INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANGEWMON ATI ONAL G REENHOUSE GAS I NVENTORIES PROGRAM ME

UNEP

IPCC NGGIP-LULUCF Programme
Second Authors/Experts Meeting on Good Practice Guidance forLand-Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry (Task 1)
andFirst Authors/Experts Meeting on Definitions for Direct HumanInduced Degradation of Forests and Devegetation of Other
Vegetation Types, and Methodological Options toInventory and Report Emissions Resulting
from these Activities (Task 2)

Meeting Report

Tampere, Finland(10 – 12 July 2002)

Supporting material prepared for consideration by the Intergovernmental Panelon Climate Change. This supporting material has not been subject to formal
IPCC review and approval process.

Acknowledgements

This report was prepared by Riitta Pipatti, Leandro Buendia, Kiyoto Tanabe, Todd Ngara,
Kyoko Miwa, and Akiko Kawase of the Technical Support Unit for the IPCC National
Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme. In preparing this report, consultations were madewith TFB Co-Chairs: Taka Hiraishi and Thelma Krug, and with the members of the LULUCF
Steering Group: Michael Gytarsky, Dina Kruger, and Jim Penman. Contributions were also
received from Co-chairs of Breakout Groups: Annette Freibauer, Bill Hohenstein, SamuelKainja, Timo Karjalainen, Rodel Lasco, Omar Masera, Gert-Jan Nabuurs, Ian Noble, Newton
Paciornik, N.H. Ravindranath, Kristin Rypdal, Bernhard Schlamadinger, and Pete Smith. We
are also grateful for the contributions from rapporteurs of breakout groups and Renate Christ of
the IPCC Secretariat, and all the experts from different countries, including those frominternational organisations.

2

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page
Executive Summary............................................................................................................... 4
1 Background and Objectives ................................................................................................ 6
2 Opening Session and Organisation of the Meeting ............................................................. 7
3 Issues/Outcomes of Breakout Group Discussions.............................................................. 10
4 Conclusion........................................................................................................................ 12
Attachments …………………………………………………………………………………. 13

3

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The First Authors/Experts Meeting on Good Practice Guidance for Land-Use, Land-Use
Change and Forestry (Task 1) in March 2002, in Eisenach, Germany, accomplished substantive
work on Chapters 2 to 5 with an accelerated handling of Chapter 2 (Basis for consistent
Representation of Land Areas) to produce the zero-order draft. The meeting discussed theinitial draft outline for each chapter of the report, paying special attention to consistency andharmonisation requirements and explored the availability of scientific and other materials. An
agreement was reached on the proposed six broad categories of land use for reporting on land
areas (i.e. forest land, cropland/arable/tillage, rangelands/pasture land, wetland, settlements,and other land). Authors were assigned to specific tasks and the gaps in required expertise wereidentified. Timeline for the development of extended outlines for sections and subsections andthe preparation of the zero-order drafts for each chapter were set and the contact persons toenhance discussions within and among chapters were named. The meeting came up with atimetable to prepare for the Second Authors/Experts Meeting to be held in Tampere, Finland, in
July 2002.
This Second Authors/Experts Meeting on Task 1, 10-12 July 2002, in Tampere, Finland, aimed
to advance the drafting of the report with the view to produce a pre-first-order draft of Chapter
2 and zero-order drafts of Chapters 3, 4, and 5. It also aimed to check for consistency among
chapters, identify missing parts or issues, and the approach on how to fill the gaps before theThird Authors/Experts Meeting to be held in October, 2002 in Brazil.
A parallel Authors/Experts meeting was held on Definitions for Direct Human-Induced
Degradation of Forests and Devegetation of Other Vegetation Types, and Methodological
Options to Inventory and Report Emissions Resulting from these Activities (also known as
Task 2). This meeting aimed to develop a detailed table of contents for the work, assign authors
to specific tasks, set a time schedule for the drafting, as well as preparing for the Second
Authors/Experts Meeting to be held in October in Brazil in parallel with the Task 1 Third
Authors/Experts meeting referred to above.
The two meetings were held in Tampere Hall, Tampere, Finland and were kindly hosted by
Finland’s Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry and Ministry of Environment. One hundred-four
persons, including ninety-six authors/experts from governments and international organisations,participated in the meetings.
The meeting advanced the drafting of the Task 1 report. All the chapters of Task 1 have now
become more cohesive. Cross-cutting issues were discussed and clarified. Consistency among
chapters was enhanced. Most grey areas were ironed out and missing gaps or issues wereadequately addressed. For Task 2, considerable progress was done to prepare a draft outline
and table of contents; elaborate the content of different chapters; identify links to Task 1; andassign authors to do the drafting.
Task 1 and Task 2 authors agreed with the schedules to prepare for the first-order drafts for
combined Governments/Experts review to take place between December 2002 and January
2003 (8 weeks). Task 1 group agreed to provide, by 26 July 2002, the summary of majorrevisions and cross-cutting issues and the list of Contributing Authors in areas or sections
lacking expertise. The Task 2 authors agreed to come up with a more detailed outline by thesame date. The pre-Brazil drafts for Task 1 Chapters 2 to 5 are expected to be ready by 15
September 2002 while Task 1 Chapter 1(to be drafted by Chapter 1 CLA’s) and Task 2 (all4

chapters) by 23 September 2002. Overall, the participants are confident that the first-zero orderdrafts for both tasks will be ready and in complete form before the Brazil meeting in October
2002.

5

IPCC NGGIP-LULUCF Programme
Second Authors/Experts Meeting on Good Practice Guidance
for Land-Use, Land-Use Change And Forestry (Task 1)
andFirst Authors/Experts Meeting on Definitions for Direct Human-Induced
Degradation of Forests and Devegetation of Other Vegetation Types,
and Methodological Options to Inventory and Report Emissions
Resulting from these Activities (Task 2)
Tampere, Finland, 10-12 July 2002
1 BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVESIn accordance with the work programme for the development of Good Practice Guidance forLand-Use, Land-Use Change, and Forestry (also known as Task 1), which was approved at
IPCC XVIII, in September 2001, Wembley, UK, the First Authors/Experts Meeting was heldon 12-14 March 2002, in Eisenach, Germany.
The Eisenach Meeting accomplished substantive work on chapters two to five with anaccelerated handling of Chapter 2 (Basis for consistent Representation of Land areas) to
produce the zero-order draft. The meeting discussed the initial draft outline for each chapter ofthe report, paying special attention to consistency and harmonisation requirements and explored
the availability of scientific and other materials. An agreement was reached on the proposed six
broad categories of land use for reporting on land areas (i.e. forest land, cropland/arable/tillage,
rangelands/pasture land, wetland, settlements, and other land). Authors were assigned to
specific tasks and gaps in required expertise were identified. Timeline for the development ofextended outlines for sections and subsections and the preparation of the zero-order drafts foreach chapter were set and contact persons to enhance discussions within and among chapterswere named. The meeting came up with a timetable to prepare for the Second Authors/Expert
Meeting in Finland in July 2002.
The IPCC, also in response to the invitation of the UNFCCC, in its decision 11/CP.7 in the
Marrakesh Accords, prepared a work plan to develop definitions for direct human-induced
degradation of forests and devegetation of other vegetation types, and methodological options
to inventory and report emissions resulting from these activities. This task is known as Task 2.
The implementation of Task 2 will be done in close cooperation with Task 1 to ensure
consistency of methodologies and products.
For Task 1, the meeting aimed to advance the drafting as much as possible by producing a prefirst-order draft of Chapter 2 and zero-order drafts of Chapters 3, 4, and 5. It also aimed tocheck for consistency among chapters, identify missing parts or issues, and the approach on
how to fill the gaps before the Third Authors/Experts Meeting.
For Task 2, the objective was to develop detailed table of contents, assign authors to specifictasks, prepare a timetable for the drafting, as well as to prepare for the Second Authors/Experts
Meeting.

