World Bank GroupIDA RMSR E S U L T S

M E A S U R E M E N T

FY23 UPDATE1S Y S T E M

IDA20 RMS
Results Framework
Since 1960, the World Bank’s International Development Association (IDA) has beenbuilding the foundations for long-term development in the world’s poorest countries. IDA
works together with client countries to tackle development challenges through a countrydriven model that emphasizes ownership, alignment with national priorities, andimproving the lives of the people most in need. IDA20 has adapted to a changing global
context to strategically address critical issues, reflected in the five special themes climatechange, fragility, conflict and violence, gender and development, human capital, and jobs
and economic transformation, as well as the four crosscutting issues of debt, governanceand institutions, technology, and crisis preparedness.
In line with the World Bank’s evolution towards outcome orientation, IDA continuously
monitors the results of the interventions it supports to understand the impact it is having
in client countries and inform adaptive management. Through the IDA Results
Measurement System (RMS) the World Bank Group tracks and measures how IDA inputs
and activities help countries deliver tangible results that contribute to high-level
development outcomes. The IDA20 RMS uses a three-tiered development results
framework with 95 indicators to track results of IDA countries at an aggregate level. It
represents the most ambitious results architecture in IDA’s history.

TIER 1TIER 2TIER 3

IDA Countries
Progress

IDA-Supported
Development
Results

IDA Organizational& Operational
EffectivenessTracks development
results in countries
supported by IDA
operations.

Includes measures ofboth the operational andorganizational
effectiveness of IDA.

Reports long-term
development outcomes
and the broader context
of countries in which IDA
operates.

2

TIER 1IDA Countries Progress
Reports long-term development outcomes and the broader context of countries
in which IDA operates.

No.

Indicator(unit of measurement)

Baseline as of June 2022
(coverage year)

Results achieved as of June
2023 (coverage year)

Source1

All IDA

FCS

FemaleAll IDA

FCS

Female26.7(2019)

34.2(2019)-

Poverty and Inequality
Platform

0.76(20152020)
44.4(20152020)
37.6(2019)-4.25(2015 2020)-

Global Monitoring Database--

Global Monitoring Database37.3(2019)-

Poverty and Inequality
Platform

0.52(2020)

0.34(2020)-

World Development
Indicators

60.5(2018)
25(20162018)
0.58(2021)
3.2(2021)

50.0(2018)
41(20162018)
0.58(2021)
4.2(2021)-WB DataBank-

WB DataBank-

12(2022)

2(2022)-

Women, Business, and the
Law

World Bank Group Goals
1

Population living on less than $2.15
a day (% of population)2

26.9(2019)

35.0(2019)-

2

Median growth rate of
consumption/income per capita of thebottom 40 percent (%)

1.2(2019)

5.9(2019)-

3

Countries with growth concentrated
in the bottom 40 percent (%)

50(2019)

100(2019)-

4

Gini Index (median index)

-

-

-

IDA20 Special Themes
Climate change
5CO2 emissions (metric tons per capita)

0.55(2019)

0.38(2019)-

6Countries without wealth depletion (%)

65.1(2017)

33.3(2017)-

7

Countries without natural capital wealthdepletion (%)

-

-

-

-

-

-

3.2
(2020)

4.2(2020)-

8
9

Average annual deforestation change(%)
Marine protected areas (% of territorial
waters)-World Development
Indicators
World Development
Indicators

Gender and Development
51(Oct 2020- (Oct 2020Oct 2021) Oct 2021)

10

Legal changes that support genderequality (number of legal changes)

11

Ratio of female to male labor force
participation rate (%)

70(2021)

79(2021)-

70.4(2022)

79.3(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

12

Maternal mortality ratio (number ofmaternal deaths per 100,000 live births)

444(2019)

604(2019)-

425(2020)

578(2020)-

World Development
Indicators

13

Proportion of births attended by skilled
health personnel (%)

62.1(2018)

59.8(2018)-

64.5(2019)

57.8(2019)-

World Development
Indicators

1 For more details on source data, please refer to the IDA20 RMS codebook.
2 To ensure reliable regional and global poverty estimates, countries are required to have survey-based poverty data conducted within three

years of the reference year, and regional estimates are only provided if they cover at least 50 percent of the regional population. However,during the COVID-19 pandemic, the extreme economic shocks and uncertainty prompted a shift in the approach. In 2020 and 2021, an annual
coverage rule instead of a three-year window is used to decide on the regions for which to report post-2019 aggregates, such that only regionswith sufficient data during or post-COVID have aggregates reported. Since, this special coverage rule is not fulfilled for all regions, the Bank is
not reporting 2020 regional and global poverty rates.

