From: jeff.dasovich@enron.com
To: alan.comnes@enron.com, angela.schwarz@enron.com, beverly.aden@enron.com, bill.votaw@enron.com, brenda.barreda@enron.com, carol.moffett@enron.com, cathy.corbin@enron.com, chris.foster@enron.com, christina.liscano@enron.com, craig.sutter@enron.com, dan.leff@enron.com, debora.whitehead@enron.com, dennis.benevides@enron.com, don.black@enron.com, dorothy.youngblood@enron.com, douglas.huth@enron.com, edward.sacks@enron.com, eric.melvin@enron.com, erika.dupre@enron.com, evan.hughes@enron.com, fran.deltoro@enron.com, gayle.muench@enron.com, ginger.dernehl@enron.com, gordon.savage@enron.com, harold.buchanan@enron.com, harry.kingerski@enron.com, iris.waser@enron.com, james.steffes@enron.com, james.lewis@enron.com, james.wright@enron.com, jeff.messina@enron.com, jeremy.blachman@enron.com, jess.hewitt@enron.com, joe.hartsoe@enron.com, karen.denne@enron.com, kathy.bass@enron.com, kathy.dodgen@enron.com, ken.gustafson@enron.com, kevin.hughes@enron.com, leasa.lopez@enron.com, leticia.botello@enron.com, mark.muller@enron.com, marsha.suggs@enron.com, marty.sunde@enron.com, meredith.eggleston@enron.com, michael.etringer@enron.com, michael.mann@enron.com, michelle.cisneros@enron.com, mpalmer@enron.com, neil.bresnan@enron.com, neil.hong@enron.com, paul.kaufman@enron.com, paula.warren@enron.com, richard.zdunkewicz@enron.com, richard.leibert@enron.com, richard.shapiro@enron.com, rita.hennessy@enron.com, roger.yang@enron.com, rosalinda.tijerina@enron.com, sandra.mccubbin@enron.com, sarah.novosel@enron.com, scott.gahn@enron.com, scott.stoness@enron.com, sharon.dick@enron.com, skean@enron.com, tanya.leslie@enron.com, tasha.lair@enron.com, ted.murphy@enron.com, terri.greenlee@enron.com, tim.belden@enron.com, tony.spruiell@enron.com, vicki.sharp@enron.com, vladimir.gorny@enron.com, wanda.curry@enron.com, william.bradford@enron.com, kathryn.corbally@enron.com, jubran.whalan@enron.com, triley@enron.com, richard.sanders@enron.com, robert.williams@enron.com, greg.wolfe@enron.com, james.wright@enron.com, dirk.vanulden@enron.com, steve.walker@enron.com, jennifer.rudolph@enron.com, martin.wenzel@enron.com, douglas.condon@enron.com, wgang@enron.com, sgovenar@govadv.com, hgovenar@govadv.com, jklauber@llgm.com, mike.smith@enron.com, john.neslage@enron.com, janel.guerrero@enron.com, eric.letke@enron.com, richard.sanders@enron.com, gfergus@brobeck.com, michael.tribolet@enron.com, robert.frank@enron.com
Date: 2001-03-30 18:42:00+00:00
Subject: Commerce Committee Letter

----- Forwarded by Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron on 03/30/2001 06:41 PM -----

