Undereye Smudges - not waterproof
I love the volume but found myself with racoon-eyes.  The first few times I didn't realize it was happening until looking in the mirror at work, and to my surprise, I had black smudges under both eyes.  Attractive!  As long as I wipe with a tissue throughout the morning, I'm OK.  I probably won't buy this again as I want a true waterproof mascara as I have oily skin.
Rating: 2 stars