Great Eyeliner!
I can see why people dislike the slight smudging throughout the day, but honestly, this is the best eyeliner I've bought. Goes on easily without irritating your eyes, and does not feel sticky when you blink. No irritation, no pain, no smearing. I cried four times in one day and it didn't smear at all! Definitely water proof, although I don't have a huge problem taking it off at the end of the day or fixing mistakes. I would highly recommend at least trying it.
Rating: 5 stars