人間関係研究（南山大学人間関係研究センター紀要）, 5, 140-150.

Î ÏÐh Ñ ÎÒÓ½h½h¾ÔÕ#$Ö×Ä@ØÄ<8ÙÚ ¿u
 !"#$%&'()*%+,( -&./012,34./05 6789:;<8=-E5>?@A7B@C

7D@>#$FGHIJ./0KLMNO'PQL-2,3RIE S#$TU%VW 789:;<8W%XY( Z[/L-(\&E,34Q2ERI#$]^_VE5`5abc!"deKL&mnPQLo2K

3KpKfghiajhkel,(\`qr%sLtUuv!"%w(+gx yV5 z_Q {E\|tU~Zhixy}'nPQypE$4%Lhkel%,(0-2K-&./05

1(

36789:;<8=\&61LtUE=&+gxxy\LJ}'QPQ\&_PQLo12,32

#$Y¡¢|£¤¥¦--§¨(©ª«``de9¬>­®Q(\&!"-&²³%´/Lh¯°

Sx±'(tUuv

4QpP#$10%./L-µE¶(·¸1(./0¹-Lº-»-2,3¼5/(½hhKLpP½h¾¿u4Q2E-§¨(xÀxÁÂQ(4\L1(Z\&hÃ-(789:ÄÅÆÇÈÉÊ-Ë&(p―140―Z%-&4W%Ûy

ÜÝÞß%à'Lo2KÔÕpPÒÓ½hWåÒÓãä½h$Ö×Ä@ØÄ<8ÙÚe-3áµEâÉ

ÔhÕ±\Ã½h¾Õ#(2EæçQLo

èéèê@?ë­ì\(ÏÐh1(-5 Ôêí8îÁÂQ(EK 3ï1L¿uKLÒÓ½hEhÃðÉ%ñ(4âr

ò°Eó°2,3
44E5¼ôõE./L-(789:;<8Jæçö÷KLtUøQ%/(#$Ùùúûü-Lýþ-»-2,3

789:;<8 
5 6=p6=  %±-L5§,0%KL%Ûy

E,3S#$TU9C9:;<8î@Ä<8Ý78ØîíÄ<8789:;<8-&E§,4âr(-§QL-2,3#$åKL789:;<85Qa%ÛQ
3C6è8A

QL-E5y°C78è8AEçp

n#$-LC=\Lè8A

En#$=-&

5Q%}'―141―

É

JQ(\&2K

Q
°6

E,



#$%}'(1L

!



#$123

"#$%&=>?+34
.

'()*56/0G"HIJK?LADE?F"cde

pq48

BC4DE?

4M&;NO

42

f@>?

$@GzD{|"}
8"

~6



g7hLK.?8KL@

U2G"8"H"M&?

5

4|"z|"z"

3?4#$

4

@A

'¡#$¢8"£¤@G¥¦§;¨©8"ª2«@¬­®¯M&°±«@l`m][«@´3?µ0

pq@G@GzLAK4Dl`m][+8>xy

#$FJ?+3

Gz5v4E?

U2@

PQl`m][no`4D
y

iF

"77zLAl`m][no`#8""8"@Al`m][no`",#$RF?"8"4?



F@

DE?F@ADl`m][no`F"

DE?FHr2K

<BC">?Pstuvw>?"LAK4xy4DE?
3/0+VWTXYZ[Y\]^_`ab>?

ijk@.

+,-.

7"8"9:;@>A88@4#$

QIRK?STU2@

X¶·¸

7zLA#$M&º+z

M&²³J@GF"¹EK?8"7

3

»78"

@G8"l`m][no`"

¼Q

½¾

¿

Àu

54">?"ILA88"7l`m][no`"4M&}+?½i>?|"z|"z½¾M&3Á>KÂKÅ>?.

Ã>}+zÄ

7"8"vÆq@G"Ç4?LAÇT#$"È¯7#$xÉ8"XÊ[Y>l`m][no`"Ï5¼&?8KL@Ë"ÌK?ÍÎ48GzLAl`m][@Ð?

.
xÒ

xÉ8"

M&}+8"

3.?$}

4Ó



.

.?

>?l`m][UÑ"`¸]

―142―.

>?ÔÕJK?

