５ノＥＥ/ESResearchTrendsintheUnitedStates
JocElleimlicll
TheOhioSI&lteUniversity
OnbehalfofNortbAmericanAss()ciali〔)ｎ、)ｒＥＩｗｉｒ()nmentaIEducaIion

Ｉ（Ｉ１１８ｌｄ（()ｓｕｍｍａｒｉｚｅｃ()nlemporaryEEresear[hnlflnda[esKlndlbciwithinthcUS､ｉｎｏｎｅｗ()ｒｄｉｌ

ｗ()ｕｌｄｂｅ￣accounlaI〕iIitWInthelbrmaleducali()、＆hrcn&Ｉ（scl1()ＯＩＳ・univcrsilies､trainingpro浬rams)．
accounlabiIi1yis（iedtoslHlnd&lrdized,hiRh-sl【lke§Ies(ingHIndproductivily，Inlederalage11des､laX1d‐
mHIna瑠cmen【agenciesandor醜niz(h(ionH､nol-fbr-I)ronls.&ｌｎｄａⅡlhefreechoiceIcarningseltin蝉(ｃ円．
parks・zoosmndaqu2lriun1s･lMlIurcceIlters･museun1s-seeFalk、2005).、(BcounInbilitylakes(〕、HI
sliHhtlydilfcrentmeKlnin鷹．Ｆ()ralgencies・HlccountabilityisthedcHreet〔）whicIleduca1iondircctIy
contributestotllereducti()ｎｉｎｐｏⅡutioIlorthcincrcnseinpositiveindicatorsofenvironmen⑬Ｉ
health，Ｆｏｒｔｈｅｅｄｕｃ【lti()､3１（)rRanizati〔)11ｓ〔)ｒＮ(iOs,accouI1tabiIityistiedwithedu[a(ionIeadillgt(）c〔)nlinuedorincreasedsupp〔)ｒｌｎ)rmissi(､ns、ilnpl(mentnti〔)nofdesiredoutcomcbeI】aviors．（)rcontributiluRt〔）lhemissi(DＩｌｏｆｔｈｅ（DrgdlI1izaliol11〕ｅｙ(Ｄｎｄｉｔｓｌ〕〔)rdcrs・ＩｎＨｌⅡlllreeviews〔)f
accoun(abili【y,researchandevalll&ltionstudiesKlredriveI】ｉｎ&ldramaticalIydiIhrentdirecliontIlal1s()ｍｅ(〕flhebasicresearchw〔)uIddiclate・UltiIIlately・ｗｅａｒeseeingKImaljorshiftinEE(romaJlinterIIalvicw〔)ｆｃontexls、risk・andrcnec[i(》、（i・eIromtheperspec(ive（DfwhaltlMlppenst(）thc
learncrorindividuaIintheproces時)ｔｏｏｎｅｏｌＥＥａｓｄｌｍｅＨｌｎｓｏｆｍｅｄｉａｔiIlgchanIgeinolherslcndinRt()wardacl1ievillRthego8llsｏｆｌｈい)r灘mizalion（0.1)()noNhueandRus鳥(),2004)．Ｗ１１ａｔｈ)11()wsare
dcscription§ｏｆｓｏｍｅｏｌｔｈｅｍ&ｍｙ【IreasofcurrentinquiryintheEEc()mmunity（)ｆｌｈｅＵ.S・andloIl
snlalleI･deHree,NorthAmericHLTI1escslaIements8lrenoIcomprehensivellord()theyrevealwhdll
currellIresearchislmdil1R・Thcseidea5arepresenIedinthecontcxt（DfL1I1derslHlndiI1g（hesludy〔)「h(》ｗｏｕｒｐｒ(》gramsIcadlowardoutcomesdesiredbvdominalllstakeh()Iders-Hovernment・school§・
coInmunities､agencies,ａＩ１ｄＮＧＯｓ－ｔｈｒ()ughstu〔Iyin屑whHltprogram32lrc,ｈ()wtheyarcconstructed．

h〔)wtI1eywork,ｈｏｗｌｈｅｙｍ雌ctthelearner,llowtheyaflbc【sociely・andhowlhevleHldtochange．
Ｆ(DrmaIEducmtion

