Stops Working!
I wanted to like these colorful liners so badly! The packaging and price were both on point. The colors once on were also long lasting and resilient - did not smear easily at all. BUT I was only able to successfully line one eye  (using the red liner) as shown in the photo. The liner stopped being as visible on my skin as I was attempting to line my other eye, no matter how hard I pressed and wiped away the oils on my face that I thought might be interfering with the visibility of the pigment, the liner was no longer as vibrant as it was initially. If I could actually use more of the liner, this product would likely receive 5 stars.
Rating: 2 stars