Works well for being natural
This works well for being so natural.  I've used all kinds of mascara though the years.  The ones I liked the best were black and waterproof.  I am not sensitive or have never had any reactions to any mascara.  This mascara looks pretty natural, has a good color of black, is not too thick and clumpy.  The only time it smudges is if I overdo the coconut oil under my eyes in the morning before applying my mascara.  It will run slightly if I cry which is not often.  I don't rub my eyes with mascara of any kind--this could smudge if I did.  But I'd rather this than use the chemical mascaras that are waterproof.
Rating: 4 stars