190

]`d/

$,&2 Lorentz violation
[eDp`fgķǷĖĠʎ î ý ŀkatori@mit.edu
2012 Ł 8 Ɛ 27 ƅ1

 +ȹ,Â
oF¶

Cʘ7ǚɅ+ƮȽƇC%D$#ʘƩǈǚɅ$,^QĎ,;%;%ģÈ'ĬǹŚF»ǱǾ+Ǜ%#<

#Bm

j

%Ȟ

 Lorentz violationʖgĬǹŚ+ǲCʗ

+ǱǾ(!#+ȹ$7A'8+'¢ĕÏ

@C#7ʖĄ 1aʗ

+Ď

#

ʘġĥ

Bɦǻ$E=BS\Qpfj ~h\(ǺȪ%©ĦB%ʖ'ǺȪ,ǘ§Ǔǚ%ř7+$KjdU\(ɱǋFț7+Ɇ+!$ʗʘǭǿ(ʆǤ%ř

$B%?AĢĦ7ʖĄ 1bʗ!7AĄ$ǵɞ+$Əő7$ɃG$*BĎ+¿a$'ƃ

a Lorentz violation ,xUʉċ$+ɑʑNnTǓAÈ#+ǿɹ

ǚ$ǘCB%ŶǅC#7ʖ2 ȇʗ/%%$ LorentzĦȝC7CFǭǿƔŏ¿%û0ƩǈǚɅ(B

violation %

^QĎ+ǭǿƔŏ¿, 246 GeV $Âǭǿ%#;ǷĠǥ$B:(,ǚɅ(,Ǯǫ,ȻC'+$ Lorentz violation FƮĦȝBŕȱ

ř

A7ʖ3 ȇʗ+:+Ə;ȥǥ'ƝȒ8

$

ŮŉƩ

^QĎ  $ǆCǕš

ǭǿ%Í#Bǿɹ,^QĎ$ǆCǕš%EǈǚɅ% SMEʖStandard-Model Extensionʗ$7
7'ħʐȓƜ

SME (Č"#ȵƛC#7++!

+ȤúǀħʐF 4 ȇ$Ȑ¤%ř7ǔ(mjoŲÛħʐ,Cȣ³

ʘ

Ŀǂȸ+ō

ÖFƜ+$Ɗǿ<ǭǿ+ƧɠȵƇ(ōȁ!%ƔŏC#7ʖ5 ȇʗmÿʊjoǓǚ(,77ƕȵƶ+ĕưC#7ʘ+!(IQ+vM

ĆȁÙɟāǱǾŧʖɞǹvM}ʗ+ MiniBooNE
ħʐ+ȓƜA7ʖ6 ȇʗ+ħʐȓƜ,mo+ɎɳF÷9ƩǈǚɅʖmj

joƩǈǚɅʗ$,ɂ

Ƈ$'+$ƂǓǚ+Ä¾$BðȡŚ

Aʘ+?

'ƂǓǚ+¾Ȯ+/%!

Lorentz violation $7 ȇ$, MiniBooNE ħʐ+ȓƜ

Lorentz violation $ɂƇ$

B&+ȵƛȓƜ%ȞīFǵ7Əő(7%:%£ő+ĵƒFǵ%ř7ʖ8 ȇʗ^ Â,ħʐĩ'+$ Lorentz violationǚɅǥ(&+?

7AƳ(7GʘȣǢǥĬǹŚ+ǲC(ǢǥĬǹŚ+ǲCʖSpontaneous Symmetry Breakingʘ7#ɂƇC7ʖĄ 1ʗ[1]ʑNnTB+ǘɋFȷãɮɽɭžŴ

ǲCʖSpontaneous Lorentz Symmetry Breakingʘ7,
SLSBʗ$[3]ɑ/;ǚɅ<ɳĞɱ×ǚɅ+?

Ď'@)zUjĎ$ǿɹŠ@C7ƩǈǚɅ$,V]I+Ɏɳʈ,ȣǓǚ(ȣǢǥgĬǹŚ+
'ɑʑN

@ŤAȁ

#

A

ʖĄ 1cʗʘ+!$;ǭǿƔŏ¿Fů#-ǭǿ,^Q(Č"% Lorentz violation ,ʅĽ(ȣǌ'ǘɋ+?

, SSBʗ(?

 +IKiIFŮŉ+nTǚɅ,G+zUjĎ2 h[\),(*F_L(ǘCB+Ą 1  ȣǢǥĬǹŚ+ǲC

2008 Ł

(ozǓǚɍFïɍ+$[2]ʘȹţ(Ƃ;C7G£Łʖ2012 Łʗ,Řʋ+sfV^ȈĞ;ǢȲǆCB%E$ʖĄ 1dʗ'8(ħɾ+ǚɅ$,ȣǢǥgĬ
ǹŚ+ǲC,ƩǈǚɅ+ȣǢǥĬǹŚ+ǲC?AÅ(ɐ%ŞCB+$+Ą,Ʈǳ$,A7G7

zUjĎ,?Aȥǥ(,hbĎ+Ǽ'+$z
UjĎ(ɻĦBŕȱ;A7G

ʘ+ȹ$,

ȥǥ(ǭǿzUjĎ%Ȭȹ7%(?

