ROLES Insights Number 2021-02 October 25, 2021

ROLES INSIGHTSROLES Insights is a commentary series written by our staff and project members on pressing issues relating topolitics, security, religion, and society. Views expressed in the analyses are those of the authors and do not
represent the official position of ROLES, nor necessarily the author’s affiliations. The commentaries may be
reproduced electronically or in print with prior permission from ROLES, but with due recognition to the author/sand ROLES. Please email: office@me.rcast.u-tokyo.ac.jp

Enhancing Civil Aviation Security: The Time is Now
Number2021-02

October 25, 2021
By Ryo Hinata-Yamaguchi

Since its inauguration in 2017, the annual Global Aviation Security Symposium hosted by the International
Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) has served as a critical international event to discuss the threats to andvulnerabilities in civil aviation security.
Under the theme of “Business Not as Usual,” this year’s round of the Symposium (AVSEC2021) held in early
September addressed issues relating to the safety and security of operations and the steps that need to be taken
under COVID-19 conditions. Furthermore, coinciding with the 20th anniversary of the September 11th
terrorist attacks, AVSEC2021 reaffirmed the international commitments in achieving the ICAO’s GlobalAviation Security Plan.
But while the international efforts are notable, there are still critical issues that hinder robust international
coordination and cooperation mechanisms for civil aviation security. Problems are particularly urgent in theIndo-Pacific, where there is much interdependence and demand for international travel despite the lack of aregional mechanism for civil aviation security.
First, the diversity in state governance means states have different styles of governing transport security. Whilethe variety in structures, processes, and circumstances is natural, it also creates obstacles for smoothinternational measures to implement Standards and Recommended Practices (SARPs). Problems are
particularly severe in states with failed governing systems that lack the adequate mechanisms for civil aviation
security, but also excessively authoritarian regimes like North Korea that naturally place greater focus on
regime security than public safety (or at least assume that the former would naturally mitigate the latter).

RCAST Open Laboratory for Emergence Strategies
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology, the University of Tokyo
4-6-1 Komaba, Meguro-ku, Tokyo 153-8904 JAPANhttps://roles.rcast.u-tokyo.ac.jp/en
office@me.rcast.u-tokyo.ac.jp

ROLES Insights Number 2021-02 October 25, 2021

Second (which somewhat relates to the first), there is still a significant number of states that have inadequate
access to necessary technologies and protocols for civil aviation security. The problems are especially notablein less-developed states with poor condition of infrastructures and platforms, as well as discrepancies inprocedures due to a lack of know-how and proper enforcement. Such issues increase the probability of humanand technical error while also creating vulnerabilities against insider threats.
Third, geopolitics continues to undermine international efforts for civil aviation security. The most notablegeopolitical victim in the context of civil aviation security is Taiwan (Republic of China), who continues to bebarred from becoming a member of the ICAO despite its active role in international civil aviation.
Consequently, Taipei has no direct access to critical information and regulations vital to flight operations.
To ensure proper global implementation of SARPs, the ICAO issued the slogan of “No Country Left Behind.”
Indeed, civil aviation security has made significant strides in recent decades. Nevertheless, international efforts
have seldom kept pace with the problems that continue to undermine the safety and security of civil aviation.
While it is easy to blame the inadequacies of international organizations, much is also about the insufficiencies
in the states’ policies and coordination among the various government organs and civil aviation operators.
Civil aviation remains to be crippled by the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, with many forecasting that it will
still take years before the industry can make a full recovery. Yet now is also the time when states and theinternational community must recalibrate and improve coordinated, cooperative, and inclusive efforts for
greater safety and security in civil aviation to truly achieve the ICAO’s motto of “uniting aviation.”***********************************************
Ryo Hinata-Yamaguchi is a Project Assistant Professor at the Research Center for Advanced Science andTechnology at the University of Tokyo and an Adjunct Fellow at the Pacific Forum. Ryo can be followed on
Twitter at @tigerrhy.

RCAST Open Laboratory for Emergence Strategies
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology, the University of Tokyo
4-6-1 Komaba, Meguro-ku, Tokyo 153-8904 JAPANhttps://roles.rcast.u-tokyo.ac.jp/en
office@me.rcast.u-tokyo.ac.jp