Depends on the color
These eyeliners are super precise and long lasting!  Great quality!  The problem is that some of them have great, vibrant colors and some of them barely show up on my skin.  Could work better on someone with fair skin, and I haven't yet tried using a light concealer underneath to brighten the base, but the greens/ blues/ purples don't need it at all and look amazing, while pinks/ yellow/ orange are barely visible on me.  Still gave it 4 stars because even if I don't use the lighter colors, it's still worth it for the price!
Rating: 4 stars