Eh...
This came highly recommended to me from a friend, and I must admit, I was disappointed. I prefer to line my eyes at the water line. I cannot do so with this as it irritates the heck out of them. I went to work with tears streaming the first time I tried. That said, it is fine to use below my lash line and across the top. It smudges easily... I don't love that in general, but I work with it by creating smoky eyes on top. It does last pretty well.
Rating: 3 stars