NĀ ALA HELE ADVISORY COUNCILHAWAI‘I ISLANDMEETING AGENDA
Nā Ala Hele Advisory Council Members:
Riley Smith, Chairman
Terrence Noda, Vice Chairman
David Rietow, Secretary
Deborah Chang
Roger Kanealii Jr
Kawehi Ryder
Michael Varney
Jeffrey Yamauchi
Christopher Seymour
Jackson Bauer, ex-officio
Rick Gmirkin, ex-officio
DATE:

November 18, 2020

PLACE:

via Zoom Video Conference:https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84981831465?pwd=blh4YmFRZmxYMmNucTdzRkVHSDJhQT
09
Meeting ID: 849 8183 1465
Passcode:
193334Call-in number option: (669) 900-9128

TIME:

6:00 P.M.

I.

Call to OrderII.

REVIEW and APPROVE MINUTES OF August 26, 2020

III.

PUBLIC TESTIMONY (Three minutes maximum)IV.

UNFINISHED BUSINESS/COMMITTEE REPORTS

If you desire to attend the above meeting and require auxiliary aids (taped materials or sign language interpreter) please request assistance fiveworking days prior to the meeting by writing to the Division of Forestry and Wildlife Branch at the address shown below or by calling/faxing
808-974-4221/808-974-4226.
Division of Forestry and Wildlife

Department of Land and Natural Resources

19 E. Kawili Street, Hilo, HI 96720

A. Nā Ala Hele Program update (Nā Ala Hele staff)
a. Program Trails updates
i. Kaulana Manu Nature Trail
ii. Upper Waiākea ATV & Dirt Bike Riding Areaiii. Pololū Trail
iv. BLNR approved NAH trails
1. Kūlanihāko‘i Mountain Bike Park
2. Pu‘uwa‘awa‘a Cone Trail
3. ‘Ōhi‘a Trail
4. Makāula-‘O‘oma Trails
5. Palila Forest Discovery Trailv. Other program trail updates
b. Historic Trails updates
i. Makalawena-Akahipu‘u Trail
ii. Saddle Road Extension – Waikoloa ancient trailsc. Access updates
i. Waipi‘o Valley Road
d. Administrative Tasks update
e. Other NAH program updates
B. Budget/Legislative Update (Nā Ala Hele staff)
C. Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail Update (Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail staff)
D. Information/Update: Tracking Tool (Deborah Chang)
E. Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe GameManagement Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for pedestrian uses.
F. Recommendation to Division of Forestry and Wildlife, Wildlife Program to amend GameManagement Area rules to require all users wear blaze orange.
G. Council Member Concerns
V.

NEW BUSINESS
A. New Advisory Council Member Applicantsa. Jeff McDevittb. Erin Stamos
B. RTP Discussion (Terrence)a. Council members roles and responsibilities; DOT Recreational Program Trail
Requirements.
b. Budget for Trails; Recent Expendituresc. Hawaii Island: OHV Expenditure (30% required)
C. Set next meeting agenda
D. Set next meeting dateVI.

ADJOURNMENT

Enclosures:
Approved Minutes of Meeting, June 24, 2020

Chair Smith’s Letter to DLNR Chair Case, DOCARE Chief Redulla, and Attorney General Connors
Advisory Council Member Application – Jeff McDevitt
Advisory Council Member Application – Erin Stamos
2019 Hawaii Island RTP Approved Budget Project List
2020 RTP Guidance Part 1
RTP Funding by state, Fiscal Years 1993 to 2018
RTP Funding by state, Fiscal Year 2018
Na Ala Hele Budget, Fiscal Year 2021; Pages 4 and 5
RTP Motorized Expenses BreakdownNĀ ALA HELE ADVISORY COUNCILHAWAI‘I ISLAND
October 8, 2020
Ms. Suzanne Case, Chair
Mr. Jason Redulla, Enforcement Chief
Department of Land and Natural Resources
Kalanimoku Building
1151 Punchbowl Street
Honolulu, Hawai‘i 96813
Ms. Clare Connors, Attorney General
425 Queen Street
Honolulu, Hawai‘i 96813
SUBJECT:

Request for Clarification of Hunting Rules in Ka‘ohe Game Management Area,
Island of Hawai‘i: TMK: (3)4-4-015:004

Chair Case, Chief Redulla, and Attorney General Connors:
At our meeting of August 26, 2020, the Nā Ala Hele Hawai‘i Island Advisory Council (NAH
Council) unanimously voted to request clarification from your offices on an issue we aredeliberating on, that could impact the Nā Ala Hele Trail System. This year the NAH Council has
been asked to consider whether the Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe GameManagement Area should be added to the Nā Ala Hele Trail Program. So far this year, the NAH
Council has discussed this at our meetings of January 22, April 1, June 24 and August 26,
without achieving majority consensus.
Question asked of the recipients of this letter:One of the primary concerns raised in testimonies against this trail being included in the NAH
Program, are safety and liability issues, if all users within the area are not appropriately dressed
to ensure everyone’s safety.
These concerns lead us to request your clarification of the following question:

Division of Forestry and Wildlife

Department of Land and Natural Resources

19 E. Kawili Street, Hilo, HI 96720

•

Can the Hunting Rules, including the wearing of blaze orange vests and hats, be applied
to all users, including non-hunters (bird watchers, hikers, etc.) within GameManagement Areas?

