Resistant because of the price, now I'm a convert!
I was a long-time holdout on the Mitchell's because of the cost, but finally knuckled under and tried it... it's simply the best.  A great clean lather, a smooth shaving experience, and a minimal scent make it a must-have in any shaving kit.  My recommendation is to cut it into fourths, leaving a smaller chunk in the bottom of your shave cup, wet your brush only, then lather.  That technique has given me over a year's use of soap, and all things considered, makes the price pretty reasonable.
Rating: 5 stars