| [ |
| { |
| "task_id": "cs_escalate_sla_breach", |
| "instruction": "It is now minute 180. Ticket 9201 belongs to an enterprise-plan customer and still has no first response. Look up the first_response_minutes of the SLA policy for that customer's plan and work out how many minutes past the SLA deadline the response now is (deadline = opened_minute + first_response_minutes). Then set ticket 9201's priority to 'urgent' and status to 'escalated', create an escalation on ticket 9201 with reason 'sla_first_response_breach', tier 'tier2' and status 'open', and post a holding reply: a ticket message on 9201 from author 'agent' at sent_minute 180 whose body states the overdue amount as 'N minutes'.", |
| "difficulty": "hard", |
| "origin": "curated", |
| "required_tools": [ |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "expected_calls": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_sla_policies", |
| "args": { |
| "plan": "enterprise", |
| "limit": 10 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "args": { |
| "ticket_id": 9201, |
| "priority": "urgent", |
| "status": "escalated" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "args": { |
| "ticket_id": 9201, |
| "reason": "sla_first_response_breach", |
| "tier": "tier2", |
| "status": "open" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "args": { |
| "ticket_id": 9201, |
| "author": "agent", |
| "body": "Apologies \u2014 our first response is 50 minutes past the enterprise SLA. An engineer is now on this.", |
| "sent_minute": 180, |
| "channel": "email" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "ground_truth": "50", |
| "vcode": "import hashlib\nimport json\n\n_SPEC = {'escalations': ['escalation_id', 'ticket_id', 'reason', 'tier', 'status'], 'kb_articles': ['article_id', 'title', 'body', 'status', 'related_ticket_id'], 'sla_policies': ['policy_id', 'name', 'plan', 'first_response_minutes', 'resolve_minutes'], 'support_customers': ['customer_id', 'name', 'plan', 'region'], 'ticket_messages': ['message_id', 'ticket_id', 'author', 'body', 'sent_minute', 'channel'], 'tickets': ['ticket_id', 'customer_id', 'subject', 'status', 'priority', 'opened_minute', 'first_response_minute', 'resolved_minute']}\n_EXPECTED_DIGEST = 'c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54'\n\ndef _quote_identifier(name):\n return '\"' + str(name).replace('\"', '\"\"') + '\"'\n\ndef _typed_value(value):\n if value is None:\n return ['null', None]\n if isinstance(value, bytes):\n return ['blob', value.hex()]\n if isinstance(value, int):\n return ['integer', str(value)]\n if isinstance(value, float):\n return ['real', value.hex()]\n return ['text', str(value)]\n\nconn = get_db()\ntry:\n _tables = [str(row[0]) for row in conn.execute(\n \"SELECT name FROM sqlite_master WHERE type='table' \"\n \"AND name NOT LIKE 'sqlite_%' ORDER BY name\"\n ).fetchall()]\n assert _tables == sorted(_SPEC), (\n 'user-table set changed: expected ' + str(sorted(_SPEC))\n + ', got ' + str(_tables)\n )\n _state = {}\n for _table in sorted(_SPEC):\n _columns = _SPEC[_table]\n if not _columns:\n _state[_table] = []\n continue\n _select = ', '.join(_quote_identifier(c) for c in _columns)\n _sql = 'SELECT ' + _select + ' FROM ' + _quote_identifier(_table)\n _rows = [\n [_typed_value(value) for value in row]\n for row in conn.execute(_sql).fetchall()\n ]\n _rows.sort(key=lambda row: json.dumps(\n row, sort_keys=True, separators=(',', ':'), ensure_ascii=False\n ))\n _state[_table] = _rows\n _payload = json.dumps(\n _state, sort_keys=True, separators=(',', ':'), ensure_ascii=False\n )\n _actual_digest = hashlib.sha256(_payload.encode('utf-8')).hexdigest()\n assert _actual_digest == _EXPECTED_DIGEST, (\n 'world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected '\n + _EXPECTED_DIGEST + ', got ' + _actual_digest\n )\nfinally:\n conn.close()\n", |
| "reward_basis": "vcode", |
| "reference_trace": [ |
| { |
| "tool_id": "search_sla_policies", |
| "arguments": { |
| "plan": "enterprise", |
| "limit": 10 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool_id": "update_ticket", |
| "arguments": { |
| "ticket_id": 9201, |
| "priority": "urgent", |
| "status": "escalated" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool_id": "create_escalation", |
| "arguments": { |
| "ticket_id": 9201, |
| "reason": "sla_first_response_breach", |
| "tier": "tier2", |
| "status": "open" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool_id": "create_ticket_message", |
| "arguments": { |
| "ticket_id": 9201, |
| "author": "agent", |
| "body": "Apologies \u2014 our first response is 50 minutes past the enterprise SLA. An engineer is now on this.", |
| "sent_minute": 180, |
| "channel": "email" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "verification_admission": { |
| "static_discrimination": true, |
| "null_rollout_failed": true, |
| "reference_passed": true, |
| "advertised_tools_only": true, |
| "attempts": 1, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_sla_policies", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 78.09884308, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "first", |
| "minute", |
| "plan", |
| "policy", |
| "response", |
| "sla" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "catalog_rank": 14, |
| "retrieval_score": 57.7456043, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "customer", |
| "first", |
| "minute", |
| "opened", |
| "priority", |
| "response", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "update" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "catalog_rank": 10, |
| "retrieval_score": 63.63701401, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "create", |
| "escalation", |
| "reason", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "tier" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "catalog_rank": 3, |
| "retrieval_score": 86.15813201, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "author", |
| "body", |
| "create", |
| "message", |
| "minute", |
| "sent", |
| "ticket" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "051e5e42dc8072e365887e4b67bd9fd799a20f310b05a79d89073412d21cca03" |
| }, |
| "mutation_budget": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 3, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [ |
| "update_ticket", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 3, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "b969dbf6d36cea63ea6afeeb56488f73b8d7b9c2652835407a39b48e1b276b7e", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "step_index": 2, |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "93b0d8a8bae94310b6a7c154f4c967dee8dd6f50dd7937b91fdf23057fec9c8c", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "step_index": 3, |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "a3a9766b21b3e41ec8f22f07eeb2b59cf9035d92e250775507c9b292111d9fd0", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "75f5f3bca73b2f8120fe2fd46df1b89001ecd70a9fe34f6aeaaa626f39e1f05a", |
| "evidence_digest": "a7a664d7e93e096247d1e721714aa1175e1330c1b2894651c6db42d64768e115" |
| }, |
| "verification_mode": "exact_state", |
| "state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "protects_full_logical_state": true, |
| "null_rollout_failures": 1, |
| "reference_passes": 1, |
| "replay_errors": [], |
| "staged_generation_shadow_accepted": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reason": "null rollout fails and exact advertised-tool reference replay passes on every attempt", |
| "oracle_replay_passed": true |
| }, |
| "attribution_safe": true, |
| "argument_realism": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.argument-realism.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "checked_call_count": 4, |
