Some Side Effects of the HPV Vaccine
what you can expect following mass vaccination of school children

by Craig Paardekooper

Data source••••••

4,486,467 individual people records
14,987,664 drug-symptom associations
19,247 unique symptoms
1,504 unique drug brand names, and3,163 unique ingredient lists.
Each drug is represented by a name consisting of a single word

This dataset enables us to rank drugs by the incidence of any adverse symptom.
In this document I look at symptoms associated with the HPV vaccines – GARDASIL,GARDASIL 9, and CERVARIX.

Dataset Downloads
Original set of 4088 csv files - here
Data files concatenated into one big file - here
One big file after data has been cleaned and organised – here
A fourth dataset is available. It is a pivot table showing the safety signals
for any of 19,245 symptoms for 1504 different drugs. It also shows every drug
sorted in order of its safety signal for any chosen symptom. This dataset has asize of only 4Mb (zipped) - here

SearchA search engine has been created that ranks drugs by the incidence of any chosen
symptom or provides a list of all symptoms for any drug - here

AUTHENTICITY OF EACH RECORD

Each record in the dataset has an ICSR, meaning an “Individual Case Safety
Report” – each report being a unique person. There are 4,486,467 reports in the
final dataset.
If you input the ID number into the URL below, then you can view the report on
the EMA website.
https://dap.ema.europa.eu/xmlpserver/PHV%20DAP/Reports/ICSR.xdo?_xpf=&_xt=form&
SR_ID=10011128660&_xpt=1&_xf=pdf
In this example, the URL is for the report with ID 10011128660. It is a pdf
hosted on the European Medical Association website.
This shows that the data is not made up. Rather, each row of data has a reportthat you can verify using the link provided.
Each downloaded report looks like this –63% of reports were submitted by healthcare professionals, and a further 35% ofreports were submitted by non-healthcare professionals - admin staff in theemploy of hospitals, private medical practices, or care services. So this datais to be taken seriously.Method of Detecting Excess Incidence of a Symptom

The Proportional Reporting Ratio is the accepted method for detecting excess
incidence of a symptom used by the Center for Disease Control, and by theEuropean Medicines Agency.
If the Proportional Reporting Ratio (PRR) for a symptom > 2, this means thatthe reporting incidence of that symptom is more than 2 x greater than theaverage rate for all other drugs.
•••

PRR > 2 = reported incidence is more than 2 x that for other drugs.
PRR > 3 = reported incidence is more than 3 x that for other drugs.
PRR > 4 = reported incidence is more than 4 x that for other drugs.

A PRR greater than 2 is regarded as a SAFETY SIGNAL by regulatory authorities
and requires –1. CAUTION
2. FURTHER INVESTIGATION

Results

Table1 : PRR Rates for each symptom
PRR > 2 = reported incidence is more than 2 x that for other drugs.
PRR > 3 = reported incidence is more than 3 x that for other drugs.
PRR > 4 = reported incidence is more than 4 x that for other drugs.

SYMPTOM

Relative Incidence(Proportional Reporting Ratio)
GARDASILCERVARIXGARDASIL 9

Demyelination
Autoimmune
DisorderMyelitis
Transverse
Cognitive
Disorder

11.96

-

6.05

4.81

2.91

5.49

8.79

-

4.06

7.19

8.78

1.09

Guillain Barre

6.89

2.86

5.25

SeizureDisturbance ofAttention
Encephalitis
Impaired Work
AbilityMemoryImpairment

6.35

3.24

4.91

5.29

3.18

1.16

5.16

3.59

4.05

4.11

-

0.66

4

3.99

0.83

Paralysis

3.87

1.98

1.82

Disability
Mental Disorder
Motor
Dysfunction
Speech DisorderMultiple
Sclerosis

3.25
2.67

1.43
1.19

1.5

2.66

5.84

1.77

2.35

1.15

1.58

2.33

0.89

0.96

2.23--

2.2

10.48

-

1.9

1.43

1.79

1.51

-

2.17

1.34

2.2

1.53

Psychomotor
Hyperactivity
MentalImpairment
TremorMental Status
Changes
Palsy

The excel spreadsheets for each of these symptoms can be viewed here.

Demyelination

HPV vaccines such as GARDASIL, GARDASIL 9 and CERVARIX are associated with aprocess called demyelination.
All nerve fibers (axons) are surrounded by an insulating layer called a myelin
sheath. Demyelination is where this myelin sheath is attacked by your own
immune system causing and nerve signal transmission to be disrupted – leading
to motor, sensory and cognitive disorders.

