Collaborative "credibility revolution" open-science & meta-research in management | Gilad Feldman
Channel: Gilad Feldman
Date: 2021-03-12

Slides: https://mgto.org/feldman2021hkust  

Talk given at Hong Kong University of Science and Technology as a PhD student workshop by Gilad Feldman on March 12, 2021 online.

Title: "Towards collaborative “credibility revolution” open-science and meta-research - ECR and student led large-scale project: Process, insights, findings, and an invitation to join."

Chapters:
00:00 Opening notes
04:35 Science challenges in the management literature
21:32 Case study: Management literature publication bias and broken review process
25:25 The science crisis in other fields
31:00 Time for a credibility revolution, principles, changing education, and mass mobilizing students
44:00 What we've done: Replications and Extensions
56:24 Mass replications and extensions in judgement and decision making
1:09:17 Collaborative meta science and community resources
1:11:42 Main takeaways for ECRs: You can lead and make a change
1:18:19 Q&A session: Theoretical contributions
1:24:18 Q&A session: When will management journal adopt replications and open-science
1:29:27 Q&A session: How to make contributions or do novelty with replications?

= Resources =

About joining the team:
http://mgto.org/joinmassreplication 

Longer version of this talk in a 3 hour workshop:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNQXsEaeEyY 

Other open-science talks: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLRAF6P3W1K4dvKaG16-dzvzxoniIDwP7R 

Syllabus Example: Advanced Social Psychology: https://mgto.org/hku2020psyc3052 

Open teaching materials: http://mgto.org/teaching-courses/ 

Collaborative open resources: https://mgto.org/pre-registered-replications/#getinvolved 

Preprints and publications from the project: preprints here:  http://mgto.org/pre-registered-replications/#preprints 

Pre-registered replications and extensions samples from 2019: http://mgto.org/hkureplications2019 

Replication Registered Report Stage 1 samples from 2020: https://mgto.org/hkuprojects2020 

RRR assessments 2019 reports: https://mgto.org/2019-rrr-assessments
RRR assessments 2020 reports: https://mgto.org/2020-rrr-assessments 
RRR assessments template: http://mgto.org/RRRassessment 

Collaborative book "Taking stock of the credibility revolution: Scientific reform 2011-now": https://www.researchgate.net/publication/337972150_Taking_stock_of_the_credibility_revolution_Scientific_reform_2011-now


= Testimonials about taking part in the project =

Adrien Fillon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hku3B1AQtg4

Wing Yiu Hung: https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/psychologys-credibility-revolution/202102/replicating-distinction-bias-joint-vs-separate 

Jieying Chen: https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/psychologys-credibility-revolution/202006/overcoming-inaction-inertia-support-open-science