'zUjĎ 

ʘ;+

ǭǿƔŏ¿F;!%B%ġĥ,zUjĎ$ǆCʘƩǈǚɅ+ȈĞʘʄĞ%

m

j

2

91

o% ʘ,  Ď%Ǫ$ɱȱ'+,



@C7

Transformationʘ;,ȳǅȟǥgēŸʗ(Ĺƃõ(¸ğB%$B%$+!+gēŸ,ǭǿzUj

µǝB%Ȟ

Ǫµǝğć'Ɗ,ô;+$Ą 3a (ǕƸFǵ7

ǋ$ĈǙ,ȣə#B+$ʘ+ƃõ¸ğŚ,ĎǪµǝ+ȣə¸ğŚ$ȬC7Ą 2 (+ǕƸFǵ[1]BȈĞ7[4]©(Ɠ+ 6 Ɗ(ǱǾĨ(ʘ·ɑœȏƧɠFǅ

-çĞ+

%7ʙ#àő+ 6 Ɗ(ôȳȳǅȟʖIK\

cKʗ(Ĭ#ƃõ(ɢG$77ġĥ,ƃõFõǭǿzUjĎ$ǆC#B%©Ħ7ǅF%ĈǙ+ȣə(?AǭǿzUjĎ,ƃõFē
#B+$ȳǅɳ(ɨǘCB;C'%E$

Ą 3 Lorentz violation F÷GgēŸ+ƧɠĄ 2 Lorentz violation %ĈǙ+ȣə ;´@

3.1 aB\),(*?O24 ƊɹùƔ$ēÛ#B+Ǔǚǥȳǅɳ ;ȈĞ

ñƃõ(ɢȪƃõFē

%B%ȈĞ+ɤĎóʘ+ǚǞ%#,ǄńĹ'&+Ǜď(?BN+ÛɳzUj%ġĥ+ǭǿzUjĎ+ɺºðȡŚ

Lorentz violation

Ȟ@C7

Ɩŋ+ĈǙ+ȣə¸ğŚ,ēEB+$Ɣŏ$7ʖĄ 3bʗ+?

'ǕƸśƈƊɹùƔ$ȬC7C,ɩƃ+ƈ(ĬBĈǙ,ȈĞǥgēŸ$ȬCʘ!7AʘLorentz violation+Ɩŋ+ȣəùƔ$ 1 ƅʖ24 Ɗɹʗ?A>%ǰ 23%,Ʈǳ(, Particle Lorentz violationʘ!7AȈĞǥƊɹ 56 Ñ 4.1 Ǹ$ĈǙ+Ł, 365 ƅ$+ɹ(gēŸ+ǲC%

ĈǙ, 366 Ăə#B%FȞ
24 Ɗɹ?A>%ǰ%

B%ĈǙ+ĂəùƔ,

ȌŒ$B%ř7;

23 Ɗɹ 56 Ñ 4.1 ǸùƔ$ēEB%B%ʘĈȳǅɳǙ+Ǜď(?BN%,Ȟ

"@ʘʅĽ(Ȥúǀ

ȓƜ%'A7!7Aġĥ+ŰõŚʘLorentz violation+ƶĦǥ'Ƚŭ,ĈǙ$+Ǔǚǥȳǅɳ+śƈƊɹ¸ğ
Ś%

%('A7

3 Lorentz violation 1r +ȇ$, Lorentz violation +ƧɠFʘņF¡#B%¢(ȷ

%

7

IK\

ɂƇ

cK,ɹɨ

# #ȷGDʕ% ȷEC#
ʖ+ɞA$ʗʘjiĴ+ɮʌ(ÇC@C $ ʖC,<$ʗʘ
ǷĠǥ$B:(,ǚɅ+Ǯǫ,ȻC7Gɱȱ'+,ʘȈĞġĥ(Ĭ#Û#B%ʖParticle Lorentz

Transformationʘ;,ȈĞǥgēŸʗ%ȳǅ
ȟ3.2 iWg\),(*?O ƃõ(ÛȈĞFñƃõ(ȳǅȟǥgēŸ$ē

B%;Ðƚ7!7AĄ 3c +? (;IK\

cKʖȳǅȟʗ ʍF 90 ń/*
#ñƃõ(ɢȪB%

ġ ĥ ( Ĭ  # Û  #  B %  ʖ Observer Lorentz@'+$ Lorentz violation ,ɐA7G%

+;ȳǅȟǥgēŸ,ä(ŅƩēŸ(ǪŋB@$

Fǯ@'ȹȟ(?

+, @ǷĠȟ+ǜƽ
#µ@CȺĦ$

¢;B

ȱ'ȓƜ$ʘ!7AʘȈĞ
B+

ɨ

#Ȳ

;C7G

ñ(Ȫ

C,ɱ

Aĸ(Ȫ

A

BǕƸ$;ʖParticle Lorentz violationʗŅƩēŸ,7;@CB+$ʘȥǥ( Lorentz violation $ŞCBǘɋ,ŅƩȊ<ȳǅȟ(¸ğ7G

3.3 CPT F_L
 CPT ĬǹŚ,gĬǹŚ%ȗĪ'ɺº(A7
+ȹ$ CPT ĬǹŚ(,7AȶC7G, CPT ĬǹŚ+ǲCʖCPT violationʗ
xrXcʙ ǷĠȟ,Ɠ(ň+$àÕ 6 Ɗ%

@ȈĞ,ȳǅȟ(ĬE$Ą$ǵɞA+%ȈĞ+ɤÛɳzUj%ǭǿzUjĎ+ɺº,ēE@'%ř%ř7?Lorentz violation +ǱǾF

%('A7ʘȥǥ(

B%vHKgēǥ$'ʘ!7A

KcUhJw'Ď+ǚɅ$+ CPT violation , Lorentz
violation FŇɐ%Ȟ

@C#7[5]ƭȇ$ɝ4

392
B SME ,+ǚɅ('#

A CPT violation , Lorentz,ı' Lorentz violation Fŵ%Fǩǥ%#A

violation +ßÑƙª$ CPT violation ,ȈĞ+SME ,+:+g$SME ,Ď+ǚɅ(ŹÛʈǭǿzUjĎ%+Ǫ

%#ǭǿzUjĎ%+Ǫ

ȈĞ(ɨ
ɳF

ɎɳF

µǝ+ɨ%#ǘCʘȈĞ%ì
B%,$ʘɨƑÚɎ

B(%&7A7?ȈĞ%ìȈĞ+Ɏɳ+ɨFCPT ĬǹŚ+ǲC%ȷ7ʘĎ+ǚɅǥ(,µǝFɓ;+$Y^hgSžŴ+Vx+ƏÒ+Z,$(ğćBic+ SME +ƝȒ8$+ȵƛ$ɞĽʘħʐ$,
24 ƊɹùƔ+ēÝF8#Ǜď(?BNʖǄńēÝʘƑÚɎɳ+ĹFB¨+%,ðȡ$Aʘȟ++¦ʗFȲǽ;B%Ɏɳ'@C,ìȈĞ%ř

ēÝFic$eMfUB%,7A7G!7ƖɎǥ(ɨħ,ÈÓ+ȈĞ$¦(ìȈĞ#;+ğćB%

%$

A7

AƄğ+ic( Lorentz violationśƈƊɹùƔ+ğć#B;

+VqVžŴʖO. W. Greenbergʗ+ CPT

C'+$

ĬǹŚ(ĬBƋɥǥ'ǚɅ(űŦBǚɅ

ɉFɸ SME F¶

ȵƛȓƜ+ǢȬ+ĎFů!%('(IQKw(ǘC7VžŴ(B?

