Both types are comfortable, stay in place
My right foot had both a bunion and a dropped metatarsal. The second toe rubs against the big toe. This product does the job. Both types are comfortable, stay in place, and provide good separation. I would have preferred a clear gel vs. the milky white since clear would be less noticeable if wearing sandals. Not sure if I will use these with sandals, but they are great inside shoes.
Rating: 4 stars