ITER CTA NEWSLETTER
No. 13, OCTOBER 2002

INTERNATIONAL ATOMIC ENERGY AGENCY, VIENNA, AUSTRIAISSN 1683–0555

FIFTH ITER NEGOTIATIONS MEETING
by Dr. M. J. Stewart, President and CEO, Iter Canada
Over the past few weeks much has been accomplished in the quest to reach an international agreement on
the joint implementation of the ITER project. Most recently, on 19 – 20 September, delegations from Canada,
the European Union, Japan and the Russian Federation met in Toronto, Canada for the Fifth ITER
Negotiations Meeting.
This recent Toronto meeting continued the work that is expected to lead to an international agreement on thejoint implementation of ITER. Beginning in September 2001, Negotiations Meetings have been hosted byeach of the four ITER Participants: Canada in Toronto, Japan in Tokyo, the Russian Federation in Moscow andthe European Union in Cadarache, France.
At this meeting, on behalf of the Honourable Herb Dhaliwal, Canada’s Minister of Natural Resources, Benôit
Serré, his Parliamentary Secretary, welcomed to Canada 78 delegates from the international participants, aswell as members of the ITER International Team. He emphasized the importance to the world of theimplementation of the ITER project and reaffirmed Canada’s recognition of fusion as a promising potential
energy source for the future.

Participants in the Meeting

The Negotiators made significant progress on a number of issues—most notably the successful beginning of
the process for the selection of a site. Under the framework of the Negotiations, a group of international
experts began the Joint Assessment of Specific Sites (JASS). The assessment of the Canadian site proposal
at Clarington, near Toronto, was the first performed and was completed just before the Fifth Negotiations
Meeting (see following article).
Four offers to host ITER have been submitted and are under consideration. The first was from Canada,submitted on June 7, 2001. On June 5, 2002 three additional site offers were submitted, one from Japan at
Rokkasho-mura in Aomori Prefecture, and two from the European Union, one at Cadarache, France and one
at Vandellos, Spain. The next assessments will be of the Japanese site in October and of the European sites
in December.
Also of significance in the Negotiations was the agreement reached on provisions for the transitional phasetowards the possible joint implementation of ITER – the ITER Transitional Arrangements. Thesearrangements would be under the auspices of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), represented
at the Negotiations Meeting by Dr. Robert E.H. Clark. Dr. Clark noted the IAEA is pleased to offer its
continuing support.
In addition, significant progress was made on a wide range of other issues including matters such as further
drafting of the Joint Implementation Agreement and the structure of the international organization that would
be created by the Joint Implementation Agreement.
During their stay in Toronto, the Negotiators attended special events hosted by supporters of Canada’s offer
to host ITER, including the Ontario Construction Secretariat, the governments of Ontario and Canada, andthe Region of Durham and the Municipality of Clarington.

Delegates attend the Welcome Reception at the Toronto Stock Exchange.
2Over the next few months, the negotiators and technical experts have a full schedule of meetings in Japan,
Spain, France, and the Russian Federation with a view to finalizing JASS by early next year and completingthe drafting of the Joint Implementation Agreement by mid-2003.
At the conclusion of the meeting, the delegations were unanimous in expressing their optimism at thesubstantial progress made on the issues critical to the implementation of the ITER project, in particular thesuccessful beginning to the process for the Joint Assessment of Specific Sites. It is expected that progress
will continue to accelerate at the Sixth Negotiations Meeting to be held in Aomori, Japan on October 29thand 30th.

JOINT ASSESSMENT OF SPECIFIC SITES FOR ITER BEGINS AT CLARINGTON
by Dr. M. J.Stewart, President and CEO, Iter Canada
Clarington, Ontario, Canada was the subject of the first official stage of the Joint Assessment of Specific Sites(JASS) for the ITER Project. The Assessment is part of the Negotiations process and is being conducted by
an Ad-Hoc Group of the Negotiators with representatives from Canada, the European Union, Japan and theRussian Federation, supported by the ITER International Team. There are five groupings of specific criteriathat the Ad-Hoc Group is using in the assessment including Technical Aspects, Socio-Cultural Aspects,Licensing Aspects, Relations between the Host Country and the International Organization (ITER LegalEntity), and Financial Aspects.
From a technical perspective, a wide range of factors are under consideration: the land area, access to andstability of the electricity power grid, seismic characteristics, the road, rail and water facilities for transport ofcomponents to the site, and the availability and expertise of the construction and operational workforce.
Socio-cultural aspects include the quality of and access to education and health facilities, the range of lifestyle
options, the cultural and recreational opportunities that would be available to the families of the ITER scientists
who would come to work at the ITER facility, and the support of the local community for the project. The
regulatory framework governing the licensing for the project is also being considered.