	Jean Munoz <jmunoz@mcnallytemple.com>
	03/30/2001 01:31 PM
		 
		 To: "'Andy Brown (E-mail)'" <ABB@eslawfirm.com>, "'B Brown Andy (E-mail)'" 
<andybrwn@earthlink.net>, "'Baker Carolyn (E-mail)'" 
<cabaker@duke-energy.com>, "'Bob Escalante (E-mail)'" 
<rescalante@riobravo-gm.com>, "'Bob Weisenmiller (E-mail)'" 
<rbw@mrwassoc.com>, "'Curtis Kebler (E-mail)'" 
<curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com>, "Dean. Nistetter (E-mail)" 
<Dean.Nistetter@dynegy.com>, "'Douglas Kerner (E-mail)'" <DKK@eslawfirm.com>, 
"'Greg Blue (E-mail)'" <gtbl@dynegy.com>, "'Jan Smutny-Jones (E-mail)'" 
<smutny@iepa.com>, "'Jeff Dasovich (E-mail)'" <Jeff.Dasovich@enron.com>, 
"'Joe Ronan (E-mail)'" <joer@calpine.com>, "'John Larrea (E-mail)'" 
<john.g.larrea@williams.com>, "'John Stout (E-mail)'" 
<John_H_Stout@reliantenergy.com>, "'Julee Malinowski-Ball (E-mail)'" 
<jmball@ns.net>, "'Kassandra Gough (E-mail)'" <kgough@calpine.com>, "'kent 
Palmerton (E-mail)'" <kent.palmerton@williams.com>, "'Lynn Lednicky 
(E-mail)'" <lale@dynegy.com>, "Marie Moretti (E-mail 2)" 
<mmoretti@mccabeandcompany.net>, "'Marty Wilson (E-mail)'" 
<mwilson@pstrategies.com>, "'McNally Ray (E-mail)'" 
<rmcnally@mcnallytemple.com>, "''Nam Nguyen' (E-mail)'" 
<nam.nguyen@powersrc.com>, "'Norton Kelli (E-mail)'" 
<knorton@mcnallytemple.com>, "'Paula Hall-Collins (E-mail)'" 
<paula.hall-collins@williams.com>, "'Pigott Jack (E-mail)'" 
<jackp@calpine.com>, "'Richard Hyde (E-mail)'" <rwhyde@duke-energy.com>, 
"'Roger Pelote (E-mail)'" <roger.pelote@williams.com>, "'Stephanie-Newell 
(E-mail)'" <stephanie-newell@reliantenergy.com>, "'Sue Mara (E-mail)'" 
<smara@enron.com>, "'Tom Ross (E-mail)'" <tross@mcnallytemple.com>, "Tom 
Williams (E-mail)" <tcwillia@duke-energy.com>, "'Alex Sugaoka (E-mail)'" 
<alex.sugaoka@uaecorp.com>, "'Bill Carlson (E-mail)'" 
<william_carlson@wastemanagement.com>, "'Bill Woods (E-mail)'" 
<billw@calpine.com>, "'Bob Ellery (E-mail)'" <bellery@spi-ind.com>, "'Bob 
