Not very impressed...
So I was really hoping this would EASILY remove eye make-up.  Well it does remove it, but not so easily.  If I apply it to a dry face and I leave it on about 30 seconds and then rub it in with my fingers - and then rinse really well  - then it works pretty well.  But you must let it sit and then rub it in (especially for mascara) - and I don't even use the waterproof kind. I also don't like that it is an oil.  I like nutrogena's natural cleanser and make-up remover much better, but couldn't find it online this time.
Rating: 3 stars