| "checked_argument_count": 14, |
| "placeholder_count": 0, |
| "findings": [], |
| "criterion": "reference arguments and instructions contain no generated test or placeholder sentinels", |
| "evidence_digest": "d5c16fdf03a468650ffd77a162a57985bd08e28de7e4af3c3df2a2a7d0fa64ba" |
| }, |
| "source_weak_vcode": false, |
| "weak_vcode": false, |
| "agent_tool_scope": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_sla_policies", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 78.09884308, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "first", |
| "minute", |
| "plan", |
| "policy", |
| "response", |
| "sla" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "catalog_rank": 14, |
| "retrieval_score": 57.7456043, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "customer", |
| "first", |
| "minute", |
| "opened", |
| "priority", |
| "response", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "update" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "catalog_rank": 10, |
| "retrieval_score": 63.63701401, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "create", |
| "escalation", |
| "reason", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "tier" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "catalog_rank": 3, |
| "retrieval_score": 86.15813201, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "author", |
| "body", |
| "create", |
| "message", |
| "minute", |
| "sent", |
| "ticket" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "051e5e42dc8072e365887e4b67bd9fd799a20f310b05a79d89073412d21cca03" |
| }, |
| "trajectory_policy": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 3, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [ |
| "update_ticket", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "enforce_mutation_budget": true, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 3, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "b969dbf6d36cea63ea6afeeb56488f73b8d7b9c2652835407a39b48e1b276b7e", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "step_index": 2, |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "93b0d8a8bae94310b6a7c154f4c967dee8dd6f50dd7937b91fdf23057fec9c8c", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "step_index": 3, |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "a3a9766b21b3e41ec8f22f07eeb2b59cf9035d92e250775507c9b292111d9fd0", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "75f5f3bca73b2f8120fe2fd46df1b89001ecd70a9fe34f6aeaaa626f39e1f05a", |
| "evidence_digest": "a7a664d7e93e096247d1e721714aa1175e1330c1b2894651c6db42d64768e115" |
| }, |
| "generation_evidence": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.product-generation-evidence.v1", |
| "evaluator_source": "independent_oracle", |
| "evaluator_implementation": "typed_logical_state_oracle_cross_checked_against_native_vcode", |
| "contract_aligned": true, |
| "contract_checks": { |
| "task_id_present": true, |
| "instruction_present": true, |
| "reference_tools_advertised": true, |
| "workflow_coherent": true, |
| "instruction_grounded": true, |
| "placeholder_free_arguments": true, |
| "strict_composition": true, |
| "strict_composition_batch_bound": true, |
| "every_mutation_necessary": true, |
| "public_reference_tools_visible": true |
| }, |
| "strict_composition": {}, |
| "strict_composition_batch_verified": false, |
| "instruction_grounding": {}, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 3, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "b969dbf6d36cea63ea6afeeb56488f73b8d7b9c2652835407a39b48e1b276b7e", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "step_index": 2, |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "93b0d8a8bae94310b6a7c154f4c967dee8dd6f50dd7937b91fdf23057fec9c8c", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "step_index": 3, |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "a3a9766b21b3e41ec8f22f07eeb2b59cf9035d92e250775507c9b292111d9fd0", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "75f5f3bca73b2f8120fe2fd46df1b89001ecd70a9fe34f6aeaaa626f39e1f05a", |
| "evidence_digest": "a7a664d7e93e096247d1e721714aa1175e1330c1b2894651c6db42d64768e115" |
| }, |
| "initial_state_grounded": true, |
| "initial_grounding_checks": { |
| "logical_schema_present": true, |
| "reference_replayed_from_snapshot": true, |
| "reset_matches_initial": true, |
| "schema_restored": true |
| }, |
| "checklist_complete": true, |
| "checklist_checks": { |
| "logical_schema_present": true, |
| "all_initial_tables_covered": true, |
| "every_table_has_explicit_columns": true, |
| "expected_spec_embedded": true, |
| "table_set_guard_present": true, |
| "exact_digest_guard_present": true |
| }, |
| "checklist_strictly_typed": true, |
| "strict_type_checks": { |
| "null": true, |
| "blob": true, |
| "integer": true, |
| "real": true, |
| "text": true |
| }, |
| "negative_probe_kills": { |
| "untouched": true, |
| "partial": true, |
| "wrong_row": true, |
| "wrong_value": true, |
| "duplicate_action": true, |
| "collateral_change": true, |
| "rollback": true |
| }, |
| "negative_probe_details": { |
| "untouched": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff" |
| }, |
| "partial": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "a3a9766b21b3e41ec8f22f07eeb2b59cf9035d92e250775507c9b292111d9fd0", |
| "expected_state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54, got a3a9766b21b3e41ec8f22f07eeb2b59cf9035d92e250775507c9b292111d9fd0", |
| "reference_prefix_executed": true, |
| "reference_prefix_error": null, |
| "probe_strategy": "prefix_before_final_mutation", |
| "omitted_mutating_call_index": 3, |
| "omitted_mutating_tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "calls_executed": 3, |
| "calls_total": 4 |
| }, |
| "wrong_row": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "b694d35af1f6efac93aaf198a19f7459e60282fbe3796a77d619475e468b1ee1", |
| "expected_state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54, got b694d35af1f6efac93aaf198a19f7459e60282fbe3796a77d619475e468b1ee1", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "reference_replay_error": null, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "escalations", |
| "column": "ticket_id", |
| "rowid": 2, |
| "before": [ |
| "integer", |
| "7" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "integer", |
| "8" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true |
| }, |
| "wrong_value": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "0b4f6d320a3fe79844e9cb7282fec6ff0ae20ecfcb012e8007c08b8adb470ba3", |
| "expected_state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54, got 0b4f6d320a3fe79844e9cb7282fec6ff0ae20ecfcb012e8007c08b8adb470ba3", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "escalations", |
| "column": "ticket_id", |
| "rowid": 1, |
| "before": [ |
| "integer", |
| "4" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "integer", |
| "5" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true |
| }, |
| "duplicate_action": { |
| "execution_succeeded": true, |
| "oracle": "declared_mutation_budget", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "trajectory_budget_rejects": true, |
| "state_verifier_rejects": false |
| }, |
| "collateral_change": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "937b16caa18fc92d3f5c980976f0b76e3c1be4f0fba9f6bb91531c88592e8461", |
| "expected_state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54, got 937b16caa18fc92d3f5c980976f0b76e3c1be4f0fba9f6bb91531c88592e8461", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "kb_articles", |
| "column": "title", |
| "rowid": 1, |
| "before": [ |
