Repository: microsoft/kiota (csharp)

Issue:
AllOf C# Inheritence
### What are you generating using Kiota, clients or plugins?

API Client/SDK

### In what context or format are you using Kiota?

Linux executable

### Client library/SDK language

Csharp

### Describe the bug

I am working with the Schwab API and their schema. I have published a repo to go along with this issue. https://github.com/pettijohn/KiotaIssue/

In the schema, there are a number of models that extend `AccountsBaseInstrument` using allOf. 

Most of these generated C# classes extend AccountsBaseInstrument, as expected (`AccountCashEquivalent, AccountFixedIncome, AccountOption, CollectiveInvestment` generate as expected). Two do not - `AccountEquity, AccountMutualFund`. E.g., 
```
"AccountEquity": {
                "allOf": [
                    {
                        "$ref": "#/components/schemas/AccountsBaseInstrument"
                    }
                ]
            },
```
Reviewing the documentation, I think this is actually by design. If I understand this correctly: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/openapi/kiota/models#components-versus-inline-models AccountEquity and AccountMutualFund fall into the rule "Class/interface with properties from the referenced schema and without a parent type."

That's a bummer, because there are instances where I only care about properties on the base type and I want to be able to treat them all the same:

```
AccountsBaseInstrument? instrument = 
        position.Instrument.AccountCashEquivalent as AccountsBaseInstrument ??
        position.Instrument.AccountEquity as AccountsBaseInstrument ??
        position.Instrument.AccountFixedIncome as AccountsBaseInstrument ??
        position.Instrument.AccountMutualFund as AccountsBaseInstrument ??
        position.Instrument.AccountOption as AccountsBaseInstrument ??
        position.Instrument.CollectiveInvestment as AccountsBaseInstrument;
var s = instrument.Symbol;
```

To work around, I added an empty property to the classes to get it to generate inheriting from the base class.

```
"AccountEquity": {
                "allOf": [
                    {
                        "$ref": "#/components/schemas/AccountsBaseInstrument"
                    }
                ],
                "properties": {
                    "ignoreme": {
                        "type": "string"
                    }
                }
            },
```

Is there a better way? Or maybe this is a feature request - if other generated classes inherit from the base class, then so should all generated classes. 

### Expected behavior

Generated classes inherit from AccountsBaseInstrument

### How to reproduce

See schema in initial commit and generate https://github.com/pettijohn/KiotaIssue/ 

### Open API description file

_No response_

### Kiota Version

1.16.0

### Latest Kiota version known to work for scenario above?(Not required)

_No response_

### Known Workarounds

_No response_

### Configuration

Docker, WSL, Ubuntu 22.04, Windows 11

### Debug output

<details><summary>Click to expand log</summary>
```


<log output here>

```
</details>


### Other information

_No response_

Pull request:
Resolves #5014

Patch:
diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md
index 7b1a04d161..9fb6bb685f 100644
--- a/CHANGELOG.md
+++ b/CHANGELOG.md
@@ -13,7 +13,8 @@ and this project adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0
 
 ### Changed
 
-- Reverts modification of responses in output openApi file when generating plugings [#4945](https://github.com/microsoft/kiota/issues/4945)
+- Fixed an issue where models would be missing when they had no properties and a single allOf entry. [#5014](https://github.com/microsoft/kiota/issues/5014)
+- Reverts modification of responses in output openApi file when generating plugins [#4945](https://github.com/microsoft/kiota/issues/4945)
 
 ## [1.17.0] - 2024-08-09
 
@@ -1414,4 +1415,3 @@ and this project adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0
 ### Added
 