Ｗｉｔｈｉｌｌｔｈｅ（()ｒｍａｌｅｄｕｃａｔｉｏｎｓｙｓｔｃｍ・cnviromulelllaIeducKltionmu帥deInonstraIcIl()ｗｉｔｃ(〕ntribulestogtudeIlt鷺row【llandmallurnlionandmorcimpor【antlyhowitdirecllysupportsthc
R〔)alsandtcstscoresoflheeducationalsvslem，ＴｏＩｈｉｓｅｎｄ.ｎ】uchoflIlecurrentresearchinn)ｒｍ&ll
educationtiesenvir()nmcntHlleducati()、pro円ramsgeneralIytoscien(BeeducHllion5taIldardsand
oulcomes、AllI1〔)ughcnviroI1InentHllsciencedocsdrawlogetberthe（IiHerentsciencebranclles、ｉｔ。(Ｄｅｓｎ(】tnecess【lrilyh】Cu§()、lhecriticiUlthi1lkinH､humanities､i1mdiIrtscoml〕onenIs8llsoimpormntIo
EE(TKlskin､2003)．Ｔｈｅ。【ln鷲ｅｒｏｆｓｅｅｉＩ１ｇｔｈｉｓａＨＥＥｉＨｔＩlatitIimitsEE.§purposetoIneetingsciel】ceg()alst(Dju島lifyilsexistenreil1lOrmalschooIsysにｍｓ(Lい'erm&1,,.1992)．Gruenewald(2004)cilutions
tl1KltinsIitutionaIizinREEwithin［hegeIleraIcduca[ioIlsys(emworksaHainslthcIieId.ｓ()ｗｎｓ()ciallyan(ｌｃ(x)loRicallytran＆lbrmativcgo&'1s．Ｍａｎｙａｓｌ)CCI§(Ｄｆｆ【)ｒｍ８ｌｌＥＥ訓ｕ〔IiesiI1thcU.S･ａｌ･cprovidiIl氏
iInp()rl（lntiIlsiRhtsintoIe&lming,IeachiIlgilndtheexchal1狸c・ＦｏⅡｏｗｉｎｌｇａｒｅｓｏｍｃ()flhebroadareas
lIlatmightnotl〕eascasilyrecolmizedintrilditi〔》nalclilssr()om-bascdrescarElL･ActionRescarch，Ａｃｔi(DnreseardlplHlcesEEil〕thccoIltexlofcdu（Hltionandsocialcl】anlKe（Slapp，1996)．AIth()u円ｈｎｏｔｌｂｒａｌｌｔｃａｃｈｅｒｓ（Menler、1996)．acli()ｎｒｅｓ“rcI】ｃａｎｐｒ(ｗｉｄｃａ
ｆｒ【Iｍｅｗ()rkIbrenvir()nmcntaIeducati()n.sIg(〕ａｌｓｉｎ筒cho()1ｓ（Lewis､2001：Ｍ()rdockaX1dKrasnv、oＥＡＷ｝?ＯＡｒＭＥＮＴＡＬＥＤＵＣＷ・ＪＯＮ１ＰＯＬ.｣勗奴〕し３

一少｡＝.〃ＣＥＩ化jJJMkﾉ】

20(〕l)．RcsearchonactionresearcIlisiI1creasiI1HIybeiI1gc(D1lductcdinEEtoexpIorcdeel)ercolmectionsoIindividualstotheirlc【lrninH､communities,ａｎｄ(〕tberschoolsubjects．
･CulturaIRelevance，EEcanrevcilI、suslain・a11dceIcbratelI1evariedcuIturaIIradilionsaI1dconnecli(〕nsolIearnerRtolheirelwironmcm(Grass,1994)．Ｓ()mercsearchersareinleresledin
understHlndin鷲11()wenvironIxlentalproblemsorissuesnretiedtolheculturesfromwhichthey
emanate（Marouli’2002;Sau1.2000)．Othersarel(x)kinRlbrlilctorslha【innuenccracialdiversity
iI1lIlefieId(e,9.James､1996:HiIt(〕rLI999;Rivers､2003)&lndinlboseengagedinEEproRrammi､鷹（Armslr()n9.1997;Hillon､2003;Jac()bsandReyhner､2002;Ｌｅｗｉｓ&lndJamcs.’”5)．Ａｎｅｎｔｉｒｅ
ａｒｅａｏｆｓｔｕｄｙｒｅｌａｔｅｄｔｏｅｃofellliI】ismcmer円eｄｉＩ１ｌｈｅｌ９７０ｓ【lndremainsanimportaI1t
contributortounderstandin円Iearnin恩ａｂ()uttheenvironmentasilprovidesaframeworklOr
studyingtheintersectbetweenhunlanandenvir〔)nmentalfacl(〕ｒｓ(Henders〔)n,１”7)．

ExperienliaIEducation．Ａ帥ronRimtersectexistsbelweellthepracliceofenviroI1ment5ll
educationandthefieldofexperienIiaIeducatiol1（Luckmann・’996)．Experientialeducati(〕I1aI1owsustoleachenvironmentaIeducHlli()、withinspeciliccontcxlsreIate。tothcIearners(Smithal1dMcGinnes,1995)t(〕helplhemundersIandc()mplexenvirollmel1⑬lissuesandincrease
impactsonproenviroI1mentalbehawior(Ewart､1996）ＡｄｕＩｔｓａｓｗｅⅡａｓｙ〔)uthpre化rexperience
andtaskcenteredIearninlg（Wrijght，2000）whichisagoalofexperientiHlｌ－ａｓｗｅⅡ総environmental-educatiDn・Regardlesso（Klge・learningh5lsanHlctivesidethatchanRestheobjectivec(Dndi(ionsh)rlheexperiencecrc5llinIFlcarninR紐salransactionbctweentheindividu8ll
andtheirelwir(〕Ilment(KraftandKielsmier」995)．

･Place-basededucntion・OnccoIl:isleIltdesireincllvironmentalｅｄｕｃＨｌｔｉｏｎｉｓｔｏｐｒｏｖｉｄｅ

ｍｅ孔ningful・coIltextualexperiencesinbotllnaturalandconstrucledenvironmentssoIearners

becomebothacildemicachieversandgoodcitizells〈Leo-NyqlIistandThc()baldl997;Ｌ()veland，2003:Ｗｏ()｡h()useandKnapp,2000)．Ｈｏｗi【ｉｓｐ()ssibletouselhel(〕caIenvironmentastllbrum
fbrIieldworkre鳥earch・servicepr〔)jccls､HIndenlrepreneuriaIenterprisesisanimportantaspe[tofplace-basededucfltionrcsearch（ＮｕⅡ，2001)．Place-basededucation（orsense（DfpInce
education）usesIlaturaIandculluralhisl(Dry（OrionＳ()ciety・’999）Ｉ(）ｈｅｌｐ円emerateemotiolMllconnectednessiI1thelearners(Sobell997)．

