9５

TeachingMethods＆ProgramDeveIopmentinEE
ｊｏｃＥ､III21MLICII
TheOl1ioS1HlteUI】iversily

ThelnstitulelbrLe&lrninglnnovHItion
Onbeh2llfofNorthAmericanAssoci2ltionlbrEnvironmcn(alEducalion

ＥＩパironmenlKlleducalionscrvesmaIlypurposes、aIlddel)endingup()ｎｌｈｅｃ()ntext・doesverv
difにrenlthings、OIleoflheprimarypurpose§ofEEInustbeheIpingIearl】ers､relKardlessofage（〕rseltinH．ｔ(）underslandc()mplexenviro11mcllt8lIissuesandbeabletothenmakecriticaldecisions
relevalntloIheirc()､比xlandculture(D8ludialndIIeimlich､2002)．Mcth()dsaretheintersecti〔)、()ftheelemeI1t＆ofIhctcachin屑IeilrninHcx(ｈａＩ１鷲ｅ（IIcimIichHlndN()rlHlnd’1994）ａｎｄｐｒいFidcaI1imp(〕r【aIltkcyt()success()rfaiIurcil1effcctivelransmissionoflhcinlendedmessKlgelolheiIl1eI1dedle&lrner．
Ｕnk)rlunaltely・manyinstructor目seIectmethodsbasedontheirownexperience、exposure、ａI】dpriormodels-o(ｔｅｎｐ(】ｏｒ、()deIsHllthat（Barzun・’991)－ｒａｌｈｅｒｔｌｌａｎｏｎｔｈｅｎｅｅｄｓ()flheIearner・lhe
Iearners,thecontent､ｌｈｅｃ(〕ntcxt･ａｎｄtheirleacl1inRabiIities、PcopleIearniI1whalc&ｌＩ１ｂｅ()rgaI1ized

紐ｓｔｈｒｅｅｄｉ凱inctpatlerns:asilldividuals,ｉｎｃ(〕llaborative円roups.（〕ｒｉｎｉｎ釧itutionalizedpKllIerns.ｅ,9．
schoolｓ(SeamaX1andFelleIlz、1989)．Ｏｕｒｒ()ＩｅａｎｄＮｏａＩｉｓｔ(）reachindividualsinwhateverpatternusillgtheslrategiesthalwiⅡｍｏ:tlikelyfaciIitateIcilrningsuccess．
BuiIdinglDroHraImsandl，｢1噸ramTheory

FormanydccHldes・ｔｈｅＵ.S，wasdrivenbycurricuIumtI1e()ryinlbrmaleducatioIlandpr()IFram
desilHnmodclslbrnoI1-fiDrmalaIldinh)rmaleduc&lti(Dnalprograms・Ryder(2006)、(〕tcsthevarietvof
prescripliwdesiImmodelsincIudingAIHo-Ileurislicthe()ry・ＡＤＩ)ＩＥ．ＡＲＣＳ、Criteri()趾referenced．

c()mponeIlldisplay､ｌＳＤ.』ＣＩＤａｎｄ（)thersandpres(ｍｌｓａｃｏｍｐａｒ脂onagainslp()stm()derntheoriesof
instrucli()ｎｋ)Cu副ｎｌｇ（〕llconslrlIctivism・actionrcseHlrch，aclivilvthe()ry・ancI1oredinstructi(〕n．
andraH()狸ｙａｎ(lthelikeThissulKge§ｔｓｔｈａｔＩｌ()ｗｗｅｔｃａｃｌｌｉｓｎｏｗｎＩ〔)ｒｃ円rouIldedinIearninlgthanin
dcsiNI1fromlhei1lstrucIi()IlalpoiIlt〔)lｖｉｅｗ・Ｗｉｌｈｔｈｅｍ()ｖｃｔ()wilrdaccouIltabilily，theneId（)fevaIualion､suseolproRrammodclsusing

