Way too dark!
I have a light complexion, so after looking at the chart above, I ordered the Ocean Surf. Wow! It was way darker than pictured! I double checked the label on the bottle just to make sure the shade was Ocean Surf. Yep, ok there.  I'd say the shade was closer to the Sand and Surf.  Leaves me wondering if maybe the wrong shade was accidentally put in the bottle. Stranger things have happened.
Rating: 3 stars