If you love Catan, you have to have this.
We love the board.  It definitely brings the game to the next level.  Some pieces are a little tight and the port symbols are so small that they are a little hard to differentiate, but still feel like we got a good value.  We haven't done Cities and Knights yet, but we will probably use the Barbadian piece on the side.  I saw a wooden one on Etsy, but it was very expensive.
Rating: 5 stars