Not pigmented, does not glide at all.
Not the liner I expected.  I purchased NYC Liners at the local big name big box low price store, but this is not the same formula at all.  Not very pigmented.  Very hard.  Pulls on eyelids.  Smudges on brows. I will Probably be returning these.  They're cheap enough it's just I will literally throw them away if I don't return them. Only 3 stars because they arrived fast and the packaging was very secure.  Hoping to find the NYC ones that are dark rich pigmented black that glides into the waterline and doesn't tug the lids.
Rating: 3 stars