Works great but has parabens
I need a waterproof eyeliner because make up tends to smudge really easily on my eyes (I'm Asian & I have eczema around my eyes so I tend to over moisturize them). The women at the makeup counter suggested this after I saw the waterproof liquid liner I used with MAC was discontinued. It lasts forever & you definitely need remover to remove it (which is the way  I like it) and in the rare moment it does somehow come off, it fades off rather than flaking. It also gives a really nice CRISP line, which is what I want.<br /><br />But it has parabens, which have been found in breast cancer tumors. The Cosmetic Ingredient Review & the FDA have found parabens to be safe but I don't really trust either (the CIR is sponsored BY the industry it reviews, hm). There's been no proven link and the study that found the parabens didn't study how much parabens are in normal tissue. So it's really up to you if you care about parabens in your products. Honestly, if it was $4-8, I would probably not care...but for $24, C'MON SON. Had to return.
Rating: 2 stars