Product review (3 stars): Triggers a solenoid problem
I'm going with three stars because it really could go either way.  On my refrigerator these filters trigger an oscillation in a valve solenoid which makes it sound like someone is hammering on the pipes. I tried both filters from the package with the same result.  Switching to either the old GE filter or a genuine new one solves the problem.

That would be one star, but it's possible that this is the fridge's fault - it came with our house and might be pretty old.