6

2 OPENING SESSION AND ORGANISATION OF THE MEETINGThe meetings were held in Tampere Hall, Tampere, Finland and were hosted by the Finland’s
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry and Ministry of Environment. The Technical Support Unitof the IPCC National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme (IPCC-NGGIP-TSU)
coordinated the meeting with support from the local organisers.
The Task 1 and Task 2 Authors/Experts meetings were preceded by a CLA (Co-ordinating
Lead Authors) meeting, held on 9 July 2002, with members of the LULUCF Steering Group,
the Co-chairs of the Task Force Bureau (TFB) and the TSU. The objectives of the meetingwere to prepare for the main meetings and to discuss the content of the work, especially thelinkages between the Chapters of Task 1, and also between Task 1 and 2. The CLAs also met
during the course of the main meetings to discuss how to advance in the work and to be
informed of the progress in issues of relevance to all Chapters.
One hundred-four persons, including ninety-six authors/experts from governments andinternational organisations, participated in the meeting (Attachment A). The meeting waschaired by TFB Co-chairs Taka Hiraishi (who also gave the Opening Remarks) and Thelma
Krug. Mr. Timo Kotkasaari, Director General of the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry of
Finland, gave the Welcome Remarks. Riitta Pipatti, Head of the IPCC-NGGIP-TSU, presented
the progress of Task 1 drafting since the First Meeting Authors/Experts in March 2002. She
gave background information of the Task 2 project and its link to Task 1 and informed theparticipants about the discussion at the side-event on LULUCF which was held at SBSTA16 inJune 2002. She also presented the objectives and expected outputs of the Tampere meeting.
Claudio Forner, of the UNFCCC Secretariat, presented the reporting requirements for
LULUCF under Article 7 of the Kyoto Protocol (KP) and gave an update on the discussions in
the Convention regarding afforestation and reforestation under the Clean Development
Mechanism. He also presented briefly some background information for the work on Task 2.
The rest of the morning session was devoted to presentations by Task 1 CLAs on the progressof each chapter:
Chapter 2 Basis for consistent representation of land areas (Jim Penman, UK) – There islittle advice in the Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories(IPCC Guidelines) on estimating and reporting of land areas. Parties to the UNFCCC use
different information sources and methods in their calculations (e.g. annual census data,
periodic surveys, and remote sensing). The challenges faced by Chapter 2 authors are: 1) how
to make best use of this information taking into account the national circumstances and forsome Parties the Kyoto Protocol requirements; and 2) the need for flexibility in using the
LUCF categories (5A to 5E) in the IPCC Guidelines to bring together above- and belowground biomass. The six broad categories of land use, which were developed at the First
Authors/Experts Meeting, are consistent with the IPCC Guidelines. These categories are
viewed to give flexibility for national circumstances and would provide the link between theabove and below ground carbon pools. The categories would allow mapping onto the LUCF
categories in the IPCC Guidelines and would provide the framework for KP accounting.
The current draft provides the four basic approaches for representing land areas: 1) existingdata on an activity by activity basis; 2) existing data on an activity by activity basis extended byan overall check on area balances; 3) land use change matrix; and 4) grid based identification of
all land. The areas in the current draft that will be developed further are: more consideration onwhat is good practice, optimum use of data sources, sampling strategy, sampling and carbon

7dynamics, and documentation.
Issues raised:-

There is a need to elaborate how the broad categories can contribute to linking themethodologies for above and below ground biomass better together than at present.

-

The need to include guidance on documenting or reporting in Chapter 2 was discussed.

Chapter 3 LUCF Good Practice (Gert-Jan Nabuurs, The Netherlands; supplemented by
N. H. Ravindranath, India) –Chapter 3 will contain most methods to be applied also in
Chapter 4 , but will not address which part of the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions may fallunder KP. The current draft has the following structure: the main entrance is the land use type(staying the same or coming from another land use), the next path is the carbon compartment(above ground biomass, soils carbon), and the non-CO2 emissions are dealt with in a separate
subchapter. Decision trees to guide the users to choose appropriate level of detail are included.
The draft contains first rough compilation of sections by land use types with much emphasis on
forests. More emphasis is needed for the sections of rangelands, settlements, and other lands,
and on default data sets. Better linkages between the biomass and soil sections are needed
across all tiers, observing consistency with the IPCC Guidelines.
The draft of Chapter 3 needs harmonisation of tier levels between vegetation types as well astier levels between Chapters 3 and 4. More emphasis on lower tiers is needed, but also the text
on the higher tiers needs improvement. Inclusion of unmanaged lands to facilitate the work in
Chapter 4 will be considered. A lot of redrafting and editorial work needs to be done totransform the draft into a good handbook.
Issues raised:-

There are difficulties in interpreting the IPCC Guidelines; the challenge is to develop
simple and practical guidance;-

There is a need to a balanced approach to the tiers; we cannot just concentrate on Tier 1
and leave out higher tiers; other tiers have to be elaborated; key source categories
should use higher tiers;-

The carbon pools are not clearly identified and further clarification is required.

Chapter 4 Supplementary Methods (Bernhard Schlamadinger, Austria) – The generalapproaches in drafting the chapter were to build on Chapter 2, in identifying lands, and to build
on Chapter 3 for methodologies in establishing estimates of stock changes on these lands.
There are still several issues to be resolved as to reporting and land accounting rules. Land canbe in multiple categories during the commitment period and that land can shift from one
category to another. Chapter 3 categories refer to current land use while Chapter 4 focuses on
combination of past and present land use. While Chapter 3 provides methods for stock-change
assessment, Chapter 4’s first step is to determine lands under Afforestation, Reforestation, andDeforestation (ARD) in each year.
The current draft needs harmonisation of tiers across activities. It needs to incorporate

8

uncertainties and the key categories concept, and has to reduce overlap with Chapters 2 and 3.
It needs to give more focus on geographical location of boundaries; verifiable information todemonstrate those pools which are not accounted for and are not sources of GHGs; distinctionof harvesting/disturbance from deforestation; harvesting on AR lands; and information todemonstrate that GHGs from activities selected under Article 3.4 of KP are not also accounted
for under Art 3.3 of the KP.
The draft proposed four methods of identifying AR lands. The Forest Management section has
the write-up available for methodological issues, but has to be harmonised with other sectionsof Chapter 4, as well as other chapters. The sections on non-CO2 emissions, completeness, anduncertainty assessment need more text. For the sections on Crop Management (CM), Grazing
management (GM), and Revegetation (RV), a move from scientific text to good practiceguidance type text will be done. These sections will also aim to provide more examples on how
to apply the guidance. On the section of LULUCF Projects, there is a need to define therelationship with national GHG accounting. This section needs to develop new methodologies
and reporting guidance as the IPCC Guidelines do not cover Projects. There is a need to avoid
overlaps with other chapters/sections as regards the measurement and monitoring of carbon
stocks. More work is needed on non-CO2 GHG and on uncertainties related to Projects.

Issues raised:-

The prioritisation of Article 3.3 before Article 3.4 was discussed;-

Potential overlaps between forest management and agro-forestry have to be addressedin the drafting.

Chapter 5 Cross-cutting issues (Kristin Rypdal, Norway) – Chapter 5 subchapters are notyet complete. The key category concept under Methodological Choice, instead of key source,
has to be expanded to include sinks. The use of the concept in decision trees on the choice of
methods in Chapters 3 and 4 was proposed. The KP issues need to be clarified. On QA/QC andtime series consistency, the results from this meeting will be used to assess the practicalusefulness to further integrate LUCF specific issues. It was noted that these areas areoverlapping and not consistently addressed in Chapters 3 and 4. Much input is needed in theverification section. There is a need to clarify the purpose of the verification text; filter out
more political issues; and identify what is practical and consistent with other chapters. The
uncertainty assessment has to be part of all methods and require more thinking.
Issues raised:-

The term “verification” is also used in the CDM context; the suggestion was to use theterm “scientific verification”;-

Clear distinction or definition is needed in using the term “verification” as opposed to“validation”.

The Task 2 issues were not discussed in detail as the authors were only starting to plan thedetailed content of the work.
During the days that followed there were schedules for breakout group sessions, CLA meetings9and Plenary Sessions. Participants were grouped into eight main break-out groups (AttachmentB) so as to advance the drafting of each chapter, resolve comments on the current draft, identify
gaps and cross-cutting issues, harmonise the chapters, and plan for the preparation of the firstorder draft for the Brazil meeting in October 2002. Some joint breakout group sessions were
held to address overlapping issues and links between chapters.

