Lauda Air Flight 004

Lauda Air Flight 004 (NG004/LDA004) was a regularly scheduled international passenger flight from Bangkok, Thailand to Vienna, Austria. On May 26, 1991, the Boeing 767-300ER crashed following an uncommanded midair deployment of the thrust reverser on the No. 1 engine, causing the aircraft to enter an aerodynamic stall, uncontrolled dive and midair breakup, killing all 213 passengers and ten crew members on board. It is the deadliest aviation accident involving the Boeing 767, and the deadliest aviation incident in Thailand's history. The crash marked the 767's first fatal incident and third hull loss. Formula One world motor racing champion Niki Lauda, who founded and ran Lauda Air, was personally involved in the accident investigation.
Aircraft
The aircraft involved was a Boeing 767-300ER, the 283rd Boeing 767 built, that was powered by Pratt & Whitney PW4060 engines and was delivered new to Lauda Air on 16 October 1989. The aircraft was registered OE-LAV and named Mozart. At the time of the incident, the No. 2 engine had been on the airframe since assembly of the aircraft (7,444 hours and 1,133 cycles) whereas the No. 1 engine (with the faulty thrust reverser) had been on the aircraft since October 3, 1990 and had accumulated 2,904 hours and 456 cycles.
Accident
At the time of the accident, Lauda Air operated three weekly flights between Bangkok and Vienna. At 23:02 ICT on 26 May 1991, the Boeing 767-3Z9ER operating as Flight 4 (originating from Hong Kong's Kai Tak Airport) departed Don Mueang International Airport in Bangkok for its passenger service to Vienna International Airport with 213 passengers and ten crew under the command of American captain Thomas J. Welch (48) and Austrian first officer Josef Thurner (41). Both pilots were regarded as very competent. At 23:08, Welch and Thurner received a visual warning indication on the EICAS display that a possible system failure would cause the thrust reverser on the No. 1 engine to deploy in flight. After consulting the aircraft's Quick Reference Handbook, they determined that the alert was "coming on and off" and that it was "just an advisory thing." The pilots took no remedial action, possibly believing that the indication was false, but also with the knowledge that the 767 could stop with only one operational reverser.
At 23:17, the No. 1 engine reverser deployed while the plane was over mountainous jungle terrain in the border area between the Suphan Buri and Uthai Thani provinces in Thailand. Thurner's last recorded words were, "Oh, reverser's deployed." Moments later, the cockpit voice recorder (CVR) recorded a shuddering sound, followed closely by a snap. Because of the reverser design, the lift on the aircraft's left-wing leading edge became disrupted because of the aerodynamic plume formed during the engine's rundown to idle thrust and resulted in a 25% loss of lift and an aerodynamic stall.
The aircraft immediately began a diving left turn. The CVR recorded a second snapping sound, followed by various alerts such as overspeed and master caution, and Welch's last recorded words: "Jesus Christ" in response to the rapid rolling sensation, "here, wait a minute" as he shut down the engine and finally, "damn it." Following this, the CVR recorded an increase in background noise followed by several loud bangs. Maneuvering overloads produced by the pilots' attempts to regain pitch control, in combination with the velocity during the dive, had already exceeded the aircraft's structural limits and destroyed the weakened rear fuselage along with the rest of the damaged flight surfaces. The loss of the tail caused further negative loading of the wings as the airplane nosed over vertically, reaching a speed of at least Mach 0.99 (the highest value that the aircraft's sensors could record), breaking the sound barrier.
The wings then failed and separated at the trailing edges, engulfing the remains of the falling aircraft in flames before impacting mountainous wooded terrain and exploding. Most of the wreckage was scattered over a remote forest area roughly one square kilometre in size, at an elevation of , in what is now Phu Toei National Park, Suphan Buri. The wreckage site is about north-northeast of Phu Toey, Huay Kamin, Dan Chang district, Suphan Buri province, about northwest of Bangkok, close to the Burma-Thailand border. Rescuers found Welch's body still in the pilot's seat.
Recovery
Volunteer rescue teams and local villagers looted the wreckage, taking electronics and jewellery, so relatives were unable to recover personal possessions. The bodies were taken to a hospital in Bangkok, but the storage was not refrigerated and the bodies decomposed. Dental and forensic experts worked to identify bodies, but 27 were never identified.