Background information:
Who we are:
The NAH Council provides advice and assistance in the implementation of the statewide trail
and access system to the Department of Land and Natural Resources – Division of Forestry andWildlife, per HRS §198D-9(2).
Conditions unique to the subject location:
Throughout the state, NAH Program Trails are located in areas that permit a mix of activities,
including hiking, hunting, cultural practices, and much more. The Palila Forest Discovery Trail isa relatively new trail that offers outstanding opportunities for observation and photography ofendemic Hawaiian birds, especially the endangered palila (Loxioides bailleui). The trail is locatedin the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area that has long been an established hunting area, and isparticularly active during bird hunting season, which extends from November to the end ofJanuary. The unique conditions to bear in mind are:• Birding is an activity that requires hidden and quiet observation. Bird hunting requires
vigilance and quick response should movement be detected. Bird hunting (ofappropriate “game” species) involves shooting at moving targets with little time todetermine if it is safe to shoot. Bird watchers are typically hiding in dense vegetation to
avoid detection by birds. These two activities are potentially conflicting.
• The bird hunter depends on the ability to identify the presence of other hunters andnon-hunters through the wearing of “blaze orange hats and vests,” which is required in
the hunting rules for those that are hunting and/or guiding, accompanying or assisting(HAR §13-122-12(f)(2)).
• Nā Ala Hele’s rules (HAR Title 13 Chapter 130) do not require the use of blaze orange(for all users) on Program Trails.
• There are no established statewide rules for Game Management Areas, for Nā Ala Heleto adopt.
Safety and liability concerns:
If the wearing of blaze orange cannot be legally required of trail users in the Palila Forest
Discovery Trail, both hunters and birders will be exposed to high risks. Hunting accidents canresult in serious injury or even death. If the State of Hawai‘i fails to take necessary safety
precautions and knowingly permits unsafe mixing of activities in its managed areas, liability

exposure to the State is a real consequence. Safety of the birding activity during bird hunting
season must be considered as well as the hunters’ liability.
Although inclusion of the Palila Forest Discovery Trail into the NAH Program could be very
beneficial for the public and the environment, the inability to impose appropriate safetymeasures, for all users of the area, is preventing the NAH Council from recommending theaddition of this trail to the System. These concerns need to be adequately clarified, before wecan make a recommendation.
Your assistance in replying to this question, so that we are fully briefed on the consequences ofour recommendation is greatly appreciated. At that time, we should have all the information
we require in order to make a recommendation to Chair Case.

Sincerely,

Riley W. Smith, P.E.
Chair, Hawai‘i Island Nā Ala Hele Advisory Council
Enclosures:
Minutes of 4/1/20 and 6/24/20 Council Meetings

Nā Ala Hele
Hawai‘i Island Advisory Council Minutes
Approved: June 24, 2020
Revised: June 24, 2020
MEETING DATE: April 1st, 2020
PLACE: Remote Conference Call
Voting Members Present:

Riley Smith - Chairman, Terrence Noda – Vice
Chairman, David Rietow – Secretary, Deborah
Chang, Jeffrey Yamauchi, Christopher Seymour,
Roger Kanealii Jr (Maha), Michael Varney

Voting Members Absent Excused:

Kawehi Ryder

Voting Members Absent Unexcused:(none)

Invited Guest:(none)

Public:Erin Stamos, Dwayne Yoshina, Meredith Speicher,
Steven Hurt, Claire Rossi de Leon

Ex-Officio:

Jackson Bauer of Nā Ala Hele, Keni Wallace of Nā
Ala Hele, Rick Gmirkin of Ala Kahakai National
Historic Trails

Ex-Officio Absent:
I. Call to Order 6:05PM
II. REVIEW and APPROVE MINUTES OF January 22, 2020
A.
Motion to approve by Terrence and seconded by Mike.
B.
Terrence corrected IV, A, g – it should read “November through January”. Also, he said thatit’s missing the name of the individual from the bird hunting community that reviewed thetrail before it was approved. Jackson did not know who that was but said that the trail went
through an EA before approval back in 2016.
III. PUBLIC TESTIMONY (Three minutes maximum)A.
Dwayne raised his concerns over the recommendation to add the Palila Forest Discovery Trail
as a Nā Ala Hele trail. His concerns were over safety during the bird hunting season.
B.
Steven raised his concerns over the recommendation to add the Palila Forest Discovery Trail
as a Nā Ala Hele trail. His concerns were over safety during the bird hunting season and that a

Division of Forestry and Wildlife • Department of Land and Natural Resources • 1151 Punchbowl Street, Room 224 • Honolulu, Hawai‘I 96813

requirement be that hikers wear reflective orange vests similar to hunters. He also advisedthat the road be limited to 4x4 vehicles only.
IV. UNFINISHED BUSINESS/COMMITTEE REPORTS
A.
Nā Ala Hele Program update (Nā Ala Hele staff)
a. Program Trails updates by Jacksoni. Kaulana Manu Nature Trail. Construction on the parking and bathroom resumed thisweek and is anticipated to be completed this summer.
ii. Pu‘u ‘O‘o Trail. Working on a plan to expand and flatten the trailhead parking toaccommodate about 20 vehicles including an ADA compliant parking stall.
b. Other program trail updates by Keni
i. Muliwai Trail. The camping site is closed due to the covid-19.
ii. ʻĀinapō Trail. The cabin is closed due to the covid-19.
iii. ATV Park and R1 off road vehicle permits have moved to an online format and thosepermits are good for one year.
iv. Kaheāwai Trail maintenance done.
v. Pu‘u Huluhulu Trails maintenance done. Debbie asked if the “KAPU” signage was still
there and Jackson replied, “no” DOCARE has them.
c. Historic Trails updates by Jacksoni. Trail to the Sea Coast (a.k.a. Kohanaiki Road). Jackson briefed the Council on thehistorical nature of the trail along with the current concerns of an affordable housing
project slated to be built where the trail is located. He met with the archeologists, Rickwith the N.P., and others. It was apparent that the trail was not being preserved in theplanning of this development. The trail is owned by the State and is very much intact.
The development is receiving Federal assistance so that comes with some leverage forhistoric and cultural protection of the trail. This is ongoing.
d. Access updates
i. Keauhou Trail. Jackson met with Perry Kealoha of KS on site. They have fulfilled all therequirements. There is just one portion of the trail that is blocked by an old crumblingrock wall. They are working with SHPD to resolve this issue before opening the trail tothe public.
e. Administrative Tasks update by Jackson. Due to the covid-19 DLNR is urged to work as
much from home as possible. We can work in the field but must drive separately. All trails
remain open, as long as they accessible through an open State or County park. All Stateparks are closed. Portable toilets remain in place and are serviced through the contractor.
f. Other NAH program updatesi. Upper Waiākea ATV Park by Terrence. Two ATV certification courses were performed.
The last wind storm did significant damage to the trails but have since been repaired.
GPS of the trail; we hope to complete in this next quarter. We continue to issue day
permits on site. However, yearly permits still need to be done online.
B.
Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail Update (Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail staff) by Rick.
Due to the covid-19 the entire staff is working remotely. We hired two more people thisweek. However, they immediately went on health and safety status which means they are
not able to work due to covid-19.
C.
Budget/Legislative Update by Jackson. No update
D.
Information/Update: Tracking Tool (Deborah Chang) Debbie moved to pass on the tracking
tool so that we can focus on the Draft Trail Guidelines. David seconded.

