Product review (2 stars): Doesn't wick well
They don't wick very well.  I have a BestAir in one and this filter in the other.  Both were full of water, and the BestAir is wet to the top and this one is only wet where the water is touching it.  I didn't want to buy a BestAir because the chlorine elimination that is standard makes the filter gross looking and I am leery of it.  This was not a good replacement, though.