JCM_ID_JC04_Mtg Rep

Date of meeting: 18 May 2015
Place of meeting: Tangerang Selatan, Indonesia

Joint Committee of the Joint Crediting Mechanism
between Indonesia and JapanFourth Meeting
Meeting Report

Agenda item 1. Opening
Mr. Rizal Edwin Manansang, Assistant Deputy Minister, Coordinating Ministry for Economic
Affairs opened the fourth meeting of the Joint Committee (JC) of the Joint Crediting
Mechanism (JCM) and gave opening remarks.
Ms. Yoshiko Kijima, Minister for Economic Affairs and Development, Embassy of Japan inIndonesia gave opening remarks.
Table: Attendance
The names of members present at the meeting are in bold print.
JC Members from Indonesian side
Assistant Deputy Minister for Multilateral Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs
Economic Cooperation and Financing
Assistant Deputy Minister for Forestry Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs(alternate)
Director for Economic Development and Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Environment
Assistant Deputy Minister for Mitigation and Ministry of Environment and Forestry
Atmospheric Function Preservation
Head of Research and Development Center Ministry of Environment and Forestry
for Climate Change and Policy (alternate)
Director of Energy Conservation (alternate)

Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources

Head of Policy Center for Climate Change

Ministry of Financeand Financing and Multilateral (alternate)
Head of Centre for Green Industry and the Ministry of Industry
Environment (alternate)Indonesia JCM secretariat

Head of Secretariat
JC Members from Japanese side1

JCM_ID_JC04_Mtg Rep

Ms. Yoshiko KIJIMA

Embassy of Japan in Indonesia

Mr. Takuro TASAKA

Embassy of Japan in Indonesia

Mr. Ryutaro NISHIMORI (alternate)

Ministry of Foreign Affairs

Mr. Yoshikazu HASUNUMA (alternate)

Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry

Mr. Yuji MIZUNO

Ministry of the Environment

Mr. Hideki KAWATO

Forestry Agency

Mr. Osamu ISHIUCHI

Embassy of Japan in Indonesia

Agenda item 2. Organizational matters
Agenda item 2.1 Adoption of the agenda
The JC adopted the agenda of the meeting.
Agenda item 2.2 Attendance
The Co-Chairs introduced the observers and the JC gave its consent to attendance ofobservers at this JC meeting.

Agenda item 3. Progress Reports of the JCM Model and Demonstration projects
Agenda item 3.1 Model and Demonstration Projects in FY2013-2014
The Indonesian side overviewed the progress in the JCM model and demonstration projects,explained the results of a site visit for one JCM model project, and introduced their views oncity-to-city cooperation. The Japanese side explained the progress of the JCM model anddemonstration projects in FY 2013-2014 and responded to the comments in the site visit
report compiled by the Indonesian JCM secretariat. The JC members exchanged their viewson the implementation of these projects and city-to-city cooperation.
Agenda item 3.2. Schedule for selecting projects under JCM financing programme inFY2015
The Japanese side explained the schedule for selecting projects under JCM financingprogramme in FY2015 and introduced the way of information sharing for the JCM promotion
scheme in Indonesia. The JC members exchanged their views on the way of information
sharing for the JCM promotion scheme in Indonesia.

Agenda item 4. Rules and guidelines
Agenda item 4.1 JCM Project Cycle Procedure
The JC considered the draft revised “Joint Crediting Mechanism Project Cycle Procedure”
and decided to further consider it.
2

JCM_ID_JC04_Mtg Rep

Agenda item 4.2. JCM Guidelines for Developing SDIP and SDIR and application toprojects
The JC considered the draft “Joint Crediting Mechanism Guidelines for Developing
Sustainable Development Implementation Plan and Report” and decided to further consider
it.
Agenda item 4.3. Draft JCM Guidelines for Developing Proposed Methodology forREDD-plus
The JC considered the draft “Joint Crediting Mechanism Guidelines for Developing Proposed
Methodology for Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation indeveloping countries; and the role of conservation, sustainable management of forests andenhancement of forest carbon stocks in developing countries (REDD-plus)” and decided tofurther consider it including through a specific meeting.

Agenda item 5. JCM Methodology
Agenda item 5.1. Proposed Methodologies: 2 (METI) methodologies
ID_PM006 “GHG emission reductions through optimization of refinery plant operation inIndonesia”
The JC considered the revised draft of the proposed methodology ID_PM006 “GHG emission
reductions through optimization of refinery plant operation in Indonesia”. Based on theconsideration, the JC approved the proposed methodology ID_PM006 with revisions, ascontained in the Annex 1 to this meeting report.
ID_PM007 “GHG emission reductions through optimization of boiler operation in Indonesia”
The JC considered the revised draft of the proposed methodology ID_PM007 “GHG emission
reductions through optimization of boiler operation in Indonesia”. Based on the consideration,
the JC approved the proposed methodology ID_PM007 with revisions, as contained in theAnnex 2 to this meeting report.
Agenda item 5.2. Proposed Methodologies: 3 (MOE) methodologies
ID_PM008 “Installation of a separate type fridge-freezer showcase by using natural refrigerant
for grocery store to reduce air conditioning load inside the store”
The JC considered the proposed methodology ID_PM008 “Installation of a separate typefridge-freezer showcase by using natural refrigerant for grocery store to reduce airconditioning load inside the store”, the review by the secretariat and responses to the review.
3JCM_ID_JC04_Mtg Rep

Based on the consideration, the JC approved the proposed methodology ID_PM008 withrevisions, as contained in the Annex 3 to this meeting report.
ID_PM009 “Replacement of conventional burners with regenerative burners for aluminum
holding furnaces”
The JC considered the proposed methodology ID_PM009 “Replacement of conventional
burners with regenerative burners for aluminum holding furnaces”, the review by thesecretariat and responses to the review. In response to the points raised by JC members, theJC concluded the following:i.

To apply the same default value for the energy efficiency of the reference burner among
projects.

Based on the consideration, the JC decided to further consider the proposed methodology
ID_PM009. The JC took note of possibility to approve the proposed methodology ID_PM009
by electronic means subject to further consideration.
ID_PM010 “Introducing double-bundle modular electric heat pumps to a new building”
The JC considered the proposed methodology ID_PM010 “Introducing double-bundle
modular electric heat pumps to a new building” the review by the secretariat and responses tothe review. Based on the consideration, the JC decided to further consider the proposed
methodology ID_PM010 especially on the issue of emission factors to be applied in themethodology. The JC took note of possibility to approve the proposed methodology
ID_PM010 by electronic means subject to further consideration.

Agenda item 6. Credit issuance procedure and registry
The Japanese side explained overview of the JCM registry system in Japan. The Indonesianside explained current procedure for issuance of credits and registry. The JC members
exchanged their views on credit issuance procedure and registry.

Agenda item 7. Way Forward
Agenda item 7.1. Status of developing draft methodologies
The Japanese side explained the status of developing draft methodologies.
Agenda item 7.2. Status of developing projects for registration
The Japanese side explained the status of developing projects for registration.

4

JCM_ID_JC04_Mtg Rep

Closing remarks
The Co-Chairs gave closing remarks and closed the meeting.

Annexes to the report
Annex 1 ID_AM006 “GHG emission reductions through optimization of refinery plant
operation in Indonesia”
Annex 2 ID_AM007 “GHG emission reductions through optimization of boiler operation inIndonesia”
Annex 3 ID_AM008 “Installation of a separate type fridge-freezer showcase by using naturalrefrigerant for grocery store to reduce air conditioning load inside the store”

5