 EN

Astrodienst Forum Archive
Astrodienst Forum › English Language Area › Discussion: Psychological and General Shopping Cart

 My Astro24.01.2023 at 13:44 [UT]« Previous topic | Next topic

Astrology»

Pages: 1
MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes (Read 391 times)

Krista ShippMember

MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« on: 03.11.2013 at 11:45 [UT] »http://www.magiastrology.com/heartbreaks.html
I have begun reading up on Magi & am finding it compelling
They use Koch charts//G & N are very important
I'd like your input on the validity of these theories
Posts: 15841
Gender:Krista~~~~keep in mind I have NOT had coffee yet
Back to top
IP Logged
Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes

Running For SnowMember« Reply #1 - on: 03.11.2013 at 13:26 [UT] »I find the Magi astrology frustrating. Back in 1995 I bought a copy of their book "Astrology Really Works!" ...
it's a good read but now out of print.
If you look carefully there is a downloadable PDF of their 3rd book on the site ...
Posts: 4782
Gender:http://www.magiastrology.com/mini-book.php ... which is all the love stuff. Again all the G and N
stuff is big in them.
My frustration with them relates to the datedness of their website and that superficially it all looks really good.
But when you want to get deeper into it ... where do you go? There just doesn't seem to be enough info.
It leads me to believe that they don't actually believe in it enough themselves to really market and promote the'product'. And if they don't believe in it ... why should I?

Back to topIP Logged
Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes

Krista ShippMember« Reply #2 - on: 03.11.2013 at 14:05 [UT] »They mention visual patterns alot- akin to Huber,,,
At times I have heard accolades about Magi- but as you mention- info is limited

K
Posts: 15841
Gender:Back to top
IP Logged

Linda Harris

Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #3 - on: 04.11.2013 at 21:00 [UT] »All I want to say is that as someone who has lived through many heartbreaks, frankly, I don't think there is any
way to avoid them.
Seriously.
Posts: 17033

Heartbreak, in many ways, is karmic. It's also connected to the authenticity of your chart. Whichever chart youuse.
Even after studying my own chart, and studying astrology for a long time, and when I should have known
better, I still got my heart broken.
Listen: whatever YOU do, you have NO control over the "other person"..... so their actions cannot be avoided,
as you would have to be a "seer" and not an astrologer to be able to predict these.
Even in synastry.... and I"m darn good at that.... you can tell people about the pitfalls of being with that personor remaining with that person, but....you just can't control whether or not that person is going to take therisk.... no matter how high... of following through.... to the end...usually. And get a broken heart.
Because love - whatever your definition of it is - is primarily unfathomable.
We don't know why we fall in love .... we have reasons, definitions, we can even predict when sometimes....
whatever.... but we just can't fathom it.
It's the great mystery.
LainieBack to top

IP Logged

Krista ShippMember

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #4 - on: 05.11.2013 at 01:22 [UT] »Lainie-Shake hands~~~been there
Posts: 15841
Gender:Even now- when I SHOULD know better- when someone turns out to be a fraud- its like a punch..
Almost like the first time
My lB so wants & needs to see the best in people

KristaBack to top
IP Logged
Piscean Moon

Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #5 - on: 05.11.2013 at 06:03 [UT] »Lainie,
I hope you never blame yourself that you know astrology so well yet your heart was broken..
The simple logic is that - in the eternal debate - free will vs destiny - it is destiny who wins.

Posts: 2085
Gender:I agree we constantly make choices - but even those choices are our destiny..each of these choices are born outof our natal chart only..
Krista - From one Piscean Moon to another - no matter what, we just can't stop seeing the best in others..don'twe? But I know regardless of having our hearts broken, we won't ever want to exchange our piscean moons forany other

Back to top

IP Loggedanna-linda
Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #6 - on: 05.11.2013 at 07:40 [UT] »Read the article and checked the synastry I have with someone I got my heart broken... very badly. TheHeartbreake aspect with G and N - yep there. Its contra-parallel (my Chiron, his Saturn) Found somethingelse interesting - My Saturn exact parallel his North Node by the minute.
Posts: 455
Gender:Back to top
IP Logged

Krista ShippMember

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #7 - on: 05.11.2013 at 10:08 [UT] »Piscean Moon- You are so rightAs every coin has two sides- there is something about Bl that is magical....
Lainie is a good astrologer- yet the heart has a mind of its own- we have all 'fallen' hard at times& add in the frustration factor of tough times
Posts: 15841
Gender:If that saying that going through hard times gave you a 'thicker skin'- I'd look like a crocodile
I say we be kinder to ourselves & each other
KristaBack to top

IP Logged

QueenofCups
Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #8 - on: 06.11.2013 at 18:49 [UT] »Quote from anna-linda on 05.11.2013 at 07:40 [UT]:GRead the article and checked the synastry I have with someone I got my heart broken... very badly. The Heartbreake aspect withand- yep there. Its contra-parallel (my Chiron, his Saturn) Found something else interesting - My Saturn exact parallel his North Node byN

the minute.

Posts: 393

This holds weight for me too. Bad heartbreak, his G m my N. Our composite N is also exactly m his natal G.
Back to top
IP Logged
Running For Snow

Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #9 - on: 06.11.2013 at 22:13 [UT] »Quote from Linda Harris on 04.11.2013 at 21:00 [UT]:All I want to say is that as someone who has lived through many heartbreaks, frankly, I don't think there is any way to avoid them.

Posts: 4782
Gender:

The only way to avoid heartbreak is not to get involved. But why would anyone want to do that?
I've been through six ... currently debating the possibility of #7 ...

Back to top

IP Logged

mistycharm
Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #10 - on: 07.11.2013 at 11:05 [UT] »Hi, to add, the G/N midpoint clashing the other person's N is also considered a heartbreak aspect, so that'sanother one to check. The N person would be the one feeling the broken heart while the G/N midpoint
person is the one who can cause that easily. Taking a quick glance, in our helio synastry, I have the o with myfirst ex.

Posts: 1793
Gender:Back to top
IP Logged
Somers69

Member

Re: MagiAstrology + HeartbreakClashes« Reply #11 - on: 07.11.2013 at 20:40 [UT] »What about aspects to other points?
My first true love that absolutely broke my heart heart has his Chiron at 22:25 and his Saturn at 24:50 Pisces my ASC is 24:32 and NN 21:11 Pisces. Even after 22 years I still can't shake it!
Posts: 2535
Gender:Back to top

IP Logged
Pages: 1

Astrodienst Forum › English Language Area › Discussion: Psychological and General« Previous topic | Next topic

Astrology»=> Discussion: Psychological and General Astrology

Go