I suppose it’s all about perspective
All of the makeup was new and unopened so thats good. Some came with manufacturers coupons attached that expired in 2005 (it’s 2022) so um… not so good. The colors are random. Example: I am an olive complexion white lady and I received some foundation for someone MUCH darker than I.  It would be safe to assume it was intended for use by someone of a different ethnicity other than my own.  I think I kept 4/5 things for myself and the rest all went to my kids makeup collection.  It was all high quality name brand stuff just extremely random.
Rating: 3 stars