Comfortable but...
THEY SMELL TERRIBLE! Very strong chemical off-gassing from the foam or plastic which is detectable before, after, and during wear. Now, to be completely fair, many mainstream insoles (e.g. Profoot and even some Dr. Scholls) at the store have this same odor which has made it very difficult for me to find an exception. The smell never goes away even after leaving them outside or baptizing them in baking soda or EOs. If odor does not factor into your judgment, these seem to be of decent quality, and I would recommend them for value and comfort if not for the stink.
Rating: 2 stars