| "text", |
| "Quarterly Partner Kb Article" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "text", |
| "Quarterly Partner Kb Article__blobfish_probe__" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true, |
| "scope": "outside_reference_write_tables" |
| }, |
| "rollback": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_replayed_before_reset": true, |
| "reset_matches_initial": true |
| } |
| }, |
| "artifact_bindings": { |
| "request": "f6c212537bb1d631098c98980543d11ea063a5858c7c9de209f575f130a99152", |
| "initial_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_final_state": "c8b1e9ac1148ccf8920e06d1a26c8bd296cc31df4bc67d0619510433017e6f54", |
| "verifier": "d857ffe7c2094d78d96598296275e4cf0c6693189812fd9dc4fc7f253489c6b0", |
| "reset_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "tool_manifest": "370fbe7dfbd0601850cdacf5db971c56f419081676fe1066112ed17d9726e6b8" |
| }, |
| "reset_reproducible": true, |
| "answer_key_isolated": true, |
| "answer_key_isolation": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.agent-task-view.v1", |
| "isolated": true, |
| "visible_fields": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "difficulty" |
| ], |
| "excluded_oracle_fields": [ |
| "ground_truth", |
| "mutation_necessity", |
| "reference_trace", |
| "required_tools", |
| "trajectory_policy", |
| "vcode", |
| "verification_admission" |
| ], |
| "leaked_fields": [], |
| "agent_view_digest": "7489e66c9c26b22632ac7b54ede0b111ffff15f50ecb0fe872b3dab4274f2f0d" |
| }, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_sla_policies", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 78.09884308, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "first", |
| "minute", |
| "plan", |
| "policy", |
| "response", |
| "sla" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "catalog_rank": 14, |
| "retrieval_score": 57.7456043, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "customer", |
| "first", |
| "minute", |
| "opened", |
| "priority", |
| "response", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "update" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_escalation", |
| "catalog_rank": 10, |
| "retrieval_score": 63.63701401, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "create", |
| "escalation", |
| "reason", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "tier" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "create_ticket_message", |
| "catalog_rank": 3, |
| "retrieval_score": 86.15813201, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "author", |
| "body", |
| "create", |
| "message", |
| "minute", |
| "sent", |
| "ticket" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "051e5e42dc8072e365887e4b67bd9fd799a20f310b05a79d89073412d21cca03" |
| }, |
| "evidence_digest": "9ea7af14aec767280be9b1a2c987e873408fdcc05588a383c99c15a6e7a285e0" |
| }, |
| "staged_generation_admission": { |
| "mode": "enforce", |
| "candidate_id": "cs_escalate_sla_breach", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reasons": [], |
| "checks_run": 25, |
| "evidence_digest": "9ea7af14aec767280be9b1a2c987e873408fdcc05588a383c99c15a6e7a285e0" |
| }, |
| "verification_mode": "exact_state", |
| "enforce_vcode_with_trace": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "task_id": "cs_close_resolved_tickets", |
| "instruction": "Tidy the queue: any ticket that already has a resolved_minute recorded must not still be sitting in status 'open' \u2014 set it to 'resolved'. Tickets without a resolved_minute stay open.", |
| "difficulty": "medium", |
| "origin": "curated", |
| "required_tools": [ |
| "search_tickets", |
| "update_ticket" |
| ], |
| "expected_calls": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_tickets", |
| "args": { |
| "status": "open", |
| "limit": 50 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "args": { |
| "ticket_id": 9202, |
| "status": "resolved" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "ground_truth": "", |
| "vcode": "import hashlib\nimport json\n\n_SPEC = {'escalations': ['escalation_id', 'ticket_id', 'reason', 'tier', 'status'], 'kb_articles': ['article_id', 'title', 'body', 'status', 'related_ticket_id'], 'sla_policies': ['policy_id', 'name', 'plan', 'first_response_minutes', 'resolve_minutes'], 'support_customers': ['customer_id', 'name', 'plan', 'region'], 'ticket_messages': ['message_id', 'ticket_id', 'author', 'body', 'sent_minute', 'channel'], 'tickets': ['ticket_id', 'customer_id', 'subject', 'status', 'priority', 'opened_minute', 'first_response_minute', 'resolved_minute']}\n_EXPECTED_DIGEST = '1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e'\n\ndef _quote_identifier(name):\n return '\"' + str(name).replace('\"', '\"\"') + '\"'\n\ndef _typed_value(value):\n if value is None:\n return ['null', None]\n if isinstance(value, bytes):\n return ['blob', value.hex()]\n if isinstance(value, int):\n return ['integer', str(value)]\n if isinstance(value, float):\n return ['real', value.hex()]\n return ['text', str(value)]\n\nconn = get_db()\ntry:\n _tables = [str(row[0]) for row in conn.execute(\n \"SELECT name FROM sqlite_master WHERE type='table' \"\n \"AND name NOT LIKE 'sqlite_%' ORDER BY name\"\n ).fetchall()]\n assert _tables == sorted(_SPEC), (\n 'user-table set changed: expected ' + str(sorted(_SPEC))\n + ', got ' + str(_tables)\n )\n _state = {}\n for _table in sorted(_SPEC):\n _columns = _SPEC[_table]\n if not _columns:\n _state[_table] = []\n continue\n _select = ', '.join(_quote_identifier(c) for c in _columns)\n _sql = 'SELECT ' + _select + ' FROM ' + _quote_identifier(_table)\n _rows = [\n [_typed_value(value) for value in row]\n for row in conn.execute(_sql).fetchall()\n ]\n _rows.sort(key=lambda row: json.dumps(\n row, sort_keys=True, separators=(',', ':'), ensure_ascii=False\n ))\n _state[_table] = _rows\n _payload = json.dumps(\n _state, sort_keys=True, separators=(',', ':'), ensure_ascii=False\n )\n _actual_digest = hashlib.sha256(_payload.encode('utf-8')).hexdigest()\n assert _actual_digest == _EXPECTED_DIGEST, (\n 'world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected '\n + _EXPECTED_DIGEST + ', got ' + _actual_digest\n )\nfinally:\n conn.close()\n", |
| "reward_basis": "vcode", |
| "reference_trace": [ |
| { |
| "tool_id": "search_tickets", |
| "arguments": { |
| "status": "open", |
| "limit": 50 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool_id": "update_ticket", |
| "arguments": { |
| "ticket_id": 9202, |
| "status": "resolved" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "verification_admission": { |
| "static_discrimination": true, |
| "null_rollout_failed": true, |
| "reference_passed": true, |
| "advertised_tools_only": true, |
| "attempts": 1, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "count_kb_articles", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_tickets", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 25.71871006, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "minute", |
| "resolved", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 47.09763948, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "minute", |
| "resolved", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "update" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "3a5a14e918ddca278d9b0cbd98e817203270b4a53895b26ed9daddb3916c123f" |
| }, |
| "mutation_budget": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 1, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [ |
| "update_ticket" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 1, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "3818ab512624f057c819a0abc4372b3efcaf62e2c88cc83dbb9c08ec09b0ee7c", |