ƱƐ+?

£+%Dɘɯ,Vq(Ȳ@C7

E$ 1998 Ł@ 3 Ł%(®

A7$,+®ɉ$ǢȬCȤúǀǱǾF!

Ȑ¤%ř7

4 Standard-Model Extension (SME)

4.2 Lorentz violation NcDp

 Lorentz violation F ³ Ȋ ǥ ( Ǳ Ǿ  B Ɲ Ȓ 8 %  #4.2.1 H",,Standard-Model Extension ʖSMEʗ ;; Lorentz violation ,ȳǅC#'+$ʅĽKiJIlĖĠ

+IY^hgSžŴʖV. Alan Kosteleckyʗ%
+ÊôǱǾȟ(?

# 1997 Ł(ŷþC7[6]Y^h3(ı%ŞC#7ÈǷĠÑɲ$;%;ȉń+?+,çĞǓǚ$ǭǿzUjĎ,ġĥFǆ

gSžŴʖĄ 4ʗ,ʅĽ(NnT+B¢$ʘÂǴĎ+?

,ĖĠɼǜƊ§(ʒCȓƜǥ(+ǱǾFĜ:B%

%('A7
ʖʘŎ,Â+ŰİžĤ$,A7Gʗȳǅ(Əɪ$ʘĈ$ðȡ'ħʐ+

7Â+ʄǴƳ%ɱ×+Åǜ$;Aʘ+ɱ×+ŴƣF

(Ĭ#Əʑ+ŠńFů # AʘƏɜ+ħʐ$, 1033 GeV

î

(1B7

+$çĞƊȸ+ùƔ(ŌʇFë6

ƔŏC7ļR^[,7(+?

' Lorentz violation+ȉń7$Ʉ4B%(ŤØ7 [8]$âƣ;ŁɣC7ʚĄ 5 x^jĖĠVx+ĬļR^ǴƳ`[ʖCourtesy of Michael RomalisʗĄ 4 Y^hgSžŴ%+ĠǜʖCourtesy of Indiana Universityʗ Ą 5 ,+ȭț$ČƖ,QL³+PxhJQ

4.1 SME 2jR

~x$^u¡ŸȫȀ(?

 Lorentz violation ,ɑʑNnTǚɅ(ɺɡ#B%Ȟ

@CB+$ǩĢ,xUɎɳ+ 1019 GeV $

G'ɑʑNnTFɧŤ$BÙɟā, 100 Łŏ
Ðƚ'$>ų#;+ƃ$ʘGeV Fȣǌ'ä±%#B% Lorentz violation ,ť+NnTʉċ$,

1019 GeV ʘ;,C¨(ŪÔC#B%ȵɰB

%;$7@,ĳ'+$ǱǾ+5%G&

ʚ IQ+ĖĠɼǜ,ƥ'ǜƽ$ÈüȔƁF;@ #B+$ʘ
'G G #âƣFɣ@ŰİžĤƻ ;7(7
IQ+ËĊǥ'ĖĠɼǜ+ǜƽ, PhD Comic Fêǎ[7]

#yLR^FÀƤʘǼʌ+R^+ȳǅ$ĕ+NFS`$
B¥Ȓ8('#7ɱ+c\k(y|gYK,ŋǌ%#ʘǿƳ+Ĭƾ(?BNFŬ
7

B:(ȭț+È##7

;ȭțÈ³ǭǿ]+(íĂəhw(?

Aʘƃõ¸ğŚ+BNFS`B

#Ă

$

4.2.2 g-2 Dp
 ǅĦȉń

Ə;?+,çĞǓǚ$ʘçĞʘçĞƟʘ#ƟĞ,ȍȈĞ+Ȱʁ'ʀó³'+$ȍȈĞ(?Bh

4

93

^j+ƃ

ȓƜFƔŏ$B%Ȟ

B¢;7ôȉĪħʐ$; g-2 ħʐʖĄ 6ʗ,ȍȈĞ+P+ƯĹɤůC7ƅƖ+ J-PARC <vMÛFǅB+$Ȥú}$ȸǟ+ƭ§ g-2 ħʐ$,ǘğ+fjFſ½ŻȦB% Ɣŏ$7[9]7ì PF¶
ʒ×$ʛ

h^j;ðȡ'%

Ą 7 vMĆȁÙɟāǱǾŧŨÕ
$Ě(Ȳ

BV

KK]MUc

hqjȩȟ;ĠǜƊ§F÷: 7 Łɹ

ǉć#BʔʘYh'&+ɲǜÛǓ;ɊǒĎ7$B\QZ@ɗ$'(qfvH? 1 Ɗɹ

4.2.5 45M=
 Ą 8 ,ReY+KWbħʐ$zĖĠVx,UOgȯ+ÆÊŲāF¶ʖĸʗʘ
KWb+Ą 6 wfU3wĆȁǱǾŧ+ g-2 ħʐǝ+VCFɘ#B@2015 Łiǝy7$ʏ¶#vM}(ůLM^cP^jIĖĠVx,ɑ²Ǆ[vHKIU^cF¶cîŒɸĜĦ

!

