Love it but it's actually a bit too waterproof
I actually totally love the product and the price was excellent but the reason for 4 stars is that it's difficult to remove.  If I don't get it all off, my eyes are a bit irritated the next morning (nothing serious enough for me to stop using it and I've used it for a couple months now).  I have to use several cotton pads with micellar water or coconut oil on each eye tp make sure it's all off.  Doesn't flake or smudge throughout the day though and is not thick or clumpy when applied.
Rating: 4 stars