BN  p,1O6j w8*>0lB("% RbØĢȻȘ ĨģĎ ÀâĳɏžĤƊĉĎɐƴƥîī ŀŎðɏƅĲǅǏĤÔĮɐ
Model building of collective housing interior work in whichvaluation analyses of work period and cost are possible* YɓIgarashiɑHɓDeguchi and MɓIchikawa (Tokyo Institute of Technology)
SɓTazawa and KɓShide (Takenaka Corporation)
Abstractɒ
In interior work of collective housing construction there are various employment types andwork relationsɑand traditional management method has its limitsɓFrom such a backgroundɑthe method of theprocess control that can contain complicated constraints and manage per worker is neededɓIn this studyɑbasedon case study in previous researchɑthe model for process control applicable to collective housing interior finishing of various forms was builtɓAndɑin the previous workɑthe combination search method of the worker
number using an experimental design was proposed. In this studyɑthe simulation examined the validity of themethod.
Key Words: Work period and costɑExperimental designɑInterior work1ūŸ¸ú4ȜɌĠt]{ɏȹı3ɐ9ǎĤȇƵŋţąÏ(J5ȁȡ@K3JƬ8ɉȮû4: Ĭ8  ŋ5Ĭ9  ŋ8ƕ?
ĉĪ8ąÏ(JȁȡA4J#K:ɉȮûNľ5&-t]{Ĩƙ9õļ8GIŧ-7ȜɌĠĉȂƎȴƹEǾè¾ȴƹq^TXiǑąÏ°ë8J#5NǱű5&3Jĺ03ȼè£ď9ƿĤţ:ąÏ°ë8Iɑıƫ9ɌĠÖĉȂƎÖ:ĹDǣ 5ǭHKJɓıȊĤ:ɑĈţ9§ƊñÒñ%K3Iɑ+9ȽƳĶņ:ƌ4J-CɑĤƯă49çǈĤ9
īƣÖ:ɀ&ɓ#&-ƭƙNšó(J-C8ɑıȊĤ9ĤǇȇƵ8:ƌ7ĤǇȇƵŎƚĘ·%K
3-ɓ&&ɑıƫ9ɌĠÖ8¡ɑĺŽ9Ŏƚ4:ơȝ9 ĤǇȇƵNǸ7#5ÀŽ7 7I1
1Jɓĺ03ɑȼè£ďNũĤ(JıȊǅ8503ɑȼè£ďN8ÑƮG ıȊ(JȓɆ5703Jɓȼè£ďıȊĤ4:ɑƿĤ(J5ıƫ9ɋǝAN§JȞ¤ĤHȴċ&ɑ¼ǽĤNǸ70-Ĺ8Đ
Ĥ57JɓȞ¤Ĥ:ɑ§Ɗñ9ǰǈ8ȸIIɑȨśƭƙŵ4J-CɑƕȠƺǓư&ůɓŨɑ¼ǽĤ:ǰǈEĤǇţ9ǳĉ%ɑ§Ɗ9ÌĹȶª9ǾȾ%HĈƌ7ĤǇ9Ȩśčý&ɑĤǇǓưĉć÷ɀ4J5ȆMK3Jɓ Ĭ8Ǹ7MK-ĒƯă8!JȔƄ8GJ5ɑ£ŋǉ±Ʈ Ɏŷ
ơ4J#5ŮH8%K- ɓ##4£ŋǉ±Ʈ5:ɑƿŎäǲ7£ŋ94ɑéŰÉ8§ƊǸMK3J£ŋ9ÍèNǄ&3Jɓ#9G8ɑĤŶǀǧ>9ŶĸɌÞɂɑ¼ǽĤ9ĤǇȇƵ8:ÑƮÖ9¦þƒ%K3Jɓ#9ǾȾ7ÈǘżN
ìB¼ǽĤ813ɑęſH sivPfq7P

