My favorite
UPDATE: Well, several years later here I am trying to order this again and I find that the Grey #5 is no longer available. I wasn't happy. I read a lot of reviews (thanks to everyone!) and decided to try Khaki Brown #4. And guess what! It's great! It's definitely a different color than the other but there's no orange and it looks great, probably even better than the Grey one. Whew!<br /><br />(Original post)  I've tried quite a few but this is my favorite eyebrow pencil so far. It does wipe off easily, but if you keep your hands off it doesn't disappear, change color or fade like others. I love the grey (which is actually a taupe on my skin. I have naturally black brows which are thinning and even some hairs are now grey and I really hate it. When I use this pencil they look more natural than the others. (My hair is silvery white grey, was black when younger.) I don't feel the color looks so harsh as flat grey or black pencils and doesn't turn orange like some browns I've tried.  I use the small end to outline and the other to fill in. I hoped to use the small to draw individual brow hairs but the pencil is quite soft and does not really work like that. Turned out not to be a problem though and at least it doesn't pull out hairs when applying.
Rating: 5 stars