Text: Rather than a roughly 16% reduction from a generation level of 4,200 billion kWh in the 1999 CEF Advanced Case, the scenario D equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 12% reduction from a generation of 4,580 billion kWh.
Entailment: The scenario D equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 12% reduction
Contradiction: The scenario D equivalent in this analysis achieved only a 9% reduction