第3回社会システム部会研究会（2013年2月28日-3月1日・岩手）qe8GIń9ȼè£ď¼ǽĤNxh~ÖÀŽJ#5NŮH8&-ɓ@-ɍɈH :ɑęſH9
ǂǊNā8ĒȺ9¨9ȼè£ď¼ǽĤNxh~Ö(JŎƚNşƆ&-ɓȏǛ813:Ǎ83ȒŮ(JɓŸǂǊ4:ɑ#KH9ǂǊNǢǣ&ɑƅĲǅǏĤ
ÔĮ5ºé4ɑU^Tir_xh}YɑNƳ3ƌ7Ķņ9ȼè£ď¼ǽĤ8ȪƳÀŽJG8xh~NŗĴ&-ɓ2.k]aȼè£ďıȊĤ4:Ǵƺ8ɑpPÚ¢4Ĥ×
NÁÍ&ĤǇȇƵNǌ3JcXiŨĲNƳJɓ##4,Ĥ×5:JŰȵƺ@5@I94§ƊNǸ7
ėȗ57JÚ¢ǋȵNɓ#9cXiŨĲ8GIɑ
çĤ×¼4é9§Ɗ¼ĔNǩIȣ&Ǹ7#54ɑ
ÐÔȚƢEȊ¯ȚƢ9īƣÖäǲ57JɓƈƴH2):#9G7ǩIȣ&ĀıȊĤ9ƬĽ8ƿƻ&ɑ
TOCɏTheory of ConstraintsɕÈǘ9ưȕɐNƳ3[_i9ųęÖNƻƺ5&-ĤǇȇƵN§ň(JŎƚNşƆ&-ɓTOC5:ɑǝǨ¼8ÈǘNȁ1!ɑ+K9
ANšó(J#58G03ǝǨ9ǞôšóNȇJưȕ
4J6)ɓ@-ȳƴH7):ɑGAɏGenetic AlgorithmɕȬƺP~\}`vɐNƳɑǩIȣ&ĀıȊĤ8
3ɑÐÔīƣÖNǭŇ8·K-ÐÔ[_i9ȄƧ4ųȪ7ĤǇȇƵN§ň(JŎƚNşƆ&-ɓȚŹEƏŹ9ÈǘżEɑ§Ɗ­Æ9ÈǘżNǭŇ&-ųȪÖ]uy]{Nȴƹ&ɑŎƚ9ƯĒq^TXiĜ9ȪƳNäǲ5&-ɓ&&ɑȉ9Ŏƚ:)KDȞ¤Ĥ9ǩIȣ&ĀıȊĤNėȗ5&3Iɑ§ƊǮ9ŅŁƗđ:ǭŇ&37ɓĺ03ɑ¼ǽĤ
8!J§ƊǮ9ǾȾ7ȽƳĶņE§ƊȵȶªǑ8GJ§Ɗñ9ƭņ9Òƺ7ćÖNǻ(#5ÀŽ7ɓ@-ɑȼè£ď¼ǽĤ9ĤǇǓư83ɑ§Ɗ
9ɄĭE§ƊȭĞ9ȫđ:Ưă9§Ɗñ9ǞɊ5Ó8
Ʌ03Ǹ7MK3-ƯƭòɆ5703JɓÀâH8):#9òɆNɑǾţ9Ʉĭ2!HK-c_XH- 59 -PG0003/13/0000-0059 © 2013 SICE

7JÚ¢q^TXiÃ&3ĒǸ%KJG7q
^TXi8ė&ɑc_X¿ư9-C8ȚƢNÍIĵ
3J-C9_Z^y}YòɆ5&3ƿƻ&-ɓ+&3ɑĺŽđĲÖØÁ4Áƀ9ėȗ5%K3#7
0-ĤǇǓư8ė&ɑţưƺ8đĲÖ&+9ÍĵŨĲNşƆ&-ɓ%H8J¨83ɑĤŕĵǮńđ&-§Ɗñţ4_Z^y}Y&-ǟƁɑ557
ū4Đ&-D9NɑşƆ&-ÍĵŎƚ8G03¾Ɖ
ȈNǸ70-ɓ+9ǟƁɑ¸§Ɗñ9İ?ȽƳūţNćJ#57 ɑ§ƊÁŕ9ćŲE´¶(?§Ɗ9ŮǃÖ8GIɑ
ǥĤŶūţN228ū8@4ǀǧ4J#5NǄ&-ɓ@-ŸǂǊǢǣ(JęſH4)9ǂǊ83ɑȼè£ď¼ǽĤNƱƲȚƢÏĤėȗNǆÒ&7HǩIȣ&§ƊNǸ7ɑƱƲȚƢĕIĀ9p
]{fq_Z^y}YòɆ5đǬ&ɑABMN
Ƴ3ɑƱƲȚƢÏĤėȗ8ĕI ~~Nxh~Ö&-ɓȼè£ď¼ǽĤxh~9¸¤²NFigɓ18Ǆ(ɓp]{fq_Z^y}Y5:ɑǴƺ8:ÏĤėȗƫé9ÏĤɄĭ8ĺ03ƱƲ(J_Z^y}YòɆNɓABMNƳJ#58G
03ɑĺŽ9p]{fq_Z^y}YòɆ4:÷ɀ40-§ƊǮ9ǼȱEȽƳĶņNǻƯ&-ɓ@-ɑǰǈ$59§Ɗñ9ćÖ8GJķɃɑ§ƊǮ9§ƊÑƮɑ£ŋǉ±ƮNǭŇ&-¼ǽĤ¸¤9ĤŶNȌ©ÀŽJŎƚNşƆ&-ɓ+9ǟƁɑFigɓ29G8ɑţąĉ(J8ĺ03ɑǥĤŶūţ:ËƝ%KJɑǦĶƺ8ǧB94:7 ɑËƝƮ:ƝĚ(J#5NǄ&-ɓ#K:ĤŶNǧCJ-C8:§ƊñNĈ œ·(JĿȀJ-CșȲ[_ią(ɑșȲ[_iNŒJ5ĤŶİ<3&@5ijVpčý(J-C5ǭHKJ.

