Product review (5 stars): Does the trick.
This ended up being the wrong knob to match my oven- I should've checked more closely but they do look very similar. My stove has bigger knobs, but my son broke one of them off (sigh). They're so expensive to replace that I didn't want to buy a new set of 4 knobs.

That said, I'll probably just use this, even though it doesn't match in size. It still fits into the spot and it will work for now.