3.5 Stars
I am not normally a plant based protein fan, but these are pretty good.  I think it will also depend on your flavor preference.  I was able to try both the oatmeal cookie and the hazelnut.  I am a chocolate lover and was expecting to love the hazelnut.  However; I was not a fan of the flavoring on that one.  However; I really enjoyed the oatmeal cookie flavor.  You get both the oatmeal and the cinnamon and it was much better than I was expecting.  It did not have any horrible aftertaste either.  It has a very slight chalky taste, but it was very little.  I am impressed overall.  Still giving 4 stars to both as they both were better than expected even though the one was not my preference (but chalkiness, formula, and etc were still great).
Rating: 4 stars