4.2.3 "*M:Dp
 ǭǿzUjĎ%ȍȈĞ+Ǫôƨ+ħʐʖñʘU^c+ɑ¯İmPwȯ+W^+(Ȳ@CBʗFP^jI+r^$Ȫʘ£7$ɞĽ+ħʐ$h^j$'µǝ,ȍȈĞ%(ɨ%ŞC7!7A Lorentz violation +h^j,òȍȈĞ%ʘÈ§+UOUxj$ȪECB4$bŲÛ,ȃ 23 §+UOUF¶? 1 Ã½+ȉń$Æɟ+ƃõ¸ğŚFǅA7[13]7z$+ħʐ%ôƊ(ʘƃõ¸ğŚFǅB%(;ŤØ7[14]ʖȓƜǥ( Lorentz violation ,Ȳ!

A7G$

ʗɌɱ'h^j$Super-KEKB $,}jUOU%ǭǿzUjĎ+ǪµǝFŵȎB%

ðȡ$ BaBar ħʐ+fjFŻĀB%Ɣŏ$7[10]bŲÛħʐ,çǚ

ǥ(,őɝ+mjoŲÛħʐ%ôŲÛħʐ+Ŀ

ǂȸ%#+ŚɎF¶  Lorentz violation +h^j$
4.2.4 q',9m=6aB

 ǭǿzUjĎ,ȈĞ+ǭǿ$+ɟń(ŌʇFë6+$ʘȈĞ+ǭǿ$+eMYvżĮʘÆĞ+ǭǿ$+Ķ
đʘȈĞ+ɑÆɟɤÛ'&ŞC7çĞǓǚĠȟ

vM}ʖĄ 7ʗ+hqj+ D0 ħʐ+Ʌƀ
Ƀ8î
đ+ȵƛ

@

Ą 8 ÆÊŲāFǝKWbħʐ¿F;%(ǭǿeMYvżĮ%ÆĞĶ
vJ]Qtc_(ÐǑC

A;7[11]{r'G#ʆǤIKiI
@$;ÐB%

C-

4.2.6 aB<aB

 4 ȇ$ɝ4ɞA CPT violation +h^j+;+
Lorentz violation +h^j%#şúFů7+ÑE$

 OPERA ħʐ(?BɑÆɟmjoȳǅ+čø[12](,Â;Ė(ȤúF;7ʘɟń+ǅĦʘE=

B TOFʖTime Of Flightʗ,őɝ+mLorentz violation (Šń,'%ȞjoŲÛ5&@C#7

ɲ+ɿ,<,A`+ Antiproton Decelerator F¶ɽĞħʐ$>ʜǘćʖ2012 Łʗì PF¶  g-2 ħʐ, J-PARC %vM
}$,ȸǟC# A7Gì

qeQĺFǐǲB(,5&ɩ$ʘALPHA ħʐ$,éŁʖ2011 ŁʗʘìƴȍçĞ+ɶƊɹjfx(ŤØʘìƴȍçĞF¶ʛ

VlDp!ʘƏɜ$,Ò:#ČŃǕš+ɫǺħʐ(;ŤØ7[15]ìƴȍʜ Ɩ;Ɖǟ;Â,7Ȳ#7GʘdwLȩʘė¶%ŝʓ$,` @ǧ7C}jʖʡʗ(Ç ìǓɎF
¶ #qeQĺ+ǐǲF¬#Bŝȟ ǣĎB $

594çĞ+ɑœȏƧɠ+ CPT ĬǹŚ(ĬBŠń,ǘćƏʑ+b+Cʖ  1018 ʗ+ 1 Ã½¨$
4.2.7 @0XZ !+;Əʑ+ȈĞ,ġĥ@$RȘq^j<ġĥȠƌżĮ+Æ,Ə;ɶɔʂF¯źB+$
+cKx+ Lorentz violation (Ĭ#Əʑ+ŠńFǵ!

7[16]
4.2.8 n8
 ǭǿzUjĎ,ɑʑNnTǚɅĄ 9 m@ŞCB+joŲÛħʐ+Ŀǂȸ%#+ŚɎ$ɱ×%,ǔÓ'ɺº(B%ƔŏC7ɱ×(ɺE Ą 9a ,mBȉĪħʐʘȄ¹çǚ+ƢȽ'&ʘ, Lorentz violation +;+$

ŌʇFïB%ŞC7

ŋ7!+^fj,mƄğ+ħʐ@,ǔ(ǡĽ

,ɀ:@C7GƏɜ+ȵƛ$,ozɍïɍȟ
IQ+NnTǬɶĤʘ^hJwe+Ʌƀ'G#
4.2.9 ZkE!

joʘ   ʘ ÆǇ(ǪPmjo+pjmIąƑǕšʘ  1 %  2 ʘ(ǪŋʘC@

åĒ+;A7[17]

joŲÛFɱ^fjħʐ%#ȵɰʄĞm@'BĿǂƪƨ

joʘe ʘ(Ǫŋ7ɞĽ'@  1 %  2,ɎɳąƑǕš%û-CB%D$

$,?Aȥ

ǥ(pjmIąƑǕš%7ÆĠ$C-!

C> +ȹ$+ƽɖ(ȶCB%,A7G

+ƣ+^fjʘ  1 %  2 ʘ+ÆɕĹ

Ǡ+áÑFæ:BǚɅĩ+ƽɖFŖC#,7GSME

FµA7CFm+ǚɅǥƮ+ƢȽ,;DGʖăƜŐʘȚAɛ8ðȡ

9b +?

Ś'&ʗʘSME F¶

joŲÛħʐ+ś

('A7mjo,ǜŤ%ƢÐ,ňǪµǝ(?B+$vqąƑǕš$$, òǼǓǚ+ȷ;ǚɅĩ(?B;+$7 ȇ$Ȑ¤BǰČȘm

±Ǫ+ĹFǜ8ĿǂƪƨjoŲÛ%#ȵɰB%Ą

Pm

joFǜŤ%7vqƈƊɹ¸ğŚ+ņʖʙʗ; LSND +icȵƛǝ(Y^hąƑǕš,pjmIąƑǕš%ôƊąƑǕš$,'gSžŴ%+ÊôǱǾȟ(ȸȅ#;@

+$ƺƘ+ƊɹēÝʘ!7A¯ɧ,pjmIąƑ;+$

Ǖš+ɱ*óE$ȬǘC7C,   %4.3 Lorentz violation NcDp
 Lorentz violation ,Ȳ!
'+
Ñ

@Ñ

#

1 %  2 % ƺƘ+ɱ*óE%#¯EB% %$$´@@&+ǻń+[K_A7Gʖ;;B

'+



#

A7Gʗ£+%DC@Ä¾Fǵic;'+$ŨŵA$ǱǾ#B+

ǘǕ$$

@£

Ǫ

µǝʘ

+Ĺ

+Ǫ

µǝʘ·

vqʘ·-ʄĞmĈǙ+ȣə(?

