JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

JCM Validation Report Form
A. Summary of validation
A.1. General Information
Title of the projectIntroduction of high-efficient wire stranding
machines to the factory of YAZAKI EDSVIETNAM Co., LTD.

Reference number

VN014

Third-party entity (TPE)

TPE-VN-002

Japan

Quality

Assurance

Organization (JQA)
Project participant contracting the TPE

YAZAKI Parts Co., LTD.

Date of completion of this report

22/03/2019

A.2 Conclusion of validation
Overall validation opinion

Positive
Negative

A.3. Overview of final validation conclusion
Only when all of the checkboxes are checked, overall validation opinion is positive.
Item
Validation requirements
No CAR or CL
remaining
Project design The TPE determines whether the PDD was completed using
document form
the latest version of the PDD forms appropriate to the typeof project and drafted in line with the Guidelines forDeveloping the Joint Crediting Mechanism (JCM) Project
Design Document, Monitoring Plan and Monitoring Report.
Project
The description of the proposed JCM project in the PDD is
description
accurate, complete, and provides comprehension of the
proposed JCM project.
Application of The project is eligible for applying applied methodology andapproved JCM that the applied version is valid at the time of submission of
methodology
the proposed JCM project for validation.
(ies)
Emission
All relevant GHG emission sources covered in thesourcesand methodology are addressed for the purpose of calculating
calculationof project emissions and reference emissions for the proposedemission
JCM project.
reductions
The values for project specific parameters to be fixed ex ante
listed in the Monitoring Plan Sheet are appropriate, if
applicable.
Environmental
The project participants conducted an environmental impact
impactassessment, if required by the Socialist Republic of Vietassessment
Nam, in line with Vietnamese procedures.
Local
The project participants have completed a local stakeholder
1JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

B. Validation team and other experts

Name

Company

Function*

Schemecompetence*

Mr.
Sachiko
Team
JQA
Ms.
Hashizumeleader
Mr.
Aya
Team
JQA
Ms.
WataraimemberMr.
TamamiTeam
JQA
Ms.
Nagayama
memberMr.
HiroshiInternal
JQA
Ms.
Motokawa
reviewer
Please specify the following for each item.

Technical
competence*

Onsitevisit

Authorized
Authorized* Function: Indicate the role of the personnel in the validation activity such as team leader, teammember, technical expert, or internal reviewer.
* Scheme competence: Check the boxes if the personnel have sufficient knowledge on the JCM.
* Technical competence: Indicate if the personnel have sufficient technical competence related
to the project under validation.

C. Means of validation, findings, and conclusion based on reporting requirements
C.1. Project design document form
<Means of validation>
By reviewing the PDD, it is confirmed that the PDD is completed using the latest
version of the PDD form (JCM_VN_F_PDD_ver02.0) appropriate to the type of projectand drafted in line with JCM Guidelines for Developing PDD and MR(JCM_VN_GL_PDD_MR_ver02.0).
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The validation team (herein after the team) concludes that the PDD is completedusing the valid form in line with the JCM Guidelines for Developing PDD and MR.
C.2. Project description<Means of validation>3