Speculation circulated that a bomb may have destroyed the aircraft, as some eyewitnesses had reported seeing a large fireball surrounding the aircraft, the result of the disintegration of the right wing during the dive. However, a terrorist motive was believed unlikely, as Austria was politically neutral with a reputation of avoiding international conflicts such as the recent Gulf War.
Investigation
The flight data recorder was completely destroyed, so only the cockpit voice recorder could be analysed. Thailand's Air Safety Division head Pradit Hoprasatsuk stated that "the attempt to determine why the reverser came on was hampered by the loss of the flight data recorder, which was destroyed in the crash." Upon hearing of the crash, Niki Lauda traveled to Thailand. He examined the wreckage and estimated that the largest fragment was about by , which was about half the size of the largest piece resulting from the Lockerbie bombing. Lauda attended a funeral for 23 unidentified passengers in Thailand and then traveled to Seattle to meet with Boeing representatives.
The official investigation, led by Thailand's Aircraft Accident Investigation Committee, lasted approximately eight months and resulted in a conclusion of probable cause: "The Accident Investigation Committee of the Government of Thailand determines the probable cause of this accident to be [an] uncommanded in-flight deployment of the left engine thrust reverser, which resulted in loss of flight path control. The specific cause of the thrust reverser deployment has not been positively identified." Multiple possibilities were investigated, including a short circuit in the electrical system. However, the destruction of much of the wiring meant that investigators could not arrive at a definitive reason for the activation of the thrust reverser.
As evidence began to implicate the thrust reversers as the cause of the accident, Lauda conducted simulator flights at Gatwick Airport that appeared to show that deployment of a thrust reverser was a survivable condition. Lauda said that the thrust reverser could not be the sole cause of the crash. However, the accident report states that the "flight crew training simulators yielded erroneous results" and that recovery from the loss of lift from the reverser deployment "was uncontrollable for an unexpecting flight crew."
The incident prompted Boeing to modify the thrust-reverser system to prevent similar occurrences by adding sync locks, which prevent the thrust reversers from deploying when the main landing-gear truck-tilt angle is not at the ground position. Aviation writer Macarthur Job has stated that "had that Boeing 767 been of an earlier version of the type, fitted with engines that were controlled mechanically rather than electronically, then that accident could not have happened."
Lauda's visit with Boeing
Lauda stated: "What really annoyed me was Boeing's reaction once the cause was clear. Boeing did not want to say anything." He asked Boeing to fly the scenario in a simulator using data different to that which Lauda had employed in his tests at Gatwick Airport. Boeing initially refused, but Lauda insisted, so Boeing granted permission. Lauda attempted the flight in the simulator 15 times, and in every instance, he was unable to recover. He asked Boeing to issue a statement, but the company's legal department replied that it would take three months to adjust the wording. Lauda asked for a press conference the following day and told Boeing that if it was possible to recover, he would be willing to fly a 767 with two pilots and have the thrust reverser deploy in air. Boeing told Lauda that it was not possible, so he persuaded Boeing to issue a statement saying that such a scenario would not be survivable. Lauda then added that "this was the first time in eight months that it had been made clear that the manufacturer [Boeing] was at fault and not the operator of the aeroplane [or Pratt and Whitney]."
Previous testing of thrust reversers
When the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) asked Boeing to test activating the thrust reverser in flight, the FAA had allowed Boeing to devise the tests. Boeing had insisted that a deployment was not possible in flight. In 1982, Boeing conducted a test in which the aircraft was flown at and then slowed to , and the test pilots then deployed the thrust reverser. The control of the aircraft was not jeopardized, and the FAA accepted the results of the test.
The Lauda aircraft was travelling at a high speed and at almost when the left thrust reverser deployed, causing the pilots to lose control of the aircraft. James R. Chiles, author of Inviting Disaster, said: "[T]he point here is not that a thorough test would have told the pilots Thomas J. Welch and Josef Thurner what to do. A thrust reverser deploying in flight might not have been survivable, anyway. But a thorough test would have informed the FAA and Boeing that thrust reversers deploying in midair was such a dangerous occurrence that Boeing needed to install a positive lock that would prevent such an event."
Passengers and crew
The passengers and crew included 83 Austrians: 74 passengers and nine crew members. Other nationalities included 52 Hong Kong residents, 39 Thai, 10 Italians, seven Swiss, six Chinese, four Germans, three Portuguese, three Taiwanese, three Yugoslavs, two Hungarians, two Filipinos, two Britons, three Americans (two passengers and the captain), one Australian, one Brazilian, one Pole and one Turk.