E.

Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe GameManagement Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers.
a. Discussion –i. Jackson briefed the Council and public on the trail history and why the trail would
benefit as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers. He agreed with the 4x4 requirement(for R1). He pointed out that many of the Nā Ala Hele Program Trails are within existinghunting areas. He pointed out that the R1 road that leads to the Palila Forest Discovery
Trail is already a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail. He agrees that brightly colored vests are agood recommendation but one that cannot be enforced due to the lack of rules
requiring hikers to wear brightly colored clothing in hunting areas. He also briefed theCouncil and public on the process of bringing a trail into the Nā Ala Hele Trail Program.
ii. The Council members generated a list of concerns and recommendations.
01.
Can we require tour companies to wear blaze orange? Jackson said “yes”.
02.
Can we require the public to have a permit? Jackson said “no”.
03.
Can we take down the existing web site or edit it to reflect the status andrules of the Nā Ala Hele Program Trails? Jackson said “yes”.
04.
Is there a sign-in area that indicates the number of users? Jackson said
there is a sign-in register at the Kilohana Check In Station, at the start of R1.
Tour groups are permitted and their numbers are limited.
05.
Signage at the Palila Forest Discovery trail head should make it clear that thetrail is in an active hunting area.
06.
Recommendation that we close the trail during the bird hunting season.
Jackson said this would be atypical and difficult to justify. NAH Program
Trails are usually open to both hunters and other user groups.
07.
Recommendation that we require only 4x4 vehicles on R1. Jackson said thatthe road is already a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail with the 4X4 requirement.
08.
Recommend that the public wear blaze orange like hunters are required to
wear.
09.
How did the EA address safety concerns?
iii. Jackson reminded the Council that if the trail comes under the Nā Ala Hele Program Trailthen the Council has the opportunity to make recommendations. If the trail is not a Nā
Ala Hele Program Trail, then it remains relatively unmanaged.
iv. David made a motion to recommend addition of the existing Palila Forest Discovery Trailwithin the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers.
After there was no “second” to the motion, he withdrew the motion.
v. Terrence moved to defer the vote until we can review the EA and consolidate ourconcerns. Debbie seconded the motion. All in favor. Jackson agreed to email the EA to
the Council members prior to the next meeting.
V. NEW BUSINESSA.
Request to approve “Revised Guidelines for the Treatment of Historical Trails” (Guidelines
Revision Subcommittee, Deborah Chang) Jackson and Debbie briefed the Council on the draft.
a. Discussion and Questions by the Council.
i. Plant survey and plant guidelines were discussed. NAH does not have the authority to
dictate specific plants but can advise in favor of and against certain plant choices.
Terrence recommended including the scientific names (genus, species) of plants
mentioned in the Guidelines to improve clarity.

ii. Public access and buffers were discussed. NAH can only maintain program trails. Trail
maintenance within resorts and other private properties is the responsibility of others,
and we can only advise.
iii. Has there been any successful enforcement by State or County on violations by homeowners or resorts? Debbie said that there has been some enforcement, and that it has
not been that successful, with lengthy, inconsistent, and sometimes non-existentenforcement. Rick said that he has been involved in many violations where in the past
the guidelines or violations were not clear. The purpose of this draft revision is totighten up the guidelines in order to minimize misinterpretations.
iv. The Council discussed the 30 ft wide buffer guideline. Rick said that previous guidelines
have not been successful. The 30 ft buffer was in part advised by SHPD. It’s also thestandard minimum buffer width around burial sites. Elsewhere in the nation some trails
have buffers that are miles wide to preserve the trail experience, so 30 ft is notunreasonable.
v. The Council discussed both climate change and rising sea levels. Rick said that theCounty recognizes that coastal trails will need to migrate inward over time. It wassuggested that the draft verbiage acknowledge climate change where appropriate.
vi. There was a mention that the photos used as examples within the guidelines seemed tofavor the West side of the island and do not include East side of the island issues. Morediversity in the examples would be helpful. Jeff volunteered to provide photos from theEast side. Jackson said that photos can be revised without the need for a Council vote.
vii. In the past, builders have ignored or moved the trail without approval just to meet theirwishes and in some cases the trail is now flanked with a wall on one side and steep
grade on the other leaving a very narrow path to walk.
viii. It was suggested that in addition to the guidelines a simple checklist be added for quick
review.
ix. It was asked who would get this document? Jackson said that the document is available
on our web site. It should be used by anyone who has a historic trail on their property.
b. Vote: Debbie moved that we approve the guidelines tonight knowing that we will continue
to update it in the near future. Terrence seconded that motion. All were in favor. Motion
carried.
B.
Council Member Concerns.
a. David. Mauna Lani 49 Black Sand Beach Access Sign Removal. Mike informed the Council
that he had heard nothing back from the County on his complaint to the planningdepartment. Riley will provide the Council members with the County link that can be used
to register concerns with the County.
b. Debbie asked if bicycle permits are required to ride in the Bicycle Park in the Waiākea
Forest Reserve. Jackson said no permit is required to ride bikes or horses in a forest
reserve. He will double-check. (See Tracking Tool #34)
c. Mike mentioned the revision of the Ala Kahakai Trail on the website. Jackson said that all
County parks are closed so access to the Ala Kahakai is restricted in certain locations rightnow. You can still access the trail through Puakō boat ramp, for example.
C.
Set next meeting agendaD.
Set next meeting date. Next meeting will be Wednesday June 24th at 6:00PM in Waimea or bytelecom.