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

The title of the proposed JCM project is “Introduction of high-efficient wire stranding
machines to the factory of YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD.” (herein after the
proposed JCM project).
High-efficient wire stranding machines with energy-saving measures such as
reinforced frames, friction reduction mechanism and application of smaller, lightweightparts and high-efficient motor are introduced to automotive wire production factory of
YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD. located near Ho Chi Minh (HCM) City. Introductionof such high-efficient wire stranding machines leads to reduction of electricity
consumption hence reduction of GHG emissions.
In the proposed JCM project, 32 wire stranding machines were installed in total. Wire
stranding machines introduced in the proposed JCM project are manufactured by
KINREI MACHINERY CO., LTD. The model number of the project wire stranding
machines installed is “DT 562.”
The project participant (herein after PP) of the host country is YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM
Co., LTD. (herein after YEV), and the PPs of Japan are YAZAKI Parts Co., LTD (herein
after YP) and YAZAKI corporation (herein after YAZAKI).
The proposed JCM project is expected to achieve the amount of 98 tCO2e emission
reduction in 2018, and 591 tCO2e emission reductions in 2019 and 2020, respectively.
The estimated emission reductions of the period between 2018 and 2020 are 1,280
tCO2e as calculated in the PDD.
The starting date of project operation is 01/11/2018 and the expected operational
lifetime of the proposed JCM project is 7 years. The equipment installed is classified
as “other equipment” of “Iron metal manufacturing industry” on a document, “Statutory
lifetime (i.e. legal durable years)” indicated by the website of National Tax Agency(NTA) as the evidence for the "Expected operational lifetime of project". Thus, the PPs
determines the expected operational lifetime based on the statutory lifetime by NTA.
The proposed JCM project was partially supported by the Ministry of theEnvironment, Japan (MOEJ) through the Financing Programme for JCM Model
projects, which provided financial support of less than half of the initial investment forthe projects in order to acquire JCM credits. The Japanese PPs transfer the technology
by the installation of new equipment and the training on operation of that installed
equipment through this project.
The team conducted document review, interviews and an on-site visit to confirm theaccuracy and completeness of the project description. The documents reviewed
during the validation are listed in Section E.2. of this report. The on-site visit including
the interviews with the PPs was undertaken on 15/01/2019. The interviewees are listed
in Section E.1.
4

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team concludes that the proposed JCM project description in the PDD is accurate
and complete.
C.3. Application of approved methodology(ies)<Means of validation>
The proposed JCM project applies the approved methodology JCM_VN_AM014"Introduction of energy efficient wire stranding machines to automotive wire production
factory" version.01.0. This methodology was approved by JC on 29 August 2018. It is
confirmed that the applied version, 01.0, of the methodology is valid at the time ofvalidation. The fulfilment of each eligibility criterion defined in the methodology is
confirmed by checking the documentation referred to in the PDD and by reviewing
comparable information.
Criterion 1: Wire stranding machine(s) with energy-saving measures such as
reinforced frames, friction reduction mechanism, energy efficient bow, and lightweightparts is newly installed or installed to replace existing wire stranding machine(s).
Through reviewing a document, “Operation manual of DT 562”, it was confirmed that
32 wire stranding machines with a model number “DT562” manufactured by KINREIMACHINERY CO., LTD. were introduced under the proposed JCM project. “DT 562”
is equipped with energy-saving measures such as reinforced frames, friction reduction
mechanism, energy efficient bow, and lightweight parts. During the on-site visit, thefollowing points were confirmed;-

32 wire stranding machines were newly installed under the proposed JCM project,-

Model number of all the wire stranding machines installed was “DT562”
Based on the confirmation mentioned above, the team confirms that Criterion 1 of theapproved methodology JCM_VN_AM014 is satisfied.
Criterion 2: Flange diameter of bobbin of a wire stranding machine installed in the5

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

project is 560mm.
Through the document review and the on-site visit, the team confirms that flange
diameter of bobbin of each wire stranding machine installed in the project is 560mm.
Criterion 3: Total motor capacity of a project wire stranding machine installed in the
project is equal to or less than 11.0 [kW].
Through the document review and the on-site visit, the team confirms that total motor
capacity of each wire stranding machine installed the project is 11.0 kW.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The

team

confirms

that

the

project

meets

each

eligibility

criterion

of

JCM_VN_AM014_ver01.0, which is the latest version of the methodology at the timeof the validation.
C.4. Emission sources and calculation of emission reductions<Means of validation>
The sources of reference emissions is electricity consumption by reference wire
stranding machines. The sources of project emissions is electricity consumption by
project wire stranding machines.
Through document review, it is confirmed that all the emission sources covered by
the applied methodology are included.
The

