Product review (5 stars): It works like it did when the fridge was brand new
This icemaker replaced the noisy and dripping one in my whirlpool side by side.  There were icicles from the old icemaker and frozen drips on food, shelves and bottom.  I researched on line for hours and was led to believe it was the water shut-off solenoid. But after seeing a review here that it actually fixed their leaking icemaker that made icicles where they don't belong and the protective finish was coming off the cube tray too, I ordered one too as the old one was groaning more and more just prior to dumping the ice. I had to take a chance it might fix the icicles everywhere they didn't belong and it did!!!!!!.  It is normal with no leaks or icicles anymore!
We're enjoying ice again. It works like it did when the fridge was brand new. FYI my model has the light sensor for the ice-bin fill level.  It took about 20 minutes to replace.  I highly recommend this icemaker.