The 6th Tokyo Conference on
Argumentation
Argumentation and Education:
Reflecting upon the 20 years ofthe Tokyo Conference
August 10th-12th, 2020
Tokyo, Japan
Sponsored byJapan Debate Association期間主催）

八月十日―JDA日本ディ
ベート協会（二〇二〇年十二日（月〜水）

第六回議論
学
国際学術会
議

August 10 (Mon)—12 (Wed), 2020
KEYNOTE ADDRESS I Christopher W. Tindale, University of Windsor, Canada“Mere Dispositions: Durability and the Teaching of Values”

KEYNOTE ADDRESS II Hiroshi Matsusaka, Waseda University, Japan“Crisis Management in Communication: New Directions in English
Language Teaching in Japan”

Session 1: 特別パネル 社会学とレトリック分析の交差
氏川雅典、明治学院大学「ヘイトスピーチのレトリック批評家はいかにして可能か？−−規制法施行以後の正当化を可能にする場の形成過程の分析」
明戸隆浩、立教大学「『差別否定』という言説—差別の正当化がもたらすもの」
須永将史、小樽商科大学「『子ども』はどのよ
うに議論されるのか—話し合いの会話分
析」

Session 2: INTERCOLLEGIATE
DEBATING
Michael Eisenstadt, California State
University, Long Beach, U.S.A.
“Public Ears and the Auditory
Shield: Sonic Spaces for
Argumentation Pedagogy”
Elijah Smith, Rutgers UniversityNewark, U.S.A. “The Kritik-Focus
Model of Debate”
小林良裕, 豊島岡女子学園中学高等学校「英語ディベートの試合での勝敗の判断の違い：ジャッジ間の判断の違いは何から生まれるか」

Session 3: SOPHISTS, PLATO &FALLACIESJohn M. Kephart III, California State
University, U.S.A. “ContestingPresumption in Public Deliberation
over Social Justice: Noble Sophistryas Argument Strategy”
Akira Kawashima, Tohoku University,
Japan. “Persuasion and Agreement:‘the Noble Lie’ in Plato’s Republic,
III”
Bernardo Alexander Attias, California
State University, Northridge, U.S.A.
“Demagoguery and Conspiracy
Theory: Rethinking Argument
Education in the Time of Social
Media”

Session 4: HISTORICAL STUDIES
Muhammad Iqbal, Université de Lille,
Lille, France and Antasari State
Islamic University, Indonesia.
“Arsyad al-Banjari’s DialecticalArgumentation on Unlawfulness ofManyanggar and Mambuang
Pasilih”

Session 5: NON-VERBAL ARGUMENT
Junyi Lv, University of Southern
California, U.S.A. “Mushroom at theEnd of the World: ‘From-scratch’Videos, Human-nonhuman
Entanglement, and Visual Wellbing”
Naoki Kambe, Rikkyo University,
Japan. “Toward a Theory of VisualArgument in 2020”

Session 6: CASE STUDIES OF
DEBATING IN JAPANRyo Hisajima, University of Tokyo, “One
Theoretical Consideration of Significanceof Dichotomy in Argumentation Education”
Kaori Miyawaki, St. Andrew's
University, Japan. “Debate
Propositions for Classroom Debate:
Voices from Debate Instructors inJapan”
Joseph P. Zompetti, Illinois State
University, U.S.A. “Kyushu Debate
Workshops: A Rationale for Policy
Debate Training”

Session 7: INTERNATIONAL
DEBATING
John J. Rief, Metropolitan State
University of Denver, U.S.A., &Brian J. Schrader, University ofMichigan-Flint, U.S.A. “Reconciling
Playing the Game with Civic
Education in Intercollegiate
Academic Debate”

Session 8: ARGUMENT &RELIGION/SPIRITUALITY
Ryushin Sudo, JSPS Research Fellow,
Japan. “Qualities of a Good Debaterin the Ancient Indian
Argumentation Theory”