Monitoring

Plan

Sheet

(MPS)

has

been

prepared

by

using

JCM_VN_AM014_ver01.0.xlsx. The team confirms that it is not altered, and its
required fields are appropriately filled in.
As for two project specific parameters to be fixed ex ante - EFelec (CO2 emission factor
per consumed electricity [tCO2/kWh]) and ECR (Electricity consumption ratio per
production unit), the team assessed the estimated value for each of them by using
supporting documents including specifications for project wire stranding machine
provided by the PPs. Regarding EFelec, it is confirmed that the PPs apply the CO2
emission factor of grid electricity for 2016 (0.9185 tCO2/MWh) issued by Ministry of6

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

Natural Resources and Environment of Vietnam (MONRE) . Regarding ECR, the PPs
apply the default value, 1.51, to the proposed JCM project. The team determines thatthese estimated value for two parameters are fixed in line with the applied
methodology.
As for the parameters to be monitored ex-post, the PPs provide an estimated valueof ECPJ,i,p (Electricity consumption of project wire stranding machine i during the periodp) to complete the ex-ante estimation of CO2 emission reductions achieved by the
proposed JCM project in Table 3 of MPS (Input sheet). Regarding the assumption andthe value of ECPJ,i,p , an issue was raised and resolved as mentioned section below.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
(Issue raised as CL01)
It is confirmed through the review of MPS that the estimated value of ECP,J,i,p(Electricity consumption of project wire stranding machine i during the period p[MWh/p]) is 28.035 MWh/p. The PPs are requested to clarify the sources andassumptions of the estimated value (28.035 MWh/p).
(Summary of the response on CL01)
No evidence for 28.035 MWh/p was provided by the PPs. The value of ECP,J,i,p was
re-calculated based on the actual monitoring conducted by the PPs during November
and December 2018. As a result, the electricity consumption is revised to 39.454
MWh/p per one project wire stranding machine.
(Assessment result of the responses on CL01)
It is confirmed that the estimated value for ECP,J,i,p is appropriately revised to 39.454
MWh/p, which is based on the actual monitored value of the project wire stranding
machine. This issue is closed.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team reaches the conclusion that the selected emission sources and GHG types
are justified for the proposed JCM project. The team assesses the estimated values
for project-specific parameters both to be fixed ex-ante and ex-post in the MPS areconsidered reasonable in the context of the proposed JCM project. The issue raisedby the team is fully clarified, which resulted in a revision of the PDD and the MPS.

7

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

C.5. Environmental impact assessment<Means of validation>
The PDD states that no environmental impact assessment (EIA) is required for the
project. The PPs referred the following document to confirm the EIA procedures andrequirements in the host country;- Appendix II, Decree No.29/2011/ND-CP of April 18, 2011, providing strategic
environmental assessment, environmental impact assessment and environmental
protection commitment
Through review of the document above, an issue was raised and resolved as
mentioned below.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
(Issue raised as CL02)
Regarding of “Decree No.29/2011/ND-CP of April 18, 2011, providing strategic
environmental assessment, environmental impact assessment and environmental
protection commitment," it is not clear if this is the current requirement of EIA in
Vietnam. Thus it is not confirmed if no EIA is required for the proposed JCM project.
(Summary of the response on CL02)
Current EIA law in Vietnam is not “Decree No.29/2011/ND-CP of April 18, 2011” but“Decree No.18/2015/ND-CP, ON ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION PLANNING,
STRATEGICENVIRONMENTALASSESSMENT,ENVIRONMENTAL

IMPACTASSESSMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION PLANS of February 14,
2015.” The PPs confirm that no EIA is required to this project in Decree No.18.
(Assessment result of the responses on CL02)
It is confirmed that no environmental impact assessment is required for the proposed
JCM project in accordance with the current EIA law in the host country.
Therefore, this issue is closed.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team reaches the conclusion that no EIA is required to the proposed JCM projectin accordance with the regulation in Vietnam.

