Dried out after 2 days
Love the tip and how it applies, also love that it's matte, but my second time using it, it dried out. I keep my eyeliners upside down to keep them from drying out, but it didn't help for this one. Definitely didn't get $12 of use out if it.  If it didn't dry out so fast, I would have given it 5 stars as it is a good liner!
Rating: 2 stars