VI. ADJOURNMENT. David motioned to adjourn. Terrence seconded. All were in favor. Meeting was
adjourned at 8:05PM.

ADA
BIISC
CIP
DHHL
DLNR
DOCARE
DOFAW
DOT
GPS
HDOT
KCRA
KRDC
KSBE
NAH
NAHA
NARS
OGR
PONC
ROD
ROHVA
SHPD

Americans with Disability Act.
Big Island Invasive Species Committee
Capital Improvement Program
Department of Hawai’ian Home Lands
Department of Land and Natural Resources
Division of Conservation and Resources Enforcement
Department of Forestry and Wildlife
Department of Transportation
Global Positioning Satellite
Hawaii Department of Transportation
Kohala Coast Resort Association
Keauhou Resort Development Corp
Kamehameha School Bishop Estate
Na Ala HeleNa Ala Hele Advisory (committee)
Natural Area Reserve System
Old Government Road
Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission
Rapid Ohia Death
Recreational Off Highway Vehicle Association.
State of Hawai’i Historic Preservation Division

Na Ala Hele
Hawai’i Island Advisory Council

I.

Public Testimony:
a.

b.
c.
d.
e.

f.

II.

Those providing testimony at our meetings are guests of our Council. They are not Council members.
They are invited to provide testimony. However, they do not have the right to question us,
participate in our meeting, nor dialogue as we discuss our agenda.
Shall be limited to 3 minutes, for each person.
Written copies of testimony should be provided and included in the Minutes of meeting.
Oral testimony must be provided in person.
Testimony for a person that is not present can be turned into the Secretary for inclusion within the
Minutes. It cannot be read at the meetings, as we will not have the opportunity to question theauthor. Electronic submittal of testimony will be allowed if provided to DOFAW 12 calendar days
prior to meeting date. Otherwise, hard copies may be distributed at meeting.
If testimony is being provided on behalf of an organization, it is required that the Board of Directorsof the organization or a majority of the members of the organization must have voted in favor of thetestimony. If this has not occurred, then it must be considered as solely the opinion of the person
providing the testimony.

Agendized presentations to the Council:

a.
b.

r5/22/13

Time allowed for presentations is 10 minutes.
It is likely that the Council will ask questions after the presentation is made. This Q&A period may
continue for 10 – 15 minutes, at the discretion of the Chair of the Council.

Nā Ala Hele
Hawai‘i Island Advisory Council Minutes
Approved: August 26th 2020
Revised: August 26th 2020
MEETING DATE: June 24th 2020
PLACE: Remote Telephone Conference Call
Voting Members Present:

Riley Smith - Chairman, Terrence Noda – Vice
Chairman, David Rietow – Secretary, Deborah
Chang, Jeffrey Yamauchi, Christopher Seymour,
Michael Varney

Voting Members Absent Excused:

Kawehi Ryder, Roger Kanealii Jr (Maha)

Voting Members Absent Unexcused:(none)

Invited Guest:(none)

Public:Beth Robinson, Brian Ley, Dwayne Yoshina, John
Howerton, Nani Pogline, Nate Riedel, Stanley
Mendes, Steven Hurt, Tom Lodge, Toni Whittington,
Lino Kamakau of DOCARE

Ex-Officio:

Jackson of Na Ala Hele, Keni Wallace of Na Ala Hele,
Rick Gmirkin of Ala Kahakai National Historic Trails

Ex-Officio Absent:(none)

I. Call to Order 6:07PM
II. House rules and background by Jackson.
III. REVIEW and APPROVE MINUTES; Terrence, Jeff.
A.
Discussion by Terrence. Page 3, item E. Missing comment from Steve Hurt that hewas consulted for this trail. Review of the meeting minutes by David suggest that
Terrence is referring to public testimony (III-B).
IV. PUBLIC TESTIMONY (Three minutes maximum)
A.
Riley went through the written testimony (Dwayne Yoshina, Tom Lodge, Steven Hurt,
Nate Riedel, and Terrence Noda).

Division of Forestry and Wildlife • Department of Land and Natural Resources • 1151 Punchbowl Street, Room 224 • Honolulu, Hawai‘I 96813

B.

