Clumpy & lashes don’t stick
This eyeliner coms in an attract black & gold tube.  Other than that, it is awful. The eyeliner is clumpy so difficult to apply. I actually ordered Twice because 1st tubedried up & was Extremely clumpy on the first time opened. 2nd tube is also clumpy and did not hold the lashes when temperatures were in 80’s... so pretty useless to me.i would not buy again.
Rating: 1 stars