Love the colors
I was so excited to receive these eye liners.  All colors came nicely packaged.  It is difficult to remove the shrink wrap on each pencil but I learned to get it started using the lines of perforation in the wrap on one end and pulling down and around each pencil slowly.  I love the sparkly eye liners and the copper and silver ones are gorgeous.  The white one is very soft and the end broke when I was swatching on my arm.  I used a normal makeup sharpener.  It's not a wooden type pencil but more of a hard plastic but my sharpener did the job just fine.  I love the pops of color on my eyes!!!  After the swatches set on my arm for a few minutes they were pretty much smudge proof.  They are not waterproof which I like since they are easily removable from my eyes.  I will enjoy these pencils and can't wait to try the green!!
Rating: 5 stars