Not good
The 'lip gloss' doesn't have any shine to it.  None. It's more of a matte, but not even rich & creamy like a good matte should be. I would say these are lip stains because they truly stain and it's very difficult to remove. They also will stain anything it comes in contact with (clothes, towel). I would've returned them if I hadn't tried a few of them. To salvage my purchase I'm going to apply a true gloss first, then one of these on top of that & possibly one more application of gloss. A lot of trouble to get shiny lips.
Rating: 3 stars