Review: Granotier has pulled layers from the characters to expose their secrets and flaws up to the last pages,
Rating: 4 out of 5
Date: 06 13, 2013
This was an incredibly compelling story that maintains that peculiar sensibility that is utterly French yet eludes description.  While most of the more procedurally focused stories I have read flow between police and criminal, Granotier mixes it up and gives us young lawyer Catherine Monsigny enmeshed in two different storylines of past and present.Lush descriptions place readers in the city of Paris or in the small village in the hills of central France. It is easy to relate to the small town feel: curious neighbors, unlocked doors and a bit of suspicion about anyone different, Parisian or immigrant.Catherine is brought forward to defend Miriam Villetrieux for the poisoning death of her husband Gaston.  As an African immigrant, orphaned at a young age and brought to Paris for a position with rather dubious employers, her life has been a difficult one until she married the well-off and older Gaston.  Where I expected to see far more covert and even overt racism displayed toward Miriam, I was surprised to see evidence of Catherine's difficulty in overcoming her own racial bias and tendency to jump to conclusions.Catherine often seemed more immature than her position and education would warrant, her rush to conclusion without fully investigating people or situations was troubling, especially as she seems to lack that essential quality of `people sense', and is a horrible judge of character.  I think there are two huge issues for her: the strained relationship with her father over his refusal to discuss her mother or her mother's death, and her education and lawyer speaks tend to become her separation and protection from situations that are emotionally difficult. I saw her as lacking in self-confidence which she covers over with a more stilted and often overly complex speech that bleeds into her personal narrative because it is safe and comfortable.  I felt for her, even if I didn't particularly empathize with her.Other characters were as well-crafted and complex, with varying degrees of success and import to the plot.  While the book did require very careful reading as the present and past often collide with little notice.  But, as the more menacing undertones start to reveal themselves the pacing changes and the distinction between past and present is more apparent and easier to follow. Bringing all of the threads to one final conclusion, Granotier has pulled layers from the characters to expose their secrets and flaws up to the last pages, and created a story that was well worth the time to read.I received an eBook copy from the publisher for purpose of honest review for France Book Tours.  I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.