This product causes irritation, physical and mental!!
This eyeliner is difficult to put on because you can't control the amount of liquid on the brush. Drying takes a few minutes. If you open your eyes all the way when still wet (like to put it on the other eye), you will find eyeliner well above your lid line. Then, once on and set, it does not come off easily. I tried using eye makeup remover and that took much scrubbing to remove. On the other eye, I used soap and water and still it was hard to remove. It came off in little pieces as though the liquid had become hard set. It also irritated my eyes. Within a short time (not long enough to finish putting on the rest of my makeup), I had to remove it because of the stinging. After removing, (it took a real scrubbing) my eyes were red and puffy. I threw the eyeliner in the garbage. I thought this would be a good brand being that it was vegan and said natural. It just wasn't worth the money and definitely not worth the skin irritation (not to mention the mental irritation) to continue using it. Please consider this product carefully before buying. I do not recommend it.
Rating: 1 stars