CBʄĞmjo+ſ$ʘLorentz violation F,:¦Ñɲ

C

C7

m

lation (Ĭ#ßÑŠń(ë07[18]¼¢ǥ(,ʘm

Ƴm

@Å,m

jo(ȾF6

B%ř

B+$

#%ř7

ĩȧ$;Bmjoħʐ, Lorentz vio-

lation +ǱǾ(ōȁ!%ƔŏC#7+ƏĖ+ǚǞ,mjoŲÛħʐ+;+Ŀǂȸ+?

F,ʘƊǿ<ǭǿ+œȏ'Ƨɠ(Šń'ōÖB @$

C,7(KWbĿǂȸ'ƃõ¸ğŚ(ŠńB+$ʘƢÐśƈƊɹ+ɺſ%'A7joŲÛħʐ, Lorentz vioB%Ȟ

@C7·

joŲÛ+Ďóʘ±Ǫ+Ĺ,+ĹFNnT$Ö

;+$( m-Ė?Ɏɳ+
2
atm/ E )C,

1GeV +m jo+Ďóʘ 1021 GeV (ǪŋʘjoŲÛħʐ,Ȥúǀ Lorentz violation +ħʐ%

%('A7 ¨+ȇ$,ħɾ+mjoŲÛ+icF¶#

Lorentz violation FŵȵƛFɂƇ%ř7

Æɟ+œı

B+%ôǚǞ$Ą 9 (+ǕƸFǵ7[1]#õFē

+ƣǠ+ǩĢ+¿ 1019 GeV ?Aı+$m

5 $,&M:Dp ƅƖ+ƢÐCB%joŲÛ(?B Lorentz violation +ƶĦǥ'Ƚŭ%'A7m$ȵƛCÈÑɲ+ȓƜ,hw(# 40 {]¨jo(,ƕǯ+ɮÑjoʘE$ʝ$ĈǙ+ȣəFȞŢB%ǭǿzUjĎ+õ

U+ǱǾ,£őǨG('B+$,'$>ǘCʘƺÛɺſ+±Ǫ+Ĺ%'AȓƜǥ(ƢÐƊ(ɨnTǓǚ,ʆǤǱǾjufU+ǃĲ(ŜG$B+@İÇCjuf-ǭǿzUjĎ%+

1 %  2 (ŌʇFë6%Ȝɟń(Ĺő;ľłÑɲ$ǱǾFȖ#4$ǘć+ʑN

ĕ%#;įƚǥ(ǱǾ¹¿ƺƘʝ èĪ(,ƺƘ+Ȝɟń+ĹF¶%,$7G[19]

#mjoŲÛFȬ6

95

6 MiniBooNE Dp

6.3 MiniBooNE $,&M:DpjR

 MiniBooNE (Mini Booster Neutrino Experiment),vM

 #ʘMiniBooNE $+m

}$ 2002 Ł

ìŗ$cUÌ$ǜŤCBʄĞʘ7,ɽʄĞ+ſ%

@ 2012 Ł7$ȪECǰČȘmoŲÛħʐ$Z,mC#'

Pmo3+ŲÛʖ;,ìĞmjjoƩǈǚɅ$Ş

jo
Pm

@ʄĞm
jo

%('A7

j



@ìʄ

jo3+ŲÛʗFǅB%$ʘ\Vl,ƢÐāÌ$+ʄĞʖ7,ɽʄĞʗ+Ðǘ$joŲÛ+Ƚŭ,¨+Ȳǽ;
              ʖɽʗʄĞ+ɤÛɳ@ȹ+ìŗF©Ħ#m

jo+NnTFÍƧŤB%mjoŲÛ,mðȡ$

jo+NnT+ɺſ'+$C,ħʐðƬ$ƢÐā(ǴĎ,'+$ʄĞ%ɽʄĞFÞÓB%,$7G7t+;
+(ʄĞm

jo

qfUVLk%#÷7C#

B+$C(;Ƽşŕȱ$Əő(ʘʄĞʘ7,

ɽʄĞ(?

#$BeMYvżĮ,RȘ

BżĮ%Ƥ°#Ą 10 w^cm

6.1

jotK+Ʀȱ$, 200 MeV ¨ʗ+ǜŤx`^(,Ƽş,,+$,&+,!%*





@'

Aʘ@=BʑNnTRȘʖŕȱ$ħʐ+ȿȏ,$,Ǭ7ħʐ+ȿȏ tK+ƦȱFĄ 10 (ǵ7[20]7ƭt,¨+ƀǖFêǎ#[22]ȍƍ@icɬūʘʖprimary beamʗ$B 8.9 GeV +ɽĞ#qfUVLk%ȊȕN+ǱǾ

w^c

'C;

ʖBoosterʗ @îAÐC71 r^Aȋ 4 × 1012 ++%©Ħ#ȾFɢ:7ɽĞʘɞĽ 5 Hz $ɏ

6.4 MiniBooNE $,&M:DpeS#+$ 30 kW %

%%'A 2012 Ł 7 Ɛǘć+ J-PARC +mjot

K+Ð×+ȋ 6 Ñ+ 1 @$C@+ɽĞ,cXfj$BzL+ơÇʄǴ|

ʖmagnetic focusing hornʗ(ũɛ7C7ɽĞ%cXf#$ƭtʖsecondary beamʗ+j+ȫȀ(?

b,ʄǴ|+ǴĎ$íƘC7+%m 
jok+%,  + bʘìmjok+%,ǴĎFìə#   bíƘC7  + 

b+Ķđ(?
+Ķđ(?