| "evidence_digest": "93e2c850176029d4448e98694685c13f2367c66d5c20bb532670acc604397788" |
| }, |
| "verification_mode": "exact_state", |
| "state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "protects_full_logical_state": true, |
| "null_rollout_failures": 1, |
| "reference_passes": 1, |
| "replay_errors": [], |
| "staged_generation_shadow_accepted": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reason": "null rollout fails and exact advertised-tool reference replay passes on every attempt", |
| "oracle_replay_passed": true |
| }, |
| "attribution_safe": true, |
| "argument_realism": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.argument-realism.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "checked_call_count": 2, |
| "checked_argument_count": 4, |
| "placeholder_count": 0, |
| "findings": [], |
| "criterion": "reference arguments and instructions contain no generated test or placeholder sentinels", |
| "evidence_digest": "dd57107ed48f50f17fdba4a068bab3ef8a7f9784b88ffd438382d8efb962229a" |
| }, |
| "source_weak_vcode": false, |
| "weak_vcode": false, |
| "agent_tool_scope": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "count_kb_articles", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_tickets", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 25.71871006, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "minute", |
| "resolved", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 47.09763948, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "minute", |
| "resolved", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "update" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "3a5a14e918ddca278d9b0cbd98e817203270b4a53895b26ed9daddb3916c123f" |
| }, |
| "trajectory_policy": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 1, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [ |
| "update_ticket" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "enforce_mutation_budget": true, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 1, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "3818ab512624f057c819a0abc4372b3efcaf62e2c88cc83dbb9c08ec09b0ee7c", |
| "evidence_digest": "93e2c850176029d4448e98694685c13f2367c66d5c20bb532670acc604397788" |
| }, |
| "generation_evidence": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.product-generation-evidence.v1", |
| "evaluator_source": "independent_oracle", |
| "evaluator_implementation": "typed_logical_state_oracle_cross_checked_against_native_vcode", |
| "contract_aligned": true, |
| "contract_checks": { |
| "task_id_present": true, |
| "instruction_present": true, |
| "reference_tools_advertised": true, |
| "workflow_coherent": true, |
| "instruction_grounded": true, |
| "placeholder_free_arguments": true, |
| "strict_composition": true, |
| "strict_composition_batch_bound": true, |
| "every_mutation_necessary": true, |
| "public_reference_tools_visible": true |
| }, |
| "strict_composition": {}, |
| "strict_composition_batch_verified": false, |
| "instruction_grounding": {}, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 1, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "3818ab512624f057c819a0abc4372b3efcaf62e2c88cc83dbb9c08ec09b0ee7c", |
| "evidence_digest": "93e2c850176029d4448e98694685c13f2367c66d5c20bb532670acc604397788" |
| }, |
| "initial_state_grounded": true, |
| "initial_grounding_checks": { |
| "logical_schema_present": true, |
| "reference_replayed_from_snapshot": true, |
| "reset_matches_initial": true, |
| "schema_restored": true |
| }, |
| "checklist_complete": true, |
| "checklist_checks": { |
| "logical_schema_present": true, |
| "all_initial_tables_covered": true, |
| "every_table_has_explicit_columns": true, |
| "expected_spec_embedded": true, |
| "table_set_guard_present": true, |
| "exact_digest_guard_present": true |
| }, |
| "checklist_strictly_typed": true, |
| "strict_type_checks": { |
| "null": true, |
| "blob": true, |
| "integer": true, |
| "real": true, |
| "text": true |
| }, |
| "negative_probe_kills": { |
| "untouched": true, |
| "partial": true, |
| "wrong_row": true, |
| "wrong_value": true, |
| "duplicate_action": true, |
| "collateral_change": true, |
| "rollback": true |
| }, |
| "negative_probe_details": { |
| "untouched": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected 1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff" |
| }, |
| "partial": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected 1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_prefix_executed": true, |
| "reference_prefix_error": null, |
| "probe_strategy": "prefix_before_final_mutation", |
| "omitted_mutating_call_index": 1, |
| "omitted_mutating_tool": "update_ticket", |
| "calls_executed": 1, |
| "calls_total": 2 |
| }, |
| "wrong_row": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "9f41aecc80176cc918187aee2b2530288efef1a9acbe6d7931931a28736c48ca", |
| "expected_state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected 1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e, got 9f41aecc80176cc918187aee2b2530288efef1a9acbe6d7931931a28736c48ca", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "reference_replay_error": null, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "tickets", |
| "column": "customer_id", |
| "rowid": 2, |
| "before": [ |
| "integer", |
| "5" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "integer", |
| "6" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true |
| }, |
| "wrong_value": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "6eda1eb95ac9faa7cbda1c262343a63ffe88c171661b7dea9cef9ac4a5279810", |
| "expected_state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected 1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e, got 6eda1eb95ac9faa7cbda1c262343a63ffe88c171661b7dea9cef9ac4a5279810", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "tickets", |
| "column": "customer_id", |
| "rowid": 1, |
| "before": [ |
| "integer", |
| "5" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "integer", |
| "6" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true |
| }, |
| "duplicate_action": { |
| "execution_succeeded": true, |
| "oracle": "declared_mutation_budget", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "trajectory_budget_rejects": true, |
| "state_verifier_rejects": false |
| }, |
| "collateral_change": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "75f090435dfa2e8f4ede8340666c201fdffff52f56bbb5519aaa73b80faf4225", |
| "expected_state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected 1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e, got 75f090435dfa2e8f4ede8340666c201fdffff52f56bbb5519aaa73b80faf4225", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "escalations", |
| "column": "ticket_id", |
| "rowid": 1, |
| "before": [ |
| "integer", |
| "4" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "integer", |
| "5" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true, |
| "scope": "outside_reference_write_tables" |
| }, |
| "rollback": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected 1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_replayed_before_reset": true, |
| "reset_matches_initial": true |
| } |
| }, |
| "artifact_bindings": { |
| "request": "443bf2a504bdc20eb8b8b5bef72bcd38bad25aabff83009e836ee81b3ca3012d", |
| "initial_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_final_state": "1eae7554b3d39153df550f64146382263ca886fc29b17ea50584006fa3d70d5e", |
| "verifier": "6a13e6829863b2246968358a0ea14a20bb986ce4c6606fafa9058fd6b1396a0a", |
| "reset_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "tool_manifest": "370fbe7dfbd0601850cdacf5db971c56f419081676fe1066112ed17d9726e6b8" |
