Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 1 of 11 PageID# 49692

Exhibit4Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 2 of 11 PageID# 49693

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTEASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIAALEXANDRIA DIVISIONIN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMERDATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATION)))

MDL No. 1:19md2915 (AJT/JFA)JURY TRIAL DEMANDEDThis Document Relates to the Consumer Cases

CLASS COUNSEL KAREN HANSON RIEBEL’S SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATIONIN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, COSTS,EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS
Karen Hanson Riebel declares as follows:1.

I, along with John A. Yanchunis and Norman E. Siegel, was appointed by this Court

to serve as Co-Lead Counsel for the Consumer Plaintiffs and Interim Class Counsel in the abovecaptioned MDL. I make this supplemental declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Attorneys’ Fees, Costs, Expenses and Service Awards. Doc. 2230. I have personal knowledge ofall the matters addressed in this Supplemental Declaration.
2.

This Declaration supplements Class Counsel’s Consolidated Declaration in Supportof Motion for Attorneys’ Fees, Costs, Expenses and Service Awards. (“Consolidated Decl.”) Doc.
2231-1. Since the filing of the Consolidated Declaration, Class Counsel and three other non-leadfirms have continued to work to effectuate the Settlement, primarily assisting Plaintiffs andSettlement Class Members with claim filing, addressing the handful of objections to theSettlement, and preparing documentation in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Final Approval. Inaddition, Class Counsel have worked closely with the Claims Administrator and Defense Counselto ensure that all Notice and Claim procedures have run smoothly. These efforts included sending

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 3 of 11 PageID# 49694

Supplemental Notice to a small subset of Settlement Class Members as detailed in paragraphs 1112 of the Declaration of Cameron R. Azari, Esq. on Implementation and Adequacy of Notice Plan,
filed as Exhibit 1 to Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Support of Motion for Final Approval of ClassAction Settlement (“Motion for Final Approval”), filed contemporaneously herewith. See also
Order dated July 15, 2022. Doc. 2245.
3.

As detailed in the Consolidated Declaration, through May 31, 2022, Class Counsel

had devoted 64,739.3 hours to prosecuting this case, resulting in a total lodestar of $37,640,583.50.
Since that time, Class Counsel has devoted additional time to representing the Settlement Class,and three law firms reported additional, valid time for the month of May 2022 to Co-Lead Counsel.
Through August 24, 2022, Class Counsel has devoted an additional 669.70 hours, resulting in an
updated total lodestar of $38,163,226.00. These new totals are detailed in the attached updated
chart reflecting the lodestar for each firm (firms with new hour and lodestar totals are highlightedin grey) (Ex. A). Again, all additional time and expense submissions were reviewed by at least
two attorneys from different Co-Lead firms, including Co-Lead Counsel’s additional time andexpense.1
4.

Considering Class Counsel’s updated lodestar of $38,163,226.00, 33.3% of theSettlement Fund would result in a fee award of $63,270,000.00, which would reflect a current
multiplier of 1.66. Such a multiplier is well within accepted ranges for class actions generally, andis consistent with ranges approved in similar cases within the Fourth Circuit. Further, the lodestar
figure above does not include the substantial amount of time that Class Counsel will be required
to devote to continuing to oversee the claims administration process and the distribution of1

As in Class Counsel’s previous submission, we conservatively applied rates in place as of 2021
rather than current 2022 rates.

4890-3634-3343 v.5

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 4 of 11 PageID# 49695

settlement funds to the Class, and to litigating any appeals. These additional hours, for which
Class Counsel will not receive any additional compensation from the Settlement Fund, effectively
reduce the multiplier, and should be considered in evaluating the reasonableness of the fee request.
5.

Since the end of May 2022, Class Counsel has incurred additional modest expenses,

and now respectfully requests reimbursement of reasonable and necessary litigation costs andexpenses in the amount of $2,345,821.98. (Class Counsel’s previous request for reimbursement
totaled $2,325,516.11). Like the time submission process discussed above, all expenses incurredsince May 2022 were reviewed by Class Counsel to ensure conformity with the billing protocol,
and all expenses incurred were reasonable and necessary, and expended in furtherance of thelitigation.
6.

