Great for the price!
Some of these are perfect - they go on smooth and stay put with a good primer.  Others don't go on as well and have to be relined over and over.  Then within a half hour they bleed even with primer.  Must be different formulas for different colors but all in all I can't complain for the price I got some really nice eye liners.  I may start tossing the ones that don't work as well and I'll still be happy.
Rating: 4 stars