Well, maybe 4.5 stars...  good slim bmx seat w/ a bit of padding (not much)
I got this for a Redline MX24, which comes with a VERY light/slim hard plastic seat.  I wanted a bmx seat with a bit more size & padding.  This one was a decent price, and looked like it would fit bike's looks (it is the light blue MX24).  Initially, I was a bit concerned out of the box because the padding is very minimal, and it is not much larger than the original seat.  However, it fits the bike very well and is significantly more comfortable than the original seat.  Redline has a fat padded bmx seat, called the "Chubby" or something like that...just too big / too much padding.  However, it seems hard to find anything between those types of seats that are too big / too much padding, and these that are small with minimal padding.  While I might have preferred something a bit bigger and a bit more padding, I don't think that is the fault of this manufacturer, just personal preference, so I would not mark them off for that.  My suggestion of 4.5 stars is the lack of any directions.  There is a bolt down the middle of the seat you access through the top middle of the seat, and here there is a slit through the material at that point.  But it was not cut.  I was frankly concerned I might permanently mess it up just by jamming the wrench through there till it tore, and wondering if there might be some other solution like a way to remove the padding first to attach the plastic.  Near as I can tell, you are actually supposed to just shove the wrench through the slit, tearing it open as needed (or maybe get a slimmer tool like exacto first).  I don't think it said anywhere what size allen wrench to use, and I only knew what size because the bolt I removed from the old seat was exposed / easy to see.  If both seats had this sort of "slit" in the covering, I might have had to try trial & error.  A tiny bit of instruction would have saved me a few minutes of confusion / stress in attaching this.  Anyway, that's a minor issue.
Rating: 5 stars