Great Deal (Surprisingly)
I did some thorough reading on the feedback and decided to take the chance, thinking I'd at least get a couple colors I like.  Based on the reviews, I guess I got lucky!  I received 6 great colors, all of them different (no duplicates), all of them colors that I would actually wear, bottles did not show any signs of previous usage, brushes were not falling apart, nothing was broken and they were well-packaged in bubble wrap, and after using them, they don't appear to be knock-offs.  I am very happy with my purchase - I received 6 awesome colors, and instead of paying $45 at a store, I only paid $17.  Yay!
Rating: 5 stars