The BEST
This product is the BEST I've tried at removing all traces of eye makeup.  It's fantastic.  Follow the directions - apply with dry fingers to a dry face.  No cottonballs or any of that.  This product is hard to find so I usually buy a few bottles at a time from Amazon.  I'm not sure why it isn't sold in stores - it's by far the best Neutrogena makeup remover!  The pump bottle makes it extra easy to use, too.
Rating: 5 stars