Not the worst but not the best, either
It's hard to find a really good waterproof mascara, and this is not bad, but it's not great either. It's a little too wet, so it pulls the curl out of the lashes, which is not a good thing. The applicator is a nice size - not too small and not too large. Unfortunately, by the end of the day (14+ hours), it starts to flake a little bit. The waterproofing does perform well, though. Tears, rain, and showering have not made it run. Yet it's easier to take off with make-up remover than other waterproof mascaras I've tried. It has a decent volumizing effect but does very little for lengthening. I plan to go back to my Laura Mercier waterproof mascara.
Rating: 3 stars