3 ISSUES/OUTCOMES OF BREAKOUT GROUP DISCUSSIONS
BOG 1 - Degradation and Devegetation Issues (Task 2)
The group benefited from the presentation of Dieter Schoene, of the United Nations Food andAgriculture Organization (FAO), on the conclusions of the FAO expert meeting on
harmonizing forest-related definitions (23-25 January 2002). It elaborated the Table ofContents and a draft outline for each chapter (Attachment C). It discussed the issue of reportingand documentation for areas like harvested wood. It identified the availability of scientificmaterial and possible overlaps and links to Task 1.
For Task 2 Chapter 2, on definitions for degradation of forests and devegetation of othervegetation types, the group provided a general description of activities and addressed regional
differences in activities and the scale of their effects. For Task 2 Chapter 3, on methodologicaloptions to estimate emissions, the group agreed that the chapter can build on Task 1 Chapter 3,
but will emphasize issues which are specific to degradation/devegetation. Task 2 Chapter 4, on
implications of different methodological options to accounting under the provisions of Art. 3.4of the Kyoto Protocol, needs to work closely with authors of Chapter 4 of Task 1. The groupassigned writing teams to each chapter and agreed on the timetable for the Task 2 report
preparation.

BOG 2 - Basis for Consistent Representation of Land Areas
The group reviewed the main text and developed guidance on relating land classifications usednationally to the six broad categories. There is a need to take Chapter 3 draft into account when
finalising the mapping tables. The KP mapping tables should be detailed and would depend on
the outcome of Chapter 4. There is a need to rationalise the six categories by better treatment of“other wooded land”; more clarity on wetlands, and to separate natural lakes and reservoirs.
The reporting on savannahs (i.e. to arable land or grassland) also needed clarification.
The use of the word ‘approaches’ was preferred to ‘formats’. Revisions were made on thedecision trees and on the description of Approaches 1-4 (see pages 7-8, Chapter 2) for greater
clarity on practical procedures. The issue of how Chapter 2 approaches can be related to thetiers in other chapters was discussed. To prepare for the first-order draft, greater precision (lesstentative) and simplification (KIS principle) will be observed. The new decision tree will take
into account optimal use of data sources. Some elaboration of the text on sampling will beneeded. Documentation will be addressed and revised classification and adjustment procedures
will be done for transitional classes.

10

BOG 3A - Forest lands, and rangelands/pasture land; and BOG 3B - Cropland,
wetland/tundra, urban, and other developed lands
The two groups started with a joint session to resolve comments by reviewers on the whole ofChapter 3. When needed, the two groups broke out into three sub-groups: biomass, soils, andnon-CO2. The inclusion of the generic issues in the introductory chapter was proposed to avoid
repetition and to shorten the chapters. The generic issues include how to map explicitly back to
the IPCC Guidelines; harmonise tiers (Section 3.1 was to provide a generic description of thetiers/methods); link biomass with soil carbon, and products; definitions of pools; improve thedefault values1; and how to deal with uncertainty.
There were presentations and discussions on harvested wood, croplands, grazing lands andshrub lands, wetlands, and settlements. There were discussions on the issue of how to link
Chapter 4 ARD with Chapter 3; how to treat litters; where peat lands and wetlands should be
addressed. A paper on tier definitions was also presented and discussed. The BOG members
agreed on the importance of getting appropriate Contributing Authors (CAs) to collectlocal/regional data/information.
The group identified priorities to work on: concentrate on instructions (cook book); identify
new default data; cross-walks to the IPCC Guidelines (reporting tables); complete verification,
uncertainties, reporting and documentation, and consistency sections with Chapter 5 authors;and incorporate the agreed tiers structures in the flow charts. The group identified andharmonised tier levels taking into account the methodology, parameters/coefficients, activity
data, and additional documentation requirements. The time schedule was set for 15 September
2002 to come up with the first-order draft.

BOG 4A - Afforestation, Reforestation, and Deforestation (ARD), and Forest
Management; BOG 4B - Revegetation, Cropland and Grassland Management; BOG 4C LULUCF Projects
On ARD and FM, the group shifted many sections to generic, introductory sections to reduce
repetition and to shorten the text. It made progress in classifying lands, but has still to come up
with wording and rationale to avoid prioritization of activities under Art. 3.4 of KP. It
developed better decision trees, identified remaining gaps, and assigned writing tasks. The
issue of disturbances was discussed as well as the issue on “managed forest” versus “forest
management”.
On cropland management, grazing land management and revegetation, the main achievement
was the alignment of the tier structure with Chapter 3 and the partial revision of the text inaccordance with the revised tiers. The next task would be to expand and enhance ‘grazing land’and ‘revegetation’ sections; to evaluate the IPCC Guidelines’ default coefficients with someauthors of Chapter 3; and to consider influences on emissions of non-CO2 gases where they are
not explicitly covered in the Agriculture or other chapters of the IPCC Guidelines.
On Projects, the section was restructured taking into account the project boundaries,
1

A question was raised about criteria for default data to be included in the report. This issue was forwarded to
CLA meeting. CLA meeting concluded that the precedent practice should be followed, namely not only the peerreviewed data but also the data submitted by authors/experts in an appropriate manner may be accepted. The
source of the default data should always be supplied.

11

measurement, link with national inventories, QA/QC, uncertainty, and reporting. Further
discussions were made on the issues of Articles 6 and 12 differences; national projects (howmuch detail; descriptive text on national projects should be avoided); methods (if there is aneed for higher requirements and tiers). A proposal to treat the project part of Chapter 4 as astand alone section was put forward. The links to other chapters were addressed by assigning
contact persons to the specific chapters.
BOG 5 - Cross-cutting issues
Substantial progress was made on the subject of completeness and consistency with otherchapters. Task 1 Chapters 3 and 4, from which Chapter 5 needs input for drafting, have thesame deadline as Chapter 5. This may cause a problem to the drafting of Chapter 5. In addition,
the group may need more Contributing Authors to complete the work. The group developed
guidance to other chapters on e.g. identifying uncertainties and the overall methods on how to
combine uncertainties. The draft paper on “Uncertainties in LULUCF inventories” wasdistributed to all Task 1 authors. Chapter 5 authors established cooperation with authors of
Chapters 2, 3, and 4 and shared expertise in various joint BOG sessions. The group reached anagreement on the proposal for key category analysis. Further work on the description will bedone and aggregation level may also need some more work. There are still unresolved issues
with regard to the Kyoto Protocol (i.e. on qualitative and quantitative matters). The group willdevelop two alternatives for comments. On QA/QC time series consistency, the group agreed togive more focus to the Kyoto Protocol issues and to non-annual data. Guidance to otherchapters on describing QA/QC (table) will be developed soon. The group will also reflect on
Chapter 3 tier structure. On verification, the group revised the outline and gave more focus on
the purpose of good practice. The Project section was largely reduced since the estimation
methods are common. The group agreed that higher tier methods may also be verification
methods (link to Chapter 3).

4 CONCLUSION
By and large, the meeting advanced the drafting of the report. All the chapters of Task 1 weremade more cohesive. Cross-cutting issues were discussed and clarified. Consistency among
chapters was enhanced. Grey areas were ironed out and missing gaps or issues were adequately
addressed. For Task 2, considerable progress was done to elaborate the contents of thedifferent chapters, identify links to Task 1, and assign authors to do the drafting.
Task 1 and Task 2 authors agreed with the schedules (Attachment D) to come up with the firstorder draft for combined Governments/Experts Review to take place between December 2002
and January 2003 (8 weeks). By 26 July 2002, the Task 1 group agreed to come up with thesummary of major revisions and cross-cutting issues and the list of Contributing Authors inareas or sections lacking expertise. Task 2 authors agreed to come up with a more detailed
outline by the same date. The pre-Brazil draft for Task 1 Chapters 2 to 5 will be ready by 15
September 2002 while Task 1 Chapter 1 and Task 2 (all chapters) by 23 September 2002.
Overall, the participants are confident that the first-zero order draft for both tasks will be readyand in complete form before the Brazil meeting in October 2002.