Oral testimony
a. Tony Wittington – Representing North Kohala Access Group, regarding the Pololū
Valley area.
i. NKAG would like the opportunity to review the lookout proposals before sending
it to the Land Board. Jackson agreed.
ii. North Kohala Community Development Plan, ordinance 151 of the County of
Hawaii. The CDP recommendation to include the vehicle trail that runs Mauka to
Makai alongside the 5-acre proposed parking area and the Kohala ditch trail as
public trails.
iii. Of the 5-acre parcel proposed in the land swap for parking at the Pololū lookout
only about 2 acres are usable due to the terrain.
b. Steven Hurt – Representing the general public, regarding recommendation to add
existing Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as aNā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers. Steve read from his submitted written
testimony dated June 21, 2020.
c. Nani Pogline – Game Management Advisory Commission Chair, regarding the
Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka`oheGame Management Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers. Nani expressed
concern that in the EA the Hawaii County Game Management Advisory Commission
was not consulted even though the trail is in the Ka`ohe Game Management Area.
It is unclear how the labeling of program trail could affect hunting in this area.
Concerns are that such designation could give hiking more importance than hunting
particularly when issues arise. We hope that in the planning that hunting be given apriority as we are the original stake holders in the area. We request that safetyissues be addressed, safety practice and liability be imposed on hikers as they are
imposed on hunters. If there is a hunting mishap, hunters should not be held liable
and hunting be put in jeopardy. If the labeling as a program trail will allow for theimposition of a safety zone in further dwindling of public hunting area, we ask forfair compensation. Furthermore, if the program trail labeling allows for more
funding the scale will continue to unjustly tip in favor of hiking. Access road
improvements already as-is end at the Palila Discovery Trail and access for huntersbeyond are left unimproved and difficult to traverse. We ask that equal attention
be dedicated to the preservation of hunting opportunities in the Ka`ohe GameManagement Area.
d. Dwayne Yoshina – Regarding Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest
Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as a Nā Ala Hele
Program Trail for hikers. Dwayne echoed the sentiments and opinions in testimony
by Steven and Nani.
e. Tom Lodge – Regarding Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery
Trail within the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for
hikers. Blaze Orange is important. Concerns over parking in the area, mowing, andreceptacles to keep it clean.

f.

Stanley Mendes – Regarding Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest
Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as a Nā Ala Hele
Program Trail for hikers. Stan brought up the point that it is the hunters that pay
for the management and upkeep of the area through the hunting license fee.
Hikers are benefiting at the expense of hunters. He also said there are no more
Palila.
g. Brian Ley – Regarding Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery Trailwithin the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for
hikers. Concerns about uncontrolled weeds and fire hazard. What is the plan todeal with additional people who may be smoking? Hunters have brought up thisconcern for years. Since the reduction of Mouflon sheep, the invasive weeds areout of control.
V. Riley asked for a motion to amend the meeting agenda to bring forward item IV-E
(Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe GameManagement Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers). Terrence moved and Debbie
seconded the motion. There was no opposition from the council.
VI. Recommendation to add existing Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe GameManagement Area as a Nā Ala Hele Program Trail for hikers.
A.
Discussion
a. Jackson briefed everyone on the trail and the reasoning for the proposal andtouched on concerns.
i. The objective is to move the management of the existing trail from DOFAW’s
Forestry Program to DOFAW’s Na Ala Hele Program (for trail management).
ii. The trail is in a Game Management Area (GMA) that does not reside within a
Forest Reserve.
iii. There are no GMA rules that have ever been drafted. We can talk about this but
it’s not something NAH can draft.
iv. The only rules that would apply would be The Game Bird Hunting and The
Mammal Hunting rules as they apply to the respective activity. Hiking is not oneof those activities so those rules do not apply to hiking.
v. The benefit of being a NAH Program Trail is that it will be actively managed,
bringing better control over those using the trail.
vi. The EA was approved in 2016. The EA was not done by NAH. Jackson went on tobetter define sections of the EA that were brought up by public testimony both
written and oral.
vii. Hunting money is not used to maintain R1. That is NAH money. Road repair andmaintenance is typically done just prior to bird hunting season.
viii. Liability applies if there is lack of signage and warnings. NAH maintains these in
the field and on our website.
ix. Blaze orange garment requirement is not a part of NAH rules. It is best
addressed under GMA rules (which don’t exist). That said, NAH can advise it as abest practice.