Session 9: 特別パネル クリティカルシン
キング教育と教材アプリの開発
竹中野歩、九州大学／データストラテジー株
式会社 「はじめに」
張小英、九州大学 「批判的思考についての考察」
竹中野歩・軸屋邦彦、株式会社 Get it Inc.
「CT トレーニングアプリの開発」
上土井宏太、九州大学 「CT アプリ利用による学習効果」
内田諭、九州大学 & 井上奈良彦、九州大
学 「大学教育におけるＣＴアプリの利用」

Session 10: ARGUMENT SCHEMESKenji Kubo, Osaka City University,
Japan. “The Evolution of Marketingin Tourism Studies—
Characteristics of the TheoreticalEvolution in Tourism”

Session 11: ARGUMENT PEDAGOGY
Yasuhito Abe, Komazawa University,
Japan. “The Uses and Abuses ofCitizen Science after Fukushima”
Joseph P. Zompetti, Illinois State
University, U.S.A. “‘Fake News’ as
Enthymeme: An Argumentative andConjunctural Analysis of Trump’s
Attacks against Mainstream News”

Session 12: SPECIAL PANEL: ARE
DEBATE COMPETITIONS BAD FOR
US POLITICAL DISCOURSE?
Rebecca J. Steiner, & Edward M.
Panetta, University of Georgia,
U.S.A. “Policy Debate Training: A
Technique to Enrich Political
Discourse in The United States”
Michael Janas, Samford University,U.S.A. “No Participation Trophies:
How Competitive Frameworks Keep
Advocates Accountable”

Session 13: TECHONOLOGY AND
ARGUMENT
Emma Frances Bloomfield,
University of Nevada, Las Vegas,U.S.A., & Paul La Plante, Universityof California, Berkeley, U.S.A.
“Biological Root Metaphors and theHistory of Machine Learning:
Arguments about Algorithms andIntelligence in Technical Discourse”
Shojiro Yasui, Ministry of Health,Labour and Welfare, Japan. “AnAnalysis of Arguments on theRadiation Risk of Thyroid Cancers
in the Fukushima Nuclear Accident
by Using the Toulmin Model”
Gordon R. Mitchell, University ofPittsburgh, U.S.A. “Debating with
Robots: IBM Project Debater andthe Advent of Augmentive
Automated Argumentation”

Session 14: Argument & GenderEdward Schiappa, Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, U.S.A. “TheSingle-Sex Colleges in the US andthe Transgender Exigency”

Session 15: CRITICAL THINKING
Xiaoying Zhang, Kyushu University,
Japan. “An Examination of Source
Credibility of Evidence in Japanese
Debate: From the Aspect of CriticalThinking Disposition”
Manfred Kraus, University ofTübingen, Germany. “TheRhetorical Progymnasmata – A
Teaching Program for CriticalThinking?”

Session 16: ARGUMENTS ON JAPANAND KOREA
Takeshi Suzuki, Meiji University,Japan, & G. Thomas Goodnight,
University of Southern California,U.S.A. “Commodore M. C. Perry’sExpedition of an American
Squadron to Japan, 1982, 1853,and 1854: A Case of Nested
Deliberation”
Hiroko Okuda, Kanto Gakuin
University, Japan. “Deciphering theTrade War Between Japan andSouth Korea: How to Read theGeopolitics of Past, Present, andFuture in East Asia”
Min Wha Han, Angelo State
University, U.S.A. “The Rhetoric ofNorth Korea and Inter-Korean
Summits”
Justin W. Kirk, University of
Nebraska-Lincoln, U.S.A.
“Obama Argue for Peace atHiroshima”

Session 17: SPECIAL Bi-Lingual
PANEL ON LEGAL EDUCATIONAND DEBATE
角松生史、神戸大学 「法的判断における「良い議論」とはどのようなものか－議論
学との協働に向けて」
Satoru Aonuma, International
Christian University, Japan.
“Academic Debate and (Pre-)Law
Education: A Japan-U.S.
Comparison”
尾下悠希＆角松生史、神戸大学 「法律事例ディベートの実践—最高裁判例を素材に」

