omg, what a joke.
This eyeliner is not waterproof.  When you apply the eyeliner it is not an even line.  The color is very faint and watered down you can barely see it.  When you put the eyeliner on the back of you hand it has the look you want on your eyes but when applied to the eyes  the color is not there.  And they say it is all day long lasting, omg, if you touch your eye in any manner off comes the eyeliner so make sure if you touch 1 eye to do the same on the other or you will be walking around having 1 eye w/ eye liner and the other without.  Total wast of money.
Rating: 1 stars