| }, |
| "reset_reproducible": true, |
| "answer_key_isolated": true, |
| "answer_key_isolation": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.agent-task-view.v1", |
| "isolated": true, |
| "visible_fields": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "difficulty" |
| ], |
| "excluded_oracle_fields": [ |
| "ground_truth", |
| "mutation_necessity", |
| "reference_trace", |
| "required_tools", |
| "trajectory_policy", |
| "vcode", |
| "verification_admission" |
| ], |
| "leaked_fields": [], |
| "agent_view_digest": "eb83f769345e73114517b7827fe4ba71330c7411700b14d33f8715393219384e" |
| }, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "count_kb_articles", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_tickets", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 25.71871006, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "minute", |
| "resolved", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "update_ticket", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 47.09763948, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "minute", |
| "resolved", |
| "statu", |
| "ticket", |
| "update" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "3a5a14e918ddca278d9b0cbd98e817203270b4a53895b26ed9daddb3916c123f" |
| }, |
| "evidence_digest": "5c208a97474df1b5b46eaf96a14712c31a297d3fe2b82b1c9903802a207c3ed9" |
| }, |
| "staged_generation_admission": { |
| "mode": "enforce", |
| "candidate_id": "cs_close_resolved_tickets", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reasons": [], |
| "checks_run": 25, |
| "evidence_digest": "5c208a97474df1b5b46eaf96a14712c31a297d3fe2b82b1c9903802a207c3ed9" |
| }, |
| "verification_mode": "exact_state", |
| "enforce_vcode_with_trace": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "task_id": "cs_duplicate_customer_name", |
| "instruction": "Two subsidiaries were onboarded under one trading name, so routing is ambiguous. How many support customers are named exactly 'Bluepeak Robotics'? Answer with the number.", |
| "difficulty": "easy", |
| "origin": "curated", |
| "required_tools": [ |
| "count_support_customers" |
| ], |
| "expected_calls": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "count_support_customers", |
| "args": { |
| "name": "Bluepeak Robotics" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "ground_truth": 2, |
| "ground_truth_derivation": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.reference-answer-derivation.v1", |
| "operation": "identity", |
| "source_step": 0 |
| }, |
| "vcode": "import json\nimport re\n_EXPECTED = json.loads('2')\n_ANSWER = str(final_answer or '')\n_STRIPPED = _ANSWER.strip()\nassert _STRIPPED, 'final answer is empty'\n\ndef _parse_answer(value):\n try:\n return json.loads(value)\n except (TypeError, ValueError):\n return object()\n\ndef _claims(value):\n out = []\n if isinstance(value, dict):\n for key in sorted(value):\n out.extend(_claims(value[key]))\n elif isinstance(value, list):\n for item in value:\n out.extend(_claims(item))\n elif isinstance(value, bool):\n out.append(('bool', 'true' if value else 'false'))\n elif value is None:\n out.append(('null', 'null'))\n elif isinstance(value, int):\n out.append(('int', str(value)))\n elif isinstance(value, float):\n out.append(('float', repr(value)))\n else:\n text = str(value).strip()\n if text:\n out.append(('text', text.casefold()))\n return list(dict.fromkeys(out))\n\ndef _has_claim(kind, expected, answer):\n folded = answer.casefold()\n if kind in ('int', 'bool', 'null'):\n return re.search(r'(?<![\\w.])' + re.escape(expected) + r'(?![\\w.])', folded) is not None\n if kind == 'float':\n target = float(expected)\n for token in re.findall(r'-?\\d[\\d,]*(?:\\.\\d+)?', answer):\n try:\n actual = float(token.replace(',', ''))\n except ValueError:\n continue\n tolerance = max(1e-9, abs(target) * 0.0001)\n if abs(actual - target) <= tolerance:\n return True\n return False\n return re.search(r'(?<!\\w)' + re.escape(expected) + r'(?!\\w)', folded) is not None\n\ndef _mask_temporal(value):\n if isinstance(value, dict):\n return {k: _mask_temporal(v) for k, v in value.items()\n if not re.search(r'(^|_)(at|date|time|timestamp)($|_)', k, re.I)}\n if isinstance(value, list):\n return [_mask_temporal(item) for item in value]\n return value\n_PARSED = _parse_answer(_STRIPPED)\nif _PARSED != _EXPECTED:\n if isinstance(_PARSED, (dict, list)):\n # A STRUCTURED answer is graded structurally: every key must\n # carry the expected value (temporal keys masked, as\n # everywhere else in grading). The claim fallback below is\n # containment-based for free text and would accept a\n # falsified value that merely EMBEDS the true one\n # ('CODE_8~wrong' contains 'CODE_8'), so structured answers\n # must never reach it.\n assert _mask_temporal(_PARSED) == _mask_temporal(_EXPECTED), (\n 'structured answer does not match the ground truth'\n )\n else:\n _CLAIMS = _claims(_EXPECTED)\n if not _CLAIMS:\n assert re.search(r'(?:^|\\b)(?:no (?:results?|records?|matches)|empty)(?:\\b|$)|^\\s*[\\[{]\\s*[\\]}]\\s*$', _STRIPPED, re.I), 'answer does not report an empty result'\n else:\n _MISSING = [claim for claim in _CLAIMS if not _has_claim(*claim, _ANSWER)]\n assert not _MISSING, 'answer is missing ground-truth claims'\n", |
| "reward_basis": "answer_match", |
| "reference_trace": [ |
| { |
| "tool_id": "count_support_customers", |
| "arguments": { |
| "name": "Bluepeak Robotics" |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "ground_truth_provenance": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.ground-truth-provenance.v1", |
| "oracle_kind": "advertised_tool_reference_derivation", |
| "ground_truth_digest": "d4735e3a265e16eee03f59718b9b5d03019c07d8b6c51f90da3a666eec13ab35", |
| "derivation": { |
| "operation": "identity", |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.reference-answer-derivation.v1", |
| "source_step": 0 |
| }, |
| "derivation_digest": "4c1b04890b352fe33c2953c21cfca6f4070f44f5064b10c3cbc59c9e9648ef2c", |
| "state_preserved": true |
| }, |
| "verification_admission": { |
| "static_discrimination": false, |
| "null_rollout_failed": true, |
| "reference_passed": true, |
| "advertised_tools_only": true, |
| "attempts": 1, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "count_support_customers", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 64.93462096, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "customer", |
| "name", |
| "support" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "b6a957ce0464924eb33a24c382fa57289c71eb85079f47cfb8da0d32c7eb731e" |
| }, |
| "mutation_budget": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 0, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 0, |
| "counterfactuals": [], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "fed5c3e5cd3de27e12fb684115d37fdbff1ed6f233c9a4ef13abf69225a79348", |
| "evidence_digest": "0771daf3d01cc646bd41a0a7ec5270da28262262ddf4570b8d2b5558e6923151" |
| }, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "verification_mode": "grounded_answer", |
| "answer_discrimination": true, |
| "reference_passes": 1, |
| "replay_errors": [], |
| "ground_truth_provenance_checks": { |
| "schema_version": true, |
| "ground_truth_content_bound": true, |
| "state_preserved": true, |
| "oracle_kind": true, |
| "derivation_valid": true, |
| "derived_answer_matches_ground_truth": true, |
| "stored_derivation_bound": true |
| }, |
| "oracle_reproduced": true, |
| "staged_generation_shadow_accepted": true, |
| "reason": "stable advertised reads, reproduced answer provenance, strict semantic answer verification, and adversarial trace probes all pass", |
