Clumpy, but great for volume.
I've had worse, but I've definitely had much better. I purchased at target, but wanted to be sure that people would be able to see my reviews. Usually the mascaras I use start clumping after the tube has been open for a  while, but this formula is incredibly clumpy from the very first use. Additionally,  it's hard to work the clumps out once they're there. The pigment is nice and dark, so I'm happy with that. I will say that the volume it adds is great. I can't attest to the length, since my lashes are naturally long (thank God), but the volume is killer!
Rating: 3 stars