#

Pm

jo

ʘ  b

#ì

Pm

jo

ƭt

ʖtertiary beamʗ%#ɬūǥ(ǜŤ$B¥Ȓ8('
7+m#

joFȋ 500m Å(BƢÐā$Ȳ

BE$w^cmjotK+ Ą 11 ( MiniBooNE $ȳǅCʄĞm,ìʄĞmjoʘ7jo¾ȮɋFÍƧŤCm

o+NnTÑĻ%#ǵ7[23]
okʘ

m

UVLk+Ş¿

(ǁ

m

jo+NnT+ɺſ
ʘqfUVL!#7qfUVLk,t#BʄĞʘ;,ìʄĞmȘ+ misIDáÑáÑ$

Lk+NnTÑĻʘt

jo%R@+qfUVŀ@'%(Ĭ#  0 b

@+RȘ+ misID ,ɳB%(Ƽş

²NnTʉċ$Đ

ŕȱ$

ȿȏ,@Fêǎ#[21]

6.2 MiniBooNE T7=
 MiniBooNE $,ǙǕ+eMYvƢÐāFǝ7
12.2m +cU+,nPKʖISČʗ$ǆ
Cm
YvV

jo%+ìŗ$$BȨʄȈĞ+eM
1280 ¼+ 8 KeÆʄĞĐ½Ȇ(?

#ȳǅ

C7ƴ+§EA(PK$ǆCı'^rQPQi%ř
%VK]jjok$ic%qf%#ȬCʘic(,ȕȸN
k(,ȊȕNìmj#eMYvÆ+Æɳ@ȈĞɈÓ%ɤÛɳFȲǽ;A7ƢÐā+ȿȏ,@Fêǎ#[22]
Ą 11 MiniBooNE mjoŲÛħʐȓƜ

#

7

96
 m

²Nn

 ĘɽȊ @8B%C,ƃƃõ(Û#B$ʘjo+ɟń<Ăəƃõ+ēÝFȲB Lorentz violation +ħʐ(,joƩǈǚɅ$ŞC9#7G7ĘɽŔŅƩȊ,ǭǿzUjĎFjokʖʗ$,ic+ɑɦ

Tʉċ$+8Ȳ@C7C,ɞĽ+mɎɳF÷GƩǈǚɅʘmBm

joŲÛ$,ɂƇ$ʘ;CLk+Şɹɨ%
A7ìmmÈNjok?

%ı%(Ƽş# <,A+?
ʞĘɽȊÌ$,ĉ%©Ħ#7$'+'@ƂǓǚ+ðȡŚjok$,ic+ɑɦ

nTʉċ$Ȳ@C7ȕȸ
A

qfUV

'

C$+

Ɏÿ;A7+©Ħ,ƠĔƮʘ·ʘ%-ʘ;

2 ȇ$ɝ4ȣǢǥgĬǹŚǭǿzUjĎ+ǲC$$%©ĦB%ʘC,ƩǈǚɅ+ȣǢǥĬǹŚ+ǲC?AÕ(ɐB%('A7ť,ɩƃ+icɑɦ,mjoƩǈǚɅ$,ŞC'+$

ƈ+ǏǍQm_ƂǓǚ+ðȡŚ

A77 4 ȇ$ɝ4ɞA Lorentz!7Aǭǿ^QĎ

@ňǪ

µǝ

$;Ʈʘ

%ôʘ%

%Fǯ

#violation F÷9ǚɅ, CPT violation Fȣǌ(÷9+$B+$ǭǿzUjĎ;Ə²ɻ+@+[K_$ġmĥ$ĉ%ŞC7+ǭǿzUjĎ+ĉŚjok%ìm

B%(;Ȥújok+ŲÛ$Ĺ

SME (;C7

7 Lorentz violation

7.2 $,&,jR

 #ʘLorentz violation , 3 ȇ$ɝ4ɞAŅƩȊ(¸ğ7GħʐȓƜFƲ4AB+(Êɞ+ŅƩȊŕȱ$+:+ÊɞŅƩ%#ĘɽŔŅƩȊFİ
Ç7ƭ( 4 ȇ$ɝ4 SME F¶ʘmjo+V]IFƎ7ƭ(+V]IFǝ#m

joŲÛFśƈƊɹ+ɺſ%#ȹɝBņFİ7Əő( MiniBooNE +ic+ɑɦ+śƈƊɹ¸ğŚFɄ4ʘİ

#NnTɤÛɳ+»ğFȋƘ7

CņFǝ# Lorentz violation+ðȡŚFɉɅ%ř7,ǚɅǥ(ƭ+ʈ$;ʖȚAɛ8ðȡʈʗ100 ¨+rc

A[25]ʘ+77$,´'ǕƸ'+$ʘ$,

Pm

'G

Ñ

jo

@

@ʄ

Ğm

jo3+ǰČȘŲÛħʐ(ɻB%7B%mjoŲÛǳǗ

śƈƊɹ $ȬCʖ ,śƈƊɹȴɟń$ 2  /23 Ɗɹ 56 Ñ 4.1 Ǹʘ,mjo+ČȘ+ɶ$ 521m $ʗʘ5 !+Ųľʖ C ʘAS ʘAC ʘBS ʘBC ʗ

14 + SME +rc$ƧŤC7[26]
2

L
C + AS sin( T ) + AC cos( T )P(   e ) =  c

7.1 Ao-KIUb
+BS sin(2 T ) + BC cos(2 T ) +ƣǠ$,ĘɽŔŅƩȊʖSun-centered coordinate
systemʗF¶

SME

 SME (!#, 4 ȇ$İÇ7m jo+ SME

%(#7Ą 12 (CFǵ7

(1)

 Ųľ+!ʖ C -rcʗ,śƈƊɹ(¸ğ'ĈǙ+ÉəʆF 23.4ÁB%(?A Z ɚ,ĈǙ+%(Ƽş#ǰČȘmȣəɚ%ŀȪ$ʘX ɚ,ǶÑǋ+ƃõʘ# Y ɚ,ñŨLorentz violation +ȵƛ%,mŅƩȊFģŤB?