#9ijVp:ĺŽHòɆ8%K3Jɑ
¼ǽĤ9ǾȾ%Ţ8ɑ#KHNÁƀ(JŎƚ:čý&37ɓɍɈH5):ɑ#9ęſHǄ&-i
jVp8ƿƻ&ɑęſH9xh~Nā8ɑĒȺ9¨8!JĒhc8ā2-xh~NƋǖ&-ɓ+&3ɑǾȾ7ÈǘżNìBȼè£ď9¼ǽĤNABM4ǻƯ(J#58GIɑĺŽŎƚ4ÀŽ70-§ƊñÚ¢9ǓưNǸJxh~NşƆ&-ɓ+9ǟƁɑ9ǰǈ9§Ɗƭņ8ķɃNJƬđ9ǰǈNÑƮ
ƺ8ąñ(J#54ɑ 8Ǆ(G8ĤŶ5[_i919řƍNɑĒȺ9Ưă49ĒƟţ5ƕȠ&3ÝŨšóÀŽJG7§Ɗñœ·ţ9ǝAèM*9niȅ9čýNŮH8&-ɓ@-ɑ§Ɗñœ·ţǝAèM*NÑƮƺ8Şǚ(JŎƚ5&3ĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚNşƆ&ɑɁĩ8ǀŰȵ4ąñ(?ǰǈNƬđ4J#5NŮH8&-ɓ&&#9xh~:ɑĒȺ8ǎĤ%K-ɌĠt]{9¨8ā23Ƌǖ%KɑĤŶ5[_i9ËƝNȩň(J-C8xh~9ŴƳłNǄ&-ɑ9¨8Ę·(J@4:ńđ&3H)ɑ9ȪƳ¨8139Ɖȋ7%K37ɓ@-ɑĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ9ŴƳł9ƉȈØÁ4:7ɓ

Figɓ3: Effect of increase of floor heating worker.

Figɓ1: Outline of model.

ĺ03ɑŸǂǊ4:ɍɈH9ǂǊ83Ǹ70ĒȺ9¨NƳ-Z__ghQNā8ɑƬđ9ȼè£ď.!47 ɑHFJȼè£ď¼ǽĤ9ĤǇǓưNȌ©Áƀäǲ7xh~NƋǖ(J#5Nƻƺ5&-ɓ»¤ƺ8:ɑTable 18Ś"J 19hcN·
Î5&ɑǥĤŶūţ5șȲ[_iNÀÎ(J#54ɑ¼ǽĤĤǇǓưNȌ©äǲ7]_gvNƋǖ&ɑɔ
19řƍH§Ɗñ9ųȪœ·ţNÁƀ4Jxh~NşƆ&-ɓųǜƺ8:ɑȼè£ď¼ǽĤ8œ·(J§Ɗñ9ţNƗđ(JȺ9bl[9ŅŁƗđ8ĕ4Jxh~NşƆ(J#5Nƻƺ5&-·Îhcıƫhc§ƊñhcFigɓ2: Effect of increase worker.

§Ɗhc- 60 -Table 1: Input data.
¼ĔƇţɑȹţɑȭĞţɑȭĞcRqǑNđǬ&-D9ǰǈɑǰǈ$59ţNđǬ&-D9§Ɗñ5§Ɗȵ9ȶªɑ§Ɗȵ9¶ǸĹǣȶªNđǬ&-D93"%ŸǂǊ4:ɑȼè£ď¼ǽĤ9ĤǇǓưNȌ©äǲ7xh~NƋǖ&-ɓxh~Ö83:ƅĲǅǏĤÔĮ9oP}YǑNā8ɑ§ƊȵȶªE§Ɗñ9ǸÒ76ɑȼè£ď¼ǽĤ8ė(Jxh~9ƋǖNǸ70-ɓ+&3Ÿxh~9ĊĵłNɑĒȺ9¨HĻHK-ǟƁ5xh~HĻHK-ǟƁNɑĤ
Ŷ5[_i9ɔ19řƍ83ƕȠ(J#54Ǆ&-ɓ7ɑxh~Ƌǖ8-03:ɑǅ]uy]{ȆȑɕSOARS9)NÇƳ&-ɓ

3.2 p,IS
ŸǂǊ4¼ǽĤĤǇǓưNȌ©(Jřƍ5&3ɑ
ǥĤŶūţɑșȲ[_iɑ§Ɗñ9ǉ±ƮNƳJɓ4ɑ+K,K9řƍ813ȒŮ(Jɓ3.1 "%?gxh~:ŅŁƗđNǸ7U^Ti57J§Ɗñ5ɑ+9§ƊñǸÒ(Jă57J§ƊƯăHƋň%KJɓŸǔ4:ɑxh~NƋň(JçȀǙ81
3ȉ(ɓ3.1.1ƨ!K;ƯăÔō>ŌJɓ§ƊǜĹ:ƯăÔō>ŌIɑȨśǻNŲŧ(Jɓ§Ɗñ:#9ǸÒNȥǅ
ŰÉ@4ǩIȣ(ɓ##4ɑȭĞ4§Ɗ8àIJ
Ì89§Ɗñĝ7NǃȐ(J9:ɑ¼ǽĤ8:ɑÛÊ5&3ȭĞ4į8§Ɗ4J9:
@4ɑ5Ɨ@IŴJ-C4Jɓ#KH9ǸÒ
:ºéǂǊƊH9oP}Y8ā2-Ċĵ7Ǹ
Ò4Jɓ

+QZ;

