Good, not great
I like the product fine - it is a lovely color, very smooth, and easy to apply.  Looks great on cheeks and lips and seems to last pretty well.  It has an odd smell - not bad, just odd.  Mine came without the cap that you see in the pictures.  Instead of a cap, it has a little plastic disk that sort of clicks on the top.  I'm not at all fond of that - I can't carry the product in my purse for fear of the disk falling off and, if you have the tiniest bit of product above the metal tube and put the disk on, it mushes up in the disk and makes a mess.  I won't be repeating this purchase b/c of that.
Rating: 3 stars