Text: The HEI re-examination lends credibility to the original studies but also found unexpected sensitivities concerning (a) which pollutants are most important, (b) the role of education in mediating the association between pollution and mortality, and (c) the magnitude of the association depending on how spatial correlation was handled.
Entailment: The HEI re-examination makes the original study seem credible.
Contradiction: The HEI re-examination makes the original study seem like a fraud.