8

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

C.6. Local stakeholder consultation<Means of validation>
A local stakeholder consultation (LSC) meeting has been conducted to invite
comments from the stakeholders as below.
Date:

6th December 2017

Venue: YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD.
Lot C3-2, Block C3, Tan Phu Trung I.P, Tan Phu Trung Commune,
Cu Chi District, HCM City, Viet Nam
Time:

13:00-14:30

Agenda
1. Opening remarks
2. Introduction about YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD.
3. Introduction about JCM project
4. Introduction Technology and Facility
5. Q&A and collection of comments
6. Closing[Local stakeholders]No.
1Organization
YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD

Position
Chief of Engineering Department

2

YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD

3

YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD

Management department Regular
employee
Production department Manager

4

YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD

Staff[The PPs]The PPs: [Viet Nam] YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD.
[Japan] YAZAKI Parts Co., LTD.
[Japan] YAZAKI corporation
The comments received at the meeting were fully taken into account and the results
were reflected in the PDD. It was confirmed through the interview with the PPs at theon-site visit that the above-mentioned process and due steps taken for the local
stakeholder consultation were appropriate.

9JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team concludes that the LSC of the proposed JCM project has completed
appropriately under the EIA.
C.7. Monitoring<Means of validation>
Through the review of the MPS and Monitoring Structure Sheet (MSS), it is confirmedthat they are described in line with the applied methodology VN_AM014 ver 01.0.
The team confirms through the on-site visit that the electricity meter was set up foreach wire stranding machine. By the interview with the PPs at the on-site visit, it isconfirmed that the PPs monitor and record the electricity consumption data of the
project wire stranding machines by using a WEB system called “POP System”
developed by the PPs. The data monitored by the electricity meter is to be stored whenthe electricity data reaches more 0.1 kW automatically. The electricity data is stored
into a data server on a daily basis. This server delivers the data of actual operation to
POP System. It can be accessed via internet by the both PPs of Japan and Vietnam.
The data of electricity consumption is to be collected and stored by POP System on adaily basis.
With respect to the monitoring structure, through the document review and interviews
with JCM technical staff and JCM managers of the relevant departments of YEV, it was
confirmed that the monitoring plan is feasible and the means of implementation of themonitoring plan, including the data management and quality assurance and quality
control procedures, are sufficient for ex-post reporting and verification.
By the interview with the PPs at the on-site visit, it was found that the interval of
calibration or replacement of the electricity measuring equipment is determined to be
7 years according to the recommendation by the manufacture. The project wire
stranding machines have already operated for 2 years in the proposed JCM project,
and the PPs plan to replace the electricity measuring equipment within 5 years.
Regarding this interval, an issue was raised and resolved as mentioned section below.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
10

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0(Issue raised as CAR01)
The interval of replacement or calibration of electricity meter is not stated in the MPS.
Through the interview with the PPs at the on-site visit, the interval is to be 7 years
according to the manufacturer’s recommendation. The PPs are requested to provide
any document showing the manufacturer’s recommendation.
(Summary of the response on CAR01)
The PPs provided a letter in which the manufacture states that the expected lifetimeof the electricity meter is 10 years under the condition of 35 degrees or less and 24
hours power supply. Accordingly, the PPs added the 10-year interval of replacement
or calibration of electricity meter to the MPS.
(Assessment result of the responses on CAR01)
The team confirms that the document from manufacturer states the expected productlifetime is 10 years in case the temperature of the operational circumstance is 35
degrees or less and the power is supplied 24 hours per day. Considering actual
operational circumstance of the project, the PPs set the interval of replacement orcalibration of electricity meter as 7 years, which is less than 10 years. The teamconfirms that the interval is set in line with the manufacturer’s recommendation.
Therefore, this issue is closed.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team confirms that the monitoring plan of the proposed JCM project is in line withthe requirements of the methodology and/or PDD and Monitoring Guidelines. It is also
confirmed that the PPs have ability to implement the described monitoring plan andthe monitoring structure is feasible.
C.8. Modalities of Communication<Means of validation>
It is confirmed that the Modalities of Communication (MoC) has applied the latest
version of MoC form. The date of submission indicated in the MoC is 04/02/2019, and
it is considered to be valid. JQA also conducted interviews with the signatories of theModalities of Communication (MoC), and then identified the personnel and theiremployment status, including the specimen signatures. Therefore, the team confirmsthat the information of all the PPs is correctly completed in the MoC.