12

Attachment A
List of Praticipants for
IPCC NGGIPNGGIP-LULUCF Programme
Second Authors/Experts Meeting on GGood
ood Practice Guidance
Guidancefor LandLand-Use, Land
Landand-Use Change
Change and Forestry
Forestry (Task 1)
andFirst Authors/Expert Meeting on the issue of “Degradation of Forest and Devegetation of
Other
Other Vegetation Types” (Task 2)
Tampere, Finland, 1010-12 July 2002

* SG (Steering Group)** CLA (Co ordinationg Lead Authors)

ARGENTINA, REPUBLICAMr Hector Daniel GINZOFIDNEU
Consejo National de Invetigaciones Cientificas y
Technologicas (CONICET)
Serrano 669, C1414DEM, C.A. Buenos Aires
Tel: (54 11) 4855 7674 ext. 56 / 4783 7467
Fax: (54 11) 48 54 56 02
hdginzo@arnet.com.ar

ARGENTINA, REPUBLICA
Dr Ernesto F. VIGLIZZOINTA, Centro Regional La Pampa
Av Spinetto 785, P.O.Box 302
6300 Santa Rosa, La Pampa
Tel: 54 (29 54) 434 222
Fax: 54 (29 54) 434 222
evigliz@cpenet.com.ar

AUSTRALIA
Dr Simon BARRY
Bureau of Rural Sciences
PO Box E11, Kingston, ACT 2604
Tel: (61 2) 6727 4144
Fax: (61 2) 6272 4687
simon.barry@brs.gov.au

AUSTRALIA
Prof Ian NOBLE **noble@rsbs.anu.edu.au

AUSTRALIA
Dr John RAISONCSIRO Forestry and Forest Products
PO Box E4008, Kingston ACT 2604
Tel: (61 2) 6281 8280
Fax: (61 2) 6281 8312
John.Raison@csiro.au

AUSTRALIA
Dr Brian TURNER
Australian National University
School of Resources, Environment & Society
Canberra ACT 0200
Tel: (61 2) 6125 3548
Fax: (61 2) 6125 0746
brian.turner@anu.edu.au

AUSTRIADr Bernhard SCHLAMADINGER **Joanneum Research, Institute of Energy Research
Elisabethstrasse 5, 8010 GRAZ
Tel: (43 316) 876 1340
Fax: (43 316) 876 91340
bernhard.schlamadinger@joanneum.at

BELARUSDr Vladimir SAVCHENKO
Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental
Protection of the Republis of Belarus, for land ,forest and landscape protection
10 Kollektornaya st. Minsk, 220048
Tel: (375 17) 2205476
Fax: (375 17) 220 5583
savchenko@tut.by

BOLIVIAMr Juan Ivar ARANA PARDO
Avenida 20 de octubre esquina Fernando Guachalla
No 2230 edificio Ex Conavi, 4to Piso, Oficina 401,
P.O.Box 9513 La Paz
Tel: (591 2) 2423497
Fax: (591 2) 2423497
ivararana@hotmail.com

BOLIVIADr David Cruz CHOQUE
Climate Change Program of Bolivia,
Environment, Natural Resource and Forestry
Development
P.O. Box 5546, La Paz
Tel: (591 2) 2423497
Fax: (591 2) 2423497
davidcruz@coord.rds.org.bo

BRAZILDr Newton PACIORNIK **Ministry of Science and Technology of Brazil
Praia do Flamengo 200 s.101
22210-901, Rio de Janeiro
Tel: (55 21) 2555 0308
Fax: (55 21) 25351266
newton@finep.gov.br

CANADADr Dominique BLAIN
Environment Canada,
Pollution Data Branch, Greenhouse Gas Division
PVM, 19e etage, 351 boul. St-Joseph
Hull, Quebec, K1A 0H3
Tel: (1 819) 953 6079
Fax: (1 819) 953 3006
dominique.blain@ec.gc.ca

CANADADr Marie BOEHM
AAFC
Research Branch
Agriculture Building, 51 Campus Drive,
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, S7N 5A8
Tel: (1 306) 975 4143
Fax: (1 306) 966 4609
boehmm@em.agr.ca

CANADADr Eric DUCHEMIN
DREXenvironnement2667 rue Knox
Montreal, QC H3K 1R3
Tel: (1 514) 937 5619
drexenv@sympatico.ca

CANADADr Ted Huffman
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
Research Branch
Ottawa, ON K1A 0C6
Tel: (1 613) 759 1846
Fax: (1 613) 759 1924
huffmant@em.agr.ca

CANADADr Henry JANZEN
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
Land Resource Sciences
Box 3000, Lethbridge, Alberta, T1J 4B1
Tel: (1 403) 317 2223 / 327-4561
Fax: (1 403) 382 3156
janzen@em.agr.ca

CANADADr Werner KURZ
Natural Resources Canada
Canadian Forest Service
506 West Burnside Road, Victoria, BC, V8Z 1M5
Tel: (1 250) 363 6031
Fax: (1 250) 363 0775
wkurz@pfc.forestry.ca

CHINA
Prof Erda LIN
Agrometeorology Institute,
Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences
12 ZhongGuanCun South Street, Beijing 100081
Tel: (86 10) 6211 9688
Fax: (86 10) 6211 9688
lined@ns.ami.ac.cn

CHINA
Prof Deying XU
The Chinese Academy of Forestry
Wan Shou Shan, Beijing 100091
Tel: (86 10) 62889553
Fax: (86 10) 62888840
deyingxu@fee.forestry.ac.cn

CHINA
Dr Xiaoquan ZHANG
Institute of Forest Ecology and Environment,
Chinese Academy of Forestry
Wan Shou Shan, Beijing 100091
Tel: (86 10) 62889512
Fax: (86 10) 62888840
xiaoquan@fee.forestry.ac.cn

14

ECUADOR
Mr Julio CORNEJO VARGAS
Ministry of Environment,
Ecuador - Undersecretariat of Environmental
Quality
Avenida Eloy Alfaro y Amazonas
Edificio M.A.G., Piso 7, Quito
Tel: (593 2) 2508510
Fax: (593 2) 2508510
jcornejo@ambiente.gov.ec

FINLANDDr Markku KANNINEN
CATIE, Costa Rica
P.O.Box 47, 7170 Turrialba, COSTA RICA
Tel: (506 5) 56 1176 / 56 6431
Fax: (506 5) 6 6166 / 56 1533
kanninen@catie.ac.cr

FINLAND
Dr Timo KARJALAINEN **European Forest Institute
Torikatu 34, FI-80100 Joensuu
Tel : (358 13) 252 0240
Fax : (358 13) 124 393
timo.karjalainen@efi.fi

FINLAND
Dr Raisa MÄKIPÄÄ
Finnish Forestry Research InstituteUnioninkatu 40 A, FIN-00170 Helsinki
Tel : (358 9) 8570 5654
Fax : (358 9) 8570 5717
Raisa.Makipaa@metla.fi

FINLAND
Dr Kim PINGOUDVTT Processes Finland
P.O. Box 1606, Tekniikantie 4C, FIN-02044 VTT
Tel: (358 9) 456 5074
(358 40) 562 7105 (mobile)
Fax: (358 9) 456 6538
kim.pingoud@vtt.fi

FINLAND
Dr Risto SIEVANEN
Vantaa Research Center
Finnish Forest Research Institute
PB 18, 01301 Vantaa
Tel: (358 9) 857373
Fax: (358 9) 857361
risto.sievanen@metla.fi

FRANCEDr Dominique ARROUAYSInstitut National de Recherche Agronomique
Infosol Unit
INRA, Orleans, Infosol, 45160 Ardon
Tel : (33 2) 38 41 48 02
Fax : (33 2) 38 41 78 69
arrouays@orleans.inra.fr

FRANCEDr Jean-Claude GERMON
Institut National de Recherche Agronomique,
INRA-CMSE,
Laboratoire de Microbiologie des Sols
17, rue Sully, 21034 Dijon Cedex
Tel : (33 3) 80 69 30 91
Fax : (33 3) 80 69 32 24
germon@dijon.inra.fr

FRANCEDr Denis LOUSTAU
Institut National de Recherche Agronomique(INRA BORDEAUX)
Domaine de l'Hermitage
BP 45, F-33611, GAZINET CEDEX
Tel : (33 5) 57 12 28 51
Fax : (33 5) 56 68 05 46
loustau@pierroton.inra.fr

FRANCEMr Gérôme PIGNARD
Ministry of Agriculture
Inventaire Forestier National
Place des Arcades, Maurin, BP 1001
34971 Lattes Cedex
Tel: (33 4) 67 07 80 86 / 84
Fax: (33 4) 67 07 80 91
gpignard@cer.ifn.fr

GERMANYDr Rainer BARITZ
State Forest Research Centre Baden-Wuerttemberg
Wonnhaldestr. 4, 79100 Freiburg
Tel: (49 761) 4018117
Fax: (49 761) 4018333
small.baritz@t-online.de (priv.)
rainer.baritz@forst.bwl.de