Class Counsel’s costs and expenses are summarized in Exhibit A, with categories

reflecting additional expenses highlighted in grey. All are the same costs that Counsel would
normally charge a monthly-paying client billed hourly. Accordingly, Class Counsel requests thereimbursement of $2,345,821.98 in expenses from the Settlement Fund.
I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746 that the foregoing is trueand correct.
Executed this 29th day of August, 2022.

/s/ Karen Hanson Riebel
Karen Hanson Riebel

4890-3634-3343 v.5

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 5 of 11 PageID# 49696

ExhibitACase 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 6 of 11 PageID# 49697
IN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMER DATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATION

FIRM

Lockridge Grindal Nauen

BILLER
Amber RaakAndrea Pittel
Arielle Wagner
Arielle Wagner
Carey Johnson
Craig Davis
Elizabeth Odette
Erik Allerson
Eura Chang
Gregg Fishbein
Gregory Myers
Heather Potteiger
Jacob Saufley
Joseph Bourne
Karen Riebel
Kate Baxter-Kauf
Kevin Ravenscroft
Krista Freier
Kristen Marttila
Kristin Condon
Mallory Harrington
Maureen Kane Berg
Megan Van Dyke
Michael Winston
Richard Lockridge
Sarah Lundberg
Sarah Lundberg
Stephanie Chen
Stephanie Chen
Stephen Owen

1

HOURS HOURLY RATE
590.50$325
1,251.50
$377
75.50
$377
18.00
$625633.90
$325
11.90
$725
0.50
$650
20.40
$250
2.30
$250
385.50
$950
27.30
$900
2.00
$325
185.20$600
106.20$750
3,081.70$950823.90$800757.10
$377
30.50
$650
214.60
$850
8.30
$425
23.50
$250
4,108.50
$750
22.50
$425
1,402.30$377
1.00$1,0501,610.50$377
142.70
$425
50.10
$377
19.50
$600
80.00
$600
15,687.40

LODESTAR$191,912.50$471,815.50$28,463.50$11,250.00$206,017.50$8,627.50$325.00$5,100.00$575.00$366,225.00$24,570.00$650.00$111,120.00$79,650.00$2,927,615.00$659,120.00$285,426.70$19,825.00$182,410.00$3,527.50$5,875.00$3,081,375.00$9,562.50$528,667.10$1,050.00$607,158.50$60,647.50$18,887.70$11,700.00$48,000.00$9,957,149.00

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 7 of 11 PageID# 49698
IN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMER DATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATION

FIRM

Morgan & Morgan

BILLER
Alex Antonio
Alysha Dean
Andre Ducote
Andrea Carbone
Angela Mirabole
Arnold Ashley
Brian Brownsell
Brian Brownsell
Caran Smith
Christina Romero
David MorseDavid Reign
Dustin Gomez
Elisha Harvey
Emily Reynolds
Emily Reynolds
Federic Nguyen
Francesca Kester
Hanna Fujimaki
Hope Whalen
Jean Martin
Jennifer Cabezas
Jennifer Miller
John Yanchunis
Justin Tomlinson
Karthik Murthy
Kenya Reddy
Kerry Marinelli
Kim Mason
Lee Walters
Lynn Billings
Marcio ValladaresMarie AppelMichael Braun
Michael Ram
Nicolette Best
Patrick Barthle
Quinn Stine
Ra AmenRa AmenRyan McGee
Ryan Maxey
Ryan Maxey
Sara Johnson
Shawn Jarecki
Stacy Kirven
Stephen BottTim Ross
Todd Hauser
Todd Scholl
Todd Scholl
Tom Cruz
Valerie Wagner

2

HOURS HOURLY RATE
702.30
$377
2.50
$381
50.20
$377
14.70
$202
379.20$377870.70
$377
22.80
$250
40.60
$377
515.80
$377
11.60
$381
1,385.90$377
107.30$300
156.20$377
336.30
$377
3.50
$250
759.40$377
103.90$377
194.20$468
374.50
$377
23.20
$381
509.60$919
325.20
$208
1.00
$202
2,971.50$950274.50
$377
95.70
$377
606.20$919
247.20$377
519.40
$377
68.30
$300
6.50
$250
237.30$864
103.30
$785
0.10
$894
205.60$950779.90$377
2,685.30$676
520.70$377
378.70$377
1,719.60$468
115.90
$764
94.90
$377
959.00
$764
25.00
$377
1,048.40$377
259.30$377
533.50$377
392.50$377
350.70
$377
75.00
$250
444.50$377
266.90
$377
0.30
$225
22,876.30