3Baseline as of June 2022
(coverage year)

Results achieved as of June
2023 (coverage year)

No.

Indicator(unit of measurement)

All IDA

FCS

FemaleAll IDA

FCS

Female14

Contraceptive prevalence by modern
methods (% of women ages 15-49)3

31.4(2018)

20.7(2018)-

32.9(2019)

23.6(2019)-

World Development
Indicators

15

Adolescent fertility rate (number ofbirths per 1,000 women ages 15-19)

83.6(2020)

94.9(2020)-

82.7(2021)

94.0(2021)-

World Development
Indicators

Source1

Fragility, Conflict and Violence16

Number of refugees by country or
territory of asylum (million)

10.2(2021)

5.1(2021)-

10.5(2022)

5.2(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

17

Internally displaced persons, total
displaced by conflict and violence(million)

42.0(2021)

40.7(2021)-

46.2(2022)

45.1(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

Jobs and Economic Transformation
18

GDP per person employed(constant 2017 PPP $)11,579(2021)

9,478(2021)-

11,707(2022)

9,434(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

19

Non-agriculture sectors, value added(as % of GDP)

79.3
(2021)

78.4(2021)-

80.4(2022)

77.1(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

20

Annual growth rate of real GDP per
capita (%)

1.7(2021)-1.6(2021)-

2.1(2022)

0.6(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

21

Proportion of population with access toelectricity (%)

63.9(2020)

49.7(2020)-

65.6(2021)

51.6(2021)-

World Development
Indicators

22

Youth employment to population ratio(age 15-24) (%)• Youth employment to population
ratio (age 15-24), women (%)• Youth employment to population
ratio (age 15-24), men (%)

38.3(2021)
31.7(2021)
44.7(2021)

36.6(2021)
33.3(2021)
39.8(2021)

38.7(2022)
32.0(2022)
45.1(2022)

36.9(2022)
33.5(2022)
40.2(2022)

23

Proportion of adults (15 years and older)with an account at a bank or otherfinancial institution or with a mobile
money service provided (%)

44(2021)

42(2021)

37(2021)

42(2022)

41(2022)

36(2022)

Global Findex

24

Proportion of adults (15 years and older)with an account at a bank or otherfinancial institution or with a mobile
money service provided, bottom 40%
(%)

-

-

-

34
(2022)

30(2022)

29(2022)

Global Findex-

World Development
Indicators-

World Development
Indicators-

Human Capital
25

Prevalence of stunting among children
under 5 years of age (%)

31.1(2021)

34.4(2021)-

30.6(2022)

34.0(2022)

26

Under-5 mortality rate (number ofunder-five deaths per 1,000 live births)

67.5(2020)

81.9(2020)-

65.7(2021)

79.7(2021)

27

Incidence of HIV (per 1,000 uninfected
population ages 15-49)

0.61(2020)

0.47(2020)

0.79(2020)

0.54(2021)

0.39(2021)

0.70(2021)

World Development
Indicators

28

Population of children who cannot readby end-of-primary-school age (%)

81.8(2019)--

83.8(2019)--

Global Learning Assessment
Database

World Development
Indicators

3 Data coverage may fall below the typical threshold of 66% aggregate reporting. Note that the indicator has changed for this cycle; the IDA19

indicator included only married women ages 15-49.

4

No.

29

Indicator(unit of measurement)

All IDA

FemaleAll IDA

FCS

Female-50.3(2019)

51.6(2020)-

50.4(2020)

95.3(2019)
58.1(2019)

-

-

-

-

56.7
(2019)

95.6(2020)
57.1(2020)

95.2(2019)-

95.3(2020)--

51.6(2019)• Ratio of girls’ to boys’ completionrate• Ratio of girls’ to boys’ enrollment rate

Results achieved as of June
2023 (coverage year)

FCS

Lower secondary gross completion rate(%)

Lower secondary enrollment rate (%)
30

Baseline as of June 2022
(coverage year)-

Source1

World Development
Indicators

55.7(2020)

World Development
Indicators-

31

People using basic drinking water
services (% of population)

73.1(2021)

63.6(2021)-

73.7(2022)

64.5(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

32

People using basic sanitation services(% of population)

46.3(2021)

36.5(2021)-

47.1(2022)

37.2(2022)-

World Development
Indicators

16(2021)

6(2021)-

16(2022)

6(2022)-CPIA Platform

34

IDA countries with improved budget
reliability, transparency of publicfinances, and control in budget
execution (number)

