Good idea in theory but didnt work for us.
Seems like a good idea but bedridden husband wont use it bec 1st X he tried the long tube had to drape to the side over his plump leg  (he is lying flat on his back)  and liquid didnt flow down fast enough bec it had to flow sideways over leg before it could go down.  I wish he would try again bec I'm tired of emptying see-thru urine bottles 6X a day.  This has 2-liter opaque container that sits on floor.
Rating: 3 stars