Worst eye liner I have ever used and this is ...
If I could give this eye liner zero stars,  I would.  Worst eye liner I have ever used and this is coming from someone who habitually buys eye liner from Target. I was not expecting much from an $8 eye pencil.  Really the only thing I expected was for it to be the only thing it claims to be: WATERPROOF. 30 min after applying it was already running and dripping into the corner of my eye.  Guess I'll stick to Target eye liners:/
Rating: 1 stars