Product review (4 stars): the original one looks and feels like matte. But this one is chrome finished
Original one is made out of steel and this one is plastic.
Frankly, the original one was very difficult to get it out and plastic one would be easier.
Having said that, the original one looks and feels like matte. But this one is chrome finished, and flashy. Fits fine.
But overall, looked ok. If anything, it would be best if you replace all of them so that it has uniform look.
I am fine with the purchase, but there are these caveat. If those are important, this is not the item that you need.