Gazette of the United States & evening advertiser. — Philadelphia [Pa.], 1794-03-08 00:00:00, page 2

In answer to the 2d position of Mr. A.
he denied that permanent {applies of pro
visions and lumWii could be derived from
any. other pait of the world than the Unit
ed States: not from the northern parts of
Europe, which either did not produce, or
were too remote to tend them : not from
the southern parti of Europe, which de
pended themlelves on the northern parts
and on America: not from Great Britain,
which imported bread, for her own use,
amounting one year with another accord
ing to the repoit of the committee of the
privy council, to the sum of near three
hundred thousand pounds sterling, and
wa% certainly not an exporter of lumber :
not fmm Ireland, which could not pretend
to rival the United Stales in anv article
but that of fait provisions ; and this was so
much dearer, that a prohibition alone of
In anlwer to the firft argument of Mr.
Ames, Mr. Madiion undertook to (hew,
that Great Britain had not pursued, but
violated the principle of the colony system.
The truefpirit ofthis system, he laid, was
to confine the trade between the parent
country and the colony, to their own ves
sels, and to allow as little trade as poflible,
between »•>* colony and foreign countries ;
but When a trade with a foreign country
became necessary to the colony, to allow
tit foreign vef/eis the fame carrying privileges
ai -?i dto their own. Colonies, he said,
were to be considered as parts of a com
mori empire. The trade between one part
ami another, as between London and
Kinglton hi Jamaica. wan to be consider
ed, equally an internal trade with the
co.g trade between London and Li
verpool, or the trade between the difTer
ejit po.t:- ol the United Stales; and might,
if d.e"tied expedient, be equally restrained
to domcttic bottoms. But when a trade
was opened between a colony and a foreign
country, the cafe was changed: the fo
reign country became a party, and had a
reciprocal claim to the use of its bottoms,
as much in the trade with the colony, as
with any other part of the empire, to which
the colony belonged. In support of this
doctrine, Mr. M. referred to the example
of every nation in Europe, except that of
Great Britoifl, which had American colo
nies. Denmajk, Sweden, the United Ne
therlands, France, Spain and Portugal,
had thei: colonies, a well as Great Bri
tain : and some of them, rigorously at
tached to the principles of the colony sys
tem : yet uot a finglc one of these"nations
had refuted, whenever a trade waspermit
t. at all between the colonies and another
country, to make the carriage common to
the veflels of both the parties. Great Bri
tain alone had attempted i monopoly in
such cases for her own vefftls. Her ex
ample therefore was an innovation on the
colony system, as well as an infraction of
the rights of reciprocity.
2d. That the Weil-Indies could obtain
fiipr,lies irom other quarters, ar.d did not
tin efore depend on the United States ' r
nay, that there was danger, by forcing
tliele fupphYs into other channels, of our
lo:' • !ie blanch of trade altogether.
sd. That tli< tiade would hardly em
ploy more than a dozen brigs, and was
the efore not worth contending for.
To enforce this tendency, he enlarged
on the ideas "he had formerly exprefled in
relation to die dependance of Great Bri
tain on the eemmefee of the United States,
and the obvious and eflential dependance
of the British Weft-Indies, on the supplies
of the United States.
On the hitter fubjeft, he entered into a
particular reply to the member from Maf
ldchufett* (Mr. Ames) who had argued
that the lirttifh regulation of the trade
bfctween the United States and the Weft
iYidies, whs conformable to the principles
of the colony system as eftablilhed by the
commercial nations of Europe, and could
not therefore be reafonablr complained of.
lirji. They will make the British na
tion frnfiblc that wv can, by just and pa
cific means, inflict cOr.fequences which
wih make it her interest, to pay a jult re
gard to our rights and interests.
Congrcfs of the United States.
fcOST!NUtD»j
Retaining the train of his obfcrvation*,
he; n.LCvxltd to explain the remedial ope
ravor of h:s proportions.
In committee of thr irbole ok Mr. WiJifon**
cfiitcb of iur. Maui Jon.
House of I'lcprtftntativM.
Ja.id'iry 3c.
ttfo-iiilbns
Mr. M. said, that he should not have
employed so much of the time of the com
mittee on this haul, if the gentleman,
Here then, it is seen, that not only in
the bread fluffs, and meats of every fort,
but in the articles of lumber and live
flock, for which, by unvierfal acknow
ledgment, the Weft Indies mud depend
either on the United States, or the Brit
ish Continental colonies j the latter are so
far from being a rival to us, or a resource
to the Weft Indies, that they continue,
at this day, to supply their own deficien
cies fiom our market.
The total of the exports, including a
few articles under other heads, amounted
to two hundred, seventy thousand, two
hundred fifty and nine dollar*.