The results of demyelination are –1. Cognitive disorders – such as disturbance of attention, memory
impairment, mental impairment, speech disorders
2. Motor disorders – such as transverse myelitis, impaired work ability,disability, motor dysfunction, multiple sclerosis, tremor, palsy
3. Brain disorders – encephalitis, may also impact visual, auditory andtactile nerves
In the Eudra-vigilance dataset used here, the reported incidence ofdemyelination after HPV vaccination is about 12 x that for other drugs.

All symptoms with a PRR greater than 2 are occurring with a significant excess
compared to with other drugs.
An excess incidence of a symptom with a particular drug compared to other drugs
indicates that the drug in question may be causing that symptom. If the symptom
is serious, then administration of the drug should be delayed pending
investigation.

Continued administration of a medication known to be associated withexcess incidence of serious symptoms compared to other drugs, may put
children’s health at risk.

Things to watch out for

PRR measures the incidence rate relative to other drugs. In this section I show
the absolute incidence rates for reported symptoms.
The most commonly reported symptoms following HPV vaccination are movement
disorders such as seizures, tremors, paralysis, Guilain-barre and multiplesclerosis. Commonly reported cognitive symptoms include attention deficit,memory impairment.
Teachers should watch out for these symptoms occurring in HPV vaccinated school
children. Please keep a record of such incidents, and report them immediatelyto your school head-master or head-mistress. Individual case details can also
be submitted to craig@howbad.info
Table 2 : Incidence Rates (Incidence rates will increase with multiple doses)

SYMPTOM

Reporting Incidence Rates(Proportional Reporting Ratio)
GARDASILCERVARIXGARDASIL 9

Demyelination
Autoimmune
Myelitis
Transverse

1 in 1297
1 in 315

1 in 512

1 in 2427
1 in 273

1 in 1655-

1 in 3436

Guillain Barre

1 in 370

1 in 865

1 in 474

Paralysis

1 in 227

1 in 446

1 in 500

1 in 324

1 in 261

1 in 2066

1 in 50

1 in 1001 in 64

1 in 156

1 in 256

1 in 688

1 in 588

1 in 830

1 in 736

1 in 619-

1 in 3759

1 in 224

1 in 223

1 in 1058

1 in 1156
1 in 1170

1 in 2597
1 in 2598

1 in 2066

1 in 2525

1 in 1153

1 in 3759

1 in 755

1 in 1538

1 in 1116

1 in 391

1 in 1013

1 in 943

1 in 3558--

1 in 1960

1 in 419-

1 in 176

1 in 232

1 in 185

1 in 3690-

1 in 2577

Cognitive
DisorderSeizureDisturbance ofAttention
Encephalitis
Impaired Work
AbilityMemoryImpairment
Disability
Mental Disorder
Motor
DysfunctionSpeech DisorderMultiple
Sclerosis
Psychomotor
Hyperactivity
MentalImpairment
TremorMental Status
Changes

Palsy1 in 1315

1 in 798

1 in 1146

Seizure is reported most often BECAUSE it is the most obvious symptom, visible
to all. Other symptoms are less frequently reported because they are harder todetect.

Risks and Benefits

Risk : Children may suffer cognitive, motor, sensory and brain disorders fromthe HPV vaccine resulting in lifelong disability.
A child with cognitive or motor disabilities will have impaired work ability,
and will be an intense burden upon poor rural families, since they will be
unable to bring in an income or help with household or farm chores.

Benefit : Children who are sexually active may be protected against a sexuallytransmitted disease (HPV)
Only those children who are sexually active would get any benefit - though eventhis benefit will be offset by the disorders described above.
Children who are not sexually active (such as children who adhere to a
Christian or Muslim moral code) will gain limited benefit from protection
against a sexually transmitted disease, but may suffer significant nerve damage
from the HPV vaccine.

For Teachers
This is a call for school heads and teachers –1. to ensure that children and parents are provided with adequate
information regarding risks, so students and parents can make an informed
choice. (this is both a legal obligation, and also an obligation under
God’s laws as outlined in the Koran and in the Bible).
2. to exercise leniency, compassion and respect for their right to decide if
a student or parent objects to this vaccination on the grounds of safety
or on the grounds of constitutional right.

For Parents
Parents should 1. be aware of these risks.
2. explain the relevant risks to their child.
3. ensure that their decision, to vaccinate their child or not, is madeknown to school authorities.

Legal Aspects

It is a crime against your local community to –1. PERSIST IN ADMINISTERING a substance that is associated with an excess
incidence of grievous bodily harm.
2. NEGLECT TO INVESTIGATE suspected harms of a substance that you areadministering to others.
3. FAIL TO INFORM parent/s and children of risks of harm in a timelyfashion.
4. ADMINISTER WITHOUT CONSENT of both parent/s and child.