| "oracle_replay_passed": true |
| }, |
| "attribution_safe": true, |
| "argument_realism": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.argument-realism.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "checked_call_count": 1, |
| "checked_argument_count": 1, |
| "placeholder_count": 0, |
| "findings": [], |
| "criterion": "reference arguments and instructions contain no generated test or placeholder sentinels", |
| "evidence_digest": "da4c1236a15b282c323844f28d3fb73dd8352ccf9bd2f28df418f6812dd789e9" |
| }, |
| "source_weak_vcode": true, |
| "weak_vcode": false, |
| "agent_tool_scope": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "count_support_customers", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 64.93462096, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "customer", |
| "name", |
| "support" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "b6a957ce0464924eb33a24c382fa57289c71eb85079f47cfb8da0d32c7eb731e" |
| }, |
| "trajectory_policy": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 0, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "enforce_mutation_budget": true, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 0, |
| "counterfactuals": [], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "fed5c3e5cd3de27e12fb684115d37fdbff1ed6f233c9a4ef13abf69225a79348", |
| "evidence_digest": "0771daf3d01cc646bd41a0a7ec5270da28262262ddf4570b8d2b5558e6923151" |
| }, |
| "grounding_policy": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.grounded-answer-policy.v1", |
| "required_read_groups": [ |
| { |
| "group_id": "table:support_customers", |
| "tools": [ |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "search_support_customers" |
| ] |
| } |
| ], |
| "reference_read_tools": [ |
| "count_support_customers" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "zero_call_killed": true, |
| "failed_reference_killed": true |
| }, |
| "enforce_grounding_policy": true, |
| "verification_mode": "grounded_answer", |
| "answer_verifier": "semantic_ground_truth", |
| "enforce_answer_with_trace": true, |
| "generation_evidence": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.grounded-answer-generation-evidence.v1", |
| "profile": "grounded_answer", |
| "evaluator_source": "independent_oracle", |
| "contract_aligned": true, |
| "contract_checks": { |
| "ground_truth_usable": true, |
| "strict_answer_vcode": true, |
| "zero_write_budget": true, |
| "zero_mutation_counterfactuals": true, |
| "grounding_policy_reference_allowed": true, |
| "grounding_policy_zero_call_killed": true, |
| "grounding_policy_failed_reference_killed": true, |
| "public_reference_tools_visible": true |
| }, |
| "oracle_reproduced": true, |
| "ground_truth_provenance_checks": { |
| "schema_version": true, |
| "ground_truth_content_bound": true, |
| "state_preserved": true, |
| "oracle_kind": true, |
| "derivation_valid": true, |
| "derived_answer_matches_ground_truth": true, |
| "stored_derivation_bound": true |
| }, |
| "reference_policy_accepts": true, |
| "reference_answer_accepts": true, |
| "negative_probe_kills": { |
| "empty_answer": true, |
| "wrong_answer": true, |
| "partial_answer": true, |
| "zero_call": true, |
| "failed_reference": true, |
| "unrelated_read": true, |
| "mutating_call": true |
| }, |
| "artifact_bindings": { |
| "request": "266010cf7903927270650bcdebdbb4cf588124dda979829d0d07cccaa9ba645f", |
| "initial_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_observations": "222d23d2970ad384c086e8b39f4cb6998e28299c200fda6cbe1e064bc2037966", |
| "ground_truth": "d4735e3a265e16eee03f59718b9b5d03019c07d8b6c51f90da3a666eec13ab35", |
| "ground_truth_provenance": "43f934c68761992ae9a42ebb47494f5ef134171be1ebdf0c1c876143c4d22651", |
| "verifier": "3abfbb5aa20c81bdd8737ef76ab5c86ad02f7de54d473ba45edb95e181fd5d30", |
| "tool_manifest": "370fbe7dfbd0601850cdacf5db971c56f419081676fe1066112ed17d9726e6b8" |
| }, |
| "answer_key_isolated": true, |
| "answer_key_isolation": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.agent-task-view.v1", |
| "isolated": true, |
| "visible_fields": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "difficulty" |
| ], |
| "excluded_oracle_fields": [ |
| "answer_verifier", |
| "ground_truth", |
| "ground_truth_derivation", |
| "ground_truth_provenance", |
| "mutation_necessity", |
| "reference_trace", |
| "required_tools", |
| "trajectory_policy", |
| "vcode", |
| "verification_admission" |
| ], |
| "leaked_fields": [], |
| "agent_view_digest": "54257ba2b211f5ab45e2909dd1eaa3a43904c8b96111d43545a7d97890db66fc" |
| }, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "search_sla_policies", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "search_ticket_messages", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "search_tickets", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "count_support_customers", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 64.93462096, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "customer", |
| "name", |
| "support" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "b6a957ce0464924eb33a24c382fa57289c71eb85079f47cfb8da0d32c7eb731e" |
| }, |
| "grounding_policy": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.grounded-answer-policy.v1", |
| "required_read_groups": [ |
| { |
| "group_id": "table:support_customers", |
| "tools": [ |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "search_support_customers" |
| ] |
| } |
| ], |
| "reference_read_tools": [ |
| "count_support_customers" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "zero_call_killed": true, |
| "failed_reference_killed": true |
| }, |
| "instruction_grounding": {}, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 0, |
| "counterfactuals": [], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "fed5c3e5cd3de27e12fb684115d37fdbff1ed6f233c9a4ef13abf69225a79348", |
| "evidence_digest": "0771daf3d01cc646bd41a0a7ec5270da28262262ddf4570b8d2b5558e6923151" |
| }, |
| "reference_observation_digests": [ |
| "038966de9f6b9a901b20b4c6ca8b2a46009feebe031babc842d43690c0bc222b" |
| ], |
| "evidence_digest": "cf1531e47a400bf11768431c5fabcd84b20e488c940d46c804ba62ea818f8b11" |
| }, |
| "staged_generation_admission": { |
| "mode": "enforce", |
| "candidate_id": "cs_duplicate_customer_name", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reasons": [], |
| "checks_run": 25, |
| "evidence_digest": "cf1531e47a400bf11768431c5fabcd84b20e488c940d46c804ba62ea818f8b11" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "task_id": "cs_dedupe_kb_article", |
| "instruction": "Two knowledge-base articles cover the same fix under the identical title 'Recovering an offline fleet controller' (article_id 9501 is published, 9502 is a duplicate draft). Delete the duplicate draft 9502 and keep the published article 9501.", |
| "difficulty": "medium", |
| "origin": "curated", |
| "required_tools": [ |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "delete_kb_article" |
| ], |
| "expected_calls": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_kb_articles", |
| "args": { |
| "query": "Recovering an offline fleet controller", |
| "limit": 20 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "args": { |
| "article_id": 9502 |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "ground_truth": "", |
