Product review (2 stars): You might as well get the real deal
Actually, I don't know why I bought this, when the genuine Holmes filter currently costs about the same or maybe just a little bit more on Amazon.

First problem was that even though it has a stiffer outer webbing, it got rather droopy once it was saturated. Possibly as result of that, my "Filter Check" meter kept indicating 'Replace', even though the filter was brand new.  I tried flipping the filter, and making other adjustments, but nothing worked.

Finally, after just a couple weeks, it started to smell kind-of skunky.

I ordered & installed a genuine Holmes filter, and now my "Filter Check" meter is 'Good'. Lesson learned.