The Committee for the 6th Tokyo Conference on Argumentation
第 6 回議論学国際学術会議 実行委員会
Executive Committee Chair: Toshiharu Tateyama 立山利治 (International BudoUniversity)
Organizing Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki 鈴木健 (Meiji University)
Japan Debate Association: Junya Morooka 師岡淳也 (Rikkyo University),
Narahiko Inoue 井上奈良彦 (Kyushu University), Kazuhiko Kakehi 筧一彦 (TheUniversity of Tokyo), Takayuki Kato 加藤貴之 (University of Nagano), Shigeru
Matsumoto 松本茂 (Rikkyo University), Yoshiro Yano 矢野善郎 (ChuoUniversity), Shojiro Yasui 安井省侍郎(Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare,Japan), Daisuke Koyama 小山雄輔 (Sharp Corporation), Noriaki Tajima 田島慎朗
(Kanda University of International Studies), Katsuya Koresawa 是澤克哉
(Hiroshima Shudo University)
The Screening Committee: Takayuki Kato 加藤貴之 (Seiwa University), Takeshi
Suzuki 鈴木健 (Meiji University), Shojiro Yasui 安井省侍郎(Ministry of Health,Labour and Welfare, Japan), Junya Morooka 師岡淳也 (Rikkyo University),
Justin Eckstein (Pacific Lutheran University)Reflecting upon the 20 Years of the Tokyo Conference on Argumentation
The 1st Tokyo Conference on Argumentation: “Beyond East and West”
Site: National Olympics Memorial Youth Center, Tokyo
Date: August 7-9, 2000
Co-Sponsor: The Institute of Educational Science, Tokai University
Organizing Committee Chair: Shigeru Matsumoto
Executive Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki & Yoshiro Yano
Keynote Speakers: Katura Shoryu, Hiroshima University
G. Thomas Goodnight, University of Southern California
The 2nd Tokyo Conference on Argumentation: “Argumentation and Social
Cognition”
Site: Tsuda College, Tokyo
Date: August 3-5, 2004
Co-Sponsor: Tsuda College
Organizing Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki
Executive Committee Chair: Yoshiro Yano & Takayuki Kato
Keynote Speakers: Giyoo Hatano, Keio University
Frans H. van Eemeren, University of Amsterdam
The3rd Tokyo Conference on Argumentation: “Argumentation, the Law & Justice”
Site: Chuo University, Tokyo
Date: August 8-10, 2008
Co-Sponsor: Chuo University
Organizing Committee Chair: Yoshiro Yano
Executive Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki & Takayuki Kato
Keynote Speakers: Takao Tanase, Chuo University
David Hingstman, University of Iowa
The 4th Tokyo Conference on Argumentation: “The Role of Argumentation inSociety”
Site: Sophia University Junior College Division, Kanagawa
Date: August 10-12, 2012
Co-Sponsor: Sophia University Junior College Division
Organizing Committee Chair: Fr. Scott Howell
Executive Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki
Keynote Speakers: Yoshiro Yano, Chuo University
David Zarefsky, Northwestern University
The 5th Tokyo Conference on Argumentation: “Argumentation and Debate”
Site: Rikkyo University, Tokyo
Date: August 6-7, 2016
Co-Sponsor: Department of Intercultural Communication,
Rikkyo University
Organizing Committee Chair: Junya Morooka
Executive Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki
Keynote Speakers: Shigeru Matsumoto, Rikkyo University
Michael D. Hazen, Wake Forest University

The 6th Tokyo Conference on Argumentation: “Argumentation and Education”
Site: e-conference, Tokyo
Date: August 10-12, 2020
Organizing Committee Chair: Toshiharu Tateyama
Executive Committee Chair: Takeshi Suzuki
Keynote Speakers: Christopher Tindale, University of Windsor
Hiroshi Matsusaka, Waseda University