§ƊƯă5:ɑȼè£ď¼9ÏĤėȗ4Jç£ŋNǄ&3JɓŸǂǊ4:£ŋ8ȶ&3ɑȼè£ď¸¤98pPčý&ɑpP$58ƗCHK-ţ
9£ŋčý(Jɓ#KH: Figɓ4 8Ǆ(G7ȹĠƋȧN«Ŵ(Jɓxh~98:8ɑȨśǻ5Ĥ9ȨśƭņE§Ɗñ§ƊNǸ8ț ?ȭĞ9ŃĂǑN«Ř&3J§ƊÔōJɓ

3.2.1

ŸǂǊ83ƳJǥĤŶūţ5:ɑȼè£ď¼
ǽĤ83ɑ]uy]{ȴċūHɑ¸£
ŋ83¸§Ɗǜ&-ŰƧ@4NÁÚ¢4WSi&ɑ+9èȇ9ŰȵNȇǒ&-D95đǬ(JɓıȊƊ:áƛƲƊ4J-Cɑıƫ9á!ƞ&Ŷȸ@48ĤŶNßCJ#5:Ɂĩ8ȰȀ7#54J-CɑŸǂǊ9řƍ8ƳJɓ
3.2.2

3.1.2+Q9§Ɗñ5:ɑ§ƊƯă4§Ɗ¼ĔNĒǸ(J¤4IƱƲȚƢ5ǭJɓç§Ɗñ:ǰǈNÍIĵ3H
K3Iɑ+K,Käǲ57J§Ɗ¼ĔƸ7J.§Ɗñ:ĵūɑƿŎäǲ7§ƊK;ɑ·ǅŰÉ87J
5Àǅ(Jɓ+&3Àǅ(J5ƯăÔō>ǸȨśǻNǃȐ(JɓÌū9ƒ§ƊK;+9ȭĞ>ɑƨ!K;§Ɗäǲ7ȭĞ>ëɑ§Ɗäǲ7ȭĞƨ!K;Ɛ_gfq8¾įɑäǲ7§ƊNŞǚ(Jɓ§ƊƯă4JȭĞ>ț 5ɑȭĞ94§Ɗ&3J
9§Ɗñ7#5ɑàIL5&3J§ƊĐ&37#5NǃȐ&ɑ§Ɗ8àIJɓ9§Ɗñ-ăèɑŪ8Đ&3-§Ɗ.0ăè:ɑ8§Ɗäǲ7ȭĞK;+9ȭĞ>țɑqu¼ǽĤ4:ƌ7ǰǈčý&3Iɑ+K,K
9ǰǈƔ9ū9Ú©9ƽă:Ɨ@03J 10)ɓŸxh~NƳJ#58G03ɑıȊĤ8!J­9§Ɗñ9§ƊƭƙNőŠ(J#5äǲ4J-Cɑ
#9Ú©8ɑ§Ɗñ+K,KÀǅ&-ūţN)J#58G03ɑƯĒ8ā2-șȲ[_iNȇǒ(Jɓ3.2.3

Figɓ4: Hierarchic structure of building.

fBNMK+Q9`-Y§Ɗñ9ąñɑıȊĤ9ĤŶNǦĶƺ8:šó
&7#5: 2 Ǎ4Ū8Ȥ?-ɓ#K8ė&3ƤƩ5§Ɗñœ·ţNćJ94:7 ɑ§Ɗñ9ǉ±Ʈ
5řƍNƳ3œ·ţNȔŤ(J#58GIɑ§Ɗñœ·ÑƮNŭ%*J#5äǲ4J5Ǆ%
K3J 11)ɓ#9řƍ:ɑ§ƊñŖŻ%K3JŶȵ9/ɑĒȺ86K.!±3J9NȇJřƍ
4Jɓ+9řƍN OR 5(K;ɑ9G8ǻ(#5ÀŽJɓALLtimeɕ¸¤ŰȵOFFtimeɕÀǅ&37ƭņ9Űȵ
DtimeɕŖŻ%K3Jƭņ9ŰȵROtimeɕĒȺ8§Ɗ&3Jƭņ9Űȵ
ORɕĒ§ƊƮ9®
5Ǫ 5ɑ
Dtime = ALLtime – OFFtime
OR = ROtime / Dtime
ŸǂǊ4Dɑ#9řƍNƳ3Ƭđ9ǰǈNȫ<ɑĵȎǰǈ9§Ɗñţ9ȔŤNǸ7#54ɑƯĒ9Ĥ
ŶG<[_iH9šóNƻř(ɓ- 61 -

4

"%?g'

5.1 $!'o?