pr()gramlhe()rybecamcincreasin座lydominan【（RoRersandHHIski，２００１)．CurrentIy･mostorgaIlizati〔〕､sandagellcicsHlrcrcquiringl〕Iallningusingprogramm()delswIlichIiIlkimended

audienccsHlnda〔tivilie§direcl1yIoll】ｅ（〕utc()mcsoflheprogramoreducationalexperiellce、Form5lnyeducat()rsandorgaIlizalions,thi爵Hhiflinplannin円ibcushaschKlngcdinslructi()I1almeIh〔〕dsu§edinvariousprojgrams．Ｔ(）ｂｅｍｏｒｅｅｆ化ctive･ancxaminati(〕、ｏｆlhedesircdoulcoIneswithlhc

audiel1ce・lllecoIltexLHlndtheHIctivityfbrceeducHltorsl〔）ｒcc()I1siderb()wtheyilrepresentil1g5md
engalHinglealrnersil1thcirlearning号lIlcmelh(DdsnndstraleRiesusedinillstruclion、Joneset【11(1995)rep()rtedlllework()fMealIs・idenlificati()、()fsevcnvariabl巳sthnいvhenpresenlil】tbccIassr(〕０ｍ、indicateelfe仁Iivetcachin鷹alldleKlrningTbesecIas§r(〕(DmvHlriables、whichcan
tranSlertoaIWIearnin関seltinRandacrosH1IlcIMC-spaIlare：
・IeamersengagediluauthenticandmultidiscipIinaryt【lsks・alsscssment§(（（)rmKll〔)rinlbrmal)bHlsed(〕nlearnersperIbrmancどｏｆｒｅ(lIt8lsks
・Iearnersparlicipatcininler&lctiveInodes()finslructi〔〕、・learnerswork(JollaborativeIy・IearnersHlre閣roupedheter(》geI1eously
・theteachcrf曲cilitat“learnillg

ＥＭＴＲＯＭＶＥｊｖＴﾉｌＬＥＤＵＣＡＴＩＯＮりりL,ﾉ51ＮO鯵３

9６

ﾉ()eE"EIMLlC"・learllerslearnlhroulgIlexploration

MelIlodsarethet()olsbywhicheducatorscHlnconslructlhese()pportunities．
Usin鷺Meth(DdstoLimkPr(DgmmGIDaIswiIhLearnerMIDlivations

ＳｏｍｅｌＩ１ｅ()ristsIlolelhercisconsistcnlc()nfusionaboulw()ｒｄｓｕｓｅｄｔｏｄｅｓｃｒｉｂｅｔｈｅｔｅ&lchiIlg

proce§s：meIhods､strale円ies，techniques，ｌ〔x)1s・devices，producls8lndothers（SeamanandFellenz,1989)．InthevernaculKMP､1,0部individu【ｌｌｓｕｓｅ￣meth()d算torehrIospecificinstruclionalstralegies・

eveI1thou闇htheoristsusemethodiIlreferencｅｔ《）larger2lpproaches，Therearenumerous
taxon()ｍｉｅｓｏｆｍｅｔｈｏｄｓａｎｄteHlchingslrateRie鳥.ｎm。（ｂｅl)urposefbraⅡｉｓｔｏｃｒｅａｔｅａｌｒ&ｌｍｃｗｏｒｋｈ》r
understandingtIleoreticalcollIleclionsnInonRdiflereIllt()()１s､aII2limed【ltprovidinge雌ctivcvehicles
lbrtran$mis烏ion（Stronge、2002)．Ａｎｅｘ;lml)IeoflherangeofstrKlteRyconsiderationsistheco【Itinuumofinstructi(DnfrominlbrmationRivingloinquiryfbrscienceIearninR(CantreⅡ､２０(〕4）toexperienIialeducationHtructures（eH,KraftandKielsmeier．’”5)．Ｆ()rmanyeducators・themore
traditionaIstructurefbrmethodsincIudesfivecateRories：
P'･(“"ku"()〃Ｍｃｌﾉl(jdJincludelr【lditionIlIlccture」ｃｃ【urewithvisu2lIaids・Iecturewithsupplements(e､R，sen&oryadded)．presentationswilhexampIesimBIuｄｉｎＲｌｉｖｅＨｌｎｉｍａＩｓ、lbeatre、monoloRues，
presentation/Iecturewithquestiol1/al1swersession､andDtberapproilcheswhere・Ｉｎａｌｌｏｆｌｈｅｓｅ・thelefIcherhoIdstheinlbrmationandcontr()IsitsreleHlseinaprimarilydidacticmanner，TI1eprimary
purposcofpresentationmeth()dsistheclflcienldeliveryofalargequantity(〕finlOrmationwiththeroleoftheeducatorbeingtopreseIltlheinlbrmaIionclearIy・simply・ａｎｄｃ()nci5ely（L()velLl987)．
Whendomewe此lpresentnIioIlmeth()diseflecliveinsupplyinIFinfOrmationtolcarnersi11adirecte｡,