LODESTAR$264,767.10$952.50$18,925.40$2,969.40$142,958.40$328,253.90$5,700.00$15,306.20$194,456.60$4,419.60$522,484.30$32,190.00$58,887.40$126,785.10$875.00$286,293.80$39,170.30$90,885.60$141,186.50$8,839.20$468,322.40$67,641.60$202.00$2,822,925.00$103,486.50$36,078.90$557,097.80$93,194.40$195,813.80$20,490.00$1,625.00$205,027.20$81,090.50$89.40$195,320.00$294,022.30$1,815,262.80$196,303.90$142,769.90$804,772.80$88,547.60$35,777.30$732,676.00$9,425.00$395,246.80$97,756.10$201,129.50$147,972.50$132,213.90$18,750.00$167,576.50$100,621.30$67.50$12,515,602.50

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 8 of 11 PageID# 49699IN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMER DATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATIONFIRM

Stueve Siegel Hanson

Webster Book

BILLER
Maragret Brulez

HOURS HOURLY RATE
103.90$275

LODESTAR$28,572.50

Michelle Campbell
Katrina Cervantes
Crystal Cook
Bria Davis
Jillian Dent
Tanner Edwards
David Hickey
David Hickey
Rachel Kenney
Mary Rose Marquart
Kate Marshall
Abby McClellan
Ross Merrill
Austin Moore
Michael Owens
Cheri Perez
Lindsay Perkins
Vong Phommachanh
Lynnette Siegel
Lynnette Siegel
Norman Siegel
Stephen Six
Charla Smith
Emily Smith
Emily Smith
Brandi Spates
Benjamin Stueve
Barrett VahleCaleb Wagner
Stephanie Walters
Stephanie Walters
Sheri Williams

705.80
8.00
3.80
21.30
2,254.70
74.50
217.70678.40419.5020.90
914.00
6.40
12.00
18.40
259.2070.40
1,467.90
12.20
110.60417.902,369.30
630.10330.30167.50157.402.80
48.00
2,471.20
73.60
16.40
1,824.60
45.50
15,934.20
341.00341.00$222,327.00$2,200.00$2,375.00$9,585.00$1,341,546.50$35,387.50$82,072.90$424,000.00$158,151.50$6,583.50$344,578.00$2,412.80$6,300.00$13,708.00$142,560.00$19,360.00$1,093,585.50$3,660.00$41,696.20$206,860.50$2,428,532.50$620,648.50$124,523.10$63,147.50$70,830.00$1,330.00$25,200.00$2,162,300.00$38,640.00$6,182.80$1,322,835.00$11,375.00$11,063,066.80$221,650.00$221,650.00

Steven Webster

CO-LEAD FIRMS & LOCAL COUNSEL TOTALS 54,838.90

3

$315
$275
$625
$450
$595
$475
$377
$625
$377
$315
$377
$377
$525
$745
$550
$275
$745
$300
$377
$495
$1,025
$985
$377
$377
$450
$475
$525
$875
$525
$377
$725
$250
$650

$33,757,468.30

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 9 of 11 PageID# 49700
IN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMER DATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATION

TOTAL
TOTAL
HOURS
LODESTAR
5.20$3,380.00
5.30$2,875.00
0.00
$0.00
3.90
$2,921.10
47.20$28,672.50
11.90$8,145.00
30.20$8,055.00
1,225.10$575,527.80
8.80$7,213.50
8.10$3,946.00
27.70$20,220.00
4.00$2,200.00
28.40$17,062.50
95.60$35,532.00
0.00
$0.00
0.00
$0.00
27.90
$14,507.502.80$1,295.00
3.70$2,775.00
0.00
$0.00
140.40$110,092.00
36.20$16,465.00
7.60$4,573.00
20.20$7,981.50
100.20$48,642.50
0.00
$0.00
109.20$58,896.00
3,043.90$1,147,834.30
4.60$3,335.00
23.00$12,650.00

