It works fine, I just have to wear it slightly further ...
The band I received was slightly (only slightly) too large, but I'm sure that was the fault of my measurement and not the crafting.  It works fine, I just have to wear it slightly further up my arm than I would prefer.  However, the issue that I took a star off for is that the findings appear to be silver in color but not actually silver plated; they turn my skin green.  Far from ideal for something meant to be worn on a constant basis.  Otherwise very nicely crafted and comfortable.  Several weeks in, and no discomfort/pokey bits and no failure of the clamps holding the band or any other parts.  Infinitely more comfortable than the bulky leather double-wrap from Bellabeat.
Rating: 4 stars