Too thick for non tying boots/shoes
Don't believe the person who says they don't make you shoes fit tight.  I put them in a pair of very well worn in Redwings and tried them on and could feel the top of my foot being forced into the top of my boots.  Perhaps that lady and her husband don't have very high arches but these things are like an inch thick at the heel and despite being tall don't fill out the shoes width wise.  I'm sure they're comfortable but they aren't going to work for me if I can barely get my foot in my boots and then can feel them wanting too slide side to side.  Another insole I had high hopes for but will be returning.
Rating: 3 stars