Wonderful Eyeliner
I really do like this eyeliner.  My only issue is that I would prefer the tip to be a little bit narrower.  I am getting too thick of a line for under my eyes and have to use make up remover on a padded eyeshadow applicator to remove the excess.  Otherwise I would have given it a 5. I love the fact that it doesn't smudge and it looks as great at 5pm as it did when i put it on at 7am!! I'm also thrilled that it doesn't make my eyes itch! I have horrible allergies and am super sensitive.
Rating: 4 stars