Very Natural Look and No Flakes
I got this mascara in the 'Coffee' color because my natural lashes are light brown (I'm a redhead). I was hoping for a weekday mascara that would look natural. This is perfect! It is fairly thin, so it takes a few swipes to get enough on, but the plus-side of that is there are no clumps. I was pleased that there were no flakes below my eye the entire day, AND I intentionally didn't wash it off at night and there were no flakes in the morning either. In terms of it being waterproof, I didn't go swimming in it, but it remained on during the day despite many sneezes (allergy season) and even a few tears after reuniting with an old friend. I won't use this for a special night out since it isn't a dramatic change, but it is the perfect thing for a workday.
Rating: 5 stars