x. The trail will not be a safety zone. Many of our Program Trails are already in
GMAs. None of our trails within GMAs are safety zones.
xi. The cost of the trail is not anticipated to be a detriment to our budget. It is analready existing trail and will continue to be maintained by the existing Mauna
Kea Forest Restoration Program due to their ongoing planting activity in thearea.
xii. There is quite a bit of Palila on that trail.
b. Motion by Terrence to deny agenda item IV-E, Recommendation to add existing
Palila Forest Discovery Trail within the Ka‘ohe Game Management Area as a Nā Ala
Hele Program Trail for hikers. Riley seconded that motion.
i. Discussion by council members
01.
Terrence summarized his written testimony.
02.
David asked for clarification from Jackson on his statement that GMA
do not have any rules. Jackson clarified that the area of land does nothave set rules whereas the activity of hunting has rules.
03.
Debbie – no questions
04.
Mike – no questions05.
Jeff – no questions
06.
Chris – no questions
07.
Terrence – The proposal is not consistent with the rules of the otheractivities in the area.
08.
Jackson responded to council members questions.
ii. Vote - 3 YES and 4 NO. There was not a majority in favor of the motion. Motion
denied.
c. Debbie motioned that we defer the decision on whether to recommend the existing
Palila Discovery Trail for inclusion in the NAH Program Trails until we receive
answers to these and other questions. Also, that if any of the council members
have questions, please email questions to Jackson and cc Riley, within 2 weeks. Jeff
seconded the motion. The following questions should be addressed by Jackson at
our next meeting.
i. The blaze orange garment concern is loud and clear. It would be helpful to know
how and if we could amend NAH rules to incorporate blaze orange requirementon trails that are in hunting areas.
ii. Is there currently and how much commercial activity is conducted on R1, R10,
and the Palila Discovery Trail? Jackson said that in February there were 3
commercial tours of 7-10 people. Commercial tours using R1 are allowed to use
the Palila Discovery Trail.
iii. Can we prohibit commercial activity in the Palila Discovery Trail? Jackson said
the council can recommend anything it wants.
iv. Debbie questioned the validity of the data showing on average 3 sign-ins a day.
She often sees more cars in the parking area than people signed in and on atleast one occasion the sign in book was completely full. We need more accurate
data. Jackson agreed that not everyone signs in and as Terrence pointed out it’snot in NAH’s rules to require sign in. It’s there in case of a brush fire, so theyknow who is in the area.
v. At the Palila Discovery Trail there is no signage warning people that they are inan active hunting area. We need consistent signage. Jackson said that may betrue but there is nothing he can do about that until the trail is incorporated into
the NAH Program Trails.
vi. Why is just one trail is listed when there are so many side trails? Who is making
these side trails? Jackson said he agrees that it is confusing, but again there isnothing he can do about it until the trail is incorporated into the NAH Program
Trails. If it were a Program Trail, he could block those side trails.
vii. Discussion by council members. No discussion.
viii. Vote – 7 YES, 0 NO. Motioned carried. Jackson to follow up with responses at
next meeting.
VII. Riley proposed that we defer all agenda items under section IV until the next meeting due
to time. There was no objection by council members. Jackson wanted to update thecouncil on Pololū. Surety Kohala Corp is donating 5 acres for lookout parking. It’s true thatof that only 2 acres are usable for parking. They are also offering the valley floor. In
exchange 10 parcels would be moved up to the valley rim which they would be able to sell.
A portion of the CIP funds is designated for Kohala community meetings to review theplans. We acknowledge the North Kohala CDP recommends the Mauka to Makai road, andthe ditch trail as public access. Surety is currently reviewing the Letter of Intent that DLNR
drafted. Once we get their comments it will go to the Board for their letter of approval.
That letter is important because that is needed by the County to proceed with Consolidationand Subdivision. Surety says that needs to happen by the end of the year to fall within theirbusiness model.
VIII. NEW BUSINESSA.
Conducting future meetings by Video Conference.
a. Riley explained that we don’t have the funding for video conferencing.
b. Jackson said that may change in July.
c. Jeff asked about Zoom. Riley had some concerns because his company does notallow Zoom on his computer. He would be able to call in but not video.
B.
Set next meeting agenda. Council is to email Jackson and Cc Riley on any agenda
items. Jackson and Riley will work on the agenda.
C.
Set next meeting date. August 26th at 6:00PM. If the meeting is in person then it will
be in Hilo for social distancing. Otherwise it will be teleconferenced.
D.
ADJOURNMENT. Terrence motioned to adjourn and Jeff Second. Meeting was
adjourned at 8:23PM.

ADA
BIISC
CIP
DHHL
DLNR
DOCARE
DOFAW
DOT
GPS
GMA
HDOT
KCRA
KRDC
KSBE
NAH
NAHA
NARS
OGR
PONC
ROD
ROHVA
SHPD

Americans with Disability Act.
Big Island Invasive Species Committee
Capital Improvement Program
Department of Hawai’ian Home Lands
Department of Land and Natural Resources
Division of Conservation and Resources Enforcement
Department of Forestry and Wildlife
Department of Transportation
Global Positioning Satellite
Game Management Area
Hawaii Department of Transportation
Kohala Coast Resort Association
Keauhou Resort Development Corp
Kamehameha School Bishop Estate
Na Ala HeleNa Ala Hele Advisory (committee)
Natural Area Reserve System
Old Government Road
Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission
Rapid Ohia Death
Recreational Off Highway Vehicle Association.
State of Hawai’i Historic Preservation Division

Na Ala Hele
Hawai’i Island Advisory Council
I.

Public Testimony:
a.

b.
c.
d.
e.

f.

II.

Those providing testimony at our meetings are guests of our Council. They are not Council members.
They are invited to provide testimony. However, they do not have the right to question us,
participate in our meeting, nor dialogue as we discuss our agenda.
Shall be limited to 3 minutes, for each person.
Written copies of testimony should be provided and included in the Minutes of meeting.
Oral testimony must be provided in person.
Testimony for a person that is not present can be turned into the Secretary for inclusion within the
Minutes. It cannot be read at the meetings, as we will not have the opportunity to question theauthor. Electronic submittal of testimony will be allowed if provided to DOFAW 12 calendar days
prior to meeting date. Otherwise, hard copies may be distributed at meeting.
If testimony is being provided on behalf of an organization, it is required that the Board of Directorsof the organization or a majority of the members of the organization must have voted in favor of thetestimony. If this has not occurred, then it must be considered as solely the opinion of the person
providing the testimony.

Agendized presentations to the Council:a.
b.

r5/22/13

Time allowed for presentations is 10 minutes.
It is likely that the Council will ask questions after the presentation is made. This Q&A period may
continue for 10 – 15 minutes, at the discretion of the Chair of the Council.

• General Funds = $1,871,488 Salaries Total = $1,698,174 Unfortunately Statedeclared a 10% restriction of General Funds leaving the program in the red• Special Funds (Liquid Fuels Tax) = Up to $250,000.This money in the past wasthought to be operation funds, but it has always been allocated to statewide
NAH positions. MOF Changes freed up a majority of this fund for program
operations. Two positions remain on this funding source.
• CTTA Revenues = Approximately $35,000/year. This revenue will go directly
back into the program and respected island that the commercial activity took
place on. CTTA has been restricted since the COVID crisis.
• FY21 RTP Fund = $848,450• De-obligating and Re-obligating older RTP project funds = $1,117,969 “rollover
funds”• HTA Funds = $530,000• Possible KUPU Interns (sizeable crews similar to the CCC’s)

