Text: Scheck, commentators agree, poked huge holes in the prosecution's claim that Woodward shook the baby and then dashed his head against a hard object.
Entailment: Commentators agree that Sheck was able to poke huge holes in the prosecution's claim that Woodward violently shook the baby and slammed its head against a hard object.
Contradiction: Scheck was not able to poke any holes in the prosecution's claim.