs are open ...
Upon initial inspection I rate this bag highly.  I read some other reviews that were critical of the enclosed  gun rugs.  The rugs are fine.  It is true that the rugs are open on three sides; one side being secured with Velcro.  But, inside the bag are two side pockets designed to hold and isolate the rugs. I don't see a problem.  Before purchasing replacement rugs check out what is supplied with the bag.