ɍɈH9xh~4:ɑxh~¼83ǰǈEǿǸ
¼ĔǑ9ŃĂNđǬ&3IɑÆ7¨8ȪƳ(J#5÷ɀ7Ƌȧ5703-ɓĺ03Ÿxh~4:ɑ·Îhc8GIıƫɑ§Ɗñɑ§Ɗ9ŃĂN·Î&ɑȌ©řƍNÀÎ(J#58G03ɑƌ7Ķņ9ȼè£ď¼ǽĤNxh~Ö&ɑȌ©ÁƀNǸ7#5Näǲ5&-ɓŸxh~8·Î(Jhc:8ɑıƫhc§Ɗñhc§Ɗhc9 3 ǈɇIɑ8»¤ƺ8ȉ(ɓŸ]uy]{8ƳJçn|wcNɑºéǂǊƊH9Ē¨8!Jhc8GIȊđ&-ɓ§Ɗñţ:ºéǂǊƊǒÀ&-œ·ţ4Iɑ
#KNr_®5&3ŏ0-ɓ§Ɗñɑ§ƊƯăɑ§
Ɗ8ȶ(Jçn|wcN Table 2 8Ǆ(ɓ7ɑȍǸõţ: 5 õ5&ɑ®:+9īÿ®NƳ-ɓ
Table 2: Parameter.
ćţê®
1Ƈţ17ȹţ113£ŋţȵàI
1LDKɑ2LDKɑ3LDK206£ŋĵ-I§Ɗţ
53
ǰǈţ
9:00
·ăŰÉ17:00
ȥăŰÉ§Ɗñţ
163ɏr_®ɐ

4.1 DV'ıƫhc:ɑȹȊđ]i5£ŋȊđ]iH
Ƌň%KJɓ3 Ǎ4Ȥ?-G8ɑ§ƊƯă8:ȹĠƋȧNƳ3Jɓ+9-CɑȹȊđ]i:pP
ê8ė&ɑōğ(JƇ5ɑȹţ9ŃĂNȊđ&3Jɓ£ŋȊđ]i4:ɑōğ(JƇɑȹ5ɑ3LDK 76
9£ŋ9ĶƭNȊđ&3Jɓ
4.2 +Q9'

5.2 @yn\U[JcFU§Ɗñhc:ɑǰǈȊđ]i914Jɓ§Ɗñ:+K,KǰǈNȊđ&ɑ+9ǰǈ8G03ɑ§Ɗ¼ĔȊđ%KJɓ
4.3 +Q'§Ɗhc:ɑ§ƊȊđ]iɑ¶Ǹ§ƊȊđ]
iɑ§ƊŰȵȊđ]i9 3 1HƋň%KJɓ§ƊȊđ]i4:ɑçǰǈ8ė&3ɑŕĵ§Ɗ9§Ɗ ID
Nȉ&3Jɓ¶Ǹ§ƊȊđ]i:ɑç§Ɗ ID 9Ìş57J¶Ǹ§Ɗ9§Ɗ ID NȊđ&ɑ§Ɗ9ÌĹ
ȶªNđǬ&3Jɓ§ƊŰȵȊđ]i:ɑçǰǈ9£ŋcRqƔ9§ƊŰȵNÁÚ¢4Ȋđ&3Jɓ5G/)Kd8Jc:x

ŸǂǊ4:#KH9xh~NƳ3ɑ§Ɗñœ·ţNƯĒHćŲ&ɑĤŶ5[_i5ijVp9ȶª8JřƍNÝŨšó(JǝAèM*9ƹȁNǸ7Jxh~9ƋǖNƻƺ5&3Jɑ]uy
]{8GJĈƐµƺřƍ49ųȪÖòɆ4:ɑn|wc9ǝAèM*òɆNȅ ĿȀJɓœ·(Jţ9ǝAèM*813ɑǰǈţ mWT 9 10 Ɠȹ9Şǚɑ1@I 10^mWT ȦI9ǋȵNŞǚ(JĿȀJɓ+#4ɑɍɈH9ǂǊ4:@)ɑ
1ɐƛƻ(JǰǈNǠJƐ9 2 Ɠȹ9ŎƚNşƆ(J1-1ɐǰǈ9ȰȀįN_[P}Y& 15 ǰǈ8ǠJ
1-2ɐ15 ǰǈ4ţƖƣNćÖ%*ɑĒɊȇƵƚ4ųDĕįɏīÿ®9ćÖɐĉǰǈNƬđ(JƐ8ɑ2ɐƛƻ&-ǰǈ813ɑ10 ƓȹţNć3ɏǰǈ:ƍƣţ4ɐniųȪȼèNȁ.(5 2 ƓȹŞǚŎƚNƳ-ɓ ŸǂǊ9ƻƺ:ɑ¼ǽĤĤǇǓưNȌ©äǲ7]_gvNƋǖ&ɑȌ©řƍ8ā2§Ɗñ9ųȪœ·ţNÁƀ4Jxh~NşƆ(J#54JɓŸǂ
5.2.1 tmC zi_ sH
Ǌ:ɑ Ǎ4Ȥ?-ęſHɑɍɈH9ǂǊNǢǣ&ɑɔ19ǂǊ8GJZ__ghQNā8ɑƌ7Ķņ]uy]{NȦ'-¸¤9ĤŶɑÜ<§Ɗñ9ȼè£ď¼ǽĤ8ȪƳäǲ7xh~9şƆNǸ7¸¤9ǉ±Ʈ8ƿƻ&ɑ#KH9Ȍ©®8ė&3§Ɗ
0-ɓƐ8ɑŸxh~NƳ3§Ɗñ9ųȪ7œ·
ñ9œ·ţ9ćÖɑƬ8ĉ7ķɃN-ǰǈţ9ǝAèM*NŞǚ(JŎƚNƉȈ&-ɓɍɈH9NȫŔ&-ɓ»¤ƺ8:¸ǰǈ813ɑ+K,K 1
ǂǊ83ɑ§Ɗñ9œ·ţŞǚŎƚ5&3ɑĒǰǈ)1 1 ąñ%*-œ·ţ4]uy]{ɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŎƚşƆ%K-ɓ&&ɑ#9Ŏ&ɑçȌ©®8!JɄ¢!NǸ70-ɓƐ8ɑɔ
ƚ9ŴƳł:ƉȈ%K37ɓĺ03ɑŸǂǊ8
3+9ŴƳłNÆ7ŞǚŎƚNƳ3ƕȠƉȈ&-ɓ 19Ȍ©®8ė(JɄ¢HniɄ¢Nǰǈ>
9ķɃįɌɄ¢5ȁ7&ɑ¢ 15 ǰǈNȫŔ&-ɓ@)ɑ  ǔ4]uy]{8ƳJn|wcȊđNȒŮ&ɑ  ǔ4ɍɈH9ǂǊ83şƆ%K-ɑĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚNȒŮ(JɓƐ85.2.2 @yn\U r[ ǔ4ɑƕȠėȗ57JtR~_i8GIĤǇ
ÁÍNǸ7ɑç×ȵ8!JěōŞǚNǸ70-Ŏ§Ɗñǉ±ƮNƳ3ȫŔ&-Ƭđ9ǰǈN¸ñƚNȒŮ&ɑ  ǔ4Ȥ?JŎƚ5ƕȠƉȈNǸ70ƌ8ąñ(J5Ũƚ4ɑĤŶ5șȲ[_iNÝŨ-ɓ