 - Initial GitHub release
-
diff --git a/src/Kiota.Builder/KiotaBuilder.cs b/src/Kiota.Builder/KiotaBuilder.cs
index 346429005b..e4ade3b5f5 100644
--- a/src/Kiota.Builder/KiotaBuilder.cs
+++ b/src/Kiota.Builder/KiotaBuilder.cs
@@ -1599,14 +1599,14 @@ private CodeType CreateModelDeclarationAndType(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, O
             TypeDefinition = codeDeclaration,
         };
     }
-    private CodeType CreateInheritedModelDeclarationAndType(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, OpenApiOperation? operation, string classNameSuffix, CodeNamespace codeNamespace, bool isRequestBody, string typeNameForInlineSchema)
+    private CodeType CreateInheritedModelDeclarationAndType(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, OpenApiOperation? operation, string classNameSuffix, CodeNamespace codeNamespace, bool isRequestBody, string typeNameForInlineSchema, bool isViaDiscriminator = false)
     {
         return new CodeType
         {
-            TypeDefinition = CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, schema, operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema),
+            TypeDefinition = CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, schema, operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema, isViaDiscriminator),
         };
     }
-    private CodeClass CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, OpenApiOperation? operation, string classNameSuffix, CodeNamespace codeNamespace, bool isRequestBody, string typeNameForInlineSchema)
+    private CodeClass CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, OpenApiOperation? operation, string classNameSuffix, CodeNamespace codeNamespace, bool isRequestBody, string typeNameForInlineSchema, bool isViaDiscriminator = false)
     {
         var flattenedAllOfs = schema.AllOf.FlattenSchemaIfRequired(static x => x.AllOf).ToArray();
         var referenceId = schema.Reference?.Id;
@@ -1624,43 +1624,49 @@ private CodeClass CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode
                     typeNameForInlineSchema :
                     currentNode.GetClassName(config.StructuredMimeTypes, operation: operation, suffix: classNameSuffix, schema: schema, requestBody: isRequestBody)))
             .CleanupSymbolName();
-        var codeDeclaration = (rootSchemaHasProperties, inlineSchemas, referencedSchemas) switch
+        var codeDeclaration = (rootSchemaHasProperties, inlineSchemas, referencedSchemas, isViaDiscriminator) switch
         {
             // greatest parent type
-            (true, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 0 }) =>
+            (true, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 0 }, _) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace),
             // inline schema + referenced schema
-            (false, { Length: > 0 }, { Length: 1 }) =>
+            (false, { Length: > 0 }, { Length: 1 }, _) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema.MergeAllOfSchemaEntries([.. referencedSchemas], static x => x.Reference is null)!, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, referencedSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, string.Empty)),
             // properties + referenced schema
-            (true, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 1 }) =>
+            (true, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 1 }, _) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, referencedSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, string.Empty)),
             // properties + inline schema
-            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 0 }) =>
+            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 0 }, _) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, inlineSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema)),
             // empty schema + referenced schema
-            (false, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 1 }) =>
+            (false, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 1 }, false) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, referencedSchemas[0], className, shortestNamespace),
             // empty schema + inline schema
-            (false, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 0 }) =>
+            (false, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 0 }, false) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, inlineSchemas[0], className, shortestNamespace),
+            // empty schema + referenced schema and referenced by oneOf discriminator
+            (false, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 1 }, true) =>
+                AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, referencedSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, string.Empty)),
+            // empty schema + inline schema and referenced by oneOf discriminator
+            (false, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 0 }, true) =>
+                AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, inlineSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema)),
             // too much information but we can make a choice -> maps to properties + inline schema
-            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }) when inlineSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && !referencedSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() =>
+            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }, _) when inlineSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && !referencedSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, inlineSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema)),
             // too much information but we can make a choice -> maps to properties + referenced schema
-            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }) when referencedSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && !inlineSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() =>
+            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }, _) when referencedSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && !inlineSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, referencedSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, string.Empty)),
             // too much information but we can merge root + inline schema
-            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }) when referencedSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && inlineSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && schema.MergeAllOfSchemaEntries([.. referencedSchemas]) is { } mergedSchema =>
+            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }, _) when referencedSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && inlineSchemas[0].HasAnyProperty() && schema.MergeAllOfSchemaEntries([.. referencedSchemas]) is { } mergedSchema =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, mergedSchema, className, shortestNamespace, CreateInheritedModelDeclaration(currentNode, referencedSchemas[0], operation, classNameSuffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, string.Empty)),
             // none of the allOf entries have properties, it's a grandparent schema
-            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }) =>
+            (true, { Length: 1 }, { Length: 1 }, _) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema, className, shortestNamespace),
             // too many entries, we mush everything together
-            (_, { Length: > 1 }, { Length: > 1 }) or (_, { Length: 0 or 1 }, { Length: > 1 }) or (_, { Length: > 1 }, { Length: 0 or 1 }) =>
+            (_, { Length: > 1 }, { Length: > 1 }, _) or (_, { Length: 0 or 1 }, { Length: > 1 }, _) or (_, { Length: > 1 }, { Length: 0 or 1 }, _) =>
                 AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, schema.MergeAllOfSchemaEntries()!, className, shortestNamespace),
             // meaningless scenario
-            (false, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 0 }) =>
+            (false, { Length: 0 }, { Length: 0 }, _) =>
                 throw new InvalidOperationException($"The type does not contain any information Path: {currentNode.Path}, Reference Id: {referenceId}"),
         };
         if (codeDeclaration is not CodeClass currentClass) throw new InvalidOperationException("Inheritance is only supported for classes");
@@ -1735,7 +1741,7 @@ private CodeTypeBase CreateComposedModelDeclaration(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNo
                     className = $"{unionType.Name}Member{++membersWithNoName}";
             var declarationType = new CodeType
             {
-                TypeDefinition = AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, currentSchema, className, shortestNamespace),
+                TypeDefinition = AddModelDeclarationIfDoesntExist(currentNode, operation, currentSchema, className, shortestNamespace, null),
                 CollectionKind = currentSchema.IsArray() ? CodeTypeBase.CodeTypeCollectionKind.Complex : default
             };
             if (!unionType.ContainsType(declarationType))
@@ -1743,7 +1749,7 @@ private CodeTypeBase CreateComposedModelDeclaration(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNo
         }
         return unionType;
     }
-    private CodeTypeBase CreateModelDeclarations(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, OpenApiOperation? operation, CodeElement parentElement, string suffixForInlineSchema, OpenApiResponse? response = default, string typeNameForInlineSchema = "", bool isRequestBody = false)
+    private CodeTypeBase CreateModelDeclarations(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, OpenApiOperation? operation, CodeElement parentElement, string suffixForInlineSchema, OpenApiResponse? response = default, string typeNameForInlineSchema = "", bool isRequestBody = false, bool isViaDiscriminator = false)
     {
         var (codeNamespace, responseValue, suffix) = schema.IsReferencedSchema() switch
         {
@@ -1760,7 +1766,8 @@ private CodeTypeBase CreateModelDeclarations(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, Ope
 