11

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team confirms that the MoC complies with all relevant forms and requirements.
C.9. Avoidance of double registration<Means of validation>
It is confirmed through the review of the relevant website (e.g. UNFCCC website,
Markit Environmental Registry, etc.) that the proposed JCM project has not beenregistered under other international climate mitigation mechanisms. The written
confirmation of the avoidance of double registration was also provided through thesigned MoC. The team cross-checked through the interview with the PPs at the onsite visit.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team confirms that the proposed JCM project is not registered under the otherinternational climate mitigation mechanisms at the stage of validation.
C.10. Start of operation<Means of validation>
In the PDD submitted for the invitation of public inputs as described in Section D, thestart date of operation is indicated as 01/11/2018. Through document review, it was
confirmed that 01/11/2018 is the day, on which 32 wire stranding machines wereoperated and the monitoring of the electric consumption was started. Through theinterview with the PPs during the on-site visit, the team cross-checked the starting dateof operation and confirmed that this date is not before January 1, 2013.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
12

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
The team confirms that the start of the operation is determined appropriately.
C.11. Other issues<Means of validation>
No other issue was identified.
<Findings>
Please state if CARs, CLs, or FARs are raised, and how they are resolved.
No outstanding issue was raised.
<Conclusion based on reporting requirements>
Please state conclusion based on reporting requirements.
Not applicable.

D. Information on public inputs
D.1. Summary of public inputs
The PDD of the proposed JCM project, which was submitted in line with the Project
Cycle Procedure, was made publicly available through the JCM website for public
inputs. The duration of call for public inputs on the PDD was 30 calendar days
subsequent to the publication of the PDD, and it started from 05/02/2019. The specific
JCM website is as below:
https://www.jcm.go.jp/vn-jp/projects/60
D.2. Summary of how inputs received have been taken into account by the project participants
No comment was received during the period of the public comments, covering
05/02/2019 to 06/03/2019. Therefore, no action is required to be taken into due
account by the PPs.

13

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

E. List of interviewees and documents received
E.1. List of interviewees
Name

Position

Organization

Mr. Naoki YANAGAWA

Factory Manager

Yazaki ESD Vietnam Co., Ltd

Mr. Takao NAKAGAME

Engineering

Yazaki ESD Vietnam Co., Ltd

Department Manager
Mr. Masaru YAMAMOTO

Production

Yazaki ESD Vietnam Co., Ltd

Department Manager
Mr. Hiroyuki WATANABEManager, A/W NYS

Yazaki Parts Co., Ltd

Promotion Office
Mr. Fumiya SATO

Associate

Mitsubishi UFJ Research andConsulting Co., Ltd

E.2. List of documents received
No.

Document Title (including version No. and/or issue date)1

Project Design Document (draft) (JCM_VN_F_PDD_ver02.0.docx)

2

Monitoring Plan Sheet and Monitoring Structure Sheet (draft)(JCM_VN_AM014_ver01.0.xlsx)

3

Modalities of communications statement submitted together with the PDD for
public comments (JCM_VN_F_MoC_ver02.0.pdf)

4Modalities of communications statement, a validated version for submissionof request for registration

5

JCM Approved Methodology JCM_VN_AM014 “ Introduction of energy
efficient wire stranding machines to automotive wire production factory, ver.
01.0”

6

JCM_VN_AM014

Monitoring Plan Sheet

7

JCM Glossary of Terms (JCM_VN_Glossary_ver01.0)

8

JCM Project Cycle Procedure (JCM_VN_PCP_ver03.0)

9

JCM Modalities of Communication Statement Form
(JCM_VN_F_MoC_ver02.0.pdf)

10

JCM Guidelines for Developing Project Design Document and Monitoring
Report (JCM_VN_GL_PDD_MR_ver02.0)

11

JCM Project Design Document Form (JCM_VN_F_PDD_ver02.0.pdf)

12

JCM Guidelines for Validation and Verification
14

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0(JCM_VN_GL_VV_ver01.0.pdf)
13

JCM Validation Report Form (JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0.docx)

14

Location information of the proposed JCM project

15

Company profile of YAZAKI EDS VIETNAM Co., LTD.