- 62 -

šóÀŽJäǲłJ#5:Ǆ%K3Jɑ#9
Ũƚ4:Ǥǫ47œ·ţ9ǝAèM*Ĉţčý(JɓŸǂǊ4: 5.2.1 ǔ9Ũƚ4Ƭđ&-ǰǈ813ɑĒɊȇƵƚ9ƼǻNƳ-ǝAèM*Nā8ĒɊNǸ70-ɓĒɊȇƵƚ4:ĒɊ94®NŅùƺ8ćÖ%*JD9NöČ5ï<ɑ+KH9öČ8ė&3Ɩƣ®N-ɓŸŎƚ4:öČÌǔ4Ƭđ&-ǰǈ8-Iɑ+9ţ: 15 öČɑƖƣţ:ąñ&7ɑ3 ąñ(J9 2 ƖƣNȍ(D95&-ɓ
#KH9öČ9Hɑ2 19öČ8ȶ&3¸39ƖƣǝAèM*N§03hcNŝà(JNµȯǪ
5ï=ɑöČ9ţ.!éţ9µȯǪNǸ5ĒɊĤţǳĉ87Jɓ#KNŒÈ&3ĒɊ(JŎƚƼǻ4Jɓ#9ƼǻNā8§Ɗñœ·ţ9āƣ
®8Ï3]uy]{NǸɑĤŶ¸¤8ķɃNJG7ǰǈNƬđ&-ɓŨƚ5&3ɑƼǻ9ǝAèM*83çǰǈ8139ţ9ąñ
0 9ăè5 3 9ăè9Ȍ©®N+K,KàI+K
H9īÿNȇǒ&-ɓǟƁN Figɓ5 8Ǆ(ɓFigɓ5GIɑzkfim_Ĥ9ǰǈ>9ķɃįɁĩ8ĉ#5Á0-ɓƐǔ8zkfim_Ĥ9ANą
ñ(J#58GIɑĤŶ¸¤NǧCJ#5äǲ9
ƉȈNǸ70-ɓ

5.3 AEJcFU
Ìǔ83ɑĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ8G03ǰǈ>9ķɃį9Ɍzkfim_ĤNȁ1!À
&ɑ+9ǰǈ8Ǡ03 10 Ɠȹąñ(J#58G03ɑ
ųȪœ·ţNÍIÀ&-ɓ&&ɑȅěōųȪȅ
79¸¤ųȪȅ79ŉ:ØÁ¸¤ųȪȅ8ȢěōųȪȅ8139Åđ9Ũƚƨɓ
+#4ɑ
ŸǂǊ4:ɑ¸¤9ĤǇ83œ·ţNȔŤ(JPqe8ė&ɑ¸¤4:7 ěōƺ7ȔŤNǸ7
#58GJšóNùJPqeNşƆ&-ɓŸǔ
4+9ŎƚNȒŮ&ɑųĹ8 2 19Ŏƚ9ƕȠƉȈN
Ǹ70-ɓ
5.3.1 %'&4v1OU
ɍɈHşƆ&-ĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ:ɑ¸ĤǇ83çǰǈ9ųȪœ·ţNŞǚ(JŎƚ40-ɓ#K8ė&3ŸǂǊ4:ɑ
¸ĤǇ4:7 ɑ
ěōƺ7ȃƧHųǵ7œ·ţNŞǚ(J#5NȍA-ɓ»¤ƺ8:ɑ
Ɛ9G7ŎɄ4ŞǚNǸ70-ɓ1)¸ĤǇNtR~_i8GIǾţ9cv8ÁÍ2)
çcv83§ƊNǸ7ǰǈNȫŔ3)
ȫŔ&-ǰǈ8ė&3ɑçcv8!JąñÑƁ9ĕįHƬđǰǈ8ǠJ4)
Ǡ0-ǰǈ8ė&3ĈƓȹ9ąñNǸɑœ·ţNƗđ(J9ŎɄNƐǔHȏ& Ȥ?Jɓ
5.3.2 %'&Figɓ5: The contribution of each worker.
5.2.3 #B<9eP

