Product review (4 stars): Works with my own setup.
It is not original filter and will never work as original filter but it gets 4 stars because of the setup I have.

Regular setup from the store has issue with filter which only gets water upwards. Store setup works fine for a short period of time but not for a long run. After my own setup, I use humidifier filters for a really long time. Just keep refilling water and of course Humidifier Bacteriostatic Water Treatment mix to kill bacteria.

I bought VicTsing 80 GPH Submersible Pump Aquarium Fish Tank Powerhead Fountain Water Hydroponic and setup tube with small holes on the top of the filter so gravity was doing the job and water was running downwards. Now I replace filters about ones a month, some times I can pull to two month.

Filter itself is ok quality. It is also taller than original filter.