I liked the color
I liked the color. I have very dark brown eyebrows, almost black and I typically use a black pencil because the brown ones are never dark enough. I took out 1 star because it's not super easy to apply. I think if you have very fine thin brows it goes on better, I have dense but thin eyebrows, so I need to fill in a few places and this is more of a, you don't have anything eyebrow pencil rather than a fill in the sparse areas pencil.
Rating: 4 stars