Product review (4 stars): I am glad that I was able to find one with the ...
Got this as a direct replacement for our broken one. The original one that was in our fridge had the coil part that was made out of plastic and that is what chipped and broke off after trying to move some ice that was clumped together. I am glad that I was able to find one with the metal part that rotates because I think that will not have any issues becoming damaged over time.

The only flaw I saw on the one I got is the little piece that sticks out of the back that should marry up to the hole in the back of the freezer was a bit off and I had to bend it a bit to get it to fit properly in the hole. If it doesn't fit in there correctly then when you select the crushed or cubed it won't work and everything will come out crushed. I have to pay attention when I put the tray back in to make sure that metal piece correctly gets inserted into the spot.

Other than that it works fine and would recommend getting this if you need to replace your older one.