House Proceedings - The Four Motions of Dissent against Speaker Bronwyn Bishop's Rulings
Channel: Australian Parliament Fan
Date: 2021-09-13

The Honourable Bronwyn Bishop AO served as Speaker of the House of Representatives between 21 November 2013 to 2 August 2015. During her time, she had four motions of dissent moved against. While this is by no means a new record, they are still interesting.

We've compiled all four motions of dissent (and more) and a bit of context. Enjoy!

The videos used in this compilation come from the following House sittings—
- 12 November 2013 (Election of a Speaker)
- 13 November 2013 (1st Motion of Dissent)
- 21 November 2013 (2nd Motion of Dissent)
- 10 December 2013 (3rd Motion of Dissent)
- 1 June 2015 (4th Motion of Dissent)
- 19 June 2013 (Bonus clip)

The transcripts of theses proceedings can be found here:
- 19 June 2013 House Sitting: https://tinyurl.com/4znsrfm7
- 12 November 2013 House Sitting: https://tinyurl.com/yvp243ju
- 13 November 2013 House Sitting: https://tinyurl.com/umrjs7t9
- 21 November 2013 House Sitting: https://tinyurl.com/afbh5was
- 10 December 2013 House Sitting: https://tinyurl.com/rakxu24u
- 1 June 2015 House Sitting: https://tinyurl.com/26h9hztn

0:00 - Election of a Speaker
0:58 - Teaser
1:16 - 1st Motion of Dissent: Context
3:36 - 1st Motion of Dissent against the Speaker's ruling
5:24 - Mover: The Hon Tony Burke MP
14:34 - Seconder: The Hon Mark Dreyfus MP QC 
14:49 - Moved that the member be no longer heard
26:23 - The Hon Anthony Albanese MP
27:07 - Moved that the question be now put
37:32 - Question put
45:59 - 2nd Motion of Dissent: Context
46:40 - Statement by the Speaker
1:00:54 - 2nd Motion of Dissent
1:01:04 - Mover: The Hon Tony Burke MP
1:11:47 - Seconder: The Hon Mark Butler MP
1:17:27 - The Hon Chris Pyne MP
1:21:19 - Moved that the question be now put
1:31:42 - Question put
1:37:42 - Point of order: social media use
1:42:38 - 3rd Motion of Dissent: Context
1:43:14 - Suspension of standing orders motion
1:43:25 - Mover: The Hon Tony Burke MP
1:43:32 - Moved that the member be no longer heard
1:51:55 - Seconder: The Hon Anthony Albanese MP
1:52:10 - Points of order
1:54:48 - 3rd Motion of Dissent
1:55:50- Mover: The Hon Tony Burke MP
1:56:38 - Moved that the member be no longer heard
2:07:02 - Seconder: The Hon Anthony Albanese MP
2:07:09 - Moved that the member be no longer heard
2:17:03 - Question put
2:25:53 - Suspension of standing orders motion put
2:29:30 - Suspension of standing orders for third reading
2:30:22 - 4th Motion of Dissent: Context
2:30:24 - Question from the Hon Joel Fitzgibbon MP
2:31:54 - Question from the Hon Tony Smith MP
2:32:22 - Point of order
2:34:32 - 4th Motion of Dissent
2:34:52 - Attempted end of Question Time
2:35:32 - Mover: The Hon Tony Burke MP
2:45:12 - Seconder: The Hon Joel Fitzgibbon
2:50:24 - The Hon Chris Pyne MP
3:00:17 - Moved that the question be now put
3:00:35 - Question put
3:09:00 - The Hon Joel Fitzgibbon MP meets the Hon Chris Pyne MP
3:09:17 - Bonus clip

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
DISCLAIMER: This channel is NOT the official YouTube channel of the Australian Parliament. We are fans of English-speaking legislatures who love watching legislative proceedings and procedure!

This channel IS NOT affiliated with the Australian Parliament. This video is not commercial or political party sponsorship and is not advertisement.

Certain videos on this channel—mainly ones including famous moments—may show advertisements. This is because that video has been copyright claimed. This channel is not monetised in any way; any money from said ads will go to the copyright claimant and not us. 

OUR TWITTER: https://twitter.com/AusParlFan

REAL AUSTRALIAN PARLIAMENT TWITTER: https://twitter.com/Aust_Parliament
REAL AUSTRALIAN PARLIAMENT WEBSITE: https://www.aph.gov.au/
REAL AUSTRALIAN SENATE YOUTUBE CHANNEL: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQptchvNlCzMKsGPU8s_6UQ
REAL AUSTRALIAN HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES YOUTUBE CHANNEL: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXkWgSgswNcdnuTjCXPoQ7w
REAL HANSARD: https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Hansard
REAL PARLVIEW: http://parlview.aph.gov.au/browse.php (we get nearly all of our videos from here)

This YouTube channel is in no way affiliated with the Crown, Queen of Australia Her Majesty Elizabeth II, Governors-General of Australia at that time Their Excellencies the Honourable
Dame Quentin Bryce AD CVO (2008–2014) and General the Honourable Sir Peter Cosgrove AK CVO MC (2014–2019), the Australian Government, the Australian Parliament, the Australian Senate, the Honourable Bronwyn Bishop MP (or her deputies), the Australian House of Representatives, anyone working at Australian Parliament House or Jim.

#AusPol #HouseofRepresentatives #Parliament