15

GERMANY
Dr Annette FREIBAUER **CarboEurope Cluster - European Office,
Max-Planck-Institute for Biogeochemistry
P.O. Box 10 01 64, 07701 Jena
Tel: (49 3641) 686 726
Fax: (49 3641) 686 710
afreib@bgc-jena.mpg.de

GERMANY
Prof Michael KÖHL
Dresden University od Technology
Wilsdruffer Str. 18, 01737 Tharandt
Tel: (49 35203) 3831612
Fax: (49 35203) 3831632
koehl@forst.tu-dresden.de

HUNGARY
Dr Zoltan SOMOGYIForest Research Institute (ERTI) , Budapest
Department of Silviculture and Yield
H-1023 Budapest, Frankel L. u. 42-44.
Tel: (36 30) 465 2684
Fax: (36 1) 326 1639
Som9013@helka.iif.hu
h9013som@ella.hu

INDIA
Prof N.H. RAVINDRANATH **CES, and ASTRA
Indian Institute of Science
Bangalore 560 012
Tel: (91 80) 360 1455 / 394 2785
Fax: (91 80) 360 1428 / 360 0683
ravi@ces.iisc.ernet.in

INDIA
Dr T SINGH
Tata Energy Research Institute,
TERI School of Advanced Studies
Darbari Seth Block, Habitat Place, Lodhi Road,New Delhi - 110 003
Tel: (91 11) 4682 100, 4682 111
Fax: (91 11) 4682144,4682145
tpsingh@teri.res.in

IRELAND
Dr Kenneth BYRNE
University College, Facultz of Agriculture
Department of Environmental Resource
Management
Forest Ecosystem Research Group
Belfield, Dublin 4
Tel: (353 1) 716 7725
Fax: (353 1) 716 1102
kenneth.byrne@ucd.ie

ITALY
Mr Lorenzo CICCARESE
Italian Environment Protection Agency (ANPA)
Via V.Brancati 48, 00144 Rome
Tel: (39 06) 5007 2618
Fax: (39 06) 5007 2649
ciccarese@anpa.it

IVORY COAST
Mr Lucien Manau DJA
Ivorian Climate Change Project
B.PV 148 Abidjan
Antenne Sud INP-HB
Cocody Danga
Tel: (225) 05 92 44 88
Fax: (225) 22 44 3901 / 20 21 04 95
luciendja@hotmail.com

JAMAICAMr Keith PORTER
Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry Department
Technical Service
C/o Forestry Department
173 Constant Spring Rd. Kington 8
Tel: (876) 9242667 8 / 9242125 / 9699068
Fax: (876) 924 2626 / 9312636
kporter@forestry.gov.jm

JAPAN
Dr Shigeo KOBAYASHIForestry & Forest Products Research Institute(FFPRI)
Matsunosato 1, Kukizaki, Inashiki, Ibaraki
305-8687
Tel: (81 298) 73 3211 (ex.246)/ (81 298)73 3781
Fax: (81 298)73 1541
ksige@ffpri.affrc.go.jp

16

JAPANDr Mitsuo MATSUMOTO
Forestry & Forest Products Research Institute(FFPRI)
Department of Forest Policy and Economics
P.O.Box 16, Tsukuba-Norin, Ibaraki, 305-8687
Tel: (81 298) 73 3211 (Ex.641)
Fax: (81 298) 73 3799
machan@ffpri.affrc.go.jp

JAPAN
Dr Toshinori OKUDA
National Institute for Environmental Studies
Laboratory of Tropical Ecology
16-2 Onogawa, Tsukuba 305-0053
Tel: (81 298) 50 2426
Fax: (81 298) 502483
okuda@nies.go.jp

JAPAN
Dr Ryosuke SHIBASAKI
Center for Spatial Information Science,and Institute of Industrial Science
University of Tokyo
4-6-1, Komaba, Meguro-ku, Tokyo 153-8585
Tel: (81 3) 5452 6412
Fax: (81 3) 5452 6414
shiba@skl.iis.u-tokyo.ac.jp

JAPAN
Dr Masamichi TAKAHASHIForestry & Forest Products Research Institute(FFPRI)
1 Matsunosato, Kukizaki, Ibaraki, 305-8687
Tel:(81 298) 73 3211 ext.357
Fax:(81 298)74 7320
masamiti@ffpri.affrc.go.jp

KENYA
Dr Phanuel OBALLA
Kenya Forestry Research Institute
P.O.Box 20412, Nairobi
Tel: (254 154) 32891/2/3 or (254 154) 32541
Fax: (254 154) 32844
kefri@arcc.or.ke
pooballa@yahoo.com

MALAWIMr Samuel KAINJA **Forestry Department
Box 30048, Lilongwe 3
Tel: (265) 1 771 761, (265) 9 918582
Fax: (265) 1 778 268
skanja@malawi.net

MALAYSIADr Ismail BIN HARUN
Forest Research Institute Malaysia (FRIM)
Natural Forest Division
Kepong, 52109, Kuala Lumpur
Tel: (60 3) 6279 7000
Fax: (60 3) 6279 7878
ismail@frim.gov.my

MALAYSIA
Mr SAMSUDIN bin MUSA
Forest Research Institute Malaysia (FRIM)
Kepong, 52109, Kuala Lumpur
Tel: (60 3) 6279 7000
Fax: (60 3) 6279 7857
shams@frim.gov.my

MALAYSIADr Jenny WONG
Forest Research Institute Malaysia (FRIM)
Natural Forest Division
Kepong, 52109 Kuala Lumpur
Tel: (60 3) 6279 7212 (DL) / 6279 7373 ext 7212
Fax: (60 3) 6279 7857 / 6279 7878
jlpwong@frim.gov.my
jlpwong@hotmail.com

MEXICODr Tomas HERNANDEZ-TEJEDA
Instituto National de Investigaciones Forestales,
Agricolas y Pecuarias (INIFAP)
Secretaria de Agricultura, Ganaderia, Desarrollo
Rural, Pesca y Alimentacion (SAGARPA)
Av. Progreso #5. Colonia Coyoacan,
04110. Mexico, D.F.
Tel:(52 55) 5658 4612 / (52 55) 5658 3596
Fax:(52 55) 5554 0357
thtejeda@colpos.mx
textom99@yahoo.com

17

MEXICODr Omar MASERA **Institute of Ecology, National University of Mexico(UNAM), Forest Products Division
C/o Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)
Room D-462, Via delle Terme di Caracalla
00100 Rome
Tel: (39 06) 57055526
Fax: (39 06) 57055137
Omar.Masera@fao.org
omasera@ate.oikos.unam.mx

MOROCCODr Abdelkader ALLALI
Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Development andForestry
DPV.BP.1387, Rabat
Tel: (212 37) 761747
Fax: (212 37) 761557
allali@mailcity.com

MOROCCODr Tijani MANDOURI
National Center of Forest Research andExperimentation (CNRF)
CNRF BOX 763, Agdal, Rabat
Tel: (212 37) 672547 / GSM (212 65) 70 26 04
Fax: (212 37) 671151
rechfor@iam.net.ma
mandouri.tijani@caramail.com

NETHERLANDS
Dr Gert-Jan NABUURS **ALTERRA - Green World Research
PO Box 47, 6700 AA WageningenTel: (31 317) 477 897
Fax: (31 317) 424988
G.J.Nabuurs@Alterra.wag-ur.nl

NEW ZEALAND
Dr Peter BEETSNew Zealand Forest Research InstitutePivate Bag 3020, Rotorua
Tel: (64 7) 343 5899
Fax: (64 7) 343 5661
peter.beets@forestresearch.co.nz

NEW ZEALAND
Mr Justin FORD-ROBERTSONNew Zealand Forest Research InstitutePivate Bag 3020, Rotorua
Tel: (64 7) 343 5899
Fax: (64 7) 343 5661
jfr@forestresearch.co.nz

NORWAYMr Harald AALDE
Norwegian Institute of Land Inventory (NIJOS)
P.O. Box 115, N-1431 Ås
Tel: (47 64) 94 97 76
Fax: (47 64) 94 97 86
harald.aalde@nijos.no

NORWAYDr Kristin RYPDAL **Statistics Norway (SN)
P.O. Box 8131 Dep, N-OO33 OSLO
Tel: (47 21) 09 49 49
Fax: (47 21) 09 49 98
kristin.rypdal@ssb.no