Ɗɹ¸ğŚ+ic(ɬ07

2joŲÛħʐ+joŲÛħʐ+śƈ@+ņFvJfjʝ!+ŲľFŵ%$$ C -rc,śƈƊɹ(¸ğ'+$ʘvJfj+ȓƜʘưA+ 4 !+rc
rc?A&CƑşC-

ɵ%'A7

7.3 jReS +ȇ$, unbinned likelihood fit $Œ@CȵƛȓƜF
ɂƇ7ņʖʙʗFǳǗĪńɺſ%#ʘ5 !+rcFƵ:7rcôĒ+ǪɺŊ 5 !+

rcFôƊ(vJfjB%7A(NĖ

+$ BS % BC Fa%©ĦȓƜ;ǵ7CF
5 rcF¶  5 rcvJfj
ʖ5 parameter fitʗ
Ą 12 ĘɽŔŅƩȊ ?BɎÿ%#ʘ&
+

ʘ%

+

#ɴƷŔŅƩȊF¶E'

A7ǳ(ɴƷ;Ăə#7(Ĭ# 3 rcvJfjʖ3 parameter fitʗ%û2%(7vJfj,tFµ@'ƃƹ$

+ȇ

$,«ş+s^jV%#icFǵ7
7.3.1 $,&#,

MiniBooNE $,!Əɜʖ2012 Ł 7 Ɛʗʘħʐ+ƏȑȓƜ%
#+ȹ$ɝ4ȵƛ+ 2 ½+ìm jok+ȓƜFǵ7[24]
ʞ Ą 13 (mjok+ȵƛȓƜFǵ7[27]

ic+śƈƊɹÑĻ,ÈN%Ê(ǵC#7

8

97

qfUVLk,śƈƊɹ(?@'%©Ħ#B+

7.4 jReS$ŀ@$ ʖǲȘʗC,C5&ȣƇ$,A7G

 %

%

1 ŁFɞ#ĉ$'% 24 Ɗ+;ic+îŒE$m

jokʘìmkʘ&@+ic+ɑɦjo

@;Ƒş'śƈƊɹ¸ğŚ,A7G$+ȓƜʘò SME rc(ɹùƔ+N śƈƊɹ+ɺſʖ23 Ɗɹ 56 Ñ 4.1 ǸùƔʗ

Ȳ!

%#ǘCBðȡŚ

@$+ȵƛ$,tfjFƵ:B% $7C, 1020 GeV

ƏĖ 3%+=@%#qfUV$[1]+ȵƛ+Õ(^I^ĆȁǱǾŧ+ LSND

B

+ 24 ƊɹùƔ+=@Lk(ǘCB%Ȳǽ;A7ʘic+N(mjoŲÛħʐ$ȳǅCicFǝ#°ȵ

Ʋ4#ı+$qfUVLk,ŀ@%©Ħ#ȵƛƛFȪ7[28]ȕȸǥ'Ƒş,²;++ʘ;

Fɢ:7

LSND $ȳǅCic+ɑɦF Lorentz violation %©
ĦB%ʘ 1019 GeV @ŕȱ%

%

Ñ

A7

[29]!7A£Ă+ȵƛȓƜ, LSND +icɑɦF
Lorentz violation $ ɂ Ƈ  B  % F ö Ħ  B ; + $ ʘ
MiniBooNE % LSND +icF Lorentz violation Fǝ#ôƊ(ɂƇB%,ʃ% % Ñ A7

8 .J
Ą 13 mj$,ǋǲȘ +ȹ$,( MiniBooNE +icFǝ# P

jok+ȵƛȓƜ #ʘ3 rcvJfj$ħȘʘ5 rcvJf

Œ@C7+ 2 !+vJfj,$,ǵ#'rc+N(ĹB;++ʘ

Œ@CBQw,°#7Əő(ǋȘ,m
ŲÛ
­

jo

śƈƊɹ(?@'%©Ħ;+$ic(

7Aɐ­'vJfj$Œ@CBQw(;7Aɐ

8@C7GC,vJfj

C -rc+8Ƒş(Ė%Fǵʘ!7AśƈƊɹ¸ğŚ,ʅĽ(
ň%

%$ȿȵƛ+ȓƜʘ+ǻń+i

c+ɐ­, 26.9%+ǳǗ$d(ǘCB% Ñ Aʘmjok+ic+ɑɦ,śƈƊɹ¸ğŚ%Ȟ

#ÿʊ'%

GQ'ȓɅ('A7[27]

mjo%ʄĞmjo(ɺB Lorentz vio-

lation +ǱǾFǵ7ȓƜ,nRhJw$+en(ĬBfj

Œ@C7°?

vM}+ MINOS m
IceCube ȳǅŧ$ʘjo(ɺBmw'ȓƜ'ǱǾjoŲÛħʐ%ãƤ+Pmjo%cLmjoŲÛ$ȪECʘ<,AnRhJ

Œ@C#7[30]7h^jC#'+,cLm jo%ʄĞm jo(ɺBŲÛ$C,ÐǘŲÛħʐʖappearance oscillation experimentʗ$,ʃʘƿęŲÛħʐʖdisappearance oscillation experimentʗ(?BIxeěŋ%řEC7Əɜ+v^+çĞǊìʄĞmjoƿęŲÛħʐ+

Double Chooz +ȵƛ(?B%ʘ+en;śƈƊɹ

7.3.2 <$,&#,

¸ğŚ,'

Ą 14 (ìm7+ȵƛ,çĞǊ+Ð×+ƊɹēÝ+ȿȏFȞjok+ȵƛȓƜFǵ7[27]

$[31]Ą 15 ( preliminary 'ȓƜFǵŢʘMiniBooNE < LSND +C%Ʋ4B%'ȵƛ$

'Aʑń

ic(śƈƊɹ¸ğŚ,Ȳ@Cʘ

vJfj+ȓƜʖħȘʗ;vJfjÕʖǲȘʗ%Ʋ4#Ė
#ɐ­BE$'ʘ7 ȇ+ MiniBooNE +m

ok%ôʘC -rc+8$ʘɞĽ+mǙ$ðȡ'mĄ 14 ìmjok+ȵƛȓƜ £ń,ic(N,Ė$joŲÛ%Ȟ

j%@C7C$ʘĈjoŲÛħʐ$ Lorentz violation

ȳǅ$BðȡŚ,

ɐ­+?