・Animporlantmovementillresear(JhaIl(leducHllionHllinstilulionsi各ｔｈｅ￣grecninHcampus
eflbrtlcdbyorganizalionssucha＄Ｓec()､〔ｌNature．、&ｗｉｄＯｒｒａｌｌｄ(〕ther§(e・頂,Berheim､2003；
Bmwning､2003:Carr(〕Ⅱ､1999)examinehowtobcltereducatestudel1tsinsustainabiIitylhroulgh
makinｇｔＩ１ｅｓｙｓｔｅｍｓｉｎｗｈｉｃｈｔＩ１ｅｙｓｔｕｄysustaiMble・Greenbuildinlgs・purchasinx.cleaninH､ａｎｄ
ｃａｍｐｕｓｐｒ()閣ramsareallparloftbeappIiedreseａｌｒｃｈｈ)cus．

鈴

Non-nDrmal/inIbrmaI

Thevastmiljorityofanindividuarslifei§ｓｐｅｎｔｎｏｔｉｎｓｃｈ()０１.university､orlbrmaItraininIK［(IIeimlich,2005)ａｎｄｎｓｈｕＩＩｕ５ｕｎｓａｒｅｂｖｌｌａｔｕｒc6llearIlingbcing（BIoom、1976)．ｏｎｅ()「thClgrowiIMg
areasoIstudyinEEｉｎｔｈｅＵＳ､ｉｓthat()｢theｆｒｅｅ､ch〔)ieeorinlbrmaI/､()nk)rmal)IealrninR．

Free-choicelearning．Ｍ〔)sｔｏ「whatiUpers()llIearnslhr(〕uRI1ouIIMCisselfmotivatedand窟uided
byｔｈｅｎeedsandinterestsoftheIeHlrner,PcopleenRageinfrec.ch()iceIearIlingthroughtheuse

ofnluseums､libraries・parks，Ielevision・newspapersandb()()ks、whenconversinlgwithIriends

andlamily,Hlndincreasingly､throughlhelnterneL(Falk6mdDierkiIlH､2002)Thisimportantlypc

oflearninHisundervaluedandpoorlyunderstood,ｅｓｐｃｃｉａＩＩｙｉｎｔｅｒｍｓｏｆＥＥ（Falk、2005)．TIlc
basichuInHIndrivcIokI1owandLlnderstan〔IthatwhichisarouI1dtllcmisalactorinfrec､choice

ＥＡ７ＶＩＲＯＭＶＥｊＶＴＡＬＥＤＵＣＡＴＩＯＡ７ＶOL.j5ＭV0.3

詔

ＥＥ/E胃Ｒ(､seilJ.cﾉＩＴ】w1dsh】Ｉﾉｌｃ〔/niIedSlilにｓenvironmelltaIIearnin鷹(Meycrs､2005)alldbyfarlhemajorityofwhHltaI〕ersollbelieves・knows．
(〕rtIUinksaboulth(jelwir()nmcnlisshal〕eｄｂｙ（ree-choiceratherlhaIIh)rmKlIIc&lrning(Heimlich
2005)．

ＡｄｕＩｔＥ【wirollmelltalLearniJlg、ｌｎｍａＩｌｙ〔ascs・tI1ereisadiscoIlncctbetweenwhatwecIaiIn
cnvir()nmentaIeducaliontobeaI1dwluatm5lllyilduItsunderslandasｌ）￣educ&ltioI1￣ａｎｄ２〉
environmellIaleducalionvcrHｕｓｌｌ【l1ure帥u(ｌｙ()renvir(〕nｍ(mmIism，Thepercel)tualdiIemmalbrs()ｍｅｗａｓ鷹eneratedbythedominHlI1IapI)roachlolearningasdenIledbylbrmaleducalionaI
syslems（Sears【lIldKesscILl964)．Ｏｎｌｈｅｏｔｈ(Ｊｒ副ｄｅｏｆｔｈｃｔｅＨｌｃｈｉＩ１間/IeHlrninRcxcIMmRe・Malhcws（2002）sugReststhHllincidcl1talaIldcveninlbrmalIear1liI1Risnotofintcrestlomany
educatiolu(ｌｌｐｒ(〕fessio1IalswllollremoreiI1teresIediIlexamininginslructi(〕n-learninlgpr()ccss
illcludiIlgseIectiol1，arrangemenI・ａｌｌ。〔IeIivery（)finlbrmationillaln51pproprialcsettin円aIIdthe
waythcIearnerinteract5withlhecnvir()､ment・TIlcvnstmajorily(〕［&ldultpubIicsperceive
environmeIltaIeducatioI1Hlsab(､｡ｖ〔)lkIlowledRealldabsoIutesbascdontheirpriorexperiencesasl〕reHldults（IIeimlicI1.2005）ｓｏａｄｕＩｔＥＥｈａ魚aprimaryIbcus()ｎｉｍＩ〕rovinHqufllily（)［lihJwIlethcrlhroughusco〔elwiroIlmcnlIbrlitera［y、ｅｍｐ(Dwerment、transfbrm(htiveIearniIlR．or
applicatiol1todaiIylileal1dsuslainabIeliviI1IF(Dmudi､2000:Ilautec(〕ceur､2002)．Ｊ()ｙｃｅａｎｄＷｅｉｌ(1980）suglgestIearningsllouldbeslrurturedl(）aidindividuHlIsin＆'(hicvinIg&lfullyIunctionin照sitaIewheretheidealandtIlerealselvesmect-thele8lrnerscapacｉｌｙｔ(）dealconstructively
wilhIikDi§respectedal】ddcvelopcdAduIteducationcanaddressb(〕lｈｔＩｌｅｎａｔｕｒＨｌｌａｎｄｔｈｅ