Gates (E-mail)'" <bob.gates@enron.com>, "'Cody Carter (E-mail)'" 
<cody.carter@williams.com>, "'Curt Hatton (E-mail)'" 
<Curt.Hatton@gen.pge.com>, "'David Parquet'" <david.parquet@enron.com>, 
"'Dean Gosselin (E-mail)'" <dean_gosselin@fpl.com>, "'Doug Fernley (E-mail)'" 
<fernley.doug@epenergy.com>, "'Duane Nelsen (E-mail)'" 
<dnelsen@gwfpower.com>, "'Ed Tomeo (E-mail)'" <ed.tomeo@uaecorp.com>, 
"'Eileen Koch (E-mail)'" <eileenk@calpine.com>, "'Eric Eisenman (E-mail)'" 
<eric.eisenman@gen.pge.com>, "'Frank DeRosa (E-mail)'" 
<frank.derosa@gen.pge.com>, "Frazier Blaylock (E-mail)" 
<frazier_blaylock@ogden-energy.com>, "'Hap Boyd (E-mail)'" 
<Hap_Boyd@enron.com>, "'Hawks Jack (E-mail)'" <jack.hawks@gen.pge.com>, "'Jim 
Willey (E-mail)'" <elliottsa@earthlink.net>, "'Joe Greco (E-mail)'" 
<jgreco@caithnessenergy.com>, "'Jonathan Weisgall (E-mail)'" 
<jweisgall@aol.com>, "'Kate Castillo (E-mail)'" <CCastillo@riobravo-gm.com>, 
"'Kelly Lloyd (E-mail)'" <kellyl@enxco.com>, "'Ken Hoffman (E-mail)'" 
<khoffman@caithnessenergy.com>, "'Kent Fickett (E-mail)'" 
<kfickett@usgen.com>, "'Lynn Lednicky (E-mail)'" 
<lynn.a.lednicky@dynegy.com>, "'Marty McFadden (E-mail)'" 
<marty_mcfadden@ogden-energy.com>, "'Paula Soos'" 
<paula_soos@ogden-energy.com>, "'Randy Hickok (E-mail)'" 
<rjhickok@duke-energy.com>, "Rick S. Koebbe (E-mail)" 
<rskoebbe@powerworksinc.com>, "'Rob Lamkin (E-mail)'" 
<rllamkin@seiworldwide.com>, "'Ross Ain (E-mail)'" <ain@worldnet.att.net>, 
"'Steve Iliff'" <siliff@riobravo-gm.com>, "'Steve Ponder (E-mail)'" 
<steve_ponder@fpl.com>, "'Tony Wetzel (E-mail)'" <twetzel@thermoecotek.com>, 
"'William Hall (E-mail)'" <wfhall2@duke-energy.com>, 
<trusso@mcnallytemple.com>, <sadlersa@earthlink.net>, <mstultz@epsa.org>, 
<rtemple@mcnallytemple.com>, <tracy.fairchild@edelman.com>, 
<megan.beiser@edelman.com>, <deborah.fiorito@dynegy.com>, <lchurch@epsa.org>, 
Katie Kaplan <kaplan@iepa.com>, <tcwillia@duke-energy.com>, 
<rwhyde@duke-energy.com>
		 cc: 
		 Subject: Commerce Committee Letter