PAPUA NEW GUINEAMr Vitus AMBIA
Papua New Guinea Forest Authority
P.O.Box 5055, Boroko, National Capital District
Port Moresby
Tel: (675) 3277907
Fax: (675) 3254433 / 3277930
vambia@datec.net.pg

PHILIPPINESProf Rodel LASCO **CFNR, University of the Philippines at Los Banos
Environmental Forestry ProgrammeCollege, 4031 Laguna
Tel: (63 49) 536 5314
Fax: (63 49) 536 3206 / 536 5314
rlasco@laguna.net
rdlasco@yahoo.com

POLAND
Dr Wojciech GALINSKISILVATICA Research Consultants
Glówna 29, Żabieniec, 05-500 Piaseczno
Tel: (48 22) 756 78 54
Fax: (48 22) 756 78 54
wgalinski@polbox.pl
wgalinski@silvatica.pl

18

POLAND
Dr Roman MICHALAK
Forest Research InstituteDepartment of Forest Management Planning andMonitoringul. Bitwy Warszawskiej 1920 r. nr 3
PL 00-973 Warszawa
Tel: (48 22) 822 49 38
Fax: (48 22) 822 49 35
R.Michalak@ibles.waw.pl

SPAIN
Dr Maria-Jose SANZ-SANCHEZ
Centro de Estudios Ambientales del Mediterraneo(CEAM)Charles Darwin 14
Parque Technologico de PATERNA
46980 Valencia
Tel: (34 96) 1318227
Fax: (34 96) 1318190
mjose@ceam.es

RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Dr Michael GYTARSKY *Institute of Global Climate and Ecology (IGCE)
Federal Service of Russia for Hydrometeorology
and Environmental Monitoring
Russian Academy of Sciences
20-b Glebovskaya str.,Moscow 107258
Tel: (7 95) 169 2198 (office)(7 95) 180 1115 (private)
Fax: (7 95) 160 0831
Mike.Gytarsky@g23.relcom.ru

SUDAN
Dr Elnour Abd Alla ELSIDDIG
University of Khartoum, Shambat
Faculty of Forestry
Department of Forest Management,
Tel: (249 13) 310104 (office)(249 13) 312658 (home)
Fax: (249 11) 780295
elnour_elsiddig@yahoo.com

RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Dr Alexander NAKHUTIN
Institute of Global Climate and Ecology (IGCE)
20-b Glebovskaya str.,Moscow 107258
Tel: (7 95) 169 0011
Fax: (7 95) 160 0831
ai_nakh@orc.ru
ainakh@rambler.ru

SLOVAKIADr Jozef MINDAS
Forestry Research Institute Zvolen
Department of Forest Environment
T.G. Masaryka Street 22, SK- 960 92 Zvolen
Tel: (421) 45 5314 206
Fax: (421) 45 5321 883
mindas@fris.sk

SOUTH AFRICA
Ms Martina R. VAN DER MERWE
Division for Water, Environment and Forestry
Technology
c/o Dr Robert Scholes
Environmentek, CSIR
P.O.Box 395, Pretoria, 0001
Tel: (27 12) 841 3397
Fax: (27 12) 841 2689
MvdMerwe2@csir.co.za

SWEDENProf Göran STÅHL
Faculty of Forestry, Umea
Swedish Univ. of Agric. Sciences
SE-901 83 Umea
Tel: 090 786 58 37
Fax: 090 77 81 16
Goran.Stahl@resgeom.slu.se

SWEDENDr Lennart OLSSON
Centre for Environmental Studies
Lund University.
Box 170, S-22100 Lund
Tel: (46 46) 2220511
Fax: (46 46) 2220475
lennart.olsson@miclu.lu.se

SWITZERLAND
Dr Andreas FISCHLIN
Terrestrial Systems Ecology ETHZ
Swiss Federal Institute of Technology
Grabenstrasse 3, CH-8952 Schlieren, Zurich
Tel: (41 1) 633 6090
Fax: (41 1) 633 1123
andreas.fischlin@ito.umnw.ethz.ch

19

TANZANIADr Willy MAKUNDI **Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
1 Cyclotron Rd. (MS90-4000)
Berkeley, California, U.S. 94720
Tel: (1 510) 486 6852
Fax: (1 510) 486 6996
wrmakundi@lbl.gov

THAILANDDr Kansri BOONPRAGOB **Ramkhamhaeng University
Department of Biology
Bangkok 10240
Tel: (66 2) 310 8416 / (66 2) 310 8395
Fax: (66 2) 310 8395 / (66 2) 310 8381
kansri@ram1.ru.ac.thbkansri@hotmail.com

UGANDAMr Paul DRICHI
National Biomass Study, Kampala
Forest Department
31 Springs Road, Kampala
Tel: (256 41) 251779
Fax: (256 41) 251778
nbsfd@imul.com

UNITED KINGDOMMr Gerry LAWSONCEH Edinburgh
Centre for Ecology and Hydology
Peniwik, Edinburgh EHZ6 QQB
Tel: (44 131) 445 4343
Fax: (44 131) 445 3943
g.lawson@ceh.ac.uk

UNITED KINGDOMDr Jim PENMAN *Department of the Environment,
Transport & Regions
Global Atmosphere Division
Room 3/F2, 123 Victoria St, London SW1E 6DE
Tel: (44 20) 7944 5225
Fax: (44 20) 7944 5219
Jim.Penman@defra.gsi.gov.uk

UNITED KINGDOMProf Keith SMITH
University of Edinburgh,
Institute of Ecology and Resource Management(IERM),
Darwin Bldg., Mayfield Rd, Edinburgh EH9 3JU
Tel: (44 131) 650 7721
Fax: (44 131) 662 0478
keith.smith@ed.ac.uk

UNITED KINGDOMDr Pete SMITH **University of Aderdeen
Department of Plant and Soil Science
Cruickshank Building, Aberdeen, AB24 3UU
Tel: (44 1224) 272 702
Fax: (44 1224) 272 703
pete.smith@abdn.ac.uk

UNITED KINGDOMDr Richard TIPPER
The Edinburgh Centre for Carbon Management Ltd(ECCM)
Tel: (44 31) 666 5070
Fax: (44 31) 666 5055
richard.tipper@eccm.uk.com

UNITED STATES
Ms Barbara BRAATZICF Consulting
1850 K Street, N.W., Suite 1000
Washington, DC 20006-2213
Tel: (1 202) 862 1177
Fax: (1 202) 862 1144
bbraatz@icfconsulting.com

UNITED STATESDr Sandra BROWN
Winrock International
1621 N Kent St, Suite 1200, Arlington, VA 22209
Tel: (1 703)525 9430, ext 678
Fax: (1 703)525 1744
sbrown@winrock.org

UNITED STATESDr Marlen EVE
Resource Exchange Intnl and Natural Resource
Ecology Lab (CSU)
2123 N Road, West Point, NE 68788
Tel: (1 970) 420 0354
AridEve@aol.com
meve@nrel.colostate.edu

20

UNITED STATESDr Linda HEATH
USDA Forest Service
Northeastern Research Station
PO Box 640, Durham, NH 03824
Tel: (1 603) 868 7612
Fax: (1 603) 868 7604
Lheath@fs.fed.us

UNITED STATESDr Bill HOHENSTEIN **USDA
Global Change Program Office
Room 670, Reporters Building
Tel: (1 202) 702 6698
Fax: (1 202) 401 1176
whohenst@mailoce.oce.usda.gov

UNITED STATESMr Bill IRVINGUS Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
1200 Pennsylvania Ave. NW
Washington, D.C. 20460
Tel: (1 202) 564 9065
Fax: (1 202) 565 2079
irving.bill@epa.gov

UNITED STATES
Ms Dina KRUGER *US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
1200 Pennsylvania Ave. NW (6202J)
Washington, DC 20460
Tel: (1 202) 564 9039
Fax: (1 202) 565 2134
kruger.dina@epa.gov

INTERNATIONALUNITED STATESProf Keith PAUSTIAN
Colorado State University
Department of Soil and Crop Science
Tel: (1 970) 491 1547
Fax: (1 970) 491 1965
keithp@nrel.colostate.edu

