rtokens: Twenty-three out of 25 charters flying illegal immigrants home since Prime Minister Alain Juppe 's government took office in May 1995 have been civilian jets .
pos: PRP VBD NNS MD RB VB NN NNS .
tokens: He said civilians should not be police accomplices .
ltokens: " We must obtain a formal commitment from ( Air France chairman ) Christian Blanc that no plane , no personnel be used to transform our air companies into charters of shame , " CFDT spokesman Francois Cabrera said .