Completely disappointed - they sucked
I realize that with such a low price these eyeliners probably wouldn't be perfect but give me a break.  First the tip of each pen was so hard it nearly ripped by skin off.  Second the colors were not bold at all and it almost seemed like they were almost empty.  And third, they totally smudge soooooooo.  Tossed them all in the trash.
Rating: 1 stars