Would not recommend
The eyeliner is good.  Unfortunately, the packaging is faulty.  If the tip of the eyeliner breaks off/falls off, there is no way to get the rest of the product to come up.  The eyeliner is rendered useless.  I got three uses out of mine, the tip fell off, and there was no way to advance the rest of the product.  I contacted Avon and they offered no remedy.
Rating: 1 stars