I expected Better
I ordered this because of the great ratings and awards, even though I thought it was pretty expensive compared to what I can buy in stores.  Maybe my expectations were too high, because I find absolutely nothing special about this mascara.  I do like that it does not give me raccoon eyes from smudging.  However, I have used others that were just as beneficial in that respect, at a much less expensive price.  Plus, I've only worn it in cold weather, not when I'm hot and sweaty.  Can't say how smudge proof it will be then.  The main thing I dislike is that it takes so many coats to do any good.  It seems diluted or something.  Maybe it's just my personal preference, but I like to see a change in my eyelashes after a single coat.  Because of that and the expense, I wouldn't buy this again.
Rating: 3 stars