Not quite what I was looking for...
I really liked the idea of fabric headbands as I thought they would be comfier than plastic headbands. They are comfier but with my somewhat short hair, I have trouble keeping the headband to the front of my head - it keeps sliding toward the back.  It holds better if I pull it farther front on my ears but I find that too hot in the summer heat.  Love the look of the twisted knot but the knot is created by looping two lengths of fabric which means it's trickier to get a smooth look as the lengths sometimes separate.
Rating: 4 stars