UNITED STATESDr Ken SKOG
USDA Forest Service
One Gifford Pinchot Dr., Madison, WI 53705
Tel: (1 608) 231 9360
Fax: (1 608) 231 9508
kskog@fs.fed.us

URUGUAY
Dr Daniel MARTINO
INIA La Estanzuela, Uruguay
GRAS, INIA La Estanzuela, Colonia 70.000
Tel: (598 574) 8000 ext.1498
Fax: (598 574) 8012
martino@inia.org.uy

ZAMBIAMr Julius P. DAKA
Environmental Council of Zambia
Corner Suez Road and Church Road
P.O.Box 35131, LUSAKA
Tel:(260 1 254130/31 or (260 1) 254023/59
Fax:(260 1) 254164 or (260 1) 250250
MotherTDaka@netscape.net
jdaka@necz.org.zm
ecz@necz.org.zm

ORGANISATIONEUROPEAN COMMISSIONDr Giorgio MATTEUCCIEC - Joint Research Centre
T.P. 051, I-21020 Ispra (VA), Italy
Tel: (39 03) 32 78 5808
Fax: (39 03) 32 78 5022
giorgio.matteucci@jrc.it

21

OBSERVERFAO
Dr Dieter SCHOENE
Forest Products Division
Viale delle Terme di Carcalla
00100 ROME, Italy
Tel: (39 06) 570 55077
Fax: (39 06) 570 55618
Dieter.Schoene@fao.org

UNFCCCDr Roberto ACOSTA
Martin Luther King Strasse 8
D-53175 Bonn,
Tel: (49 228) 815 1419
Fax: (49 228) 815 1999
racosta@unfccc.de

UNFCCCMr Claudio FORNER
Martin Luther King Strasse 8
D-53175 Bonn,
Tel: (49 228) 815 1445
Fax: (49 228) 815 1999
cforner@unfccc.int

UNITED STATES
Ms Katie BICKEL
USDA
Global Change Program Office
Room 112-A, J.L. Whitten Building
1400 Independence Avenue, SW
Washington, DC 20250-3810
Tel (1 202) 720 9978
Fax (1 202) 401 1176
kbickel@oce.usda.gov

IPCC
TASK FORCE BUREAU CO-CHAIRJAPANMr Taka HIRAISHI *National Institute for Environmental Studies
C/o Institute for Global Environmental
Strategies (IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
hiraishi@iges.or.jp

BRAZILDr Thelma KRUG *Secretaria de Politicas Cientificas e Programas de
C&T
Ministerio da Ciencia e Tecnologia
Esplanada dos Ministerios
Bloco E, 2-°andar, 70067-900, Brasilia
Tel: (55 61) 317 8128
Fax: (55 61) 226 0834
tkrug@mct.gov.br

IPCC SECRETARIATDr Renate CHRIST
C/o World Meteorological Organization
7 bis Avenue de la Paix,
C.P. 2300, CH-1211
Geneva 2, SWITZERLAND
Tel: (41 22) 730 8574
Fax: (41 22) 730 8025

christ_r@gateway.wmo.ch

22

IPCC-NGGIP/TSU
Dr Riitta PIPATTI
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies(IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115, Japan
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
pipatti@iges.or.jp

Mr Kiyoto TANABE
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies(IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115, Japan
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
tanabe@iges.or.jp

Mr Leandro BUENDIA
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies(IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115, Japan
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
buendia@iges.or.jp

Ms Kyoko MIWA
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies(IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115, Japan
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
miwa@iges.or.jp

Dr Todd NGARA
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies(IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115, Japan
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
ngara@iges.or.jp

Ms Akiko KAWASE
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies(IGES)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi
Hayama, Miura, Kanagawa 240-0115, Japan
Tel: (81 468) 55 3750
Fax: (81 468) 55 3808
kawase@iges.or.jp

FINNISH ORGANISER
Ms Marjaana VAINIO-MATTILA
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
Department of Rural Areas and Natural
Resources
P.O. Box 30, FIN-00023 GOVERNMENT
Streetaddress: Hallituskatu 5A, Helsinki, Finland
Tel: (358 9) 160 54095
Fax: (358 9) 160 52450
marjaana.vainio-mattila@mmm.fi

Mr Juha-Pekka Snäkin
Ministry of the Environment
Environmental Protection Department
P.O. Box 35, FIN-00023 GOVERNMENT
Streetaddress: Kasarmikatu 25, Helsinki, Finland
Tel: (358 9) 169 39692
Fax: (358 9) 160 39439
juha-pekka.snakin@ymparisto.fi

Ms. Johanna PÄTTINIEMI
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
International Affairs Unitjohanna.pattiniemi@mmm.fi

Ms. Sari LAPPIMinistry of the Environment
Environmental Protection Department

Ms. Hanna-Mari AHONEN
Ministry of the Environment
Environmental Protection Department
hanna-mari.ahonen@ymparisto.fi
23Mr. Jarko LEHIKOINEN
The Information Centre of the Ministry ofAgriculture and Forestry, IT-group
jarko.lehikoinen@mmm.fi

Mr. Henrik KROHNS
henrik.krohns@mmm.fi
The Information Centre of the Ministry ofAgriculture and Forestry, IT-group

Mr. Toni PIRINEN
toni.pirinen@mmm.fi
The Information Centre of the Ministry ofAgriculture and Forestry, IT-group

Mr. Lauri LEHTO
lauri.lehto@mmm.fi
The Information Centre of the Ministry ofAgriculture and Forestry, IT-group24

Attachment B
IPCC NGGIP-LULUCF Programme
Second Authors/Experts Meeting on Good Practice Guidance
for Land-Use, Land-Use Change And Forestry (Task 1)
andFirst Authors/Expert Meeting on the issue of “Degradation of Forest and Devegetation of Other
Vegetation Types” (Task 2)
Tampere, Finland, 10-12 July 2002
Breakout Group Co-chairs, Rapporteurs, and Members,
and Plenary Rapporteurs

BOG 1: Task 2 – Degradation and Devegetation Issues
Co-Chairs: (to be decided at the meeting by all Task 2 CLAs; 1 from developed country and 1
from developing country)
Gary RICHARDS (Australia)
LIU Shirong (China)
Timo KARJALAINEN (Finland)
Samuel KAINJA (Malawi)
Rapporteurs:
Julius DAKA (Zambia)
Members:
Juan Ivar ARANA PARDO (Bolivia)
Tomas HERNANDEZ (Mexico)
Shigeo KOBAYASHI (Japan)
Roman MICHALAK (Poland)
Masamichi TAKAHASHI (Japan)
Gerald John LAWSON (UK)*Marie BOEHM (Canada)

Absentee:
Richard BIRDSEY (US)Gyde LUND (US)Robert SCHOLES (South Africa)
Andreas SCHULTE (Germany)

IPCC:
Renate CHRISTBOG 2: Task 1-Chap2: Basis for Consistent Representation of Land Areas
Co-Chairs:
Bubu Pateh JALLOW (Gambia)
Rapporteurs:
Ismail BIN HARUN (Malaysia)
Members:
Dominique ARROUAYS (France)
Peter BEETS (New Zealand)Paul DRICHI (Uganda)
Ted HUFFMAN (Canada)
Michael KOHL (Germany)
LIN Erda (China)
Lennart OLSSON (Sweden)
Ryosuke SHIBASAKI (Japan)

Jim PENMAN (UK)Bill IRVING (US) – (also as Plenary
Rapporteur)
Brian TURNER (Australia)
Julio VARGAS (Ecuador)
Ernesto VIGLIZZO (Argentina)
Ralph ALIG (US)*
Absentees:
Ronnie MILNE (UK)James HRUBOVCAK (US)NGGIP-TSU:
Todd NGARA

25

BOG 3 - A: Task 1-Chap3: Forest lands and rangelands/pasture land
Co-Chairs:
N.H. RAVINDRANATH (India)

Gert-Jan NABUURS (Netherlands)

Rapporteurs:
Harald AALDE (Norway)

Willy MAKUNDI (Tanzania)

Members:
Abdelazim Yassin ABDELGADIR(Sudan)Samsudin BIN MUSA (Malaysia)
Dominique BLAIN (Canada)David Cruz CHOQUE (Bolivia)
Lorenzo CICCARESE (Italy)
Justin FORD-ROBERTSON (New
Zealand)
Wojciech GALINSKI ( Poland)
Michael GYTARSKY (Russia)
Linda HEATH (US)Bill HOHENSTEIN (US)Denis LOUSTAU (France)
Kim PINGOUD (Finland)
John RAISON (Australia)
Vladimir SAVCHENKO (Belarus)
Risto SIEVANEN (Finland)
Ken SKOG (US)XU Deying (China)
Carlos CERRI (Brazil)*
AbsenteeJames BARTON (New Zealand)