         if (schema.IsInherited())
         {
-            return CreateInheritedModelDeclarationAndType(currentNode, schema, operation, suffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema);
+            // Pass isViaDiscriminator so that we can handle the special case where this model was referenced by a discriminator and we always want to generate a base class.
+            return CreateInheritedModelDeclarationAndType(currentNode, schema, operation, suffix, codeNamespace, isRequestBody, typeNameForInlineSchema, isViaDiscriminator);
         }
 
         if (schema.IsIntersection() && schema.MergeIntersectionSchemaEntries() is OpenApiSchema mergedSchema)
@@ -1964,6 +1971,7 @@ private CodeClass AddModelClass(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema sc
             }
         }
 
+        // Recurse into the discriminator & generate its referenced types
         var mappings = GetDiscriminatorMappings(currentNode, schema, currentNamespace, newClass, currentOperation)
                         .Where(x => x.Value is { TypeDefinition: CodeClass definition } &&
                                     definition.DerivesFrom(newClass)); // only the mappings that derive from the current class
@@ -1973,6 +1981,7 @@ private CodeClass AddModelClass(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema sc
     }
     private IEnumerable<KeyValuePair<string, CodeType>> GetDiscriminatorMappings(OpenApiUrlTreeNode currentNode, OpenApiSchema schema, CodeNamespace currentNamespace, CodeClass? baseClass, OpenApiOperation? currentOperation)
     {
+        // Generate types that this discriminator references
         return schema.GetDiscriminatorMappings(inheritanceIndex)
                 .Union(baseClass is not null && modelsNamespace is not null &&
                         (openApiDocument?.Components?.Schemas?.TryGetValue(baseClass.GetComponentSchemaName(modelsNamespace), out var componentSchema) ?? false) ?
@@ -2160,7 +2169,8 @@ internal static void AddDiscriminatorMethod(CodeClass newClass, string discrimin
             logger.LogWarning("Discriminator {ComponentKey} not found in the OpenAPI document.", componentKey);
             return null;
         }
-        if (CreateModelDeclarations(currentNode, discriminatorSchema, currentOperation, GetShortestNamespace(currentNamespace, discriminatorSchema), string.Empty) is not CodeType result)
+        // Call CreateModelDeclarations with isViaDiscriminator=true. This is for a special case where we always generate a base class when types are referenced via a oneOf discriminator. 
+        if (CreateModelDeclarations(currentNode, discriminatorSchema, currentOperation, GetShortestNamespace(currentNamespace, discriminatorSchema), string.Empty, null, string.Empty, false, true) is not CodeType result)
         {
             logger.LogWarning("Discriminator {ComponentKey} is not a valid model and points to a union type.", componentKey);
             return null;