First officer Josef Thurner had once flown as a copilot with Niki Lauda on a Lauda Air Boeing 767 service to Bangkok, a flight that was the subject of a Reader's Digest article in January 1990 that depicted the airline positively. Macarthur Job stated that Thurner was the better known of the crew members. Captain Thomas J. Welch lived in Vienna but originated from Seattle, Washington.
Notable victims included:
Clemens August Andreae, an Austrian economics professor, was leading a group of students from the University of Innsbruck on a tour of the Far East.
Pairat Decharin, the governor of Chiang Mai province, and his wife. Charles S. Ahlgren, the former U.S. consul general to Chiang Mai, said: "That accident not only took their lives and that of many of Chiang Mai's leaders, but dealt a blow to many development and planning activities in the town."
Aftermath
About a quarter of the airline's carrying capacity was destroyed as a result of the crash. Following the crash of OE-LAV, the airline operated no flights to Sydney on 1, 6 and 7 June. Flights resumed with another 767 on 13 June. Niki Lauda said that the crash and the ensuing period constituted the worst time in his life, even worse than the recovery from injuries that he had sustained after a crash in the 1976 German Grand Prix. After the Flight 004 crash, bookings from Hong Kong decreased by 20%, but this was offset by an increase in bookings by passengers based in Vienna.
In early August 1991, Boeing issued an alert to airlines stating that more than 1,600 late-model 737s, 747s, 757s and 767s had thrust-reverser systems similar to that of OE-LAV. Two months later, customers were asked to replace potentially faulty valves in the thrust-reverser systems that could cause reversers to deploy in flight.
At the crash site, which is accessible to national park visitors, a shrine was erected to commemorate the victims. Another memorial and cemetery is located at Wat Sa Kaeo Srisanpetch, about away in Mueang Suphan Buri district.
In popular culture
The crash of Flight 004 was featured in the second episode of Season 14 of the Canadian documentary television series Mayday, titled "Testing the Limits."
See also
TAM Transportes Aéreos Regionais Flight 402
Pacific Western Airlines Flight 314
Notes
References
Citations
Accident Report — Lauda Air Flight 004 (Archive) — Aircraft Accident Investigation Committee, Ministry of Transport and Communications Thailand, Prepared for World Wide Web usage by Hiroshi Sogame (十亀 洋 Sogame Hiroshi), a member of the Safety Promotion Committee (総合安全推進 Sōgō Anzen Suishin) of All Nippon Airways
Aircraft, Volume 71. Royal Aeronautical Society Australian Division, 1991.
Chiles, James R. Inviting Disaster. HarperCollins, 8 July 2008. , 9780061734588.
Job, Macarthur. Air Disaster, Volume 2. Aerospace Publications, 1996. , 9781875671199.
Parschalk, Norbert and Bernhard Thaler. Südtirol Chronik: das 20. Jahrhundert. Athesia, 1999.
Further reading
Gilbert, Andy. "Lauda Air". South China Morning Post. Thursday 26 May 1994.
Aviation Week & Space Technology. 1991-10-03 (32), 1991-10-06 (28–30)
External links
Lauda Air Crash 1991: still too many open questions — Austrian Wings — Austrias Aviation Magazine
"การสอบสวนอากาศยานประสบอุบัติเหต" Department of Civil Aviation (Archive)
"Lauda Air B767 accident report" Ministry of Transport & Communications Thailand (in English)
"Computer-Related Incidents with Commercial Aircraft The Lauda Air B767 Accident". (Archive) Bielefeld University. 26 May 1991.
Lauda Air Flight 004 (Index of articles) — South China Morning Post
"flugzeugabsturz_20jahre.pdf" (Archive) University of Innsbruck. — Includes list of University of Innsbruck professors, assistants, and students who died on Flight 004
Last flight of the Mozart (Der Todesflug der Mozart, German) — Austrian Wings — Austria's Aviation Magazine
PlaneCrashInfo.com — Lauda Air Flight 004
Cockpit Voice Recorder transcript and accident summary
Grand Prix History — Biography on Niki Lauda (Contains information about Flight 004)
Airliner accidents and incidents caused by mechanical failure
Aviation accidents and incidents in 1991
Aviation accidents and incidents in Thailand
Accidents and incidents involving the Boeing 767
1991 in Thailand
Lauda Air accidents and incidents
Austria–Thailand relations
May 1991 events in Thailand
Niki Lauda
Airliner accidents and incidents caused by design or manufacturing errors