1

INCREASING READINGFLUENCY IN YEAR 5
STUDENTS LEARNING
JAPANESE AS A
SECOND LANGUAGE
KATHLEEN DUQUEMIN
Gardenvale Primary School, VIC

ABSTRACTThis chapter outlines a pedagogical study conducted in a government primary school which aimed to increase
reading fluency in Grade 5 students learning Japanese as a Second Language. The scaffolded activities
and incorporation of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) throughout the program are outlined
along with the various assessments – both formative and summative – that provided the structure forthe study. This study proved to be highly successful in providing Grade 5 students with the tools required
to improve their reading fluency in hiragana without the need for romaji support. As students’ reading skills
improved, their motivation for learning Japanese increased. While the study included a broad range of activities,
student feedback suggested that the Interactive White Board (IWB) Word Magnets were the most favoured andeffective learning activities.

2

INTRODUCTION
Studies have shown that even reading a first language (L1) is a complex process (Nassaji 2011), and when it comesto reading in a second language (L2) more complications arise, particularly relating to cross-linguistic and sociocultural
influences (Bernhardt 2005). Reading ability is further hampered by the amount of exposure to the L2; low exposure canresult in limited word recognition ability (Gorsuch & Taguchi 2008, 2010). In addition, L2 readers tend to focus more on the
vocabulary and grammar than on comprehension (Horiba 1990).
It is difficult to define reading fluency conclusively, and researchers have taken a variety of approaches to the concept.
While some suggest fluency is made evident through smooth reading with no hesitation (Yamashita & Ichikawa 2010),
others suggest accuracy, automaticity and prosody are important components of reading fluency and claim that in fluent
readers word recognition and comprehension occur simultaneously (Kuhn et al. 2010). Some researchers claim thatword recognition is just the first step to comprehension (Samuels 2007). The definition of fluency for the purpose of thisstudy combines elements of these approaches; reading fluency is here defined as reading with accuracy and automaticity
with evidence of comprehension, with a focus on comprehension (indicated by matching written words and sentences toimages) rather than reading aloud.

BACKGROUNDRATIONALE
Teachers of Japanese as a Second Language (L2) in Victorian primary schools face many challenges, including mixed
abilities within a class, class sizes, school culture, community support and adequate resourcing. Time allocation is one of
the most significant challenges. While languages attract similar weighting to other elective subjects in most secondary
schools, the majority of primary schools allocate only one 40–50 minute class per week to second language study.
At Gardenvale Primary School, the Japanese program has strong community support and generous resourcing but faces
the same time allocation issue as many primary schools. Students learn Japanese from Foundation level to Year 6, attending
language class once a week for a 50 minute period. Despite being enthusiastic learners in a relatively positive environment
for language learning, in the past students have not progressed easily from being capable readers of characters and words
to becoming fluent readers of texts. While Vygotsky suggests that students need to be in a “zone of proximal development”(ZPD) for meaningful learning to occur (Wood & Wood 1996), this goal has been a challenge to incorporate into planningdocuments for 600 students across seven year levels in 24 separate classes. This is due in part to a lack of time to create
individualised learning plans for such a large number of students, as well as limited class time available to differentiate
learning experiences. As a result, learners have not always received the necessary support to move into the ZPD. The
focus of this study was to develop a highly structured and scaffolded program through which students could achieve
the specific goal of an increase in fluency when reading a short text, with an emphasis on progressing the students fromindividual word recognition to comprehending text as a whole.

3

THE STUDY
In order to improve learners’ fluency, a fourteen-week plan was developed which consisted of scaffolded tasks designed
specifically to move students into the ZPD with a variety of supports. The scaffolded tasks included both digital and nondigital activities and were designed for individual, small-group and whole-class configurations. The project began with arevision of hiragana to make certain all students were familiar with the characters and all of their conventions (diacritic
marks, blended sounds). Assessments included a pre-test, a series of formative assessments and a post-test toward theend of the study (summative assessment). The study concluded with individual assessment tasks that demonstrated
student mastery of the macroskills of reading and speaking.
The topic chosen for the reading material used in the study was “travel”. It included vocabulary relating to vehicles and place
names, and the sentence structure “I go to ~ by ~” (see Table 1). This topic was new to all students, so no individual student
would be expected to have a linguistic advantage. All words were introduced in hiragana even though traditionally loanwords are written in katakana. Students are not introduced to katakana characters at this primary school and therefore it
was felt that introducing them at this point would cause confusion and take the focus away from reading. Also, at this levelof study more value is placed on the ability to read hiragana than adopting traditional spelling conventions.
Transport vocabulary

