WEERAMANTRY INTERNATIONAL CENTRE
FOR PEACE EDUCATION AND RESEARCH-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NUCLEAR REACTOR CATASTROPHE IN JAPANAN OPEN LETTER TO THE WORLD’S ENVIRONMENTAL MINISTERS
ByC. G. Weeramantry
Former Vice President, International Court of Justice, The Hague
President, International Association of Lawyers against Nuclear Arms
Founder Trustee, Weeramantry International Centrefor Peace Education & Research
March 14th 2011
The earthquake in Japan and the resulting damage to nuclear power plants have sent
shock waves and a dire note of warning to the world’s entire population. Despite
their obvious dangers, nuclear reactors are proliferating worldwide and sowing theseeds of pollution and congenital deformities for a thousand generations to come(the half life of Plutonium 239, one of the bi-products of nuclear activities is 24,100years).

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5/1, Dharmaraja Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 1 2500229 Fax: 0094 114 720480
E-mail: info@wicper.org

PageIf people of the Stone Age had been able to cause damage to the environment andcause congenital deformities to our generation, we would have condemned them assavages, brutes and barbarians. Yet, even if they could have caused such damage,they could have had no idea of the irreparable harm they were causing togenerations yet unborn. We, on the other hand, who are fully aware of thecatastrophic damage we are causing to unborn generations, still proceed regardless,1

Unborn generations are just as much members of the human family as ourselves but
have no voice to speak for themselves. We take advantage of this and are damaging
them catastrophically by our breach of trust of this environment of which we arecustodians and not owners. Every single citizen is a trustee of the environment. All
the more are Governments trustees, and in particular the environmental ministers of
the world bear a special responsibility in this regard. We are in default of our duties
if we continue to keep open such possibilities and create more, despite ourknowledge of their dreadful consequences. Our generation and particularly thosewho are specially entrusted with the care of the environment will have to answer
before the bar of history for our default and abuse of trust. Indeed we arecommitting the gravest possible crime against future generations and are doing sowith a full consciousness of the effects of our actions.

WEERAMANTRY INTERNATIONAL CENTRE
FOR PEACE EDUCATION AND RESEARCH------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------pursuing activities which, it is patently clear, will release these dangers sooner orlater. We continue to build nuclear reactors all over the world.
Even a school child is aware that no power on earth can insure against earthquakes,tsunamis, wars, insurrections, negligent management and other disasters. These will
inevitably occur over a period of years and not only do we know this as a virtualcertainty, but we know also that there is no known means of eliminating them. This
makes us savages, brutes and barbarians several times over. In a supposedly
enlightened age, we are, with total disregard of any sense of responsibility,
proceeding to build more reactors, pursuing short term advantages while being fullyaware of the long term perils we are inflicting on our own posterity. Solar and otherrenewable energy sources provide all the energy the world needs but we neglectthem, for there are great profits for those few who are engaged in the nuclear
energy enterprise, whatever the costs to the vast majority and the generations yet tocome.
As a result we have become the most destructive generation in all of human history,
regardless of the fact that we are destroying the undoubted birthright of billions ofhuman beings for whom we hold the environment on trust.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5/1, Dharmaraja Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 1 2500229 Fax: 0094 114 720480
E-mail: info@wicper.org

PageAlso, nearly thirty years ago, in The Slumbering Sentinels: Law and Human Rights inthe Wake of Technology, Penguin 1983, pp 139-141, I foreshadowed this danger,
referring to leakages from nuclear reactors and the possibilities of major accidentsthreatening our very survival. I referred also to the possibility that, if the residents ofa city were exposed to radioactive contamination through a serious nuclear accident,
the national interest may demand their compulsory sterilisation to prevent the birthof an unprecedented number of defective children, observing that “we are only anuclear accident away from this”. I referred also to the fact that a major accident
near a populated city could cause property damage and health damage which could
not be estimated even in hundreds of billions of dollars, and for which insurance
coverage would be beyond the realm of possibility. As early as 1982, the Nuclear

2I take the liberty of addressing you on this matter as I have for over 30 years
campaigned against the dangers of nuclear weapons, nuclear reactors and nuclear
waste. As early as 1985, I toured the major cities of Japan at the instance of theJapan Scientists’ Association delivering lectures on the dire dangers to humanity
resulting from nuclear weapons, nuclear reactors and nuclear waste.