zkfim_Ĥ9ţɏr_®: 3 ɐN 0 
H 10 ąñ&-ăè9+K,K9Ȍ©®N Figɓ6 8
Ǆ(ɓąñ7&ɑ(7M/r_®8!JǟƁƷå8qfi%K3JƧ4IɑĤŶ 236374Áɏ164 ū 3 Űȵ 34 Áɐɑ[_i 2 ³ 9961 ½570-ɓė&3ɑzkfim_ĤN 1 ąñ%*-ǟƁ:Ʒĥ8qfi%K-Ƨ4IɑĤŶ 225164
Áɏ156 ū 8 Űȵ 44 Áɐɑ[_i 2 ³ 8205 ½57Iɑr_®8ƕ?ɑG+ĤŶ 8 ūɑ[_i 1700
½šóäǲ4J#5NǄ&-ɓB^12@)ɑ¼ǽĤċ@03HĐĤ(J@49¸Ĥ
ǇNtR~_i8GIcvÁÍ&-ɓ##4Ȇ
tR~_i5:ɑ¥ū@4869§Ɗ@4Đ&3K;ǵNǻ(ƻƍ®57JD94ɑºéǂǊNǸ703JƊ59oP}Y8GIđC-ɓŸǂǊ4:ɑřƍ57J§Ɗȹ9¸ȭĞ83ǜ(J#5NtR~_i5&ɑ4 19tR~_iNȊđ& 5 19cv8ÁÍ&-ɓFigɓ7 8¸ĤǇNÁÍ&-ùNǄ(ɓFigɓ7: All the processes are divided.
5.3.3 7'i_sHcvƔ8šóNùJ-Cɑçcv¼4§ƊNǸ
7ǰǈ8ƿƻ(K;ǵɓĺ03ɑĤǇǻHçc
v¼4§ƊNǸ7ǰǈNȫŔ(Jɓ@): A c
v¼4§ƊNǸ7 24 ǰǈ8ƿƻ&-ɓ
5.3.4 <93PFigɓ6: The increase effect of worker of unit bath.

- 63 -=i_W?

Ɛ8ɑƬđ&- 24 ǰǈ9/ɑ69ǰǈąñÑƁ9ĉǰǈNƉȈ&-ɓŨƚ5&3:ɑçǰǈN+K,K 1 ąñɑ2 ąñ9 2 Ɠȹ9ąñNǸɑĤŶ5[_i8ė&3ķɃį9ĉǰǈNȫO.ɓ
ąñ%*-ǟƁɑTable 3 8Ǆ( 8 ǰǈ8šóÑƁȁHKɑƬ8Ȟ¤ǰ8ąñÑƁɌ#5Á0-ɓ
Table 3: The effect by increase of the personnel.
ǰǈȞ¤ǰsjĤüĤĆÀ&ĤdXiĤ
ǡŜƖǺƱĤǯƦȵÂIĤŦƪĤ

5.3.5 W?i_1 ąñĤŶ[_išó®
šó®
ɏÁɐ
ɏ½ɐ
512
198740266.2
204060687
398040720.6349320567.2
312540947
239960592.6
193700280.2
65380<92 ąñ
ĤŶ[_išó®
šó®
ɏÁɐ
ɏ½ɐ
1179.4432580
372.4
61800
274.4
-401720-619-1334960-708.4-1567420
636.6-293800-107.8-1179860
15.2-310660

G/)KT?

Ìǔ4Ȟ¤ǰ9ąñÑƁ A cv83:Ɍ
#5Á0-ɓĺ03ɑA cv¼49ĤŶ5[_iNšóÀŽJäǲłɌȞ¤ǰ9ąñĪNćÖ%*3ųȪœ·ţNƗđ&-ɓȞ¤ǰ9ąñĪN 0 
H 4 @4ćÖ%*-ǟƁN Fig. 8 8Ǆ(ɓ#9ǟƁHɑɖcv83Ȟ¤ǰɏr_®ɕ4 ɐN 3 ąñ(J#58G03ųDĤŶ5[_iÝŨNšó4ɑĤŶ: 1774 Áɏ1 ū 5 Űȵ 34 Áɐɑ[_i: 112 9ËƝäǲ4J#5NǄ&-ɓȞ¤ǰ:¸ĤǇ83ųÄ9§Ɗ4JĀƂȅ¤9§ƊNŕĵ&3Jɓĺ03ųÄ9§Ɗ9œ·ţNą
ñ%*J#58G03ɑ+9§ƊNǙŬ Đ(J#54ɑĹǣ§Ɗ8DǙŬ ƿŎ4J-CɑĤŶǀǧ4-5ǭHKJɓ@-ɑçcv83
ŞǚNǸ7#58G03ɑ¸Şǚ8ƕ?ŞǚǕøN
ĉĪ8ȟƝ&7HɑšóNÑƮƺ8Ǹ7J#5NǄ&-ɓ@-ĒɊȇƵƚ9ǟƁ5ƕȠ(J5ɑěōŞǚ8G03ĻHK-ǟƁ:šóĪę% ɑĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ:ɑ¸ĤǇ83ąñÑƁ9X}gQW~7ǰǈNȫ=98´K-Ŏƚ4J5Ȇ-ɓ

Figɓ8: The increase effect of worker of building frame.