Places vocabulary

くるま
たくしー
ばす
でんしゃ
しんかんせん
じてんしゃ
ひこうき
ふね
へりこぷたー
あるいて

はし
えき
くうこう
おてら
とりい
じんじゃ
ほてる
りょかん
おんせん
こうえん

Table 1: Vocabulary introduced in this study

Year 5 students (85 students in total) were chosen as the target group for this study for the following reasons:• students had already learned all hiragana characters and therefore could focus solely on developing
reading skills;• students were enthusiastic and self-motivated and therefore were more likely to adopt a positive
attitude to the challenge of reading;• students were already familiar with Japanese word order, therefore sentence structure and othergrammatical elements would be more easily identified and understood.

4

PROGRAMSCAFFOLDED TASKSThe tasks were scaffolded to ensure students were both building on previous knowledge and being challenged academicallyand therefore being moved into the ZPD. The initial activities focused on hiragana revision, and moved on to word recognitionand sentence construction activities which incorporated the RR methodology11 (see Table 2). This scaffolded approach
would enable students to increase accuracy and comprehension of the vocabulary, resulting in increased reading fluency.

Initial phase of
study

Revision of hiragana and all conventions
Oral introduction of vehicle vocabulary through “transport rap” song
Oral introduction of place names using flash cards and mnemonic stories
Oral introduction of sentence pattern and vocabulary to be covered

Pre-Test
and post-test

Pre-test of1) basic hiragana character recognition;2) hiragana character reading knowledge (including blended sounds and voiced/unvoiced consonants);
3) whole word recognition (matching words to images);4) sentence recognition (comprehension by matching sentences to images).
NB. In each section there was a timed element, so that improvements in reading times could bemeasured from pre- to post-test.
Post-test (identical to pre-test) (see Appendix)

Learning
activities

Introduction of new vocabulary using Triptico Word Magnets2
Word order activities using Triptico Word Magnets
Vocabulary Introduction/Revision using Flash cards
Grammar Hunt – collaborative task and Interactive Whiteboard (IWB) PowerPoint interactive
Particle races – matching particles to correct nouns using word cards
Sentence word order activities using IWB and word cards
Karuta games using picture and word cards
Creation of Travel Mini book

Assessment
tasks

Formative assessments:
swatter game using flashcards
swiping game using Triptico and IWB
karuta card game using pictures and words
Revision activities at beginning of each lesson
Summative assessments:
Creation of annotated Map including labels for places and transports
Tellagami recording (using Tellagami App on iPad) based on reading map Student feedback – discussion

Table 2: Outline of scaffolded tasks

PRE-TEST AND POST-TEST
The pre-test and post-test were identical in order to clearly identify change in students’ recognition and reading skills.
The pre-test occurred in term 2, and the post-test was conducted in term 3, ten weeks after the beginning of the Project.
The pre-test (reproduced in the Appendix) occurred in week three of the Project. This time was chosen for two reasons:1) by week three, students had thoroughly revised hiragana and were once again confident in recognising the charactersand conventions; and2) students had participated in three weeks of oral activities and had demonstrated through formative assessment activities(transport song and flashcard-swatter games) their familiarity with the vocabulary and sentence structure.

1 ‘RR methodology’ refers to the Repeated Reading Method, in which students read and re-read texts in order to improve their speed, accuracy andcomprehension of the text.
2 ‘Triptico Word Magnets’ refers to a Web Tool (https://tripticoplus.com/). This tool allows teachers to create and edit interactive screens containing words
and images for use on IWB.

5

Students were instructed that these pre-test results would not be used for any reason other than as a starting point for the
study, so as to minimise the incidence of stress or nerves in completing the test. They were asked to complete each section
and then record the time taken to complete the task, after which they were asked to put down their pencil and turn the page
over. The same structure applied to all other sections of the pre-test. At the end of the pre-test, all papers were collected
and scores were recorded on an Excel chart.

