Good but funky-smelling
I was hoping this would be like Trader Joe's Pumpkin Body Butter, which I can't get during the pandemic because reasons. While it has a nice consistency and seems to moisturize my feet well, I am not sure that describing the scent as pumpkin pie is accurate. To be sure, there's a definite scent of pie spices, but there's also an odd smell that reminds me of the liniment my grandma used to use for her arthritis. I'm not sorry I bought it, but the smell is just a bit off.
Rating: 4 stars