27(2022)

9(2022)-

4(2023)--

Public Expenditure andFinancial Accountability
assessments portal

35

Statistical Performance Indicators(scale from 0 to 100)

49.3
(2019)

42.6(2019)-

49.7(2019)

42.9(2019)-

World Development
Indicators

36

IDA countries with increased tax
fairness and progressivity (number)

-

-

-

6
(2021)

2(2021)-IMF Government Finance
Statistics

37

Unweighted average increase in tax-toGDP ratio in at least those IDA countries
with tax revenues below 15 percent of
their GDP for three consecutive years
(%)

0.34
(20192021)

0.38(20192021)-

0.24(20202022)

0.09(20202022)-

IMF Government Finance
Statistics

-

-

-

35.3
(2021)

34.6(2021)-

World Development
Indicators

-

-

-

18.8
(2020)

22.5(2020)-

World Development
Indicators

IDA20 Cross-cutting Issues
Debt
33

IDA countries with low or moderate risk
from unsustainable debt (number)

Governance and Institutions

Technology
38

Individuals using the internet in IDA
countries (% of population)

Crisis preparedness
39

Prevalence of undernourishment in IDA
countries (% of population)

5

TIER 2
IDA-Supported Development Results
Tracks development results in countries supported by IDA operations.

No.

Indicator(unit of measurement)

IDA19 Results(FY21-FY22)
All IDA

FCS

4.0

-

IDA20 Results(FY23)
FemaleAll IDA

FCS

4.67

0.19

Expected
Range/Value
Female (FY23-FY25)

Source

IDA20 SPECIAL THEMES
Climate Change
10 GW

World Bank
Operations
PortalMonitored

World Bank
Operations
Portal20

World Bank
Operations
Portal1

Generation capacity of renewableenergy (Gigawatt)

2

Net GHG emissions (tCO2eq/year)

3

People provided with access toclean cooking (million)

4

IDA countries supported to
implement and/or update their
NBSAPs (Number of countries)

16

7

20

5

IDA countries with completed
Country Climate Development
Reports (Number of countries)

13

530 - 40-29,063,545 -13,365,752-20,523,982 -13,414,661

4.08

2.50

World Bank
Operations
Portal and
NBSAPswebsiteWorld Bank
Operations
Portal,Regional CCDR
Coordinators

FCV

6

IDA FCS supported in building
capacity to use field-appropriate
digital open-source tools forcollection and analysis of
geo-tagged data, and apply thistechnology to enhance project
implementation and coordination(Number of countries)

14

17

18

GEMS'syearlycounting
methodology6.5 - 7.0

World Bank
Operations
PortalJobs and Economic Transformation (JET)
7

Farmers adopting improved
agricultural technology (million)

2.42

0.32

8

Area provided with new/improved
irrigation or drainage services(Hectares, million)

0.82

9

People provided with new or
improved electricity service (Numberof people, million)

24.35

0.60

2.63

0.59

0.04

0.24

0.04

1.5 - 2.0

World Bank
Operations
Portal

11.89

10.83

6.48

35 - 50

World Bank
Operations
Portal

6

1.06

No.

Indicator(unit of measurement)

IDA19 Results(FY21-FY22)

IDA20 Results(FY23)All IDA

FCS

FemaleAll IDA

FCS

18.80

0.72

10.11

6.48

0.48

Beneficiaries reached with financial
services supported by World Bank
operations – Businesses (Number ofbusinesses, million)

0.48

0.11

0.22

0.07

11

Beneficiaries in IDA countries of jobfocused interventions (million)

26.48

6.75

11.74

2.60

12

People with enhanced access totransportation services (million)

16.37

3.06

4.67

13

People provided with improved
urban living conditions (million)

20.30

8.0

Beneficiaries reached with financial
services supported by World Bank
operations – People (Number ofpeople, million)

Expected
Range/Value
Female (FY23-FY25)

3.00

10

8.12

Source5.0 - 6.5
World Bank(o/w 95%
Operationsindividuals and Portal, OPCS
5% firms)
data

Monitored

World Bank
Operations
Portal

1.99

90 - 105

World Bank
Operations
Portal8.01

2.30

15 - 20

World Bank
Operations
Portal4.80

Human Capital14

Beneficiaries of social safety net
programs (million)

170.10

21.50

86.92

23.88

3.11

12.94

75 - 375

World Bank
Operations
Portal15

People who have received essential
health, nutrition, and population
services (Indicator reporting total
from sub-indicators 16, 17 and 18
below) (million)