FY21 Operation Total After Salaries andRe-class

2019 - Report - Overview - Recreational Trails - Environment - FHWA

Page 1 of 2

Table 2: Number of projects per State for FY 2018
Table 2 shows RTP funds apportioned to each State for the most recent year of the program. The funding is based on the amounteach State received in FY 2009. In that year, half of the funds were distributed equally among all States, and half were distributed
in proportion to the estimated amount of off-road recreational fuel use in each State: fuel used for off-road recreation bysnowmobiles, ATVs, off-road motorcycles, and off-road light trucks.
This table also shows obligations by State. Obligations are the Federal government's legal commitment to pay or reimburse theStates or other entities for the Federal share of a project's eligible costs.
State# 2018 Projects

FY 2018 Apportionment

FY 2018
Obligation

Alabama

7$1,732,289$1,641,681

Alaska26$1,512,643$1,279,965

Arizona27$1,915,514$1,551,663

Arkansas

15$1,479,029$1,517,451

California

1$5,698,627$1,232,608

Colorado

16$1,575,735$1,862,492

Connecticut(1)

0

0

0

Delaware

1$896,623$1,146,573

District of Columbia (4)1$816,847$378,332

Florida22$2,576,507$1,803,554

Georgia19$1,722,736$2,700,181

Hawaii122$950,859$950,859

Idaho

44

$1,693,454$1,740,359

Illinois20$1,510,044$1,504,285

Indiana9$1,189,692$1,360,439

Iowa

10

$1,361,069$895,233

Kansas14$1,370,407$1,160,000

Kentucky

20$1,410,151$1,222,209

Louisiana

15$1,502,467$1,765,319

Maine

27

$1,428,314$864,338

Maryland

16$1,112,384$306,822

Massachusetts

75$1,174,862$2,519,509

Michigan (2,3,4)

0$2,825,415$2,803,369

Minnesota

34$2,391,888$111,000

Mississippi

17$1,348,305$1,385,249

Missouri9$1,646,765$1,521,835

Montana50$1,590,638$1,478,169

Nebraska

5$1,205,213$1,010,014

Nevada22$1,344,370$843,561

New Hampshire25$1,255,265$1,250,000-$356,423

New Jersey (2,3,4,5)

0$ 1,214,489

New Mexico9$1,415,533$991,878

New York

4$2,182,510$2,301,306

North Carolina

31$1,597,424$1,004,032

North Dakota

10$1,120,562$851,515

Ohio

14$1,655,132$1,245,845

Oklahoma

9$1,769,212$1,547,045

Oregon (2,3)

0$1,594,051$2,458,434

Pennsylvania

12$1,971,353$2,652,190

Rhode Island

1$856,384$1,492,653

South Carolina

12$1,199,108$872,616South Dakota

12$1,125,821$963,674

Tennessee

14$1,624,207$2,372,272

Texas

19

$3,954,874$4,751,233

Utah

32

$1,546,233$1,437,997

Vermont

51$1,017,730$864,430

Virginia

3$1,511,889$1,310,671

Washington

17$1,867,407$1,729,333

West Virginia

16$1,297,964$1,123,554

Wisconsin

41$2,146,076$1,853,349

Wyoming22$1,459,731$1,304,741

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/recreational_trails/overview/report/2019/

6/14/2020

2019 - Report - Overview - Recreational Trails - Environment - FHWA

Total to States

994

Page 2 of 2

$82,365,802 $72,579,414

2018 Obligation Rate

88.12%

1. State's Governor opted out of the RTP: CT
2. State has not yet provided funding and match information for FY 2018 projects: MI, NJ, OR
3. State did not obligate funds in FY 2018: MI, NJ, OR
4. State has not provided funding and match information for FY 2017 or a prior year(s): DC, MI, NJ
5. Negative amount represents deobligated funds
Source: Federal Highway Administration Office of Planning, Environment, and Realty
https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/recreational_trails/funding/ apportionments_obligations/recfunds_2018.cfm

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/recreational_trails/overview/report/2019/

6/14/2020

2019 - Report - Overview - Recreational Trails - Environment - FHWA

Page 1 of 1

Table 3: Funding by State, FY 1993-2018
Table 3 shows the number of projects funded plus the amount of funding by State for Federal FY 1993-2018.
This table shows the total RTP funds obligated by each State during the period. In addition, the "Total Other Funding" column shows how much additional
match was provided by project sponsors. Note that the matching funds are generally higher than the 20 percent minimum required by RTP. In 9 States thematch is higher than the total RTP funds apportioned.
Since 1993, more than $1.3 billion in RTP funds generated nearly $971 million in other funds, resulting in a total of over $2.27 billion for trails: 57 percent
from Federal funds and 43 percent from other sources.
State

1993-2018 Projects

Total RTP Funding

Alabama

366$29,532,434

Total Other Funding$9,753,756

Alaska481$16,735,231$5,271,411

Arizona279$22,808,685$5,933,478

Arkansas361$14,568,213$9,041,604

California

408$64,036,361$40,722,574

Colorado

434$17,121,474$24,516,929

Connecticut (1)369$19,178,479$11,921,480

Delaware152$11,225,196$6,273,502

District of Columbia (4)36$7,876,842$1,811,722

Florida238$31,205,137$26,797,829

Georgia335$30,242,518$24,145,157

Hawaii

1,362$12,286,726$3,254,532

Idaho

652

$22,930,889$19,241,182

Illinois

297$28,984,437$13,442,707

Indiana156$21,910,959$6,783,264

Iowa

123

$28,061,126$7,046,905

Kansas337$19,460,793$12,537,381

Kentucky

526$19,704,416$19,322,140

Louisiana389$23,458,491$21,795,532

Maine

681

$16,139,355$5,592,927

Maryland860$20,446,378$7,689,145

Massachusetts503$14,392,286$12,248,934

Michigan (2,3,4)

