my favorite eyeliner for tightlining
This is, hands down, my favorite eyeliner for tightlining.  I wouldn't necessarily recommend it for any other type of lining as the pencil is very soft.  But it tightlines like a dream and the pigment lasts all day.  With other eyeliners I would have to reapply at least once to get through the workday.  Of course, by the end of the day, my eyeliner isn't nearly as dark as it was in the morning.  But I only apply once, before leaving home, and at the end of a workday you can still see the liner.  I've gone swimming with it and it didn't run at all.
Rating: 5 stars