Product review (5 stars): I finally found one that fit!
I previously bought one of these that was aluminum but it didn't fit properly because my stove was slightly higher than my counter so it wouldn't lay flat.  This product hugs both the counter and the stove perfectly.  I also decided on the black because my granite counter top was very dark (green/black/burgundy) and because I read that the clear can stain and it's hard to get the stain out.  Hopefully, this will wear well.  But as of today, I'm very happy with this product.