Really good charcoal grey shade
I am with the MANY others who miss the maybelline charcoal grey eyebrow pencil, but this is one of the better substitutions I have found.  Good consistency and good color, not too black etc.  I have thinning eyebrows with dark hair, and black pencils are too heavy and the brown pencils are too red.  This is worth trying, I am glad I did!
Rating: 5 stars