I prefer the tins to the boxes.
I purchased two different gift cards for two different amounts in two different packages.  They arrived within a few days and they came just as ordered.  The tin box was good quality and looked just as pictured.  The cardboard giftbox was my error, It was a Hanakkah box, I didn't look closely so I put the gift card in a card without the box.  That being said, the box was nice as well but I do prefer the tins.
Rating: 5 stars