teacber-1o-learnermanner．

、jβ(ｗＷｏ〃ＭｗＡ(jdsrangefrom爵mallNroupactiviticsI(）ｆｕｌｌ鷹roupdiscussions、ｂｒ&lins(ormillRapproaches,groupvotin円.ａｎｄＨｌｈ()ｓｔ()foIherslrateRieslhalengageIearnerswitheacIl()1her，Over
lOyearsalYo、acollcagueandlRathereddescriplions5lI1dcitalionsfbr（〕verl20diffCren【屑r〔)up
discussionstrategiesforawork5h〔)ｐ〔)nlHrouI〕ｐｒ()cess､Discussi〔)nmethods&ｌｒｅｕｓｅｄｌ(）shareknowledgeamonRIei1rncrs・createsyner鷹y･clicitideasandiJ110rma(ion・andsolveproblems，Wben
do【〕ｃwell・discussionmeII1〔)ｄｓｈｅｌｐｍ〔)veIearniI]lE1toevaluativelevelsthroughconstructcdsitualions
developedandman副Redbylheeducator．
、is(･〔JWP八・jVcJ川)ｄｓａｒｅｏ〔Ienth()seusedinconservaliolleducati(〕､,outdo()reducati()n.andexperientiHlleducation・Ｆｏｒｓ()meeducators、discoverymc(hodsincIudeexperientiaImcthodswhiIeinothertax(〕nomies，experienti8lImethodsarepresenledasadislinclcategory、１，（)thertilxonomies・
discussionmethodsarecollsideredpartofdiscovery・RegKlrdIess,discoverylearninRisb8lsedonthe
premisethatlcarnersalreadykｎｏｗｏｒｈａｖｅｔｈｅｉｌｂｉｌｉｔｙｔｏｋｎｏｗmostthings、Disc()veryIearningcan
incIudegames､experiments・andprocessaclivilie5・WhendoneweILdiHc(werymetb()dsappeilr
cflbrtlessininstructioｎ（thoughthevtakelremendousamountｓｏ［preparationｔｉｍｅ).engagethe
learnersfuⅡy・【lndareoften“fun￣hands-()n.miI1ds-()I121ctivitics．
Ｍ２【ｌｊ(J・Increasinlgly,mediaarcvicwedasadislinclmeth〔)doI()gicaIapproachtoteacI1inH、１，１)art・Ｉｈｅｒａｌ)idilywitllwhichIechnoI〔)ｇｙｉｓｉｍｐｒ()vingiscrealin鷹ｗａｙｓofuRinlgmediatoshare
cxpcricnccsaIldsensorvexperienceswithlcarnersthHltthecduCatorcouldn〔)Ｉ〔)therwiseprovide、
WhcndoncweII・thceducalorpreparestheIeIlrnersIbrIhemediumHlndtheiniOrInationth5lli＆reIevantt(〕tbecliIss・course、ｏｒprogram・Mediacansupplcmentancducati〔)nalexperiencewith(Dpp()rtunitiesli)rIcarIler＆thiltwouldothcrwi:ｅｌ)ｅｉｍｐ()ssiblelo§eeorhear-8lnelectronｉｃ(〕ｒｎＩｍ・
bHlsedIieIdtrip：iIlterviewswilhexpe1･IscieIltisls：tanlgiblcd()cumemationofKlnolher,sexperiencc
Hlndthclikc