ｈｕｍａ⑩cause〔Ｉｉ§ｓｕｃｓｏｌｔｈｅｅｌｗｉｒｏｎｎｌｅＩｌｌａｓａｌｅａｒnillgpri〔)rilvwiththc￣complexiIyof
environmentI〕ec(DmiIIglhetexttobeconliIluaⅡvreread＆lndint(Jrpreted．〔sonstalu11vhelping
pe()pletobuildaIldrebuildlheI11seIves(Orcllcc､2002）･Citize血Science・Ｏｎｃｏｆ［ｈｃｇｒ(〕winglllovemenls、andthereh)rcKll･ea§ofinquiryiIl【ｅｒｍｓｏ［
efncacy､ｉｓｔｈａＩｏ〔cilizensEicn〔ｃｌｎｌＩ】cclassro(､、､citizenscieIlceisofteIlteKlchersconductinR
their（〕ｗｎｒｅｓｅａｒｃｈａｎｄｌｈｅｌ１ｕｓｉｎ鷹ｔｂｅｄａｌａｔｏｉｍｐｒｏｖｅｔｈｅｉｒｃＩａｓｓｒ()()ｍｐｃｒ〔ormaIlce（ShcpHIrds()ｎｅ（【11.2003)．MoreRenerallly．（jtizcluscienccistllecontinu(〕u§，intelgrated，ｑ１ｎｄ
ｓｅ〔luentialprograml】】in度()fengaMgil1Igindividu&llsinRathcrinHmealliIlgfuｌｄａｔａｕｓｅｄｈ)rscientificinquiryandrelics〔)ｎｉｔｓａｃｃｏｕｎｌａｂｉｌｉｔｙ（alldlI1efocus（〕ｆｍｕｃｈｏｆｌｈｅｒｅｓｅａｒｃｈ）ｉｎｔｈｅ
ｄｅｖｅｌ()pmcntofthedatalKalIleringrigo「(Vac〔xDb､Brantlyal1dW1litMOr(]・’996）．ＣoInmullily-bIlHedEducaIi()lLAsmuchofnon-schooIIenrnin脛isbasedonwllKllpeopIel1ｅｅｄｔ〔DlivctIleirlives，lhercisasigni(ica【lttraIlslbrmaltivepurp()ｓｅｉｎｃ〔)mmunity-bascdcducationaI
progra、ｓ(Cloverela1.2000;Ｂ〔)yerandMichilel-Roth､2005)．Conm1uniIy-bKlsededucalio11()ccurs
inawlrieIy（Dfsettingswitllawidevilrielv〔)llbci（Bruening、１９９４)．Oneofthemostexcitillg
aspecls()ｆｔｒｕｅｃ(〕mmunity-bas(ｊｄＥＥｉＨｔｈａｔｉｓｉｔｉｎ(erRenerali(Dnal（ＧａⅡaRherandH()gan,２(XX)）
andleHldsusloneedingt()createand飢ｕｄｙｍ()delsofwhatworks,where､why・ａＩｌｄｈｏｗ・Ｉ、（hepoliticalsystem（)ｌｔｈｃＵ.S雲．ｐ&lrlicipal()ｒｙｃｉｔｉｚｅｎｓｈｉｐｉｓｉｍＩ)()rtHlI1t・andenvironmeIltal
responsibilityisapartofcitizenshiI〕IhHlt（)ItenmusII〕etallgb（（PcteI．s、］993)．Ultimately．
ｃ()mmunity-b&lsededucationgr()ｗｓｆｒ()InlheIucedsofthoseinlhecollumunity（oftendrivellby
hcalth，safely･andIamilycon(erns）ａｌｌｄｉｓｉIllerelbrcinstaIutlyreIい,antalldmeanilMgful（Enos,
1999)．

IZnvironIncntaleduca(i(〕I1rescar(ＤｈｉｎｔｈｃＵＳ.【l1ldindcedinNorthAmcricHlisnotaI1cal･ｔｉ間h〔lyreI&ltedb()ｄｙｏ鵬tudy，MysilnplealIcmI〕（ｔｏｉⅡuslralclhebl･ealdthofEErelatedt(）thcmesoI

educalionaIIresearchis・ＩｈｏＩ)e,ａｍｃａｌｌｓｂｙｗＩｌｉｃｈｌｏｒｅｗａｌｌｈｅｌｒｅｍendou：vZlrietvoftopic§､effbrts．
￣

andintel】ｔｓｉｌＵｔｈｃｒｅ葛carchcommunilv、EveryeIcmcnt（〕ｆｔｌ)ｅexample葛abovccHl11bc・ａｎｄｉｎｍａｎｙ

ｃａｓｅｓｉｓｂ(Jin19.ｅｘ(lmincdfr()mHu1iIrravofperspcctivcsusillgaIargearscnaIofresearcht()()lsand
str[lteRies・ThercisnoparEldiHm（〕frescarchd〔)minatingiIlIheU.S，todav・RKlther、tｈｅｎｅｅｄｔｏ

