Three stars, would be higher if one product wasn't open.
This box is fair. A lot of lipgloss, lipstick, and mascara. These are fine. Mostly Covergirl and the Katy Kat collection.<br />One big flaw was one one lip stain was open, the top was out in the bottom of the box, and some of the product was squeezed out of the tube.
Rating: 3 stars