Ƒş%

'A²'

#77

';+

A7vJfj+ȓƜ;ic(śƈƊɹ¸ğŚFɀ:B;+$ʖħȘ%ǋǲȘʗȿȵƛ+ȓƜ+ɐ
­, 3%+ǳǗ$d(ǘC'%[27]C,²ǳǗ$Ñ

A7

ʑNnTǓǚ+ĽɈ@ %#²E$;' 2 ň% %D$śƈƊɹ¸ğŚ+ǢȲ%

E$,A7GĄ 15 2012 Ł 7 Ɛ+ ICHEP2012 $ǢȬC Double Chooz (?
BśƈƊɹ¸ğŚ+ preliminary 'ȵƛȓƜ998 %,ȷ

#;7ðȡŚ

'E$,A7G· -ņʖʙʗ+C -rc+8 Ƒş(ĖĎóʖ·ʘ
MiniBooNE +m jok< Double Choozʗʘm 
joŲÛ+ic,śƈƊɹ¸ğŚFǵ7G
T¸ğŚ
ǘ(£ť

@ Lorentz violation Fŵ%
Ȳ#B!

BIo

+m

m

ðȡ$ʘ

joŲÛ(ɺLorentz violation $BðȡŚ;ģÈ(,öĦ$7G[32]OPERA ħʐ+m
;ʘ@(;Nn>jo+ƃ

jo+ TOF

%WwFĹɛG@<
Æ?Aɟʕ'G#%;

# Lorentz violation (Ə;ŽŠ$B%Ȟ
ʑNnTė³m.A@C#Bɑ

jo(ɺBh^j,7ÈȪEC#7G 4 ȇ$ɝ4ɞAť, Lorentz violation (ɺB®ɉ
F 3 Ł%(ɸ#7ƭĂ, 2013 Ł 6 ƐƆ+Ħ$Ȥú+B¢,/KiJIl,wj
7$ɒʟ

[5] Greenberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002) 231602.
[6] Colladay and Kostelecky, Phys. Rev. D55 (1997) 6760;
D58 (1998) 116002; Kostelecky, Phys. Rev. D69 (2004)
105009.
[7] http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php[8] Brown et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010)151604.
[9] Bennett et al., [Muon g-2 Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett.
100 (2008) 091602.
[10] Aubert et al. [BaBar Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett 100(2008) 131802.
[11] Hohensee et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 170402.
[12] T. Adam et al. [OPERA collaboration], arXiv:1109.4897[hep-ex].
[13] Herrmann et al., Phys. Rev.D80 (2009) 105011.
[14] Mueller et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 (2007) 050401.
[15] Amole et al. [ALPHA collaboration], Nature 483N7390(2012) 439.
[16] Kostelecky and Mewes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006)
140401; 99 (2007) 011601.
[17] Hohensee et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 (2011) 151102.
[18] Kostelecky and Russell, arXiv:0801.0287 [hep-ph].
[19] Giunti and Kim, Found. Phys. Lett. 14 (2007) 213.
[20] Aguilar-Arevalo et al. [MiniBooNE collaboration], Phys.
Rev. D81 (2010) 092005.
[21] Aguilar-Arevalo et al. [MiniBooNE collaboration], Phys.
Rev. D79 (2009) 072002.
[22] Aguilar-Arevalo et al. [MiniBooNE collaboration], Nucl.
Instrum. Meth. A599 (2009) 28.

Ą 16 2010 Ł(ȪEC5th meeting of CPT and Lorentz
Symmetry+ʀóÎǭñȂ+ȢFȒG$B+ȩȟʖCourtesy of Indiana Universityʗ

[23] Aguilar-Arevalo et al. [MiniBooNE collaboration], Phys.
Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 101802; 105 (2010) 181801.
[24] Aguilar-Arevalo et al. [MiniBooNE collaboration], Əő('A7ʑNnTm¯

+ȹFƎƫ®F

#C

arXiv:1207.4809 [hep-ex].

^șʀĝü+Ǧƨ%ʘȹ+ƞƮFŨ

[25] Kostelecky and Mewes, Phys. Rev.D69 (2004) 016005.

#C\QZĖĠ+ĚƗåĒ(ŠɇFȬ%ř

[26] Kostelecky and Mewes, Phys. Rev.D70 (2004) 076002.

7ʠ[27] Aguilar-Arevalo et al. [MiniBooNE collaboration],;fPY

arXiv:1109.3480 [hep-ex].

[1] Katori, arXiv:1206.6915.

[28] Auerbach et al. [LSND collaboration], Phys. Rev.D72[2]http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureat(2005) 076004

es/2008/nambu-lecture.html[29] Katori, arXiv:1008.0906 [hep-ex].

[3] Kostelecky and Samuel, Phys. Rev. D39 (1989) 683.

[30] Adamson et al. [MINOS collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett.

[4] Kostelecky, Scientific American, 93-101 (Sept. 2004).

101 (2008) 151601; 105 (2010) 151601; Abbasi et al. [IceCube
collaboration], Phys. Rev. D82 (2010) 112003.

'8(Â,+ȹ$ǵ LSND % MiniBooNE % Double
Chooz +ȵƛ<ǘɋɅ+ǱǾ$ IUPAP C11 Young Scientist Prize% +F£Łʖ2012 Łʗ7¢%ɨ %F<B+,ɱȱ'% $
ʠ +ȹ,ÂÒ:#ƅƖɁ$Ǝȹ$ĕ+ĭɷɁ+ȼ,Â ÜŨ(! ;+'+$ȿȏ,êȞƀǖFêǎ#ʟ[31] Katori, to be published in ICHEP2012 proceedings.
[32] Abazajian et al., chapter III of arXiv:1204.5379 [hep-ph].