ｌＷＷＲＯＮＭＥｌＶＴＡＬＥＤＵＣＡＴＩＯｊＶＶＯＬ､ﾉ5ＭV0.3

7℃【ＩＣ/】ｊｌｌｇＭＣ【ﾉ】ｏｄＳｆノンmlFf刊"JDCvehWJ]eJJtjJIEE

9７

及,(忙此,r-(ＩｂｓｆﾘＷＤＭ"ＩＣＷど(''71"１８．AswithaIIcluster日ｏＩｍｅｔｈ(〕｡s,thcrearcentircbooksandc〔)urses
dediEatedtoc(〕nceptsofindividualizedinstruction､ｐｒ()grammedlearninH.anddistanceeduc弧i０，．１，
aⅡｏｆ［hese．［hereｉｓ【lneducat(Dr-theymaybeinadiflerentlocaIion：asynchronousininteractioll：
enga鷲edmoreiI1lhedevelol)mentthanlhetransmissi()ｎ(〕flheink)rmati〔)､:prescnlinlg．(〕冊ｄｅｍａｎｄ,infbrma(i()nviaelectr()､i(ｙmedia;（)ｒｐｌａｙｓ〔)ｌｎｅｏｔＩｌｅｒｒ()IcinsIlapinlFtheleHurninRthHlMbI1owslh&ｌｌｄｉＨｅｒｓｆｒ(〕mtheteachcrinfront()ｆｔｈｅ恩roup、TheimentoflhesemeIIlodsi§ｔ()ｐｒ()videinh〕rmation
tothel(JarnereilherwI1enthelearncrneｅｄｓｏｒｗａｎｔｓｔｏＩＨａｉｎｔｈｅｉｎｋ〕rmHlti()n．ｏｒ（ｏｐｒ()vide
inlbrmationwidelytoa［onlemporarygroupofIearners・Whendonewell，teacher-aI)seJ1t/distancelearninRmethodsproviderichilndrewardinRexperiencesfbrindMduaIizedlearning．
Ｔｈｅｉｎにnｔ（)（instruc【ionislolklciIitateIearniI1g：withineIwir()nmenlaleduc&lliollthisiIlcludes
appIyin皿heskiIIsolcrilicaItIlinkingｉｍｄｄｅｃｉ馬ion･mi1king・Ｔｈｅｔｏ()lsawailabIetouslofHlcilitatcthis

learningarcmanyandweIleedｔｏｕｓｅＨｌｓｍａｎｙｏftheseslrRlte円ies.！(jchI1iques･ｐｒ()ducls､Ｃｌ･devices
asnccessarylosHltiMy11】ediverseneeds（)fIearners・ａｎｄｔｏｍ(l(ｃｈｏｕrstrategicslolheabiIities・
characterisIics・andlcvclsofourIcarners(Woolfblk・’990)．Studiesoverseveraldecadescontinuelo

revcalthatdiftrent:lpproachest〔)teKlchinlFcanallbeequallyeffective()requaⅡyil】eIYective(BiehIerandSnowman､1986)．OurroleistofiI1dwbalworksHlnｄｕｓｅｔｈｅｔ(Dolsappropriately．
Refbrences

Barzun.』.､ｌ９９ＬＢ(,gilIﾉl(,rEf刀ＩＦ〃噸()"『,】〔wMjrj,"1s(!〃(jqcAj"ｇ("I(ﾉﾉ巴(''７１j'19．Chicago:TheUniversityoI
ChicaRoPress・Biehler,ＲＦ・IlndlSn〔)ｗman，1986.ＰＳＷか,ｍg)･(ｲﾉＷｊ(，‘『〔，'`，(J(･ﾊﾉ"９．５lhEdilion、Boston:HouRhton
MimillCompany・