ＥＭＷｉｌＯＮＭＥ」ＶＴ・ｑＬＥＤＵＣＷ７０ｊＶＶＯＬ・ｌａＡ７０３

〃eEHejrIMjrﾉ］

5.1

knowtheefficacyoｆｔｈａｔｗｈｉｃｈｗｅｄ(〕,theculturalandsociaIconstructsinwhichtheseeducali()nal

prolHramsoccur・ａｎｄｔｈｅｒｅａＩａｎｄｄｅｃｐｉｍｐａｃｔｓｏｆｏｕｒｐroIFrK1msonthelivesofpeopIedrivethe
resc4lrcIlthatwed()．Andwcconlinuallvdisc(ｗｅｒｌＩＭｌｔｗｈｅｒｅｗｅａｒｅＲｒｏｗｓ()ｕｔｏｆｗｈｅｒｅｗｅｃｎｍｃ
ｆｒｏｍ－ｂｌｌｌthatchal1geispo:sible．

ASI〔)nRasweareheIdaccouX1tabIe．
ReIbrences

ArmstronH．Ｃ（1997）Ｓ()ciaImetapborsalldtheirimplicalionsforenvironmentaleducation，
ＤＭ'ｗｌ"ＩＣ"Ｍﾉ“Ｉ(wri(’'1Rejialr`･ﾉ１．３u):２９ﾕ12．

Berbeim.Ａ・(2003）・HowgreenislXreen？、い,elopingaprocessfOrdetermininHsustainabiIilywhen
planningcampusesaI1dacademicbuildillgs/゛ノリ(J""i"R〃r〃jgA”“M(･qljW１．３１⑤:９９.llq
Bloom.Ｂ､Ｓ(1976)〃【""〔lmchqmcJE"Jli(PS('"。“伽〕oﾉﾉﾋﾞ("71j"R・NewYork・ＭｃＧｒａｗ－ＨⅢＢｏｏｋCompany，
Browning・ＷＤ.（2003）￣Successfulstrategics［orplanninRagreenbuilding.'・ノ，AJ""i,,g〃ｒ｣YiXA2r
EWcwjo"、３１⑤:111-19．

Brucning,Ｔ､11．（Ｅｄ）（1994）Theｍｅ：EIwirollmentaIedlIcaltionprograms・Agrjclｲﾉﾉ(ｲﾊﾟ【ﾉEdIH〔､α"o〃ＭＩＲﾛﾆﾉ"F、６７(6)Ｂ()yer、ＬａｎｄＷ、MichaeI-RoIh（2005）￣IndividLIaI/ＣＯⅡectivediaIecticoffree-choicelearninRina

community-basedmappingprojecL“〃ｗｉ,v"l"'`ﾂIMlEWlに(lji｡'『Ｒ“e`'比ﾉ１．１１⑤:335351
Carr〔)ｌＬｌＥ(1999）℃reeninlgthecamplIs.”Ａｂ(’1ｕｉｃ('"''１１３．３(h):4-9．

Ｃｌover.、.E"Ｓ､Ｆ()Uen・ａｌｌｄＢ,llaⅡ(2000）７７'２〃ﾛ川'Ｔ(ｿ『、,1s/iwl】`"io":EmWTj,,,)lfP,"(lハ1.ＭF(hに(,ri（)"、２，`】
Edition，Toronto,Onlario:YorkUniversityB()()kslore・

Diludi･ＳＳ.(2000）ＥＶ)lDj･"lgcJM,ｗｌ,"(''1'(Wir(?、〔ＷｌＪﾉ(jw-ljrwrE(Ｄ"""u,"irj“(ｿ庇汰iMJ"ＪＡ`ﾉ“(〃"WSJ,（(ﾉｖｍｒｅｒ(''１１"ＩＣ"“rr(Jr噸j“ん'･〃ｌ(J""i"＃２"''"･()"脈"『αに｡,に(lriwlﾉ,'･og'･ﾛﾘﾙUnpublisheddoctoral
disserlnti()n．Columbus:ＴｈｅＯｈｉｏＳｔ【l[ｅUniversity，

Ewert．Ａ・（1996）．Experientialeduc【lti()nandnaturalresourcemanalKemen【.￣ノMTI(ｌｌｑ/ＥＶ，F"f'1Jj〔'ノ図Iにα"`〕'１．１９山:29.33.

Ｅno５．Ａ.｡.（1999)．￣ReaLreIevant・meaningfulle【lrning:Community-basededucationinnative

communities.“AnI】uaIconferenccoftheNationaIIndial1Educati(､、Association、OklahomaCi(y・OK

FHllk.』､11．（2005）￣Free-choicecnvirollmen(alIearning:FraminNthediscussi()n.藏匠'(i｢(j"''１２'１J(Jｌ“lにａｒｊ("lReJcﾛﾊﾞﾉＬｌｌ⑤:265.280．

FalkJ･ＩＬ＆Dierking,Ｌ､，.（2002).Ｌ“”'LFWilﾉl()1ｌｊＬｊ"ljr3f〃()ｗｌＷ２－Ｃﾉloi“しど(l'･'1j"ｇ（７）YH'1Ｗr"lj'ｌｇ
ＥＷｃｑ"p"､WalnutCreek･ＣＡ:AItaMiraPress、