M&

S8"

×ØÙ

¼&88UÇÇ}28"@Sv"?7>KLkAK

+ÚÛ@ÜÝÜYZ[Þß·^8UÑ7"8"@A>Ñ7"8"@>Al`m][Ö@S½i4|"}?

àá?G"×

-?S

@4



7"äLA!"#$:

D|"z|"z8".

éäRKLAæxy¥ç©"7mÜXè"7êª#ëK"7ì



X¶ð

GR#$z

GR#$Fäå+K4"?





òó

.?46íîæ©ñ/0"7@A2K
ôõ4

.

¥ç©ñ

àï

|"z|"z@4+|"z|"S?ö÷øù>?u8"7úL@4

7"äLAÇ4
û#$ü ì4DxyF U2ýËþ  .
?ôKû®¯
7"

2ü">?Ì8"

?SL>A.?ø?+4xy@U2$?R2@4@4

7@

A
¹>L>|"z|"z½¾
&º+z

ÚÛG

@AD®¯F"#$$}ìi|"}


[M

ø57L?³Ì54ÕG"äLA÷®¯""+Jk<=!?}xy#T&ì.

#$"4l`m][®¯@?8"R7zLA}Lz




X¢%Í%Í%Í

/0"M$i"8"-?}

%&

!

―143―





?LA'(

!"#$(#3456%&'()"*789:;#DEFGH7IJ=D9*)<=(>'?@AB*C!&KL`(#$[=+W\]ab*)%#=*D$^78cN'(i&j,)$7-l.

UV$W

AB

MN#YIJ&D$ghZ/1de+,MN#O

Y=(>Z".V$&V$&
%#?@AB+,-./012

PQ3RDS'"#78D&'(>T+X$.$<N#WD
9

78_

/1de=f

$kjW

!m/1de8st=(>)"*uv'(>)

neopqr-l.

9$78V$&V$&%T+$.`"#*Z=(>34

?@wx. $yzD<?@{9AB|}

X$z?@9&*)"

~
*

T+!#34

=%#$.

yz&K.yz*34<j'(>|}*'?@9#y\=%&

2 $.N#$ =#$ 8$. '(>q1D9&$8$?@9&9¢£(¤*

$ym"#$.¡N

8$$¥

78.

ym" $ 8$=*D$^ '(>W'&) AB*q1

DR [=¦§.¨8 $ 8$=(>q1©ªAB$*«&®¯°±

3

V$&V$&¬8$²³$.´­$WD

8$y­V$&V$&%

9[=y;=9$7µ.'(>)"*3²³-(#¶·C¸¹º¸C¸¹
!»#ECD¸¹7f¸¹(#$=*y¼$ ½¾'h;>¿À4DCÁÂÃCÄÅÆJD$$È.W

#fABEÍ

<PQ3¥ÇÉÊ$Ëº8[=®¯°±²³=%#Ì!

¯ÎE#$KLy¼$½¾#

=(>?@ABÏÐÑÒÓD

XCDyzÖ$D
$

8$*f*ABÔÕ(#V$&V$&#$=(>AB­;=Ëº8$=%&f$―144―f×a3ØÙaÚ(##?@$Ëº8$=%&ÛÜ~ÝÞ$!&jW34$

ßËº8$=

(>).)"*?@âÙ.
:<åæV$W.
$

8$

D¯ê

N'(>)
ë.

D)

)

AB$$D&'(>ABD

8#$?@*)ìí´­½$^

V$&.
$

D

f'(>34XC²³.

#÷ºX

"=*D9T+U

È'"#Dí

D=*D=*D$^

¶KyÁyøÆJ

=#
D$õN

8$

!.$

ì?@

9$

9

$.

=%#

=%#

$

8

I8$^

$ÏÐ3R21

Öµ*Ù



=*D

78V$&V$&D¯ê¸¹.X`.ÀD34ÆJ"#$y<=DJ"m½s=

[È'"#èq1©ª$Ñ(#$KL

U(>).AB¯ê*úûD9(üýTþ($%#í$$öyU*)Y*øù?@¯Î$AB

9$õN<"'(>¯ÎÁf,=(>q1DT+'(>)

Aî$Ëº'(>W'&AB!#a3V$&V$&[$Ëº8$.

