Dries out too quick.
I like E.L.F. products but was disappointed with this eyeliner.  It has great precision and nice, dark color but unfortunately it dries out very quickly especially if you are lining your eye over already applied foundation, face powder or eye shadow. The already applied make-up gets transferred onto the eyeliner tip and dries it out too quickly.  I have found that after about five uses, it's too dried out to use anymore.
Rating: 2 stars