Smudges, Clumps and hard to remove
I bought this because it had so many rave reviews. The first time I used it it seemed ok until I made the mistake of rubbing my eyes. Didn't realize until later When I looked in the mirror that I had raccoon smudges all around my eyes. Trying to get it all off was no fun. I used special mascara remover and then water and cleanser. It left lots of residue to stain my washcloth. I decided to try again the next day and make sure not to rub my eyes. After I applied it  I made the mistake of blinking. Now it was all over my face below lower lids. Again very hard to get it all off as it had clumped in various places. It left me with burning, blurry eyes.  I had to return it. I really felt bad since it had such glowing reviews I was sure I was going to love it. I guess you can't trust Amazon reviews any more, or perhaps I just got a bad batch. Whatever the reason, I'm very disappointed.
Rating: 2 stars