WEERAMANTRY INTERNATIONAL CENTRE
FOR PEACE EDUCATION AND RESEARCH------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Regulatory Commission (NRC) released estimates of death and property damage
from reactor accidents running to over $300 billion in crowded city areas. TheHarrisburg nuclear leak demonstrated, even then, how close we could be to anuclear accident, the percentage possibility of a nuclear accident occurring
somewhere in the world being assessable at between 5 and 10% within the next few
years. Such reasonable forecasts of possible catastrophes have somehow been
completely submerged by the combined political and economic strength of those
who advocate the extension of nuclear energy.
In my Dissenting Opinion in the case in which an Advisory Opinion was sought fromthe International Court of Justice on the legality of nuclear weapons, I discussed thepossibility of damage to nuclear reactors and the lethal doses of radiation to exposed
persons 150 miles downwind and the radioactive contamination of the environment
more than 600 miles away. I also discussed the damage caused by the Chernobyl
incident, for years after its occurrence, to all species of life for thousands of square
miles in the vicinity, which necessitated the pouring in of medical personnel, supplies
and equipment from across the Soviet Union in a manner which strained theresources even of that powerful nation. Smaller states could be completely crippled
by such an accident, with a loss of income, loss of life, loss of jobs and loss ofresources from which it would take generations to recover. Medical injuries caused
included convulsions, vascular damage, cardio vascular collapse, keloids and cancers.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5/1, Dharmaraja Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 1 2500229 Fax: 0094 114 720480
E-mail: info@wicper.org

Page

Any plea for the abolition of nuclear reactors would be incomplete without
reference to the problem of disposal of nuclear waste. Nuclear waste carries all theelements of radioactive danger to health and the environment and there is noknown means of disposal of these toxic accumulations. Whether they be buried in
the depths of the ocean or deep trenches or salt beds, or wherever else, we cannot
guarantee for twenty-four thousand years that they will remain safe in theirrepositories, and we would be inflicting this source of inter-generational,
environmental, and physical damage on future generations in a manner which is
totally unjustifiable by any standards of morality or law.

3

Having discussed these dangers in judgments, publications and lectures worldwide
for so many years I have been devastated at the thought that my worst premonitions
have come to pass and worse can follow if we continue with our betrayal of trust
and abandonment of responsibility towards our children and our children’s children.

WEERAMANTRY INTERNATIONAL CENTRE
FOR PEACE EDUCATION AND RESEARCH------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Another danger, which by itself is sufficient to justify the total abolition of nuclear
reactors, is that nuclear waste from hundreds of reactors cannot possibly be
accounted for and it is well known that such records are not maintained, even by theInternational Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). This material is the raw material needed
for the manufacture of nuclear weapons and there is here an open invitation toterrorists across the world to interest themselves in the manufacture of nuclearweapons. This is particularly dangerous in a world in which the necessary knowledge
for the construction of a nuclear weapon is available on the internet, as I have beenassured by eminent physicists.
In the result, the continuance and proliferation of nuclear reactors violates every
principle of humanitarian law, international law, environmental law andinternational sustainable development law.
The traditional wisdom of ancient peoples such as the Native Americans used toordain that no serious decision concerning the community should be taken without
considering its impact for seven generations to come. Traditional African wisdom has
decreed that any major decision affecting a community should bear in mind thethree-fold face of humanity – those who went before us, those who are alive here
and now, and those who are yet to come – without which the decision taken would
be a lopsided one.

Page

It is not only traditional wisdom we disregard. We disregard also the wisdom of thegreat religions of the world, which are likewise united in their concern for the peopleof the future. Jesus Christ warned that it would be better for those who place
obstacles in the way of children to have a millstone around their neck and to bedrowned in the ocean. The Koran states that the true followers of the Almighty arethose who tread lightly on the earth. Buddhism teaches that not even a sovereign isthe owner of land, but only a trustee, and Hinduism prescribes detailed duties lying
on the sovereign to look after every department of environmental protection.

4

Our modern technological civilisation disregards all such traditional wisdom in
addition to disregarding the governing principle that we should tread lightly on theearth, which underlies all environmental law (I have expanded on these aspects in
Tread Lightly on the Earth: Religion, the Environment and the Human Future,
Stamford Lake, 2010).

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5/1, Dharmaraja Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 1 2500229 Fax: 0094 114 720480
E-mail: info@wicper.org

WEERAMANTRY INTERNATIONAL CENTRE
FOR PEACE EDUCATION AND RESEARCH------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Judaism likewise, in numerous teachings, elevates protection of the environment tothe level of a primary duty.
All these are aspects which must necessarily engage the attention of ministers
charged with care of the environment, in an age when the environment is being
threatened as never before during the hundreds of thousands of years of humanity’s
existence on the planet.
I urge on you, as custodians of our environment, the need for immediate action tohalt the construction of new reactors, explore alternative energy systems and phaseout the existing ones. Populations throughout the world need to be alerted to thedangers we are facing. The one-way flow of information on the benefits of nuclear
reactors needs to be reversed.
Failure to take these steps will result in the commission of crimes against future
generations and a gross betrayal of the trust which we owe to our children and ourchildren’s children. You are in a position to play a leadership role in this crisis. This is
an appeal to you, as those primarily responsible for the care of our planet, to do allwithin your power to avert the catastrophes that loom ahead.

Page5

Time is running out. Please act now.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5/1, Dharmaraja Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka
Tel: 0094 1 2500229 Fax: 0094 114 720480
E-mail: info@wicper.org