GREAT IF YOUR GOAL IS TO LOOK LIKE A CLOWN.....
I generally love ELF cosmetics, but this is the worst. It is a neon blue, so I have no idea where “black” or “navy” fit in this description,  It is easy to use, but it does not stay where you put it. I don’t understand how, but it was on my hands, the counter and was hard to get off those surfaces. I checked and there was no earthquake while I tried to apply it, which is really the only thing I can come up with for it being everywhere.  By hour 2, the eyeliner had moved from the liner position I had started with to staining the top portion of my eyelids, making me look like a 1970s roller derby queen. Good luck getting it off too. Went to the bathroom to use soap and water to scrub it off, and it is still there, use ponds cold cream - STILL there.  Very disappointed, will not use again or buy this eyeliner again.  I will put it in a bag, then into another bag followed by a box and toss it into the garbage hoping that I am able to get rid of it without staining my entire house and animals.
Rating: 1 stars