Text: Some texts claim that the first Jews arrived in India at the time of the Babylonian exile, in 587 b.c. ; others bring them to Cranganur, on the Malabar coast, in a.d. 72, about the time that the disciple Thomas is thought to have brought his Christian mission to India.
Entailment: The text are inconsistent about when the Jews came to India.
Contradiction: The Jews never came to India.