Nice consistency but not water resistant enough
At first I was pretty happy with the consistency of this mascara. It applies smoothly and doesn't clump. It looks nice on the lashes. However, I was really hoping it would be more resistant to water. I was ideally looking for an organic mascara that is waterproof, but have yet to find one so I gave this 'water resistant' one a shot. If your eyes tear, it will definitely smear across your eye area. I'm fed up with how many times it has gotten smudged. I had to stop using this after a while.
Rating: 2 stars