Was - Best. Mascara. Ever. Now - Just Okay
I've been using this product for several years - the tube color has changed & the formulation with it. Old formula - quick to apply, super long lashes without clumps, fully waterproof but amazingly easy to remove with a cloth & water & tiny bit of soap. New forumla - quick to apply, kinda long lashes still no clumps, fully waterproof ... & now so hard to remove that I scrub my eyes & wind up with irritated under-eye skin.
Rating: 3 stars