D:"é

9$KL34*V$&V$&V$&ºT+$*':)=*D

çè$.¦§(#

347.

ïðÄÅñNWWòó5ôC¦§.D

$D#$7

34?@=)ÏÐÔÕ.

f$½

8ãä

'

jWy­['(>3R21¢£.

#V$WY

¸%&'

(>217#3R21=*34$

D=ÄÅñN%D<<aÚ.ïÖaÚ.

$X9õN#Ã(#$yz'(>)="y¼$BD'8J=È:"D½¾#3R<¦§.9U)''?@ABöD&é#y/qKLqr*?@A$¥L=(> %&8$*9:;3'!&-(#yz*

=*D$^'(>21=#$õN

9D3RJ#11=(>3R

217é<"#3$3$)

8Xy
$%#

è#$"#

!#?@AB$%#q1DR9&ñ(#$#8V$W¸U(#1o1*217#X

{ÁaÚ.

#$8%&'(>
~7#$

21J#1o1―145―

!"#$%&'()

0*123425^

0_`>a1e3fg

O[6**@A9(BPQRST6RR&Y+,

Z]3

0^-./IJ9KL9:MNO0

[:R\+,

6789:;<=>?

'&'CD%EF%GH
UV:WX

*





6*

6*

Rbc^^

0^

0d

0R&Y>hi'1

j1kl>&m&Y

kl>op

0^

*



n&Y

?6:<=q/0:'

6rsWXt(u'vnB'&Yw51
yza1
R

x0&Y>de3fg

x{|}R&Y+,

:BB6*P9R

:/5P%

u>o0P

*0©{.ªA>«6*¡

6{.<=¬<~­®¯R

i>²*/¥¨RR»\

d_`>0´



6½¾

e3xÂÃTÄ>

<=Æ5P%ÇÂÃT&m&cR¥¦§°dRµ¶·¸>¹º6^:

'BR>

>hi%**R5P%³HUi

*R

R%&g>(x%P±RrR&m>

2¼Rq

%

*

x:'5P%>V:*¤1¥¦§R¥¨R9>

@A

/05P%>

/¢£:R\~R[x*¿{.<=ÀRÁ>m¡ÂÃT]6^:PR<=ÈÉPQÂÃT

2Å:ÃR;<=Ë±ÂÃT

2Å&cR;

ÂÃTÂÃTÌÂÃTÊÍÂÃ

T ÎÏ:ÃRÐ{ÇÑÒ<=Ó±jRÂÃTRÔÕ Ì ÌÌÍÌÎÏjRÂÃTRÖ×ÎÏPÑÒØÑÒ<=ÎÏÙÚ

6*b~

Û>ÜÝ<=:'j*>ÞßR¢£
{{à^

0^0R

3áâáãäåæ>ç¡ï

%P*1'RÓRÁèéêãëìJíîR

RBB50§ðµR[x:Ã>

'>IJ9>Þß%/ñc>¡―146―*(:'j1òó%j1°%(RõkJö/0÷ø%áâáãäåæ>ù±%&'TjRèéêãëì%Rúûü3HQR¾**>0j1^0Ã6%:0^:*èéêãëì÷å/ÎÏRb%

//*>:143'1¼R>%B:

36çx

:/^0^<=õkJÎÏ{T>j1'RE±

T>



Rãä¸2

T>¢

|Û>ÜÝ%

R{(6<=Û>6ÑÒR3©>
e33'1ñR>{.<=*RbB'&'(n

ÑÒ9:Z[RTR{:0R2¼

TR%B%jRKL9:TR


6HRu>ÙÚa10*RõkJö/0><5

*6*0RbB'¥¦§_x:úûP%6(Rãä¸2¼RB's:'2¼4R789<=3m>

:/

%%B%>g>

ZRbB'a1sa1ãä¸>:

RxPþYR

PQ>j*>Þß%6;<=R
/b%R&'L®òó<=ö/0V

%P%TRJ9:3:'Û>(Ra1

6¾

6¢£RÙÚ

R3?6>:ý6*>?