316$38,380,501$26,583,670

Minnesota

514$33,163,603$59,156,950

Mississippi

299$24,097,534$6,026,418

Missouri340$25,436,262$26,815,856

Montana957$22,197,312$18,985,992

Nebraska

140$16,624,177$7,836,816

Nevada360$17,586,809$9,960,292

New Hampshire

788$14,257,765$15,382,510

New Jersey (2,3,4)

846$18,014,988$43,805,535

New Mexico203$16,927,819$6,420,524

New York

434$33,208,352$13,470,311

North Carolina

567$30,994,767$39,047,788

North Dakota

286$16,654,049$4,845,964

Ohio

319

$25,785,988$24,276,090

Oklahoma

307$27,600,964$14,918,619

Oregon (2,3)

437$20,997,202$20,700,498

Pennsylvania

397$34,371,901$21,847,360

Rhode Island

377$7,064,002$2,936,098

South Carolina

278$17,819,864$6,062,199

South Dakota

391$20,941,050$11,856,826

Tennessee

256$20,819,369$6,225,859

Texas

512

$60,867,170$21,113,675

Utah

567

$27,060,414$44,859,092

Vermont

1,262$13,950,290$23,473,914

Virginia

305$22,139,997$9,450,338

Washington

674$27,616,592$45,453,587

West Virginia

304$13,205,585$3,691,801

Wisconsin

697$23,389,157$43,477,087

Wyoming
Total:

496$23,133,671$14,711,545

22,975$1,186,613,580$888,537,305

1. State's Governor opted out of the RTP: CT
2. State has not yet provided funding and match information for FY 2018 projects: MI, NJ, OR
3. State did not obligate funds in FY 2018: MI, NJ, OR
4. State has not provided funding and match information for FY 2017 or a prior year(s): DC, MI, NJ
The source for the data in Tables 3 is information voluntarily provided by the States and District of Columbia for the Recreational Trails Program Database(http://www.rtpinfo.org).

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/recreational_trails/overview/report/2019/

6/14/2020

S-20-262 Transactions for ACT 587
CC
Proj NoPH Act Amount0420 RTPNRT
22 5872,540.00
0420 RTPNRT
22 5872,540.00
0420 RTPNRT
22 5872,540.00
0420 RTPNRT
22 5872,540.00

Vendor NameGECKO ENTERPRISES, INC.
GECKO ENTERPRISES, INC.
GECKO ENTERPRISES, INC.
GECKO ENTERPRISES, INC.

Proc Date
3/19/2020
3/19/2020
3/19/2020
3/19/2020

Purchase or Service Explanation
Portable Toilet contract with Gecko Enterprises for Waialee OHV Park
Portable Toilet contract with Gecko Enterprises for Waialee OHV Park
Portable Toilet contract with Gecko Enterprises for Waialee OHV Park
Portable Toilet contract with Gecko Enterprises for Waialee OHV Park
Portable Toilet contract with Gecko Enterprises for Waialee OHV Park
Credit card purchase to Ina Signs for ADA signs installed at Kilohana (Trailhead to Puu Laau Road (R1)/Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Credit card purchase to Orchid Isle Ford for routine mainteance to Na Ala Hele F350 truck
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Purchase of laptop computer to be used by NAH staff in the management of NAH trails
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Portable toilet rental for Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park and Kilohana (Trailhead for Mauna Kea ATV/Dirt Bike Riding Area)
Credit card purchase to Kiser Motorcycles for various ATV/UTV parts and supplies used at the Upper Waiakea ATV/Dirt Bike Park

0420

RTPNRT

22

587

2,540.00 GECKO ENTERPRISES, INC.

3/19/2020

0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430

RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT

22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22

587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587
587

338.38 FIRST HAWAIIAN BANK
165.5 FIRST HAWAIIAN BANK
148.18 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
148.18 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
473.42 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
148.18 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
441.42 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
512.29 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
427.33 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
510.94 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
510.94 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
510.94 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
148.18 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
148.57 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.

1/10/2020
1/10/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020
2/5/2020

0430

RTPNRT

22587

510.94 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.

2/5/2020

0430
0430
0430
0430
0430
0430

RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT
RTPNRT

22
22
22
22
22
22

587
587
587
587
587
587

1,627.89 CDW GOVERNMENT

2/12/2020
4/9/2020
4/9/2020
4/9/2020
5/11/2020
5/28/2020

0430

RTPNRT

22

587

427.33 HAWAII JOHN'S INC.

5/28/2020

0430

RTPNRT

22

587

621.27 FIRST HAWAIIAN BANK

4/9/2020

0430

RTPNRT

22587

5/11/2020 Credit card purchase to Home Depot for various trail maintenance supplies and hardware

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22587

154.93 FIRST HAWAIIAN BANKSERVICE RENTALS &139.56 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &278.75 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &285.47 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &139.56 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &278.75 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &285.47 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &139.56 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &278.75 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &285.47 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &155.63 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &139.56 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &142.73 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &155.63 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &139.56 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &142.73 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &155.63 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &139.56 SUPPLIES INC

512.29148.57427.33148.57148.57HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
HAWAII JOHN'S INC.
HAWAII JOHN'S INC.

2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

SERVICE RENTALS &142.73 SUPPLIES INC
ATLAS INSURANCE AGENCY,
4,212.88 INC.

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

4,514.23 PACIFIC PIPE CO.

3/3/2020 Irrigation supplies MMXPark

0440

RTPNRT

22587

188.06 PACIFIC PIPE CO.

3/3/2020 Irrigation supplies MMXPark

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

0440

RTPNRT

22

587

TOTAL

SERVICE RENTALS &358.42 SUPPLIES INCSERVICE RENTALS &293.92 SUPPLIES INC
35,052.75

2/7/2020 MMXPark Portapots
2/18/2020 Insurance for MMXPark

6/10/2020 MMXPark Portapots
6/10/2020 MMXPark Portapots