G5111aRberJJ，ａｎｄＫＨｏＮａｎ（2000）Tnter間e【lerationalc()mmuI1ity-bflsedlearnin鷹andscienceeducation.”ノoMrlInlWfCsaj庇･ﾉli"S(鯵iF"cG7m(･hj"９．３７⑨:107-8．

Grass,RunI1inR（199`I）TowardsamuIticuIturaIeIwironmentaleducation・萄MIIlrj〔wﾉｒＩｌｍﾉＥ(ﾉﾛα"i〔"『、２Ｇｋ13033．

Gruenewa１．．，．Ａ（2004）・ハＦ()ucauIdianimalysis〔)fenvironmentaleducati(〕､：TowardIhesocioecoloHicalchaⅡenRe()ftI1eEarthChHlrtcr.'・Olrrj(TｲﾉlＩ''1ﾉ''9'ｲﾉﾊ,、３４u):71-107．
HeimIichJ.Ｅ(2005）￣IntroducIiontothcspeciaIissuc・菌ＥｍＷｗ""(wr(ulEYnに("i〔)〃Ｒ“αl比ﾉ１．１１⑤、
HeimlichJ.E，（2005〉￣AdulllearninRalldlIleeIwir()､ment.￣ＴｈｉｒｄＷ()rldElwir〔)l1InentalEducati(DI1
ConHress・Turino,ＩＴ、

Henderson,Ｋ,Ａ･(1997）￣ＥＣ()たminismandexpcrienti2lle〔lucali(〕､.￣.ﾉ()uUnlqバリＥＶ,F"e"〃ﾉEけI化α"('"、
２０(Ｊ:130133．

Hilton．Ｓ,（1999）Sig"(/ＭＭｒｌ披巴Vwiﾋﾟﾉに`，j'〔''1〔ﾉ(ｗ(，er')(llh3(ゾノＷ"o"αＩＰａｒＡＳＦ（i“Ｆ‘lにｑｌＤｎｉｑ"dDIrc,ｧ,Ｗｅｍ．UnpubIisbedthesis、Columbus:TheOhioStateUniversity，
Ｈｉｌｌ０１１．ｓ（2002）ＣＩＩﾉﾉ皿庇lﾉﾉｾ化ｊｗＴ`ゾIⅢjsjJ(j（１１"(ﾉ`'rsM"ｲﾉj''９(ＷＶ<"i〔)"ｕｌｐｑｒＡＳｅパノ“'1`llIl〃Ｊｌｒ“(，【イパピ〃1口"(【g〔，lljc"'．UI1publisheddissertation．Ｃ〔)lumbus:ＴｈｅＯｈｉ(DSt8lteUniversity．

ＥﾉV1W(ＯＭＶＥＮＴＡＬＥＤＵＣＡＴＩＯ｣ＶＶＯＬｌａ/V0.3

ljEﾉF糟iHescfljrﾉｌＴｒ()lJdsjl】ｒｈｃＵｎｊ化ｄＳｔｆｌ化ｓ

5５

jacobs.、.Ｔ・ａｎｄＪ・RcyhI】c『(2002)ハ.(7)("｡i"lWrG(ＩＭＩﾊﾟｗ()$Iｲﾉﾉﾉ)ｏｍＷＰ"`wllﾉＭ("1ＷﾉＡｌ(Jﾊﾟﾊ''(Jln'(,Ⅶ(ﾉｗｌｒｓ"(･(･“Ｊｗｌ(ﾉ(ｗｌｒⅡr(l／ハピriJ(19【,、ＥＲＩＣＤｉ円est‘159990．Charleston・ＷＶ：Clcaringh()use〔)nRural
EducationaIldSmHlIISch()()1s．

James.Ｋ(1996）鐸Milkingchange:RecogIuiziIlgcuIlure..､ノ(ｊｗＴＭﾉ(ゾＥＷ"〔w“ｌ低ﾉ'（(wri()'『、１９G､:127-3`1．

Joyce.Ｂ・ａｎｄＭ・Weil(1980）ノM(jdrﾊｲｿﾞｗ(･ﾉln１９．２MEdilioIl，EnRIewoodCliffS､ＮＪ:Prenlice-IIaⅡ.Inc・
KrafI､ＲＪ･ａｎｄＴ･Kielsmier(Eds)（1995）ＥＷｒｒ""(Ｉ化(''･"j"ginf(･ｶｲﾉｐｈ(''1〔ﾉﾉijgAc1.cd"(w/io"・Dubuque、
１Ａ:Kel1dallIIuntPubIisIlin間Company、
Le-NyquesLD・ａｎｄＰ・The()bald（11K)7）￣Ｔ()wardilpedallgolFyo〔place：Findingcomm()ｎｇｒ()undlbr
ruralreHeHlrchers・teachereducator:，ａｎｄｌ〕ractilioners.．、AmericnnEducati()nnlResear仁I】
Association、Chica関〔).１L，Levermann，Ｔ,Ｗ､（1992〉７ｶＦｗｌ"β(ゾfwl，j庇''1'"(,"ＭＩＭ（〔'nrio〃ｊ〃"Ｕ､S、Washin円t()､，Ｉ).C､:Ｓ()ｉｌ
Ｃ()nscrv狐i()nServicc

