It's good - but very hard to wash off, so doesn't work for me.
Looks great and doesn't smudge. But doesn't wash off at the end of the day. Even after several minutes of effort to remove it and irritating my eyes, I still woke up with smudges under my eyes the next morning so I guess I hadn't gotten it all. So definitely not for every day for me. It makes sense - you can't have it all!
Rating: 3 stars