NGGIP-TSU:
Kiyoto TANABE

BOG 3 – B: Task 1- Chap3: Cropland, wetland/tundra, urban, and other developed lands
Co-Chairs:
Annette FREIBAUER (Germany)
Rapporteurs:
Kenneth BYRNE (Ireland)Members:
Eric DUCHEMIN (Canada)
Lucien DJA ( (Ivory Coast)
Jean-Claude GERMON (France)
Hector GINZO (Argentina)
Anwar Sheikhaddin Abdu KHALIL(Bahrain)Josef MINDAS (Slovakia)
Keith PAUSTIAN (US)

Tijani MANDOURI (Morocco)

Keith SMITH (UK)
Absentee:
Rizaldi BOER (Indonesia)
Observer:Kathryn BICKEL (US)NGGIP-TSU:
Leandro BUENDIA

26

Task1&2/Main/Doc.2

BOG 4 – A: Task 1- Chap4: Afforestation, Reforestation, Deforestation, and Forest
Management
Co-Chairs:
Rodel LASCO (Philippines)
Rapporteurs:
Kansri BOONPRAGOB (Thailand) – (alsoas Plenary Rapporteur)
Members:
Sandra BROWN (US)Nagmeldin Gutbi ELSIDDIG (Sudan)
Werner KURZ (Canada)
Mitsuo MATSUMOTO (Japan)
Alexander NAKHUTIN (Russia)
Zoltan SOMOGYI (Hungary)

Bernhard SCHLAMADINGER (Austria)

Gerome PIGNARD (France)

ZHANG Xiao-Quan (China)
Andreas FISCHLIN (Switzerland)*
Observer:
Dieter SCHOENE (FAO)

BOG 4 –B1: Task 1 – Chap4: Cropland and Grassland Management, Revegetation
Co-Chair:Pete Smith (UK)
Rapporteur:
Members:
Henry JANZEN (Canada)Peter KUIKMAN (Netherlands)*

Absentee:
Pascale COLLAS (Canada)

NGGIP-TSU:
Riitta PIPATTI

27

Task1&2/Main/Doc.2

BOG 4 - C: Task 1 – Chap4: LULUCF Projects
Co-Chairs:
Omar MASERA ( Mexico)

Ian NOBLE (Australia)

Rapporteurs:
Jenny WONG (Malaysia)
Members:
Abdelkader ALLALI (Morocco)
Vitus AMBLA (Papua New Guinea)
Barbara BRAATZ (US)Markku KANNINEN (Finland) Jorge)
Thelma KRUG (Brazil)
Daniel MARTINO (Uruguay)
Phamuel OBALLA (Kenya)

Richard TIPPER (UK)Ignacio DEL VALLE (Colombia)**

Observer:Claudio FORNER (UNFCCC)TFB Members:
Taka HIRAISHI (Co-chair, Japan)

BOG 5: Task 1 – Chap5: Cross-cutting issues (Chapter 5)
Co-Chairs:
Newton PACIORNIK (Brazil)

Kristin RYPDAL (Norway)

Rapporteurs:
Martina van der MERWE (South Africa)
Members:
Rainer BARITZ (Germany)
Simon BARRY (Australia)
Marlen EVE (US)Dina KRUGER (US)Raisa MAKIPAA (Finland)
Giorgio MATTEUCCI (European
Commission)Toshinori OKUDA (Japan)
Keith PORTER (Jamaica)
Jose Maria SANZ-SANCHEZ ( Spain)
T.P. SINGH (India)
Goran STAHL (Sweden)

Albertus Johannes DOLMAN(Netherlands)*
Bo LIM (UK)*
Riccardo VALENTINI (Italy)*
Absentees:
Michael GILLENWATER (US)
Mamadou HONADIA (Burkina Faso)
James SMITH (US)
Observer:Roberto ACOSTA (UNFCCC)NGGIP-TSU:
Kyoko MIWA

28

Attachment C

Task 2 Table of Contents (Elaborated)
Chapter 1 Introduction
Chapter 2 Definitions for Degradation of Forests anddevegetation of Other Vegetation Types (linked to Task
1- Chapters 2, 3)
2.1. Definitions of direct human induced degradation anddevegetation
2.1.1 Definitions & descriptions of ‘direct human induced degradation’ and‘devegetation’2.1.2 Description of direct/indirect human induced activities & naturaleffects which effect degradation & devegetation.

2.2 Description of Forest Degradation & Devegetation Activities••

2.2.1 General Description of Activities
description of activities and direct human-induced effects on carbon stocks and
GHG emissions (aggregate list applicable to all regions … e.g. thinning, weeding,ground preparation etc.)‘devegetation’ in the context of ‘converse of revegetation’ or context of all nonforest land’?
2.2.2 Europea) scale of effects of activities on C Stocks…. literature examples … case studies .. not all countries .. consider both
short-term and longer-term effects .. consider likely geographic scale ..
b) scale of effects of activities on GHG emissionsc) impacts on social, economic and biological functions
2.2.2 Asia & Pacific Shigeo Kobayashi, Shirong Liu & Gary Richardsa) .. c) as above.
2.2.4 Americasa) …c) as above
2.2.6 Africaa) …c) as above.

29

2.2.7 Conclusions on Global scales of effects

Chapter 3 Methodological Options to Inventory
Emissions from Direct Human Induced Activities
3. 1 Methodologies to estimate emissions from degradation offorest and devegetation of other vegetation types (Building on
Task 1 Chapters 3-4, but emphasizing issues particular todegradation/devegetation).
3.1.1 Estimation of emissions from direct human interventions in degradation offorests, including uncertaintiesb) Changes in biomassc) Changes in soil carbond) Harvested woode) Non-CO2 GHGs
3.1.2 Estimation of emissions from devegetation of other vegetation types,
including uncertaintiesa) Identification of affected areasb) Changes in biomassc) Changes in soil carbond) Non-CO2 GHGs
3.1.3 Implications for Full Carbon Accounting & Land Categorisaton

3.2 Reporting and documentation(providing only guidance)
3.2.1 Tables and Worksheets for computation of emissions .. coordinated with
Task 1 Chapter 3,4,5 (including effect of tier)3.2.2 Tables and Worksheets for reporting of emissions … coordinated with Task
1 Chapter 4 (including effect of tier)

Chapter 4 Implications of different methodologicaloptions to accounting under the provisions of Article 3.4of the Kyoto Protocol
4.1 Overview of accounting reporting rules in the Kyoto Protocol(i.e. Arts 3,5,7,8, 6 (,12?))30

4.2 Methods & Guidelines
4.2.1 Degradation of Forestsa Afforestation, Reforestation, Deforestationb. Forest Management
4.2 2 Devegetation due to human induced
a. Cropland management,b Grazingland management,c. Revegetation
4.2.3 Devegetation on other lands (need for full carbon accounting & unbalanced
Kyoto interpretations)Annexes - Sources of Information & Reporting
Templates(avoiding pers comm. For grey literature must be reviewed by authors & IPCC needs
reference copy.)

31

Attachment D

SCHEDULE FOR FIRST-ORDER DRAFTS FOR REVIEW
26 July

Post Tampere papers
Task 1: Summary of major revisions and cross-cutting issues, listof CAs, lacking expertise
Task 2: Detailed outline
Both: Presentations (final plenary), work plan for Brazil

15 September

Pre-Brazil drafts (Task 1: chapters 2-5)

23 September

Pre-Brazil drafts (Task 1: chapter 1; Task 2)

1-4 October

Brazil meeting

18 October

Post-Brazil drafts from CLAs to TSU/SG

23 October –1 November

COP8 (Report of progress; Side-event)

18 November

Harmonisation of draft reports by CLAs/ SG/TSU

25-26 November

Final Draft/TFB

1 December –31 January

Review

Notes:
Pre-Brazil draft needs to be near final (all difficult issues resolved) so that Brazil meetingcan focus on cross-group discussion
Final First-order drafts to TSU –date need to be early enough to allow time for TSU/SG
to finalise draft.

32