Review: 4 stars
Rating: 4 out of 5
Date: 02 9, 2014
Personally, I think Jamie got off too easy.I understand why he was hurt and angry - but he says that he believed that she hadn't had an affair - but he still leaves for 5 years. 5 years without a word and it seemed like he only came back because his heir died. Not because he missed Cat or because he forgave her but because he needed an heir.In his defense Cat did something really stupid and did not think of how her actions would affect Jamie. But to pout about it for 5 years!  What she did was stupid but the punishment did not fit the crime.I think Cat let him off too easy - he didn't grovel at all - sure he admitted that he was a fool to stay away so long - but that is not good enough.  He hurt her worse than she hurt him.  He punished her for being stupid and wounding his pride.  He left and didn't communicate with her at all for 5 years because she hurt his feelings. 5 years!I think if it had been a year I could have forgiven him. Or even if he had written to her over the years - but he didn't.  And she doesn't even ask if he was faithful to her over those years. She says she was faithful to him and he says nothing.  I could have even forgiven him if he at least admitted that he had been faithful - but he didn't.The story was well written and had a bit of steam - but I just couldn't get past him abandoning her for 5 years!