Packaging allowed one to break.
One of the two was snapped in half so I'm giving them three stars (the file snapped inside the case, the case was intact). The one I got that wasn't broken is just as I expected: it's nice and seems to work well (only time will tell if it dulls quickly), and the case is attractive and closes/stays closed well (not sure how the case would hold up to being carried around in a purse). I'd gotten these so I could leave them out hoping having them handy would encourage me to keep my nails from getting ragged. Too bad as now I'm one short. I would have used the second one.
Rating: 3 stars