Cantrel1.,..2004Ｅ〃P《･ｌｎｗ(wcﾊﾉ"ｇ〃'.Ｓ〔ﾉﾉﾉα"‘ＷｔＪｌ《,rCwDrF汀("iｲﾉ〃αﾊｲ(w『(,r刊．Columbus､ＯＨ：Ohio
DepartmemofNatur【llR“()urces

Dau〔ｌｉ.Ｓ・;ｌｎｄＪ・EIIeimIich､2002.鐸Environment(lleducation:Callilbedcfined?”１，Ｊ.E・HcilnIicIl（DeveIoper）Ｅ"0,jﾊﾟ,"",c"'(ノハ,〔ﾉ'Ｉ(･【'"(,肱Ａｒ(?Mlr(･どﾉｗ(ﾉｶ､(,A・BIoomington，１Ｎ：PhiDeltaKappa
Educati()nalFoundaIi()n．

IlcimIicbJ.E､ａｎｄＥ.Ｎ()｢I&lndl991・Ｄｅｗﾉ”i'JRrc(lrhj'１９sい･ｌ`,〃I(J(ﾉ'ｲﾉﾉ`(h((wJi(''1．SallFrancisc():Josscy
Bilssjones,Ｂ,F､.Ｇ・Valdez.』．Ｎ(〕wakowski､andCRRlsInussen、1995.Ｐ/IlRgj"９i肱Ｃﾉ！()()Ji"ｇ(J"。〃Ji,１９２㎡'J〔w"ｐＭﾉr(,cルリ(〕mgy、N5lperv北.ＩＬ:Ｎ()rthCcntralRcgionaIEducalionalILabora(Cry、Kralt､ＲＪ・ａｎｄＪ､KieIsmcier（Eds）1995.ＥＷ'･iF"'ｉｎ肱ｑｍｊｌｌｋｉ,ＩＦ(,A⑪〔ｊｈ("'〔ﾉﾉljjYﾉﾘﾋﾟr('(ﾉIＩ(ｗ〃,ＬＢ()uIder・
Colorado:Ａｓ§〔)cialionlbrExperielltialEducaliolL

RogerＳ．Ｐ．』..Ｔ､Ａ・IIacsi,ｅｌａＬ(Eds.).200ｑＰ'⑪g'YH'''7川(,ｏｎ･〃ＩＥｗｌﾊｲ("i〔)":〔W(化"g“`"ｌｄＯｐ/)(,"1,,1"j“、NewDirectionslbrEvaluRltion､SanFrancisE()Jossey-BassPublishcrs・

Ryder.Ｍ,､2006.ｈＭＷ(･"o"`lMrsjlq,',,'〔jdk七ｓ(ｈｏ()lofEducati(〕n．Universityo（Ｃ()１０rad(〕atDenver，
http://carb(〕n.cudeIwer・edu/~mryder/itc-datHl/idm()dels｣)tmIAccessed3Feb2006、SeamaI１．，．F・ａｌｌｄＲ.Ａ・FclleI】z･’989．恥，〔･"ｗＡｗ"gj“/ｂｒｌ《，ﾛc/li"ｇ(,(ﾉMﾉ「.v，Columbu:,ＯＩＩ：MerrilI
PublishiI1gCompaIly・

Str〔)､関c・」.IL2002Qll(ｲﾉｨ"ハイゾピ雌(･'八，(''２(（(･ルパ．Alexandria･ＶＡ：ＡＳＳ()ci&ItioIln)rSupcrvisi()naI1d
CurricuIumDeveI(〕pment・Ｗｏ()IfbIk､八.E､､11)９０EmI(w"の"〔'小⑪.(九)んNy､4IhEditioI1.1〕osIon:AllvnandBac〔)l】.

ＥＮＷＲＯＡＭＥｊｖＴＡＬＥＤＵＣ,ｌＴＫＷｖＯＬＪ５Ａ７Ｏ３