Clumpy mess
I really want to like this.  It goes on thick, but too thick.  I have tried using it very lightly or applying it in coats, but each time it's a mess.  If you have to clean up a smudge, good luck.  It is waterproof.  Even soap and water don't  work well to get it off, you'll have to use something with oil.  So if you've already don't your foundation and then have to clean up your mascara after applying, which you will, you'll also remove your foundation around your eyes.
Rating: 2 stars