Color is the issue!
Unless you have very dark auburn hair, the "Auburn" is way too dark.  First, I'm not sure why a 2-pack should have two different colors --- as a redhead, why do I also want Chocolate?  Why not a two-pack of the same color instead, or at least the option.  Second and most important, the "auburn" is not for a natural redhead.  It is actually labeled "Auburn Brown" on the box, but online it is just "Auburn".  Misleading, and again, why two different colors?  Redheads have really gotten the short end of the stick for as long as I can remember, when it comes to the cosmetic industry (not just this company).  In a nutshell, I'm throwing both of these away --- total waste of money for me.
Rating: 2 stars