210.3682.23

134.25

72.13

50.67

48.56

285 - 430

World Bank
Operations
Portal16Children Immunized (million)

76.10

25.59

38.05

20.76

13.81

10.38

105 - 200

World Bank
Operations
Portal17

Women and children who havereceived basic nutrition services(million)

114.42

46.10

76.27

39.59

28.71

26.39

140 - 150

World Bank
Operations
Portal18

Deliveries attended by skilled healthpersonnel (million)

19.87

10.55

11.79

8.15

11.79

40 - 80

World Bank
Operations
Portal19

COVID-19 vaccine doses
administered (million)

Monitored

WB, WHO,IMF, WTO Task
Force tracker

20

Number of large-scale assessmentscompleted at primary or secondary
level (number)

36

8

21

People provided with access toimproved water sources (million)

15.83

4.35

22

People provided with access toimproved sanitation services(million)

10.20

1.62

212

IDA20 CROSS-CUTTING ISSUES
Debt

7

12

1

25 - 35

Enterprise
Data Center
(EDC)

7.95

8.23

3.87

13 - 20

World Bank
Operations
Portal

5.13

14.86

2.73

12 - 28

World Bank
Operations
PortalNo.

23

Indicator(unit of measurement)
IDA countries publishing annual andtimely public debt reports (Numberof countries)

IDA19 Results(FY21-FY22)
All IDA

FCS

41

12

IDA20 Results(FY23)
FemaleAll IDA

FCS

35

10

Expected
Range/Value
Female (FY23-FY25)

Source30 - 35

Debt
Transparency
Heatmap

Governance and Institutions

24

IDA countries provided statistical
capacity building support by the
WBG for the implementation ofhousehold surveys (Number ofcountries)

54

27

Countries collecting disability data
25 with IDA support (Number ofcountries)

50

16

55

Household
SurveyScorecard by
Poverty GP

29

8

Monitored

Poverty andEquity GP

Technology
26

People provided with enhanced
access to broadband internet(million)

47.10

15.30

66.86

42.25

80 - 88

World Bank
Operations
Portal and
OPCS data

62

26

48

17

55 - 70

World Bank
Operations
Portal17

3

Monitored

World Bank
Operations
PortalCrisis Preparedness

27

Countries supported toward
institutionalizing disaster risk
reduction as a national priority with
IDA support (Number of countries)

28

Countries integrating adaptive social
protection into national systems
with IDA support (Number ofcountries)
DELIVERING OUTCOMES

29

30

31

Satisfactory outcomes of IDA
60
67
Country Partnership Frameworks (%(FY19-FY22) (FY19-FY22)
IEG rating, 4-year rolling)

68
67(FY20-FY23) (FY20-FY23)70%

IEG CLR
documents

Satisfactory outcomes of IDA
operations:
84.8
78.2
• as a share of commitments (% IEG(FY19-FY21) (FY19-FY21)
rating, 3-year rolling)• as a share of operations (% IEG
81.0
74.8
rating, 3-year rolling)(FY19-FY21) (FY19-FY21)

87.4
82.4
(FY20-FY22) (FY20-FY22)80%

IEG Ratings

80.2
73.9
(FY20-FY22) (FY20-FY22)

75%

Advisory Services and Analytics(ASA) objectives accomplished(client rating, %)

90

89

79

64

80%

World Bank
ClientSatisfaction
Survey32

Client feedback in IDA countries on
WBG effectiveness and impact on
results (Average rating scale: 1-10)

7.8

7.7

7.5

7.1

7

Country
Opinion
Surveys33

Client feedback in IDA countries on
WBG knowledge (Average rating
scale: 1-10)

7.5

7.6

7.7

7.5

7

Country
Opinion
Surveys8

TIER 3
IDA Organizational & Operational Effectiveness
Includes measures of how IDA finances, monitors, and implements for outcomes.

Indicator
No. (unit of measurement)

Benchmark Value(FY22)All IDAFCSResults(FY23)All IDAFCSExpected
Range/Value(FY23-FY25)

SourceFINANCING OUTCOMES
1

IDA Budget Anchor (%)

74

70<= 100%Management
Discussion and
Financial Statements

2Bank budget to Portfolio Volume Ratio(per $ billion under supervision) ($million)9

9

Monitored

World Bank Enterprise
Resource Planning

3

Average cost of IDA supervision projects(implementation support) ($ thousand)

207

205

226

224

Monitored

World Bank Enterprise
Resource Planning4

Share of climate co-benefits over totalcommitments in IDA-supported
operations (%)

37

41

38

41

5

Share of adaptation co-benefits overtotal climate co-benefits in IDAsupported operations (%)

