Product review (5 stars): Fit well, but one very small cosmetic issue.
Update 4/16 - After posting a question, I was shown the solution to the knob not seating all the way on the post. When I removed the old knob, a small metal sleeve was left on the post. Once I removed that, the new knob slid right in and is perfect.

**********

Overall, a 5. I watched the video on Maytag/Whirlpool site, the instructions were great and it went together in seconds.

The only issue is that it seems to sit a little higher on the post than the other. So the dial is not completely flush. I suppose I could drill it out a bit, but it really is just a cosmetic thing. I will stick with the old rule 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it'. For what it is, the operation is fine.

Really happy with Maytag/Whirlpool and Amazon for having this item available. Had a tech come out, I would have been charged $50+ just for the visit and then the part. Instead, got it fixed for less than $15.