6¶ǸǂǊ9Z__chQNā8ɑǾȾ7ÈǘżNìBȼè£ď9¼ǽĤNƌ7Ķņ9ȼè£ď8
ȪƳäǲ7xh~NƋǖ&-ɓ@-ɑ¼ǽĤ8!
J§Ɗñœ·ţòɆ8ė&3ɑ¶ǸǂǊ4şƆ%K-ĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ9ŴƳł9ƉȈNǸ70-ɓ+9ǟƁɑçcv8!JěōŞǚŎƚ8G
03ÑƮƺ8šóäǲ4JǰǈNƬđ(J#5NǄ*-ɑĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ4ĻHK-ǟƁ
8:Ü;70-ɓĺ03ɑĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-ŞǚŎƚ:¸ĤǇ8!JąñÑƁ9ɌǰǈNƬđ(J4ŴƳ7Ŏƚ4J#5NŮH8&-ɓųĹ8ŸǂǊ4:ɑěōŞǚŎƚGIĒɊȇƵƚNƳ-¸¤ŞǚŎƚ´K3J#5NǄ&-ɑ
9¸¤ŞǚŎƚ5:ƕȠ&37ɓĒɊȇƵƚNƳ
-ŞǚŎƚ9ŴƳłNǄ(-C8ɑ9¸¤ŞǚŎƚ5ƕȠ(J#5Ĺ9ȓɆ5&3ƒ%K3Jɓ@-ɑ§ƊŰȵ9;H1NǭŇ&37ɓ
&&ɑĒȺ8:§Ɗñ9­9ǲÎ8GI§Ɗ9ȴċHĐ
@49Űȵ8:;H1Ʊ'Jɓ@-ɑƯăÔōH§ƊƯă@49ǆÒŰȵ8ȶ&3ɑȹ9§ƊƯă5ɑØȹ9§ƊƯă@49ǆÒŰȵ8:ĦƱ'Jɓ&&ɑŸxh~83:ɑ69ȭĞ>D 1 _gfqɏ1 Áɐ4ǆÒ(Jƌ8703Jɓ#KH
9ĒȺ9¼ǽĤ59ȿNºéǂǊƊ9ŅȁNā8¬Ƒ(J#5ȓɆ57Jɓ

5hLX1) ƅĲǅÒƲǂǊōɕȜɌĠt]{ĨăÒëɏ2012ɐ2) ƈƴɑãȷɑǶƘɑēȖɑȲĈɕǩIȣ&ĀıǖĤ8
!J TOC NƳ-ĤǇȇƵ8ȶ(JǂǊɑūŸıǖĎȇƵǗȕťȼɑǐ 557 æɑ281/288ɏ2007ɐ3) ŀŎɑƠƜɑǷƥɑġŸɕȼè£ď9¼ǽĤ8!JĤǇnc9ÁƀɑūŸıǖĎŐǹĂíȼɑǐ
15 ħɑǐ 30 æɑ557/562ɏ2009ɐ4) ęſɑĨģɑÀâɑŀŎɑƠƜɕ]uy]{8GJȼè£ď¼ǽĤȇƵ9Ȍ©ɑJAWS2009ɏ2009ɐ5) ɍɈɑĨģɑÀâɑŀŎɑƃȖɕABM NƳ-ȼè£ď
¼ǽĤ8!JĤŶ5șȲ[_i9ÁƀɑJAWS2011
ɏ2011ɐ6) ÏǶɑǏ¼ɑźɕTOC Ŋƶtl^wiɑūŸǲƮÙtl^wiacɏ1999ɐ7) ȳƴɑãȷɑȲĈɑÕġɕǩIȣ&ĀĤ8!JȬ
ƺP~\}`vNƳ-ĤǇȇƵŎƚ9ǭĖ5Ēq^TXi>9ȪƳɑūŸıǖĎȇƵǗȕťȼɑǐ 552 æɑ
255/262ɏ1999ɐ8) ÀâɑĨģɑǁĄɑŀŎɑƃȖɑƠƜɕÃq^TXic_X¿ư>9ĈǲĤÍ!9Òƺ_Z^y}
YɑJournal of the International Association of P2MɑVol.6ɑ
No.1ɑ179/189ɏ2011ɐ9) http://www.soars.jp
10) úüȦƾɕīň 24 Ĭį¹ºĤȊȇÐÔÚ©ɏ2012ɐ11) ɍɈɑĨģɑÀâɑƠƜɑŀŎɑƃȖɕȼè£ď¼ǽĤ
ȇƵ8!JɁđĀȀö9U^Tir_xh}
Y8GJķɃÁƀɑJAWS2010ɏ2010ɐ

- 64 -