Product review (3 stars): Had to break in.
This seemed to take a little while to break in compared to the one that actually came with the fridge.  It was pretty noisy at first like there was air in it(and I ran several gallons through it at first), but after a couple of weeks it seems to have settled down fine.  It is also a tad longer so I had to remove the shelf to get it in.  Considering how much less it was then the manufacture's brand, I don't mind the minor inconvenience and will buy it again.