59

55

53

51

>= 50%

WB-internal Climate CoBenefits Dashboard and
CCG Co-Benefits Report

Total private mobilization of WBGsupported operations/transactions in
IDA countries ($ billion)

7.92

3.10

7.90

4.10

Monitored

World Bank Operations
Portal

3.02

1.00

3.43

1.37

Monitored

World Bank Operations
PortalTotal private mobilization of WBGsupported operations/transactions in
IDA countries - Indirect mobilization($ billion)

4.91

2.10

4.47

2.73

Monitored

World Bank Operations
Portal7

IDA countries with the lowest Human
Capital Index supported to improve thesustainability of human capital financing(Number of countries)

23

12

14

6

15

Multiple Global
Practices (EDU, GOV,
HNP, MTI and SPJ)8

IDA financing commitments withdisaster risk management co-benefits($ billion)

6.09

2.294

5.67

2.02

2

Climate Change CoBenefits assessment

64

Total private mobilization of WBGsupported operations/transactions in
IDA countries - Direct mobilization($ billion)

WB-internal Climate
35% over FY21- Co-Benefits Dashboard
FY25
and CCG Co-Benefits
ReportThis indicator has been retroactively updated to reflect a new methodology for calculating DRM co-benefits adopted for IDA20.

9

Indicator
No. (unit of measurement)

Benchmark Value(FY22)All IDAFCSResults(FY23)All IDAFCSExpected
Range/Value(FY23-FY25)

SourceMONITORING OUTCOMES
9

Satisfactory Bank performance in IDAfinanced operations (% IEG Ratings, 3year rolling)• Overall (% IEG Ratings, 3-year rolling)• At entry (% IEG Ratings, 3-year rolling)• During supervision (% IEG Ratings, 3year rolling)

10

Quality of M&E in IDA-financed
operations (% IDA commitments, IEG
ratings, 3-year rolling)

11

IDA projects with an AA Resilience
Rating (Number)

12

Percentage of IDA operations with
substantial climate co-benefits including
at least one climate change indicator in
the results framework (%)

13

Percentage of IDA-supported projects
that demonstrate a results chain bylinking gender gaps identified in analysis
to specific actions that are tracked in
the results framework (%)

87.9
86.4
89.5
(FY19-FY21) (FY19-FY21) (FY20-FY22)

86.0(FY20-FY22)

85.5
86.3
83.9
83.2
(FY19-FY21) (FY19-FY21) (FY20-FY22) (FY20-FY22)
90.8
88.0
93.0
92.2
(FY19-FY21) (FY19-FY21) (FY20-FY22) (FY20-FY22)
64.7
61.7
69.9
(FY19-FY21) (FY19-FY21) (FY20-FY22)80%

IEG Ratings

Monitored
Monitored

67.3(FY20-FY22)60%

IEG Ratings

2

2

10

Board-Approved PADs,
RRS template

93.9

97.8

95%

Project PADs

World Bank Operations
Portal and Gender Portal

93

96

96

96

60%

IMPLEMENTING FOR OUTCOMES
AO 3a.12 –Disbursement Ratio byYear
AO 3a.2 – Portfolio
Status Indicator by Year

14

Disbursement ratio (%)

19.1

20.8

18.8

20.4

20%

15

Proactivity Index (%)

82.1

81.6

82.4

82.4

80%

16

IDA-supported operations that address
and respond to gender-based violence(GBV) (Number)

114

38

40

18

Monitored

World Bank Operations
Portal17

Country programs informed bydiagnostics on crisis preparedness(Number)112

Monitored

SCDs and CPFs/CENs
approved within Fiscal
Year

18

Facetime index in FCS(Index/Number of days)

12/191,556

Monitored

HR Dashboard

19

Share of IDA IPF operations that applied
the concept of universal access at design(% of approved IDA IPF in FY)

28.1

22.4

28.0

12.0

Monitored

IPF ESF summaries andmanagement plans

20Countries supported by IDA to take IFFrelated actions (Number)

14

-

10

5

Monitored

World Bank Operations
Portal21

Client feedback on WBG on
responsiveness and staff accessibility(Average rating scale: 1-10)

7.1

7.0

7.2

6.9

7

Country Opinion Surveys

22

Client feedback on WBG on
collaboration with other donors(Average rating scale: 1-10)

7.8

7.7

7.2

7.5

8

Country Opinion Surveys

23

Projects with beneficiary feedback at
design (%)

98

97

99

98

100%

Citizen Engagement
Database (FURL: CEDB)

25/171,183

10

11