STRUCTURE OF LESSONSEach class followed a similar structure:• R evision activity using flash cards/Triptico Word Magnets – discussion/
sharing reading strategies• Introduction of new materials (vocabulary, grammar, sentence structure)• explicit teaching of new material• small group activity to reinforce new learning – peer learning• r eading-revision using Triptico Word Magnets/word cards – formative
assessment• individual activity – writing sentences/creating annotated map/
recording Tellagami• lesson end – discussion – revision of new learning and connecting it to prior learning
At the beginning of each lesson, during the revision activity using the IWB and the Word Magnets, the students were asked
to share their strategies for how they read the word. Students were encouraged to apply a variety of reading strategies tothe reading tasks and were reassured that all strategies were valuable. The strategies used by them included:“I listen to the sound of the first part of the word and look for that character”;“I listen for a character that I know and try to find it on the board”;“I listen to the number of syllables in the word and then work out which word has the same number ofcharacters”;“I knew that it started and finished with で (でんしゃで) so just looked for the word with a matching
character at the beginning and end”;“It looks like two people in a hotspring”;“I knew that one sound was repeated so I tried to find the word which had repeated characters”;“I remembered from last week”;“I don’t know, I just know”;“I guessed”.

FORMATIVE ASSESSMENT
Throughout this study, there were several data collection points where formative assessment took place.
• R evision activities – these were structured in such a way that it was possible to ascertain student familiarity
with character knowledge/vocabulary/sentence structure.
• S entence structure activity using word cards – this activity involved students working in groups of 4 or 5
to create sentences using cards which contained nouns, particles and the verb いきます. This allowed theteacher to circulate amongst the groups and provide additional support where needed.
• V ocabulary-swatter / karuta activity – assessed students’ ability to recognise several pictures and/or
words when given an aural clue.

6

One or more of these activities were included in each week’s lesson plan, allowing ongoing formative assessment ofstudent ability, and this in turn was used to inform planning for the following week’s lesson.
The value of ongoing formative assessment was particularly evident inweek four, when the “Create a sentence using the cards on your table”
activity revealed that a significant number of the students were struggling
with the correct word order. Many of the groups were placing the verb
before the place-noun and particle, replicating the English word order of“I go to [place]”. As a result, the following week’s lesson was adjusted toinclude a focus on word order and the structure of sentences using the
Triptico Magnets on the IWB. Formative assessment in the week after
showed that students had become more familiar with the Japanese word
order as all groups were using the correct sentence word order.
Other examples of formative assessment informing teaching methods occurred during the initial revision activity in eachlesson. Where a number of the students were displaying difficulty in recognising and/or reading the words, the lesson
would be adjusted to include a short word recognition and reinforcement activity such as karuta or swatter which provided
an opportunity for all students to practise their word recognition.

SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT
In week ten, students began the final assessment activity for this unit of work. The assessment activity involved three parts:1) students were required to create an illustrated map and include and label all of the vehicles and places on the map;2) using the map created, students were required to write five sentencesthat would follow a path around their map using the appropriate
sentence structure,(transport) で (place name) に いきます。;
3) students were asked to create a Tellagami avatar, photograph their
map as the background image, and then read and record three of theirsentences using the app. As the app does not allow editing, reading had
to be recorded in one continuous stream.

RESULTSINCREASES IN READING SCORES
While there were improvements across all areas of reading (individual characters, words and sentences), the mostsignificant was in the reading of whole words and sentences. In reading whole words, only 2% of all students received
100% in the pre-test, whereas in the post-test this number increased to 27%, with 56% of students receiving a score of
70% or above. In reading sentences, the number of students who received a score of less than 20% decreased from 61%
to 8% from pre- to post-test, and at the other end of the scale the percentage of students who received a score of 100%
increased from 8% to 58% – with 74% of all students receiving a score of 60% or more. This showed a significant increasein the accuracy with which students could read the words, and their matching of words to images reflected an increase incomprehension of the whole words and sentences.
Throughout the study, when working with the IWB and the Triptico Word Magnets the students were invited to share theirreading strategies for whole words with the class. The strategies drew on students’ existing knowledge and experience(e.g. “in しんかんせん the ん looks like the wheels of the train”) and the sharing of these strategies afforded students new
ways of reading Japanese words. This explicit focus on reading strategies using the IWB and Word Magnets was seen by
the students as one of the most effective tools for learning and remembering new vocabulary.

