Not for me
This might work for some people.  It's plenty thick and the cushioning is nice.  What I do not like is that it allows your body to shift from side to side a bit. It might not be a big deal on a bucket-type of seat with a lot of side support, but on an average desk chair, it has too much sideways instability for my taste.  FWIW, I am 6-1 and 195 lbs.
Rating: 3 stars