FYI, if you haven't already seen this, Congressional Democrats on the 
Commerce Committee are leading an effort to send the attached letter to 
President Bush.

Thanks,
Jean


-- 
Jean Munoz
McNally Temple Associates, Inc.
916-447-8186
916-447-6326 (fx)

  


______________________________________________________________________________
____
>     The Californian Members of the Energy and Commerce Committee, Reps.
> Waxman, Eshoo, Capps, and Harman would like to encourage the Caucus to
> sign the attached letter to the President urging the President to
> intervene at FERC.  The letter asks the President to support the
> Governor's request regarding wholesale electricity sales this summer and
> to investigate recent allegations of overcharges.    
> 
>                         March 29, 2001
> 
>     The Honorable George W. Bush
>     The President
>     The White House
>     Washington, DC 
> 
>     Dear Mr. President:
> 
>         We are writing because our constituents and millions of
> Americans across the West need your intervention at the Federal Energy
> Regulatory Commission (FERC) in order to address serious problems with the
> Western energy market. 
> 
>         As you know, California has been experiencing an electricity
> crisis that has resulted in blackouts throughout the state, inconvenienced
> millions of citizens and businesses, and disrupted the state's and
> region's economy.  Indeed, this crisis seriously threatens to cause
> long-term damage to the economy of California, the Western region, and
> perhaps the entire country.
> 
>         The crisis is the result of a dysfunctional energy market
> where wholesale prices of electricity have spiked exorbitantly.  For
> example, wholesale prices on December 15, 2000, ranged from $429 per Mwh
> to $565 per Mwh, compared to prices from $12 per Mwh to $29 per Mwh one
> year earlier.  Wholesale prices have jumped as high as $1400 per Mwh.  In
> fact, the California Independent System Operator (ISO), the state's power
> grid operator, has projected that electricity which cost $7 billion in
> 1999 will cost $70 billion this year.  These skyrocketing prices can only
> partly be explained by natural gas price increases and increased energy
> demand.
> 
>         These exorbitant price spikes have led FERC Commissioner
> William L. Massey to state on February 8, 2001:
> 
>         These high prices serve only to continue a massive wealth
> transfer out of the region.  Is it worth dragging down an entire regional
> economy, or perhaps even the national economy, for the theoretical purity
> of unfettered price signals?  I say no.  I call on my fellow commissioners
> to consider a time out now.  It's our statutory obligation. . . .  FERC's
> timidity  and hands-off approach is eroding consumer confidence and
> destroying the consensus that heretofore supported a market based
> approach.  
> 
> 
>         The dysfunctional nature of the market has apparently
> allowed it to be manipulated.  The California ISO last week presented FERC
> with findings of a comprehensive study of pricing data in California's
> wholesale electricity market over the last 10 months.  According to the
> Los Angeles Times, the ISO's study found "evidence of market manipulation
> and consistent patterns of bidding far above costs" and that "suppliers
> commonly offered electricity at twice their costs."  The ISO has estimated
> the cost of the potential overcharges between May 2000 and last month are
> high as $6.3 billion.    
> 
>         Unfortunately, FERC actions have fallen far too short.  To
> date, FERC has not aggressively worked to address market manipulations,
> despite finding last fall that wholesale prices were not "just and
> reasonable."  Nor is FERC apparently willing to seriously consider
> addressing runaway wholesale rates.
> 
>         The state of California is taking heroic measures, but this
> is an issue California cannot address alone.  In a February 28, 2001,
> meeting with the California delegation, FERC Chairman Curt Hebert
> confirmed the widespread understanding that the California market is not
> working.  He called the California market "broken," and acknowledged the
> regional problems posed by the market.  Additionally, Chairman Hebert
> stated that "I don't think there is any way California can pull itself out
> of this thing alone."  As Mr. Hebert knows, California has no authority
> over wholesale electricity sales.  These sales fall solely within the
> jurisdiction of the federal government.
> 
>         Despite FERC's recognition that California cannot address
> this problem alone, FERC seems unwilling to assist California and the
> West.  FERC's March 9th order sets the arbitrary expectation that unjust
> and unreasonable prices cannot occur in the absence of a Stage 3
> Emergency.  Energy economist Severin Borenstein has stated that this
> expectation "defies economic logic."  The March 9th order is also
> inconsistent with FERC's December 15 order and ignores the fact that when
> market power exists, prices can be unreasonable even when supply is not
> within 1.5% of demand.
> 
>         Mr. President, you have the authority to rein in the impacts
> of this dysfunctional market and protect the citizens of California from
> exorbitant wholesale price spikes.  In October 2000, when you were in
> California, you stated, "I believe so strongly that part of this region is
> going to suffer unless you have a president who is willing to tell the
> FERC to do what is right for the consumer."  Now, we are respectfully
> calling upon you to do just that.
> 
>         This is not a partisan issue.  At the Western Governors
> Association meeting in early February, eight Western governors -- three
> Democrats and five Republicans -- requested that the Administration
> immediately impose wholesale price caps throughout the region.  Governor
> Davis of California, Governor Kitzhaber of Oregon, and Governor Locke of
> Washington have now reiterated this request to FERC with a short-term
> pragmatic proposal that will preserve adequate incentives to attract 
additional generation. 
> 
>         We believe that electricity generators should make a
> reasonable profit and that these profits should be sufficient to encourage
> the development of needed generation.  Federal action to temporarily
> intervene in California's failed wholesale market can accommodate these
> needs.  Governors Davis, Kitzhaber, and Locke have referenced Commissioner
> Massey's suggestion of a temporary cost-based price cap on spot market
> sales in the Western interconnection, combined with an exemption for new
> generation sources to ensure that new sources of energy are encouraged.
> Such an approach could reinstate consumer confidence in wholesale sales,
> ensure generators receive sufficient market signals, and prevent future
economic hemorrhaging in the West.

        Mr. President, we request that you help protect California's
economy, and indeed that of the Western region and the nation.  Please
support the Governors' request on wholesale rates, investigate the recent
allegations of overcharges, and act to prevent a dysfunctional electricity
market from damaging our constituents and a major engine of the nation's
economy.

                        Sincerely,