Its ok
This mascara caused some irritation to my eyes - a mild burning.  So I would not recommend it for sensitive eyes.  It does stay on without flaking or clumping.  It does seem to be smudge proof and waterproof.  It really didnt add any volume to my lashes.  They seemed slightly longer but not any thicker.  For the price, I'd say it is ok.
Rating: 3 stars