The Clarington site is located on the northern shore of Lake Ontario in the Greater Toronto Area.
3

The evaluation was conducted over four days through a series of visits to the site itself (located between theDarlington Nuclear Generating Station and the St. Mary’s Cement plant), a review of materials included in
Canada’s submission to host ITER, presentations from the group leading Canada’s offer and experts on
specific aspects of the offer, and a tour of the Greater Toronto Area and the community of Clarington.
A team of over 100 experts participated on behalf of Canada including representatives from governments,academia, the private sector, community leaders and service providers.

JASS participants at the spot where the tokamak would be located on the proposed ITER site at Clarington

Co-incident with the site assessment process were visits to Clarington by community representatives fromAomori, Japan and from Vandellos, Spain. They toured Canada’s proposed site and visited Clarington
community leaders.
This assessment was the first of an ITER site and it was successfully conducted. As a result, the sameprocess will be followed in the upcoming evaluation of the Japanese site at Aomori in October, and inDecember at the French site at Cadarache and the Spanish site at Vandellos.

4LIFE GOES ONby Dr. Genn Saji, former Head of Safety Division, ITER San Diego JWSAlex Kashirski, who was a member of the ITER Joint Central Team Safety Division, passed away on
29 September 1998 (see ITER EDA NEWSLETTER VOL.7, NO.9). Four years after this tragedy, Katya
Golubchikova, former secretary of the Safety Division, and I were able to visit the Kashirski family, now inMoscow, on 21 September, 2002.
Alex was survived by his wife Natasha, and by two sons, Dennis and Andrei. They live together in anapartment of about 80 m2 in Krylatskoye, which is located at the outskirts of Moscow, about 30 minutes by asubway from downtown Moscow. Natasha is keeping the apartment very cosy and treated us to a table fullof Russian cuisine. She noted that most of the vegetables on the table were grown at their country house.
Natasha is now working as an information technology (IT) communication engineer, involved in building anIT highway with fiber optics for a railway company. Dennis, thanks to support from friends of ITER in
Sand Diego even after the closure of the San Diego ITER Joint Work Site, got a BS in Computer Science fromthe University of California in San Diego in 2001, and worked in a US company as an intern, before he
returned to Moscow in 2001 to live with his mother and younger brother. He is now working as an IT engineer
for a bank in Moscow and is trying hard to get himself fully integrated in Russian society, after nearly ten yearsof absence from Russia, during which time the country has drastically changed in almost every way. It washeart- warming to see his fatherly attitude in the family. Andrei is now grown up, even taller than the late Alex,to become a sophomore in a high school. He is a very good student and is already allowed to take somecollege courses twice a week. Currently he hopes to enter the State University of the School of Economics.
So I was happy to find them all doing very well. However, I had to realize the sad reality that nothing cansubstitute for the role of Alex as a loving father in their family. It was touching for me to find Alex’s guitar heused to play for us at parties, his piano, and his picture taken at Dr. Ed. Cheng’s residence in Rancho SantaFe, without Alex in his bedroom. Natasha still keeps all of Alex’s books on physics. Andrei needs a father’s
love and advice more than ever now until he finishes his education and finds his position in the society.
As I see it, the Kashirski family still needs the moral support of many people. We should share our warm
hearts with each other, to be an ITER family. This, in the end, is one of the most attractive parts of ITER as
an international project.

In Kashirski’s Moscow apartment: Dennis, G. Saji, Andrei. and Natasha5I request all of our ITER colleagues to keep warm feelings for the family of our late Alex and of the families ofother ITER participants, who passed prematurely away. Kashirski’s family, in particular, can be reached by
Dennis’ private e-mail address: dkash78@yahoo.com.
Thinking about the future of ITER, I would like to stress that in connection with the ITER siting, everyone
should understand what it means to be relocated to a foreign site for a prolonged time, affecting family lives
for good or bad. Those working towards ITER’s siting, construction and operation should appreciate theimportance of the ‘human being’ who is working for the realization of fusion and every effort should be madeto support the families of the international members, even after their return to their home countries.

Printed by the IAEA in Austria
November 2002

02-02816

Items to be considered for inclusion in the ITER CTA Newsletter should be submitted to B. Kuvshinnikov, ITER Office, IAEA,Wagramer Strasse 5, P.O. Box 100, A-1400 Vienna, Austria, or Facsimile: +43 1 2633832, or e-mail: c.basaldella@iaea.org(phone +43 1 260026392).