Good but not Great
I used Pantene when my hair was relaxed and loved it!  I am about 14 months into my transition to natural hair so needless to say I stopped using the for women of color line and switched to other products.  Because I had a great experience with Pantene in the past I decided to give their new cowash a try as a cheaper option to the As I Am co wash that I am currently using.  For me, I would definitely say that the As I Am co wash gets the 5 stars -- great smell, no tangles, soft/smooth hair and works great with my conditioners and oils that I use after co-washing.  The Pantene was good too, great smell and no tangles but I noticed my hair was not as soft as it usually is.  As it stands now I will continue to use the As I Am cowash to get the results that I am used to :-)
Rating: 3 stars