Test patch:
diff --git a/tests/Kiota.Builder.Tests/KiotaBuilderTests.cs b/tests/Kiota.Builder.Tests/KiotaBuilderTests.cs
index 8be6d794da..18955acc29 100644
--- a/tests/Kiota.Builder.Tests/KiotaBuilderTests.cs
+++ b/tests/Kiota.Builder.Tests/KiotaBuilderTests.cs
@@ -7840,6 +7840,80 @@ public async Task InheritanceWithAllOfWith3Parts3SchemaChildClass()
         Assert.Single(groupClass.Properties.Where(static x => x.Name.Equals("facetprop1", StringComparison.OrdinalIgnoreCase)));
         Assert.Single(groupClass.Properties.Where(static x => x.Name.Equals("facetprop2", StringComparison.OrdinalIgnoreCase)));
     }
+
+    [Fact]
+    public async Task InheritanceWithAllOfBaseClassNoAdditionalProperties()
+    {
+        var tempFilePath = Path.Combine(Path.GetTempPath(), Path.GetTempFileName());
+        await using var fs = await GetDocumentStream(@"openapi: 3.0.1
+info:
+  title: OData Service for namespace microsoft.graph
+  description: This OData service is located at https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0
+  version: 1.0.1
+servers:
+  - url: https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0
+paths:
+  /directoryObject:
+    get:
+      responses:
+        '200':
+          content:
+            application/json:
+              schema:
+                $ref: '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.directoryResult'
+components:
+  schemas:
+    microsoft.graph.directoryResult:
+      required: ['fstype']
+      oneOf:
+        - $ref: '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.file'
+        - $ref: '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.folder'
+        - $ref: '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.link'
+      properties:
+        fstype:
+          type: string
+      discriminator:
+        propertyName: 'fstype'
+        mapping:
+          'file': '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.file'
+          'folder': '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.folder'
+          'link': '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.link'
+    microsoft.graph.baseDirectoryObject:
+      properties:
+        path:
+          type: string
+    microsoft.graph.file:
+      allOf:
+        - '$ref': '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.baseDirectoryObject'
+    microsoft.graph.folder:
+      allOf:
+        - '$ref': '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.baseDirectoryObject'
+    microsoft.graph.link:
+      allOf:
+        - '$ref': '#/components/schemas/microsoft.graph.baseDirectoryObject'
+      properties:
+        target:
+          type: string");
+        var mockLogger = new Mock<ILogger<KiotaBuilder>>();
+        var builder = new KiotaBuilder(mockLogger.Object, new GenerationConfiguration { ClientClassName = "Graph", OpenAPIFilePath = tempFilePath }, _httpClient);
+        var document = await builder.CreateOpenApiDocumentAsync(fs);
+        var node = builder.CreateUriSpace(document);
+        var codeModel = builder.CreateSourceModel(node);
+
+        // Verify that all three classes referenced by the discriminator inherit from baseDirectoryObject
+        var folder = codeModel.FindChildByName<CodeClass>("Folder");
+        Assert.NotNull(folder.StartBlock.Inherits);
+        Assert.Equal("baseDirectoryObject", folder.StartBlock.Inherits.Name);
+
+        var file = codeModel.FindChildByName<CodeClass>("File");
+        Assert.NotNull(file.StartBlock.Inherits);
+        Assert.Equal("baseDirectoryObject", file.StartBlock.Inherits.Name);
+
+        var link = codeModel.FindChildByName<CodeClass>("Link");
+        Assert.NotNull(link.StartBlock.Inherits);
+        Assert.Equal("baseDirectoryObject", link.StartBlock.Inherits.Name);
+    }
+
     [Fact]
     public async Task NestedIntersectionTypeAllOf()
     {