Lewis.Ｍ､Ｅ・(2004）￣Ateacher.＄sch(x〕IyardtaIe:ⅡluminaIingthcba円ariesofprac(icingparticipalory

acli()l1rese8lrchpedRlgogy,鰊ＥｌＭＴｊ""『E"/(,/fthに.(l"（)〃Ｒｆｗﾊﾟ･ﾉ『、１０q):89-114．
Lewis.Ｓ・ａｎｄＫ・James(1”5）￣WhoscvoiccsetslheaRcndafOrEE？Misconceptionsinhibilinlgracial
andcuIturaldiver局ity..､ノ(ﾉｨｲ"ｌｑハリ臼川ﾉﾊﾟ’'1"ｌＥｗｌ庇ﾊｲc(JJj('"．２６U):512．
LovclHInd.Ｅ(2003）“AchieviIlgacildemicR(〕HlIslI1r()ughplace-basedIc&lrI1inR:Student§inIivestatcs
showhowl()ｄｏｉＩ.￣RUuMIl('ors.`l(1):O1L

MarouIi､Ｃ（2002）￣MulticulturaIenvironmcI】ｔａｌｅ(luca【i()I】:TheoryandPracticc､萄Ｃ"Ｍﾉi('ルルＭＭﾉ(ｿ・ど"Ｗｍ""1Ｗ(IlEt/lＩ(･("j`)"、７q〕:26-42．

Mathいvs.ＧＡ・（2002）￣Le4lrninRprocessandstylesforhumHlndevclopmenl＝BestpracIicesill

lc&lr11ing・織ｎ.()〔ｗ,(ﾉﾉ"9s：ＬＷＭＮＬ(ｗｌｌｊｌｌｇルパイ,(7[,/、(,wPﾉｲﾘ),ＩｌｗｌｊＪハノＷ,,iFw(!/Ｃ化ＭＰＢバノ)fcrn,巳v、

Intcrna1ioI1nICon(crence〔)nLifeI()ngLeHIrninHkDrSocialDcvelopmen1．KeralIa､India、Menler､Ｌ（1996）￣Acti〔)ｎｒｃ目earch(lndscllooIil1ilialivesinejwir()nmentaIeducati()１１:Aresp()nse［(ＤＪ()hllElli()しDIwj,T),1,,1c,『『(lﾉLWrqJjｲ,'1尺“(,(ﾉﾊﾟﾊ．２u):375-77．

Meyers．Ｒ､Ｂ、（2005）国Ａｐｒ&lHmali(Pepistcm()Iolgyk)ｒfree.cb(〕icelearning．Ｅグパi、""'(ｗｆｑノＥｾﾉ,『〔･ａ"『)〃Ｒ(ｗ(J(､ﾊ．ＩＩｕ):309-320.

Ｍ()()rcJ.（2005）￣BarrierBandp&lｔ１１ｗＨｗｓtocreati【IRSustainnbilityeducillioI1pr()Hrams:Poli(ｗrheloric【１，〔Ireality.￣DnWT"l〃"'(ｲﾉＥｔｍ(w"(〕,ＪＲ“c`lrcﾉＬ１Ｉ⑪:537-555.
Ｍor｡()(２k．ＫｉｍｄＭ.Ｅ，Ｋｒa葛nｙ（2001）￣Pllrlicil〕iltoryac(ionrcsearcIl：八ｔh(j()rcti(ＢＨＩ１ａｎｄｌ)racticKlI
frKlmcworklbrEE、ノ〔'"､！(l/(ゾ幻Ｍｗｌｌ"(ﾘlr【llEthl(w"の,Ｌ３２ｕ:ｌ５２ｑ
ＮｕｌＬＥ.Ｈ(2001)Ｒ'"wハ[ﾉＩＤ()ん("１１ﾙ,ﾉ)庇lil｡i(ｗ,,7ｌｍｈｌ''ｲﾉﾙﾉ'/４W'７Ji''９("ldj"sﾉﾉﾉﾊﾞ"i(，"、RurKlITrusIFcaturc〔ＩＰｒ()jrcls、WashiI】関ton.ＤＣ:RurauISch()(ＤｌａｎｄＣ()mmunilyTru剖．
０.Don()ghue.Ｒ,ａｎｄＭＲｕ§ｓｏ(20()l）￣EmerginHl〕Klt1ern§〔)fab帥ra仁ti(Dninclwironmentalcducali()n：Ａｒ(ｗｉｅｗ（)fmalcrial§１，ct１１()(]s，andprofcs§i()naIdevel()I)ｍｅｎＩｌ〕ersI)cctives、ＥＩｌＷＪＴ〕""】ど"ＭノロO

ａｍＭｊ〔'〃Ｈ(，JmJY･ﾉＬ１０⑤:331-351．

Orefice,Ｐ．（2002）“Thecreati()ｎｏｆｋｎｏｗｌｃ〔lgethr()ugh（Jnvir()I1mentKlleduallion.￣ＩｎｌＰ，
Haulec()ceur.ｅd・ＥＷ`卿(･(腕(〃(Ｗｊ(''1j〃(，ｗﾊ`(ｈ')．/j/iP・ALP",１２COO、ＨａｍＩ)urg.Ｇ(JrmaIw：United
NalionsEduca【ioI1aI､scientific､nndCullul･al〔)１．円aniz(llion・

Orio1lS()ciely（1999）￣1,t(）ｌＩ１ｅｌｌｅｌ(I：ＡＨｕｉｄｅｔ(〕ｌ()calIyIbcuscdtea[luiI1R・繩NalureLitera〔vSerics・
CrcatBarkin厘t〔)n.ＭＡ:（)rionS(xjelv・Peter鳥.Ｒ（1993）￣Par[icipal()ryciIizensIliI):Alcilrnedwayo（living,宮WhilcPaper・Plainr()ｗ、NII：
ＧＩ(〕balHoriz()ns．

