Review: Two murders form the core of a strong psychological thriller
Rating: 4 out of 5
Date: 09 1, 2013
Catherine Monsigny, a young lawyer, takes on the defense of Myriam Villetreix who is accused of poisoning Gaston, the man who apparently saved her from deportation by marrying her.  Catherine sees the case as her springboard to fame, although she wonders how she will interest Parisian reporters in the murder of a farmer in a rural community in central France.  It happens to be the same community where Catherine's mother was murdered when Catherine was only four years old.  Catherine's mother was killed in a park where Catherine was found crying in a stroller.  The killer was never identified.As Catherine was growing up, her bottled-up father refused to talk to her about her mother.  Her father always tried to replace the reality of her mother's death with a myth, casting her mother as a princess struck down by evil witches, and Catherine as a girl who is protected by fairies.  Her memories of that day -- someone handing her the piece of cloth she had dropped -- might be false.  She may have been too young to remember anything, as her father has always insisted.Catherine is an introspective character.  She is young and nave.  "She believes in everything she has not experienced."  Yet she is also rebellious and adventurous, as she proves by bedding one of her clients early the novel, shortly after she gets him acquitted. She wonders whether she is (like some of the people she sees accused of sex crimes) a mere "consumer of flesh," unable to see her partners as anything other than objects of her desire.  As the novel progresses, Catherine undergoes a maturation process, feeling by the end of the story that, at the age of twenty-six, she is "older than the rest of the world."In part, The Paris Lawyer is a family drama.  The primary focus is on Catherine as she discovers her mother's secrets, but it is also on Catherine's father, who coped with his wife's death as best he could (although not in the way that Catherine wanted) and lives in fear that his daughter no longer needs him.  To a lesser extent, the story involves a different family drama, that of Myriam and Gaston, "two people mistreated by life" who either loved or despised each other, depending on the observer's viewpoint.  More fundamentally, The Paris Lawyer is a thriller, cleverly woven from various plot threads in ways that are both obvious and subtle.  Title notwithstanding, it is a psychological thriller rather than a legal thriller.  Myriam's trial remains in the background for much of the novel, serving as a framework for the larger story.Sylvie Granotier slowly builds a suspenseful atmosphere from a series of ambiguous incidents and flashes of buried memories.  Through much of the novel, I was puzzled about where the plot was taking me, a pleasant departure from the stacks of predictable thrillers that substitute silliness for depth. The Paris Lawyer is ultimately a contemplation of guilt in all its different guises, but it is also a good story that ends with surprising revelations about the killers of Gaston and of Catherine's mother.  Its only flaws (small ones, I think) are that the novel's denouement borders on melodrama and the story is more intellectually than emotionally engaging.  If I could, I would give The Paris Lawyer 4 1/2 stars.