Decommissioning: A New Era for Nuclear Power; a Need for Congressional Oversight
Channel: eesionline
Date: 2019-05-13

More information at: https://www.eesi.org/briefings/view/051319nuclear

The Environmental and Energy Study Institute (EESI) held a briefing on the new era of the U.S. nuclear power industry as its electricity generation winds down and decommissioning of nuclear power plants ramps up. Decommissioning is the process of dismantling a closed plant, securing or removing its radioactive waste, and lowering a site’s residual radioactivity. Getting it right is critical to communities’ health and safety. Getting it wrong could pose existential threats.

    Hon. Greg Jaczko, Former Chair, Nuclear Regulatory Commission
    Download Slides: https://www.eesi.org/files/Gregory_Jaczko_051319.pdf
    Skip to presentation: https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=3m17s

    Len Hering, Rear Admiral, Sr. U.S. Navy (Ret.); safety expert
    Skip to presentation: https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=18m54s

    Leona Morgan, Co-founder, Nuclear Issues Study Group
    Download Slides: https://www.eesi.org/files/Leona_Morgan_051319.pdf
    Skip to presentation: https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=32m57s

    Kevin Kamps, Radioactive Waste Specialist, Beyond Nuclear
    Download Slides: https://www.eesi.org/files/Kevin_Kamps_051319.pdf
    Skip to presentation: https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=46m11s

    Bemnet Alemayehu, Staff Scientist and Radiation Health Expert, Natural Resources Defense Council
    Download Slides: https://www.eesi.org/files/Bemnet_Alemayehu_051319.pdf
    Skip to presentation: https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=1h43s

    Marvin Resnikoff, Senior Associate, Radioactive Waste Management Associates
    Download Slides: https://www.eesi.org/files/Marvin_Resnikoff_051319.pdf
    Skip to presentation: https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=1h7m11s

    Mary Olson, Director, Nuclear Information and Resource Service Southeast
    Download Slides: https://www.eesi.org/files/Mary_Olson_051319.pdf
    Skip to presentation (1 of 2): https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=1m28s
    Skip to presentation (2 of 2): https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=1h20m05s

    Question & Answer Session
    https://youtu.be/lijK9IjCvIo?t=1h21m59s

The U.S. civilian nuclear fleet is aging out. As civilian reactors approach the end of their operating lives, their economics have been undercut by less expensive natural gas-fired generation. Even though nuclear owners are demanding state subsidies to keep some aging plants open a while longer, it will not stop the coming wave of closures. Six reactors have shut down since 2013. Another 15 are slated to close by 2025. Most of the civilian reactor fleet will inevitably close over the next 20 years.

As plants close, previously profitable assets become liabilities owners are eager to offload. Enabled by recent legislative and regulatory changes, private companies (chiefly Holtec International’s joint venture with the Canadian firm SNC-Lavalin and NorthStar’s joint venture with French subsidiary Orano, formerly Areva) are stepping in to acquire the plants, taking over their licenses, liability, decommissioning funds and waste contracts. Their business model is to decommission as quickly and inexpensively as possible, claiming any remaining decommissioning funds as profit. Economic incentives encourage them to pack highly radioactive spent fuel into thin-walled dry storage canisters not designed for the decades or centuries of storage that may be needed. Absent a geologic repository, the companies plan to ship high-level nuclear waste to Consolidated Interim Storage (CIS) sites – one owned by Orano in Texas and another by Holtec in New Mexico.

There is currently little opportunity for meaningful input from citizens, municipalities or states into the companies’ decisions on decommissioning, nuclear waste, or use of ratepayer-financed decommissioning funds. Yet more than 80 reactor communities and communities near waste storage sites, plus countless communities along proposed radioactive waste transport routes (which traverse 75 percent of Congressional districts), will be profoundly affected by those decisions.

Waste transport, CIS and the emerging privatized model of decommissioning and waste stewardship raise dilemmas and potential safety threats that have yet to be solved, or in some cases adequately studied. Even so, Congress will be called upon this year to decide on legislation and appropriations regarding CIS, Yucca Mountain and other key issues related to decommissioning. Congress has the power to require studies and stronger oversight of decommissioning.

To explore these issues, distinguished experts including regulators, independent scientists, NGO advocates, and representatives of affected communities, spoke and answered questions at the briefing.

This briefing was cosponsored by Beyond Nuclear, Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Natural Resources Defense Council, Nuclear Energy Information Service, Nuclear Information and Resource Service, Riverkeeper, the Samuel Lawrence Foundation, and other participating groups..