River§ｍＬ.(2003ル1(ﾉ“〔･「〃’'八℃α"ｗｌ〔J"(,"(lハノI《(ﾊ･`ｿ7舵IUwgr(ｿﾞｲﾉｨ"`jtD(),7,"blj(･ﾉＷＩ“仇,〃町･ｄｕｊｉ,,ｗ,ﾉﾉ(J,『`ノ〃'("'(IgE"'(wハイg2"r化汀６Ｗ肱，(．､雌｣in(，〔w/Ｍ･(I1JIIﾉ)((,ｒｓｑ/('〃ｌＩＭ)("'`IJT'【I.("ﾉｺﾞﾉﾉ'ど(ｌｂｉｌｉｒｗｌﾉﾉﾊﾋﾞﾊﾟ《，Ｈﾊﾟｊｌｌ"・ｗｊ

ｄｆｗ"lロ"l(''１９〃，(ﾉ脈rwW("'ｄ''1(J"(JNC'"wIl(JHC''(･』`,J、UnpubIisIlcdthe月is．Ｃ()Iumbus:TheOIlioStalc
UniversiIy、Saul.、(2000）￣ExpaIIdi噸Cｌwir()nIXIenlilleduc【llion:TIlinkinlgcriIicillly・thiI1kingcullurally・算ノ()【"w(ｌ／（ｿﾞﾉﾋﾞ,lvj'ｗ'''1Ｆ"'ﾛﾉＥｔｈｌ(･〔'"()'Ｌ３１Ｃ｣):5-8．

SearS.P.・aIldKessen.Ｗ・（1964)．￣SIalcmelllolpurp()sesandobjcctives()fsciellceeducaIionin

ＥＪＷ７好OjVMEArT/ＭＢＤ【/CﾉｌＴＩＯＮＶＯＬＪ５Ｌ｣VOL３

〃cEWeimlrh

5６

Scho【〕１s￣Ｊｉ，wTMlq/R“uPaJrjljjl馳陀lw7rncﾊ"1K．２U);3.6．

Sllepardson.、..』･Ha1･bor.Ｃ・Ｂｅｌｌ.』･Meyel．.Ｔ､LeuenberHcr.Ｈ･KlagHes・KIndW･Burgess(2003）￣ENVISION:Tcmche1･saseIlviro[umcn(aI鰯cien1i帥s,轡JrM"７Jαﾉq/､E､，ilwl"ＩＦ"、Ｉ“'r(l”Ｌ３４③:８－】LSmitb.』.G､､ＪＲ､McGinni＆（1995)￣ExperientiilleducationlbrurbnnAfricanAmericans・Ｊｌｗ’uαバリEx7〕ご"ellJi【化けMH(lliD恥１８⑤:153.57．

SobeLD.（1997）・SenseofPIilceCdtlcationn》rtheelelnenmryyears.,、PruCeediK1gsfr()ｍＣｏｍｉｎ盤
Ｈｏｍｅ:DeveIopingaScI1seofPIKlceinourComlIllJnitiesHmdSch()ＯＩＳ，
Stapp.Ｗ､B･(1996)Ｅ,wiJwl"Iwm化dIucmi(,"んrr"IpDMw"Ｂｌｕ『:Ａｃｒｍ,,爬蝿【』施触IFIdlajm,,lIMylFTJble"ｌｍｈ，"19．
Dubuque,１Ａ:Kendall/Ｈｕ[ltPublishinK．

Tnskin､０．(2003）EnviroIlmentaleducation:NewerafO1･scicnceeducnti()n．Paperpresemediltthe
HoosiersAssocintionInrScienccTeachers、IndiKMlzlp(〕Iis,１Ｎ・VKlcoob・皿．Ｅ･BrantIy,ａｎｄＬ・WbiteIbrd（1996）￣PubIicparticip乱tioIlinurbaJuenvirDnmen⑬I
manHl照emeJlt:Amodcllbrpron】ptillRcomlmlnily-basedenvironmentnImanngementinpcri･urbnn
are:Iii.'･Washington.、.C､:PeaceCorp５．

Ｗ(D0dhousc,』.L･HlndC.E･Knapp（2000）PIIice-bK1sedcurricuIumaI1dinstructi()､:Outdo(〕rand
environmcntaIcdLlcationapproHlclles，ERICDilHest‘I`18012．ChKlrleslon、ＷＶ，Clcaringh(〕ｕｓｅｏｎ
ｌ･urHlIEdu唖qtionnndSmallScho⑪1s・

Worstcr.、（1990)MvlI"てP,忠“`"ID"ｈｗＩハirl〔ｊｊＴ(ｿα･()ｌｐｇｉａｌｌｉｄＢ“・Cambridge:Cambrid噂eUniversity
Pres乱

Wright・Ｔ・Ｓ八.(2000）･NomorCpcI1cils..､ｌｌｏｍｏｒｅｂ()okS？ArguingIbrtheuseofexpelFientiallearniI岨
inpostsec()l1dHlryenvironlm〔mtHU1島tudicscltlssro〔)1,...〃“"ｗｕ陀Ｃｌ趣〃ﾉｨﾚI"ｙｉｄｌ．１３．

ＥＮＶＩＲＯＮＭＥｌＶＴＡＬＥＤＵＣＡＴＩＯＮｌ/OLI5MVDL3