Not what I expected.  Better!
I liked the old goop.  White, gritty, didn't need water to rinse it off.  I ordered this without reading the directions and found you had to wash it off.  I was disappointed as the whole reason to have goop for me was to be able to de-gunk my hands without coming back in the house to wash them.  I gave it a squirt anyway.  I see why you need to wash it off as it's a bit more oily than the old goop.  But it works very well and it rinses off even in cold hose water.  And it smells very nice.  And it doesn't dry out my hands.  Okay, not what I expected but the trade off made it better for me.
Rating: 5 stars