Product review (5 stars): Visually identical to Samsung's except labels. Works fine
I compared it with the Samsung's, visually there was virtually no difference other than labels. The black rubber rings were the same. Some review did mention that missing rings  could be the cause of a few reported leakage. Installed easily have not seen any leakage after 24 hours. Tried the ice produced with this filter, I found no strange smell. Everything works fine.

Update: 10/24/2017 It has been a couple of months now and the filter has worked flawlessly.