{6:'T
Ru>g1u9LÙx**>ÎÏ>KA{R(R¢£òóúûRVtu%
**P
2¼

B

6*]]>O

%:'e3'¡'1{.O"R:>a1



IJ>3

R¦

>

R?6>e3%

/TR
í'1

JB'&m&cR
*

2Å\¡

R2¼2Å

63

ÏRb>/ªA

R

:B

**

6*

22Å

2¼Z[Rb~>2¼

/TR

2¼Rúûü6{

çx%

:*

6

*
3

2¼Rúûü6{xj6PÎ¤5>ÎÏç



2¼Rú

ûü6{ R* 2¼ 6* ¤ fg%?6 
2¼>Í2¼Rn2¼ÎÏZ[Z[―147―!

!"#$%&'()*+,-0+123456789E./:!;<+=>?0@ABCD

"=FG2+HIJK

>LMNOPH>

QR>LSTKUV&@MWMXYZ@[\]DC^034_XD`aK7"^0bc12"^0b@dO%De7fgd@12UVhij7f^0klm12>?+noFpq_
rsK&"fKH12:7!
fYZ!UVTKtu+e

12C"fK0+cnvwhexb12TKyz{0|!

MX^00+>|K7}~7fR

0@12UV+atuKMX!>?/KIfH"RG2K

Ff012&4Ff+=

*w

=!"+P@0ej7f+`t>>WKI
J

MNH

t>nvW:7@¡¢£¤¡¥¦Ff§¨>©ª«¤¡¬z:Jt&7­®¯°±²³+
FF



¡¢£¤¡"¥F´µHr`F¶fK·¸&@ª°"FFfH¹º¤»¼34½

"@d+¾Jj¾Jt&¿C&+À&JafFÁÂ*f=F+ÃaÄFJ0x|J!

!

tu+FfH

Å+¢^0Æ©ÇzÈ7ÉfKHUÊx|ËffÌÍÉÎÏTK

0+IF>ÐFÒÓÔÕ+ª¡£¤¡Å+¥ÑMXÏ¹º¤»¼34Öz7KHJfK ª ¹º¤»¼34×7!ÖØz@12UV ÙÚÙ¥Û¤«ÜÝÞ+=)ß>?à:>©ná""f+aMXâã+:·¸&@Êäå+G2KJª¹º¤¡æî+·¸@Y!

'ïF0KH7¶@!

JòJïF0K

―148―

wçèHéêëMXCéê/ìíª¹º¤¡æ

HéêëMXI!

!1234+=F+ðñR§õö!I÷7fYZùJ+¸&`FJü+0¤þËýHþ+:¶ø·¸@fúûFf´Jt>+anv¥¶fKJJF7fRÔ+R@0´µ+FfÕex@tJJ¾MaéêI^b§+eFJF¶T+I^0¹º¤¡æFMX+J»ªHt+@d+H¾@J}ºKò@¶+HI!"Føø+DE`034+¦FfµKKH7ï´øøïFfYZMXâãT+z7=F

"=Fpq_!aj

7=FfJ0@@ÙÚÙ¥Û¤«ÜÝÞT@m)ß>?"MXÎÏ@þ

UVH

fÅ*@MXUVÕõö¸&0

12UVXD=!Ï+7Ëf0@¤Û ¢£ ¥~¤H + +=>?¦F´µ:J ;<Kz@ + C+À&Ja 7f>|K7f>?I!J@°¹»æ Û¤+= UVÊO+AÁ0@=FÄ!
ÉjÇ¦HG2Çz >©d ()*+Aex7I!m+:r@f§KIô
DMX4KH >Ñ>?+: 
=F+´>?H É 7KI!
ï  
KI! øø ÉÄ! :×KI! MX
KI! =©;< whexKI¦>?´¢ô

!"#¤¤¢Ý¥Ù¤
ª¹º¤¡æMX ütéêI^X¢MX ìíMXK7ª¹º¤>»¼MX ù¤Û¢£¥~¤
+=>? J~¤ ­¢¢P¢^¢ç¢Ä¢ü 3­MXUV,-*>? nt>
―149―}

!"#
$%&' ()*+,-. /"#0123
456789:;<=>?@A BCDEFGHIJKL30123L3MNOPQ RSTBCDEFGUVBCDEFGWXQ YZ

RSTBCDEFGU

V[\]^ S_`Ba BCDE―150―bc decf"#