| "vcode": "import hashlib\nimport json\n\n_SPEC = {'escalations': ['escalation_id', 'ticket_id', 'reason', 'tier', 'status'], 'kb_articles': ['article_id', 'title', 'body', 'status', 'related_ticket_id'], 'sla_policies': ['policy_id', 'name', 'plan', 'first_response_minutes', 'resolve_minutes'], 'support_customers': ['customer_id', 'name', 'plan', 'region'], 'ticket_messages': ['message_id', 'ticket_id', 'author', 'body', 'sent_minute', 'channel'], 'tickets': ['ticket_id', 'customer_id', 'subject', 'status', 'priority', 'opened_minute', 'first_response_minute', 'resolved_minute']}\n_EXPECTED_DIGEST = 'de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453'\n\ndef _quote_identifier(name):\n return '\"' + str(name).replace('\"', '\"\"') + '\"'\n\ndef _typed_value(value):\n if value is None:\n return ['null', None]\n if isinstance(value, bytes):\n return ['blob', value.hex()]\n if isinstance(value, int):\n return ['integer', str(value)]\n if isinstance(value, float):\n return ['real', value.hex()]\n return ['text', str(value)]\n\nconn = get_db()\ntry:\n _tables = [str(row[0]) for row in conn.execute(\n \"SELECT name FROM sqlite_master WHERE type='table' \"\n \"AND name NOT LIKE 'sqlite_%' ORDER BY name\"\n ).fetchall()]\n assert _tables == sorted(_SPEC), (\n 'user-table set changed: expected ' + str(sorted(_SPEC))\n + ', got ' + str(_tables)\n )\n _state = {}\n for _table in sorted(_SPEC):\n _columns = _SPEC[_table]\n if not _columns:\n _state[_table] = []\n continue\n _select = ', '.join(_quote_identifier(c) for c in _columns)\n _sql = 'SELECT ' + _select + ' FROM ' + _quote_identifier(_table)\n _rows = [\n [_typed_value(value) for value in row]\n for row in conn.execute(_sql).fetchall()\n ]\n _rows.sort(key=lambda row: json.dumps(\n row, sort_keys=True, separators=(',', ':'), ensure_ascii=False\n ))\n _state[_table] = _rows\n _payload = json.dumps(\n _state, sort_keys=True, separators=(',', ':'), ensure_ascii=False\n )\n _actual_digest = hashlib.sha256(_payload.encode('utf-8')).hexdigest()\n assert _actual_digest == _EXPECTED_DIGEST, (\n 'world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected '\n + _EXPECTED_DIGEST + ', got ' + _actual_digest\n )\nfinally:\n conn.close()\n", |
| "reward_basis": "vcode", |
| "reference_trace": [ |
| { |
| "tool_id": "search_kb_articles", |
| "arguments": { |
| "query": "Recovering an offline fleet controller", |
| "limit": 20 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool_id": "delete_kb_article", |
| "arguments": { |
| "article_id": 9502 |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "verification_admission": { |
| "static_discrimination": true, |
| "null_rollout_failed": true, |
| "reference_passed": true, |
| "advertised_tools_only": true, |
| "attempts": 1, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "count_kb_articles", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_kb_articles", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 35.31364258, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "article", |
| "id", |
| "title" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 59.62271215, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "article", |
| "delete", |
| "id" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "1cafdbbbe1d3e8523315d13e17e82954f9b984e53abc0ff8a04ab57d467742fc" |
| }, |
| "mutation_budget": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 1, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [ |
| "delete_kb_article" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 1, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "b846965ad61223796d228edc0b50bb468f3c307456b94920aadbc3c695da67dd", |
| "evidence_digest": "7c4d66bffacfaa76f6984481d4b52e61d66f7d19f2ea93e24f578bf9ce872f9b" |
| }, |
| "verification_mode": "exact_state", |
| "state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "protects_full_logical_state": true, |
| "null_rollout_failures": 1, |
| "reference_passes": 1, |
| "replay_errors": [], |
| "staged_generation_shadow_accepted": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reason": "null rollout fails and exact advertised-tool reference replay passes on every attempt", |
| "oracle_replay_passed": true |
| }, |
| "attribution_safe": true, |
| "argument_realism": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.argument-realism.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "checked_call_count": 2, |
| "checked_argument_count": 3, |
| "placeholder_count": 0, |
| "findings": [], |
| "criterion": "reference arguments and instructions contain no generated test or placeholder sentinels", |
| "evidence_digest": "560cb8eea53af47ca47dfd8c07f9520ff1e06d3c2166526c567ff3fbb0fff6d9" |
| }, |
| "source_weak_vcode": false, |
| "weak_vcode": false, |
| "agent_tool_scope": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "count_kb_articles", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_kb_articles", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 35.31364258, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "article", |
| "id", |
| "title" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 59.62271215, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "article", |
| "delete", |
| "id" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "1cafdbbbe1d3e8523315d13e17e82954f9b984e53abc0ff8a04ab57d467742fc" |
| }, |
| "trajectory_policy": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-budget.v1", |
| "mutating_tools": [ |
| "create_escalation", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "update_ticket_message" |
| ], |
| "max_mutating_calls": 1, |
| "reference_mutating_calls": [ |
| "delete_kb_article" |
| ], |
| "reference_trace_allowed": true, |
| "duplicate_action_killed": true |
| }, |
| "enforce_mutation_budget": true, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 1, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "b846965ad61223796d228edc0b50bb468f3c307456b94920aadbc3c695da67dd", |
| "evidence_digest": "7c4d66bffacfaa76f6984481d4b52e61d66f7d19f2ea93e24f578bf9ce872f9b" |
| }, |
| "generation_evidence": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.product-generation-evidence.v1", |
| "evaluator_source": "independent_oracle", |
| "evaluator_implementation": "typed_logical_state_oracle_cross_checked_against_native_vcode", |
| "contract_aligned": true, |
| "contract_checks": { |
| "task_id_present": true, |
| "instruction_present": true, |
| "reference_tools_advertised": true, |
| "workflow_coherent": true, |
| "instruction_grounded": true, |
| "placeholder_free_arguments": true, |
| "strict_composition": true, |
| "strict_composition_batch_bound": true, |
| "every_mutation_necessary": true, |
| "public_reference_tools_visible": true |
| }, |
| "strict_composition": {}, |
| "strict_composition_batch_verified": false, |
| "instruction_grounding": {}, |
| "mutation_necessity": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.mutation-necessity-evidence.v1", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "mutating_step_count": 1, |
| "counterfactuals": [ |
| { |
| "step_index": 1, |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "replay_succeeded": true, |
| "omitted_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "failure_step_index": null, |
| "necessary": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "missing_steps": [], |
| "bypassable_steps": [], |
| "invalid_counterfactuals": [], |
| "reasons": [], |
| "criterion": "deleting each advertised mutation from the exact reference trace must fail replay or change the final logical state", |
| "input_digest": "b846965ad61223796d228edc0b50bb468f3c307456b94920aadbc3c695da67dd", |
| "evidence_digest": "7c4d66bffacfaa76f6984481d4b52e61d66f7d19f2ea93e24f578bf9ce872f9b" |
| }, |
| "initial_state_grounded": true, |
| "initial_grounding_checks": { |
| "logical_schema_present": true, |
| "reference_replayed_from_snapshot": true, |
| "reset_matches_initial": true, |
| "schema_restored": true |
| }, |
| "checklist_complete": true, |