In the official statement of our exports
for the year as late as 179 1, moll of the
articles lent to the Britift continental co
lonies, were of a fort and ail amount so
directly to the point, that he hoped the
committee would excuse him-for repeat
ing them in detail. He stated them as
follows:
It was a wafle of time, Mr. M. said,
to disprove by minute enquiries, the pos
sibility of supplying the British Welt In
dies from the old continent, on terms
that would not be worse than abandoning
them altogether. The truth was that
the gentleman (Mr. A.) had in this par
ticular, gone beyond the mod sanguine
advocates of the Britilh policy, Mr. Knox
and Lord Sheffield themfclves ; who li
mited their ultimate hopes of supporting
the Weft-Indies without the aid of the
United States, to the remaining pofTef
iions of Great Britrin on this continent.
He would proceed, he said, to (hew what
foundation there was for the opinion of
these gentlemen, and the gentleman from
MalTachufetts, in favor of this resource.
And he was able to givt the molt full and
decisive evidence in the cafe, by recurring
to 1 an authentic document ot our own,
from which it appeared, that the conti
nental colonies of Great Britain, instead
of being able to fumifh the Weft India
colonies, were themselves dependent for
the very articles wanted there, on the sup
plies of the United States.
ours, could ga*n a market for hfrs. The
gentleman had relied on the csnpacity of
Ireland to extend her cultivation of wheat,
so as to spare supplies of this article also.
Such a revolution in her interior state was
not very probable. But he ouvht at lealt
tohave renumbered, that as the palture
lands of Ireland should be turned into
wheat lidds, her export of beef would de
crease, in proportion as Ihe might be ena
bled to export bread.
Beef,
Mutton,
Tongues,
Butter,
Lard,
Cheese,
Trunnela
Oak Planks and 1
Boards, J
Pine, do. 17,0000
Maple and beach, do. 7,5000
Live Slock.
Horned Cattle,
Horses,
Sheep,
Hogs,
Poultry,
Shingles, ' 43,000
Staves and heading, 128,000
Handfpikei,
Hoopa,
Laths,
Blocks,
Oar-rafters,
Bread-Stuffs and Rools.
Wheat, 3,125 bushels
Rye, 2,201
Barley, 32
Indian corn, 80,734
Oats, 314
Buckweat, 26
Peas and beanj,
Rice,
Flour,
Sliip-ftufF,
Rye meal,
Indian meal,
Buckwheat, do.
Bread,
Crackers,
Potatoes,
OnioßS,
Pork,
Bacon,
Fresh Pork,
Beef,
Meatj, bfc.
178
361 dozens
IVood,.
1,418
84 tierces
27,197 barrels
J >774
2,396
353
29,290
364 kegs
20 bushels
5*5
2?4 barrels
3J2
881 ft
29.334
92,269
561 carcases
30 barrels
33 firkins
5.720 lb
1,826
14,267
3,000
3,000
857
1,500
39
>.5'7
312
100
It had been said that our tonnage was
prored by the official returns to be in
creasing with an unexampled rapidity.
To this Mr. M. answered ; that the in
crease ought not to be compared with o~
tlier examples, but with our own natural
faculties, and reasonable expe&ations
that the increase of our population requir
ed an annual increase of at'leaft five per
It had been urged that the proposed
reftri£tions on the trade with Great-Bri
tain would produce clamors here as well
as there, and that Congress might be
obliged to recede, before the Britiih go
vernment would be under the neceflity of
doing so. To this Mr. M. replied, that
he was under no such apprehension. He
thought more favorably of the good sense
as well as virtue of his fellow-citizens. On
the fide of Great-Britain it had been (hewn
there would be the greatest distress, and
the least ability to bear it. The people
there were not accustomed, like the peo
ple of the United States, to felf-denying
regulations. They would not have the
fame confidence in the justice of their caufr.
And it was particularly worthy of remark,
that the people of Great-Britain would be
difheaitened, and the government alarmed,
by reflecting, that their lofles fiom the
ftlifting of commerce into other channels,
and not only of their manufa&ures, but
manufacturers, to other places, would be
permanent and irretrievable; whereas on
our fide, they would be temporary facri
fices for durable and valuable acquisitions.
Secondly. The resolutions would have
the effect of encreafing our marine, and
thereby at once cheapening and fecuririg
the carriage of onr productions, and pro
viding for our fafety. These advantages
having been already fufficiently explained,
need not, he said, be again developed.
It had been remarked by a member
from Maflachufetts, (Mr. Ames) that if,
as dated by a report of Mr. Jefferfon,
Great-Britain was so often at war, her
wars, by depriving us of her (hipping,
would soon have the wished eflcft, of re
placing it with American (hipping. This
reasoning Mr. M. said, supposed what was
contrary to prudence and probability.
What merchants would build snips, which
a peace, always more or less in profpcCt,
would throw out of employment ;' unlefg
it were for special purposes, where the
momentary gain might. outweigh the
eventual facrifice.
Mr. M. said he was not less surprised
at the 3d position of the gentleman from
MaflachufetU, viz. that the Weft-India
trade could be carried on by a dozen
brigs; and consequently, was not an ob
jc£i worth our pursuit. The plain answer
to this argument was, to state the fact,
that the (hipping entered in one year from
the British Weft-Indies, was not a dozen
brigs, but 107,759 tHns -
Besides the immediate importance of
this auxilliary resource for our navigation,
he remarked, that there were two confi
deratioin which enhanced the value of the
object : one, that as the Weft-India arti
cles could be brought cheaper in Ameri
can ve' r e!s, they would come cheaper to
American consumers ; the other, that as
our supplies would at the fame time be
carried cheaper to the Weft-Indies, the
people there could afford to consume the
more of them.