7

DECREASE IN TIME TAKEN
The second set of data that was collected was the time it took students to complete tasks. All students were required
to record the time taken to complete each section of the pre- and post-test. While it was expected that all times would
decrease, the results did not consistently reflect this expectation. In the individual character reading, speeds did decreasefor 72% of the students; however, in the sentence reading section, over 50% of students showed an increase in time taken
to read. The reason for the increase in time became apparent when students relayed that they had guessed the correctsentence in the pre-test, but in the post-test they actually read all of the sentences before selecting the correct one.

STUDENT OPINIONSIn the final session of this project, students were asked to discuss their experiences relating to this unit of work.
They were also asked to rank the activities in order of most to least helpful. The students ranked the activities as follows:
1. Triptico Magnets
2. sharing strategies – talking about how to read words
3. music/songs/raps
4. the mini books
5. playing karuta/particle races
6. using hiragana charts to read characters

CONCLUSION
One of the most notable aspects of this study was the observation that the students’ motivation to learn language increased
as their reading fluency improved.
The results of this study strongly supported the use of a structured series of scaffolded learning activities to reinforce
the development of students’ reading Japanese as an L2 with increased accuracy and comprehension. The inclusionof frequent formative assessment to ensure all students were within the ZPD proved to be valuable and the studentsharing of strategies proved to be one of the most effective learning activities in the development of reading skills.
The IWB was instrumental throughout the study, both in providing a visual and tactile language learning tool and inestablishing a whole-class focus for reading skill development.
The revelation that students were more confident in reading words and sentences than in reading individual hiragana
characters provides an interesting challenge for teachers. While Japanese language teachers have a duty to ensure
students thoroughly learn to read and write hiragana characters, the results of this study would suggest there is a strong
need for balance between individual character recognition, whole word and sentence recognition, and comprehension –for both academic and motivational purposes.
This study revealed an improvement in reading fluency – both in accuracy and comprehension – in the majority of students
involved and therefore achieved the goal of the pedagogical innovation that was the subject of this research. There is a needfor further research into applying a similar structured and scaffolded approach in the development of other macroskills inprimary students studying Japanese as a Second Language, with particular focus on methods of improving language skill
development within the limited resources available to primary language teachers.

8

REFERENCES
Bernhardt, E. 2005. “Progress and Procrastination in Second Language Reading”. Annual Review
of Applied Linguistics, 25 (2005): 133-150.
Gorsuch, G., & E. Taguchi. 2008. “Repeated Reading for Developing Reading Fluency and Reading Comprehension: The case of EFL learners in Vietnam”.
System, 36(2): 253-278.
———. 2010. “Developing Reading Fluency and Comprehension Using Repeated Reading: Evidence from Longitudinal Student Reports”. Language Teaching
Research, 14(1): 27-59.
Horiba, Y. 1990. “Narrative Comprehension Processes: A Study of Native and Non-Native Readersof Japanese”. The Modern Language Journal, 74(2): 188-202.
Kuhn, M. R., P. J. Schwanenflugel, & E. B. Meisinger. 2010. “Aligning Theory and Assessment of Reading Fluency: Automaticity, prosody, and definitions offluency”. Reading Research Quarterly, 45(2): 230-251.
Nassaji, H. 2011. “Issues in Second Language Reading: Implications for Acquisition and Instruction”. Reading Research Quarterly, 46(2): 173-184.
Samuels, S. J. 2007. “The DIBELS Tests: Is speed of barking at print what we mean by reading fluency?”
Wood, D., & H. Wood. 1996. “Vygotsky, Tutoring and Learning”. Oxford Review of Education, 22(1): 5-16.
Yamashita, J., & S. Ichikawa. 2010. “Examining Reading Fluency in a Foreign Language: Effects of text segmentation on L2 readers”. Reading in a Foreign
Language, 22(2): 263-283.

9

APPENDIX

10