This Black shadow did not work as eyeliner at all
I hoped this would be good for using as black eyeliner.  I literally could not get it to apply, stick in any kind of reasonable manner.  It's got a consistency like wax, and just balls up for the most part.  I really feel like I'm missing something? I tried different brushes, using moisture, not using moisture on the brush, and even a Q-tip just to scoop it out and press it on.  No go.  This stuff would not go on my eyelids, no way, no how.  Now maybe as theatrical style eye makeup if that's what you want, you could glob it on..?  I don't know.
Rating: 1 stars