16

Company profile of YAZAKI Parts Co., LTD.

17

Company profile of YAZAKI corporation

18

1.Evidence of starting date of project operation
2.Report of wire stranding machine installation

19

Statutory lifetime (i.e. legal durable years) indicated by the website of
National Tax Agency (NTA) as the evidence for the Expected operational
lifetime of project,https://www.keisan.nta.go.jp/survey/publish/34255/faq/34311/faq_34360.php

20Operation Manual of DT562

21

Blueprint of Flange diameter of bobbin of a wire stranding machine (560mm)

22

Specification of DT562

23

Layout of 32 project wire stranding machines

24

Degree No.29/2011/ND-CP of April 18, 2011, providing strategic
environmental assessment, environmental impact assessment andenvironmental protection commitment25

1.Invitation letter for Local Stakeholder Meeting
2.participant list
3.Agenda of Local Stakeholder Meeting
4.Minutes of Local Stakeholder Meeting26

1.Presentation material for Local Stakeholder Meeting - the proposed JCM
project
2.Presentation material for Local Stakeholder Meeting - JCM project scheme

27

1.Source of electricity consumption of project wire stranding machine[MWh/p] - Expectation electricity consumption (April 2019 - March 2020)
2.Evidence of electricity consumption of project wire stranding machine Operation hour

28

User manual of smart electric energy monitor

29

Evidence document of CO2 emission factor (0.9185 tCO2/MWh) issued by
Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment of Vietnam (MONRE) in
2016

30

Actual data sheet of electric power consumption of project wire stranding
machine (Nov. and Dec. 2018)15

JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

31

Degree No.18/2015/ND-CP of February 14, 2015, prescribing environmental
protection master plan, strategic environmental assessment, environmental
impact assessment and environmental protection plan

32

Evidence for lifetime of smart electric energy monitor and calibration issued
by OMRON Corporation

33

Project Design Document (revised) (JCM_VN_F_PDD_ver02.0.docx)

34

Monitoring Plan Sheet and Monitoring Structure Sheet (revised)(JCM_VN_AM014_ver01.0.xlsx)

16JCM_VN_F_Val_Rep_ver01.0

Annex Certificates or curricula vitae of TPE’s validation team members, technicalexperts and internal technical reviewers
Please attach certificates or curricula vitae of TPE’s validation team members, technical experts
and internal technical reviewers.
Statement of competenceStatement of competence
Name:

Ms. Sachiko Hashizume

Name:

Mr. Hiroshi Motokawa

Qualified and authorized by Japan Quality Assurance Organization.

Qualified and authorized by Japan Quality Assurance Organization.

Function

Function

Date of qualification

Date of qualification
Validator

2015/11/20

Validator

2014/12/22

Verifier

2015/11/20

Verifier

2014/12/22

Team leader

2018/6/22

Team leader

2014/12/22

Technical area within sectoral scopes

Technical area within sectoral scopes

Date of qualification

Date of qualification
TA 1.1. Thermal energy generation

2015/11/20

TA 1.1. Thermal energy generation

2014/12/22

TA 1.2. Renewables

2015/11/20

TA 1.2. Renewables

2014/12/22

TA 3.1. Energy demand

2015/11/20

TA 3.1. Energy demand

2014/12/22

TA 4.1. Cement and lime production-

TA 4.1. Cement and lime production

2014/12/22

TA 4.6. Other manufacturing industries-

TA 4.6. Other manufacturing industries

2014/12/22

TA 5.1. Chemical industry-

TA 5.1. Chemical industry

TA 10.1. Fugitive emissions from oil and gas-

TA 10.1. Fugitive emissions from oil and gas

TA 13.1. Solid waste and wastewater
TA 14.1. Afforestation and reforestation

2015/11/20-

17

TA 13.1. Solid waste and wastewater
TA 14.1. Afforestation and reforestation

2014/12/22-