He had heard the language of the gen
tleman on this fubjeft, with allonidiment.
That Mr. Knox and Lord Sheffield, Bri
tilh lubjefts, viewing the profpedt with
British eyes, at the dillance of three thou
sand miles, in the year 1783, when little
enquiry and no experiment could assist
them, Ihould have run into the error, was
perhaps not so marvellous. But, that an
enlightened citizen of America, feeing
with American eyes, living in the neigh
borhood as it were of the scene, in a (late
whose wharves afford proofs of the daily
dependance of the British Continental co
lonies for the neceflaries of life, on the
market of the United States, fliould, in
the year 1794. adopt the opinion that
thofc colonies could supply the I Hands,
after a trial of nine years had probably
forced the authors of the opinion, Knox
and Sheffield themselves, to abandon it,
could not be heard without some surprize ;
and mud be considered at lead as the ful
led proof, that the gentleman had not
given fufficient attention to the present
fubjecJt, to claim that weight which was
in general due to his observations.
(Mr. Ames) had not attempted to revrve
the arguments with refpeit to Canada and
Nova Sfcotia, which had milled Great
Britain in her political calculations and
ptefent views.
A Jourtiexman Bookbinder
WANTED,
W ho can be recommended for his industry
and fobri':ty—He may hear of employ by
applying to Mp.HenxyKammerer, N0.34,
North Third-Art: c.
March 8,
For Sale by the Subscribers,
Muscovado suga*- m hhds. &bbis.
Hyson and Souchong Teas.
Sherry Wines, of luperior quality, in pipes
at>d quarter caiks.
Spanilh Indigo.
Boston Beef, in barrels.
And a small invoice of Mufiins.
NALBRO' & JOHN FHAZIER,
A gentleman from Massachusetts (Mr.
Dexter) had said, he could read no fucli
tendency in the propositions. Mr. M.
Thought it impoflible to read the propo
sitions with attention, and not perceive,
that they mud have the like tendency
with the other means, by which manufac
tures had been promoted. If the dutiet
already laid, were calculated to produce
this effect, an increase of those duties in
any instance, mull have a tendency to in
crease the effect. In answer to the ob
jection that, a change in the policy of
Great-Britain, might put an end to the
additional duties, and ensnare those who
should proceed under the influence of them,
he remarked, I. That the fame might be
said in some degree of the regulations now
in force. A treaty with Great-Britain
might ftipulatc changes which would af
fect our manufacturers. But as there was
a just confidence, that the intcrefts of this
dafs of citizens would in this cafe be at
tended to by the government j it might
be expetted, that equal attention would
be paid to them, in any other cafe. 2.
The progress of things in this country,
and the probable acceflion of foreign ma
nufacturers, might be relied on to support
whatever undertakings (hall have once got
a footing.
Botfs, one dollar—Pitt, three quarter*
of a dollar—and Gallery, half a dollar.
Vi-vat Refpublico.
With the original Overture and Accompa
niments.
Every one has his Fault.
To which tuill be added y
Thirdly. Another efFect incident to
the proposed measure, would be an addi
tional encouragement to domestic manu
factures.
He reminded the committee of an ar
gument, which had, on former occasions,
been much p'refled by several mercantile
members, for encouraging our own navi
gation ; to wit: that American vefftls,
from a spirit of enterprise, and a unison
between private and public interests, would
explore new fields of commerce, and new
markets for our produce, which foreign
carriers would leave unattempted. Tiie
trade to China opened by American vel
fcls, had been often ascribed to this cause.
Mr. M. said the argument seemed to be
countenanced also, by the present state of
our mediterranean trade j which had, since
our independence, been confined by the
Barbary corsairs to foreign bottoms. Pre
vious to the revolution, when American
vessels could be the carriers, the trade was
very considerable. Since the excluflon of
our vessels, though the carriage of our
produce is fafe to Britilh, and several other
foreign vessels, yet this branch of trade
had withered as much as most others have
grown. In 1790, the exports cleared for
the mediterranean, were but 31,726 dol
lars ; and in the year following, the im
ports no more than n,J22 dollars.
cent ; that an a.Tumption by foreigners
of American names, had probably increa
sed the apparent quantity of our (hipping ;
that the war or preparations for it, by
withdrawing foreign (hipping, had proba
bly also had some little temporary effeift ;
that the principal cause of the increase,
was the extenlion of our trade with the
French dominions, whichi some members
seemed so little inclined to secure and fof
ter, by measures which appeared to him
belt fitted for the purpose.
The Poor Soldier.
THIS EVENING, March 8,
Will be performed,
J NEW COMEDT t
(never performed here but once) called
March 8.
NEW THEATRE.
jf Comic Opera, w t<wo ASs, called
( Speech to be continued.)
fmw4W
•djt