| "checklist_checks": { |
| "logical_schema_present": true, |
| "all_initial_tables_covered": true, |
| "every_table_has_explicit_columns": true, |
| "expected_spec_embedded": true, |
| "table_set_guard_present": true, |
| "exact_digest_guard_present": true |
| }, |
| "checklist_strictly_typed": true, |
| "strict_type_checks": { |
| "null": true, |
| "blob": true, |
| "integer": true, |
| "real": true, |
| "text": true |
| }, |
| "negative_probe_kills": { |
| "untouched": true, |
| "partial": true, |
| "wrong_row": true, |
| "wrong_value": true, |
| "duplicate_action": true, |
| "collateral_change": true, |
| "rollback": true |
| }, |
| "negative_probe_details": { |
| "untouched": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff" |
| }, |
| "partial": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_prefix_executed": true, |
| "reference_prefix_error": null, |
| "probe_strategy": "prefix_before_final_mutation", |
| "omitted_mutating_call_index": 1, |
| "omitted_mutating_tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "calls_executed": 1, |
| "calls_total": 2 |
| }, |
| "wrong_row": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "6d296e2840587ab942bfaf2fe358d8a26e971c7acb74294198404d7edb06caf0", |
| "expected_state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453, got 6d296e2840587ab942bfaf2fe358d8a26e971c7acb74294198404d7edb06caf0", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "reference_replay_error": null, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "kb_articles", |
| "column": "title", |
| "rowid": 2, |
| "before": [ |
| "text", |
| "Quarterly Domestic Kb Article" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "text", |
| "Quarterly Domestic Kb Article__blobfish_probe__" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true |
| }, |
| "wrong_value": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "34ed18fe0c91341f7e96e6a9ee9e6f93d8b867dc10479ac48ef5a473486d73aa", |
| "expected_state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453, got 34ed18fe0c91341f7e96e6a9ee9e6f93d8b867dc10479ac48ef5a473486d73aa", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "kb_articles", |
| "column": "title", |
| "rowid": 1, |
| "before": [ |
| "text", |
| "Quarterly Partner Kb Article" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "text", |
| "Quarterly Partner Kb Article__blobfish_probe__" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true |
| }, |
| "duplicate_action": { |
| "execution_succeeded": true, |
| "oracle": "declared_mutation_budget", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "trajectory_budget_rejects": true, |
| "state_verifier_rejects": false |
| }, |
| "collateral_change": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "5090cf165c94fdfb98c907252ccd00e9ac558bc57a4a9120320c11cd23a136e5", |
| "expected_state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453, got 5090cf165c94fdfb98c907252ccd00e9ac558bc57a4a9120320c11cd23a136e5", |
| "reference_replayed": true, |
| "mutation": { |
| "table": "escalations", |
| "column": "ticket_id", |
| "rowid": 1, |
| "before": [ |
| "integer", |
| "4" |
| ], |
| "after": [ |
| "integer", |
| "5" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "mutation_applied": true, |
| "scope": "outside_reference_write_tables" |
| }, |
| "rollback": { |
| "oracle": "typed_logical_state_digest", |
| "oracle_rejects": true, |
| "native_verifier_rejects": true, |
| "actual_state_digest": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "expected_state_digest": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "native_error": "world state differs from the exact reference outcome: expected de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453, got 54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_replayed_before_reset": true, |
| "reset_matches_initial": true |
| } |
| }, |
| "artifact_bindings": { |
| "request": "114ecdb21e3b6234810801e295fa38686402846156a007224073789a79a4fbc9", |
| "initial_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "reference_final_state": "de2a3a8b7f6caa23812e6d2618eb20d7364487c7ef6a24c5ff2a2b4dff5dc453", |
| "verifier": "7ee57ad787826f65bc1e209a668447a43ecdb24652a6f9edcd50ab5366f94cdd", |
| "reset_state": "54f177fa652248d9e4b2ac7b5c8a4d11e8e6baf808f24fd6d6f8164f7eaa79ff", |
| "tool_manifest": "370fbe7dfbd0601850cdacf5db971c56f419081676fe1066112ed17d9726e6b8" |
| }, |
| "reset_reproducible": true, |
| "answer_key_isolated": true, |
| "answer_key_isolation": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.agent-task-view.v1", |
| "isolated": true, |
| "visible_fields": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "difficulty" |
| ], |
| "excluded_oracle_fields": [ |
| "ground_truth", |
| "mutation_necessity", |
| "reference_trace", |
| "required_tools", |
| "trajectory_policy", |
| "vcode", |
| "verification_admission" |
| ], |
| "leaked_fields": [], |
| "agent_view_digest": "62ad20dd4c73ca3a853639917a26916afeb975ec39731b8c0136cd90ee347c97" |
| }, |
| "public_tool_visibility": { |
| "schema_version": "blobfish.public-tool-retrieval.v1", |
| "inputs": [ |
| "task_id", |
| "instruction", |
| "advertised_tool_catalog" |
| ], |
| "uses_private_solution_metadata": false, |
| "catalog_size": 43, |
| "cap": 40, |
| "distractors": 8, |
| "visible_tool_names": [ |
| "search_escalations", |
| "get_escalation", |
| "create_escalation", |
| "update_escalation", |
| "delete_escalation", |
| "count_escalations", |
| "transition_escalation_status", |
| "list_escalations_for_ticket", |
| "search_kb_articles", |
| "get_kb_article", |
| "create_kb_article", |
| "update_kb_article", |
| "delete_kb_article", |
| "count_kb_articles", |
| "transition_kb_article_status", |
| "list_kb_articles_for_ticket", |
| "get_sla_policy", |
| "create_sla_policy", |
| "update_sla_policy", |
| "delete_sla_policy", |
| "count_sla_policies", |
| "search_support_customers", |
| "get_support_customer", |
| "create_support_customer", |
| "update_support_customer", |
| "delete_support_customer", |
| "count_support_customers", |
| "get_ticket_message", |
| "create_ticket_message", |
| "update_ticket_message", |
| "delete_ticket_message", |
| "count_ticket_messages", |
| "list_ticket_messages_for_ticket", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "create_ticket", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "delete_ticket", |
| "count_tickets", |
| "transition_ticket_status", |
| "list_tickets_for_support_customer" |
| ], |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| { |
| "tool": "search_kb_articles", |
| "catalog_rank": 6, |
| "retrieval_score": 35.31364258, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "article", |
| "id", |
| "title" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "tool": "delete_kb_article", |
| "catalog_rank": 1, |
| "retrieval_score": 59.62271215, |
| "matched_tokens": [ |
| "article", |
| "delete", |
| "id" |
| ], |
| "visible": true, |
| "semantically_grounded": true |
| } |
| ], |
| "all_reference_tools_visible": true, |
| "all_reference_tools_semantically_grounded": true, |
| "accepted": true, |
| "scope_digest": "1cafdbbbe1d3e8523315d13e17e82954f9b984e53abc0ff8a04ab57d467742fc" |
| }, |
| "evidence_digest": "76358161103b6e3ad4f56e994cf3ffd7eff5909e1a8b966b6e9444588868b3fa" |
| }, |
| "staged_generation_admission": { |
| "mode": "enforce", |
| "candidate_id": "cs_dedupe_kb_article", |
| "accepted": true, |
| "reasons": [], |
| "checks_run": 25, |
| "evidence_digest": "76358161103b6e3ad4f56e994cf3ffd7eff5909e1a8b966b6e9444588868b3fa" |
| }, |
| "verification_mode": "exact_state", |
| "enforce_vcode_with_trace": true |
| } |
| ] |