NON-LEAD FIRMS
Abington Cole & Ellery
Ademi & O'Reilly, LLP
Badgley Mullins Turner PLLC
Barbuto & Johansson
Barnow & Associates
Barrack Rodos Bacine
Beasley Allen
Berger Montague
Bleichmar Fonti & Auld
Blood Hurst & O'Reardon
Bragar Eagel & Squire
Breit Cantor Grana Buckner
Cafferty Clobes Meriwether & Sprengel
Capstone Law
Chestnut Cambronne
Clinton & Peed
Cohen & MaladCohen Milstein
DiCello Levitt Gutzler
Edelson & Associates
Emerson Firm
Feinstein Doyle Payne & Kravec
Fine Kaplan and Black
Foulston SiefkinFranklin D. Azar & Assocaites
Geoff McDonald & Associates
Gibbs Law GroupGlancy Prongay & Murray
Goldman Scarlato & Penny
Golomb Spirt Grunfeld
Golomb & Honik
Grabar Law OfficeGrenier Law Group
Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro
HausfeldHellmuth & Johnson
Heninger Garrison Davis
Herman Jones
Kantrowitz Goldhamer & Graifman
Karon LLC
Kelly Guzzo
Kessler Topaz Meltzer Check
Kohn Swift
Levin Sedran & Berman LLPLukins & Annis Attorneys

369.300.00
833.50
0.00
29.10
31.60
21.00
33.50
15.50
71.40
14.40
0.00
996.800.00
4$140,092.50$0.00$318,096.90$0.00$23,937.00$12,072.20$15,247.00$29,647.50$9,924.50$23,207.50$7,389.00$0.00$376,459.20$0.00

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 10 of 11 PageID#IN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMERDATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATION
49701
NON-LEAD FIRMS
Mason Lietz & Klinger
Whitfield Bryson & Mason
Milberg Phillips Grossman
Nussbaum Law Group
Podolsky Law Offices
Shub Law GroupSpector Roseman & Kodroff
Stull Stull & Brody
Terrell Marshall Law GroupThe Consumer Law GroupThe Consumer Protection Firm
The Grant Law Firm
The Law Offices of Dale W. Pittman
The Vernia Law Firm
Tousley Brain Stephens
Tycko & Zavareei
Vita Law Offices
Walsh
Wolf Haldenstein
Ziegler Diamond Law
Law Office of Michael A. Ziegler
Zimmerman Reed
Zwerling Schachter & Zwerling
NON-LEAD FIRMS TOTALSGRAND TOTALS

5TOTALTOTALHOURS
LODESTAR
407.00$140,125.500.00
10.60
0.00
136.00
8.40
63.30
0.10
0.00
384.80
39.20
1.00
0.00
2.70
1,945.00
6.20
23.80
6.10
30.80

$0.00
$8,961.50$0.00$51,725.00$4,978.00$52,988.00$72.50$0.00$145,069.60$29,400.00$375.00$0.00$1,260.50$799,593.10$4,030.00$15,440.00$5,559.00$9,520.00

67.90$35,789.50
0.00
$0.00
10,570.10$4,405,757.70
65,409.00$38,163,226.00

Case 1:19-md-02915-AJT-JFA Document 2251-4 Filed 08/29/22 Page 11 of 11 PageID#
IN RE: CAPITAL ONE CONSUMERDATA SECURITY BREACH LITIGATION
49702
CATEGORY
Copies/PrintingDeposition
ESI Processing & HostingExperts
Filing Fee
Hearing Transcripts
Mediation
Postage/FedEx/UPS
Research (Pacer/Westlaw)
Service/Courier
Telephone/Fax
Travel (Transportation/Meals/Hotel)
Misc.

6

TOTAL
EXPENSES$40,783.99$195,983.06$293,323.09$1,379,395.16$14,971.00$4,751.60$20,035.00$6,811.75$260,335.89$12,886.46$1,053.63$111,796.24$3,695.11
TOTAL $2,345,821.98